Innovations in Chronic Pain Management · Innovations in Chronic Pain Management Mark P. Jensen,...
Transcript of Innovations in Chronic Pain Management · Innovations in Chronic Pain Management Mark P. Jensen,...
1
Innovations in ChronicPain Management
Mark P. Jensen, Ph.D.University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
Wednesday, April 20, 2016ASCH Webinar
Disclosure
- Author of two books on the topic of this workshop,
- Receive royalties from the sales of those books
2
- Provide a neurophysiological model that can be used to guide hypnosis assessment and treatment,
- Model two specific strategies
- Questions and discussion
Webinar Goals and Overview
Facilitate a shift from this…
My pain is
horrible manage-able
3
To this…
My pain is
horrible manage-able
And to this…
Sensations are
horrible safe
4
And from this…
My life is
horrible meaning-full
To this…
My life is
horrible meaning-full
5
Sensations are
horrible safe
My life is
horrible meaning-full
BIS and BAS
BIS BAS
6
BIS and BAS
BIS BAS
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
BIS and BAS
BIS BAS
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
7
BIS and BAS
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠
Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
BIS and BAS
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
8
BIS and BAS
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)
BIS and BAS
PainPerception
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(+)
(-)
9
BIS and BAS
PainPerception
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
Key features
Automaticity
10
Key features
Automaticity∆ via associative learning, not logic
Automaticity
BIS and BAS reponses are automatic – you cannot easily stop them.
11
Example 1
Example 1
VOMIT
12
Example 1
We all had emotional, behavioral, and cognitive responses….
Example 1
We all had emotional, behavioral, and cognitive responses….
That were automatic
13
Which system?
BIS BAS
Which system?
BIS
Emotion and affect
14
Which system?
BIS
Emotion and affect
Behavior
Which system?
BISCognitive Content
Emotion and affect
Behavior
15
Example 2
Example 2
Read the following
16
Example 2
Read the following
Example 2
Now read the following
17
Example 2
Example 2
18
Example 2
Context (cues) influence our responses
Example 2
Context (cues) influence the response
Their influence is automatic
19
Example 3
Example 3
What is the color of fresh fallen snow?
20
Example 3
What is the color of fluffy (not rain) clouds?
Example 3
What is the color of a fresh sheet of standard Xerox paper?
21
Example 3
What do cows drink?
Example 3
Context (cues) influence our responses
22
Example 3
Context (cues) influence our responses
Their influence is automatic
Example 4
How many of each species …?
23
Example 4
How many of each species …did Moses put on the ark?
Example 4
How many of each species …did Moses put on the ark?
24
Example 4
Context (cues) influence our responses
Example 4
Context (cues) influence our responses
Their influence is automatic
25
The characteristics of automaticity and mutual activation among networks may explain the effects of “seeding”
Example 5Bargh, J.A., Chen, M., & Burros, L. (1996). Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of
trait construct and sterotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71, 230-244.
26
Example 5Bargh, J.A., Chen, M., & Burros, L. (1996). Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of
trait construct and sterotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71, 230-244.
Group 1: Make 4-word sentences from 30 short word lists, like…
ball the throw toss silentlyfrom are Florida oranges temperaturehe observes occasionally people watchessky the seamless grey isate she it selfishly allus bingo sing play let
Example 5Bargh, J.A., Chen, M., & Burros, L. (1996). Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of
trait construct and sterotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71, 230-244.
Group 1: Make 4-word sentences from 30 short word lists, like…
ball the throw toss silently (e.g., Throw the ball silently)from are Florida oranges temperaturehe observes occasionally people watchessky the seamless grey isate she it selfishly allus bingo sing play let
27
Example 5Bargh, J.A., Chen, M., & Burros, L. (1996). Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of
trait construct and sterotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71, 230-244.
Group 2: A different list, such as …
flew eagle the plane aroundthe push wash frequently clothesthey obedient him often meetsend I will mail it you flowers the enjoy viewcat ran dog fast the
Example 5Bargh, J.A., Chen, M., & Burros, L. (1996). Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of
trait construct and sterotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71, 230-244.
Outcome variable:The time it took participants to walk down a hallway after the conclusion of the experiment
28
Example 5
Example 5
Group 1 list
ball the throw toss silentlyfrom are Florida oranges temperaturehe observes occasionally people watchessky the seamless grey isate she it selfishly allus bingo sing play let
29
Example 5
Group 1 list
ball the throw toss silentlyfrom are Florida oranges temperaturehe observes occasionally people watchessky the seamless grey isate she it selfishly allus bingo sing play let
The characteristics of automaticity and mutual activation among networks may also explain the very large impact of HYP-CT on pain intensity
30
BIS and BAS
PainPerception
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
BIS and BAS
PainPerception
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
31
Hypnosis enhances efficacy of CBT
Kirsch, Montgomery, & Sapirstein, 1995- Meta-analysis of 18 studies comparing CBT
vs. CBT supplemented by hypnosis- Pain, insomnia, hypertension, obesity,
phobia/anxiety, duodenal ulcer- Adding hypnosis substantially enhanced
treatment outcome; CBT+HYP > 70% receiving CBT alone. Perhaps adding hypnosis to CT will might
enhance ability benefits of CT?
Hypnosis enhances CT
32
Average Pain Intensity
Pre Post
.04
.23
.56
.97
*
*
*
Hypnosis enhances CT
Pain Interference
Pre Post
-.03
.11
.16
.46
*
Hypnosis enhances CT
33
Catastrophizing
Pre PostPost
.19
.27
.45
.61
*
Hypnosis enhances CT
What’s wrong w/ HYP Pain reduction?
34
What’s wrong w/ HYP Pain reduction?
It focuses on….
What’s wrong with pain-focused HYP?
It focuses on….pain
35
What’s wrong with pain-focused HYP?
It focuses on….pain
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
What’s wrong with pain-focused HYP?
It focuses on….pain
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
36
What’s wrong with pain-focused HYP?
It focuses on….pain
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
What’s wrong with pain-focused HYP?
It focuses on….pain
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
37
Which system does “pain” activate?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
Pain
Which system does “pain” activate?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
Pain
38
Which system does “pain” activate?Which system does “pain” inhibit?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
Pain
Which system does “pain” activate?Which system does “pain” inhibit?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
Pain
39
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….Life
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
40
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….Life
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….Life
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
41
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….Life
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
What’s right with HYP-CT?
It focuses on….Life
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
42
Which system does “joy” activate?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(+)
(-)
Joy
Which system does “joy” activate?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(+)
(-)
Joy
43
Which system does “pain” activate?Which system does “joy” inhibit?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(+)(-)
(-)
Joy
Which system does “pain” activate?Which system does “joy” inhibit?
BIS BASCognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(+)(-)
(-)
Joy
44
A treatment that does this…
Images courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Results in this
Pain
BIS
BAS
Cognitive Content (e.g., Pain = Danger, Anticipate punishment)
Cognitive Content (e.g., Hurt ≠ Harm, Anticipate reward)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Anxiety)
Emotion and affect (e.g., Excitement)
Behavior (e.g., Withdraw, “Stop, look, & Listen”)
Behavior (e.g., Approach, Goal-Directed)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Rumination, Hypervigilance)
Cognitive processes (e.g., Acceptance, Cognitive flexibility)
(-)(+)
(-)
45
Impact of thought change
Changing thoughts …- Has been shown to reduce depression in
individuals who are depressed (Jakobsen et al., 2011; Rupke et al., 2006)
- Has been shown to reduce pain intensity in individuals with chronic pain (Ehde & Jensen, 2004; Jensen et al., 2011))
Remember…
BIS and BAS reponses are automatic – you cannot easily stop them.
46
So…
Changing activity within the BIS-BAS systems will have automatic effects on pain
Hypnosis…
- Changes what is activated and inhibited within the automatic response (BIS-BAS) systems
- Can make changes quickly- Can create responses that are
automatic (seem effortless)
47
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
So we are looking to identify useful thoughts
And then make them automatic
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
Open questions and reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
48
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
Open questions and reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
Open questions and reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
49
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
Open questions and reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
Provide those suggestions with in a more formal hypnosis session
Using Open Qs and Reflection to Identify ATs
Open questions to elicit adaptive thoughts (effective hypnotic suggestions) about pain
Reflective listening (restate and “test drive” suggestions)
50
Adaptive Thoughts (often, BAS)
Self-efficacy (I can…)Importance (I would like…)Affirmations (I am…)Optimism/Hope (It will…)Flexibility (Either way…)Intent (I will….)
I can…
I can’tI will…
I will never…
51
Open Qs to identify content
I can…
I can’tI will…
I will never…
Reflection to enhance & “test drive” suggestions
I can…I can’t
I will…I will never…
52
Hypnosis to enhance suggestions
I can…I can’t
I will…I will never…
Open Questions
Open questions are ones that cannot be answered with a “yes’ or “no”
Open questions do not elicit specific answers like name or date.
Open questions get the client talking, hopefully about change
Using open questions you can demonstrate empathy and acceptance, and elicit ATs (potential suggestions)
53
Converting Closed to Open Questions
Did you exercise much last week?
Do you do get to the gym three days a week?
Are you feeling better?
Are you willing to improve your diet?
Did you call the trainer I recommended?
Reflective Listening
Reflective listening involves being interested in what the person has to say and respect for the person’s inner wisdom.
Key element is hypothesis testing. A reflective statement tests a hypothesis: Is this what you mean?
54
Reflective ListeningImportantly…- Reflections can be used to nurture
connections that already exist.- Can use reflections as to plant seeds for
new connections.- Reflections can be viewed as suggestions;
self-, “non-hypnotic”, and a source for formal hypnotic suggestions.
Forming Reflections
An effective reflective listening response is a statement, not a question. With questions inflection goes up at the end. With statements, inflection stays down at the end.
Example:- You’re angry about what I said?- You’re angry about what I said.
What is the effect of questions versus statements?
55
Forming reflections1. Repeating (repeat an element).2. Rephrasing (repeat with synonyms).3. Paraphrase (repeat best guess at meaning; like
saying the next sentence instead of repeating the last one).
4. Reflection of feeling (paraphrase that emphasizes the emotional dimension).
Reflections are “truisms” as far as the client is concerned. They build rapport and a “yes” set, and yield useful suggestion content.
Reflective listening: Tips
Reflective listening (positive suggestion) stems:“So, you think…”“Your are wondering if…”“It sounds like …”“It must feel…”
Non-reflections:AdviceQuestioningWarning
56
Hypnotic cognitive therapy
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
Provide those suggestions with in a more formal hypnosis session
Demonstration 1
A volunteer interested in feeling better – less pain (more comfortable), more energy, more confident, happier….
57
Demonstration 1
Therapist’s role: Listen for, note and “test drive” the ideas that are already inside the client that might make good suggestions – ideas and thoughts that you would want to nurture
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Demonstration 1
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
58
Demonstration 1
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
Provide those suggestions with in a more formal hypnosis session
Demonstration 2
Therapist’s role: Listen for, note and “test drive” the ideas that are already inside the client that might make good suggestions – ideas and thoughts that you would want to nurture
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
59
Demonstration 2
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
Demonstration 2
Open questions/reflections to identify and “test drive” thoughts as suggestions
Negotiate which suggestions the client finds most useful
Provide those suggestions with in a more formal hypnosis session
60
Questions,Comments,
And Discussion
Thank you!
Images courtesy of stockimages at FreeDigitalPhotos.net