LeBars Et Al

! "#%$'&)(*! +,-/. & 0

13254768259)6):=?;A@CB%:D25E B%FG; ;A9)986)HIB%6)@KJL9M6)EN:OBPJLQN689)6RBTS 6)E

@CSU9)6)ENVN476)@KJL9WJXENV :PHNFG;A476)@KJL9Y472ZB[J\B%68EG] @^25E_BPJX6)EG;A47:

`badcfehgLi `kjmlYnpo[nTe\gXi qsrptvuiwnNxKy>z|{7eXgLi }?j~g

R//R8/8Tp8'8+/

R#R/T% +

'8/R8''+R/'8 '*/''-/PR^)R8

KP8R/)+'''

TA+%"RA//+)*+8Z

)K+"8"'K%-P'C

T

Rp"+^)7

T

T

-

T

'"%+'R^R/P)+P'+['RO+

R^R+8-bC^+

h/\R+"RK

T

'p/+L8-X

0

7/)

++'

T

T

0

)+

"'X

T~s

Z+R+\b

0

X

T

-R)%Tb'TbT )"+%+ +8C/

)+87+RRK8R#RT++8)R/8T ++

)

wK++ O*+^R+R+R[/PK%8

#R^"%/^R

7Op+P'# P+8p+

+>R/R))88

eXrR

T+/hR+R>++ +h/p

+RP^I+%/''

A^/*G+'_

K8)[p+h'

A)

*C

0

0

*7

+P'")O8X#[RR8+-

+8-*

0!

8

0

TC+/\bR+P

CPP /b /C++P7#/b++b

)KRC8RpT)*'

"

pT/[''^>PT[R+

+"

$#

++

0

+"p8TR+

8O+%

&

RRC

K8^+'

&

(*),+-/.

00

+p12h8

01

#

++

(3),+$-/.

C"C+R

4

1#

(3)+-/.

0

#

*8465*p+

R7

%C%)

0

+ +O/5R)^''+RRR

*8^b)+8+P/[%)U)

0

+p

58/+p++>Z+Z+*CR7^+p+5+

b"OR-%*[#\>#8["A*R>\8

'

:9

+\)PpPNPRR \+[CR+RP

^#/hX^'5R[

p"R

0

#

=?@'[

PCRC"ACB['+D6 RC

0

0

p

0

7

T+Ab7[ R[^

+[R'O^+K+[R8R++[

L8/7+'[kXLR"+/

L*+

T""*R'L)X)+p'7R"'^R'

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

^

pR+

#

+ vp-*

01

/)#

0

C )R

B[+AR+A

(3)+-/.

0

R A+8*R[)+%

0$

/"'L^/#/X-ZX+L5p'ZT

AR'\ +PAhRT''

hT"'

"P-)'^R/

%R+R+C*b%"*'

X\RK[+RXK+>*'%

RPRKRLRX^ZC/-)'

!

>K

;

(*),+$- .

0

'"[/C+/)

R"b_X5)+C+R'

:&

+

"

R+

+ZRL7R5AZR+\b+^+R

+8'X'T ++h+LCRRX)'P

+

*

(*) +-/.

'-* )Oh8R-

$#

+8"R

0

CCRC+R)7

T

*/p^PRR

R%+#/

T

\C~R%+/

T

7R'+[

0

+p/#/ZZCX

"+RTR*hCK)[hCK+R

!9

*8bp+KR )

0%

#Tp"[RP'+

'&

(3)+-/.

#

+

(*)+-/.

R7

'*+

8-"+p)++R

+7)pOT"R"*+/

&

0

R%88+%)R

()w*

8

+,)W

0

*

7

"h~+>

(-)M*

0

["

* /.10

#R-R)#/

T

5X

Z""

R'Z+L)X/h+Z+7+ /.10

TbRR"-'

p+p'+Cb+

0

R*

&

8T+T+C>-

RRC-)R)R"'8Op R

A'R'+'

A-+8P/-R XC

+ALRR"2/+

-'L

"7

b#pR/

T

>$3

T*>^R+C

,

w' p)KR_\)+

%

R+[^* "RR hR8T ++'O

+8'bR+bR8KAR*8

7+RP

C7#R +O#/K%+)

Tb7'K'T

+\

(-)>8-)*8

>)+"T4//+\R7h#>RR+8

&

(*)4+-/.

'RLpC+v ^L[AKRP+)+

"+PC7>+/+A#Rb7/

+OR+R+A-R+

#

+

(*)'+-/.

^"*+%R

)'R)T%/%+7R%'P*8>')

+R/R8'C)

R

0

8

CC[p+R

^L+PpK*7CC+XLC+)+LR/R))

R'8+T/>[>+

5

O#P/RT/)776b#898;: ?> 8RR 8 =#CBD

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

(a) (b)

Rotating table

Camera

rotating

table

light

projector

motor

roller

sphere (or cylinder)camera

G~

0

z

roller

structure fixed on the rotating table

F~

! #"%$&('*)+-,. 0/1234"65879+#):G;-DE'B1S+=>G/8) G7/T'*;

4'*7),8'*;% UH95C,C'*;='V>G;Q E+#WGF 7R/1'*;!"65FX (+-'B1S>G/Y),8'Z;4>G) G)7R/[S) (3F\'^]

_

ea`cbedCdCTfOg?f hdijZd*kldfOgZm a k8bnd ang od

0

.p

(

(3) +- +

+C#1(

0

0

rq^s

C0 tvu-

+- )wt

T-+ /#/+ *h+8p+

0

++

R

+ZZ^'RKp/pp R+%>'

U+)C%)C/>

*

0

"0

p

R

RC

RC+ RR< RC

7*# 7+p7R

['R7R[>+h+)'ORCRhC-

b++

x

'#7R7>+p/#/L5h8"#_R7+

*+\R'X8

0

p

0

7

%

+hCC'hL'bR

+8

5^+7>++Lb+

0

T

>-[+

(

+++%pKP%C

%"

>[P[P+CR^/

^

'h8'h)L) )R++PC )+

+P

!ynz!{

)}|~

89 0

z*

R

0

z-=9

0

z{:

83

0

BQ(rKIM9

z

0

[%RR^#RK

)

(7

+az

h*Cb8++R7-%)-*T 8*)

R

0

)^88[CRR+ Py^W

'+ &++8C*O+'-7

++'R

7

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

T7+#/Y

|

0

)

z

[%p R)-*Lb)

)

7

0

0

7

)L p%)P'R^>PPbP

"

P+

%R^#Rc~

0

)

0

T

)

r )

0

z

>R\'

)

p+R/+

7'R _7

b"T )"+6O

+d

T

TpT )"+G"\*+

Tb

C)-+R+#K+Rp R)-*'KC*+)-

)-*+8'7bRR/\+R

&

+RA

7

LbZ

8

1

0

*

&

%'\

0

p

*C/#/\'[fbR+

*/pP+8RCR[[/pp+,8z-8z

!#"Kz-"Gz "

%/+bT

TP#RT 'RP^'

"

)$

z

)

"

z%

)

"

*

&

+

>R^7R+'K

'&

0

-

8Tz

+^-bZX

/+_8>_

0

>^

//>+R

_A8)p)+'b/

^R-R

C' )%O*/ORRO+C

T>^ RpPRCR+pR+R+Cb+8 /&

(3)+-/.

R

%

K

'L^'-L+!

z

"

z(

)(P+RPA^+p

'T)R+^b%'R

9

p+7pC8p+8

ORR

0

)8"P+8+

R+^)

)

"

0

*

+R*'+CA) &

(3)>+-/.

R

C

++'+8

)

M/+R>* )

PR%

T7#Rb

'R

)

"

U+R

"

)

T

0

*

0

&

%+\XR'R+[LRP/'%X*C'\Zb

))>"%RR>

T

T

R)+pTA

0

,+

8

)[*R"+'+A8CT +)-*/

/^K+R'

%

*+RTb%^++

9

^

RRR'"+#C+"CT +8-*'++

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

resonance (-1,1,2) with 16 axial half-wavelengths

if +1-1=2

G/(1+G)resonance (-1,1,1) with 4 axial half-wavelengths

in the absence of global rotation

0 5 10 15 203

2

1

0

1

2

3

number n of axial halfwavelengths

fre

qu

en

cy ~


if +1-1=2

G/(1+G)~ ~

~ ~

ITMr7RH95C'*;-H-7>G/ ;='#FX G)7>G/25>G7R/C)HU>4@?),8'H=) G;-H"2 G/M1N9H#:8 0;='*H".'*7\['*/8DV>^1'*H

@>0;v),8'O;-H=)V 0/1H#'B+->0/1H=DU FRF\'*;S;B 1G79 F N G'*/8: F Hv;B'*H95C'=+#)7G'#F W#"

7R/ ),C' +#WGF 7R/1'*;S>@Q,8'*7\[K,G/1G7/^79107R/GN /T]

p s[+b\87

T

U

0

->*%*+8^#+>

+8

0

+$- +#

+

_#RhA#R"+>58bRR+

88+RhTA""#/

[

+7%)87/8T ++

#

R[PR*+%)

8

0

>k4

0

KR+'-)

'+

;

00

#

#

!

00

7RR*T'P[*)K8%)++

CR%*O+'"R[/+' '+""Tv*

p R+

yez{

) |y,+

z{ "+

=%(.-M90/ 1

*

0R0

T"*+7T+)#/%8R7)

#

?O@+

+R*pA'[p\*b)++

+8T%+TT ^'KRTR*+R

"T T)7

T

+R

P/pR*R bRRRT+'>T+RT32-)C

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

number n of axial halfwavelengths

reso

na

nt

glo

ba

l ro

tati

on

G

IT,C'=>0;='*)79+= F 58;='B1G79+#)79>0/8H@>G; ),C';='*H*>G/M G/8) 0 GF :M'*H >4@ ),8' [ FX>(3= FG) 0)79>G/S;B G)!'o 0H @-:/M+#)79>G/

>4@Z),8'%/8:^1GHQ7R/>G:4@6,8'*7\[K,G;%),8'?DU>^1'*H

*LH-DV FRF+#;4>GH=H#'*H@>G;QDU>^1'*H

'*L FX G;9['?H#:C G;='*H @>G;Q),8'

DV>^1'*H

*L H=DU FRF H#:C G;B'*H @>G;%),8'?DU>^1'*H

'*L FX 0;9['?);*7 G/^1'*H

/U G/1

H=DU GFRF );*7 G/^1'*H

^],8' @>G;#3#791(1'*/ 3- 0/1 + +.7RH%1'#F 7RD%7R)!'B1P3#W

),8'%1( GH4,8'B1 F 7R/'*H#]

/'?R *8R'

)G

|

0

283

B

z

0

2ZC\'+8#/%h+P/'

ex

+ h'+

&%'8R[8\#P+

0

X'bK ZhR

P'+^%T ++R

"+

)r|

R! +

z:

! +

zR

B

z

0

">R'

)$#

0

2

0

2

p%/% )

0

2

&KT

Rp*/p-R-%Tp R'

)

'

2

(

."2

& )

'

2

(

. 2

)%+bRTC++8/C'p

2-P+8*)%[T Pb%+'$&++8

)') 3P1

0

'

83+

'

*

0

7

&

^

#

?@'>

R

*\+/[*R#>+C

>\+C5R>^'R-bTp R

Z'7ZR-RC,) )

0

0

7

7%X8C

T

'

&

0

>

'

8)++8T7+A

-

T+

0

2K/R%+hC*+RT

+#/

#

4?@'

R

-

)/. |

7

0

10

2

|

0

Z

0

R

B

*

0

&

h8"R5OR+ 2 )R+5)++

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

+R-+Z*K+R\+X8hR87)XRAA>+

0

)R ~

0

,

x

(

*

0

+

x

x

)R)-*T+^)

x

)

(

CO)C)8/

P

;

+>7 P78+p[T [*R

^*['/C+^"[p

0

0

+%

0

p

+

0

8"R+ R

x

(

R%)R8++R[TCO

^RR^)

%

-

) .

|

7

0

0

2

|

0

Z

0

83+

x

(

(

x

(

,

x

(

z

0$

(

/K'*+"CR"p['

R^8) )K8+>T7)

)

7

7

0

|

0

(

[

0

Z

0

0

(

0

L

[

0

(

0

+

(

0

(

(

+

z

')

T

0

0

*

0

T"\-AZ^'XA87K)*+8+8K+

+z

T+'-%*+ /#/

T+

C))%OR%/+)' )k

0

)

0

8+ T +)-*QLA"R T +8-* +

)

7

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

global rotation rate G

gro

wth

ra

te

/

-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4

n=4

n=3

n=5

n=6

n=7

n=12n=15

(b)

(a)

-0.6 -0.4 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

global rotation rate G

gro

wth

ra

te

/

-0.2

n=3

n=2

n=14

n=11

n=8

n=6

n=5

n=4

other instable modes

with n=20-25

ITT7RH*+->0:HE[G;B>GN ), ;B G)!'.>4@P),8''#FRF 7 5M)79+= F 7R/8H=) (3#7RF 7R)WDU>^1('

.1'*)!'*;-D?7/T'B1 3#W),8'

FX>^+= FE G/M F W0H-7H 0H c@*:0/ >4@ ),8' [ FX>(3= FV;B>0) G)79>G/;4 G)!'

@>G; a[G7G'*/+#W F 7R/M1'*; >4@ ;4 (1G7R:0;E'BA*5C'*;-7RDE'*/C) FDU'= 0H-: F 791PF 7R/'*H @#>G;?),8'B>G;B'*)79+= FI5M;B'B1G79+#)79>G/CH#] ,C'

5M;B'B1G79+#)!'B1/8:G/ '= +-,

;B'*H#>0/ G/C) 3= G/10L H=) G;*)7/GD S7R/c! #"? 0/1 S7R/!34"#" DE'B GH=:G'

'B (+-, 'BA*5C'*;-7RDU'*/8) FI5>07R/8)!]%$Z>G)!'E),C G)67R/ ! #"^Lr 1(1G7R)79>0/ FO;='*H*>G/ 0/+-'*H N'*;B'v>(3#H#'*;G'B1U@>0;,l7R/ ),8'

;4 G/0) (+=+#:

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

(a)

0 105 15 20

0

2

4

6

8

10

z (cm)

time (s)

(b)

0 105 15 20

0

2

4

6

8

10

z (cm)

time (s)

ITMT$ 5 G)79>0)!'*Do5>G;4 F1G79 [G;B GD%Hr>(3#) G7/T'B1 3#WE'BAG);B (+#)7R/[S),8'6H* GDE'rF 7R/T'5 G;4 FRF\'#FT)>V),8'Z;4>G) G)79>G/

^AG7H?7R/ 'B (+-,7RDU ['E>@S S[G7G'*/ ^71'B>YH#' #:8'*/+-' &r! #" DU>^1'P $0L!(L,#-" N 7R), GH4,C>GN / 7R/ [G:"U 0/1

5 #'K]2H=) G/10H@#>G;r),8'?1G7H-) 0/+-'

FX>0/%'%)/K+)%P

''%A/K\

R%RP+7p

x

)%)"++C

R88RRR*p+C8"C*'

>O+++O_

+PR\)7ZZ~^+ R7'L8 )

0

'&

(*) +$- .

R

0

3(

s

(t$ (

R

)^++P* 84 R

b*

+'+L)\^R+%

T

)b

x

)-8-*

bR

9

/X#RC^LA'

/'R

)+%"T RRAR+C'A)A+RRP>'A) &

(*)D+$-/.

R

hR)8^+

T[+CA">^+8A

'K)+++)R+C)

*

0

)

+RROT +)-*

0

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

)A/

0

z

0

z

0

R

&

/)

T

I

*

/)+

8'

C+RARCpA)

%

CbX\O

R-*Rb'R+\)XC+++

'/+>)C7R8T > [R

7

-R +++Rp''*8

+A"8['

T"'"+WR

+KR8R+)+)+'Cp+K*R

T*p+

p+++ R'PT+

+R""b+pR%%R

'b7

0

7

T

w

*

0

PO++8+R

7

RO/

0

z

0

z

0

p %K[+

w1+

) ) +$)

s

(>+

+$-X4C

)1(

t(

0

z

0

z

0

TO/R7A/

0

z

0

z

0

'*+-8+7RT"CO

++*+R

%

k+8+' CR++T+RC- #

")b+AR

O+R RAO++#\

*+R RT*"+^K7R8Tb7++

)CP*R%

0

"&

bP 7>>

% &

(*) +-/.

TORTO^'*+

T

+8+C

7

+-5b)R%R+C

0$

+bZ>-

+Rh%#/XR++#\XR%KX*+

^O'R8-'

T

)

*

3

*

R7

R

T

)

*

3

*

'++

+8 PT^[8+KOb[+)+R-P+

'+L+

T

+'+[T

0

ZA8>^'

*7 %+[ +P7

7

+

7AR

T

)

*

p T)R'"K

8 CR#O7R+

+'T )R+T*+R +

TCCC*

8'

/'+T*'+[R^8KRR8pbPRR)OP)

'+7[/ &

(3) +$- .

T p'P++

+C+AR\bR8T ++

"

)-)

%

+

CR*R+C#+

"9

OK^

[+R#*8+'+ +KRPp

T

)N

0

)-*[R+R+/+Ob+R'-)*+8O-R

R++#hC8

T%R-p+[)*+8

\R

8RR 8[)+

%

R'88++8/

+P+^++'ORTC8R'/+)

0

TTp+*+C*8pTQ#'O'K^%R+

O")+OROR/7A-R/O-

^8

+'7*+/pK)*+8#

T

)

*

-

T

)

2

-

RT+R8

0

*

7

->R

7

*

+'+

%

7+R+

TP++R'pR

*

(

*

(

8+bCT

'/+\+R-b+PC+XR+%7+

*KR['b [7

^>C#*8)R'7

^ P- >$3

0

R

)RR8T8p

R #T *RP88

T

T

RR*

T

)N

0

+

b'[h"8 )AR+8*/p+ +[

*8p

T

&

0

T"*PP+OR

T

U

0

^+

/++'p

T

)

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

00

G

= 0 Hz

n=4

G

=+0.499 Hz

n=2

G

=+0.145 Hz

n=3

G

=-0.069 Hz

n=5

G

=-0.134 Hz

n=6

G

=-0.163 Hz

n=9

G

=-0.186 Hz

n=11

G

=-0.203 Hz

n=14

G

=-0.231 Hz

n=20

G

=-0.257 Hz

n=25

IT C G;-79 G)7>G/>@Q),8'%N G'#F\'*/[G),>4@Z),C'%DU>^1'

G'*;*H=:

0

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

mode (0,2,1)

mode (1,3,1)

mode (0,2,2)

mode (1,3,2)

mode (-1,1,2)

G=0.110 Hz

n=5

~

G=0.368 Hz

n=4

~

G=0.794 Hz

n=3

~

G=0.198 Hz

n=6

~

G=0.418 Hz

n=5

~

G=0.440 Hz

n=5

~

G=0.222 Hz

n=8

~

G=0.415 Hz

n=8

~

ITM 79+#): 3#H'*; G'B1%DU>^1('*Hn>4@o'#FF 7 5M)79+= F

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

0

/

28/%/R /+CR)-+R8 +8+ % ' /#

m + ^+)+/'RP'8p/R+')/+/+ 288+++ ) _

T + ')+O/8

/'8R# ) > +/8 ///8%/

D8+)R28/%/T/%8>b+R/% R+//#+8R/#/#+8/D8'8^/"/R[+

8-/'8+R' L/8+')T)+ 7R >X/RC#+)+ 8+ 48

/+)8R8%/KC7+/8RK/7/8+//# 8+#R+828/%+ +8/ '

88/8#) 8R/+*#R+R# -!' 88#+'/ #>5/8p//8+# +PR//%R

7/8"+') 8 8R/'+

/R+ 28/%/

#

+' ' '' +'

+' '' +

' #+ ++

' # '

+ #+ ++

+ # +'

' #' +'

' # ++

' #+

' # +'

' + ++ '

+'

'

+ + +

'' '

''

'+

'+ +' +

+' + ++'

++

+' + ++

+ ' +

' ' + '' '

'+ ++ '

++ ' '

' + + +

+' ' '

+' ' '

+ +' ' + +

+' $ ' ' ' '

'+ + '

%

ea`cbedCdCTfOg?f hdijZd*kldfOgZm a k8bnd m *X'_5Rh8R8>U#R%RCR

5>^+URARKh)RAU+U

0

0

ThRR

'ZR+CR_)^hR\C

'

-w

-+b+R8T )v

0

07

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

M R7/+%-+#8K+[/8%+/RP+8/'%RR+8 /D8'8R

8R#/R/%/R > '/

)RP/8 /R8/8-# 8/#+/'8+8=:288

8/'C'"/8T28/%++RO-

/R+ 28/%/

%R

/'' + ' + +' '' ''

+ +' +' +'

/'' + # '' +

' +

+ ' ' + +' + + '

+' ' ' + +' + + ' '

+ + '+ '' '

#' ' ' + '+

+ +' ' ' ''

' ' +

' ++ ' ' + ' ' ++ '+

' ++ ' ' +' '+ '+' ''

' +' ' + ' R

+ ++ R '+ ' +

' #' ' + +' + + '

' ' + + +' R R ' '

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 140.25

0.5

0.75

1

1.25

1.5

1.75

relative time t (s)

mo

de

am

pli

tud

e A

(cm

) best exponential fit

A=0.42exp(0.098t)

IT -/87)79 F8'0> F :G/S),G: [K,S)7RDU'e>4@ ),8'nDV ^AG7RD%:D ;4 (1G79 F8 GDo5MF 7R):C1'o>4@ ),8'nDV>^1'

7R/ ),8' +#W F 7R/M1'*; >4@U;B (1G7:H

k +C+#D G/1v,8'*7\[K,G) G)7R/[v G)

Z ++(P' ^

"%N 7R),2 Q[ FX>(3= F;4>G) G)79>0/>4@

'K],8'%3-'*H=)

'BA*5>G/'*/8)79 GF O)7R/1G7+- 0)!'*HQ %[G;4>GN ),2;4 G)!' Z +' ]

)

0

+++R'+R%[R^

) !#

"

0

>%RR

"7T )"+

TR+ p'R+[AXhC)+

!

'P+R

/'K)&

(3)+-/.

R

P'/R'*/p+^+p )7[

R)+

b7>8B[

0

8P+

+>)CP

#

+*)

)

*+88T"p R)-*

T%8R>)+

)['>*8O88#+R^7K+p

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

0

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

fre

qu

en

cy

spin-over


and 1 radial structure if +1-1=2

G/(1+G)

~

number n of spatial halfwavelengths

~ ~

ITT r7H5C'*;-H=79>G/a;B'#FX G)79>G/c5>G7R/C)H6@>0; 9H=) G;-H" G/M1 s 9H#:8 0;='*H"7R/ cH95C,8'*;B'^]

,G/T'65M;='*H#'*/C)!'=127R/

I[G:4@

^AG7 FI,C F @#J9N G'#F\'*/ F :G/

7R/ ;B'='*/8H95 G/#"G] G;9['QH=W0DU3=> F HrH=) G/M1o@>G;r),C'?'*7\['*/CDU>^1'*HZN 7R),v),8'ZH=7RDe5F\'*H=) ;B (1079 FH=);-:C+#):;B' &

/.7RH6),8'*/c),8'Q/C:DV3-'*;V>4@Q ^AG79 GF,C F @#J9N G'#F\'*/G;r),8'V+#WGF 7R/M1'*;^]H-7/0) G)79>G/ GH

@>0;r),8'V+#W F 7/1'*;-L U;='*H*>G/M G/+-'

Q7RHQ'BA(+#7R)!'B1%58;B>^79107R/G7R/C)H?7RH6[G7G'*/ 3#Wc"!]# $*"& 'BA( GDe5F\'*H @#>G;?),8'V/>0/ ;4>G) G)7R/[c+= GH#'297]'^]O),8'VH587R/MJ!>G'*;!"2 G/1

@>0;6 ?;4>G) G)7R/[E+= GH#'r G;B'Q'BA*5MF 79+#7R)9F WQHB,>GN /T] '*H#>0/ G/M+*'*H63-'*)N '='*/c'*7\['*/CDU>^1'*HnN 7R),S),8'oH=7RDo5MF\'*H-);4 (1G79 GF

H=);-:8+#):G/T'rH=):8107'B1S7R/2),8'5M;='*H#'*/8)I5 *5C'*;^]

P+R+

p)p )KT[+Rp*+

'R+pK+R^R'

R+'+hR8)C[A'+8CAC

/+COp+R8 )

0

+ROO+R8 )G

0

+)R+*O%O

0

z

0

z

0

-)

%

*'

ARK/KXK)"+7) T ++P-+\RRL)

T+R'R%>+R

(

)

(

(

)

(

(

(

)

T

0

T

Rp/+>^R

b8pbP"+PO

-+pp+R PO)8R 4

%*-

O"M/

#

+

(*) +-/.

7

R"A#'

>*PR+'K)C%R'^b

0

%U

'%/P)+4

0

z

0

z

0

P'b+8>%+8

*(

s

(#t (

%P

( )U *

0$

~#b-+

++8/2 )

*

)+C%

T

T

[pR'R+

3

+[Rp

*

R+O+ )R RP8

%

8'

0

z

0

z

0

7*R'ORRRp8 ++

+

T

'+R'-p^

0

A)-*CP)+Cp

0

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

n=1

(spin-over)

n=4

n=3

n=2

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

y

O

y

O

y

O

y

O

x

O

x

O

x

O

x

O

ITa$4@?),8' >GN H-);-:C+#):G/ 0/+-'

@>0; 0 G;*7>G:G) G)7>G/ ^AG7RHZ7R/.),8'

n5FX G/'

;B'*H-:F )7R/[o@*;4>GD ),8'QH=:K5C'*;*7Do5>GH=7R)79>0/>@Z),8'Q3= GH#' >GN ;4>G) G)79>0/ G/M1 >@r),C'Q7R/8H=) (3#7RF 7R)WUDU>^1'^] Z GH4,8'B1

F 7R/'*H%H=) G/M1Z@>G;^7RH*+->0:HV3=>G:G/P58;B>=[G;='*H=H=7G'#F W2DV G)+-,8'*H?),C'V;-7\[G791

+=>G/C) G7R/T'*;;B>G) G)7>G/T]/ ),8';-7\[K,@.),8'7R/CH-) 3#7F 7R)W

DV>^1'^] W +=>G;-;='*H95>G/10H2)> ),C'2H95M7R/8J> G'*;2DU>^1' I (+= #K'--+ ! $%$ "#" s +=>G;-;='*H95>G/10H.)>

),8'e)N 7R/8J,0>0;*)!'BAVDU>^1'e>4@e>0:83#/M>U # #"*" G/1Z)>%),8'63-'*H=)O>4@o>G:GNF\'B1^['*L),8'6>G),8'*;eDU>^1'*H, G'

/M>G) W('*) 3-'='*/>(3#H#'*; G'B1P'BA*5C'*;-7RDE'*/C) FRF W(]

TP)//P+

0R0

+8/[+

'KP)/C

T

N

0

&

K^P)#+^'p#.

"L)\++8Z8+ +R[

T

bLb'R-

3

*

\/)5++*+/8+>

5C

+' e

&

7O%ORP'R8+RR+R+"C

)

7

R

^p*8)R)CC[T

'+-_%C+8ORT"O

//8Tp+C)*+8-)+RC///

+h+[vR

%

T

)

*

3

*

7

T

)

*

0

3

*

T

)Y

*

0

3

*

7

T

)

*

7

3

*

*

C++7\K+

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

0

G

=0 n=1~

G

=-0.170 Hz n=2~

G

=-0.196 Hz n=3~

G

=-0.264 Hz n=6~

G

=-0.242 Hz n=5~

G

=-0.226 Hz n=4~

G

=-0.279 Hz n=7~

ITl0N H=);-:C+#):;B' 0H-H*>^+#79 0)!'=1 N 7R), G/ 7R/8H=) (3#7F 7)W DV>^1'

%@>G;

1G7 o'*;B'*/8)e[ FX>(3= FO;B>G) G)7>G/ ;4 G)!'*H

7R/ ),8'v1'R@>0;*DU'=1YH95C,8'*;=' N 7R), G/ 'B+-+-'*/C);*79+#7)W v 0/1

IA'=1 :G) G)7>G/

' X ''Y' w 'b

"G] ,8'%DU'= 0H-:@? ^AG79 GF

,C GF @#JN G'#F\'*/[G),U7R/M1G79+= G)!'B1] -/2),8'*H#'n5M79+#):G) G)79>G/ ^AG7RHo7RHe,C>G;-7 ^>G/C) F\]

R*CR+'%+hR'AC\)/

+

x

))-*

"R'R+*AX\R

#RC7T " +

#

++

(3)+-/.

7

e>g nm

*'T Rp'+R+78+8/-

RT"/#/

RRRRR +#)+

+AR*+

+\

(vO+7b-p>+'O

'R++^R8C+R^R

^'pO R'

7+%)+RR>/RC)++CU+

x

+)

)-*'XK^R[%'PRCXK))b+

R7)O>-+R++R+R%RR

RC R"R+7RPPT'R)/%R

T

&

T

0

/-')+[p#/ '*+A7'

+XR++

+4 +'8R+

&

R+'[*+RR

_++CZO

T

0

Z\/)+

/

0

z

0

z

0

A R5K#/p R)"+Kp^T

#+8C+RP>+b-C)- /

T p1

^%)RR

+b'R+K88+LKR'/CR"+L

0

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

&*R/8)+%//T+8/8//+ 8/R/'RT/888 K%R

+8/ ^>-D8R8/O'RR w '?)K/ + R[8 A#+

8+ > #+/Rp/%+/+'/#+8'8 h+8 R+//*/R/+%/+

/R>//%)/'Z 8-/'8+Rh/8''8+ 8 8/ + ! /8")L28/%

8R#/R/*/8/D8'8RP%/R> +R/[+)^'T/D8/

/R+ 28/%/

'

+' ' +

' +

' ''

+' '

+ +

+' +

+' '+'

+' ' '

+' '+ '+

+' ' +

' ''

' + '

' ++ '

' +' +

' +

++ '

+ ' '

' ' '

+ +'

+'

+' '+ 'R

+' +' +

+ ' ++ +

'' ' +

'' ++ ''

'' ' ++ '

' $ ' ' +'

'

' + '+

' ++ +'

' ' '+

++ '' +'

++ '+ '

++ +

++ + R

++ + '

'+

+

+ +

#+^)+[)T^P'^)KR8T ++K

7#CR8CR )'+[%+C

9

RR%Lb)+-LZ^+KR+KR#+\#L>+

U'8

&

RR

UR_^)

R

(3) +-/.

R

- C ( (3)

)1(=(3- - )/ +$-!

) + - )

0

0

CR/++ 7b*8 ^#8

R+ +PP /++O+R+RC

*

'

L/+[*/C'/\+8'O)b)

)>5\+'p RL+

T

'+R'7Z\\#+R

R+RKR /

0

z

0

z

0

+'%8+L+

C)

* 8R#

T

++

\C+RRh++8/ C

(*) +$- .

0

#

4?@+

R

RR++'8+7R)

)+88

R P7*)*+'%- & R

X#R>+O#+)A*h++hA+ #/

A7R+hCR%AOA)))+O7

+P//>'' 5RhT8b ^>-/

P++RR

%

++%+++R+R

'*++8ObRKR+p8-KRbK

) '+

'RR)R/%RR++

%C)

0

+ h8

0

CPRpXR[

+>%+TR)+TR^-^b+8

)))+ 7

#

++

(3)+-/.

R

#

#

4?O@+

R

TPp> ? ) B[-CR[8pRb

++TR^*

6

SS+''-28/%/'R+8 'R%) /8)+ //+/#)8#

n'B>*5C,WGH#] oH=);B>*5,++8-//R%R#+)8>8B/

+/:)'%TR'R/'R Q] F :=US'+% ''R/'";> ! R//)+R-838>

[#+8'R/+8/RTT/ !')/#+8 ;4>^+K] >GW(]$M>^+K]"VWN"E8# +

X27H%,3YOZ:5[6;\Y ]Q*^"_'` ++'28/%/8h/R[R / 8+#- +/

88 , "+8\/8"R+ 88bL/8

/=Q] F :71oRc'=+-,C]"k8K'N* '

+%C8n? 7=U=U)+''P 8R/8+R# n/C/8:C F '^7'*Na>4@ F :G)7>G/8H67/. +=>G/C) G7R/T'B1E;B>G) G)7/

. ( + .:(( .:( +$-

)877 8/+#R+R# -/+/#[D8R8/+ '=>-5C,*5C, ,*5C,*5,^+K] r]I$>^+K] I>G/1(]=Z]"F5N8#) +

[ C'0T1CC

U?+'"8 //8 > 8+R# K >+R%R#+)8p^+

# 88# ,A(= 5 6'+ RT+R# -8?> +O+' /)#+%

C>!-//)" 8'-+ 8#=Q] F :GH#]+-'B G/] , G

O

o

'+rp%/8//R%R'))88-+8- +/ ,

LeBars Et Al

Documents

Transcript of LeBars Et Al