KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs...

28
, 30 , 2 , 2018 1439 271 , 30 , 2 , 271 297 , 2018 1439 : 7677 1658 1 , 2 20 12 1438 ; 11 06 1439 : , , , , 196 , , : , , , , , , : , , _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Organizational conflict management requirements in girls private schools at Buraydah city and their impact of the performance of functional teachers from their perspective Alyia Mohammed Ismail Sharaf (1) , and Awatif Ali Alsaif (2) Al Qussaim university (Received 11/09/2017; accepted 27/02/2018) Abstract: The phenomenon of conflict management in any workplace relates to various interactions between differences in terms of cultural, behavioral and educational factors. In schools, the leadership is responsible for preventing conflict by addressing, identifying and taking action in order to resolve it. The study aims to identify the most important organizational conflicts in terms of administration requirements. In addition, the leadership has to identify the impact of conflict management in schools on the functionality of teachers. The study used descriptive methods. The study sample was made up of 196 teachers from primary, intermediate and secondary private schools. A questionnaire was used for data collection. The most important results of the study are as follows. Firstly, there is the importance and needs of conflict management requirements in the schools in terms of effective communication, good relationships, a good climate of effective regulatory procedures, and democratic leadership. Secondly, there is insufficient knowledge of organizational conflict in school management at the school leadership level. Thirdly, there are no significant differences between the impact of conflict management in terms of the education and experience of the school leadership. The study offers some recommendations to limit the sources of conflict between teachers in schools. Keywords: school leaders, organizational climate, Conflict. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ 1 (1) Professor of educational administration poster, Department of Foundations of Education, Faculty of Education, Al Qussaim university. : Dr.alyia @yahoo.com e-mail: 2 (2) Assistant Professor of Management and Educational Planning, Department of Foundations of Education, Faculty of Education, Al Qussaim university.

Transcript of KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs...

Page 1: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 271 –

�� �������� ��� ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2�" " , 271 − 297 ,2018��1439� � $�%:7677−1658�

������� �� ��� ����� ����� ������� ����� � ��� �� ��� ������

�� �!"#�$�%& '�()�� *����+,���# �-.$ ,� �/�"��

01 2�&/ � �3 ���&416$ ,8�9�� :� 2�;� ,� <& = � 8>�)&426

)*+,�� ��$�- � . /0�� � 120�12�1438;� /0�� 3415 . 11�06�1439� �

@�A�9��: )6�� �7� 89:�;� <�$ ����=>� ?� ��@�:A�� B9C��@:��5 D�*E:��5 ���F:�� ���*:G B�H�IJ�� 3K . L�-$5 ��*4M L� �N O�P�� ��)6�=�,Q5 )R=� S5 T:U��$5 TV%��W5 ��$�X:$ �FA O�P�� �R-�$ �6��*1 Y$ Z�F:� [:�� �I% �� \*I ]5 �� 8 �65 ,��C�= �,��F )� S �� ^ _W ��I�%

O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$ ,`%� �� [a*b0:�� 0��� ��I�% �� c$ A:�I�5 ,[@*N��� B\���� d��S eC `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W `�X�G� eC 8��:��5R f �I�% �� �0*C cE�5 ,[@g���196 � �a*��:�� 3h���� i�ja� �a��$� [k� :]�– lI:�� −mG��j�� � ,��I�% �� L��S �G�4:�I]� c�G�K5 ,��g�n� `%� ���

c�gV5�I�% �� fk�:G _W : o�*p D�p ��*M��,a�� L���*15 ,q���= [�a*b0V r�0$5 ,�*G�HGW B�19C5 ,q��= q�+V� Y$ `%� �� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$ �=�V�*FaG ,�� L%��s� t � �g�A5 `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W �=�,Q u,G�*I% , L%��W `��X�G� . ��0*��� ����=S ?� �*k�+�hW ���]� B�v w5��= -V ]

_W tx�V YRk��S eC O�P��� �*a*��:�� ��h���–Lyn� �,`%� �� ?a���� ? O�P�� Z*��IS Y$ z�� B�*g:�� {�4 �I�% �� cg5S5 |

��C��'�� �/�!��:`%� �� L��1 ,[a*b0:�� r�0�� ,�P�� O| _________________________________________________________________________________

Organizational conflict management requirements in girls private schools at Buraydah

city and their impact of the performance of functional teachers from their perspective

Alyia Mohammed Ismail Sharaf(1), and Awatif Ali Alsaif (2)

Al Qussaim university (Received 11/09/2017; accepted 27/02/2018)

Abstract: The phenomenon of conflict management in any workplace relates to various interactions between differences in terms of

cultural, behavioral and educational factors. In schools, the leadership is responsible for preventing conflict by addressing, identifying and

taking action in order to resolve it. The study aims to identify the most important organizational conflicts in terms of administration

requirements. In addition, the leadership has to identify the impact of conflict management in schools on the functionality of teachers. The

study used descriptive methods. The study sample was made up of 196 teachers from primary, intermediate and secondary private schools. A

questionnaire was used for data collection. The most important results of the study are as follows. Firstly, there is the importance and needs

of conflict management requirements in the schools in terms of effective communication, good relationships, a good climate of effective

regulatory procedures, and democratic leadership. Secondly, there is insufficient knowledge of organizational conflict in school management

at the school leadership level. Thirdly, there are no significant differences between the impact of conflict management in terms of the

education and experience of the school leadership. The study offers some recommendations to limit the sources of conflict between teachers

in schools.

Keywords: school leaders, organizational climate, Conflict.

_________________________________________________________________________________

�1� }%�~�� ����� L%��s� v�:IS )*+,�� ��$�- �*��� �*�X| (1) Professor of educational administration poster, Department of

Foundations of Education, Faculty of Education, Al Qussaim

university.

�5�X�s� �y��: Dr.alyia @yahoo.com e-mail:

�2� C�H�� m��� l*FA:��5 L%��s� v�:IS )*+,�� ��$�- �*��� �*�X| (2) Assistant Professor of Management and Educational Planning,

Department of Foundations of Education, Faculty of Education, Al

Qussaim university.

Page 2: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 272 –

���D� �L� ��N O�P��� 3ja� ����*4M 3�K . L��-$5

��@�:A�� B9C�@:��5 D*E:��5 ��F:�� ��*:G B�HIJ�� )6��=�,Q5 )R=� � S5 )6� �7� 89:;� <$ ���=>� ?

���ap _W �=����s�%�5�>� ; �=���0:�� _W t�J��� ���� )R0* \*= O�P��5 ���+:��5|

B\b0���� 3��K . ���-$ O�P����5, � ���:V5 TV��:H$5 T��X�S, �H�IJ�� e�C �%��Q� Y��4:V )Q Y$5

?�$���� }�I eC5,)Rk��S5 )V �vW T0$ L��=s� YXa�5 Y�$ q �:�$ % 1 �-= ,�z*zg L%+ T�$ 3$��:��

�S . O�P�� �t:H$ �� �,� �I% $ � �*�C�@�� Y$ eCS �*�aC �*�S �RbV �0 Y$5 ,L *- �,��F TV%��W c� �vW

m���� k�,�� B���@K ) S Y$ �V [:�� O�P�� L%��W |� ,�*aH��2010 ,"102�|

? O�P�� _W ���X@�� `%� �� L�bG c0��4V 15����W5 ���� 3�$�C O�P��� iS t��V �� *�,V L�bGd,

��%�- T0$ u�A:�� Z�5 ���� e�C 3*�� ��-55 ,��� ���@K k�, �y�:�V L����$ L��bG5 ,m%��s� �x��C5

3 ,�*G�HGs� B9C�@:�� Zh�+V �*�*4M �*zg L� �N 3�;�� D*E:��5 � �:�� �5% eC �b=�za�� ��%5�5 L%��W ��F+$ L����� L�b0�� ��� l4V%� 15 ,�I% ��

O�P��,W 5 %��1 t��;S5 �*��W ZG�- O�P�� i� �] TV%��s �I�$ �-�h }�0 iS5 ,�*4�I u�A:�� Y$

T*�C d��,��5 T0$� ,L��,��5 L ������2013, "200�, q�g�� �6��*15 �ab0�� L%��W 8 R:HV O�P�� L%���=

q4,$ t:H$ _W O�P��, ���@��5 T�*= o�p�$ 3 3;�� T0$ ?�$ t:H$ eC ��*���= L���� 8 � �ab0��

�R*= ?�$���� 8� S5 �R=� S �*,z:� �6d�@K5 �ab0��| [:�� B�19��� Y$ L ,�$ �X4� `%� �� -V5

� 5S 3X~ m�JV� Y�$ O�P��� B]��h ��-5 _W �; ����h�$ Y��$ %��F:V [��:�� B����1�0:��5 B���@��A�� O�P���� ����h�$ _W ���I% �� �����=S ?�� 89:��;]�

b0:��[a*, ��- . L���4$ �QJ�� m���5 k�H��� 3�a��� T0C f:0�5 Y�C ��9; Y$ )���� y�� �*a*b0V B9X~$

���% � C, Z�*E:��5 d��>� B] ��$ ���@AG� [ 5 ���*-�:Gs� B��:H��$ ����@AG�5� ,m5���=%�2014,

"9�, �=��s� W _W ��@0�� lE��� ?a���� `�Hh� V5 @0�� . �,j�� %�~�� ;�� �4��I  X�0�� � e�C �

L��*,�� %5� ¡�� �0 5 ,[@*N�� )Rk��S � DQ�V5 eC d��S

?a���� )Rh5%5 ��0��� ��4�I5S ���W�| 5�� ��4V O�P���� L%��W Z*����IS � ���:V 85���b�� �

��@�:A�� �1���5 ¢�*h ; _W ��I% �� �k�1 ����� �1 £ � o�IS �� A:I� �0N O�P�� L%��s �� TGS T0$ � ) �H

T�0$ ���5 O�P��� 3�*�,V . LD4K L%+, ����� )�Q i> 5S 85���b�� {��� D��E:� ����*:G ���;� o���I>

¤ ��� D��p i��X� ] ��1 q5>� o���I>�; vW W L%��W i

Page 3: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 273 –

� � o�IS eC P:,V ]5 �G5��� x*a:V O�P��, 15Y$ ¥3K %��S� ,��/��5 )*���� 4C2009," " 270 −

275; ,¦@F+���$ 2010 " " ,395 −396 ¦@F+���$ ; ,i��a0��52014 " ,16 �O�P��� L%��W Z*��IS _W [�:��

3ja:V . i5��:�� o�IS5 ,�F�H��� �� A:I� o�IS, 5lI�� 3�� o�IS5 ,���$���� o��IS5 , o��IS

Z0�:��5 ,�$5�H�� o�IS, o�IS i�:jh�4�� ��,V5B�,���, 5$ A:H� k�1 T�M>� <�-��:� �I% �� 8��

. §�v5 �R@1$ YC �C%�+:���5 h �15 ,TV�*h9g T*�W ���� k�1 %�RN5 O�P��� )1��@:� ���*:G ��I% ��

¨�© 1 t�;S L � - B9X~$C _W ��I% �� w�FG Y�R*�C L�F*H�� Z�+�5 [-%�n� <a:��� |

5 O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$ ) S � ^ YXa�.: 1 − q�+V]� B�*�aC 3*�@V [:��� 3�jª L%5 ���

�I% �� . �����5 �*a*��:�� )b0�� ��$ ��,¢�*h iW � ��k�, ����bG Ld���@K ���*,^ . q����@�� %5 ���� ���I% ��

��� q�+V]�m �*,^ zG ?�$���� �R- T*-V . T�4:� ���I% a�� �C����� 8� �� >�«� ,[��a����5 i�H��h

2013 ,"247 � q�+�V]� 3k�I5 <$ 3$��:�� q9; Y$j� ��\ )Rk��S )*C V . )RHV [:�� � ) %�� Y$ �x�

��R*= ¨�$ �G]�5 �I% a�� d\:G]�,��*���=5 q�+�V]� [0�ViS iX� . <*¬ B� �7]� ��%��a:�I]� �,�5

q���4:��5 }�~��� ��� m�J�� _W �K%�~��� . v��©�

B�%��,�� ��0��� �5��� <=%5 ,Ta*b0V5 3a��� �,��:�� 3a���5���@�� �5� | 2 − s� B���19��� ���*a0V �*G�H��G ���V [��:�� Y��$ 3$����L�QJ�� �$b0$ 3;�� ��@�� B� �7�5 }�I .

3a���,= Y� <$ 3a��� YXa� �R,��M Y���;­� ��,��F Ld�0 ��$ YH�h� *@:H�V5 ,) �� �,V5 ) ��� ¦b^

����=S �G�K d�I B�y; Y$ )® � ,B�C�¬ 5S � ¦V��:�5 YC §�v ���M )R4���F� ���:�I]�5 ,)R=5�N L�C��$

e�C 3a���5 ) �C�~a `�Hhs�5W )6��-�h O�4��� ,�F�����2007 ,"295 �ª=s� B�19���x�K�V �*G�H�G

eC��4G�- �%��4:C� ?�$����� m�0��� ZG�U� �9�aX$ � ,m���� ZG����V5 - ��; eC C�H�5 m ?� �5��V

5 ���=>�V�� eC <�~ ��RU� �*H�0V °�*� �� ,B�%��4 ��H�=W5 ?�I5±��� ?� [�C\U� 3�a��� �5% ��;5

���s q���� )® � L%��4��5 %�X:]� �5%«� ,²�� ��2012, "168 � ��³* ���; eC "�^ �*C��� L��*,��5

���*,z:� [C���¬ 3X~�� 3��a�V ����z:$ ���@��:$ 3��aCs� B��19��� )�C� q9; Y$ L-��� 8� >� �*G�H�G

´��W 3X~ | 3 − [a*b0:�� r�0��¢*h ��R:*�C�= �I% �� a:HV

��U��$ e�C L% �,��5 , k�H�� [a*b0:�� r�0�� §�v Y$ [�:�� 3�a��� B��C�¬ �*�C�= eC5 ,�4�+�� B9X~�� l���� �=�V t $ eC5 ,[a*b0:�� 3X*�� �R*�C 3a:~�

Page 4: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 274 –

@�� 3�a��� B��C�¬ uk�+�; )�R=5 ,)R0* \*= ,����� %�~����5 ,���C\U� ��zG ���*v�U� d����C>� %����5

3��a��� d���I±�� d]���� 5S �Rk����C>5 ���� d]���� |� ,¦@F+$2010 ,"550�; 3a��� �*�=� �� Y$ �x� ��

�J�� \ ?�$���� ? d��>� . x*a:��5m Y�$ 3�*�,:�� _W )R0* \*= B�C�P��|

e��C <��,V5 �*�³H���� �*��I% �� L%��s� L%��W . ����� 3��a��� r���0$ ���³*6 q9��; Y��$ O�P����m Y��Xa�

���,V5 )R0* \*= q��4:�� ���h]� �*,^ Y$ ?I5±��� ,��*-�:Gs�5 d��>� ?H^5 ,[C\U� 3a��� zG �4p���

5 )*C VU� 3*RHV5 ,�R��5 ,�*@*N�� ��R<�=% �5���� )� ��0���,���� ��$>� m>� Ld��@K <�=% . C�H�� d�� [@*N����� ,m ��0U�2002," 95�, ���*,^ )��Q Y��$5

��I% a�� d\:�G]� L�����5 ?I5±�a�� [@*N�� �������C 3X~ | 4 − �*M��,a� �� L��*,����*Fa0�� Dp��*�:V [�:��

�����G B�%���1 v��©] L%~��5 mS��� q��4:� "�@�� ; L%��W e�C L%���1 L���*1 Z��F:V O�P��� L%��W i�= T*�C5

:��B�C�� Y$ �R0C {Aa:� �$5 ,?�$���� ? B9C�@ 1 ��9E:�I� ���5��5 D$ �:�� �@�g ��6�*M ?� 3�a^

zG �RR*-V5W�5��:��  =�0:�� d�Kv, T�*�C Z�V�� �$5 Y$Ws� B�X�$ w9M ,T��$ ?�$���� t � %�X:]�5 O�

3;�� 8 R:H�� m��� ��F:��5 DE:�� µ� hW )Q Y$5

T:I% $|� ,m 0U�2002 , ""57 −58 � [M��,a� ��� la0�� iS \Kª ��*,^ e�C "���

<����V ��0C ���I% �� �����=S ?�� L�5�H����5 q ����� mS���5 mS��� ���h�5 ,B�*�³H���;­� e�C 3a���5

[�H���5 �*G�G>� Y$ u�A:�� ���=>� ? �RU� �*H0V3��a��� l*��FA:�� . ������@�� �K%�~����5 ,i5����:��« |

� ,��U� 4C2006 , ""97−98 � ��; eC C�H� �� ¶ ^ ��C�= �*I% $ �³* �*4�H��� B�C�P��� ��-5 Y�$

?� �*��s� B�C�P��5 �@�/�� �H=�0�� eC <�~V5s� eC x@^ [:�� ���=>� �� �� 3a��� . %�X:]�5 O�

�z-�0�� L%��s� o�4IS ) S Y$| s5b0:�� O�P�� L%�� `%� �� [a* `�X�G� eC

[@*N�� B\���� d��SW %��Q� . 3ja:V5 ,�*4��I5 ��*�� 8� � S5 �DQ�V5 TV �5 O�P�� OG eC §�v �1:�5

�� o���IS e��C5 ,���I% ��L����,���*�C�@ )��6%��W . , 0X� �-%� ·1� T0$ L��=s�5�� ,��/���5 )*���� 4C

2009 , " "262 −263�,^ YXa� T*�C5 §��V �� �� \*= %�Q­�:

EF$G:H� ��IJ� ����K:

− �1�F�� *�V?�$���� Z ��� ���W5 �I% �� O�P�� ���:I�K �0$�X�� B��� �:I]�5 |

− %��X=S )�R= e�C O�P��� . ?K%�~��� x*@^ 3�� q�g�� ��5 ,O�P��� d��0QS {�4��� )R��

Page 5: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 275 –

��X~��,�J� 1 §�v i�= m �*QV _W ? i5��:�� ��5SO�P�� 8��MS|

− �1 [�:�� B9X~��� _W ��4:G]� O�P�� T-��I% �� . L�-$ iXV, _W � �y*= L�%� Dp �R0X�5

�FH��,�� q�h ���W eC �I% �� 3a�V )Q Y$5 | − �J�m eC 3�=S �5��$ �� B�%��1 _W O�P��

¸% �� d��>�| − ��CW e��C O�P���� 3��a�� �C�~��$ �����V L��

3��=S "��= 8�~�:K�5 ,) �R- �*H0V5 ,?�$�����a:H�� ?Hz:��5 D*E:��|

− �*H@G B�-�h O�4�W eC O�P�� 3a���5�m �*G�5 ��� B� �7]��I% �� . |

��z 8��S5�2008 � iSO�P����:�@� ���,��M ·�1S %\j:�I�5 ,B��1�F�� D�@V5 ,t:H�� d�,V%9�

\ B�G�X$s��I% �� 8� S �*,^ . *@� | − �� �I�IS O�P���� i��X� iS Y��Xa� B���*�a�� �

s��I% �� . x*@z:��5 %�X:]�5 O� | − �� �CG O�P���� %���4:C��q�+��V]� Y��$ , 3��h5

�1�M �:@� O�P��q�+V9� �ak��5 L � C �| − ���I% �� ?�$������ ���*a*��V Ly��; i��X�|

�"30�| E�#�I�:����9�� ��IJ� :

− , ��k�x�� ���@0�� lE�����5 ,�*4�H���� �C�~����

��- ���-55���$ d B�%���*V ��aG5 ��,��5 ���* ��X�� ?�$���� ? �$+n�; �5�� 3�a��� %:= _W t�J� ��

���I% �� ���*,^ i5� q��� ���� i5����:�� ����15 �����@���*a*��:�� �R=� >|

− L%��s� c��15 }9R:��I�5 ,����4:G]� c*:~��V � R-5$ . . �%\j:�I� Y�$ ] � ,B�C�P�� �R-�

�*���@��5 Ld�@X�� t:H$ ���� �� ,��:0$ �F~GS| − )R:F�I ��= eC L��,�� <=�; _W t�J�� ���

�I% �� . ���$ Dp r�0$ | − 3��j$ ���0*�$ B�*K���I O�P���� Y��C f:��0�

���@0�� o�zH��G]�������:]�5 ����x��� � ,���C\U� Y��C55S ,L]��4$9�� %�~��s� 5S ,��*�>� � �� `�H�h

T���W5 3a��� YC Z*E:��| − O�0�g B�*K��I . Zk�� O�P�� }�� 1

eC �@M���� �4�p5 ,)R0*� "�A�> x*z:�� 3j$ %��,�� *������ D��X@:��� |5 )*������ ��4C��/���� ,2009 ,

"264�| − ,B�C\U�5 ���=>� d]5 � ® ,= T0C )�0�5

5 L%��s� ?� �,j�� q\�CS _W ����=>� d�U5 ,?�$�����¹� d��F;>� *+V . 3ja:V5 ��,:G]� d��@;W 5S Y���;

B�$��$| − ºO�P�� � ® »B��0��� RU�5 c1�� % ®5 ;

�*���@��5 ���@X�� t:H$ Y$ ���� ��|

Page 6: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 276 –

− �%���� O�P���� ����¼� t ��� ������� � ��� >�?*0��� "�A�� | ,�z2008, "31�|

5�� }�0 L%��W i5� q�^ [:�� B�1��� Y$ � � ¶ ^ 5S `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P��T0$ , �Rz*�V YXa�5

�� \*= : 1 − ��MAN�� ��O)"��:

− ���+�$ )�� ��RF�V [:�� ���=½� L��*,�� x**��*+A�;Y��;­� `@G . ,��5 LDE�� Dj� �� � | S

5 �=��,?Hh 2008," 432�| − ��4:�� [a����5 [C\:-]�5 .�,j��5 ¾A~�� Y

?a���� ?{�4�� )R��|� 5 ¦@F+$i��a0�� ,2014, " 2�P

− <�a:��� ����=S ?� q�+�V]� B�*�aC %+1¸% ��|

− L% �G5 ?�a���� t � ��0��� �5��� ��@AG����@�� �5� 3a���5 i5��:��|

− <�a:��� ����=S ?� �*G�H�Gs� B�19��� dI�¸% � |

− v�©� eC L%��1 ��C�= �*I% $ L��*1 �=�V � C�R:15 . �4I�0�� B�%��,�� |

2 − ���� ��� ��O)"��:

− ?a���� eC q\C>� <��V dI | − ���R�� ��I%�� . ��I% �� ���±% ��5 � C

B�4-���5| − q\�����C>� . 3;� �����:��5 ������*-�5��]�

B�g�+:;]�5� | ,m5�=%�2014, "104�| − B] �$ ��@AG�W�I% �� �*-�:G| − d���@:K]�5 �,�H���� B�C�P���� L%��W � ��C�Rk�:h�� |5 �=�� S?Hh ,2008 ,"432�| − `%� �� o�zgS * B�*h9+�� {� ��XV%�

�*� >�|� 5 ¦@F+$i��a0��, 2014," 2�| − B�d����-s�5 3��a��� ��C�1 ����5 � ��C

�� �F4V��� | − dIa*b0:�� r�0��[B�0h�~�� L�jK5 ,�I% ��

B�=9:;]�5| Bd�- 15 ��I�%� Morake, Nnior Machomi

�2011� 4=jzYC c�� T�-�V [�:�� B�� �z:�� L���, . O�P�� L%��W c@~�K5 ,?+��� �G�H�V . `%� ��

iS �I�% �� fk�:GL��1 L� ��N O�P�� i5y:�� `%� �� £����@$ ] \���K ,����R0$ B�%����R$ _W i5����,:@� )���¿S

5W ��,��F �*I% �� B�C�P�� <$ 3$��:�� B�*�*V��I,�*��W Z�% V L%5À �I�% �� cg5S5 L��1 `%� ��

�k�=5 ��*�� ���s�5 ¸% �� O�P�� L%��W w�M eC )R�I%� a O�P�� 3�^ Y$ )R0Xa� \ O�P�� L%��W

�s� D*E:�� �,^ �*��W L1 _W´�| �I�%� c= 5Ghaffar, Abdul Zaman, Amir

Page 7: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 277 –

Naz, Asia� 2012� O�P��� L%��W Á\GS 3�=S �=��$ _W �$� A:I� t � �L���1 ��g�n�5 ��$���� ���G�j�� `%� ���

B%��S5 ,i�:HK�4�� 89:�;� Y�$ )p���� TGS _W fk�:0 `%� ��� ��R0C ��$���� `%� ��� . O�P�� Á\GS ��*4M

W �g�n� Y$ ?C0�� 9K iS ]L��1  �@G ���4V� `%� ��� O�P�� L%��W laG, O�P��� L%��s o�IS 3�=S iS \K

TH@G �1�� ��*4F� ZHG>� o�I>� | ��I�%� c�G%�15Radford, Jessica H.� 2013 �

B�%+�V ?L���1 O�P��� L%��W Z*���I> `%� ��� ,�*��@�� O�P�� L%��W Z*��IS5 ,���@�� %��+$ � ^5

Á\GS5 ,O�P��W T-�V [:�� �6%��L��1  ��� d�I±%5 ��-5 YC �I�% �� fk�:G B�@IS5 ,�XI�yG . )*��:��

B�%+��V ?� �����5 89:�;�L���1 L%��s `%� ���� ] \�K ,���@�� O�P��� L%��W . )���IS ?5 O�P��

�44I iXV �I% �� �0*�$ �³= -V���s� ,O�P�� � �= 3��@�� ���@�� o��I>� ��� i5��:�� o�IS iS _W

O�P�� L%��s| �I�%� fk�:G B%��S5Boucher, Miley �2013 �

W� O�P�� L%��W Á\GS � ^ _L��, . �*k� :]� `%� �� o��IS5 ¸% ��� r��0�� ? �19���5 ,�0*�5%�K ��]5

B%��S5 ,O�P�� L%��W���4V%� ��-5 _W fk�:0 D�4K Á� \K ,O�P�� L%��W o�IS5 ¸% �� r�0�� B��J$ ?

)�R= l4V��L���1 �*H�*k��� L%��s� B��I%\� `%� ���

5 ,���,j�� _W O�P���� ���R-�� ���1�O\:��I]� 8����M½� �C%�+:�� �%= O�P�� ����1 �U��$5 L��4$ �,��F5 �|

)*����� �4C5 w������ �4C ��I�%� c�jz 15�2013� YC <1�5 O�P�� [a*b0:�� `%� �a )*���:��

����� �b=�za 8��:��5 ,�k�F�� eC �� A:�I� �-%� L���1`%� ��� o��I> �5��@:�� . L%��W O�P���

,[�a*b0:�� �� ^5 ?� ��19��� O�P��� [�a*b0:��

�� A:��I�5 o���IS �5���@:�� . L%��W O�P����

��19C ��-5 Y�C ��I�% �� fk�:G B�@IS5 ,[a*b0:�� �*M�4V%������ � ?�� B�%��R$ �5���@:�� 3�K5Y�$

B�C�P�� �*+A~�� B�C�P��5 §���K5 ,�*�I% ��*M�4V%� B�19C �-5� ? ���� W �5�@:�� B�*�*V��I

3K5Y$ B�C�P�� �*+A~�� B�C�P��5 ,�*�I% ��� C5 �-5 �19C *M�4V%�� ? l*�FA:�� �5��@:��

3K5 Y$ B�C�P�� �*+A~�� ��5�*I% �� B�C�P. 5B%��S�I�%� [�F4��5 B�����U��2014� _W

WB�*�*V��I L%��W [@*N��� ������ �R:19C5 O�P�� ����=S ?� w5��= }�0 cG�K �vW �$ �=��$5 ,?a��a�� [�a���� 3 J��5 [@*N�� xK��� 89:;� �I�% �� �0*C �� A:�I� iS _W ��I�% �� c+��;5 ,��*�a��� Lyn�5

��d�%s �*��C �-% cG�K O�P�� L%��W B�*�*V��I, �$� A:���I� ���� �jKS5�K%�~�����5 i5�����:�� �, ����R�1S5

W [@*N��� ������ �*�X�� �-% ��5 ,Z0�:�� �*�*V��I

Page 8: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 278 –

���� w5�= -V ]5 ,�*��C cG�KW �*k�+h �� A:I� . �s `%� �� m�� $ �,=5 O�P�� L%��W B�*�*V��I DE:� �

N�� xK����*�a��� Lyn�5 ,[a���� 3 J��5 [@*| m�R~�� �I�%� c= 5�2014 � eC 8��:�� _W

����G�j�� �k���F�� `%� ��$ . k�H���� [��a*b0:�� r���0�� � ^5 ,�R:*�C�= eC §�v `�X�G�5 �*C\:-� �$b0aK ����G�j�� `%� ���� O�P���� L%��W . <��4:�� o���I>�

��IS ?� ��19��� 3�*�^5 ,�k�F�� O�P��� L%��W Z*�c�gV5 ,[a*b0:�� r�0��5 �I�% �� _W B]��� �=�V

�bG �R-5 Y$ LD4K �-% [a*b0:�� r�0��L��1� � `%� �$� A:��I� O�P���� L%��W Z*����IS ���jKS5 ,?��a����5 �

��]� B�v w5�= -V ]5 ,}%�~:��5 i5��:�� o�ISW��0�� q��h ���0*��� �����=S B�F��I:$ ?�� �*k�+��h r�

t � k�H�� [a*b0:��L��1 ) ��bG ��R-5 Y�$ `%� �� �,=5[a���� 3 J�� DE:� �, �,=5 w5�= -V \0* D�E:� �

Lyn� B�0I � C| ��15S ���I�%� B ��KSaiti, Anna �2015� _W

`%� ���� . O�P���� ����a:z�� %��+���� ��� ^ L%5�i�G*�� �*k� :]�O�P�� OG � ^5 ,�DQ�V5 d��>� eC

,¸% �� . �~�0V B�C�P��� iS fk��:0�� B�RNS ¢*h h eC �*a*b0V5 �*+A� o�4I> `%� ��,d��I \�K

�M��0�� . ��R0C y�KS L%+� ��À�� `%� �� . �~0Vt�;>�, i5���:��5 3�$�X:�� i�� ��I�% �� ��� )C V5

)*a+:� �*H*k��� 3$���� [ §I\:��5W Ld�0 �*�*V��I`%� a�� 3�=S d��S x�x�V5 B�C�P�� L%��s|

�I�%� �$SDogan, Soner �2016� c= � �,= µ �^ [:�� B�C�P�� d�%5 �0$�X�� o�4I>� )**,V _W

�,=5 �I% �� . B�%���,��5 ?�a���� d�%�5 B�%+�:� �s�5 ����M�,a B�C�P���� �$ A:H���� B�*�*V����I

o�4��IS iS ���I�% �� fk���:G c@~��K5 ,���*K� `�@*��I?�a���� 8P�V ��,��F� <-�V B�C�P�� , w5��@��5

�@�� 89:;�5 ,���W[�:�� B��C�x0�� 3�h B�*�*V���I 5 ,� A:HV . �*�I% �� L%���� �I�*I mS �-5 � C

�3hO�P�� | Z*��IS eC � *K�V �,�H�� B�I�% �� Y$ ?4:�5

5W �R$ A:H�� [�:�� [�a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�*�*V��IL��1 ,`%� ��B�I�% �� �� c0��4V 15 ; vW W �R��� i

� c��a: �s�5 Z*����I>� Y��C �~��X�B�*�*V����I �� ��4V � DH��@V5 Ly��n�5  0U���K B�D��E:�� {�4��� �

3 J��5,[a���� _W c= t�;>� B�I�% �� {�5 r���0��5 O�P���� L%��W Z*����IS ?�� ���19��� ���=��$

����� 5S ,[a*b0:��[@*N�� �=��$ _W c= t�;S5 ,�� T-�V [:�� B�� z:��L��,�� L%��W . ,`%� �� O�P

��15 ,���0��4:$ B���I�% �� fk���:G Bd���-5S c���¬ <�a:��� e�C �DQ�:� O�P�� L%��W �*�S eC B�I�% �� ����:�I� C�I 15 �� ,�*a*��:�� �*�a���5 ¸% ��

Page 9: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 279 –

L%��W ��R@$ e�C d���� d��,�W . �,�H��� B�I�% ��5 T4*��IS5 ,O�P��W DQ��:�� B�v 3$����5 TV�*�*V��I

4�H��[�,:�V5 ,T�*�C ´���s�5 [ <�$ ��*���� ��I�% �� O�P���� L%��W Z*����IS ����5�0V . �,�H���� B���I�% �� . �*���� �I�% �� x*a:V \0* ,B�DE:�� {�4 �R:19C5

O�P���� L%��W B���4�F:� ����5�0V `%� ���� [��a*b0:�� L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >�`�X�G�5 , §��v d��S e�C

���� � ^5 ,[@*N�� B\Y$ �� �*@*K L%��W B�1�$ `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P��|

� ����� ��!N�:

Y�$ q :�$ % 1 _W �-�h . `%� �� Y$ DjX�� e�C ���@��5 ?V5����5 3���5 �aU� Z0�:� O�P��

���R:*�C�=5 ��� aG, Y��$ L� ���:$ q�X���S }���0 Y��X�5 ���:� ����*:G `%� ���� . µ ��^ O�P���� ,B�*H��0U� �

)Ra*��1 89:��;�5 ,B���=�,j�� . �����=>� 89:��;�5 )6�y��;5 ���*=�,j�� )6���*@�;5 ) �C�~��$5 )6�����C5

[:��5 )6� ,:�$5 �*a���� Y$ �¿�� �,V _W B�=9:;�

. B�R-5 �b0�� qh lFn� f$�y���5 B�I�*H���5

B�*��5 ��� 5 ,�R,*,^ B��=9:;]� �,:�I \:�h _W

O��, \%5� � � iX� �vW à ]W ,T�*�C L�F*H��� ):V <�0� Z*��IS �� A:I� T���@V 5S T�0$ YXa� �R�� iS

¢*h �4I�0$ d�-S D=V q9; Y$ � C�+V5 Ta1�@VWGT y:�� 1 º{�`%� ��� L���1 ��X~�$ O�P��� ��� iS

����,��M �4��gS O�P���� iS ]W ,���R*�C d����,�� Z���F:V?a���� t:Ha d�,V%9� %\j:�I�5 ,)6��1�M D�@V5 ,

�I% �� 8� S �*,^ . *@� \ )6�G�X$W ·1S T*�C5 ,fk�:G B%��S ,= m�R~��� ��I�%� �2014 � L%5� _W

t �� [�a*b0:�� r��0�� x�x�V L���1 ��R- Y�$ `%� ���5��?a��a q��� eC x*K��� q9; Y$ t�;S �R- Y$

q�+V]��*G�H�Gs� B��19��� )C�5 Y�$ )*C �V 3�-S L����� e�C 3�a���5 ,�*�I% �� �³*4�� . [a*b0:�� r�0��

��=��$5 [C5L���1 L%��W Z*���I� `%� ��� [�a��$5 �� �*�� ��a��� Z�% :�� q9; Y$ ��C 3X~ O�P�� ,

i������5 <��~��� ��I�%� c��gV \K�2014 � iS _W O�P��� L%��s L �h�5 �*�*V��IW 5S o�I� �� A:I�

@V ] �Ca� 5S o�IS Á�40:I� Z� 3 ; k�,�� ��R$ [ �k�,�� ���R$ <�*¬ [�FE:� B��4�F:��5 B��I%\�� Y$

,TH@G O�P�� �1$ ZI�0V5��5 º5 �4I }��0 iS - ��=��� ��1� d���-s ��I�% �� ��� � �~�X� Y�C )� S

`%� ���� [��a*b0:�� O�P���� L%��W B���4�F:$ ���*� >� L �� �0� aI�X�G�T e�CB\���a�� [@*N��� d��>� ;

O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$ YC �I�%� ��S -V ] TGW ¢*h`%� �� [a*b0:�� . ?:jh�4�� )�C �5 h|

� ����� 0���G:

− [���a*b0:�� O�P����� L%��W Z*�����IS ���� ^`%� ��|

Page 10: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 280 –

− � ^ ) S [�a*b0:�� O�P��� L%��W B��4�F:$`%� ��� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� L �|

− O�P����� L%��W B����I�X�G� e���C 8�����:��`%� �� [a*b0:��L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� d��S eC

[@*N�� B\����|

− �=��$W ��$}��0 c�G�K �v ���]� B�v w5��=W e�C O�P��� L%��W `��X�G� . B\����� ?� �*k�+hS _W tx�V YRk��� �*H0U�− �*a*��:�� ��h��� −Lyn� |�

− ¶ �^ [:�� B�1��� ) S eC 8��:�� L%��W Y�$ `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P��B�04�� �*� >� |

� ����� ��QG:

�DH��@V ���I�% �� � ��,V���*a�C � L%��W B���4�F:� �`%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P��5 , �9*��^aC ���* `��X�G] �

`%� ��� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��WB��04�� ��*� >� e�C �� d��S[@*N�� B\��> � �z*�V )Q , [:�� w�F�� 3�=

C�HVL��1 <�=�� [�a*b0:�� O�P��� L%��W eC `%� �� B\���� d��S t:H$ Y® �� [@*N��� ������ ��*,^5��0��� �5��� <=%5|

5V:��I�% �� Y�$ L *@:H�� B�RU� � �, 3a~�V5 �L����1`%� ���� � )RC9M��� L%��W B���4�F:$ )�� S e��C

O�P�� ��,� \� )R�I%� $ 3;�� [a*b0:�� �� . Ld��@Xd��>� §����K5 ,�)*����:��5 ���*��� L%��5� ���,V ¢��*h

Y���� `%� �� L��1 d�,:G� . �00,$ D���$ <� º� )� R~

. Ld�@X��W ��4K�$ e�C L% �,��5 3�a��� ���FV5 ���GP���� B� �:H$5 ,�Z�% �:�� ��$���� L%��s�� ¢�*h

µ� z:I� �,V B�-�*:h]� )k9V ���V �*4�% V f$�� ���FV5 ���C�@�� ������ B����*,�� L� ��:��5 �*��@��

)6�%�R$)R�aC . )R:*�C�= L����5 )R:��@K <=% 8 � | � ����� ��R G:

.  *k���� q�JH�� � z:�5:��$ B��4�F:$ L%��W`%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P��B�04�� �*� >� L �� �0� a

G�56�I�X�� ��R-5 Y�$ B\���a�� [@*N�� d��>� eC ?Y �bG 5V�*��:�� B]±�H:�� T0$ O�@:: 1 − `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W Z*��IS �$

B\���� �bG �R-5 Y$? 2 − [���a*b0:�� O�P����� L%��W B����4�F:$ ����$`%� ��B\���� �bG �R-5 Y$ ? 3 − [��a*b0:�� O�P���� L%��W B���I�X�G� ���$`%� ��L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� B\����� d��S eC [@*N��Y �bG �R-5 Y$ ? 4 − ���]� B�v w5�= -V 3 W ?� �*k�+�h

_W tx��V YRk��S eC O�P�� L%��W `�X�G� . B\����� �*H0U�− Lyn�− �*a*��:�� ��h����?

5 − `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�1�$ �$ >�L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� B\���� �bG �R-5 Y$?

Page 11: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 281 –

� ����� S- �:

)V �� A:I� [@g�� fR0�� ���*4M <�$ T:4I�0��R=� S5 �I�% �� |

� ����� �$�C:

��*G�X$ �5 ��h�: e��C ���I�% �� ���*4FV P��:1��*� >� `%� ��,L ��� �0� a B�04�� 5 )��V [�:��40

�*� S �I% $�:�� �$���� L%��s�)*+�,�� ��,F0a )*��� |27�05�1437� |�

���*0$� �5 ��h : 3+��@�� . ���I�% �� ���*4FV )��V ����� q5>� ¸�% ��¸�% ��1437–1438� |

��/ �5 h :\���$ e�C ��I�% �� �*4FV )VB �*� >� `%� ��B�04�� � ´�C �L �� �0� a|

� ����� ��T��M�:

�U��� V W���� :�,*,^ Z�F� 3aC 5S �$S ,T T0C ¦0p ] ¸�IS dÅ������� �*���� �E��� )��$ ,

2008�| XX�� ��� ���XX�� ����� Y)XX-'�(Management of

organizational conflict) :

ª ���@�� 341 Y$ L�A:�� B�d��-s�5 q��=>���I% �� �� $ � ¦�G�>� ��� _W O�P�� %��S 3*�,:�

���:��5 3�a��� Lx=��h �³* )*C :�5 ��,z�� �a0��5 )*�I% �� �*�C�@�« |� , a�2011 ,"85�|

T��@���V ):��5W w���F��5 Z*����I>� T��G� ���*k��-

� ��z�� ���I% �� ��k�1 � ���A:� [��:�� B�d����-s�5 Y��$ 5S ?=�M ? �~0V [:�� �=�:�� � C5 �%��:�� B]�h

S e�C Lx�@�5 ���I 3aC �³* D=:� �I% �� 3;�� �jKs�¨�:G |

��������� ��� ����� ����� :

B��-�*:h]� 5S B�I%\�� �¿� �*k��-W 8��V5�� �$�9����� �R�*�@V 5�R�,g .):*� ;¸% �� <a:���

��R@*NV . 5 �*�I% �� B�C�P��� L%��W$���R- mS B�DEV 5 d��>� Ld�@K <=��3C�@:�� �*,^´���s� ?�

O�P�� 8��MS| ������ ������:

8��V5W ��*$Xh D�p ��I% $ 3K �¿� �*k��- ��=�K )� �,:� ����=S ��Ca� 5S ���= � �~�GS �+;�$5

��$ 3�,a �*a*��:�� B�$ n�,m L%��5 ��R*�C 8/V5 )*��:��5 �*���| '�()�� *����:

�y- T=�� �2010�TG� ª [�:�� ���R��5 �F~�G>��ab0�� . �N�� ��5�x�,�*��@�� fk�:0��5 ��R,,� [:��

���0 T�aC q�� .; Ld��@X ��ab0�� 8� � S ��*,z:� �� �,=5 ���*�C�=5s� ���abG>�5 ���h�:�� �%���a�� � ����%��

3��a��� L� ��z�� w���F��5 B�d����-s�5 ��C�,��5« �"51 ��*���� �I�% ��5 �@:� ��F+�� �� 5, 8I5

T �;�V |

Page 12: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 282 –

��� ��>H�� ����� Z��:

� ����� ���G:

�� B a:C� i�*4:I]� eC �I�% 5 �� �CW Y$?:jh�4��, Y$ iX:�53 Z*��IS YC �R0$ q5>� ;%5��

L%��s� . )����5 ,O�P���� 3��h�13 � %��z��5 ,L���,=O�P��� L%��W B�4�F:$ YC ��j�� . )���5 ,`%� ���

Z*V��� ¤ �º �3K B��,= � C5 ���S ��%S�5, 5, 6, 7� ,�$ Y�C ¢��j�� %z��5 [�a*b0:�� O�P��� L%��W B��1

)��5 `%� ���15 �L�,=|

[�\�����:

T���C )�V i�*4:I9� �*�5>� L%+�� �� CW �e��C q������ . ?+��+A:�� ?��aXz�� Y��$ ���Ca�

e��C )��Xz�� m����� ��$ t %5���z� B�%���4��� 3��*j� ,i�*4:�I]� 8� � > ��R:$d9$5 �Rh�55 i�*4:I]�

�� {� d��-W �5� ��4V B9� ��: L��H��� B��bh9� �?aXz��, {�� 8��h5 �p�*�g L��CW c�5�0V [:��5

B�%�4��� {� �=��W 5S B�%�4���|

[�9]F�<;���� :

^$�.416: _`)� <;���� [�9]F�P

�)T�� 2��"�

a��]�F�

b)�9�

��F���

q5>� %z�� :O�P�� 3h . �*I% �� L%��s� Z*��IS 0.524 0.01 q��@�� q�+V]� 0.695 0.01

s� B�19����*G�HG 0.497 0.01 [a*b0:�� r�0�� 0.314 0.05

L��*,�� laG 0.695 0.01 ��j�� %z�� : `%� �� . O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$�O�P�� Y$ ���

%z�� lI:$ 0.754 0.01 ¢��j�� %z�� :�� . [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�1�$`%� 0.648 0.01

�G�4:I]� lI:$ 0.709 0.01

������ %5���z�� iS ��H���� q5 ��U� Y��$ ����:�

?�:H$ 0C ��*k�+hW�0.01 ,0.05� 3�$��$ iW ¢�*h , ? �$ <,� Á�4V%]��0.754 _� 0.315|�

Page 13: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 283 –

�D���� ���c�� �'�G−d��#$�e : ^$�.426:F� �$�T� [�M�� 2��"�$ ���c�� 2��"� _`)� f���� P

�)T�� ���c�� 2��"� [�M�� 2��"�

q5>� %z�� :O�P�� 3h . �*I% �� L%��s� Z*��IS .750 0.866 q��@�� q�+V]� .736 0.858

s� B�19����*G�HG .728 0.853 [a*b0:�� r�0�� .742 0.861

L��*,�� laG .801 0.895 ��j�� %z�� : `%� �� . O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$�O�P�� Y$ ���

%z�� lI:$ .751 0.867 ¢��j�� %z�� :`%� �� . [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�1�$ .801 0.895

�G�4:I]� lI:$ .780 0.884

q5 ��- Y��$ ����:��2 � iS 3��$��$ B���4Q���@�S

� r�4G5�K�0.7806,3XK �G�4:I9� B�4Q �4HG y:�V5�R*�C �\:C]� YXa��G�4:I]� B�4Q . |

�-� �&$ � ����� g�h:

3��j�5 ���*,4M �*k�~��C ���0*C60% Y��$ <��a:��� ,�g>� T�*= B\����� � �C ��4� t���5�289 � ��a��$

� )*+,�� �,F0a )*��:�� �$���� L%��s�27�05�1437� � ,

��0*��� ����=S � �C Æ�5�196 � 3�h���� i��ja� ��a��$ ���a*��:��� [k� ��:]� − l��I:�� −mG���j�� � `%� ����

L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >���*���� ��E��� `% V [:�� ,>� `%� �� ���4:I� )V5�*40-; B\���� {� i> §�v5

��*���� �E��� YQ z:� ] `%� �� §�: , Y�$ ���:� \�K )1% q5 U��3 �È�:�� :

^$�.436:� ��)R�� W9 ��$ �����!��� _`)� g�i)�j�C ,� � �"�� ����"��� ��C���$ ���k� ���$ ��9 l� P

mU��� b)�9�� ���!��� ��9 ��

����I 149 76% �*H0U�

����I Dp 47 24% Y$ 31S5B�0I 68 35%

Y$5 31S _W 10B�0I 49 25% Y$10 Y$ 31S _W 15�0I 31 16% Y$15Y$ 31S _W 20�0I 26 13%

�$ n� L $

20�jK�= �0I 22 11%

Page 14: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 284 –

g��] n ^$�.436P

mU��� b)�9�� ���!��� ��9 ��

[k� :� 96 49% lI:$ 56 29% �� ?�a�V [:�� ��h��� mG�Q 44 22%

��o�MCH� �l�"��:

��$�1c ���R:U��$5 B���G�*4�� q���;�� i���:jh�4�� �*k�+hW [k�+hs� f$�Gy�� ���M YC ��SPSS� ,5)�V

A:��I�� �4��I�0�� �*k�+��hs� Z*����I>�5 B���U���� ��I�% �� ��³IS YC ��-Â�|

�-�NO� �$ � ����� So��#:

F$G� : ���.H� ,& ^�p9�� ^$��: ����� W��� G ��

������� �� ��� ������/�"�� ��# �-.$ ,� ?

����-�5 Y��C ���� q�JH���� )��V o�H��:h�

B�FI:�� �*�H�� �=��zG]�5B� ���%�*��� B�-% ��

���=S �0*��� YC 3K L�,= Y$ B���,= ,i�*4:�I]� \�K )�V

o�H:h� lI:�� ,����� 15 )V �R4*V�V �4*V�V �*���0V� �d��0

eC B�FI:�� �*�H�� B�=��zG]�5 ���%�*��� ��-% �

���=S �0*C �I�% �� eC `�*,�� ,�X�� q5 U�5 )1% �4� ��� �� fk�:0��|

^$�.446: _`)���� )��� ����9r� ��s��T#F�$ �����"������� 2C V �� ���� ����H� W��� � P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

�Ds�)��

1 °� q\�C>� ����Gs i5��:�� �*,^ . C�H� ���@�� �5� 3a��� eC B\��a�� L%��s� <*�~V �C

�1�5| .982 4.50 2 �=�$L ~

2 YR:�*�=�� Y�$ ��x� ��I% �� O�P��� ��R-�� lFn� <�5 . }���]� B\��a�� L%��s� �\I

s�5 � ,:��5 3a������G| .974 4.19 7 �=�$

3 e��C <�~��� Z��I�0$ 3��� q��g�� ���@�:É w���F �C%�+��:�� 8����M>� <��$ L%��s� 3��g�:V

3a���| .997 3.99 11 �=�$

4 �5�� 3�a���5 i5��:�� �*,^ _W m�J� �C%�+:�� 8��M>� ? �b0�� B�R-5 Z��,V L%��s� ��5��

���@��| .956 4.17 8 �=�$

5 3a��� eC q�41s� ��� _W m�J� �C%�+:�� 8��M>� <$ 3g�:�� L%��s� {=%| .904 4.25 4 �=�$L ~

Page 15: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 285 –

g��] n ^$�.446P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

�Ds�)��

6 L%��s� �� A:I�S . �*4�H��� _W m�J� O�P�� d�¿s �C%�+:�� 8��M>� eC lE���5 L,�� o�I

3a���| 1.07 4.21 6 �=�$L ~

7 �R@1$ YC �C%�+:�� 8��M>� <-��:� B�,��� o�IS L%��s� �� A:I� <�*aU� ��x:�� . C�H�

3a��� C�,| 1.34 3.11 13 ���

8 �*G�HGs� B�19��� �*a0V eC C�H� i�X$s� % 1 �C%�+:�� 8��M>� ? L%��s� �*=V| .833 4.30 3 �=�$L ~

9 ���� O�P���� 3��h . ���*a*b0:�� �k������5 �6�*h9��g L%��s� �� A:��I�m ��x��:��5 ����b:G� _W

��B\��| .956 4.14 9 �=�$

10 �V q�h ���s 3k� L C L%��s� )� ,V ?� �*H�=�0:�� B�% �,�� d�0 . ) �H� O�P�� 8��MS

B\����| .864 4.14 10 �=�$

11 �*�I �C%�+:�� 8��M>� <*¬ �C�~$ �k 6 L%��s� ��5�� x�*K��� _W t�J�� O�P��� L �h {�@n �

��� . � �:��53a| .859 4.22 5 �=�$L ~

12 ��*�=� �� ���@AG�5 L]�4$9�� _W t�J� �I% �� B\���� ? µ ^ [:�� B�C�P�� L%��s� 3 �7

3a���| 1.16 3.94 12 �=�$

13 [@*N���� ������� ���,� B�*�5JH����5 ����R�� <����V ��0C B�% ��,��5 B�d���@X�� L%��s� L���C��$

B\��a�� | .868 4.51 1 �=�$L ~

lI:�� .530 4.12 �=�$

º� )1% q5 U� Y$ Ëh9�4 � Y�$ B��,= cI iS

c�I5 ,L ~� ��=�$ Bd��- �1 q����� ��� B��,=�=�$ Bd�- B��,=, ��� L h�5 L�,=5 , §�v tx��5

_W 3�*� O�P�� 3h . �*I% �� L%��s� Z*��IS iS _W � CW�5 ,�C%�+:�� 8��M>� d��� B��19��� eC ��@�

´�H��� l�I:�� Æ�� 15 ,�4*M L%+ ?C��0:�� ? 3XK %za���4.12 � ��*G�j�� ��³@�� . <,� lI:$ 5

¸\n� `�*,�� B�³= Y$�3.40− 4.19 � [:�� �³@�� ¦ 5

m%�*��� 8��zG]� �5 ,�*��C �-%� _W D~V�530|� ,�0�� �� 5[A:H�V [�:�� Z*���I>� � ��V L%��s� �R$

V%�4��� �g�;5 O�P�� 3h . �*I% ��? )1% �13, 1 �, Y$ 3K �I�%� fk�:G <$ �@:� �$ 5�,t ���n� 2008,

a�, 2011, ,i����� 2013|�

Page 16: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 286 –

E�#�I� :H����. ,& ^�p9�� �c��Z: �� ������� �����

����� �� ��� � ��� ����� %& *��G �/�"�� '�()��

,� .$�- ,���#?

^$�.456: _`)���� )��� ����9r� ��s��T#F�$ �����"�� ������ V ����� ����� �������4����� ,� �r�6P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

�Ds�)��

1 >� �4�� q5�q��@�� q�+V]� �

+V]� O�GS �=�K L%��s� �� A:I� q�� C�g− l� −[,=S �| .90278 3.7083 22 �=�$

2 L%F:$5 �j� h q�+V� 3k�I5 L%��s� �� A:I�| .90736 4.1875 8 �=�$

3 q�+V]� Y$ �*k��� 8 �� L%��s� � ^| .73368 4.2812 4 �=�$L ~

4 B\���� ? *-5 )k�� q�+V� �-5| .87629 4.1667 10 �=�$

5 �WB\���� ? 3g�:�� )*C :� �*I% �� 85�b�� �=�X L%��s� ��| .90030 4.2812 4 �=�$L ~

6 5 B� �7� O9F:I��Y6�-�*:h�5 Y69X~$ qh B\���� d�%| .99124 4.2083 7 �=�$L ~

7 ��j�� �4���s� B�19����*G�HG�

�ak�1 �*G�HGW B�19C �$�1W eC L%��s� L% 1q��4:�� ���h]� eC | .89884 4.4062 1 �=�$L ~

8 8��M>� 3K �C�~$ L�C��$ eC L%��s� L% 1| 1.15428 4.1354 12 �=�$

9 �I% �� ���=S ? ���HG]�5 l���� /G _W L%��s� [�I| .97593 4.2292 6 �=�$L ~

10 �W mÌS [C\:-� r�0$ D=: L%��s� �\: �´�| .91430 4.2917 3 �=�$L ~

11 ���@�� �5� [C\U� 3a��� eC L%��s� <*�~V| 1.06323 4.1458 11 �=�$

12 ¢��j�� �4���[a*b0:�� r�0���

B\��a�� ��0��� �5��� <=% eC L%��s� "�h| 1.08536 4.1250 13 �=�$

13 h]�5 Z�� �a�@$ �*H@G d�-S L%��s� �,^B\���� ? i5��:�� �5%5 ���| 1.14364 4.0312 19 �=�$

14 �I% �� i�$>�5 Y$>� �=�V eC L%��s� "�h| .84531 4.3021 2 �=�$L ~

15 ��z:$ �@��:$ 3aC �³* ��; eC L%��s� "�h| 1.12542 4.1042 15 �=�$

16 ?5 �R0* ����4:�� �,j�� O%x L%��s� �\: �t�;S �R- Y$ YR��5 B\���� ?5 �R- Y$ B\���� | 1.24799 4.0521 17 �=�$

17 <���� �4���L��*,�� laG �

B\���� ? �RU� �*H0: L%��s� ��*1| 1.03426 4.0937 16 �=�$

Page 17: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 287 –

g��] ^$�.456P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

���Ds�)

18 B\���� B�% 15 B��� �:I� �=��$ eC L%��s� L% 1| 1.08275 3.9792 20 �=�$

19 3a��� �³* ?Hz:� B\���� B�h�,$5 d�%� L%��s� Z*h�V| 1.07684 4.0521 17 �=�$

20 B�C�� µ5 � �407 <*aU� eC B�g�+:;]�5 B�*�³H�� L%��s� )*b0V5 � ^| 1.02324 4.1771 9 �=�$

21 Rk�%� YC D4�:�� ���z B\��a�� L%��s� �\IY %�X=S5 Y| 1.08536 4.1250 13 �=�$

22 B\��a�� B�F�H��5 B�*h9+�� {� L%��s� {�@V| 1.17674 3.6979 23 �=�$

23 �1$ 3K ��*4F� ���4V L� �:$ ����*1 Á\G> L��*,�� �� A:I�| 1.04835 3.8958 21 �=�$ %za�� lI:�� 1.012 4.1163 �=�$

)1% q5 - Y$ ��:��5 � ´�H��� l�I:�� iS 3�XK %za���4.1163�, ��³@�� . <�,� l�I:$ � 5

¸\n� `�*,�� B�³= Y$ �*G�j���3.40− 4.19���5 , D~ m%�*��� 8��zG]� Æ�5 ,�*��C �-%� _W �1.012 � ¢*h

=S �,=�$ �-%� c0��4V L%��W B��4�F:$ q�h ��0*��� d�� ;O�P�� B��4�F:$ �=��V L%5�5 ��*�S e�C q �� ��

`%� �� O�P�� L%��W | − q5>� ���4�� B�%���4C Bd���- ��15 4 ^�MXX]F�

^�"'��6 ? �5��� ´�Hh lI:a �4.2812 :3.7083�, L%��s� ?� Í�,0��5 %��� �E� �=�V _W §�v <-�� 15

��5 �*I% ��B\��, �*�I% �� L%��s� Y�X� _W �=��s� 8��:�� . C�H� �� q��@�� 3g�:�� B�%�Ra ���s� Y$

O�P�� o�4IS eC,T�h ��5�� )Q Y$5 | − ���j�� ��4�� B�%��4C Bd��- \K � ��XOw"��

��#�9XX#H� � ?�� �5����� ´�H��h l��I:a�4.4062 :

4.1354�,�����5 m� L%5�5 ���*�S _W D~��� B���19��

s� O�P��� Y�$ ��� ��*�aC . ´��s� � %5�5 �*G�HG�I% �� 3;��, B��19��� �\: ]� iS _W §�v tx��5

�5 �- ��; eC C�H� �*G�HGs�m B��19C5 �5���V {�4�� YR��5 B\���� ? l�V ��1 ��@:� �$ 5 ,

��I�%� fk��:G <$�,m ���n� 2008� iS _W �=���s� , G�H$ ��X~�$ µ5 h 0C B\��a�� �*I% �� L%��s� L

B���19��� )��C� . D��4K 3X~�� )RH��� ���I% �� ���$�I% a�� d]��5 �*G�HGs�|

− ¢����j�� ���4�� B�%���4C Bd���- \��K � d�XX ��

XX�� ��� � ?�� �5����� ´�H��h l��I:a�4.3021: 4.0312�,_W §�v <-��5 t���� [z+��� r��0�� �=�V

� ¦�C���� w5��@� <��$ ��=�:� \� B\����� ?�� �����@�5 ,Y6���G�X$W5 Y6�% ��1 ���I�%� fk���:G T��V KS ���$ ��

�t�R~�� ,2014� �Rh��G5 �I% �� 8� S �*,z:� | − <���� �4�� B�%�4C Bd�- 15 �����D�� u#6

? �5��� ´�Hh lI:a�4.1250:3.6979 � tx���5

Page 18: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 288 –

T�*-V e�C �*�I% �� L%��s� L% �1 _W §�v 8���M>� ��-% L�,�� 5S �F�H��� �� A:�I� � �C5 ,�C%�+:��

�g�h O�P�� eC d��,�� . LD4K �z�+�$ e�C ��R0$ � ¤q�C t:H$ �*,^5 �*$9:��5 3a������Gs� Y$ |

�XXEc��I :jXX��c�� ^�p9XX�� %XX& �XX��.H� xXX] : �XX�

����XX��� XX�� ��� ���XX�� ����� ��XX �!"#� �XX�����

��X��� �X ��� �� ���'�()X�� �/X�"�� *��G %X& ,X�

,���# �-.$?t�� �� ��>H� V P

E�"��� :g����� ^�p9�� %& ���.H� x] : �X.)] 2X�

��F� ��y [$�s� ����� ��!"#� V �/�"�� z� ��o�MC

{� b|XX"] ,XX-o��G %XX& ���XX��4 ��9XX l�− �}XXk�−

����"��� ��C���6?

1 − ��9 l� mU�� :

^$�.466: _`)� �D�"��� So�� �����9 l� z� [$�'�� ��F�P

�)T�� ��9 l� v�9r� u )��� �Ds�)�� �.�� � ��O mI~��� x�C [$�'�� ��F�

����I 4.14 �=�$ q5>�

����I Dp 3.93 �=�$ 1.294

0.19 �*��

.4500

���� Dp

����I 4.15 �=�$ q5>� �4��

����I Dp 3.86 �=�$ 1.516

0.22 �*��

.0590

����

����I 4.25 L ~ �=�$ ��j�� �4��

����I Dp 4.06 �=�$ 0.712

0.10 �*��

053.0 ���� Dp

����I 4.12 �=�$ ¢��j�� �4��

����I Dp 4.06 �=�$ 0.202

0.03 �*��

0300.

���� Dp

���I� 3.31 ���

��j��

<���� �4�� ����I Dp 3.58 �=�$

1.027 0.15

�*��

8610. ���� Dp

����I 3.31 ��� ¢��j��

����I Dp 3.58 �=�$ 1.027

0.15 �*��

8610. ���� Dp

����I 3.89 �=�$ lI:��

����I Dp 3.88 �=�$ 0.052

0.14 �*��

1650. ���� Dp

fk���:0�� D~��V )��1% q5 ��U� . �0a���:�� �6 � _W Y$ q5>� �4�� . l,= �*k�+hW ��]� B�v w5�= �-5

���]� t:H$ 0C ��j�� %z���0,05 � B�F�I:�� ?�

�,=5 �0*��� ���=S B���:I] �*�H��B�*H�0U� D�E:� �, 9�= %5��z�� [1�� ��$S ,B����H�� �0*C ���+� §�v5

��]� B�v w5�= -VB�*H0U� ?, _W §��v tx���5

Page 19: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 289 –

3�g�:��5 ,B�� �7]� <*¬ . q�+V]� B�*�aC 3*�@V 3�a��� B��I%�� . d�I ����=5 L�QJ$ �,��F )R0* \*= \� d�%­�5 )* ��@�� 3�,0� �*G�HGs� B�19��� q�� . 5S

��@�:A�� )R=� S5 ) �R- *hV _W t�J�, )�Q Y�$5 �:��5 o%�,:��5 §I\:�� �� A:I� q9; Y$ )R0* \*= ��

���=�:V [��:�� q�+��V]� ���*�aC . ���*0,:�� 3k���I5 ���=�K

TV�4�F:$5 P��� B�%FV5| 2 − �}k� ��) mU�� :

B���:I] �*k�+hW B]]� �-5 Y$ �,z:�� ��4V �I�% �� �0*C ���=SB�0I DE:� � �� A:I� )V Lyn�

m����h>� Y����4:�� 3��*�^�One Way Anova � \��K �:�� q5 U� Tz�� )1%�7�|

xO� ^$�.476: _`)� EDs$ � ����� � �& ���sG ������ F �����"�� ��s��T#F�$ ����9r� ��� )����}k� ��) mU�� �u�9��� ,������ 2��� P

f����� ,������ ���M� ���r� ��.�� ��"���� �)h ��"���� u )�� 0 ��O ��� x�CmI~ ��F���

��o�MCH�

B�Ca��� ? 4 2.268 0.567

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 51.456 0.275 q5>� %z��

�X�� Oa��� 191 53.724 2.06

.04

�*�� 0.088

���� Dp

B�Ca��� ? 4 0.95 0.238

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 81.68 0.437 ��j�� %z���1� �X�� Oa��� 191 82.63

0.544 .01

�*�� 0.704

���� Dp

B�Ca��� ? 4 3.505 0.876

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 143.842 0.769 ��j�� %z���2� �X�� Oa��� 191 147.347

1.13 .02

�*�� 0.34

���� Dp

B�Ca��� ? 4 3.454 0.864

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 185.085 0.99 ��j�� %z���3� �X�� Oa��� 191 188.539

0.873 .02

�*�� 0.481

���� Dp

B�Ca��� ? 4 5.464 1.366

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 142.695 0.763 ��j�� %z���4� �X�� Oa��� 191 148.159

1.79

.04

�*�� 0.133

���� Dp

Ca��� ?B� 4 5.464 1.366

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 142.695 0.763 ¢��j�� %z��

�X�� Oa��� 191 148.159 1.79

.04

�*�� 0.133

���� Dp

B�Ca��� ? 4 2.152 0.538

B�Ca��� 3;�� 187 46.193 0.247 lI:��

�X�� Oa��� 191 48.345 2.17

.04

�*�� 0.073 ���� Dp

Page 20: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 290 –

?4:� )�1% ��H�� q5 U� Y$ �7 � ��-5 � �C ��0*C ����=S B���:I] �*�H�� B�FI:�� ? w5�=

�,=5 �I�% �� ���]� t:H�$ �0C Ly�n� B�0I DE:� ��0.05� ��0*��� ����=S ? w5�= �-5 � C <-�� \%5 ,

3��a��� )*��b0V5 ��C�,� B\������ o��*:��I�5 )��R= _W ¢*h �*� >� `%� ��W)¿ [�a*b0V r��0$ . i~�*��

 �@G . ?��~�:$5 mS��� . ?%�,:$ )R��� �� h�5

3a��� 85�N, ��I�%� <�$ ��@:� ��$ �� 5 � ,L�=���U�2013 � m�R~�� �I�%� fk�:G <$ ��:¼5�2014�|

3 − ����"��� ��C��� mU�� :

B���:I] �*k�+hW B]]� �-5 Y$ �,z:��� ��4V ��I�% �� ��0*C ���=S� )�V ��*a*��:�� ���h��� D�E:�

m���h>� Y���4:�� 3*�^ �� A:I��One Way Anova ��:�� q5 U� Tz�� \K )1%� 8|�

xO� ^$�.486: EDs$ � ����� � �& ���sG ������ F �����"�� ��s��T#F�$ ����9r� ��� )��� _`)� ����"��� ��C��� mU�� �P

f����� ,������ ���M� �.�� �

���r�

�)h

��"����

u )��

��"���� 0 ��O mI~��� x�C ��F��� ��O

b)�9�

��F���

B�Ca��� ? 5 4.174 0.835

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 49.55 0.266 q5>� %z��

�X�� Oa��� 191 53.724

3.133 0.08

�*�� 0.01 0.01

B�Ca��� ? 5 7.689 1.538

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 74.941 0.403 ��j�� %z���1� �X�� Oa��� 191 82.63

3.817 .090

�*�� 0.0030 0.01

B�Ca��� ? 5 21.363 4.273

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 125.983 0.677 ��j�� %z���2� �X�� Oa��� 191 147.347

6.308 .140

�*�� 0.0 0.01

B�Ca��� ? 5 40.101 8.02

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 148.438 0.798 ��j�� %z���3� �X�� Oa��� 191 188.539

10.05 .210

�*�� 0.0 0.01

B�Ca��� ? 5 8.608 1.722

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 139.55 0.75 ��j�� %z���4� �X�� Oa��� 191 148.159

2.295 .060

�*�� 0.047 0.05

B�Ca��� ? 5 8.608 1.722

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 139.55 0.75 ¢��j�� %z��

�X�� Oa��� 191 148.159 2.295

.060 �*�� 0.047 0.05

Page 21: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 291 –

g��] n xO� ^$�.486P

f����� ,������ ���M� ��.��

���r�

�)h

��"����

u )��

��"���� 0 ��O mI~��� x�C ��F��� ��O

b)�9�

��F���

B�Ca��� ? 5 2.821 0.564

B�Ca��� 3;�� 186 45.524 0.245 lI:��

�X�� Oa��� 191 48.345 2.305

0.06

�*�� 0.046 0.05

)�1% q5 - Y$ ?4:��8 � B�v w5��= �-V T�GS ��]�WB�FI:$ B��� ,V ? �*k�+h ����=S B���:�I�

�,=5 �I�% �� �0*C��*a*��:�� ���h��� D�E:� � t:H�$ �0C�0.05 ��G�4:I]� %5��5 ���S <*¬ ., ��a*1 c�E� ¢*h

8� 3.133 � q5>� %za��� . �*�I% �� L%��s� Z*���ISO�P�� 3h � � % �1 ��] �0.01� ��a*1 c�E� �15 8

�3.817 � �����j�� %���za���%��W B����4�F:$ . O�P����� L `%� ��ªq5>� �4��:q���@�� q�+V]� « � � % �1 ���]

�003|�, 5 ����a*1 c���E�8� 6.308 � �����j�� %���za��� `%� ���� . O�P���� L%��W B���4�F:$ª����j�� ���4��:

�*G�HG]� B�19���« � � % 1 ��] �000|� �a*1 cE� \K ,8� 10.050 � ���j�� %za����P��� L%��W B��4�F:$ . O

`%� ��ª¢��j�� �4��:[�a*b0:�� r��0�� « � � % �1 ���]

�000|� ���a*1 c��E� \��K ,8� 2.295 � ����j�� %��za��� `%� ��� . O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$ª<����� ��4��: l�aG

L��*,��« � � % 1 ��] �047|� ��a*1 cE� \K ,F� 2.295 � ¢����j�� %��za��� [��a*b0:�� O�P���� L%��W B���1�$

`%� �� � � % 1 ��] �047| �tx��5 3�X� iS _W §��v �1 T�GS _W �=���s� �R+�k�+;5 �6\�I �*a*��V ��h�$ ��³* B�v5 t�;>� YC ��,:H$ �I% a ��h�$ 3K iXV

�0��4:$ �*a*b0V, ��6�%�R$ . ��@�:É L%��s� i�XV È��:��5 ��a*1 c�E� �15 ,�6�% �15 �R+k�+;5 �6�*K�I58

:a %za�� ��C lI�2.305 � � % 1 ��]�5�046|�P

� E9��;:H� ���. ,& ^�p9�� ���k�: �� �O)"��

����� ����� �� ��� ������� ������ ��X ��� �X ���

����� ,� �-.$ ��# �/�"��?

^$�.496: _`)���� )��� ����9r� ��s��T#F�$ �����"�� ��O)"��� ��� ����� ����� V ������������ P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

�Ds�)��

1 O�P�� L����� L�b0�� o�*p�´��W O�� ��*I% �� L%��s� t �| 1.01623 3.6875 1 �=�$

2 �I% �� 8� S �*,^ � ¼ \ O�P�� �*NV eC �I% �� L%��W L% 1 ���| 1.10192 3.5208 4 �=�$

3 B\���� B�1�M )b�$ �@0:HV 1 [:�� B�C�P��5 B�=9A�� �*I% �� L%��s� 3 �7| 1.31837 3.5104 5 �=�$

Page 22: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 292 –

g��] n ^$�.496P

Y ����"�� 0��T#F�

t���"��

u )���

v�9r�

W�]�]

����"��

�.��

�Ds�)��

4 � �I�*I eC �*I% �� L%��s� �\:C�� � i z:�5 Y,@:� ] ¦:h B\���� ? �1�@:�| 1.442 3.26 10 ���

5 `%� �� o�zg� �RM�4V%] L%��s� * B�*h9+�� xK�� ��1| 1.207 3.59 2 �=�$

6 ��C 3X~ L%��s� Ld�@K ���| 1.367 3.26 11 ���

7 ��W w�M5 Z*��IS YC d�% a�� �$ ,�� Z�% :�� f$�� q�@pWO�P�� L%| 1.236 3.35 7 ���

8 m�@�� 5S l�H:�� m��*,�� la0�� L%��s� �� A:I�| 1.421 2.97 14 ���

9 �*I% �� L%��� �*0R�� Lyn� ��1| 1.292 3.24 12 ���

10 �I% �� 3;�� B\���� B�*H0- � �V| 1.338 2.97 15 ���

11 ��� )*15 B� �7� . Y��4:��B\�| 1.108 3.58 3 �=�$

12 B\���� ? �*a*b0:�� �=�,j�� u,G| 1.058 3.40 6 �=�$

13 B\���� ? �*G�HGs� B�19��� dI| 1.289 3.16 13 ���

14 YR0* \*= q�+V]� B�%�R$ �� A:I] B\���� %�,:=�| 1.240 3.27 9 ���

15 �I% �� [a*b0:�� r�0�� dI| 1.314 3.27 8 ���

%z�� lI:$ 1.24990 3.33591 ���

)��1% q5 ��- Y��$ ����:��9 � ������� l��I:�� iS

Æ� %za���3.33591�, �j��j�� �³@�� . <,� ��� 5 Y�$¸\�n� `��*,�� B�³= �2.60 – 3.39�,� 5 [ [�:�� ��³@��

, ��� �-%� _W D~V m%�*��� 8��zG]� Æ�5�1.24990 � _5>� ���4V��� . Bd���- ¢��*hB���1�� O�P���� L%��W

L��b0�� o��*p eC u0V [:�� L%�4��� `%� �� . [a*b0:�� O�P��� L������´���W O�� � �*�I% �� L%��s� t ��

Æ�� ´�H�h lI:a�3.6875 � Æ�� m%��*�$ 8���zG�5�1.01623�5 ,eC u0V [:�� L%�4��� �*G�j�� �4V��� . Bd�-

o�z�g� ��RM�4V%] L%��s� �* B�*h9+��� xK�� ��1`%� �� Æ�� ´�Hh lI:a �3.59 � m%��*�$ 8���zG�5

Æ��1.207� ,5 u0�V [�:�� L%��4��� �j��j�� �4V��� . Bd�- eC ´�H�h l�I:a B\����� )*�15 B�� �7� . Y��4:��

�3.58 � � m%�*�$ 8��zG�5�1.108�,5 ��4V��� . Bd�-� eC u0V [:�� L%�4��� ����� ��I% �� L%��W L% �1 ����

��I% �� 8� � S ��*,^ � �¼ \� O�P��� ��*NV eC Æ�� ´�H�h lI:a�3.5208 � Æ�� m%��*�$ 8���zG�5

�1.10192�5 , u0�V [�:�� L%�4��� �H$�n� �4V��� . Bd�- eC [�:�� B�C�P���5 B�=9A�� �*I% �� L%��s� 3 �7

�@0:HV 1 Æ�� ´�H�h l�I:a B\����� B�1�M )b�$�3.5104 � Æ� m%�*�$ 8��zG�5�1.31837�, Bd��-5 .

e��C u0��V [��:�� L%���4��� �I��H���� ���4V��� ���=�,j�� u��,G

Page 23: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 293 –

Æ��� ´�H��h l��I:a B\������ ?�� ���*a*b0:���3.40 � Æ� 1 m%�*�$ 8��zG�5�1.058� 15 , ��4V��� . Bd��-u0V [:�� L%�4��� LD;>� e�C B\����� B�*H�0- � ��V

��I% �� 3;�� Æ�� ´�H�h l�I:a �2.97 � 8���zG�5 Æ� m%�*�$�1.338�, L%��W ��=�,Q u�,G _W §��v tx��5

,�*I% �� L%��s� t � �g�A5 �I% �� [a*b0:�� O�P����,�� �*I% �� L%��s� �F�I Y$ B\���� 8; 5S; ¢*h

���:��I� � ��C . ���� §���v ���RN ���*4F:� B\������ ��RH �G�4:I]�, mS �,C d��¿W 3RH��� Y�$ TGS �g�;5

B���:�I� BP�:1� ,= T*�C5 ,�*� >� `%� �� �a��$ [�:�� %��z ��,=��� B��-%� �� A:�I� e�C �0*��� ���=S

? BPzG�� ���5 �=�$ � <�*¬ ?� %z�� §�v eC�0*��� ���=S�� ��Ì �*�V Y$ )p��� eC [�k9�� B�$��

�� ?� �|

'�()�� *����$ ����� W��� G z� �Ow"��: xO� ^$�.4106: _`)�f���� F� �$�3 z� a��]�F�P

f����� 1 2 3 4 5

����� W��� G −

^�"'�� ^�M]F� 0.646** −

H� ��Ow"����#�9# 0.515** 0.668** −

�� ��� d� �� 0.569** 0.672** 0.906** −

����D�� u# 0.034 0.022 0.089 0.144 −

** ��F� b)�9� � & ����0.01

)1% q5 - Y$ ?4:��10 � D4K Á�4V%� -� TGS

?� Á��4V%� ��-5 ���V� ¢�*h i�*4:I]� %5�� ? T�:a*1 Æ�� q���@�� q�+V]�5 O�P�� Z*��IS�646|�,

¥q�� 5 t:H�$ �0C �01|� \�K , ?� Á��4V%� �-�s� B�19���5 O�P�� Z*��IS T:a*1 Æ� �*G�HG�515|�,

t:H�$ �0C q�� 5�01|� ?� Á��4V%� �-� \�K , T:a*1 Æ� [a*b0:�� r�0��5 O�P�� Z*��IS�569| � 5

t:H$ 0C q���01|� Z*���IS ?� Á�4V%� -� \K ,

T�:a*1 � L��*,�� laG5 O�P���034| ��� � 5 �0C q t:H$�05|�|

�NO� �So�� �� :

− O�P��� 3h . �*I% �� L%��s� Z*��IS 3*� � ��C _WW e��C ����@z�� �C%�+��:�� 8����M>� d�����

��4*M L%+ ?C��0:�� ? B�19���;�0�� ��� [ � ��V 3��h . �*��I% �� L%��s� �R$ A:H��V [��:�� Z*����I>�

O�P��|

Page 24: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 294 –

−W B��4�F:$ �=�V L%5�5 �*�S O�P��� L%�� `%� ���� B���19��� _5>� ���4V��� Bd���- ¢��*h

V �¿> ;�*G�HGs� - ��; eC C�H�5 m5 �5��V d��0{�4��� YR��5 B\���� ? l�V ��1 B�19C Y�$

,���*��W ���,��F ���RaC� q9��;5 §����K ���:��I]�R4��F�Y �C�~a `�Hhs�5 Y e�C 3�a���5 W O�4��

6�-�hY ¼ ����* [�C\U� 3�a��� �5% �YR0 ��*a0V5® � L%��4��5 %�X:]� �5%���� [a*b0:�� r�0�� )Q ,Ym

eC 3a�� q��4:�� ���h]� �*,^B\����� ? ���,V5 3a��� zG ´��s� %�~�� 5S �4p���[�C\U� ?H�^5

d��>��*-�:Gs�5R$�R$ 3*RHV5 ,Y L�C��$ _W �=��s����@�� w5�@� Y6�% �1 <�$ ��=�:� \� B\����� ?� ��

��� �$>� ,�*@*N�� Y6�G�X$W5m Ld��@K <�=% . C�H� [@*N�� d��>� 5<=%��0��� �5��� q��@�� q�+V]� )Q ,

�D=��:� �*��I% �� L%��s� ?�� ���,G5 %���h ���E�B\����5, ���s� Y$ �*I% �� L%��s� YX� _W �=��s�

:�� B�%�Ra e�C 8���:�� . C�H�� ��� q��@�� 3g�O�P�� o�4IS,T�h ��5�� )Q Y$5 L��*,�� laG d�-5 ,

� LD;>� �4V��� .g�T ? L�5�H��5 q ��� �*,^ eC <����V ��0C ������@�� w5���@�� L���C��$5 ���I% �� �����=S

B�*�5JH�� ¶ �^ ��C�= �*I% $ �³* ��; eC C�H� �� B�C�P��� ��-5 Y$ �H�=�0�� e�C <�~�V5 �*4�H���

e�C x@^ [:�� ���=>� ? �*��s� B�C�P��5 �@�/��

s�3a��� . %�X:]�5 O� | − [���a*b0:�� O�P����� L%��W B����1�$ � ����:V

3ja:V5 ,B�04�� �*� >� `%� �� . L%��W ��=�,Q u�,G L%��s� t ��� ���g�A5 `%� ���� [��a*b0:�� O�P����

�*I% �� ��1 , �* B�*h9+�� xK��L%��s� ,�*�I% �� B����=9A�� �*���I% �� B�%��s� {���� 3��� �75 ��$ ,�� Z�% :�� f$�� q�@pW5 ,�I% �� B�C�P��5

O�P�� L%��W w�M5 Z*��IS YC `%� �� L��,�| − ��]� B�v w5�= -V ] W ����=S ? �*k�+h

�0*�����S e�C O�P��� L%��W `�X�G� . d ����=S��0*��� _W tx�V� �*a*��:�� ��h���−Lyn� �, _W §��v <-��5

B� �7]� <*¬ . q�+V]� B�*�aC 3*�@V| − t:H$ 0C �*k�+hW ��]� B�v w5�= �-5

��]��0,05 � ���=S B���:I] �*�H�� B�FI:�� ? �,=5 �0*���B�*H0U� DE:� �, B\���� �0*C ���+� §�v5

B����H��| − �*�H��� B�F�I:�� ?� w5��= �-5 � C

� �,=5 ��I�% �� ��0*C ���=S B���:I] B�0�I D�E:� � ����]� t:H��$ ��0C Ly��n��0.05�; )��R@� §���v5

`%� ��� 3�a��� )*�b0V5 �C�,� B\���� o��*:I�5�*� >�|

− ��]� B�v w5�= -VW B��� ,V ? �*k�+h ��0*C ���=S B���:I� B�FI:$� �,=5 ��I�% �� D�E:� �

Page 25: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 295 –

��*a*��:�� ��h��� t:H�$ �0C�0.05 � ����S <�*¬ .i�*4:��I]� %5���5, tx����5 ����h�$ 3��X� iS _W §���v

�R+k�+;5 �6\I �*a*��V, i�XV �1 TGS _W �=��s� ��,:H�$ ��I% a ��h�$ 3K ��³* B�v5 t��;>� Y�C

�0��4:$ �*a*b0V,. �@�:É L%��s� iXV È�:��5 �6�%�R$ �6�% 15 �R+k�+;5 �6�*K�I5 |

− � 5 i�*4:�I]� %5��� ? D4K Á�4V%� -� ¥q�� t:H$ 0C �01| � t:H�$ �0C q�� TGS � C�05| �

L��*,�� laG5 O�P�� Z*��IS ?| ���\)]� ����� :

\����� ?� O�P��� Z*���IS Y$ �� YXa�B ���M YC `%� �� :

− Z*����I>� � ���V L%��s� �R$ A:H��V [��:�� C�P�� 3h . �*I% ��TCG5 O�P�� ��*4F� � ��4V B�|

− /G`%� ��� [�a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W �=�,Q, �*I% �� L%��s� t � �g�A5|

− 3*�@VB�4�F:$ Y�$ `%� ��� O�P��� L%��W ,q���= [�a*b0V r�0$5 ,�*G�HGW B�19C5 ,q��= q�+V�

Dp �*M��,a�� L��*15�*FaG | − d�0%H- ,YR���5 B\����� ?� �,j�� Y$

L%��s�5 B\���� ?5 | − `%� ��� B� k�1 ? �5�@:�� B�%�R$ x�x�V

�R:�� . �*4�I B�C�� ��S d�:h] |

− D=Vr�0$´��W ¸% $ º� �Xa Y3K ?�$����� ���z ) �bG B�R-55 )Rk�%� YC D4�:�� Y$ �I% ��|

− ^ x��*@\������B <��=�� ���� �a:H��$ 3X~�� Y6��0�$ ��% �x�5 Y[@*N�� ,��� �$>� m C�H��

s� L����5 [@*N�� d��>� ?H^ .�*-�:G, �� )Q Y$5 O�P�� Y$[4�H�� |

− L%���15 Lx�*a:$ ����V �*I% $ B���*1 d�,:G��*�C�@ �*a*��:�� �HIJ�� L%��W eC |

− ,C B�%5 ��� 4�% :����*`%� ��� B� �k�,�

Y�RC9Mse�Cµ �hS Z*���I>� ��j� �� . 3�h�C�P��5 B��FV 6�%�R$����*,�� Y.

− L���� �\: ]� f$�y �*C:�� �R-�� �´H0

��)*��: \*= ���:� . O�P�� `%� ��. * * *

$ ���M�� �o�Og.����

EF$G :����"�� g.����:

�=�� S ,�a� q��¬ ;?H�h5 , )*�b��� �4C �$9�I�2008|� s��*@+����5 �*��I% �� L%�� ,��% 0X��Is� : ����$�U� %��

L � U�|

�z, �*FC 4C �I� �2008�P e�C � �QS5 O�P�� L%��W Á\GS �z+���� L%��5 e��C ���*,*4FV ���I�%� [��a*b0:�� ����F:��

Lxp O�F1 . �*0*FH�@�� |%~�0$ D�p D:H�-�$ ���I%,L :�� �*�K�*$9Is� ��$�U� L%�� ,xpL|

y-, a� Y��� 4C �2010�| d��>� eC ��QS5 m%��s� O� s�

Page 26: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 296 –

[@*N�� :� �$ m�� �$ e�C ��*,*4FV ��I�%� ����K5 `%xp O�F, �*�5 �� µE��L| L%~0$ Dp D:H-�$ ���I%,

�*$9Is� ��$�U� L%��:�� �*�K ,xpL| � ��4C ,[��F4�� ; ����; ���a� ,B������U� ���a� �2014 |�

B�*�*V��IW L%��W O�P�� t � m�� $ `%� �� ��G�j��

�R:19C5 ����� ?�$����� [@*N��� ��,F0a 3�k�h . d� {� B�DE:�� ,�*=��-a� �� ��� ��$�- i���-

O�= ����� �*G�HGs�− ����H�� ,3 �2� ,24 | 3*¬ d�@g ,L�=��U��2013 |�Z*��IS L%��W ���PO� [�a*b0:��

��R:19C5 O� �s� m%��s� t �� m�� �$ B��� �$5 `%� �� �*$X�� . �b=�� }�X�� Y$ ��R-5 ) ��bG,

,B�I�%� ����� ����� ,i�%>� ,40� 2|�

m 0U�, a� *H�� q��C �2002�| [�a*��:�� l*FA:��5 L%��s�s�L���$ ��±% [�*V��I,Á 2� ,�����: ���� |

i�Hh,YHh a� ;[a����5 , ?0H�h �a��2013�| L%��s������, Á3 ,i\Ci�%>� ,:LDH�� %�� |

��n� ,m ÏS Y a� �2008�| Z*��ISW[a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��

t � m�� $ ���G�j�� `%� ��� ��*$X�� ��0� a ��X$

�$�X�� �R:19C5 ��0��� �5��� ?�a��a�� Y�$ ��R-5

) ��bG� �$ ����I%L%~�0$ D�p D:H�-����*��� ��*�K , ��$�-St�,�� �|

²��� ��, �$���C ����I �2012�| ?�� ���j� �� �*��I% �� L%��s���$�~�� L�U�5 �����,c�X�� :��*H�� %�� |

L ������,�I 3��G ;L��,��5 , a�S ?$�2013�| ��*4FV t �$ L%��W Z*���I> }�X�� �b=�� . ��G�j�� `%� �� m�� $

[$9�Is� %�b0�� �=5 [a*b0:�� O�P��, ������ �����*H@0��5 ����� ,Y��z4�� ,14� 2�, 200|

m5�=%� , q�$��2014�P [@*N�� ����� eC [a*b0:�� O�P�� �QS?�$������ :. ���*G� *$ ���I�%�L�XH�� 3���X�� �H��IJ$

�L%~�0$ Dp D:H-�$ ���I% |�s� ������ ��*�K �*G�H�GD�; a� ��$�- �*C\:-]�5,�k�xU� |

�*aH��, YH�z�� �4C �2010� |�*�I% �� L%��s� . B��I�%� ,i�%>� ,i\C: $��� %�� |

<��~�� ,i������5 ;����g ��C , YH�z�� 4C �+�h�2014 |�W��h�,$ �*�*V����I r���0�� ����F:� O�P���� L%��W . �

,)*+��,�� ����$�� [��a*b0:�� ����$�- ���*��� ���*�K �����>�� �, ,P$ 3� 159�,711|

m�R~��, YHh i�F�I �2014�| L%��W Z*���IS5 [a*b0:�� r�0�� Y�$ \R0�* �19���5 �k�F�� ��G�j�� `%� �� . O�P��

?a����5 Y��� �� �bG �R-5, � Ã�C ����*��,P�$ , 1 �47�, 273 − 318|

��U� 4C, *H��� Ð� 4C �2006�| l*�FA:��5 ������ L%��s�m���,������ , ����H�� :È5 �� /0�� %��|

w����� 4C,���K� �aM�= ;)*����� 4C5, �ÏS W )* ����2013�| ���FV %5� �� �$ ��I% �� . L%��W O�P��� [�a*b0:��

`%� a ��:��)* �� A:I� ����� o�IS �5�@:��| ��� @0��� )��C5 ��*��� . ��*�C B�I�%� ,����H��� ,3

�44�, 59| �K�� a� �$�IS,)*���� 4C ;��/��5, �ÏS ��aC S )��� �

�2009�|)*����:�� . ���j� �� ����%��s� 3;� ���� ,i\��C , i�%>�:<��:��5 /0�� f �0�� %�� |

%�:É ÏS ,�aC�2008 |�L����� �*���� �E��� )��$L� ��,�� , :Z:X�� Ã�C |

��a� , *�H���� 8�S�2011�| `%� ��$ m�� ��$ Z*����IS ���QS

Page 27: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

�� ���������� � ���� ,30 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 297 –

��0M�$ }�I eC [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��s ����� )*��:��?a����, ��*��� �*�K ���,L%+�0�� ���$�- ,P�$ ,1

�76�, 85| ¦@F+$,�F��� �4C ��I� [� 2010�| s� Ã���$ ������ L%��

� - Ã��� L � -Á ,3,L� �,�� :´���� �X@�� %�� | ¦@F+$,F��� 4C �I� ;[i��a0��5,��� }%�4$ m� 2014�|

5 O�P�� L%��WW `%� ��� m�� $ d��S ��F:� TV�*�*V��Ic�X�� �FI:��| ������ ������ ��*@�� ��$�- ���

H@0��5,�*P$ ,3� 3� ,2 − 16| �F�����, Ð���FC x�x��� 4C �2007�| d�� . �*�I% �� L%��s�

����� m%��s� �X@��,i�%>� i\C : $��� %��| E��#�I :��� .�� g.����:

Boucher, M (2013). The Relationship of Principal Conflict

Management Style and School Climate (Ph.D.

Dissertation) University of South Carolina.

Retrieved April 25/2016.from http: //eric.ed.gov/?

Dogan, S. (2016). Conflicts Management Model in School:

A Mixed Design Study. Journal of Education

and Learning, 5 (2), 2000 -219,.from

http://eric.ed.gov/?q=Conflict+Management+in+sch

ool&id=EJ1097381.

Ghaffar, A., & Amir Naz, A. (2012). A Comparative Study

of Conflict Management Styles of Public & Private

Secondary Schools' Principals - Bulletin of

Education & Research., 34 (2), 59-69. Charts.from

http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.qu.edu.sa/ehost

/detail/detail?vid=6&sid=0af39b0b-b7d9-4d7d-

96f0-d2ab985f73b8%40sessionmgr101&hid.

Morake, N., Monobe, R., & Dingwe, S. (2011). Challenges

Facing Managers in Managing Conflict in Schools

in the South and South Central Regions of

Botswana. Online Submission, US-China

Education Review B 5 ,695-701.from

http://eric.ed.gov/?q=Conflict+Management+in+sch

ool (2010-+2016+)&pg=3&id=ED527676.

Radford, J. (2013). Assessing Conflict Management Style

of Educational Leaders as a Means to Improve

Relationships and Effectiveness. ProQuest LLC,

Ed.D. Dissertation, University of South

Dakota.from

http://eric.ed.gov/?q=Conflict+Management+in+sch

ool (2010-+2016+)&id=ED564849.

Saiti, Anna. (2015). Conflicts in Schools, Conflict

Management Styles and the Role of the School

Leader: A Study of Greek Primary School Educators,

Educational Management Administration &

Leadership, 43 (4), 582-609, Retrieved April .

25/2016 from http://eric.ed.gov/?

* * *

Page 28: KSU - ˆ˙ ˝ ˆ ˝ ˛˚ ˘ ˇ ,˛˙ # ˝-.$ ,ˇ / +' () * ˚ %& ˜ ! #$...k˘, ˘@K 3,*G˘HGs B9C˘@: Zh˘+V **4M *zg Lˇ ˘N 3˜; D*E:5 : ”5% eC b=˘za %5•5 L% W ‘F +$ L“˘

8� a� �*�C5 ,�*H�� �C �M�C: `%� �� [a*b0:�� O�P�� L%��W B�4�F:$L �� �0� a B�04�� �*� >� |||

– 298 –