Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ......

39
The views of third-party speakers and their materials distributed are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Charles Schwab & Co., (“Schwab”). Third party speakers are not affiliated with Schwab. Schwab Institutional is a division of Schwab. ©Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. Member SIPC. Kathryn A. Hall Chief Executive Officer & Chief Investment Officer Hall Capital Partners LLC Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and Donor- Advised Funds Nothing contained herein constitutes investment, legal, tax or other advice, and Hall Capital Partners is not soliciting any action based upon it. The information contained in this material is current as of its date only, and may be based upon certain assumptions. Hall Capital Partners makes no representations as to the reasonableness of such assumptions or the likelihood that such assumptions will coincide with actual events and this information should not be relied upon for that purpose.

Transcript of Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ......

Page 1: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

The views of third-party speakers and their materials distributed are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Charles Schwab & Co., (“Schwab”). Third party speakers are not affiliated with Schwab. Schwab Institutional is a division of Schwab. ©Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. Member SIPC.

Kathryn A. HallChief Executive Officer & Chief Investment OfficerHall Capital Partners LLC

Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and Donor- Advised Funds

Nothing contained herein constitutes investment, legal, tax or other advice, and Hall Capital Partners is not soliciting any action based upon it. The information contained in this material is current as of its date only, and may be based upon certain assumptions. Hall Capital Partners makes no representations as to the reasonableness of such assumptions or the likelihood that such assumptions will coincide with actual events and this information should not be relied upon for that purpose.

Page 2: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

2

Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and Donor-Advised Funds

I. Current ClimateII. Direct Impact on Endowments and FoundationsIII. Direct Impact on Donor-Advised FundsIV. Implications for AdvisorsV. Looking Ahead

Page 3: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

3

I. Current Climate

Page 4: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

4

Current Climate

Amidst the turmoil of the past year, several themes have emerged and remain at the forefront of investor concern including

Volatility Liquidity

Complexity and Proliferationof Investment Choices

Risk and ReturnExpectations

Scandals and Transparency

Page 5: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

5

Performance of Major Equity Markets

Source: S&P, MSCI

Major Indices Comparative Total Returns

-60%

-40%

-20%

0%

20%

40%

60%

Jan-07 May-07 Sep-07 Jan-08 May-08 Sep-08 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09

S&P 500 Index MSCI EAFE Index MSCI EM Index

Page 6: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

6

Dramatic Volatility in Global Markets

During the period from January 1979 through June 2008, the S&P 500 only experienced moves of more than 2% (up or down) on 3% of days as compared to 53% of days in 4Q08

85%

61%

33%48%

73%

12%

19%

14%

16%

19%

3%20%

53%36%

8%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

1Q79-2Q08

3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09

Greater than 2% up or down Between 1% and 2% up or down Between -1% and +1%Source: S&P

Page 7: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

7

VIX Peaked in November

Source: CBOE

Note: The VIX index is an index of implied volatility on S&P 500 index options

VIX Volatility Index

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Jan-07 May-07 Sep-07 Jan-08 May-08 Sep-08 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09

Lehman Brothers files bankruptcy

Page 8: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

8

Liquidity or Lack Thereof….

Page 9: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

9

Liquidity or Lack Thereof…

Some investment managers found an asset/liability mismatch when faced with large redemptionsThose with leverage tended to be impacted more greatlyTechniques employed to stem the outflows include• Gates• Sidepockets• Liquidating pools• Fee concessions

Investment Managers

Page 10: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

10

Liquidity or Lack Thereof…

Endowments have experienced significant draw-downs“Denominator effect” results in outsized allocations to private investmentsPursuit of creative solutions to alleviate liquidity issues• Sales of private equity investment portfolios• Sales of other assets• Accessing capital markets

Endowments

Page 11: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

11

Evolving Investment Landscape

Proliferation of investment opportunities exists • Across asset classes • Globally

Increasingly difficult to evaluate and distinguish amidst quickly changing and complex investment optionsDue diligence requires greater expertise and time commitment Global perspective is essential

Page 12: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

12

Risk and Return Expectations

Investment risk and return expectations are being re-evaluated and a deeper understanding of underlying drivers of value is required• Volatility: Risk vs. return trade-off

• Appropriate capital base and liquidity to weather significant short-term volatility

• Duration of opportunity• Balance appeal of high short term tactical returns with re-

investment risk

• Underlying exposure: Greater granularity• Impact of leverage• Illiquidity premium: Investors must be significantly

compensated for illiquid capital

Page 13: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

13

“If it’s too good to be true…”

Scandals have rocked the investment world over the past year and have spanned both the corporate world and Wall Street

Investors ranging from small individuals to sophisticated endowments to hedge funds have been impacted by these schemes

Bernie Madoff Satyam Marc Dreier

Page 14: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

14

II. Direct Impact on Endowments and Foundations

Page 15: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

15

Current Climate Impact on Endowments and Foundations

Operational challengesInvestment policy reevaluation• Spending policy • Objectives and guidelines• Asset allocation• Governance

Heightened scrutiny of investment decisions

Page 16: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

16

Operational Challenges Due to Budget Constraints

A sizeable percentage of the operating and/or grant-making budget is often funded by the investment poolWith declines in these pools, endowments and foundations are• Cutting budgets• Establishing hiring freezes or reducing staff• Curtailing expenses (e.g., grant-making, financial aid)

Reduced donations and more requests for financial aid and grants in difficult markets compound these challenges

Page 17: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

17

Revisiting the Investment Policy Statement

An investment policy statement provides the framework for investing and defines important roles and responsibilitiesCritical elements are under review• Spending policy• Objectives and guidelines• Asset allocation• Governance

Page 18: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

18

Spending Policy and Intergenerational Equity

Spending policies define an institution’s choice to balance the needs of past, present and future generationsIntergenerational equity requires consideration of short-term needs and long-term asset preservationThe current market environment has tested these two competing objectivesFlashback two years ago, Congress was arguing that payouts were too low and universities were stockpiling money; now that concern has changed

Page 19: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

19

Spending Policies Open for Debate

PLANNED CHANGES TO SPENDING RATES FOR FY2010

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

No Changes PlannedPlan to Increase RatePlan to Decrease RateUnknown/No Response

Source: NACUBO-Commonfund Endowment Study, Follow-Up Survey, Nov. 2008

Page 20: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

20

Investment Objectives Subject to Constraints

The investment objective defines an investment return goal for an organization and is impacted by constraintsKey constraints faced by institutions• Spending policy• Percentage of operating budget funding the institution• Predictability of cash flows• Time horizon & liquidity

As these constraints come under pressure, the ability to fulfill objectives is challenged

Page 21: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

21

Asset Allocation Transition

HISTORICAL ASSET ALLOCATION FOR ENDOWMENTS

Source: 2008 NACUBO Endowment Study

23.6% 19.2%10.8%

64.3%

51.9%

39.4%

3.1%

12.9%

22.6%

13.6%

11.7%4.6% 5.3% 1.9%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

1999 2008 2008Endowments

>$1B

OtherReal AssetsPrivate EquityHedge FundsEquityFixed Income

+9.8%

+6.3%4.4% 10.7%

-12.4%

Page 22: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

22

Key Lessons of Asset Allocation

Asset allocation provides the framework to achieve the investment objective Key lessons and considerations• Appropriate liquidity is paramount• Illiquid investments should generate a sizeable premium• True diversification must be an investment goal• Leverage should be evaluated carefully• Flexibility is valuable• Each Investment Committee should follow its own path

Page 23: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

23

The Decision-Making Challenge

Today’s complex environment renders governance more challenging than ever beforeStructures vary from internal CIO and staff oversight to fully outsourced solutions with variants in betweenFiduciaries are reevaluating their current governance structure and, in some cases, contemplating changesIneffective decision-making can lead to paralysisThere is no one right solution

Page 24: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

24

Rethinking Roles

Expected Growth of Outsourced Nonprofit Assets

Source: Casey Quirk

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

< $500MM $500MM - $1B > $1B

20082012

Estimated% of

AssetsOutsourced

Endowment Size

Page 25: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

25

Why Use an Outsourced Investment Advisor

Enhances the ability of the Investment Committee to maintain a long-term strategic orientation when the “real time” decision-making is thoughtfully delegatedProvides collaborative opportunity for the advisor to leverage the insights and specific expertise of the Investment Committee membersAllows for proactive, tactical responses to rapidly evolving market dynamics

Page 26: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

26

The Bar Has Been Raised

Heightened scrutiny on all investment decisions• Transparency and disclosure • Liquidity terms• Return expectations and risk • Fee structure

Higher standards apply to all participants• Advisors• Investment committees• Investment managers

Page 27: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

27

III. Direct Impact on Donor-Advised Funds

Page 28: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

28

Appeal of Donor-Advised Fund Increased in Current Market

Donor-advised funds offer advantages to private foundations for smaller and mid-sized pools of charitable capital• Upfront tax deduction• Cost advantaged• Administrative ease• Privacy• No minimum distribution requirementsThese advantages are more pronounced in today’s market environment Demand is growing, especially among larger pools of capital

Page 29: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

29

Investment Choice Expansion

Recent growth in donor-advised funds has fueled demand for further enhancements to investment optionsInvestment advisors are gaining the ability to manage charitable assets in largest donor-advised funds and desire ability to construct multi-asset class portfoliosKey areas of interest and new options include

Socially ResponsibleInvestments

Asset AllocationVehicles

TIPs

Page 30: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

30

The Challenge of Implementation

High payout rates, recent value declines and heightened scrutiny on investment decisions provide strong tailwinds to drive for greater variety of investment optionsChallenge that emerges is balancing the goals and responsibilities of multiple audiences• Advisors and donors desire expansion of investment

options both within existing asset classes and to include a broader range of alternative assets

• Donor-advised fund administrator as fiduciary must judiciously and carefully expand allowable investments

Page 31: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

31

IV. Implications for Advisors

Page 32: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

32

Drivers of Success Today

Investment success, experience and conviction continue to be key attributes for advisorsToday’s focus includes

Increased Transparency

Enhanced Risk Management Organizational Stability

Greater Accessibility and Accountability

Customization

Page 33: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

33

Differentiate through Flexibility

As decision-making models evolve, flexibility in working with multiple audiences is essentialProactive engagement and partnership will differentiate top investment advisors

InvestmentAdvisor

Investment Committee

Endowment and FoundationStaff

Investment Manager

Page 34: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

34

Attributes for Outsourced Advisors

As the need for an outsourced or partially outsourced investment advisor increases, those who can fulfill this role will benefitEssential elements of the outsourced model• Global scale and access• Ability to customize • Client advocacy • Exceptional due diligence • Conflict-free business

Page 35: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

35

V. Looking Ahead

Page 36: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

36

Evolving Landscape

Investment model will continue to evolve as investors recover from the past year• Investment policies• Asset allocation• Liquidity assessment• Decision-making process

Higher governance standards Regulatory developments will continue to emerge

Page 37: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

37

Due Diligence – Tougher Questions

Investment strategy• Defined vs. actual: Lower tolerance for “drift”Liquidity• Stated terms vs. characteristics of underlying portfolio Fees• Importance of aligning incentives and understanding

implications for managers during drawdownsTeam• Understanding role, impact and potential distractions of

each person Risk Management• Systems, firm culture, potential conflicts of interest

Page 38: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

38

Expectations for Asset Managers

Remain forward-looking to adapt to evolving policy and regulatory changesIncrease transparency and improve communications • Develop capabilities to provide appropriate level of

information tailored to individual investor needs and interests

Review investment terms and update policies to best match strategy of underlying investments

Page 39: Investing for Nonprofit Endowments, Foundations and … · Endowments, Foundations and Donor- ... Risk vs. return trade-off ... aid and grants in difficult markets compound these

39

Be Nimble but Faithful to Key Principles

Appropriate investment policies and asset allocationsEvolving performance evaluation metrics• Shift towards absolute return vs. relative performance on

benchmarks• Fulfillment of intended role and differentiated return

pattern within portfolioEffective decision-making for hiring and firing managers• Avoid paralysis!Suitable liquidity and flexibility to invest strategically in dynamic markets

Investment Advisors & Investment Committees