Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

17
9: ''d :u a= !o oq Q9 j4 E oJ.i i-Jo v 9.'i -4 d s= F tal >€ E ta6e ;9E 9! X ,l 4d d q:_ I .=J g E'b& a{x o*; 9E I t"€ ; E E E €, =:E€ r'1rE $ EZEE€gfTEgE -&P-itro-:Ees-a. Ig?E;€EF:-e8. EEE;;I*?3;E r$E:AEE€ssi=T eIEEEE!F*g€ lS=;=E:hE&€ ;x:.iE:i:r:s" gd d1**iEE-EA --oocY3!4*!f ='sF==Ea5d>6 zazfJz{:tH* t ZE H + s-h 3 e e i ;g;EE*F;;:F nEb$silAsTE 'csEt--65Ex€€ :€ *-U f €; E:E: i o i -'J' - c o Y e 6 E: 3 Zi'l*f iE;g nt d ! ,;>P E:EEPE 2 E a ! Irl u =Ea-9 6P-:Xd ., = a-: Y €€aEt-3 c b E5r: '-E o o Q{i ;-- o-E'F ovr>!- !oo.a o!>oG> 6 .;'n .=9cod! o.i.i-dc 5 3.-3 e E.E 6 d .l r 6 wa7'd-:j- o:--J* .;6JO.lJ?: : FE F F; '- o- uti o :1 H":€;€ E = HE 3e U -6€ qE >\ -d gl o oE'l EF E'a,P- oA oi:a a !pOeE i B= E r'9 >a^> bE;di c b'=ot-O I i: A k':- ^ 6-E}E: HOOYI Z - c a =E AiE&,8 .=lc^E: ot;cd6"d: )4 p = tr .^ e !oC-O- I = ; > .- [;8CXs d-c 'tr: A E:9,gFE EN!-o:oi )i: a M tr oo ;.9 00:: Eo; *io5600 :-.F.! 5 o * o -AE:389F EAE;F:i L-E-O '*e.= 8 g"i f, E:E e 5 f b EFEtP6g 4i E g: ; 3 g E E E " F3 e s r i €a g 3 hi ! o a.;'tr J !: tr a 7 E= & ; I sE !' =.9 q r'6 99oli€tFg :si-oEB boHoii_-o; a ) c o 9{ a5 -tl:o.:o-o C) (J q) c) o I d 0l a cg () q) (,) q) & o q) ,)t cl lo \(, () J A v d rt) 6l q) : GI Q

description

Reference and Semantic de Kripke.

Transcript of Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

Page 1: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

9:

''d:ua=!ooqQ

9

j4 EoJ.ii-Jov 9.'i

-4 d

s=

F

tal>

€ Eta6e

;9E9!

X

,l 4d

d q:_I

.=J

g

E'b&

a{xo*;

9E I € t"€ ; E

E E

€, =:E

€ r'1rE $

EZ

EE

€gfTE

gE-&

P-itro-:E

es-a.Ig?E

;€EF

:-e8.E

EE

;;I*?3;Er$E

:AE

E€ssi=

TeIE

EE

E!F

*g€lS

=;=

E:hE

&€

;x:.iE:i:r:s"

gd d1**iEE

-EA

--oocY3!4*!f

='sF

==

Ea5d>

6zazfJz{:tH

*t Z

E H

+ s-h 3 e e i

;g;EE

*F;;:F

nEb$silA

sTE

'csEt--65E

x€€:€

*-U f €; E

:E:

i o

i -'J'

- c

o Y

e 6

E: 3 Z

i'l*f iE;g

nt d

!,;>

P

E:E

EP

E2 E

a ! Irl u

=E

a-96P

-:Xd

., =

a-:

Y

€€aEt-3

c b E5r:

'-E

o o Q{i

;-- o-E

'Fovr>

!-!oo.ao!>

oG>

€ 6

.;'n.=

9cod!o.i.i-dc5 3.-3 e E

.E6

d .l

r 6

wa7'd-:j-

o:--J*.;6JO

.lJ?:

: FE

F F

;'-

o- uti o

:1

H":€;€

E

= H

E 3e

U

-6€ qE

>

\-d

gl o

oE'l

EF

E

'a,P-

oA

oi:a a

!pOeE

i B=

E r'9

>a^>

bE;di

cb'=

ot-OI

i: A

k':- ^

6-E}E

:H

OO

YI

Z

- c

a =

EA

iE&

,8

.=lc^E

:ot;cd6"d:)4 p =

tr .^ e!oC

-O-

I =

;

>

.-

[;8CX

sd-c

'tr: A

E:9,gF

EE

N!-o:oi

)i: a

M

tr oo

;.9 00:: E

o;*io5600:-.F

.! 5

o *

o-A

E:389F

EA

E;F

:iL-E

-O'*e.=

8 g"i f,E

:E € e 5 f b

EF

EtP

6g4i

E g: ;

3g E

E E

" F3

e s r i €a g

3 hi ! o a.;'tr

J !:

tr a

7 E

=

€ & ; I € sE

!' =

.9 q r'6

99oli€tFg

:si-oEB

boHoii_-o;

a )

c o

9{ a5

-tl:o.:o-o

C)

(Jq)c)oId0lacg()q)(,)q)

&oq),)tcl

lo\(,

()JAv

drt)

6lq):G

I

Q

Page 2: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

E iJ LA

b 9 b >=

E =

A";'E

EY

E',8; f;E

EE

€ E g E

€ Fa E

F riE

i; E

+: rE

;;ii€ 6. e "c

e,o.e3l;i

;.3 xi?=R

6 B e' =

= :€;€

E i i9; I

g

: I ! ti{€; ai ii iE

gE ai E

ii i i iE ?E

is:e : ; lt;'t;

At ;!

12 8? >' a " o 7--ii

* o

i ;Ei i;i a!il ig+

;:;; ei EiE

;i :*€€ f, g : g E

TE

i;til;: E

ry; :=E

i*! uer

' E i E

g* iE€; 'autiE

iii; iE*iiiIt

a*i;E':E

iyrE7 5F

:3s j

- $ r s: i; € E

E E

Et€i E

Ei;;;T

! E;i;i

t i: l:: *:E ' I s : 3"E

;: i€'i iEE

*Ei{

€ g$ E iE

i ! g; iAf iE

3 H i E

; E E

EE

E;gf

rcs#;ilEE

::iE

8:;E9€H

5:B.9.E

3 - F E

i 3.s'l "t*'=

":ir}iFbd:

n g = n =

i e f, 5E

I

e i i il,3.U

.s" q" i s fE

uz:= iE

Es7l

:: FF

e*zEzZ

:P

g'-E:uI.=

IjEi

iar=n;eB

E€f

E =

: ' 3 s Ei E

zfr: E

q s +n i I [l

aS

: I ?6 Z s I il E

#g;r€gi2r,E

eE?.E

E H

s€ E 5Z

E I

€;'sEt,t,E

+a-sE

a!!!^(Ee(.1!

E E

€: : : I X

Eg:

_a@!2oJ

E E

€ F; t * H

ar 3,6i

^"9d:3o.EE

d2 k

a =

a

: ..

d L

C

3; F I *e S

r i E

*a?.:i'e: i

re a E i

E!-E

EsE

F3-a€€

&doato46Aq

ip s

eg;ejj

r c,

- o

- c

l.t -

.:c.^rdoo!-o!i>

,*5

i le?:

€g -;

-ri=9

s,<.

E

-E;;3

33' i

E?"-

iz i

Ezzt

EX

-e

'"c=o--i

=._

=

-uEi!

?e i

i6 ,,-6 3

=

E

iLa&

.j,-seE=

zE

=&

2.99*F5afi$E

Ei gi;H

i=;

zF* 3et;-g

="E

atE F

:E

s4d3 F

:141!L=

.aL(

t ..

) :-

'.-:i=

2:? I gE

4 i=--tE

E.-

;E2"e?,t2 .z-u*ieiI

Ea

frHa:H

3o!o

-ooH!6,

€€ a E

;E:taF

2c t

*232?!e I

4- 6

.a b!-q;EF

*

Ao

o. E

:.i o

A>

{j

if'l o =

'-z e' -

dF

ts E

3;;ePb

'zi

=i E

zii r, V'z *

7e 'V

L"rElitZ

an

8 c tr

>o.

E;

= E

E

a 6

!i 9E

I

so €

e!*

e_E

#.,8; E

>

'=

:9 -e

- ,+

t -.q

aE=

) F

- ?

F.,i'a

ui Z

: tE

i..is aE

i1" i;

=A

sEE

-e&aE

oe '=

E = 3P

*i

Page 3: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

€ll;it; E

=,=

,r ii ;E

E F

ii€ie;e

E?:!! ::E

i€s3rii€

eE{:: €trE

;EH

:E

"iiE

e:E?€ ieii :igE

;leaiiiiisiiti!Ei;

: g; e =

i 1; :: E

# E ; $ I ; #

E;E

; EE

:fIiEE

€iaES

isE

E ft *:

c o E E

-::E€r

:i I E

=tsr

:* Es g$gi E

i EE

?e;E ;; gE

E g

6CA

€3#EE

'=

33o

EH

Sri

Eb:

.g-;.8- F

;SE

€g5s d=

-€-*^3lr-

->i

iE:E

! €tfE6

A=

Ur-

.9 s- 6 6

= b

q?

- -.'E

D

g'O

E

Y-N

aLC'6

'E sE

.e * l3E

ai=a'o

E 5 E

F€

'e = I

'1 -9t, *U

o-t"{.i

Z;t

;.oto'i.=o

lEi,q^;

o>i

!:EE

n beE

u o

L.9 t

- "-EJi

E "€

oc7^-tJ,-o3!i!m

L3:-98

EE

tE

i;-c- .=

6d.'l o 6.=

5 - E

:E

e 3 i ; * t t

s=o*

d - o_

=

? gt.6 i'c--.o

Lt6

E c-o

c *

oil:i 7 E

l *

s €E

HE

tS

g-;oi'E

PE

fr9 c)E

Rc-{Jd'-

tr E

=

'5;i

E s5€€ A

:€ FqoH

zFQzFat'lFtuaztrIFlAt-l

of-]FlF]aad

ooo=o _:l

ox-.8g.F

sO

, o .r

G2F

9-o;;rN

o!!

oC

o!1E

^,i ,-

^=

>xb'

odo=o>

cuo*P

.83;..9

o<

>athd7,d

-;.:a

hgeh

^,e e

E

.o gia

- 92

E

A:

Ea

3E.

P

.6.a \

C

=

.r9,

!1 oE€

E E

;d

;: x=

-.:ai;6

!:-q 4

* b.:d

ai od-

6 o.i

o

poAIo6=

i g.-

I-c-91=-

a .

.=

aaonrE

cogii)

o>

oE

-

'54q=

ilco.=o

E-

L-O

"=a

.-!uovt=4-;-.

oX

.o'il o

tr

€d

4tupaoGo!oOood

Atr

Mbo

o

Page 4: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

?E?! g3i

E $:

=oY

q!t=<

'EH

(E:

= i:F

o::

e.600iie;'-F

;sE5:

b€;;:-'i€;€.E

H ; E

;; : : E

E

=>

.2Ertn'E

g8oE

^q.Y=

l?6eboboc E

E "s8e F

ts;;F

E c i

? A E

- c

s:

;; l€ E

gr E :

-sE

- "

r I?

l:o !

tF

S h.=

o5.c

iEIi€,F

E;E

5='t

o,.!: =€

= o a-.9

bE=

;;FgaE

E{.!tr9"5trij=

o.-l-

q.E-c.r

F P

bo

d u: S r E

s -1 a

.o":?9>

E=

:e:€7#37=

qfEB

E>

EE

.:6J=

<.i>

'i:.iE

aoagRI

n c.E

:6€f!gr;€:tr"95f;iF

;.a:6fi;--.IE

r!.E

E6-.9!r"r'€S

'iooaa2Y,9-E

gE3C

EE

AH

.FE

.

ai H I

b F +

E

F I

+ d ;5

?EE

ii;HE

I g:i;H

€S

il*; g'-'

a-^e-

as; :l;i

€e?i*;;

€EE

E

:Eii

€;1 t;E

".q E

a;;E

rE

B.E

E e

-qo:i;=

F

CS

" a ftanf

, O

-E.E

;;E

E

€E?;

P

fr;€ *e;

s E

,=R

Q3

E*=

dE

; '.s"u5 H

s3;z

H€:

;F; q€fi €;lE

E

qEt

'i*+

':.i',!:=

iEg.e

5 I E

F

,E: .- >

2;

a il r a -''

,|' qf6

bF-

=€E

"E

;b8!

' siE

F

l:ii;!Eeig:

c E

A;

Ii:eEIeE

Ee::i

&

EE

E

€€iVE

'aaE E

yEis

'; E

:E

iEA

€;fHE

E,E

:-r;i

€E;

.;€EE

*E=

g.EE

EH

€€,h

-tr:E

-9E =

ts tr tr!

E

.E+

E-E

chF

.o--.t-i-o

i!iO

LO.9 6-

o >

a z'69.

u^o9?@

>.

-e Ht3

"s

S:'."; E

ga-r:E E

o:o:.Y

2 t

aE

=E

F

r'o

E-ti=

=^ g::H

E,:

EE

n

!;e; E E

1g:g-tEe

E'IE

E a E

pB!€ ?l;

ZA

i,-2i. zi!--'4 *:'die:e € E

;E"€3 H

xE.'=

-"3i aO'#!** E

e:-isir:

z?7=ri i;E

tA1-_L

p _e -gi€:tr:; t e ; : E

E : s * ; ::F

E=

r*E E

i,E:s t 345

EE

?r!a3'EE

;ssss

tEiF

Eiig:E

i ;llE E

E: E

?EiiZ

? ?E ; ! t e t

E ; a ;E

ul:*ZE

Ei

E'.E

E!E

! I * ?? " - . g: i'l; iii ; E

!aqtEE

l!

'c1l?iiEE

lllgaalz\2121111i€igii; :zE

lgit +i =

F"r;; * qii

x i ; zr elt E i i i i i i

E uzzlll'ta i a

;:'A?isE

iE€E

i;sEe ;ea;i lE

i : ErE

EE

iEi9i =

212"i

E 9 a s a € -*'E

taie zt='?E

E

: t-E z=

zi E d

Page 5: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

dcEo

:.e 9E=

: !i:

; X

=

qlai-=

trco.!!o-trE

,h'E

-

!':O!

-:;as=

;

;'=

: o

c=

r\

9Xg"

A:q

vo=d

+:9'b-9

.",.: d

O

O

-- Y

@ild"'

J^-O&

t6cP

2ba

-o.oY.2

de-C5I

bo-a/C5 E

=i

o- -

O<

6!?O

Pd

>6d/

-6=4

'=-o!

!6a.a

^-oogDA

Lq-

- 9*n

cEz9,

o-E)

E Z

ed

EE

fq E

€E

v-- #3#E

Ei;E

E

;.-

E€

iE;c

o6 9C

a

.c ^

!t,O

n ).p,h

=i

E=

io

rr'6 E

_ri :

! E

Ei-;9

F 5

6^ il-i

l- F

l.E,

;o3; '-

g: F

,taa'=

e :b6.;

o I

:.t c

ii

-6 c

c- 5U

!;

X E

H

.T5

Etrt

i:.^o!o6E

'r =

l?c93€

(J o E

u r

d a r

c o qt

: g

" "!tro!3d.=

S

nUd

F

E:;

oi:.E

, s i e,

Eu

71!€eE

t;3*&

,L:o-1-t-r==

i):oL-

d ;';€

'Etr(.P(vytu-

E

isg:38 E

€Ei

L _o

=."

^ -.qa

Ut

O.9

a-a*F

accigr^.=B

:-

-E9>

.io" Y

''- L"

dr r-apE

H; *?€i

=o

.- Q

^ d

o -;:Y

e

rF

'.3".7E

'., o E

9 e i

E

3=E

:?,.=

:6".=

Xth--O

t=<

-9qivd

393-;E

qss;; 4

'L el

"i Ji HE

E

E.U

EE

+-E

E

is?B

4J

EE

b^E'=

3=

,=d>

4

A

==

iiaa 'ct'5trd

t6

F]

Ir

bocdo-C!io>

:l'gaaau6.*_6,o 'o c

:99:,:!

o q

o50dod)dcdoEo!qod

+.9

=xu=aaogxboH

6t

€{:. :,

,r_. -.:ii i

aa-oi.a ;d.h{B

eZZ

Zd<

-c=E

p;=p,9,5_

_c-d L;c9

y:"._6ey A

.-;€

=

=8=

.-,j:g,zat

421E.*-.'-.

Xil

'= v a# 'E

E? €

? E

A - -o: E

,- E

"-,"tr:iootrd6.'ti

Z ?iE

?r'.;"t=z-oi

E Z

i.zE

Ei$z7

s i ?-E

^c gEE

E-:?gE

€ e

.u*3 -6

a

e p Y

il" ZE

Z"8!tE

vEP

ei ,

i:zE iE

==

E ;a;*e;€

lge 33E

r E3 ;:c:gt*€l

b;o !;E

;-:E

EE

;#a",q:elIt;:;tF

,il ;t;,a:a:;+E

€EH

+iE

|AlE

;"", ?i:qi?EE

Ee*

?a--'eEH

.:.?!€[e* u==

='E

i=pii?l

to \rE

EE

i'rrn*lrur1'uft * , ,?r"'iz,='i';=

= 31

3

cl

o

Page 6: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

+;;lE

iEF

g;;; f n;;IiEi :€E

ieEE

g!,!;EE

E

$

EtitE

€gi?ii; EiiE

'-eE =

!!iE!i:;iiiiE

E

E

i€et{;E;j ii} 1{ii€E

+i iii:iE

iiii;;rt rE

, !aiiIEa;i!!E

;iE!!E

EE

;i.;gE

iiE ii;i;i :E

Iia!il':E;;;iz?zE

'E;i ;;

Eiii : ! E

i iE iii

EaE

ii siii?i aii ii tii i i *iza:laE

iiE iE

BiiI;Ii+

Ei! [E

€:EisaE

;IE ;e;;ft E

}E

6

rgb.=

dE

I 3'-

=_z

d!O

.--aY

90Eqo

X9>

u'2coF

o!

r 9:"#:.

e.-^8

cE;E

x=$Z

bb;

c llF

gE=

-!.i r€f

9 __

ai;;.E

eg ;i?,

g S

€ H

gBl

*Ee

€EE

dg:p

HE

g e=

.- 41tz e":E

t,3Ee

-Ei"tZ

-.ZB

1E;

; Z

eaz."qi,aa:,r

LEt=

.-22>

-L,'=

d_o

.,';PE

eE

s::E,,-e?€

-o,^E€"B

i€ LZyaE

iE

ZE

1 E

B:i'uE

I ssA!oa

g:E;

;'i+2-i.

'^:".i.?.e-_

al_E

pbo=

Ee??2;? utii|A

zS

ieu e;6F

EF

E.,i:, *r=

;:",&

i2 E

-*u?t,zE^;:+

:EF

: i! e :

E E

Ei e E

:;: ; *,s E€E

E;

3*i2-EA

'-i-!Es

E

z Y.e.r

qv<acn6

Page 7: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

E i E

; i:ii * €=!E

' ;iE;'iE

3 Fgu zilE

'F; a; E

E;

*isrE:aiiE

r;'i l1tE?E

te iiiilez*Ei l;iil

iE1l iiillill

gg tl i l iil li e€ t E iliil illiiri

E i

E ; iull3 : ; i

a i +zE

i! ?i i E i:E

*Ei ai

E ; i ! ; i I il

E3 i iA

1 : ?11 1 ; i 1 i 1 I I ii i e I I ;Le*1l*t;i i ; fi i ;

aE I

oooc=

! 6tr

'oBo

<d

d-d

.3xogoo!oaE9.c tr

3;:;

_8

Qv:

2

o : Et il?:E

; 9". "e :?; i :g 6ElE

EE

t€i*aai€ii gi*€r He E

E s

o o 6 u! 9.4

a ?.2. 4

ai',72Z

",=ziE

'-'=E

ZE

i72a E

3 3o-c.'l

7 Y

=

a

oo

-6 -9

uo ,9.=

d

4ir.o

o."9Oo:!ld-oi'ada,

.X9

.\dH=

(!o.,.6

916Y

c)

?€d.=

>r:

udil2 tr;o,o-F

.5t-or^C

e

.75 2

A-=

-.E-u

! .90.€.E

tr .do-b

')P)

4. c

H.F

od!-I

9Ctr

6a(n

Page 8: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

-8*i-.r'o 99:E

'=

;5 -

6 j

o" q

6aaE.2

E'Jqi:

it H;E

VrE

aE

"i4i *3 * a

trFt>

-5,^oo6.9

q ^ {

boo F

trii::€

53eo;6

S€.e

:0,.3>

*S_yt

cocIEra)-=

o-1't-qo;t

,ag)*,

€::;q E

zEd

q-E"is-6-a

oaoEo-crf

;€; U

€r E

e'= b

E *4 E

g-;-:;-8dO

^v=/

:: ; a E€ f :

i-a' oE

aFH

:fi"$::;S

--: F 3.=

+=

: !: E

-E E

p, E ! =

:3-dg;;:E

=€S

:i

s i H€: s *

q

=

Bei E

* d;85,Fe

;:-sJrltaH;

" |E

:XE

;2 a.E

Vic5.-c:E

lr*-

=z

sE;; g: u::E

EI

5=899i/,

q]!p.

qnr.-.o4id'-87;f-.9,c3-3-=

!E

E.E

) ,;

6:- ,Y

.1-)LO

.^ao.9q:dix

troE

"ad F

E E

cdii

r'trq 6 !

tr g

E c

ET

-.t:; .E

s3

ica'-A3

E

:s,-sdigx

3 F

i.;:=

G-

f,f 6#;s z

gEoif;-o.E

3!.

- S

? tr

="F

trUE

,b3

to\o*oE-E

.o=

e

Y/a

- d

Lvrva-,aO

€i o'J=

't!

-a'eA

U..J.=

-!iru*>

e!d,:

- d

h ?

E

?=5

+=

!

! cd

aE

=a

E dH

-:.352 E

H

En s?€E

-r;u E

7E.: =

H;:H

EE

E

9.9E

>

u;.E-o6*

n tE

tr 6r'-*

d o.j

=

-Ot

! C

-t99 i==

i

&

>..,

E €F

'eq:€ E

eio

oJ, d

- -

-F

u d

i ,o

P

>':

a'- d

=.=

h!

;;

E'-gE

E4H

€ : E

E.E

i::eFeb€

9 ,a

-E=

>l.:-ei!;q.aai>7

***'",?g?t *

.€'::

6- =;

o i U

-

e ;

*t'-,

1-!ac.Etni

j .=

2=1i'=

) 'E

:r,l

O-=

Gr\6)

6.troAY

a.=-eA

eBo

r966

;i€.s€ooE

E'E

b , .. =.g F

9 T , F

e , € [-BH

;:u*lEii€i!:;iii

*E'rpE

E

Ea;z

o

ziu:A;ias i#l'eiiE

t:nsl=

8i::gEE

gz;=3B

e=

E:'>

,>F

tr:

+ d

q

! i e a-; F ii€ : E

g : a: E l u'"

E -E

EC

9 a: ='=

"q E Y

?' i En" i

z < r e E

z e E.: ", ",,i I

8" -,i,o, Eg'r-q E

a ? t=A

?Ee'u

,n F 3;

E

E;!

s = e g g E

H *3; s:; :

. '

l'i, r'lill ii'l

:g:3iE=

-FE

si €: E

tg=*:P

=n€=

v2:EE

€ Eg:8

*;"EseF

;+gt€;H

:r+iE

o, - E o ".8 -_i e *.oE

: F

.g : It8iE

'zZ;E

g€a'-E €gu:

FE

*EsE

.Hs€E

7*p:9.-s-.6-e- ---

E"Z

=;E

Zay

;tg:EE

Eeb -",o,E

Hb:

39x7tu U

g"sFA

H

5Et

d od

- c.9

*'i 9e'

L o

".i:H

'EE

23EeS

7: E

Ei

9':Egj"F

E-!

e.!:

e*:g;tEE

sH

PE

r9E

99-,,t o:,po

is€:-=

!.4.,c.2_.8 -::9

9EesE

l;;t- i' F

?E

g=!ciro-t'J

€gpg;i-.,:E

:E:

;*e>

Y'9;

o'ii -

E c

iv'=

>

E %

g E € *e e t ?'

, -ag E-i€!.bs.g.c-*€

E*.8tr

e;ts!EH

Hg€ E

"gi3

n 6t

c 6 a t

ooobodooDoc6oOocd

v!q .v,

V-c.cJ

jo466

Page 9: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

E:iiagli z{liiiiiiil giiiiE

iEii ??ii ii

gaiiE;l? aE

I iEa;f,gA

i :EIeiii;E

E aiii :i

t iiii;lti iglil:iEiil,E

iiEiE

iEB

i 'Eii E

i

t iiisi?eg E+

ii EE

?! EiiliiiiE

iEiE

i,liiE ii

iii: E

E iiii i iiA

Ei il

€ tiEE

SiiiE

iiii ; : sf s,, $

. ,..,.: ,., , .,-r ,.il:

,t,;.'1

E,T

Efif; ?|E

gEg*;:;

F€e.24=

s 5*gE

..EE

e;--e9*E

:gt ?€E

Eer:iooS

d!€5E

sEE

EgE

tEi:H

SA

=r-rE

gEii =

-3Ee nA

::"f aA=

E3 , e

9 ^ ". -E i

- h e ts F o -

itv? ;fE

gFE

ei*:!.P vE

;H

ee€-A

niZ

BF

;=aiir 2*", ii

5g::ci

1€i€;iti e,ucrt ti:rF

E

s{l!iF.;;

E!!E

; c-€*

: F";

e $?'$'€F;:

g

;A;^

gs:93-.;!o-oq ca.ziEg?f.

EI":

t:iE;; Z

Z,Z

aea it nz'zEE

iiEA

a!i Aii

;€EiieF

g? 8esez2zci.B

E pE

,; r ! *-; E ggE

F. s i; ii

E E

IE|A

iir?,g ;;1it'N

EA

E egi ; E

; gE H

?AE

i' iE*'

A?Z

:€3ji6;"se

av)da

Page 10: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

(

;EE

€! s:;gEtE

:iEE

f,!Ei E

Hai€iE

; EiE

i€3B

;iiFg E

?i?iiiiti litii giiliiiE iE

1€siE

{ iBiii iE

iiiiiiEE

giiiiiiiiiiiEi it;iiii,

€ ??igi E#E

i ;i:EE

?; ;ili+;;:ra€E

i iEiiiiii

IE i3 zl,i it iai aai € iE

i lia! i ;i! ii F

E iigi i ; j s

qo,=.9E

X6L--d+

S;o.Ljlco

o9?E

*u

---oava:--y9otda-q"3

73&

dtj

aE--ozzd=o

i.:

B3

EgU

a.E

i qp-euoo0m

99E

KS

'd€98e0?€F

gE?i$

;*;4eE!g:E

;: a?

E H

€ a=sl!: s e"-

!E:

ssH.*H

3i-zqa)E

.E5'

EE

a€;bEZ

EE

Ai:s

:EE

iEiB

i$g€_ h -3 =

_ .* B

-^: g HE

?^i=-E

oEo tB

; bi',H

Eg;f

=*4"-'

: "^E €; * E

iT eE

* i !?; f E gi€i

::ErE

a €t:? i:: ! $;i'42'q,

,'i;; H

F i E

F' € r' i

s : e :1?'a'ee$! aE

t gE B

i! gEi€ aa€'E

€F#

=i

!Eezaa>

:ddobo

rqod)H6opooto.9o!Z

c:

<.t

ANO

Page 11: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

ts olB

>

oa

c- <

E.=

>

,* o

o ts

o -!

r:EfrA

oq2oXF

-o o tr

s-CE

€ r Fi

!i11>oo

F!3E

eec,ooe R

b€;6--o!-=

!.-o

d !

o.=Y

o-.=E

H 3A

HE

a.=

d 5

d

€tt€ E

fo€ -? o

otr9",*}Itl H

;9.1iaodJud!o^.

gEE

Eg

Eg.':-g

h>do:

- trt5

>N

O

el5L-

EE

€EE

.=:c.?

bt

'o -

>':t=

:ead-:oo>.E

!

O76E

p'E

F X

Pb

oE

E E

E

F

, ....,1;r'ij,ln

6)

9 z'E -- 2n-

6^--ioooB

--= g'E

>ddE

RH

.;ctsa'"@

';,6L>a-.d

o-o--Y=

-v ?2=

;=u'

o:--itred';

I 2=

.==

g<

oa€&oEaOtrooqO

d€

Page 12: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

Cda

€--oo^cd6Io

:oodh0 i:tr?qoo-

c op

'o o

'=.6

O

ae:E

d!E

F

q -c

o.oaib

cEts >

-m

a iD

-- 5..2 € €

d€ .E

42>

hooIo

ZE(t)

d

OzI

'O€oq:

Eg

6'o3E

: E

E}E

Fe g€

E?

:. ge?

Eg

2 i=

ts t-

a E

Ed

='-

i- i-q-

?bt

g'Pt

o e

'd 8og

.2eE

bE

*s

AA^tr

vde

j [iE

u.

boaIe

Z zery-

^e!

P

E

E e-ar

s.d)

o;'

q ta^

oe

. o

i ^n

H

6'o !

o^iL;xaEo

&

b't 9:

Eat

E

t :

>,

o-c god

tr 9

i A

P

O

boocE

.=g

r,-iajhacd

E

.sE e.t

-s A

d*qF3

l: F

; E

^ >

e 2

- a

; e€

5E

2?

7E

2 eZ

=

e7 -;;

=t =

=

. o.--i

.=

.; FF

7sFF

T

-B

"s? E

z -:

:i h-=

o

i: .S

i--

.dC

A:C

OL.]\-

6

Page 13: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

L

EE

FiE

€a:i. IEE

i$FE

Eig;E

iiii[E i-E

Eg g

E

E *

A s=

i E: ur

T s?ee f,tE

:: lfEE

iE ;F

Eg 3:; E

;ti;t€i+

i;i ;: ;;:ir:cE;; ,E

E;;g: H

:;r; 'a .I

J, 2 4" : :j = E

:i ::U

E-E

:3:iZE

=,=

,?: ;FR

+ ; E

E p z* -

E E

EE

i I 3E 3t

aa:;iiEE

gET

uEE

{A€*aE

g gFF

;;;€i ; I E

,! S : s F

;i iE

q'u *":iF3 ;?t+

xi?p:* '=*;;'i

E

E :E

E € B

€ E; E

i ;;f$iiscE

?i;iF6€ ;ii

Es F

3! !; E

f) ?;-:.9:c€Es; i:€8,

t gIiiiigtiE iiiiiE

EiriE

EiiiiilF

iiiii iiiE

i;€€€:6Ffi ii:E

IIEU

T|E

I,EE

:FE

s;+gF

iiE

E2E

, i;i E

+ E

sc EE

s r?€iiiiEiE

iiiigEiliff i E

z,*;,a

=E

E ?,E

2 E,1',ni=

2J-E=

;--I'E2o

E!E

iTiu;€€=

qAqa2=

aio*A-€.*

i,z;?E; lgiii:E

;; lt:iiE I l:?H

i FgA

aE

o-c*EE

sb(:H

BE

s!;;i

E l1i i E

1*11 I ql E LE

ig E? I ? ai i fi 3i E

,elgei1rt1i?ltllEtxezz*I:c1?iE

lE

1111i1 eElll ztlllJ,?tii 111!'z€; eE

Et

e s e i s ? ? € a E

?r;a=lr;i\A

E i i ? e=

aE c E

ZazZ

E"' s E

:; -8 E

t

e-E+

eEQ

A'E

-t-O6.=

6oE

a)ao"-2'---/E

:\ePa--

--D

a-S

EsZ

4sai

q?'" -

=-o

c6 $€ E

ii: F

"6"tre

!,^cD6-

-u-:a,t4tA

41,,.-:tEb

YO

!+-r'LE

i€&?-aE

-P,=

o-Yad

E"=

:!E-s'

o-a'4'-t.><

dE-.6

?.AZ

g"et*p>

29d2.9-

3 a: -ts";! sqE

t

-9 o ^ c

VE

t; E

E E

a o

o L

a >

.2o co 5 "i ,;99-:

€&3=

>=

Li 9-

=

qo=

a-- a

d:-i'

E)-^

od^5

.=P

ddr

! O

O

!'O

o

::?oH

JSdd

- >

,=

o6=

Page 14: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

iiriggiilgiiliiglEiigilli;iaiiiigiiigl;i

r ltl,iiEEirgiiiiiiiigi tiii i;,iiiiiiE;Eliiiie iii ig?E E$;ii€gE l?iEEE aiis ii

'giEi

aiiii;{;iftlSSEi;3

Es€ iaR i*g;rilEetsilia iiii iiii;iiii*:;iir;

- , -,:.: .)

StEii,sFEEE E-;iEia|+aE E [:eEp;'ieee2'ea:^E:1Z€iF€EE-E;*:*;zirt'-$*X' c - d >=!- c; a = a

; o.Y! U c

P 3=EzEE"s-EE-tE **ni9E6 >X =989s= 90 SgEr'iE ;?i=El"E;sri=.=r=,-EiE:'i -.-.8]i+=-iSEAE!'"_ eai;ii +rl;E;rzErx-tre.8 :*i=*\ erEPEH'rinx3!;E>; g1pE?? gZYYZ:l'29-Q E ErEeet" e+3g =;; E€ ? =;t;b ? *!c li ! iFu;Ess EetaSEgEfi'BEEi:"'=lEei'r:u s€ ieptr; E + f Z?i& Ee! Ag A c.: eH-Ee F _ J-: &e f 3=€)l .?' -2e-. -o e,ES:i.u sr r:s gqi-s Z*EE;i: iE E;:E€? ; ;; s.9E *" E : Fq: Ea?*U ; ; A YA= =i z i''^" iE : : iSe

,igEl*lzzzzaz'*81?Ei!:ilrlarlili?;

6

O

Page 15: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

ot IE.:6a aa-,i-doo

65Id€;o; oEi/o >:1tsoia-ax

EE.:-o€do/o>o9=tEa,

! q!.F rrr b6C>

- 2nqx*

BE 6

Epl!>qo! E

a6a8 9"5e 3o.:R5e

q

>d

a

9.2.?9.e9E_38.=.2f,,9,:6.9F9+EY F 4 o ><!t'EsXEIe:7e#!);jtr!EEoOFSo;)cnU- d^x !E o a ^15ax>r:i:lJ;gEE.i.qsft€€IEZFEE?32",;^:S.- u.Y - -5.-6.;.-rz-^9.eHgsHi€*BF |.

= >'; o

- -

EE sE;E E-E E

.Hs;.E.-r91"o.EF;b3€9eF;EgEE:r9oBE b I E Ei i = F:tr= 9 -.F- 6 og uE b e og *;3o€ =;'69lE-o5i9ooL;ooE9o(!;!rOX E.E!tr^>

6 ==-q -.: >- 6:Ee.z ii 6Eo: F= do

i,f ,,1i.

E:.E€ e.$9 ts-ggej S - " n -o _- j t , o oTi=t :E9 ""a-"i4E uc IE!5a s!*E ;. rO a ,n j E

=>Eis ?;z-= ij.!: j= 6.2-9.2 ij ;

-=dnc=M-o"8""'53 €,i€Ei g(51- :;:.92 '2.u-.9? 2.i*;: ?:5r'^ E't-.2 trE -:;- d !?:9'oC.?iq -6tri'^, Ei+A': E*g=i :;!23 8"7=2i z

. 9 ^,.-.==ae-:A Ei*Z! HEEEE E:!E; icv 9 "'acc4 ?A eiLo dtr.=to9

,-dNgo

.;

dogs€d

:'.i,

+ 6 u a - o o -!,:"_d._!_-_:B€

?E siE!E;E€38R9 s^EgV.9t dE I U

:E E€-itEf*!BtE E :y eE S.:Et € e* 9!*sE E:= e€ Fsb 2e?.Yy-Ad.-L=6-=c; d -' tr L dd

-E e?-a E-3 E "3iE gt€g;EP FE 9 9 E ; € EE[: 9"E.E3EE3. = E g 3 =YE:BE ii!.:EEEEgE .!rEEEss32 E!SzEb9 ?= ' Fl9i 'EgE iz:E=E9 EE &O'b E P

€ :! : ei|Ii|il'i;;; eEE?;c;:E:itE:;e€I;Eg:E

oo

od

oog

a€do

&

doo6

a

Page 16: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

(

?iE i;s*i;i ilifii E *:E; €;i ii€;!l,;tii:E €i;!eE; ;;ia* E EEr;i a+,?E:;;iit3AaSi;B aiFE;;'g ;€;$: i iii€ r€iii;rEE: c!;s;f; E 'i'i*u'ii i EiE! I$:tElatiiifii

E i:; : *,i;ig;iiA, : EF;e ,E*lii ;?Ei!gEi!E

€ E;g =EE;'i,E:i;ut;i ;i?igiigl5;f!B:;eiEE ;E€ e :;il€i3;i

i e= E'€ ;i??i' i-'ii eEi€??iii;i E\EE+EEE

i :;E*; -Ez;€EaiE : Es+ se+::a;e r.EE#:EEE;

odooa:!o od 4iLo= e--i v ,,a-e/ ht

Y<2.__! 6

'A,noCEt-n t ?--6:_PDAo d -t

' J at Eon-l o o

> NE o y6-?ai

9d

>:a^a>gtroFoaz919v9ot

oddo

o:

o o d e e q E d? g E5>:!===,--EfrzetjiEa E pAE"zEE.E",-EE 9. q.:e=tPV'98;o e ';nt66 39'ie € 3@ - - @- a > v >ePEzZE-'- o +EE=,E=gEErZ e gE.oO t cEti .? =9Jj,;Ad1,v.i d a trt9*i:FEF, e nj c q i d: d,:- a i; q-'9 -E ut: E d b€E-?:-'?anY, e -'-;3.?^:iE-.-1 ' '-":E:E;;re ; eY- aZ ii i tr ! 4 t O.E ' -<aa c :'E o -oE g €

oo

Eco:soog

gv,;'iVP.F'ao6

d

Page 17: Kripke Speakers Reference and Semantic Reference

r

I

I

dari

o

,io

!.

F2

U

E6

EA.{F

z3'.:=:"q2-E€ad!c-dd

.!ott&

)A,Laa2o j! o3 [e -e.5+h-toar-9Exr t x< o-cf'!ox=H >.! H X!!!e-o

* E + irFXE€:o? 9F,9i=-ooo: cd- 9

.= \.= ;n o= 96 trY:!OQ

9Sd-h.s g € EOd;dtrvo-'.:!F;-9 F X.: o0 d i -.:

= i.@ o? tr F63Xo-r-b"BE g c::#t60o':' - o .O€ 1x g-L-=d6!.9 E c8.eEc.9i * H tr.;1dYox9)a-=o =.! a'-'t)iC

= tr Ji

.......,-L::.Lt

+ 3; * F E :?iEt; i =E;1:t;Eti alF"E€;FEjEili=:EE FuqEertEsEE$€tegEg :E*!€*-rEEE*f;E;€rC EEgEeF=s;!So c ! c€ : o E i F c "= - q ': 9 i?*eii ;;gt€EEIE[$€;t!:s :;es€5:E::EsEE;E: E*jri€ai€EsiigE:E :;ciEe3EE?:iH;i:E EE*A;E;;!uc: E Ei 5-e- E"vEf fi"4 ;=2ixZ -o F - bo= - o. @ I a o = : €

= c6i Fi E c'-

= a'o* a-i!*: ; d

E E E E I a ; : E ? !;: n E i.;=;€:;H *ZEEE:!€EF',:€FS€tsiFnt"-8i-a;;ii; >.j s j : ?: L. I 'l:.+e !

= t :

l:i:";gEE;EE:EgHEE;{Efa33i 3E l.=!€gH'EE

(nt(

z/&F(,pt-t

Iz

Q-9

=oatAx6o-

=E-e3 .a EEEE g= 3> Esd!,? + ?sEE ;* *E .Egl"-E E <--o=i F ie=: gE ;, E=o !Eb! 2v :€ 2il - c 6! a _. o^ !x' ;oF =o{! Ek :E 'A d:EE H; =;E E

E :l--6b =a d Z" 3*iEE 53,8; EO : F F: Zv P- ftE,.E:a-e ?2'e*-, !ir EE=.; =fii22 EE ob-6: -q3=-o ua "- 99'2 c.E b.;q t53o=; 53s it€€: 6e

Z"rE =-,c ;IM6 o ., t d od I E i 6 b,b.=

e?E 4a €=z L 9+ za: EE ;'-2 --6!*Eo, d _! tu a d =,^'-'d - a -s -c S'6=n!==^O

- (;,8 e *o UT -a e; t9696d:i0E7"-!-E=ia az-,r !)3-a=Z&tr : " o i :-! . o'tr = bA€ ; J 9!. E 9Y v2235E:E

t a E'. - ' I - ?a s7g e€€ + ?d

6

+

d

Q