Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

download Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

of 70

Transcript of Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    1/70

    #!&%!!!$

    &$#!#$%%'$

    4:8041#05708039,9;08425043899:9438":0439

    % %%# %

    !% #%

    # $

    &$% % $&!#

    %%!!!$

    #!#$%%'$

    %&!$#$!

    # #

    % # '

    & #

    4907 .425,3,398

    .425783 ,9 0,89 430

    97/ 41 90 949,

    02-078 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;08 ,70

    3/.,90/-04

    425,3,398

    '#!%#!%

    &3/07830/ !%$ 2489 70850.91: 10 98 /:

    '0710/425,3914790250,.203941904347,-0#03,94

    4743, .:77039 90 01 :89.0 41 90 $:57020 4:79

    070,1907 #08543/039 :543 90 74:3/8 41 097,, 41 !:-.

    %7:89 :5,-0 '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ 7,19 ,3/

    477:5943,81448

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    2/70

    !#%#$%%%

    0;07,8905489434101:89.0479089,3/34190

    $:57020 4:79 ,8 ,3 3899:943 -003 84 9,390/ 9 90

    507.05943 41-,8,3/ 5,79,9 ,8 98 343490;03 390 /,7

    /,8 41 2,79, , ,8 90 .01 2,897,90 -0,;0/ 9 8:.

    ,774,3.025:39,3/.3.823/0914790,:9039.7:041

    ,94570;,905:-.2:89,;0,-84:9097:89,3/.431/03.0

    390 :89.0 574-9 39079 ,3/ 25,79,94190 202-078 41

    90$:570204:79%4,;0,3:89.02:.2470,01:89.0

    4/408349;0:59490050.9,94341-030,08,7810

    -043/70574,.8941,9,250/090,-9414:73899:943894

    1:3.943,3//85038097:0:89.0949050450

    %043899:943574;/08,574.0881474/390:/.,794

    ,..4:39 43 90 573.50 9,9 84;07039 708/08 3 90 50450

    ,3/ , 4;0732039 ,:9479 02,3,908 1742 902 %0

    43899:943574;/08147,20.,382947024;0411.,84

    -097, 5:-. 97:89 .4229 .:5,-0 ;4,9438 41 90 43899:943

    ,3/7,19,3/.477:5943

    3,,9904;07,2439,3/,,1-0147090

    304;0732039 ,8 94 -0 8473 3 #08543/039 #03,94 4743,

    ,8,554390/01:89.04190$:570204:799457490.9,/

    ,3/ ,-09 47, ,.,5,,7744 3 07 0114798 94 08.,50

    ,..4:39,-9 147 07 ,.98 ,8 !708/039 41 90 !55308 8

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    3/70

    ,554392039 ,8 2,/0 3 ;4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ -

    4;079:733 43089,-80/09., ,3/ 0, 573.508 147-//3

    5708/0398 1742 2,3 2/39 ,5543920398 8 ,88:25943 41

    90 548943 41 01 :89.0 ,8 9:8 2,/0 5488-0 - ,

    .42-3,94341;4,939043899:943,3/90313/3,894

    :891 9 0 3473 0,2508 41 434:7,-0 ,3/ 09.,

    -0,;479,984:/,;02,/0925488-094,..0592:.088

    ,88:20411.0:3/078:./:-4:8,3//84347,-0.7.:289,3.08

    %0 $:57020 4:79 9801 3 943, ; ,894 070 9

    /0./0/ 94 :54/ !708/039 48/,/4 ,.,5,, 3 ;4/3 90

    2/39 ,5543920398 41 8 570/0.08847 ,748 ! ,7., 5,/

    97-:90944304198147207.018!43934:99,9!708/0395/4

    ":734 411070/ , 2/39 ,554392039 94 147207 01 :89.0

    ,3:047,303,2-,88,/473$5,3,3//087394709:7394

    98 4:79 0;03 ,8 ,884.,90 :89.0 47,3 ,8 903/070/ ,3 ,/

    39072 ,554392039 907094 - !708/039 ":734 ,1907 90 ,9907

    ,/ 489 90 00.943 94 !708/039 ,8,8, ,3/ -01470 0,;3

    90 !708/03. $,/ 2-,88,/47 /0.30/ 94 6:,1-03 41 90

    45343 9,9 90 2,9907 84:/ -0 019 94 90 3.423 30

    00.90/!708/039

    3 9,.3 !708/039 ,7.,8 2/39 ,5543920398 90

    $:570204:794-807;0/9,9/024.7,9.70850.9,3/411.,801

    70897,39 84:/ ,;0 .,7,.9070/ ,7.,8 ,.9438 03 ,

    ,3:,7

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    4/70

    3,943 02-,78 43 00.93 98 0,/0785 4:7 43899:943 ,8

    :/., ,3/ 8947., 570.0/0398 , 025,80 9,9 3.:2-0398

    2:89-0-,770/1742,-:839075407894;090280;0847907

    5,798,38 :3/:0 ,/;,39,0 9,79 90 5:-. 47 ,7,88 ,3/

    ,72 , 8:..088478 ,/23897,943 - 93 98 ,3/8 - 20,38 41

    2,.4:8249;,90/ ,5543920398 :79072470 9 8 .42243

    80380 94 -00;0 9,9 ,1907 90 574.,2,943 41 90 00.943 41

    !708/039 ,.,5,, 8 ,8 34 2470 9,3 , .,709,07

    ,/23897,943 0 ,8 /:9 -4:3/ 94 5705,70 147 90 47/07

    97,3810741,:947990 3.423 !708/039 ,3/ 0 84:/349 /4

    ,.98 . 0 4:9 94 34 4:/ 02-,77,88 47 4-897:.9 90

    54.084188:..0884790$:570204:798,/

    9 98 570.0/039 3 23/ ,3/ 9 90 0,9 ,999:/0

    94,7/8293 411., 5407,9 90 .48041,3 ,/23897,943 84

    ,8349948,-49,09030990570803943899:943038730/

    ,.0,7574-943432/39,554392039803!708/039/0

    '#,248970/942,0:/.,,5543920398390.483/,841

    8 ,/23897,943 90 $:57020 4:79 ;4/0/ 902 7089,93 90

    897.9 -,3 43 ,5543920398 349 :89 94 00.:9;0 /05,792039

    5489438-:990:/.,7

    4$4;02-073#05543920398/,90/,7.4143,904',03:0,,3/43!,./4',,79,,8:/084190#043,%7,4:79417,3.,49,3/417,3.,-,3,9:,3970850.9;0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    5/70

    3/09903!708/03947,,.,5,,7744/0./0/94

    3470,5,89570.0/03983.:/390430089,-80/-0743

    1,907!708/03948/,/4,.,5,,347/0794,55439,01

    :89.003-,320,8:7090894741904:79,8843-

    90/0.,/0,4114720701:89.0,3:047,390,3/2,7

    .,80 41 943, 90 43899:943 9801 ,3/ 90 4;02-07

    03 -,3. #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ;4/3 !708/039

    #,2482/39:/.,,55439203988:.,3,554392039,8

    ;00/,8/,3074:8,3/32.,94,:9039./024.7,.

    %0 /0.843 41 78 7744 ,8 570280/ 43 #08543/0398

    574;03 :801:3088 ,3/ 8 ,2-9438 .42-33 9 07 549.,

    .,.:,9438 94 2,0 2 , 3 5,79307 3 78 77448 5,3 94

    0;,/0,3/,;4/,..4:39314707411.,,.94388:801:3088

    ,3/ 7:90883088 070 574;03 1742 90 920 0 807;0/ ,8 07

    !708/039, 01 41 $9,11 !708/039, $54082,3 ,3/ ,8 .93

    0.:9;0 $0.709,7 , 5489438 41 90 089 97:89 .431/03.0

    ,3/:999407307411.,,3/507843,,11,78

    84,9,3/8:-807;03.09:80,730/2,3,554392039

    94 90 $:57020 4:79 ,8 884.,90 :89.0 ,9 , 920 03 78

    7744,81,.33:2074:8.,0308,3/-0800/-,5:-.

    .,247147,..4:39,-9

    ,.0/9,;,.,3.3905489434101:89.080903

    039 430 8905 1:7907 ,3/ .438570/ 9 #08543/039 4743, 94

    2,30:;078,554392039,801:89.0--70,3570.0/0398

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    6/70

    089,-80/ - 07 43 1,907 . 570280/ 2/39

    ,5543920398 ,8 2,.4:8 390710703.0 3 90 ,-9 41 , 30

    00.90/5708/03994,;0,1700,3/31:1382,3/,90

    390$:570204:79#08543/039,8.43889039,.90/3,

    2,3307 9,9 57490.98 78 7744 07 0, 2,30:;078 0 3

    411.0,3/900,,3/,/23897,9;0,3/230880019-03/

    84 ,8 94 250/0 90 4;07320398 0114798 94 0,.9 ,..4:39,-9

    ,3/:89.0

    8 0,/0785 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,8 80;070 074/0/

    5:-. .431/03.0390;07/0.8432,3 574.088 4190

    4:79 /:0 94 90 2,3307 3 . 90 4:79 ,8 ,3/0/ /43

    /0.8438 43 94 70.438/07 4;079:73 ,3/ 4;079:73 ,,3 9480

    /0.8438708:933,3:3570.0/0390/89,90411:3907284190

    ;07/.984190089.4:79390,3/

    801:89.0#08543/039,8-003,;83908503/3

    415:-.1:3/8-3/9409.,89,3/,7/841-0,;47050.90/349

    43412-:981,2397:0/,3/.438570/,,3898104

    :89.08 ,3/ -0,;0/ 2470 0 , 8.411, 9,3 01 :89.0 3

    701:8394/8.4808,88098,3/,-9084943,80-0,;0/

    3 , 2,3307 9,9 8 3.43889039 9 90 /39 ,3/ 574-9

    050.90/ 41 , 202-07 41 90 .4:79 -:9 ,8 :80/ 8

    ,/23897,9;0 54078 147 5,798,3 549., 03/8 94 57490.9 4907

    411.,85:93411.0147908,2070,8430,8,554390/9478

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    7/70

    !708/039 47, ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 038:70 80 0;,/08

    ,..4:39,-914707,.98

    8 09., -3/3088 3974/:.943 41 549., 5,798,385 ,9

    90 050380 41 /:0 574.088 ,3/ 397:0 394 90 .4:79 ,9 90

    050380 41 90 705:9,943 41 8 104 :89.08 8 :3/07233

    -,8.,3/.0780/573.508413900.9:,13,3.,,3/09.,

    43089 - :83 8 54078 349 94 ,77;0 ,9 90 97:9 47 4/ 90

    .4:79949008989,3/,7/8-:93890,/94.4;07:5,3/0.:80

    908479.42384190.4:79,8-097,0/5:-.97:89-074/3

    5:-..431/03.0390,/23897,94341:89.0

    !:-.411.0 8 570280/ 4390 2,3903,3.0 41 5:-. 97:89

    ,;3-097,0/9,997:89#08543/039#03,944743,82,31089

    :31994.4393:0,801:89.002:89-0250,.0/

    %%$%

    %0701470 98 ,.943 147 250,.2039 8 -74:9 ,,389

    01:89.0#03,944743,3,..47/,3.0990574;843841

    $0.94379.0419043899:943439074:3/841 ,

    097,, 41 !:-. %7:89 - :5,-0 '4,943 41 90 43899:943

    ,3/.7,19,3/477:5943

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    8/70

    %!#%$

    425,3,398 ,70 .:77039 02-078 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;0 7085438-0534.9038 ,3/9,5,078 ,3/,70

    ,410, ,0 47 5:7548084190 389,39'0710/ 425,39147

    250,.2039.425,3,3982,-0807;0/950,/38349.08

    ,3/ 574.08808 ,9 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 43899:943 8

    ,9,8,3 4250":043 9 %0 -73 98 ,.943 147 ,3/ 43

    -0,14190!04504190#05:-.4190!55308-,:9479

    419043899:943.438890399907.;.,3/.43899:943,/:908,8.90385:-.807;,398202-0784190-,7,3/02-078

    41904:8041#05708039,9;08,8,03984190!045090;,74:8

    80.947841903,943,3/490750450847,3,9438

    #08543/039 #% # 8 90 3.:2-039 01

    :89.04190$:570204:794190!55308,3/8-038:0/3

    8 411., .,5,.9 0 2, -0 807;0/ 9 8:22438 ,3/ 4907

    574.08808,98411.0,//7088,990$:570204:79:/3941

    ,3,

    #%$

    03#08543/039,88:20/411.0,801:89.043,

    0 // 84 /08590 , 43899:943,25480/ -,3 43

    ,5543920398 . 90 $:57020 4:79 2,/0 5488-0 ,3/

    5072990/:3/07,339075709,9439,9897,30/.70/:94.,3/.4224380380 ,3/ 0;03 4780 0110.9;0 -740 90 , %0

    :89.08 9,9 2,/0 98 5488-0 .43899:90 , ;493 -4. 9,9

    #08543/0390,/8,801:89.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    9/70

    %0,554392039,82099/08570,/5:-.3/3,943

    ,3/ 57490898 ,8 9 ,8 4-;4:8 247, /:-4:8 8 ,554392039

    .,20 :89 430 00 ,1907 , 30 !708/039 ,8 ,70,/ 00.90/

    ,3/:89,10008-01470,30!708/039,8941472,,88:20

    411.0 08590 90 43899:943, 574-943 90 570.0/039

    089,-80/3943,;,894./0.,70/9,9,33.:2-039

    !708/039 ,554393 411.,8,190790 00.943 418 8:..08847 ,8

    !708/039 48/,/4 ,.,5,, ,7:0/ 7057080390/ 2,.4:8

    8,-49,0 41 90 0570880/ 41 90 50450 ,3/ /08590 90

    $:570204:798438947.57080390/90890730,250

    41 , 147207 01 :89.0 ,3:0 47,3 4 /0.30/

    70,554392039 94 90 .4:79 - !708/039 5/4 ":734 ,8 9

    .43899:90/ , 2/39 ,554392039 #08543/039 0,07

    ,..0590/8548943%8,8349989,3/3901,.99,94190

    9700-7,3.08414;073203990:/.,7,890248970,9

    /0503/039 :543 247, ,8.03/,3. ,3/ 09., 39079 ,8 90

    14:3/,94341985407,3/092,.40;070,9902590/94

    .,24:1,08-7,03,2-943-9,384,941411.0-01470

    903 !708/039 47, ,.,5,,7744 3 80.709 8:55480/ ,9

    9033902473341,-043/908.7:9341902,88

    20/,,3/905:-.

    #08543/0398 ;493 5,99073 ,3/ ,.9438 ,1907 8,554392039 ,8 884.,90 :89.0 ,3/ ,907 ,8 01 :89.0 ,8

    /8.:880/-04,;0-003,393-:91,7,3/25,79,

    3 90 0,7 9,9 #08543/039 ,8 5708/0/ 4;07 90 4:79 41

    ,89#08479905345045081,9390:89.088902,8-003

    70,9:3/07230/7,9079,3:5190/974:,8070841/:-4:8

    /0.84380330070/-2

    8:077, !,-:,3 !,,.0 /08 4743, 4,99,3 1742 20/,!5530 , 36:707 , .45 4190,79.08 ,99,.0/,8 330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    10/70

    3890,/41,88:73,3/897039033903/0503/03.0,3/

    25,79,94190:/.,7#08543/039,83890,//0243897,90/

    0 8 570/85480/ 94 1,;47 ,3/ 57490.9 78 47, ,.,5,,

    7744 4 ,/ ,554390/ 2 94 8 548943 ,8 01 :89.0 3

    -7,03/870,7/419043899:943

    3 1,.9 708:98 41 90 $4., 0,907 $9,9438 $:7;08 309

    8,981,.9437,93839097/6:,7907413/.,909,9,243

    90 .4:3978 945 411.,8 43 #08543/0398 8,981,.943 7,938

    ,;0-003,07483.0$05902-07088,981,.9437,93

    8.4388903930,90/-8/88,981,.9437,93

    4390,#08543/039.4397,794857434:3.020398

    ,8,40/,3/0;0303.4:7,0/90/090747,943419070850.9

    ,3/97:89/:094904:79-5:9934-89,.083905,941

    90 504508 80,7. 147 97:9 ,,389 7,19 ,3/ .477:5943

    03.74,.3 43 90 0.:8;0 5407 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;08 94 39,90 250,.2039 574.00/38 574;/3 ,

    802-,3.0 41 0, .4;07 94 ;0 47207 !708/039 47,

    ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 07 :8-,3/ 90 455479:39 94 08.,50

    57480.:943 ,3/ 17:897,90 90 03/8 41 :89.0 5072993 90

    4:79 94 7050,90/ 15145 43 98 43 /0.8438 3 ;4,943 41 98

    437:080.:835,,7823.4397,899490897303989,3/,7/8050.90/ 41 47/3,7 .400 89:/0398 ,3/ 90,.078 ,3/ 0;03

    7054790/03,3349433.9,.6:73,8809841;,:0

    -:90;0370847939450997,19,3/.477:5943147843507843,

    57419,3/.43;0303.0

    !4-090 #,938 /0.30 147 945 411.,8 :8308847/.94-07 .454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    11/70

    %0 425,3,398 070- ,..:80 #08543/039 41 3:2074:8

    ,.98 9,9 .425780 , 097,, 41 !:-. %7:89 - :5,-0

    '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ . 7,19 ,3/ 477:5943 9,9

    703/07 2 ,-84:90 :319 147 90 548943 41 01 :89.0 41 90

    $:570204:79

    #&$#!%

    #08543/039 -097,0/ 90 !:-. %7:89 .422990/ :5,-0

    '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ 7,19 ,3/ 477:5943 3 90

    14432,3307

    #%

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#& $

    %# ## # !#%%

    $&$#' $$ '' % ##

    $%#%#%%$!!%%$

    $&!# % &$% &% $ &&$

    !!%% $ % &$% % %

    !#$%

    #%

    #$!% %% &! '% %

    $%%&%#%#%!&%#&$%

    %$$%% !&$ $%%%$$%$ %$ %#%$#"

    $#%%$%%&%

    #%

    #$!%%%&!'%$ %

    $%%&% %# % !& %#&$%

    % % $#' % $%#%$%#$ #% ' $% %

    $%%&%%%!#'$%%(#%

    &$%!#$!#'!%

    %#% !#% !

    %$&!#%%%#%%#$

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    12/70

    &$ &$ % $$& !

    !! $$ &%# $$

    #% $$' %% %#$

    ## %#& # !!%% $ %

    $&$$%%%$##

    $$!#%$&!#%

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% #

    %% &! '% % $%%&%

    %% $## % !#!

    $!#%!#$$$&$%%&$"&%## $% % &$ #!#$%%'$ %

    $ # % !% %

    &$#%$'##&%##

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#&

    %#%##$$!#%%$$%%

    $## % !#! #$ &% %$$ '' % #% %$

    %!#%%$%!#'

    #%'

    #$!%%#%!&%#&$%##%

    &% $ % %% #% %&%#% $% % !#!#

    '$%% &$% % $&!#% # %

    !!$ &!% $& &%#%

    $%$!#!##!$%$%%&%

    %&$#!#$%%'$'!%

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#& $!#%% #% %!## #$%#

    ## %# '# ## !#$% #

    !## # &$ $&

    ## ## % ' % !!#%&% %

    $! !#$&% % #&$%#% % $

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    13/70

    &$% $%#% % $&!# %

    $ % %'% % %# '

    #%!%%%$%

    $&!#%$%#

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% #

    %% #% ##&!%

    #&$ % &% # %

    '!%&$!#

    %$%$

    $&$$%#&$#!%

    #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#& $ %#

    ## # !#%%

    $&$#' $$

    '' % ##

    $%#% # % %

    $!!%%$$&!#

    % &$%

    %& % $ &&$

    !!%% $ %

    &$% &! % %

    !#$%

    $0. 79.0 ' 41 90 43899:943 .0,7

    574-9890!708/03917422,3,5543920398939424398

    220/,90 -01470 90 309 5708/039, 00.9438 ,3/ :5 94 90

    03/ 41 8 9072 0.059 147 902547,7 ,5543920398 94 00.:9;0

    5489438 03 .4393:0/ ;,.,3.08 90703 570:/.0 5:-.

    807;.0 47 03/,307 5:-. 8,109 3 90 .,80 41 3 #0

    5543920398,90/,7. 41 43,904',03:0,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    14/70

    ,3/43!,./4',,79,,8:/084190#043,%7,4:7941

    7,3. ,4 9 ,3/ 41 7,3. ,-,3,9:,3 9 90

    $:57020 4:79 7:08 9,9 98 574;843 -,78 90 ,554392039 41

    202-0784190:/.,7

    40;07390.,804179:74/0,8974;:/.,,3/

    ,74:3. ,3/ !708/039 47,,.,5,,774409 , 3 #0

    55.,-9 1 $0.943 79.0 ' 1 %0 43899:943 %4

    5543920398 %4 %0 :/.,7 89094 !03/4, !5530 ,7

    884.,943 ;8 09 , 90 $:57020 4:79 70;0780/ 90

    ',03:0, 7:3 ,3/ 0/ 9,9 90 43899:943, 574-943

    83:,7 /408 349 ,55 94 90 $:57020 4:79 253 9,9 9

    ,550843949000.:9;0/05,792039,3/,4907.4:798407

    9,3 90 $:57020 4:79 08590 90 4-;4:8 30,9;0 ,3/

    .431/03.08,9907325,.99,9,2/39,554392039-,3

    4:943!708/0394:/,;043905045081,9390$:57020

    4:79,3/90:/.,88902#08543/0390,078,20088,3/

    94:9 0;03 , 39 41 80170897,39 ,3/ /0.,/0, ,..0590/ 8

    2/39 ,554392039 ,8 01 :89.0 - 903!708/039 47,

    ,.,5,,7744

    :/08 2:89 038:70 9,9 349 43 8 907 .43/:.9

    ,-4;070574,.-:99,998507.0;0/94-084390;041,

    70,843,-04-807;07

    3,//94390-0,;47,3/.43/:.941:/08 2:89 70,1172 90 504508 1,9 3 90 39079 41 90

    :/.,7:89.02:893492070-0/430-:92:89,84-0800394

    -0 /430 %080 ,70 706:70/ :3/07 94 41 90 2489 25479,39

    80.943841904/041:/.,43/:.9850.1.,,34343

    39079 40;07 ,8 , 2,9907 41 5:-. 70.47/ 1742 8 ;07

    57424943 94 90 089 548943 3 90 :/., 07,7.

    #08543/039,8;4,90/9080570207574;8438

    4$4;02-07$# # 48 4 $ # 4

    ,7. $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    15/70

    3/00/ 08-70, 7054790/ 9,9 90 ;493 70.47/ 41

    #08543/039 848 9,9 0 ,8 .43889 039 8/0/ 9 90

    ,/23897,943 3 549.,831.,39.,808 0 77448 54.08

    ,3/,/23897,94308-70,1:79077054790/03997,.0/90

    ;4935,9907341$:570204:79:89.084743,4/0/,

    507.039 3 1,;47 41 7744 ,3/ 98 ,8 -01470 8 2/39

    ,554392039,801:89.0

    %8 9703/ .4393:0/ 0;03 478030/ -097,3

    #08543/0398570/8548943948/09774447073907089,9,3

    ,3/ ,.4898 0;03 ,9 90 .489 41574899:93 90 34-0 .,:8041

    :89.0

    %:8 3 7,44 ; %0 !5530 %7:9 4228843 41

    #08543/039 /0,9 90 1,9, -4 94 0.:9;0 7/07 4

    /,90/ : 03990/ 70,93 90 !5530 %7:9

    422884341$25#08543/039570;0390/,38:.-4/

    1742 -03 .70,90/ 34 47 3 90 1:9:70 9070- 57490.93 8

    5,974308817423;089,943

    34907.,8090$9,9:8":43907/073,207,

    ,3,,3:.2,3;0.:9;0$0.709,7 !,6:94.4,7

    806:,,55,3$002343.:0#08543/0398$:570204:79

    4:/349-0.439039,,3898253:130.:9;07/074

    /,90/:%40903/77448.43974,3/31:03.04;07

    90 30 ,/23897,943 /430 974: 2,88;0 ,8923:90

    ,5543920398 3 .79., 5:-. 5489438 #08543/039 4:/ ,,3

    13/1,:930.:9;07/074/,90/:

    $00 :89.0 4743,8 ;493 70.47/ 1,;478 7744 08-70, 0-7:,7 995308-70,5:89.0.4743,8;49370.47/1,;478,77441,91:57394:98,99,.0/,8330 07041

    #40.02-07#4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    16/70

    0.:9;0 7/07 4 ,8 88:0/ 570.80 94 70;40

    /39 5543920398 2,/0 - 90 7744 /23897,943 3

    /05,7920398 ,03.08 411.08 ,3/ 3897:2039,908 3.:/3

    4;0732039430/ 47 .439740/ .47547,9438 %080 /39

    5543920398 070 2,/0 5488-0 - 78 7744 .:733 4:9

    ,55439203981475:25489834;0732039430/,3/.439740/

    ,03.08 43 , /, -,88 ,3/ -,./,93 902 94 -01470 90

    .43899:943, -,3 43 ,5543920398 /:73 ,3 00.943 5074/

    :79078:.,5543920398,/900110.941074/3903907941

    9000.:9;0080908,20,82,/03.425090/870,7/

    41 90 39039 ,3/ 8579 41 90 .43899:943, -,3 43 2/39

    ,5543920398 0110.9;0 /057;3 90 30 ,/23897,943 41 90

    5407942,09843,554392039894908054894389,8147

    908070,84389,9,37/071742900.:9;0300/0/94-02,/0

    347/0794570;039901:7907/07,/,943419050450897:89,3/

    .431/03.034:74;07320393899:9438

    09 .43889039 9 8 5,99073 41 8:554793 47,

    ,.,5,,7744 #08543/0398 $:57020 4:79 88:0/ , $9,9:8

    ":43907/0794570;039902502039,943410.:9;07/07

    4 ,3 90 389,39 .,80 7010.98 ,3 ,117439 94 90

    3/0503/03.0 41 90 :/.,7 9 8 080 , .,80 41 :/.,

    4;0770,.:543,.406:,-7,3.414;073203920,3994/07,98011479894.:7-.477:5943-8:..088;03:139888:,3.08

    8 884.,90,3/01:89.0#08543/039,83470/

    09., 570.0/0398 -0,;0/ 9 , ,. 41 39079 .,893 90

    $:57020 4:79 3 /8705:90 :/08 ,70 050.90/ 94 -0 -043/

    70574,. 13,3., 09., ,3/ 90 :80 41 907 ,:9479 ,3/

    $00 7744 88:08 2/39 2,/3088 41 ,5543920398 $ 08 ,9995,-8.-3308.423,943,774488:082/392,/3088,5543920398,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/,833007041800,8490 89 41 /39 55439008 1742 $ 08 995,-8.-3308.428908/01,:910849078/434,/8%#/398*8*:305/1,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/,833007041

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    17/70

    54078!,798,385,1:701:8,9470.:80280184,894,;4/

    ,35488-025:9,94341,.431.94139070893.:/3905,3

    -,. 41 /0-98 41 549., 7,99:/0 47 4,9 ,70 , -097,, 41

    5:-.97:89,3/.4397,79490.,343841:/.,.43/:.9

    8 147 90 .,80 41 0334 $2043 6:34 ;

    4228843 43 0.9438 8:57, 90 $:57020 4:79 /030/ 90

    509943 41 903 $03 0334 $ 6:34 ,,389 # 4

    .70,93 ,3/47 70/0133 90 1789 ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41

    ,2,7308$:79,8/0-00;0/,3/.431720/-8:-806:039

    0;03989,990/897.9807070/0130/,3/.70,90/94,88:709,9

    90 !708/039 47, ,.,5,,77448 843 ,94 7744 .4:/

    7:3 ,3/ 3 3 90 30 .70,90/ /897.9 94 ,;4/ , .439089

    -09003 90 5708/0398 843 ,3/ $0.709,7 #4,3/43/,,

    4,390/94709:7394,2,7308$:7947:3384//897.9%8

    30 /897.9 ,8 :50/ .4397,7 94 90 05.9 .43899:943,

    706:7020399,92,3/,908,232:2545:,9434194:3/70/

    11994:8,3/14790.70,94341,08,9;0/897.9

    %03 $03 6:34 ,7:0/ 9,9 #05:-. .9 4

    .70,93 90 1789 ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41 ,2,7308 $:7 ,8

    :3.43899:943, -0.,:80 90 5745480/ 1789 /897.9 4:/ 03/ :5

    9 , 545:,943 41 088 9,3 4743 08590 98.0,71,.9#08543/0394743,;490/3;4,943419043899:943

    ,,389903$036:348509943

    4780#08543/0394,99,9920,8,70,/-03

    .438/070/ -787744 ,890309 01:89.0 // 349 3-9

    $0.943 79.0 ' 41 90 43899:943 147 90 .70,943 41 08,9;0 /897.982,3/,9089,94370888,2,0,70,554794320394108,9;0/897.98-,80/43 90 89,3/,7/8 10/ 3 $0.943 %080 .43899:943, 89,3/,7/8 ,8 1,7 ,8545:,943 8 .43.0730/ ,70 574547943, 705708039,943 232:2545:,94341 507 08,9;0 /897.9 5747088;0 7,94 3 90 3.70,804108,9;0 /897.98 ,8 90 545:,943 -,80 3.70,808 ,3/ :314729 3,554794320394108,9;0/897.983574;3.08.908,3/900974549,3,3,,70,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    18/70

    2801%082501,.98#08543/03985,9743088,8902490741

    90573.5,-0301.,74190.70,943419030/897.9%:8,

    ;49031,;47419030/897.9,8,;49031,;47417877448

    843,3/4:/9:803/0,72247094787744,3/038:708

    ,554392039 3 825089 90728 #08543/039 ,390/ ,3/ 300/0/

    842093 1742 78 7744 0 8 ,554392039 ,8 309 01

    :89.0 78 7744 3 9:73 ,390/ 47 300/0/ 842093 147

    #08543/039094.70,90,3008,9;0/897.914707843,94

    7744%0!0450.,3/4902,9

    048,9,-09,997,.8#08543/0398;4935,99073

    3 .,808 2570880/ 9 5:-. 3907089 ,3/ 3;4;3 90

    77444;0732039817439,,88,:9843.43899:943,798574794

    8 ,554392039 ,8 01 :89.0 8 90 9,-0 84

    #08543/0398;4908/.9,90/349-8.438.03.0-:984,9

    ,3/8:-807;03.0948,5543935407

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    31472,943

    %0.344 ;

    ,3/ 0,

    !,.1. ,3:,7

    0,!,.1. .4397,.9 ;4/0/147 349 :3/0743 5:-.-//3

    880390/

    $,3,,8;0.:9;0

    $0.709,7 0-7:,7

    %0!708/039388:3!74.48 ,3/03 7/07 4 // 349 0.00/ 07 54078 ,801 0.:9;0 ,3/

    422,3/07301

    43.:770/

    %0.843 ; ,7.

    82880/ 5099438 94 /86:,1073,3/4 !40 7 77448 7;,.,3//,90147905708/03.,8, 5708/039,-0 43 90 74:3/9,9 0 8 349 , 3,9:7,-473534

    880390/

    !20390 ; 729,

    0.02-07%0 !708/039 2, 2,0,5543920398 3 ,3 ,.93.,5,.9 94:9 8003.43172,943 1742 904228843 43 55439203980;0303437088838088430 349 :89 ,/ 39072,5543920398

    43.:770/

    $03,90;729,57

    88:0/ - 78 7744. ,40/ 00.:9;0/05,792039 0,/8 94 3;4000.:9;057;008;,/

    43.:770/

    :/,3 ; $03,::89

    %0 5708/039, /70.9;0 .574-90/ .079,3411.,841 90

    43.:770/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    19/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    0.:9;0 -7,3. ,3/ 90 !1742 ,550,73 3 43708843,0,738 94:9 90 !708/0398.4380398;,/

    ,2-34;

    .94-07

    ,2-348$, 3 ,,38

    509943 147 94,4,504508 39,9;0 94 ,203/ 9043899:94394.43;0794:7147241 4;0732039 1742 5708/039,94 5,7,2039,7 9:8 ;37744 90 455479:39 94-0.420 90 5720 238907 ,3/0;,/0 90 43899:943,574-943 43 7000.943 ,8!708/039 ,8 /82880/ 147,;31,0/94.42599043899:943, 706:7020398 41

    .43/:.93,50450839,9;0

    880390/

    ,;/;7744,

    !708/039, !74.,2,943 485,79.43899:943,5,79:3.43899:943,

    880390/430/%3,8/88039%3,;490/94/8288, 90

    5099438 43 90 1443

    74:3/8$3.0!!3148,7,89

    8 ,3 007.80 41 90!708/0398 .,3 4:954078882,794!!9 84:/ 080 -08:89,30/ 1443 90

    7:3 3 $,3,,8 ;0.:9;0$0.709,7

    %0 9,04;07 41 90 ,

    %7-:30 8 34 4307 ,:89.,-0 88:00;0790088 %3, ,84.4220390/ 43 90!708/0398 020703.9,04;07 54078 3 9880 0 9 81:3/,2039, 84:3/ 94

    .43897:079$0.943419043899:943,8706:73 .43708843,,5574;, -01470 ,9,04;07 2, -00110.90/ 98 47/3 8,2-;,039 9:8 9 8 ,84.43899:943, 507288-0147 90 !708/039 94007.80 9,04;07 540780;03 94:9

    43708843, ,5574;, 30.05943, 389,3.08

    8:-0.9 43 94 :/.,70;0

    880390/ 1742 90

    2,479 7:3 9,9 904;07-70,/9 ,3/ ;4/ 147;,:03088/4.97308,5543 94 1,., .,0308

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    20/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    41 1700 8500. 89,9:9083.723,89,9:908,3/349 1700 8500. .,8082, -0 .,030/ 4390 74:3/ 9,9 90 ,70

    ;4/ 147 ;,:03088 7008500. .,808 ,70 2470574507 .,030/ 4390 74:3/ 414;07-70,/9:79072470 !! 30907 .70,908 347/23808 ,3 798 474-,9438,9840;07

    0307, 7/07 4 8

    080 ;,/ -0.,:80

    0;03 1 570280/ 43 ,89,90 41 020703. 9.,3349 ,:9470 9029,74754.094347047 ;4,90 .43899:943, 4789,9:947798 47 03147.0,8 .425090 ,03 9490 8:55708843 41 ,088;403.0

    %0$:570204:7984:/

    349 5,88 :543 903/;/:, .,28 41 3:7

    ,783 1742 ,30,23,943 41 !! ,3/ ,8 ,550/83.098349,9707411,.98

    ,;0 ; 43,0

    0-7:,7709,550/ .43;078,9438-09003 7744 ,3/ ,7.,34349574-90/1742,73

    880390/

    07;$03,90,7.

    07 349 ,-0 147 .4390259 147349,550,733$03,900,73843 % 0, . ,830/947744,3/07854:80

    -0.,:80890892438.4;070/-00.:9;057;00

    43.:770/

    -,,3 ; 6:34

    :!! .422:3.,9438 .4;070/- 00.:9;0 57;00 007.80/-787744,3/3491475:-./8.48:70

    43.:770/

    0334 $2043

    6:34 ;

    4228843 43

    0.9438 # 457

    030/ 90 509943 41 903 $030334$6:34,3/:50/# .70,93 90 1789 ,3/80.43//897.9841,2,7308$:790 /897.98 070 .70,90/ 94,88:70 9,9 77448 843 ,9477447:3:3.4390890/83.0

    903 $0.709,7 #4,3/43/,, ,8 709:733 94,2,7308 $:7 94 7:3 ,,3 147437088.4397,7949005.9.43899:943, 706:702039 9,9706:708 , 232:2 545:,943

    43.:770/ // 349 3-9/08590 -03 ,70,/.438/070/ ,8 430 41 903423008 147 90 309 01:89.0 - 90 24907 903! 41 90 573.5,-0301.,74190.70,94341

    9030/897.9%:8,;49031,;47 41 90 30 /897.9 8 ,;49031,;4741903!8843,3/9:8

    -/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    21/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    41 94 :3/70/ 119 94:8,3/ 147 90 .70,943 41 ,08,9;0 /897.9 %03 $036:34,7:0/9,9#05:-..94 9,9 .70,90/ 90 1789

    ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41,2,7308$:78:3.43899:943,-0.,:80 90 5745480/ 1789/897.9 03/ :5 9 ,545:,943410889,34743 08590 98 .0,71,.94743,;490/,,389903$036:3485099433;4,943419043899:943

    8/0 1742 90 850.1. .,808 0703 /8.:880/ 90

    1443 .,808 /0./0/ - 90 4:79 9 #08543/039 ,8 01

    :89.01:7907-097,8.43889039,.413/0503/03.0,3/-,8

    94,7/857490.937744

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    7,44 ; %0

    !5530 %7:94228843 41 # 4 0.02-07

    0.:9;0 7/07 4 .70,93

    90 %7:9 4228843 ,8/0.,70/:3.43899:943,

    4743,.43.:770/

    , 207,

    ,3,,3:.2,3 ;

    0.:9;0 $0.709,7

    !,6:94.4,7# 4 .94-07

    $9,9:8":43907/07%0$:57020 4:79 706:70/ 905,7908 94 4-807;0 90 $%%&$"& 570;,3 -01470 9088:,3.0410.:9;07/074/,90/:

    %0 4743, $ 43.0 ,,39,790/ 90 4;073203980114798 94 6:08943 902/39 ,55439203982,/0 - 7744 94 ;,74:85489438 34;0732039,3/974 , 2430 703. ,990 30 ,/23897,94380114798 94 7047,30 90

    4;0732039 ,3/ 09 7/ 41.477:594;0732039411.,8

    47, ,.,5,,

    7744 ; 43 0,

    /0 2, 09 , #48 480:0 % 7744 ;

    430,/02,09

    , # 4 4;02-07

    %02547,770897,3347/07%#88:0/,,38990,9.8947/0788:0/,,3899077448

    %0 343 7744 ;493-4. 3 90 $:57020 4:790/ - #08543/039 ,8988:0/ , %# ,,389 90,9.89 47/07 9070-;3 ,3 455479:39 1479077448 94 08.,50 1742 90:78/.943 41 90 !55308%0 %# ,8 88:0/ /0859090 ,73 3.4388903.08 3

    90 509943 41 147207!708/039 7744 ,8.90/ -884.,90:89.0$07034%08,20 ;493 -4. 0/ 90%# 220/,90 00.:947/08590343.425,3.09,570.43/943

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    22/70

    #$!% %%&! '% %

    $%%&%# %#

    %!&%#&$%

    % $$ % % !& $

    $%%%$$%$ %$

    % #% $ #"

    $#%%

    $%%&%

    9 8 574;/0/ 147 3 79 $0.943 41 90

    43899:943 9,9 , 5:-. 411.07 47 025400 8, :543

    ,88:2594341411.0,3/,8419039070,1907,82,-0706:70/-

    ,8:-29,/0.,7,943:3/074,9418,88098,-908,3/309

    479390.,804190!708/03990'.0!708/0399002-078

    4190,-309,3/4907.43899:943,411.08,3/411.0784190

    ,720/ 147.08 9 0307, 47 1, 7,3 90 /0.,7,943 8, -0

    /8.480/94905:-.3902,3307574;/0/-,

    #08543/0391,0/94/8.48094905:-.889,902039

    41,88098,-908,3/309479,8706:70/-9043899:943

    9 8 ,84 7054790/ 9,9 8420 41 90 574507908 41

    #08543/039 ,70 349 3.:/0/ 3 8 /0.,7,943 41 8 ,88098

    ,-908 ,3/ 309 479 3 ;4,943 41 90 ,397,19 ,3/ .477:59

    57,.9.08,.9

    #08543/03980808:850.90/,3/,..:80/41,;3

    ,..:2:,90/499030,9,.6:73,8809841;,:08,3/

    0053 -,3 ,..4:398 9 :0 /054898 9 ,8 -003 7054790/

    9,9#08543/039,8,24349078,8620907,5,7920393,

    5480, 47/!745079 /0;0452039,9 90479 3%,:,8

    07054790/98,808.43899:943,706:70/:3/0779$0.

    419043899:94338$9,9020394188098,3/,-908,3/

    09 479 $ 8 98 ,.6:8943 8:89,30/ ,3/ /:8:554790/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    23/70

    -83.420,8,5:-.411.,$3.08,88:25943,8884.,90

    ,3/ 8:-806:039 01:89.0,8 0.4250/ 9 98/:9 41

    5:-./8.48:70

    #$!% %%&! '%$ %

    $%%&%%#%

    !& %#&$% %%

    $#' % $%#%

    $%#$ #% '

    $% %

    $%%&% %% !#'$

    %% ( # %&$%!#$

    !#'!% %#%

    !#% !

    % $&!# %

    %%#%%#$

    &$ &$ %

    $$& !!!

    $$

    &%# $$ #%

    $$' %%%#$##%#

    !!%% $ %

    $&$$%

    %%$ ## $$

    ! # % $&!#

    %

    #08543/039 ,8 ,554390/ 94 90 $:57020 4:79 43

    57 - 78 47, ,.,5,,7744 !747 94 8

    ,5543920390807;0/77441472,30,78,807.014189,11

    ,3/ 854082,3 03 80 ,8 '.0!708/039 ,3/ ,907 ,8 07

    !708/039, 0141$9,11 !708/039, $54082,3 ,3/ .93

    0.:9;0$0.709,7

    79 ' $0.943 41 90 43899:943 574;/08

    9,9 ,( 02-07 41 90 :/.,7 2:89 -0 , 507843 41 574;03

    $009958.:/.,74;5:89.08.4743,55

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    24/70

    .4250903.0 39079 574-9 ,3/ 3/0503/03.0 02-078 41

    90 :/.,7,70050.90/94,;0908014:76:,9082,3/,90/

    - 90 43899:943 -0.,:80 9080 1472 90 ;07 14:3/,943 147

    2,39,335045081,9390:/.,7%:89,8-0037:0/

    -340889,390$:570204:799,9

    !0450 4 7:3 90 :/.,7 5,79.:,7 :89.08

    ,3/ :/08 2:89 349 43 -0 5741.039 3 -49 908:-89,39;0,3/574.0/:7,,850.984190,-:9247025479,39 90 2:89 5488088 90 089 /0700 4139079 ,3/ 574-9 ,3/ ,3 :36:08943,-0 247,

    :5793088-4939075:-.,3/57;,90;0894:0;07411.03904;0732039807;.08

    , 5:-. 97:89 34548943 0,.98, 70,907/02,3/43247, 7904:83088 ,3/ :5793088 9,3 , 80,9 3 90

    :/.,709.,573.508,3/,8038041574570984:/ -0 2,39,30/ 94:9 . 90 1,9 41 90

    50450 3 90 :/.,7 84 3/85038,-0 3 ,3 47/07

    84.09.,3349-0570807;0/

    :89;0770.03990151455341904743,4:7943

    99903/,398,3/$90,7/8884.,9434190!55308$!

    ;!553073083.09,9070.,41,$05902-07

    0.8434190$:570204:798$0.43/;843/033,$0.43/

    4943147#0.438/07,94341907:331,;4741$!43,

    2070 09907 1742 !5530 7308 .4:380 99 89094 03/4,

    4 8 90 7054790/ 0,/ .4:380 41 #08543/0398 5,9743088 8003300894 317,,3/94:9706:73,.4220391742

    47349.0949049075,7908940,79078/0-097,#08543/0398

    ,. 41 09., 573.508 ,3/ 8 /8/,3 147 1,73088 . ,8

    074/0/ 90 1,9 41 90 50450 3 90 :/.,7 147 #08543/039

    2801 .,:80/ ,3/ ,40/ 90 ;4,943 41 90 ,/;0780 5,798

    .43899:943,7994/:0574.088

    ,-:8,3;:/0!,,,:,34#%.94-07

    3#0074,947089028,734:7941550,8884.,90:89.002097402097,9390710703.0430,141,$:850.90/7:":0034,7.

    #4370,94394/23897,9;04$

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    25/70

    %02,990782,/0478083.09070.,87054790/94

    ,;0 -003 ,9 90 389,3.0 41#08543/039 4743, 4 ,/2990/

    9,9303-90/174290.,804903.,30:8918

    390710703.0398.,8094/,9,05,79473907107034

    ,9 8 0;03 2470 /89:7-3 8 9,9 :3/07 #08543/039

    4743,8,9.,801:89.090$:570204:79,550,7894-0

    ,.93432070099078059//0317429480.43.0730/,3/90

    49075,7908,3/,1742908,20,078909403/4,

    92:89-070.,0/9,9908,208909403/4,7490

    ,507843,0990794#08543/039.,84.,:80/901514553

    3900,:041908;.,8092:89,84-070.,0/

    9,9 89094 03/4, 8 ,84 90 8,20 507843 4 10/

    /23897,9;0 ,9907 4 $ ,3/ ,8 ,243 90

    509943078390$:570204:79454890/9,97877442,

    ,55439 90 309 01 :89.0 /08590 90 .43899:943, -,3 ,3/

    974: . 509943 2,/0 9 5488-0 147 90 $:57020 4:79 94

    0920 ,3/ 574;/0 349 43 , 897,30/ -:9 4-;4:8 0774304:8

    -,88 147 90 2/39 ,3/ .43899:943,574-90/ ,554392039

    41#08543/039

    3 98 .4330.943 #08543/0398 ;493 5,99073 0;035747 948/:-4:8 ,554392039 ,8 01:89.0.0,7574;08 ,

    -,8 ,3/ 2,31089 5,79,9 147 78 7744 92:89 -0 3490/ 9,9

    :3/0790,-,8300/349-0574;0394,.9:,08998034:

    9,9 90 01 :89.08 ,.9438 03/ 90280;08 94 , 70,843,-0

    8:85.43 9,9 0 /408 349 5488088 90 706:70/ 574-9 ,3/

    25,79,93#48,:74;',3:0;,90$:570204:790/9,9

    :/084:/34943703/07,:89.4770.9,3/

    # 48 ::89 0-7:,7 57 :30

    79:74/0,8974;:/.,,3/,74:3.,3/!708/03947,,.,5,, 7744

    098:57,

    4#%:30

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    26/70

    25,79,/0.843-:984://48438:.,2,3307,894 -0 1700 1742 ,3 8:85.43 ,8 94 98 1,73088 ,3/25,79,9 ,3/,894 8 39079 0, :/0 84:/5488088 5741.03. 3 , 3 47/07 9,9 0 .,3

    .42509039 .43897:0 ,3/ 03147.0 90 , 9 8 247025479,39 9,9 0 84:/ ,.9 ,3/ -0,;0 3 8:. ,2,3307 9,9 90 5,7908 -01470 2 84:/ ,;0.431/03.0 38 25,79,9%:89 8349034:9,90 /0./08 .,808 94:9 -,8 ,3/ 1,;47982 47 8 9

    8:11.0399,9031,.97/828014157054880884388,.9:,9438 84:/ 24704;07 38570 9,9 -001 0

    ,08,7810,:/02:8934943-05:70-:9-043/

    8:85.43&3/078.4738:550/(

    %0-,7807147:/08,3/-310703.0089

    147:89.08,3/24890850.,9001:89.0-0.,:8090

    .,7,.90741,:/08507.0;0/-905045034943974:

    8411.,,.98-:9,84974:857;,90247,8,87010.90/3

    809073,-0,;47%:8

    , :/0 84:/ 3 , 503/3 47 574850.9;0

    9,943-014702-08.7:5:4:8.,701:94,;4/

    8:. ,.943 ,8 2, 70,843,- 903/ 94 ,03 90

    8:85.43 9,9 8 84., 47 -:83088 70,9438 47

    1703/858 .43899:90 ,3 002039 3 /0907233 8

    :/., .4:780 &3/078.473 ,3/ 025,8088:550/(

    1,/0.8439,9 8 0,.4770.947 :891,-0.,3

    8:11071742,8:85.434125,79,9247084,/0.8439,9803970:38:554790/-0,70,8433%:89,8-0030/9,9

    ,:/048347,39411,7002039,7,3/6:901,2,70,

    573.508 ,3/ ,/23897,9;0 70:,9438 ,8 , 2,70/ 503.,39

    147,553:34794/40;03897,30904708,3/.43.0598390

    ,/:/.,943 41 .43974;07808 0-98 3/110703.0 94 ,3/ 0;03

    /8/,3 147 /:0 574.088 ,3/ 90 7:0 41 , ,5508 90 ,

    28., .,57.4:8 ,3/ 4557088;0 ,3/ /85,8 -,8 ,3/

    ,, ; :/0 0 8, 4 % : 07 41 4:79:03.,234;:/008,4%:

    ,343,343841:/.,9.8/23897,9;07/074/,90/::89419005,79203941:89.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    27/70

    5,79,98:31994-0,:/0

    #08543/039 1:7907 .42574280/ 8 3/0503/03.0

    03 8 10 7893, 4743, ,..0590/ ,3 ,554392039 43

    ,7.17427847,774494904,7/419043,

    ,3,02039 47547,943 %0 8 , 4430/

    8:-8/,7 .47547,943 41 90 ,808 43;07843 0;0452039

    :9479,4;0732039430/,3/.439740/.47547,943

    .70,90/:3/07#05:-..94

    $479 ,1907 ,88:23 07 05,3 4- ,9

    8074:8 .425,398 070 10/ ,,389 78 4743, - 07 104

    4,7/202-078,80,8174290,3,02039,3/7,3,3/10

    0254008 41 90 78 4743,8 00.943 ,8 70.947 ,3/

    !708/039 ,8 7054790/ 9/7,3 3 , 7084:943 5,880/ - 90

    4,7/ 41 70.9478 41 -0.,:80 41 ,.98 41 28.43/:.9 ,3/

    3003.0450841904,7/#084:9439/7,378

    4743,8 00.943 ,8 !708/039 ,3/ ,72,3 90 !48943

    !,507 5705,70/ - 90 ,3,02039 ,3/ 90 7083,943

    09907 41 70970/ 4:7941 550,8 :89.0 %04/474 #0341742 90

    4,7/ 41 70.9478 , 41 . .743.0 90 8074:8

    770:,7908 .422990/ - 78 4743, ,70 ,99,.0/ 07094 ,8

    33008,3/70850.9;0

    3890,/ 41 ,.93 :543 90 8074:8 .425,398 ,,389

    78 4743, 78 7744 3897:.90/ , 202-078 41 90 94

    903/07 907 .4:7908 7083,9438 220/,90 1907 90

    7083,9438 78 4743, ,8 709,30/ ,3/ 0;03 5742490/ ,1907

    !708/039 7744 0570880/07 /0870147 784743,8 00.943,8

    ,72,341904,7/

    ,7,307,;4.84348#%#%#%#%#%#%,3/#%$05902-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    28/70

    08590 90 3:2074:8 4907 .425,398 ,,389 78

    4743,3.:/34301742,:4,47#03,/4,:989,070

    0 57490890/ 78 4743,8 24;0 94 705,.0 90 202-078 41 90

    ,3,02039%0,2 3;4,943419090728419 4:3.

    #084:9434.57490.989080.:7941903:70390

    414.,708/03984..:5305489438390.47547,943,.45

    41 8 09907 /,90/ : 8 ,99,.0/ ,8 330 ,3/

    /08590,/;078013/383907054799,9,84089,-80/9,9

    80 ,8 2574507 4/3 411.0 3 $9 3,9:8 ',0 3 ":043

    9784743,,83497024;0/174207548943$0,80;03

    ,40/ 94 7,. :5 :330.088,7 0503808 949,3 $ :3/70/

    309%4:8,3/3/30:3/70/9%700!0848!

    . 80 85039 4/3 411.0 3 ":043 9 03 8

    4507,9438 070 , 3 ,:4 9 .45 41 90 705479 8

    ,99,.0/,8330

    784743,84-,8038:70/9850.1.3897:.9438

    417877440570880/974:80;07,/087009907888:0/9490

    850.1., 94 038:70 90 00.943 41 78 4743, 9480;07,

    5489438390.450841.,70,99,.0/,833008

    ,3/%8,8405,38/08590908074:8.425,398

    ,,389784743,78774430;077024;0/071742-:9

    3890,/059435742493,3/57490.9307

    784743,8,5543920398,;4,94341904/041

    :/.,43/:.99,9574;/08

    :/08 8, 349 ,4 1,2 84., 47 490770,943858 94 31:03.0 :/., .43/:.947 :/2039

    %057089041:/.,411.08,349-0:80/4703994

    ,/;,3.0 90 57;,90 39070898 41 49078 347 .43;0 47

    507294907894.43;090257088439,990,703,850.,54894394 31:03.0 90 :/0$0.,343

    025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    :/08 8, 349 :80 47 03/ 90 570890 41 90:/.,411.094,/;,3.090757;,9039070898479480

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    29/70

    41,202-07419071,2 4741,34300803478,90 .43;0 47 50729 49078 94 .43;0 90 257088439,9 ,3430 8 3 , 850., 548943 2574507 9431:03.0 902 3 90 5071472,3.0 41 :/., /:908

    $0.,343025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    %004/041:/.,43/:.91:7907574;/089,9

    98:309.,147,2,897,90,3/202-0784181,294,814747

    70.0;0,31930.,30147,3,.9/4304794-0/430-90

    :/0390.4:780418:/.,1:3.9438

    :/08,3/202-078419071,2088,30907,8 147 347 ,..059 ,3 19 -06:089 4,3 47 1,;47 370,94394,393/4304794-0/4304742990/94-0/430-247073.4330.9439905071472,3.041 :/., /:908 $0. ,343 025,88 ,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    :/08 8, 349 43 -0 1700 1742 3,557457,90

    .4330.94389,3/ 31:03.0- 9000.:9;0 ,3/08,9;0 -7,3.08 41 4;0732039 -:9 2:89 ,84,550,794-017009070174294,70,843,-04-807;07$0.,343025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    0,7 , 7488 2574507 ,94: 507843, ,3/

    2:9:,-0301.,70,94385-0900390#08543/039,3/78

    7744,8.70,90/03784743,,8,554390/9490%08,:3/07900.:9;005,7920390,/0/-

    787744%0,55439203941784743,3,898089

    2,3,02039 411.07 8 .0,7 3903/0/ 94 80.:70 90 4,9 ,3/

    ;490 41 #08543/039 3 90 $:57020 4:79 3 , 82,7 .,80 90

    $:57020 4:79 14:3/ 9 :309., 147 90 :/0 94 ,4 8

    /,:9078 94 ,..059 90 -:83088 41107 41 5078438 4 ,;0 ,

    503/3.,80-0147090:/08.4:79

    %0 0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9 147 90!5530 :/.,7 5708.7-08 9,9 :/08 8, 038:709,9349438907.43/:.9,-4;070574,.-:99,99

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    30/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    31/70

    ,..4:39.,739490:/.,7507843,0503/9:708

    9890701470,55,70399,99070870,843,-074:3/

    944/#08543/039 147 90 7054790/28:80415:-.1:3/8,3/3

    ,.98 9,9 4:/ 6:,1 ,8 ;4,9438 41 90 ,397,19 ,3/ .477:59

    57,.9.08 ,.9 3.:/3 2,;078,943 41 5:-. 1:3/8 ,3/ :80 41

    5:-.1:3/814757;,905:754808

    3 ,//943 #08543/039 4743, 1,0/ 94 2,39,3

    89,3/,7/8 41 :/., .43/:.9 3 .4330.943 9 90 '.43/0

    2,88,.70 .,80 3 90 574.088.,890/ /4:-9 :543 90 3907941

    90$:570204:799801

    :/08 2:89 0-9,3/ 5742490 89,3/,7/8 41

    :/., .43/:.9 3 47/07 94 703147.0 5:-. .431/03.0 3 90

    :/.,7 . 8 1:3/,2039, 94 90 2,3903,3.0 41 :/.,

    3/0503/03.0 %4 /4 84 9 8 706:70/ 9,9 8 47 07 .43/:.9

    -493,3/4:941.4:792,39,38,3/03,3.0890.431/03.041

    905:-.900,574108843,3/9,39839025,79,94190

    :/0 ,3/ 41 90 :/.,7 3.:/0/ 3 98 5708.75943 41 ,9

    .43899:908 ,..059,-0 ,3/ 343,..059,-0 .43/:.9 8 9,9 7:0

    9,9 :/08 8, 349 343 0 , 574.00/3 8 -01470 47

    .4:/ .420 -01470 902 2,0 ,3 .422039 9,9 2970,843,--0050.90/94,110.9904:9.420418:.574.00/3

    4725,7902,310891,730884190574.088478, :/082,0

    ,3.42203935:-.474907809,929,110.9901,797,41

    ,3 507843 47 88:0 080 :/08 8, 349 3 90

    5071472,3.041:/.,/:908-47/847.43/:.9 2,31089-,8

    $008!7088#00,80890-4078,.98,5700259;024;0:,;,,-0,9995-,:42/,3/.4:707.425.9,8524/0 ,7.;08:.999 1,91: 57394:9 41 90 ,79.0 8,99,.0/,833007041

    $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    32/70

    47570:/.094,7/8,35078434774:5437700;,3974:3/8

    08590 9080 897.9:708 #08543/039 ,8 /70.9

    /0-07,90 ,3/ 8,20088 ,9902590/ 94 /08974 90 .70/-9

    ,3/ 89,3/3 4190 $:57020 4:79 9 70850.9 94 430 25479,39

    ,3/ 5:-..00-7,90/ .,80 9,9 ,8 -01470 9 43 ,:942,9.

    ,550,90.00-7,90/'.43/0,88,.70.,80

    $420920 3 0,7 $05902-07 ,:74 '.43/0

    8:7;;3 202-07 41 90 '.43/0 1,2 4 070 2:7/070/ 3

    ,3/ ,390 2030 41 90 '4:390078 ,389 720 ,3/

    477:5943'5,/,.4:7908.,:54390#08543/03938

    .,2-078,19078,554392039,801:89.0

    :73 90 .4:7908 ., '.43/0 ,80/ 90

    #08543/039 ,-4:9 90 89,9:8 41 90 2:950 2:7/07 .,80 ,,389

    :-079 0-- ,3/ 90 4907 ,..:80/ . ,8 ,9 90 920

    503/3 ,550, -01470 90 $:57020 4:79 08590 90 4-;4:8

    25745709 #08543/039 3890,/ 41 70-:113 '.43/0 147 ,83

    90 6:089438 03,0/ '.43/0 3 , 507843, ,3/ 05,790

    .43;078,943 70,7/3 , .,80903 503/3.438/07,943-01470

    90$:570204:79

    4780 3 90 .4:780 41 90 .43;078,943 #08543/039

    94/ '.43/0 3 90 570803.0 41 2030 9,9 104 :89.0

    39434,754 ,8,00/ 4--3 147 90 ,.6:99, 41:-079

    0-- ..47/3 94 '.43/0 3 , 8473 11/,;9 /,90/ ,3:,7

    #08543/039 8,/ 9,9 %,,,3 -73,-7,84 ,9 3

    25:038,,3 3 ,754 ,3 ,3,3 2, ,8,2, 5,7,

    2,5,,,38,, 8 0-- ,754 ,8 70, ,729893 ,3/

    31:03.38.40,:0894,.6:90--(4747/8949,90110.9

    $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 !04504190!55308;0,3409,#0.02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    33/70

    2030 .4774-47,90/ '.43/08 89,902039 3 8 43 8473

    11/,;9/,90/,3:,7

    %01,.99,9#08543/03985409'.43/070,7/3

    , .,80 503/3 -01470 90 $:57020 4:79 8 3 9801 ,70,/ ,

    8074:8-70,.41907:041.431/039,99,92:89-02,39,30/

    -904:79970850.994.,808503/3-014709,80,890

    /0-07,9438 41 90 202-078 41 90 4:79 $:. .431/039,9 8

    ,-84:90 30.088,7 347/07 94 038:709,9 202-078 41904:79

    ,70 38:,90/ 1742 4--3 ,3/ 57088:70 .423 1742 ,3 41 90

    9,39841,503/3.,80#08543/0398,.943,801:89.08

    39801:3-0.423,3/:347941,01:89.0

    3/00/ 3 #0 09907 41 !7 08/3 :89.0 437,/4

    ',86:090$:570204:798,3.9430/,:89.041904:7941

    550,8 147 , 82,7 ,.9 41 /8.:883 , 503/3 .,80 9

    39070890/5,7908147,;31,0/942,39,39089,3/,7/41

    3/0503/03.0,3/57457099,98706:70/412%0$:57020

    4:791:79070/

    %,3 8 .43;078,943 9 8 -74907 ,3/ 803.4:39078 9 7 /0 47, 940907 :89.0 $,-4;0890257088439,908,..088-0944--89844:/:31,797942,35:,90.4:79574.00/38;03

    ,88:23 ,7:03/4 9,9 :89.0 $,-4 ,8 349 24;0/- 8 -749078 706:089 ,3/ 9,9 0 700.90/ 7 /047,8 -7-0 41107 90 4:79 1008 .42500/ 94 .,:89.0 $,-48 ,9903943 94 8 43 8479.4238 :3/0790.7.:289,3.08990;070,89:89.0$,-484:/,;0 70,0/ 9,9 8 /8.:88438 41 .4:79 2,990780850.,94809,9,;034909-0032,/0415:-.

    70.47/950784384,7039070890/390.,800703.70/- 3/8.7009 ,3/ 903/0/ 94 :3/07230 90

    39079 41 :/., 574.08808 0 800 34 70,843 9470;0780 90 !,308 13/3 9,9 :89.0 $,-48.43;078,9438 9 8 -74907 ,3/ 7 /0 47, 070

    3/8.7009,3/257:/039

    4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    34/70

    $31.,39#08543/039830/,3/.43.:770/990

    ,-4;02039430/ #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 09

    #08543/039 4743, .422990/ 90 8,20 5073.4:8 ,.9 41

    /8.:883,503/3.,80939070890/5,7908

    4780 40;07 8 90 1,.9 9,9 #08543/039 397:0/

    ,,389904347,3/3907941,104:89.038,-803.03

    90 574.088 2,33 ,3/ :3/07233 90 .70/-9 41 90

    $:57020 4:79 ,8,3 3899:9435,393 147 '.43/0, 5.9:70

    41,4:799,988:-0.9949031:03.0414304:941:89.08

    ,3/2,39,550,79,9900;039:,/0.84341904:79390

    .,80 4:/ -0 ,997-:9,-0 94 39073, ,729893 ,3/ 31:03.0

    #08543/039 /089740/ 90 .70/-9 41 90 ;07 3899:943 9,9 0

    ,88:55480/94-00,/3

    3 973 94 53 90 -,20 41 , 5488-0 ,.6:99,

    :543,104:89.0#08543/039,8280184390800/841

    /8.439039,3//897:894190$:570204:799,5,799,398

    9,55030/'.43/0,3/2030//7,80908:55480/39073,

    ,729893,3/31:03.0-014709020/,090.,80,83

    9013,89,0841/0.843574;43'.43/094570025990

    /0.843 9 30,9;0 5:-.9 #08543/039 2801 8 :9 41

    /70.9 :3/07233 90 97:89 ,3/ .431/03.0 41 90 5:-. 3 90$:57020 4:79 70,7/088 41 ,9 98 /0.843 4:/ ,;0 ,907

    9:730/4:994-0

    47808989,990,.94190#08543/039;4,908$0.

    41 #05.9 47 90397,19,3/477:59!7,.9.08.9

    .574-98,3411.,1742/;:3;,:,-031472,94341

    , .431/039, .,7,.907 ,.6:70/ - 8 411.0 47 - 2 43

    ,..4:39418411.,54894394:3,:9470/507843847700,83

    8:. 31472,943 3 ,/;,3.0 41 98 ,:9470/ 700,80 /,90 9 8

    .0,7 1742 90 .43909 41 90 .43;078,943 9 '.43/0 ,3/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    35/70

    20309,9#08543/039,883,390,9907945705,70147,3

    ,.6:99,,3/ ;3 902 8420430 94 -,20 9070147 ;0390

    574104190.,8098349:370,843,-094,88:209,9,990

    920 41 90 .43807;,943 90 $:57020 4:79 ,/ ,70,/ -0:3

    /0-07,9438 43 90 .,80 ,3/ 9,9 #08543/039 ,70,/ ,/ ,

    8038041,990/0.84341904:794:/574-,--0

    #08543/039 4743, 9 :3/:0 ,890 25745709 ,3/

    770:,79/82880/903907509,70.70,943,.47547,943.,80

    :3/078:85.4:8.7.:289,3.08

    #08543/039 ,8 ,..:80/ - 073,3/4 ,2548 41

    :309., .43/:.9 03 0 209 0 5,790 9 90 ,07 41 90

    ,/;07805,793.4330.9439,503/3.,80-0147023,3

    ,990259 94 /0103/ 2801 ,,389 90 .425,39 147 :309.,

    .43/:.9 10/ ,,389 2 - ,2548 #08543/039 05.9

    ,/2990/;4,93 90 0 4/0 41:/., 43/:.9 38 09907

    /,90/ 0-7:,7 94 90 :/., ,3/ ,7 4:3.

    #08543/039701:90/90.,241,25489,90,00/2099

    ,,0741!0-47547,9433.4330.9439,.,80503/3

    -014702-:9.4:39070/9,9

    3 90 .4397,7 9 ,8 ,2548 2801 4 ,.9;0970/9457088:7020394/0./3#4381,;47,85089070/-.,81742/110703950450438

    -0,1843,/288433800.:9;08:22,70,80/ :89.0 303,:90770 $,39,4 ,5:3,3,3/ 043,7/4 ":8:2-3 ,243 49078 94 3907.0/0147225,888:550/

    38;074347/8#08543/039,/2990/9,9;,74:8

    5078438 070 ,-0 94 .422:3.,909 2 3.4330.943 9 ,

    .,80 9,9 ,8 503/3 -01470 2 570.80 3 ,3 ,990259 94

    #4

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    36/70

    31:03.02387084:94341908,/.,803,43280194

    -0,5574,.0/-5078438.03007097394007.80

    907 31:03.0 4;07 2 43 , 5,79.:,7 .,80 503/3 -01470 2

    ,3/ 3 1,3 94 9,0 47 39,90 ,557457,90 /8.53,7 20,8:708

    ,,389 8:. ,.9438 #08543/039 ;4,90/ -,8. 570.0598 41 90

    0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9 . 574;/08 ,243 49078

    9,9

    ,343

    3/0503/03.0

    $0. :/08 8, 007.80 90 :/., 1:3.9433/0503/039 43 90 -,88 41 907 ,880882039 41 901,.98 ,3/ 3 ,..47/,3.0 9 , .438.0394:8:3/0789,3/3 41 90 , 1700 1742 097,304:8

    31:03.0 3/:.02039 57088:70 970,9 47 390710703.0/70.9473/70.91742,36:,790747147,370,843

    $0. :/08 8, 349 ,4 1,2 84., 47 490770,943858 94 31:03.0 :/., .43/:.9 47 :/2039%057089041:/.,411.08,349-0:80/4703994,/;,3.0 90 57;,90 39070898 41 49078 347 .43;0 47507294907894.43;090257088439,990,703,850.,5489439431:03.090:/0$0.:/088,34943-0170017423,557457,90.4330.9438 9 ,3/ 31:03.0 - 90 00.:9;0 ,3/08,9;0 -7,3.08 41 4;0732039 -:9 2:89 ,84

    ,550,794-017009070174294,70,843,-04-807;07

    ,34339079

    $0.:/088,038:709,9349438907.43/:.9

    ,-4;070574,.-:9 9,9 98507.0;0/94-084390;041,70,843,-04-807;07

    $0. %0 -0,;47 ,3/ .43/:.9 41 :/08 2:8970,1172905045081,9390390794190:/.,7

    :89.02:893492070-0/430-:92:89,84-0800394-0/430$0. :/08 84:/ 9,0 47 39,90 ,557457,90

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    37/70

    /8.53,720,8:708,,389,07847.4:7950784330147:3574108843,.43/:.941.90:/02,,;0-0.420,,70

    ,34325,79,9

    $0. :/08 8,038:709,98 4707 .43/:.9-493

    ,3/4:941.4:792,39,38,3/03,3.0890.431/03.041 90 5:-. 90 0, 574108843 ,3/ 9,398 3 90

    25,79,94190:/0,3/4190:/.,7

    ,343'

    !745709

    !745709,3/90,550,7,3.0415745709,70088039,94905071472,3.041,90,.9;90841,:/0

    $0. :/08 8, ,;4/ 25745709 ,3/ 90,550,7,3.041257457093,41907,.9;908

    %47089,903 3#00990741!708/3:89.0437,/4

    ',86:090$:570204:790/9,98:..43/:.9,24:390/94

    , 1,:70 94 2,39,3 90 89,3/,7/ 41 3/0503/03.0 ,3/

    57457099,98706:70/41,:/0

    47 025,88 #08543/039 830/ ,3/ .43.:770/ 9

    90 ,-4;02039430/ #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 $:70

    #08543/039,801:89.0.,3349-0002591742908,207:0

    ,3/573.50801:89.002:893 1,.9-00/94,07

    89,3/,7/%0$:570204:791:79078,/41:89.08

    0 9 2, -0 97:0 9,9 1742 , 58.44.,

    89,3/543947/3,75078438.,3,;0,/0;,70941;,/ 70,.9438 94 ,3 ;03 89:,943 :89.0 $,-4

    84:/-0,7323/8411.0,8,2,897,904190,550,90 .4:79 8098 2 ,5,79 1742 47/3,7 5078438

    03908:-0.941.4389,395:-.8.7:93202-07841

    90-03.84:/1700,3/3,..059-0,;47,

    70897.9438 9,92, -0;00/-47/3,7 .9038 ,8

    4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    38/70

    -:7/038420025,888:550/

    4704;07#08543/0393494384:/,;08.7:5:4:8

    :,7/0/ 8 705:9,943 ,8 , $:57020 4:79 :89.0 9 -044;0/

    :543294,;0/430,5489;0,.994038:709,9,2548,3/

    90 ,99078 0288,708-0 /0,9 9 ,/23897,9;0 147 90 -7,03

    ,990259 94 31:03.0,2,897,90 4190$:57020 4:79%80

    :99071,0/94/4

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% # %%

    &! '% %

    $%%&%%%%

    $## % !#!

    $!#% !#$

    $$& $%%&$ "& %

    ## $% % &$

    #!#$%%'$ % $# % !%

    % &$

    #%$ '##

    &%##

    3 $05902-07 2-:/82,3 07.0/9,8

    :90770 10/ , !09943 147 07947,7 ,3/ !74-943 -01470 90

    $:57020 4:79 8003 94034390 4229900 43:89.0 41 90

    4:80 41#05708039,9;08 1742 574.00/3 9 90 250,.2039

    574.00/38,,38907:907708895,0/!0994357,0/147

    , %02547,7 #0897,33 7/07 ,,389 90 250,.2039

    574.00/38

    -/ $0.943,343419004/041:/.,43/:.9254808:543:/08,3

    4-,943 94 9,0 47 39,90,557457,90 /8.53,7 20,8:708 ,,389 ,078 47.4:79 50784330 147:3574108843,.43/:.941.90 :/02, ,;0 -0.420,,70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    39/70

    9 :3/:0 ,890 90 1443 /, ,1907 13

    #08543/039220/,909,-0/:907708!09943/08590901,.9

    9,9 349 , 90 :89.08 ,/ 70.0;0/ 47 70,/ 90 !09943

    #08543/039 7,74,/0/ 90 574.00/38 3 47/07 94 ,;0 , $9,9:8

    ":43907/0788:0/31,;4741:90770%8,8.431720/-

    :89.0 ,7, 4:7/08 $07034 3 07 43.:773 5343 94 90

    0-7:,70.843

    3 , 13, 3490 90 88:,3.0 41 90 $9,9:8 ":4390 7/07 3 98 .,80 ,8 2489 :31479:3,90 9 ,8

    88:0/ 4;07 90 4-0.9438 41 :89.08 39434 ,75443.9,,75447,08,3/2801-00;0/903,8 -00;0 34 9,9 90 4:79 3 88:3 90 8,/ 47/07,8 4;07 397:8;0 9 70850.9 94 , 5407 9,9 /408349 -043 94 9 - 70897,33 94:9 0,73 , .406:, -7,3. 41 4;0732039 %8 -001 ,8 2,/02470,.:90-901,.99,99047/07,8;490/:5433

    902473341$05902-0794:990-0301941

    ,03:30314720//0-,9083.080;07,202-07841

    904:792801 3.:/0/,/3490990370.0;0/,

    .454190!09943

    $:570204:79/0;0770.0595:-80/-90308

    2,,3008-70,,84840/9,924894190:89.0870.0;0/

    90!09943,190790/0-07,943809700:89.084;490/

    94 88:0 90 $9,9:8 ":4390 7/07 70.0;0/ 90 509943 43 43

    $05902-07 , /, ,1907 9089,9:8 6:4 ,390 47/07 ,8

    7,390/%080:89.08070:89.08'0,8.4078,23,3/!070

    %088:,3.04190$9,9:8":43907/078,-097,,

    41 90 5:-. 97:89 83.0 9 .0,7 840/ #08543/0398

    ,3/0/3088-,88:-807;03.0,3/5,798,385%088:,3.041,

    #4$05902-07 $00 330, .454190/0;07705479,8 8039 -90$:57020 4:7994 90

    43 #4/414 ,7N,8 $00 ,84 330 147 , 1,91: 57394:9 41 90 /0;0770.059,85:-80/-08-70,398,79.00;0770.059848:89.08;490/43 :90770 509943 -01470 70.0;3 .4508 ,;,,-0 43995308-70,5/0;0770.059848:89.08;490/43:90770509943-0147070.0;3.4508

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    40/70

    $9,9:8":43907/07,,389,.406:,-7,3.414;0732039

    94:9 0;03 90 -03019 41 90 :89.08 70,/3 90 /0.843 8 ,

    97,33., ,-:80 41 5407 94 1,;47 , 9,39 ,3/ 94 4-897:.9 90

    250,.2039 574.088 %0 88:,3.0 41 90 47/07 ,84 /70.9

    ;4,908 90 573.50 41 805,7,943 41 54078 83.0 90 $:57020

    4:79570;0390/904:801742/4398.43899:943,2,3/,9041

    39,93250,.2039574.00/38

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#& %

    #%##$$!#%%

    $$%%$##%

    !#!#$&%%

    $$''%

    #% %$ %

    !#% % $

    %!#'

    %0573.504122:9,-94113, :/20398843041

    90 57247/, 7:08 147 ,;3 , .70/-0 ,3/ 0110.9;0 88902 41

    ,/23897,94341:89.0&3/0798573.50

    9,943 2:89 03/ ,3/ 90723,90 8420920 ,3/8420070,3/98088039,94,30110.9;0,3/011.039,/23897,943 41 :89.0 9,9 43.0 , :/2039 ,8

    -0.42013,903335,79-0349 974:,20708:-9071:0/057;0/419017:984190;07/.9

    8 05,30/ - 90 $:57020 4:79 3 98 0,7089 0,78

    8:. , 573.50 8 ,3 25479,39 706:702039 147 , .70/-0 ,3/0110.9;08890241,/23897,94341:89.09:8

    43.,.;$,3/,3-,,3#,.932;,-,/0#457$#

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    41/70

    9 8 97:0 9,9 9 8 90 5:75480 ,3/ 3903943 41 90 ,9,9.4:79884://0./0,6:0894388:-2990/94902+,8 97:9 ,3/ :89.0 706:70 ,3/9,9 9 870,9 94 -0/0870/ 9,9 , :/20398 84:/ -0 84 /0./0/ -:9

    .439743,3/770889-070,8438415:-.54.,3/4184:3/ 57,.9.0 3 90 .4:798 /02,3/ 9,9 ,9 90 78414..,843, 07747 :/20398 41 .4:798 /0907233.43974;07808 8:-2990/ 94 902 84:/ -0.42013, ,98420/0139092010/-,47-,7:04157,.9.0

    70.430/ - , 84 ,8 94 -0 9070,1907 -043/ 90.43974 0;03 41 90 .4:79 . 703/070/ 902 147 90

    5:7548041.4770.93077478411,.94741,394.3 90 45343 41 90 .4:79 9 2, ,;0 1,03 %0 ;075:75480 147 . 90 .4:798 ,70 47,30/ 8 94 5:9 ,3

    03/94.43974;07894/0./0906:0894388:-2990/94909,398,3/94/09072309070850.9;079841905,7908 9 90 1: 340/0 9,9 .4:798 ,70 34931,-0 90 9,398 8:-29 907 70850.9;0 .,28 147:/2039,3/90,;0,79,9842092047490794,;0 13, :/2039 43 . 90 .,3 70 ,8 , 13,/8548943419088:08:-2990/,3/94349,990708,303/94909,943

    #08543/03940;07 ,89:730/8-,. 43 98920

    43470/ 573.50 41 90 22:9,-9 41 13, :/20398 3 349 :89

    430 -:9 80;07, .,808 41 5:-. 831.,3.0 9:8 ,43 90

    4:79 94 ,3 5:-. 3494709 ,8 , 1514553 4:79 9 0,89

    94 41 9080 151458 ,70 343 94 ,;0 -003 389,90/ 974:

    507843, 099078 47 05,790 .422:3.,9438 ,//70880/ 94 90

    #08543/039

    730/4;470390!,9 $00 1470,250 #06:04 #$:57020 4:79 151458 7/ 920 8 30 .908

    ,3,$9,3/,7/0-7:,733007041#06:04#9080,:0/054708 .4:79 15145 ,3,$9,3/,7/,7. 330! 07041.023,/, ! $:57020 4:79 15145 .431:808 .9 2,478 !5530 $9,70-7:,7 330" 07041 420 #4 43.908 7,08 ,8 $15145 7--0/!5530, 36:707 ,7. 330#07041 3,,938 3 30 $ 15145 $:7,4 %4/, , 3309958:7,494/,.42/3,,9383308.1514592 330$07041#42074!$:89.098500784;071514508-70,57330%07041

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    42/70

    %700.00-7,90/.,808,;05,79.:,7089,-80/90

    $:57020 4:798 1514553 705:9,943 90 0,:0 41 908 ;

    .,803;4;390.70,9434130.90890.,8041

    ,;,774;729,.3;4;0/9057424943413,,98,3/

    1742 2:3.5,994 574;3.0 ,3/ 90$! ;!55307308

    3.09,.,80.3;4;0/90709703.2039570;4:80/

    94-00,4119,9903/,398-903,94381,.,7707390

    900,:041908,3/$!.,80890#08543/0398.:5,-9

    ,8 -097,0/ - 90 1,.9 9,9 90 15145 ,8 570.0/0/ -

    507843, ,3/ 05,790 .422:3.,9438 349 50,/38 1742 ,

    ,0741,5,79,3/.0707,390/94:9;3904907

    5,79,3349.0 47/:0574.088 3 90 ,;,774 .,80 90 15145

    ,8 389,90/ - 90 3907;03943 41 3435,7908 4 8944/ 94

    -0301913,3.,,3/549.,174290704503341,13,,3/

    00.:947:/20399490473,.,80

    %0 0,:0 41 908 ; .,80 ,8 473,

    /0./0/-90$:570204:79434;02-07070390

    4:79 /0.,70/ ,8 :3.43899:943, ,3/ ;4/ 90 .43;07843 41

    2:3.5,908 394 .908 /:0 94 1,:70 94 2009 90 0,

    706:7020398 147 3.420 147 .908 :3/07 90 4., 4;0732039

    4/0 &543 24943 147 70.438/07,943 %0 4:79 ,11720/ 98

    :/2039 43 57 ,1907 90 4:79 /030/ , 574-90/80.43/2494314770.438/07,94310/-902:3.5,908%0

    7:3-0.,2013,43,

    08590 90 13,9 41 90 473, :/2039 ,8 0 ,8

    90 89,3/3 574-943 ,,389 , 80.43/ 24943 147

    70.438/07,943 90 ,70;0/ 5,7908 5078890/ 3 8003 ,

    70;078,41904:798473,/0.843%010/80;07,50,/38

    ,4-;4:83903/0/94.7.:2;03990574-943,,38980.43/

    0,:041908;8:57, #57$!;!8:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    43/70

    ,3/8:-806:03924943814770.438/07,943,3/948:-;079907:0

    4322:9,-94113,:/20398949

    , 4943 94 203/ 90 #084:943 41 57

    0.,733890,/9,9#08543/0398 4943147

    #0.438/07,9434190#084:94341,7.,3/

    49431470,;0940,3/%4/2999,.0/$0.43/

    4943 147 #0.438/07,943 41 90 0.843 ,90/

    4;02-07#02,3&37084;0/,3/9443/:.9

    :7907 !74.00/38 %07043 4943 94 203/ 90

    #084:9434157

    -4943147#0.438/07,9434190#084:94341

    :30

    .&7039494394#084;0!03/33./0398

    / 550, 944347,-001:89.0#03,94 $

    !:34,3/884.,90:89.039434/:,7/4,.:7,

    94 !,79.5,90 3 90 #084:943 41 #08543/0398 4943

    147#0.438/07,9434190#084:94341:30

    3,3:,7900,.4:380487054790/,84900,/.4:38041147207!708/0397744307!:3/07,3/

    4907 .,808800 33008 94 ( 147 90 89003 .908

    89094 03/4, 7490 , 507843, 09907 349 , 50,/3 94 90

    $:57020 4:79 ,83 147 90 4:79 94 70.438/07 98 /0.843 -

    ,43 90 5,79.5,943 41 :89.08 4 070 349 5708039 /:73

    90/0-07,9434190473,/0.843/,90/4;02-07

    34907 507843, 09907 349 , 50,/3 ,88039 94 90 $:57020

    4:79 - 90 4., .01 00.:9;08 41 90 89003

    2:3.5,908574850.9;0.908

    3.40,7$0990788978:85.4343.944/!5530,36:707::89

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    44/70

    30.02-0790$:570204:7970;0780/90

    /0.843 41 4;02-07 /08590 90 1,.9 9,9 90 /0.843

    ,8 ,70,/ 13, ,3/ 00.:947 ,3/ 9,9 90 50,/38 ,3/

    .422:3.,9438 9,9 0/ 94 90 /0.843 070 0907 057088

    574-90/ 50,/38 47 34350,/38 9,9 ,;0 34 5,.0 3

    9,9434790#:08414:79

    %8 5742590/ 90 0,:0 41 908 94 10 , 24943 147

    70.438/07,9439470;0780900.02-077:3.,390

    ,990394341904:7994903.4388903.4190/0.843990

    89,3/3#:08414:79,3/90573.5084113,941:/20393

    ::89 90 $:57020 4:79 70;0780/ 90 0.02-07

    /0.843,3/70389,90/98473,4;02-07/0.843

    8 01 :89.0 ,3/ 0,/07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 0 84:/ 349

    ,;0,40/904:7994039079,3574-90/50,/38-0.,:809

    :3/072308903907941904:79,3/987:0841574.0/:70

    08590 98 7:3 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07

    #08543/0398 0,/0785 903 039079,30/ ,3 :3:8:, ,3/ 949,

    :3570.0/0390/ 14:79 24943 147 70.438/07,943 10/ - 90

    2:3.5,908 43 $05902-07 3 0-7:,7 90

    4:79 7,390/ 90 24943 147 70.438/07,943 ,3/ 70;0780/ 90

    70;078, 41 90 70;078, 41 90 473, /0.843 0 9 70389,90/ 98 770:,7 /0.843 70;0783 , :/2039 9,9 ,/ 43 -003

    13, ,3/ 00.:947 %0 :3570.0/0390/ 1514553 41 90

    $:570204:79,55030/3:89,85,341824398,3/:3/0790

    8,209:90,041#08543/0394743,

    $:-806:039 390.,8041,;,774;729,/0,3

    990.43899:943,94190.70,9434190!74;3.0413,,9

    1,91: 57394:9 41 90 ,79.0 ,8 14:3/ 399530831436:70730936:7070,/30870438;00,7$0990788978:85.43843.944/8,99,.0/,8330&

    $:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    45/70

    8,3/ 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/0398 ,9. ,,3

    50714720/ :/., ,.74-,9.8 03 9 70;0780/ 98 473, /0.843

    0;0394:9,/,70,/-0.42013,,3/00.:947,89,9:8,

    90247090/-901,.99,99070,8,70,/,339741

    :/2039

    398.,8090$:570204:79,//0./0/,,38990

    .43899:943,9 41 90 .70,943 41 90 !74;3.0 41 3,,9 8,3/

    -,. 3 0-7:,7 %0 :/2039 -0.,20 13, ,3/

    00.:947,3/,339741:/2039,82,/043,

    ..47/3 94 90 #:08 41 4:79 90 397 41 :/2039 8 ,

    238907,,.99,9 70.47/890,-84:90 770;4.,-9 41,/0.843

    41,.4:79,1907908,20,8-0.42013,,3/00.:947043/

    ,5,:8-070,84340;0790$:570204:7914:3/9020,38

    94 .43/:.9 90 ;07-, 23,89.8 ,3/ 802,39. .439479438

    30.088,7945071472,949,:3570.0/0390/:/.,842078,:9

    %8 ,2,3 2,30:;07 ,8 ,..42580/ :543 90

    389,943 , 1: 2439 ,1907 90 0397 41 :/2039 41 84.,0/

    249438 147 3907;03943 - 90 574850.9;0 574;3., 411.,8 ,3/

    .43708843,705708039,9;08413,,98,3/.070/030/

    - 90 4:79 .438/073 9,9 90 070 349 0;03 5,7908 94 90

    473,574.00/38,3/3907;03943.,3349-0,40/,190790.,80,8,70,/-00390723,90/%8,81440/-,3&7039

    494394#0.,39741:/2039/,90/.94-0710/-

    90803435,7908.904:799037,390/5,;390,147

    ,70.438/07,943,3/70;078,4190:/2039.,8,70,/

    13,

    3 84 /43 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/0398

    0,/0785,82,/0,97,;08941 98437:0841 574.0/:70,3/

    /0243897,90/9,990708,.9:,4343025479,397:0070

    90708,,3/.4330.94390708,,3/0;07939,9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    46/70

    ,078 34 ,-4:9 :/., 574.0/:70 .42243 80380 1,7 5,

    ,3/ :89.0 -0.420 2449 ,3/ ,.,/02. 03 .43174390/

    998507;078434190#:08414:79$4-,9,39.4397,794,

    :/.,70,843,898,.941904:799,90;03884.,90:89.0

    74354390/4:93888039353439,990/0.843/70.9

    ;4,90/984339073,7:08,3/,90,8997002,4714:3/,943841

    90,/23897,94341:89.05,79.:,7

    ,907:04370.438/07,943-,43,24943

    147 70.438/07,943 .4397,7 94 90 7:0 ,,389 80.43/

    249438 147 70.438/07,943 ,3/ ,1907 90 574.00/38

    ,/,70,/90723,90/

    -907:04313,941:/20398-7045033,

    .,809,9,70,/,99,30/13,9974:90,791.041

    ,249439470.,039741:/2039,3/

    .907:0433907;03943-,433907;03943

    ,190790574.00/38,/,70,/90723,90/

    3 1,.9 884.,90 :89.0 743 .4:/ 349 /0 8

    ,-84:90 /8:89 9 90 4:798 7:3 3 8 /88039 .483 9 ,8

    1448

    &30 90 .,80 41 ,,7:8 4 7480 1742 90/0,/ 974: , 27,.0 3,,9 708:770.90/ -0.,:8090 4:79 /870,7/0/ 98 43 7:08 ,3/ 089,-80/:7857:/039, 573.508 1 .4:780 9 .,3 82,7 -0.,0/,27,.0,83470;078,.4:/,;09,035,.01:89430419080708 4197,38708843854390/ 4:9//349 9,0 5,.0 4 8:. 708:770.943 .,3 ,5503 3

    90$:570204:798,.4393:384:7.04143/07

    729,;,;,7748:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    47/70

    %080 94 .,808 43 0772,3/073 ,70 41 .4:780 43

    945 41 90 .,80 41 $! ; !5530 7308 3. .

    84.,808 90 $:57020 4:798 503.,39 147 88:3 1514553

    /0.8438 3 98 .,80 90 $:57020 4:79 ,/ ,70,/

    5742:,90/ , /0.843 /,90/ : 4/3 9,9 90

    709703.20390110.90/-!34124709,3419819

    ,9903/,398,80,%8/0.843-0.,2013,,190790$:57020

    4:79/030/913,9!8 49438 147 #0.438/07,943 43

    .94-07 ,3/ $05902-07 :74:8 40;07 90

    #084:9438/033!849438147#0.438/07,94307070.,0/

    - ,34907 #084:943 3 ,9 80020/ 94 -0 , 805,7,90

    ,/23897,9;0 .,80 4 $ 43 90 840 -,88 41 ,

    507843,099078:-2990/9490$:570204:79-8909403/4,

    !8,073/,89900,:041908;.,8034

    455479:39 ,8 ;03 94 90 4907 5,79 94 708543/ 94 89094

    03/4,8 507843, ,550, 09907 ,9 9080 1514553

    /0.8438 .0,7 089,-8 8 9,9 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07

    #08543/039 4743,8 ,9. 83 94 -03/ 4;07 -,.,7/8 94

    ,..424/,902070099078-0,739083,9:704147207!708/039

    47,,.,5,,77448,07

    ' #08543/039 097,0/ 90 !:-.

    %7:89 774,93 &394 28013/%44229900070,90/

    %0 :9479 3/ :78/.943 %4

    25745073;089,90300/

    773 02-07 1 %0 $:57020

    4:79 47 %0 !:75480 1

    .:5,93 2 $:. :9479

    3/ :78/.943 8 !74507

    #05480/%043899:943390

    4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 ;,

    250,.2039

    ,343 80. 41 90 0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9

    /02,3/8097020247,89,3/,7/841,:/08,3/:89.08

    $:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    48/70

    90 2:89 038:70 9,9 349 43 907 .43/:.9 8 ,-4;0 70574,.

    -:9 9,9 9 8 507.0;0/ 94 -0 84 3 90 ;0 41 , 70,843,-0

    4-807;07%88-:9.438890399,;07433041:7857:/03.0

    ,/ - 90 $:57020 4:79 9,9 :/08 84:/ ,;4/ , 14728 41

    25745709 3.:/3 90 ,550,7,3.0 41 25745709 9 8 ,84

    57,.9.,,:3;078,7:0,243:/.,70847//0

    %0'3:,;80.:9;0$0.709,7 .,80.43.0730/ ,

    509943 - 4907 0, 8.4,78 43 -0,1 41 90 8:7;;3 534

    .42147942034203570880/39480:,8,;07-4..:53,5,3080147.08/:7390$0.43/47/,7439090479,9

    90574-943 ,,3897,50,3/80:,,-:80 3920841,7 8:8

    .4038339073,943,,,3/9070147090$9,90,/,/:994

    5:78:0907.,28174290,5,30804;0732039&54370;041

    90 4:798 /0.843 /033 90 .421479 42038 509943 9 ,8

    ,00/ 9,9 7,25,39 5,,782 ,8 .422990/ - 90 5430390

    884.,90:89.0,7,34/0,894

    %0,00/5,,7823'3:,.425780/90;07-,92

    193 94:9 ,997-:943 ,3/ 03.425,883 -49 90 473,

    ,:9478 79903 909 ,3/ 144934908 41 831.,39 5479438 41 -448

    ,3/ ,79.08 1742 39073,943, , 4:73,8 9,9 8:554790/ 90

    9047 9 0,89 9700 14703 ,:9478 478 070 ,00/

    5,,70/:9,8/017429088:0415,,7829801,1907.453

    174290,79.08904:79,00/2,/0902,550,7948:55479

    90 4554890 .43.:843 0 90 4:79 :80/ 902 94 /03 90

    509943 070,8 90 2,907,8 507 80 84:/ ,;0 -003 8003 94

    1,;47907,39907041

    9 ,550,78 9,9 9 , .0,7 39039 41 04307,93 ,

    202-07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 #08543/039 3 ;4,943 41 90

    #457

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    49/70

    43899:943 14720/ ,3 9.8 4229900 9,9 /0907230/ 90

    .:5,-9 41 , :89.0 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,3 250,.,-0

    411.07 #08543/039 ,/ 34 5407 94 /4 98 83.0 :3/07 90

    43899:943905407942,0,..4:39,-0250,.,-0411.078

    -0430/ 94 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 %:8 #08543/039

    -097,0/ 90 5:-. 97:89 - ,774,93 :394 2801 ,3/ 94 ,

    42299000.70,90/ 90,:9479,3/ :78/.943943;089,90

    ,3 ,00/ 202-07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 %4 70907,90 8:.

    ,:9479,3/:78/.943,8-003705480/-9043899:943390

    4:8041#05708039,9;08;, 250,.2039 .43899:93 8:. ,

    .4229900,3/-,774,93:3942801540794/090723090

    .:5,-9 41 :89.0 /0 ,894 ,3/ 04307,93 2 3 90 03/

    #08543/0399070-03.74,.0/43908405407,3//:94190

    4:8041#05708039,9;0894/0907230-250,.20390907

    :89.00,894 ,8 94-00/,..4:39,-03;4,943 4190

    573.50 41 805,7,943 41 54078 41 90 08,9:70 ,3/ 90

    :/.,7

    9 2, -0 70.,0/ 9,9 90 473, ,:9478 805,7,90.425,30/ 94 90 $:57020 4:79 ,-4:9 90 3./039 0 90

    509943078 10/ , 24943 147 70.438/07,943 -:9 90 #08543/039

    850,3 974: 90 4:79 /23897,947 39, ,334:3.0/ 9,9

    34 ,.943 4:/ -0 9,03 43 90 2,9907

    %8 ,8 /08590 9070.0594190.425,3981742901789419700,:9478303

    903:2-0741,:9478,/3.70,80/949700//90#08543/039

    $00,57416:0894385,,7824147,,,::89,;,,-0,99952,,,.42530892 , 1,91: 57394:9 41 . 8,99,.0/ ,8330' $00 ,84 90 3/;/:, 09907 41 7 789,3 %,28 .:80/ 94 -0 ,;,,-0 ,9 9958.7-/.42/4.%,280990794$:570204:79 ,.4541 .8 ,99,.0/07094,8330'02,417

    ,7 8 . ,8 6:490/ 09038;0 3 !,-:,3 :947 108 .425,399$!5530,36:707:,.4541.8,99,.0/07094,8330 ' ,3/ , .422039 2,/0 - 7 ;,3 7//0 3 70854380 94 : 39073,943, , 5,,782 -0/0;8 !55308 $:57020 4:79 :89.09954534:784739073,943,,5,,782.,70-0/0;85553088:57020.4:79:89.0,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/07094,8330'

    !,-:,3.4:79349 574-35,,782!5530,36:707:30.454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    50/70

    /0./0 94 ,.9 - ,334:3.3 90 1472,943 41 ,3 9.8 #0;0

    4229900.425780/41202-0784190 4:79 94 3;089,9090

    2,9907

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#&$ !#%%

    #% %!##

    #$%# ## %#

    '# ## !#$%

    # !##

    # &$ $ &

    ####%'%

    !!#%&% % $!!#$&% % #&$%#%

    % $ &$%

    $%#% % $&!# %

    $ % %'%

    % %# ' #

    % ! % %

    %$ % $&!#

    %$%#

    %0$:570204:79:3/0790#08543/039305.,-

    .4384/,90/90805,7,90509943810/-147207!708/03947,

    ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 07 :8-,3/ :0 7744 3 47/07 94

    6:0894390;,/94190,9.897/07888:0/,,389902-

    9005,79203941:89.05:78:,39947.:,74743.,

    88:0/ - 90 :3/07 77448 ,/23897,943 .4384/,93

    90 5099438 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/039 :3/: ,;0

    :0 7744 ,3 :3,77,390/ -03019 83.0 90 ,00/ :7039

    0,9300/841!708/03977444:/34-00903/0/942

    4780 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 90 #08543/039

    220/,90,.90/:54390!09943,3/7,390/90%#/08590

    90 1,.9 9,9 9070 ,70 .0,7 3.4388903.08 3 147207 !708/039

    77448 509943 9,9 .,898 8074:8 /4:-98 43 90 83.079 ,3/

    :703. 41 07 706:089 94 0,;0 90 !55308 8 /09,0/ 3 90

    33$:570204:797010785,,782.,809409.8.4229900!5530,36:707:.454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

    #48,3/4;02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    51/70

    /88039 41 :89.0 , 4:7/08 $07034 !708/039 7744 57080390/

    3.43889039 ,3/ 574-,- :397:91: 89,9020398 ,-4:9 07

    89:,943 :89.0 $07034 .90//4.:203988:-2990/- 90 147207

    5708/0398 /4.9478 -03 07 .,28 41 970,9 94 10 8/0 1742

    .,3083908941.4:3970880,390/94;89!708/0397744

    ,8,845,333945,79.5,90394.4310703.0803.0:89.0

    $07034 3490/ 9 80028 3.437:4:8 147 50994307 4 ,8 ,80/

    9005,79203941:89.0,3/984:7994449:2,39,7,3

    .43.073 43 07 570.,74:8 89,90 41 0,9 94 .4229 07801 94

    ,9903/9080200938,3/.4310703.08,990784147803307

    58.,.43/943

    4704;07 9 ,550,78 1742 7054798 9,9 90 5430390 94

    429050994380707,110/,8,3884.,90:89.0&3/0790

    39073,#:084190$:570204:79,%#.,343-0.438/070/

    :543 90 70.42203/,943 41 90 5430390 ;/039 3 ;0 41

    .079,3 4-0.9438 ,,389 90 7,39 41 90 %# , 4/3 41 ,

    0,73939084795074/411;0/,8,870.42203/0/

    08590 98 70.42203/,943 90 #08543/039 0330070/ ,

    2,479 41 ;4908,8,,3891;0 /88039078 90 220/,907,39

    ,3/88:,3.04190%#31,;4:741147207!708/0397744,3/07

    :8-,3/3-,9,39;4,943419074339073,7:08

    9,84,550,78174290.447/3,90/,.98419077448

    9,990070.447/3,939#08543/03984:79474.,39

    -0 05,30/ 9,9 90 2,/0 2:950 -4438 43 90 8,20 /,

    050.93 9,9 90 .,3 0,;0 90 .4:397 43 90 ;078,20 /,

    90750,147,%#,894-0/0./0/98349/11.:9948009,9

    90,8988:,3.04190%#,8,-7,03,..4224/,9439490

    7744849439,9#08543/039-0394;07-,.,7/894,/,3/

    ,-0990774485,3940,;090.4:3974390;07/,4190

    80884343907%#50,%04:798411.04:789,9:8:,03/,9

    52070 0903/0/ 94 ,4 90 77448 94 5489 , 20,8 !

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    52/70

    243-43/,907,3/904:79574.088807;07,8/7,190/94807;0

    90%#:54390,3/90$,1907411.04:78

    84/085909,91,.99,9904:79:3/07#08543/039

    ,/ /43 .43/9438 147 90 88:,3.0 41 90 %# #08543/039

    ,40/9088:,3.04190%#349989,3/3901,.99,99,8

    089,-80/ 9,9 !708/039 7744 ,3/ :0 7744 1,0/ 94

    .425 9 ,3 088039, 570.43/943 9,9 ,8 20,39 94 038:70

    90 ;0893 41 .4:79 :78/.943 3 90 0;039 90 77448 100

    57480.:943%0.43/943,8949

    %0 509943078 8, ,55439 , 0,705708039,9;0.4224394-4941902470.0;0

    8:-5403, 47/078 ,3/ 4907 0, 574.08808 43 907

    -0,1 /:73 907 ,-803.0%05099430788, 8:-29903,2041900,705708039,9;0,84931;0

    /,81742349.00704125,888:550/

    %0$50.,!40741994730/,90/4;02-07

    .9088:0/94907.4:3801,89489,909,9907.4:380,/

    9054079470.0;08:-5403,847/078,3/49070,574.08808

    3890,/90430254070/907.4:38094574/:.08:22438

    4770.0;0/4.:2039,70;/03.0

    %,9 # ! ## 41 0,,02,770/5349708/03.0,9,/,4$97009!,384 ":043 9 /4 070- 3,20 .43899:90 ,3/

    ,55439 %% # %! 080 41 0,,05349411.0,//7088,974:3/1447$,%3 %4078 ,;07 $9 79,8 03907 !,8 0974,3,,82 0,705708039,9;0390!55308,3/94-0297:0,3/,1:,99473031,.914723,205,.0,3/ 890,/ 94 /4,3/5071472 901443 ,.98,3/938949

    %483;071,3/10,7990389,902039

    %42,0,3/57080399490.4:79,3,55.,9433.4330.9439,3574.00/383908:9%4574/:.08:224384770.0;0/4.:2039,7

    0;/03.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    53/70

    %42,0,3/10.4257428047,.4310884341:/2039,3/947010790.,8094,7-97,943%4/05489,3/9/7,,32430147905:75480

    41,3574.00/3%44-9,3.450841/4.:20398,3/5,5078,3/0307,94/4,4907,1:,.9830.088,714790.43/:.941908,/.,8025,888:550/

    ;79:0419077448,-0.91,:7094.425998570

    .43/943 90 %# 84:/ 349 ,;0 -003 88:0/ 347 /0020/

    0110.9;0

    :0 94 90 77448 ,-0.9 1,:70 94 .425 9

    43/943 90 $:57020 4:79 03-,3.3984;02-07

    /0-07,9438-,;4904114:3/9,99070,834.425,3.0

    9 90 80.43/ .43/943 41 90 %# 43806:039 147 1,:70 94

    .425 9 ,3 088039, .43/943 147 90 %# 90 %# 8 349

    0110.9;040;07-,;4904190$:570204:79/0./0/

    9070,834300/9405.989,90900,0110.94390%#41

    90 343.425,3.0-5099430789 43/943 :2-07 4190

    0,707 #084:943 8 8:..3.9 89,90/ 3 :89.0 , 4:7/08

    $070348/88039

    %0 2,479 ,7:0/ 9,9 8:. , .,71.,943 8

    :330.088,7 -0.,:80 9 8 .0,7 9,9 90 %# 8

    .43/943, ,3/ .,3349 -0 2,/0 :80 41 :39

    .425,3.0 ,8 -003 /430 9,890701470 90 803804190 2,479 9,9 ,8,3 411844941 90 333 ;4909,9 9070 ,8 1,:70 - 509943078 94 .425 943/943 :2-07 90 %# 8 25.9 /0020/8:8503/0/:3990708.425,3.098:..43/943;07430 -00;0/ 9,9 9 4:/ -0 .0,7 94 , 9,9 ,

    .43/943,%#8,998.43/943,

    40;07 90 $:57020 4:79 $5408507843 /,8

    ,76:02,/0,5:-..,2.,8,70/3,20/,4:9098

    9,9904:79489038-/0./0/9,990%#,80110.9;0/08590

    #48,3/4;02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    54/70

    343.425,3.0 9 ,3 088039, .43/943 41 90 %# 0 0;03

    54890/9,99077448.,3890,;090.4:39798349,-09,9

    #08543/039 // 349 .,8980 ,76:0 147 8 4:979 1,80 ,3/

    5:-.28705708039,943#08543/039,801:89.084:/,;0

    .,0/949,8,76:0147280,/3905:-.,894902547941

    90$:570204:79803-,3.7:33890,/0702,30/8039,3/

    // 349 -4907 94 .4397,/.9 ,76:0 9070- ,/3 ,76:0 3

    8570,/31,80308,-4:990,.9434190$:570204:79

    478090#08543/039//349.4770.990/0.8439,9

    ,8 88:0/ /08590 90 1,.9 9,9 90 /0.843 // 349 7010.9 90

    ,7002039 ,3/ /0.843 2,/0 -90$:57020 4:79/:73 907

    /0-07,9438434;02-07#08543/0398:-;0790/90

    41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,3/ 25480/ 8 :3,907, - 2,3 9

    080,550,79,990%#,80110.9;0/08590343.425,3.0

    984325480/570.43/943

    0,7 90701470 #08543/039 343 10/ ,76:0

    9074380380,3/254794190/0-07,943841904:794390

    %# 88:0 %8 1,80 2088,3 3903/0/ 147 90 5:-. ,8

    /0-07,902,/0 - #08543/039 94 2,0 9,550,7 9,9 3/00/

    90 77448 .,3 0,;0 220/,90 ,3/ ,9 ,3 920 0,7

    #08543/0398,.943840/-,8,3/,5,798,389,3.031,;474190 77448 #08543/0398 ,.943 41 .,:83 , 1,80 2088,0 ,3/

    9893 90 80380 ,3/ :3/0789,3/3 41 90 4:79 /:73 98

    /0-07,9438 43 98 2,9907 -097, 349 43 8 ,. 41

    3/0503/03.0.4250903.0,3/574-9-:9247025479,3990

    247, 1-07 94 /850380 :89.0 ,8 0 4:/ ,4 , 17:897,943 41

    :89.014790534!0450147507843,,3,3/.4229203994

    82/39-0301,.947

    4780 /08590 90 13/3 9,9 90 77448 1,0/ 94

    .4259,3088039,.43/9434190%#90$:570204:79

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    55/70

    0,/0/ - #08543/039 4743, 3 , ;490 7:0/ 9,9 90 %#

    ,830110.9

    ' #$!%%#%!&%#&$%#%%#%

    ##&!%

    #&$ %

    &% # %

    '!% &

    $! # %

    $%$

    %0 $:57020 4:79 ,8 ,3 3/0503/039 84:7.0 41

    3.42049079,398 8,703903,943,-:/09 9.40.98 1742

    0;079,3913,.425,39/4.091008.,70:80/14790

    $50., 4,3.0 147 90 :/.,7 $ ,3/ -,8. 0, 1008

    .49490:/.,0;0452039:3/984793493

    9,9 90 :/.,7 0;0452039 :3/ ,3/ 90 /:.,7 :3/

    5,79,04190 3,9:70 4197:89 1:3/8 %0 8-03 .40.90/ 14790-03019 4190202-078 ,3/507843304190:/.,79405

    038:70 ,3/ :,7,3900 90 3/0503/03.0 41 90 :/.,7 3 90

    ,/23897,943 41 :89.0 9 8 ,84 3903/0/ 94 ,:2039 90

    ,4,3.084190202-078,3/507843304190:/.,7,3/94

    13,3.0 90 ,.6:8943 2,3903,3.0 ,3/ 705,7 41 411.0

    06:52039,3/1,.908

    #08543/039,8 7054790/1,0/ ,3/ 701:80/ 94 705479

    43 90 89,9:8 41 90 :3/8 ,3/ 90 $ .40.9438 &3/07 8

    0,/078590$:570204:79,87054790/1,0/9470299490

    :70,: 41 %70,8:7 , $ .40.9438 3 ;4,943 41 90 54. 41

    97,385,703. ,..4:39,-9 ,3/ 44/ 4;073,3.0 %070 8

    080 90 7054790/ 1,:70 41 #08543/039 94 ,..4:39 147 1:3/8

    700,80/ ,3/ 85039 147 :310/ 5489438 3 90 :/.,7 ,3/ 1742

    ,:9470/,3/1:3/0/-:9349.70,90/.4:798

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    56/70

    3 5,79.:,7 90 ,33:, ,:/9 705479 41 90 $:57020

    4:794190!55308330.439,30/904-807;,9439,9

    :3702990/1:3/89490:70,:41%70,8:7,24:390/94!43

    5,041330

    3904907,3/ 90 $50., ,4,3.0147 :/.,7,43 9 90 0307, :3/ :/.,7 0;0452039 :3/ 3 90

    ,24:39 41 ! 43 070 2889,90/ 708:93 1742 /0,0/

    ,3/473435705,7,94341-,370.43.,94389,9020398,3/343

    70.47/3:3.4770.90/70.43.390285,041330

    #$&%,3/!##

    ##5:78:,399490574.0/:70,//43-$0.943

    79.0 41 90 43899:943 43 ..4:39,-9 41 !:-.

    11.078 90 :3/07830/425,3,398 ,8 02-078 4190 4:80

    41#05708039,9;08.43899:93,90,8943097/41,90202-078

    907041 070- 10 90 389,39 '0710/ 425,39#084:943 41

    250,.2039,,389#08543/0394347,-001:89.0#03,94

    4743, ..47/3 9 8 2489 70850.91: 57,0/ 9,9 3

    ,..47/,3.09#:0'4190#:0841!74.0/:703250,.2039

    !74.00/38 5742:,90/ - 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 94

    97,3829 94 90 $03,90 41 90 !55308 90 389,39 '0710/

    425,39#084:943 41 250,.2039 94 807;0 ,8 90 79.08 41

    250,.203914797,

    %070,1907 :3/07830/ 425,3,398 70850.91: 57, 9,9

    90 4347,-0 02-078 41 90 $03,90 .43/:.9 97, 14799 ,3/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    57/70

    9070,1907 703/07 , :/2039 41 .43;.943 ,,389 #08543/039

    4347,-001:89.0#03,944743,

    90770018:89,3/06:9,-0,7008057,0/147

    ":04390974,3,0.02-07

    !%$

    $% $%#%

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    58/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    59/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    60/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    61/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    62/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    63/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    64/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    65/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    66/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    67/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    68/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    69/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    70/70