Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

download Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

of 6

Transcript of Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    1/6

    J Clin Periodontol 2000; 27: 267272 Copyright C Munksgaard 2000

    Printed in Denmark . All rights reserved

    ISSN 0303-6979

    F. Mercado1, Roderick I. Marshall1,

    Alexander C. Klestov2 and

    Is there a relationship betweenP. Mark Bartold11Department of Dentistry, University ofQueensland, 2Rheumatology Department,rheumatoid arthritis andRoyal Brisbane Hospital, Australia

    periodontal disease?

    Mercado F, Marshall RI, Klestov AC, Bartold PM: Is there a relationship between

    rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease? J Clin Periodontol 2000; 27: 267272.

    C Munksgaard, 2000.

    Abstract

    Aim: The aim of this study was to determine whether there is a relationshipbetween disease experience of rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease.Methods: 1412 individuals attending the University of Queenslands School ofDentistry were assessed for the prevalence of periodontal disease and rheuma-toid arthritis. Analysis of data obtained from a self-reported health questionnaireand dental records was carried out and included: number of individuals referredfor advanced periodontal care (test group); number of individuals attending forroutine dentistry; determination of rheumatoid arthritis, cardiovascular diseaseand diabetes mellitus through self-reporting and assessment of prescription medi-cations; assessment of periodontal disease through assessment of existing oralradiographs.Results: In patients referred for periodontal treatment, the prevalence of self-reported rheumatoid arthritis was 3.95% which is significantly higher than thatseen in patients not referred for periodontal treatment (0.66%) and also that

    reported in the general population (1%). Of those referred patients with rheu-matoid arthritis, 62.5% had advanced forms of periodontal disease. These resultswere mirrored in the results of the self-reported prevalence of cardiovascular diseaseand diabetes mellitus which was consistent with the published higher prevalencein periodontal patients.

    Key words: periodontal disease; rheumatoidConclusions: Based on data derived from self-reported health conditions, and notarthritis; inflammation; self-reported health

    withstanding the limitations of such a study, we conclude that there is good evi-questionnaire

    dence to suggest that individuals with moderate to severe periodontal disease areat higher risk of suffering from rheumatoid arthritis and vice versa. Accepted for publication 14 June 1999

    Periodontal disease is an all-en-compassing term relating to the de-structive inflammatory disorders of thehard and soft tissues surrounding teeth.All forms of inflammatory periodontaldisease are associated with a constel-lation of bacteria, predominantlyGram-negative anaerobic or facultativespecies present on tooth root surfacesas a biofilm. Long-term plaque ac-cumulation induces chronic inflam-mation of the periodontal tissues,which may lead to destruction of theattachment of the periodontal ligament

    and the adjacent bone (Page et al.1977). By this stage, simple removal ofthe irritants is no longer sufficient topermit unconditional and complete re-generation of the damaged tissues. Ulti-mately, if untreated, the affected teethbecome loose and may be lost if the dis-ease continues to be active.

    Recent studies have shown that peri-odontal disease may be related to anumber of systemic diseases includingan increased incidence of atheroscler-osis, coronary heart disease, myocardialinfarction and stroke (De Stefano 1993,

    offenbacher 1996, Beck et al. 1996,Haraszthy et al. 1998). Periodontal dis-ease is also known to be a major com-plication of diabetes (Yalda et al. 1994)and management of periodontal diseaseresults in better controlled diabetes(Miller et al. 1992).

    In addition to the above well docu-mented examples, a number of otherchronic conditions of altered connectivetissue metabolism, hormone imbalanceand altered immune function have like-wise been associated with increased riskof periodontal disease (Bartold 1991).

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    2/6

    268 Mercado et al.

    Of these, rheumatoid arthritis is of par-ticular interest since it is a chronic in-flammatory disease which demonstratesremarkably similar patterns of soft andhard tissue destruction to those noted inchronic periodontitis (Snyderman et al.1982). Although the aetiologies of these

    diseases are distinctly separate, theunderlying pathological processes are ofsufficient similarity to warrant consider-ation of the hypothesis that individualsat risk of developing rheumatoid ar-thritis may also be at risk of developingperiodontitis, or vice versa. Indeed,should an individual have a particularsystemic predisposition towards alteredimmune function or altered connectivetissue metabolism (for example, geneticpolymorphisms leading to altered neu-trophil function, specific HLA pheno-types consistent with poor immune de-

    fence, or altered expression of cytokinessuch as IL-1), then the potential for sus-ceptibility to multiple diseases related tosuch functions is possible.

    Therefore, the primary aim of thispreliminary study was to test the hypo-thesis that individuals with periodontaldisease would have a higher prevalenceof rheumatoid arthritis than those indi-viduals without periodontal disease.The secondary aim was to test thehypothesis that those individuals withrheumatoid arthritis would have ahigher prevalence of advanced forms of

    periodontal destruction, than patientswith periodontal disease but withoutrheumatoid arthritis. We chose to carryout this initial study on the basis ofdata collated from self-reported healthquestionnaires recognising the limi-tation of such data but needing prelimi-nary data to indicate whether a largerand more detailed study to investigatethis issue is warranted.

    Methodology

    Prior to commencement of this study

    approval had been obtained from theHuman Ethics Committee of the Uni-versity of Queensland. A total of 1412subjects ages 2070 were included in thestudy (see Table 1 for subject distri-

    Table 1. Distribution and ages of cohort

    studied

    Periodontitis Control

    group group

    no. subjects: 809 603

    mean age (year s) 44.32 42.28

    bution). The subjects were all patientsattending the University of QueenslandDental School for dental treatment.Within the study, two groups were iden-tified. The periodontitis group (PG)were derived from studying the recordsof 809 consecutive individuals referred

    for periodontal treatment. The remain-der, were the general group (GG) andconsisted of 603 consecutive individualsattending a clinic for general dentaltreatment (other than referred peri-odontal treatment).

    The prevalence and severity of peri-odontitis was ascertained from thedocumentation in each subjects dentalrecords and assessment of past dentalradiographs using the modified Hugo-son and Jordan (1982) classification(Table 2).

    To determine the prevalence of rheu-

    matoid arthritis, the patients dentalrecords were obtained and the latestmedical-dental questionnaires wereevaluated. To be identified as sufferingfrom rheumatoid arthritis, the patientsmust not only have self reported thepresence of such a condition but alsohave had the prescription of a medi-cation consistent with such a conditiondocumented (medication included vari-ous NSAIDs, methotrexate, etc.). As-sessments of the records for the pres-ence of cardiovascular disease and dia-betes mellitus were also noted in the PG

    group since these two systemic con-ditions have been well documented fortheir association with periodontitis andthus would provide a measure of valid-ity to the rheumatoid arthritis data. Foran individual to be included in thesegroups not only must they have self-re-ported the presence of such a conditionbut they must also have, in their rec-ords, documentation of the prescriptionof a medication consistent with the

    Table 2. Modified Hugoson and Jordan classification for periodontal disease

    Perio 0 no discernible radiographic evidence of bone loss

    Perio 1 (mild) proximal bone loss reaching at most 1/3 of normal bone height

    Perio 2 (moderate) proximal bone loss between 1/3 and 2/3 of normal bone height

    Perio 3 (severe) proximal bone loss more than 2/3 of normal bone height

    Table 3. Distribution of rheumatoid arthritis in a periodontitis population

    Rheumatoid arthritis No rheumatoid arthritis Totals

    P2-P3 20 (2.4%) 340 (42.0%) 360 (44.5%)

    P0-PI 12 (1.5%) 437 (54.1%) 449 (55.5%)

    Totals 32 (4.0%) 777 (96%) 809 (100%)

    presence of cardiovascular disease ordiabetes mellitus.

    Following collection of the data, t-test analyses were used to determinedifferences in the prevalence of peri-odontitis and rheumatoid arthritis, inthe cohorts studied using the same test,

    the difference in the prevalence of mod-erate to severe periodontitis in individ-uals with rheumatoid arthritis was alsoevaluated against those without rheu-matoid arthritis.

    Results

    The prevalence of rheumatoid arthritisin the periodontitis group (PG) was3.95% which was significantly greaterthan that found in the general group(GP) 0.66% (p0.05) The overall preva-lence of rheumatoid arthritis, is shown

    in Fig. 1. Among the 36 subjects whoreported to have rheumatoid arthritisand were taking the prescribed medi-cations, 33 (92%) had radiographic evi-dence of moderate to severe alveolarbone loss (P1, P2 or P3).

    The prevalence of moderate to severeperiodontitis (P2-P3) in the peri-odontitis group (PG) (44.5%) was, asexpected, much greater than in the gen-eral group (0.1%). Within the PGgroup, as shown in Fig. 2 and Table 3,20 out of 32 (62.5%) of the patientswith rheumatoid arthritis suffered from

    advanced forms of periodontal destruc-tion (P2 or P3). Only of those withoutrheumatoid arthritis, 340 out of 777(43.8%) suffered from more advancedforms of periodontal disease. Thus, pa-tients with rheumatoid arthritis weremore likely (p0.05) to have moderateto severe bone loss (P2 or P3) thanmilder forms of disease (P0 or P1).

    To test the validity of using self-re-ported information, we also determined

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    3/6

    Rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease 269

    Fig. 1. Prevalence of disease in various populations. The prevalence of rheumatoid arthritis

    (RA) cardiovascular disease (CVD) and diabetes mellitus (DM) was monitored in the peri-

    odontitis group (PG) and general group (GG). Data from previously published studies are

    included for comparison.

    Fig. 2. Prevalence of periodontal disease in individuals with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) cardio-

    vascular disease (CVD) and diabetes mellitus (DM). The prevalence for zero to mild (P0-P1)

    and moderate to severe periodontitis (P2-P3) is shown. The scoring system (P0-P3 is as de-

    scribed in Table 2).

    the prevalence of self-reported cardio-vascular disease (CVD) (14.2%) anddiabetes mellitus (DM) (6.1%) withinthe periodontal group. While thesevalues are somewhat higher than thosereported for the general population(Nathan 1993, Saskatchewan HeartHealth Program 1997), they are consist-ent with the reported prevalence ofthese conditions within a periodontalpopulation and is consistent with these

    patients tending to have more systemicdiseases generally (Rees and Brasher1974, Peacock & Carson 1995).

    Discussion

    It is generally accepted that the preva-lence of advanced periodontitis in hu-man populations ranges between 515%(American Academy of Periodontology,1996). In the present study we report

    that the prevalence of moderate to se-vere periodontitis is significantly elev-ated in individuals suffering from rheu-matoid arthritis (unadjusted relativerisk 4.7). In addition, the converse alsoholds true in that individuals referredfor periodontal treatment also appear

    to have a higher prevalence of rheuma-toid arthritis compared to the generalpopulation (unadjusted relative risk1.5).

    These findings are based on theanalyses of data obtained from self-re-ported health questionnaires and evalu-ation of oral radiographs. Althoughgathering information from healthquestionnaires results in data that areless reliable than those obtainedthrough laboratory/clinical examina-tions, this method is cost-effective andreliable enough to be used in epidemio-

    logical and clinical studies (Ho et al.1997, Nery et al. 1987, Suomi et al.1975). Indeed a recent study has shownthat there are high levels of agreementbetween self-reported health conditionsand actual presence of the condition (kranged from 0.710.90) (Ho et al. 1997).Thus, such an approach is valid for apilot study before moving to more elab-orate and larger scale studies.

    In an effort to test the validity of ourfindings we monitored the self-reportedprevalence of cardiovascular diseaseand diabetes mellitus. The prevalence of

    both cardiovascular disease (CVD)(14.2%) and diabetes mellitus (DM)(6.1%) within the PG group, while con-sistent with other studies (11.623.5%for CVD and 4% for DM) (Rees &Brasher 1974, Brasher & Rees 1970,Peacock & Carson 1995), these valuesare far greater than the currently ac-cepted general population figures of 6%for cardiovascular disease (Saskat-chewan Heart Health Survey, 1997) and2.4% for diabetes mellitus (Nathan1993, National Diabetes Data Group,1985). As these published figures com-

    pare favourably with the findings in thisstudy they offer a measure of validity tothis methodology (self-reporting) andtherefore to the self-reported rheuma-toid arthritis experience data collectedin this study.

    The findings that 58% of the patientswho reported to have DM and 64.6%of patients with self-reported cardio-vascular disease had significant levels ofperiodontal bone loss (P2 or P3) werenot surprising since numerous studieshave shown that diabetes increases therisk of severe periodontitis and peri-

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    4/6

    270 Mercado et al.

    Fig. 3. Possible interrelationships between rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease.

    odontal disease progression approxi-mately 23 fold (Gross & Genco 1998)and that periodontal disease may be arisk factor for cardiovascular disease(Beck et al. 1996).

    The observation that 3.9% of pa-tients in the study referred for manage-ment of periodontal disease had self-re-ported rheumatoid arthritis is particu-larly noteworthy. This is a very highprevalence compared to the 1% preva-lence reported in the normal population

    (Arnett 1988). The additional findingthat 62.5% of the rheumatoid arthritispatients suffered from more advancedforms of periodontal destruction (P2 orP3) supports the hypothesis that notonly is there a higher prevalence ofrheumatoid arthritis amongst individ-uals referred for periodontal treatmentbut that those individuals with rheuma-toid arthritis have a greater prevalenceof advanced forms of periodontal dis-ease. The increased prevalence of rheu-matoid arthritis in the periodontitisgroup in this study suggests a possible

    link between the manifestation of thesetwo chronic inflammatory diseases.

    To date, only a few studies haveexamined the extent of the associationbetween RA and periodontal diseaseand, amongst these studies, the resultshave been conflicting (Helminen-Pak-kala 1971, Blair & Chalmers 1976,Kasser et al. 1997, Tolo et al. 1990). Thelack of uniformity in classifying thevarious forms of periodontal diseaseand rheumatoid arthritis in these

    studies has made it difficult to comparethe above studies. In the present studywe have recognised that periodontitishas a variable expression with regardsto its severity. Therefore, by trying tocorrelate the experience of rheumatoidarthritis with moderately to advancedperiodontitis we believe we are gettingcloser to determining whether underly-ing systemic components may impacton the manifestation of these two dis-eases. If all forms of periodontal dis-ease (from very mild gingivitis to ad-vanced periodontitis) were to be in-

    cluded (as has been the case in moststudies) then the likely correlation be-comes weaker due to a dilution of thepatient cohort with significant disease.

    Since we have identified a possible re-lationship between rheumatoid arthritisand moderate to severe periodontitis we

    propose that, in a proportion of thesepatients, a hitherto unidentified disable-ment or dysregulation of commonpathologic mechanisms operate in thesetwo chronic inflammatory diseases. In-deed, there are remarkable similaritiesin the pathogenesis of these two con-ditions at both the cellular and molecu-lar level (Fig. 3). Both conditions relyupon an initial competent surveillanceby neutrophils which if either insuf-ficient or over exuberant leads to earlytissue damage, subsequent recruitmentof lymphocytes, immunemediate pro-

    tection, together with degradation ofthe tissues, the release of myriad cyto-kines, lymphokines and prostanoidpathways all point to a common under-lying regulatory mechanisms in thesetwo conditions despite their differingaetiology (Kornman et al. 1997, Reyn-olds et al. 1997, Offenbacher et al.1993).

    In conclusion, while all of the studieslinking periodontal disease to varioussystemic diseases need further investiga-tion, the available data are becomingcompelling to indicate a significant re-

    lationship between periodontal diseasein systemic health. This study highlightsthe potential for a relationship between2 of the most common and debilitatingchronic inflammatory conditions affect-ing humans and warrants further de-tailed investigation.

    Zusammenfassung

    Gibt es einen Zusammenhang zwischen rheu-

    matoider Arthritis und marginaler Parodonti-

    tis?

    Das Ziel dieser Studie war es, einen mogli-

    chen Zusammenhang zwischen dem Vorkom-men rheumatoider Arthritis und marginaler

    Parodontitis festzustellen. 1412 Personen, die

    die Zahnklinik der Universitat von Queens-

    land aufsuchten, wurden auf marginale Paro-

    dontitis und rheumatoide Arthritis unter-

    sucht. Es wurde eine Auswertung von Daten

    vorgenommen, die aus einem Befragungsbo-

    gen mit Angaben der Patienten zur Gesund-

    heit und zahnarztlichen Befundunterlagen

    entstammten. Diese Daten umfaten: Zahl

    der Personen, die zur weiterfuhrenden

    Parodontaltherapie uberwiesen waren (Test-

    gruppe), Zahl der Personen, die sich zur

    Routinebehandlung vorstellten; Angabe

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    5/6

    Rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease 271

    rheumatoider Arthritis, kardiovaskularer Er-

    krankungen und Diabetes mellitus durch die

    Patienten selbst und Erfassung verschriebe-

    ner Medikamente; Beurteilung marginaler

    Parodontitis aufgrund existierender Ront-

    genbilder. Bei Patienten, die zur Parodontiti-

    stherapie uberwiesen waren, lag die Prava-

    lenz selbstgenannter rheumatoider Arthritis

    bei 3.95%, was statistisch signifikant hoherlag als die Pravalenz bei den Patienten, die

    nicht uberwiesen waren (0.66%) bzw. die Pra-

    valenz die sich aus den Angaben einer durch-

    schnittlichen Population ergab (1%). Von den

    Patienten mit rheumatoider Arthritis litten

    62.5% an fortgeschrittenen Formen der mar-

    ginalen Parodontitis. Diese Ergebnisse spie-

    gelten sich in den Angaben zur Pravalenz

    kardiovaskularer Erkrankungen und Diabe-

    tes mellitus wider, die bei Patienten mit mar-

    ginaler Parodontitis hoher lag. Basierend auf

    den Daten aus den Patientenangaben zur Ge-

    sundheit kann die Schlufolgerung gezogen

    werden, da Patienten mit moderater bis

    fortgeschrittener Parodontitis ein erhohtes

    Risiko haben, an rheumatoider Arthritis zuleiden und umgekehrt.

    Resume

    Existe-t-il une relation entre la polyarthrite

    rhumatoide et la maladie parodontale?

    Cette etude avait pour but de determiner

    sil existe une relation entre latteinte de

    polyarthrite rhumatode et de maladie pa-

    rodontale. Chez 1412 sujets frequentant

    lEcole Dentaire de lUniversite de Queens-

    land, les prevalences de la maladie

    parodontale et de la polyarthrite rhumato-

    de ont ete determinees. Une analyse desdonnees obtenues en se basant sur un

    questionnaire de sante rempli par les sujets

    eux-memes, et a partir des fiches dentaires,

    a ete pratiquee et comprenait: le nombre

    de sujets adresses pour soins parodontaux

    avances (groupe test), le nombre de sujets

    sadressant pour des soins dentaires

    ordinaires; enregistrement de la polyarthri-

    te rhumatode, des maladies cardiovasculai-

    res, et du diabete sucre, a partir des rensei-

    gnements donnes par les sujets eux-memes,

    et enregistrement des medicaments

    prescrits; enregistrement de la maladie pa-

    rodontale a partir des radiographies bucca-

    les existant. Chez les patients adresses pour

    traitement parodontal, la prevalence de lapolyarthrite rhumatode ressortant des in-

    dications des patients etait de 3.95%, ce

    qui est significativement plus eleve que ce

    quon constatait chez les patients qui

    netaient pas adresses pour traitement pa-

    rodontal (0.66%), et plus eleve aussi que ce

    qui ressortait des indications de la popula-

    tion en general (1%). Parmi les patients

    adresses et souffrant de polyarthrite

    rhumatode, 62.5% presentaient des formes

    avancees de maladie parodontale. Ces

    resultats etaient le reflet des resultats de la

    prevalence dont il etait rendu compte pour

    les maladies cardiovasculaires et le diabete

    sucre, en concordance avec lelevation de la

    prevalence chez les patients parodontaux.

    En se basant sur les donnees provenant des

    informations fournies par les patients sur

    leur sante, et en depit des limitations de ce

    genre detude, on peut conclure quil existe

    des preuves indiquant que les sujets

    atteints de maladie parodontale moderee a

    severe ont une risque plus eleve de souffrirde polyarthrite rhumatode et inversement.

    References

    American Academy of Periodontology.

    Epidemiology of periodontal diseases

    (1996) Journal of Periodontology 67, 935

    945.

    Arnett, F., Edworthy S. & Bloch, D. (1988)

    The American rheumatism Association

    1987 revised criteria for the classification

    of rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis and

    Rheumatism 31, 315324.

    Bartold, P. M. (1991) Connective tissues of

    the periodontium. Research and clinical

    implications. Australian Dental Journal136, 255261.

    Beck, J., Garcia, R., Heiss, G., Vokanos, P.

    S. & Offenbacher, S. (1996) Periodontal

    disease and cardiovascular disease. Journal

    of Periodontology 67, 11231137.

    Blair, G. S. & Chalmers, I. N. (1976) The

    dental status of a chronically disabled sec-

    tion of the community. A study of 139 pa-

    tients suffering from rheumatic diseases.

    Journal of the Dental Association of South

    Africa 31, 329336.

    Brasher, W. J. & Rees, T. D. (1970) Systemic

    conditions in the management of peri-

    odontal patients. Journal of Periodonto-

    logy41

    , 349352.De Stefano, F., Anda, R., Kahn, H., Willi-

    amson, D. & Russell C. (1993) Dental Dis-

    ease and risk of coronary heart disease

    and mortality. British Medical Journal306,

    688691.

    Grossi, S. G. & Genco, R. J. (1998) Peri-

    odontal disease and diabetes mellitus: A

    two-way relationship. Periodontology 2000

    3, 5161.

    Haraszthy, V., Zambon, J., Trevisan, M.,

    Shah, R., Zeid M. & Genco, R. (1998)

    Identification of pathogens in atheroma-

    tous plaques. Journal of Dental Research

    67, 11231137.

    Helminen-Pakkalam, E. (1971) Periodontal

    conditions in rheumatoid arthritis. A clin-ical and roentenological investigation. Part

    two. The study in rheumatoids. Proceed-

    ings of the Finnish Dental Society (suppl.

    IV).

    Ho, A. W., Grossi, S. G., Dunford, R. G. &

    Genco, R. J. (1997) Reliability of a self-

    reported health questionnaire in a peri-

    odontal disease study. Journal of Peri-

    odontal Research 32, 646650.

    Hugoson, A. & Jordan, T. (1982) Frequency

    of individuals aged 2070 years according

    to severity of periodontal disease. Com-

    munity Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology

    10, 187192.

    Kasser, U. R., Gleissner, C., Dehne, F., Mit-

    chell, A., Willerhausen-Zonnchen, B. &

    Bolten, V. Y. W. (1997) Risk for peri-

    odontal disease in patients with longstand-

    ing rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis and

    Rheumatism 40, 22482251.

    Kornman, K. S., Crane, A., Wang, H. Y., Di

    Giovine, F. S., Newman, M. G., Pirk, F.

    W. & Wilson, T. G. (1997) The interleukin-1 genotype as a severity factor in adult

    periodontal disease. Journal of Clinical

    Periodontology 24, 7277.

    Miller, I., Manwell, M. & Newbold, D.

    (1992) The relationship between reduction

    in periodontal inflammation and diabetes

    control: a report of 9 cases. Journal of

    Periodontology 63, 843848.

    Nathan, D. M. (1993) Diabetes mellitus. In:

    Rubenstein, E. & Federman, D. D. (eds):

    Scientific American Medicine. New York,

    Scientific American, 127.

    National Diabetes Data Group (1985) Dia-

    betes in America: diabetes data complied

    1984. NIH publication no. 851268, Wash-

    ington, DC.Nery, E. B., Meister, F., Ellinger, R. F., Es-

    lainl, A. & McNamara, T. (1987) Preva-

    lence of medical problems in periodontal

    patients obtained from three different

    populations. Journal of Periodontology 58,

    564568.

    Offenbacher, S., Heasman, P. & Collins, J.

    (1993) Modulation of host PGE2 secretion

    as determinant of periodontal disease ex-

    pression. Journal of Periodontology 1, 432

    444.

    Offenbacher, S. (1996) Periodontal diseases:

    Pathogenesis. Annals of Periodontology 1,

    179225.

    Page, R. C. (1998) The pathobiology of peri-odontal diseases may affect systemic dis-

    eases: inversion of a paradigm. Annals of

    Periodontology 3, 109120.

    Page, R. C., Offenbacher, S., Schroeder, H.

    E., Seymour, G. J. & Kornman, K. S.

    (1997) Advances in the pathogenesis of

    periodontitis: summary of developments,

    clinical implications and future directions.

    Periodontology 2000 4, 216248.

    Peacock, M. E. & Carson, R. E. (1995) Fre-

    quency of self-reported medical conditions

    in periodontal patients. Journal of Period-

    ontology 66, 10041007.

    Rees, T. D. & Brasher, W. J. (1974) Incidence

    of certain systemic conditions among pa-

    tients presenting for periodontal treat-ment. Journal of Periodontology 45, 669

    671.

    Reynolds, J. & Meikle, M. (1997) Mechan-

    isms of connective tissue destruction. Im-

    portance of the balance of MMPs and in-

    hibitors in tissue destruction and impli-

    cation for human periodontitis and its

    treatment. Periodontology 2000 14, 144

    157.

    Saskatchewan Heart Health Program (1997)

    Saskatchewan heart health survey. Canada

    Concern 26, 2327.

    Snyderman, R. & McCarty, G. A. (1982)

    Analogous mechanisms of tissue destruc-

  • 8/8/2019 Is There a Relation Betw RA and Perio

    6/6

    272 Mercado et al.

    tion in rheumatoid arthritis and peri-

    odontal disease. In Genco, R. J. &

    Mergenhagen, S. E. (eds.): Host-parasite

    interactions in periodontal disease. Amen-

    can Society for Microbiology, Washington

    DC. pp 354362.

    Suomi, J., Horowitz, H. & Barbano, J. (1975)

    Self-reported systemic conditions in adult

    study population. Journal of Dental Re-search 54, 1092.

    Tolo, K., & Jorkend, L. (1990) Serum anti-

    bodies and loss of periodontal bone in pa-

    tients with rheumatoid arthritic. Journal of

    Clinical Periodontology 17, 288291.

    Williams, R. C. (1990) Periodontal disease.

    New England Journal of Medicine 322,

    373382.

    Welborn, T., Knuiman M., Bartholomew,

    H. & Whittall, D. (1995) 19891990 Na-

    tional Health Survey: prevalence of self-re-

    ported diabetes in Australia. MedicalJournal of Australia 163, 129132.

    Yalda, B., Offenbacher, S. & Collins, J. G.

    (1994) Diabetes as a modifier of peri-

    odontal disease expression. Periodontology

    2000 6, 3749.

    Address:

    P. M. Bartold

    Department of Dentistry

    University of Queensland

    Brisbane QLD 4000

    Australia

    Fax: (07) 3365 8135

    e-mail: p.bartold/mailbox.uq.edu.au