Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ......

31
Lake temperature and fish populations Gretchen Hansen, WI DNR Jordan Read, USGS Luke Winslow, USGS

Transcript of Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ......

Page 1: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Lake temperature and fish populations

Gretchen Hansen, WI DNRJordan Read, USGSLuke Winslow, USGS

Page 2: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline
Page 3: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Walleye recruitment is declining in Wisconsin

Annual change in age‐0 walleye catch per mileStrong decline (>6.6%)

Decline (0‐6.6%)

Increase (0‐6.6%)

Strong increase (>6.6%)

Page 4: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Largemouth bass density is increasing

Annual change in LMB >8in spring catch per mileStrong decline (>4%)

Decline (0‐4%)

Increase (0‐4%)

Strong increase (>4%)

Page 5: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Temperature as ecological “master factor”

Temperature

GrowthSurvivalReproduction

Nutrient cycling

NP

Page 6: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Is water temperature related to fish community change?

Page 7: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Long‐term temperature records are rareAll Wisconsin Lakes Lakes with > 1 in‐situ observation

Page 8: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Multi‐faceted approach to increase availability of lake temperature data• Citizen monitoring pilot program• Model to hindcast and forecast temperatures for thousands of WI Lakes

Page 9: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

• 48 lakes spanning gradients of size, clarity, location• Hourly monitoring of surface water temperature• Deployed ASAP post‐ice‐out, retrieved as late as possible before ice‐on

1‐2 feet below water surface

Zip ties

Safety ropeComm. 

Alignm

ent

Sensor

This end of the logger must be at least 1 to 2 feet below the water surface

Citizen monitoring

Page 10: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

42 of 48 loggers returned

Citizen monitoring

Page 11: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline
Page 12: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Read et al. 2014. Ecol. Model. 291C: 142‐150

Hindcast and forecast lake temperatures

Page 13: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Read et al. 2014. Ecol. Model. 291C: 142‐150

Hindcast and forecast lake temperatures

CLM!

Page 14: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

x 2300 lakes x 25 years x 3 periods

1989‐20142040‐20642065‐2089

• Max. surface water temp• Mean summer surface temp• Growing degree days• Duration of ice free season• Duration of stratification 

• CV in surface temp, 0‐30 and 30‐60 days post‐ice off 

• Height of water column and days between 19‐23 ⁰C 

• Date at which surface temp> 8.9 ⁰C  and 5 ⁰C

Derived temperature outputs

Model outputs

Page 15: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Contemporary trends in water temperature(1979‐2014)

Page 16: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

What does this mean for fish?

www.basspro.com

GH1

Page 17: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Slide 16

GH1 GH takes over hereGretchen Hansen, 10/22/2015

Page 18: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Water temperature influences fish

Page 19: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Projected future water temperaturesSurface water temperatures Ice‐cover duration

Page 20: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

How do we expect lakes to change?

Mid‐century (2040‐2059) Late century (2070‐2089)

Lose Maintain Gain Lose Maintain Gain

27.2 63.2 9.6 62.3 30.3 7.4

WALLEYE(% of lakes)

Page 21: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

How do we expect lakes to change?

Mid‐century (2040‐2059) Late century (2070‐2089)

Lose Maintain Gain Lose Maintain Gain

27.2 63.2 9.6 62.3 30.3 7.4

WALLEYE(% of lakes)

Page 22: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

How do we expect lakes to change?

Mid‐century (2040‐2059) Late century (2070‐2089)

Lose Maintain Gain Lose Maintain Gain

27.2 63.2 9.6 62.3 30.3 7.4

Mid‐century (2040‐2059) Late century (2070‐2089)

Lose Maintain Gain Lose Maintain Gain

7.4 78.2 14.3 2.6 66.2 31.2

WALLEYE(% of lakes)

LARGEMOUTH BASS(% of lakes)

Page 23: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

From models to management

• Prioritize management actions– Protect resilient lakes– Guide stocking

• Bound realistic expectations– Lake‐specific– Classify lakes

Page 24: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Acknowledgements

• Citizen volunteers, past and present!• CLM coordinators and WDNR biologists• Dan Isermann and Andrea Musch, UWSP• Kevin Wehrly (MI), Pete Jacobson (MN)• Midwest Glacial Lakes partnership• Funding from CLMN, Sportfish restoration funds, USGS NWCCWSC, NECSC

Page 25: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Questions/Discussion

Gretchen [email protected]

608‐221‐6330https://gretchenhansen.squarespace.com

Page 26: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Walleye recruitment predicted by lake morphometry and water temperature

Prob

ability of w

alleye re

cruitm

ent

Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s)

Shoreline development 

factorUpdated from Hansen et al. 2015 CJFAS 72(5): 661‐672

Degree days

Page 27: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Walleye recruitment predicted by lake morphometry and water temperature

Prob

ability of w

alleye re

cruitm

ent

Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s)

Shoreline development 

factorUpdated from Hansen et al. 2015 CJFAS 72(5): 661‐672

Degree days

Page 28: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Largemouth bass abundance predicted by water temperature, lake order, and Secchi

DrainageSeepage

Degree days

Prob

ability of h

igh ba

ss abu

ndan

ce

Lake order Secchi depth (m)

Page 29: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Long‐term fish community changes

Page 30: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Long‐term fish community changes

Page 31: Lake temperature and fish populations · 10/22/2015  · • CV in surface temp, 0 ... Gretchen.hansen@wisconsin.gov 608‐221‐6330 ... Lake area (ha) Conductivity (μS/s) Shoreline

Long‐term fish community changes