Learning Transfer System Inventory research
description
Transcript of Learning Transfer System Inventory research
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Research to Practice:Learning Transfer Lessons
Dr. Ed Holton, CEOJones S. Davis Distinguished Professor of Human Resource,
Leadership & Organization DevelopmentLouisiana State University
1www.LTSGlobal.com (888) 877-9531
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
United States Training Industry• $134 BILLION spent in the U.S. in 2008
(ASTD)– Direct cost only; no trainee salaries/wages
included
• Only 10 – 30% results in changed job performance
2
$100 BILLION IS WASTED EVERY YEAR!
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
But it gets worse…..• Opportunity Cost:
– Research says return of 8:1 is reasonable for good training
• Add salaries and wages of trainees • Thus, the real cost is over
3
$1 TRILLION IS WASTED EVERY YEAR!
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Put This Into Perspective
• U.S. government is spending this much to bail out all the banks and insurance companies
• Imagine what the loss is WORLDWIDE?• How can we tell our CEO’s that we waste 70-
90% of the money they invest?• Why can’t we do better?
4
#1 PROBLEM IN TRAINING TODAY
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Training Transfer
• Definition– The effective and continuing job application of
the knowledge and skills gained in training
5
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Questions:
• How much training transfers into job performance in– Your organization?– Your country?
• Why are we content to accept such poor results?
6
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
The Future of Training
• Training is essential in the global knowledge economy
• But, if we can’t deliver transfer, then training is wasted
• The future of the training profession depends on solving this problem
• It’s time to get serious!!!!!
7
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Dr. Ed Holton, CEOJones S. Davis Distinguished Professor of Human Resource,
Leadership & Organization DevelopmentLouisiana State University
8
Learning Transfer System Inventory
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Learning Transfer System Inventory (LTSI)
• Measures 16 factors– barriers and catalysts to transfer– factors tied to ‘leverage points’’ which are
opportunities for intervention
• A diagnostic tool• An evaluative tool• Grounded in previous learning transfer
research
9
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
LTSI continued
• 5 point Likert response scale(strongly disagree to strongly agree)
• Scales– 11 for specific training program– 5 for training in general
10
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
Latest Developments
• Global validation study– 6,120 respondents– 17 countries (very diverse)– 14 different languages
• Scales work across cultures and languages
11
LTSI Fundamental Structure
12
Ability Motivation WorkEnvironment
X X =
TRANSFER
The 16 LTSI Factors
© copyright Training Transfer Solutions LLC13
Ability
Content Validity
Transfer Design
Opportunity to Use
Personal Capacity
Motivation
Transfer Effort-Performance Expectations
Transfer Performance-Outcomes Expectations
Learner Readiness
Motivation to Transfer
Performance Self-Efficacy
The 16 LTSI Factors
© copyright Training Transfer Solutions LLC14
Work Environment
Supervisor Support
Supervisor Sanctions
Peer Support
Performance Coaching
Personal Outcomes Positive
Personal Outcomes Negative
Resistance to Change
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
• Learning transfer is a universal problem• Factors affecting it have been confirmed
globally• Remarkable similarity in pattern of
responses around the world• No cultural differences detectable
15
Global Findings
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
1. Content Validity– Universally mediocre– Due to cost reductions to drive efficiency??
2. Transfer Design– Highly variable, but often mediocre
16
Leverage Points-Ability
Transfer Is Dead-On-ArrivalWithout These Two Factors
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
3. Personal Capacity– Often mediocre– Trainees are too overworked and stressed to
try new things– Increasing problem?
17
Leverage Points-Ability
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
• Generally motivation to transfer is good• However,
– While trainees report they can change their performance if they try…
– The link between changing their performance and positive outcomes is weak!
18
Leverage Points-Motivation
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
• Most serious issues are in these factors• Reflects:
– Lack of a systemic focus on learning– Over-emphasis on design and delivery– Silo nature of learning and development
departments
19
Leverage Points-Work Environment
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
1. Accountability– No consequences for NOT transferring– Few rewards for transfer
20
Leverage Points-Work Environment
If Transfer Doesn’t Matter Then Can We Blame Trainees?
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
2. Supervisors-Two Patterns– Laissez-Faire
• No proactive support for transfer• No proactive opposition to transfer• THEY JUST DON”T CARE
– Actively Oppose Transfer
21
Leverage Points-Work Environment
Can’t Expect Transfer Unless We Engage the Superviors
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
3. Learning Community– Peer Support can be MORE powerful than
supervisor support– Performance Coaching is usually weak
22
Leverage Points-Work Environment
Need to Systematically Engage the Community of
Learners
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
1. Diagnostic data is a powerful catalyst for change
2. Performance change data is necessary for accountability
23
Leverage Points-The Power of Data
Everything Important in Organizations Is Measured
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC
• Bad News– Traditional training is often systemically
flawed
• Good News– ENORMOUS potential for improved ROI
• Less could be more• Learning Transfer System Audit Checklist
24
Conclusions
© copyright Learning Transfer Solutions Global LLC25
Contact Info:
www.LTSGlobal.com
LinkedIn: Dr. Ed Holton
Facebook.com/LTSGlobal
Twitter: DrEdHolton
(888) 877-9531