l R'OK0A`Zonline.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/neutrino-c03/parke/pdf/Parke.pdf · Î Ï ÐÒÑ4ÓÕÔÂÖ...
Transcript of l R'OK0A`Zonline.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/neutrino-c03/parke/pdf/Parke.pdf · Î Ï ÐÒÑ4ÓÕÔÂÖ...
��� ������ ��� ������������� ���� �� ��� � ���� � ������� ���
!#"%$'&)( $+* , - .0/�$1 2436587:9<;>=
? @BADC E FHG @JI�KMLMK4A�K KNIHO E F�P Q�I+RSLMKT?UKV Q'A�WX@YI+Z\[] ^ ZT_+A`R\I+@Ja bdc�egf h @<RSWiK0A�@XR\I] fjC+Z k I�K0A`R\l m RSn�A�C+Z o�@qprcts�RSu�KMuH@XW<@BAvm c�W<RgA�w] c�K4sDKNl ZxA`Zys{z Z%|SZ}I�ZysDKSax@<Z~wy[�M� � �M� KSIHO �M� � �g�] � E ��e0P Q+G �jbdR\l _�W<Z}l Z}I�A�K4s�@�Avm] � Q�l l K4s�m�S���4�:�:���r���i���}���<�����X���D�����X� �¢¡£��¤�¥�¥�¦¨§
© ����� ��)ªj�«� ¬¬¬® � ¯ ° �H�`� � ���H± ��²������� ° © ³ � ��� � � ³ �® ¯ �´������ � µ�µµ® � � ¶�¶�����·¸º¹�» ¹)¼ ½ ��� ° ¶ ���+�� ��± ± �¾��� ��� � ¯ � ��� �
�¿ � � �������� À �Á�Â� ������Á� Ã�Ã�ÃÄ �� � Å � ���Æ����� ½ ��������� ½ ��� � � � ¿Ç�¢¼ È� ¯ ��� �� É ����� Ê Ë Ì
¯ ��� ��É �� � É ����� Ê Í Ã�Ã�Ã
Î Ï�ÐÒÑ4ÓÕÔÂÖ ×�ÏØÔÂÙ�Ú0ÛÜ u�Q'A a%KNI uÝZ Z~KNw�@<WBm l R'O+@<Þ�Z}O A�R KNa%axR\l l R'O�K0A`Z ß�à áãâ
äÕå�æ ç è é æ é äÕå é çfjC+Z _�KMsDKNl ZxA`Zys@Xê~K0A`@<R\I Q�w�Z~O nÕRNsjADC+Z QHI+@BA�K4s�m G P �l K0As�@qëÂìîí ì+@Yw
ïï ðÇñóò6ðÇñõô ðÇñóòÇö%ñ�ô ö}ñóòÇ÷~øùYú
û ð ô£ò ö ñõô û ö ñõò ö ô£ò ð ñ�ô ÷ùXú
ð ôvò ð ñõô û ö ñõò ö ô£ò ö ñ�ô ÷ùXú
ð ñõò ö ô£òö6ôvòÇö%ñ�ô û ö}ñõò:ð`ô£ò�ðÇñõô6÷ùYú û ö6ô£ò:ðÇñ�ô û ö}ñóò6ð`ôvòÇö%ñ�ô:÷
ùXúðÇñóò6ð`ôvò
üü
? C+Zys�Z ý�þ:ÿ � ayR\w��xþ:ÿ KSIHO �6þ�ÿ � w�@YI��xþ:ÿØF� � Ö �¾Ú Ó� Ï�Ú� Ö �óÖ�� Ö��îÑ Ù�� Ó��ÂÑ0Ö�Ú ÖÆÛTÑ � Ö�Ú Ö ÓóÛä � ß ä�� �� �H��� � ��� á}ß
��� � � �
^ ZT_�A�R\I+@Ja bdc KNI�O f h @XRSWJK0A`@<R\I @YIV w�ax@<WXWJK0A`@<R\I�w� ���� �"! # $ %��� %�"!
� ��"! ��� # $ %�"! %���� �
�vP & '�P ')( k ^ Ü @YI *NKSaTQHQHl â:[bdc h @<RSWiK0A�@XR\Iî[+ ,- . / 0 �21 �4365 ,- / 0 %�21 %�4365f h @XRSWJK0A`@<R\I¢[+ ,- . / 0 � 1 � 3 5 ,- / 0 � 3 � 1 5Ï7�98 / 0 %�21 %�4365 ,- / 0 %�43 %�21:5bdcÁf h @XRSWJK4A�@<R�Iî[Ï;�< + = . / 0 �21 �43>5 ,- / 0 %�43 %�21?5
k l _�W<@�A�QHO+Z nÕRNs � � � � �@BA � � CD � A ß E� ßGF éIHKJMLNPORQSUT �H�� VXW LNPOZY[]\
� A � E� � F é HKJ^LL OUQSUT �H�� VXW LL O Y[]\ _` a b `c ` d d ed a a ba ` c `fhgjiRk lnmPopl qr ots u
v w]x y{z]|P}~x4���4��x ����y��2�P����|����� � � ����� ��� � ��������|�� � ��x�� � |P��}Kx Ü�� � � � � } ¡ �� ¢£ � } ¤¦¥ § ¤©¨ � � ª�}«�¬� ���®����� � �Z���]¯ � � ����� ��� �°¯ z � � ±� ²M³ ´² � µ·¶ ¸U¹»º¥½¼ ¨7¾ ¶4¿¥½¼ ¨ µ � À Ü �K�°¯�Á � ¡ �K�°¯ ©Á]à ¡ Ä ² ¿ ¢ �� µ ² Å ´² µ À Æ ² ¿ �~��¯�Á � ¡ �~��¯ ©Áhà ¡� ² ¾ ´² À ÂÇ�~��¯ � Á � ¡ �K�°¯ � ©Á à ¡ ¾  ² ¿
10−3
10−2
10−1
sin22θ13
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1νµ→νe at δ=π/2 or 3π/2
∆m2
12 = 7×10−5
eV2
∆m2
12 = 1.5×10−4
eV2
P−PP+P
suppressed
CHOOZ
Psolarby� È | �©É ���Ê�Ê��}Z� � �Ë"Ì~Í Â ÎÐÏÐÑ�Ò Ó �K�°¯ � ©Á]à �� � ¯ � Á � ¡ ÔÖÕ Â �Ø× � à ��Ø× � à ¡�Ù Â� � � ² ¿ � �®�]�ÚÁ]à ¡ �®�]��Á � ¡ �K�°¯ ©Á]à � �K�°¯ Û � � Ü ºÞÝß ÝÜ º Ý ß»à]áâ ãåäçæhè�é
���P����� � �����]¯ ê ��ëhw�����ë]w]�«�ʱv �ì�«w �«w�}�|Ê| ¯�|��4��}���¯��]�B��| � � ¯ � �Ê�®|����ʱí�j��� �Ø× � î�«w�}�|Ê| � �ï���°¯�ë � ¯�ë½��|�� î Á � ¯�� �]¯�| ð È �ñ} ò z4���ñ� � �Z��¯�ëó w � �K| î � ôõ÷ö�øù äçæ øûú¬ø;úåüþýjÿ æ�� ú ä���� ø�� ü ÿ� ä� ä æ ü ����� � ø � ü ��� ú¬ø���� ü ��������� ü � úä�� � ����� øÿ � ä ú ������� ü � ü�ü���� ü�� ÿ úåü�ýjÿ æ � ú ä!� ü ���#" ä ý ��� ü � ü ÿ ø " ü$� ø�% �'&� ò � ( È ê y*) +~ð ±µ·�Ø× �¸U¹ º µ � Â-,/. 0 Ñ2143 ¡25�6 ��~��¯ �  Á � ¡ À Ñ , 1 Á � ¡ 7 � 8 � Æ .#9 µ;: ¥ ¡ µ � À Ã�(� <:� ) ± < � ��X× �¿ � ¾ = 0 Ñ>1?3A@ 5�6 ��~��¯ �  Á à � � 1 ,/BC. Á à � 7 � D � ÒE1 9 µF: ¨ � µ � À Ã8) y�� ð�ò ) ± Ü ðBw�� �EG ¢�~��¯ �  Á]à ¡ H 1 , Ñ Áhà ¡ H ��JI � K 9 µF: ¨ ¡ µ � H Â?,L.CM<ONP< y*Q yR) S +jyT( � Q U N^� ( yR<V+WQ yP(�±X Y�ZP[\^] � 1 ,/_ S |a` b c�ed @gfih j Û Ü º Ý kelnm�po @�q à Isr àutwv Ý áX xuy ] z\^] � Ñ ,/. S |{` b c| ¡ � fih j Û Ü º^Ý kJl�m�io @�q à Isr àPtwv Ý áyЯ2|P}�ë½��|�� 7 ÒC1 M w���ë]w�|P} � }�| 1 ô B � ¯"�  ô 1 S |a` }�|�� ó ô
©¯"� È | �¦É
10−3
10−2
10−1
sin22θ13
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1νµ→νe at δ=π/2or 3π/2 at 2nd peak
∆m2
12 = 7×10−5
eV2
∆m2
12 = 1.5×10−4
eV2
P−PP+P
suppressedCHOOZ
Psolarby
� È | �©É ���Ê�Ê��}Z� � � �~��¯ �  Á à ¡ À }�~F� Ý ��� ß Ý��� � Ý � Ý à � ¡ �� Ü º^Ýß ÝÜ º Ý ß à���
� ¯ � ���]� x � £ �«w�| NÞ�� È }��ñ� � ���������åx È ���©��±
� ò^w2| ð È � ð È }�| � � �Z���]¯ ±² Ü ¤©¨^§ ¤¦¥���� × �¡ à ³ � × �� à ³ � ³ ¶4¢� ² Ü ´¤ ¨ § ´¤ ¥ � Å � × �¡ à ³ÊÅ � × �� à ³ � ³ ¶4¢À ² Ü ´¤©¨^§ ´¤¦¥�� Å � × �¡ à ³ ¾ � × �� à ³ Õ ¾ � ³ ¶4¢� òMw�| ò�� ð È }�|Ê� � �����h¯�±² Ü ¤ ¥ § ¤ ¨ ��� × �¡ à ³ � × �� à ³ � ³ ¶4¢� ² Ü ´¤©¨^§ ´¤¦¥�� Å � × �¡ à ³ÊÅ � × �� à ³PÅ � ³ ¶4¢À ² Ü ´¤ ¨ § ´¤ ¥ � Å � × �¡ à ³ ¾ � × �� à ³ Õ Å � ³ ¶4¢� À ��} � �2| �~��ëh¯ � £ �Ø× � à � £ � } ��w2� £ � � x Õ � £ � ±Ü����s� ¢ ¾ �X× � à �C� Ü��s��� ¢ �P�]� � ¾ Ü����s� ¢ �K�°¯ �2�
�
�
� ��
) |2� ����}�|��gQ |P� NB| � � ����¯�|]±w]��� ó ±��E� �M�M�g�ç¯ � ô É | É ô�� ó � � w £ ¯ ���<Ç +U±"w�| ó �û| ��� 1�Ñ>1 _ 1�Ñ K�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�E�C�E�E�E�
Det. 2
The NUMI Beamline
Two functionally identical neutrino detectors
Det. 1
"
Q |®� U |®��|��Ö�Z� }�) |>� ���ì}�|���±w]��� ó ±��E� �M�M�g�û����� � ����� ô £ ¯ � � ô ëñ��z��<Ç +U±"w�| ó �û| ��� 1  Ñ>1C1E1 .
N�}�� � É w � zh|�¯ ��� ê �h� |��¬� �¦É | ) v + È È
< � ÂE. Æ 1 É � �ñ} Â�BEB 1 É �Q |®� NÞ| � � ���°¯�| î Q |®� U |P��|��Ö���ñ} ±w]��� ó ±��E� �M�M� ô ¯�|��4��}���¯�� ô �Ú¯2� ô ëñ��z��<Ç +U±"w�| ó �û| ��� 1  1 . 1 Æ 1
� � ê �Z� (4� ó |P}�¡ |�¯�|Ê}�ë©x � ¯�� ������� � ¯��®|]±
� Q � � + |�¯�|P}�ë©x � ¯"� ���°�¬� � ¯��P|½±
¢ £*¤�£*¥ ¦¨§©¦O¤ ¦Oªu¦ Í ¦O¤�£�« Ì ¦ ˬ®°¯ ®°¯È }�|��P���~���]¯ � | � ����}�|�� |�¯]� � £±/²�³ ´´¶µ ± � ¯�� ·¹¸»º ´�¼¾½ ´¶µ� ¿ À ·¹· Á ¸»Â�à À Ã�Ä�ÅÇÆ À ºÉÈ ·¹¸�Ê˺ ÌËÍ ² ³ ´´Îµ
ÏaÏaÏaÏaÏÐaÐaÐaÐaÐÑaÑaÑaÑÒaÒaÒaÒ ÓaÓaÓÔaÔÕaÕaÕaÕÖaÖaÖaÖ×a×ØaØ
ÙaÙaÙaÙÚaÚaÚaÚ ÛaÛÜaÜÝaÝaÝaÝaÝaÝÞaÞaÞaÞaÞ
ßaßaßaßaßàaàaàaàáaáâaâãaãaãaãaãäaäaäaäaä
åaåaåaåaåæaæaæaæaæ
NORMAL INVERTED
12
31
2
3} Solar
Solar {
<−
−A
tmos
pher
ic−
−>
çè éêµ τeparke@� ·¹¸»º ´ ¼¾½ ´Îµ ë ì í î ´ ïÂÇ�~��¯ � Á � ¡ � Ññð ò ÂÇ�P�]� � Á � ¡ � Ñ Ä ò�K�°¯ � ©Á � ¡ 1 ô/K Ñ 1 ô;K _ 1 ô/KEK Ñ ô 1C1 �~��¯ � ©Á � ¡ò 1 ô Ò 1 ô  1 ô Ñ 1 ô 1 ò�~��¯ � Á � ¡ 1 ô Ò . 1 ô Æ 1 1 ô Æ . 1 ô . 1 �®�h� � Á � ¡�P�]� � Á � ¡ 1 ô _C. 1 ô _ 1 1 ô .E. 1 ô . 1 �K�°¯ � Á � ¡
®°¯ ® 5¦VªP¦ Í ¦O¤�£�«Çó ¬� ` � }Kx4�°¯�ë �«w2| ð È � } ò z4���ñ� � ���°¯�ë ó w � �K| î � î � ��� w � ����©� w�|P} ó � } � � |®��|Ê}Z�^ª2��|�� ëñ��z]|�� � ¯ |Ê����� ó �K| ô� (4� � ����¯�ë � £ � ��|��Þ� x �®}��]�����K|��Ö�Z���]¯ îõô � � � ¯"���|P��|�� ��� } �~��GÊ| ëñ�ìz]|���|®z]|�¯]��} � �Z| �)}�|>� �2�ì}�|��| � ó |P}���� |�¯]� � � | � ó |P}K�Z���~| ô
� ò ��� ( �½���4�Z���]¯�� Ü Á ³ � ¢ £ � }�| � �Uw w���|P} � }Z�Rwhx � £ ��|É ¯�� � � ���n�©�«w2|P} ó � } � � |P��|Ê}Z� ôè>�÷ö � æìä!� ø ������� ÿ%ø� � ä ÿ �ù� úú� üþúûÿ�ü "A� %nö � ú¬ø�û�øÿ øwü#ý©ý�ú ä û�ø��Xø�þ
� � � ���®����� � �����h¯ � � ����� ��� õ é øù � ÿ°ø!ü]ö � ú¬øúûø�ÿ ø!üCý©ý�ú ä û�ø��Xø &� � � | Á ���ÿ��|Ê}�|�¯]� ��� � � � � ¯"� Õ Å �
� ò^w2| �2�ÿ��|P}�|�¯]� ê ��|P} � }Z�Rw2��|�� ëñ��zh| � ��� �]��� � � � | Á
U |Êëñ|�¯�|P} � �Öx £ �ñ} òñ�ú` ���ñ� � �����]¯�±� ð � ¯�¯��©� ���°�¬�Z��¯�ëh������w w���|Ê} � }«�Rw]xt�����
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0P(ν) (%)
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
T[P
(ν)]
(%)
L = 130 km, E = 250 MeV
T+, sin22θ13 = 0.05 (upper)
T+, sin22θ13 = 0.0427 (lower)
T−, sin22θ13 = 0.0575 (upper)
T−, sin22θ13 = 0.0490 (lower)
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0P(ν) (%)
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
T[P
(ν)]
(%)
L = 130 km, E = 250 MeV
no solution
no solution
¢ £*¤�£*¥ ¦¨§©¦O¤ ¦Oªu¦ Í ¦O¤�£�« Ì ¦ ˬ®°¯ ® 5ãåä��!��� ü�� � �n��� ö � ú¬ø�û�øÿ°ø!ü#ý¦ý�ú ä û�ø��Øø �«è ø æ�� ü æ ü]ö�ø æ � ø�ÿ � øwü ��� � ú¬ø úpÿ �è ý æ�� ýåü ÿ ö �Øø � ÿ�ü ��� ü��]ø�� ü � ø!ü�� ä! ü ö � ø " ü�ú¬ø � ü� Øü æ ú¬ø ú " ü��»ühö;ü�ú¬ø � ©ý � ü æ ü�� � ú " úåü æ ü � úûÿ�ü æ�� ö � ú¬ø�û�øÿ°ø!ü#ý¦ý�ú ä û�ø��Øø!ü#�Öø æ û�ü� ·¹¸�º°Ê ½ � ·¹¸»º ½�� µ � Å°Âùº� ����� � ��� � ë ! " ½ ´ # $ "&% ')(+* �-, # . /-02143657# 8 9:8 ; :<�= > :<�? 5 @ ! A&%4B C $ AD% ')(+* ; , C . /-021E3657# 8 9F G�HJI-H KMLONQP�RSNUTWVYXYZ\[^]YV_Ta`b`cTWV)[�`edNQfW`�ghJi�jU]�gLlk�monQprq�mQs�KMtomomQsvuwux y z { |~}}U� � � ��&� }��U��� }D� � �� ���� y z ����� � } | � } � }S� | }U� � � � }��� � � � �� � �U��� � ���� � ����� � � �� ���� z � }}U� �U��� } �O� � } � � � }��� � } ����� }&� ���� ��� � y z � � x y ���� ���¡ ¢¤£+¥ t¦¨§ ¢ª©}¬« � y ®¯� � � � ��� ® � z ° ��±7²6³ ´eµ¶ · G¸H ¹ º¼» ½�I�H ¾U¿ÁÀ�ÂÄÃŽ�Æ_Æ�¿ ÇÉÈ�ÇÊIrË�HÌI Í Î Ï¶ ½ÊÐ�Ë ¾rG�H Ñ º�»DÇ2È�ÇÊIÒË�HJI Ó ÔÕ×Ö¶ · G�Ø�» Ù tÚ Û Ü�Ý¼Ü Í Þ (àß áãâåä�æ\ä æ\çèä éëêíìãîðï�ä+ñåñvñò È�ÇÊI óôDõ ó�ö ÂÄÐ�¾�HJIÒÃ÷Gð½ÊÐ�øÉH ù Õ-ú ½ÊÐ�Ë û Õ-ú ü
ý ÇÉÆÄØÁ¾�Â_Ç�Ð ¾�Ç ¾rG¸Hl»×H HOþÿØ�½ ¾ÒÂwÇ�Ð�»���Âwø�иÇÊI-ÂÄÐ�ø ¾�HJI�� »DÇÉÈ� ��� t� � � � � �� � � � � �Ï � � ÃeÇ�» ��� � Ô úÏ
�� � � � � � ���Ï � � ÃeÇ�» � � � Ô úÏ Ý· G¸H ÆĽʻ¬¾&Hlþ�Ø�½�ÆwÂY¾S¿ ø2Â���HO»�Ø�» ½ÊÐ HOþÿØ�½ ¾ÒÂwÇ�Ð ÇÉÈ�¾rG�H È�ÇÊI��ò������ ü »× Р��� ò������ ü ÃÌÇ�»�� ò������ üF G� Ã~G ÃŽÊÐ àH Ø�» HOË ¾ÒÇ »×ÇÉÆ���H ÈWÇÊI �"!$# ¾ ÂÄÐ%��ÇÉÆ&��Hl» ½Ó ò������ ü F G¸Â Ã÷G øÉÂ&��Hl» Ø�» ¾SF Ç » Ç2Æ ØÁ¾ÒÂwÇ�Ð�» ½ÊÐ�Ë » H̾׾�ÂÄÐ�ø¾rG¸Â » »�þÿØ�½�I�H I-ÇÿǾ ¾ÒÇ 'ÅHÌI�Ç øÉÂ&��Hl» Ø�»�¾rG�H àÇ�Ø�Ð�Ë�½�I׿ ÇÉȾrG¸H ½ÆwÆwÇ�F HOË I-HÅøÉÂwÇ�Ð(!
%*)�* îðï�ä æ ç ä,+ (.- æ�î0/1+ ä32 -54*Oì*- *Jæ6/ æ ì æ7/v(8+:9¶ ý Ç F7ÂY¾rG Ï » Â_ø�Ð�» ÇÉÈ;�6< Õ¶ ½ÊÐ�Ë Ï À+Ç�»-»×Â= �ÂwÆwÂY¾�Â_Hl» ÈWÇÊI »×Â Ð Õ Õ-ú¶ F H Gð½���H  РøÉHOÐ�HÌIc½�Æ > *O(6âvì æ7/å(8+è* !
? ò A@ � CB üò A@ � CB ü F G�ÂÄÃ÷G  »&¾ÒÇ àH ÃÌÇ%� À�½�I-HOË F ÂY¾rGDFE G GIH J GLKNMPO GRQSDUTWV KXGZYN[\V^] D_MP[\Q `
� � a ? ò @ � B üò @ � B ü `
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.50.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
P(ν) (%)
CP
[P(ν
)] (%
)
∆θ/θ (%) for L =295 km, E = 1 GeV
(a) (∆θ/θ)12
0
0
3
3
5
5
7
6
8
0
−1
(c) (∆θ/θ)13
−3
3
3
3
5
4
6
7
8
no solution
(d) (∆θ/θ)14
1
no solution
3
35
56
7
8
(b) (∆θ/θ)34
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
0
0
910
1215
910
1215
910
1215
CP(+)
CP(+)
CP(−)
CP(−)
0.05
0.02
0.05
0.02
¶ �A< Õ Ô Õ b c Í Ü"dIe ò ½f +Çg��H ü Í c Í Ü"d0h ò àHJÆ_ÇOF ü HCi Õ
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.50.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
P(ν) (%)
CP
[P(ν
)] (%
)
∆θ/θ (%) for L =295 km, E = 1 GeV
(a) (∆θ/θ)12
0
20
0
10
CP(+)
CP(+)
0
(c) (∆θ/θ)13
10
3
12
1
20
25
17
6
15
6
no solution
(d) (∆θ/θ)14
−1
no solution
15
13
10
10
20
25
13
(b) (∆θ/θ)34
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
no solution
0
0
CP(−)
CP(−)
5−2−3
10
15
2
−5
7
7
12
7
7
12
25
0.05
0.02
0.05
0.02
YjM^Q Ï ?lk Ïnm ojp q TWV^M^Q r\s t¶ u »× иø » ÂÄÐ Õ Ï Õ-ú Ü�Ýwvnx y z ò Ü Ý y ü z ò Ü Ý{x ü}|����� } �O��~ ���� �
�U��� } �O��~ } �� �� �U��� } � }S� �U��� } �O� � � � ����� } � ~ ���}S� z ��� � � �U��� } � ~ } �}U� z �g� �� µ � � � µ � ��� � � µ �%���6�� µ � � � µ �A� ��� � µ �Å{,�C�� µ �A� � µ ��� ��� � µ �7� ����A����� ���l�����~�
#SÈ »×Â Ð Õ Ï Õ-ú � Í ¾rG¸HlÐ ¾UF Ç »×ÇÉÆÄØÁ¾�Â_Ç�Ð ÈWÇÉI Ô ú½�I-H I�HJÆĽ�¾�HlË )¿ %5� B��/×0 � ���w�R� ~ ���}S����w�R� ~ } �}S� %5� / �/-0¶ �� ½Êà ¾ ½ ¾ ¡ »-ÃÌÂwÆwÆ ½ ¾�Â_Ç�Ð ¢ ½ £� Øj� |¤ ��¥ �¦���j§¨��©ª©��«§�¬Q�W��¬�g¬��%�®©¯�÷�%�®©ª°\�±�~� µ
² ý ÇÉÆÄØÁ¾�Â_Ç�Ð |¶ î�æ ³ ´�µ,/åâåâ�î�æ7/1¶8+ · º/åß ìèß 2 ä�æ ä�ï\ß /1+ äU»
? YjM^Q k Ïnm YjM^Q k ͦm? q [¼Y k Ͻm YjM^Q ¾
� �%� ���®¿À�÷�Á���÷�Á§¨� �\� §¨�\�" ��¬ÄÃÄÅ �¶ Æ æ î_+;¶�æ ç ä�ï Ç È_É 2 ä�æ ä�ï\ß /1+èäU»? q [¼Y k Ͻm q [\Y ¾
Ê�ËfÌ ��©�Í�Î%° ¬��%�:�=�¦Ïª¬$¬Ñк� °AÍÓÒA�«Ï�§¨�AÏ�Ô_Õ ÔªÖ ©��«¥ �}¥ ×À�®©�к�¼�AÎ%�ÓØ�,�}ÒA�\¬�� �ÁÍ�Ϫ¬�Í�Î%° Ì Í�Ï�� ×"�¨¬�к�®�}Î Ù ��©Ú ��� �
k ͦmZÛ k Ͻm TÜQ Ý ¾¢ Þ�ßÀà8á âªãÄä åPáCâ¨å¼änæºåPänç£èÀâêéëä%ì åíé£ìjîCá ï¹éëáñð®Þ7ð�î}ï%ß ò Þ�ßì¹ä�â à8á ó¹áñâêáñð¨ò é£ì¹á¦ó(ôlõ"á�á ön÷ ø ù ú è¹û üÄì¹áCý"â¦þ
ÿ�� õjõ"ü������ ÷ ��� ÿ ø� � û ì¹á¦èÀâêð^é£ì¹änç=ágå^å ó¹ä%è¹àjçëá � � ó¹ágî�Þ�ß � ágÞnî�âêänð�å�ô ���� õ ���� ú è øUÞ½î�â�ä½ðíßIô ��� õ ���
��� ���� � � � �� � ! "$#�� #�%'&)(�*,+-&/. 0
13254765894;:=<>2547?@2BADCE2F:�GIH-CKJDL-2MLNA=HO89P�QRPSHSTVUMWYXZUV[�WN\]�^-_S894;:/`aCbL-cSLO894;:�GdCbL5Ae894fHO8gP�Q7PSHSTBUMWYX5XghNU5U<>CbL-25ij2BAD2F:/k�^lLOmMiB2Zno2M:/pq254riV8sHO89P�QRPSHSTVUNh5U-X9WYXZU tvu w x y{z}|�~o�B���)� � x z�� � � ��|�����x y{z�|�~o�j���)�
0 1 2 3 4 5 6JHF P(νµ → νe) [%]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Nu
MI P
(νµ
→ ν
e) [
%]
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
EJHF = 0.8 GeVENuMI = 1.5 GeV
õ3é ò é=ç Þ7ð â�ä ön÷ ø � ú è¹û üS� � � ön÷ ø � ú è¹û ü�� ��
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
0 1 2 3 4 50
1
2
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
JHF P(νµ→νe) [%]
NuM
I P(ν
µ→ν e)
[%
] JHF neutrino vs. NuMI anti−neutrino
(d)
(a)
EJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 1.5 GeV
EJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
(b)
ENuMI = 2.0 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
(c)
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
sin22θ13 = 0.09
0.05
0.02
� é óXâ¨ï änæLâ¨ïNá � ée�ÁÞ7ð�å�ô ������� �� � ����� �� ���$�
õ3é£ìjîCá �¡ ï�Þ�ù%á 䣢¤¢Uä%åíé&âêá åPér�%ì ú � î�ÞnìjîCá�ç=ç£Þ7âêé=äÁì þ
tvu w x y{z}|�~o�B���)� � x z�� � x y{z�|�~o�j���)�
0 1 2 3 4 5 6JHF P(νµ → νe) [%]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6N
uM
I P(ν
µ →
νe)
[%
]
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
EJHF = 0.8 GeV
ENuMI = 1.5 GeV
õ3ᥢ_Þfð¨Þ6â�é=ä%ì änæ*÷ é=á�ð¨Þ7ð¨î«ï¹éëá¦å¥¦e¦;¦ � Þ6â�é=ä änæõ3çë䣢8ágåñô� �:� �§ ¨ � �:� �§ © ª¬« �V® ¯ °�±��²�V³{´¬�3µ ¯ � �N® ¶°O±·�²�V³{´¬�3µ ¶¸ �%�º¹ª� » ¼9½ ¾V¿qÀÂÁ Ã Ä ÅÆ Xgh Ç ÈºÉ�ÊÌË Æ XghÅ ÍÏÎ Ð7Ñ�ÒÓ É·ÔfÉ�ÊYÉ·Ô Ð È Ò3Õ7Õ×Ö Ð Ô=È ¹ª� Ò3ÑOÐ Ô/Ø ¼�Ù%� È ¹$ÀÌÚÜÛ Ô=ÈÝÊ Ð É·Ô É ÚÞ½ ¾B¿ ¼àß�À�áâ ã Ûfäæå ÕrÒ ¹ Ø �ç¹ ÑYÕ É ä"�'¹ Ò Ê Ð Ééè â ê Ûfäæå Ñ Ó Ò3Õ7Õ �ç¹ ÑYÕ É ä"�'¹ Ò Ê Ð É á � é óXâ¨ï änæ ÿ ágìjîCéëç å ���
����� �� � �I��� �� ��� �Þ6â å�Þ½ò á Ë·ë ì Í ãÄá ï�Þ�ùÁá Þnì é£ó¹á¦ì%â�é�â�ß ���� �� í �I��� ��é ò ¢jçëé=á¦å å^ò Þfçëç(ã é óÀâ®ï þ
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
0 1 2 3 4 50
1
2
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
JHF P(νµ→νe) [%]
NuM
I P(ν
µ→ν e)
[%
]
JHF neutrino vs. NuMI neutrino
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
(a) (b)
EJHF = 0.8 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
(c) (d)
EJHF = 0.6 GeV
õ3ᥢ_Þfð¨Þ6â�é=ä%ì ¢NðêägùÀé óNá¦ó Ëoë ì Í ¯ïî�ð ñ ò Ëoë ì Í ¶oó�ô �\á¦å�â õ3ᥢ.Þ7ð¨Þ6â�é=ä%ì Þ6â � åêîCé=çëç£Þ6â�é=ä%ì û ÞAý¹é ò èjò
�Lä%ìõ�ná�ð'�SÞ½åPá�ç=é£ì¹á æ ä½ðSú èNû ü
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
0 1 2 3 4 50
1
2
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
JHF P(νµ→νe) [%]
NuM
I P(ν
µ→ν e)
[%
]
JHF (L=295 km) neutrino vs. NuMI (L=915 km) neutrino
ENuMI = 1.875 GeVEJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 2.5 GeV
ENuMI = 1.875 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
(a) (b)
EJHF = 0.8 GeVENuMI = 2.5 GeV
(c) (d)
EJHF = 0.6 GeV
�\áCâ^âêá�ð åPᥢ.Þ7ð¨Þ6â�é=ä%ì Þ6â å�Þ½ò á � öo�lþ÷ ér�%ïNáñð � �nä3äXóÞ÷õ�*Þ7ðø�náñð � à.Þ½ó æ ä½ð å�â®Þ6â�é å�âêé î�åñþ
� � �� Þ6â Þ �RäÁìõ�náñðù�SÞ½åíá�ç=é£ì¹á ú è¹û ü
0 1 2 3 4 5 6NuMI P(νµ → νe) [%]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
NuM
I P(ν
µ →
νe)
[%
]
L = 915 km, E = 1.875 GeV
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
0.02
0.09
0.05 = sin22θ13
÷ éëáñð®Þ7ð�î}ï%ß åíáú¢_Þ7ð®Þ6âêéëä%ì �nä3äÀó àFèÀâ ú � û�%è�Þfð¨Þ½ì%â�á�ágó þ
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
0 1 2 3 4 50
1
2
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
JHF P(νµ→νe) [%]
NuM
I P(ν
µ→ν e)
[%]
∆θ/θ [%] for positive and negative ∆m2
13
JHF neutrino vs. NuMI anti−neutrino
0.5 0.3
0.3
(d)
0.7
−0.3
−0.3−0.5
3
3
−0.7
5
(a)
EJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 1.5 GeV
EJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
(b)
3
3
5
7
7
−3
5
−3
−5
−7
−3
−3−5
−7
58
−10
10
−5
−5
−8
ENuMI = 2.0 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
(c)
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
sin22θ13 = 0.09
0.05
0.02
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
∆m2
atm > 0
∆m2
atm < 0
0 1 2 3 4 50
1
2
3
4
5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
JHF P(νµ→νe) [%]
NuM
I P(ν
µ→ν e)
[%]
∆θ/θ (%) for positive and negative ∆m2
13
JHF neutrino vs. NuMI neutrino
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.6 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.8 GeV
(a) (b)
EJHF = 0.8 GeVENuMI = 2.0 GeV
(c) (d)
50
40
30
35
25
50
40
35
30
25
EJHF = 0.6 GeV
30
25
40
20
40
4030
25
20
40
4030
25
20
30
25
20
30
25
20
30
25
20
25
ü % #�*õýþ. ÿ'#�* (�ý�+$% ý 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6JHF P(νµ → νe) (%)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6N
uMI P
(νµ →
νe)
[%
]
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
ENuMI = 1.5 GeVEJHF = 0.6 GeV
w/o av.
av. (20%)
1
0 1 2 3 4 5 6JHF P(νµ → νe) [%]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Nu
MI P
(νµ
→ ν
e) [
%]
∆m2
13 > 0
∆m2
13 < 0
EJHF = 0.8 GeV
ENuMI = 1.5 GeV
w/o av.
av. (20%)
2
�lì¹á�ð$��ß � ù%áñð®Þ��né£ìõ� ó¹ä3á¦å¼ú � û á��8á¦î�â åPᥢ_Þfð¨Þ6â�é=ä%ì þ
õ�� û û � ��� ô� � � � ���� � ~·��� ��� � � � � ��� �"!$#�% �é å & � � ú ' ��� ø(� � 䣢¤¢8änð*)¨è�ì¹é+)-,Áþ û ï . / æ10nç£ó ó .¥�2.gì .ñð3&½î4, é65�5^è . î7&½ì 89. 5:02;�ù<.¦ó
= é+)®ï ò è ;>)êér¢�;?. ò .@&25^èXð�.¦ò .¦ìA)35B02C �ED F ��� ôG@HJIKHú .7LM)�NPORQ 0 &$QTS � Q<)�OR�VU .7LM)�NPO6QW0 &X) � 5�Y$Z\[ &^]_Z`= O+)3a;R&EN$�2. b &�):)c.dN .���.7Y4) egf"� hU .7LM)�NPORQ 0 &�) & aWOr�Aa .�Nji ö�f = O>)ka 5Pb &E;l;?.dN b &�)P)�.�N.d��.@Y4)jO65 h�� mnm`o��poqirU û ÷�OlC`YsaW0A5*.@Q Y7&XNP.tCuL ;l;+,vZw xzy m|{}U L [ o~8�0$)ka QW.7LM)�NPO6QW0A5�O65'�z0�0MS C10$NS OR5�)cO6Qõ�ALWO65�a O6Qõ� )3a . b &25P5ja Ol.dN3&XNcY�aA, ¢WNP0@��O6S .@S
ë ì �� ¯ î�ð ñ ò ë ì �� ¶oó ô Zw x2y m|{VU L [ o�0AQ . Q .7L�)PNPORQ 0A5 &$Q�S 0AQW.&$QA)cO�{qQ .7LM)�NPORQ 0A5�OR5'�20�0MS C�0$N S .�)c.dNkb ORQ O6Qõ� � °O± &$QTS ��Zh�ORb Ol;R&XN )�0 x2y m�{ �xzy m &$QTS U L [ oV{ �U L [ osZw � ��y � ��� � z����g|�� ��y{y���� |·� y2�|�\�j�¡�Z||���B� � �n�p���7���n�`�u��� � �9�n�<�^�K�_�X��� ���