In Re 2003 Bar Exams

8/9/2019 In Re 2003 Bar Exams

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/in-re-2003-bar-exams 1/6

Republic of the Philippines

SUPREME COURT

Manila

EN BANC

B.M. No. 1222 April 24, 2009

RE: 2003 BAR EXAMINATIONS

x - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x

ATTY. DANIO DE !U"MAN, Petitioner,

R E S O L U ! O N

YNARES#SANTIA!O, J.:

his treats the Petition for "u#icial Cle$enc% an# Co$passion #ate# No&e$ber '(, )((* file# b% petitioner +anilo #e

u$an. /e pra%s that this /onorable Court 0in the exercise of e1uit% an# co$passion, 2rant petitioner3s plea for 4u#icialcle$enc%, an# thereupon, or#er his reinstate$ent as a $e$ber in 2oo# stan#in2 of the Philippine Bar.0'

o recall, on 5ebruar% 6, )((6, the Court pro$ul2ate# a Resolution, in B.M. No. '))), the #ispositi&e portion of 7hich

rea#s in part8

9/ERE5ORE, the Court, actin2 on the reco$$en#ations of the !n&esti2atin2 Co$$ittee, hereb% resol&es to :

;'< +!SBAR Att%. +AN!LO +E U=MAN fro$ the practice of la7 effecti&e upon his receipt of this RESOLU!ON>

x x x x

he sub4ect of the Resolution is the lea?a2e of 1uestions in Mercantile La7 #urin2 the )((@ Bar Exa$inations. Petitioner

at that ti$e 7as e$plo%e# as an assistant la7%er in the la7 fir$ of Bal2os Pere, one of 7hose partners, Marcial

Bal2os, 7as the exa$iner for Mercantile La7 #urin2 the sai# bar exa$inations. he Court ha# a#opte# the fin#in2s of the

!n&esti2atin2 Co$$ittee, 7hich i#entifie# petitioner as the person 7ho ha# #o7nloa#e# the test 1uestions fro$ the

co$puter of Bal2os an# faxe# the$ to other persons.

he Office of the Bar Confi#ant ;OBC< has fa&orabl% reco$$en#e# the reinstate$ent of petitioner in the Philippine Bar.

!n a Report #ate# "anuar% , )((, the OBC ren#ere# its assess$ent of the petition, the rele&ant portions of 7hich 7e

1uote hereun#er8

Petitioner narrate# that he ha# labore# to beco$e a la7%er to fulfill his father3s chil#hoo# #rea$ to beco$e one. his tas?

7as not particularl% eas% for hi$ an# his fa$il% but he 7ille# to en#ure the sa$e in or#er to pa% tribute to his parents.

Petitioner a##e# that e&en at a &er% %oun2 a2e, he alrea#% i$pose# upon hi$self the #ut% of ren#erin2 ser&ice to his

fello7$en. At ' %ears, he starte# his exposure to public ser&ice 7hen he 7as electe# Chair$an of the San22unian2

Dabataan ;SD< of Baran2a% u?tu?an, a2ui2 Cit%. +urin2 this ti$e, he initiate# se&eral pro4ects benefitin2 the %outh in

their baran2a%.

hereafter, petitioner focuse# on his stu#ies, ta?in2 up Bachelor of Arts in Political Science an# e&entuall% pursuin2Bachelor of La7s. !n his secon# %ear in la7 school, he 7as electe# as the Presi#ent of the Stu#ent Council of the !nstitute

of La7 of the 5ar Eastern Uni&ersit% ;5EU<. /ere, he spearhea#e# &arious acti&ities inclu#in2 the con#uct of se$inars for

la7 stu#ents as 7ell as the hol#in2 of bar operations for bar exa$inees.

http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2009/apr2009/bm_1222_2009.html#fnt1




+espite his $an% extra-curricular acti&ities as a %outh an# stu#ent lea#er, petitioner still $ana2e# to excel in his stu#ies.

hus, he 7as conferre# an Aca#e$ic Excellence A7ar# upon his 2ra#uation in Bachelor of La7s.

Upon a#$ission to the bar in April ', petitioner i$$e#iatel% entere# 2o&ern$ent ser&ice as a Le2al Officer assi2ne#

at the San22unian2 Ba%an of a2ui2. Si$ultaneousl%, he also ren#ere# free le2al ser&ices to less fortunate resi#ents of

a2ui2 Cit% 7ho 7ere then in nee# of le2al assistance.

!n March )(((, petitioner 7as hire# as one of the Associate La7%ers at the Bal2os an# Pere La7 Offices. !t 7as #urin2

his sta% 7ith this fir$ 7hen his craft as a la7%er 7as polishe# an# #e&elope#. +espite ha&in2 entere# pri&ate practice, he

continue# to ren#er free le2al ser&ices to his fello7 a2ui2eos.

hen in 5ebruar% )((6, b% a su##en t7ist of fate, petitioner3s flourishin2 career 7as cut short as he 7as strippe# of his

license to practice la7 for his alle2e# in&ol&e$ent in the lea?a2e in the )((@ Bar Exa$inations.

+e&astate#, petitioner then practicall% loc?e# hi$self insi#e his house to a&oi# the rather una&oi#able conse1uences of his

#isbar$ent.

On March )((6, ho7e&er, petitioner 7as 2i&en a ne7 lease in life 7hen he 7as ta?en as a consultant b% the Cit%

o&ern$ent of a2ui2. Later, he 7as #esi2nate# as a $e$ber of the Secretariat of the People3s La7 Enforce$ent Boar#

;PLEB<. 5or the next fi&e ;F< %ears, petitioner concentrate# $ainl% on ren#erin2 public ser&ice.

Petitioner hu$bl% ac?no7le#2e# the #a$a2in2 i$pact of his act 7hich unfortunatel%, co$pro$ise# the inte2rit% of the

bar exa$inations. As coul# be borne fro$ the recor#s of the in&esti2ation, he cooperate# full% in the in&esti2ation

con#ucte# an# too? personal responsibilit% for his actions. Also, he has offere# his sincerest apolo2ies to Att%. Bal2os, to

the Court as 7ell as to all the )((@ bar exa$inees for the unforeseen an# uninten#e# effects of his actions.

Petitioner a&erre# that he has since learne# fro$ his $ista?es an# has ta?en the sai# hu$blin2 experience to $a?e hi$ a

better person.

Mean7hile, as part of his Petition, petitioner sub$itte# the follo7in2 testi$onials an# en#orse$ents of &arious

in#i&i#uals an# entities all attestin2 to his 2oo# $oral character8

'< Resolution No. '(', Series of )((G, 0Resolution Expressin2 5ull Support to +anilo . +e u$an in hisApplication for "u#icial Cle$enc%, En#orsin2 his Co$petence an# 5itness to be Reinstate# as a Me$ber of the

Philippine Bar an# for Other Purposes0 #ate# 6 "une )((G of the San22unian2 Panlun2so#, Cit% of a2ui2>

)< 0!san2 Bu?as na Liha$ na Na2lala%on2 !paratin2 sa Dataas-aasan2 /u?u$an an2 Buon2 Suporta n2

Pa$unuan at $2a Dasapi n2 Southeast People3s Hilla2e /o$eo7ners Association, !nc. ;SEP/HOA< ?a% +anilo

. +e u$an sa Dan%an2 Petis%on2 Ma2a7aran n2 Dapata7aran at an2 Boluntar%on2 Pa2-susulon2 sa

Dan%an2 Da?a%ahan Upan2 Maibali? sa Dan%a an2 $2a Pribilehi%o n2 !san2 Abo2a#o0 #ate# ' "une )((G of the

Southeast People3s Hilla2e /o$eo7ners Association, !nc. ;SEP/HOA<, !ba%o-ipas, Cit% of a2ui2>

@< 0!san2 Bu?as na Liha$ na Na2lala%on2 !paratin2 sa Dataas-aasan2 /u?u$an an2 Buon2 Suporta n2

Pa$unuan at $2a Dasapi n2 Sa$ahan2 Resi#ente n2 Maulin2 Cree?, !nc. ;SAREMAC< ?a% . +anilo . +e

u$an sa Dan%an2 Petis%on2 Ma2a7aran n2 Dapata7aran at an2 Boluntar%on2 Pa2-susulon2 sa Dan%an2Da?a%ahan Upan2 Maibali? sa Dan%a an2 $2a Pribilehi%o n2 !san2 Abo2a#o0 #ate# ' "une )((G of the

Sa$ahan2 Resi#ente n2 Maulin2 Cree?, !nc. ;SAREMAC<, Lo7er Bicutan, Cit% of a2ui2>

6< 0!san2 Bu?as na Liha$ na Na2lala%on2 !paratin2 sa Dataas-aasan2 /u?u$an an2 Buon2 Suporta n2

Pa$unuan at $2a Dasapi n2 Sa$ahan n2 $2a Maralita ;PULON DEN+!< Nei2hborhoo# Association, !nc.

;SAMANA< ?a% . +anilo . +e u$an sa Dan%an2 Petis%on2 Ma2a7aran n2 Dapata7aran at an2

Boluntar%on2 Pa2-susulon2 sa Dan%an2 Da?a%ahan Upan2 Maibali? sa Dan%a an2 $2a Pribilehi%o n2 !san2

Abo2a#o0 #ate# ' "une )((G of the Sa$ahan n2 $2a Maralita ;PULON DEN+!< Nei2hborhoo# Association,

!nc. ;SAMANA<, Sta. Ana, Cit% of a2ui2>



F< 0An Open Letter Attestin2 Personall% to the Co$petence an# 5itness of +anilo . +e u$an as to 9arrant

the rant of "u#icial Cle$enc% an# his Reinstate$ent as Me$ber of the Philippine Bar0 #ate# * "une )((G of

Mi2uelito Naareno H. Llantino, Lao2an, respeses an# Llantino La7 Offices>

< 0esti$onial to the Moral an# Spiritual Co$petence of +anilo . +e u$an to be rul% +eser&in2 of "u#icial

Cle$enc% an# Co$passion0 #ate# F "ul% )((G of Re&. 5r. Paul . Bala2tas, Parish Priest, Arch#iocesan Shrine of

St. Anne>

G< 0esti$onial Letter0 #ate# '* 5ebruar% )((* of Att%. Loreto C. Ata, Presi#ent, 5ar Eastern Uni&ersit% La7

Alu$ni Association ;5EULAA<, 5ar Eastern Uni&ersit% ;5EU<>

*< 0!san2 Bu?as na Liha$ na Na2lala%on2 !paratin2 sa Dataas-aasan2 /u?u$an an2 Buon2 Suporta n2

Pa$unuan at $2a Dasapi n2 Sa$ahan2 Bisi2 Da$a% sa Daunlaran, !nc. ;SAB!SDA< ?a% . +anilo . +e

u$an sa Dan%an2 Petis%on2 Ma2a7aran n2 Dapata7aran at an2 Boluntar%on2 Pa2-susulon2 sa Dan%an2

Da?a%ahan Upan2 Maibali? sa Dan%a an2 $2a Pribilehi%o n2 !san2 Abo2a#o0 #ate# * "ul% )((* of the

Sa$ahan2 Bisi2 Da$a% sa Daunlaran, !nc. ;SAB!SDA<>

< Boar# Resolution No. (), Series of )((*, 0A Resolution Reco2niin2 the Contributions of +anilo . +e

u$an to the People3s La7 Enforce$ent Boar# ;PLEB< I a2ui2 Cit%, Attestin2 to his Ut$ost +e#ication an#

Co$$it$ent to the Call of Ci&ic an# Social +ut% an# for Other Purposes0 #ate# '' "ul% )((* of the People3s La7

Enforce$ent Boar# ;PLEB<>

'(< 0A Personal Appeal for the rant of "u#icial 5or2i&eness an# Co$passion in 5a&or of +anilo . +e u$an0

#ate# '6 "ul% )((* of Att%. E#7in R. San#o&al, Professor, Colle2e of La7, San Sebastian Colle2e I Recoletos>

''< 0An Open Letter Personall% Attestin2 to the Moral co$petence an# 5itness of +anilo . +e u$an0 #ate# F

Septe$ber )((* of Mr. Nixon 5. 5a#ero2, +eput% ran# JDnKi2ht, Dni2hts of Colu$bus an# Presi#ent, eneral

Parent-eacher Association, a2ui2 National /i2h School, Lo7er Bicutan, a2ui2 Cit%>

')< 0esti$onial Letter0 #ate# F Septe$ber )((* of Att%. Pri$iti&o C. Cru, Presi#ent, a2ui2 La7%ers Lea2ue,

!nc., u?tu?an, a2ui2 Cit%>

'@< 0esti$onial Letter0 #ate# )' October )((* of "u#2e /ilario L. La1ui, Presi#in2 "u#2e, Re2ional rail Court;RC<, Branch )'*, ueon Cit%> an#

'6< 0esti$onial Letter0 #ate# )* October )((* of "ustice Oscar M. /errera, for$er "ustice, Court of Appeals an#

for$er +ean, !nstitute of La7, 5ar Eastern Uni&ersit% ;5EU<.

Citin2 the case of !n Re8 Carlos S. Basa, petitioner plea#e# that he be affor#e# the sa$e ?in#ness an# co$passion in or#er

that, li?e Att%. Basa, his pro$isin2 future $a% not be perpetuall% foreclose#. !n the sai# case, the Court ha# the occasion

to sa%8

Carlos S. Basa is a %oun2 $an about ) %ears of a2e, a#$itte# to the bars of California an# the Philippine !slan#s.

Recentl%, he 7as char2e# in the Court of 5irst !nstance of the Cit% of Manila 7ith the cri$e of ab#uction 7ith consent,

7as foun# 2uilt% in a #ecision ren#ere# b% the /onorable M.H. +e Rosario, "u#2e of 5irst !nstance, an# 7as sentence# to be i$prisone# for a perio# of t7o %ears, ele&en $onths an# ele&en #a%s of prision correccional. On appeal, this #ecision

7as affir$e# in a 4u#2$ent han#e# #o7n b% the secon# #i&ision of the Supre$e Court.

x x x x

9hen co$e next, as 7e $ust, to #eter$ine the exact action 7hich shoul# be ta?en b% the court, 7e #o so re2retfull% an#

reluctantl%. On the one han#, the &iolation of the cri$inal la7 b% the respon#ent attorne% cannot be li2htl% passe# o&er.

On the other han#, 7e are 7illin2 to strain the li$its of our co$passion to the utter$ost in or#er that so pro$isin2 a career

$a% not be utterl% ruine#.



Petitioner pro$ise# to co$$it hi$self to be $ore circu$spect in his actions an# sole$nl% ple#2e# to exert all efforts to

atone for his $is#ee#s.

here $a% be a reasonable 2roun# to consi#er the herein Petition.

!n the case of Re8 Petition of Al Ar2osino to a?e the La7%er3s Oath ;Bar Matter G')<, 7hich $a% be applie# in the

instant case, the Court sai#8

After a &er% careful e&aluation of this case, 7e resol&e to allo7 petitioner Al Caparros Ar2osino to ta?e the la7%ers oath,si2n the Roll of Attorne%s an# practice the le2al profession 7ith the follo7in2 a#$onition8

!n allo7in2 Mr. Ar2osino to ta?e the la7%er3s oath, the Court reco2nies that Mr. Ar2osino is not inherentl% of ba# $oral

fiber. On the contrar%, the &arious certifications sho7 that he is a #e&out Catholic 7ith a 2enuine concern for ci&ic #uties

an# public ser&ice.

he Court is persua#e# that Mr. Ar2osino has exerte# all efforts, to atone for the #eath of Raul Ca$ali2an. 9e are

prepare# to 2i&e hi$ the benefit of the #oubt, ta?in2 4u#icial notice of the 2eneral ten#enc% of %outh to be rash

te$erarious an# uncalculatin2.

x x x x

Mean7hile, in the case of Ro#olfo M. Bernar#o &s. Att%. !s$ael 5. Me4ia ;A#$inistrati&e Case No. )*6<, the Court JinK

#eci#in2 7hether or not to reinstate Att%. Me4ia to the practice of la7 state#8

he Court 7ill ta?e into consi#eration the applicant3s character an# stan#in2 prior to the #isbar$ent, the nature an#

character of the char2es for 7hich he 7as #isbarre#, his con#uct subse1uent to the #isbar$ent an# the ti$e that has

elapse# in bet7een the #isbar$ent an# the application for reinstate$ent.

Petitioner 7as barel% thirt% ;@(< %ears ol# an# ha# onl% been in the practice of la7 for fi&e ;F< %ears 7hen he 7as

#isbarre# fro$ the practice of la7. !t is of no #oubt that petitioner ha# a pro$isin2 future ahea# of hi$ 7here it not for the

#ecision of the Court strippin2 off his license.

Petitioner is also of 2oo# $oral repute, not onl% before but li?e7ise, after his #isbar$ent, as atteste# to o&er7hel$in2l% b% his constituents, collea2ues as 7ell as people of ?no7n probit% in the co$$unit% an# societ%.

9a% before the petitioner 7as e&en a#$itte# to the bar, he ha# alrea#% $anifeste# his intense #esire to ren#er publicser&ice as e&i#ence# b% his acti&e in&ol&e$ent an# participation in se&eral social an# ci&ic pro4ects an# acti&ities.

Li?e7ise, e&en #urin2 an# after his #isbar$ent, 7hich coul# be percei&e# b% so$e as a #ebilitatin2 circu$stance,

petitioner still $ana2e# to continue exten#in2 his assistance to others in 7hate&er $eans possible. his onl% pro&es

petitioner3s stren2th of character an# positi&e $oral fiber.

/o7e&er, still, it is of no 1uestion that petitioner3s act in cop%in2 the exa$ination 1uestions fro$ Att%. Bal2os3 co$puter

7ithout the latter3s ?no7le#2e an# consent, an# 7hich 1uestions later turne# out to be the bar exa$inations 1uestions in

Mercantile La7 in the )((@ Bar Exa$inations, is not at all co$$en#able. 9hile 7e #o belie&e that petitioner sincerel%

#i# not inten# to cause the #a$a2e that his action ensue#, still, he $ust be sanctione# for un#ul% co$pro$isin2 the

inte2rit% of the bar exa$inations as 7ell as of this Court.

9e are con&ince#, ho7e&er, that petitioner has since refor$e# an# has sincerel% reflecte# on his trans2ressions. hus, in

&ie7 of the circu$stances an# li?e7ise for hu$anitarian consi#erations, the penalt% of #isbar$ent $a% no7 be co$$ute#

to suspension. Consi#erin2 the fact, ho7e&er, that petitioner ha# alrea#% been #isbarre# for $ore than fi&e ;F< %ears, thesa$e $a% be consi#ere# as proper ser&ice of sai# co$$ute# penalt% an# thus, $a% no7 be allo7e# to resu$e practice of

la7.

9/ERE5ORE, PREM!SES CONS!+ERE+, it is respectfull% reco$$en#e# that the instant Petition for "u#icia

Cle$enc% an# Co$passion #ate# '( No&e$ber )((* of petitioner +AN!LO . +E U=MAN be RANE+



Petitioner3s #isbar$ent is no7 co$$ute# to suspension, 7hich suspension is consi#ere# as ser&e# in &ie7 of the

petitioner3s fi&e ;F< %ear #isbar$ent. /ence, petitioner $a% no7 be allo7e# to resu$e practice of la7.

he reco$$en#ation of the Office of the Bar Confi#ant is 7ell-ta?en in part.1avvphi1.zw+ 9e #ee$ petitioner 7orth% of

cle$enc% to the extent of co$$utin2 his penalt% to se&en ;G< %ears suspension fro$ the practice of la7, inclusi&e of the

fi&e ;F< %ears he has alrea#% ser&e# his #isbar$ent.

Penalties, such as #isbar$ent, are i$pose# not to punish but to correct offen#ers.) 9hile the Court is e&er $in#ful of its

#ut% to #iscipline its errin2 officers, it also ?no7s ho7 to sho7 co$passion 7hen the penalt% i$pose# has alrea#% ser&e#

its purpose.@

!n cases 7here 7e ha&e #ei2ne# to lift or co$$ute the supre$e penalt% of #isbar$ent i$pose# on the la7%er, 7e ha&e

ta?en into account the re$orse of the #isbarre# la7%er 6 an# the con#uct of his public life #urin2 his %ears outsi#e of the

bar .F 5or exa$ple, in Halencia &. Antini7, 7e hel#8

/o7e&er, the recor# sho7s that the lon2 perio# of respon#ents #isbar$ent 2a&e hi$ the chance to pur2e hi$self of his

$iscon#uct, to sho7 his re$orse an# repentance, an# to #e$onstrate his 7illin2ness an# capacit% to li&e up once a2ain to

the exactin2 stan#ar#s of con#uct #e$an#e# of e&er% $e$ber of the bar an# officer of the court. +urin2 respon#ents

#isbar$ent for $ore than fifteen ;'F< %ears to #ate for his professional infraction, he has been persistent in reiteratin2 his

apolo2ies an# pleas for reinstate$ent to the practice of la7 an# unrelentin2 in his efforts to sho7 that he has re2aine# his

7orthiness to practice la7, b% his ci&ic an# hu$anitarian acti&ities an# unble$ishe# recor# as an electe# public ser&ant, asatteste# to b% nu$erous ci&ic an# professional or2aniations, 2o&ern$ent institutions, public officials an# $e$bers of the

4u#iciar%.

An# in Bernar#o &. Att%. Me4ia,G 7e note#8

Althou2h the Court #oes not li2htl% ta?e the bases for Me4ia3s #isbar$ent, it also cannot close its e%es to the fact that

Me4ia is alrea#% of a#&ance# %ears. 9hile the a2e of the petitioner an# the len2th of ti$e #urin2 7hich he has en#ure# the

i2no$in% of #isbar$ent are not the sole $easure in allo7in2 a petition for reinstate$ent, the Court ta?es co2niance of

the rehabilitation of Me4ia. Since his #isbar$ent in '), no other trans2ression has been attribute# to hi$, an# he has

sho7n re$orse. Ob&iousl%, he has learne# his lesson fro$ this experience, an# his punish$ent has laste# lon2 enou2h. x x

x

Petitioner has sufficientl% #e$onstrate# the re$orse expecte# of hi$ consi#erin2 the 2ra&it% of his trans2ressions. E&en

$ore to his fa&or, petitioner has re#irecte# focus since his #isbar$ent to7ar#s public ser&ice, particularl% 7ith the

People3s La7 Enforce$ent Boar#. he attestations sub$itte# b% his peers in the co$$unit% an# other estee$e# $e$bers

of the le2al profession, such as retire# Court of Appeals Associate "ustice Oscar /errera, "u#2e /ilario La1ui, Professor

E#7in San#o&al an# Att%. Loreno Ata, an# the ecclesiastical co$$unit% such as Re&. 5r. Paul Bala2tas testif% to his

positi&e i$pact on societ% at lar2e since the unfortunate e&ents of )((@.

Petitioner3s subse1uent trac? recor# in public ser&ice affor#s the Court so$e hope that if he 7ere to reac1uire $e$bership

in the Philippine bar, his achie&e$ents as a la7%er 7oul# re#oun# to the 2eneral 2oo# an# $ore than $iti2ate the stain on

his recor#. Co$passion to the petitioner is 7arrante#. Nonetheless, 7e 7ish to i$part to hi$ the follo7in2 stern 7arnin28

0Of all classes an# professions, the la7%er is $ost sacre#l% boun# to uphol# the la7s. /e is their s7orn ser&ant> an# for hi$, of all $en in the 7orl#, to repu#iate an# o&erri#e the la7s, to tra$ple the$ un#erfoot an# to i2nore the &er% ban#s of

societ%, ar2ues recreanc% to his position an# office an# sets a pernicious exa$ple to the insubor#inate an# #an2erous

ele$ents of the bo#% politic.0*

$%ERE&ORE, in &ie7 of the fore2oin2, the Petition for "u#icial Cle$enc% an# Co$passion is hereb% RANE+ !N

PAR. he #isbar$ent of +AN!LO . +E U=MAN fro$ the practice of la7 is hereb% COMMUTED to SE'EN ()*

YEARS SUSPENSION &ROM T%E PRACTICE O& A$, rec?one# fro$ 5ebruar% 6, )((6.

SO OR+ERE+.























CONSUEO YNARES#SANTIA!O

Associate "ustice

9E CONCUR8

REYNATO S. PUNO

Chief "ustice

EONARDO A. +UISUMBIN!Associate "ustice

ANTONIO T. CARPIOAssociate "ustice

MA. AICIA AUSTRIA#MARTINE"

Associate "ustice

RENATO C. CORONA

Associate "ustice

CONC%ITA CARPIO MORAES

Associate "ustice

DANTE O. TIN!A

Associate "ustice

MINITA '. C%ICO#NA"ARIO

Associate "ustice

PRESBITERO . 'EASCO, R.

Associate "ustice

ANTONIO EDUARDO B. NAC%URA

Associate "ustice

TERESITA . EONARDO#DE CASTRO

Associate "ustice

ARTURO D. BRION

Associate "ustice

DIOSDADO M. PERATA

Associate "ustice

UCAS P. BERSAMIN

Associate "ustice

In Re 2003 Bar Exams

Documents

Transcript of In Re 2003 Bar Exams