Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split...
Transcript of Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split...
![Page 1: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
COSTissupportedbythe
EUFrameworkProgrammeHorizon2020
COSTAc(onTU1208
“CivilEngineeringApplica(onsofGroundPenetra(ngRadar”
Introduc(ontoelectromagne(cmodellingofGPR&
overviewonavailablecommercialandfreesoHwaretools
LaraPajewski
SapienzaUniversity,Rome,Italy
![Page 2: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Whatdowemodel?
§ Knowing the iniAal and boundary condiAons (properAes of theelectromagneAc source; geometrical and physical features of the
scenario), the goal is to find a soluAon to the GPR forwardsca-ering problemand calculate the electromagneAc field in any
pointofthespaceandinanyAmeinstant.
![Page 3: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Why?
§ ToimproveourunderstandingofGPR
GPR radargrams oMen have no resemblance to the subsurface or
structures over which the profile was recorded. Various factors,
including the innate design of the survey equipment and the
complexityofelectromagneAcpropagaAonintheground/structure,
candisguisecomplexstructuresrecordedonGPRreflecAonprofiles.
An EM simulator canhelpus to understandhow target structures
gettranslatedintoGPRradargrams.ItcanalsoshowthelimitaAons
of GPR, highlight its capabiliAes and help us to understandwhere
andinwhatenvironmentsthistechniquecanbeeffecAvelyused.
![Page 4: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
§ TochoosethemostproperGPRequipmentforasurvey.
§ To aid the interpreta(on of complex data sets and find out
unknowndetailsabouttheinvesAgatedstructure/subsurface.
§ To test new data-processing/imaging algorithms or assess the
effecAvenessofexisAngones.
§ Todesignandop(misenewGPRantennas.
§ AforwardEMsolvercanbeusedaspartofaninverseEMsolver
(automaAcinterpretaAonofGPRdata).
EMModellingforGPR–Why?
![Page 5: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Geometry SyntheAcRadargram
EMModellingforGPR–Why?
This is a simple scenario, the main purpose of an electromagneAc
simulatorisnottosolvesuchasimpleproblem…
![Page 6: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
FielddistribuAonasafuncAonofAme
EMModellingforGPR–Why?
…butsAll,thismovieeffecAvely
showshowtheelectromagneAc
simulatorcanhelpustovisualize
andunderstandthe
electromagneAcphenomena
takingplaceinaGPRscenario.
![Page 7: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Howcanwedoit?
§ By solving theMaxwell’s equa(ons governing the propagaAon
and scaZering of electromagneAc waves, subject to iniAal and
boundarycondiAons.
WalloftheWarsawUniversityLibrary
![Page 8: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
Faraday’sLawofinduc(on
Ampere-MaxwellLaw
describeshowaAmevaryingmagneAcfieldcreatesanelectricfield
statesthatmagneAcfieldscanbegeneratedintwoways:byan
electricalcurrent(theoriginal"Ampère'slaw")andbychanging
electricfields("Maxwell'saddiAon”)
![Page 9: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
Gauss’ElectricandMagne(cLaws
Con(nuityofElectricCharge(notpartofMaxwell’sequaAons)
describestherelaAonship
betweentheelectricfieldand
theelectricchargesthatcauseit
statesthatthereareno
"magneAccharges”
anempiricallawexpressing(local)charge
conservaAon;mathemaAcallyitisanautomaAc
consequenceofMaxwell’seqs.;itstatesthatthe
divergenceofthecurrentdensityJisequaltothe
negaAverateofchangeofthechargedensityρ
![Page 10: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
Integralequa(ons
![Page 11: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
ByusingStoke’sanddivergencetheorems…
…wegetthedifferen(alequa(ons
![Page 12: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Differen(alEqua(ons
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
ThesearefirstorderparAaldifferenAalequaAonswhichexpresstherelaAonsbetweenthe
fundamentalelectromagneAcfieldquanAAesandtheirdependenceontheirsources.
![Page 13: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Maxwell’sEqua(ons
§ In Maxwell’s equaAons, the field vectors are assumed to be
single-valued, bounded, conAnuous funcAons of posiAon and
Ame.
§ InordertosimulatetheGPRresponsefromaparAculartargetor
set of targets, the integral or differenAal Maxwell’s equaAons
have tobe solved subject to the geometryof theproblemand
theiniAalcondiAons.
![Page 14: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–Cons(tu(veRela(ons
§ ForsimplecaseswheretheelectricalproperAescanbeassumed
to be frequency independent, the convoluAons reduce to
mulAplicaAons. For isotropic media, the tensors reduce to
scalars.Inthesecases,computaAonsaresimplified.
![Page 15: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–
HowcanwesolveMaxwell’sequa(ons?
§ Analy(callywithgreatbraineffortandonlyforsimplescenarios!
Lotsofbrainpower Li-lecompu9ngpower
§ Numerically with less brain effort
andformorecomplexandrealisAc
scenarios!
Lotsofcompu9ngpower Li-lebrainpower
Integral /Differential Formulations Frequency /Time Domain
![Page 16: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–
HowcanwesolveMaxwell’sequa(ons?
§ HigheraccuracyàlongerAme&highermemoryrequirements.
§ AnalyAcal-numerical techniques contemplaAng a relaAvely
simplemathemaAcalformulaAonandamostlynumericalnature
areeasytoimplementandversaAle.
§ To develop and implement full-wave formulaAons with higher
analyAcal complexity, a deeper physical insight into the
considered problem is needed. Usually, these approaches are
lessversaAleand,whenapplicable,theyarefastandefficient.
Computa(onalissues
Accuracy Execu(on(meMemory
requirements
![Page 17: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–
Whatisthebestcomputa(onalmethod?
§ MethodofMoments(MoM)
§ BoundaryElementMethod(BEM)
§ FiniteElementMethod(FEM)
§ FiniteDifferenceFrequencyDomain(FDFD)
§ ParAalElementEquivalentCircuit
(PEEC)
§ FiniteIntegraAonTechnique(FIT)§ AsymptoAcMethods(GTD/UTD/
PO)
§ FiniteDifferenceTimeDomain
(FDTD)
§ TransmissionLineMatrixMethod
(TLM)
§ FiniteElementTimeDomain
(FETD)
§ FiniteVolumeTimeDomain
(FVTD)
§ GeneralizedMulApoleTechnique
(GMT)
§ Time-DomainMethodof
Moments(TDMoM)
§ CylindricalandSphericalWave
Approach(CWAandSWA)
§ OtherMethods
![Page 18: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
EMModellingforGPR–CommercialsoHware
§ AnsoMHFSS§ CSTMicrowaveStudio
§ COMSOLMulAphysics
§ XFDTD§ …
Agoodlistisat
www.cvel.clemson.edu/modeling/EMAG/csoM.html
![Page 19: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Agoodlistisat
hZp://www.cvel.clemson.edu/modeling/EMAG/free-codes.html
• NEC2 - theNumericalElectromagneAcsModeling (NEC)codeis a widely used 3D simulator based on the method ofmoments. Itwas developed at Lawrence LivermoreNaAonalLaboratory more than 10 years ago and has been compiledand run onmany different computer systems. It uses a textinterface. There a several free or inexpensive graphicalinterfacesthatdopre-andpost-processingofNEC2models.Agoodfreeinterfaceis4nec2.
• Thereisa2DFDTDsolverincludedinmatGPR(freewaretoolforGPRdataprocessing)
EMModellingforGPR–Freewaretools
![Page 20: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
• MEEP–aFDTDsimulaAonsoMwarepackagedevelopedatMIT.Itsupports 1D/2D/3D/cylindrical problems, distributed-memoryparallelism,anddispersiveandnonlinearmedia.PMLboundariesareimplemented.ThesoMwareiscompletelyscriptableviabothC++andScheme(GNUGuile)interfaces.
• GprMax – a FDTD solver, for 2D (TMz)/3D numericalmodelling.The first version was developed by Prof. Antonis Giannopoulos(The University of Edinburgh, UK) in 1996. In the past 3 years,gprMaxhasbeensignificantly improvedby theresearch teamofTheUniversity of Edinburgh and as a contribuAon to the AcAonTU1208. E2GPR is a free graphical interface developed by aresearchteamofSapienza/RomaTreUniversity,IT,todopre-andpost-processingofgprMaxmodels.
EMModellingforGPR–Freewaretools
www.gprmax.com
www.GPRadar.eu
![Page 21: Introduc(on to electromagne(c modelling of GPR & overview ...gpradar.eu/onewebmedia/TU1208 TS Split - Pajewski - Intro to EM... · § Finite Element Time Domain ... § COMSOL MulAphysics](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051720/5a78e1247f8b9a21538eb1dc/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
COSTissupportedbythe
EUFrameworkProgrammeHorizon2020
Thank you!
Join COST Action TU1208!
www.GPRadar.eu [email protected]