INTRODUCTION TO CYBERNETICAL PHYSICS
description
Transcript of INTRODUCTION TO CYBERNETICAL PHYSICS
1
INTRODUCTION TO INTRODUCTION TO CYBERNETICAL PHYSICS CYBERNETICAL PHYSICS
Alexander FRADKOV, Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering
St.Petersburg, RUSSIA
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
------------------------------------------------------------------------Prague, UTIA, November 1, 2006
2
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
OUTLINE1. Introduction2. Features of the control problems in physical systems3. Results from the “Control of Complex Systems” Lab 3.1. Energy control of conservative systems 3.2. Excitability analysis of dissipative systems 3.3. Examples: Kapitsa pendulum, escape from potential well; 3.4. Control of molecular systems: classical or quantum? 3.4.1. Dissociation of diatomic molecules 3.4.2. Dissociation of triatomic molecules 3.5.Controlled synchronization of two pendulums 3.6 Excitation of oscillations and waves in a chain of oscillators.4. Conclusions
3
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Publications on “Control of chaos” and “Quantum control” in 1990-2004 based on data from Science Citation Index (Web of Science)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004
"Control of Chaos""Quantum Control"
4
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Publications of 1990-2004 in Physical Review A-E, Physical Review Letters with the term “control” in the title
0
50
100
150
200
250
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004
5
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Publications of 2003:“Control AND Chaos” - - - - - - - 462“Control AND Quantum” - - - - 658 Total - 1120========================================================
IEEE Trans. Autom. Control - - - - - - - - 321 IFAC Automatica - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 220 Systems & Control Letters - - - - - - - - - - 107 Intern. Journal of Control - - - - - - - - - - 172 Total - 820 (In Russian – 3 journals, ~350 papers) ****************************************“Control AND Lasers” - 180 “Control AND Thermodynamics” - - - 79“Control AND Beams” - 260 “Control AND Plasma AND Tokamaks”- 102
6
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory «Control of Complex Systems»
- There are two fields of application of controlling friction. Obviously there will be technological applications for reducing vibration and wear. But controlling friction experiments can also be used to increase our understanding of the physics of dry friction. For example, using these methods one can measure the effective friction force as a function of the sliding. ( Elmer F.J. Phys. Rev. E, V.57, 1998, R490-R4906.)
- We have summarized some recently proposed appications of control methods to problems of mixing and coherence in chaotic dynamical systems. This is an important problem both for its own intrinsic interest and also from the point of view of applications. Those methods provide insights also into the origin of mixing and unmixing behavior in natural systems.(Sharma A., Gupte, N. Pramana - J. of Physics, V.48, 1997, 231-248. )
- We develop novel diagnostics tools for plasma turbulence based on feedback. This ... allows qualitative and quantitative inference about the dynamical model of the plasma turbulence. (Sen A.K., Physics of Plasmas, V.7, 2000, 1759-1766.)
- The aim of the researches is twofold:-- to create a particular product that is unattainable by conventional chemical means;-- to achieve a better understanding of atoms and molecules and their interactions. (Rabitz H. et al., Science, 2000, 288, 824-828.)
7
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Cybernetical physics - studying physical systems by cybernetical means
Fields of research:– Control of oscillations – Control of synchronization– Control of chaos, bifurcations, – Control of phase transitions, stochastic resonance– Control of mechanical and micromechanical systems– Optimal control in thermodynamics– Control of plasma, particle beams– Control of molecular and quantum systems
8
John DoyleControl and Dynamical Systems, Caltech
http://www.cds.caltech.edu/~doyle/
AA new physics?
CDC 2001 PLENARY LECTURE:
9
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Connecting physical processes at multiple time and space scales in quantum, statistical, fluid, and solid mechanics, remains not only a central scientific challenge but also one with increasing technological implications.
CDC 2004 PLENARY PANEL DISCUSSION: Challenges and Opportunities for the Future of Control
Moderator: John Doyle Panelists: Jean Carlson, Christos Cassandras, P. R. Kumar,
Naomi Leonard, and Hideo Mabuchi http://control.bu.edu/ieee/cdc04/
10
2. TYPES AND FEATURES OF CONTROL PROBLEMS IN PHYSICAL SYSTEMS
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Type 0: u=const (parameter optimization, bifurcation analysis)Type 1: u=u(t) (program control; u=Asin(ωt) - vibrational control)Type 2: u=u(t,y) - feedback control
Features: 1. Control is small:
lmn RxhyRuRxuxFx )(,,),,(:Plant
,|)(| tu
x – state, u – input (control), y – output (observation).
2. Goal is “soft”
is small.
11
Control goals:– Excitation
– Chaotization/ dechaotization
Extension: partial stabilizationResults: transformation laws ( instead of conservation laws)
– Synchronization
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
12
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
3. RESULTS OBTAINED IN CCS Lab:3.1. Energy control of conservative systems
upqHpqHHqHp
pHq ),(),(,, 10
n,Hamiltonia ninteractio),(system, free of (energy) nHamiltonia),(
pqHpqH
10
u=u(t) - control (forces, fields, parameters). ).()(),( * tHtptqH0Control goal :
Problem: Find control algorithm u=U(q,p), ensuring the control goal for .,)(
pqxx 0
Difficulties: 1. Control is weak: small,|)(| tu 2. Nonlocal solutions are needed
13
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Speed-Gradient (SG) algorithms
Q(x,t)
tx(t),tQt,Ru,RxF(x,u,t), x mn
0(2)if0
10 )(
)(
)(
4):SGA
30):SGA
form) (finite
form) (diff.
Qub
ΓΓ,QΓua
u
Tu
)sign)(,)(0z if0)(
zzΨzzΨzzΨ T
System:
Goal:goal function
where (e.g.
14
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Existing results (Fradkov, 1979, 1985):
15
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Speed-gradient energy control
],[,)()( :Goal * pqxHxHxQ 221
,, *HHHHu 10
HHHQ *
Theorem. 1. Let .)(: when, 010 0 QxQxxHH
Then . allfor )( * 0xHtxH
2. Let 010 HH , in a countable set.
Then either system free of mequilibriu
where,)(or )( *
x
xtxHtxH
Control algorithm:
16
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Extension: Stabilization of invariants
( h(x)=0 - invariant surface of free system)
17
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Theorem (Fradkov, Shiriaev et al, 1997)
.(0) achieved is 0)( goal Then the
|det|: re whebounded, is component connected0 A3.
span re whe,0)(,for dim A2.
,0for 0 )(passivity 0for 0 A1.
.Let .at bounded and continuous be
2 and 1 their andLet
T
T2
T0
ΩxtxQεZ(x)Z(x)xΩD
D : εZ fZ, LZ(x),Z(x),LZ(x), L S(x)
xQΩxlS(x)ΩxZ(x)(x,u)Q
u(x,u)Qg(x)h(x)m, Z(x)l
QQ(x)x:ndsth f, g,
ε
fff
sderivative
18
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
3.2. Excitability analysis of dissipative systems
00
)()(),(, p
pH
pRpRqHp
pHq T
Example. Swinging the damped pendulum
19
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Upper and lower excitability indices:
(5),)(suplim)(
0)0(|)(|
____txV
xut
(6),)(suplim)(
0)0(|)(|
txV
xut
Passivity: :0)(,0 xV(x)
t
dsxuwxVtxV0
T )]([))0(())((
V(x) - storage (energy-like) function, w=w(x) - “passive output”
20
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Theorem. (Fradkov, 2001)
21
20
21
20
||)(||
,||)(||Let
wxw
dwxVwα
dm
2
1
2
1 00 ρ
γ)()( Then
Remark: To prove the left inequality is substituted.
.sign wu
21
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Special case: Euler-Lagrange systems with dissipation )1(,)()()( uqqRqqA
dtd
)()(21 T qqqAq)q(q, H
R - vector of dissipative forcesTotal energy:
Upper and lower excitability indices: ,)(1)(
E
(2)00
,suplim)()(|)(|
____
(t)qq(t),xut
H
(3)00
,suplim)()(|)(|
(t)qq(t),xut
H
__Theorem.
Then00If 2T2 .)(,||)(||,)( dqqqqRqqAi
dm
22
2
)()(
Corollary. .ρ
C)~(E,ρ qρ)q R( then 0 and If
Remark. Locally optimal control is: .qu sign
22
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Excitability of pendular systems: cos1
21, 22
011 HSimple pendulum:
23
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Coupled pendulums [A.Fradkov, B. Andrievsky, K. Boykov. Mechatronics, V.15 (10), 2005 ]
222222122112211 2
cos121cos1
21,,,
kH
24
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Laboratory set-up• Mechanical unit; • Electrical unit (interface init);• Pentium III personal computer
25
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
26
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
3.3. Example 1: Stephenson-Kapitsa pendulum
.cos121
,sinsin
20
2
20
H
u
b) Feedback control:
tAtutAtr sin)(sin)( 2a) Classical Stephenson-Kapitsa pendulum:
.2,)( ** mglHHtH Speed-gradient algorithm:
.~,/~)(lim)(,)(
)(sin)()(sign)(
*
**
HtHtHtH
ttHtHtu
t
2000
27
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
28
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Example 2: Control of escape from a potential wellNonlinear oscillator: u )( Duffing potential:
42)(
42
Problem: find conditions for escape from a potential well by means of excitation of minimum intensity min,|)(| uutu A) Harmonic excitation:
21.025.0.sin)( min ututu (H.B. Stewart, J.M.T. Tompson, U. Ueda, A.N. Lansburg, Physica D, v. 85, 1995, pp. 259-295.)
B) Speed-gradient excitation: Theory:
Experiment:
sign)( utu 1767.025.0,25.0,2 min** uHHu
122.0min u
29
Simulation results
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
30
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
31
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Efficiency of feedback
32
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory «Control of Complex Systems»
3.4. Control of molecular systems - femtotechnologies
33
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
3.4.1. Controlled dissociation of 2-atomic moleculesClassical Morse oscillator:
20
21
2
)()(),()()(),( qqeDqVtEqqV
mppqH
Quantum Morse oscillator:
.)(,)()()(2 2
2
qdqtEqqVqm
H
** ,)(),( :Goal HHtptqH dissociation energyExample: hydrogen fluoride (HF)
a.u...,. 2501256787600
eVDaDd
2
2
01
017411em
aa.γe
, a.u. of length
34
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
M.Goggin, P.Milonni (LANL). Phys.Rev.A 38 (10), 5174 (1988).
),cos()cos()( d) c,
,,.
)cos()( b)a,
tEtEtE
mD
tEtE
L
L
2211
00
029790
a,c) - classical model; b,d) - quantum model
35
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Control of HF molecules dissociation - classical dynamics
)sin()( 200 ttEtE )(sign)( tpEtE 0
Linear chirping: Speed-gradient:
36
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Control of HF molecules dissociation - quantum dynamics
)sin()( 200 ttEtE )(sign)( tpEtE 0
Linear chirping: Speed-gradient:
37
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
(Ananjevskij M., Fradkov A.,Efimov A., Krivtsov A., PhysCon’03)
38
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
39
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory «Control of Complex Systems»
3.4.2. Controlled dissociation of 3-atomic molecule Aux.problem: Controlled Energy Exchange
– cooling of molecules; - selective dissociation;– localization of modes; - passage through resonance
)(1221
q,p,uHHHHHH
ion)stabilizat partial ed(constrain :goal Control 2211 )()( ** HtH,HtH
0)( )(min
2
1 :tionGeneralizau,xQ
u,x Q
)(- 21 :algorithm-SG QQu
40
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Controlled dissociation of 3-atomic moleculeFull Hamiltonian of molecule in external field:
Molecular Hamiltonian (Rabitz, 1995; Fujimura, 2000) :
R1, R2 - displacements of bond length; P1, P2 - conjugate momenta; E(t) - controlling field.
Speed-gradient control algorithm:
Control goal:
)(),( 21 tERRdHH mol
),()()( 122 2112221121
2
22
1
21 RRVRVRVPP
cMmp
mpHmol
)(2
,)( 111
21
1*1 RVmpHwhereHtH
)(sign)( 1 tPtu
41
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
42
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
43
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
3.5. Control of chaos by linearization of Poincare map ‘
44
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Method of Ott-Grebogi-Yorke (OGY):
The problem is reduced to a standard linear control problem.
Challenge:How much time and energy is needed for control?
01
whenoff switched is Control 2.Sxk
45
3.5. CONTROLLED SYNCHRONIZATION
)()(sin)()(
),()(sin)()(
221222
022
112112
011
tftukttt
tftukttt
3.5.1. Model of coupled pendulums
- )(ti (i = 1, 2) deflection angles;
- ui(t) (i = 1, 2) controlling torques;
- 21 , ff disturbances;
- k coupling strength (stiffness of the spring).
Andrievsky B.R.,Fradkov A.L. Feedback resonance in single and coupled 1-DOF oscillators // Intern. J of Bifurcation and Chaos, 1999, N 10, pp.2047-2058.
46
222222122112211 2
cos121cos1
21,,,
kH
3.5.2 Design of synchronization algorithm
Goal function: )()1()()( xQxQxQ H
weight102121where
2
221
,)()(
,)(
*HxHxQ
xQ
H
10 gain,0,,
form relay)()()1()()(
form lproportina)()()1()()(
*21
1
1
HH
tttsigntu
ttttu
H
H
H
47
222222122112211 2
cos121cos1
21,,,
kH
Total system energy:
.],,,[,)(21)(
}1,1{,21
21),(
T2211
2*
221
221
xHxHxQ
Q
H
)()1()()( xQxQxQ H
48
3.5.3 Synchronization algorithms:
10 gain,0,,
form relay)()()1()()(
form lproportina)()()1()()(
*21
1
1
HH
tttsigntu
ttttu
H
H
H
49
motion antiphase - 1, 21
2
1
2
22
200.7,
, 1 , 5.0 ,10
sH
s
sk
s
*
3.5.4 Simulation results
50
)0.1( loss with system , 1, 121
-s
51
motion inphase - 1, 21
52
0.1)( loss with system , 1, 21
53
3.6. EXCITATION OF OSCILLATIONS AND WAVE IN THE CHAIN OF OSCILLATORS
3.6.1. Model of chain dynamics
54
Control goal:
SG-control laws:(1)(2)
Total energy:
55
Control law (2), ω=1.26, k=2, H*=18.75, N=2502. γ=0.5, α=0.7 (energy control and synchronization)
3.6.2. Simulation results
56
Space-time Diagram
57
Excitation of oscillations
58
3.6.3. Control of cyclic chain
59
Antiphase oscillations wave
60
Energy and control time histories
61
3.6.4. Control of the chain of oscillatorswith incomplete measurementsNonlinear Luenberger observer
62
Simulation results
63
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
4. Conclusions
Cybernetical physics - studying physical systems by cybernetical means
Fields of research:– Control of oscillations – Control of synchronization– Control of chaos, bifurcations– Control of phase transitions, stochastic resonance– Optimal control in thermodynamics– Control of micromechanical, molecular and quantum systems
64
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
Publications: •Fradkov A.L. Exploring nonlinearity by feedback. Physica D, 128(1999), pp. 159-168.•Fradkov A.L. Investigation of physical systems by means of feedback. Automation & Remote Control, 1999, N 3. •Фрадков А.Л. Кибернетическая физика. СПб:Наука, 2003.•Fradkov A.L. Application of cybernetical methods in physics. Physics-Uspekhi, Vol. 48 (2), 2005, 103-127.• Fradkov A.L. Cybernetical Physics: From Control of Chaos to Quantum Control, Springer-Verlag, 2006.
65
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
66
Institute for Problems of Mechanical Engineering of RASLaboratory “Control of Complex Systems”
More info at: http://physcon.ru/
1st International Conference 1st International Conference PHYSICS and CONTROL PHYSICS and CONTROL (PhysCon 2003) (PhysCon 2003)
20–22 Aug. 2003, Saint Petersburg, RUSSIA2nd International Conference 2nd International Conference
PHYSICS and CONTROLPHYSICS and CONTROL (PhysCon 2005) (PhysCon 2005)24–26 Aug. 2005, Saint Petersburg, RUSSIA(200-250 participants, 30-33 countries)