Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

18
Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT Mike Connor: AM Session Bruce Thompson: PM Chair Sheila Tucker: Press liaison Jennifer Hunt: Timekeeper Jon Leatherbarrow: Video Lawrence Hall of Science All our speakers Meeting Credits

description

Meeting Credits. Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT Mike Connor: AM Session Bruce Thompson: PM Chair Sheila Tucker: Press liaison Jennifer Hunt: Timekeeper Jon Leatherbarrow: Video Lawrence Hall of Science All our speakers. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Page 1: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT Mike Connor: AM Session Bruce Thompson: PM Chair Sheila Tucker: Press liaison Jennifer Hunt: Timekeeper Jon Leatherbarrow: Video Lawrence Hall of Science All our speakers

Meeting Credits

Page 2: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Choosing a Future Bay: The Long Term Fate of PCBs

and Other OrganicsJay Davis

Ben Greenfield

Jon Leatherbarrow

Nicole David

San Francisco Estuary Institute

Page 3: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

One Box Mass Budgets

OUTPUTSOutflowBurialVolatilizationDegradation

INPUTSDischargesRunoffAtmosphereHotspot erosion

Page 4: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

PCBs Present concentrations about 10 times higher than

threshold for concern Slow decline in the Bay in last 20 years New sources minimal – restricted in 1979 Residual loading from watershed and atmosphere Degradation is negligible Associate with sediment particles Somewhat volatile One-box final report in press, multi-box draft by

January 2004

Page 5: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 1000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

50% of present

25% of present

10% of present

0 kg

Predicted Long Term Trends in PCB Mass (kg) with Varying Loads

Page 6: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 1000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

50% of present

25% of present

10% of present

20 kg

10 kg 0 kg

Predicted Long Term Trends in PCB Mass (kg) with Varying Loads

Page 7: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

PAHs

Present concentrations at threshold for concern

No clear trend in the Bay in last 20 years Masses are large Degradation is significant Significant continuing inputs Associate with sediment particles Somewhat volatile One-box final report in prep

Page 8: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 400

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

140000

50% of present

0 kg

7500 kg

15000 kg

Predicted Long Term Trends in PAH Mass (BBF, kg) with Varying Loads

Page 9: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Organochlorine Pesticides

Present concentrations at threshold for concern Decline in the Bay in last 20 years New sources minimal – cancelled in 1972 Residual loading from watershed and

atmosphere Degradation is faster than PCBs Associate with sediment particles Somewhat volatile One-box draft report out soon

Page 10: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 400

100

200

300

400

500

50% of present

Predicted Long Term Trends in DDT Mass (kg) with Varying Loads

0 kg

20 kg

40 kg

Page 11: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

PBDEs

Threshold for concern not well known Concentrations exponentially increasing Use is increasing Loading up the “blenders” in the Bay and

the watershed Degradation probably minimal Associate with sediment particles Less volatile than PCBs No full analysis yet

Page 12: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

PBDEs have NOT been thoroughly reviewed yet

Model can be used to get a preliminary peek at the how the Bay would generally respond to this TYPE of scenario

Increasing Loading Scenario

Page 13: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 1000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000Exponential Increase

EI for 10 yr, then 40 kg/yr

EI for 10 yr, then 0 kg/yr

PBDE-like Loading Scenarios

Page 14: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Year

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 1000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

EI for 10 yr, then 0 kg/yr

EI for 20 yr, then 0 kg/yr

PBDE-like Loading Scenarios

Page 15: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Next Steps for Modeling in the RMP

Contaminant Fate Workgroup meets tomorrow

Local scientists and invited members Joel Baker and Tom McKone

Multiple boxes

Page 16: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

A Multi-box Model

Page 17: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Next Steps for Modeling in the RMP (cont)

Quantify uncertainty Extend food web model Better input data

– Sediment dynamics– Degradation rates– Outflow – Average concentrations– Historic long term trends

Page 18: Linda Russio: Organizer Patricia Chambers: Pulse, photos Todd Featherston and Mike May: IT

Closing Remarks