Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae...

18
Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of

Transcript of Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae...

Page 1: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Lecture 1

History of the Milky WayGalileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others

The idea of spiral nebulae asisland universes (Kant)

The Great Debate of 1920:Curtis vs. Shapley

Page 2: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 3: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Discovery of the Milky Way

Page 4: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

William Herschel (1738-1822)1773 - aged 35, reads a book on astronomy1774 - starts making mirrors, telescopes & observe1781 - discovers a “comet” (in fact, Uranus)1782 - appointed as Cours Astronomer, drops

music as a profession1783 - finds his first galaxy 1785 - finds his 1000th new object1802 - a total of 2500 nebulae & clusters discovered

20ft focal length reflector, magnif. x157

Page 5: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Discovery of the Milky Way

Page 6: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

‘Island universes’of ImmanuelKant

Page 7: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Through the 18th-centurytelescopes, spiral galaxieslooked a lot like blurry,perhaps gaseous objects.

Hence the idea that they’remuch smaller parts of theMilky Way.

But...

Page 8: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

English-Irish nobleman Lord Rosse (W. Parsons) and his Leviathan

M51 then and now

(HST, 2.4m, 1990)(1.8m, 1845)

Page 9: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 10: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 11: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 12: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Carroll & Ostlie “Intro to ModernAstrophysics

Page 13: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 14: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Distance measurement: Cepheids and RR Lyr variablesThe Cepheid variables are evolved young, massive stars and lie within the crowded spiral arms of a galaxy. There are few of them in a galaxy. Cepheid variables have periods 1-100 days. Henrietta Leavitt found them in 1912 in Large and Small Magellanic Clouds and noticed P vs. M relationship. This relationship can provide us with M (absolute magnitude) or equivalently L (luminosity) of a Cepheid variable. Since these stars are bright, they can now be seen and used out to distance of 40 Mpc.

Page 15: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Distance measurement: RR Lyr variablesThe other class of variable stars are RR Lyrae variables (named after the prototype pop II star RR Lyrae or RR Lyr). Discovered by Wlliamina Fleming at Harvard in 1901.

RR Lyrae stars are evolved old, low-mass stars, and can be seen in the uncrowded halos of galaxies, especially in globular clusters.

M=+0.6...0.7(e.g.,RR Lyr: 0.61,d= 262 pc from HSTparallax) [d]=pc

Page 16: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

Distance measurement: RR Lyr variables

They are a stage in the evolution of a lower-mass star, and therefore are generally more numerous than Cepheid variables. A single globular cluster may have dozens of RR Lyrae stars. Periods of RR Lyrae stars are typically 0.3 to 1 day, making it possible to see one or more periods (cycles) in a single night of observations.

The period-absolute magnitude (or alternatively P vs. L) relations have been known but initially somewhat incorrectly calibrated. E.g, RR Lyrae stars’ AVERAGE absolute magnitude is +0.6, which corresponds to 49 L_sun.

The P=M relation in I-band (near IR, ~9000A): M_I = +0.471 -1.132 log P + 0.205 log Z.

The RR Lyr variables can be seen and used as standard candles out to distances up to about 0.74 Mpc.

Page 17: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:
Page 18: Lecture 1 History of the Milky Way Galileo, Hershel, Kapteyn and others The idea of spiral nebulae as island universes (Kant) The Great Debate of 1920:

100 in Hooker telescope

1922-23