inventory Forms

50
IDENTIFICATIO Property name ( Address or Stre County: Erie Owner Lawre Original use Si Architect/Builde DESCRIPTION Materials -- ple Exterior Walls: Roof: Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For build prints are accep Please staple on submitted in a s Maps Attach a printed recognized featu possible. Prepared by: Jak Telephone: 516- HISTOR NYS OFFICE O & HISTORIC P P.O. BOX 189, (518) 237-8643 ON (if any) et Location 21 ence and Vivian ingle Family Res r, if known ase check those wo sto vin as sto / location: Wood nown: Chimneys ex clear, original p dings or structur ptable for initial s ne photograph p separate envelop d or drawn site m ures so that the ke Palant -467-6256 IF YOU ARE PREP RIC RESOU OF PARKS, RECR PRESERVATION WATERFORD, N Saint Catherine Town/C Quinn sidential e materials that a ood clapboard one nyl siding sphalt, shingle one d half-timbering s have been rep xcellent hotographs of th res, this includes submissions. providing a comp pe or stapled to a map indicating the property can be PLEAS PARING A NATION URCE INVEN REATION NY 12188 es Court City: Buffalo, NY Address Current u are visible wood shi brick aluminum asphalt, r brick on walls and ga laced. Double-g good he property prop s exterior and int plete view of the a continuation sh e location of the e accurately posi address 18B Aff email jakepala@ (See Re E PROVIDE TH NAL REGISTER NOM NTORY FO use Single Fam Date of c ngle m siding roll bles and a stucc glazed window p posed for nomina terior views, gen structure or pro heet. property in rela tioned. Show a finity Lane @buffalo.edu everse) E FOLLOWING MINATION, PLEAS ORM Village/Ham mily Residential construction, if k vertical boards poured concrete cement-asbesto wood shingle poured concrete co façade panes installed. fair ation. Submitted neral setting, out operty to the fron ationship to stree north arrow. In INFORMATION SE REFER TO THE A OFFICE mlet: known 1927 plywoo e concre os other: metal e concre Date: deterio d views should r tbuildings and la nt of this sheet. A ets, intersections nclude a scale or Date 11/9/ N ATTACHED INSTR E USE ONLY od ete block sla ete block orated epresent the pro ndscape feature Additional views s or other widely r estimate distan /2014 RUCTIONS ate operty as a es. Color s should be nces where

Transcript of inventory Forms

Page 1: inventory Forms

IDENTIFICATIO

Property name (

Address or Stre

County: Erie

Owner Lawre

Original use Si

Architect/Builde

DESCRIPTION

Materials -- ple

Exterior Walls:

Roof:

Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For buildprints are accep Please staple onsubmitted in a s Maps Attach a printedrecognized featupossible. Prepared by: Jak Telephone: 516-

HISTOR NYS OFFICE O & HISTORIC PP.O. BOX 189,

(518) 237-8643

ON

(if any)

et Location 21

ence and Vivian

ingle Family Res

r, if known

ase check those

wo

sto

vin

as

sto

/ location: Wood

nown: Chimneys

ex

clear, original pdings or structurptable for initial s

ne photograph pseparate envelop

d or drawn site mures so that the

ke Palant

-467-6256

IF YOU ARE PREP

RIC RESOU

OF PARKS, RECRPRESERVATION WATERFORD, N

Saint Catherine

Town/C

Quinn

sidential

e materials that a

ood clapboard

one

nyl siding

sphalt, shingle

one

d half-timbering

s have been rep

xcellent

hotographs of thres, this includessubmissions.

providing a comppe or stapled to a

map indicating the property can be

PLEAS

PARING A NATION

URCE INVEN

REATION

NY 12188

es Court

City: Buffalo, NY

Address

Current u

are visible

wood shi

brick

aluminum

asphalt, r

brick

on walls and ga

laced. Double-g

good

he property props exterior and int

plete view of the a continuation sh

e location of thee accurately posi

address 18B Aff

email jakepala@

(See Re

E PROVIDE TH

NAL REGISTER NOM

NTORY FO

use Single Fam

Date of c

ngle

m siding

roll

bles and a stucc

glazed window p

posed for nominaterior views, gen

structure or proheet.

property in relationed. Show a

finity Lane

@buffalo.edu

everse)

E FOLLOWING

MINATION, PLEAS

ORM

Village/Ham

mily Residential

construction, if k

vertical boards

poured concrete

cement-asbesto

wood shingle

poured concrete

co façade

panes installed.

fair

ation. Submittedneral setting, out

operty to the fron

ationship to stree north arrow. In

INFORMATION

SE REFER TO THE A

OFFICE

mlet:

known 1927

plywoo

e concre

os other:

metal

e concre

Date:

deterio

d views should rtbuildings and la

nt of this sheet. A

ets, intersectionsnclude a scale or

Date 11/9/

N

ATTACHED INSTR

E USE ONLY

od

ete block

sla

ete block

orated

epresent the prondscape feature

Additional views

s or other widely r estimate distan

/2014

RUCTIONS

ate

operty as a es. Color

s should be

nces where

Page 2: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Narrative Description of Property: 21 Saint Catherines Court is a lot with a single family residence, located in the Elmwood district in Buffalo, New York. The house faces directly east, sitting on an irregularly-shaped parcel of land. The property is approximately 50-feet-wide along the east edge, 70-feet-wide in the west edge, and 108-feet-deep.1 There are two buildings located on the property. The main house is positioned in the center of the parcel, and a garage is located near the southwest corner of the lot; the garage has a flat roof and one carport. The main building is two-and-a-half stories in height. Built in the Tudor Revival style, the house has an exterior composition of stucco and dark wood half-timbering. Its floor plan is irregularly-shaped with ten corners. The main block of the building has a steeply-pitched side-gabled roof that intersects with a front-facing gable on the rear slope. A smaller two-story block with a front-facing gable is submerged within the southwest corner of the main block. The building has three chimneys. Two chimneys mirror one another at each end of the main roof; these are non-contributing, as they were added sometime after 1983 to replace the original chimneys, as evident in photograph 0003. The mirroring chimneys are clad in stucco as they extend to the tops of their respective gables, and then continue beyond the roof in brick. The third chimney is located along the rear slope of the main roof, nearing the southwest corner of the main block A narrow driveway runs along the south edge of the building. This driveway is shared with 25 St Catherines Court, which is the property immediately south of 21 St Catherine’s Court. The brickwork of the driveway is a recent addition and thus non-contributing. Front Elevation (east) Fenestration along the east face of the building is arranged asymmetrically, as with the rest of the house. The main block of the front elevation is divided into three bays. The left-most bay has an unclad first floor and narrow-studded half-timbering on the second. There are two fenestrations, both vertically aligned on the first and second stories of the house. The fenestration on the first story is a narrow casement window which utilizes a lattice styled glazing. The standalone window on the second story is a two-pane-wide and four-high casement window. A small one-and-a-half story block protrudes off the second bay from the left; this is where the main entrance is located. The entrance block dons a steeply-pitched front-facing gable roof, which has a slight overhang, and is adorned with small wooden brackets along the bottom edge.2 The gable extends from top of the first-story wall, at a steep angle, to intersect with the main block’s side-facing gable roof. Both the gable and first floor of the entrance block consist of narrow-studded half-timbering. A paired casement window, two-panes-wide and four-high on each sash, is centered on the gable. This pairing is of equal width and is perfectly aligned with the front door on the first story. The front door has fifteen square panels and a wide rectangular frame, which may be Tudor or Spanish eclectic. A small ashlar stone porch with three steps is extended from the entrance. Along the left and right edges of the porch is simple wrought-iron railing. The right-most bay is almost twice the length of the middle entrance bay. There are two fenestrations on each floor, aligned but asymmetrical. A narrow lattice-glazed casement window occupies the fenestration near the left corner on the first story (positioned close to the entrance bay). Near the right corner of the first story is a ribbon window with five sashes, two-wide and four-high on each. Irregularly cut ashlar stone has been used from the sill of the ribbon window to the base of the building. A casement window (identical to all of the other eight-paned windows) is positioned on the second story, aligned with the lattice-glazed window on the first story. 3 A paired casement window, with eight-paned sashes, is also located on the second story, centered with the first story ribbon window.4 Only a portion of the block located on the southwest corner of the property can be seen in the front elevation. From this angle, it deceives as a two-story extension with a shed roof. The east elevation of this block is adorned with one six-paned casement window on the second floor. Side Elevation (South) The gable roof of the main block faces the south elevation. The main gable is broken at its peak by a brick and stucco chimney, and then a third the way down towards the rear of the house by another intersecting gable. There are four fenestrations on the main block of the house, three of them to the right of the chimney, and another on the upper-left

1 The City of Buffalo, "City of Buffalo Property Viewer." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://gis.city-buffalo.com/cobapps/PublicApps/default.aspx . 2 The eight brackets in total are arranged symmetrically with a widened gap between the middle two brackets. 3 Together, the glazed window and eight-paned window above it mirror the windows located on the bay left of the entrance. 4 This paired window is identical to the paired window located on the entrance gable.

Page 3: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

corner of the unit; the latter is a small two-wide and two-high casement window, just above the secondary block’s side-facing gable. The upper-right-most window is a twelve-paned casement window, located on the gable roof. A large double-hung 8/16 sash window sits below the casement window, vertically situated between the first and second stories. A tiny casement window with a lattice glazing, slightly smaller than the casement windows on each side of the front entrance block, located on the first story wall, in alignment with the sash window There are four windows and one door on the block which projects from the main unit. Two narrow casement windows are symmetrically placed on the second story of the block, just below the roofline. A third identical window is located near the right corner of the block, placed in such a way that its top two panes are level with the other two windows’ bottom panes, thus this window is situated between the first and second stories of the building. A side entrance door is positioned directly below the offset window, slightly recessed into the wall. A three part casement window is located to the left of the door, also on the first story Narrative Description of Significance: Located in the Elmwood neighborhood, St Catherines Court penetrates a block bound by Cleveland Avenue to the north, Tudor Place, West Ferry Street, and Elmwood Avenue (going clockwise). The house at address 21 of Saint Catherines Court was built in 1927, the same decade in which many other houses on Saint Catherines Court were built.5 The house exhibits characteristics of Tudor eclectic architecture, which it shares with many of the neighboring properties along the cul-de-sac. Rather than being a landmark building, 21 Saint Catherines Court is a fragment which contributes to the historical fabric of the Elmwood neighborhood. It was constructed during a period of change, where massive parcels of land being divided to accommodate additional houses, the appearance of a garage was becoming more prominent, and the United States of America was falling into an economic depression (when massive homesteads were less apparent).6 Saint Catherines Court as a street did not exist prior to 1916.7 In its stead was a massive 13-acre parcel of land extending from the Chemical No. 5 Firehouse to Delavan Avenue, as part of John J. Albright’s private estate, and before that, Charles Wadsworth’s estate. John Albright John J. Albright was an industrialist who was born in 1848, in Buchanan, Virginia, and had grown up living in Scranton, Pennsylvania. In 1868, following his graduation Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Albright returned to Scranton from Troy, New York to become an entrepreneur in the coal industry. Albright amassed quite a profit from freight shipping, eventually selling coal under a partnership with Andrew Langdon in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and later starting an asphalt business with Anzi Lorenzo Barber when he moved again to Washington D.C. By 1883, Buffalo had become a major inlet for coal shipping from Pennsylvania. Still deeply involved in the coal industry despite his asphalt business, John Albright took his family to settle in Buffalo during that year.8 The Albright family moved into the former residence of Charles F. Wadsworth, a gothic revival house built in 1855, once easily recognized by its tower with castellation and glass conservatory. In 1901, the Wadsworth house was damaged in a fire, prompting John Albright to build a new house on the same property. John Albright commissioned architect Edward Brodhead Green to design his house at 730 West Ferry Street.9 E.B. Green completed projects for John Albright on several occasions, one of the most well-known of these buildings being the Albright-Knox Art Gallery (originally just the Albright Art Gallery).10 Saint Catherines Court Built in the Tudor style, John Albright’s new estate was designed by Green in reminiscence of a mansion near Bath, England. The English manor was named “Saint Catherines Court,” for which the cul-de-sac was named after.11 John Albright lived in his E. B. Green house until his passing in 1931, when he died with a significantly smaller fortune due to the recent economic depression. The house was demolished in 1935 and the property was divided into several lots and two streets, Saint Catherines Court and Tudor Place.12 The parcel of land where 21 Saint Catherines Court sits is immediately west of the original boundaries of John Albright’s estate. When John Albright moved to Buffalo in 1901, this parcel had extended from the Chemical No. 5 Firehouse to West Ferry Street, and was addressed as 694 West Ferry Street. The land was occupied by a single family residence, a carriage house, and a hen house.13 During the 1920s, this parcel had been divided into parts of 17, 21, 25, and 31 Saint Catherines Court, and the entire parcel of land occupied by 690 West Ferry Street.8 5 The City of Buffalo, "City of Buffalo Property Viewer." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://gis.city-buffalo.com/cobapps/PublicApps/default.aspx . 6 Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five, (New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1935), 442. 7 Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five, (New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1916), 455. 8 Betsy Taylor, The Ivy Grows Again: A History of the Albright Estate from 1890 to the Present, (Buffalo, NY: Nardin Academy, 1998). 9 Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm. 10 John Douglas Sanford, The Gallery Architects: Edward B. Green and Gordon Bunshaft, (Buffalo, NY: Albright-Knox Art Gallery, 1987). 11 LaChiusa, Chuck. "Buffalo Architecture and History." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://www.buffaloah.com/h/alb/index.html. 12 Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm. 13 Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Four, (New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1900), 397.

Page 4: inventory Forms

Ownership Three years afteconsisted of a 3with his wife, Mahouse was purcunder the namefrom Irene S. Wover the decade Photos

0001. Front faça

0002. Detailing

14 United States C15 The City of Buffsearch.

er the house was33-year-old man ary, his two daugchased by Lawree of John R. Gibs

Wright in 1985. Ines, the property

ade of 21 Saint C

on front elevatio

Census, 1930 falo, "Real Proper

OfficA

s initially constru who worked as ghters, Peggy anence and Vivian son, who had attn 1979, James Shad consistently

Catherines Cour

on of the house.

rty Tax Services."

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ucted, 21 Saint Ca broker, namednd Patricia, and Quinn, the propetained the prope

Shaffer sold 21 Sy been used as a

rt. Photograph t

Photograph tak

Accessed Novem

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

Catherines Courd Charles Marvin a cook and nurserty was assess

erty from Martha Saint Catherinesa single family re

aken by Jake Pa

ken by Jake Pala

mber 28, 2014. http

ric Preservation ction Agency

rt was worth rougn Pardee, born ose.14 By contrassed at $510,000. L. Morgan in 19

s Court to Wrightesidence.

alant.

ant.

p://www2.erie.gov/

ghly $20,000. Ton March 1st in 1st to its original w. Prior to the Qu990. Morgan hat.15 While the ow

/ecrpts/index.php?

The owners at th1894. Mr. Pardeworth, in 1993 wuinns, the housed purchased the

wnership has cha

?q=real-property-p

e time ee lived

when the was

e house anged

parcel-

Page 5: inventory Forms

0003. Photograp

0004. John Albr

0005. Charles W Maps

ph taken on Dec

right Estate built

Wadworth House

OfficA

cember 21st, 198

in 1901, no long

e built in 1855, n

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

83. Image courte

ger standing. Im

o longer standin

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

esy of the Buffal

age courtesy of

ng. Image source

ric Preservation ction Agency

lo History Museu

Chuck LaChius

ed from The Pic

um.

a

cture Book of Earrlier Buffalo.

Page 6: inventory Forms

0006. 21 Saint C

0007. John AlbrSanborn Map.

0008. Wadswor

Catherines Cour

right Estate (righ

rth Estate (right)

OfficA

rt highlighted in r

ht) and original p

and original par

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

red. Sourced fro

arcel of land tha

rcel of land that i

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

om 1935 Sanbor

at is now 21 Sain

is now 21 Saint C

ric Preservation ction Agency

rn Map.

nt Catherines Co

Catherines Cou

ourt (left), both in

rt (left). Sourced

n red. Sourced f

d from 1900 San

from 1916

nborn Map.

Page 7: inventory Forms

0009. 21 Saint Clinton Brown A Bibliography: Insurance Maps Insurance Maps Insurance Maps

Catherines CouArchitectural Com

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

OfficA

rt, highlighted inmpany.

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

n red, is located i

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

in the Elmwood

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

ric Preservation ction Agency

District in Buffal

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

lo, New York. M

900.

916.

935.

Map sourced fromm the

Page 8: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

LaChiusa, Chuck. "Buffalo Architecture and History." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://www.buffaloah.com/h/alb/index.html. Savage, Virginia, and Lee McAlester. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984. Sanford, John Douglas. The Gallery Architects: Edward B. Green and Gordon Bunshaft. Buffalo, NY: Albright-Knox Art Gallery, 1987. Severance, Frank. The Picture Book of Earlier Buffalo. 1912. Taylor, Betsy. The Ivy Grows Again: A History of the Albright Estate from 1890 to the Present. Buffalo, NY: Nardin Academy, 1998. The City of Buffalo, "City of Buffalo Property Viewer." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://gis.city-buffalo.com/cobapps/PublicApps/default.aspx . The City of Buffalo, "Real Property Tax Services." Accessed November 28, 2014. http://www2.erie.gov/ecrpts/index.php?q=real-property-parcel-search. Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm.

Page 9: inventory Forms

IDENTIFICATIO

Property name(

Address or Stre

County: Erie

Owner Paul B

Original use Si

Architect/Builde

DESCRIPTION

Materials -- ple

Exterior Walls:

Roof:

Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For buildprints are accep Please staple onsubmitted in a s Maps Attach a printedrecognized featupossible. Prepared by: Jak Telephone: 516-

HISTOR NYS OFFICE O & HISTORIC PP.O. BOX 189,

(518) 237-8643

ON

if any) George F

et Location 54

Buck Jr.

ingle Family Res

r, if known E.B.

ase check those

wo

sto

vin

as

sto

/ location:

nown:

ex

clear, original pdings or structurptable for initial s

ne photograph pseparate envelop

d or drawn site mures so that the

ke Palant

-467-6256

OfficA

RIC RESOU

OF PARKS, RECRPRESERVATION WATERFORD, N

F. Plimpton Hou

Cleveland Aven

Town/C

sidential

Green and Ass

e materials that a

ood clapboard

one

nyl siding

sphalt, shingle

one

xcellent

hotographs of thres, this includessubmissions.

providing a comppe or stapled to a

map indicating the property can be

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

URCE INVEN

REATION

NY 12188

se

nue

City: Buffalo, NY

Address

Current u

ociates

are visible

wood shi

brick

aluminum

asphalt, r

brick

good

he property props exterior and int

plete view of the a continuation sh

e location of thee accurately posi

address 18B Af

email jakepala@

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

NTORY FO

use Single Fam

Date of c

ngle

m siding

roll

posed for nominaterior views, gen

structure or proheet.

property in relationed. Show a

ffinity Lane

@buffalo.edu

ric Preservation ction Agency

ORM

Village/Ham

mily Residential

construction, if k

vertical boards

poured concrete

cement-asbesto

wood shingle

poured concrete

fair

ation. Submittedneral setting, out

operty to the fron

ationship to stree north arrow. In

OFFICE

mlet:

known 1925

plywoo

e concre

os other:

metal

e concre

Date:

deterio

d views should rtbuildings and la

nt of this sheet. A

ets, intersectionsnclude a scale or

Date 11/9/

E USE ONLY

od

ete block

sla

ete block

orated

epresent the prondscape feature

Additional views

s or other widely r estimate distan

/2014

ate

operty as a es. Color

s should be

nces where

Page 10: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

(See Reverse)

PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION

IF YOU ARE PREPARING A NATIONAL REGISTER NOMINATION, PLEASE REFER TO THE ATTACHED INSTRUCTIONS

Page 11: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Narrative Description of Property: The house at 54 Cleveland Avenue sits on a large rectangular parcel of land, facing north. This house is a two and a half story frame structure with an irregular floor plan; its plan is laid out with sixteen corners, somewhat resembling an “L” shape towards the front of the property. Being that the house was constructed in the mid-1920s, the style of architecture can best be classified as eclectic with elements of Colonial Revival, French Eclectic, and Italian Renaissance. The house’s rambling floor plan and presence of gabled roofs identify most closely with the Colonial Revival style of architecture. However, the house’s stucco façade and detailing such as its elaborate wrought iron railing on window balconets are prominent on Italian Renaissance and French Cclectic houses. Front Elevation (North) The main block of the house is two and a half stories in height, with a hip roof with a deck. A front-facing gable intersects with the hip roof on the second bay from the right, defining the entrance. A wing expands from the right side of the front face elevation, consisting of a two-story block with a front-facing gable, and in in front is the one-story garage block with a hip roof. The wing and main block meet at a corner, where there is yet another block that can be seen on the front facade. This block is extremely small, crowned with a parapet wall. The top edge of the parapet meets with the bottom left corner of the entrance gable. The bottom of the parapet is indicated with a molding that aligns with the eave on the two-story wing’s roof; this indicates a circa three-foot difference in height between the main elevation and the wing elevation. The main block of 54 Cleveland Avenue has five fenestrations, including windows and a door. This block has three bays. The central bay consists of the front entrance (a multiple-paned glass door with quoining), and two windows. A 6/6 double hung window with an iron-railed balconet is located on second story, centered above the entrance. A tiny arched casement with six panes of glass is centered on the front-facing gable, above the 6/6 window. A faint outline can be seen in the stucco on either side of the arched window, indicating that it once had shutters. The first story of the rightmost bay of the main block has one small casement window with six panes, not identical to the casement window on the gable roof. The left bay mirrors the right-most bay, save for a small 4/4 double hung window on the second story of the right bay, near the corner of the wall. The small block with the parapet is located to the right of the entrance unit. The front face of the block has three fenestrations, one on the first floor and two on the second. The first story has a pair of 4/4 double hung windows separated by a mullion, situated close to the left corner of the block. A pair of arched narrow casement windows with sixteen panes on each exists on the second story, aligned with the first story windows. A gable dormer with shingle exterior walls and 6/6 double hung window intersects with the main roof and is positioned in line with the parapet block. The two-and-a-half-story wing that projects from the left-most unit has but one small casement window positioned in the center of the front facing gable. An outline of shutters can be seen on each side of the window, along with their remaining shutter fasteners. A square is recessed into the stucco façade, located below the window as a crude attempt at filling in a gap in the wall. Another wing exists on the front elevation, projecting from the right of the main block; however, the second story of this wing is completely shrouded by an overgrown tree. A grouping of four casement windows with transoms can be seen on the first story elevation, each one being 6/15. Front Elevation (West) Three blocks appear on the west elevation which are still visible from the front of the property, the northeast wing that projects from the main block, the small block with parapets, and the one-story block where the garage is. Upon the west face of the garage block is one 6/6 double hung window, centered on wall. This window is barely visible between two large topiary balls, but it is still adorned with both louvered shutters. The wing can be seen to the right of the garage block, divided into two bays with a fenestration of six openings for windows, three on each floor. Two windows exist on the left bay of the wing, both of which are accompanied by louvered shutters. On the second floor near the left corner is a 9/9 double-hung window, with a smaller 6/6 double hung window is on the first story directly below. To the right of the first story window is a 6/6 double hung window with louvered shutters, repeated once to its right and once more on the second story, immediately above it. The sixth window is located on the second floor, close to the right corner of the block, where the wing meets the small block with parapet. This window is a tiny 4/1 double hung window, being the only window on the block without shutters. Above the right bay of the wing a gabled dormer, intersecting with the wing’s gabled roof. This dormer has wooden shingles, like the small dormer on the north elevation, but also a grouping of three 4/4 double hung windows. The small block with the parapet is completely bare on the west elevation. Narrative Description of Significance: 54 Cleveland Avenue is located in the Elmwood neighborhood of Buffalo on a block bound by Cleveland Avenue, to the north, Delaware

Page 12: inventory Forms

Avenue, West Fdesigned by archad been part onot constitute asdemonstrates ththe Albright Kno 800 West Ferry Originally the pllived on the parchouse was a stathe course of th The Holt house property throughlived on a large primary residenhis property at 8remaining portio Ownership In 1925, E.B GrF. Plimpton. GeAccording to theJanuary of 1996selling the prope Photos

0001. Front elev

16 Gurney Becker17 Insurance Maps18 Buffalo Courier19 Buffalo Courier20 Buffalo Courier21 Buffalo Evening22 Buffalo Courier23 United States C24 The City of Buffsearch.

Ferry Street, andchitecture firm ofof 800 West Ferrs a landmark, 54he architectural cox Art Gallery.

Street ot of land extendcel with his wife,ately Greek Reve 1880s, prompt

had been sold th John Otto &So parcel of land ince.19 Instead, A800 West Ferry Son of 800 West F

een and Associaeorge Plimpton pe 1930 Census, 6, when the houserty to Mr. Buck,

vation of the hou

r & Bourne Real Es of Buffalo, New r, December 13, 19r, August 27, 1905r, October 7, 1905g News, April 3, 19r Express, FebruaCensus, 1930 falo, "Real Proper

OfficA

d Tudor Place, gof Edward Brodhery Street (to the s4 Cleveland Avecapability of E.B

ding from 800 W, Lucretia, his soival Building, witting Elizabeth an

o a department ons to John J. Aln close proximityAlbright resold theStreet to Dr. GeoFerry Street to D

ates designed a proceeded to livethe house was vse was sold to P, at an estimated

use on 54 Clevel

state & Insurance York: Volume Five901.

5. . 923. ry 10, 1929.

rty Tax Services."

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

oing clockwise. ead Green and Asouth), along witnue is a strong c. Green and Ass

West Ferry Streeton, Walter, and hth a pediment sund Rosa sell the

store owner, Wibright in 1905. J

y to Hengerer’s fe house the samorge Moseley; th

Darwin R. Martin,

house at 54 Clee in the house wvalued at $43,00

Paul Buck Jr. by d value of $775,0

land Avenue. P

e, (New York, NY:

Accessed Novem

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

The house at 54Associates.16 Pth the house direcontributor to thesociates, who ha

t to 54 and 64 Chis two daughterupported by Ionic house in 1887.1

lliam Hengerer, John Albright waformer home, thume year he had phe latter subdivid, who erected an

eveland Avenue with his wife, Mar00.23 The most rLouis and Molly 000.24

hotograph taken

: Sanborn Map Co

mber 28, 2014. http

ric Preservation ction Agency

4 Cleveland AvePrior to the buildinectly west of it, 6e character of thad designed man

leveland Avenuers, Elizabeth andc columns. Lucr18

and had remainas a businessmaus Albright did npurchased it to Wded the parcel fon apartment tow

to be lived in byry, and their childrecently recorde Cloutier. The C

n by Jake Palant

ompany, 1935), 44

p://www2.erie.gov/

enue was constrng’s construction64 Cleveland Avhe Elmwood neigny buildings thro

e had belonged d Rosa, starting retia, Alonzo, an

ned in his possesan involved in theot make 800 We

William Gratwickor additional houer upon the parc

y the Plimpton fadren, Elizabeth,

ed purchase of thCloutiers had ow

t.

41.

/ecrpts/index.php?

ructed in 1925, an, 54 Cleveland

venue.17 Thoughghborhood, whileoughout Buffalo,

to Alonzo Holt, win 1873. The Ho

nd their son had

ssion until he soe coal industry, aest Ferry Street k.20 In 1925, Grausing. 21 Mosely cel.22

amily, headed by Jane, and Cheshe house occurre

wned the house s

?q=real-property-p

as Avenue h it does e it including

who had olt family’s died over

ld the and had his

atwick sold sold the

y George ster. ed in since 1973,

parcel-

Page 13: inventory Forms

0002. The front

0003. The garag

t elevation, as se

ge located on th

OfficA

een from the nor

e northeast wing

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

rthwest corner o

g of the house.

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

of the property. P

Photograph take

ric Preservation ction Agency

Photograph take

en by Jake Pala

en by Jake Palan

nt.

nt.

Page 14: inventory Forms

0004. The hous Maps

0005. 54 Clevel

0006. 800 West

e at 800 West F

and Avenue hig

t Ferry Street hig

OfficA

Ferry Street, as o

hlighted in red.

ghlighted in red,

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

owned by the Ho

Sourced from 1

as under owner

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

olt family betwee

935 Sanborn Ma

rship of William G

ric Preservation ction Agency

en 1873 and 187

ap

Gratwick. Sourc

77. Photograph

ced from 1916 S

Courtesy of Chu

Sanborn Maps.

uck LaChiusa.

Page 15: inventory Forms

0007. 54 CleveArchitecture Co Bibliography Buffalo Courier, Buffalo Courier, Buffalo Courier Buffalo Courier, Buffalo Evening Gurney Becker Insurance Maps

eland Avenue is mpany.

August 27, 190

December 13,

Express, Februa

October 7, 1905

g News, April 3, 1

& Bourne Real E

s of Buffalo, New

OfficA

highlighted in re

5.

1901.

ary 10, 1929

5.

1923.

Estate & Insuran

w York: Volume F

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

d, as it sits in the

nce

Five. New York,

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

e Elmwood Distr

NY: Sanborn M

ric Preservation ction Agency

rict of Buffalo, N

Map Company, 19

New York. Sourc

900.

ced from the Clinnton Brown

Page 16: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five. New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1916. Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five. New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1935. LaChiusa, Chuck. "Buffalo Architecture and History." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://www.buffaloah.com/h/alb/index.html. Savage, Virginia, and Lee McAlester. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984. The City of Buffalo, "City of Buffalo Property Viewer." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://gis.city-buffalo.com/cobapps/PublicApps/default.aspx. The City of Buffalo, "Real Property Tax Services." Accessed November 28, 2014. http://www2.erie.gov/ecrpts/index.php?q=real-property-parcel-search. United States Census, 1930

Page 17: inventory Forms

IDENTIFICATIO

Property name (

Address or Stre

County Erie

Owner James

Original use Si

Architect/Builde

DESCRIPTION

Materials -- ple

Exterior Walls:

Roof:

Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For buildprints are accep Please staple onsubmitted in a s Maps Attach a printedrecognized featupossible. Prepared by: Jak Telephone: 516-

HISTOR NYS OFFICE O & HISTORIC PP.O. BOX 189,

(518) 237-8643

ON

(if any) Louis Gr

et Location 64

s Bangs and She

ingle Family Res

r, if known Loui

ase check those

wo

sto

vin

as

sto

/ location:

nown: Double-G

ex

clear, original pdings or structurptable for initial s

ne photograph pseparate envelop

d or drawn site mures so that the

ke Palant

-467-6256

OfficA

RIC RESOU

OF PARKS, RECRPRESERVATION WATERFORD, N

reenstein Reside

Tudor Place

Town/C

erry Willoughby

sidential

s Greenstein

e materials that a

ood clapboard

one

nyl siding

sphalt, shingle

one

Glazed Window I

xcellent

hotographs of thres, this includessubmissions.

providing a comppe or stapled to a

map indicating the property can be

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

URCE INVEN

REATION

NY 12188

ence

City: Buffalo, NY

Address

Current u

are visible

wood shi

brick

aluminum

asphalt, r

brick

nstallation Date

good

he property props exterior and int

plete view of the a continuation sh

e location of thee accurately posi

address 18B Af

email jakepala@

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

NTORY FO

use Single Fam

Date of c

ngle

m siding

roll

e:

posed for nominaterior views, gen

structure or proheet.

property in relationed. Show a

ffinity Lane

@buffalo.edu

ric Preservation ction Agency

ORM

Village/Ham

mily Residential

construction, if k

vertical boards

poured concrete

cement-asbesto

wood shingle

poured concrete

fair

ation. Submittedneral setting, out

operty to the fron

ationship to stree north arrow. In

OFFICE

mlet:

known 1925

plywoo

e concre

os other:

metal

e concre

deterio

d views should rtbuildings and la

nt of this sheet. A

ets, intersectionsnclude a scale or

Date 11/9/

E USE ONLY

od

ete block

sla

ete block

orated

epresent the prondscape feature

Additional views

s or other widely r estimate distan

/2014

ate

operty as a es. Color

s should be

nces where

Page 18: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

(See Reverse)

PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION

IF YOU ARE PREPARING A NATIONAL REGISTER NOMINATION, PLEASE REFER TO THE ATTACHED INSTRUCTIONS

Page 19: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Narrative Description of Property: 64 Tudor Place is a rectangular parcel of land located on the southwest corner at the intersection of Cleveland Avenue and Tudor Place. Land is elevated, retained by short wall of quarry rock, laid out in a regular course, while the north edge is retained by deteriorated brick and concrete fence. The house is a two and a half story Tudor styled brick building with a basement, its front entrance oriented to the east. The floor plan of the house is irregular with fourteen corners, including porches. A prominent gable roof is located on the main block, facing eastward, which overlaps with another front facing gable on a secondary block for the entrance. Front Elevation (East) At first glance, the east elevation looks like the side of the building, for the entrance is not located on the main block, yet that unit is still the most prominent element on this elevation of the house. The main block has a medium pitched front gabled roof, which extends from the left-most wall to the top of a porch located on the first story (the segment of the gable atop the porch is clad with jagged-cut weatherboard). The side of a gabled dormer, clad with stucco and half timbering, can be seen intersecting with the left slope of the main roof, immediately above the porch. The main block has six symmetrically-arranged fenestrations. Windows are divided equally amongst the building’s left and right bays, mirroring one another on each side of an elaborate chimney. The first story consists of two casement windows with center openings. Both windows appear to be double-glazed, situated upon an alcove that protrudes from the main wall and intersects with the base of the chimney. Windows on the second story are centered with the first story windows. Both of the second story windows are 10/10 double-hung windows, which also appear to be double-glazed. Two quarter round windows mirror one another upon the gable roof to each side of the chimney (the three panes on each window are arranged into a sunburst design). A wing for the front entrance projects from the right side of the main block and is set further back. The front door is close to the corner of the wall perpendicular to the main block. A narrow casement window is positioned to the right of the front door. The window is crowned with a label mold, connected to the door’s hood mold. A side gable roof on the one story entrance block can be seen intersecting with the main block’s front gabled roof and wall. The pitch of the side gable gradually decreases towards the front of the elevation before cantilevering over the entryway. A brick and half-timbered gabled dormer, that almost reaches the edges of the first story walls, is situated on the second story of the entrance block. The main block’s gable overlaps with the dormer’s gable (overlapping gables are not uncommon amongst Tudor style houses). A glazed casement window three-wide and three-high is centered on the half-timbered dormer. Side Elevation (North) The most prominent element of the north elevation is the unit with the entrance. Upon this elevation, one can see the front face of the entrance block’s asymmetrical gable roof with varying pitch (the top-most portion of this roof is clad in a jagged-cut weatherboard, as seen on the east elevation). There are ten fenestrations of various sizes located upon the entrance block, all of which are divided amongst two bays (the left and right bay are split by a crevice in the brickwork offset to the left with the peak of the gabled roof). Three casement windows are spaced unevenly but still aligned along the first story of the left bay. A shallow oriel projecting from the main wall with a large transom casement window is located on the second story, centered with the right-most two casement windows on the first story. The first story of the right bay has a group of three 6/6 double hung windows, separated by mullions. Another identical 6/6 double hung window exists on the second story, aligned with the left-most window on the first story (this window is also centered with the peak of the roof). A small two-wide and-three high casement window is located above the standalone window and is positioned close to the top of the gable, and immediately above that is an even smaller window, which at first glance appears like an air vent. The main block projects from the right side of the entrance block; the wall on this face of the building is barren, save for an arch on the first story, and a shield-shaped ornament cast in plaster on the second story. A one-story block with a decked hip roof projects from the right of the main block. This block has three narrow garage ports, which do contribute to the historical fabric of the building. Narrative Description of Significance: Positioned at the southwest corner of Cleveland Avenue and Tudor Place, the house at 64 Tudor Place is significant both individually and as a contributing factor of the neighborhood around it. The house was completed in 1925, as designed by architect, Louis Greenstein, who had also lived in the residence with his family as its first owner.25 Prior to the erection of Greenstein’s house, the land

25 Muskat, Barry. "One sweet Tudor on Tudor." Buffalo Spree: The Magazine of Western New York, 2007. http://www.buffalospree.com/buffalospreemagazine/archives/2007_12/1207tudor.html (accessed November 23, 2014).

Page 20: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

where 64 Tudor Place is now was a fragment of John J. Albright’s estate. During the years after 1916, Albright’s estate was subdivided into several parcels and two roads, Tudor Place and Saint Catherines Court, marking a new era for the neighborhood and suburbia as a whole.26 John J. Albright The Albright estate was located on a 13 acre parcel of land extending from the Chemical No. 5 Firehouse to Delavan Avenue, which had belonged to Charles Wadsworth prior to Albright’s arrival to Buffalo. John J. Albright was an industrialist who was born in 1848, in Buchanan, Virginia, and had grown up living in Scranton, Pennsylvania. In 1868, following his graduation Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Albright returned to Scranton from Troy, NY to become an entrepreneur in the coal industry. Albright amassed quite a profit from freight shipping, eventually selling coal under a partnership with Andrew Langdon in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and later starting an asphalt business with Anzi Lorenzo Barber when he moved again to Washington D.C. By 1883, Buffalo had become a major inlet for coal shipping from Pennsylvania. Still deeply involved in the coal industry despite his asphalt business, John Albright took his family to settle in Buffalo.27 The Albright family moved into the former residence of Charles F. Wadsworth, a gothic revival house built in 1855, once easily recognized by its tower with castellations and glass conservatory. In 1901, the Wadsworth house was damaged in a fire, prompting John Albright to build a new house on the same property. John Albright commissioned architect Edward Brodhead Green to design his house at 730 West Ferry Street.28 E.B. Green and Associates completed projects for John Albright on several occasions, one of the most well-known of these buildings being the Albright-Knox Art Gallery (originally just the Albright Art Gallery).29 Albright’s personalized estate was designed in a formal Tudor architectural style, reminiscent of a manor in Bath, England named “Saint Catherines Court.”30 John Albright lived in his E. B. Green house until his passing in 1931, when he died with a significantly smaller fortune due to the recent economic depression. The house was demolished in 1935 and the property was divided.4 Louis Greenstein A Buffalo native, Louis Greenstein was born in 1886, and had spent the earlier portion of his architectural career as a draftsman, working for McCreary, Wood and Bradney in 1907, then for Green & Wicks the following year (the same Green who had designed Albright’s estate), and then worked as Chief Draftsman for the Edgar E. Joralemon architectural firm. In 1909, Greenstein attended Columbia University in New York City to study architecture, and then returned to the city of Buffalo in 1914 to set up his own private practice.31 Greenstein had designed a number of residences throughout Buffalo, such as the house on 40 North Street and 239-241 Lombard Street.32 Louis Greenstein had also designed institutions such as Tapestry Charter School, Temple Beth David, and the Medical Arts Building, also in Buffalo. In 1924 Louis Greenstein designed the seal for the City of Buffalo, which was selected from 73 designs that had been submitted for a competition to design Buffalo’s new flag.7

Ownership According to the 1930 United States Census, Louis Greenstein lived at 64 Tudor Place with his wife, Irma, Irma’s mother, Elizabeth Aaron, and her brother, Abraham Aaron. At that time, the house was estimated to be worth $35,000. The most recent deed information indicates that the house has been under ownership of James Bangs and Sherry Willoughby since November of 2011. Bangs and Willoughby purchased the property from Mark Sebastian and David Hall who had acquired the property in 2003 from Richard Griffin.33

Photos 26 Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five, (New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1916), 455. 27 Betsy Taylor, The Ivy Grows Again: A History of the Albright Estate from 1890 to the Present, (Buffalo, NY: Nardin Academy, 1998). 28 Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm. 29 John Douglas Sanford, The Gallery Architects: Edward B. Green and Gordon Bunshaft, (Buffalo, NY: Albright-Knox Art Gallery, 1987). 30 LaChiusa, Chuck. "Buffalo Architecture and History." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://www.buffaloah.com/h/alb/index.html. 31 Walkowski, J. Clinton Brown Company Architecture ReBuild The Pierce Building in the Theater Historic District , "H. Seeberg Building Application for Listing on the State and National Registers of Historic Places." Last modified January 11, 2011. Accessed November 23, 2014. 32 Kost, Ellen. Daemen College, "Amherst Designates Curtis Hall on The Daemen Campus as Historic Landmark." Last modified August 17, 2011. Accessed November 24, 2014. http://www.daemen.edu/news/Newsreleases/Pages/AmherstDesignatesCurtisHallontheDaemenCampusasHistoricLandmark.aspx. 33 The City of Buffalo, "Real Property Tax Services." Accessed November 28, 2014. http://www2.erie.gov/ecrpts/index.php?q=real-property-parcel-search.

Page 21: inventory Forms

0001. The east protruding head

0002. Taken froused for the gab

elevation of 64 Tder bricks with no

om the southeasbled dormer has

OfficA

Tudor Place is wo particular patte

st corner of the p been crafted int

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

where the entranern to them. Pho

property, the souto a floral design

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

ce is located. Totographed by J

uth elevation hasn. Photographed

ric Preservation ction Agency

The brickwork enake Palant.

s a more rustic pd by Jake Palan

ncompasses a F

presence than tht.

lemish Rowlock

he street elevatio

and some

ons. The stucco

Page 22: inventory Forms

0003. Taken fromasonry betweeand symbols in

0004. Taken fro

om northeast of en the half-timbethe masonry of t

om the northwest

OfficA

the property, it isered framing is athe main walls.

t of the property

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

s evident that tharranged sporad Photographed b

. Photographed

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

e house’s side gically with some

by Jake Palant.

d by Jake Palant

ric Preservation ction Agency

gable has a slighe of the bricks cu

.

ht curve towardsut at irregular ang

s the bottom of thgles. Greenstei

he slope. The n also hid patterrns

Page 23: inventory Forms

0005. A detailewall lamp. Phot

0006. Taken fromanufactured d

d view of the frotographed by Ja

om the northwesuring the 1920s

OfficA

ont entryway. Thke Palant.

st of the property. Photographed

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

he house addres

y, the garage bad by Jake Palant

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

ss number “64” is

ys are narrow, a.

ric Preservation ction Agency

s crafted in cast

as they were des

iron on the doo

signed to accom

r’s fanlight, and

mmodate the sma

on the pane of a

aller cars that we

a

ere

Page 24: inventory Forms

0007. John Alb

0008. Charles W

0009. Architectat Buffalo.

right Estate built

Wadworth Hous

tural Drawing of

OfficA

t in 1901, no lon

e built in 1855, n

Temple Beth El

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ger standing. Ph

no longer standin

in Tonowanda b

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

hotograph courte

ng. Image sourc

by Louis Greens

ric Preservation ction Agency

esy of Chuck La

ced from The Pic

stein. Courtesy o

aChiusa.

cture Book of Ea

of Jewish Buffalo

arlier Buffalo.

o Archives Projeect at the University

Page 25: inventory Forms

0010. Temple B1924. Photograp

0011. The Seal

Beth David (nowph courtesy of K

l of the City of B

OfficA

w Faith MissionarKarl Josker.

uffalo, designed

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ry Baptist Churc

by Louis Green

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

h) located at 626

nstein. Courtesy

ric Preservation ction Agency

6 Humboldt Park

y of the City of B

kway in Buffalo,

Buffalo.

designed by Loouis Greenstein in

Page 26: inventory Forms

Maps

0012. 64 Tudor

0013. 730 West

r Place, highlight

t Ferry Street, as

OfficA

ted in red. Sour

s owned by John

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

rced from 1935 S

n Albright. Sourc

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

Sanborn Map.

ced from 1916 S

ric Preservation ction Agency

Sanborn Map.

Page 27: inventory Forms

0014. 730 West

0015. 64 TudorCompany. Bibliography Betsy Taylor, Th

t Ferry Street, as

r Place, highlight

he Ivy Grows Ag

OfficA

s owned by Cha

ted in red, locate

gain: A History o

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

rles Wadsworth.

ed in the Elmwoo

f the Albright Es

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

. Sourced from

od District of Bu

state from 1890 t

ric Preservation ction Agency

1900 Sanborn M

ffalo. Sourced f

to the Present, (

Map.

from the Clinton

Buffalo, NY: Nar

Brown Architect

rdin Academy, 1

ture

1998).

Page 28: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

City of Buffalo, Accessed November 24, 2014. http://www.ci.buffalo.ny.us/. Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five. New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1900. Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five. New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1916. Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five. New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1935. John Douglas Sanford, The Gallery Architects: Edward B. Green and Gordon Bunshaft, (Buffalo, NY: Albright-Knox Art Gallery, 1987). Josker, Karl. "Temple Beth-David 626 Humboldt Parkway, Buffalo." Last modified May 07, 2014. Accessed November 24, 2014. http://www.pbase.com/image/28726944. Kost, Ellen. Daemen College, "Amherst Designates Curtis Hall on The Daemen Campus as Historic Landmark." Last modified August 17, 2011. Accessed November 24, 2014. http://www.daemen.edu/news/Newsreleases/Pages/AmherstDesignatesCurtisHallontheDaemenCampusasHistoricLandmark.aspx. LaChiusa, Chuck. "Buffalo Architecture and History." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://www.buffaloah.com/h/alb/index.html. Muskat, Barry. "One sweet Tudor on Tudor." Buffalo Spree: The Magazine of Western New York, 2007. http://www.buffalospree.com/buffalospreemagazine/archives/2007_12/1207tudor.html (accessed November 23, 2014). Savage, Virginia, and Lee McAlester. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984. Severance, Frank. The Picture Book of Earlier Buffalo. 1912. State University of New York at Buffalo, "JBIC015: Architectural drawing of new Beth El building and school, Eggert Road, Tonawanda, N.Y. (Louis Greenstein, Architect)." Last modified February 2012. Accessed November 24, 2014. The City of Buffalo, "City of Buffalo Property Viewer." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://gis.city-buffalo.com/cobapps/PublicApps/default.aspx . The City of Buffalo, "Real Property Tax Services." Accessed November 28, 2014. http://www2.erie.gov/ecrpts/index.php?q=real-property-parcel-search. United States Census, 1930 Walkowski, J. Clinton Brown Company Architecture ReBuild The Pierce Building in the Theater Historic District , "H. Seeberg Building Application for Listing on the State and National Registers of Historic Places." Last modified January 11, 2011. Accessed November 23, 2014. Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm.

Page 29: inventory Forms

IDENTIFICATIO

Property name(

Address or Stre

County:Erie

Owner Charle

Original use Si

Architect/Builde

DESCRIPTION

Materials -- ple

Exterior Walls:

Roof:

Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For buildprints are accep Please staple onsubmitted in a s Maps Attach a printedrecognized featupossible. Prepared by: J Telephone: 51

HISTORIC R NYS OFFICE & HISTORICP.O. BOX 189

(518) 237-86

ON

if any) Rudolph

et Location 690

es and Nance Ba

ingle Family Res

r, if known Land

ase check those

wo

sto

vin

as

sto

/ location: Stucc

nown: Double G

ex

clear, original pdings or structurptable for initial s

ne photograph pseparate envelop

d or drawn site mures so that the

ake Palant

6-467-6256

OfficA

RESOURCE INV

OF PARKS, REC PRESERVATIO9, WATERFORD643

B. Flershem Ho

0 West Ferry Str

Town/C

asil

sidential

dscaped by Haro

e materials that a

ood clapboard

one

nyl siding

sphalt, shingle

one

co and Half-timb

Glazed Windows

xcellent

hotographs of thres, this includessubmissions.

providing a comppe or stapled to a

map indicating the property can be

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

VENTORY FOR

ECREATION ON D, NY 12188

ouse

reet

City: Buffalo, NY

Address

Current u

old Olmsted

are visible

wood shi

brick

aluminum

asphalt, r

brick

bering on gables

Installed

good

he property props exterior and int

plete view of the a continuation sh

e location of thee accurately posi

address 18B A

email jakepala

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

RM

use Single Fam

Date of

ngle

m siding

roll

. Oxidized Copp

posed for nominaterior views, gen

structure or proheet.

property in relationed. Show a

Affinity Lane

[email protected]

ric Preservation ction Agency

Village/Ham

mily Residential

construction, if k

vertical boards

poured concrete

cement-asbesto

wood shingle

poured concrete

per Fixtures.

fair

ation. Submittedneral setting, out

operty to the fron

ationship to stree north arrow. In

OFFICE

mlet:

known 1930

plywoo

e concre

os other:

metal

e concre

Date:

deterio

d views should rtbuildings and la

nt of this sheet. A

ets, intersectionsnclude a scale or

Date 11/9

E USE ONLY

od

ete block

sla

ete block

orated

epresent the prondscape feature

Additional views

s or other widely r estimate distan

9/2014

ate

operty as a es. Color

s should be

nces where

Page 30: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

(See Reverse) PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION

IF YOU ARE PREPARING A NATIONAL REGISTER NOMINATION, PLEASE REFER TO THE ATTACHED INSTRUCTIONS

Page 31: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Narrative Description of Property: 690 West Ferry Street is located in Elmwood Village of Buffalo, New York. The property rests on a long quadrilateral shaped parcel of land, about 70-feet-wide and 281-feet-deep, its front oriented to the south. There are two buildings on this parcel, consisting of a large house in the center of the property, and a three stall garage on the northeast corner of the lot. The main building is a two and a half story residence with an irregular floor plan. Its exterior is composed primarily of burnt clay brick with some stucco and dark wood half-timber elements; the roofing is clad in slate shingles. The material composition and the building’s two prominent front-facing gable roofs epitomize the Tudor architectural style. Front Elevation (South) The front elevation of the house is namely comprised of two blocks with parallel front-facing gables. There are five fenestrations arranged symmetrically on the left block. A semi-hexagonal bay window with transoms is centered on the first story of said block. The bay window consists of seven multi-paned units with trefoil arches, two units on each side and three in the center. A low-pitched oxidized metal roof rests atop the bay window, its green color matching that of the gutters and eaves on the house. Three windows are seen on the second story of the block. A group of four casement windows, three wide and six high on each, is centered on the wall. On both sides of the group window are standalone casement windows with diamond-patterned glazing. The glazed casement windows are aligned at the top, but do not extend to the bottom edge of the grouped-window. Herringbone brick is used on the gable roof, juxtaposed with black half-timbering. A rectangular oriel protrudes slightly from the center of the gable. The oriel divided into three casement windows with diamond-patterned glazing, the central unit slightly wider than the side units. The extrusion is supported by a plaster corbel with a floral motif. The right block consists of two window openings and a wide chimney centered at the front elevation. The portion of wall between the chimney and the second floor of the left block is slightly recessed, leaving a small alcove for a shed roof between the first and second stories and a small casement window directly above it. The wall is also slightly recessed the right of the chimney on both the first and second story. A casement window with transom is positioned on the second story, near the right corner of the chimney. A tiny one-story block with a front-facing gable can be seen right of the main unit, projecting diagonally from the east elevation (the entrance faces southeast). This unit defines the entryway, which can be accessed through a gothic pointed arch with concrete molding. A metal lamp fixed above the point of the arch highlights the entrance block. Side Elevation (East) The east face of 690 West Ferry Street is a complex mass of units, which can be divided into four bays on the right, and one wing on the left, behind the diagonal entrance block. A front-facing gable with an overhang sits atop the two bays on the right side of the elevation, adorned with half timbering and beige-colored stucco. A double-glazed three-wide and five-high casement window is centered upon said gable. Another gable rests on the left-most bay, overlapping yet another gable (the latter being half-timbered and adorned with a casement window, as well). A wide shed dormer is positioned in between the front facing gables of the left and right-most bays, intersecting with the side of the main block’s gable roof. The dormer consists of three evenly-spaced paired casement windows, three-panes-wide and five-high on each sash. Five fenestrations can be seen on the right-most bay. The first story consists of two identical windows, partially concealed by a brick wall, more than likely three-wide and five-high casement windows to match the other windows on the building. An alcove, which protrudes from the main wall but is still shaded by the overhanging gable, is positioned on the second story in the upper-left corner of the block. The alcove is irregularly-shaped and clad with half-timbering. Half timbering divides the unit into four panels that run parallel to the main wall, and a smaller panel on the right, that intersects with the main wall at an acute angle.34 A glazed casement window with an arched top adorns each but the left-most panel (the right-most window is narrower than the others, to correspond with the dimensions of the diagonal alcove panel). A Quatrefoil design is beveled into solid wood panels between each window and the roof.35 The second bay from the right is a semi-hexagonal protrusion from the main elevation, which meets the edge of the gable roof where parallel. There are three fenestrations. A small casement window, three-wide, and three-high, is centered at the top edge of the bay. A casement window three-panes-wide and five-high is vertically aligned with the small window and positioned between the first and second stories of the building. An antique lantern fixture is centered and positioned below the lower window, identifying a point of entry on the first floor. The third bay from the right is the largest component of the east elevation; it is positioned in line with the long shed dormer. The bay has 34 Many alcoves throughout the façade are “supported” by large wooden brackets, for aesthetic purposes. 35 A quatrefoil is a symbol with ties to Christianity and High Gothic Architecture. “Quatrefoil” means “four leaves,” represented as four overlapping circles.

Page 32: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

ten fenestrations, with four windows on the first floor and six on the second. A group of three casement windows is located on the first story, positioned at least a foot away from the right edge of the bay. The greater portion of these windows is concealed by a brick wall, but judging by the windows on the second story, it can be assumed that the first story windows are three wide and four high. A small casement window with diamond-patterned glazing is positioned near the left edge on the first story. Two casement windows, three-panes-wide and four-high, are located on the right half of the second story elevation. A box-shaped alcove divided into four panels through half-timbering is located near the upper-left corner of the bay on the second story. Upon each of the four panels are an arched-top casement window, three-wide and six-high. A metal shed roof is exposed, hanging over the alcove. A two-story window rests upon the left-most bay of the east elevation. The window is divided into nine units, 3x3. Each unit is a casement window, three-wide and five-high for the bottom three units, and three-wide and four-high on the middle and top units.36 A trefoil-shaped arch adorns each of the top-most windows, while the transoms that divide each row of windows are carved with a vine pattern. A stained glass panel with an abstract design breaks the grid on the center-most window. A narrow opening with wooden louvers for ventilation is centered on the front-facing gable roof immediately above the massing of windows. The front entrance block can be seen where the “wing” intersects with the series of bays (the wing is really the main unit seen on the front elevation of the building, though it is not as prominent on the side elevation). A small casement window with a diamond pattern glazing is located on the second story of the wing, near the edge of the entrance block’s gable roof. A two-story alcove meets the left corner of the entrance block, where it the entrance intersects the wing. Like many of the other wall projections, this alcove is divided into eight panels shared amongst the first and second stories by half-timber cladding. The first story of the alcove consists of four casement windows with central transoms; glazing consists of a simple geometric stained glass pattern, which does not appear consistently throughout the house. The second story of the alcove is also composed of four windows, but these windows have basic rectangular panes with arched tops. Said windows are double-glazed and thus likely to be altered since construction. Narrative Description of Significance: The Rudolph Flershem House is situated at 690 West Ferry Street in the Elmwood Historic District of Buffalo, New York. The house was constructed in 1930, designed in the Tudor Revival style, built adjacent to the former site of John J. Albright’s estate. Flershem commissioned Harold LeRoy Olmsted (a distant relative of Frederick Law Olmsted) to landscape the property. The house is highly ornamented, and some of the leaded-glass used in the building’s more elaborate windows appears to be intact. The architecture of the Flershem House is significant in that it epitomizes Tudor revival architecture in a neighborhood of post-World-War I houses. Harold Olmsted completed an array of landscaping projects for affluent clients, such as James F. Foster at 12 Saint Catherines Court and John P. Wickser at 245 Nottingham Terrace. In 1924 Harold Olmsted also designed the house of James and Fanny How at 41 Saint Catherines Court, despite not being a licensed architect.37 According to the Sanborn insurance maps of Buffalo, 690 West Ferry Street was actually part of a larger parcel of land addressed as 694 West Ferry Street. In the 1920s, the property divided into parts of 17, 21, 25, and 31 Saint Catherines Court, in addition to the entire lot at 690 West Ferry Street.38 The property shared boundaries with the John J. Albright estate at 730 West Ferry Street; today 690 West Ferry Street shares a brick wall with the Nardin Academy, where part of the Albright estate used to be. John Albright John J. Albright was an industrialist who was born in 1848, in Buchanan, Virginia, and had grown up living in Scranton, Pennsylvania. In 1868, following his graduation Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Albright would return to Scranton from Troy, NY to work in the coal industry. Albright amassed quite a profit from freight shipping, eventually selling coal under a partnership with Andrew Langdon in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and later starting an asphalt business with Anzi Lorenzo Barber when he moved again to Washington D.C. By 1883, Buffalo had become a major inlet for coal shipping from Pennsylvania. Still deeply involved in the coal industry despite his asphalt business, John Albright would take his family to settle in Buffalo during that year, and acquire a large portion of land in the Elmwood district.39 Rudolph Flershem In 1930, a businessman by the name of Rudolph Byford Flershem purchased 690 West Ferry Street to live there with his family. Hailing from Chicago, Illinois, Flershem was an esteemed industrialist and an alumnus of the Harvard graduating class of 1898. In 1920, Rudolph Flershem married Alice Jamieson Donnell; the couple had had three children, Jane, Anna, and Robert.40 The Flershems were especially affluent; their house on West Ferry Street had an estimated value of $80,000 in 1930, where they lived with a cook, two maids,

36 The center-most window’s grid is broken by a stained-glass panel with an abstract design. 37 Shelgren, Olaf, and Francis Kowsky. "Rider-Hopkins Farm and Olmsted Camp Nomination for inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places." Accessed November 24, 2014. http://buffaloah.com/a/kowsky/camp/hp/hp.html. 38 Insurance Maps of Buffalo, New York: Volume Five, (New York, NY: Sanborn Map Company, 1935), 442. 39 Betsy Taylor, The Ivy Grows Again: A History of the Albright Estate from 1890 to the Present, (Buffalo, NY: Nardin Academy, 1998). 40 Thayer, William. The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Volume 28.

Page 33: inventory Forms

and a waitress. Late OwnershipThe most recenNance Basil. Whad been owned Photos

0001. Taken frofront elevation.

0002. Window fthe wall with a w

41 United States C42 The City of Buffsearch.

After settling in

p t deed for the pr

Western Relocatiod by Robert and

om southeast of Photograph by

fenestration on twooden sill. Pho

Census, 1930 falo, "Real Proper

OfficA

Buffalo, Rudolp

roperty is from 2on Inc. held the Ann Reich, who

the house. TheJake Palant.

the front elevatiootograph taken b

rty Tax Services."

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ph Flershem atta

009, when 690 Wproperty from Mo had purchased

e building can on

on of the house. by Jake Palant.

Accessed Novem

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

ained the position

West Ferry StreeMarch to Octoberd from James M.

nly be seen from

Windows posit

mber 28, 2014. http

ric Preservation ction Agency

n as the Vice Pr

et was purchaser of 1995 before . Marinello in 19

m close-up due to

ioned on brick s

p://www2.erie.gov/

resident of the M

ed from John. L. selling to Pett.

984.42

o a large oak tre

surfaces are usu

/ecrpts/index.php?

Marine Trust Com

Pett by CharlesPrior to 1995, th

e shrouding mos

ally slightly rece

?q=real-property-p

mpany.41

s and he house

st of the

essed into

parcel-

Page 34: inventory Forms

0003. The eastNardin Academ

0004. Taken frotree. Photograp

0005. Taken froPhotograph take

t elevation of they. Photograph ta

om south of the ph taken by Jake

om southeast of en by Jake Pala

OfficA

e house, as seenaken by Jake Pa

property, the froe Palant.

the building, thent.

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

n from the parkinalant.

ont elevation of th

e front entrance

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

ng lot of 700 Wes

he house canno

of the house has

ric Preservation ction Agency

st Ferry Street. T

ot be seen directl

s a Gothic style

The red brick wa

ly from the stree

arch, distinguish

all is shared with

et due to a mass

hed by its steep

h the

ive oak

pitch.

Page 35: inventory Forms

0006. The east

0007. The eastby Jake Palant.

0008. Upon thePalant.

elevation of the

t elevation of the

e east elevation,

OfficA

house, as seen

e house, one can

a side entrance

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

from the southe

n see the two-sto

e can be seen be

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

east at the Nardi

ory window with

ehind the brick w

ric Preservation ction Agency

n Academy. Ph

a trefoil motif ju

wall at the Nardin

hotograph taken

st behind a shru

n Academy. Pho

by Jake Palant.

ubbery. Photogr

otograph taken b

raph taken

by Jake

Page 36: inventory Forms

0009. PhotograMuseum. Maps

0010. 690 Wes1935 Sanborn F

aph of 690 West

st Ferry Street is Fire Insurance M

OfficA

Ferry Street fro

highlighted in reMap of Buffalo.

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

nt façade, taken

ed, as evident af

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

n on February 8th

fter the demolitio

ric Preservation ction Agency

h, 1984. Photog

on of the John J.

graph courtesy o

. Albright Mansio

of the Buffalo His

on. Sourced fro

story

m the

Page 37: inventory Forms

0011. A duplexmansion was lo

x was built at the cated on the adj

OfficA

location occupiejacent parcel to t

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ed now by 690 Wthe right. Sourc

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

West Ferry Streeced from the 191

ric Preservation ction Agency

et and several ot5 Sanborn Fire

ther properties. Insurance Map

The John J. Albof Buffalo.

bright

Page 38: inventory Forms

0012. 690 WesBrown Architect Bibliography Insurance Maps Insurance Maps Insurance Maps LaChiusa, Chuc Sanford, John D Savage, Virginia Taylor, Betsy. T Thayer, William The City of Buffbuffalo.com/cob The City of Buffparcel-search. United States C

st Ferry Street is ture Company.

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

ck. "Buffalo Arch

Douglas. The Ga

a, and Lee McAl

The Ivy Grows Ag

. The Harvard G

falo, "City of Buffbapps/PublicApp

falo, "Real Prope

Census, 1930

OfficA

highlighted in R

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

itecture and His

allery Architects:

ester. A Field G

gain: A History o

Graduates' Maga

falo Property Vieps/default.aspx .

erty Tax Services

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

Red, as located in

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

tory." Accessed

Edward B. Gree

uide to America

of the Albright Es

zine, Volume 28

ewer." Accessed

s." Accessed No

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

n the Elmwood D

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

November 10, 2

en and Gordon B

n Houses. New

state from 1890

8.

d November 10,

ovember 28, 201

ric Preservation ction Agency

District of Buffalo

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

2014. http://www

Bunshaft. Buffalo

York, NY: Alfred

to the Present. B

2014. http://gis.c

14. http://www2.e

o, New York. So

900.

916.

935.

w.buffaloah.com/

o, NY: Albright-K

d A. Knopf, Inc.,

Buffalo, NY: Nar

city-

erie.gov/ecrpts/i

ourced from the

/h/alb/index.htm

Knox Art Gallery

1984.

rdin Academy, 1

ndex.php?q=rea

Clinton

l.

y, 1987.

998.

al-property-

Page 39: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm.

Page 40: inventory Forms

IDENTIFICATIO

Property name(

Address or Stre

County:Erie

Owner Buffal

Original use Si

Architect/Builde

DESCRIPTION

Materials -- ple

Exterior Walls:

Roof:

Foundation: Other materials/ Alterations, if kn Condition: Photos Provide several whole. For buildprints are accep Please staple onsubmitted in a s Maps Attach a printedrecognized featupossible. Prepared by: Jak Telephone: 516-

HISTOR NYS OFFICE O & HISTORIC PP.O. BOX 189,

(518) 237-8643

ON

if any) George A

et Location 126

o Land Holding

ingle Family Res

r, if known E. B

ase check those

wo

sto

vin

as

sto

/ location: Copp

nown:

ex

clear, original pdings or structurptable for initial s

ne photograph pseparate envelop

d or drawn site mures so that the

ke Palant

-467-6256

OfficA

RIC RESOU

OF PARKS, RECRPRESERVATION WATERFORD, N

A. Forman Hous

60 Delaware Av

Town/C

Company

sidential

. Green and Ass

e materials that a

ood clapboard

one

nyl siding

sphalt, shingle

one

per Fixtures throu

xcellent

hotographs of thres, this includessubmissions.

providing a comppe or stapled to a

map indicating the property can be

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

URCE INVEN

REATION

NY 12188

se

enue

City: Buffalo, NY

Current u

sociates

are visible

wood shi

brick

aluminum

asphalt, r

brick

ughout property

good

he property props exterior and int

plete view of the a continuation sh

e location of thee accurately posi

address 18B Aff

email jakepala@

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

NTORY FO

Addres

use Office Build

Date of c

ngle

m siding

roll

.

posed for nominaterior views, gen

structure or proheet.

property in relationed. Show a

finity Lane

@buffalo.edu

ric Preservation ction Agency

ORM

Village/Ham

ss

ding

construction, if k

vertical boards

poured concrete

cement-asbesto

wood shingle

poured concrete

fair

ation. Submittedneral setting, out

operty to the fron

ationship to stree north arrow. In

OFFICE

mlet:

known 1915

plywoo

e concre

os other:

metal

e concre

Date:

deterio

d views should rtbuildings and la

nt of this sheet. A

ets, intersectionsnclude a scale or

Date 11/9/

E USE ONLY

od

ete block

Stucco

sla

ete block

orated

epresent the prondscape feature

Additional views

s or other widely r estimate distan

/2014

ate

operty as a es. Color

s should be

nces where

Page 41: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

(See Reverse)

PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION

IF YOU ARE PREPARING A NATIONAL REGISTER NOMINATION, PLEASE REFER TO THE ATTACHED INSTRUCTIONS

Page 42: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Narrative Description of Property: The George A. Forman House is located at 1260 Delaware Avenue in Elmwood Village in Buffalo, New York. The parcel is irregularly-shaped, 173-feet-wide and 72-feet deep; it used to consist of the lot that is now addressed at 836 Auburn Avenue, which is now being used for multiple residences. The front entrance of the Forman House faces the southwest side of the parcel, thus the building opens up onto Auburn Avenue rather than onto Delaware Avenue, which runs along the southeast side of the property. The architecture of the house at 1260 Delaware Avenue can be described as Colonial Revival, a style which had flourished during the earlier 20th Century. The floor plan of the Forman House is irregular, though its main unit is symmetrical. A side-gabled roof with parapets at the ends can be seen atop the main unit; a two-story wing projects from the northwest face of the main block, also capped with a side-gabled roof with parapets. Many of the building’s architectural features, such as windows and shutters, are painted green, giving the façade an earthy presence in combination with the off-white stucco wall covering. Most of the stucco walls are deteriorated and blackened from damage caused by the ivy that covered the house (the ivy now appears to be withering, marring the beauty of the architecture). Front Elevation (Southwest) The front elevation of the Forman house’ is divided into three blocks. The main block is on the right side of the elevation, with the two-story wing projecting from its left. A small one-story block with a flat roof is located where the wing meets the main unit. The main unit is divided into three bays (separated by the presence of downspouts) and is almost completely symmetrical. The right-most bay consists of four fenestrations. A casement window with a transom light is located on the first-story elevation, near the right-corner of the block. The window opens from the center, two-panes-wide and four-high on both its left and right sash; the transom light has four panes going across. Functional shutters accompany the window; each one divided into a top panel and bottom panel, whereas the top panel is louvered. A balcony with cast-iron railing is located on the second story, aligned with the first story window. A set of doors which are identical to the massive first-story transom window opens onto the balcony. A 6/6 double hung window with shutters is located on the first story, to the left of the transom window. The shutters on this window are completely louvered. Another 6/6 double hung window with shutters can be seen on the second story directly above the first double hung window (this window is slightly wider than the one located on the first story). The wider of the double hung windows is repeated on the center bay and the left-most bay, all three vertically-aligned upon the second story elevation and evenly spaced apart. In addition, every other window on the right bay is mirrored on the left bay of the block. The main entrance, a double-door with unpedimented entablature cast in concrete, is located below the double hung window on the center bay. The door itself is constructed from an oxidized copper, a material which appears on a lot of the house’s detailing. A narrow 4/4 double hung window is positioned to the right of the front door. Five concrete steps lead up to the entrance, lined by a concrete retaining wall, which encompasses the shrubberies in front of the house. As previously noted, the left-most bay of the main block is a mirrored version of the right-most bay, with exception to the addition of a small 1/1 double hung window in between the large double hung window and balcony door on the second story. Three identical shed-roof dormers intersect with the main roof, aligned with the front entrance in the central bay and the second-story balcony doors on the outer bays of the elevation. Each dormer has a detached pair of small casement windows, two-wide and two-high each. An unadorned stucco chimney is positioned on the front slope of the roof, to the right of the left-most dormer. A small one-story block is positioned at the corner where the wing of the house intersects with left side of the main block. An arrangement of three windows, separated by short pilasters, can be seen on the front elevation of the one-story block. The central unit is six-wide and three-high, and atop is a transom with six panes running across the width of the window. Narrow casement windows are positioned on each side of the central unit; both are one-wide and three-high with a single-paned transom light. A square alcove is positioned at the corner between the one-story block and the west wing of the building. With exception to the small alcove, the block has a decked roof with eaves constructed from green oxidized metal. The two-story wing projects from the left of the main block. A casement window that is four-wide and two-high (where the upper panes are shorter than the lower panes) is located on the second story. The window has barred shutters and opens onto the decked block below. The same type of window repeated twice to its left on the second story wall. The other two windows are evenly-spaced with the first window, but lacking the barred shutters. A glass door with an aluminum frame is located on the first story and is aligned with the left-most window (this door is non-contributing, as it has not been cast in oxidized copper). A concrete ramp, which was added later for accessibility, leads to the aluminum-framed door. Side Elevation (Southeast) The parapet which outlines the front face of the main block’s gable roof can be seen on the southeast elevation of the building. The

Page 43: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

elevation is divided into two bays, separated by a massive stucco chimney, centered with the gable. The left and right bays mirror one another precisely, with six fenestrations. Two balconies are located upon the second story, one on each side of the chimney’s mass. The doors opening onto each balcony resemble the doors leading to the second story balconies on the front elevation of the house (double doors with transom lights and shutters). The doors are repeated again twice on the first story opening onto a crude concrete deck, with each set of doors centered under the balconies. A 4/4 double hung window can be seen positioned on the front facing gable, on each side of the chimney mass. The small double hung windows do not include shutters. A two-story wing can be seen projecting from the right side of the main block. The first story of the “wing” is partially-open, simply there to support a second story unit. From this elevation, one can see three Doric columns on the first story of the block: one on the left near the main block’s wall, and two near the right corner. A wall can be seen beyond the columns, adorned with a geometric framework made from cast iron. Simple entablature rests atop the first story columns, a modern adaption of the architecture on Ancient Greek Temples. The architrave of the entablature is cast in concrete whereas its cornice is constructed from oxidized copper. A four-wide and three-high center-opening casement window with a transom, but no shutters, is positioned in the middle of the second story wall, above the cornice. A parapet wall is seen directly above the top of the window, intersecting with the lower portion of the main block’s roof. A three-foot-high wall, clad in stucco with concrete molding, sits in front of the house. The title of the organization associated with the building “The Foundations of Kaleida Health” is set on the wall with brass lettering; the signage is of course non-contributing. Rear Elevation (Northeast) The right side of the rear elevation at the Forman House is obstructed by a stucco wall and trees; however, the left portion of the elevation can be seen clearly from the parking lot of 1272 Delaware Avenue. The left-most bay on the elevation consists of two fenestrations, a door opening onto a balcony, on the second-story, and a door opening onto the lawn, on the first story. These two units are identical to the other balcony doors seen throughout the property, with multiple panes, a transom light, and shutters. A downspout separates the left-most bay from the bay to its right. The second bay from the left has eight fenestrations. Three windows are arranged symmetrically on the second story, each unit spaced apart by approximately five feet. The windows at either end are 4/4 double hung windows, while the center unit is a large four-wide and three-high casement window with a center opening and transom light, adorned with a barred window grille, but no shutters. A completely unadorned version of the four-wide three-high casement window with transom light is repeated five times on the first story, closer to the right edge of the bay. These windows are separated by pilasters and are crowned with entablature. The second story wing projects from the front of the third bay from the right, supported by four evenly-spaced Doric columns located on the first story. Three windows exist on the second story, evenly spaced apart. Two-wide three-high casement windows with transom lights exist at the ends, while the middle unit is a four-wide three-high window with a center opening and a four-wide transom light. The remainder of the rear elevation, on the right, is obstructed by trees and the stucco wall. Side Elevation (Northwest) The parapet gable on main block can be seen on the northwest elevation. The front-facing gable of the building’s west wing overlaps the main unit’s gable. The one-story block with an alcove is positioned to the right of the wing, at the corner of where the wing meets the main block. There are three windows on the main block’s elevation, all of them positioned on the gable. A small 4/4 double hung window is centered below the peak of the roof. A 6/6 double hung window is immediately below the tiny window, and is repeated again to its right. Two fenestrations exist upon the one-story block at the intersection of the main unit and the wing. A four-wide and three-high window with a four-wide transom light can be seen near the right corner of the small block. A multi-paned double door with a six-wide transom light sits to the left of the window, separated by a pilaster. Another pilaster is positioned to the left of the door, separating it from the alcove, which dons a 6/6 double hung window along its northwest elevation. A patio room, which appears to suffered severe weathering damage, exists in front of the west wing. Four fenestrations, arranged symmetrically, are positioned on the second story of the wing (above the patio room). Two 6/6 double hung windows, spaced evenly apart occupy the second story wall. Two smaller 6/6 double hung windows, close together yet not connected, are positioned between the second story and the gable. The upper portion of the wall has suffered from deterioration over the years, refinished with a material that does not match the color of the building’s stucco façade. Narrative Description of Significance: Located at the intersection of Auburn Avenue and Delaware Avenue in Elmwood Village in Buffalo, New York, the George A. Forman

Page 44: inventory Forms

House was builtstands out from Century, the Gedesigned three happens to be o The Forman LegGeorge Alfred Findustrialist frompresident upon Delaware Avenuaccumulated en In despite of hisseparated. Geoto build her a mand moved into Wicks).43 George A. FormJust as his fatheAvenue. In 1925house behind toCensus, George Late OwnershipToday, the GeoFoundation. Thnames of Jamesin 1985.45 Photos

0001. Taken frothe George A. F

43 Edward Dunn, 44 Martin Wachad45 The City of Buffsearch.

t in 1915 by E. B the older Victor

eorge A. Formanmansions in Bufone of such histo

gacy Forman was the m New Jersey wimoving to Buffaue by the archite

nough wealth fro

s upper-class rooorgia used the mansion at 77 Oa the Charles W.

man er and sister-in-la5, ten years afteo his wife, Lucie e A. Forman’s w

p rge A. Forman H

he Buffalo Land Hs Allen and Rich

om southwest ofForman House.

Buffalo's Delawarelo, Oakland Placefalo, "Real Proper

OfficA

B. Green and Asian Era houses a

n House was moffalo for memberorical relics.

second son of Gith an education lo. George V. Fects Green and Wm the oil industr

ots, Howard Artemoney her husba

kland Place. Ge Goodyear house

aw had done, Gr the house wasM. Forman, and

widow also lived w

House is owned Holding Companhard Lippes, who

f the property, thPhotograph take

re Avenue: Mansioe: Gracious Living rty Tax Services."

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

sociates. The halong Auburn Avre than just a prrs of the highly-e

George V. Forma from Princeton orman amassedWicks (E. B. Grery to enable his k

er Forman lived mand left her and ceorge V. Formane at 888 Delawa

eorge Alfred sous built, George Ad his children, Gewith three servan

by the Buffalo Lny has owned tho were practicing

he symmetrical ben by Jake Pala

ons and Families, in Buffalo, (BuffaloAccessed Novem

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

ouse namely havenue. While exoduct of its time

esteemed Forma

an, born after HoUniversity; he w

d a large fortune een and Associakin and their fam

modestly with hicommissioned En’s daughter, Maare Avenue, also

ught E. B. GreenA. Forman died weorge Jr. and Lunts and a maid,

and Holding Coe property since

g attorneys. Lipp

block of the frontnt.

(Buffalo, NY: Cano, NY: Buffalo Her

mber 28, 2014. http

ric Preservation ction Agency

as characteristicsxemplifying the e

e. The architectuan Family, and th

oward Arter Formwas part of the E

from the oil tradates). In additionmilies to live in op

s wife, Georgia E. B. Green and ary Forman, maro built by E. B. G

n and Associateswith a net worth oucile Forman. Ac and her inherite

mpany and is bee 2005, while befpes and Allen ac

t façade does no

isius College Presritage Unlimited,).

p://www2.erie.gov/

s of Colonial Reveclectic architectural firm E. B. Grhe house at 126

man. George V.astern Oil Compde, and had his mn to pampering hpulent mansions

Mead Greene FSons (among Erried into the we

Green and Assoc

s to build his maof around $5-milccording to the 1

ed property was w

eing leased to thfore then the procquired the prop

ot reflect the ove

ss, 2013). . /ecrpts/index.php?

vival architecturture of the early reen and Associ

60 Delaware Ave

. Forman was anpany, and had bemansion built at himself, George s throughout Buf

Forman, until the. B Green and Aalthy Goodyear

ciates (Green an

ansion at 1260 Dllion.44 George A1930 United Staworth around $2

he Kaleida Healtoperty was undeperty from Rober

erall irregular floo

?q=real-property-p

e, and 20th iates had enue

n ecome its 824 V. Forman ffalo.

y Associates) Family nd

Delaware A. left the tes

200,000.

th er the rt Moriarty

or plan of

parcel-

Page 45: inventory Forms

0002. The front Photograph take

0003. A chimneJake Palant.

entrance has a en by Jake Pala

ey can be seen p

OfficA

door made fromnt.

partially embedd

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

m copper, which h

ded in the wall al

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

has been oxidize

long the southea

ric Preservation ction Agency

ed to a color tha

ast elevation of t

at matches the sh

the Forman Hou

hutters on the ho

use. Photograph

ouse.

h taken by

Page 46: inventory Forms

0004. Taken fro

0005. Taken altaken by Jake P

0006. Taken froby Jake Palant.

om east of the Fo

ong the southeaPalant.

om the northeas

OfficA

orman house. P

ast elevation of th

st of the house, t

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

Photograph taken

he building, the

he rear elevation

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

n by Jake Palant

house is current

n is difficult to se

ric Preservation ction Agency

t.

tly leased to the

ee completely be

Kaleida Health

eyond the stucco

Foundation. Ph

o wall. Photogra

hotograph

aph taken

Page 47: inventory Forms

0007. The northPhotograph take

0008. A photogrMuseum. Maps

0009. The curre

hwest elevation en by Jake Pala

raph of the Geor

ent lot at 1260 D

OfficA

of the house is dnt.

rge A. Forman h

Delaware Avenue

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

difficult to descri

house taken on D

e as it stands in

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

be solely in word

December 8th, 1

2014. Image so

ric Preservation ction Agency

rds, due to the co

953. Photograp

ourced from Buff

omplex arrangem

ph courtesy of th

falo parcel viewe

ment of building

he Buffalo Histor

er.

units.

ry

Page 48: inventory Forms

0010. 1260 as

0011. Originallyconstruction of t

it appeared in 19

y there were twothe George A. F

OfficA

916. Sourced fr

o parcels of land orman House. S

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

rom the 1916 Sa

where 1260 DeSourced from th

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

anborn Fire Insur

elaware Avenue se 1900 Sanborn

ric Preservation ction Agency

rance Maps of B

sits now. The la

n Fire Insurance

Buffalo.

and was used as Maps of Buffalo

s a natural pastuo.

ure prior to

Page 49: inventory Forms

0012. 1260 DelClinton Brown A Bibliography Dunn, Edward. Insurance Maps Insurance Maps Insurance Maps LaChiusa, Chuc Sanford, John D Savage, Virginia Taylor, Betsy. T The City of Buffbuffalo.com/cob The City of Buffparcel-search. Wachadlo, Mart

laware Avenue, Architecture Com

Buffalo's Delawa

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

s of Buffalo, New

ck. "Buffalo Arch

Douglas. The Ga

a, and Lee McAl

The Ivy Grows Ag

falo, "City of Buffbapps/PublicApp

falo, "Real Prope

tin. Oakland Plac

OfficA

highlighted in rempany.

are Avenue: Man

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

w York: Volume F

itecture and His

allery Architects:

ester. A Field G

gain: A History o

falo Property Vieps/default.aspx.

erty Tax Services

ce: Gracious Liv

ce of Parks, RecreAn Equal Opportu

ed, rests at the e

nsions and Fam

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

Five. New York,

tory." Accessed

Edward B. Gree

uide to America

of the Albright Es

ewer." Accessed

s." Accessed No

ving in Buffalo. B

eation and Histounity/Affirmative Ac

edge of the Elmw

milies. Buffalo, NY

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

NY: Sanborn M

November 10, 2

en and Gordon B

n Houses. New

state from 1890

d November 10,

ovember 28, 201

Buffalo, NY: Buffa

ric Preservation ction Agency

wood District in B

Y: Canisius Colle

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

Map Company, 19

2014. http://www

Bunshaft. Buffalo

York, NY: Alfred

to the Present. B

2014. http://gis.c

14. http://www2.e

alo Heritage Unl

Buffalo, New Yor

ege Press, 2013

900.

916.

935.

w.buffaloah.com/

o, NY: Albright-K

d A. Knopf, Inc.,

Buffalo, NY: Nar

city-

erie.gov/ecrpts/i

limited,

rk. Sourced from

3.

/h/alb/index.htm

Knox Art Gallery

1984.

rdin Academy, 1

ndex.php?q=rea

m the

l.

y, 1987.

998.

al-property-

Page 50: inventory Forms

Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency

Western New York Heritage Press, "John J. Albright Estate, West Ferry Street." Accessed November 10, 2014. http://wnyheritagepress.org/photosofweek/albrightestate.htm.