II K@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z*">z . 7@H:bD,&F\846z?FzB ...

$: II K@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z*">z . 7@H:bD,&F\846z?FzB ...$
II

K@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z *">z. 7@H:bD,&F\846 z ?FzB@&. «+>,|*"»; || :zH,D"HJD>460">D. ',D@| «+>,|*4». MJ*@0>p &48@>">>b «+>,|*4». %zDT z <@&" «+>,|*4». )D"<"H4R>zH&@D4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. 9zH,D"HJD" BD@ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@.

§ 1. 7@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z *">z. A,DT46, &z*@<46 >"< H&zD >@&@(@ J8D"|>F\8@(@B4F\<,>FH&" — «+>,|*"» 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ — B,D,>@F4H\ >"F >" F"<J <,0J XVIII H" XIXFH@:zH\. )&z zFH@D4R>z *@$4 &4D"2>@ B@2>"R"`H\Fb >" >z6: FH"D" ',H\<">V4>", 2 ||FH"D@F&zHF\84< 04HHb<, b8@` $J:" &@>" *@ CJ<’b>P,&F\84N D,L@D< («G"8 &zR>@6 B"<’bHz$J&":@ — J >"F & ',H\<">V4>z 8@:4F\»), z H" >@&" I8D"|>", V@ >"FH":" 2 (J$,D>F\84<4JFH">@&"<4 H" B@T4D,>>b< >" J8D"|>F\8, T:bN,HFH&@ «0":@&">@|» (D"<@H4 *&@Db>FH&J.1 @*>@(@ $@8J, HD@b>F\846 8zT, 8@2"P\8z 2&4R"| +>,p&4N F@BJH>48z&, $@(4 z $@(4>z &FH"D@8@2"P\84N J$D">>bN; 2 *DJ(@(@ — 8DzB"PH&@, F,:b>4 «B">F\8z z 8"2,>>z», H4F8R4>@&>4PH&", «FJ**z z FHDbBRz $,2H@:8@&z, B@&zD,>z, F,8D,H"Dz»... y >, Hz:\84 «+>,|*"», F"<7@H:bD,&F\846 H,0 $J& BD@*J8H@< B,D,N@*@&@| *@$4, — 2 04&4<4 F4<B"Hzb<4 *@8@:\@D4H>@(@ <4>J:@(@ &z> FB@:JR"& J&"0>, BD4F:JN">>b *@ >@&4N 8J:\HJD>4N H":zH,D"HJD>4N F<"8z&, V@ 6T:4 2 D@Fz6F\84N P,>HDz&.

A,DT4<4 D@8"<4 04HHb z B,DT4< &4N@&">>b< &z> <zP>@ $J& 2&’b2">46 2 8J:\HJD>@`J8D"|>F\8@` FH"D@F&zHR4>@`. ="D@*4&Fb &z> &@F,>4 1769 D@8J & (:JNz6 BD@&z>Pzb:\>z6A@:H"&z, 6@(@ $"H\8@ $J& <":,>\846 <"(zFHD"HF\846 JDb*@&,P\, *z* >":,0"& *@ *JN@&>@(@FH">J; B,DTJ >"J8J &z> *zFH"& FH"D@&4>>4< 2&4R"p< J *b8". !:, *,*":z H@ &F, F4:\>zT,@24&"`H\Fb *@ >\@(@ &B:4&4 D@Fz6F\8z. C@8J 1783 — 1784 6@(@ &z**"`H\ *@ E:@&,>F\8@|,Bz2>zT, 7"H,D4>@F:"&F\8@| F,<z>"Dz|, V@ F"<, >" H@6 R"F B,D,$J&":" & A@:H"&z. U@b&:b:" F@$@` Pb F,<z>"Dzb, <@0>" ("*"H4 Dz2>@. 1 @*>@(@ $@8J, & >z6 B@&4>>@ $J:@ V@F\2@FH"H4Fb *"&>\@(@, HD"*4Pz6>@(@, FBz:\>@(@ 2 H4<4 «JR4:4V>Z<4 8@:@>4b<4», b8zBzT:4 &z* 74|&F\8@| !8"*,<z|; 2 *DJ(@(@ — >" >,| B@:@04&, <"$JH\, F&@` B,R"H\H@(@R"F>46 "DN4,B4F8@B E:@&,>F\846 =484L@D G,@H@8z, :`*4>" &,:48@|, z >, Hz:\84$@(@F:@&F\8@| @F&zH4. %z*@<@, V@ BD@(D"<" E:@&,>F\8@| F,<z>"Dz| $J:" B@T4D,>"; 8Dz<*"&>zN <@&, &&,*,>@ >@&z: LD">PJ2\8J 6 >z<,P\8J; <@0:4&@, 2&,D>JH@ $J:@ J&"(J z >"D@Fz6F\8J F:@&,F>zFH\. %46T@&T4 2 F,<z>"Dz|, 7@H:bD,&F\846 b846F\ R"F 04& >" F,:z,JR4H,:``R4 B@ B@<zV4P\84N *@<"N. GJH &z>, b8 F&z*R4H\ $z@(D"L, «$Z&": >" FN@*$4V"N4 4(D"N >"D@*>ZN 4, F"< B,D,@*,HZ6, JR"FH&@&": & >4N, BD4:,0>@ &F:JT4&":Fb &>"D@*>Z6 (@&@D, 2"B4FZ&": B,F>4 4 F:@&", 42JR": b2Z8, >D"&Z, @$ZR"4, @$Db*Z, B@&,D\b4 BD,*">4b J8D"4>P,&, 8"8 $Z BD4(@H@&:bb F,$b 8 BD,*FH@bV,<J HDJ*J». !:,N"D"8H,D>@, V@ P,6 F"<46 «HDJ*» &4>48"p Bz* &B:4&@< D@Fz6F\8@(@ H&@DJ, " L@D<" 6@(@FH@|H\ J 2&’b28J >, 2 7@>4F\84< H" =,8D"T,&4R,<, >, 2 F4:"$zR>4< |N &zDT,<, " 2R@H4D4FH@B@&4< b<$@< D@Fz6F\84N B@,Hz&.

)":\T" 8"D’pD" 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ V, $z:\T, &Hb("p 6@(@ & @$@D@H D@Fz6F\8@(@8J:\HJD>@(@ 04HHb. % 1796 D. &z> &FHJB"p >" &z6F\8@&J F:J0$J, $,D, JR"FH\ J ;@:*"&F\8z<B@N@*z 1806 — 1807 D., " & >"FHJB>@<J D@Pz &4N@*4H\ J0, 2 @*FH"&8J, V@$4 R,D,2 *&" D@84B,D,6H4 >" F:J0$J (D"0*">F\8J, 2"6>b&T4 B@F"*J >"*24D"H,:b & A@:H"&F\8@<J *@<z&4N@&">>b *zH,6 $z*>4N *&@Db>. Ob F:J0$", F"<" B@ F@$z >,2>"R>", &&,:" 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@& 8DJ( (J$,D>F\8@(@ R4>@&>4PH&" H" *&@Db>FH&" z *@B@<@(:" 6@<J 2"6>bH4 & P4N 8@:"NB@<zH>, <zFP,, 2"&*b84 F&@p<J «J<J 4 H":">H"<». %z> 2z6T@&Fb 2 H@*zT>z< (,>.-

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 22

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

(J$,D>"H@D@< ;":@D@Fz6F\84<, 8>. 9@$">@&4<-C@FH@&F\84<, $J& 6@(@ FBz&D@$zH>48@<J FBD"&z @D(">z2"Pz| 8@2"P\8@(@ @B@:R,>>b 1812 D., " B@Hz<, & @$FH"&4>"N <4D>@(@ R"FJ,@*>4< 2 >"6&4*"H>zT4N "<"H@Dz& B@:H"&F\8@(@ H,"HDJ, BD4 R@<J *J0, &*"H>@ &48@>J&"&8@<zR>z D@:z & B’pF"N B@BJ:bD>@(@ H@*z D@Fz6F\8@(@ *D"<"HJD(" 7>b0>z>". U, $z:\T,,b8 &4F:@&:`pH\Fb $z@(D"L, «:`$4: 4 :"F8":» 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >"FHJB>48 9@$">@&"-C@FH@&F\8@(@ >" (,>,D":-(J$,D>"H@DFH&z, 8>. CpB>z>, :`*4>" T4D@84N z :z$,D":\>4NB@(:b*z&, H@6 F"<46 CpB>z>, V@ Bz* R"F B@:\F\8@(@ B@&FH">>b 1831 D. BD@,8HJ&"&&z*D@*4H4 8@2"PH&@, *@B@&z*"`R4 ;48@:z y, V@ «<":@D@FF46F84, 8D,FH\b>,» B@>,&@:,>zF4:@<zP\ «BD@4F8"<4 P"D,*&@DP,& 4 <":@D@FF46F84N FH"DT4>, B@0,DH&@&"&T4NFR"FH\,< D@*4>Z *:b F&@4N &Z(@*». ):b >\@(@ 7@H:bD,&F\846 >"B4F"& F&@` «="H":8J-A@:H"&8J», " *:b 6@(@ *DJ04>4, V@ $J:" 8JD"H@D8@` *z&@R@(@ z>FH4HJHJ, «BD,*BD4>b:@(D@<>Z6 4 >"BD"F>Z6 HDJ*», B,D,8:"&T4 2 LD">PJ2\8@| <@&4 «C"2<ZT:,>4b @D"FB@:@0,>44, F 8"84< *@:0>@ BD4FHJB"H\ 8 RH,>4`... F&. +&">(,:4b @H 9J84». % H@6F"<46 R"F &z> >":,0"& *@ A@:H"&F\8@| Lz:z| #z$:z6>@(@ H@&"D4FH&" z $J& R:,>@<<"F@>F\8@| :@0z «9`$&4 8 3FH4>,», V@ BD@zF>J&":" & A@:H"&z &zFz<>"*PbH\ D@8z&, *@2"8D4HHb &FzN <"F@>F\84N @D(">z2"Pz6 >"BD48z>Pz P"D`&">>b ?:,8F">*D" y-(@. a846 $J&2 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ <"F@> z b84< R4>@< &2"(":z <@0>" B@(@*4H4 6@(@ H&,D,246, HD@N4F8,BH4R>46 D@2J< 2 <"F@>F\8@` <zFH48@` — P, B4H">>b *@F4H\ Pz8"&,. =" *J<8J A./4H,P\8@(@, <"F@>FH&@ <@(:@ Nz$" Hz:\84 «J8DzB4H4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & 6@(@ >,*@&zD’| *@Lz:@F@LF\8@| <J*D@FH4, V@ FB4D"pH\Fb >" FHJ*z`&">>z BD4D@*>4R4N >"J8», z V, B@R"FH4& «6@(@ @B@24Pz6>@<J &z*>@T,>>z *@ *JN@&,>FH&", 2 b84< <"F@>4 >, 2(@*0J&":4F\ J$"("H\@N D,:z(z6>4N B4H">>bN». !:, R4 >, B@<4:8@&@ $J*, &48:`R>@ >" D"NJ>@8<"F@>F\84N B@(:b*z& &z*>,FH4 R4F:,>>z &4B"*4 «+>,|*4» BD@H4 *JN@&,>FH&" z &R,>4N,«B@Bz& z Lz:@2@Bz&» z H@6 2>"<,>4H46 @$D"2 JR,>@(@ & B,8:z, V@ & H@&"D4FH&z «FJHb(4» z«<"DH@B:bF"»

Lz248J BD@&"*4& y H@:8J&"& b84NF\ <@>"*z&, y *J<"&, 2&z*84 &2b&Fb F&zH.

a8 $4 H"< >, $J:@, ":, <"F@>FH&@ z H,"HD":\>, "<"H@DFH&@, 2>"6@<zFH\ 2*D"<"H4R>@` :zH,D"HJD@` D@Fzb> z BD4>":,0>zFH\ *@ «G@&"D4FH&" :`$4H,:z& D@Fz6F\8@|F:@&,F>@FH4», *,D0"&>" F:J0$" z D@Fz6F\8" :,8HJD" — &F, P, & &,:48z6 <zDz @F:"$4:@ &7@H:bD,&F\8@<J (@:@F B@B,D,*>\@| J8D"|>F\8@| HD"*4Pz|. A,D,(:b*"`R4 «;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"», <4 :,(8@ <@0,<@ B@$"R4H4 @$:4RRb 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, D@Fz6F\8@(@R4>@&>48" z «F:J0$zFH"». ?*4> 2 B,DF@>"0z& B’pF4, ;4N"6:@ QJBDJ>, RJ<"8, 2 &,:484<B"HDz@H42<@< @*B@&z*"p <@F8":,&z >" 6@(@ BD48"28J: «M@N:Z >48J*" >, (@*bHFb, *" (@:@FJ >4N N@D@T»: — «=z, F:J04&46, H"8" &"T" B@F:@&4Pb H,B,D >z8J*4 >, (@*4H\Fb... G,B,DJ0, >, H,, V@ *"&>@ $J:@... ?F\ 2"(:b>\ J FH@:4P`, & @*>J z *DJ(J, H" 2"(:b>\ z & F,>"H, H"84>\Fb B@ <z>zFHD"N, H" H@*z 6 (@&@D4, R4 (@*bH\Fb >"Tz 8J*4 R4 >z?» U@ P, H"8,, b8 >,BD@FH@*JT>" (@D*zFH\ BD@&z>Pzb:\>@(@ R4>@&>48", V@ B4T"pH\Fb &4F@8@2"F:J0,>4<42,<:b8"<4? — ! @H zV, BD48:"*. #z@(D"L B@,H", J0, P4H@&">46, E. A. EH,$:4>-

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 23

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

7"<,>F\846 @B@&z*"p BD@ H,, b8 2JFHDzR"& 7@H:bD,&F\846 D@Fz6F\84N :zH,D"H@Dz&. «%F,B@RH4 B@F,V"&T4, A@:H"&J BJH,T,FH&,>>484 4 :4H,D"H@DZ $Z&":4 J >,(@ (BD4B@<4>"`E&4>\4>", 32<"6:@&", A@(@*4>", ;"D8,&4R", '@(@:b); & B@*@$>ZN F:JR"bN7@H:bD,&F846 (@&@D4: >,<>@(@, >@ &F, F8"2">>@, 4< $Z:@ B@:>@ 04&@(@ 4>H,D,F" 4(:J$@8@<ZF:4b». U@ P, H"8,, b8 >, BzpH,H BD@&z>Pzb:\>@(@ :zH,D"H@D" B,D,* >"|0*04<42 FH@:4Pz (@FHb<4? y Nz$" >, N"D"8H,D>, P, FHD,<:z>>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ Bz*HD4<"H4 F&@`(z*>zFH\, >, BD4>424H4 D,BJH"Pz|, >, &4B"FH4 2 H@>J? Mz$" B,D,* >"<4 >, 04&46 @$D"2J8D"|>F\8@(@ B4F\<,>>48" — BD,*FH"&>48" D @ F z 6 F \ 8 @ | :zH,D"HJD>@| BD@&z>Pz|?— G"84< 7@H:bD,&F\846 & *z6F>@FHz 6 $J& — z H@<J, <@0,, 6@(@ «+>,|*J» D"Pz@>":\>zT,D@2(:b*"H4 & 2&’b28J 2 D@Fz6F\84< HD"&,FHJ&">>b<, ">z0 2 &,:48@*>z<4 H" Dz2*&b>4<4&zDT"<4, " «="H":8JA@:H"&8J» H" «;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"» 2zFH"&:bH4 >, 2 z>H,D<,*zb<4H" z>H,D:`*zb<4, " 2 *D"<"H4R>@` H&@DRzFH` H@(@R"F>4N D@Fz6F\84N "&H@Dz& — «8@:8@(@»S"N@&F\8@(@ H" «B,D,4<R4&@(@» 7>b0>z>"...

% 30-N D@8"N 7@H:bD,&F\846 &&"0"& F&@p *z:@ 2"8z>R,>4< z F"< >,<@& Bz*&@*4H\Bz*FJ<84 F&@|6 F@D@8:zH>z6 BD"Pz: B,D,(:b*"p z &4BD"&:bp &@FH">>p «+>,|*J», b8J B,D,*"p*:b *DJ8J N"D8z&F\8@<J 8>4("D,&z %@:@N4>@&J, >"*z:bp ED,2>,&F\8@(@ H,8FH@<«="H":84-A@:H"&84», 2"8z>RJp F&z6 B,D,8:"* «+&">(,:\F84N D"2<ZT:,>46». =" B@R"H8J1835 D. &z> 2&z:\>bpH\Fb &z* @$@N B@F"*, b8z 2"6<"& — >"*24D"H,:\FH&" & *@<z &4N@&">>b*&@Db>F\84N *zH,6 H" B@B,R4H,:\FH&" >"* «$@(@J(@*>Z< 2"&,*,>4,<» z F8@D@ BzF:b H@(@— &@F,>4 1838 D. J<4D"p, @*BJFH4&T4 >" &@:` 8z:\8" *JT F&@|N 8DzB"8z&.

E<,DH\ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, b8 :`*4>4, BD4R,H>@| *@ D@Fz6F\8@(@ :zH,D"HJD>@(@ 04HHb,@*<zR,>@ $J:@ 8z:\8@<" >,8D@:@("<4 & D@Fz6F\84N R"F@B4F"N.

§ 2. 7@H:bD,&F\846 z ?FzB@&. ;4 &0, FHDz&":4Fb 2 H&,D*0,>>b<, V@ H&@DRzFH\7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >"68D"V, 2’bF@&JpH\Fb 2 B@(:b*J BF4N@:@(z| R4H"R". y P, & &,:48z6 <zDzH"8. 7@H:bD,&F\846 >, >":,0"& *@ B4F\<,>>48z& 2 B@8:48">>b, *:b b84N &F, 04HHbB@:b("p & |N :zH,D"HJD>z6 BD"Pz; >,B,D,<@0>" B@HD,$" *z:4H4Fb F&@|<4 *J<8"<4 2T4D@84< F&zH@< >, $J:" 6@<J &z*@<", BD4>"6<>z & Hz6 <zDz, b8 || 2>":4 S,&R,>8@,KD">8@, 9,Fb I8D"|>8". 5@(@ H&@D4 &Fz B@FH":4 >,<@& &4B"*8@&@, >, 2 &>JHDzT>\@|B@HD,$4 &4F:@&J, ":, 2 b8@(@F\ 2@&>zT>\@(@ Bz*(@>J, z b&:b`H\ F@$@` 8@D,8H4&, " H@ zBD@FH46 &z*(J8 >" &z*B@&z*>z H&@D4 D@Fz6F\8z. «;4D>Z6 @$Z&"H,:\», «:`$4<,P BJ$:484»,«&,F,:Z6 D"FF8"2R48, *JT" *DJ0,F84N 8@<B">46, @FHD@J<>Z6 $":"(JD, RH4<Z6... 2"F&@` BD4&,H:4&@FH\ 4 N:,$@F@:\FH&@», — 7@H:bD,&F\846 B4F"& B@<":J, & N&4:4>4&z*B@R4>8J @* F:J0$@&4N H" H@&"D4F\84N @$@&’b28z&, B4F"& *:b D@2&"(4, >, >"*"`R4F&@|6 BD"Pz b8@(@F\ $z:\T@(@ 2>"R,>>b, >, B@FBzT"`R4 2 *DJ8@<, 2"*@&@:,>46"&*4H@Dzp` 8z:\8@N BD4bH,:z& H" 2>"6@<4N.

%F, P, & *@FH"H>z6 <zDz 2’bF@&Jp, R@<J >"6$z:\T46 6@(@ H&zD — «A,D,:4P\@&">"+>,|*"» — B4F":"Fb >" BD@Hb2z Pz:4N HD4*PbH4 :zH. yF>Jp B,D,8"2, >z$4 7@H:bD,&F\846D@2B@R"& || V, >" F,<z>"DF\8z6 :"&z, @H0, B,D,* 1789 D@8@<, z V@ F"<, 2" >,| *zFH"& &z>

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 24

1. AzF:b H@(@, b8 Pz Db*84 $J:@ >"B4F">@, *@ 74p&" *z6T@& :4FH 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ *@ '>p*zR" 2 *>b 27

(DJ*>b 1821 D., @BJ$:z8@&">46 & A,H,D$JD2z z D">zT, &z*@<46 2 8@D@H8@(@ B,D,8"2J A. y. 1"6P,&" (&FH"HHz «E&z*@<zFH\ R4 FH4Nzb», 2 BD4&@*J 150-4N D@8@&4> >"D@*0,>>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, «7>4("D», 1919,

R. 25-26, FH@D. 1657-1662). 94FH Pz8"&46 H4<, V@ & >\@<J F"< 7@H:bD,&F\846 B@*"p B@R"H8@&J *"HJ F&@p|BD"Pz >"* «+>,|*@`»: «b >"* <":@D@FF46F8@` ]>,4*@` 26 :,H $"`T84 $"`», — B4T, &z>. ?*D"NJ&"&T4&z* 1821 D. *&"*PbH\ TzFH\ :zH, <"p<@ Dz8 1795-6.

2. % *,&’b>@FH4N D@8"N 7@H:bD,&F\846 <"& &48z>R,>4<4 :4T, HD4 R"FH4>4. Oz HD4 R"FH4>4 z 2’b&4:4Fb*DJ8@< J B,DT@<J A"DBJD4>@<J — & 1798 z & *DJ(@<J — B,D,*DJ8@&">@<J 2 A"DBJD4>@(@ — &4*">>z1808 D. Q,H&,DH" R"FH4>" 2’b&4:"Fb Hz:\84 & HD,H\@<J &4*">>z, "&H@D@&@<J (1809 D.). Oz:8@&4H@ 0 JFb«+>,|*"» &46T:" & F&zH J0, B@ F<,DHz "&H@D", & N"D8z&F\8@<J &4*">>z %@:@N4>@&" (1842).

%@:@N4>@&F\846 H,8FH >,V@*"&>@ B,D,*DJ8@&">@ Bz* D,*"8Pzp` %. UJD"H": y. 7@H:bD,&F\846.

%zD(z:zp&" +>,|*". A,D,*DJ8 B,DT@(@ B@&>@(@ &4*">>b 2 1842 D., >"8:"*@< 8>4("D>z ="J8@&@(@G@&"D4FH&" z<. S,&R,>8". 9\&z& 1918. 1 >@&zT4N &4*">\ >"68D"V, — &4*">>b «%z8J»: G&@D4 y&">"7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, Bz* D,*"8Pzp`, 2 B,D,*>z< F:@&@< H" BD4<zH8"<4 E,D(zb mLD,<@&", 74|& 1909 (1 &4*.),

1917 (2 &4*.). EB,Pzb:\>@ *:b T8@:4 H,8FH +>,|*4 (F8@D@R,>46) &4BJFH4:@ &-&@ «7D4>4Pb»: y&">7@H:bD,&F\846, +>,|*" 2 BD4<zH8"<4 H" 8D4H4R>4<4 FH"HHb<4. S8z:\>" $z$:z@H,8" Bz* D,*"8Pzp`?:,8F">*D" )@D@T8,&4R", 1, 74|& 1919.

3. 7>4(" BD@L. M. y. A,HD@&": ?R,D84 J8D"4>F8@6 :4H,D"HJDZ XIX FH@:,H4b, 74,&, 1884, $J:" B,DT4<$z:\T@(@ D@2<zDJ @(:b*@< >@&@(@ J8D"|>F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&" (FH@D. 457 +XII). ;. A. )"T8,&4R >" 2"("*C@Fz6F\8@| !8"*,<z| ="J8 >"B4F"& >" 8>408J A,HD@&" *@8:"*>J z hDJ>H@&>J D,P,>2z`. %4*DJ8J&">@ || &«?HR,H, @ 29 BD4FJ0*,>44 >"(D"* (D. I&"D@&"», BD4:@0. 8 LIX H. 1"B4F@8 !8"*. ="J8, EB$. 1888, FH@D.

37, 301.

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

@* T8z:\>4N F&@|N H@&"D4Tz& >"2&J «D4L<"R"». !:, H,8FH@&z B@Dz&>b>>b1 *"`H\ >"<Bz*FH"&4 ("*"H4, V@ «+>,|*J» *@BD"&*4 $J:@ D@2B@R"H@ Bz2>zT,, *,F\ 8@:@ 1794 — 1795D., J0, BzF:b H@(@, b8 2’b&4:4Fb & F&zH B,DTz R"FH4>4 D@Fz6F\8@| «]>,4*Z, &Z&@D@R,>>@6>" 42>">8J» ?FzB@&" H" 7@H,:\>zP\8@(@. 1 Pzp` *"H@` FN@*4H\Fb z H&,D*0,>>b $z@(D"L",V@, 04&JR4 >" F,:z, B@ &4N@*z 2 F,<z>"Dz|, 7@H:bD,&F\846 V, Hz:\84 «(@HJ&"&Fb *@<"6$JH>\@| BD"Pz». 1"8z>R,>@ «+>,|*J» >" B@R"H8J 20-N D@8z&2.

1 B,DT4N 0, Db*8z& B@,<4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ &4bF>bpH\Fb, V@ P, H&zD >, Pz:8@<@D4hz>":\>46, V@ 6@(@ 2"<4F,:, 8@<B@24Pzb z >"&zH\ NJ*@0>z 2"F@$4 2"B@24R,>@ 2RJ0@<@&>@(@ 2D"28". G"84< 2D"28@< *:b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ $J:" «]>,4*"» ?FzB@&", H&zD>, B,DT@Db*>@| &"(4 :zH,D"HJD>@|, ":, B@BJ:bD>46 z 0&"&46, T4D@8@ 2"8D@p>46 z >, 2:,,b8 >" F&z6 R"F, &48@>">46. a8 z @F8z:\84 7@H:bD,&F\846 8@D4FHJpH\Fb ?FzB@&4<, b846FBD"&0>z6 &2"p<@FH@FJ>@8 @$@N «+>,|*» — P, B4H">>b V, >, &4DzT,>, @FH"H@R>@. !8"*.A,HD@&3 ("*"&, V@ 7@H:bD,&F\846 2"B@24R4& & ?FzB@&" «F"<J` 4*,` B,D,:4P@&">>@6]>,4*Z»; " 6@(@ 8D4H48, 84|&F\846 BD@L. )"T8,&4R, &"("&Fb, R4 >, F:z* >"&zH\ ?FzB@&"&&"0"H4 >"F:z*J&"R,< 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ z, 8@:4 8z>,P\-8z>P,< >, BD4FH"& >" H,, H@ Hz:\842&"0"`R4 >" «$@:,, D">>pp B@b&:,>4, ?F4B@&" & B,R"H4», BD4 B@&>z6 >,<@0:4&@FHzBD4BJFH4H4 6@(@ 2>"6@<FH&@ 2 DJ8@B4F@< 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. =, $D"8Jp 6 z>T4N, $z:\TF8:"*>4N z B:JH">4N B@(:b*z&. !:, *@F4H\ B@&,DN@&@(@ D@2(:b*J, V@$ JFH">@&4H4 &,:48J2":,0>zFH\ J8D"|>F\8@| «+>,|*4» 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ @* D@Fz6F\8@| — ?FzB@&" H"7@H,:\>zP\8@(@. A@B,DT, — V@ H@D8"pH\Fb B:b>J B@,<4. a8 &z*@<@, ?FzB@&, @*84>J&T4F:"&>@2&zF>46 &FHJB %,Dhz:zb 2 6@(@ «Arma virumque F"n@» («FBz&"`, F:"&:`») H" «;J2@`»(«Musa, mihi causas memora»), D@2B@R4>"p F&@` B@,<J, b8 z 6@(@ 2D"2@8, >z<,P\846

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 25

4. ):b BD48:"*J B@Dz&>b6<@ N"D"8H,D4FH48J 9b&z>z|. I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@:

)@R8" $J:" 2":\@H>" BH4Pb,

y22"*J, FB,D,*J 6 8DJ(@<;

Q,D&@>", F&z0", b8 84F:4Pb,

y &F, N@*4:" B"&4R@<;

)@D@*>", D@F:" z 8D"F4&",

AD4FHJB>", *@$D", >, FB,F4&",

'>JR8", `D:4&", <@:@*".

% ?FzB@&":

=@ *@R\ F4b $Z:" 4 *,&8",

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

HD"&,FH4H@D #:`<"J,D, $,2B@F,D,*>\@ 2 N"D"8H,D4FH484 (,D@b:

]>,6 $Z: J*":@6 *,H4>" 3 F"<@6 N&"HF8@6 <@:@*,P.

7D@8 2" 8D@8@< &z> z*, 2" %,Dhz:zp<, >" F&z6 8@B4: B,D,D@$:b`R4 8@0,> 6@(@ ,Bz2@*,@$,DH"p 6@(@ «B@(J*8J» >" 0"DH, B@&,DH"p || «>" DJFF8@6 :"*», >, BD@BJF8"`R4 >zR@(@$z:\T-<,>T &"0:4&@(@, >, <4>"`R4 «>z H4H:", >z0, Hz| 8@<4». 7@H:bD,&F\846 & @F>@&JF&@(@ H&@DJ B@8:"*"p B:b> ?FzB@&", &F:z* 2" >4< &z> B@R4>"p F&@p @B@&z*">>bN"D"8H,D4FH48@` +>,b:

+>,6 $J& B"DJ$@8 <@H@D>46 y N:@B,P\ N@H\ 8J*4 8@2"8

z *":z &Fz (@:@&>z ,Bz2@*4 %,Dhz:zp&@| B@,<4 B,D,8"2Jp 2" ?FzB@&F\8@` B@,<@`: >,<">z @*>@| %,Dhz:zp&@| D4F4, b8J $ &z> &>zF J F&@p @B@&z*">>b >,2":,0>@ @* D@Fz6F\8@|«+>,|*4». _>@>" H" +@:, $JDb >" <@Dz, D@<"> +>,b 6 )z*@>4, B@F@:\FH&@ ;,D8JDzb, &H,R"+>,b, BD@V":\>" FP,>", *@8@D4 H" F<,DH\ )z*@>4 — & 1-z6 R"FH4>z; B@<4>84 !>Nz2" &EzPz:z|, B@p*4>@8 +>H,::" 6 )"D,F", B@0"D GD@b>F\8@| L:\@H4, BD@<@&" +>,b *@ $@(z&,F<,DH\ A":z>JD" — & R"FH4>z yy-z6; 2JFHDzR 2 Ez&z::@`, FP,>4 & Bz*2,<>@<J P"DFH&z,8"DH4>4 B,8:" z D"`, &4F"*8" & 9bPz|, HD@b>F\8, B@F@:\FH&@ & 9"H4>", D@2D4&*4B:@<"H4R>4N 2>@F4> <z0 >"D@*"<4 R,D,2 N"H>\@(@ PJP48", V@ >":,04H\ «P"DF8@6<Z2>4P,» R4 H@ P"DF\8z6 «>b>\Pz» — &F, P, 7@H:bD,&F\846 B@*"p >"< J Hz6 &,DFz|, & H@<J(J<@D4FH4R>@<J @F&zH:,>>z, b8, &z> 2>"6T@& & ?FzB@&". % ?FzB@&" &z> 2"B@24R"p z $z:\TJR"FH4>J F&@|N N"D"8H,D4FH48: «>, B:@NJ» )z*@>J, || F,FHDJ 6 B@D"*>4P` '">>J(«>"&FBD"&084 *z&8J N@H\ 8J*4»), @:z<Bz6F\8@(@ (z>Pb ;,D8JDzb, H"8@(@ B@*z$>@(@ F&@|<&4(:b*@< *@ D@Fz6F\8@(@ B@TH"Db, «$":"(JD"» 6 (J:b8J A":z>JD"-«B@D@<V48"»,B,D,&z2>48" M"D@>", 2"F<":\P\@&">@(@, ":, 2"D@2J<z:@(@ («D"2*JH@6, $J*H@ $Z B"&:4>»),<4D@:`$>@(@ P"Db 9"H4>", V@ 2>"& @*>J Hz:\84 &z6>J — «F@ &2*@D:4&@6 F&@,6 0,>@`»z 9"H4>@&J *@R8J 9b&z>z`, «*,&8J, @H<,>>J` @H BD@R4N &F,N», V@ FH":" b$:J8@< >,2(@*4B@<z0 +>,p< z GJD>@<4. y >, Hz:\84 N"D"8H,D4FH484, >, Hz:\84 (J<@D4FH4R>z 8@<,>H"Dz

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 26

?H<,>>"b @H BD@R4N &F,N,

C,2&4H\Fb F >,` >, 42*,&8",

?H&,*",H &Fb8 F (@D,< F<,N.

?>" $Z:" 8"8 N@:\ 4 >,(":

94P@ ,, $,:,, F>,(",

! V,R84 H@R>@ <"8@& P&,H,

C@F:", FHD@6>", F&,0", 8D"F4&",

AD4FHJB>" &F,< 4 >, FB,F4&",

3 $Z:@ J0 @F\<>"*P"H\ :,H.

(R. IV, B. VII, 30).

5. A@Dz&>.:

! & $JD` <@D,< ,N"H\ F8:428@... (R. II, B. V, 7).

6. A@Dz&>.:

! &,HDZ <,0*J H,< B@*J:4

% 2"HZ:@8 F4:\>@ 8@D"$:b<...(R. II, B. IV, 7).

7. A@Dz&>.:

7"8 ,*84 HD@4 >, B@FJHR4TX,

G"8 >" H@T>, 2"04&@H4H;

=" &F,< >ZH\, HZ 2"0,:J*R4T\3 >" &@DR":, 2"$D`T4H... (R. IV, B. VII, 1-3).

8. A@Dz&>.:

...%ZF@8@6 >,$@:\T@6 BD4(@D@8

IFH"&:,> $Z: & HD4 B@:@FZ

7D"F"&4P"<4 B:@V"*>Z<4,

9`$@&>4P"<4 2"&@*>Z<4

3 B@*<"FH,D\b<4 <J0,6

E H@:B"<4 V@(@:,6 >"N":\>ZN

3 8JR,6 *,&@8 H,"HD":\>ZN,

3 @$V4N *"D@&ZN *,H,6.(R. yyy, B. VI. 33).

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

2 BD4&@*J H4N R4 z>T4N ,Bz2@*z&, ":, 6 @8D,<z &4D"24, B@Dz&>b>>b, &:JR>z "L@D42<4,8<zH:4&z FB@FH,D,0,>>b, &,F,:z «F:@&@42&4H4b», <"8"D@>zR>z BD@<@&4 — $"("H@ *,R@(@,V@ FH"&4H\Fb >" 8@TH FH4:zFH4R>@(@ N4FHJ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, R"FH@-(JFH@ B@8"2JpH\Fb2&4R"6>4< F@$z B,D,8:"*@< 2 ?FzB@&". — % D@Fz6F\8z6 «+>,|*z» 2>"6*,<@ <4 zN"D"8H,D>,, (:4$@8@-FJN@BJH>p <zD8J&">>b HD@b>Pz& BD@ H,, V@ «& $JD` <@D,< |N"H\F:42\8@, R@&>z& >zNH@ >, Bz*8Jp»5, z P,6 @$D"2 N@*@&@(@ &zHDJ, &zHDJ «& B@H4:4P`» («!&zHD4 22"*J &F, HDJ$4:4 % B@H4:4P` 6@(@ R@&>"<»)6, z 0"Dh@>@&46 &FHJB *@ IY-@| R"FH4>4— «#@DVz& b8 HD4 >, B@*,>\8JpT»7, z H"8z >"&zH\ *Dz$>,>\8z D4F@R84, b8 B:"R «(JDH@&4N»*zH,6 J B,8:z, V@ 8D4R"H\ z D,B,HJ`H\, >"Dz8"`R4 >" F&@|N B">\<"H@88. !:,, >"F:z*J`R4?FzB@&", B,D,8"2J`R4 z B,D,8:"*"`R4 6@(@, 7@H:bD,&F\846 >z*, >, FH"p F:J(@` F&@(@:zH,D"HJD>@(@ 2D"28". %z> B@&@*4H\Fb 2 >4<, b8 Dz&>46 2 Dz&>4<. % @*>4N &4B"*8"N, *,6@(@ 2D"2@8 2">"*H@ $"("H@ F:z& &4HD"R"p >" L"8H4R>, @B@&z*">>b, 7@H:bD,&F\846

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 27

9. G"8, >"BD., J III R"FH4>z, *, @B4FJpH\Fb &z*B:4HHb +>,p&@| L:\@H4 @* $,D,(z& EzPz:z|,?FzB@& 2"2>"R"p 8@D@H8@:

=" B":J$, (D,$PZ D"FF,&T4F\3 $J*H@ $,:,>Z @$’,&T4F\,7D4R":4 B,F>4, 8H@ RH@ 2>":.

7@H:bD,&F\846 P4< >, 2"*@&@:\>bpH\Fb z *@*"p Pz:J FHD@LJ, H@R>@ 6 *@8:"*>@2"2>"R"`R4 «D,B,DHJ"D» HD@b>Pz&:

AD@ E"("6*"R>@(@ FBz&":4,94$@>\, FBz&":4 z BD@ EzR;a8 & Bz8z>,D4 >"$4D":4,a8 <">*DJ&"& 8@2"8 &F` >zR.A@:H"&F\8J F:"&4:4 S&,*R4>J... z H. *.

«% ?FzB@&" Hz:\84 >"Hb8, — B4T, 2 P\@(@ BD4&@*J /4H,P\846, — J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@— Pz:46 <":`>@8, B@&>46 FB@("*z& BD@ <4>J:,, b8z 6 B@ F,6 R"F :J>"`H\ & >"D@*>zNBzF>bN» (+>,|*" 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & 2&’b28J 2 :zH. XVIII &., J8D. B,D,8:., FH@D. 100).

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

FH4F8"p 6@(@ z 2 5-6 FHD@L D@$4H\ V@>"6$z:\T, HD4-R@H4D4 — B@Dz&>. FHD@L4,BD4F&bR,>z B,DT4< &D"0,>>b< HD@b>Pz& &z* Gz$D" H" :"H4>F\8@| 2,<:z (?FzB@&, R. III, 19-26; 7@H:bD,&F\846 IV, 16-18). I *DJ(4N &4B"*8"N, *, ?FzB@&F\8" 8">&" *"p BD@FHzD 6@(@Jb&z, &z> 2":`$84 B@T4D`p D"<84 @B@&z*">>b, &>@FbR4 & >\@(@ F4:J 04&4N, 8@>8D,H>4NB@*D@$4P\9. I HD,HzN (>" 0":\, P, HD"B:bpH\Fb >, R"FH@) &z> Pz:8@< B@84*"p F&z6 2D"2@8," 2 >4< z HD"*4Pz6>z, %,Dhz:zp&| "$@ 2 %,Dhz:zp< 2&’b2">z @$D"24, &z**"`R4Fb B@HJ0>z6H,Rz| &:"F>@| @$D"2@H&@DR@FH4, z H@*z F8:"*"p F&@| >"6bF8D"&zTz, >"6H":">@&4HzTzFH@Dz>84. )@ >4N $,2B,D,R>@ >":,0"H\ @B4F4 B,8,:\>4N <J8 — J HD,Hz6 R"FH4>z (FHD@L469-80, 83-101) z B@R"FH4 — &@p>>4N 2$@Dz& J 9"H4>F\8z6 2,<:z (IV, 101-122). GJH <"H,Dzb:7@H:bD,&F\8@<J *":4 6@(@ `>"P\8z ,H>@(D"LzR>z FHJ*z|, 6@(@ T4D@8, 6 *@8:"*>,2>"6@<FH&@ 2 >"D@*>z< F&zH@(:b*@<.

%2"(":z &48:"* J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ bF8D"&zT46, >z0 & ?FzB@&". I >\@(@ pFH\ <4FH,PH&@2(JFH4H4 &D"0,>>b, Bz*8D,F:4H4 *J<8J, D,HJTJ&"H4 (@H@&46 J0, >,h"H4&. A"<’bH"pH,<J8J >,&*"H>4N Bz|Hz& J Bz*2,<>@<J P"DFH&z? AD@ >,| *@8:"*>@ (@&@D4H\ ?FzB@&, ":, b8F:"$@:

A4F"H,:4 FH4N@& >,(@*>ZN, 7@H@DZ & F&,H, 04&JR4,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 28

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

%F,N F:JT"H,:,6 $:"(@D@*>ZN, 7"8 >@R\` <,D284, FZR4, %F,(*" FH4N"<4 2"(:JT":4 3 *@ 2"D,2J *@F"0*":4 Q4H">4,< A"D>"FF84N *,:, — ?H &F,N 2*,F\ &@ BD,2D,>\4 $Z:4 3 >48@(@ >, >"N@*4:4, 7H@ $Z B@F:JT"H\ 4N N@H,:.

7@H:bD,&F\846 *@*"p *@ D4FJ>8" &F\@(@ *&z-HD4 :z>z|: 2:,(,>\8" 2z*N"p >"B@R"H8J,HD@N4 z>TJ, FJ&@DzTJ 8"DJ *@$4D"p H" V, & 8z>Pz :,*&,-:,*&,, Bz&>"Hb8@< H@D8"pH\FbF,$, F"<@(@ — z b8 @04&"p, b8 <z>4H\Fb &z* H@(@ &,F\ @$D"2@8:

' " 6 , ( " 6 ! … H " > z ( * , B D " & * 4 * z H 4 , #D,N>b 0 >"D@$4H\ :4N" $z:\T:E4*z:4 H"< F8JR>z Bz|H4,A4F"DRJ84 B@(">4N &zDT.%,:48z| H,DBz:4 <J84:{ < 2 & ’ b 2 " > z $ J : 4 z D J 8 4 , — ;@& J H"H"D H,DBz:4 B:z>.?H H"8 z > " T $ D " H B@B"*,H\Fb,U@ B4T,... =, @FH,D,0,H\Fb — a846 0, &H,DB4H\ 6@(@ NDz>?..

7@H:bD,&F\846 &2"(":z B,D,&"0"p F&@(@ D@Fz6F\8@(@ B@B,D,*>48" :zH,D"HJD>4<N4FH@<. !:, N4FH J >\@(@ F&@pDz*>46. %z> >, &z:\>46 @* *,b8@| (DJ$@FH4: 6@(@ «+>,|*"»F<zpH\Fb R"F@< 2">"*H@ (@:@F>@ z $,2B"D*@>>@. %z> >, &<zp "$@ :z>JpH\Fb >" &:"F>J DJRD@2D@$:bH4 F`0,H: B:b> 6@(@ «+>,|*4» 2"B@24R,>46, z NJ*@0>z 2"F@$4, <@H4&4,$z:\TzFH\ 8"DH4> — RJ0z, &2bHz >"BD@8"H, ":, 2"H, & RJ04N D"<8"N z B@ RJ0@<J 8@>HJD@&z&z> J<zp B@8:"FH4 (JFHz L"D$4, *"H4 04&z 6 H,B:z 8@:\@D4. 7@H:bD,&F\846 bF8D"&zT46@* ?FzB@&" & B@$JH@&4N 8"DH4>"N, $"("HT46 >" 04&z *,H":z & @B@&z*">>z, BD"&*4&zT46J BF4N@:@(z|; <"6FH,D>@ z *@H,B>@ 2J<z& &z> B,D,B@&zFH4 F&z6 :zH,D"HJD>46 2D"2@8. G"846J0, $J& J >\@(@ *"D — FB,Pzb:\>@ *@ :4P`&">>b H" B,D,D@$84.

§ 3. “+>,|*"”; || :zH,D"HJD>46 0">D. 9zH,D"HJD>46 0">D, *@ b8@(@ >":,04H\ «+>,|*"»7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, 2&4R"6>@ 2&,H\Fb HD"&,FH@&">@` B@,<@` "$@ HD"&,FHzp`, «42>">8@`»,b8 (@&@D4:4 H@*zT>z H,@D,H484 :zH,D"HJD4, D@2J<z`R4 Bz* P4< F:@&@< «@B4F">4,TJH@R>Z< 4 *"0, >4284< F:@(@< H,N F"<ZN BD@4FT,FH&46, 8@4 BD,0*, B@ &"0>@FH4F&@,6 $Z:4 @B4F">Z F:@(@< &ZF@84<». G"8 F"<@ &42>"R"p F&z6 H&zD z ;48@:" ?FzB@& —J BD4F&bH>@<J :4FHz *@ F&@(@ <,P,>"H", S,T8@&F\8@(@:

a, &Z$D"& *D,&>`` B@$"F8J,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 29

10. I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ — 6 R"FH4> z 7500 b<$zR>4N Db*8z& FJBD@H4 12 BzF,>\ z 10 H4FbR(,8F"<,HDz& %,D(z:zb.

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

E8D@B": 42 >,6 F<,T>J` F8"28J, A@ >@&@<J F@&F,< @*,:; 3 @$,D>J&T4 > " 4 2 > " > 8 J , 7"8 $J*H@ F&@6F8J` 2,<:b>8J, =" >@&Z6 :"* & FH4N"N 2"B,:.

O4<4 L@D<J:"<4 Pz:8@< &42>"R"pH\Fb FH@FJ>@8 B@,<4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ *@%,Dhz:zp&@| «+>,|*4». O, >, B"D@*zb, $@ «B"D@*4b F@FH@4H & BD4<,>,>44 H@(@ 0,F@R4>,>4b 8 *DJ(4< BD@4FT,FH&4b< 4 *DJ(4< :4P"< F B,D,<,>@6 >,8@H@DZN&ZD"0,>46», z D"2@< 2 H4< >, B,D,8:"*, >"&zH\ >, «B,D,8:"* 2 B,D,8:"*J», $@ B,D,8:"*BDb<Jp *@ >"6H@R>zT@(@ &z*H&@D,>>b H@>J z «*JNJ» B,D&@H&@DJ, " H@> z FH4:\«A,D,:4P\@&">@| +>,|*4» R"F"<4 BD@FH@ BD@H4:,0>z H@>@&z %,Dhz:zp&@| B@,<4.

G&zD 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ b&:bp F@$@` 8@D@H84610 z FH4F:46, 2J<4F>, @*<z>>46 V@*@H@>J, B,D,8"2 L"$J:4 :"H4>F\8@(@ B,D&@H&@DJ, 2 BD@BJF8@< $"("H\@N N"D"8H,D>4N z&"0:4&4N ,Bz2@*z& @FH">>\@(@, — z BD4 H@<J B,D,8"2, 2D@$:,>46 >, 2 @D4hz>":J, " 2*":,8@| F&@|< *JN@< @* >\@(@ B,D,B@&z*84.

%,Dhz:zp&" B@,<" $J:" &,:484< B"HDz@H4R>4< H&@D@<, V@ *"&"& &4F:z& D4<F\84<>"Pz@>":\>4< (@D*@V"<, 2&’b2J`R4 C4< 2 *"&>\@` z >" &Fz &z84 F:"&,H>@` GD@p` (C4<— *DJ(" GD@b) z 2@*b("`R4 & FH4F:z z 8D"F>z L@D<J:4 H@*zT>p B,D,8@>">>b J F&zH@&z6<zFz| C4<F\8@| z<B,Dz|. 1 P\@(@ B@(:b*J P,>HD":\>, <zFP, & B@,<z >":,04H\ H"84<,Bz2@*"<, b8 B@0,0" GD@| z &4Nz* +>,b 2&z*H4, 2 $"H\8@< >" B:,R"N H" FH"HJb<4 $@(z&-2"FHJB>48z& (yy-yyy BzF>z); H" V, — H"8 2&">, BD@D@PH&@ !>Nz2@&, & 8z>Pz YI-@| BzF>z, H,<zFP,, *, $"H\8@ !>Nz2 & m:zF,6F\8z6 *@:4>z B@8"2Jp >,D@*0,>z *JTz >"V"*8z&, @B@&z*"pBD@ <"6$JH>` |N *@:` H" 2"F:J(4 B,D,* *,D0"&@` z 2"8z>RJp F&@p @B@&z*">>b H"8@`N"D"8H,D4FH48@` >"Pz@>":\>@(@ (,>zb C4<J:

y>Tz 2DJR>zT,, b8 H4, @*:4&"H4<JH\ FH"HJ| 2 <z*z y 2 <"D<JD@&@| $D4:4 04&z Dz2\$4H4<JH\ :4Pb, 7D"V, & FJ*"N BD@<@&:bH4<JH\ z *@8:"*>zT, &z* H,$, EL,DJ @8D,F:bH\ >,$,F>J z 2zD 8DJ(@&, @$,DH">>b:G4 0 B"<’bH"6, (D@<"*b>4>, D4<F\846, b8 BD"&4H4 F&zH@<.?H *, <4FH,PH&@ H&@p: & FJB@8@| HD4<"H4 >"D@*4, ;4:J&"H\ V4D4N Bz**">Pz& z &8D"6 *@&@6@&J&"H\ (@D*4N.

I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ @B@&z*">>b BD@ B@0,0J GD@| BD@BJV,>@ 2@&Fz< (& ?FzB@&" &@>@2"6<"p &,F\ 8z>,P\ y R"FH4>4), " 8D"F>@<@&>, BD@D@PH&@ !>Nz2" 2&,*,>@ *@ D@2<zDJ *&@N>,B@&>4N FHD@L:

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 30

11. % ?FzB@&" R"F"<4 &4b&:bpH\Fb.

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

+>,` (@*z &0, 0JD4H4F\, ?* >\@(@ <"p D@2B:@*4H4F\%,:4846 z 2"&2bH46 Dz*;%Fz< F&zH@< $J*, JBD"&:bH4,A@ &FzN JF`*"N &@`&"H4,Az*&,D>, &FzN F@$z Bz* FBz*.

7Dz< B"HDz@H4R>4N H4D"* H" zFH@D4R>4N ,8F8JDFz& J L@D<z BD@D@PH&, J %,Dhz:zp&z6«+>,|*z» B,&>, <zFP, 2"6<"`H\ R4F:,>>z H@B@(D"LzR>z H" (,>,":@(zR>z &8"2z&84 6 >"Hb84.)@ >4N >":,0"H\: F<,DH\ A":z>JD", V@ <"p B@bF>4H4 >"2&J A":z>JD@&@(@ <4FJ >" Bz&*>zyH":z|, F<,DH\ z B@N@D@> FJD<"R" ;z2,>" (@* >\@(@ — <4F ;z2,> & @8@:4Pz =,"B@:b),FB@("* BD@ 7"FHJ, <"<8J +>,p&J, V@, B@<,DT4, B,D,*":" F&@p >"6<,>>b @*>@<J 2BD4$,D,0>4N <zFH 7"<B">z|. ="&zH\ z<,>" FB@*&40>48z& +>,b — E,Dh,FH", ;>,FH,b,7:`,>Pzb H" z>T., &&,*,>@ >, FBD@FH": >"6<,>>b E,Dh,FH" *"p 2<@(J B@FH"&4H4 & 2&’b2@82 B"HDz@H4R>@` :,h,>*@` "D4FH@8D"H4R>46 Dz* E,Dhz|&, >"6<,>>b ;>,FH,b — Dz*;,<<z|&, " >"6<,>>b 7:\@">H" — Dz* 7:`,>Pz|&. G, F"<, 2>"R,>>b <"p 6 z<’b 7"Bzb,@F"*R@(@ 7"BJ|. O, «H@6, — (@&@D4H\Fb BD@ >\@(@, — V@ >"6<,>>b F&@p B,D,*"&8"<B">F\8@<J <zFHJ» (%,Dhz:z6, +>,|*" V, 117 sqq.). I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ 2"<zFH\ P\@(@&,F,:" >,@N"6>zFH\ z & z<,>"N, z & (,>,":@(zR>4N H@>8@V"N. 5@<J @*>"8@&@ >"2&"H4A":z>JD" — A":z>JD@< z G"D"F@<; 9`P,Hz6 :,(8@ B,D,H&@D`pH\Fb & >\@(@ >" 9JH,Pzb, "HD@b>,P\ E,D,FH B@8"2JpH\Fb & DJHJ:\F\8z6 :"&z z >" *@*"RJ B@B"*"p & DJ84 +>,p&z, b846HJH 0, — >, 2>"`R4, V@ &z> D@$4H\ — z 2"$4&"p 6@(@ >" F<,DH\:

A@(4$ HJH H"80, ND"$D46 =J<", I$4& E,D,FH", 6@(@ 8J<"...

%2"(":z &F,, V@ & %,Dhz:zp&z6 «+>,|*z» p F B , P 4 L z R > @ D 4 < F \ 8 @ ( @ ,FH">@&4H\ || D4<F\8J *JTJ — || B " H D z @ H 4 R > " z * , b , " D N , @ : @ ( z R > z, 8 F 8 J D F 4 , | | ( , > , " : @ ( z R > z * @ ( " * 8 4 — & F , P , J7 @ H : b D , & F \ 8 @ ( @ 0 " * > @ ( @ & z * ( J 8 J > , 2 > " N @ * 4 H \ 11.

y>"8T, FH"&:,>>b J >\@(@ *@ ,BzR>@| <">,D4 %,Dhz:zb. %:"F>, <">,D" %,Dhz:zb >,>":,04H\ 6@<J F"<@<J. %@>" — HD"*4Pz6>" z &4D@F:" 8" hDJ>Hz &42>">>b '@<,Dz&F\84NB@,< H&@D"<4 8">@>zR>4<4, 2D"28"<4, &z* b84N >, <@0, &z*N@*4H4 >z @*4> B@,H-,Bz8.1"8:48">>b <J2, <>@(@F:@&>z 6 *@8:"*>z, H"8 2&">z ,BzR>z B@Dz&>b>>b z B@*&z6>,<@H4&J&">>b B@*z6: @*>@ >"HJD":\>,, 2 BF4N@:@(z| *z6@&4N :`*,6, " *DJ(, >"*BD4D@*>,,R,D,2 &HDJR">>b & :`*F\8z FBD"&4 $@(z& — @H (@:@&>z N"D"8H,D>z @2>"84 &4TJ8">@| zTHJR>@| <">,D4, b8@| *@*,D0J&":4F\ D4<F\8z B@,H4 z b8@| &,:484< <"6FHD@< $J&%,Dhz:z6. E4> F8,BH4R>@(@ &z8J, &z>, D@2J<zpH\Fb, $J& *J0, *":,846 @* >"|&>@| &zD4'@<,Dz&F\84N B@,< & !B@::@>" H" <J2, $@(4>\ FBz&J H" B@,2z|; 6@(@ 2&,DH">>b *@ <J2 $J:@

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 31

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

>"F8Dz2\ :zH,D"HJD>4< 2"F@$@<, — ":, P4< 2"F@$@< &z> 8@D4FH"&Fb R"FH@ 6 @N@R,. G"8,>" B@R"H8J 1-@| 8>4(4 &z> BD@F4H\ <J2J &48:"FH4 BD4R4>4 _>@>4>@| >,>"&4FH4 FJBD@H4+>,b, " >" B@R"H8J 8>4(4 Iyy-@|, *, B@R4>"pH\Fb @B@&z*">>b BD@ &z6>4 & 9bPz|, «D4<F\8"y:zb*"» — D@2B@&zFH4 6@<J BD@ FH">@&4V, zH":z6F\84N B:,<,> Bz* R"F +>,p&@| &4F"*84.% F,D,*4>z Hzp| 0 8>4(4 <J24 <"`H\ BD4("*"H4 &FzN &"H"08z&, V@ &4FHJB4:4 & B@Nz*BD@H4 +>,b.

%4 $@ $@(4>z z 2>"pH, &F,, — " *@ >"F *@:,Hz:4 94T &z*(@<ó>4 F:"$,>\8z B,D,8"2z& H4N (,D@|R>4N.

GD"B:b`H\Fb V, 2&,DH">>b *@ <J2 J BzF>bN IX z M-z6, 8@0>@(@ D"2J >" B@R"H8Jb8@(@F\ >@&@(@ ,Bz2@*J. y2 P4N B’bH4 &FHJB>4N 2"8:48z& %,Dhz:zb 7@H:bD,&F\846 (&F:z*2" ?FzB@&4< H" 7@H,:\>zP\84<) 2$,Dz("p HD4 @FH">>z, ":, &Fz B,D,&@*4H\ 2 «&4F@8@(@»FH4:` & >42\846, Jb&:b`R4 B@&":,>J <J2J & @$D"2z FH"D@| BD@&z>Pzb:\>@| B">>4, «@*FH"D@FH4 F&"D:4&@|», 2 b8@` >zNH@ «>, 0,>4N"&F\, >, 0"DHJ&"&»:

?N, F8z:\84 <J2 H"84N >" F&zHzI 8@0>z< (@D@*z 6 B@&zHz — I8D4:4 $ 2&,DNJ &>42 A"D>"F.a <J2J 8:4RJ >, H"8J` — %,F,:J, ("D>J, <@:@*J`:EH"D4N >,N"6 $D48" A,("F.

A,D,N@*4<@ *@ z>T4N @F@$:4&@FH,6 ,BzR>@| <">,D4 %,Dhz:zb, *@ B@*&z6>@(@<@H4&J&">>b B@*z6. %HDJR">>b $@(z& J :`*F\8z FBD"&4 — *DJ(" D4F" Pzp| <">,D4 —2$,Dz("pH\Fb J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >, 2"&0*4. A@,H 2"*@&@:\>bpH\Fb z>@*z BD4D@*>4< :4T,<@H4&J&">>b<. 1D"28@< <@0, B@F:J04H4 2("*J&">46 J0, ,Bz2@* F<,DH4 A":z>JD". I%,Dhz:zb P,6 (@:@&>46 8,D<">4R HD@b>F\8@| L:\@H4 (4>, &z* DJ84 F"<@(@ $@(" F>J:

G,<Db&" >@Rz J0, *@Fb(":" F,D,*4>4 >,$";Gb08@ FH@<4:4F\ B:"&Pz z — 2>,F4:,>z — 84>J:4 &,F:"G" >" B@<@FHz <J:8z< H" B@ :"&"N H&,D*4N B@:b(":4.

=" H@6 R"F 2 &4F@8@(@ ,H,DJ 2:zH"p >" 8@D"$,:\ $@( F>J; &z> BD46<"p >" F,$, &4(:b*@*>@(@ 2 H@&"D4Tz& A":z>JD@&4N, >"<"("pH\Fb &4D&"H4 J >\@(@ 2 DJ8 8,D<J&">>b, ":,*@F&z*R,>46 FH,D>48 >, *"pH\Fb, >, BJF8"p 8@D<4:"

y >, @*&@*4H\ @R,6 @* 2zD >" &4F@8@<J >,$z.

y Hz:\84 8@:4 $@( $,D, & DJ84 (":J28J, @8D@B:,>J &@*"<4 Bz*2,<>4N Dz8, FH"D46

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 32

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

*@F&z*R,>46 F:J(" +>,|& 2"B"*"p & F@>.

1>b&T4F\ J(@DJ H@*z z >" 8,D<J JB"&T4 2&4F@8", #@( @*D4&"p FH,D>@ z FH,D>4R@(@ & <@D, F84*"p. ;"D>@ 8D4R"& A":z>JD, >" B@<zR F@BJH>48z& 8:48"&, — #@( :,(8@8D4:46, b8 BH"N, 2:,Hz& z V,2 J B@&zHDz. ;4D>@ H4< R"F@< B:4&:4 8@D"$:z B@ T4D@8@<J <@D`, ;4D>@ *Dz<":4 B:"&Pz, 2"$,2B,R,>z F:@&@< =,BHJ>", y >"$:40":4F\ J0, *@ $,F8,Hz& F4D,>, *@ H4N $z:4N E8,:\ :4N@&zF>4N, 2"Fzb>4N (JFH@ 8zFH\<4 <@D,N@*Pz&, y 2"RJ&":4 2*":,8", b8 $JN"p <@D, @$ 8"<z>\, — ':b>J& *@ 8,D<4 +>,6 z B@$"R4&: >,<" A":z>JD"; Ez& *@ FH,D>" z B@&z& 8@D"$,:\ F&z6 B@ H,<Db&4N &@*"N, Gb08@ 2z*N"`R4 6 F:\@24 ::`R4 >"* >,*@:,` *DJ(": «? A":z>JD,, *:b R@(@ B@&zD4& H4 >,$J z <@D`? #J*,T :,0"H\, >,B@N@&">46, H4 >" BzF8"N >,&z*@<4N!»

I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ F<,DH\ BD4N@*4H\ B@ 8,D<">4R" & z>T4N @$FH"&4>"N z 2 z>T@|BD4R4>4. AD@V"`R4Fb 2 FzPz:z6Pb<4, FH"D46 A":z>JD «>"N:4FH"&Fb (@Dz:@R84» «B@ F"<,>z:\2b». 1"&&"04&T4 >,$,2B,8J (B’b>46 8@:@ FH,D>"), +>,6 >"8"2Jp 2"$D"H4 6@(@ 2R"D*"8":

=@ &4*>@, V@ B">J G"D"FJ="B4F">@ H"8 >" D@*J,U@$ Hz:\84 *@ P\@(@ &z> R"FJ G,DBz& >" F&zHz Pz< $z*J, — #@, D@2N4H"&T4F\, $D42>J& & &@*J, =4D>J&, z, >, FB4H"&T4 $D@*J, ="&&4D4>84 BzT:" *JT".

% z>T4N &4B"*8"N &HDJR">>b $@(z& 2$,Dz("pH\Fb, ":, N"D"8H,D 6@<J >"*"pH\Fb Dz28@(J<@D4FH4R>46. ?H, >"BD., ,Bz2@* 2 $JD,` & E,D,*2,<>z< <@Dz, V@ 2 >\@(@D@2B@R4>"pH\Fb «+>,|*"». I %,Dhz:zb P` $JD` Bz*z6<"p +@:, $@( &zHDJ, 2 >"8"2J P"D4Pz$@(z& _>@>4, V@ >"<"("pH\Fb @*&,D>JH4 >,>"&4F>4N HD@b>Pz& @* J:`$:,>@| 7"DH"(,>4.G, F"<, z & 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, 2" &46>bH8@< *48@|, ,L,8H@&>@| @$FH">@&4, & b8J &&@*4H\ >"F:"H4>F\8" B@,<": >z *@V@&@(@ @FHD@&" F,D,* <@DF\8@| BJFH4>z, >z &4F@8@| F8,:z, *, >"HD@>z F4*4H\ 2 $,D:@< J DJ8"N &:"*48" &zHDz&, >z 2"<8>,>@| B,R,D4, *, Hz &zHD4 $JDN"`H\— B,D,* >"<4 2&4R"6>" N"H" 2 :"&"<4 8@:@ FHz>, 2"<@0>46 N"2b6F\846 *&zD; z &zHD4 J7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ BD@FH@ :,*"Rz H" &"6:J&"Hz >"6<4H4, z F"< +@: J >\@(@ >,FBD@<@0,>@*D"2J &&@:4H4 $@(4>4>J &@:`: &Fb 6@(@ R,:b*\ D@2$D,:"Fb 2 *&@DJ —

#@D,6 >,*J0 :,04H\ 2 B@N<z::b,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 33

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

! =@H B@|N"& >" &,Fz::b,1,L4D 0,, *"&>z6 >,(@*b6,1 *z&R"H"<4 2"0,>4N"&Fb,! +&D J &4>>484 >"6>b&Fb, — a8 N@R,T, H"8 z BD@<4T:b6!

#JDb F8z>R4:"F\. I %,Dhz:zb <@DF\846 $@( =,BHJ>, 2 HD42J$P,< J DJ8"N, BD@>@F4H\Fb& 8@:zF>4Pz B@ F"<z6 B@&,DN>z &@*; J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ &z> 2’b&:bpH\Fb >, & 8@:zF>4Pz —>z!

... <4HH` @Fz*:"&T4 D"8", EN@B4&F\ >" >\@(@, b8 $JD:"8", y 2 <@Db &4D>J&, b8 8"D"F\...

!$@ @H zV, BD48:"*, @FH">>z6, 2 VII 8>4(4 %,Dhz:zp&@| B@,<4: B@R"H@8 &z6>4 & 9bPz|.;@H4&J&">>b B@*&z6>,. %z6>" D@2(@DbpH\Fb H@<J, V@ 1) _>@>" &48:48"p 2 B,8,:\>@|H,<Db&4 LJDz` !::,8H@, b8@| FHD"T4H\Fb F"< A:JH@> z b8z6 *@ *JTz «:4T, FJ<>" &z6>"H" (>z&, H" 2:@R4>>, Bz*FHJBFH&@»; !::,8H@ N@*4H\ B@<z0 HD@b> H" DJHJ:\Pz&, @*&z*JpFz<’` 9"H4>@&J, GJD>" z F8Dz2\ 2"B":`p F,DPb &@D@0>,R,`, 2) HD@b>Pz B@DJTJ`H\ BD"&"B@:`&">>b: F4> +>,|& !F8">z6-yJ: D">4H\ >" &:@&"N BD4DJR,>@(@ @:,>b, V@ >":,04H\:"H4>b>@&z GzDD@&z. 7@H:bD,&F\846 2$,Dz("p @$4*&" <@<,>H4. !:, J >\@(@ LJDzb Gz2zL@>"<":@ R4< >"("*Jp %,Dhz:zp&J !::,8H@. y N@R &@>" H"8 F"<@ :`H" 6 >,F4H", «bN4*>zT" @*&FzN &z*\@<», ":, & || B@b&z >,<" >zR@(@ z<B@2">H>@(@: & *z< P"Db 9"H4>" &@>" «&8@RJpH\Fb8:J$@R8@<», " F<,DH,:\>J >,>"&4FH\ *@ HD@b>Pz& D@2B":`p 2&4R"6>4<4 $"$’bR4<4>"T,BH"<4 6 >"<@&"<4. U@0*@ zFH@Dz| 2 GzDD@&4< @:,>,<, H@ || B,D,H&@D,>@ (&F:z* 2"?FzB@&4< z >z<,P\84< HD"&,FH4H@D@< #:`<"J,D@<) & >"6&,F,:zT, @B@&z*">>b BD@«>b>\R4>@(@ PJP48"», V@ *@R"F>@ 2"(4>J& @* HD@b>F\84N N@DHz& z F&@|<4 @$(D42,>4<46 @$F<@8H">4<4 8zFH@R8"<4 BD4F:J04&Fb b8 BD4&z* *@ B,DT@(@ «THJDN@$@R>@(@ $@`».

y H"8 &F`*4. 1 2@&>zT>\@(@ $@8J B@,H4R>z 2"F@$4 %,Dhz:zb 2@FH"`H\Fb >z$4>,B@DJT,>4<4: &HDJR">>b $@(z&, 2"8:48">>b <J2, >"&zH\ T4D@8@<@&>z, 8"DH4>>zB@Dz&>b>>b (*4&. V, 93 — 94), — " : , H @ > & 2 b H @ * z b < , H D " : \ > @B D @ H 4 : , 0 > 4 6 : * , J % , D h z : z b — * D " < " H 4 2 < , ( , D @ | 2 < ,J D @ R 4 F H " < @ & " , 2 & @ D J T : 4 & z F P , > 4 , H " < J7 @ H : b D , & F \ 8 @ ( @ — L " D F , & , F , : " : , ( 8 @ & " 0 > z F H \ z& : J R > z , N @ R > , 2 " & 0 * 4 & 4 F @ 8 @ | B D @ $ 4 * @ H , B 4 .

!:, &Fb Fz:\ «A,D,:4P\@&">@| +>,|*4» — >, Hz:\84 & Pz6 Dz28z6 >,&z*B@&z*>@FHz(J<@D4FH4R>@(@ FH4:` B@&"0>@<J, @H@R,>@<J B,&>4< BzpH,H@< F`0,H@&z, ":, z & H@<J,Vó >"<"("&Fb B@8"2"H4 & F&@|6, D@Fz6F\8z6, HD"&,FHz| ?FzB@& — & J<z>>z >"*"H4 F&@p<J(J<@D@&z >"Pz@>":\>@(@ N"D"8H,DJ, >"8:"FH4 >" &R4>84 +>,b 6 HD@b>Pz& (JFH46J8D"|>F\846 8@:\@D4H. A,DT,, V@ &48@D4FH@&Jp & P\@<J >"BDb<8J 7@H:bD,&F\846, P,z<,>". ;4 $"R4:4 &0,, b8 & ,Bz2@*z 2 A":z>JD@< HD@b>F\8@(@ 8,D<">4R" >"2&">@G"D"F@<. % z>T@<J <zFPz B,D,* >"<4 HD@b>F\846 &@D@0$4H =,&H,F,«BD@6*4F&zH z

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 34

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

>,B,&>46», FB,Pzb:zFH «("H4H\ (D,$:z». AD@ >\@(@ R4H"p<@:

=,&H,F@< &Fz 6@(@ *D"0>4:4, A@->"T@<J 0 &z> 2&"&F\ ?NDz<.

U, BD48:"*. +>,6 FN@*4H\ *@ B,8:" B@$"R4H4Fb 2 $"H\8@< !>Nz2@< z B@ *@D@2z2JFHDzR"pH\Fb 2 «(D@<"*@` 2>"8@<4N *JT», 2 JFz<" H4<4 HD@b>Pb<4, V@ 2"(4>J:4 &*@D@2z. %Fz «HD@b>F\8z *JTz» >@FbH\ FJH@ J8D"|>F\8z z<,>":

A,*\8", G,D,T8", S,:zL@>",A">\8", ?NDz<" z M"D8", 9,F\8", ?:,T8" z E42\@>", A"DN@<", yF\8" z K,F\8".

AzF>z P4N HD@b>Pz&, 2"$"&4 z BF4N@:@(zb, |N J$D">>b z 2&4R84 — &F, R4FH@ J8D"|>F\8,.A:4&JH\ &@>4 <@D,< *,F\ 8@:@ EzPz:z| — FBz&"`H\ BzF,>\ «8@2"P\84N, ("D>4N,2"B@D@2\84N», BD4|2*bH\ *@ 7"DH"(,>4 — D@2&"0"`H\Fb >" *@2&z::z «ND,V48@< z(@D`*J$@<», «&z28@<» z ("2"D*@&@` (D@` «& Fz< :4FH8z&»; BD4$J&"`H\ *@ P"Db 9"H4>" zBD4>@FbH\ FH"D@&4>>4< 2&4R"p< «>" D":,P\»

A4Dz( 2"&*@&084 z2 "DT4>y F@:4 — 8D4<84 z $"N<JH84...

EH"D@&4>>46 B@$JH, FH"D@F&zHF\8, 04HHb &F`*4 &B:zH"pH\Fb & B@,H4R>J H8">4>J(D,8@-D4<F\8@| :,h,>*4. )&zD P"Db 9"H4>", @$F"*0,>46 8:,R">>b<, F&zH:4Pz, B@@$$4&">zTB":,D"<4, 2"F:">z 84:4<"<4 H" Db*>b>4<4 *@Dz08"<4, @$&zT">z B@DHD,H"<4 «&FzN$"("H4Dz&», Jb&:b`H\Fb >"< b8 2"<@0>" *@<z&8" BD@&z>Pzb:\>@(@ B@:JB">8"; HD@b>F\8,B:,<’b, V@ @$:4&"pH\Fb B@H@< >"* :"H4>@`, FH"D">>@ &4D@$:b`R4 :"H4>F\8z H < J ,< > J , 2 * @ , H : @ , B,D,>@F4H\ >"F & @$FH">@&J FH"D@| J8D"|>F\8@| T8@:4, 2 ||«AzbDF\8@` (D"<"H8@`» H" >,<4>JR4<4 «FJ$zH8"<4»; " @B4F JRH4 J P"Db 9"H4>" "$@8"DH4>4 D"`&">>b BD"&,*>48z& J m:zF,6F\84N B@:bN 2>"6@<:bH\ >"F 2 JFz<" D@28@T"<4HD"*4Pz6>@| J8D"|>F\8@| 8J:z>"Dz|: «@HDz$8"<4 H" T"DB">4>"<4», «(">JFz&8"<4 H"8":(">z&8"<4», «&"D,>48"<4 BT,>4R>4<4 $z:4<4 H" BJN84<4 *@ 8"&’bDJ $JN">Pb<4».)@ P\@(@ BD4B:zH"pH\Fb $,2:zR >"Hb8z& z @$D"2z&, J2bH4N 2 04&@| FJR"F>@FH4 "$@>,*"&>\@(@ <4>J:@(@. GD@b>Pz, «2"8JD4&T4» — D@2(J:b&T4Fb & EzPz:z|, FBD"&:b`H\ >"$@(z& &D"0,>>b F,:", B@>bH@(@ 0"N@< B,D,* H"H"D"<4:

% EzPz:z| H"8, H&@D4H\Fb, U@ &"< $4 HD,$" B@*4&4H\Fb: G " < 8 D 4 8 , < @ & B z * F H J B " @ D * " .

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 35

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

+>,6, 2JFHDzR"`R4F\ 2 !D8"*F\84< P"D,< +&">*D@<, D,8@<,>*JpH\Fb 6@<J: «b —8@T@&46 +>,6 HD@b>,P\»; +&Dzb: 2"FB@8@`p F&@(@ $@6@&@(@ H@&"D4T" =z2",B@F4:"`R4F\ >" F&@(@ $"H\8":

;z6 $"H\8@ $J& F , D * ` 8 @BDzR>46...

y >"&zH\ 9"H4>, <4D>46, FH"D46 P"D@8, «F,DP,< z *JT,` *":,846 @* &z6>4», z H@6 JD@2<@&z 2("*Jp BD@ > " T J E z R . ! B@Dz&>b>>b: «=, H"8 D@2F,D*4H\Fb *@$D@*z6, 8@:4B " > & @ 2 > 4 6 B @ 2 @ & * " F H \ », " <Dz6>z 2z*N">>b 2" FH"D@&4>@`: «G"8 &zR>@6B"<’bHz $J&":@» — &F, P, >, Hz:\84 F<zT4H\ R4H"R", ":, 6 2"Pz8"&:`p, 2"z>HD4h@&Jp, >,Hz:\84 >" (J<@D4FH4R>46 :"* B,D,D@$:bp B@&"0>J 8:bF4R>J L"$J:J, ":, 6 04&@H&@D4H\||, &BD"&:b`R4 & || D"<84 T4D@8@ FN@B:,>J z BD"&*4&@ 2<":\@&">J 8"DH4>J J8D"|>F\8@(@B@$JHJ. O,6 , H > @ ( D " L z R > 4 6 D , " : z 2 < « + > , | * 4 » z p F H \ H D , H bN " D " 8 H , D > " D 4 F " H D " & , F H z 6 > @ | < " > , D 4 7 @ H : b D , & F \ 8 @ ( @. )@ H@(@ F"<@(@, &4*4<" DzR, 2<"("& z ?FzB@&, >"*"`R4 F&@|6 )z*@>z H" || 8"DH"(,>F\8@<J*&@D@&z 8@:\@D4HJ D@Fz6F\8@| B@<zV4P\8@| FH"D@F&zHR4>4, 8@:4 V, BD@P&zH":4 «$"DF84,$"DZ>4» H" «F,>>Z, *,&JT84», " «8@8@T>48» H" «H,:@(D,68"» >, $J:4 V, &404Hz«&,HD,>>@6 LD">PJ2F8@6 <@*@6», — ":, 6@(@ D,":z2< $z*>zT46 >" L"D$4; 6@<J >,2"&0*4 &*"pH\Fb B@&,D>JH4 %,Dhz:zp&J «B@(J*8J» >" H"846 $"0">46 6@<J «DJFF8@6 :"*».y b8 >, 2&JR4H\ B,D,$z:\T,>>b< LD"2" ?. a. mL4<,>8@, V@ « “+>,|*"” 7@H:bD,&F8@(@@H>@F4HFb 8 «]>,4*,» ?F4B@&" 8"8 04&@6 P&,H@8 8 0":8@<J HDbB4R>@<J 42*,:4`» —& (:4$4>z || :,04H\ &zD>, FB@FH,D,0,>>b; B@Db* 2 04&4<4 8"DH4>"<4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@FBD"&*z <@0, 2*"H4Fb, V@ ?FzB@& H" 7@H,:\>zP\846, J F&@|< FHD,<:z>>z &z*H&@D4H4&,:48@D@Fz6F\846 B@$JH, «H@:\8@ F@R4>b`H — (DJ$@-BD@2"4R,F84, HJF8:@ 4<>@(@F:@&>@».

§ 4. ',D@| “+>,|*4”. )":,8@ <,>T, <4FH,PH&" J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & N"D"8H,D4FH48"N*zp&4N @Fz$. GJH ?FzB@& 2>"R>@ B,D,&"0"p 6@(@ &4HD4<">zFH` @$D"2J z H@>J.AD4(:b>\<@Fb N@R" $ *@ (@:@&>4N B,DF@>"0z& 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@: 6@(@ HD"8HJ&">>b 1,&F"H" @:z<Bz6Pz&, +>,b z HD@b>Pz& J&,F\ R"F 2<z>bpH\Fb. =" >z< @*$4&"`H\Fb H@ ?FzB@&, H@7@H,:\>zP\846, H@ >"<"(">>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ BD@H4FH"&4H4 |< F&@| @$D"24, &4B:@*4J8D"|>F\8@(@ hDJ>HJ. 5@(@ 8"BD42 HD"&,FH4H@D" Bz*8"2Jp 6@<J &F, >@&z 6 >@&z B@&@D@H4& B@Dz&>b>>bN H" ,BzH,H"N, >, @(:b*"`R4F\ >" H,, @F8z:\84 &@>4 &’b0JH\Fb 2 B@B,D,*>z<4N"D"8H,D4FH48"<4.

+>,6 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, D@2J<zpH\Fb, >, <"p >zR@(@ FBz:\>@(@ 2 $:z*4<, B"F4&>4<(,D@p< %,Dhz:zb: &z> >, FH"&4H\, b8 H@6, F&@|N &R4>8z& J 2":,0>zFH\ @* &@:z $@(z&,&4b&:,>@| & BD@D@PH&"N H" H"p<>4N B@2>"8"N. I B,DT4N R@H4D\@N R"FH4>"N, *,7@H:bD,&F\846 B,D,D@$:bp ?FzB@&", P, "8H4&>46, 0&"&46, «<@H@D>46» «B"DJ$@8»,J*"H>46 «>" &F, 2:,p», V@ 2"&2bH@ «F"*4H\ (@B"8"» & 7"DH"(,>z, 2&@*4H\ 2 J<" )z*@>J,«8JB"pH\Fb & $D"2z», $JD:"8" «&,F,:@(@ 8TH":HJ», V@ >z >"* R4< >, 2"*J<JpH\Fb z & b8@(@>"&zH\ F<,DH\ )z*@>4 >, &48:48"p >zR@(@, 8Dz< P4>zR>@(@:

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 36

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

... =,N"6 |6 &zR>, P"DFH&@, ;,>z 0, *@&(@:zH>p B">FH&@ y V@$ *DJ(" &*@&" 2>"6T:"F\!

% R"FH4>z V z VI <4 $"R4<@ +>,b *":,8@ B@<zD8@&">zT4< J B4bPH&z, D@2FJ*:4&4< z@$"R>4<. %z> F8:"*"p *@(@&@D4, D@2B@Db*0"pH\Fb &z6F\8@&4<4 R"FH4>"<4 z Pz:8@<B@&"0>@ $,D, F&@` <zFz` @F"*R@(@ >@&@| GD@|. )"&>b N"D"8H,D4FH48", B@&H@D,>" & YI-6R"FH4>z:

+>,6 BD@6*4F&zH z >, BD@<"N,% &z6>z z 2DzF, z B@FH"Dz&,AD4&z*Pb $J& B@ &FzN F@*@<"N,%,*<,*z& $"R4& z HN@Dz& —

&4*"pH\Fb H,B,D >,FBD"&,*:4&@` z >,F:JT>@`. % +>,p&z &4b&4:4F\ >@&z D4F4: &z>H":">@&4H@

>,F, *4B:@<"H4R>, BD,*FH"&>4PH&@, &z> J<zp & H@>8z6 z &4TJ8">z6 L@D<z &z**"H4@FH">>` T">J 2"$4H@<J >" &z6>z F@`2>48@&z (BD@<@&" >"* Hz:@< A"::b>H", VI, 81); &>\@<J $"("H@ F"<@B@&"(4; H,B,D &z> :4P"D, «8 *@$DJ 2 >"HJD4 F8:@>>46», &z> >"<"("pH\FbB,D,B4>4H4 >,B@HDz$>J $z68J, $@ — «BD@ V@ &FzN F">(&zF BD@:4&"H\?»... @*>@ F:@&@, P,&0, >, B,DT46-:zBT46 $JD:"8", " <J*D46 H" D@2&"0>46 $"H\8@ 8@2"P\846, >" 2D"2@8FJR"F>4N 7@H:bD,&F\8@<J 8J$">F\84N H" >"**J>"6F\84N @H"<">z&, V@ H"8 JB,DH@*@<"(":4F\ >" RJ04>z >@&4N 2,<,:\ *:b 8@2"P\8@| 8@:@>z2"Pz|.

G"8 F"<@ >,:,(8@ >" FJPz:\>J B@FH"H\ F8:"*"`H\Fb z Hz @8D,<z D4F4, V@ <"`H\FN"D"8H,D42J&"H4 %,>,DJ. %,>,D" 2’b&:bpH\Fb & B@,<z 8z:\D" D"2: z>HD4(J`R4 >" ?:z<Bz& F4>@&4N z>H,D,F"N, &@>" H@ >"8:"*"p 2 1,&F@<, H@ D@$4H\ &4N&"H84 BD@H4 >\@(@. % 8z>Pzyy-@| R"FH4>4 &@>" &4|2*4H\ 2 &z24H@` *@ =,BHJ>", || 2@&>zT>z6 &4(:b* — B@FH"&",B@&@*0,>>b, J$zD — F&z*R4H\ BD@ B,&>J &4H@>R,>zFH\. %@>" <"p &:"F>46 D4*&"> z F4*4H\J >\@<J, «<@& F@H>48" b8@(@F\ B">z»; || 8@>z BD"&4H\ «<"TH":zD», @*b(>,>46, b8 >":,04H\B">F\8@<J <"TH":zD@&z:

#J:" >" >\@<J $z:" F&4H" y2 T"B@&":\F\8@(@ FJ8>"... z H. *.

y D"BH@< & VI-i6 R"FH4>z, & bF8D"&z6 FP,>z $@0,F\8@| >"D"*4, <4 2>"N@*4<@ >@&J —Pz:8@< @*<z>>J — N"D"8H,D4FH48J $@(4>z:

%,>,D" — <@:@*4Pb F<z:", #@ &F, 2 &@p>>4<4 04:"y 2 >4<4 $4H, <’bF@ |:", y B@ HD"8H4D"N BJ>T B4:", ;">4T84 @LzP,DF\8z BD":",

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 37

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

1 FHD`R8@< (@Dz:8J BD@*"&":"...

U@ $ HJH >, $J:@ — 2"B@24R,>>b & 7@H,:\>zP\8@(@ R4 &:"F>46 8"BD427@H:bD,&F\8@(@, >"&zb>46 @LzP,DF\84<4 FB@("*"<4, — ":, B,D,* >"<4 >, J8D"|>F\846,NJH@DF\846, " D@Fz6F\846 «"D<z6F\846» B@$JH, >, B@&"0>" F@H>4R4N", " 0&"&"<"D84H">H8", V@ H@D(Jp & B@N@*z z «HDbF,H\Fb» & @$@2z 2" &z6F\8@<.

#z:\T, &4HD4<">@FH4 & *DJ(@Db*>4N B@FH"HbN B@,<4 — <4D>@<J 9"H4>@&z,N"D"8H,D>z6 !<"Hz, &@6@&>4R@<J GJD>z 2 6@(@ 2&4R8"<4 «@*FH"&>@(@ &@p>>@(@», P\@<J"<"H@D@&z «@NH4DF\8@(@ <,*J» H" «R"` 2 (@Dz:8@`», &2"(":z & JFzN H4N B@FH"HbN, V@N"D"8H,D42J`H\Fb & @*>@<J-*&@N <zFPbN z «8@D@H84<4 J*"D"<4».

AD"&*", z HJH HD"B:b`H\Fb R"F@< NJ*@0>z B@<4:84. G"8, $,2B,D,R>@ >,&*"H>@`&46T:" J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ <"H4 +&Dzb:". EP,>" || B:"RJ >"* F4>@< >":,04H\ *@>"6L":\T4&zT4N FP,> «+>,|*4». % z>Tz< <zFPz, *, B,D,* 7@H:bD,&F\84< $J:" B@*z$>"F4HJ"Pzb — F<,DH\ A"::b>H" z «$"H\8z&F\8" B,R":\» +&">*D", &z> >"B,D,* @*<@&4&Fb @*@B4FJ z F"< >"&z& H@<J <@H4&4:

G" $"! =, &Fb846 H"8 2<J*DJp, a8 F"< %,D(z:z6 >"<":`p, ! b *@ 0":` >, <"FH"8.

=,2*"H>zFH\ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ *@ «0":`» &4b&:bpH\Fb HJH B@&>@` <zD@`. AzF:bFHD4<">@(@ @B@&z*">>b BD@ B@*&4(4 6 F<,DH\ +&Dzb:" H" =z2", HD"&,FH@&">@(@ 2 B,&>4<"DH4FH4R>4< H"8H@<, H"8 >,BD4p<>@ R4H"H4 BD@ +&Dzb:@&J <"HzD, V@ &@>", 2"RJ&T4 BD@F<,DH\ F4>", —

7D4R":", h,*2":"F\, 8"R":"F\,7J&z8":", b8 B@D@Fb...

=,BD"&*@B@*z$>@, B@-$":"(">>@<J HD"(zR>@ 2&JR"H\ z || BD@8:bHHb DJHJ:"<:

! &4, V@ +&DJFb J$4:4, U@$ &"T BD@B"& F@$"R46 Dz*!...?N, R@< >, 2&zD b, R@< >, :\&4Pb, Q@< >, F8"0,>" b &@&R4Pb, U@$ <>z DJHJ:\Pz& D@2zD&"H\, U@$ F,DP, &4D&"H\ 2 HD,$JN@`, I<"2"H\ <@D*J |N <"28@`, U@$ <"F:"84 |N B@F<@8H"H\!...

!>H4NJ*@0>zFH\ Pzp| FP,>4 BD,8D"F>@ &z*Hz>bpH\Fb B@,H4R>4< B:"R,< +&Dzb:@&@|<"H,Dz J %,Dhz:zb. G"<, BD4(@:@<T,>" (@D,<, &@>" >, 2>"N@*4H\ F4:4 *:b BD@8:bH\; &@>"&Fb D@2:4&"pH\Fb & HJ0:4&4N F8"D("N: >,N"6 DJHJ:\F\8z FHDz:4 z & >,| @*$,DJH\ >,B@HDz$>,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 38

12. % *,&’b>@FH4N D@8"N 7@H:bD,&F\846 <"& &48z>R,>4<4 :4T, HD4 R"FH4>4. Oz HD4R"FH4>4 z 2’b&4:4Fb *DJ8@< J B,DT@<J A"DBJD4>@<J — & 1798 z & *DJ(@<J —B,D,*DJ8@&">@<J 2 A"DBJD4>@(@ — &4*">>z 1808 D. Q,H&,DH" R"FH4>" 2’b&4:"FbHz:\84 & HD,H\@<J &4*">>z, "&H@D@&@<J (1809 D.). Oz:8@&4H@ 0 JFb «+>,|*"» &46T:" &F&zH J0, B@ F<,DHz "&H@D", & N"D8z&F\8@<J &4*">>z %@:@N4>@&" (1842).%@:@N4>@&F\846 H,8FH >,V@*"&>@ B,D,*DJ8@&">@ Bz* D,*"8Pzp` %. UJD"H": y.7@H:bD,&F\846. %zD(z:zp&" +>,|*". A,D,*DJ8 B,DT@(@ B@&>@(@ &4*">>b 2 1842 D.,

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

|6 04HHb, " &,:4846 $"H\8@ $@(z& 2<4:@F,D*4H\Fb >"* >,`, B@F:"&T4 |6 F<,DH\ z BD"&@J&z6H4 & G"DH"D.

§ 5. MJ*@0>p &48@>">>b “+>,|*4”. A@DJR >,&4*,D0">@FH4 N"D"8H,Dz& >" 8"D$«+>,|*z» HD,$" B@8:"FH4 V, 2"(":\>J >,*@*,D0">zFH\ H@>J. «A,D,:4P\@&">" +>,|*"», V@H@D8"pH\Fb &48@>">>b, H&zD *J0, z *J0, >,Dz&>46. AD4R4>4 H"8@| >,Dz&>@FH, FH">JH\ *:b>"F bF>z, 8@:4 <4 BD4("*"p<@, V@ «+>,|*"» B4F":"Fb >" BD@Hb2z Pz:4N HD4*PbH4 :zH z V@>" BD@Hb2z P4N HD4*PbH4 :zH 2<z>b:4Fb F<"84, B@&z&4 z &B:4&4, (D@<"*b>FH&@ 6 B@$JH,2<z>b&Fb >"D,THz F"< "&H@D, 6@(@ B@(:b*4, @Pz>84, 6@(@ FH"&:,>>b *@ (D@<"*b>FH&", *@&:"F>@| F&@p| H&@DR@FH4 z *@ 2>"Db**b Hzp| H&@DR@FH4 — >"D@*>\@| <@&4. a8 >,, 2$,D,(H4p*>zFH\ H@>J & B@,<z, D@2B@R"Hz6 2" <@:@*4N :zH, " 2"8z>R,>z6 >" B@D@2z FH"D@FH4!

1 B@(:b*J FH4:` 6 &48@>">>b «B,D,:4P\@&">" +>,|*"» BD,*FH"&:bp HD4 &"DzbPz|HD"&,FHz6>@| <">,D4. A,DTz *&z R"FH4>4 &D"0"`H\ (DJ$4<, ":, V4D4<, >,Bz*D@$:,>4<8@<z2<@<, B@*z$>4< *@ 8@<z2<J $JD:,F8>4N &zDTz& XVIII &. % R"FH4>"N III — IY-z6 (J<@D"&H@D" &4H@>RJpH\Fb, @B@&z*">>b FH"p *@8:"*>zT4<, 7@H:bD,&F\846 *@2&@:bp F@$z &F,$z:\T, 6 $z:\T,, &z*FHJB"H4 @* B,D&@H&@DJ, *@8:"*>@ D@2D@$:b`R4 @8D,<z ,Bz2@*4,2"$"D&:``R4 |N >@H8"<4 (D@<"*F\8@| F"H4D4. ?FH">>z *&z R"FH4>4 B@8"2J`H\ B,&>J&H@<J "&H@D@&J; 7@H:bD,&F\846, &4*4<@, B@FBzT"p 2"8z>R4H4 D@2B@R"HJ BD"P`,B,D,8"2Jp & @*>z6 R"FH4>z B@ 2 — 3 BzF>z %,Dhz:zb; @B@&z*">>b &,*,H\Fb FJN@,&4D@*0J`R4Fb R"F"<4 & b8JF\ D,:bPz` BD@ JFBzN4 z &HD"H4 HD@b>F\8@| &"H"(4. E"< "&H@DBD42>"pH\Fb, V@ 6@<J Hb08@ FH":@ B4F"H4:

G,B,D $,2 F@D@<" BD42>"`F\,U@ HDJ*>@ $4H&J @B4F"H\,y b8 >z <@DVJF\, >z FH"D"`F\,U@$ &zDTz (:"*8@ T8">*J&"H\, — G" $"RJ B@ <@p<J &4*J,U@ F8@<B@>J` B">"N4*J... z H. *.

y FBD"&*z: &"DH D@2(@D>JH4 Y-HJ R"FH4>J, BD@R4H"H4 || B@R"H@8 «#z*" >, B@ *,D,&"NN@*4H\» z B@Dz&>bH4 6@(@ 2 B@R"H8@&4<4 FHD@L"<4 III "$@ IV R"FH4>4, V@$ B@$"R4H4, b8H@> @B@&z*">>b FH"p &4<JT,>@ D,H@D4R>4<, " 04&z *,H":z 2"FHJB"`H\Fb <:b&4<4BD@<@&"<4 H" &H,DH4<4 D@2J<J&">>b<412, H"8 2&. «2"(":\>4<4 <zFPb<4»:

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 39

>"8:"*@< 8>4("D>z ="J8@&@(@ G@&"D4FH&" z<. S,&R,>8". 9\&z& 1918. 1 >@&zT4N&4*">\ >"68D"V, — &4*">>b «%z8J»: G&@D4 y&">" 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, Bz* D,*"8Pzp`, 2B,D,*>z< F:@&@< H" BD4<zH8"<4 E,D(zb mLD,<@&", 74|& 1909 (1 &4*.), 1917 (2 &4*.).EB,Pzb:\>@ *:b T8@:4 H,8FH +>,|*4 (F8@D@R,>46) &4BJFH4:@ &-&@ «7D4>4Pb»: y&">7@H:bD,&F\846, +>,|*" 2 BD4<zH8"<4 H" 8D4H4R>4<4 FH"HHb<4. S8z:\>" $z$:z@H,8"Bz* D,*"8Pzp` ?:,8F">*D" )@D@T8,&4R", 1, 74|& 1919.

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

?, F@>! 2 H@$@` 2"$J&"p<%F, (@D, z F&@` >"B"FH\,QD,2 H,$, F4:4 >"$4D"p<,#,2 H,$, 0 <JFz:4 BD@B"FH\.G4 @F:"$z&T4N J8DzB:bpT,% H`D<z >,&4>>4N JHzT"pT,1:@*z|& F>4V"<4 FHD"T4T... z H. *.

Gz:\84 & *&@N FP,>"N @FH">>z R"FH4>4 «+>,|*4» Bz*z6<"`H\Fb >" &4F@HJ B@B,D,*>zN— & >"D"*z $@(z& >" ?:z<Bz («?:z<BF\8" 8"D&"F"D\») H" A"::b>H@&@<J B@N@D@>z. Q4 >,>"&@*4H\ P, >" *J<8J, V@ 7@H:bD,&F\846 F"< BD@N@:@& Bz* 8z>,P\ *@ F&@p| B@,<4?EH,$:4>-7"<,>F\846 BD4>"6<>z F&z*R4H\ >"<, V@ & 20-30 DD. &z> «HDJ*>@ F@(:"T":Fb»R4H"H\ «>,@HB,R"H">>Z, ,V, V 4 VI-y` R"FH4» «+>,|*4», H"8 V@ 6@<J, F4>@&z *"&>\@(@BD4bH,:b B@,H@&@(@, Hz:\84 @*>@(@ D"2J 6 *@&,:@Fb B@RJH4 "&H@D@&, R4H">>b.

§ 6. %zDT z <@&" “+>,|*4”. %zDT@&" L@D<" «+>,|*4» >" H@6 R"F, 8@:4 B@,<" 2’b&4:"FbJ F&zH, $J:" *:b J8D"|>F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&" &,:48@` >@&4>@`. ),FbH4Db*8@&" FHD@L" 2BD"&4:\>4< z FHD@(4< R,D(J&">>b< D4<, R@H4D4FH@B@&46 b<$, :,(846 H" *2&z>846, >zR@(@FBz:\>@(@ >, <"`H\ 2 F4:"$zR>4< J F&@|6 @F>@&z, >, Pz:8@< H@>z2@&">4< &zDT,<=,8D"T,&4R" H" ">@>z<>4N "&H@Dz& $JD:,F8>@| :zH,D"HJD4. O, B,D,F"*0,>46 >"J8D"|>F\846 hDJ>H D@Fz6F\846 &zDT *@BJT8z>F\8@|, *@$"H`T8@&F\8@| *@$4, N@R, BD"&*",&2bH46 >, J &4*"H>4N, b8 ),D0"&z> "$@ 7"B>zFH, ":, F,D,*>zN, «B,D,FzR>4N» :zH,D"HJD>4N*zbRz&. ):b >"F L"8HJD" P\@(@ &zDTJ &4*"pH\Fb Hb0,>\8@`, H"8@` FH":" &@>" 2 R"Fz&S,&R,>8", V@ BD4V,B4& >"T@<J B4F\<,>FH&J :,(846 2D,L@D<@&">46 b<$ BJT8z>F\8@|B@D4, — ":, *:b FJR"F>48z& 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ P, $J:@ FBD"&0>p &,DF4Lz8"Pz6>, *4&@.

I &zDTz «+>,|*4» >"< @*D"2J &B"*"`H\ & @8@ *&z N"D"8H,D>z @F@$:4&@FHz: 1) >,2DJR>,,>,BD4D@*>, z >,<,:@*z6>, D@2<zV,>>b F:z&, V@ H"8 JHDJ*>`p R"F@< R4H">>b — @F@$:4&@2"&"0"`H\ FB@:JR>484 & F,D,*4>z Db*8": «)@ :bFJ < @ & :bN4 T"H>J:4F\», «!>N42" V @ $ >, BD@(J:bH4», «A,D@< & B"B,Dz b 8 B4F>,T», «y2(4>J $,2 &@*4 < @ & D"8» —z 2) B@&z:\>46, >,<@& 2"HD4<">46 H,<B 6@(@ &zDTJ. 1":,04H\ P,6 H,<B @* N"D"8H,D>@(@*:b &FzN H@(@R"F>4N B@,Hz& 2"F@$J — >, D@$4H4 D4H<zR>@(@ >"(@:@FJ >" *DJ(z6 FH@Bz,>"BD., «AD@84>J&T4Fb, &,F\ HDJF4&Fb», «1"&2bHzT46 @* &FzN $JD:"8», «AJH4&@R8J %,>,Dz*"&». — EN,<":

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 40

13. AD@ &Fz Pz H,D<z>4 *4&. J a8J$F\8@(@ «="J8" &zDTJ&">>b», 74|&, 1922, @F@$:4&@ FH@D. 34, 47.

14. 7@H:bD,&F\846 *J0, :`$4H\ P,6 D4H<zR>46 Nz*. "I B,DTz6 R"FH4>z, >" 660 Db*8z& &z> 8@D4FH"pH\Fb>4< 16 D"2; J *DJ(z6, >" 750 — 23 D"24; J HD,Hz6, >" 1410 — 68 D"2.

15. Oz8"&@ B@Dz&>bH4 &zDT 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ 2 &zDT,< ?FzB@&". ):b ?FzB@&" H"8 F"<@ z & H z 6 0 ,< z D z N"D"8H,D>z z FB@:JR>484 & F,D,*4>z Db*8" («=@ & $">\8, R H @ $ 2"<,D2:Z 8@FH4 C"FB"D4H\*@$DZ< R,D,*@<», «7"8 @&PZ & H,F>@< * e 2"(@>,, 7&"F>"b (JV" 8 " 8 >" *>,») z BzD4Nz| & 2 H" 3

FH@Bz R@H4D4FH@B@&@(@ b<$" («7D"F"&4P"<4 B:@V"*>Z<4, 9`$@&>4P"<4 2"&@*>Z<4»; «AD4R":4:4Fb>, FBD@FbFb», «AD@FH4H,:\>@ 4 B@*4&4H\Fb», «AD48:,4&"b, BD4$4&"b», «A@<@DV4:Fb 4 B@R,F":Fb» z H.

*.). ="&zH\ @*>@ z H, F"<, D@2<zV,>>b F:z& & *@*"H8@&4N D,R,>>bN; & ?FzB@&": «=" B":J$, (D,$PZD"FF,&T4F\», J 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@: «A@F:JN"&T4 +>,6 ?NDz<"». ;@0,, 2&z*F4, 2 ?FzB@&" H" D@Fz6F\8@|&,DF4Lz8"Pz| XVyyy &., R,D,2 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, B@N@*4H\ z S,&R,>8@&,: «C@2$4&T4 &zH,D R@D>z N<"D4, :z($z:b <@Db @*B@R4H\», z >,<" Bz*FH"&4 &&"0"H4 P,6 2&@D@H @F@$:4&zFH` >"D@*>\@| F4>H"8F4, b8 P,D@$4:4 7J:zT H" 'Dz>R,>8@.

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

^ — | ^ ^ | ^ — | ^ —

7Dz< P\@(@ D4H<zR>@(@ N@*J, 7@H:bD,&F\846 R"FH,>\8@ 8@D4FHJpH\Fb z *DJ(4<, V,$z:\T, 2"HD4<J`R4< D4H<. %z> BD"8H48Jp @*>@R"F@&J 2"<z>J *DJ(@(@ z HD,H\@(@ b<$"FH@B"<4 $,2 >"(@:@FJ, H. 2&. BzD4Nzb<413 — >"BD., «a(" Pb z 2"(@&@D4:"», «yF8@DR4&TJ`Fb& *J(J», «? BJP\&zDz>8J 7JB4*@>,»14. EN,<" P4N Db*8z& H"8":

^ — | ^ ^ | ^ ^ | ^ —

1*,$z:\T@(@ Db*84 2 BzD4Nzb<4 & *DJ(z6 z HD,Hz6 FH@Bz $J&"`H\ &"08z z >,<J24R>z; ":,7@H:bD,&F\846 J0, &<zp >"*"H4 |< :,(8@FH4 H" <,:@*z6>@FH4. %z> Bz*$4D"p & Db*@8 *&@pF:z&, *@&(4N, ":, 2 @*>"8@&@` "$@ BD4$:42>@ @*>"8@&@` 8z:\8zFH` F8:"*z&, z>@*z 2 H4<4F"<4<4 2&J8"<4 >" B@R"H8J 8@0>@(@ F:@&", z >,<4:@(@ &D"0,>>b J0, >,<"p. G"8z Db*84,b8: «C@20,&Dz:@F\ z 2"(@Dz:@F\», «A@B:"8"&T4 z B@D4*"&T4», «A@F&"H":4F\ zB@8J<":4F\», "$@: «1 @$FHD40,>4<4 (@:@&¿<4, 3 Bz*Dz2">4<4 B,:,>¿<4» — R4H"`H\FbH"8 F"<@ :,(8@, b8 9,D<@>H@&F\8z «7@RJ`V4, 8"D"&">Z % BD@FHD">FH&, $D@T,>>ZNF&,H4:» "$@ /J8@&F\8@(@: «7"8 @$:"R8@ BD4 bF>@< *>, 1 " H , D b > > @ , && Z T 4 > , 3 & F@:>,R>ZN ,(@ :JR"N = , > J 0 > @ , > " > , $ , F " x »15.

%2"(":z, 2 D4H<zR>@(@ B@(:b*J &zDT 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ $"("H46 z Dz2>@<">zH>46.A@24R4&T4 J D@Fzb> |N R@H4D4FH@B@&46 b<$, &z> @*D"2J *@Dz&>b&Fb |< H,N>zR>@`*@F8@>":zFH` F&@(@ b<$" z F&@p| «*,P4<4». % «+>,|*z» <@0>" &8"2"H4 Pz:J >428JBD,8D"F>@ 2$J*@&">4N, $,2*@(">>4N V@*@ D4H<J, FHD@L. G"8z & yyy-6 BzF>z FHD@L4 79, 80,82, & yI-6 — 101, 114 («'J*, & 9"Hz| *2&z> &zV@&46»), 118 («#J:4 2:"Hz| *>z !FHD,|»), 122(«=, N<"D" F@>P, 2"FHJB4:"»). GD@N4 (zDT, FH@|H\ 2 ,&L@>zp`: & «+>,|*z» >, &4|<@82JFHDzH4 FB@:JR,>>b 2&J8z&, b8z 2 &,:484< HDJ*@< >"*"`H\Fb *@ &4<@&4 («7 R@DH"< z V@$z *JN; >, B"N», y, 2, "$@ «a8 (":4R & &D,<’b >,B@(@*>,», IV, 28).

; @ & " «+>,|*4», H"8 F"<@, b8 z &zDT ||, $J:4 *:b F&@(@ R"FJ &,:4R,2>@| &"(4BD4*$">>b<. )"&>zTz B4F\<,>>484, V@ B@F:J(J&":4Fb >"D@*>\@` <@&@` & z>H,D<,*zbNH" B@$JH@&@(@ 2<zFHJ &zDT"N, $D":4 P` <@&J & || Bz&>zR>@-J8D"|>F\84N *zb:,8H4R>4N

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 41

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

L@D<"N. 1&z*F4 J 7@>4F\8@(@, )@&(":,&F\8@(@ z & z>T4N "&H@Dz& H"8z L@D<4, b8 «B:J*»2"<. B:z*, «&zH» (&z6H) z «&J6H», *J6*JH\ 2"<. *z6*JH\, @D`< z Fz`< 2"<. @D,<@ z Fzp<@,8"0`H\ 2"<. 8"0JH\, «B@6T@:» 2"<. BzT@& z H. *. I 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ J8D"|>F\8J <@&J <4RJp<@ & || P,>HD":\>z6, B@:H"&F\8@-84|&F\8z6 (@&zDPz, b8" 2 H@(@ R"FJ z &N@*4H\ J:zH,D"HJD>46 J04H@8. ?FH"H@R>@ JH&,D*4& ||, b8 @F>@&J :zH,D"HJD>@| <@&4, S,&R,>8@.

I8D"|>F\8" >"D@*>b <@&" J *"&>zT4N "&H@Dz& >, &42>"R":"Fb R4FH@H@` F:@&>48". %>z6 B@&>@ $J:@ B@:\F\84N, F:@&’b>F\84N z >"&zH\ :"H4>F\84N F:z&. 9,8F4R>46 <"H,Dzb:7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ *":,8@ R4FHzT46, N@R z & >\@(@ HD"B:bpH\Fb *@F4H\ FH"D@F:@&’b>F\84N,B@:\F\84N («P,D"», «BD"FJ>@8», «z2&@<B4H4») z @F@$:4&@ D@Fz6F\84N ,:,<,>Hz&(«ND"$D46», «N&"FHJ>», «4FB@:4>», «(@>4H\ "N4>,|», «FJ*,$ B@ &@:z» etc.). !:, >, & R4FH@HzFBD"&"; >"6$z:\T" 2"F:J(" <@&4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ — P, >"*2&4R"6>, $"("HFH&@ ||F:@&>48". «+>,|*"» 2"Lz8FJ&":" z *@>,F:" *@ >"F F4:J BD,8D"F>4N "DN"|2<z&,BD@&z>Pzb:z2<z&, H,N>zR>4N &4D"2z&. 7@H:bD,&F\846 2>"& Pz>J F&@|< F8"D$"< z :`$4& |NB@8"2J&"H4. ?FzB@& J F&@|6 «%Z&@D@R,>>@6 >" 42>">8J ]>,4*,» R"FH@ B4T"pH\Fb$"("HFH&@< F&@p| <@&4, B,D,F4B"pH\Fb F4>@>z<"<4, 8@N"pH\Fb & ,BzH,H"N (B@Dz&>.N"D"8H,D4FH484 9b&z>z| 6@(@ z 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >" FH@D. 49). !:, 7@H:bD,&F\846 >z*, >,N@R, B@FHJB4H4Fb 6@<J <zFP,<. ?H N"D"8H,D4FH48" 6@(@ )z*@>4:

C@2J<>" B">z z <@H@D>", ):b >,| HD@N4 P4N z<,>: GDJ*bV", *J0, BD"P\@&4H", %,F,:", ("D>", F">@&4H"... (y, 21).

!$@ @H @B4F Hzp| <J84, b8@| 2"&*"&":" (DzT>4< J B,8:z LJDzb Gz2zL@>":

%@>" $,2 &Fb8@(@ @$<">J y V4D@, $,2 @$4>b8z&, C@$4:" (DzT>4< *@$DJ T">J, C,<>b<4 *D":", <@& $48z&, 7JF":", (D42:", $4RJ&":", 7D4T4:", T8&"D4:", V4B":", G@BH":", *DbB":", B,8:", A@D@:", 8@DR4:", B4:b:", %,DHz:", D&":", TB4(J&":" y 8D@& z2 Hz:" |N B4:".

1 NJ*@0>\@(@ $@8J Pb <@&" 2">"*H@ 8@>8D,H>", (DJ$", N@R" &:JR>" 6 @$D"2>". ?H b8,>"BD., «>"@R>@» B@8"2">@ "&H@D4H,H GJD>" & yH":z|:

G" 6 &4*>@, V@ >, $J& & 2>,&"2z, #@ &Fz FJFz*>z 8@D@:\84 A@ BD@2\$z, >z$4 B@ BD48"2z,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 42

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

A @ 2 " B " : b ` R 4 : ` : \ 8 4 , AzT:4 & B@N@* 2 F&@|< >"D@*@<, 1 > " R 4 > > b < , B @ H D J N @ < z B : @ * @ < .

A@Dz&>b>>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ BD,8D"F>@ &z**"`H\ >"D@*>` BF4N@:@(z`: |< &:"FH4&"

BD@<@&4FH" :bBz*"D>zFH\ BD48"2@8. ;@D, @$D4*"p HD@b>Pb<, «b8 RJ<"8"< *@V &@F,>4».+>,6, B,D,:b8"&T4F\, HDJF4H\Fb @* FHD"NJ, «<@& F4*b @N:bB >" 8@>z»; $:"(@*"H>" H,B:z>\z V"F:4&, *@2&z::b D"` >"("*J`H\ BD@ FzDb8 z &,:48@*>z F&bH":

=z N@:@*>@ $J:@, >z *JT>@, ! F"<, H"8, b8 & FzDb8"N; =, &,F,:@ z H"8 >, F8JT>@, =" &,:48@*>zN b8 F&bH8"N.

! B@b&" D">zT>\@| 2@Dz &48:48"p @$D"2 BT,>4R>@| &"D,>4Pz:

I0, F&zH@&"b 2zD>4Pb #J:" >" >,$z, b8 B’bH"8!$@ BT,>4R>" &"Db>4Pb,y >,$@ D*z:@Fb, b8 <"8.

Ob 8@>8D,H>zFH\ &4D"2J, V@ R"FH@-(JFH@ B,D,N@*4H\ J &J:\h"D>zFH\, BD,8D"F>@&z*B@&z*":" L@D<z HD"&,FHz6>@| B@,<4, 2 || >"N4:@< *@ 8"D48"HJD4, 2 || Hb0z>>b< J $z8T"D0@&">@-D,":zFH4R>@(@ &z*H&@D,>>b 04HHb. 7@H:bD,&F\846 $J& &,:484< <"6FHD@<«HD"&,FHz6>@|» <@&4 z >" *@&(46 R"F JH&,D*4& || & J8D"|>F\8z6 :zH,D"HJDz.

§ 7. )D"<"H4R>z H&@D4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. 7Dz< «+>,|*4», 7@H:bD,&F\846 :4T4& BzF:bF,$, Hz:\84 *&z D,Rz $z:\T@(@ D@2<zDJ — *&@"8H@&J @B,D,HJ «="H":8"-A@:H"&8"» H"@*>@"8H@&46 &@*,&z:\ «;@F8":\-Q"Dz&>48». A4F">@ |N @*>@R"F@&@ 2 V — VI-` R"FH4>"<4«+>,|*4», *,F\ 8@:@ 1819 p., " &4*DJ8J&">@ 2>"R>@ Bz2>zT,: «="H":8J-A@:H"&8J» — &«I8D"4>F8@< E$@D>48,» ED,2>,&F\8@(@ 2" 1838 D., " «;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"» — H"< 0,, ":,R,D,2 HD4 D@84 B@ F<,DHz "&H@D", & 8z>Pz 1841 D.

IH&@D,>@ |N *:b A@:H"&F\8@(@ H,"HDJ, *, 7@H:bD,&F\846 @*4> R"F 2"&z*J&"&D,B,DHJ"D@<: & 6@(@ B@F<,DH>4N B"B,D"N 2>"6*,>@ &:"F>@DJR>@ B,D,B4F">46 *:b&4FH"&4 H,8FH @*>zp| 2 7D4:@&F\84N 8@<,*z6.C,B,DHJ"D A@:H"&F\8@(@ H,"HDJ F8:"*"&Fb2 B@BJ:bD>4N H@*z D@Fz6F\84N B’pF 7D4:@&", 7>b0>z>", 8>. S"N@&F\8@(@. ?*>" 2 8@<,*z6@FH">>\@(@ — «7"2"8-EH4N@H&@D,P», &4FH"&:,>" & M"D8@&z z & A@:H"&z, B’pF", >,B@2$"&:,>" N4FHJ, ":, B@2>"R,>" B@&,DN@&4< z HD@N4 8"D48"HJD>4< HD"8HJ&">>b<J8D"|>F\8@(@ 04HHb, z FBD4R4>4:"Fb *@ >"B4F">>b «="H":84A@:H"&84». % @*>z6 z2 FP,>«="H":84» 2>"N@*4<@ &4D"2>J >" P, &8"2z&8J. %4$@D>46 ;"8@(@>,>8@ D@2B4HJp A,HD"BD@ M"D8z&, N"D8z&F\8z >@&4>4 z N"D8z&F\846 H,"HD:

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 43

16. «7"2"8-EH4N@H&@D,P», b8 >"2&"& 6@(@ S"N@&F\8@6, «">,8*@H4R,F8"b @B,D"-&@*,&4:\», >"B4F">46 &1812 D@Pz z H@*z 0 JB,DT, &4FH"&:,>46 >" FP,>z. 5@(@ F`0,H>" 8">&" z F4HJ"Pz| J &,:48z6 <zDz&48@D4FH">z & «="H":Pz» 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. ',D@|>b «7"2"8"» ;"DJFb, *@R8" &*@&4 )@$D,>R4N4, :`$4H\7:4<@&F\8@(@, «N@D@T@(@ FH4N@H&@DP", ND"$D@(@ &@4>"», ":,, F8@Db`R4F\ <"H,Dz, *"p 2(@*J &46H4 2"8@2"P\8@(@ H4FbP\8@(@ (?) B">" ADJ*zJF". 1 ADJ*zJF@< 2"@*>@ BD"P`p z 'D4P\8@, «B@&zH@&46 B4F"D»,

;"8@(@>,>8@ «="H":84». ADJ*zJF &B,&>bp ;"DJF`, V@ || <4:46 2"(4>J& >" &z6>z (*zb BD4FH@F@&">" *@1709 D.), " 8@:4 7:4<@&F\846 HJH 0, B@&,DH"pH\Fb 2-Bz* A@:H"&4, @$4*&" BD4bH,:z >"<"("`H\Fb*@&,FH4, V@ 7:4<@&F\846 2:@R4>>@ D@2HD"H4& P"DF\8z (D@Tz, b8z <":4 BzH4 >" &z*T8@*J&">>b <4D>@(@>"F,:,>>b. !:, 8>b2\, V@ $,D,H\Fb 2" D@2F:z*J&">>b FBD"&4, z 6@(@ R,F>46 *,>V48 ),<4> &4&@*bH\:4N@*z|& >" R4FH,, " ;"DJF` 2’p*>J`H\ 2 7:4<@&F\84<.

I8D"|>F\8" <@&" S"N@&F\8@(@ FBD"&*z 0"N:4&", N@R" D@Fz6F\8z "&H@D4, &&@*bR4 J8D"|>F\8z LD"24 *:b<zFP,&@(@ 8@:\@D4HJ, z H,B,D B4TJH\ >, 8D"V,.

?H BD48:"*4. ;"DJFb FBz&"p:

— 7@:4 >" &@6>4 &4> :b0,,

7J:b F,D*,>\8@ BD@$\,H\,

I<4D"&T4, & 4 p > @ , F8"0,:

;4:"b 2" <>@6 J<D,H\.

A D J * 4 J F . ! &@H 0, >4; J < 4 p H@ &4> J < 4 D , 4 H@(@ >, F8"2"&.

; " D J F b .(B@RH4 B"*"b). %4> J<4D!

A D J * 4 J F . ! V@ 0, H4, 2<4:J6Fb, >, &":4Fb. Eb*\ 0, HJH >" B D 4 4 2 $ @ 8 .

U, 8D"V46 *J,H ADJ*4JF-'D4P\8@:

— ',6, (,6, 'D4P8@!

— U@ H"< 2" 8D48?

— ',6, (,6, 'D4P8@!

— !, B">,! — & < 4 ( !

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

% 4 $ @ D > 4 6 . E8"04 0, $D"Hz8J, b8, H@$z :JRR, &FzN B@:`$4:@Fb, b8 8"0, B">&@2>46, :4P,<zDFH&@?

% @ 2 > 4 6 . =, :4P,<zDFH&@, " :4P,*z6FH&@!... A , H D @ . ;,>z B@:`$4:"Fb >"T" <":@D@Fz6F\8" 8J<,*zb. G"< $J:" ;"DJFb, $J&

7:4<@&F\846, AD@*4JF z 'D4P\8@. % 4 $ @ D > 4 6 . C@28"04 0, V@ &@>4 D@$4:4, V@ (@&@D4:4? A , H D @ . EBz&":4 <@F8@&F\8z BzF>z >" >"T (@:@F. 7:4<@&F\846 H">P`&"& 2

<@F8":,<, " V@ (@&@D4:4, H@ HDJ*>@ D@2z$D"H4, $@ P` THJ8J >"B4F"& <@F8":\ B@->"T@<Jz *J0, B@B,D,&,DH"& F:@&".

% 4 $ @ D > 4 6 . ;@F8":\? =zR@(@ 0 z (@&@D4H4. ;"$JH\, &,:\<4 >"T8@*4& z>"8@:@H4& (@D@NJ 2 8"BJFH@`.

C@2<@&" H@R4H\Fb *":z, ":, %4$@D>46 >zb8 >, <@0, 2"FB@8@|H4F\:

% 4 $ @ D > 4 6 . ?H H@ Hz:\84 >,R,BJD>@, V@ <@F8":\ &2b&Fb B@->"T@<J z BD@ >"FB4F"H4, >, $"R4&T4 2D@*J 8D"` z >, 2>"&T4 2&4R"|& z B@&zD’b >"T@(@16.

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 44

— )@&(@ 0*"H\ <>4 >, (@*4HFb,

GD,$" 2"D"2 2 * 4 F \ b&4H\Fb.

=J 0, F8@Dz6! =J 0, F8@Dz6! A@F8@Dz6!

— G@HR"F 4*J!

— ',6, H@D@B4F\!

— G@HR"F 4*J!

— 1"D"2 b&4F\!

— % 2 * 4 H \ 0JB"> b H@D@B:`Fb,

3 b8 D"2 8 H,$, b&:`Fb...

%@H b 4 2 * 4 F \ , &@H b 4 2*4F\, b 4 2*4F\!

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

!&H@D, &4*4<@, N@R, BD@H4FH"&4H4 «7"2"8J» F&@` «="H":8J», *"&T4 & >z6 BD"&*4&J8"DH4>J J8D"|>F\8@(@ «2&4R"`».

a8 0, &48@>"& 7@H:bD,&F\846 P, F&@p 2"&*">>b?1>">>b J8D"|>F\8@(@ B@$JHJ $J:@ & >\@(@ Dz2>@<">zH>, z (:4$@8, (P, <4 2>"p<@ 2

«+>,|*4»); >, $D"8J&":@ 6@<J 6 H&,D,2@(@, FB@FH,D,0:4&@(@ D@2J<J, V@ &<zp D@2Bz2>"H4z &z*H&@D4H4 04HH\@&J BD"&*J. ;@&" *z6@&4N @Fz$ $,2B,D,R>@ &z**"p H@(@R"F>J 04&JD@2<@&J, >"&zH\ J D,B:z8"N %@2>@(@, >, &&"0"`R4 >" *,b8J |N THJR>zFH\. IN"D"8H,D4FH48"N >,<"p 0"*>4N BD4$z:\T,>\. «M"BJ> z 2"&2bH46 `D4FH"» %@2>46,N4HD46, b8 :4F, %4$@D>46, V@ «*, >, B@Fz6, H"< z &D@*4H\Fb», G,DB4:4N", ;48@:" — P,&F, «B@ $:"(@FH4 %F,&4T>,(@ :`*4», 2 JFz<4 :`*F\84<4 R,F>@H"<4 z N4$"<4. %4$@D>46,BD4 &Fz6 F&@|6 2"B@$z(:4&@FHz B,D,* F4:\>4<, >, B@2$"&:,>46 B@RJHHb FBD"&,*:4&@FH4:&z> >, &"("pH\Fb @**"H4 >":,0>, A,HD@&z, 8@:4 H@6 *"DJp ="H":Pz &Fz F&@| 2"D@$zHR">F\8z(D@Tz. ="&zH\ N"$"D>48 %@2>46 «@H D@0*,>4b D"FB@:@0,> 8 *@$DZ< *,:"<» z, 8@:4 *@Fz|N >, D@$4&, H@ &48:`R>@ 2" «>,*@FJ0>@FH4` B@ *@:0>@FH4». ;,>T, 04&@(@ 6N"D"8H,D>@(@ & «B@24H4&>4N» B@FH"HbN — ="H":Pz 6 A,HD@&z, ":, >zR@(@>,BD"&*@B@*z$>@(@, >"*J<">@(@ >,<"p z & >4N.

m*4>,, V@ @F:"$:bp D,":z2< «="H":84-A@:H"&84», — P, || 2"B@24R,>" 2 FJR"F>@(@D@Fz6F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&" L@D<" @B,D,H4: @H, D@2$4&">>b 04&@| D@2<@&4 &@8":\>4<4>J<,D"<4, V@ D@$4H\ *zb:@(4 2">"*H@ THJR>4<4, H" V, F">H4<,>H":\>, 2"$"D&:,>>bD@<">Fz&, b8z "&H@D &8:"*"p & JFH" (,D@|>z:

Q4 V"F:4&" H" $4:4>", V@ D@FH, J B@:z, U@ >" B@:z >" BzF@R8J, $,2 D@F4 >" F@>Pz? Gb08@ 04H4 $,2 <4:@(@ z & F&@|6 FH@D@>Pz... ?6, <"H4, <"H4! F,DP, >, &&"0"p, 7@(@ D"2 B@:`$4H\, 2 H4< z B@<4D"p.

I F&z6 R"F P, FBD"&:b:@ &D"0,>>b. «;>@(4, <,FH" @B,D,HHZ», — B4F"& D,P,>2,>H«E,&,D>@6 AR,:Z», — «F@(D,HZ >,BD4>J0*,>>@6 H,B:@H@6 RJ&FH&" 4 4FH4>>@ <@(JHHD@>JH\ N@Hb >,F8@:\8@ RJ&FH&4H,:\>@, F,D*P,». ):b FJR"F>@(@ R4H"R" Pz «2z(DzHzB@RJHHb<» <zFPb, RJ:z <@>@:@(4 A,HD" H" ="H":84, F@:@*8z D@<">F4 H" 2:,(8"

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 45

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

Bz*BD"&:,>z >"D@*>z BzF>z, *4*"8H4R>z D,B:z84 & D@2&’b2Pz («="H":8@! G,B,D <4 >z8@:4>, D@2:JR4<@F\. #@( >"< *@B@<z( B,D,>,FH4 $z*4 6 >"B"FHz. %z> B@<@0, >"< &zD>@`:`$@&’` z B@Db*@R>@` 042>z`»... z H. *.) — FH">@&:bH\ >"6F:"$zTJ FH@D@>J «="H":84».Oz D4F4 F">H4<,>H":\>@| <">,D4 2"(:JT"`H\ D,":zFH4R>46 H@> B’pF4, FBD"&*z *":,846& Pz:@<J @* «F@:@*,>\8@(@ B,D,$@DV,>@(@ F">H4<,>H":z2<J, b846 2>"p<@, >"BD., 27"D"<2z>@&F\84N @B@&z*">>z&» (mLD,<@&).

«;@F8":\-Q"Dz&>48» 2 NJ*@0>\@(@ $@8J 2>"R>@ B@FHJB"pH\Fb «F&@|6 2>"<,>4Hz6:zH,D"HJD>z6 F,FHDz». «="H":8"-A@:H"&8"» <"60, $,2*@(">>" & D@2J<z>>z "DNzH,8H@>z84H" NJ*@0>\@| ,8@>@<z|. )zb & >z6 D@2&4&"pH\Fb T&4*8@; &Fz B@&@D@H4 z>HD4(4 <@H4&@&">z— >zV@ >, 2"(D@<"*0Jp BD@FH@(@ z bF>@(@ B:b>J. ="&zH\ D@2J<J&">>b (,D@|&, 8Dz<@*>@(@, V@ H@D8"pH\Fb N"D8z&F\8@(@ B@FH"&:,>>b «7"2"8"-EH4N@H&@DP"», &>JHDzT>\@2&’b2">z 2 *zp`. % «="H":Pz-A@:H"&Pz», — B4F"& BD@L. ?. ?. 7@H:bD,&F\846, — «<>@(@042>4, BD@FH@HZ 4 *D"<"H4R>@FH4», «&F, F@&,DT",HFb... & @$Z*,>>@6 FL,D,, $,2 &Fb84N2"BJH">>ZN 2"&b2@8 4 D"2&b2@8», «&F, B@:>@ <":@D@FF46F8@6 BD4D@*Z 4 `<@D"». %«;@F8":z-Q"Dz&>48J» J8D"|>F\8@(@ 8@:\@D4HJ <,>T,, (J<@D ,:,<,>H"D>zT46, *zbD@2&4&"pH\Fb >, H"8 <"6FH,D>@, *zb:@(4 >, H"8z bF8D"&z. %Fb B,DT" FP,>", *@ B@b&4 >"8@>J <@F8":b, D@2Hb(>,>"; *,V@ & >z6 &4*"pH\Fb >,>"HJD":\>4< z 2"6&4<, — >"BD48:"*,B@:,<z8" <z0; G,Hb>@` z K4H48@< FH@F@&>@ y@F4L" AD,8D"F>@(@. 1">"*H@ 8"D48"HJD>@2&JR"H\ BzF>z: <@F8":,&" «),&R4>" <@b B,D,bF:"&8"... C@*>"b <,>b RJH\ >, JT4$:"» —z K4>H48@&":

A,D@ H4 :,$,*4>,, MDJFH":\>46 8":"<"D...

+:,<,>H *4*"8H42<J 2"6<"p & «;@F8":z» *":,8@ $z:\T, <zFPb, >z0: J «="H":Pz».E,>H,>Pz| F4B:`H\Fb, b8 z2 <zN": «% F&,H, R"FH@ F:JR",HFb, RH@ 4 *@$D@*,H,:\ 8"0,HFbB@*@2D4H,:\>@6», «=, $J*\<@ >,J<@:4<z *:b *DJ(4N, @*>4< F@$z 2"2@D>@(@ >,BD@V"6<@», «SJH8", 8FH"H4 F*,:">>"b, $@:\T, *,:",H B@:\2Z, R,< FHD@(4, >"FH"&:,>4b»z H. *. ;@D":z2Jp >, Hz:\84 <@F8":\, V@ >,<@& FB,Pzb:\>zFH\ <"p &4(@:@TJ&"H4 B@&R"`RzD,Rz, ":, z ;4N"6:@, z G,Hb>", z >"&zH\ K4>H48, 8@:4, &4&,*,>46 >" R4FHJ &@*J, @$zPbpFH"H4 BD48:"*@< «8@ 4FBD"&:,>4` &F,N 4 8"0*@(@».

AD4 &Fz< Hz< 2 «;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"» &@*,&z:\ H":">@&4H46 z 0&"&46, $,2 Dz28@(@L":\TJ z >"*<zD>@| 8"D48"HJD4.

m*4>46, NH@ >, B@(@*0J&"&Fb 2 Pzp` @Pz>8@`, $J& 7J:zT. ?(:b*"`R4 J8D"|>F\8,B4F\<,>FH&@ >" FH@Dz>8"N «?F>@&4», &z> 2"84>J& B’pFz || 8D"6>` >,BD"&*@B@*z$>zFH\, b8",>" 6@(@ *J<8J, B@:b("p >"6(@:@&>zT, & Hz<, V@ & D@:z @*JD,>@(@ R@:@&z8" &7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ Lz(JDJp RJ<"8: RJ<"84 0, b8 &z*@<@, >":,0"H\ *@ >"6D@2&4>,>zT4N,:,<,>Hz& :`*>@FH4, z HDJ*>@ BD4FH"H4 >" *J<8J, V@$ $J&":46 RJ<"8 B@&zD4& H"84<>"|&>4< R"D"< z 2"8:bHHb<, b8 <@F8":,&z.

;zD8J&">>b 7J:zT", b8 2"&0*4, FH@D@>>4Rz z >,FBD"&,*:4&z. %"DH B@Dz&>bH4«;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"» 2 JFzp` &@*,&z:\>@` :zH,D"HJD@`, >, <4>"`R4 :,(8@(@ H4BJ

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 46

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

8@<,*z6, b8 %4>>4R,>8@&" «A">>" ;"D"», z >"< FH">, bF>@, V@ NJ*@0>z N4$4 «;@F8":b»— T"D0, B,D,F"*" — &:"FH4&z &F\@<J P\@<J :zH,D"HJD>@<J 0">D@&z, " 6@(@ F4:\>z D4F4,b8 8@:\@D4H>" <@&" z 0&"&46 *zb:@(, B@&4>>z $JH4 B@FH"&:,>z >" 8@TH :zH,D"HJD>@(@N4FHJ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@.

§ 8. 9zH,D"HJD" BD@ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. A4F\<,>>4P\8" *zb:\>zFH\ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ z2>"R,>>b || & zFH@Dz| :zH,D"HJD>@(@ &z*D@*0,>>b FH":4 BD,*<,H@< >"60&"&zT@(@ z>"6Dz2>@(@:@FzT@(@ @$<zD8J&">>b & >"J8@&z6 z 8D4H4R>z6 :zH,D"HJDz.

A,DT46, NH@ FBD@$J&"& @Pz>4H4 :zH,D"HJD>, >"*$">>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, $J&7@FH@<"D@&. 5@(@ FH"HHb: «?$2@D F@R4>,>46, B4F">>ZN >" <":@D@FF46F8@< >"D,R44»J<zV,>" Bz* BF,&*@>z<@< ypD,<z| '":84 & ":\<">"Fz «;@:@*48» >" 1844 D. 1>"R,>>b7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, >" *J<8J y. '":84, B@:b("p & Hz<, V@ &z> B,DT46 J("*"& «B@HD,$>@FH\&D,<,>4», B@&FH"&T4 BD@H4 8:bF4P42<J z &4b&4&T4 J8D"|>F\8J >"D@*>zFH\ &@D4hz>":\>z< JH&@Dz D">zT,, ">z0 B@b&4:4Fb B,DTz &4*">>b BzF,>\. AD@H,FH BD@H48:bF4P42<J H" z>H,D,F *@ >"D@*>\@| F&@pDz*>@FH4 &42>"R4:4 2<zFH z L@D<J 6@(@:zH,D"HJD>@| *zb:\>@FH4. «%@ &D,<b JB"*8" 8:"FF4P42<" 4 &H@D0,>4b & ,&D@B,6F84,:4H,D"HJDZ D@<">H4R,F84N 4*,6, — B4F"& 7@FH@<"D@&, — &8JF @$V,FH&" BD4>b: F"<@,FHD">>@, >"BD"&:,>4,: >, F<,:4 D"FFH"H\Fb F &,D@` & 2"&,H>Z, BD,*D"FFJ*84, >, F<,:4BD4>bH\ L@D< >@&@(@ D@*", 8"2"&T4NFb ,V, *484<4, F<,b:4F\ >"* H,< 4 *DJ(4<; B:@*@<H"8@6 >,D,T4H,:\>@FH4 b&4:Fb @F@$Z6 D@* F@R4>,>46... A4F"H,:\ $D": BD,*<,HZ8:"FF4R,F84,, @*,&": 4N & D@<">H4R,F8J` @*,0*J 4 H"84< >,F8:"*>Z< >"Db*@< F<,T4:BJ$:48J». %,F\ ,L,8H «+>,|*4» z B@:b("p & Dz28z6 >,&z*B@&z*>@FHz 8:bF4R>@| L"$J:4 H"|| J8D"|>F\8@| D"<84. «Q,(@ :JRT,? ;":@D@FF46F846 b2Z8 — F"<"b D@<">H4R,F8"bL@D<". “]>,4*"” — F"<@, 8:"FF4R,F8@, F@*,D0">4,». !:, H,B,D (H@$H@ & 40-N DD.) *@$"HD"&,FHz6 <4>J:"Fb — «D@<"H4R,F8"b L@D<" FH":" >"< >,RJ0*", " 8:"FF4R,F8@<JF@*,D0">4` <Z &@2&D"H4:4 *@:0>@, J&"0,>4,». 1>"R,>>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ z 6@(@H&@DR@FH4 &z* H@(@ @*>"8 >, 2<,>T4:@Fb. %HD"H4&T4 F&@p 2>"R,>>b b8 HD"&,FHzb,«+>,|*"» (7@FH@<"D@& (@:@&>4< R4>@< (@&@D4H\ BD@ «+>,|*J») >"$J:" >@&@| &"(4, b8B,DT46 D,":\>46 B@$JH@&@-@B4F@&46 H&zD >"D@*>\@` <@&@`. «;Z &4*4< & >,6... —B4F"& 7@FH@<"D@& — 1) &,D>J` 8"DH4>J <":@D@FF46F8@6 042>4: "&H@D N@D@T@ 2>":;":@D@FF4`, 04: & >,6 4 F >,`, B@:\2@&":Fb &F,<, RH@ $Z:@ J >,(@ B,D,* (:"2"<4... 2)?>" *D"(@P,>>" *:b >"F B@ >,B@*D"0",<@<J ̀ <@DJ, F 8@H@DZ< "&H@D 42@$D"0": B@D@844 F<,T>J` FH@D@>J F&@,(@ >"D@*". EH@4H H@:\8@ &FB@<>4H\ @B4F">4, "*": &F, (D,T>484>@FbH >" F,$, R,DHZ <":@D@FF46F84, 4 *"0, @FJ0*,>Z >" H"84, <J84, 8"84, H@:\8@BD4*JH & (@:@&J <":@D@FF4b>4>J. 3) a2Z8 ,(@, BD"&4:\>Z6, $:,FHbV46, >"D@*>Z6 &&,:4R"6T,6 FH,B,>4, @FH">,HFb F"<Z< :JRT4< B"<bH>48@<, 4 >"*@$>@ F@2>"H\Fb, RH@,*&" :4 J 8@(@ @> *@F4(",H H"8@6 BD"&4:\>@FH4 4 >,BD4>J0*,>>@FH4 D,R4».

% 50-60-N D@8"N *:b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >"FH":" B@D" Dz284N >,h"H4&>4N @Pz>@8. A,DT"2 >4N >":,04H\ F8J$,>H@&z QJBD4>z (BD@L. ?. ?. 7@H:bD,&F\8@<J, «;@F8. %,*@<.», 1856,R. 41). E8J$,>H QJBD4>" &4&@*4H\ 2-Bz* F&@(@ J*"DJ «="H":8J-A@:H"&8J» (6@(@ &4F@8J@Pz>8J @FH">>\@| <4 $"R4:4 &4V,), ":, 2 H4< $z:\T4< 2"B":@< &z> >"B"*"pH\Fb >"«+>,|*J». «+>,|*"», >" 6@(@ *J<8J, «>, $Z:" &Z2&">" B@HD,$>@FHb<4 J8D"4>F8@(@

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 47

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

@$V,FH&"», &@>" $J:" «B:@*@< F@&D,<,>>@(@ >"BD"&:,>4b DJFF8@6 F:@&,F>@FH4», " *:b"&H@D" || «>, $@:,,, 8"8 TJH8@`, 2"$"&@`». «AD4 &F,6 &Z*,D0">>@FH4 & 42@$D"0,>44<":@D@FF46F8@(@ N"D"8H,D" & “A,D,:4P@&">>@6 ]>,4*,”, <Z >, <@0,< >"2&"H\ ^H@BD@42&,*,>4, &B@:>, >"D@*>Z<; J0, @*>@ H@, RH@ @>@ $Z:@ b&:,>4,< F:JR"6>Z<, &2>"R4H,:\>@6 FH,B,>4 J<,>\T",H ,(@ >"D@*>@FH\; *":,,, &(:b*Z&"bF\ & >,(@BD4FH":\>,,, <Z >, &FHD,R",< H@(@ <4:@(@ BD@FH@*JT4b, H@(@ BD4D@*>@(@ `<@D",8@H@DZ6 F@FH"&:b,H 8@D,>>J` R,DHJ BD4D@*>@(@ <":@D@FF46F8@(@ N"D"8H,D". %2(:b*"&H@D", 4<,`V46 P,:\` F<,T4H\ F&@4N R4H"H,:,6 &@ RH@ $Z H@ >4 FH":@, &ZFH"&:b`V46B@H,N D"*4, &@@R4` <4D", &F, F@ F<,T>@6 FH@D@>Z, F@&,DT,>>@ BD@H4&,> 8@D,>>Z<R,DH"< <":@D@FF46F8@(@ N"D"8H,D"».

G,, V@ J F8J$,>H" QJBD4>4 &4F:@&:,>@ @$,D,0>@, FHD4<">@ z FH@FJpH\Fb &48:`R>@*@ «+>,|*4», & 7J:zT" B,D,N@*4H\ J FBD"&0>z6 "8H @$&4>J&"R,>>b z B@T4D`pH\Fb >" &,F\:zH,D"HJD>46 >"$JH@8 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. =" B@(:b* 7J:zT", :zH,D"HJD>" *zb:\>zFH\7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ — @*>" 2 L@D< J8D"|>F\8@(@ D,>,h"HFH&". % J8D"|>F\8z< 04HHz 2"&0*4$@D@:4Fb *&z FH4Nz|: <zFH" H" T:bN,HF\8z <"pH84, V@ D"2-J-D"2 @*D4&":4Fb @* >"D@*>\@|@F>@&4, — z F,:" H" NJH@D4, V@ &zD>@ BD4 Hz6 @F>@&z 2@FH"&":4Fb z b8z 7J:zT >"24&"p«<4D@< F&,04<, B@:>Z< `>@T,F84N &,:48@*JT>ZN FHD,<:,>46 4 B@^H4R,F84N (D,2».

Az* HJ *@$J, 8@:4 7@H:bD,&F\846 &46T@& >" «:zH,D"HJD>J >4&J», H@$H@ & 8z>Pz XVIII— >" B@R"H8J XIX &z8J, &,DN4 J8D"|>F\8@(@ >"D@*J &z**z:4:4Fb @* BD@FH@(@ :`*J z b&:b:42D"284 ">H4>"D@*>\@(@ F<"8J z B@$JHJ, $@ >"$J&":4 >"D@*>zFH\ &,:48@D@Fz6F\8J,&,:48@D@Fz6F\8, 8J:\HJD>, @$:4RRb; >424, <"F4 :4T4:4Fb &zD>z FH"D@&4>z, ":, &HD"R":4F&z*@<zFH\, $,2F4:z $J:4 >" F&@|N D,R>48z& 2*@$JH4Fb. =,V"FHb 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & Hz<, V@&z> B@B:4& 2" H,Rzp` z & F&@|N H&@D"N &4F:@&4& H, BD,24DFH&@ 6 (:J<, 2 b84< &,DT84@*&,DH":4Fb @* >"D@*>\@(@ 04HHb. a8 :`*4>" H":">@&4H", 7@H:bD,&F\846 >, <z(2@FH"H4Fb F:zB4< *@ H4N F8"D$z&, b8z H"|& J F@$z :`*, ":,, >, <"`R4 2*z$>@FH,6(,>zb:\>4N, &z> >, B@*J0"& FH"H4 B@>"* B@>bHHb F&@(@ &z8J z *"H4 >"D@*>\@<JF&zH@(:b*@&z z >"D@*>\@<J B@$JH@&z BD"&*4&46, >, 8"D48"HJD>46 &4D"2. %z> 2 :,(84<F,DP,< BzT@& F:z*"<4 J8D"|>F\84N ">,8*@H4FHz&, b84N $"("H@ $J:@ & *&@Db>F\8@<J z>,*&@Db>F\8@<J H@&"D4FH&z. «GD@b>F846 (,D@6 & &4*, J8D"4>F8@(@ $D@*b(4 F<,T4:H@&"D4V,6 7@H:bD,&F8@(@ *@ F:,2, z DJ8@B4F\ ,(@ >"R":" N@*4H\ B@ DJ8"<. A@<,V484J8D"4>F84, D"FF<,b:4F\ >"* «]>,4*@6» >, NJ0, @L4P,D@&, D"FN@N@H":4F\ >"* >,6 4 4N:"8,4, J0, >, B@N@04, >" H,N, @H 8@(@ @>4 $Z:4 @H@D&">Z *&@D@&@6 042>\`... ?*>4BD@FH@:`*4>Z >, F<,b:4F\, — 4< $Z:@ >, *@ “]>,4*Z”». — %4F>@&84 7J:zT" *J0,FJ&@Dz. % <@&z 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ &z> $"R4H\ «8"$"P8J` D,R\», & «+>,|*z» — «$JD:"P8@,`D@*FH&@», & «="H":Pz-A@:H"&Pz» — "L,8H@&">@-L":\T4&J @B,D,HJ, &@8":\>z >J<,D4b8@| >,*":,8@ @*z6T:4 @* B,D,$z:\T,>@ F">H4<,>H":\>4N D@<">Fz& XVIII &. I7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >, $J:@ B@&"0">>b >z *@ F,$,, >z *@ >"D@*J, >z *@ >"D@*>\@| <@&4: «F"<"b<ZF:\ >"B4F"H\ B"D@*4` >" b2Z8, F&@,(@ >"D@*" B@8"2Z&",H @HFJHFH&4, J&"0,>4b 8^H@<J b2Z8J». y Hz:\84 & @*>@<J *@$"R"p 7J:zT BD"&@ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >" *,b8J Bz:\(J— & H@<J, V@ &z> F"< «F<JH>@ B@RJb: $,22"8@>4, F&@,(@ F<,N" 4 B@* 8@>,P F<,b:Fb J0,$,2 4F8D,>>@FH4».

Ez<*,FbHz-&zFz<*,FbHz D@84 — *@$" B,&>@| «D,"$z:zH"Pz|» 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & 8D4H4R>z6

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 48

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

:zH,D"HJDz. E`*4 FH@FJ`H\Fb: @Pz>8" 7@FH@<"D@&" & 6@(@ FH"HHz BD@ J8D"|>F\8J B@,2z`& ND,FH@<"Hz| g,D$,:b («A@^24b F:"&b>», 1871 D.), FH"HHb-B,D,*<@&" 7"HD">@&" *@&4*">>b 1874 D., «%z*R4H4 2 zFH@Dz| J8D"|>F\8@-DJF\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&"» ?. 7@T@&@(@ &2"8@D*@>>@<J «E&zHz», 1881, 1-2 (2 N"D"8H,D>@` @Pz>8@`, *zb<,HD":\>@ BD@H4:,0>@`BD4FJ*"< 7J:zT": «;4 >"B,D,* JF\@(@ & B4F">>bN 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ $"R4<@ 6@(@( : 4 $ @ 8 J F 8 @ D $ BD@ >"D@*>` >,*@:`») z >"D,THz FH"HHb =. ;. %. (&z*@<@(@D@Fz6F\8@(@ B@,H" 5. ;. ;z>F\8@(@) & «=@&4» 2" 1885 D. — ="&zH\ 7J:zT J P` B@DJ&z*N@*4H\ @* F&@(@ *"&>zT@(@ B@(:b*J z & B,D,*<@&z *@ F&@p| «MJH@D>@| B@,2z|» (9\&z&,1882) &42>"p 2" H&@D"<4 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ B,&>, NJ*@0>p z >"&zH\ (D@<"*F\8, 2>"R,>>b:«% >z6 B@$"R4:4 2,<:b84 F&@p B@FBz:\FH&@, B@$"R4:4 N@R 2 &4&@D@HJ, H" &F, 0 H"84 >,F:zBJ`R4, b8 F:zBJ&":4, 2"N4:4&T4F\ *@ RJ0@<@&>@| 8>4084». U@*@ F&z*@<@FH47@H:bD,&F\8@(@ 7J:zT 2@FH"pH\Fb *"&>zT@| *J<84: «7@H:bD,&F\846 B@8@Db&F\>,*@&z*@<@<J &,:z>>` >"D@*>\@(@ *JN", $J& Hz:\84 F:zB4< 2>"Db**b< J8D"|>F\8@(@F&zH@(:b*J» z H@<J «F"< >, 2>"& *@$D,, V@ &z> D@$4H\».

% >"J8@&@-8D4H4R>z6 :zH,D"HJDz 90-N DD. — & 2"(":\>4N @(:b*"N z FB,Pzb:\>4ND@2&z*8"N — D@2B@R4>"pH\Fb J0, *,H":\>, &4&R,>>b :zH,D"HJD>4N *0,D,:7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ (;. A. )"T8,&4R: 7 &@BD@FJ @ :4H,D"HJD>@< 4FH@R>48, «;@F8":b-Q"Dz&>48"», ;":@DJFF8"b 4 *DJ(4, $JD:,F8>Z, «]>,4*Z» — «74,&F8"b EH"D4>"», 1893,XII z 1898, IX).

1 2"(":\>4N B4H">\ >"J8@&4N *@F:z*>48z& Pz8"&4H\ >"6$z:\T, @*>@: @F8z:\84@D(">zR>@` :">8@` &N@*4H\ 7@H:bD,&F\846, b8 "&H@D «+>,|*4», & D@2&4H@8 J8D"|>F\8@(@B4F\<,>FH&" z R4 >, & HzF>zT@<J 2&’b28J FH@|H\ &z> 2 FJR"F>4< 6@<J D@Fz6F\84<:zH,D"HJD>4< DJN@<. O\@<J B4H">>` A. /4H,P\846 BD4F&bH4& FB,Pzb:\>J BD"P`:«]>,4*" 7@H:bD,&F8@(@ 4 *D,&>,6T46 ,, FB4F@8 & F&b24 F @$V4< @$2@D@< <":@DJFF8@6:4H,D"HJDZ XVIII &,8"», 74,&, 1900 (J8D"|>F\846 B,D,8:"* — 74|&, 1919). %FJB,D,RB@B,D,*>48"<, A,HD@&J H" )"T8,&4RJ, /4H,P\846 BD@$Jp *@&,FH4, V@ «+>,|*"»7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ &4D@F:" $,2B@F,D,*>\@ 2 J8D"|>F\8@| HD"*4Pz| XVIII &. 1 Pzp` <,H@` &z>Bz*8D,F:`p @*<z>4 & H@>z 6 &48@>">>z & ?FzB@&" z 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ z D@2(:b*"p «+>,|*J»@FH">>\@(@ b8 @F@$:4&46, F&@pDz*>46 H4B HD"&,FHz|. A@,<" ?FzB@&", >" 6@(@ *J<8J, pB"D@*zb «&48:`R>@ :zH,D"HJD>"»; || D@:b — *4F8D,*4HJ&"H4 FH"D46 >"$D4*:46:zH,D"HJD>46 >"BDb<@8, — H4< R"F@< b8 7@H:bD,&F\846 «>, <"p 0"*>@(@ >"<zDJ&HDJR"H4Fb & $@D@H\$J 2 BF,&*@8:bF4R>4< >"BDb<8@<, $@D@H\$J, V@ 8z>,P\ XVIIIFH@:zHHb &4>48:" & <@F8@&F\8z6 :zH,D"HJDz, — H"8 F"<@ &zDTz-B"D@*z|, V@ 8@D4FHJ&":4Fb$z$:z6>4<4 H" p&">(,:\F\84<4 @B@&z*">>b<4, 2@&Fz< >, <":4 >" J&"2z Bz*8@BJ&"H4F\ Bz*|N "&H@D4H,H». «1 P\@(@ B@(:b*J +>,|*" 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ p @D(">zR>, BD@*@&0,>>b<zFP,&4N &zDTz&, >" b8z $"("H" $J:" J8D"|>F\8" :zH,D"HJD" & XVIII FH@:zHHz».

1 Bz2>zT4N FH"HH,6 >"6&"0:4&zTz *&z, *zb<,HD":\>@ BD@H4:,0>z &4F>@&8"<4:«7@H:bD,&F\846» E. ?. mLp,<@&", B,D,*>p F:@&@ *@ &4*">>b «%z8J», z «y&">7@H:bD,&F\846 & F&zH:z FJR"F>@(@ 6@<J D@Fz6F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&"» ;. m&T">" (K,*`T84)— & «E$@D>48, M"D\8@&F8@(@ 3FH@D48@-L4:@:@(4R,F8@(@ ?-&"», H. XX. mLD,<@& B@*z:bp2 /4H,P\84< 6@(@ B,D,8@>">>b, V@ 7@H:bD,&F\846 «<zP>4< 8@Dz>>b< *,D04H\Fb» &J8D"|>F\8@<J <4>J:@<J, V@ B@B,D,*>484 6@(@ «+>,|*4» — P, z>H,D<,*z| H" z>H,D:`*z|,

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 49

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

&,DH,B H" H&@DRzFH\ >,&z*@<4N >" 6<,>>b <">*D@&">4N *b8z&, «J8D"|>F\84N $"D*z&, V@,`D@*FH&J`R4, >,F&z*@<@ D@$4:4 &,:48@| &"(4 *z:@, 8:"*JR4 B,DTz Bz*&":4>4 >"D@*>\@(@B4F\<,>FH&"». ;. m&T">, >"&B"84, B,&,>, V@ :zH,D"HJD>" *zb:\>zFH\ 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ p:4T, &z*(J8 FJR"F>@(@ 6@<J D@Fz6F\8@(@ :zH,D"HJD>@(@ 04HHb 2 JFz<" N"D"8H,D>4<4 *:b@FH">>\@(@ B@(:b*"<4 H" 2"F@$"<4.

=" FH"HHz mLD,<@&" :,04H\ &4D"2>" B,R"H\ H@(@ 2"(":\>@(@ B@(:b*J, b84< B,D,6>bH"6@(@ &,:48" zFH@Dzb B4F\<,>FH&": *:b >\@(@ &F, >@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ <"p @*>@@$:4RRb — &42&@:\>,, >"D@*@:`$>,, *,<@8D"H4R>,, " J8D"|>F\846 B4F\<,>>48 2">,R4F:,>>4<4 &4|<8"<4 B@&H@D`p @*4> z H@6 F"<46 H4B (J<">zFH"-*,<@8D"H". O,6B@(:b* 2"H4D"p B,&>z (D">4Pz <z0 BF4N@:@(zp` B@8@:z>\ z B@FH"Hz 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@,«z>H,:z(,>H" F & @ | N R"Fz&, F8@&@D@*4>Pb z <"F@>"», >"*"p D4F J8D"|>F\8@(@z>H,:zh,>H" 90-900-N DD. % @F&zH:,>>z E. ?. mLD,<@&" 7@H:bD,&F\846 >, Hz:\84 F&z*@<@BD4FHJB"p *@ F&@p| :zH,D"HJD>@| BD"Pz, ":, 6 L@D<@` F&@p| F&z*@<@FH4 >"$:40"pH\Fb *@>"F. 5@(@ <,H@` >z$4H@ $J:@ B@FH"&4H4 B,D,* «D"&>@*JT>Z, @R4» (zD8, >"D@*>, 04HHbFB@>,&"0,>@(@ J8D"|>F\8@(@ «F<,D*"»; 6@(@ LD"24 BD@ 8@:`RJ <J04P\8J BD"&*J z >" &Fz$@84 (>JRJ B">F\8J $J:4 >, BD@FH@ FH4:z2"Pzp` Bz* >"D@*>z BD4B@&z*84, b8z 6@<J*@&@*4:@Fb RJH4 >" F,:z, ":, $,2B,D,R>4< (@:@F@< 6@(@ FBD"&0>\@(@ B,D,8@>">>b; 6@(@&4N&"H84 BD@H4 FH"D4N <J2, BD@H4 FH"D4N B">b>@8:

a <J2J 8:4RJ >, H"8J`, %,F,:J, ("D>J, <@:@*J`:EH"D4N >,N"6 $D48" A,("F —

H"bH\ J F@$z >"Hb8 >" «z*,` @>@&:,>>b», 2 b8@` &z> «2"N@*0J&"&Fb 8@:@ :zH,D"HJD>@|>4&4», " 6@(@ 8"DH4>4 «"$F@:`H4FH4R>@-$`D@8D"H4R>@(@ ?:z<BJ» H" 2,<>4N B":"Pz&b&:b`H\ F@$@` (@FHDJ F"H4DJ >" H@(@R"F>46 F@Pzb:\>@-B@:zH4R>46 :"*. — ! & m&T">"?% m&T">" 7@H:bD,&F\846 :`*4>", V@ &4D@F:" & B@>bHHbN XVIII &., 2 6@(@ B@(@D*@` *@>"D@*J; :`*4>" 2 &J2\84< F&zH@(:b*@< z FJH@ @LzP,DF\84< FH"&:,>>b< *@ «H"84N D,R,6,b8 R,FH\, <@D":\ H" z>T,». 'D@<"*F\8@| F"H4D4 & «+>,|*z» &z> >, $"R4H\ z Hz>z. a8 >"2&"H4F"H4D48@< B4F\<,>>48", b846 >, <"p, & JFb8z< D"2z >, &<zp «B@8"2"H4 FJFBz:\>@FHz F&@|Nz*,":z&», b846 F"< D@28@TJp 2 F&@|N «$D4*84N H" FH4*84N FP,>» z «& $@D@H\$z 2>,<@D":\>zFH` b&:bpH\Fb 2">"*H@ JFHJBR4&4<»? A"HDz@H42<J H" >"Pz@>":\>@| F&z*@<@FH47@H:bD,&F\8@(@ m&T"> H"8 F"<@ >, $,D, B@&"0>@. 7@:4 $ B@,H $J& B"HDz@H@< "$@ <"&04&, B@RJHHb HD"*4Pz|, H@ >, 8"2"& $4 BD@ EzR, V@ H"< «&*,>\ B’b>z FB:bH\ z 8D"*JH\&>zR», >, >"24&"& $4 T&,*z& BD4 2("*Pz BD@ A@:H"&F\8J $4H&J «BD@R&"D"<4». y *":z &<@:@*,Rz< 2"N&"Hz 8D4H48 B@&,DH"p *@ 7J:zT" z B@&H@D`p 6@(@ *"&>p H&,D*0,>>b, V@7@H:bD,&F\846 H&@D4& >,F&z*@<@. «U@ >"*"p H"8@(@ 2>"R,>>b H&@D@&z 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@,V@ &z> &48:48"& >@&J ,B@NJ & J8D"|>F\8z6 :zH,D"HJDz? =@&4N z*,6 &z> >, <"& — :4T Hz,b8z $J:4 JH,DHz, >, $J& &z> 0"*>4< *@D@(@&8"2@< >" $J*JR>zFH\... ;@&" 6@(@ D@$4:">@&4<, F:@&@!» !:, … «F"< 7@H:bD,&F\846 >, $J& F & z * @ < 4 6 & , : 4 R 4 > 4H @ ( @ z F H @ D 4 R > @ ( @ L " 8 H J , z F8"0,<@, V@ >, 7@H:bD,&F\846 &@F8D,F4&

;48@:" 1,D@&. =@&, J8D"|>F\8, B4F\<,>FH&@ 50

+:,8HD@>>" $z$:z@H,8" J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4

J8D"|>F\8, F:@&@ ($@ &@>@ 04:@ & >"D@*z), — " F:@&@ Pz:@(@ J8D"|>F\8@(@ >"D@*J &4>,F:@7@H:bD,&F\8@(@». G"8z & 8@D@H8@<J &48:"*z (@:@&>z 8D4H4R>z @Pz>84 :zH,D"HJD>@(@>"*$">>b 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@. a8 $"R4<@, &Fz &@>4 8DJ0"H\ 8@:@ HD\@N @F>@&>4N B4H">\: 1)b8, FH">@&4V, 2"6<"p 7@H:bD,&F\846 FJBD@H4 J8D"|>F\8@| HD"*4Pz| XVIII &. z FJR"F>@(@6@<J D@Fz6F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&", 2) @F8z:\84 &z> p (D@<"*F\84< F"H4D48@<, " 6@(@ «+>,|*"»B@&"0>4<, hDJ>H@&>@ 2"*J<">4< B@$JH@@B4F@&4< H&@D@< z 3) @F8z:\84 F"<7@H:bD,&F\846 $J& F&z*@<46 FBD"&0>\@| &"(4 D@2B@R"H@| >4< BD"Pz. %z*B@&z*z, b8z *"`H\>" Pz B4H">>b @8D,<z "&H@D4, D@2$4&"`H\ |N >" *&z D@2$z0>z H,Rz|: @*>" Bz*>@F4H\7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ b8 &,:48@(@ NJ*@0>48" F:@&" z *@$"R"p & >\@<J F&z*@<@(@ F&@p| <,H4F"H4D48" z @>@&4H,:b J8D"|>F\8@| :zH,D"HJD4 — z*, &@>" @* 7@FH@<"D@&", B@6<"p7@T@&@(@ H" /4H,P\8@(@, " >"68D"F>@<@&>zT46 &4D"2 2>"N@*4H\ J E. ?. mLD,<@&";*DJ(" >"<"("pH\Fb J<":4H4 B4F\<,>>4P\846 N4FH 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@, $,D, Bz* FJ<>z& 6@(@J8D"|>F\8J F&z*@<zFH\ :zH,D"H" z (D@<"*b>4>", *@$"R"p & 6@(@ H&@DR@FHz 2"Bz2>,>46 &z*(J8D@Fz6F\8@(@ :zH,D"HJD>@(@ 04HHb — Pb H,Rzb, V@ B:4>, &z* S,&R,>8z&F\8@|N"D"8H,D4FH484 «+>,|*4», b8 «F<zN@&4>4 >" <@F8@&F\846 8TH":H», B">Jp & J8D"|>F\8z68D4H4Pz 2 7J:zT,&4<4 FH"HHb<4 & 60-N DD., " D. 1909 *"p F,$, 2>"H4 Dz28@` FH"HH,` ;.m&T">".

U@*@ BD"P\ $z@(D"LzR>@(@ 2<zFHJ, H@ |N *J0, >,$"("H@: 04HHb 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ V,&4<"("p B4:\>4N FHJ*z6 — BD"Pb y. ;. EH,T,>8" — «3. A. 7@H:bD,&F846 , "&H@DJ8D"4>F8@6 ]>,4*Z», 74,&, 1902, N@R" 6 <"p Bz*H4HJ:\>J 8&":zLz8"Pz` «8D4H4R,F8"b$4@(D"L4b», ":, <zFH4H\ J F@$z *@F4H\ >,B,D,&zD,>4N *">4N z b&>4N &4("*@8 (>"BD., 2B@&>@` &zD@` B,D,8"2">J ">,8*@HJ BD@ 2JFHDzR 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ 2 8@2"8"<4, V@,*z2>"&T4Fb BD@ 6@(@ "&H@DFH&@ «+>,|*4», 2"BD@TJ`H\ 6@(@ *@ F,$, 2" FH"DT@(@).Oz8"&46 B@DHD,H 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ >" H:z zFH@D4R>4N @$FH"&4> *"p ?. a. mL4<,>8@(+L4<,>8@ !., 7@H:bD,&F846 & 4FH@D4R,F8@6 @$FH">@&8,», 2$zD>48 «_0>"b CJF\», 1905,H. II). 7@H:bD,&F\8@(@ & @$FH">@&z B@$JH@&z6 <":``H\ "DH4FH4R>z ,H`*4 '@D:,>8",«%@FB@<4>">4b» EH,$:4>"-7"<,>F\8@(@ (A@:H"&", 1883) H" *@8J<,>H4 y. K.A"&:@&F\8@(@ — & 8>42z «A@:H"&"», 4FH@D4R,F846 @R,D8... 1802 — 1856 DD. (A@:H"&",1910).

9zH,D"HJDJ *@ @8D,<4N B4H">\ *4&. J &,:48z6 «yFH@Dz| J8D"|>F\8@(@ B4F\<,>FH&"» E.?. mLD,<@&" H" & $z$:z@(D"LzR>z< B@8"2>48J 7@<"D@&" 2 mLD,<@&F\84< *@*"H8@<.

II K@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z*">z . 7@H:bD,&F\846z?FzB ...

Documents

Transcript of II K@H:bD,&F\846. #z@(D"LzR>z*">z . 7@H:bD,&F\846z?FzB ...