Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted...

32
www.valentiabiopharma.com A Drosophila high-throughput drug screening platform identifies inhibitors of misregulated alternative splicing events in myotonic dystrophy Irma Garcia-Alcover

Transcript of Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted...

Page 1: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

www.valentiabiopharma.com

A Drosophila high-throughput drug screening platform identifies inhibitors of misregulated alternative splicing events in myotonic dystrophy

Irma Garcia-Alcover

Page 2: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Consequences of traditional HTS drug discovery

“Poor selection of hits

with limited predictive

value for clinicaloutcome”

“Slow-down in the

development of new and

innovative medical products”

“Waste of funds (millions of $)

and efforts (years of research)”

Page 3: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery

•Unpredicted toxicity

•Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side

effects

•Therapeutic effects not translating to traditional

mammalian models and humans in the clinic (i.e.

neuromuscular diseases) when cell-organ physiological

connections critical in development of disease

•Time component of disease progression not

recapitulated

Page 4: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Drug discovery problems

Model organisms

Toxicity and activity

evaluation in the same

experimental approach:

entire organism

Traditional drug development

• Between 12 and 15 years

• Investment ~800 millions $

• 80% of cost in preclinical assays

Page 5: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

in vivo drug discovery benefits

“shift from one disease-one target to multifactorial disease paradigm:

drug discovery in whole animals”

Page 6: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

in vivo drug screening

• Information of the therapeutic effect of a compound in a complete

organism

• Several advantages vs in vitro

Compounds identified by positive screening have two main

characteristics:

• Ameillorate a phenotype that mimics hallmarks of the human disease

• Their pharmacological properties are compatible with life

Toxicity and activity evaluation in the

same experimental approach: entire

organism

Page 7: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Process & output

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

1st year 2nd year

Vector design

Transformation

Confirmation

Disease model development time

Vector design

Transformation

Confirmation

Drosophila

Mouse

start R&D

3-6 months, HTS format, and low cost

>1,5 years, no HTS format, and high cost

Page 8: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

In vivo Drug Discovery

Page 9: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

75% of human genes

causing disease are

conserved in

Drosophila

Short time frame

from drug

dosing to results Large, sophisticated

number of genetic

tools/fly stocks

available

No ethical issues.

Low variability at

low costs

(Flies are CHEAP)

Identification of new

drugs in WHOLE

organism

Culture conditions

compatible with

large-scale screens.

Fundamental aspects of

cell biology conserved

from Drosophila to

humans

Page 10: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Toxicity and activity

evaluation in the same

experimental approach:

entire organism

Short time frame from drug dosing to results

Large number of genetic tools available

Low variability at low costs

Page 11: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Examples of diseases modeled into the fly:(reviewed in Pandey and Nichols, Pharmacol. Rev. (62) 2:A-Z, 2011)

•Alzheimer

•Parkingson

•Hungtington Disease

•Epilepsy

•Cognitive and affective disorders as depression

Diseases Afecting CNS

•Asthma

• Inflammatory mechanism related with inflammatory bowel disease and necrotizing enterocolitis

•Related pathways – Toll and toll-like receptos, nuclear factor kB, TNF and JAK/STAT

Inflammatory diseases

•Obesity

•Diabetes

•Glycerol kinase deficency

Metabolic diseases

Page 12: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

How Valentia (VLT) flies can help

•VLT can build custom “humanized” Drosophila

disease models and evaluate compound activity

•After VLT modeling (2-3 months), results in weeks

not months/years

• Study large numbers of functional pathways, risk

genes and human mutations

•Provide fast, simple assays (phenotypic and

biochemical/molecular) for drugs response

•Test chemical libraries on a whole organism,

estimating drugs response in the same way that

human do

Page 13: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Drug Discovery

Drosophila modelgeneration and

validation

Drug screening

Hits validation

4-6 months 1000 comp./week 1-6 months

• Target identification• Readout selection• Model generation• Model validation

• Robustness of the assaystatistically validated

• Throughput:1000 compounds/week

• Additional Drosophila assays

• Validation studies in otherbiological systems (mice, human cells)

Page 14: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

In vivo drug screening platform

1. FLY CROSSES

2. DRUG PLATES PREPARATION

(Robot with stackers)

3. SEEDING (Sorter Cytometry)

4. HOMOGENIZATION (Robot with stackers)

5. READING (Envision Reader

/Scanner)

6. ANALYSIS

F0:Adults F1:Embryo/Larvae F1:Adults

Page 15: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

A case study: Myotonic Distrophy type 1 (DM1)

www.valentiabiopharma.com

Page 16: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Source:http://omim.org/entry/160900

•Overall worldwide prevalence: 1 / 8,000. Higher in some populations

like in Quebec (Canada). High penetrance.

•Multifactorial disease. Mainly a

muscular disorder: Myotonia,

progressive muscular wasting

and weakness.

•But also cataracts, hypogonadism, arrythmias, infertility, cognitive

dysfunction, mental retardation…

Myotonic Dystrophy type 1

Page 18: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

3’5’(CTG)n (AAA)n

CAP

Size of CTG repeat

50 - 400

5 - 37

38 - 49

5’ UTR Coding region 3’ UTR

DM1 Phenotype

“Premutation” Asymptomatic

Normal

DMPK gene (19q 13.3)

Science, 1992

Molecular cause

Page 19: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

3’5’(CTG)nCAP

5’ UTR Coding region 3’ UTR

DNA expansion

Disease symptoms

But is a non-coding DNA expansion…

Page 20: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

3’5’(CTG)nCAP

5’ UTR Coding region 3’ UTR

DNA expansion

Disease symptoms

RNA gain of function(toxic RNA formation)

But is a non-coding DNA expansion…

Page 21: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Aberrant splicing

Serca1

Tnnt3

Tnnt2

IR

(~several genes)

ClC1

SAJ EROMEN

SAJ EROMEN

Mbnl2

STAT3

STAT1

RARγ Sp1

Mbnl1

hnRNPF

Staufen

NonA

Splitends

hnRNPH

Protein sequestration

Mbnl1

From Mastroyiannopoulos et al. Biol Cell 2010

Molecular pathogenesis

Page 22: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Aberrant splicing

SAJ EROMEN

SAJ EROMEN

From Turner and Hilton-Jones (2010). J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 81(4):358-67

Pathogenesis

Bin-1

Mbnl1

Molecular pathogenesis

Page 23: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

DM1 is a very complex disease

Page 24: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Mbnl1 importance in DM1

Kanadia et al., 2003

wt Mbnl1-/- DM1

Mbnl1–/– patientsClcn1 + +

Sercal + +Tnnt3 + +

ZASP + +

z-Ttn + +

z-Ttn + +m-Ttn + +Capn3 + +

Alp + +

Fhos + +

Gfat1 + +Mbnl1 + +Mbnl2 + +

Page 25: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

A DM1 fly model

Suma

CG30084 TnT

Defectos histológicos

Defectos de splicing

Secuestro de Mblen forma de foci

Garcia-Lopez y Monferrer et al., 2008

(CTG)480 repeticiones

Page 26: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Cons. exon Alt. exonintron intron

Cons. exon Reporter

STOP

Reporter

Exon inclusion

No reporter expression

Cons. exonAlt. exon

STOP

Alt. exon

STOP

Cons. exon

Exon exclusion

ReporterCons. exon Cons. exon

Reporter expression

ReporterCons. exon Cons. exon

Human minigen-reporter construct

Page 27: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Spliceosensor flies

ReporterGene CUG toxic RNA

Mhc-Gal4>UAS-Construct

2

4

6

8

0

Re

po

rte

r le

vels

Page 28: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

In vivo drug screening platform

1. FLY CROSSES

2. DRUG PLATES PREPARATION

(Robot with stackers)

3. SEEDING (Sorter Cytometry)

4. HOMOGENIZATION (Robot with stackers)

5. READING (Envision Reader

/Scanner)

6. ANALYSIS

F0:Adults F1:Embryo/Larvae F1:Adults

Page 29: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Research Development

ScreeningHit Identification

Validation & Optimization

Pre-clinic Clinic

VLT015

VLT001

VLT003

VLT004

VLT005-29

> 15,000 small molecules

30-35 hits

1 lead (VLT015)

screening analyisis and validation

Secondary assays validation

Modelo DM1

Rastreo de compuestos

Page 30: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Mechanism of action

Hairpin destructuration and MBNL1 release

Page 31: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

Examples of diseases modeled into the fly:(reviewed in Pandey and Nichols, Pharmacol. Rev. (62) 2:A-Z, 2011)

•Alzheimer

•Parkingson

•Hungtington Disease

•Epilepsy

•Cognitive and affective disorders as depression

Diseases Afecting CNS

•Asthma

• Inflammatory mechanism related with inflammatory bowel disease and necrotizing enterocolitis

•Related pathways – Toll and toll-like receptos, nuclear factor kB, TNF and JAK/STAT

Inflammatory diseases

•Obesity

•Diabetes

•Glycerol kinase deficency

Metabolic diseases

“Models mostly available for in vivo HTS approaches”

Page 32: Irma Garcia-Alcover  · Weakness of hits from traditional HTS drug discovery •Unpredicted toxicity •Off-target interactions leading to undesirable side effects •Therapeutic

THANKS FOR YOUR TIME

Department of Pharmacology(University of Valencia)Dr. Diego CortésLaura Moreno

Department of Genetics(University of Valencia)Dr. Rubén ArteroDr. Amparo García-López

Aknowledgements:

VLT staff (Scientific Park of Valencia)Arturo López-CastelDr. Jordi ColonquesJuanma Fernández-CostaMari Carmen ÁlvarezIsabel CampilloAida TomásJosé Rubén Tormo

[email protected]