IPD eConference presentation
Transcript of IPD eConference presentation
1
AIA/AGC/ McGraw-HillAIA/AGC/ McGraw-HillIntegrated Project Delivery Case Integrated Project Delivery Case StudiesStudieshttp://aia.org/ipdcasestudies
Jonathan Cohen, FAIA LEED [email protected]
April 22, 2010April 22, 2010Stagnito Media IPD eConferenceStagnito Media IPD eConference
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
2 ©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
http://aia.org/ipdcasestudies
3
AIA California Council IPD Task Group
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
http://www.ipd-ca.net/
4
the goals of IPD
Early knowledge - increased certainty means lowered risk
Recapture of explicit and hidden contingencies Improved information exchange and sharing of
expertise– Less duplication of effort/less rework– Fewer RFIs/submittals/change orders
Creation of a virtual enterprise around project– Alignment of goals– Collaborative working environment– More transparent process– Fewer disputes
Easier to attain sustainability/operational goals
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
5
how do we define IPD?
Early involvement of key participants Multi-party contract Jointly developed/validated targets Shared risk/reward based on project
outcome Collaborative decision making/control Reduced liability exposure
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
6
desirable conditions
Mutual respect and trust Collaborative innovation Intensified early planning BIM used collaboratively Open communication Transparent financials (open book) Co-location Lean design/construction/operations
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
7
case studies
Autodesk AEC Division HQ, Waltham MA Cardinal Glennon Children’s NICU, St. Louis MO Encircle Health Ambulatory Care Center, Appleton WI St. Clare Health Center, Fenton, MO Sutter Fairfield Medical Office Building, Fairfield, CA Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, ASU, Phoenix,
AZ
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
8
case studies
1 corporate, 1 public university, 4 not-for-profit healthcare providers spread across the country
1 TI fit-out, 1 addition/renovation, 4 new buildings $12 million to $150 million construction cost Budgets met, schedules met with exceptions No change orders, except owner-initiated Designers and builders felt adequately compensated Participants will use IPD again No disputes!
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
9
Sutter Health Medical Office Building, Fairfield CA
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
10
Sutter Health Medical Office Building, Fairfield CA
Owner: Sutter Regional Medical Foundation Architect: HGA Architects and Engineers Builder: The Boldt Company
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
11
Sutter Health Medical Office Building, Fairfield CA
3-story, 70,000 SF, $19.5 million MOB Pilot project for IPD: first relational integrated form of
agreement (IFOA) in USA Design: 12 months Construction: 15 months Non owner-initiated change orders: 0 Budget and schedule met Sutter Health has committed to IPD for its $5.5 billion
capital program. IPD projects underway: – California Pacific Medical Center, SF– Eden Health, Castro Valley
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
12
Sutter Health Medical Office Building, Fairfield CA
From the Integrated Form of Agreement:
– The parties recognize that each of their opportunities to succeed on the Project is directly tied to the performance of other Project participants. The parties shall therefore work together in the spirit of cooperation, collaboration, and mutual respect for the benefit of the Project, and within the limits of their professional expertise and abilities.
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
13
Autodesk AEC Division HQ, Waltham MA
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
14
Autodesk AEC Division HQ, Waltham MA
Owner: Autodesk Inc. Architect: KlingStubbins Builder: Tocci Building Companies
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
15
Autodesk AEC Division HQ, Waltham MA
3 story, 60,000 SF interior office fit-out Design and construction: 35 weeks Incentive compensation layer used based on targets:
– Budget and schedule– Sustainability goal– Design quality compared to benchmarked projects– 3rd party neutral evaluator of “soft goals”
Non owner-initiated change orders: 0 Budget and schedule met Design-to-fabrication used LEED Platinum – CI
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
16
Autodesk AEC Division HQ, Waltham MA
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
17
Encircle Health for ThedaCare, Appleton WI
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
18
Encircle Health for ThedaCare, Appleton WI
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
Owner: Encircle Health, an LLC composed of ThedaCare and independent physician groups
Architect: HGA Architects and Engineers Builder: The Boldt Company
19
Encircle Health for ThedaCare, Appleton WI
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
Ambulatory care center with labs and imaging
Physician owned LLC 157,000 SF, $35.4 million Design: 5 months Construction: 11 months Non owner-initiated change orders:
0 Budget and schedule met, except
for weather delay Sustainability goal: LEED Silver Sustainability achieved: LEED Gold
20
SSM St. Clare Health Center, Fenton, MO
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
21
SSM St. Clare Health Center, Fenton, MO
Owner: SSM Healthcare Architect: HGA Architects and Engineers Builder: Alberici Constructors
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
22
SSM St. Clare Health Center, Fenton, MO
6-story, 158 bed hospital + 85,000 SF medical office building + 75,000 SF ambulatory care center = 430,000 SF total
$148.3 million Design: 28 months Construction: 29 months Non owner-initiated change orders: 0 Budget met Schedule extended due to programmatic changes
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
23
SSM Cardinal Glennon Children’s, St. Louis
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
24
SSM Cardinal Glennon Children’s, St. Louis
Owner: SSM Healthcare Architect: Christner Inc. MEP Engineer: McGrath Inc. Builder: Alberici Constructors, Inc.
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
25
SSM Cardinal Glennon Children’s, St. Louis
138,000 SF, $45.5 million children’s hospital addition 60 unit neonatal intensive care, 10 surgical suites IPD adopted after project had started Construction: 24 months, finished 3 weeks ahead of
schedule Change orders: 0 Budget and schedule met Financial incentives paid out of unused contingency -
$400,000 saved and distributed out of $1,000,000
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
26
Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, ASU
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
27
Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, ASU
Owner: City of Phoenix User/Occupant: Arizona State University Design Architect: Ehrlich Architects Executive Architect: HDR Architecture Builder: Sundt Construction
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
28
Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, ASU
“Public-Public” partnership: City of Phoenix/ASU 6 story, 225,000 SF, $63 million Classrooms, media production labs, auditorium, TV
production studio, retail Design/Build contract but IPD adopted informally Extremely tight schedule met, budget met Design to permit: 10 months Construction: 15 months Non owner-initiated change orders: 0 LEED Silver
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
29
Walter Cronkite School of Journalism, ASU
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
30
Conclusions
It works! Better management of risk – transparency
eliminates “hidden contingencies” Flexible, shifting roles, blurring of
boundaries between designer and builder More engagement of owner Financial incentives are controversial Creative adaptation to different
circumstances Principles can be applied to public
procurement
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
31
The IPD Facilitator
Designs IPD process unique to project and client Independent of architect and builder – works for owner Acts as evangelist/educator to internal and external
stakeholders Assists in establishing a legal framework Assists the owner in design and construction team
selection Facilitates interactive communication during project Creates IT standards for information exchange Assists in setting project goals Assists in evaluation of goal attainment
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved
32
AIA/AGC/ McGraw-HillAIA/AGC/ McGraw-HillIntegrated Project Delivery Case Integrated Project Delivery Case StudiesStudieshttp://aia.org/ipdcasestudies
Jonathan Cohen, FAIA LEED [email protected]
April 22, 2010April 22, 2010Stagnito Media IPD eConferenceStagnito Media IPD eConference
©2010 Jonathan Cohen - all rights reserved