INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors...

30
INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides provide a glimpse at new developments in the Spokane/Inland Northwest region, including the addition of Stevens and Pend Oreille counties to the Spokane MSA. This presentation contains population estimates through July 1, 2013, since the 2014 numbers had not be released at the time of the presentation. Those slides will be updated with 2014 estimates when new data is released by the Census Bureau. No significant variation in trends is expected in the new data. Most of these slides are self-explanatory, but if you have questions or wish permission to quote proprietary portions of the presentation, please contact us at [email protected] , or contact the cited original sources. Also, we have in-depth reports on some of the topics raised these slides for purchase in our online store. Thanks for your interest in spokanomics.com. We hope you’ll visit the site often. Shaun O’L. Higgins Managing Principal THEOXALISGROUPLLC

Transcript of INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors...

Page 1: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

INTRODUCTION

The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides provide a glimpse at new developments in the Spokane/Inland Northwest region, including the addition of Stevens and Pend Oreille counties to the Spokane MSA. This presentation contains population estimates through July 1, 2013, since the 2014 numbers had not be released at the time of the presentation. Those slides will be updated with 2014 estimates when new data is released by the Census Bureau. No significant variation in trends is expected in the new data. Most of these slides are self-explanatory, but if you have questions or wish permission to quote proprietary portions of the presentation, please contact us at [email protected], or contact the cited original sources. Also, we have in-depth reports on some of the topics raised these slides for purchase in our online store. Thanks for your interest in spokanomics.com. We hope you’ll visit the site often. Shaun O’L. HigginsManaging PrincipalTHEOXALISGROUPLLC905 W. Riverside Avenue, Suite 212Spokane, WA 99201

Scroll Down to View Slides

Page 2: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Ready for New Heights

The INW Regional Economy: Midyear 2014 and Beyond

Remarks of SHAUN O’L. HIGGINS

THEOXALISGROUPLLC

© 2014 The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 3: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Caveats and Disclaimers• I’m an economic handicapper and amateur economist. I don’t do theory.

• We don’t want to be self-fulfilling prophets of doom, so we tend to be positive. Please listen for “qualifying phrases.”

• Views expressed are my own and may change tomorrow.

• My views may not reflect those of COGO or Secured Financial.

• The accuracy or inaccuracy of any previous forecast doesn’t mean a thing.

• My data, though reliably sourced, is subject to varying interpretations.

• Metrics that were once relevant may no longer matter; metrics that are relevant today may not be relevant in the future.

• Nothing in this presentation should be construed as investment advice or as an endorsement of any investment advisory service.

• The presentation will last about 35 minutes, with brief Q&A to follow.© 2014 The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 4: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

What You Will Hear A Context for Understanding Regional Economics

*Demographic Status and Projections:

MSAsRegional GDP

Population and IncomeHome-value and other Real Estate Information

*Job-Creation Performance and Employment Factors

*Why things are looking up – and why you should be, too

Page 5: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Grant Forsyth, Chief Economist, Avista Corp,Governor’s Economic Forecast Advisory Group

Dr. Patrick Jones, Eastern Washington University,Spokane Community Indicators

Kootenai County Community IndicatorsChair, Spokane Mayor’s Advisory Council on Economic Vitality

Steve Scranton, Washington Trust Bank

Doug Tweedy, Washington State Employment Security, Labor Market & Economic Analysis Branch

Job Growth Update , W. P. Carey School of Business, Arizona State University

Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Department of Commerce

Sources and Acknowledgments

Page 6: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Sources and AcknowledgmentsThe Spokane Journal of Business

The Spokesman-Review

The Pacific Northwest Inlander

U.S. Census Bureau

Spokane Board of Realtors

Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA)

Ann Glendening

The Economist

Bloomberg Business Week

The Wall Street Journal

The New York Times

Page 7: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

The Inland Northwest

Page 8: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Inland Northwest Basics 1,063,272 people (0.34% of U.S. Population) 39,240.9 Square Miles 23 Counties in Three States $18.1 Billion in HH Income 90,419 Business Firms $13.6 Billion in Retail Sales $24.4 Billion in GDP (about 0.17% of U.S. GDP)

Sources: 2010 U.S. Census; Bureau of Economic Analysis-U.S. Department of Commerce, 2012 (covering 2010 GDP trends by Metro area; compilations, derivatives and comparatives by Shaun O’L. Higgins

© 2014 The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 9: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Metropolitan and Micropolitan Statistical Areas

Metro and Micro areas are geographic entities delineated by the Office of Management and Budget for use by Federal statistical agencies in collecting, tabulating, and publishing Federal statistics.

The term "Core-Based Statistical Area" (CBSA) is a collective term for both metro and micro areas.

A metro area contains a core urban area of 50,000 or more population, and a micro area contains an urban core of at least 10,000 (but less than 50,000) population.

Each metro or micro area consists of one or more counties and includes the counties containing the core urban area, as well as any adjacent counties that have a high degree of social and economic integration (as measured by commuting to work) with the urban core.

Source: U.S. Office of Management and Budget

Page 10: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Inland Northwest Metro/Micro Areas

Combined Statistical AreaSpokane-Spokane Valley-Stevens-Pend Oreille, WA MSA,

plus Coeur d’Alene, ID MSA

MSAsSpokane-Spokane Valley-Stevens-Pend Oreille, WA

Coeur d’Alene, ID Lewiston-Clarkston ID-WA

Micropolitan Statistical AreasMoses Lake WA

Moscow IDPullman WASandpoint ID

© 2014 The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 11: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

T

The New Spokane MSA

• Three Counties (Spokane, Stevens, Pend Oreille)• 5,641.75 square miles in area

• 535,724 people

(To imagine what 535,724 people looks like, think of 15-16 Martin Stadiums filled to overflowing)

We now have an international border,and. . .

© 2014 The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 12: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

We’re Larger than Connecticut!

Page 13: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

What it Means

The new designation moves us into the Top 100 U.S. metro areas, making us more visible on the maps of business locators and retailers, and it better positions us to grow jobs, receive grants, and participate more fully in some federal programs.

Another change makes us even bigger. . .

Page 14: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

We’re also part of a CSA(Combined Statistical Area)

Our new Combined Statistical Area includes Kootenai County

• Total estimated population of about 680,000. (Equal to about 58 Spokane Veteran’s Arenas

packed to capacity for a basketball games!)

• 71st largest Combined Metro Area in the U.S.

• 6,685.68 square miles in area, making us . . .

Page 15: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Almost as big as New Jersey

Page 16: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

The Spo-Koo CSA Has More People than…

Page 17: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

. . . more people than. . .

Page 18: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

. . .more people than. . .

Page 19: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

POPULATION ESTIMATESApril 1, 2010-July 1, 2013

Area 2010 2013 est Change

U.S. 308,747,716 316,128,839 2.4 %Idaho 1,562,652 1,612,136 2.8 %Montana 989,417 1,015,165 2.6 %Washington 6,724,543 6,971,506 3.7 %Lewiston-Clarkston MSA 60,888 62,125 2.0 %Coeur d’Alene MSA 138,494 144,265 4.7 %Spokane MSA (old definition) 471,221 479,398 1.7 %Spokane MSA (new definition) 527,648 535,724 1.5 %

Census Bureau will release new estimates soon; no surprises expected

Source: US Census Bureau, 2014 . Latest series available. Regional derivations by SOH

Page 20: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Population Growth Rates 2010-2013GSI Comparative MSAs

Raleigh-Cary NC 7.4%Boise ID 5.5%Colorado Springs CO 5.1%Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue WA 5.0% Salt Lake City UT 4.8%Madison WI 3.6%Reno-Sparks NV 2.9%Albuquerque NM 1.8%Tucson AZ 1.7%Spokane WA 1.5%Mobile AL 0.3%

Source: US Census Bureau, 2014 . Latest series available. Derivations by SOH

Page 21: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Real GDP by Metro Area, 2010-2012MSA Change 09-10 10-11 11-12 Current /Rank

Spokane-Spokane Valley 1.0% 1.5% 1.7% $17.4 billion (178)Coeur d’Alene -0.8% 0.0% -2.4% $ 3.7 billion (373)Lewiston 0.8% -1.0% -0.3% $ 1.7 billion (317)

All U.S. Metros 2.4% 1.7% 2.5% $12,207 billion

INW Regional estimate (including non-Metro): $24.4 billion (or, about 0.17% of U.S. total)

Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Dept. of Commerce; regional estimate, The Oxalis Group LLC

Page 22: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Regional Job-Creation Performance SnapshotMay 2013 to May 2014

Non-Agricultural Wage and Salary Jobs

Area Rank ‘13 Rank ’14 Change Thousands of Jobs (Growth Rate) Job Growth 2013 2014

Spokane 132 280 0.2% 1,400 216,300 216,800C d’Alene 5 145 1.6% 900 57,100 58,000Lewiston 15 269 0.4% 100 26.900 27,000U.S. NA NA 1.8% 2,399,000 136,793,000 139,192,000

From May Peaks to May 2014United States: 138,611,000 (May 2007): Now UP 581,000 jobs, or 0.42%

Spokane: 224,400 (May 2008): Still DOWN 7,600 jobs, or -3.39%

Coeur d’Alene: 58,700 (May, 2008): Still DOWN 700 jobs, or -1.19%

Lewiston: 28,000 (May 2007): Still DOWN 1,000 jobs, or -3.57%

Data Source: Job-Growth Update, W. P. Carey School of Business, Arizona State University, June 2014 .Regional compilation and derivation : Shaun O’L. Higgins The Oxalis Group LLC, June 2014.

Page 23: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

GSI Comparative CitiesJobs Snapshot: May Peak to May 2014

MARKET May 2014 2007/08 Difference % Change Raleigh-Cary NC 559,300 525,800 33,500 6.37%Salt Lake City UT 674,900 640,100 34,800 5.44%Madison WI 364,500 353,100 11,400 3.23%Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue WA 1,825,100 1,785,400 39,700 2.22%Boise-Nampa ID 281,000 279,300 1,700 0.61%Colorado Springs CO 259,700 262,100 ( 2,400) - 0.92%Tucson AZ 366,600 386,100 (19,500) - 5.05%Mobile AL 174,300 186,000 (11,700) - 6.29%Albuquerque NM 370,300 398,000 27,700) - 6.96%Reno-Sparks NV 202,900 224,600 (21,700) - 9.66%

10-Market Total 5,078,600 5,040,500 38,100 0.76%

SPOKANE 216,800 224,400 ( 7,600) -3.39%

U.S. 139,192,000 138,611,000 581,000 0.42%

© 2014The Oxalis Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Page 24: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME Five-Year Average, 2008-2012

Selected Geographies

Geography MHI

U.S $53,046 Idaho $47,015 Washington $59,374 INW Region $46,185

Spokane County $49,615 Spokane MSA (new) $48,729 Nez Perce ID $45,567 Asotin WA $42,345 Kootenai ID $48,075 Grant WA $45,531

Bonner ID $41,379 Latah ID $39,466 Whitman WA $34,169

Source: U.S. Bureau of the Census. Latest data, March 2014. (www.census.gov)

Page 25: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Housing Price CaveatWhen using the FHFA House Price Calculator, please note that it does not project the actual value of any particular house. Rather, it projects what a given house purchased at a point in time would be worth today if it appreciated at the average appreciation rate of all homes in the area. The actual value of any house will depend on the local real estate market, house condition and age, home improvements made and needed, and many other factors. Consult a qualified real estate appraiser in your area to obtain a professional estimate of the current value of your home.

Source: FHFA

Page 26: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

The Housing PictureHousing prices have held up better in some places than others

over the past five years.

If you bought a home for $100,000 in the 1st quarter of 2009……it’s likely value today looks like this:

Coeur d’Alene: $84,798 Spokane: $85,068 Lewiston: $98,796

Tri-Cities: $105,102

If you bought in the 1st quarter of 2004, it looks like this:

Lewiston: $152,050 Coeur d’Alene: $133,158 Spokane: $129,262

Tri-Cities: $123,426 Source: FHFA Home Price Calculator, June 2014. Comparatives copyright 2014, Oxalis Group LLC.

Page 27: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

More on Real Estate

Housing Sales and Price ProjectionsSpokane County: Annualized single-unit sales, FLAT to UP 0.5-1.0%, compared

to 2013. Median prices likely to be FLAT to UP 1.0-1.5%, compared to 2014. Low mortgage

rates and eased lending policies have spurred first-time home-buying a bit. May and June 2014 improved the trend for both unit sales and prices, following a

slow start to the year. Kootenai County: Strong market in first six months. Annualized single-unit sales, UP

6.5-7.5%, compared to 2013. 2014 median prices likely to be UP 8.0-9.2%, compared to 2013.

Apartment Vacancy Rates and Rents Spokane County (countywide): 55th tightest market of 275 markets ranked by REIS. Current vacancy rate about 4.9%. Market ranks 143rd (REIS) in rent-growth, about 0.4%. New construction and affordability issues have put governors on rent growth, but demand remains strong and points to continuing, but slow, growth in rent.

Kootenai County: Vacancy rates likely to rise bit, putting pressure on rental growth, both due, in part, to expansion of apartment projects in 2013.

Oxalis Group LLC projections. Copyright 2014, The Oxalis Group LLC

Page 28: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Commercial Real EstateRETAIL SPACE

In 2013, both Spokane and Kootenai counties, vacancy rates fell (dramatically in Kootenai County). Rents held steady.

For 2014, the picture is largely the same, with some nuances:*

At the end of May 2014, Spokane ranked 40th in the nation in retail vacancy rate among 190 markets measured by REIS, which reported a rate of 9.8%. The market ranked only 172, however, on rent growth, at -0.4%.

Kootenai County is not ranked by REIS, but various reports from there by leading commercial agents, indicate that retail-sector rents have stabilized in the $10-$11 range, with vacancy rates expected to hold steady or fall a bit at the 4-5% range in Hayden , the 6-7% range in Coeur d’Alene, and to hold or fall slightly from a rate of about 17% in Post Falls.

Oxalis Group LLC analysis based on private discussions and/or published reports from reis.com, NAI Black, Kiemle & Hagood, Valbridge Property Advisors, Spokane Board of Realtors, and others.

Page 29: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

Office SpaceSPOKANE(county wide)

Current vacancy rate of about 12.8%, but varies greatly based on cities and areas within cities (down from about 18% in 2010).

REIS rank 27. Rent-growth essentially flat at 0.3%.

Forecast: Slow but steady progress on both rents and vacancy in2014, but still a tenant market in most areas.

KOOTENAI (county wide)

Rents flat and vacancy rate steady.Forecast: Same as Spokane: steady progress.

Both markets anticipating growth improved rents and vacancies in 2015, with 2014 holding at 2013 levels.

Oxalis Group LLC analysis based on private discussions and/or published reports from reis.com, NAI Black, Kiemle & Hagood, Valbridge Property Advisors, Spokane Board of Realtors, and others.

Page 30: INTRODUCTION The following slide are from an early July 2014 presentation in Spokane to investors and clients of a private-lending company. The slides.

THANK YOU!

THEOXALISGROUPLLCDecision-making data for business,

communities and non-profits

***Comments, questions or permissions? Email: [email protected]

Copyright 2014. The Oxalis Group LLC