ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and...

13
ISSN- 2456-219X, Volume 1 Issue 3, Page 84-96 Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Biomechanics __________________________ *Corresponding Author : P.R Chitragar Email Address:[email protected] Use of Hydrogen in Internal Combustion Engines: A Comprehensive Study Parashuram R Chitragar * , Shivaprasad K V ** , Kumar G N *** * Department of Mechanical Engineering, VPKBIET Baramati, India **Department of of Automotive Engineering, College of Engineering and Technology, Dilla University, Ethiopia ***Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITK Surathkal, India ________________________________________________________________________ Abstract Hydrogen’s combustion properties made it as a capable fuel to combat the current situations of depletion of the fossil fuels and to safeguard the environmental pollution problems. Its energy content per unit mass and higher heating value is almost about three times that of current fossil fuels. Hydrogen ignites across a wide range of concentrations, from about 4 to 74 percent, and only requires a small amount of energy to initiate ignition. Moreover when hydrogen reacts with oxygen to generate energy, the resulting reaction product is water vapor. In view of the above hydrogen can be used as a fuel in internal combustion engines or in fuel cell vehicles. In this paper a thorough review was made to bring awareness among buddy researchers working on hydrogen about combustion fundamentals, its anomalies, fuel induction strategies, performance, emission and safety related aspects for utilizing it in IC Engines as an alternative fuel. 2016 Published by Rational Publication. Review Article Article History Received 08/08/2016 Revised 17/10/2016 Accepted 26/10/2016 Keywords: I C Engine; Hydrogen; Injection; Ignition; Performance; Emissions; Safety 1 Introduction Petroleum and its derivatives are in phase of depletion. On the other side automotive emissions are increasing due to use of fossil fuels. Meanwhile stringent emission regulations on automotive provoked many of the researchers to search for the feasible alternative fuel for the internal combustion (IC) engines. Among the available alternative fuel options; hydrogen finds prominent place to replace the present fossil fuels in IC engines. Hydrogen is available abundantly in nature and gives near zero-emissions when used in IC engines. It can be used in fuel cells or directly in IC engines [1-3] . The attempt of developing a hydrogen engine was reported by R.W. Cecil in the early of the 19th century itself. During mid of the last century Otto used synthetic producer gas which probably had a hydrogen content of over 50%. Hydrogen has since been used extensively in the space program since it has the best energy-to-weight ratio of any fuel & lighter than other fuel and has been utilized in the upper stages of launch vehicles on many space missions and for rocket engines.

Transcript of ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and...

Page 1: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

ISSN- 2456-219X, Volume 1 Issue 3, Page 84-96

Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Biomechanics

__________________________ *Corresponding Author : P.R Chitragar

Email Address:[email protected]

Use of Hydrogen in Internal Combustion Engines: A

Comprehensive Study Parashuram R Chitragar

*, Shivaprasad K V

**, Kumar G N

***

*Department of Mechanical Engineering, VPKBIET Baramati, India

**Department of of Automotive Engineering, College of Engineering and Technology, Dilla University, Ethiopia ***Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITK Surathkal, India

________________________________________________________________________ Abstract

Hydrogen’s combustion properties made it as a capable fuel to combat the current

situations of depletion of the fossil fuels and to safeguard the environmental pollution

problems. Its energy content per unit mass and higher heating value is almost about three

times that of current fossil fuels. Hydrogen ignites across a wide range of concentrations,

from about 4 to 74 percent, and only requires a small amount of energy to initiate ignition.

Moreover when hydrogen reacts with oxygen to generate energy, the resulting reaction

product is water vapor.

In view of the above hydrogen can be used as a fuel in internal combustion engines

or in fuel cell vehicles. In this paper a thorough review was made to bring awareness among

buddy researchers working on hydrogen about combustion fundamentals, its anomalies, fuel

induction strategies, performance, emission and safety related aspects for utilizing it in IC

Engines as an alternative fuel.

2016 Published by Rational Publication.

Review Article

Article History

Received 08/08/2016

Revised 17/10/2016

Accepted 26/10/2016

Keywords: I C Engine; Hydrogen; Injection; Ignition; Performance; Emissions; Safety

1 Introduction

Petroleum and its derivatives are in phase of depletion. On the other side automotive emissions are increasing due

to use of fossil fuels. Meanwhile stringent emission regulations on automotive provoked many of the researchers to

search for the feasible alternative fuel for the internal combustion (IC) engines. Among the available alternative fuel

options; hydrogen finds prominent place to replace the present fossil fuels in IC engines. Hydrogen is available

abundantly in nature and gives near zero-emissions when used in IC engines. It can be used in fuel cells or directly in

IC engines [1-3]

.

The attempt of developing a hydrogen engine was reported by R.W. Cecil in the early of the 19th century itself.

During mid of the last century Otto used synthetic producer gas which probably had a hydrogen content of over 50%.

Hydrogen has since been used extensively in the space program since it has the best energy-to-weight ratio of any fuel

& lighter than other fuel and has been utilized in the upper stages of launch vehicles on many space missions and for

rocket engines.

Page 2: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

85

Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view of its ability to be produced from a host of non-fossil sources [4-5]

. Hydrogen

combustion does not produce any of the major pollutants such as carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbon (HC), sulphur

oxides (SOx), smoke etc. An oxide of nitrogen (NOx) is the single pollutant which needs to be closely monitored[6-7]

.

Thus, hydrogen is probably the unique versatile fuel which provides permanent solutions to fuel dependency, fuel

depletion and global environmental problems. This paper tried to provide an overview of hydrogen as a possible major

fuel of the future, which can be used in an internal combustion engines.

2. Scope for Hydrogen.

Internal combustion engines are either spark ignition (SI) engines or compression ignition (CI) engines. An IC

engine can be run on different fuels. Currently practical SI engines are gasoline operated whereas CI engines use diesel

as their major fuel. Hydrogen is one of the energy carriers which can replace fossil fuel and can be used as electricity

generator in fuel cell vehicles (FCV) or as a fuel in hydrogen fueled internal combustion engines (𝐻2𝐼𝐶𝐸).

Fuel cell vehicles using hydrogen are attractive for their potential efficiency, quiet running, modular and their

emission is only water vapor [8]

. On the other hand, they require excessively high purity hydrogen, need more space and

weight to install the battery and storage tank and hence they are currently compromised due to cost and durability

concerns [2]

.

On the other hand, hydrogen internal combustion engines offer a number of very interesting advantages. They are

less expensive and they run with hydrogen of only industrial purity [2]

. There are different ways to use hydrogen as a

fuel in IC engines; it can be used in liquid state, or in gaseous state. A cryogenic storage up to capacity of 20K

approximately is required if it is used in liquid state but is injected in gaseous state or it can be used in gaseous state

like liquid petroleum gas (LPG) and compressed natural gas (CNG). Gaseous hydrogen storage systems are large and

heavy wherein liquid hydrogen storage systems are much smaller and lighter but must operate at cryogenic

temperatures. Hydrogen can also offer the opportunity of running on mixed fuel with gasoline and diesel fuel [9, 10]

.

3. Hydrogen as a Fuel

3.1 Hydrogen Production

Hydrogen is produced from a wide range of primary resources, employing wide range of technologies. Despite its

abundance occurrence in the universe, it does not occur freely on earth, as it reacts very rapidly with other elements.

For this reason, the majority of hydrogen is bound into molecular compounds. The hydrogen can be extracted from

higher energy fossil fuels or lower energy water [11]

.

Fig. 1Hydrogen production path[30]

Page 3: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

86

Alternative methods of hydrogen production include thermochemical water decomposition, photo conversions,

photo biological processes, production from biomass, and industrial processes. A hydrogen production path is

summarized in Fig 1.

3.2 Combustive Properties of Hydrogen

Combustion properties of hydrogen are presented in Table 1, and are detailed below:

3.2.1) Flammability: Hydrogen has a wide flammability range of 4-75% in comparison with all other fuels. As

a result, hydrogen can be combusted in an IC engine over a wide range of fuel-air mixtures. A significant advantage of

this is that hydrogen can run on a lean or rich mixture [7]

.

3.2.2) Ignition Energy: Ignition energy is the amount of energy required to ignite a combustible vapor or gas

mixture. At atmospheric conditions, hydrogen has very low ignition energy. The minimum ignition energy of a

hydrogen–air mixture is 0.02mJ which is an order of magnitude lower than that required for gasoline. This enables

hydrogen engines to ignite lean mixtures and ensures prompt ignition. But it poses problems of premature ignition and

back fire.

3.2.3) Quenching Distance:This parameter measures how hydrogen flames can travel closer to the cylinder

wall before they extinguish. As compared to gasoline and other fuels, hydrogen has small quenching distance of 0.64

mm against 2.0 mm of gasoline. Consequently, this increases the tendency for backfire.

3.2.4) Auto ignition Temperature: Hydrogen has relatively high auto ignition temperature of 858 K. This high

temperature allows larger compression ratios to be used in a hydrogen engine than in a hydrocarbon engine. This

higher compression ratio leads to higher thermal efficiency of the engine. On the other hand, hydrogen is difficult to be

ignited in a compression ignition engine; because the temperature needed for ignition is relatively high. [12]

3.2.5) Flame Speed: Hydrogen has high flame speed at stoichiometric ratios of nearly 2.65 m/s which is an

order of magnitude higher (faster) than of conventional fuels. This means that hydrogen engines can more closely

approach thermodynamically ideal engine cycle.

3.2.6) Diffusivity: Hydrogen possesses remarkably high diffusivity of 0.61𝑐𝑚2/𝑠. This ability to disperse in

air is considerably greater than gasoline and is advantageous for two main reasons. Firstly, it facilitates the formation

of a uniform mixture of fuel and air. Secondly, if a hydrogen leak develops, the hydrogen disperses rapidly. Thus,

unsafe conditions can either be avoided or minimized and leaking hydrogen is not a pollutant to the environment [7, 12].

3.2.7) Density: Hydrogen has very low density of 0.082kg/m3. This results in two problems of IC engine.

Firstly, a very large volume is necessary to store enough hydrogen to provide sufficient driving range. Secondly, it

reduces the power output.

3.2.8) Air-Fuel Ratio: The stoichiometric or chemically correct air-fuel ratio for the complete combustion of

hydrogen in air is about 34:1 by mass. This is much higher than the air-fuel ratio (14.7:1) required for gasoline. Since

hydrogen is a gaseous fuel at ambient conditions it displaces more of the combustion chamber than a liquid fuel.

Consequently less of the combustion chamber can be occupied by air. At stoichiometric conditions, hydrogen displaces

about 30% of the combustion chamber, compared to about 1 to 2% for gasoline.

Table1. Properties of hydrogen, gasoline and diesel [7, 8, 12]

Property Hydrogen Gasoline Diesel

Chemical formula H2 C8H18 C12H23

Page 4: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

87

3.3. Use of Hydrogen in Fuel cell vehicles

A fuel cell is an energy conversion device that can operate using a variety of fuels and oxidants. Hydrogen has long

been recognized as the most effective fuel for practical fuel cell use since it has higher electrochemical reactivity than

other fuels [12]

.A hydrogen fuel cell converts the chemical energy of hydrogen fuel into electricity without any

intermediate thermal or mechanical processes and this energy is used to power the vehicles.

Fig.2 Hydrogen fuel cell [12]

In hydrogen fuel cell, the hydrogen and the oxidizer (oxygen/air) themselves comprise of an anode, cathode

respectively with an electrolyte in between. The hydrogen fuel cell as shown in Fig.2 is suitable for automotive

applications which uses low temperature (less than 1000C) and have solid electrolyte that conducts hydrogen

ions.Hydrogen fuel cell systems operate without pollution when run on pure hydrogen, the only by products being pure

water and heat. But they are costly, heavy and need more space.

Molecular weight (g/mol) 2.015 110 ≈200

Flammability limits (%) 4-75 1-7.6 0.6-5.5

Minimum ignition energy (mJ) 0.02 0.24 --

Stoichiometric A/F ratio on mass basis 34.3 14.6 14.5

Flame temperature (K) 2318 2473 2600

Auto ignition temperature (K) 858 500-753 453-593

Quenching distance at NTP (mm) 0.64 2.0 ---

Density at 1 atm and 300K (kg/m3) 0.082 730 830

HHV (MJ/kg) 141.7 48.29 44.8

LHV (MJ/kg) 119.7 44.79 42.5

Diffusion coefficient into air at NTP (cm2/s) 0.61 0.05 4.63

Flame velocity (m/s) 2.65– 3.25 0.30-.50 0.22–0.25

Octane number 130+ 87 30

Page 5: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

88

3.4. Use of Hydrogen in IC Engines

3.4.1. Use of Hydrogen in Spark Ignition Engines

Hydrogen is an excellent candidate for use in SI engines as a fuel having some unique and highly desirable

properties, such as low ignition energy, fast flame propagation speed and wide operational range. The hydrogen fuel

when mixed with air produces a combustible mixture which can be burned in a conventional spark ignition engine at an

equivalence ratio below the lean flammability limit of a gasoline/air mixture. The resulting ultra-lean combustion

produces low flame temperatures and leads directly to lower heat transfer to the walls, higher engine efficiency and

lower exhaust of NOx emission [7]

. Fig.3 shows the use of liquid and gaseous hydrogen in SI engines

Fig.3 Use of hydrogen in SI engine [31]

3.4.2. Use of Hydrogen in Compression Ignition Engines

Hydrogen cannot be used as a sole fuel in a compression ignition engine, since the compression temperature is

not enough to initiate the combustion due to its higher self-ignition temperature [13]

. Hence hydrogen cannot be used in

CI engine without the assistance of a spark plug or glow plug. However it can be used as an additional fuel with diesel

in CI engines.

Hydrogen as an additional fuel to accompany diesel fuel in CI engine increases the hydrogen to carbon ratio of

the entire fuel and injecting it in small amounts to a diesel engine could decrease heterogeneity of a diesel fuel spray

due to the high diffusivity of hydrogen which makes the combustible mixture better premixed with air and hence more

uniform combustion.Conventional diesel engines can be converted to operate on hydrogen–diesel dual mode with up to

about 38% of full-load energy substitution without any sacrifice on the performance parameters such as power and

efficiency [14]

.

4. Combustion Anomalies

The properties that make hydrogen such a desirable fuel for IC engines also bear responsibility for abnormal

combustion events associated with it. In particular, the wide flammability limits, low ignition energy and high flame

speeds can result in undesired combustion phenomena generally summarized as combustion anomalies.Theseanomalies

include pre ignition (surface ignition), backfiring, rapid pressure rise and auto ignition [15]

. The suppression of

abnormal combustion in hydrogen engine has proven to be quite a challenge and measures taken to avoid abnormal

combustion have important implications for engine design, mixture formation, and load control.

4.1. Pre-Ignition

Page 6: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

89

Pre-ignition is often encountered with hydrogen engines because of the low ignition energy and wide flammability

limits of hydrogen. As a premature ignition causes the mixture to burn mostly during the compression stroke, the

temperature in the combustion chamber rises, which causes the hot spot that, leads to the pre-ignition to increase in

temperature, resulting in another earlier pre-ignition in the next cycle [16]

. This advancement of the pre-ignition

continues until it occurs during the suction stroke and causes backfire.Pre-ignition is more pronounced when the

hydrogen–air mixtures approach stoichiometric level and at higher engine speed and load due to higher gas and

component temperatures.

4.2. Backfire

Backfire is a violent consequence of the pre-ignition phenomena. When pre-ignition occur at a point near the inlet

valve when the valve is open, the enflamed charge can travel past the valve and into the inlet manifold, resulting in

backfire. This problem is particularly dangerous in pre-mixed fuel inducted engines where there is the possibility that

an ignitable fuel-air mixture is present in the inlet manifold [17].

The occurrence of backfiring is generally limited to

external mixture formation concepts. Any measures that help avoid pre-ignition also reduce the risk of backfiring.

4.3. Auto-Ignition and Knock

Knocking combustion is a common problem found in hydrogen-fuelled engines. When fuel and oxidizer inside the

cylinder reaches extremities of temperature then end gas ignites spontaneously without the aid of spark which is termed

as auto-ignition, then follows a rapid release of the remaining energy generating high-amplitude pressure waves,

referred as engine knock. The amplitude of the pressure waves can cause engine damage due to increased mechanical

and thermal stress. The tendency of an engine to knock depends on the engine design as well as the fuel-air mixture

properties [18]

.

5. Fuel Delivery Systems

The mode of fuel induction system plays a critical role for hydrogen operated IC engine. Different fuel induction

mechanisms were evaluated experimentally in [19]

. Those systems can be grouped into three main types as stated in

most of the literatures [1, 20, 21]

. Those are discussed in following section.

1. Fuel Carburetion Method (CMI),2. Inlet Manifold and Inlet Port Injection; and 3. Direct Cylinder Injection (DI)

5.1. Fuel Carburetion Method (CMI)

This is the oldest and simplest technique where gas carburetor is used for carburation of hydrogen fuel. This is also

called as central injection system. This system has advantages of not requiring high supply pressure as for other

methods and making it easier to convert a standard gasoline engine to hydrogen or a gasoline-hydrogen engine. The

disadvantage of this technique is that the volume occupied by the fuel is about 1.7% of the mixture and hence results in

15-20% power loss.

Thus, this method is not at all suitable for hydrogen engine, because it gives rise to uncontrolled combustion at

unscheduled points in the engine cycle. Also the greater amount of hydrogen/air mixture within the intake manifold

compounds the effects of pre-ignition which leads to back fire[12, 17, 19]

. A schematic diagram illustrating the operation

of fuel carburetion method is shown in Fig. 4.

Page 7: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

90

Fig.4 Fuel carburetion method [7]

5.2. Inlet Manifold and Inlet Port Injection

The port injection fuel delivery system injects fuel directly into the intake manifold at each intake port by using

mechanically or electronically operated injector, rather than drawing fuel in at a central point. Typically, the hydrogen

is injected into the manifold after the beginning of the intake stroke. Electronic injectors are robust in design with a

greater control over the injection timing and injection duration with quicker response to operate under high speed

conditions.

In port injection, the air is injected separately at the beginning of the intake stroke to dilute the hot residual gases

and cool any hot spots. Since less gas (hydrogen or air) is in the manifold at all time, pre-ignition is less severe [22]

. The

inlet supply pressure for port injection tends to be higher than for carbureted or central injection systems, but less than

for direct injection systems [12]

. A schematic diagram illustrating the operation of inlet port injection is shown in Fig. 5.

In this system, the inducted volume of air per cycle is kept constant and the power output can be controlled by the

amount of fuel injected into the air stream, thus allowing lean operation. The fuel can either be metered by varying the

injection pressure of the hydrogen, or by changing the injection duration by controlling the signal pulse to the injector [16]

.

Fig.5 Inlet manifold and inlet port injection [7]

5.3. Direct Injection Systems

This system is more technologically sophisticated and involves forming the fuel-air mixture inside the

combustion cylinder after the air intake valve has closed. Here hydrogen is injected directly inside the combustion

Page 8: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

91

chamber with the required pressure near the end of compression stroke. As hydrogen diffuses quickly, the mixing of

hydrogen with air takes place instantaneously. For ignition spark plug is used as a source. The problem of drop in

power output as was in manifold induction/injection can be completely eliminated by this method[7]

. A schematic

diagram illustrating the operation of direct injection is shown in Fig.6.

Fig.6 Direct injection system [7]

Direct injection is the most efficient injection system compared to other methods. The power output of a direct

injected hydrogen engine is 20% more than for a gasoline engine. While direct injection solves the problem of pre-

ignition in the intake manifold, but it does not necessarily prevent pre-ignition within the combustion chamber [12]

. In

addition, due to the reduced mixing time of the air and fuel in a direct injection engine, the air-fuel mixture can be non-

homogenous [23]

.

6. Ignition System

Due to hydrogen’s low ignition energy limit, igniting hydrogen is easy and gasoline ignition systems can be used.

At very lean air fuel ratios (130:1 to 180:1), the flame velocity is reduced considerably and the use of a dual spark plug

system is preferred.

Ignition systems that use a waste spark system should not be used for hydrogen engines [12].

These systems energize

the spark each time when the piston is at top dead center irrespective of running stroke. Therefore the waste sparks

acts as a source of pre-ignition for hydrogen engines. For gasoline engines, waste spark systems work well and are less

expensive than other systems.

Spark plugs for a hydrogen engine should have a cold rating and have non-platinum tips to avoid oxidization with

air as platinum is catalyst. A cold-rated plug has a shorter insulator nose and dissipates heat from the plug tip to the

cylinder head quicker than a hot-rated spark plug and firing end stays cooler than hot rated spark plug. The insulator

nose of a cold spark plug also has a smaller surface area. This means the chances of the spark plug tip igniting the air-

fuel charge is reduced. Hot rated spark plugs are designed to maintain a certain amount of heat so that carbon deposits

do not accumulate. Since hydrogen does not contain carbon, hot-rated spark plugs do not serve a useful function.

7. Performance Parameters

7.1. Thermal Efficiency

Page 9: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

92

The theoretical thermodynamic efficiency of an Otto cycle engine is based on the compression ratio of the engine

and the specific-heat ratio of the fuel as shown by the equation (1).

𝑡ℎ

= 1 − 1

𝑣1𝑣2 −1 (1)

Where 𝑡ℎ = Theoretical thermal efficiency,

𝑣1

𝑣2 = the compression ratio,

= Ratio of specific heats.

The thermal efficiency of the engine is higher if the compression ratio and/or the specific heat ratio is higher.

The compression ratio limit of an engine is based on the fuel’s resistance to knock. A lean hydrogen mixture is less

susceptible to knock than conventional gasoline due to its higher octane number and therefore can tolerate higher

compression ratios. The specific-heat ratio is related to the fuel’s molecular structure. Higher the specific-heat ratio

lesser the molecular structure complexity. Hydrogen has a much simpler molecular structure than gasoline and

therefore its specific-heat ratio (γ = 1.4) is higher than that of conventional gasoline (γ = 1.1).

7.2. Power Output

The theoretical maximum power output from a hydrogen engine depends on the air-fuel ratio and fuel injection

method used.

As mentioned earlier the stoichiometric air-fuel ratio for hydrogen by mass is 34:1. At this air-fuel ratio,

hydrogen will displace 29% of the combustion chamber leaving only 71% for the air. As a result, the energy content of

this mixture will be less than it would be if the fuel were gasoline (since gasoline is a liquid, it only occupies a very

small volume of the combustion chamber, and thus allows more air to enter).

Since both the carbureted and port injection methods mix the fuel and air prior to entering the combustion

chamber, these systems limit the maximum theoretical power obtainable to approximately 80-85% that of gasoline

engines. For direct injection systems, which mix the fuel with the air after the intake valve has closed (and thus the

combustion chamber has 100% air), the maximum output of the engine can be approximately 15-20% higher than that

for gasoline engines.

Therefore, depending on how the fuel is metered, the maximum output for a hydrogen engine can be either 15-

20% higher or 15-20% lesser than that of gasoline if a stoichiometric air-fuel ratio is used. However, at a

stoichiometric air-fuel ratio, the combustion temperature is very high and as a result it will form a large amount of

nitrogen oxides, which is a major pollutant. Since one of the reasons for using hydrogen is low exhaust emissions,

hydrogen engines are not normally designed to run at a stoichiometric air-fuel ratio.

Typically hydrogen engines are designed to use about twice as much air as theoretically required for complete

combustion. At this air-fuel ratio, the formation of NOx is reduced to near zero. Unfortunately, this also reduces the

power output to about half that of a similarly sized gasoline engine. To make up for the power loss, hydrogen engines

are usually larger than gasoline engines, and/or are equipped with turbochargers or superchargers.

8. Emissions

The combustion of hydrogen with oxygen produces water as its only product:

2𝐻2 + 𝑂2 = 2𝐻2𝑂 (2)

The combustion of hydrogen with air however can also produce oxides of nitrogen (NOx):

Page 10: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

93

𝐻2 + 𝑂2 + 𝑁2 = 𝐻2𝑂 + 𝑁2 + 𝑁𝑂𝑥 (3)

The oxides of nitrogen are created due to the high temperatures generated within the combustion chamber

during combustion. This high temperature causes some of the nitrogen in the air to combine with the oxygen in the air.

The amount of NOx formed depends on the air-fuel ratio, compression ratio, engine speed, ignition timing and whether

thermal dilution is utilized or not [12, 24]

.

In addition to oxides of nitrogen, traces of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide can be present in the exhaust

gas, due to seeped oil burning in the combustion chamber. Depending on the condition of the engine (burning of oil)

and the operating strategy used (a rich versus lean air-fuel ratio), a hydrogen engine can produce from almost zero

emissions (as low as a few ppm) to high NOx and significant carbon monoxide emissions.

Fig.7 illustrates a typically NOx curve relative to equivalence ratio for a hydrogen engine. A similar graph

including other emissions is shown in Fig. 8 for gasoline.

Fig.7 Emissions for a hydrogen engine [24]

Page 11: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

94

Fig.8 Emissions for a gasoline engine [12]

As Fig. 8 shows, the NOx for a gasoline engine is reduced as equivalence ratio decreases (similar to a hydrogen

engine). However, in a gasoline engine the reduction in NOx is compromised by an increase in carbon monoxide and

hydrocarbons [8, 25]

.

9. Safety

Taking into account of hydrogen’s lower buoyancy, high auto-ignition temperature, high specific heat and

diffusivity, it has been argued that hydrogen is a much safer fuel [26, 27]

. Experiments carried out on hydrogen leak in

moving vehicle as shown in fig.9 shows that, because of dispersion, the risk of explosion is minimal[28]

. It has also been

demonstrated that a hydrogen fire causes less damage to a vehicle than a conventional fuel[29]

. Some have even argued

that in the case of a crash, hydrogen fuel is no more dangerous than conventional fuels. On the other hand, because of

its wide range of flammability in air and its low ignition energy, hydrogen as fuel sets new challenges for safety in

storage and in use.

Page 12: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

95

Fig.9 Safety of hydrogen

10. Conclusions

The key outcomes of this study are summarized below:

Hydrogen can be used in internal combustion engines either as a fuel, or in terms of a fuel cell.

Hydrogen can be used in internal combustion engines either as pure or blended with gasoline engine.

Hydrogen can be used in spark ignition engines with or without any modifications in the existing systems.

Pre-ignition can be avoided by adopting proper design of injection method and providing cold rated non-

platinum type spark plug.

Backfiring in hydrogen engines is limited to external mixture formation operation and can be avoided by

adopting appropriately designed direct injection system.

Thermal efficiency of the hydrogen operated engine is higher than gasoline and diesel operated engines.

Power output of hydrogen internal combustion engine is 15-20% more or less than the gasoline or diesel

engine which depends upon the fuel injection method adopted.

H2ICE are attractive for reducing global warming and local pollutions problems in comparison with gasoline

and diesel engines.

Hydrogen is a safer fuel than conventional fuels. Hydrogen engine may achieve lean-combustion in its actual cycles thus reducing NOxemissions.

References:

[1] Das LM. Hydrogen engines: a view of the past and a look into the future. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy.

1990 Dec 31;15(6):425-43.

Page 13: ISSN- 2456-219X Journal of Mechanical Engineering and ...rationalpublication.com/admin/public/uploads/7/97_pdf.pdfP.R Chitragar et. al 85 Perhaps hydrogen is the ideal fuel in view

P.R Chitragar et. al

96

[2] Fayaz H, Saidur R, Razali N, Anuar FS, Saleman AR, Islam MR. An overview of hydrogen as a vehicle fuel.

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2012 Oct 31;16(8):5511-28.

[3] Fayaz H, Saidur R, Razali N, Anuar FS, Saleman AR, Islam MR. An overview of hydrogen as a vehicle fuel.

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2012 Oct 31;16(8):5511-28.

[4] Veziroğlu TN, Şahi S. 21st Century’s energy: Hydrogen energy system. Energy conversion and management. 2008

Jul 31;49(7):1820-31.

[5] Hart D. Hydrogen–a truly sustainable transport fuel?. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment. 2003 Apr

1;1(3):138-45.

[6] Das LM. Hydrogen engine: research and development (R&D) programmes in Indian Institute of Technology (IIT),

Delhi. International journal of hydrogen energy. 2002 Sep 30;27(9):953-65.

[7] Ciniviz M and Hüseyin K. Hydrogen use in internal combustion engine: a review. International Journal of

Automotive Engineering and Technologies. 2012; 1(1), 1-15.

[8] Soberanis ME, Fernandez AM. A review on the technical adaptations for internal combustion engines to operate with

gas/hydrogen mixtures. International journal of hydrogen energy. 2010 Nov 30;35(21):12134-40.

[9] Karim GA. Hydrogen as a spark ignition engine fuel. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2003 May

31;28(5):569-77.

[10] Shivaprasad KV, Raviteja S, Chitragar P, Kumar GN. Experimental investigation of the effect of hydrogen addition

on combustion performance and emissions characteristics of a spark ignition high speed gasoline engine. Procedia

Technology. 2014 Dec 31;14:141-8.

[11] Verhelst S. Recent progress in the use of hydrogen as a fuel for internal combustion engines. international journal of

hydrogen energy. 2014 Jan 13;39(2):1071-85.

[12] Lanz A, Heffel J, Messer C. Hydrogen fuel cell engines and related technologies. College of the Desert, Energy

Technology Training Center; 2001.

[13] Saravanan N, Nagarajan G, Sanjay G, Dhanasekaran C, Kalaiselvan KM. Combustion analysis on a DI diesel engine

with hydrogen in dual fuel mode. Fuel. 2008 Dec 31;87(17):3591-9.

[14] Boudries R. Hydrogen as a fuel in the transport sector in Algeria. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2014

Sep 12;39(27):15215-23.

[15] Verhelst S, Wallner T. Hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engines. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science.

2009 Dec 31;35(6):490-527.

[16] Verhelst S, Verstraeten S, Sierens R. A comprehensive overview of hydrogen engine design features. Proceedings of

the institution of mechanical engineers, Part D: Journal of automobile engineering. 2007 Aug 1;221(8):911-20.

[17] Overend E. Hydrogen combustion engines. The Unıversıty of Edınburgh, School of Mechanical Engineering.1999;

pp. 1-77

[18] Verhelst S, Wallner T. Hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engines. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science.

2009 Dec 31;35(6):490-527.

[19] White CM, Steeper RR, Lutz AE. The hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engine: a technical review. International

journal of hydrogen energy. 2006 Aug 31;31(10):1292-305.

[20] Das LM. Studies on timed manifold injection in hydrogen operated spark ignition engine: performance, combustion

and exhaust emission characteristics (Doctoral dissertation, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi).

[21] Das LM. Near-term introduction of hydrogen engines for automotive and agricultural application. International

Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2002 May 31;27(5):479-87.

[22] Saravanan N, Nagarajan G. Performance and emission studies on port injection of hydrogen with varied flow rates

with diesel as an ignition source. Applied Energy. 2010 Jul 31;87(7):2218-29.

[23] Masood M, Ishrat MM, Reddy AS. Computational combustion and emission analysis of hydrogen–diesel blends with

experimental verification. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2007 Sep 30;32(13):2539-47.

[24] Shivaprasad KV, Chitragar PR, Kumar GN. Effect of Hydrogen Addition on Combustion and Emission

Characteristics of High Speed Spark Ignition Engine-An Experimental Study. SAE Technical Paper; 2015 Apr 14.

[25] Das LM. Exhaust emission characterization of hydrogen-operated engine system: nature of pollutants and their

control techniques. International journal of hydrogen energy. 1991 Jan 1;16(11):765-75.

[26] Veziro TN, Barbir F. Hydrogen: the wonder fuel. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 1992 Jun 30;17(6):391-

404.

[27] Utgikar VP, Thiesen T. Safety of compressed hydrogen fuel tanks: leakage from stationary vehicles. Technology in

Society. 2005 Aug 31;27(3):315-20.

[28] Tamura Y, Takeuchi M, Sato K. Effectiveness of a blower in reducing the hazard of hydrogen leaking from a

hydrogen-fueled vehicle. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2014 Dec 3;39(35):20339-49.

[29] Ubong EU. Safety issues in hydrogen transportation. InElectrical Insulation Conference and Electrical Manufacturing

& Coil Winding Technology Conference, 2003. Proceedings 2003 Sep 23 (pp. 395-401). IEEE.

[30] http://www.fsec.ucf.edu/en/consumer/hydrogen/basics/images/HydrogenProductionPaths.gif.

[31] http://images.tutorvista.com/cms/images/44/hydrogen-fuel-stroke-engine.JPG