Income and Livelihood Restoration Program Report · Construction Law 16/2003/QH11 on compensation...
Transcript of Income and Livelihood Restoration Program Report · Construction Law 16/2003/QH11 on compensation...
Income and Livelihood Restoration Program Report February 2014
VIE: Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Plant
Prepared by Viet Nam Electricity (EVN) GENCO 3 Thermal Power Projects Management Board 1.
EVN GENCO 3
Thermal Power Projects Management Board 1 (TPMB1)
MONG DUONG (2 x 500MW) THERMAL POWER PLANT PROJECT
INCOME AND LIVELIHOOD
RESTORATION PROGRAMME REPORT Contract No: TPMB1-EVN/ADB-2610L2MFF-Consulting-002
February 2014
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 2 of 56
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction of the project ........................................................................................................... 6
2. Objectives of Income and Livelihood Restoration Planning ..................................................... 6
3. Entitled People to participation the IRP ..................................................................................... 7
4. Policy Framework ......................................................................................................................... 8
4.1 National Policy Framework..................................................................................................... 8
4.2 Province Policy Framework .................................................................................................... 9
4.3 ADB Policy Framework .......................................................................................................... 9
5. Socio- Economic Profile of the affected households ................................................................. 11
5.1 Labor and employment structure ........................................................................................... 11
5.2 Income Sources ..................................................................................................................... 11
5.3 Monthly Income of Affected Households ............................................................................. 12
5.4 Vulnerable Groups ................................................................................................................ 13
5.5 Gender ................................................................................................................................... 13
6. Results of Consultation with Affected Households and Stakeholders .................................... 13
6.1 Identify Stakeholders ............................................................................................................. 13
6.2 Consultation with Affected Households, Vulnerable Groups ............................................... 14
6.3 Consultation with local authorities and mass organizations .................................................. 14
6.4 Consultation with Relevant Partners (DOLISA, Department of Economics, Agricultural
Promotion Center, Provincial WU, Women Union Vocational Schools, etc) ................................... 14
6.5 Results of Community and Other Stakeholders Consultations ............................................. 14
7. Income Restoration Program ..................................................................................................... 15
7.1 Income restoration models .................................................................................................... 16
7.1.1 Organizing vocational training courses and job recommendations for members in the
working age of the AHs ................................................................................................................. 16
7.1.2 Develop the models of Acacia cultivating to strengthen productive capacity in the
remaining land. ............................................................................................................................. 18
7.1.3 Develop the breeding models training those are applied new breed, new technique (to
rear the cattle such as cows) ......................................................................................................... 20
7.2 Allowance for Living and Production Rehabilitation: .......................................................... 22
7.3 Communications/capacity building activities........................................................................ 23
8. Cost estimation ............................................................................................................................ 24
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 3 of 56
9. Implementation Arrangement.................................................................................................... 29
9.1 The principles for the implementation .................................................................................. 29
9.2 Implementing Arrangement .................................................................................................. 29
9.2.1 GENCO 3 ...................................................................................................................... 29
9.2.2 Thermal Power Project Management Board 1 (TPMB1) ............................................. 30
9.2.3 Assigned Compositions of the parties involved ............................................................. 30
9.2.4 Responsibilities .............................................................................................................. 30
9.3 Implementation Procedures ................................................................................................... 31
9.4 Activity mechanism of the Steering Committee of the IRP .................................................. 31
10. Implementation Schedule ....................................................................................................... 34
11. Monitoring and Evaluation .................................................................................................... 37
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 4 of 56
List of table
Table 1 People who are entitled to participate in the IRP ...................................................................... 7 Table 2 Situation of Employment of Affected Households .................................................................... 11 Table 3 Main Income Source Structure of Affected Households(%) ..................................................... 12 Table 4 Income Bracket of Households (Unit: VNĐ) ............................................................................ 12 Table 5 Training for Communications/capacity building awareness ................................................... 23 Table 6 Summary of Cost Estimation for the IRP ................................................................................. 25 Table 7 Vocational Training for the member of affected households ................................................... 27 Table 8 Cost estimation for supporting the Acacia Cultivating model ................................................. 28 Table 9 Cost estimation for supporting the livestock model (to rear the cattle) ................................... 28 Table 11 Implementation Plan for livelihood restoration activities ..................................................... 34
Appendix
Appendix 1 List of the affected Households .......................................................................................... 38 Appendix 2 List of vocational training centers in Quang Ninh province. ............................................. 45 Appendix 3 Comparison between pre-project income and expected incomes gained from proposed
income restoration programs mentioned above ........................................................................... 49 Appendix 4 Registration forms for Income Restoration ........................................................................ 51
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 5 of 56
Abbreviations
AP Affected Person
AH Affected Household
DOLISA Department of Labour – Invalid and Social Affair
IRP Income Restoration Program
PPMU : Project Provincial Management Unit
DED: Department of Economic Development
WU: Women Union
ISC: Implementation Support Consultation
DOLISA: Department of Labour, Invalid, and Social Affair
PC People’s committee
TPMB1: Thermal Power Management Board
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 6 of 56
1. Introduction of the project
Mong Duong Thermal Power Plant complex with a total combined capacity of 2’200 MW, is
located in the Mong Duong Ward (Cam Pha town, Quang Ninh province). It is situated along
Highway 18, 300 km northeast of Hanoi and 18 km from the Center of Cam Pha town. The
Project site is located at the mouth of the Mong Duong River and includes one ward (Mong
Duong) and one commune (Cam Hai). The objective of building this Plant is to increase the
capacity of the thermal electric power source and contribute to the stable supply of electricity
throughout the year and especially in the dry season when the hydro plants do not generate
much of their maximum capacity.
The Mong Duong Thermal Generation Plant complex needs a large amount of fresh water
from Quarter Four, 2013. It is calculated that, the combined Plant needs 15.000 m3 of fresh
water per day. A fresh water supply system therefore must be constructed to serve the project.
The system consists of the reservoir, the pumping station, the 10 KV power supply to serve
for the pumping station, the water pipe line, and the access road.
Of which, only the Reservoir area and the Water Pineline area relate to land acquisition and
resettlement.
2. Objectives of Income and Livelihood Restoration Planning
The IRP focuses on the APs as a result of involuntary acquisition of land for the Project. The
land acquisition process is considered as involuntary when project affected people (APs) or
communities do not have the right to refuse land acquisition resulting in displacement. Land
acquisition in a project might lead to displacement for the local communities. For the ADB,
there are two types of displacements: physical and economic. Physical displacement is
defined as the actual physical of the people leading to relocation, loss of residential land, or
loss of shelter, whereas the economic displacement refers to loss of reproductive land or
assets, access to reproductive assets, income sources, or means of livelihoods (Source: SPS,
2009).
This project requires moving both physically and economically. Therefore, Income
Restoration Plan (IRP) was prepared in order to (i) ensure entitlements for Project affected
persons (APs) are prepared in a transparent, consistent and equitable manner;(ii) identify
severe APs that require assistance other than cash compensation to restore their livelihoods;
(iii) design and implement the measures for income and livelihood restoration; and (iv)
establish monitoring and evaluation mechanisms on IRP implementation.
The aim of this IRP is to minimize the adverse impacts of the Project and to ensure that
income and livelihoods of AHs will be restored and improved better or at least equal pre-
project levels.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 7 of 56
3. Entitled People to participation the IRP
People who are entitled to participate in the IRP are the severely affected households due to
loss from 10% or more of productive land (such as agricultural and, aquaculture ponds,
gardens, etc) or loss from 10% or more of income source from livelihood activities, relocated
households and the vulnerable households (such as poor HHs, HHs with heroic Vietnamese
mothers, invalids or martyrs families, HHs with disabled persons, single woman headed-
household, ethnic minorities who are specified in the 2003 Land Law, Decree 197/2004/ND-
CP of the Government of Vietnam and the compensation, assistances and resettlement
policies of Quang Ninh Province(refer to entitlement matrix table in the RAP 2012).
In the scope of the IRP, a fund for the development and implementation of specific programs
is established based on the need assessment to participate in the economic development
models of the affected households or group of affected households. In the meantime, the
Program also takes into account the priority on programs to improve income and livelihood
for the vulnerable households.
The survey result showed that, of total affected households, there are 186 households are
entitled to participate in the income restoration program. These are the households whom
losing 10% or more of productive land, of which, 37 resettled households and 20 households
belong to vulnerable group ( include: the household who lose 10% or more income source,
and relocation, the ethinic group, the poor household, the woman lead of affected households
impacted by the project)
Table 1 People who are entitled to participate in the IRP
Project
commune or
ward
Lose from 10% or more of
agricultural land without relocating Lose from
10% or
more of
agricultural
land and
relocating
Vulnerable
groups
TOTAL
10%-30% 30%-
70%
70%-
100%
Lose from
10% or more
of income
source,
and/or
relocation
Reservoir
Component 20 20 23 37 20
120
Mong Duong 18 10 13 37 20
120
Pipeline
Component 51 15 0 0 0 66
Cong Hoa 29 9 0 0 0
38
Cam Hai 22 6 0 0 0
28
Total 69 25 13 37 20 186
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 8 of 56
4. Policy Framework
This section outlines the principal policy and legislative framework that pertains to land
acquisition and involuntary resettlement in Viet Nam. It provides a summary of the relevant
ADB policies and Viet Nam Government policy. The ADB policies facilitate the resettlement
of property owners without the undesirable conditions imposed upon them by local legislation.
Both the local and international legal frameworks provide adequate compensation, support to
affected private and public parties in a transparent manner even when expropriation procedures
are used and the land is acquired through public interest. In other words, the international and
national policy/legal frameworks complement each other in providing residents of affected
settlements resettlement options. They also ensure that those who opt against resettlement
benefits would receive compensation at replacement cost.
4.1 National Policy Framework
The current documents directly related to the policy of livelihood support policies and income
restoration due to land acquisition and resettlement include:
Decree No.197/2004/ND-CP, on compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement in the
event of land recovery by the State.
Circular No.14/2009/TT-BTNMT dated 1/10/2009, guiding to implement Decree
197/2004/NĐ-CP.
Decree 69/2009/ND-CP of 13/8/2009 regulated on Land Use Planning, Land Pricing,
Land Acquisition, Compensation, Assistance and Resettlement.
Decree No.84/2007/ND-CP, which stipulates issue of LURC, land acquisition, land
use right implementation, procedure of compensation, and assistance in the event of
land recovery by the state and grievance redress.
Circular No.14/2008/TTLT/BTC-BTNMT guiding to implement some articles in the
Decree No. 84/2007/NĐ-CP
Construction Law 16/2003/QH11 on compensation and relocation of people affected
by ground clearance for investment projects.
Decision No. 1956/QD-TTg 27/11/2009, the Prime Minister approved "Vocational
training project for rural labors til 2020".
Joint Circular No 112/2010/TTLT-BTC-BLĐTBXH dated 30/7/2010 of the Ministry
of Finance and the Ministry of Labor-Invalids and Social Affairs guiding the
issuance, management and use of agricultural vocation training pilot cards fromthe
budget of national target Program of Employment and Vocational training and
Circular No. 128/2012/TTLT-BTC-BLDTBXH on amending and supplementing
Circular No. 112/2010/ TTLT-BTC-BLĐTBXH. (There are three types of cards: red
card for rural workers to be eligible for preferential policies, people contribute to the
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 9 of 56
revolution, the poors, ethnic minorities, the disabled, people who are recovered their
cultivation land are supported for short-term vocational training (vocational
elementary level and vocational training less than 3 months) with maximum support
level is 3 million dong per person per one training course
Decision 52/2012/QD-TTg dated 16/11/2012 issued by the Prime Minister, which
regulated on policies of vocational training and job creation support for labors who
are acquired their agricultural land. Accordingly, supported objects the labors who
directly participate in agricultural production which their agricultural land is
recovered by the State without compensation land to satisfy the conditions: permanent
residence at households with agricultural land recovered; people at working-age;
there is a need for vocational training, job change, job search, job creation loans.
Employees are entitled to support policies in a period of 3 years after the land
acquisition decision. The forms of support include support training (short-term,
intermediate, advanced levels); support the domestic job as well as foreign one. This
Decision takes effect on 1/1/ 2013.
4.2 Province Policy Framework
Quang Ninh Province People’s Committee Decision 499/2010/QD-UBND of 11/2/2010
(decision regarding compensation, support and resettlement when the state acquires land in
Quang Ninh Province) provides details for the application of compensation, assistance and
eligibility regimes set out in Decree 69/2009/ND-CP.
Decision 1221/QĐ-UBND dated 29/05/2013 issued by the PPC, approved the budget
allocationto implement the pilot project of agriculturally vocational cards providing for rural
laborers in Quang Ninh province in 2013.
4.3 ADB Policy Framework
The ADB Safeguard Policies applying to solve the negative impacts of the CSEDP
consolidates three existing safeguard policies: (i) involuntary resettlement policy (IR, 1995),
and guideline for implementation F2/BP (9/2006), (ii) Safeguard Policy Statement (2009).
Closely associated with two social safeguard policies is the Policy on Gender and Development
(1998), Ethnic Minorities Policy (EMP, 1999). The population of the commune mostly affected
by the project, Ward No. 10, is inhabited predominantly by members of the two ethnic
minorities living in this area, Dao and Tay, while in the area affected by the pipeline, the
majority is Kinh. It is evident that project impacts affect mainly representatives of ethnic
minority groups. Therefore it is justified - or required - to put emphasis on this aspect in the
entire implementation process of restoration programs
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 10 of 56
The objective of ADB Policy on IR is to avoid or minimize the impacts on people, households,
businesses and others affected by the acquisition of land and other assets, including livelihood
and income. Where resettlement is unavoidable, the overall goal of the ADB policy is to help
restore the living standards of the affected people to at least their pre-project level by
compensating for lost assets at replacement costs and by providing, as necessary, various forms
of support and assistance.
Following are the key principles in the Bank’s policy on involuntary resettlement:
a. Involuntary resettlement should be avoided where feasible.
b. Where population displacement is unavoidable, it should be minimized by exploring all
viable project options.
c. Preference will be given to land-based resettlement strategies when affected livelihoods
are land based
d. All compensation is based on the principle of replacement cost.
e. Each involuntary resettlement is conceived and executed as part of a development
project or program
f. Affected people should be fully informed and consulted on compensation and/or
resettlement options.
g. Institutions of the affected people, and, where relevant, of their hosts, are to be
protected and supported. Affected people are to be assisted to integrate economically
and socially into host communities so that adverse impacts on the host communities are
minimized and social harmony is promoted.
h. The absence of a formal legal title to land is not a bar to ADB’s policy entitlements.
i. Affected people are to be identified and recorded as early as possible in order to
establish their eligibility through a population record or census that serves as an
eligibility cut-off date, preferably at the project identification stage, to prevent a
subsequent influx of encroachers of others who wish to take advance of such benefits.
j. Particular attention must be paid to the needs of the poorest affected households and
other vulnerable groups that may be at high risk of impoverishment. This may include
affected households without legal title to land or other assets, households headed by
women, the elderly or disabled, and ethnic minority peoples. Appropriate assistance
must be provided to help them improve their socio-economic status.
k. The full costs of resettlement and compensation should be included in the presentation
of project costs and benefits.
l. Budget for relocation and rehabilitation comes from ADB loan financing for the
project, to assure timely availability of the required resources and ensure compliance
with involuntary resettlement procedures during implementation.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 11 of 56
Other policies of the ADB should be applied in making and implementing resettlement plan
and income restoration program are (i) public information policy (3/2005) and implementation
guideline L3/BP (9/2005), and (ii) explanation mechanism (as showed in the implementation
guideline L1/BP guide, issued on 29th
October, 2003).
5. Socio- Economic Profile of the affected households
5.1 Labor and employment structure
Surveyed AHs in Mong Duong commune have a combined total of 224 members. Of these,
nearly 108 people are employment from 15 to 60 years old, and 10 People is unemployed and
2 others people are seeking empoyment. In Cong Hoa, among140 members who have
employment belong to the 15 to 60 age group. Surveyed AHs in Cam Hai commune has 71
members. Of the total, 24 people are employment between 15 to 60 years old. Around 6 people
are unemployed, while 1 person is seeking the job. Most of the labors in the project areas are
working for as farming workers for large farming owner, working in coal mining , storage and
trading, wood processing company etc. (see the table below).
Table 2 Situation of Employment of Affected Households
No Employment
Mong Duong Ward
Cong Hoa Commune
Cam Hai Commune Total
No. of AHs (HH)
No. of APs
(perso
n)
No. of AHs (HH)
No. of APs
(person)
No. of AHs (HH)
No. of APs
(person)
No. of AHs (HH)
No. of APs
(person)
1 Employment 108 202 36 140 24 71 168 413
2 Unemployed 10 21 2 3 3 6 15 30
3 Seeking employment
1 1 0 0
1 1 2 2
5.2 Income Sources
The below table shows the structure of income sources of the afffected households (include the
primary income income sources of the household head and the other members of the
households. From this it is quite clear that the main income of the Mong Duong is from forest
plantation and agriculture (with 96 households get primary income from agriculture (30 hhs)
and acaciaplanting (66 hhs). Each AP household has 4.5 ha of Acacia on average (from 2.0 to
8.0 ha, depending on the number of family members), and one ha of Acacia trees can be sold at
a price of 30.000.000 VND after six years of growth. Beside the primary income, the affected
household in Mong duong ward add secondary income from other activities such as
acaciaplanting (25 hhs) agriculture (10 hhs) and also from the coal mining and business
In Cong Hoa commune, the most important primary income of the household is from business
(10 hhs among 38 households) meanwhile the highest secondary income is from acacia
Planting (7 hhs among 22 interviewed hhs). All the affected households are trying to restore
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 12 of 56
their production capacity to creatjobs for their family member’s. However, both of their
primary and secondary income are considereably affected
Cam Hai comune has higher main income sources from Acacia Planting/Forest (16 among 28
affected households). The fishing households who are affected by the project are trying to keep
their fishing activities in other sections of the Mong Duong river and other places. And they
have also trying co get income from the secondary income such as from agriculture (5 hhs),
acaciaplanting (5hhs) and other source of income (5hhs). In general, the main income of the
Cam Hai local will be decrease by the project impact.Structure of household income is shown
in the table below.
Table 3 The primary and secondary income sources of Household’s head (HHs)
No Categories of Income source
Mong Duong Ward (hhs) Cong Hoa Commune
(hhs) Cam Hai Commune (hhs)
Primary Income
Secondary Income
Primary Income
Secondary Income
Primary Income
Secondary Income
1 Agriculture 30 10 8 5 3 5
2
Acacia Planting/
Forest
66 25 9 7 16 5
3 Aquaculture 2 0 4 5 2 0
4 Coal Mining 5 1 2 1 2 0
5 Business 5 1 10 2 2 2
6 Other source 12 3 5 1 3 5
Total 120 40 38 22 28 17
Source: SES
5.3 Monthly Income of Affected Households
On average, each AP household has an income of 4.050.000 VND/month (3.8 family members/
a household). In which, 40% of the surveyed household is average income per capita per month
form 651.000 VND-1000.000VND, 16.4% of the surveyed households is average income per
capita per month is from 1.000.000VND-2.000.000VND. Income less than 500.000 per capita
per month is 8.5% in N010 Mong duong ward, 10% in Cam Hai and6.4% in Cong hoa
Commune. The income level more than 2.000.000VND per capita per month focus in Cam Hai
with 10% and Cong Hoa8.5%
Table 4 Income Bracket of Households (Unit: VNĐ)
Project
(thousand
Less than
500
501.-650 651-1000 1.000-2.000 More than
2.000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 13 of 56
VND/ per
capital)
Qu
anti
ty %
Qu
anti
ty %
Qu
anti
ty %
Qu
anti
ty %
Qu
anti
ty %
Ward 10 10 9.1 45 40.9 40 36.4 10 9.1 5 4.5
Cam Hai 2 10.0 3 6.4 10 50.0 4 20.0 2 10.0
Cong Hoa 3 6.4 5 10.6 20 42.6 15 31.9 4 8.5
Total 15 8.5 53 29.9 70 40 29 16.4 11 6.2
Source: SES
5.4 Vulnerable Groups
There are 20 households belonging to vulnerable groups, they are the poor, disabled persons,
single woman headed households with dependant, revolution or invalids person or loneliness
elderly, etc. These households will be entiled to join the IRP. Most of the APs belong to an
ethnic minority.
5.5 Gender
During the Individual Interview, 90% the affected household still not get their Land use rights
certificates (LURC). However, the household said that Land use rights certificates (LURC) for
residential plots will be registered under the namesof both husband and wife. LURCs for plots
at the resettlement site will also be registered under the names of both husband and wife.
However, with regard to agricultural lands LURCs in the area are usually issued to women as
they directly involved in agricultural production activities.
During group discussions, DPs mentioned that household members rely on men’s decision
with regard to business decisions while women are responsible for household chores. Men are
more likely affected because they are the primary income-earners in the households. In Mong
duong commune, when we asked about shifting to a new job most of the interviewed said that
they are old and cannot work as hired labour. They are relying on their children for support.
Younger male said they will shift to seasonal construction work. Women have to take care of
their families, look after their children, etc.
6. Results of Consultation with Affected Households and Stakeholders
6.1 Identify Stakeholders
The potential stakeholders of the project include local affected people and organisation or
agencies, local authorities, none-government, and other representatives of the affected people.
Consultation and information disclosure is implemented in transperence which can not be
absent during preparing and implementing the IRP.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 14 of 56
TPMB1 together with Cam Pha RC implemented public information by providing the project
information to local authorities and affected people. The community meetings for information
disclosure to local authorities, consultations with the stakeholders and the interviews were
organized during this process.
6.2 Consultation with Affected Households, Vulnerable Groups
Propagate the awareness of the importance of livelihood restoration and
opportunities to participate in livelihood restoration programs designed for the
Project;
Keep up the economic capacity and economic development after the land
acquisition;
Finding out about the needs and expectations of affected households in participating
the IRP
6.3 Consultation with local authorities and mass organizations
Update socio-economic policies including basic guidelines and instructions at the
province, city, ward or commune levels, and their implementation process;
Update the local status of socio-economic development and opportunities/challenges for
the development of livelihood restoration models, especially for affected households
and vulnerable groups;
Existing social support programs in ward or commune level
Assimilate experiences and guidance for building contents of livelihood restoration
programs in the project area.
6.4 Consultation with Relevant Partners (DOLISA, Department of Economics,
Agricultural Promotion Center, Provincial WU, Women Union Vocational
Schools, etc)
Learn experiences in the implementation of livelihood restoration models suitable for
those whose land are acquired;
Learn about the market demand for skills, careers and other agricultural products and
handicrafts;
Identify potential partners in the implementation of livelihood restoration programs in
detail.
6.5 Results of Community and Other Stakeholders Consultations
The consultation is deployed at various levels: municipal, city, commune and affected
household. The accessibility to affected households faced difficulties due to the fairly large
number of households (total of affected households who are entitled from the IRP is 186 HHs);
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 15 of 56
of which, some of them are working far from home or moved to another place for living, these
households do not directly do farming therefore it cause the difficulties to access them. This
also affects on registration to take part in the IRP of the AHs.
Survey result of need of participate in the IRP also showed that many AHs don’t aware the
important role of these activities and therefore they do not register to participate in the IRP as
well as not propose other options at individual level. Therefore, during the survey, the Project
has been continuous communicating to aware the necessary of the IRP. The Project considered
these communication activities as a part of income restoration activities. The households who
meet the conditions to join the IRP and have not been registered yet, can register if they will be
in-need later.
The consultation result showed that, the project area have advantage conditions to conduct the
productive activities such as cow rearing, Acacia cultivating, cow raising, pig breeding,
forestry trees, etc…In addition, the none-agricultural activities such as sewing embroidery,
handicraft production are also advantages inthe project area.
The households affected by the Project have been consulted and assessed on needs of
livelihood restoration. Their views and opinions about the restoration of livelihood after
resettlement are shown as follows:
Of 186 households who are the beneficiaries of income restoration program, there are 95
households (51.0%) responded to registration for income restoration models, 39
households (20.9%) are elderly households and 32 other households (17.2%) are no in-
need of participate-in the Program. 20 remaining households (10.75%) have not made up
their minds so they could not answer, these households will register in the future if they
will be in-need
Of 95 above-mentioned registered households, most of them are agricultural households
(breeding, growing), 30 households registered to rear cattle; 30 households registered to
Acacia cultivating, 35 households registered to join in “other activities”. All these
households look forward to join production technique training courses.
Of 95 above registered households, there are 40 members of households who are in-need
of vocational training courses such as driving, information-technology, mechanic,
tailoring, textile industry, electricity, electronic, welding, medical, house-working,
cooking).
After receiving the listof the affected households whom are in-need of vocational
training, TPMB1will support to contact with local institutions to facilitate the training for
the in-need affected households if neccessary.
7. Income Restoration Program
The Income Restoration Program includes many different activities as the follows:
1. Income restoration models:focus on the activities which help to recover the AHs’
income to be equal or better than pre-project.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 16 of 56
2. Allowance for Living and Production Rehabilitation:Focus on support for livelihood
and production stablization assistances during the transition period to help the affected people
stabilize their lives after land acquisition.
3. Communications/capacity building:The consultation process showed that many
affected households are still not aware of the importance of the IRP. Therefore, awareness-
raising activities for the affected households have been implemented to help affected
households to aware of the importance of the program and the use of compensation, assistance
for the right purpose, help ensure sustainable livelihoods for the affected households.
Specific description of each income restoration activity is showed at the belows:
7.1 Income restoration models
Income restoration activities aim to restore livelihoods for the affected households who are lost
their income sources due to project implementation, including the households with severely
affected agricultural land and the households who are affected their income source from
business or production. All in-working-age membersof the severely affected household, if they
are in-need of vocaltional training, will be funded for vocational training as specified below.
At the same time, the households those are recovered less than 50% of agricultural land are
entitled to join one model of production, the households those are recovered from 50% or more
of productive land are entitled to participate in the models of agricultural/forestry production
suggested below (Acacia cultivating, livestock).
The activities/models are applied in this Project include:
7.1.1. Organizing vocational training courses and job recommendations for members of
the AHs in the working age;
7.1.2.Develop models of Acacia Cultivating to strengthen productive capacity in the
remaining land;
7.1.3. Develop the breeding models those are applied new breed and new technique to
rear the cattle.)
Details as the follows:
7.1.1 Organizing vocational training courses and job recommendations for members
in the working age of the AHs
Along with policies to attract employees to work for long-term in the facilities or works under
the Project, the Project support for basically vocational training (short term training courses
less than 6 months )will be given priority) and occupation recommendation for the members of
the APs.
Through discussions with the leaders of theDepartment of Labor, Invalids and Social Affairs of
Quang Ninh Province on the issues of human resources and solutions for the unemployment
situation, the results showed that the vocational school or training centers of the province are
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 17 of 56
focusing on training for the workers for some sectors which attract a lot of labors in the locality
such as coal and miningsector, civil electricity, electronic, driving, welding,mechanic, cooking,
tourism, hairdresser, etc.
Members in working-age of the affected households who are in need of vocational training
shall be admitted into the vocational training institutions in the province with free fee for one
training course (including the level of preliminary training , intermediate and vocational
colleges) (not applicable to the applicants want to learn at the vocational training centers out of
the province). At the same time, after completion, the project will coordinate with vocational
schools to introduce students to enterprises or companies which are in-need of recruitment.
The Program also consulted with the AHs to identify the needs of them.
From the result of consultation with the AHs, the Project identified some occupations which
are suitable for the members of the AHs and the trend of labor market, such as driving,
welding, mecahnic, civil electricity, electronic, cooking, hairdresser, etc.
Vocational training model is specified as the follows:
a. Object: Members of AHs at appropriate age (from 18 to 35)
b. Entitlements:support the school fee, transport and mealyassistance and job
introduction after completing the course.
c. Activities: Coordinate with the Vocational Schools or TrainingCenter in
QuangNinh province for the implementation ofvocational trainingsfromtheir
member'sexpectation: tailoring, engineering (agricultural machinery repairand
construction), motorcyclerepair, driving,electro mechanics, refrigeration, cooking,
and bodyguard, etc. The Vocational Schools/Training Centers is tent to sign
contract of vocational traing coorperation includes: Industrial and Construction
Vocation College of Quang Ninh Province , Mining College Hữu Nghị, Industrial
College of Cam Pha, Vocational Center of Cam Pha City,Provincial Women Union,
Vocational College belong to Mining Company on the basis of contract principles
between the project, the Vocational Schools or Training Centers will directly
organize propaganda and training in the communes.
Coordinatewith enterprisesandcoal mining companies in Quang Ninh
Province and the surrounding area for recruitment and training such as
Mong Duong Coal Mining Company, Cam Pha Mining Company, Hong
Cam and Huu Nghi Mining Company, etc to recommend the job
opportunities to the labors.
Establish database of households who are in need of job training, education
level, experience, skills and profession they want to follow.
Create and maintain relationships with Project Management Unit of
construction project, the business establishments, industrial parks and
factories, enterprises in the region to determine the employment needs of the
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 18 of 56
mentioned organizations(such as: number of people for recruitment,
required qualifications and recruitment plans) and reached an agreement to
provide personnel to these enterprises.
Design a program to provide information about available jobs they are
recruiting by posting recruitment ads in the affected communes as well as
job vacancies notified by local speaker in the commune.
Coordinate and establish relationships with contractors who build the
reservoir and pipeline to give priority in recruiting labors of AHs. The labor
standards and labor safety laws need to be guaranteed. There is no
discrimination in remuneration for men and womenof the same type of
work, at the same time, do not use child labor for the construction and
maintenance of the construction
Build and maintain relationships with the vocational training center to
organize training courses in accordance with the preferences of the affected
households.
d. Economic Benefits: After participating in vocational training and job stability, the
member of the affected household will have a stable income (expected income is
around 2.5 million - 5 million VND/month) to cover for their life and support their
family.
e. Social benefits / social impacts: Creating jobs for the main labor of the household,
focusing on those who have good health and education level, ability to acquire
knowledge.
f. Theconditionsfor the development of local models: Locality with training centers
or vocational school is capable of providing training and job placement. There are
several industrial parks, export processing zones in neiboring areas with high labor
demand, capable of receiving the objects who have completed vocational training
programs.
g. Model replication and guide for implementation. This modelis supportedby
TPMB1, the Vocational Training Centers or schools in Cam Pha City, business
establishments, industrial parks, factories and enterprises in the region.
Along with vocational training and job recommendation for the members of AHs, the Project
conducts the activities/models of productions or business for the members of AHs in the aging
from 30 or more. Details as the follows:
7.1.2 Develop the models of Acacia cultivating to strengthen productive capacity in
the remaining land.
These are the closed models, ensuring from production stage to consumption stage, help the
people feel safe of the output and help to bring sustainable income for them. These models is
applied for the communes Cong Hoa Comune, Cam Hai Comune and Mong Duong Ward, etc
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 19 of 56
wherereas the conditions on productive land are available and the AHs are in-need of
participate in the models.
The Project with coorperate with the Agricultural Extension Centers and Department of
Economics to implement the training courses on application of technics and the guidelines on
capacity and productivity improving, using the high quality Acacia trees
a. Objects: Members of AHs at the age from 30 to 60
b. Benefits: Communication program about the program on the basis of Agricultural
Extension information. Enrolling in model introduction course and model
implementation skills. These households will be supported the Acacia cultivating
experience from the Service Centers
c. Activities:
Organization programs to introduce the models and techniques of Acacia
cultivating or high quality growing support to provide seeds/ new breed;
Coordinate with Agricultural extension center of the Province and city,
Agricultural extension associations and another organization that have been
successful in their model and get experience sharing.
Technical Support for AHs during production: IRP Implementing Unit
establishing by Quang Ninh PPC will sign a Contract of Technical Support
with the Economic Department and the Center of Agricultural Extension
whom will be in charge of technical supports to the AHs. Technical supports
include the guidebook, technical training of growing and taking care of
vegetables or rice and pilot growing, monitoring the progress of pilot
growing and technical support during whole the production process.
d. Economic benefits:
Low fixed costs (AHs normally have available land for production
development in their home);
Low operation costs due to taking advantage of labor power of the member
in the family;
Big and stable consumption market in the locality and neigboring regions.
The estimately expected income 400,000 – 700,000 dong per person per
month. This meant they could have better income comparing to Pre-project.
e. Social benefits/ impacts:
Create jobs for unemployed labors. Old people may join this program to
improve their income;
This model does not require much time, and farmers might undertake other
jobs at the same time;
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 20 of 56
f. Conditions for the localities to develop the models:
Suitable climatic conditions and soil
Have little environmental impacts compared to other models;
g. Model replication
For the new models, they will be chosen from a number of projects and
Provincial Farmers Association at the localities and be able to replicate to
about 30% of households who have little remaining land area in Cam pha
city; through learning experiences from Agricultural Extension Centers and
Agriculture and Department of Economics in Campha city, these models
have been applied in the locality which appropriate with land condition and
bringing a high effectiveness;
Farmers Association and City and Provincial Extension Centers to
encourage farmers to adopt the models and encourage farmers to implement
the model.
7.1.3 Develop the breeding models training those are applied new breed, new
technique (to rear the cattle such as cows)
Breeding households will be join the breeding technic training courses to learn how to get a
high economy effectiveness, ensure hygiene and food safety. These households will get the
experience by specialist. With this assistance and job transition support which they had
received earlier, they will have the basic knowledge to implement the model and restore
income lost by the project. Thus, with this model, households can fully restore their income
lost by the project, even higher than Pre-project.
The Project with coorperate with the Agricultural Extension Centers and Department of
Economics of Cam Pha to implement the training courses on application of breeding technics.
a. Objects: Members of AHs at the age from 30 to 60
b. Benefits: Communication program about the program on the basis of Agricultural
c. Extension information. Enrolling in model introduction course and model
implementation skills. These households will be supported (new breeds or livestock
supplies, etc.) from the Service Centers.
d. Activities:
Organization programs to introduce the models and techniques of breeding,
provide new breeds;
Coordinate with Agricultural extension center of the Province and city,
Agricultural extension associations and another organization that have been
successful in their model and participate in experience sharing.
e. Economic benefits:
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 21 of 56
Low fixed costs (AHs normally have available land for making breeding
facilities in their house);
Low operation costs due to taking advantage of available source of foods
surrounding;
Big and stable consumption market in the locality and neiboring regions.
The estimately expected income from this is around 300,000 – 400,000 dong
per person per month. This meant they could restore their income lost by the
Project and even have a better income comparing to Pre-project.
f. Social benefits/impacts:
Create jobs for unemployed labors. Old people who afford to work may join
this program to improve their income;
This model does not require much time, and farmers might undertake other
jobs at the same time;
Take advantage of available field for growing and rearing;
g. Conditions for the localities to develop the models:
Suitable climatic conditions and soil
Have little environmental impacts compared to other models;
Farmers can use natural grass growing under storey of perennial trees as
animals’ food. They also can plant elephant grass along borders of industrial
farms;
Available source of foods such as cassava, maize, sweet-potato are available
to fatten animals.
h. Model replication
For the new models, they will be chosen from a number of projects and
Provincial/City Farmers Association at the localities and be able to replicate
to about 30% of households who have little remaining land area in project
areasthrough learning experiences from Agricultural Extension Centers and
Agriculture and Department of Economics, these models have been applied
effectively in the locality.
Farmers Association and City and Provincial/City Extension Centers to
encourage farmers to adopt the models and encourage farmers to implement
the model.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 22 of 56
7.2 Allowance for Living and Production Rehabilitation:
This is a basic activity as the first condition to help the households to restore their income. The
assistances for each specific beneficiary as the follows:
a) Assistance for households with agricultural land
For households:
Loss less than 10% of total production land householding: Cash compensation
for agricultural land at 2,000,000 VND/ m2 in maximum; forest land at 500
VND/m2; annual crop land, perennial tree land, aquaculture land, and other
production land: 1,500 VND/m2.
Loss from 10% - 30% of total production land holding: rice subsidy by 90 kg of
rice/member for all members of household who will not have to relocate; 180 kg
of rice/member for all family members in case where household who will have
to move to areas with difficult socioeconomic conditions; 360 kg of rice/
member for all family members in case where household will have to move to
areas with difficult socio-economic conditionsLoss more than 30% - 70% of
total production land holding: rice subsidy by 180 kg of rice/member for all
members of household who will not have to relocate; 360 kg of rice/member for
all family members in case where household who will have to move to areas
with difficult socio-economic conditions; 720 kg of rice/ member for all family
members in case where household will have to move to areas with difficult
socio-economic conditions
Loss more than 70% of total production land holding: rice subsidy by 360 kg of
rice/member for all family members of household who will not have to relocate;
720 kg of rice/member for all family members in case where household who
will have to move to areas with socio-economic conditions; 1080 kg of rice/
member for all family members in case where household will have to move to
areas with difficult socio-economic conditionsAssistance for job change and
job creation: for the Households who directly use the agricultural land: Annual
crop land, salter land: cash compensation by 2.5 times of affected land value;
Other types of agricultural land: cash compensation by 2.0 times of affected
land value
Assistance for vulnerable households: Women headed households, households under
preferential social policies, poor households, elder and disabled headed households,… as per
definition of vulnerable household as specified in this UREDMP: Vulnerable households shall
be entitled to additional assistance in cash by VND 2,000,000 to VND 5,000,000 as stipulated
in the Article 40 of the Decision No. 499/2010/QĐ-UBND of Quang Ninh PPC
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 23 of 56
7.3 Communications/capacity building activities
Communication for raising awareness will be implemented through many different forms aim
to enhance awareness and orient a sustainable livelihood for the community in general and the
AHs in particular.
Table 5 Training for Communications/capacity building awareness
No. Activities Unit Quantity Descriptions
1 Communications and
dissemination of
effective economic
models
Times
(of
News)
05 Communicate about effective
economic models in the region,
in the country and other areas;
provide technical guidance and
production outputs
communications through the
Cam Pha radio and Quang ninh
province Television (each news
from 15’- 20)’
2 Training on
management and
implementation of the
IRP (for leader of
villages/commune,
women union, TPPMU
officials; officials from
City economic
department; City
DOLISA
Day 1 Strengthen awareness for the
affected communities on the
policies and orienting of income
restoration; enhance the skills on
management, monitoring and
report of implementing the IRP
in the area including the
knowledge and skills on
managing funds
3 Capacity Buiding
training for
Vulnerable group and
Severely affected
household
times 3 Focus on the group discussion
through IRP consultant and
commune officials meeting such
as Women Union Meeting,
Farmer Union meeting every 3
months. The contents of group
discussions are about: (i) the
situation of affected household at
the new relocation place; (ii)
their challenges in restoration
stratergies and their
recommendation to improve and
restore their income and living
standards.
4 The training on
managing finances for
time 1 Support by training for women to
improve women's access to credit
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 24 of 56
women/ ethnic women
and Women Union
members
and financial services;
strengthening the women in
planning and managing their own
development activities;
development of household
financial institutions including
the savings and loans and
improvement of women capacity
to promote agricultural
productivity and off-farm
business enterprises.
5 Support the severely
affected household in
Resevoir (Mong duong
ward) to purchase or
term land lease some
agricultural lands from
the Cam Pha forestry
state-owned company
time 1 Step 1: Households will send
their purchase to commune /
ward committee
Step 2: TPMB1 will have
meeting with local authorities to
consider the application and
approve according to the legal
framework of the project
Step 3: Commune / Ward will
send the recommendation
document to the Cam Pha town
(attack the list of households
purchasing forest land)
Step 4: Cam Pha City will have
meeting with Campha Forestry
Company and consider the
supporting area for farmers
Step 5: Cam Pha City Committee
will send a letter to the
Department of Environmental
Resources Quang Ninh to revise
the Land Using of Cam Pha
Forestry Company
Step 6: People's Committee of
Quang Ninh Province give the
temporary land Use Right
Certificate for the affected
household
8. Cost estimation
Total estimated budget for the IRP is VND 356,785,000. Detailed cost estimation is showed at
the tables belows:
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 25 of 56
Table 6 Summary of Cost Estimation for the IRP
No Activity Unit Q’tity Unit Amount
/Contract
I Capacity and Awareness Acitivities
Communications and dissemination of
effective economic models on the Quang
Ninh radio and television channels.
The cost includes the cost of hiring the
journalism of the radio and television
channels Cam Pha town collect the
information from affected households
and write articles about the IRP
implementation to improve
understanding of local people about the
income restoration program of the
project. The provisional budget is 60
million VNĐ (the details will be
estimated and ask the provincial
approval)
60,000,000
II Training on management and
implementation of the IRP (for leader of
villages/commune, women union,
TPPMU officials; officials from City
economic department; City DOLISA
3 Youth Union members; 3 Farmer
Union members; 3 Women Union
members; 3 Red Cross members. Total:
12 members
3,200,000
Hiring the Conference Hole Day 1
500,000
500,000
Market Pcs 1
500,000
500,000
Fee for the teacher(2 persons x 1 days,
500.000 dong per person per day)
Person
x day
2
500,000
1,000,000
Tea-break Person
x day
12
30,000
360,000
Document Pcs 12
20,000
240,000
Allowance for participants Person
x day
12
50,000
600,000
III Budget for Support for Vocational
Training
230,400,000
Support for training for members of the
AHs to work in the Project's facilities
230,400,000
IV Budget for Support to Implement the 12,750,000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 26 of 56
Models
Acacia Cultivating Model Estimation
(Details in the Table 8)
4,250,000
Budget for supporting livestock model
(Details in the Table 9)
8,500,000
V Allowance for facilitors or motivators
in the ward or communte to deploy the
IRP (1 persons per each commune,
500.000 per each x 3 communes/ward=
1500.000đ/month)
Tháng 12
1,500,000
18,000,000
Sub-total (1)
324,350,000
VI Contract management +
administrative activities fee (10%)
Sub-total (3)
32,435,000
TOTAL (1+3) 356,785,000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 27 of 56
Table 7 Vocational Training for the member of affected households
No Training sector Training
time
Q'tity
Fee/month
Amount
(VNĐ)
(month) (person) (VNĐ)
1 Mechanics, welding 6 8 1,200,000 57,600,000
2 Car/Motobyte Repair 6 8 1,200,000 57,600,000
3 Consumer electronics/ water
conduiter
6 8 1,200,000 57,600,000
4 Garment Industry worker 6 8 1,200,000 57,600,000
5 Cooking 6 8 1,200,000 57,600,000
TOTAL 40 230,400,000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 28 of 56
Table 8 Cost estimation for supporting the Acacia Cultivating model
No Item Unit Q'tity Support
Value
Amount
1 Training for Acacia Cultivating techniques
(2courses x 15 persons/course = 30 persons, 2
courses)
4,250,000
Hiring conference hole Day 2 500,000 1,000,000
Market Pcs 1 500,000 500,000
Fee for teachers: 500.000 dong/day x 2
persons x 2 days
Day
2 1,000,000 2,000,000
Tea-break Time 15 30,000 450,000
Document book 15 20,000 300,000
Table 9 Cost estimation for supporting the livestock model (to rear the cattle)
No Item Unit Q'tity Support
Value
Amount
1 Livestock training (to rear the cattle): 2
courses x 15 persons / Course = 30 persons,
2 days /per course
8,500,000
Hiring conference hole day 4 500,000 2,000,000
Market pcs 2 500,000 1,000,000
Fee for teachers: 500.000 VNĐ/perday x 2
persons / course x 2 days x 3 courses
day
4 1,000,000 4,000,000
Tea - break time 30 30,000 900,000
Document book 30 20,000 600,000
Total 8,500,000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 29 of 56
9. Implementation Arrangement
9.1 The principles for the implementation
a.Clearness and transparence
• The policies and entitlements of livelihood restoration programs should be
publicized widely for affected people through the local media, the local
administrative system and the local seminars;
• The self-governing boards of the livelihood restoration programs elected by the
community must provide beneficiaries with related documentation and information,
funding and spending for livelihood restoration programs in full as well as provide to
those who carry out coordination and assessments as required.
b. Community consultation
• The livelihood restoration programs proposed in this report are mainly resulted in
the consultation with the organizations and agencies in Cam Pha city. However,
household consultations continue during the project implementation to ensure the
compliance with the requirements, conditions and current conditions of people.
• In addition, the consultation will continue in the mid-term review of livelihood
restoration activities to understand people’s feedback and demand for support as well
as for the adjustment of the project management in a more effective way.
c.The priorities
(i)At first, priorities are deemed that in addition to the benefits and entitlements from the
RPs was approved by ADB and the City PC, affected households are given with
preferences (but not limited to) the participation in the following cases:
• Access to assistance funds from the project (such as sanitation revolving fund,
v.v.);
• Join the livelihood restoration models sponsored by the Project;
• Participate in capacity building programs, visiting models and priorities in the
training and recruitment;
• Other cases.
(ii) Secondly, priorities will be given to affected household upon their degree of impact
on the production land and houses (i) vulnerable levels of affected households (ii) and
affected households with highly feasible livelihood restoration models which have positive
impact to other affected households.
9.2 Implementing Arrangement
9.2.1 GENCO 3
Genco 3 is the Executing Agency, responsible for approving project documents, providing
funds and guidance to TPMB1 and for overall implementation and coordination of the
project, including IRP, land acquisition and resettlement and UREMDP activities.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 30 of 56
9.2.2 Thermal Power Project Management Board 1 (TPMB1)
Thermal Power Project Management Board 1 (TPMB1)(Client) prepares and implement
the IRP with support from the consultant and City PC. Institutional arrangement for
implementation IRP as the follows:
9.2.3 Assigned Compositions of the parties involved
TPMB1: (i) responsible for prepare IRP and estimate costs for it to submit to the
ADB and PPC for approval; (ii) reponsible for implementing the IRP; (iii) internal
monitoring and reportregularly of the results and progress to the ADB.
Cam Pha City PC: Cam Pha City PC is responsible for support to implement
income restoration program.
A "Steering Committee of IRP Implementation” will be establishedafter being
approved under TPMB1. This Steering Commiteeincludes:
- Representatives from TPMB1
- At level city: Representative of the City’s leadership, City RC, the related
agencies (Farmer’s Association, Women’s Union, Agriculture Expansion
Station,Economic Department);
- At ward or commune level: Representative of ward or commune, Farmer’s
Association, Women’s Union, Land Officials, village leaders.
The Steering Committee is resposible for inspecting, supervising, monitoring: (i) to
implement the IRP, (ii) to quarterly report on the IRP implementation and (iii) to
participate in solving the issues of implementation process.
9.2.4 Responsibilities
TPMB1plays a key role in the program implementation, TPMB1 is responsible for:
(i) survey, colect data and making the list of participant meeting the criteria and the
real conditions, making the detailed cost estimate and submitting it to the ADB for
approval to implement; (ii) prepare the estential procedures to choose and sign
contract with the organizations/agencies/individuals with expertise in the delivery
of input services such as vocational training, technical training for production
(plants, crop, animals, breeding construction in accordance with the current
regulations and forms of the Laws; (iv) take a final account of IRP implementation
cost and site clearance cost; (v) quartely report on implementation to the ADB.
Steering Committee members at the ward/commune level: shall be responsible for
coordinating with the TPMB1 with support from the consultant in survey, data
collection and make a list of participants in the program according to each model
and checking, monitoring the implementation of the program in the location.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 31 of 56
9.3 Implementation Procedures
- Step 1: Preparation. (within 20 days since the ADB approved the IRP)
TPMB1 consults with the City PC to set a Steering Commitee of IRP
implementation;
TPMB1 held a meeting of Steering Commitee of IRP, to disseminate the content of
IRP of the Project and assign specific tasks for the members; conduct community
meetings to disseminate, instruct the affected households to regist the Program and
make the list of participant by each model in the location.
- Step 2: Submit cost estimation for approval
Based on the surveyed list and the support level for each household by each model
in the location, TPMB1 make a detailed cost estimation to implement;
- Step 3: Implementation.
Based on cost estimation, the TPMB1 conduct selecting and sign contract with the
service providers of vocational training, technical training of prodution, materials
and breeding, food, etc according to the national criteria.
Implement the contracts of service providing meet the objectives and progress of
the Program
The Steering Commitee conduct checking, supervising, monitoring and supporting
based on its functions and responsibilities to the model implementation.
- Step 4: Acception and Final accoument .
The TPMB1 will host the acceptance of training result, service providing for the
model, completing by each contract; payment and final account of the contracts in
accordance with the regulations.
Gather documents for transfering the budget, payment and final account of IRP
implementaion budget.
9.4 Activity mechanism of the Steering Committee of the IRP
The Steering Committee members participate in the IRP implementation on a part
and dissolve upon completion of the Program Implementation. Allowances of
members and stationeries of the Steering Committee are included in the cost
estimate.
Starting time of the Steering Commitee is from the first quarter 2014 until
completing the Progam.
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 32 of 56
Structure of IRP implementing arrangement
Responsibilities of the organizations or agencies in the structure of IRP
implementation
(1) PPC: Responsible for leading, review and approve the IRP after ADB’s approval;
(2) TPMB1: complete the IRP report with the support from Implementation Support
Consultation (Poyry) and submit to ADB and PPC for approval, monitor and submit the
internal monitoring and periodic reports of results and implementation progress to ADB;
(3) Implementation Support Consultation (Poyry): support PPMU in develop the content
and detailed cost estimation of the IRP, support to implement and internal monitoring of
IRP implementation;
(4) City PC, City RC: Responsible for implementing IRP and report to the PPC and
PPMU, leading project ward or commune in implementing;
PPC
Ward/ Commune PC
Implementation
Support Consultation
ISC (Poyry) (3)
(1)
Affected households
participating the IRP
TPMB1
Management and
Implementation
Unit of the IRP
City Cam Pha RC
Implementing Partners
City DED
Vocational Schools or
Center
City Cam Pha WU
City DOLISA
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 33 of 56
(5) Implementing partners (including Provincial Women Union, Vocational Schools,
DOLISA, City DED etc) are responsible for technical assistances, professional
consultation, vocational training, loans for production or business of AHs;
(6) Monitoring Consultant: Responsible for supporting, monitoring and proposal of
adjustment measures for inappropriate contents of the IRP during implementatioon
process
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 34 of 56
10. Implementation Schedule
The activities in this plan are designed for the 12 months, projected from the first quarter
in 2014 to the end of 2014.
Table 10 Implementation Plan for livelihood restoration activities
No Description Year 2014/Quarter Unit/staff
responsible I II III IV
I Preparation of activities
1 Establishment of self-
governing boards
/ administrators/accountants
x TPMB1
2
Provide equipments and
stationeries for IRP
implementation
x TPMB1
Management
and
Implementation
Unit of the IRP
3 Disclosure of information on
policies and livelihood
restoration programs
(through workshops and
local information channels)
x City Cam Pha
Women Union,
TPMB1,
ward/commune
PC
4 Transfer of activities
between the consulting units
x TPMB1
Management
and
Implementation
Unit of the IRP
5 Consultations and
registration of livelihood
restoration model
(continuous development)
x City Cam Pha
Women Union,
TPMB1
6 Negotiations and signing
contracts of cooperation
agreement with vocational
schools
x x TPMB1,
Vocational
Training
Center, Cam
Pha City DED
7 Set up database for the
management of livelihood
restoration households and
sample for specific
management models
x TPMB1
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 35 of 56
No Description Year 2014/Quarter Unit/staff
responsible I II III IV
II Propaganda activities
Information about effective
programs and organization of
sightseeing
x x TPMB1
III Implementation of specific
livelihood restoration
programs
1 Collection of registration
forms for the agriculture
model (including the support
in building the model)
x TPMB1,
Ward/Comune
PC
2 Assessment of the feasibility
and implementation of
models
x TPMB1,
Implementation
Support
Consultation
(Poyry)
3 Signing agreements on the
services support for the
veterinary extension (based
on the registration demand)
x TPMB1,
Vocational
Training
Center,
4 Collection of the additional
registration forms of IRP
x TPMB1
5 Assessment of the
feasibility/additional
consultation and
implementation of the
models
x TPMB1,
Implementation
Support
Consultation
(Poyry)
6 Collection of registration
forms for vocational and
skill training
x x TPMB1
7 Contact with partners and
organization of vocational
and skill training
x TPMB1
8 Contact with employers
(cum training)/for agreement
and negotiations and labor
supply
x TPMB1
III Reviews/coordination
(monitoring and report on x TPMB1,
Implementation
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 36 of 56
No Description Year 2014/Quarter Unit/staff
responsible I II III IV
implementation of the IRP
will be conducted and
submitted to the ADB every
quarter)
Support
Consultation
(Poyry)
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 37 of 56
11. Monitoring and Evaluation
The coordination and evaluation of livelihood restoration programs may be in the
qualitative and quantitative forms of the reporting system or independent evaluation
programs. The assessment can be done by the self-management boards under the
assistance of the supervision consultants and by the external monitoring agency.
Monitoring and report on implementation of the IRP will be conducted and submitted to
the ADB every quarter.
To ensure the objectivity in evaluating impacts of programs while respect the feedback
from households in the programs, the participatory evaluation method by in-depth
interviews and group discussions will be applied;
The assessment and evaluation indicators maybe (but are not limited to) the following:
The outputs of types of crop and livestock before and after participating in a
program;
Total number of persons who have been trained and had jobs;
The percentage of people who have job stability in the total number of trained
people;
The number of sessions of propaganda/training and impact assessment;
The number of employees recruited by contractors;
Economic models (new sectors, types of new production and business) to be
introduced compared to previous models;
Testimonials of people about program impacts;
Changes of scale, output for each specific program (shrimp, catfish, livestock,
poultry, other farming);
Participation rate of poor/vulnerable households in the complex/cooperation
models
The percentage of the poor/vulnerable households approaching project loans
The poverty rate of poor/vulnerable households compared to the previous
indicators (updatedsurvey data in 2012).
Assessment of income restoration extent of affected households after benefiting
from the program compared to the baseline;
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 38 of 56
Appendix
Appendix 1 List of the affected Households
Cộng Hòa commune
No Name of
household head Ethnic
Family member
Job situation of the hhs members Primary
Income Secondary
Income
Male Female
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Employment Unempoyment
1 Bàng Phương Hùng Kinh 2 1 2 3 Worker
Forestry planting
2 Bế Văn Mít Tày 1 1 1 1 2
Forestry planting Trader
3 Bế Văn Viện Tày 1 1 2 1 2 Farmer Forestry planting
4 Bùi Hữu Đài Kinh 2 1 1 2 Farmer Forestry planting
5 Bùi Hữu Luân Kinh 2 1 1 3 Farmer Forestry planting
6 Bùi Đức Chinh Kinh 1 1 Trader Forestry planting
7 Đào Xuân Tuy Kinh 1 1 3 1 Trader Forestry planting
8 Đỗ Thành Minh Kinh 1 1 Worker Trader
9 Đỗ Thị Bảy Kinh 1 3 1 Farmer Worker
10 Hà Thị Thuỷ Tày 3 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
11 Hà Văn Chung Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
12 Hà Văn Lường Tày 1 1
Forestry planting
13 Hà Văn Lưu Kinh 1
Forestry planting
14 Hà Văn Mùi Kinh 2 1 1 2 Trader Forestry planting
15 Hà Văn Năm Kinh 1 1 2 Farmer Forestry Planting
16 Hà Văn Tần Kinh 1 3 4 Farmer Forestry Planting
17 Hà Văn Thuỵ Kinh 1 3 2 3 Farmer Forestry Planting
18 Hoàng Minh Thắng Kinh 1 1 Soldier Trader
19 Hoàng Thị Minh Tày 1 1 1 1 2
Forestry planting
Forestry Planting
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 39 of 56
20 Hoàng Văn Toàn Tày 3 2 5 Farmer Forestry Planting
21 Lại Văn Tòng Kinh 3 1 4 Worker Forestry Planting
22 Mã Văn Sáng Tày 1 2 1 1 3 Farmer Forestry Planting
23 Ngô Thị Vân Kinh 1 1 3 4 Trader Forestry Planting
24 Nguyễn Đức Nhuần Kinh 3 2 5 Trader
Forestry Planting
25 Nguyễn Đức Thành Kinh 1 1 Worker
Forestry Planting
26 Nguyễn Đức Tốt Kinh 1 1 Soldier Forestry Planting
27 Nguyễn Hữu Nhuyên Kinh 2 3 5 Farmer
Forestry Planting
28 Nguyễn Ngọc Hiến Kinh 1 1 Soldier Forestry Planting
29 Nguyễn Thị Thuỷ Kinh 1 2 2 2
Forestry planting
Forestry Planting
30 Nguyễn Thị Tình Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Trader Forestry Planting
31 Nguyễn Văn Huế Kinh 1 1 Soldier Forestry Planting
32 Nguyễn Văn Phượng Kinh 2 2 4 Farmer
Forestry Planting
33 Nguyễn Văn Thành Kinh 1 2 1 2 Farmer
Forestry Planting
34 Nguyễn Văn Tới Kinh 1 1 Soldier Forestry Planting
35 Nông Văn Lan Tày 2 1 1 3
Forestry planting
Forestry Planting
36 Phạm Nam Hương Kinh 1 1 Soldier Forestry Planting
37 Phan Thị Nhật Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Trader Forestry Planting
38 Tô Văn Nà Sán Dìu 1 1 1 2 3
Forestry planting
Forestry Planting
Cam hai:
No Name of
household head Ethnic
Family member Job situation of the hhs members
Primary Income
Secondary Income
Male Female
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Employment Unempoyment
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 40 of 56
1 Bùi Văn Tay Kinh 3 1 2 Forestry Planting
2 Đào Xuân Quang Kinh 1 1 2 2 Forestry Planting
3 Hà Văn Dương Kinh 1 1 Trader
4 Hà Văn Tình Kinh 1 1 Worker Forestry planting
5 Hoàng Văn Ngọc Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Farmer Forestry planting
6 Lê Đức Tính Kinh 1 Trader
7 Lưu Đức Oanh Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Worker Forestry planting
8 Đỗ Văn Lỳ Kinh 2 1 1 3 Forestry Planting
9 Mai Thị Việt Kinh 1 1 2 1 3 Worker
10 Hoàng Văn Ngọc Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Farmer Forestry planting
11 Nguyễn Văn Việt Kinh 1 1 Farmer
12 Nguyễn Văn Tần Kinh 3 2 5 Farmer Forestry
planting
13 Nông Thị Vấn Tày 1 Trader
14 Phạm Bá Quyết Kinh 1 1 2 Worker
15 Phạm Thị Gái Kinh 2 2 3 2 Aquaculture Forestry
planting
16 Trần Thị Thúy Nga Kinh 3 1 3 Worker Forestry
planting
17 Phạm Thị Thu Ánh Kinh 1 1 2 Worker Forestry
planting
18 Trương Thị Dịu Kinh 1 1 1 2 Worker
19 Trương Văn Trò Kinh 2 1 Aquaculture
20 Trần Thị Bùng Kinh 1 1 1 1 Aquaculture
Forestry planting
21 Trần Thị Châu Kinh 1 1 Trader
22 Từ Minh Ngọc
Sán Dìu 1 2 1 2 Farrmer
Forestry planting
23 Hoàng Văn Nghiên
Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Aquaculture Forestry planting
24 Nguyễn Văn Vi Kinh 1 1 Worker
25 Vũ Thị Chạp Kinh 4 3 7 Aquaculture
26 Hà Mạnh Hùng Kinh 1 2 1 2 Worker Forestry
planting
27 Nguyễn Văn Thắng
Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 Worker Forestry
planting
28 Lý Văn Quân Kinh 1 1 1 2 Worker
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 41 of 56
No10.ward
No Name of
household head Ethnic
Sexual
Job situation of the hhs members Primary
income Secondary
income
Male Female
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Under 18
years old
Above 18
years old
Employment Unempoyment
1 Bàn Văn Năm Dao 1 1 1 2
Farmer
2 Bùi Quang Chiến Kinh 1 3 1 2 Farmer
3 Bùi Quang Chính Kinh 1 Farmer
4 Bùi Quang Cường Kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer
5 Đàm Văn Ắm Tày 1 2 1 2 Farmer
6 Đặng A Sắt Dao 1 1 2 2 Farmer
7 Đặng A Ửng Dao 3 1 3 2 Worker
8 Đặng Phúc Tiến Dao 2 1 1 3 Farmer
9 Đặng Thị Loan Kinh 1 1 3 Worker
10 Đặng Văn Ba Dao 2 1 3 2 2 Worker
11 Đặng Văn Nguyên Dao 1 1 2 1 1 Worker
12 Đặng Văn Tư Dao 3 1 2 1 5 Farmer
13 Đặng Xuân Ba Dao 1 1 1 1 Farmer
14 Đặng Xuân Cường Dao 2 1 1 1 2 Farmer
15 Đặng Xuân Lương Dao 1 1 1 2 Farmer
16 Đặng Xuân Minh Dao 1 3 Farmer
17 Đào Đức Thọ Kinh 1 1 1 2 Farmer
18 Đào Văn Chuỳ Kinh 1 1 1 2 Worker
19 Đỗ Thị Hồng Kinh 2 1 1 Retirement
20 Đỗ Văn Biên Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 Farmer
21 Hà Văn Hầu Tày 1 1 1 3 1 Forestry planting
22 Hồ Quay Phương Dao 1 1 1 1 2 2 Farmer
23 Hồ Văn Đức Dao 2 1 2 1 2 Farmer
24 Hồ Văn Phúc Dao 1 1 1 1 Worker
25 Hồ Văn Thanh 1 2 2 1 7 Worker
26 Hoàng Thị Bé Tày 1 1 1 2 Farmer
27 Hoàng Thị Kim Dao 2 1 2 1 2 Farmer
28 Hoàng Thị Liên Tày 1 3 2 2 Forestry planting
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 42 of 56
29 Hoàng Văn Anh Kinh 1 1 1 Forestry planting
30 Hoàng Văn Khoa Tày, Dao 1 1 1 1 1 Farmer
31 Hoàng Xuân Đoàn Tày 1 1 1 1 Forestry planting
32 La Văn Bộ Tày 2 1 1 1 Forestry planting
33 La Văn Huấn Tày 1 2 Farmer
34 Lê Văn Nam Kinh 1 2 2 2 Farmer
35 Lê Văn Nhất Kinh 1 2 3 2 Worker
36 Loan Văn Phổ Tày 1 Forestry planting
37 Loan Văn Quang Tày 2 1 Forestry planting
38 Loan Văn Tô Tày 1 1 Worker
39 Loan Văn Tường Tày, Nùng 1 2 2 Worker
40 Loan Văn Việt Tày 1 2 Forestry planting
41 Lộc Văn Vương Tày, Kinh 2 1 1
Forestry planting
42 Lục Văn Hùng Tày 1 1 Forestry planting
43 Lương Văn Cò Tày 1 1 Forestry planting
44 Lương Văn Yên Tày, Dao 1 1
Forestry planting
45 Lý Minh Trọng Dao 1 1 1 Farmer
46 Lý Minh Tuấn Dao 1 1 Farmer
47 Lý Thị Hai Dao 2 2 Farmer
48 Lý Thị Tư Dao 1 Farmer
49 Lý Văn Hai Dao 2 1 2 1 Farmer
50 Lý Văn Năm Dao 2 1 2 1 2 Forestry planting
51 Lý Văn Phúc Dao 2 1 2 Forestry planting
52 Lý Văn Sáu Dao 2 1 2 1 Farmer Forestry planting
53 Lý Văn Tư Dao 2 2 1 1 2 Farmer Forestry planting
54 Lý Văn Việt Dao 2 2 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
55 Lý Xuân Cảnh Dao 3 1 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
56 Lý Xuân Minh Dao 2 1 3 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
57 Lý Xuân Thắng (Lý Xuân Hồng) Dao 1 1 2 1 3
Forestry planting
58 Ngọc Văn Bẩy Tày 1 1 1 1 2 Forestry planting
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 43 of 56
59 Ngọc Văn Chiều Tày 4 1 1 Forestry planting
60 Ngọc Văn Miêu Tày 1 1 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
61 Nguyễn Bảo Long Kinh, Dao 1 1 1 1 Farmer
Forestry planting
62 Nguyễn Đức Thức Kinh 1 1 2 1 Farmer Forestry planting
63 Nguyễn Như Đạo Kinh 2 1 1 2 Retirement Forestry planting
64 Nguyễn Quốc Đệ Kinh 1 1 2 1 Retirement Forestry planting
65 Nguyễn Sỹ Nam Kinh 1 Worker
66 Nguyễn Thanh Cảnh Tày 1
Forestry planting
67 Nguyễn Thị Hoa Kinh 2 2 Forestry planting
68 Nguyễn Thị Linh Kinh 1 1 2 Forestry planting
69 Nguyễn Văn Long Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 Worker
70 Nguyễn Văn Luân Kinh 1 1 Farmer
71 Nguyễn Văn Nức Kinh 1 2 Farmer
72 Nguyễn Văn Sỹ Kinh, Tày 1 2 1 Farmer
73 Nguyễn Văn Tá Tày 1 1 1 1 2 Farmer
74 Nguyễn Văn Thanh Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 Worker
75 Nguyễn Văn Thụy Kinh 1 2 1 2 1 Worker
76 Nguyễn Xuân Qúy (Qúy Ngà) Kinh 1 1 1 1 Trader
77 Nông Quốc Khánh Tày 2 4 1 Worker
78 Nông Văn Toản Tày 1 Forestry planting
79 Phạm Huy Cường Kinh 1 1 Forestry planting
80 Phạm Thị Giang Kinh 1 1 Forestry planting
81 Phoòng Cắm Công Dao 1 1
Forestry planting
82 Phoòng Cắm Tắc Dao 2 1 1 1 Forestry planting
83 Phoòng Cắm Thành Dao 1 1 1 1 1
Forestry planting
84 Phoòng Đình Huy Dao 1 2 1 1 Farmer
85 Phoòng Đình Phú Dao 1 2 Farmer
86 Phoòng Đình Thống Dao 3 1 1 1 Farmer
87 Phoòng Đình Vinh Dao 1 2 1 2 1 Forestry planting Worker
88 Phoòng Tắc Qúy Dao 1 2 1 3 1 Forestry planting Worker
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 44 of 56
89 Phoòng Tài Múi Dao 1 1 Forestry planting
90 Phoòng Thị Mai Dao, Kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer
91 Phoòng Văn Sinh Dao 3 1 1 2 1 Farmer Forestry planting
92 Phoòng Văn Tư Dao 2 2 1 Farmer Forestry planting
93 Phùn A Hải Dao 1 1 1 Farmer
94 Phùn A Phúc Dao 1 1 3 1 1 Forestry planting
95 Phùn A Sơn Dao 1 3 Forestry planting
96 Phùn Văn Tư (Phoòng Thị Mai) Dao 1 1 1 1 Farmer
97 Tạ Hữu Hợi Kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer Worker
98 Triệu Chăn Thống Dao 1 1 1 1 Trader Worker
99 Triệu Kim Tề Dao 5 4 1 Forestry planting Worker
100 Triệu Quý Bình Dao 2 1 1 Forestry planting Worker
101 Triệu Quý Dếnh Dao 2 1 2 1 Forestry planting
102 Triệu Quý Quân Dao 3 2 1 1 2 Forestry planting
103 Triệu Qúy Sáng Dao 3 1 4 1 1 Worker
104 Triệu Xuân Lợi Dao, Chiêm 1 1 4 Worker
105 Vi Văn Đăng Tày, kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer
Forestry planting
106 Vi Xuân Lộc Tày 1 1 3 1 Farmer Forestry planting
107 Vũ Văn Tơn Kinh 1 1 Trader Forestry planting
108 Phùn Thị Minh Dao 1 1 2 1 Aquaculture
109 Vi Thị Hồng Tày 1 3 2 Farmer
110 Vi Thị Huệ Tày 1 3 Farmer
111 Vi Văn Muội Tày 1 3 Farmer Forestry planting
112 Triệu Quang Sáu Farmer Forestry planting
113 Vi Văn Đăng Tày, kinh 1 1 1 1
Forestry planting
114 Vi Xuân Lộc Tày 1 1 3 1 Forestry planting Trader
115 Vũ Văn Tơn Kinh 1 1 Forestry planting
116 Đỗ Thị Hồng Kinh 2 1 Trader
117 Đỗ Văn Biên Kinh 1 1 1 Trader
118 Triệu Chăn Thống Dao 1 1 1 1 Worker
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 45 of 56
119 Lý Văn Việt Dao 2 2 1 1 Farmer Forestry planting
120 Triệu Kim Tề Dao 5 4 1 Farmer
Appendix 2 List of vocational training centers in Quang Ninh province.
No. Names of the
vocational training
centers
Locations &
Phone numbers
Management
agency
Vocation & scale of training
I Vocational School
Vocational School-
Belong the
Industrial College
Cam Pha
No 78, Nguyễn
Văn Trỗi, Cẩm
Thuỷ, Cẩm Phả,
Quảng Ninh
ĐT: (033) 3862
091
http://www.cdcnc
p.edu.vn
Industrial
College Cam
Pha
Computer Network Administration,
Technical repairs, computer
assembly, Civil power, Electricity
industry, South, Processing plants
and product design, Textile- fashion,
Business accounting
Vocational School-
Belong the
Industrial and
Construction
College Quang ninh
767 Nguyễn văn
Cừ, TP. Hạ Long,
Quảng Ninh
ĐT: 033.835272
Department of
Trade and
Industry
Quang Ninh_
Industry Training: South, Computer
network administration, Sewing
fashion, Business accounting,
Electricity industry
Vocational School
of Commerce –
Tourism Quang
ninh
No.58, Nguyễn
Văn Cừ, Hồng
Hải, TP Hạ Long,
Quảng Ninh
ĐT: (033) 3854
497
http://www.halon
gact.edu.vn
Thanh Hoa
Department of
Trade and
Industry
Food processing techniques, - Tourist
Guide, Restaurant Service,
Travel Management - restaurants –
hotels, Electronics, Automotive
technology, South, Metal cutting,
Techniques refrigeration and air
conditioning, Devices, Repair
techniques and computer assembly,
Information Technology, Business
accounting,
Vocational School
Cam Pha city
Cam Son ward,
Cam Pha city
People’s
committee of
Cam Pha
Exploiting radio equipment, Mining
TV equipment, Electronics, Industrial
electronics, Civil power, Information
technology, Computer network
administration, Reporters and editors
base station, Business accounting;
The school enrollment 200students in
2011.
Vocational School -
Belong to the
Mining College of
Hong Cam mining
company
No2, Bạch Long,
P. Bạch Đằng,
TP. Hạ Long,
Quảng Ninh.
ĐT: 033.626306 –
Hong Cam
mining
company
Training human resources for the
sector of mining include: Electricity
industry, Electronics, Automotive
technology, South, Metal cutting,
Techniques refrigeration and air
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 46 of 56
No. Names of the
vocational training
centers
Locations &
Phone numbers
Management
agency
Vocation & scale of training
Fax: 033.62630 conditioning, Devices, Repair
techniques and computer assembly,
Information Technology
Vocational School -
Belong to the
Mining College of
Huu Nghi mining
company
Thanh Sơn ward,
Uông Bí, Quảng
Ninh
ĐT: 033.54467 –
Fax: 033.584306
Huu Nghi
Mining
company
Training human resources for the
sector of mining include: Electricity
industry, Electronics, Automotive
technology, South, Metal cutting,
Techniques refrigeration and air
conditioning, Devices, Repair
techniques and computer assembly,
Information Technology
II Colleges, Intermediate-level professional have vocational training
Industrial
Vocational College
Cam Pha city
No 78, Nguyễn
Văn Trỗi, Cẩm
Thuỷ, Cẩm Phả,
Quảng Ninh
ĐT: (033) 3862
091
http://www.cdcnc
p.edu.vn
Minister of
Labor Invalids
and Social
Affairs
Industry Training: Industrial
Electronics, Automotive technology,
South, Metal cutting, Techniques
refrigeration and air conditioning,
Devices, Repair techniques and
computer assembly, Information
Technology, Business accounting,
Sewing and fashion design;
Industrial and
Constructional
Vocational College
Uong Bi city
Phương Đông,
Uông Bí, Quảng
Ninh
ĐT: (033) 3854
497
, Department
of Labor,
Invalids and
Social affairs
Quang ninh
province
Colleges level : including 200
training target 36 months:
- Business Accounting
- Corporate Governance
- Food
- Hotel Management
Electronics Industry, Civil power,
Sewing Machine Repair, Technical
refrigeration and air conditioning,
Food processing
techniquesIntermediate level: 120
training target 24 months include:
- Business Accounting
- Corporate Governance
- Food Processing 40
Primary system: 7 trades with 1795
targets school from 3 to 6 months
(according to the scheme of the
Prime Minister 1956)
- Growing of crops
- Information Technology
- Tourist Guide
- Automotive Technology
- Restaurant Service
- Techniques for sugar cane
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 47 of 56
No. Names of the
vocational training
centers
Locations &
Phone numbers
Management
agency
Vocation & scale of training
- Mushroom cultivation techniques
III Vocational training center
Center of Informal
Education and
Vocational Training
of Cam Pha City
No.11 Cam Son,
Campha City
Department of
Education and
Training
Short-term vocational training:
mechanic, technique of processing
food and tourism services,
application computer, vocational
training for the farmers whose land is
recovered.
Center for
Vocational and
driver training-
People’s police
Academy
Hon Gai, Halong,
Quang ninh
Ministry of
Public
Security
Organize of training and licensing
drivers
Quảng ninh
Centers for
Vocational training
Thanh Hoa union
Bãi Cháy ward,
Hạ Long city,
Quảng Ninh
Tel: 033.3846.182
General Labor
Confederation
of Vietnam.
The array of activities: Consulting
job training, job placement, and
policies related to labor relations,
provide information on the labor
market, About jobs in countries and
to work in labor-exporting. The
Center has allowed eight vocational
training and vocational elementary
level include: Sewing Industry,
Mechanics (mound-welding) ,
Information Technology Office,
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 48 of 56
No. Names of the
vocational training
centers
Locations &
Phone numbers
Management
agency
Vocation & scale of training
Electronics Industry, Civil power,
Sewing Machine Repair, Technical
refrigeration and air conditioning,
Food processing techniques; and
Link training on the needs of
learners.
Centers for
Vocational training
Đầm Hà
Đầm Hà Town,
Quảng ninh
Department of
Education and
Training
Vocational training: Motorcycles
repair and paint refurbish, Car repair,
Civil power repair, utilities,
Electronic repair, Refrigeration,
Engineering(weldingmound),
Accounting , Driving
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 49 of 56
Appendix 3 Comparison between pre-project income and expected incomes gained from proposed
income restoration programs mentioned above
To illustrate better the possibility to restore the income of affected households who have
the remaining land which is still viable to cultivate, it is assumed that the household has
the income from 2,000 m2 of paddy planting, they will be acquired the land in different
scenarios like 10%, 30%, 50% and 70%, their expected income correspondingly after
successfully participating in the income restoration programs will be presented in two
tables below. According to results of income restoration assessment, almost all severely
affected households registered to participate in high yield paddy cultivate program,
husbandry program, and one young member of their family participating in vocational
training. Therefore, in general they can have three income sources from Income
Restoration Programs as the follows:
Comparison between pre-project income of AH and expected incomes of AH gained from the
proposed income restoration programs
Annual Incomes of AH from agriculture land
pre-project and after land acquisition
corresponding with scenario of land acquired
Expected Annual Income of AH from Proposed
Income restoration programs
Rate of
land
acquired
Income
pre-
project
from land
Income
from
remaining
land
Loss of
income
from land
Hygiene
vegetable
growing on
remaining
land
Pig raising
increase
after attend
training
Poultry
raising
increase
after attend
training
Total
10% of
agriculture
land
12,000,00
0
10,800,00
0 (1,200,000) 18,360,000 7,000,000 8,500,000 50,060,000
30% of
agriculture
land
12,000,00
0 8,400,000 (3,600,000) 14,280,000 7,000,000 8,500,000 42,380,000
50% of
agriculture
land
12,000,00
0 6,000,000 (6,000,000) 10,200,000 7,000,000 8,500,000 34,700,000
70% of
agriculture
land
12,000,00
0 3,600,000 (8,400,000) 6,120,000 7,000,000 8,500,000 27,020,000
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 50 of 56
Annual Income from agriculture land pre-project and Income after land acquisition
corresponding with scenario of land acquired
Rate of
land
acquired
Income
pre-project
from land
Income
from
remaining
land
Loss of
income
from land
Acacia
Cultivating
remaining
land
(Percent)
Rear the
cattle
(cows)
(Percent)
Total
(Percent)
10% of
agriculture
land/Fores
tryland 12,000,000 10,800,000 (1,200,000) 1.53 0.58 4.17
30% of
agriculture
land/Fores
try land 12,000,000 8,400,000 (3,600,000) 1.19 0.58 3.53
50% of
agriculture
land/forest
ry land 12,000,000 6,000,000 (6,000,000) 0.85 0.58 2.89
70% of
agriculture
land/forest
ry land 12,000,000 3,600,000 (8,400,000) 0.51 0.58 2.25
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 51 of 56
Appendix 4 Registration forms for Income Restoration
MONG DUONG THERMAL POWER PROJECT – SOCIO ECONOMIC SURVEY FOR
IRP
REGISTRATION OF ASPIRATION
PARTICIPATION IN ECONOMIC RECOVERY PROGRAMS
Only applied to households moved houses or acquired with 10% agricultural land and/or
affected income source from production/business/service and/or the vulnerable household)
Component: ………………………………………………………..……………..
Ward/commune: ………………............ Hamlet/quarter: …………………………..…….
Date/month/year:............../........./2013
I. GENERAL INFORMATION:
C1. Name of affected householder (land owner):………….……………..
Address: ………………………………………………………….……….
Telephone: ………………………………………………………….……
C2. Main occupation:
1.Farmer 7.Handicraft
2.Worker 8. Unemployment
3.State officials 9. Housemaid
4. Businessman 10. Retirement
5. Soldier/security 11. Pupils/student
6. Free occupation 12. Other (Detail):
……………………………..
C3. Gender: 1. Male 2. Family
C4. Age: ……………………...
C5. Group: ………………………...
C6. Education:
0. Iliteracy 3. High School
1. Primary School 4. College/University
2. Secondary School 5. Post Graduate
C7. Status of acquired agricultural land
1. No acquired productive land
2. 10% - 30% production land
3. 30% - 70% production land
4. > 70% production land
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 52 of 56
C8. Aeffected business?
1. Yes 2. No
C9. New residence ?
1. No resettlement
2. Will move to resettlement site
3. Self-arrange resettlement
4. Self-arrange resettlement elsewhere
C10. Vulnerable household:
1. No vulnerable household 6. Disable
2. Poor (with certificate) 7. Revolution household
3. Invalid/martyr 8. Loneliness household
4. Loneliness Elderly 9. Other:...........................
5. Female-headed household (with dependant)
C11. Information of member in the households (in the household book):
Total of members:…......person
No Full name Relationship
to householder
(a)
Gender
(b)
Age Education
(c)
Main
occupation
(d)
Total of
average
income per
month
(dong/month/
person)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Code:(a): Relationship to householder: 1.Householder; 2.Spouse ; 3.Children; 4.Parents;
5.Grandfather/mother; 6.Niece/ Nephew; 7.Brother/sister; 8.Relatives
(b):Gender: 1.Male; 2. Female
(c): Education:1.Illiteracy; 2.Primary; 3. Secondary; 4. High school; 5. Colleague/
University; 6. Master
(d): Occupation: 1.Farmer; 2.Worker; 3. State Officials; 4. Businessman; 5. Soldier/security;
6. Free occupation; 7.Handicraft; 8. Unemployment;9. Housemaid;
10. Retirement; 11.Pupils/student; 12. Other (Detail): ……………………..
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 53 of 56
C12. Income source of household:
No Income (estimate) Amount (dong/hh/month)
1 From salary
2 From agriculture/forest/aquaculture
3 From business/service
4 From giving/policy allowance
5 From other: free occupations
6 Total
C13. Living standard classification:
1. Poor 2. Near poor 3. Average 4. Fair 5. Rich
C14. Average expenditure per month (dong/month):
No Detailed expenditure (estimate) Amount (dong/hh/month)
1 Food
2 Education (school fee, books, etc.)
3 Health
4 Electricity
5 Water
6 Environment and security fee
7 Cost for production/business/trade/service
8 Traveling, clothing, shopping, wedding, etc
9 Other costs
10 Total expenditure
C15. In 12 months ago, did Household obtain loans?
1. Yes 2. No
C16. If so, Purpose of loan?
1 Husbandry/Farming Amount: ………………………………
2 Family expense Amount: ………………………………
3 School fee Amount: ………………………………
4 Business Amount: ………………………………
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 54 of 56
5 Housing Amount: ………………………………
6 Other (detailed):……………… Amount: ………………………………
Monthly interest? …………………………………………………………………
II. FOR HOUSEHOLDS WHO ARE IN NEED OF PRODUCTION,
CULTIVATION AND HUSBANDARY
C17. At present what are your main types of cultivation/husbandry…………………
C18. Do you plan to continue or expand these types of cultivation/husbandry?
1. Yes 2. No
C19.If yes, what do you want the Project to support to continue developing
cultivation/husbandry?
1.Support for more capital 3.Introduction output 5. Other (detail)
2.Visiting model 4. Technical training
C20. Do you plan to change to any new types of cultivation/husbandry?
1. Yes 2. No
(If yes, what type of models …………………….…………………………………)
Estimated capital: (if possible)…………………………………………………
C21. What do you want the Project to support to Pilot or change to new types of
cultivation/husbandry:
1.Support for more capital 3.Introduction output 5. Other (detail)
2.Visiting model 4. Technical training
III. FOR HOUSEHOLDS WHO ARE IN NEED OF VOCATIONAL TRAINING AND
JOB CREATION
(for members who participated in job training may enroll in advanced training)
C22. In your family, are there any members attending a vocational training
organized in your locality? 1.Yes 2. No
C23. If yes, please inform the table below (list all training sessions, short-term and
long-term, including production and business skills)
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 55 of 56
No Full name Age Gender Names of
any
attended
job
training
courses
Time
(month) Training
venue
(Name of
school/vocatio
nal training
center
/agricultural
extension
center, ...)
Job after
training
Funds
(If the State’s
funds, make
lear what
kind of the
programs)
1
2
3
4
5
C24. Please register specific names of family members who wish to participate in
vocational training:
No Full name Age Gender
Education Expected
job
Expected
workplace
Expected
salary (VNĐ/month)
Expected
time for
learning
(months
1
2
3
4
5
IV. FOR HOUSEHOLDS WHO ARE IN NEED OF SUPPORT TO CONTINUE OR
CHANGE TO PRODUCTION - BUSINESS
C25. What are your types of production and business?
.................................................................
C26.What do you want the Project to support to continue or expand your production
and business? 1. Yes 2.No
C27. If yes, what kind of support:
1.Allowance for more capital 3. Introduction of output
2.Technical training 4. Touring patterns
5. Touring patterns……………………………
C28.Do you plan to change to new types of production and business? 1.Yes: 2.No:
Income and Livelihood Restoration Programme Report
Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project
Page 56 of 56
C29. What do you want the Project to support tochange to new types of production and
business?
Yes: No:
C30. If yes, what kind of support:
1.Allowance for more capital 3. Introduction of output
2.Technical training 4. Touring patterns
5. Touring patterns……………………………
C31. Do you want to establish a consortium/joint venture or other partnerships or not?
1. Yes: 2. No:
V. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
If you have any suggestions or desire, please write in the space below.
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
THANK YOU VERY MUCH!
Certification of household Certification of consultant Certification of local authority