LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G....

56
LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Division of Waters

Transcript of LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G....

Page 1: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries

and Gravel Pits

Jeffrey A. Green P.G.

Jeremy A. Pavlish

Minnesota Department of Natural Resources

Division of Waters

Page 2: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Quarries and pits can affect ground-water and surface-water systems in various ways.  •lowering of local ground-water and surface-water levels from mining operations and mine dewatering•changes in turbidity levels in ground water due to blasting and quarry operations•interruption of ground-water conduit flow paths by rock removal•temperature change (thermal impacts) in springs and surface-water streams

 

Page 3: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Previously Documented Impacts

• Lundin and Fretham Quarries, Steele County

• Quarries mined Galena limestone and dewatered to allow dry mining.

• Lundin was in operation from ~1969 to 1987

• Fretham was in operation with continuous dewatering from 1976 to present.

Page 4: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Fretham Quarry, Steele Co.

Page 5: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Documented Impacts (cont.)

• Between 1986 and 1992, three domestic well interferences were filed.

• All three wells were located 1000’ to 1300’ from the Fretham Quarry.

• All three wells were constructed into the Galena and were shallower than the depth of the quarries.

Page 6: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 7: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

• The DNR Division of Waters investigated and determined that the quarry dewatering was the cause of the out-of-water complaints for the three domestic wells

• The company involved agreed to have the homes connected to the municipal water supply

Page 8: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Documented Impacts (cont.)

• LeRoy Quarry, Mower County.

• Sub-water table limestone quarry.

• Quarry dewaters at a rate of about 200 to 800 gpm in order to mine.

• Several dye traces have been performed in and around the the quarry to map both the natural and disrupted ground water flow.

Page 9: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Osmundson Quarry @ LeRoy MN

Page 10: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 11: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

LCMR Study of the HydraulicImpacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits

Page 12: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Why we did this study.

• Quarries and gravel pits are necessary for society.

• Potential exists for impacts to ground water.

• Many LGU’s have questions about the impacts.

• Little information on those impacts.

Page 13: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

The Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Study was funded by the 2001 Legislature as recommended by the Legislative

Commission on Minnesota Resources. Funding is from the

Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund.

Page 14: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Objectives

• Study the relationship between quarries, gravel pits and ground water systems.

• Better understanding of conditions that lead to ground water impacts.

Page 15: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 16: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 17: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 18: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Limestone Quarry Investigations

Page 19: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Golberg Quarry, Olmsted Co.

Page 20: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 21: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 22: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 23: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Kraemer Quarry, Burnsville MN

Page 24: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 25: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 26: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 27: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 28: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Video logging Results- Kraemer & Golberg Quarry Wells

During the spring of 2005, DNR Waters staff used a downhole camera to inspect the 5 observation wells at these sites

Staff inspected both the cased and open hole sections

No deformation or damage to the cased portions of the wells was visible

No obvious impacts to the open hole sections were visible

Preferential (conduit flow) was observed in several of the wells

Page 29: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 30: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 31: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 32: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 33: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 34: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 35: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 36: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 37: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 38: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 39: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Over 90% of the basin feeding the Big Spring now rises in the quarry

Page 40: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 41: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Gravel Pit Investigations

Page 42: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Felton Pit, Clay Co.

Page 43: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 44: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 45: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Leitzen-Grabau Pit in Olmsted County

Page 46: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 47: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 48: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Mathy Donovan Pit in Olmsted County

Page 49: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 50: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 51: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 52: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 53: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 54: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Conclusions

Page 55: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
Page 56: LCMR Study of the Hydraulic Impacts of Limestone Quarries and Gravel Pits Jeffrey A. Green P.G. Jeremy A. Pavlish Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

This information is part of the DNR Waters Hydraulic Impacts of Quarries and Pits report. The full report is available at:

http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/publications/waters/quarries_impacts.html