IEEE Standards - draft standard template · Web viewAs defined in IEEE Std. C37.93 and IEEE Std....
Transcript of IEEE Standards - draft standard template · Web viewAs defined in IEEE Std. C37.93 and IEEE Std....
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
P525tradeD2Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Sponsor
Substations Committeeof theIEEE Power and Energy Society
Approved ltDate Approvedgt
IEEE-SA Standards Board
Copyright copy 2013 by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers IncThree Park AvenueNew York New York 10016-5997 USA
All rights reserved
This document is an unapproved draft of a proposed IEEE Standard As such this document is subject to change USE AT YOUR OWN RISK Because this is an unapproved draft this document must not be utilized for any conformancecompliance purposes Permission is hereby granted for IEEE Standards Committee participants to reproduce this document for purposes of standardization consideration Prior to adoption of this document in whole or in part by another standards development organization permission must first be obtained from the IEEE Standards Activities Department (stdsiprieeeorg) Other entities seeking permission to reproduce this document in whole or in part must also obtain permission from the IEEE Standards Activities Department
IEEE Standards Activities Department445 Hoes LanePiscataway NJ 08854 USA
1
2
3
4
56789
101112131415161718
19
2021222324252627
282930
31
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Abstract The design installation and protection of wire and cable systems in substations are covered in this guide with the objective of minimizing cable failures and their consequencesKeywords acceptance testing cable cable installation cable selection communication cable electrical segregation fiber-optic cable handling power cable pulling tension raceway recommended maintenance routing separation of redundant cable service conditions substation transient protection
123456
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Notice and Disclaimer of Liability Concerning the Use of IEEE Documents IEEE Standards documents are developed within the IEEE Societies and the Standards Coordinating Committees of the IEEE Standards Association (IEEE-SA) Standards Board IEEE develops its standards through a consensus development process approved by the American National Standards Institute which brings together volunteers representing varied viewpoints and interests to achieve the final product Volunteers are not necessarily members of the Institute and serve without compensation While IEEE administers the process and establishes rules to promote fairness in the consensus development process IEEE does not independently evaluate test or verify the accuracy of any of the information or the soundness of any judgments contained in its standards
Use of an IEEE Standard is wholly voluntary IEEE disclaims liability for any personal injury property or other damage of any nature whatsoever whether special indirect consequential or compensatory directly or indirectly resulting from the publication use of or reliance upon any IEEE Standard document
IEEE does not warrant or represent the accuracy or content of the material contained in its standards and expressly disclaims any express or implied warranty including any implied warranty of merchantability or fitness for a specific purpose or that the use of the material contained in its standards is free from patent infringement IEEE Standards documents are supplied AS IS
The existence of an IEEE Standard does not imply that there are no other ways to produce test measure purchase market or provide other goods and services related to the scope of the IEEE standard Furthermore the viewpoint expressed at the time a standard is approved and issued is subject to change brought about through developments in the state of the art and comments received from users of the standard Every IEEE standard is subjected to review at least every ten years When a document is more than ten years old and has not undergone a revision process it is reasonable to conclude that its contents although still of some value do not wholly reflect the present state of the art Users are cautioned to check to determine that they have the latest edition of any IEEE standard
In publishing and making its standards available IEEE is not suggesting or rendering professional or other services for or on behalf of any person or entity Nor is IEEE undertaking to perform any duty owed by any other person or entity to another Any person utilizing any IEEE Standards document should rely upon his or her own independent judgment in the exercise of reasonable care in any given circumstances or as appropriate seek the advice of a competent professional in determining the appropriateness of a given IEEE standard
Translations The IEEE consensus development process involves the review of documents in English only In the event that an IEEE standard is translated only the English version published by IEEE should be considered the approved IEEE standard
Official Statements A statement written or oral that is not processed in accordance with the IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual shall not be considered the official position of IEEE or any of its committees and shall not be considered to be nor be relied upon as a formal position of IEEE At lectures symposia seminars or educational courses an individual presenting information on IEEE standards shall make it clear that his or her views should be considered the personal views of that individual rather than the formal position of IEEE
Comments on Standards Comments for revision of IEEE Standards documents are welcome from any interested party regardless of membership affiliation with IEEE However IEEE does not provide consulting information or advice pertaining to IEEE Standards documents Suggestions for changes in documents should be in the form of a proposed change of text together with appropriate supporting comments Since IEEE standards represent a consensus of concerned interests it is important to ensure that any responses to comments and questions also receive the concurrence of a balance of interests For this reason IEEE and the members of its societies and Standards Coordinating Committees are not able to provide an instant response to comments or questions except in those cases where the matter has previously been addressed Any person who would like to participate in evaluating comments or revisions to an IEEE standard is welcome to join the relevant IEEE working group at httpstandardsieeeorgdevelopwg
Comments on standards should be submitted to the following address
Secretary IEEE-SA Standards Board445 Hoes LanePiscataway NJ 08854USA
Photocopies Authorization to photocopy portions of any individual standard for internal or personal use is granted by The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc provided that the appropriate fee is paid to Copyright Clearance Center To arrange for payment of licensing fee please contact Copyright Clearance Center Customer Service 222 Rosewood Drive Danvers MA 01923 USA +1 978 750 8400 Permission to photocopy portions of any individual standard for educational classroom use can also be obtained through the Copyright Clearance Center
1234567
89
10
11121314
15161718192021
2223242526
2728
2930313233
343536373839404142
43
44454647
4849505152
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Notice to users
Laws and regulations
Users of IEEE Standards documents should consult all applicable laws and regulations Compliance with the provisions of any IEEE Standards document does not imply compliance to any applicable regulatory requirements Implementers of the standard are responsible for observing or referring to the applicable regulatory requirements IEEE does not by the publication of its standards intend to urge action that is not in compliance with applicable laws and these documents may not be construed as doing so
Copyrights
This document is copyrighted by the IEEE It is made available for a wide variety of both public and private uses These include both use by reference in laws and regulations and use in private self-regulation standardization and the promotion of engineering practices and methods By making this document available for use and adoption by public authorities and private users the IEEE does not waive any rights in copyright to this document
Updating of IEEE documents
Users of IEEE Standards documents should be aware that these documents may be superseded at any time by the issuance of new editions or may be amended from time to time through the issuance of amendments corrigenda or errata An official IEEE document at any point in time consists of the current edition of the document together with any amendments corrigenda or errata then in effect In order to determine whether a given document is the current edition and whether it has been amended through the issuance of amendments corrigenda or errata visit the IEEE-SA Website at httpstandardsieeeorgindexhtml or contact the IEEE at the address listed previously For more information about the IEEE Standards Association or the IEEE standards development process visit IEEE-SA Website at httpstandardsieeeorgindexhtml
Errata
Errata if any for this and all other standards can be accessed at the following URL httpstandardsieeeorgfindstdserrataindexhtml Users are encouraged to check this URL for errata periodically
Patents
Attention is called to the possibility that implementation of this standard may require use of subject matter covered by patent rights By publication of this standard no position is taken by the IEEE with respect to the existence or validity of any patent rights in connection therewith If a patent holder or patent applicant has filed a statement of assurance via an Accepted Letter of Assurance then the statement is listed on the IEEE-SA Website at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcompatentshtml Letters of Assurance may indicate whether the Submitter is willing or unwilling to grant licenses under patent rights without compensation or under reasonable rates with reasonable terms and conditions that are demonstrably free of any unfair discrimination to applicants desiring to obtain such licenses
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
iv
1
2
34567
8
910111213
14
151617181920212223
24
252627
28
2930313233343536
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Essential Patent Claims may exist for which a Letter of Assurance has not been received The IEEE is not responsible for identifying Essential Patent Claims for which a license may be required for conducting inquiries into the legal validity or scope of Patents Claims or determining whether any licensing terms or conditions provided in connection with submission of a Letter of Assurance if any or in any licensing agreements are reasonable or non-discriminatory Users of this standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any patent rights and the risk of infringement of such rights is entirely their own responsibility Further information may be obtained from the IEEE Standards Association
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
v
1234567
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Participants
At the time this draft Guide was completed the D2 Working Group had the following membership
Debra Longtin ChairSteve Shelton Vice Chair
Participant1Participant2Participant3
Participant4Participant5Participant6
Participant7Participant8Participant9
The following members of the ltindividualentitygt balloting committee voted on this Guide Balloters may have voted for approval disapproval or abstention
[To be supplied by IEEE]
Balloter1Balloter2Balloter3
Balloter4Balloter5Balloter6
Balloter7Balloter8Balloter9
When the IEEE-SA Standards Board approved this Guide on ltDate Approvedgt it had the following membership
[To be supplied by IEEE]
ltNamegt ChairltNamegt Vice ChairltNamegt Past ChairltNamegt Secretary
SBMember1SBMember2SBMember3
SBMember4SBMember5SBMember6
SBMember7SBMember8SBMember9
Member Emeritus
Also included are the following nonvoting IEEE-SA Standards Board liaisons
ltNamegt DOE RepresentativeltNamegt NIST Representative
ltNamegtIEEE Standards Program Manager Document Development
ltNamegtIEEE Standards Program Manager Technical Program Development
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
vi
1
2
34
5678
91011
121314
15
1617
18
192021
222324
252627
28
2930
31
32333435
363738
394041
424344
4546
47
4849505152535455
56
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Introduction
This introduction is not part of P525D2 Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
This revision of the guide makes the following changes
a) Annex P was added to describe a large station example
b) The communications cable information was expanded throughout the document
c) Miscellaneous updates were made throughout the document
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
vii
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Contents
1 Overview111 Scope112 Purpose2
2 Normative references2
3 Definitions2
4 Control and instrumentation cable341 General342 Service conditions (see Annex B)443 Cable selection (see Annex C)444 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)745 Routing (see Annex F)746 Transient protection (see Annex G)847 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)848 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)949 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)9410 Handling (see Annex K)9411 Installation (see Annex L)9412 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)9413 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)9
5 Metallic Communication cables951 General952 Service conditions2053 Metallic cable selection2154 Cable system design2255 Transient protection2356 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)2557 Handling2658 Installation (see Annex L)2659 Acceptance testing27510 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)28
6 Fiber-optic cable2861 General2962 Service conditions3863 Cable selection3964 Cable system design4165 Transient protection4566 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)4667 Handling (see Annex K)4768 Installation (see Annex L)4769 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)48610 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)49
7 Power cable (ac and dc lt= 1 kV)4971 Service conditions (see Annex B)4972 Cable selection (see Annex C)4973 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)50
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
viii
1
234
5
6
789
1011121314151617181920
2122232425262728293031
3233343536373839404142
43444546
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
74 Routing (see Annex F)5075 Transient protection (see Annex G)5076 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)5077 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)5078 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)5079 Handling (see Annex K)50710 Installation (see Annex L)50711 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)51712 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)51
8 Power cable (1 kV to 35 kV)5181 Service conditions (see Annex B)5182 Cable selection (see Annex C)5183 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)5284 Routing (see Annex F)5285 Transient protection (see Annex G)5286 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)5387 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)5388 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)5389 Handling (see Annex K)53810 Installation (see Annex L)53811 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)53812 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)53
Annex A (informative) Flowchart54
Annex B (normative) Service conditions for cables55
Annex C (normative) Control and power cable selection63C1 Conductor63C2 Ampacity65C3 Voltage drop66C4 Short-circuit capability74C5 Insulation75C6 Jacket76C7 Attenuation76C8 Cable capacitance77
Annex D (informative) Design checklist for copper communication cables entering a substation78D1 Pre-design78D2 Communications requirements78D3 Cable protection requirements79D4 Site conditions79D5 Interface with telephone companyservice provider79D6 Cost considerations80D7 Communications system design80
Annex E (normative) Cable raceway design81E1 Raceway fill and determining raceway sizes81E2 Conduit82E3 Cable tray85E4 Cable tray installation87E5 Wireways88E6 Direct burial tunnels and trenches88
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
ix
123456789
10111213141516171819202122
23
24
252627282930313233
3435363738394041
42434445464748
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex F (normative) Routing91F1 Length91F2 Turns91F3 Physical location and grouping91F4 Fire impact92
Annex G (normative) Transient protection of instrumentation control and power cable93G1 Origin of transients in substations93G2 Protection measuresmdashGeneral considerations95G3 Protection measuresmdashspecial circuits99
Annex H (normative) Electrical segregation104
Annex I (normative) Separation of redundant cables105I1 Redundant cable systems105I2 Design considerations105I3 Separation105
Annex J (normative) Cable pulling tension calculations107J1 Cable pulling design limits and calculations107J2 Design limits107J3 Cable-pulling calculations110J4 Sample calculation113
Annex K (normative) Handling118K1 Storage118K2 Protection of cable118
Annex L (normative) Installation119L1 Installation119L2 Supporting cables in vertical runs121L3 Securing cables in vertical runs121L4 Training cables121L5 Cable conductor terminations121
Annex M (normative) Acceptance testing123M1 Purpose123M2 Tests123
Annex N (normative) Recommended maintenance and inspection125N1 General125N2 Inspections125N3 Testing methods for metallic cables126N4 Maintenance126
Annex O (informative) Example for small substation128O1 General128O2 Design parameters128O3 Select cables construction130O4 Determine raceway routing131O5 Cable sizing134O6 Design cable raceway155
Annex P (informative) Example for large substation162P1 General162
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
x
12345
6789
10
11121314
1516171819
202122
232425262728
293031
3233343536
37383940414243
4445
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
P2 Design parameters162P3 Select cables construction166P4 Determine raceway routing169P5 Cable sizing176P6 Design cable raceway203
Annex Q (informative) Bibliography219
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
xi
12345
67
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
IMPORTANT NOTICE IEEE Standards documents are not intended to ensure safety health or environmental protection or ensure against interference with or from other devices or networks Implementers of IEEE Standards documents are responsible for determining and complying with all appropriate safety security environmental health and interference protection practices and all applicable laws and regulations
This IEEE document is made available for use subject to important notices and legal disclaimers These notices and disclaimers appear in all publications containing this document and may be found under the heading ldquoImportant Noticerdquo or ldquoImportant Notices and Disclaimers Concerning IEEE Documentsrdquo They can also be obtained on request from IEEE or viewed at httpstandardsieeeorgIPRdisclaimershtml
1 Overview
The main clauses of the guide are organized by cable type and each of these clauses has been organized to match the general steps involved in the design process for a substation cable system (see Annex A for a flowchart diagram) Common information for each type of cable is placed in the annexes and is referenced from the body of the guide The rationale for organizing the guide in this manner is to make it easier for the user to find the information needed as quickly and efficiently as possible especially for those individuals unfamiliar with the design of cable systems in substations
11 Scope
This document is a guide for the design installation and protection of insulated wire and cable systems in substations with the objective of minimizing cable failures and their consequences This guide is not an industry standard or a compliance standard
12 Purpose
The purpose of this guide is to provide guidance to the substation engineer in established practices for the application and installation of metallic and optical cables in electric power transmission and distribution
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
1
1
2
3
45678
910111213
14
151617181920
21
222324
25
2627
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
substations with the objective of minimizing premature cable failures and their consequences This guide emphasizes reliable electrical service and safety during the design life of the substation
Regarding cable performance no single cable characteristic should be emphasized to the serious detriment of others In addition to good installation design and construction practices a balance of cable characteristics is necessary to provide a reliable cable system
Solutions presented in this guide may not represent the only acceptable practices for resolving problems
This guide should not be referred to or used as an industry standard It is being presented to aid in the development of wire and cable system installations and is not a compliance standard
2 Normative references
The following referenced documents are indispensable for the application of this document (ie they must be understood and used so each referenced document is cited in text and its relationship to this document is explained) For dated references only the edition cited applies For undated references the latest edition of the referenced document (including any amendments or corrigenda) applies
Accredited Standards Committee C2-2002 National Electrical Safety Codereg (NESCreg)1 2
IEEE Std 575 IEEE Guide for the Application of Sheath-Bonding Methods for Single-Conductor Cables and the Calculation of Induced Voltages and Currents in Cable Sheaths3 4
IEEE Std 835 IEEE Standard Power Cable Ampacity Tables
3 Definitions acronyms and abbreviations
For the purposes of this document the following terms and definitions apply The IEEE Standards Dictionary Online should be consulted for terms not defined in this clause 0
ABS Conduit fabricated from acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene
ADSS All dielectric self supporting
Design life of the substation The time during which satisfactory substation performance can be expected for a specific set of service conditions based upon component selection and applications
EPC-40 Electrical plastic conduit for type DB applications fabricated from PE or for type DB and Schedule 40 applications fabricated from PVC
EPC-80 Electrical plastic conduit for Schedule 80 applications fabricated from PVC
EPT Electrical plastic tubing for type EB applications fabricated from PVC
FRE Conduit fabricated from fiberglass reinforced epoxy
IED Intelligent electronic device
0IEEE Standards Dictionary Online subscription is available athttpwwwieeeorgportalinnovateproductsstandardstandards_dictionaryhtml
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
2
12
345
6
78
9
10111213
14
1516
17
18
1920
21
22
2324
2526
27
28
29
30
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
IMC Intermediate metal conduit
IRIG-B Inter-range instrumentation groupmdashtime code format B a serial time code format to correlate data with time
OPGW Optical power ground wire or optical ground wire
RMC Rigid metal conduit
ROW Right-of-way a leased or purchased corridor for utility lines
Schedule 40 Duct designed for normal-duty applications above grade
Schedule 80 Duct designed for heavy-duty applications above grade
Service life of cable The time during which satisfactory cable performance can be expected for a specific set of service conditions
STP Shielded twisted pair
Type DB Duct designed for underground installation without encasement in concrete
Type EB Duct designed to be encased in concrete
UTP Unshielded twisted pair
4 Control and instrumentation cable
41 General
Substation control cables are multiconductor cables used to transmit electrical signals with low voltage levels (less than 600 V) and relatively low current levels between apparatus [eg power transformers circuit breakers disconnect switches and voltage or current transformers (CTs) etc] and protection control and monitoring devices (eg relays and control switches status lights alarms annunciators etc) Substation control signals may be digital or analog [eg voltage transformer (VT) and CT signals] and the control signal may be continuous or intermittent Control signals may be ldquoonrdquo or ldquooffrdquo with short or long time delays between a change of state
The complete substation control cable assembly must provide reliable service when installed in equipment control cabinets conduits cable trenches cable trays or other raceway systems in the electric substation environment
Instrumentation cables are multiconductor cables used to transmit low-energy (power-limited) electrical signals with low voltage levels (typically less than 130 V) and relatively low current levels between equipment (usually electronic such as monitors and analyzers) and control equipment for apparatus Signals in instrumentation cables could be continuous or intermittent depending on application
As used in this guide instrumentation cables consist of cables transmitting coded information (digital or analog) for Supervisory Controls and Data Acquisition (SCADA) systems substation networks event recorders and thermocouple and resistance temperature detector cables
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
3
1
23
4
5
6
7
8
910
11
12
13
14
15
16
17181920212223
242526
27282930
313233
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
In the United States cables are usually designed and constructed in accordance with NEMA WC 57ICEA S-73-532 [B96]
As used in this guide leads from CTs and VTs are considered control cables since in most cases they are used in relay protection circuits
42 Service conditions (see Annex B)
43 Cable selection (see Annex C)
431 Conductor sizingThe function and location of the control and instrumentation cable circuits affect the conductor size A conductor that is used to connect the CT secondary leads may have different requirements than a cable that is used for the VT secondary leads Outdoor control cables may require larger conductor size to compensate for voltage drop due to the relatively long distance between the equipment and the control house especially for high-voltage and extra-high-voltage (EHV) substations Smaller size control cables can be used inside the control building due to the short runs between the panels
Because of new designs using microprocessor relays and programmable logic devices there has been a general trend to increase the number of wire terminals on individual panel segments and or racks This trend is limited by the practicality of decreasing terminal block and test switch size in order to accommodate the additional terminals Decreasing terminal size creates a practical limit of maximum wire size However violation of minimum wire size requirements could cause voltage drop that results in a failure to trip or current overload that damages the cable Consideration should also be given for minimum sizing for mechanical strength
4311 CT circuitsA multiconductor control cable is typically used for a CT secondary circuit which contains all three phases (or one phase only for a single phase CT circuit) and the neutral The CT cable conductor should be sized such that the CT standard burden is not exceeded The CT cable conductor should also be sized to carry the CT continuous thermal rating (eg 10 A 15A) and up to 20 times its normal load current from 01 s to 05 s during a fault (IEEE Std C57133-1983 [B75])
Excessive impedance in CT secondary circuits can result in CT saturation The loop lead resistance of a CT secondary should not exceed the required maximums for relay instrument and revenue metering circuits Long cable runs such as those found in large transmission stations can lead to increased impedance values Methods to reduce impedance of the CT secondary circuit include increasing the conductor size and though not preferred running parallel conductors The physical parameters of the termination points should be considered when utilizing large andor multiple conductors
4312 VT circuitsVT secondary circuits connect the VT secondaries to the protective and metering devices The load current for these devices is very small however the voltage drop should be considered The conductor size should be selected such that the VT standard burden is not exceeded and so that the voltage drop is very small in order to provide the protective and metering devices with the actual voltage at the location of the VTs
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
4
12
34
5
6
789
10111213
14151617181920
212223242526
272829303132
3334353637
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
4313 Trip and close coil circuitsAmpacity and voltage drop requirements should be considered when determining the size of the control cables that connect to the trip and close coils of the circuit breakers The conductor size should be capable of carrying the maximum trip coil current and allow for adequate voltage drop based on the trip coil rating To ensure that actuation of a circuit protective device does not result in a failure to trip the circuit protection should be selected with a trip rating that is significantly higher than the expected duty The trip and close cable conductor should have an ampacity that exceeds the trip rating of the fuse or circuit breaker protecting the circuit
4314 Circuit breaker motor backup powerSome high-voltage circuit breakers use an acdc spring-charging motor connected to the dc control circuit These motors can run on dc if the normal ac station service voltage supply to the circuit breaker is lost The circuit breaker motor supply cable should be selected with a continuous duty ampacity that equals or exceeds the expected ac and dc motor current The conductor should be sized such that the voltage drop at the minimum expected ac and dc supply voltage provides a voltage at the motor within the motor rating
The load characteristic of a typical spring charging motor is shown in Figure 1 The typical current draw is much higher than the specified ldquorunrdquo current and should be considered in the design
Figure 1mdashSpring charging motor load characteristic
4315 Alarm and status circuitsAlarm and status circuits carry very small current and voltage drop is not a concern As a result a smaller size conductor can be used for these circuits
4316 Battery circuitsThe station battery will have an operating range with a minimum terminal voltage The battery cable conductors should be selected so that the voltage drop from the battery terminals to the utilization equipment for the expected load current does not result in a voltage below the minimum voltage rating of the utilization equipment DC utilization equipment such as breaker trip coils and protective relays will have a minimum voltage rating for operation A designer should use end of discharge voltage for critical
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
5
12345678
91011121314
1516
1718
192021
222324252627
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
circuits These would include circuit breaker trip and close coils that are required to operate at the end of a batteryrsquos discharge period
432 Voltage ratingLow-voltage control cable rated 600 V and 1000 V are currently in use For control cables applied at 600 V and below 600 V rated insulation is most commonly used Some engineers use 1000 V rated insulation because of past insulation failures caused by inductive voltage spikes from de-energizing electromechanical devices eg relays spring winding motors The improved dielectric strength of todayrsquos insulation materials prompted some utilities to return to using 600 V rated insulation for this application
433 Cable constructionThe principal components of substation control cables include conductors conductor insulation shielding tape and filler and jacket
Conductors for substation control cables may be solid or stranded and may be uncoated copper tin-coated copper or leadlead alloy coated wires Stranded conductors usually consist of 7 or 19 wires for Class B stranding Conductor size usually ranges from 9 to 14 AWG (American Wire Gauge) but conductor size as small as 22 AWG may be utilized Caution should be exercised before using such small conductors because of the possibility of mechanical damage
Insulation for each conductor in a control cable is made from an extruded dielectric material suitable for use in either wet or dry locations or dry-only locations and at maximum conductor temperatures ranging from 60 degC to 125 degC depending on the type of insulation material utilized Common insulation materials include but are not limited to polyethylene (PE) cross-linked PE (XLPE) Types 1 and 2 silicone rubber (SR) synthetic rubber (SBR) and ethylene propylene rubber (EPR) Types 1 and 2 and polyvinyl chloride (PVC) The thickness of insulation varies with the type of insulation material conductor size and voltage rating
Shielding is used in some control and instrumentation cables to reduce or eliminate electrostatic interference from outside sources on cable conductors or groups of conductors or to reduce or eliminate electrostatic interference between cable conductors or groups of cable conductors within a cable Cable shields typically consist of metal braid or tapefoil that encloses the insulated conductor or group of conductors The shield type can affect the physical characteristics of the cable (flexibility weight etc) and should be considered in relation to the installation requirements A drain wire is frequently found on shielded cables using metal tapefoil to aid in the ease of shield termination Shields and drain wires are usually constructed of copper copper alloy or aluminum
Tape consisting of dielectric material is utilized to bind and separate layers of construction and fillers made from thermoplastic or other materials are utilized to form a cylindrical shape for most cable assemblies
Control and instrumentation cables are provided with an outer jacket that can provide mechanical protection fire resistance or moisture protection Care should be taken to utilize a jacket material that is suitable for the environment in which is installed Factors to consider include moisture chemicals fire temperature UV exposure personnel occupancy etc
Methods for identification of control cable conductors by number with base and tracer colors on each conductor are discussed in Appendix E of NEMA WC 57-2004ICEA S-73-532 [B96] Inner jackets for multi-conductor cables may be color-coded as well (reference Table E-1 Table E-2 and Table E-3 of NEMA WC 57-2004ICEA S-73-532 [B96] for guidance)
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
6
12
345678
91011
1213141516
17181920212223
2425262728293031
3233
34353637
38394041
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
44 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)
45 Routing (see Annex F)
All control circuits in a substation should be installed in a radial configuration ie route all conductors comprising a control circuit in the same cable and if conduit is used within the same conduit
Radial arrangement of control circuitry reduces transient voltages Circuits routed into the switchyard from the control house should not be looped from one piece of apparatus to another in the switchyard with the return conductor in another cable All supply and return conductors should be in a common cable to avoid the large electromagnetic induction possible because of the very large flux-linking-loop arrangement otherwise encountered Also this arrangement helps avoid common impedances that cause differential and common-mode voltages This recommendation is especially important for supply and ground circuits
If the substation has a capacitor bank all control cables not specifically associated with capacitor controls or protection should be removed from the immediate area around the capacitor bank to avoid induction of surges into relaying systems or possible control cable failure during capacitor bank switching The routing of control cables from capacitor bank neutral CTs or VTs should be kept at right angles with respect to the common neutral for single point grounding and in parallel with the tie to the substation ground for peninsular grounding to minimize induction (ldquoShunt capacitor switching EMI voltages their reduction in Bonneville Power Administration substationsrdquo [B26]) Control cables entering the capacitor bank area should be kept as close as possible to the ground grid conductors in the cable trench or on top of the duct run or in contact with the ground grid conductor if directly buried (see IEEE Std C3799-2000 [B74])
All dc circuits are normally ldquoradialrdquo ie the positive and negative leads (ldquogordquo and ldquoreturnrdquo circuits) are kept within the same cable In alarm and relay circuits where there might be one positive and several negative returns all leads should be in the same jacket
In circuits where the positive and negative are in separate cables for specific reasons the positive and negative should be physically close together wherever practical Measures should be taken to avoid shorting the positive and negative such as barriers insulation separate conduits etc The positive and negative could be in separate cables due to the required size of the conductors or the physical location of the connected positive and negative terminals such as the circuit between the station battery and the battery charger or DC panel board
Where dc motors are connected to the substation control battery as for motor operated disconnect switches the voltage may be provided by a ldquoyard busrdquo The yard bus is a single pair of large conductors that are sized to supply several or all of the connected motor loads simultaneously
46 Transient protection (see Annex G)
High energy transients may cause failures in low-voltage substation equipment such as solid-state relays transducers measuring instruments and remote terminal units (RTUs) connected at the ends of control or instrumentation cables In a substation environment the high energy sources typically include power- frequency fault currents lightning or switching transients Sometimes these influences are also responsible for erroneous operations of relays causing partial or entire substation shutdown The overvoltages may even damage transient surge suppressor devices such as metal oxide varistors or gas discharge tubes at the terminals Shielded cables are typically applied in higher voltage substations (voltages at 230 kV and higher) or at lower voltages for specific applications
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
7
1
2
34
56789
10
111213141516171819
202122
232425262728
293031
32
3334353637383940
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
47 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)
Segregation of control cables in the substation cable trench or cable tray system is generally not necessary
Control cables should not be installed in ducts or trenches containing medium-voltage cables (greater than 1000 V)
48 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)
49 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)
410 Handling (see Annex K)
411 Installation (see Annex L)
412 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)
Control cables should be insulation-resistance tested prior to connecting cables to equipment They may be tested as part of the system checkout
413 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)
5 Metallic Communication cables
This clause covers the following for metallic communication cables within and to substations
1) General
2) Service conditions
3) Cable selection
4) Cable system design
5) Transient protection
6) Cable pulling
7) Handling
8) Installation
9) Acceptance testing
10) Recommended maintenance
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
8
1
2
34
5
6
7
8
9
1011
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
51 General
Substation communications may require multi-conductor metallic communication cables to transfer communication signals at low voltage and current levels using a protocol to the substation andor within the substation Those cables that enter the substation either overhead or underground are addressed by other IEEE standards such as
IEEE Std 487 This standard presents engineering design practices for special high-voltage
protection systems intended to protect wire-line telecommunication facilities serving electric
supply locations IEEE 487-2007 has been broken down into a family of related documents (ie
dot-series) segregated on the basis of technology Std 487 contains the General Considerations
common to the entire lsquodot-series The documents in the entire series are
a) IEEE Std 487 General Considerations
b) IEEE Std 4871 for applications using On-Grid Isolation Equipment
c) IEEE Std 4872 for applications consisting entirely of optical fiber cables
d) IEEE Std 4873 for applications of hybrid facilities where part of the circuit is on metallic
wire-line and the remainder of the circuit is on optical fiber cable
e) IEEE Std 4874 for applications using Neutralizing Transformers
f) IEEE Std 4875 for applications using Isolation Transformers
IEEE Std 789 This standard covers the appropriate design requirements electrical and mechanical
parameters the testing requirements and the handling procedures for wires and cables used
principally for power system communications and control purposes that are to be installed and
operated in high-voltage environments where they may be subjected to high voltages either by
conduction or induction coupling or both Coaxial and fiber optic cables except for those used in
Ethernet applications are specifically excluded
This guide addresses the design and installation of metallic cable types wholly contained within a substation
a) Telephone cables and other multiconductor communications cables that are not serial Ethernet or
coaxial cables
b) Serial cables (RS232 RS485 and Universal Serial Bus (USB))
c) Ethernet cables
d) Coaxial cables
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
9
1
2
3456
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
2627
28
29
30
31
32
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
This clause also addresses the different terminations used for these types of cables Metallic communication cables are typically unshielded twisted pairs (UTP) such as many types of Ethernet and serial telephone and Ethernet cables Shielded twisted pairs are also common IEC 11801 attempts to standardize the definitions for different combinations of cable screening (unscreened foil screened braid screened braid and foil screened) and pair shielding (unscreened or foil screened) and number of twisted conductors (twisted pair and twisted quad)
511 Telephone cable and multiconductor communication cablesThese types of cables have been essential for providing voice and data circuits to substations for decades Phone cable types can be dictated by whether the connection is dial-up or leased line In many cases two copper wires (tip and ring) for each dial-up telephone line are run from a substation to a local telephone companyrsquos point of presence (POP) usually addressing the GPR design issues in IEEE Std 487 Tip and ring refers to the two wires or sides of an ordinary telephone line where tip is the ground side (positive) and ring is the battery (negative) side
Phone circuits are typically identified with the Plain Old Telephone Service (POTS) or voice grade communications which are limited in bandwidth to between 300 and 3400 Hz so modems provide digital service over the analog phone lines POTS lines are part of the public switched telephone network (PSTN) Today the PSTN has migrated from the original days of copper telephone lines to include fiber optic cables microwave transmission links cellular networks communications satellites and undersea cables The PSTN connects these together in switching centers allowing any telephone in the world to communicate with any other The PSTN is now almost entirely digital in its core and includes mobile as well as fixed telephones
Multiconductor communication cables may also be used for pilot wire protection using pilot wires which may use any combination of private wires and telco wires Pilot wire connects together two or more protective relays where dc or ac signals are connected together using pilot wires where ac pilot wire protection is mostly akin to modern line differential protection A relay at each end of the protected circuit converts the current flow at one line terminal to a composite single-phase quantity Because the two relays are connected by pilot wires the quantity at one terminal can be electrically compared with the quantity at the other terminal If the correct match between terminals does NOT occur a trip of the circuit breakers at each terminal will be initiated More information on pilot wire systems exists in IEEE Std 487 and IEEE Std C37236 Once inside a substation pilot wire cables will be run from some terminal point to the end device
In addition to POTS lines and pilot wires multiconductor communications cables are used for dedicated four-wire leased line phone circuits typically providing low-speed serial SCADA communications and teleprotection applications as described in IEEE Std C37236 Unlike dial-up connections a leased line is always active is not connected to a telephone exchange (no phone number) does not provide DC power dial tone busy tone or ring signal The fee for a connection is a fixed monthly rate The primary factors affecting the monthly fee are distance between end points and the speed of the circuit Because the connection is dedicated the carrier can assure a given level of quality typically considered class A B or C service As defined in IEEE Std C3793 and IEEE Std 487 Class A is non-interruptible service performance (must function before during and after the power fault condition) class B is self-restoring interruptible service performance (must function before and after power fault condition) and class C is interruptible service performance (can tolerate a station visit to restore service) Not all leased lines are four wire circuits Leased lines can transmit full duplex (transmit and receive at the same time) or half duplex (transmit or receive one at a time) Leased lines can be synchronous where the data is transmitted at a fixed rate with the transmitter and receiver synchronized Leased lines are not just limited to low-speed serial communications
Phone cable conductors regardless of dial-up or leased line are individually insulated The conductors range in size from 22 to 26 AWG copper The conductors are twisted and may be shielded in pairs from as few as 2 pairs up to hundreds of pairs and in groups of 25 pairs The twisted pairs also have a de-facto
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
10
123456
789
10111213
1415161718192021
22232425262728293031
323334353637383940414243444546
474849
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
standard color code for up to 25 pairs Cables over 25 pairs have the first 25 pairs isolated with ribbons using the colors of the color code starting with the first color code the second 25 pairs with a ribbon with the second color code and so on until all cables are identified into a ldquosuperrdquo binder Those super binders can then be combined using the same color code scheme too forming even larger cables
512 Serial cablesSerial cables have traditionally been essential for the transfer of basic digital data signals to and within a substation Typically serial cables do not enter a substation but can be abundant within a substation The conductors are twisted and can be shielded twisted pair (STP) or unshielded twisted pair (UTP) with or without overall shielding Serial communications is commonly known as ldquoRS232rdquo and ldquoRS485rdquo The official standards for each (TIA-232-F and TIAEIA-485-A) do not define specific cable construction requirements only cable characteristics such as capacitance Both RS232 and RS485 cables are typically unshielded but there may be an overall cable shield andor braid The cables may have twisted pairs (more typical of RS485) or not (more typical of RS232)
Serial cables may need to support baud rates between 1200 to 115 kbps for RS232 and can extend to over 1 Mbps for RS485 Baud rates are typically limited by several factors including cable length and capacitance See IEEE C371
5121 Serial RS232 cablesRS232 cables typically have between 2 and 9 conductors depending upon what signals are required by the devices being connected together The standard actually specifies 20 different signal connections typically substation intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) today use only transmit data (TX) receive data (RX) and signal ground others that may be included are request to send (RTS) and clear to send (CTS) and are commonly referred to as ldquohardware handshakingrdquo signals When RTS and CTS are not present software flow control or handshaking is used Connections with modems will typically have even more signals and conductors Cables must be properly selected in tandem with the connectors used (discussed later)
RS232 devices are classified as either data communications equipment (DCE) or data terminal equipment (DTE) DCE devices are digital devices that connect to a communications line for the purpose of data transfer without regard to its content (eg a modem) DTE devices are digital devices that transmit or receive data and require communications equipment for the data transfer DTE devices terminate a communication line and require DCE equipment for the data transfer DCE devices are connected directly to the communication circuit used between two DTE devices DTE devices usually use a male plug connector and DCE devices a female connector As a general rule nine pin DTE devices transmit on pin 3 and receive on pin 2 and nine pin DCE devices transmit on pin 2 and receive on pin 3 Avoiding the use of DCE equipment is very common between two devices This is accomplished through the use of a null modem cable that acts as a DCE between the devices by swapping the corresponding signals (such as TX-RX and RTS-CTS)
5122 Serial RS485 cablesTrue RS485 cables have three conductors two for the communication bus and one for signal ground There does exist ldquo4 wirerdquo RS485 but these do not strictly adhere to the TIAEIA-485-A standard RS485 has three signal wires typically denoted as
a) ldquoArdquo ldquo-ldquo and ldquoTxD-RxD-rdquo
b) ldquoBrdquo ldquo+ldquo and ldquoTxD+RxD+rdquo
c) ldquoSCrdquo ldquoGrdquo
This does not mean that all vendors denote them the same way which means care is required in wiring together devices that are from different vendors Re-wiring an RS485 circuit is not uncommon because of
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
11
1234
56789
10111213
141516
1718192021222324
2526272829303132333435
36373839
40
41
42
4344
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
this labeling problem and good documentation is recommended especially when vendorsrsquo implementations do not agree and the A line must be connected to the B line for the circuit to work Care should be used to not use the shield as the third conductor (ldquoSCrdquo or ldquoGrdquo) as this may introduce noise into the communications circuit and cause the communications to fail when noise becomes an issue Optical isolation provided in many devices may remove the need for the signal ground and circuits may combine devices that use optical isolation and those that do not
Serial cable conductors are typically individually insulated and range in size from 22 to 26 AWG copper The cables may be assembled with terminations may be twisted may have shielded pairs may have an overall shieldfoilbraid and may have armor - in any combination The shield protects the signal conductors from interference A bare drain conductor may be present to provide a grounding connection for the shield
5123 USB cablesUSB was designed to standardize the connection of typical computer peripherals such as keyboards pointing devices and printers but also digital cameras portable media players disk drives and network adapters USB is used to communicate and to supply low-voltage dc power It has become commonplace on other devices such as smart phones and video game consoles USB has effectively replaced a variety of earlier communication interfaces such as serial and parallel ports as well as separate power sources for portable devices because of the power supply allowed in the specification USB USB 20 USB 30 and USB wireless specifications are maintained by the USB Implementers Forum and are available for download
USB 20 is most common today where the specification specifies a cable with four conductors two power conductors and two signal conductors plus different connector styles The cable impedance must match the impedance of the signal drivers The specification allows for a variable cable length where the maximum cable length is dictated by signal pair attenuation and propagation delay as well as the voltage drop across the ground conductor The minimum wire gauge is calculated from the current consumption There are differences between high-full speed cables and low-speed cables most notably the required shield in the former and an optional shield in the latter also the required drain wire in the latter The specification requires a shield be terminated to the connector plug for completed assemblies The shield and chassis are bonded together The user-selected grounding scheme for USB 20 devices and cables is to be consistent with accepted industry practices and regulatory agency standards for safety and EMIESDRFI
USB cable may be used for applications of RS232 andor RS485 communication provided there is a proper converter from USB to RS232RS485 These converters are commonplace today Other applications which may be critical are for peripheral connections from computers to keyboards pointing devices and touch screens Care should be used in selecting USB cables and converters that meet the environmental requirements of the application Rugged USB cables and connectors are available but the connectors may be vendor-specific and may not be supported by devices Cable lengths should be carefully considered given the performance-based length specification It is possible to convert USB to Ethernet or extend USBrsquos range by converting to Ethernet cable given the proper converter
513 Ethernet cablesThere are several designations for communication cables which originally started out as ldquolevelsrdquo and eventually became known as categories and then abbreviated to ldquoCATrdquo (for category) designations that today primarily apply to Ethernet cables Some are still official categories maintained by the TIAEIA Cable category characteristics and use are listed below
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
12
123456
789
1011
121314151617181920
21222324252627282930
3132333435363738
3940414243
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Table 1mdashCable characteristics or ldquoCATrdquo cables
Category Use Standard Frequency Bandwidth
1
2 4 MHz 4 Mbps
3 16 MHz 10 Mbps
4 20 MHz 16 Mbps
5 100 MHz
5e 100 Mhz
6 250 MHz
6A 500 MHz
Known as ldquovoice graderdquo UTP copper circuits used for POTS (plain old telephone service)
No standard exists
Originally called Anixter
level 1
Less than 1 MHz
Low speed UTP cabling for older computer networks telephone networks and is no longer commonly used
No standard exists
Originally called level 2 by Anixter
Typically UTP cabling although also available in screened twisted pair commonly called ldquostation wirerdquo that was the first cabling category standardized by the TIAEIA and commonly used on 10BaseT Ethernet networks in the 1990s
TIAEIA-568-C
100 Ethernet 10BASE-T
UTP cabling briefly used for 10BaseT networks that was quickly superseded by CAT55e cable that is no longer recognized by the TIAEIA
Cabling that is typically UTP but also could be STP can also carry video telephony and serial signal and is no longer recognized by the TIAEIA
Originally defined in
TIAEIA-568-A
10 Mbps 100 Mbps 1000 Mbps
100 Ethernet 10BASE-T
100Base-TX 1000BaseT
Enhanced CAT5 cabling that can be 24-26 awg UTP or STP which improved upon CAT5 cablersquos performance and resulted in CAT5 cable being no longer recognized by the TIAEIA
Originally defined in
TIAEIA-568-A-5 in 1999
10 Mbps 100 Mbps 1000 Mbps
100 Ethernet 10BASE-T
100Base-TX 1000BaseT
Standard cabling for gigabit Ethernet networks is 22-24 awg UTP or STP
TIAEIA-568-C
10 Mbps 100 Mbps 1000 Mbps 10GBaseT
100 Ethernet 10BASE-T
100Base-TX 1000BaseT 55
10GBaseT
Augmented CAT6 cabling can be UTP or STP
TIAEIA-568-C
100 Ethernet 10BASE-T
100Base-TX 1000BaseT 10GBaseT
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
13
1
2
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Cat 7 cable with four individually-shielded pairs inside an overall shield has been proposed but is not in common use today Cat 7 is designed for transmission frequencies up to 600MHz which should enable it to carry 10-Gigabit Ethernet (10GBaseT) but requires a redesigned RJ-45 connector (called a GG45) to achieve this speed 10GBaseT networks are not yet widely available and may not be able to compete with fiber optic networks
514 Coaxial cablesCoaxial cable consists of
a) An outer jacket
b) An outer shield consisting of one or more layers of braid andor foil
c) A dielectric insulator such as polyethylene (PE)
d) An inner solid or stranded conductor
The outer shield of foil andor braid acts as both a shield and a return path conductor An ideal shield would be a perfect conductor without bumps gaps or holes and connected to a perfect ground However a smooth solid and highly conductive shield would be heavy inflexible and expensive Thus cables must compromise between shield effectiveness flexibility and cost Braided copper wire for the shield allows the cable to be flexible but it also means there are gaps in the shield layer thus reducing the shieldrsquos effectiveness Foil improves the coverage when combined with the braid
There are names for coaxial cables originating from military uses in the form ldquoRG-rdquo or ldquoRG-Urdquo The RG designation stands for Radio Guide the U designation stands for Universal These date from World War II and were listed in MIL-HDBK-216 published in 1962 which is now withdrawn The RG unit indicator is no longer part of the military standard now MIL-C-17 Some of the new numbers have similar characteristics as the old RG numbers One example is Mil-C-172 and RG-6 cables These cables are very similar however Mil-C-172 has a higher working voltage at 3000 V (versus 2700 V for RG-6) and the operating temperature of Mil-C-172 is much higher at 185degC (versus 80degC for RG-6)
The RG designations are still common Cable sold today under any RG label is unlikely to meet military MIL-C-17 specifications Subsequently there is no standard to guarantee the electrical and physical characteristics of a cable described as ldquoRG- typerdquo Today RG designators are mostly used to identify compatible connectors that fit the inner conductor dielectric and jacket dimensions of the old RG-series cables Because of these issues care should be used to select the proper cable based upon the application and installation requirements for temperature and other environmental factors
Most coaxial cables have a characteristic impedance of 50 52 75 or 93 Ω
Table 2mdashCommon coaxial RG designationsCable type UseRG-6 A 75 ohm cable type
Commonly used for cable television (CATV) distribution coax used to route cable television signals to and within homes CATV distribution coax typically has a copper-clad steel (CCS) center conductor and an aluminum foilaluminum braid shield with coverage around 60RG-6 type cables are also used in professional video applications carrying either base band analog video signals or serial digital interface (SDI) signals in these applications the center conductor is ordinarily solid copper the shielding is much heavier (typically aluminum foil95 copper braid) and
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
14
1
23456
78
9
10
11
12
131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
32
33
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
tolerances are more tightly controlledRG-8 RG-8 is a 50 ohm cable used in radio transmission or in computer networks
RG-58 is a larger diameter cable than RG-8RG-11 A 75 ohm cable typeRG-58 RG-58 is a 50 ohm cable used in radio transmission computer networks or
power line carrier applications RG-58 is a smaller cable than RG-8RG-59 A 75 ohm cable originally used for CATV but is being replaced by RG-6RG-213 A 50 ohm cable used for power line carrier applications
Advantages of coaxial cable include the following high bandwidth low signal distortion low susceptibility to cross-talk and noise low signal losses and greater information security However coaxial cable is more difficult to install heavier and does not have the flexibility offered by twisted pair cables
The shield of a coaxial cable is normally grounded so if even a single bit of shield touches the center conductor the signal will be shorted causing significant or total signal loss This occurs at improperly installed end connectors and splices In addition the connectors require proper attached to the shield as this provides the path to ground for the interfering signal Despite being shielded coaxial cable can be susceptible to interference which has little relationship to the RG designations (eg RG-59 RG-6) but is strongly related to the composition and configuration of the cable shield Foil shielding typically used with a tinned copper or aluminum braid shield with anywhere from 60 to 95 coverage The braid is important to shield effectiveness because the braid
a) Is more effective than foil at preventing low-frequency interference
b) Provides higher conductivity to ground than foil and
c) Makes attaching a connector easier and more reliable
For better shield performance some cables have a shield with only two braids as opposed to a thin foil shield covered by a wire braid ldquoQuad-shieldrdquo cables use four alternating layers of foil and braid which is typically used in situations involving troublesome interference Quad-shield is less effective than a single layer of foil and single high-coverage copper braid shield Other shield designs reduce flexibility in order to improve performance
Typical uses of coaxial cable are for transmission of radio frequency signals The most common uses in substations are for antenna connections to satellite clocks and satellite clock timing signal distribution Other substation uses include microwave radio and power line carrier (PLC) applications Equipment manufacturers should be contacted to provide guidance on application-specific cable selection
515 TerminationsTerminations are used to connect communication cables to the various IEDs for the purpose of communications There are various types of terminations A different type of termination can be used on either end of the cable Regardless of the terminations used for communication cables care should be taken to match each signal assigned to each conductor terminal or pin on each end of the communication cable This ensures that the communications works properly Terminals and signals should be identified clearly on drawings typically in common details especially when a custom cable and termination are required for the application These are typically referred to pin-out diagrams Also note that while there are common connectors for serial cables and Ethernet cables as discussed the presence of the one of these connectors does not guarantee the port signaling is the typical type This is especially true for RJ45 ports which are commonly used for Ethernet RS232 or RS485 communications
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
15
1
234
56789
101112
13
14
15
1617181920
21222324
2526272829303132333435
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
5151 Punchdown blocksPhone cables are typically terminated to a 66-block punchdown block common to telephone systems or a 110-block punchdown block common to higher speed cable terminations for CAT 5 and 6 cables A punchdown block is named because the solid copper wires are ldquopunched downrdquo into short open-ended slots that are a type of insulation-displacement connectors These slots typically cut crosswise across an insulating plastic bar with two sharp metal blades that cut through the wirersquos insulation as it is punched down These blades hold the wire in position and make the electrical contact with the wire as well A punchdown tool is used to push the wire firmly and properly into the slot making the termination easy because there is no wire stripping and no screw terminals Patch panels are commonly replacing punchdown blocks for non-voice applications because of the increasing performance demands of Ethernet cabling
5152 TerminalsA terminal strip may be used to land the communication conductors These types of connections are typically used for terminating RS485 cables but may also be seen for RS232 connections and rarely for Ethernet connections or coaxial connections Care should be used to properly identify the conductor signals and terminal block labels so as to properly associate them with the signals for the terminal connection being used
5153 DB connectorsRS232 cables are typically terminated in connectors commonly called DB9 or DB25 today The original RS232 connector was a 25 pin connector but that connector is much larger than the connector associated with the DB25 connector seen today The D-subminiature connector was invented by Cannon 1952 with an operating temperature between -54degC and 150degC The product had a standard series prefix of ldquoDrdquo and different shell sizes (A B C D E) followed by the number of pinssockets Connectors of six different sizes were later documented in MIL-24308 (now withdrawn) with a temperature range from -55 degC to +125 degC A similar 25 pin connector is defined in ISOIEC 60211 without any temperature range The DB connectors with crimp connectors are standardized in IEC 60807-3 and solder style connectors in IEC 60870-2 both with five shell sizes for 9 15 25 37 and 50 pins The temperature ranges from -55 degC to +125 degC and -55 degC to +100 degC for IEC 60870-3 IEC 60870-2 adds another temperature range from -40 degC to +100 degC
Each DB connector is designated as male (plug) or female (jack) The pins may be crimped or soldered onto the conductors in the cable The most common connectors are 9 pins (DB9) 15 pins (DB15) 25 pins (DB25) 37 pins (DB37) and 50 pins (DB50) though others are used Serial cables have various combinations of gender and pins such as a DB9 female connector on one end (DB9F) and a DB25 male connector on the other (DB25M) In addition just because a cable has connectors with nine pins on both ends this does not mean all nine pins are actually connected through the cable How the pins are connected through the cable may only be discoverable by pinning out the cable with a simple ohm meter to test connectivity between one pin on one end with each pin on the other end The pin out may be specified on a specification sheet or drawing Providing a pin out diagram is typically required when requesting a custom cable from a cable manufacturer A pin out diagram also validates that the selected cable will actually work with the signals on the pins for the connected IEDs
Extreme care must be performed when connecting serial ports together via serial cables because the signals on the pins may not be properly connected by the cable resulting in damage to the communication port that may be beyond repair
Please reference the vendorrsquos documentation to properly identify the pin signal definitions for both cable connectors and IEDs
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
16
123456789
1011
121314151617
181920212223242526272829
3031323334353637383940
414243
4445
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Figure 2mdashTypical serial DB-style connectors
5154 RJ (registered jack) connectorsRegistered jack (RJ) connectors typically terminate communication cables and jacks located on devices The RJ designation describes the physical geometry of the connectors and a wiring pattern in the jack inspection of the connector will not necessarily show which registered jack wiring pattern is used The same modular connector type can be used for different registered jack connections While registered jack refers to both the female physical connector (modular connector) and its wiring the term is often used loosely to refer to modular connectors regardless of wiring or gender The six-position plug and jack commonly used for telephone line connections may be used for RJ11 RJ14 or even RJ25 all of which are names of interface standards that use this physical connector The RJ abbreviations only pertain to the wiring of the jack (hence the name registered jack) it is commonplace but not strictly correct to refer to an unwired plug connector by any of these names
The types of cable connectors are a plug type of connector when the device has a receptacle They are typically used for telephone and network type applications but can be used for serial ports and other ports as well Some common designations are shown below TIA-1096-A specifies some temperature range for the connectors based upon change in contact resistance between -40 degC and +66 degC under varying humidity conditions There is no specification for vibration only mating and unmating cycles
IEC 60603-7 specifies a temperature ranges and vibration conditions The temperature range is between -40 deg C and +70 deg C for 21 days based upon climatic category 4007021 from IEC 61076-12006 The vibration requirements are taken from IEC 60512 with a frequency range between 10 Hz to 500 Hz Amplitude at 035 mm acceleration at 50 ms-2 and 10 sweeps per axis
For Ethernet cables TIA-598-C requires connecting hardware be functional for continuous use over the temperature range from -10 to 60 degC
Table 3mdashCharacteristics of RJ connectorsCommon Name
Wiring Connector Usage
RJ11 RJ11C RJ11W 6P2C For one telephone line (6P4C if power on second pair) RJ11W is a jack from which you can hang a wall telephone while RJ11C is a jack designed to have a cord plugged into it
RJ45 8P8C 8P8C modular connectors are typically known as ldquoRJ45rdquo an informal designation for TIA-568A or TIA-568B jacks including Ethernet that is not the same as the true RJ45RJ45S The shape and dimensions of an 8P8C modular connector are specified in TIA-1096-A but this standard does not use the term 8P8C (only as a miniature 8 position plug unkeyed and related jack) and covers more than just 8P8C modular connectors however the 8P8C modular connector type is described in TIA-1096-A with eight contacts installed The international standard for the 8P8C plug and jack for ISDN is ISO-8877 For Ethernet cables the IEC 60603-7 series specifies not only the same physical dimensions as the 8P8C for shielded and unshielded versions but also high-frequency performance requirements for shielded and unshielded versions of this connector for frequencies up to 100 250 500 600 and 1000 MHz
RJ48 RJ48 8P8C Used for T1 and ISDN termination and local area data channelssubrate
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
17
12
3
456789
1011121314
1516171819
20212223
2425
26
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Common Name
Wiring Connector Usage
digital servicesRJ48 RJ48C 8P8C Commonly used for T1 lines and uses pins 1 2 4 and 5RJ48 RJ48S 8P8C keyed Commonly used for local area data channelssubrate digital services and
carries one or two linesRJ48 RJ48X 8P8C with
shorting barA variation of RJ48C containing shorting blocks in the jack creating a loopback used for troubleshooting when unplugged The short connects pins 1 and 4 and 2 and 5 Sometimes this is referred to as a ldquosmart jackrsquo
Figure 3 shows a generic 8P8C receptacle
Most vendors do not provide detailed specifications on the RJ45 jack provided in their devices In some situations where temperature or vibration is a concern the vendor should be consulted regarding their specifications
Figure 3mdashGeneric 8P8C receptacle
5155 Coaxial connectorsCoaxial cables are frequently terminated using different styles of connectors including BNC (Bayonet Neill Concelman) TNC (threaded NeillndashConcelman) and N The BNC connectors are miniature quick connectdisconnect connectors that feature two bayonet lugs on the female connector mating is achieved with only a quarter turn of the coupling nut BNCs are ideally suited for cable termination for miniature-to-subminiature coaxial cable (RG-58 RG-59 etc) The BNC was originally designed for military use and is widely used in substations for IRIG-B time distribution signals The connector is widely accepted for use up to 2 GHz The BNC uses a slotted outer conductor and some plastic dielectric on each gender connector This dielectric causes increasing losses at higher frequencies Above 4 GHz the slots may radiate signals so the connector is usable but not necessarily stable up to about 11 GHz BNC connectors exist in 50 and 75 ohm versions matched for use with cables of the same characteristic impedance BNC connectors are typically found on IEDs for IRIG-B input although terminal blocks are also used on some IEDs for IRIG-B input
The TNC connectorrsquos impedance is 50 Ω and the connector operates best in the 0ndash11 GHz frequency spectrum and has better performance than the BNC connector TNC connectors can be found on some satellite clocks for the coaxial cable connection to the antenna
The N connector is a threaded connector used to join coaxial cables It was one of the first connectors capable of carrying microwave-frequency signals Originally designed to carry signals up to 1 GHz todayrsquos common N connector easily handles frequencies up to 11 GHz and beyond
MIL-PRF-39012 covers the general requirements and tests for RF connectors used with flexible cables and certain other types of coaxial transmission lines in military aerospace and spaceflight applications
Also used with coaxial connectors are tee connectors that allow coaxial cable runs to be tapped These are commonly found in IRIG-B time distribution systems There also may be a need to convert from coaxial cable to TSP cable which can be accomplished by using breakout connectors Care should be used in
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
18
1
2
345
67
8
9101112131415161718192021
222324
252627
2829
303132
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
properly terminating the coaxial cable with a termination resistor Work is underway to create a recommended practice for cabling the distribution of IRIG-B signals within substations
52 Service conditions
For typical service conditions (or environmental performance) for metallic communication cables serving and within substations and switching stations see Annex B Typical environmental ratings are discussed in Annex B but the specific types of metallic communication cables (ie serial and Ethernet cables) and terminations are discussed previously in this clause
Environmental performance for indoor and outdoor cable will likely impact the cable jacket For indoor cables the NEC divides a buildingrsquos inside area into three types of sections plenums risers and general purpose areas A plenum area is a building space used for air flow or air distribution system which is typically above a drop ceiling or under a raised floor that is used as the air return for the air handling Cables burning in the plenum space would give off toxic fumes and the fumes would be fed to the rest of the building by the air handling system injuring people who may be a long way from the fire A riser area is a floor opening shaft or duct that runs vertically through one or more floors Anything that is not riser or plenum is general purpose
The NEC 2011 designates the following metallic communication cable types
a) CMP as communications plenum cable
b) CMR as communications riser cable
c) CMG as communications general-purpose cable
d) CM as communications general-purpose cable
e) CMX as communications cable limited use
f) CMUC as under-carpet communications wire and cable
Note that none of these specifically include ldquotray cablerdquo in the name Tray-rated metallic communication cable is a complicated topic as the 2011 NEC allows CMP CMR CMG and CM cables to be installed in cable trays without any ratings However there is no exact specification of tray rated cable leaving the user to define the requirements of tray rated cable Ultimately a tray rated metallic cable (and perhaps fiber optic cable) is likely to conform to
a) NEC Article 318 ldquoCable Traysrdquo and Article 340 ldquoPower and Control Cable Type TCrdquo
b) Flame tests per UL 1277 ICEA T-29-520 ICEA T-30-520 and the 70000 BTU ldquoCable Tray
Propagation Testrdquo per IEEE Std 383
c) Rated 600 V
Outside plant cable can be run inside a building per the NEC requirements up to 50 feet Outside plant cables generally differ from inside plant cables in the jacket and any filling compound or gel used to limit the ingress of water into the cable Conductor deterioration from water will cause noise on metallic communication cables either from the cable or from the termination
Service conditions include ground potential rise (GPR) for metallic communication cables originating from outside the substation
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
19
12
3
4567
89
101112131415
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
2324252627
28
29
30
31
32333435
3637
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Any metallic communication cable connection to a substation or switchyard from outside the substation is where IEEE Std 487 applies Here GPR should be considered in order to protect sensitive equipment This consideration requires close coordination with the engineering staff of outside entities (eg telephone company) to ensure appropriate isolation equipment is installed As a result offsite equipment is adequately protected from unacceptable voltage increases in the event of a fault See IEEE Std 487 for the IEEE recommended practice for protecting wire-line communication facilities serving substations or switchyards
Even inside a substation GPR and other environmental effects may also be a concern when using metallic communication cables IEEE Std 1615 provides recommendations on when to use fiber and metallic cables within a substation
53 Metallic cable selection
Selection of metallic communication cable types depends upon the application used for the cable for example RS232 RS485 or Ethernet communications In selecting a cable generally the larger conductor sizes help reduce the effects of resistance on signal transmission but many standards dictate the size range of the conductors as indicated previously
Ultimately metallic cable selection depends upon meeting the installation requirements as noted above and compliance with the type of communication circuits involved This clause specifically addresses the following types
a) Telephone cable (and multiconductor cable that is not serial Ethernet or coaxial)
b) Serial cable
c) Ethernet cable
d) Coaxial cable
Note that it is now common to use Ethernet cable for both serial cables and telephone cables Using Ethernet cable in this manner requires extreme care to insure not only the proper termination of the cable but the connection of the cable to the correct communication port (ie it becomes very easy to connect a cable used for serial communications into an RJ45 plug function as an Ethernet port)
Selection of RS232 and RS485 serial cables depends upon how many signal wires are required by the communication ports what shielding is required the transmission speed the distance and the environmental requirements The RS232 and RS485 standards are protocol agnostic not defining any kind of message structure These standards were only designed to connect devices together so they could communicate using protocols RS232 is typically used for point to point communications that may be just a simple ASCII protocol or more complex masterslave protocol RS485 is selected for point to multipoint communications using a protocol that is masterslave in function See Annex H of IEEE Std C371-2008 for more information on RS232 and RS485 circuits including their distance limitations correct shield termination practices and the options available for extending the cable length
Selection of the termination method is heavily dependent upon end devices Some devices provide serial port connections that are DB9F terminal strips or RJ45 connectors There may or may not be a difference between what signals are present in each termination type It is highly recommended to use the termination form factor most common with the implementation DB9F when using serial RS232 terminal block when using RS485 and RJ45 when using Ethernet However this may not be the optimum approach for a particular application because signal pins are not available in one form factor versus another
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
20
1234567
89
10
11
12131415
161718
19
20
21
22
23242526
272829303132333435
363738394041
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
In other cases such as IRIG-B distribution there may be multiple port types supported by the IEDs and satellite clock For example the satellite clock IRIG-B output may only support a BNC connector and the IEDs support a variety of BNC terminal block and DB9 connectors One approach here might be to use coaxial cable as the main distribution bus with breakout cables to support the connection to the IEDs Use of a coaxial cable may provide added noise immunity and provide differentiation between other communication cables It may also be decided that STP cable is the better approach with appropriate converters to each of the IEDs and satellite clock
54 Cable system design
Cable system design includes issues related to raceway routing segregation and separation
541 Raceway designAnnex E contains more details on electrical cable raceway design noting that when metallic communication cables are installed in raceway without other electrical cables raceway fill is not required (Article 800 of NEC 2011) Fill ratios for metallic Ethernet cables may be in accordance with TIA-569-C pathway percent fill requirement when installed in a raceway without current carrying conductors
The metallic communication cable raceway will be different inside and outside the substation control house Inside the control house use of cable tray and conduit is common When installed in its own raceway that raceway should be supported per TIA-569-C NEC Article 800 contains the installation requirements for raceways that support metallic communication cables
In the substation yard use of cable tray conduit underground duct and a trench system is common Conduit and duct offers protection from crushing ground disruption rodents and other environmental abuse In addition the cable is easier to replace or upgrade in the future Several methods and types of conduit systems are used For example one configuration includes pre-manufactured segregated ducts or large ducts with multiple plastic high-density PE ldquoinner ductsrdquo installed inside The inner ducts can be smooth walled or corrugated either longitudinally or horizontally
One of the types of conduit used for buried communication cable is the continuous-reeled type Such continuous duct is popular because it is inexpensive and offers enough protection to allow the use of the less expensive cable constructions
542 RoutingMetallic communication cables are typically routed in a manner to increase electrical segregation as well as physical damage in order to maintain a high level of availability Also see Annex F for more routing information common to communication cables regardless of type Routing for diversity or redundancy is discussed in Annex I
543 Electrical segregationIf it is necessary to run communications cable in parallel with control or power cable it is recommended that the separation be as great as possible and consideration given to using a shielded cable While separation standards exist for Ethernet cabling it is good practice to follow the same requirements for all other metallic communication cables Metallic communication cables can be installed in a route that is parallel to control cable and AC power distribution cables TIA-569-C provides general guidelines for separation of metallic Ethernet cabling from branch power circuits in an office environment or a MICE E1 classification where pathway separation is generally not required TIA-1005-1 addresses separation in industrial spaces with an E2 and E3 MICE classification However power circuit types are not typical of a substation environmentrsquos CT and PT circuits
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
21
1234567
8
9
1011121314
15161718
192021222324
252627
2829303132
33343536373839404142
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Co-installation of telecommunications cable and power cable is addressed by TIA-569-C and the NEC where minimum separation requirements of electrically conductive telecommunications cable from typical branch circuits requires
a) Separation from power conductors
b) Separation and barriers within raceways and
c) Separation within outlet boxes or compartments
Zero pathway separation distance is permitted when the electrically conductive telecommunications cables the power cables or both are enclosed in metallic pathways that meet the following conditions
a) The metallic pathway(s) completely enclose the cables and are continuous
b) The metallic pathway(s) are properly bonded and grounded per TIA-607-B and
c) The walls of the pathway(s) have a minimum thickness 1 mm (004 in) nominal if made of steel or
15 mm (006 in) nominal if made of aluminum
No separation is required between power and metallic telecommunications cables crossing at right angles
In addition metallic communication cable should not be installed near fluorescent lights TIA-1005-1 requires metallic Ethernet cabling be separated from fluorescent lamps and associated fixtures by a minimum of 5 in
Also see Annex H for more information on electrical segregation common to communication cables regardless of type
544 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)
55 Transient protection
551 High-speed data circuitsThe following guidelines are provided for computer circuits and the circuits for high-speed data logging applications using low level analog signals
a) The circuits should be made up of STP cables For noncomputer-type applications such as annunciators shielding may not be required
b) Twisting and shielding requirements for both digital input and digital output signals vary among different manufacturers of computerized measuring systems Separation of digital input cables and digital output cables from each other and from power cables may be required Where digital inputs originate in proximity to each other twisted pair multiple conductor cables with overall shield should be used or multiple conductor cable with common return may be permitted and overall shielding may not be required Digital output cables of similar constructions may also be permitted Individual twisted and shielded pairs should be considered for pulse-type circuits
c) Cable shields should be electrically continuous except when specific reasons dictate otherwise When two lengths of shielded cable are connected together at a terminal block an insulated point on the terminal block should be used for connecting the shields
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
22
123
4
5
6
78
9
10
11
12
13
141516
1718
19
20
212223
2425
26272829303132
333435
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
d) At the point of termination the shield should not be stripped back any further than necessary from the terminal block
e) The shield should not be used as a signal conductor
f) Use of STP cable into balanced terminations greatly improves transient suppression
g) Use of a common line return both for a low-voltage signal and a power circuit should not be allowed (Garton and Stolt [B22])
h) Digital signal circuits should be grounded only at the power supply
i) The shields of all grounded junction thermocouple circuits and the shields of thermocouple circuits intentionally grounded at the thermocouple should be grounded at or near the thermocouple well
j) Multi-pair cables used with thermocouples should have twisted pairs with individually insulated shields so that each shield may be maintained at the particular thermocouple ground potential
k) Each resistance temperature detector (RTD) system consisting of one power supply and one or more ungrounded RTDs should be grounded only at the power supply
l) Each grounded RTD should be on a separate ungrounded power supply except that groups of RTDs embedded in the windings of transformers and rotating machines should be grounded at the frame of the respective equipment as a safety precaution A separate ungrounded power supply should be furnished for the group of RTDs installed in each piece of equipment
m) When a signal circuit is grounded the low or negative voltage lead and the shield should be grounded at the same point
552 Metallic cablesMetallic communication cable is vulnerable to transients that occur within a substation IEEE Std 1615 recommends metallic cable only within the same panel in all circumstances fiber or metallic cable between panels and fiber optic cable for cables leaving the control house and terminating in the substation yard Communication ports can be protected against transients when compliant to standards such as IEEE Std 1613 or IEC 61850-3 but error-free communications before during and after the transient is only specified by IEEE Std 1613
Cable shielding using metal braid or Mylar film is an important requirement for telephone cabling within a substation Crosstalk electromagnetic interference (EMI) and transient spikes can seriously affect the transmission of digital signals The most effective method to provide a low signal to noise ratio is to shield the individual pairs An overall shield limits exterior interferences but will not protect against internal coupling and cross-talk In general communications cable shields are grounded at one end to prevent ground loop potentials and the associated noise In cases where equipment designs require grounds at both ends capacitors can be used between the shield and ground to block dc voltages Isolation amplifiers have also been employed
Isolation devices may be used to protect communication ports that are not rated for substation transients per IEEE Std 1613 This can be accomplished using surge protection devices that are commonly available for RS485 circuits or fiber optic transceivers that are commonly available for RS232 RS485 and Ethernet ports
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
23
12
3
4
56
7
89
10
1112
1314
15161718
1920
21222324252627
2829303132333435
36373839
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
553 Isolation of telephone cablesIn general the local telephone company provides or requires the electric utility to provide one or more isolating devices in the substation When provided by the telephone company they may lease and leases the protection interface including its maintenance to the electric utility One or more of the following protection devices may be installed to protect against power-frequency GPR
Typically the following isolation equipment is used
a) Drainage unit (drainage reactormutual drainage reactor) is a center-tapped inductive device designed to relieve conductor-to-conductor and conductor-to-ground voltage stress by draining extraneous currents to ground
b) Isolating (insulating) transformers provide longitudinal (common mode) isolation for the facility They can also be used in a combined isolating-drainage transformer configuration
c) Neutralizing transformers introduce a voltage into a circuit pair to oppose an unwanted voltage They neutralize extraneous longitudinal voltages resulting from ground voltage rise or longitudinal induction or both while simultaneously allowing ac or dc metallic signals to pass
d) Optical couplers (isolators) provide isolation using a short-length optical path
For additional information on these methods see IEEE Std 487-2000 [B56] IEEE Std 1590 [B71] IEEE Std C3793 for cables carrying voice grade telephone circuits and the most current version of IEEE Std 789
56 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)
The pull tension of the communication cable being installed shall not be exceeded For metallic Ethernet cable this is 110 N (25 lbf) per TIA-568-C There are no cable specifications for RS232 and RS485 cables while USB cables are typically too short for pulling and the USB standard does not include any specification for cable pulling tensions For all cables always follow the vendor specifications on maximum cable pulling tension
TIA-569-C states that the following will impact cable pulling tension
a) Conduit size
b) Length of conduit
c) Location and severity of bends
d) Cable jacket material
e) Cable weight
f) Number of cables
g) Conduit material
h) Lubricants
i) Direction of pull
j) Firestopping
Conduit sizing is directly related to the planned diameter of the cable and the maximum pull tension that can be applied to the cable without degradation of the cable transmission properties It also depends upon
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
24
12345
6
789
1011
121314
15
161718
19
2021222324
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
3637
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
whether the cable termination is pulled with the cable or not The pull tension limit is based on the strength of the conduit (including sidewall pressure) the tensile strength of the pull line the geometry of the conduit system and the tensile strength of the cable The position of the bends and length of the conduit system will affect the pull tension that will be imposed on a cable Pulling cables from different directions may result in different pulling tensions Lubricants can be used to reduce pulling tensions but care should be practiced in lubricant selection taking into consideration compatibility with cable jacket composition safety lubricity adherence stability and drying speed
57 Handling
The conductors in communications cable are typically twisted pairs Cable performance will degrade when the cable is improperly handled Cable stress such as that caused by tension in suspended cable runs and tightly cinched bundles should be minimized Cable bindings if used to tie multiple cables together should be irregularly spaced and should be loosely fitted (easily moveable) The cable shall not be subjected to pulling tension exceeding the pulling strength rating of the cable The cable bend radius shall be greater than or equal to the minimum bend radius requirement during and after installation
See Annex K for common requirements for cable handling
58 Installation (see Annex L)
In order to support the full speed and capability of communication cables it is essential that the cables be installed with care to avoid kinks excessive pulling tension and exceeding the minimum bend radius of the cable TIA-568-C provides cabling installation requirements for Ethernet cabling
Communication cable installation shall meet the requirements of the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC) (Accredited Standards Committee C2-200211) Although the National Electrical Code (NEC) (NFPA 70 2007 Edition [B100]) is not applicable to substations under the exclusive control of electric utilities it provides valuable guidance
Probably the most common installation mistake is making tight bends in any communication cable Tight bends kinks knots etc in communication cable can result in a loss of performance The minimum bending radius should be considered by the engineer when specifying the communication pathway
Specific coefficients of friction depend on cable jacket type conduit type and the lubricant
59 Acceptance testing
Note that Annex M is not applicable to communication cables This clause covers test procedures for metallic communication cables
591 Ethernet cablesCommunication cable performance is dependent upon the quality of the terminations Unlike power and control cable the number of connectors available can vary greatly for communication cables Ethernet cables should be terminated per TIA-569-C Termination of other communications cables are generally not governed by standards Proper termination is usually confirmed by monitoring the communication channel for errors and finding no errors over an extended period of time such as days or weeks after termination
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
25
1234567
8
91011121314
15
16
171819
20212223
242526
27
28
2930
313233343536
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Many Ethernet cables in substations should be tested to meet TIA-1005-A which is for telecommunications cabling in industrial premises This standard provides additional requirements to the tests in TIA-568-C2 However this only covers Category 3 5e 6 and 6A and there are a variety of ldquoEthernet cablesrdquo so acceptance testing may be specified by any of the following
Category 3 5e 6 and 6A per ANSITIA-568-C2
Category 5 (1000BaseT) per TIA TSB-95
Category 6 per TIAEIA-568B2-1
TIA TSB-155 (for installed Category 6 cable to support 10GBaseT)
ISO TR 24750 (for installed channels to support 10GBaseT)
ISOIEC 11801 (for Category 1 2 3 5e 6 6A 7 and 7A in general purpose cabling systems)
EN 50173 as the European equivalent to ISOIEC 11801
IEEE 8023 10BASE-T 100BASE-TX 1000BASE-T
IEEE 8023an 10GBASE-T
For all other Ethernet cables follow the manufacturerrsquos recommendations
592 USB cablesUSB cables are tested to the USB specification but can be tested by third parties using the ldquoCables and Connectors Class Documentrdquo available from the USB website
593 Other cablesBecause of the low voltage requirements of non-Ethernet communication systems a continuity check for all conductors is all that is typically required but this can be difficult when the cable connectors are not located near each other In addition continuity does not mean that a communications cable will function properly There can be additional issues causing the problem such as improper
a) Cable shield connections
b) Cable ground connections
c) Signal wire connections
d) Connector installation
e) Cable selection
f) Cable capacitance
g) Termination (RS485 and IRIG-B typically exhibit these problems)
h) Power to connected devices andor port-powered converters
i) Application layer protocol configuration (ie Modbus IEEE 1815 (DNP3) etc)
This is typically why these cables are only checked when there is a communication problem
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
26
1234
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
151617
1819202122
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
510 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)
6 Fiber-optic cable
This clause covers the following for fiber optic communication cables within and to substations
1) General information regarding fiber optic cable types
2) Fiber types
3) Cable construction
4) Overall jackets
5) Terminations
6) Service conditions
7) Cable selection
8) Cable system design
9) Transient protection
10) Cable pulling
11) Handling
12) Installation
13) Acceptance testing
14) Recommended maintenance
61 General
Fiber optic cables are commonly used inside the substation fence because a substation typically has an electrically noisy environment (see IEEE Std 1613 and IEEE Std 1615) Fiber optic cables rely on the principle of the total internal reflection of light This means that fiber optic cables ldquoconductrdquo light (infrared or visible) over distances that depend upon the cable construction installation and transmitter strength and receiver sensitivity
Inside the substation fence fiber optic cable is commonly used to connect together substation IEDs instrumentation such as optical CTs and PTs and communication devices These devices are commonly located in the control house or somewhere within the substation yard typically in yard equipment cabinets Fiber optic cables are typically used in point-to-point links however one point may be a passive or active and allow the creation of multipoint fiber optic loops Metallic armored fiber optic cable should not be installed within a substation See clause 64
Fiber optic cables are also used to connect the substation IEDs to other equipment located outside the substation transporting communications between protective relays for protective relay applications between substations and interconnecting simple to large substation networks to utility enterprise and operational networks Refer to IEEE Std 1590 for fiber optic cable entering a substation and crossing the zone of influence (ZOI)
IEEE Standard Std 4872 (published in 2013) and IEEE Std 4873 as referencewill replace the existing IEEE Std 1590
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
27
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
1920212223
242526272829
3031323334
3536
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
All fiber cables have the same basic components that vary with the type of fiber core and cable construction as shown in Figure 4
a) Core The core is transparent to light and is typically made from glass or plastic
b) Cladding The cladding consists of an optical material on the layer outside the core that reflects or
bends the light back into the core Cladding is typically 125 μm thick
c) Buffer The buffer can be made of multiple layers that do not carry light The buffer protects the
inner layers from moisture and damage where moisture inhibits the performance of the core The
buffer also includes strength members typically made of aramid yarn to prevent the fiber from
breaking
d) Jacket The jacket provides the outermost layer or layers of protection for the fibers The jacket
materials depend on the application and serves as mechanical protection to the fiber core and
cladding inside Metallic and non-metallic armoring can be considered part of the cable jacket
Common types of fiber optic cable jackets with and without armoring are discussed in clause 64
Cable color and fiber colors have color codes per TIA-598-C when containing a single type of fiber
Figure 4mdashTypical fiber cable construction
62 Fiber types
Three types of optical fibers find common usage singlemode glass multimode glass and plastic Comparisons between cabled versions of glass fiber are shown in Table 4 based upon amendment 2 of IEC 11801 (for glass fiber) with TIA and IEC cross references Distances shown are typical
Table 4mdashFiber type characteristicsSpecification Multimode Singlemode
Plastic OM1 OM2 OM3 OM4 OS1 OS2ITU-T NA NA G6511 G6511 G6511 G652
Table 2G655C G655D
TIA NA 492AAAA
492AAAB 492AAAC-B 492AAAD 492CAAA 492CAAB
IEC 60793-2-10 Type (MM)IEC 60793-2-50 Type (SM)
NA A1b A1a1 Type A1a2 Type A1a3 B13 B4C B4D
Core μm NA 625 50 50 50 9 9
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
28
12
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
131415
1617
18
192021
22
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Cladding μm NA 125 125 125 125 125 125Laser Optimized NA No No Yes Yes No NoWavelength of transmitted light nm
NA 8501300
8501300
8501300
8501300
13101550
1310 1383 1550
Maximum attenuation dBkm NA 3515 3515 3515 3515 10 04Minimum modal bandwidth-length for overfilledlaunch at 850 nm(MHzmiddotkm)
NA 200 500 1500 3500 NA NA
Minimum modal bandwidth-length for overfilledlaunch at 1300 nm(MHzmiddotkm)
NA 500 500 500 500 NA NA
Minimumeffective modal bandwidth-length at 850 nm(MHzmiddotkm)
NA Not specified
Not specified
2000 4700 NA NA
100 MB Ethernet channel distance m
NA 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000
1 GB Ethernet channel distance m
NA 275 550 550 1000 2000 2000
10 GB Ethernet channel distance m
NA 33 82 300 550 2000 2000
40 GB Ethernet channel distance m
NA Not supported
Not supported
100 150 2000 2000
100 GB Ethernet channel distance m
NA Not supported
Not supported
100 150 2000 2000
Other types of fiber exist that are not in Table 4 Plastic fibers are not shown because there are no standards for plastic fiber optic cables Bend-insensitive fiber has been introduced for singlemode (BISMF) and multimode fiber (BIMMF) Bend insensitive fiber is of interest when tight bends can not be avoided in the cable installation Any bend insensitive fiber only addresses the optical performance at tight bends and does not change the fiberrsquos other capabilities Bend insensitive fibers are generally available in OM2 OM3 and OM4 multimode versions and singlemode versions Some manufacturers have decided to make all multimode fiber as bend-insensitive fiber Care should be used when testing bend insensitive fibers and when installing both normal and bend insensitive fiber It is still being argued within industry whether or not interoperability exists between standard and bend-insensitive fibers Standards for BIMMF and BISMF are
a) ITU-T G657 provides two categories of single mode fiber
1) Category A fiber that is ITU-T G652 compliant
i) A1 provides a minimum 10 mm bending radius
ii) A2 provides a minimum 75 mm bending radius
2) Category B fiber that is not ITU-T G652 compliant
i) B2 provides a minimum 75 mm bending radius
ii) B3 provides a minimum 5 mm bending radius
b) IEC 60793-2-10 for multimode fiber provides a 375 mm bending radius
c) ITU-T G6511 for multimode fiber provides a 15 mm bending radius
Table 5 compares the different fiber alternatives
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
29
1
23456789
1011
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Table 5mdashComparison of fiber types
Consideration Singlemode fiber Multimode fiber Plastic fiber (HCS)Distance Longest Moderate ShortestCost Moderate Moderate LowestUse Inter-substation fiber Intra-substation fiber
Moderate distances to outside substation
Intra-substation fiber of short length
621 Singlemode fiber Singlemode glass fiber has a fiber core diameter of about 9 microm which is much closer in size to the wavelength of light being propagated about 13 microm The result is that only a light ray at a 0deg incident angle can pass through the length of fiber without much loss The core is small enough to restrict transmission to a singlemode This singlemode propagation happens in all fibers with smaller cores when light can physically enter the fiber The mode depends on the wavelength of the light used as calculated by EIATIA-455-191 (FOTP-191) Singlemode fiber typically has a core diameter of 8 to 10 μm and uses near infrared wavelengths of 1310 nm and 1550 nm Because of a singlemode of light transmission the number of light reflections created as the light passes through the core decreases lowering attenuation and creating the ability for the signal to travel faster and farther than multimode
Because of the small core singlemode fiber transmitters require very precisely mounted lasers and the receivers require very precisely-mounted photodiodes The cost of the laser and associated driver circuitry contributes to the cost of fiber links Singlemode is used for high data rates or distances longer than a few kilometers
Cable performance classifications of singlemode fiber are unclear
OS1 is dispersion-unshifted singlemode fiber that has a nominal zero-dispersion wavelength at 1310 nm OS1 is appropriate to internal tight buffered cable construction OS1 is an old specification for singlemode fiber traceable to ISOIEC 11801 published in 1995 The term OS1 was introduced around 2002 OS1 is a general term used to specify singlemode optical fibers that comes under the heading of ITU-T G652
OS2 is dispersion-unshifted singlemode fiber that has a nominal zero-dispersion wavelength in the 1310 nm transmission window The origins of OS2 fiber are in the industrial premises standard ISOIEC 24702 and OS2 was introduced in 2006 These fibers are characterized by having a low environmentally stable attenuation coefficient in the vicinity of 1383 nm which is traditionally referred to as the ldquowater peakrdquo The low attenuation values of OS2 fiber are typically only realistic in loose tube cables or blown fiber where the original optical fiber is almost unaltered by the cabling process
There is a slight problem of guaranteed interoperability between OS1 and OS2 fibers because an OS1 cable is not simply an indoor version of an OS2 cable When using the OS1OS2 performance specifications make sure they are for the constructed cables and not just the optical fibers contained within them
622 Multimode fiberMultimode fiber has a core diameter that is relatively large compared to a wavelength of light 50 to 1000 microm compared to lightrsquos wavelength of about 1 microm Light can propagate through the fiber in many different ray paths or modes for this reason the name is multimode There are two types of multimode fibers the simpler and older step-index multimode and graded-index
Step-index fiber has same index of refraction (the ability of a material to bend light) all across the core Modal dispersion causes pulses to spread out as they travel along the fiber the more modes the fiber
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
30
1
2
3456789
101112
13141516
17
181920212223242526272829
303132
3334353637
3839
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
transmits the more pulses spread out Different rays travel different distances taking different amounts of time to transit the fiberrsquos length When a short pulse of light is transmitted the various rays emanating from that pulse arrive at the other end of the fiber at different times and the output pulse will be longer in duration than the input pulse This is called modal dispersion or pulse spreading which limits the number of pulses per second that can be transmitted down a fiber and still be recognizable as separate pulses at the other end This limits the bit rate or bandwidth of a multimode fiber A typical step-index multimode fiber with a 50 microm core is limited to approximately 20 MHz for one kilometer or a bandwidth of 20 MHzbullkm
Graded index multimode fiber has a gradual change in the index of refraction across the core from a maximum at the center to a minimum near the edges This design leverages the phenomenon of light traveling faster in a low-index-of-refraction material than in a high-index material The graded index allows light rays that travel near the edges of the core travel faster for a longer distance thereby transiting the fiber in approximately the same time as other rays traveling more slowly near the center of the core A typical graded-index fiber may have bandwidth between 200 MHzbullkm and 3 GHzbullkm Subsequently multimode fiber allows high data rates at long distances (for example 100 Mbps at approximately 2000 m) Multimode fiber transmitters typically use precision-mounted LEDs and the receivers use precision-mounted photo-diodes The main limitation of the media is the optical pulse dispersion which is predominant at high data rates and long distances
High performance multimode fibers are also available for use with gigabit Ethernet networks utilizing laser light sources Laser optimized cables are specifically designed for these networks because of the smaller optical budget limits or link loss budgets By optimizing the link loss of the cable longer cable runs are possible
The OM designations are to specify the cabled performance of the fiber and are as follows
OM1 is a legacy grade fiber originally was designed for use with 1300 nm LEDs that operate at speeds of 100 Mbps
OM2 fiber enables extension of legacy 50 μm MMF cabling and is typically used for entry-level 1 Gb speed performance
OM3 laser-optimized fiber is the minimum recommended performance level for new installations today OM3 is fully compatible with legacy OM2 installations
OM4 is a laser-optimized fiber that further extends the capabilities of OM3 and is fully compatible with legacy OM3 and OM2 installations OM4 is recommended when OM3 distance ranges are exceeded or it is anticipated they will be exceeded in the future
Using two different types of fiber in the same run should be avoided because it can cause severe losses Connecting a 50125 multimode fiber to a 625125 multimode fiber results in easy coupling of the smaller core of the 50125 to the 625125 fiber and is very insensitive to offset and angular misalignment However the larger core of 625125 fiber overfills the core of the 50125 fiber creating excess loss
623 Plastic fiberPlastic fiber optic cable as a general term can be organized into the following types of multimode cables
a) hard-clad silica (HCS)
b) polymer-clad fiber (PCF)
c) hard plasticpolymer clad silica (HPCS)
d) plastic clad silica (PCS)
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
31
1234567
89
1011121314151617
18192021
22
232425262728293031323334
35363738
3940
41
42
43
44
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
These plastic cables have a glass core and plastic cladding These typically have a step index profile and exhibit a limited bandwidth of approximately 20 MHzbullkm to 30 MHzbullkm The most successful implementation is HCS of a 200 microm or 230 microm size
There is also polymerplastic optical fiber (POF) that is made out of plastic with the core material as polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) and fluorinated polymers used for the cladding material POF could also be based on perfluorinated polymers (mainly polyperfluorobutenylvinylether) that offer greater bandwidth performance POF is transparent to light within the visible spectrum from 400-780 nm where the most commonly used LEDs and photodiodes work with red light at 650 nm The POF core size can be up to 100 times larger than the core of glass fiber
Plastic fiber losses are extremely high but the material is very inexpensive Plastic fiber selection can be driven by very low-cost LEDs and detected by inexpensive photo-transistors but the fiber can only be used over shorter distances that are also very typical in substation applications However there are no standards for plastic fiber
POF and HCS characteristics make it more suited for some applications over traditional glass fiber such as applications that require
very tight bend radius where these products may have a bend radius as low as 20-25 mm without excessive attenuation
visual troubleshooting where the assemblies transmit the signal using visible light making the user aware of its attachment to an active laser and allowing them to avoid associated dangers
wide tolerance for scratching and contamination (when using higher frequencies) that allows performance at an acceptable level despite some compromise in physical condition
resistance to an environment that includes strong vibration
POF is typically used for illumination and medical applications where communications is a specialty application and there are no standards for this POF as there are for multimode and singlemode fibers Care should be used when using POF from different vendors to ensure they are compatible
624 Cable constructionThere are a wide variety of fiber optic cable constructions using the fiber types discussed in the previous clause In addition to choices of fiber type the number of fibers can range from two to hundreds
In addition there is an internal dielectric tension member aramid strength member a duct that is integral with the cable and armor The cable diameter is a function of the construction and ranges from 4 mm to more than 20 mm Additional information about available cable constructions is available from various manufacturers Cable types are loose tube tight buffer and ribbon types
625 Loose tube cablesLoose tube cables are composed of several fibers inside a small plastic tube each tube is wound around a central strength member surrounded by aramid strength members and jacketed
The buffer tubes are color-coded A gel filling compound or water absorbent powder impedes water penetration through the loose tube and the fiber can freely move within the tube This construction provides a small high fiber count cable This provides less strain and the fiber expands and contracts with changes in temperature Loose tube fiber can be used in conduits strung overhead or buried directly into the ground In addition the fibers have better bending performances as the fiber inside can wander inside the loose tube cable Loose tube cables can be stretched more during installation without stressing the optical fiber Loose tube cables are most widely used in outside plant applications because it offers the best protection for the
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
32
123
456789
10111213
1415
16171819202122
232425
262728
29303132
333435
36373839404142
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
fibers under high pulling tensions and can be easily protected from moisture with water-blocking gel or tapes Some outdoor cables may have double jackets with a metallic armor between them to protect from chewing by rodents or kevlar for strength to allow pulling by the jackets Loose tube fibers can be constructed into cables that are armored all dielectric self supporting (ADSS) or optical ground wire (OPGW)
626 Tight buffered cablesTight buffered cables have the buffering material in direct contact with the fiber which tightly wraps around the optical fiber This provides a rugged cable structure for better mechanical protection of fibers during handling and installation The strength members are placed either after the outer cable jacket or around each individual fiber optic jacket which is often referred to as sub-jackets
Tight buffer cables are typically used when cable flexibility and ease of termination are important with the following types
Simplex and zipcord are used mostly for patch cord or jumper applications where the fiber is installed between patch panels between end devices or between end devices and patch panels Simplex cables are one fiber tight-buffered (coated with a 900 micron buffer over the primary buffer coating) with aramid fiber strength members and jacketed The jacket is usually 3mm (18 in) diameter Zipcord is simply two of these joined with a thin web Simplex and zipcord cable constructions may allow for indoor andor outdoor installations
Distribution cable is a very popular indoor cable because it is small in size and light in weight They typically contain several tight-buffered fibers bundled under the same jacket with aramid strength members and sometimes fiberglass rod reinforcement to stiffen the cable and prevent kinking These cables are used for short dry conduit runs riser and plenum applications The fibers are typically double buffered and can be directly terminated but because their fibers are not individually reinforced these cables need to be broken out or terminated inside a patch panel or junction box to protect individual fibers
Breakout cable is very popular for rugged applications for direct termination without patch panels Breakout cables consist of several simplex cables bundled together inside a common jacket This provides a strong rugged design however the cable is larger and more expensive than distribution cables Breakout cable is suitable for conduit runs riser and plenum applications Breakout cable can be more economic in some situations because there they require much less labor to terminate
627 Ribbon cablesRibbon cable is preferred where high fiber counts and small diameter cables are needed Ribbon cable has the most fibers in the smallest cable because all the fibers are laid out in rows in ribbons and the ribbons are laid on top of each other Ribbon cable is usually the lowest cost and 144 fibers may have only a cross section of about 32 mm 6 mm for the fiber and 13 mm for the jacket Ribbon cable is outside plant cable and can be filled with gel or water absorbent powder to prevent harm to the fibers from water
628 Overall jacketsThis includes temperature sunlight and exposure to water
Some available constructions include cables designed for the following
a) Indoor (plenum and riser)
b) Outdoor including
1) OPGW (see IEEE Std 1138)
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
33
12345
6789
10
1112
1314151617181920212223242526272829303132
333435363738
3940
41
42
43
44
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
2) all-dielectric self-supporting (ADSS) (see IEEE Std 1222)
3) wrapped (see IEEE Std 1594)
4) direct-bury armored
c) Multi-use or indooroutdoor
629 Indoor cable jacketsIndoor cables use flame-retardant jackets cables may have double jackets with metallic or non-metallic armor between them to protect from chewing by rodents or aramid for strength allowing the jacket to be pulled Indoor-outdoor cables have a PE outer jacket that can be removed to expose a flame-retardant inner jacket for use within buildings
The overall jacket should be suitable for the conditions in which the fiber optic cable will be installed The NEC 2011 designates the following indoor fiber optic cables
Optical Fiber Nonconductive Plenum (OFNP) cables have fire-resistance and low smoke production characteristics They can be installed in ducts plenums and other spaces used for building airflow This is the highest fire rating fiber cable and no other cable types can be used as substitutes
Optical Fiber Conductive Plenum (OFCP) cables have the same fire and smoking rating as OFNP cables but they have a conducting armor or central strength member which is usually steel OFCP cables must be properly grounded at both ends As a result OFCP cables can not be installed in the same cable tray or conduit as power cables
Optical Fiber Nonconductive Riser (OFNR) cables are used in riser areas that are building vertical shafts or runs from one floor to another floor OFNR cables can not be installed in plenum areas since they do not have the required fire and smoking rating as plenum cables
Optical Fiber Conductive Riser (OFCR) cables have the same fire rating characteristics as OFNR cables but they have conducting armor or central strength member such as steel OFCR cables should be properly grounded at both ends OFCR cables can not be installed in the same cable trays or conduits as power cables
Optical Fiber Nonconductive General-Purpose (OFNG) cables are typically used in horizontal cabling single floor applications OFNG cables can not be used in plenums or risers
Optical Fiber Conductive General-Purpose (OFCG) cables have the same fire characteristics as OFNG cables but they have conducting armor or central strength members such as steel OFCG cables should be properly grounded at both ends They should not be installed in the same cable tray or conduits as power cables
Nonconductive optical fiber general-purpose cable (OFN)
Conductive optical fiber general-purpose cable (OFC) Some fiber optic installations may require extra protection for the cable due to an installation environment with congested pathways damage due to rodents construction work weight of other cables and other factors Both metallic and dielectric armored options exist Inside a substation control house or other building use of indoor rated cables with metallic armor is avoided For discussion of armor see clause 642
When jacket coloring is used for indoor cable the color coding typically follows the following for indoor cable of a single fiber type for non-military applications per TIA-598-C
Yellow ndash singlemode optical fiber (TIA-492C000TIA-492E000) Orange ndash multimode optical fiber (50125 TIA-492AAAB 625125 TIA-492AAAA 100140) Aqua ndash Laser optimized 50125 micrometer multi-mode optical fiber (TIA-492AAAC) Grey ndash outdated color code for multimode optical fiber Blue ndash polarization-maintaining fiber
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
34
1
2
3
4
56789
1011
12131415161718192021222324252627282930313233
3435363738
3940
4142434445
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Other jacket colors may be used as long as they are agreed to by the user and manufacturer
The cable can also be installed in a colored conduit (or innerduct) in lieu of the jacket coloring to better differentiate the cable from the other substation cables
6210 Outdoor cable jacketsOutdoor rated cable requires protecting the fibers from the environment especially water Either a gel or absorbent tape or powder is used to prevent water from entering the cable and causing harm to the fibers Generally this applies to loose tube or ribbon cables but dry water-blocking is used on some tight buffer cables used in short outdoor runs Outside cables generally have black polyethelene (PE) jackets that resist moisture and sunlight exposure sometimes these jackets are color-coded like indoor cable when they indooroutdoor rated The cable can also be installed in a colored conduit (or innerduct) in lieu of the jacket coloring to better differentiate the cable from the other substation cables
Some outdoor cables may have double jackets with metallic or non-metallic armor between them to protect from chewing by rodents or aramid for strength allowing the jacket to be pulled Indoor-outdoor cables have a PE outer jacket that can be removed to expose a flame-retardant inner jacket for use within buildings
Fiber optic cable installed in underground applications may have an overall metallic armored jacket Metallic armored fiber optic cables are often installed for added mechanical protection Two types of metallic armor exist
Interlocked armor is an aluminum armor that is helically wrapped around the cable and found in indoor and indooroutdoor cables It offers ruggedness and superior crush resistance
Corrugated armor is a coated steel tape folded around the cable longitudinally It is found in outdoor cables and offers extra mechanical and rodent protection
Use of metallic armoring in fiber cables is avoided in substations and power plants The use of metallic armoring for fiber cables is a carryover from the phone companies that were not familiar with installations where there is substantial ground potential rise Metallic armored cable is terminated outside the substation to transition to another fiber cable type that is more appropriate for installation in a substation See IEEE Std 4872
OPGW is not considered metallic armored cable but when used should not be used for building entrance Even with the best grounding practices it is possible for a severe ground potential rise to vaporize a section of the fiber cable and damage other cables andor equipment or personnel in its proximity Typically OPGW cable is terminated in an outdoor cable enclosure where it is spliced to another cable type more suitable for building entrance
Dielectric-armored cable options exist offering the protection of armor without the requirement for grounding and bonding the armor and without the need for a conduit
6211 TerminationsLoose tube cables with singlemode fibers are generally terminated by splicing pigtails onto the fibers and protecting them in a splice enclosure Multimode loose tube cables can be terminated directly by installing a breakout kit or fan-out kit which sleeves each fiber for protection In each case the fibers are ultimately terminated with connectors
There are hundreds of fiber optic connectors that can be used to terminate fiber optic cables The ones in common use are shown in the Table 6 Multimode connectors typically follow the cable color code Singlemode connectors are blue when angle-polished singlemode are green Outlets are also similarly color coded In most cases the choice of a devicersquos fiber termination is done by a vendor who may
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
35
1
23
456789
1011
12131415
161718
19202122
2324252627
2829303132
3334
3536373839
40414243
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
provide no or limited options The introduction of the SFP (small form-factor pluggable) transceivers allows the user to install the transceiver appropriate for each application (fiber type and distance) SFP transceivers may usually use the LC connector but in some instances different connector types may be available to provide the desired connector type
Table 6mdashFiber optic cable connectors
Acronym
Name Standard Description SM MM POF Ferrulemm
ST 1 Stab and Twist2 Straight Tip3 Square Tip
1 IEC 61754-22 FOCIS 2
EIATIA-604-2
The most common connector used in substations that features an individual bayonet locking system for each fiber Similar in appearance to a BNC connector
Rare X 25
SC 1 Square Connector2 Stick and Click3 Subscriber
Connector4 Standard Connector
1 IEC 61754-42 TIA-568-A3 FOCIS 3
EIATIA-604-3
Contains housing for both fibers and has a push-pull locking mechanism Snaps into place Can be a single ferrule or duplex Replaced by LC connector
25
MT-RJ 1 Mechanical Transfer Registered Jack
2 Media Termination Recommended Jack
1 IEC 61754-182 FOCIS 12
EIATIA-604-12
Uses a latch mechanism similar to the 8P8C connector There are male and female connectors Only allows removal of both fibers
X 245times44 mm
LC 1 Little Connector2 Lucent Connector3 Local Connector
1 IEC 61754-202 FOCIS 10
EIATIA-604-10
Allows independent removal of the fibers Snaps into place Used for high density applications Commonly found on small form pluggable (SFP) transceivers Replaced the SC connector
X X 125
FC 1 Ferrule Connector2 Fiber Channel3 Face Contact
1 IEC 61754-132 FOCIS
EIATIA-604-4
A legacy competitor to the ST with better performance for single-mode fiber Have been replaced by SC and LC connectors Used for high density installations
X 25
SMA 1 Sub Miniature A Screws into place Considered obsolete
X X Varies
VPIN Snaps into place with push-pull coupling Used in industrial and electrical utility applications
X 22
V-pin (VPIN) Versatile Link and VersaLink and are all names given to the proprietary fiber optic connector originally developed by Hewlitt-Packard which is now owned by Avago These are connectors are not typically used on singlemode and multimode fiber cables
Single-mode fiber typically uses FC or ST connectors expect LC on high bandwidth equipment Multimode fiber typically uses ST connectors expect LC on high-bandwidth products (Ethernet) equipment
63 Service conditions
The service conditions listed in fiber optic cable specifications likely differ from the service conditions experienced in substations See Annex B for the general discussion of the mechanical ingress climatic or electromagnetic (MICE) characteristics IEC TR 62362 offers additional guidance on the selection of optical fiber cable specifications relative to MICE
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
36
1234
5
6
7
89
10
111213
14
15161718
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Mapping the MICE characteristics onto existing fiber optic cable standards will likely change the cable construction so the cable can perform within the required environment Fiber optic cables are typically classified as outside plant (OSP) or inside plant Environmental requirements are specified in several fiber optic cable standards where operating temperature is a typical concern in substations Telcordia GR-20 and ICEA S-87-640 contain reliability and quality criteria to protect optical fiber in all operating conditions installed as outside plant Outdoor cable standard ANSIICEA S-87-640 defines very low temperatures as -50 degC with normal operation of -40 to 70 degC
For indoor plant Telcordia GR-409 and ICEA S-83-596 define the environmental requirements ICEA S-83-596 defines normal operating temperature ranges for different types of indoor cable 0 to 70 degC for backbone horizontal and all interconnect cables -20 to 70 degC for riser and general purpose vertical backbone and 0 to 70 degC for vertical plenum The 2011 NEC Article 770179 requires all indoor optical fiber cables have a temperature rating of not less than 60 degC (140 degF) The TIA standards for multimode and singlemode fiber also contain temperature performance requirements over the range of -60 to +85 degC
For OPGW IEEE Std 1138 references TIAEIA-455-3 for a temperature range of at least ndash40 ordmC to at least 85 ordmC For ADSS IEEE Std 1222 references a temperature range of ndash40 ordmC to +65 ordmC For wrapped fiber IEEE Std 1594 references TIAEIA 455-3A for a maximum temperature range of ndash40 ordmC to 85 ordmC These standards also include other environmental requirements and tests for these types of cables
In addition to the service conditions for the cable service conditions for the optical connectors are also important The IEC 61754 series and the TIA-604 series have no temperature requirements for fiber optic connectors Annex A of TIA-568-C3 requires fiber optic connectors perform from -10 degC to 60 degC using TIA-455-4 (FOTP-4) and TIA-455-188 (FOTP-188) The referenced TIA-455 standards actually allow wider temperature ranges from -65 degC to 500 degC Connectors and cable used in the same environment should be rated for the same temperature range
64 Cable selection
Each fiber optic cable is typically specified with the following information for proper application Before starting the selection process determine the options available in the end devices for each fiber run including fiber type connectors wavelength and bandwidth These will likely impact the selection of fiber cables to be used as designated by
a) Fiber type
b) Buffer tube configuration
c) Number of total fibers
d) Cable jacket
e) Terminations
641 Fiber typeSelecting the proper fiber type (plastic multimode singlemode) typically follows the following steps
a) Calculate the distance involved (route)b) Determine the required bandwidthc) Determine the attenuation requirements
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
37
1234567
89
10111213
14151617
181920212223
24
25262728
29
30
31
32
33
3435
363738
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
If possible consideration should be given to using the same type of fiber and wavelength and mode-type throughout the substation This will minimize the number of converters needed but it is likely that all three fibertypes are required for different applications
Fiber type selection results in the specification of the following
a) Fiber type glass that can be single mode or multimode or plastic with the following
specifications
1) Corecladding diameter
i) Singlemode 9125 μm
ii) Multimode 50125 or 625125 μm
2) Fiber performance designation (including attenuationloss performance) as listed in the table
above
i) OM1 OM2 OM3 and OM4 for multimode
ii) OS1 and OS2 for singlemode
3) Wavelength of transmitted light
i) Singlemode is typically 1310 or 1550 nm
ii) Multimode is typically 850 or 1300 nm
642 Buffer tube configurationsLoose or tight
643 Total number of fibers and tubesCables with more than two fibers (ie patch cables) require selecting the total number fibers and number of tubes and number of fibers per tube requires color coding per TIA 598-C Total fiber cable capacity and the number of fibers per tube both typically contain even number of fiber counts based upon powers of two 2 4 8 16 32 64 etc This is not always the case and no standard exists for how many fiber strands are allowed per tube andor per cable
When fiber cables are terminated on each end by patch panels the total number of fibers and fibers per tube should be matched with the patch panel capacity so that any one fiber cable is not terminated across different patch panels
Consideration should be given in the final fiber count in providing adequate spare capacity Enough capacity ensures that the failure of individual strands can be easily replaced by using an available spare strand But this may also increase the number of supporting equipment (patch panels splice trays enclosure size etc) that will increase installation and maintenance costs
644 Cable jacketSelect the cable jacket characteristics required for the application These are typically based upon the following
1) Environmental considerations such as temperature2) Bend requirements3) Installation requirements such as low installation andor operating temperature
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
38
123
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
1718
192021222324
252627
28293031
323334
353637
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
4) Armoring but for safety as well as dependability avoid using any metallic armor in the fiber cable anywhere near a substation
5) Other
Cable jacket selection depends upon the installation location such as indoor outdoor or indooroutdoor See IEC TR 62362 for guidance on the selection of optical fiber cable specifications relative to mechanical ingress climatic or electromagnetic characteristics See Annex B for the applicable characteristics for a substation
Plastic fiber cables are typically the most inexpensive cables and connectors but are distance limited that may or may not impact their selection in the substation Multi-mode cables are less expensive to install less efficient than single-mode cables and are used for shorter runs within substations and outside substations The termination devices are less expensive than for single-mode Regardless of fiber the transmission distance is impacted by the optical loss of the cable the insertion loss of any splices or connectors the reflection loss of any splices or connectors and the transmitter power and receiver sensitivity
65 Cable system design
Because fiber optic cables typically have many strands of fiber in them they differ from other communication cables and require more planning and design Consideration should be undertaken at the start of the design for
a) Future expansion
b) Type of splicing to be used (fusion andor mechanical)
c) Type of connectors to be used
d) Patching of fiber strands to complete a communication path and subsequent location of patch
panels and splice enclosures
e) Level of system reliability required that may impact the routing
f) Pole clearance requirements when run overhead within or exiting a substation
g) Right of way or easements for boring or installing underground conduit when exiting a substation
With fiber cable system designs the use of lasers in equipment designed for long fiber runs may result in overdriving the receiver photodiode on shorter runs which can cause the fiber link to fail
Impurities in the glass fibers degrade the light signal within the fiber depending upon the wavelength of the transmitted light and the distance between transmitter and receiver When the signal is transmitted over great distances optical regenerators may be required to boost signal strength
The following clauses specifically address cable route design routing electrical segregation and separation of redundant cable
651 Cable route designFiber optic cable route design is more than just a raceway design where Annex E contains more details on electrical cable raceway design and Annex I contains information on diversityredundancy
Fiber optic cable route design includes raceway support hardware splice enclosures and patch panels Splicing is integral to the enclosures and patch panels
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
39
123
4567
89
1011121314
15
161718
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
2728
293031
3233
343536
3738
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
6511 RacewayWhen fiber optic cables are installed in raceway without electrical conductors raceway fill is not required (NEC 2011) raceway fill is only required when optical fiber is located within the same raceway as electrical cable (NEC 2011)
The substation fiber optic cable raceway will be different inside and outside the substation control house Inside the control house use of cable tray and conduit is common Trays and conduit dedicated for fiber runs may be colored yellow or orange for the specific application When installed in its own raceway that raceway should be supported per TIA-569-C NEC Article 770 contains the installation requirements for raceways that support fiber optic cables and compositehybrid cables which combine optical fibers with current-carrying metallic conductors
In the substation yard use of cable tray conduit underground duct and a trench system is common Conduit and duct offers protection from crushing ground disruption rodents and other environmental abuse In addition the cable is easier to replace or upgrade in the future Several methods and types of conduit systems are used For example one configuration includes pre-manufactured segregated ducts or large ducts with multiple plastic high-density PE ldquoinner ductsrdquo installed inside The inner ducts can be smooth walled or corrugated either longitudinally or horizontally
One of the types of conduit used for buried fiber optic cable is the continuous-reeled type Such continuous duct is popular because it is inexpensive and offers enough protection to allow the use of the less expensive cable constructions
Transitions from indoor plant to outdoor plant require careful planning when not using indooroutdoor rated fiber optic cable Proper patch panel placement is required to ensure proper transitioning between outdoor only cable to indoor only cable
For best transient avoidance use all-dielectric cable within a two inch PVC conduit where rodent protection is required For larger rodents use larger four inch conduit
6512 Support hardwareSupport hardware is used for connecting the cable to support structures such as poles or towers Fiber optic cable can include a messenger wire when not using ADSS cable trunions with a cushion for a typical pole connection deadend ties storage loops etc
For OPGW hardware can be dependent on existing transmission line structures and design if it is replacement of an existing static wire For a new transmission line there are different types of supports available
For OPGW hardware see IEEE Std 1591 For ADSS hardware see IEEE Std P15912
For storage loops there are H frames cross arms or spools available for poletower mounting that can be used with or without a splice enclosure mounting These are typically used to store the extra cable needed to remove the splice enclosure and bring it down to a hut or splice trailer for additional splicing or testing Other types of storage units exist that are typically for slack storage that can be utilized for restoration and repairs It is preferred to have stored fiber built into the design
Particular care for the cable jacket is very important with fiber optic cables Tight tie wraps staples clamps and such that may be acceptable for electrical cables should not be used with fiber cables Non-metallic cable straps (with ultraviolet protection and other proper environmental ratings) may be used without issue
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
40
1234
56789
10
111213141516
171819
202122
2324
25262728
293031
32
3334353637
38394041
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
6513 Splice enclosuresSplice enclosures are sealed canisters that mount on distribution or transmission poles with a storage loop or can also be hung from a cable These contain splice trays for splicing between two or more fiber optic cables There are multiple sizes of enclosures depending on the cable types counts and number of splices to be housed in the enclosure Bullet resistant covers are available for these as well if required Splice enclosures for fiber optic applications are required to seal so they prevent moisture from entering the closure Moisture is detrimental to the fiber splices Splice installation procedures may include a pressure test to verify that the assembly has been executed properly and that there are no leaks For example 5 psi may be pumped into the closure through an air valve and soapy water sprayed in the sealing areas to identify any leaks
Qualified products can withstand use in a variety of environments such as inside plant outside plant below ground above ground etc
Splice enclosures may also be required in an underground location either in a handhole or splice vaults GR-902 provides requirements for handholes and other below-ground non-concrete splice vaults
6514 Patch panelsPatch panels come in a variety of types from very small housing only 4 count cables to very large housing multiple large count cables and 96 or more terminations Patch panels can be ordered with pre-terminated fiber pigtails pre-terminated fiber cable of specified length or no pre-terminated connectors to the patch panel The pre-terminated type is preferred as field termination of fiber is very tedious and requires high precision for acceptable losses at the connectors Larger patch panels are typically located in a communications rack in substations and smaller patch panels in yard cabinets
Patch panels typically include connectors splice trays splice protectors hook and loop cable tie-downs fiber management spools and built-in strain relief lugs for securing fiber cable
When patch panels are installed on the front of cabinets the front rails should be recessed at least 4 inches to provide room for cable management between the patch panels and cabinet doors and to provide space for cabling between cabinets Similarly if patch panels are to be installed on the rear of cabinets the rear rails should be recessed at least 4 inches
Patch panels shall not be installed in a manner that prevents service access
Some implementers believe patch panels to be potential points of failure and prefer to minimize or avoid such connections as much as possible Patch panels and the additional connections can impact the overall systemrsquos reliability
Patch panels should be used to maintain system flexibility in a substation to accommodate frequent adds moves and changes Patch panels may require additional space in racks and cabinets They are also used to provide a centralized location for testing and monitoring
6515 SplicingThe most common type of splicing although the machines are expensive is fusion splicing due to accuracy and speed Mechanical splices are cheaper but generally require more time for installation and typically have losses ranging from 02 to over 10 dB depending on the type of splice Fusion splicing have lower losses usually less than 01 dB where a loss of 005 dB or less is usually achieved with good equipment and an experienced splicing crew
Mechanical splicing is also performed but these can be larger and take up more space in a splice tray When mechanical splices are used the size of the splice tray needs to be confirmed to properly contain the splices
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
41
123456789
10
1112
1314
15161718192021
2223
24252627
28
293031
323334
353637383940
414243
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Splicing of all fibers in a cable may or may not be required The number of splices required balances current needs against splicing time and costs
652 RoutingFiber optic cable routing follows the same principles as described in Annex F However unlike electrical conductors fiber optic cables have patch panels for interconnecting fibers that are similar to termination cabinets or terminal blocks However there is a significant difference because optical fibers are commonly spliced as an accepted practice
Plan the route using a detailed written plan of installation for each required run of fiber cable This plan includes the fiber cable specification location of equipment patch plans splice details testing requirements data forms for testing personnel experience level and assignment installation methods identification of potential problem areas safety issues etc
Ensure that the cable length is always long enough for the run because fiber splicing is expensive and complicates the design installation and testing Ensure that the route does not include any bends that exceed the cable bend radius
Ensure that patch panels are used to terminate cables inside the control house and inside yard cabinets
Fiber optic cable routing should follow the requirements of TIA-569-C regardless of support for Ethernet Care should be used when routing fiber cables through areas with different environmental requirements
NEC 2011 Article 77048 provides guidance on optical fiber cable that enters a building Unlisted conductive and nonconductive outside plant optical fiber cables are permitted in building spaces other than risers ducts used for environmental air plenums used for environmental air and other spaces used for environmental air This is allowed only when the length of the cable within the building from its point of entrance does not exceed 50 ft the cable enters the building from the outside and the cable is terminated in an enclosure like a patch panel or splice enclosure This exception allows for reasonable conversion from outdoor cable to indoor cable at a convenient location Nonconductive fiber optic cable does not need to be listed and marked where the cable enters the building from the outside and is run in raceway consisting of Intermediate Metal Conduit (IMC) Rigid Metal Conduit (RMC) Rigid Polyvinyl Chloride Conduit (PVC) and Electrical Metallic Tubing (EMT)
Once the cable system is completely designed calculate the link loss budget or power link budget or optical budget This calculation is based upon the fiber characteristics number of splices and connectors and transmitter power and receiver sensitivity If the losses are too great the design process needs to start again looking for ways to decrease losses such as reducing the number of splices or improving the fiber performance If the fiber run is too short the transmitter power may overwhelm the receiver causing the link to fail
653 Electrical segregation Electrical segregation is not required for non-conductive and conductive fiber optic cable but may be considered whenever copper and fiber cables reside in the same raceway In this case use of innerduct or other means of providing a dedicated raceway can be considered It is becoming more common to install a separate cable tray system for communication cables in substations thereby segregating control and power cable from communication cables This is required in other types of buildings such as data centers and IT rooms By segregating the two types of cables the installation reduces the risk of bend radius and crush-load violations of the fiber optic cables
In cable tray and trench fiber optic cable may be subjected to stress due to the weight of other cables which can induce micro-bending into the fiber optic cable Therefore it is a common practice to place the fiber optic cable in a separate duct installed in the tray trench or conduit (usually plastic) or use a cable
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
42
12
34567
89
1011
121314
15
1617
18192021222324252627
282930313233
3435363738394041
424344
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
construction with an integral duct This not only protects the cable but also allows easier identification from metallic cables
654 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)Since fiber optic cables also include splice closures and patch panels consideration should be given to keeping these facilities separated as well as the redundant cable
66 Transient protection
Transient protection is not required due to the inherent properties of the fiber unless metallic armored cable is used Unless armored fiber is used Annex G is not applicable Use of armored cable should be avoided within the substation due to the grounding requirements for the armor Armored fiber optic cable may be exposed to lightning induced AC voltage or other foreign electrical surges To protect personnel and equipment a low resistance path to ground or ldquogrounding pointrdquo is provided at any location where the cable armor is exposed such as splice joints and cable ends
Bonding and grounding of metallic armored fiber optic cable is often misunderstood or overlooked The NEC and several industry standards promote safe and effective bonding and grounding practices NEC Article 770 classifies a fiber optic cable containing non-current-carrying metallic components such as armor or metallic strength members as conductive This is why conductive fiber optic cables are bonded and grounded as specified in NEC-2011 Article 770114 Besides the NEC ANSITIA-568-C ANSITIA-569-B and ANSITIA-607-B also provide additional guidance Data centers have also relied on ANSITIAEIA-942 Some locations may have specific local codes for grounding and bonding that may differ from the NEC and industry standards Always consult the local authority having jurisdiction with specific questions regarding compliance
Understanding how to bond and ground a fiber optic system with armored cable can be confusing When all the components of a system are properly bonded together and grounded to the earth the risk associated with electrical current harming personnel or damaging property and equipment is reduced The first step is to bond the cable armor to the bonding conductor when the armor is exposed A bonding conductor is typically a short length of copper wire that can be strandedsolid insulatedcovered or bare such as 6-AWG copper strand that complies with both the NEC and ANSITIA-607-B
The bonding conductor can be attached to the armor by the use of a listed clamp lug or connector as stated in the NEC Once the clamp is installed vinyl tape can be applied around the clamp and exposed armor to protect the installer and the fiber from any sharp edges where the armor is exposed
For the metallic armor fiber optic cable to be fully grounded the bonding conductor is bonded ultimately to earth by connecting the bonding conductor to a dedicated path back to a ground grid or ground rod When inside a substation control house the dedicated path can be a direct run or created by attaching to a rack or cabinetrsquos bonding system that eventually connects to the substation ground grid
67 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)
There may be special design considerations requiring maximum pulling tension or minimum bending radius that cannot be calculated using the guidelines in Annex J Fiber optic cable pulling should follow the requirements of TIA-568-C In other situations follow the guidelines from the cable manufacturer
Depending on the cable construction the maximum allowable pulling tension on fiber optic cable on short runs of non-self supporting cable can vary from 200 N (45 lb) to more than 3000 N (680 lb) The maximum allowable tension for a particular fiber optic cable should be obtained from the cable manufacturer This
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
43
12
345
6
789
101112
131415161718192021
222324252627
282930
31323334
35
363738
394041
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
maximum recommended pulling tension should be noted on any drawings installation instruction etc The theory of pulling tension is the same for fiber optic cable as it is for metallic conductor cable Pulling tension can be calculated based on cable weight conduit system design and coefficient of friction
Fiber optic cables are often pulled for much longer distances than metallic conductor cables especially OPGW and ADSS runs originating from outside the substation These long pulls minimize the number of splices in fiber optic cable which introduce losses and reduce fiber performance The light weight of the cable internal tension members and tube or duct in the cable itself makes these long pulls possible Proper lubrication and good conduit installation are also necessities
The special nature of fiber optic cable pulling ie long pull lengths and longer pull durations require unique lubricants Lightweight fiber optic cable rubs on all sides of the conduit through the natural undulation of long straight runs Many common lubricants flow to the bottom of the raceway and lose effectiveness in this type of pulling
For ADSS cable tension see IEEE Std 1222 For OPGW cable tension see IEEE Std 1138 For wrapped cable tension see IEEE Std 1594
68 Handling (see Annex K)
Since optical fibers have only a thin buffer coating the fibers alone must be carefully handled and protected to prevent damage The glass fibers are usually well protected by buffer tubes duct armor etc which are part of the cable construction Even though the glass in the fiber is actually stronger (higher tensile strength per unit area) than a metal conductor there is very little cross-sectional area in a fiber available for strength and support For this reason most fiber optic cables have other components to provide the strength for cable support during pulling handling etc
For ADSS cable handling see IEEE Std 1222 For OPGW cable handling see IEEE Std 1138 For wrapped cable handling see IEEE Std 1594
69 Installation (see Annex L)
In order to support the full speed and capability of fiber optic cables it is essential that the fiber cables be installed with care to avoid kinks and excessive attenuation whenever the cables are placed vertically or bent Avoiding kinks and sharp bends is essential to the life of the fibers as well as their performance TIA-568-C provides cabling installation requirements for fiber optic cables used for Ethernet which can also be applied to other non-Ethernet applications (ie serial communications)
Fiber optic cable installations in the US should meet the requirements of the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC) (Accredited Standards Committee C2-200211) Although the National Electrical Code (NEC) (NFPA 70 2011 Edition [B100]) is not applicable to substations under the exclusive control of electric utilities it provides valuable guidance
Fiber optic cables in substations can be installed in the same manner as metallic conductor cables however this practice requires robust fiber optic cables that can withstand normal construction handling and still protect the fibers inside There are important differences to be considered in the handling and installation of fiber optic cable as compared to metallic conductor cable
Probably the most common installation mistake is making tight bends in the cable Tight bends kinks knots etc in fiber cable can cause micro-cracking or growth of flaws in the fiber with resulting loss of performance Minimum bending radius in fiber optic cable is typically in the range of 20 times the cable
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
44
123
45678
9101112
1314
15
161718192021
2223
24
2526272829
30313233
34353637
383940
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
diameter This bending radius should be considered by the engineer when specifying conduit bends and pull box openings or sizing guide pulleys sheaves mid-assist capstans etc
As with metallic conductor cable specific coefficients of friction depend on cable jacket type conduit type and the lubricant as well
Short-length fiber optic cable pulls may not require lubricant however for long or complex cable pulls lubricant is critical to making an efficient high quality installation The requirements for fiber-optic cable pulling lubricant are the same as those for metallic conductor cable
a) Compatibility with cable outer covering tube or duct
b) Complete and even coating on the cable for friction reduction at all friction points
c) Consistent low coefficient of friction (over time)
The eventual bandwidth available is highly dependent upon the quality of the workmanship exhibited in termination of fiber optic cables Glass fiber optic connector performance is affected both by the connector and by the glass fiber Concentricity tolerances affect the fiber fiber core and connector body The core optical index of refraction is also subject to variations Stress in the polished fiber can cause excess return loss The fiber can slide along its length in the connector The shape of the connector tip may be incorrectly profiled during polishing The connector manufacturer has little control over these factors so in-service performance may well be below the manufacturers specification
For installation of OPGW (see IEEE Std 1138-2009 [B66]) For ADSS installation see IEEE Std 1222 For wrapped cable installation see IEEE Std 1594
610 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)
Testing fiber optic cables connectors splices and closures fall into two categories factory testing and field testing Factory testing is sometimes statistical for example a process check A profiling system may be used to ensure the overall polished shape is correct and a good quality optical microscope to check for blemishes Optical Loss Return Loss performance is checked using specific reference conditions against a reference-standard singlemode test lead or using an ldquoEncircled Flux Compliantrdquo source for multimode testing Testing and rejection (ldquoyieldrdquo) may represent a significant part of the overall manufacturing cost
Field testing is usually simpler depending on the fiber run and splicing A special hand-held optical microscope is used to check for dirt or blemishes and an optical time-domain reflectometer (OTDR) used to identify significant point losses or return losses A power meter and light source or loss test set may also be used to check end-to-end loss Fiber optic cable should always be tested on the reel prior to installation after installation after splicing and then each fiber strand end-to-end Damage can occur to the fiber during any one of these operations which may make one or more fibers unusable if the problem can not be fixed
Prior to commissioning each fiber strand should be tested from both ends for both attenuation and light levels although IEEE Std 1138 does not require every strand of OPGW be tested It is imperative to test both directions to avoid the ldquoblindrdquo spots associated with the cable terminations If these cable test records are stored for future reference degradation of the network can be identified during maintenance
The IEC 61300 series provides basic test and measurement procedures for interconnecting devices and passive components such as connectors splices and closures GR-771 provides testing requirements for fiber optic splice closures
For optical Ethernet cables splices are allowed a maximum of 03 dB loss per the EIATIA-568-C standard This loss per splice may also be applied to any optical cable
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
45
12
34
567
8
9
10
11121314151617
1819
20
212223242526
272829303132
33343536
373839
4041
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
The use of lasers in equipment configured for long fiber runs may result in overdriving the receiver photodiode on shorter runs which can cause data errors In addition to checking the received optical power level for excessive attenuation the installer must also ensure that the maximum receive level is not exceeded If this occurs the use of an inline attenuator may be required
Care must also be exercised when using laser transmitters at long wavelengths and high speeds such as 1300 nm 1000BASE-LX over multimode fiber A phenomenon known as differential mode dispersion (DMD) can cause received data errors even when the optical power is within limits Mode conditioning cables can be used to reduce or eliminate these effects Decade-old 625125 micron cable is especially susceptible to DMD
For testing of OPGW see IEEE Std 1138 and IEEE Std 15911 for OPGW hardware For testing of ADSS see IEEE Std 1222 For wrapped cable testing see IEEE Std 1594
611 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)
7 Power cable (ac and dc lt= 1 kV)
Low-voltage power cables are designed to supply power to utilization devices of the substation auxiliary systems rated 1000 V or less
71 General
Low-voltage power cables are designed to supply power to utilization devices of the substation auxiliary systems rated 1000 V or less This may include but is not limited to low voltage power for station lighting receptacles control room auxiliary power motors switches transformers batteries etc Substation services include both AC and DC voltages
Cables range in size from 14 AWG to 2000 kcmil Triplex single conductor and three conductors per cable are typical cable constructions Both copper and aluminum conductors are used with copper cables being more common
In the United States cables are usually designed and constructed in accordance with NEMA WC 70ICEA S-95-658 [B97] UL 44 UL 83 or UL 854
72 Service conditions (see Annex B)
Differing conditions within a substation need to be examined to determine the appropriate cable to be used Some considerations are ambient temperature length and location of cables nominal system voltages expected fault levels normal and emergency loading conditions and expected lifetime of the systems or substations
Station service cable is likely to be exposed to open air at the transformer connections to the tray or weatherhead (REWRITE)
(WILL LIKELY BE MOVED TO ANNEX B)
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
46
1234
56789
1011
12
13
1415
16
17181920
212223
2425
26
27282930
3132
33
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
73 Cable selection (see Annex C)
731 Conductor sizingSee IEEE Std 835 for sizes based on ampacity and other factors
732 Voltage ratingIn the past some users found it prudent to install cables with insulation rated at a higher voltage level of 1000 V to prevent failures caused by inductive voltage spikes from de-energizing electromechanical devices eg relays spring winding motors The improved dielectric strength of todayrsquos insulation materials prompted most utilities to return to using 600 V rated insulation for this application Low-voltage power cable rated 600 V and 1000 V is currently in use
74 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)
75 Routing (see Annex F)
76 Transient protection (see Annex G)
77 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)
Consideration should be given to minimize insulation deformation when cable diameters differ greatly Consideration should also be given when dealing with cables that do not have compatible operating temperatures andor different voltage ratings When cable classifications are mixed the power cable ampacity is calculated as if all the cables were power cables
Segregating low-voltage power cables in the substation cable trench or cable tray system is generally not necessary In areas where low-voltage power cables are not normally expected it may be necessary to segregate or identify these cables so as to increase personnel safety
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
47
1
23
456789
10
11
12
13
14151617
181920
21
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
78 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)
79 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)
710 Handling (see Annex K)
711 Installation (see Annex L)
When single conductors are used in trays for two-wire or three-wire power circuits cables should be trained and securely bound in circuit groups to prevent excessive movements caused by fault-current magnetic forces and to minimize inductive heating effects in tray sidewalls and bottom
Consideration of circuit voltage drop may lead to cables larger than the available space in typical service panels and connectors Typical enclosure sizes and entryways may be replaced with larger enclosures and entryways in the design phase to account for the larger cable sizes or multiple conductors per phase This may reduce the possibility of for example having to use conductor reducing terminal connectors within an enclosure due to limited interior space or bending radius constraints
712 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)
Consideration should be given to using stress cones or stress relief at termination points for cables operating at circuit voltages greater than 600 volts
713 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)
Low-voltage power cables may be insulation-resistance tested prior to connecting cables to equipment These cables may be tested as part of the system checkout
The low-voltage power cable insulation resistance tests should measure the insulation resistance between any possible combination of conductors in the same cable and between each conductor and station ground with all other conductors grounded in the same cable
8 Medium voltage power cable (1 kV to 35 kV)
Medium-voltage power cables are designed to supply power to substation utilization devices other substations or customer systems rated higher than 1000 V
NOTEmdashOil-filled and gas-insulated cables are excluded from this definition and are not covered in this guide
The proper design of medium voltage power cable systems is dependent on many factors including system nominal voltage system fault level voltage drop conductor material insulation and shielding material type of ductwork (whether direct buried or in duct) phase spacing (and conductor spacing) phase arrangement number of conductors installed method of shield grounding earth thermal resistivity ambient temperature current loading load cycling and load factor These factors make it prudent to consult industry codes
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
48
1
2
3
4
567
89
101112
13
1415
16
1718
192021
22
2324
25
262728293031
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
81 Service conditions (see Annex B)
82 Cable selection (see Annex C)
821 Conductor sizingPhase transposition andor proximity heating should be considered for long runs of medium-voltage power cables See IEEE Std 835
822 Voltage rating and insulation levelFor medium-voltage cables it is usual practice to select an insulation system that has a voltage rating greater than the expected continuous phase-to-phase conductor voltage For solidly grounded systems (with rapid fault clearing) the 100 insulation level is typically selected The 133 insulation level is typically applied on systems where clearing time exceeds one minute but does not exceed one hour The 173 insulation level is typically applied where de-energization can exceed one hour or is indefinite The delayed clearing times are typically used with high-impedance-grounded or ungrounded systems (such as a delta system) where continuity of operations or an orderly shutdown is critical The 133 and 173 insulation levels may also be selected where the application meets the requirements of a lower level but additional thickness is desired
823 Cable constructionA shielded construction is typically used for 5 kV and higher rated cables The use of shielding and shield grounding of medium-voltage power cables minimizes deterioration of cable insulation or jackets caused by surface discharges (electrical stress) reduces the hazard of shock to personnel and confines the electric field within the cable
A shield screen material is applied directly to the insulation and in contact with the metallic shield It can be semiconducting material or in the case of at least one manufacturer a stress control material At the high voltages associated with shielded cable applications a voltage gradient would exist across any air gap between the insulation and shield The voltage gradient may be sufficient to ionize the air causing small electric arcs or partial discharge These small electric arcs burn the insulation and eventually cause the cable to fail The semiconducting screen allows application of a conducting material over the insulation to eliminate air gaps between insulation and ground plane
Various shield screen material systems include the following
a) Extruded semiconducting thermoplastic or thermosetting polymer
b) Extruded high-dielectric-constant thermoplastic or thermosetting polymer referred to as a stress control layer
83 Cable raceway design (see Annex E)
Medium-voltage power cable circuits are recommended to be installed in dedicated raceways Control protection instrumentation and communications circuits should not be installed in the same raceway as the medium voltage cables unless separated by a solid fixed barrier When installing cables in cable trays medium-voltage power cables should be installed in a single layer The sum of the cable diameters should not exceed the cable tray width
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
49
1
2
345
6789
101112131415
1617181920
21222324252627
28
29
3031
32
3334353637
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
84 Routing (see Annex F)
85 Transient protection (see Annex G)
An additional function of shielding is to minimize radio interference The selection of the shield grounding locations and the effects of single and multiple grounds are points to be considered for the proper installation of shielded cable The shielding recommendations contained in IEEE Std 575 should be followed
86 Electrical segregation (see Annex H)
Medium-voltage power cables should be segregated from all other cables and installed so that their voltage cannot be impressed on any lower voltage system Methods for achieving this segregation include the following
c) Installation of medium-voltage cables in raceways that are separated from low-voltage power and control cables and from instrumentation cables Installation of different voltage classes of medium-voltage power cables in separate raceways is also recommended Cables installed in stacked cable trays should be arranged by descending voltage levels with the higher voltages at the top
d) Utilization of armored shielded cables (separate raceways are still recommended)
87 Separation of redundant cable (see Annex I)
88 Cable pulling tension (see Annex J)
For additional information on pulling of dielectric power cables see AEIC CG5-2005 [B1]
89 Handling (see Annex K)
810 Installation (see Annex L)
The ends of medium-voltage power cables should be properly sealed during and after installation
811 Acceptance testing (see Annex M)
Shielded and unshielded medium-voltage cables should not be subjected to high-voltage dc tests insulation resistance tests are recommended (IEEE Std 400-2001 [B53])
812 Recommended maintenance (see Annex N)
Copyright copy 2013 IEEE All rights reservedThis is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft subject to change
50
1
2
3456
7
89
10
1112131415
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
2425
26
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex A
(informative)
Flowchart
Figure A1 shows the flowchart process for design and installation of cable systems in substations
Figure A1mdash Flowchart process for design and installation of cable systems in substations
51Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
START
Determine Service Conditions
Cable Selection
Determine Voltage Rating
Determine Cable Charactiristics Required
Determine Cable Construction Required
Are Communication Cables Applied
Is a New Cable Raceway Design Required
Route Cables in Raceway
Recheck that Conductor Sizing Cable Characteristics and Cable Construction
are Still Appropriate
Does Electrical Segregation Need to be
Considered
Is a Redundant Separate Cable Required
Are Cable Pulling Tensions Required
Ensure Proper Handling
Installation
Acceptance Testing
Determine Recommended Maintenance
Finish
User Design Checklist
Undertake Cable Raceway Design
Determine Electrical Segregation Required
Determine Separate Cable Requirements
Undertake Cable Pulling Tension Calculations
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Determine Transient Protection
Annex B
Annex C
Annex D
Annex E
Annex F
Annex G
Annex H
Annex I
Annex J
Annex G
Annex K
Annex L
Annex M
Annex N
No
No
No
No
1
2
3
45
678
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex B
(normative)
Service conditions for cables
The service conditions for electrical cables are as follows
a) Cables should be suitable for all environmental conditions that occur in the areas where they are installed (see ICEA and NEMA standards on cable for information concerning cable ratings)
b) Cable operating temperatures in substations are normally based on 40 degC ambient air or 20 degC ambient earth Special considerations should be given to cable installed in areas where ambient temperatures differ from these values as noted below
c) Cables may be installed in a variety of methods including direct buried duct banks conduits and trenches below ground or in cable trays conduits and wireways above ground or any combination thereof Cable may be required to be suitable for operation in wet and dry locations
d) Where practical the service life of the cable should be at least equal to the service life of the equipment it serves or the design life of the substation
e) Consideration should be given to the expected duration of emergency loading and fault levels
Items c and d also apply to communication cables Note that environmental conditions that are contained within IEEE Std 1613-2009 and IEC 61850-32002 should be carefully considered for any cables connecting to devices that are compliant to these standards especially communications cables An IED whose performance exceeds that of a connected communications cable is likely to suffer communication performance issues when the temperatures exceed the ratings of the cable but not the IED In this case depending upon the applications and function of the IED a cable failure may be just as serious as an IED failure When selecting the cabling for IEDs specifically communication cable careful consideration ensures that the cablersquos temperature ratings and IED temperature ratings are within the same acceptable range This allows the cable to perform when each IED is operating within its specified range
Note that some communications specifications include specific cable requirements For example the USB 20 cable specification requires an operating temperature range from 0 degC to +50 degC and be UL listed per UL Subject 444 Class 2 Type CM for Communications Cable Requirements Copper and fiber cables used for Ethernet have specific cable requirements in TIA 568-C0 where additional requirements are found in TIA 1005 for industrial premises
TIA 1005 and TIA 568-C0 include a ldquoMICErdquo classification for Mechanical Ingress ClimaticChemical and Electromagnetic environments The MICE concept was founded in Europe during the development of EN 50173-3 but is now completely harmonized at the international level in IEC 247022006 IEC 61918 TIA 1005 and TIA 568-C0 The MICE concept allows the description of the environmental conditions in a precise and unambiguous way But it should be noted that the MICE classification system is not a
52Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
567
89
10
11121314
1516
1718
1920212223242526272829
303132333435
363738394041
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
component test specification does not replace existing international or national standards and existing international or national standards for components contain the test requirements and schedules for product qualification Note that MICE does not cover all environmental characteristics as security problems such as protection against manipulation and attack safety for people and animals fire hazard and explosion risks are not covered by the MICE classifications In every case national laws and standards as well as safety regulations are taken into consideration
Substation communication cabling may traverse areas with a wide range of environments or may be localized along a cabling channel The MICE environmental classification is stated with the use of subscripts (MaIbCcEd) where a b c and d are sub-classifications that are numbered from 1-3 These sub-classifications relate to the severity of the environmental parameter where the most benign environmental classification is described as M1I1C1E1 and the harshest environmental classification is described as M3I3C3E3 For example the parameters for the climatic (C) element may be C1 in one parameter and another parameter may be C3 Since the harshest parameter severity applies the climatic classification would be C3 This applies to the other classifications so if the ingress classification is I1 the climaticchemical classification is C3 and the electromagnetic element is E2 this mixed environmental classification could be stated as M1I1C3E3 The severity of each MICE element is based upon the parameter with the worst-case harshness within the element Tables in this annex show a complete listing of elements and parameters except for the chemical characteristics See TIA TSB-185 for tutorial information on the MICE classification system
Table B1mdashReference for specific parameter boundaries for the mechanical classification
Parameter M1 M2 M3
Shock and bump in peak acceleration Note that for bump the repetitive nature of the shock experienced by the channel shall be taken into account
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M2
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M6
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M8
40 msminus2 100 msminus2 250 msminus2
Applies to areas in a commercial office building where products are mounted on light structures subject to negligible vibration
Applies to areas close to heavy machinery
Applies to areas on with extremely high vibrations such as power hammers
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 references IEC 60870-2-2 clause 4 which
states class Bm applies to substations and references IEC 60721-3 Value is 100 msminus2 with a half sine duration of 11 ms
Vibration in displacement amplitude (2 Hz to 9 Hz) and acceleration amplitude (9 Hz to 500 Hz)
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M2
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M6
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3M8
15 mm 70 mm 150 mm5 msminus2 20 msminus2 50 msminus2
Applies to areas in a commercial office building where products are mounted on light structures subject to negligible vibration
Applies to areas close to heavy machinery
Applies to areas on with extremely high vibrations such as power hammers
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 references IEC 60870-2-2 clause 4 which
53Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234567
89
10111213141516171819202122
2324
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
states class Bm applies to substations and references IEC 60721-3 Ranges are
10-15 msminus2 over a frequency range of 2 ndash 9 9 ndash 200 200 ndash 500 Hz with a displacement of 30 mm
Crush (TSB-1852009)
IEC 61935-2 and IEC 61935-2-20Test IEC 61935-2-20
There is no specific difference in the referencesCrush (ISO 24702-2006)
45 Nover 25 mm (linear)min
1 100 Nover 150 mm (linear)min
2 200 Nover 150 mm (linear)min
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 not specified
Impact (TSB-1852009)
IEC 61935-2-20There is no specific difference in the references
Impact (ISO 24702-2006)
1 J 10 J 30 JIEEE Std 1613 not specified
IEC 61850-32002 not specified
Tensile force (TIA-568-C)
This aspect of environmental classification is installation-specific and should be considered in association with IEC 61918 and the appropriate component specification
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 not specified
Bending flexing and torsion (TIA-568-C)
This aspect of environmental classification is installation-specific and should be considered in association with IEC 61918 and the appropriate component specification
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 not specified
From the comparisons in the tables above the MICE mechanical element for a substation can be M2 if using IEC 61850-32002 but when using IEEE 16132009 no specific requirements results in a user specification of the mechanical element
The I classification or ingress can be related to IP (ingress protection) code defined in IEC 60529 that uses a system of two numerical digits to define the level of both foreign object and moisture protection The highest level for MICE I3 designates environments that can be correlated to both IP codes and NEMA enclosures
Table B2mdashDescription of Protection Level for First Number in IP CodeNumber Description Definition0 Not protected1 Protected against solid foreign objects of 50 mm diameter and
greater2 Protected against solid foreign objects of 125 mm diameter
and greater3 Protected against solid foreign objects of 25 mm diameter
and greater4 Protected against solid foreign objects of 10 mm diameter
and greater5 Dust protected Protected from the amount of dust that would interfere with
54Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
4567
8
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
normal operation6 Dust tight No ingress of dust
Table B3mdashDescription of Protection Level for Second Number in IP CodeNumber Description Classification0 Not protected1 Protected against vertically falling
water dropsProtected against vertically falling water drops
2 Protected against vertically falling water drops when enclosure tilted up to 15deg
Protected against vertically falling water drops when enclosure is tilted up to 15deg
3 Protected against spraying water Protected against water sprayed at an angle up to 60deg on either side of the vertical
4 Protected against splashing water Protected against water splashed against the component from any direction
5 Protected against water jets Protected against water projected in jets from any direction
6 Protected against powerful water jets
Protected against water projected in powerful jets from any direction
7 Protected against the effects of temporary immersion in water up to 1 m
Protected against temporary immersion in water up to 1 m under standardized conditions of pressure and time
8 Protected against the effects of continuous immersion in water
Protected when the enclosure is continuously immersed in water under conditions that are agreed between manufacturer and user but are more severe than for classification 7 This may not mean that water does not enter the cabinet only that entering water produces no harmful effects
Table B4mdashReference for specific parameter boundaries for the ingress classification
Parameter I1 I2 I3
Particulate ingress (empty max)
No class No class No class125 mm 50 μm 50 μmIP2xMay be NEMA 1
IP4x IP4x and IP5xMay be NEMA 4 4X
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 references IEC 60654-4 as an applicable
guideline
Immersion IEC 60529 and IEC 60664-1No class No class No classNone Intermittent liquid
jetle125 lminge63 mm jetgt25 m distance
Intermittent liquid jetle125 lminge63 mm jetgt25 m distance andimmersion(le1 m for le30 min)
IPx0 IPx5 IPx5 IPx6 and IPx7May be NEMA 4 4X 6 6P
55Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 references IEC 60654-4 as an applicable
guideline
The National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) 250 standard includes protection ratings for enclosures similar to the IP code However the NEMA 250 standard also dictates other product features not addressed by IP codes such as corrosion resistance gasket aging and construction practices So it is possible to map IP codes to NEMA ratings that satisfy or exceed the IP code criteria it is not possible to map NEMA ratings to IP codes as the IP code does not mandate the additional requirements
Table B5mdashCross reference between IP Codes and NEMA EnclosuresIP Code Minimum NEMA Enclosure
rating to satisfy IP CodeIP20 1IP54 3IP66 4 4XIP67 6IP68 6P
From the comparisons in the tables above the MICE ingress element for a substation can be I1 I2 or I3 if using IEC 61850-32002 as a guideline when using IEEE 16132009 there is no guidance
The C element climaticchemical is shown here for climatic only Chemical environments are not typical to substations where the definition in IEC 60654-4 for Class 1 environments are those sufficiently well controlled so that corrosion is not a factor in determining corrosion See ISO 24702 for the complete definitions of the chemical characteristics
Table B6mdashReference for specific parameter boundaries for the climatic classification
Parameter C1 C2 C3
Ambient temperature
ISOIEC 11801 IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K8H
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K7
minus10deg C to +60 degC (connector only for C1)Note cable in referenced standard is minus20deg C to +60 degC
minus25deg C to +70 degC minus40deg C to +70 degC
56Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123456
7
89
10
1112131415
1617
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Parameter C1 C2 C3
Applies to commercial premises that may consist of either a single building or of multiple buildings on a campus
Applies to entrances of buildings some garages in sheds shacks lofts telephone booths buildings in factories and industrial process plants unattended equipment stations unattended buildings for telecom purposes ordinary storage rooms for frost-resistant products and farm buildings
Applies to weather-protected locations having neither temperature nor humidity control
IEEE Std 1613-2009ndash20 degC to +55 degC
IEEE Std 1613-2009ndash30 degC to +65 degC
IEEE Std 1613-2009ndash40 degC to +70 degC
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C1 (3K51K3)ndash5 degC to +45 degC
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C2 (3K6)ndash25 degC to +55 degC
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C3 (3K71K5)ndash40 degC to +70 degC
Temperature gradient
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K1
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K7
IEC 61131-2
01deg C min 10deg C min 30deg C minApplies to occupied offices workshops and other rooms for special applications
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C1 (3K51K3)05deg C min
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C2 (3K6)05deg C min
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C3 (3K71K5)01deg C min
Humidity IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K3
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K4
IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K5
5 to 85 (non-condensing)
5 to 95 (condensing)
5 to 95 (condensing)
57Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Parameter C1 C2 C3
Applies to normal living or working areas offices shops workshops for electronic assemblies and other electro-technical products telecommunications centers storage rooms for valuable and sensitive products
Applies to kitchens bathrooms workshops with processes producing high humidity certain cellars ordinary storage rooms stables garages For the more humid open-air climates they may also be found in living rooms and rooms for general use
Applies to some entrances andstaircases of buildings garages cellars certain workshops buildings in factories and industrial process plants certain telecommunications buildings ordinary storage rooms forfrost-resistant products farm buildings etc
IEEE Std 1613-2009 states 55 relative humidity outside of the device or enclosure or cover for a temperature within the defined operational and nonoperational ranges with excursions up to 95 without internal condensation for a maximum of 96 hIEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C1 (3K51K3)20 to 75
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C2 (3K6)10 to 100
IEC 61850-32002IEC 60870-2-2Class C3 (3K71K5)10 to 100
Solar radiation IEC 60721-3-3Class 3K3-3K6
IEC 60721-3-3 Class 3K7 IEC 60068-2-51975contains a table covering wavelengths from UV to IR that totals 1 120 Wmminus2
700 Wmminus2 1120 Wmminus2 1120 Wmminus2
IEEE Std 1613 not specifiedIEC 61850-32002 not specified
From the comparisons in the tables above the MICE climatic element for a substation can be C1 C2 or C3 if using IEC 61850-32002 but when using IEEE 16132009 C3 should be used
Table B7mdashReference for specific parameter boundaries for the environmental classification
Parameter E1 E2 E3
Electrostatic discharge IEC 61000-6-1IEC 61326
Electrostatic discharge ndash Contact (0667 μC) 4 KVElectrostatic discharge ndash Air (0132 μC) 8 KV
No descriptionIEEE Std 1613-2009 specifies tests at all of the following levels
contact discharge of 2 4 and 8 kVair discharge of 4 8 and 15 kV
IEC 61850-32002 not specified
Radiated RF ndash AM IEC 61000-2-53 Vm at (80 to 1000) MHz 10 Vm at (80 to
58Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
45
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
3 Vm at (1400 to 2000) MHz1 Vm at (2000 to 2700) MHz
1000) MHz3 Vm at (1400 to 2000) MHz1 Vm at (2000 to 2700) MHz
No description No description
IEEE Std 1613-2009 specifies 20 Vm rms The waveform shall be amplitude modulated with a 1 kHz sine wave Modulation
shall be equal to 80 with the resulting maximum field strength not less than 35 Vm rms The test carrier frequency shall be swept or stepped through the range of 80 MHz to 1000 MHz IEC 61850-32002 specifies either IEC 61000-4-3 class 3 (10 Vm) or IEEE C37902 (same reference as IEEE Std 1613)
Conducted RF IEC 61000-6-1IEC 61326
IEC 61000-6-2IEC 61326
3 V at 150 kHz to 80 MHz 10 V at 150 kHz to 80 MHz
No description No descriptionIEEE Std 1613-2009 does not specify
IEC 61850-32002 does not specify
Electrical fast transientBurst (EFTB) (comms)
IEC 61000-6-1 IEC 61000-2-5IEC 61131-2
IEC 613262001 Annex A Table A1
500 V 1000 V 1000 VNo description No description No descriptionIEEE Std 1613-2009 defines oscillatory and fast transient surge withstand capability (SWC) tests as distinct tests oscillatory is 2500 V and fast transient is 4000 VIEC 61850-32002 specifies oscillatory waves per IEC 61000-4-12 class 3 (2000 V line to ground and 1000 V line to line) and common mode disturbances up to 150 kHz as per IEC 61000-4-16 level 4 (not shown here) and fast transient waves per IEC 61000-4-4 class 4 and above (4000 V on power ports and 2000 V on signal and control ports) IEC 61850-32002 specifies surges as per IEC 61000-4-5 (test levels to class 4) with waveforms 1250 micros and 10700 micros and peaks up to 4000 V
Surge (transient groundpotential difference) ndashsignal line to earth
IEC 61000-6-2500 V 1000 V 1000 VNo description No description No description
IEEE Std 1613-2009 does not specifyIEC 61850-32002 does not specify
Magnetic field (5060 Hz)
IEC 61000-6-1 IEC 61000-6-1 IEC 61000-6-2IEC 61326
1 Amminus1 3 Amminus1 30 Amminus1
No description No description No descriptionIEEE Std 1613-2009 does not specify
IEC 61850-32002 does not specify
Magnetic field(60 Hz to 20000 Hz)
No reference No reference No referenceffs ffs ffsNo description No description No description
IEEE Std 1613-2009 does not specifyIEC 61850-32002 does not specify
59Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
ldquoffsrdquo (for further study) are preliminary and are not required for conformance to ISO 24702
Note the ISO 24702 provides guidance for the classification of electromagnetic environments in Annex F where distance from fluorescent lights is the most common for application to substations When the distance is less than 015 m this is classified as E3 greater distances may be classified as E2 or E1 Resistance heating can also be common to substation cabinets where a distance less than 05 m is classified as E2 and distances greater may be classified as E1 From this information and from the comparisons in the tables above the MICE electromagnetic element E for a substation can be E3 when using IEC 61850-32002 and IEEE 16132009
Note that for all above comparisons with IEC 61850-32002 where equipment forms an integral part of high voltage switchgear and control gear clause 2 of IEC 60694 applies and is not taken into consideration here
To summarize a substation environment could be classified as M2I1-3C1-3E3 but this depends significantly on the localized conditions and requirements for each substation There also may be several different ratings for a substation environment one for the control house and other for other areas like outdoor cabinets associated with circuit breakers transformers capacitor banks and other outdoor electrical equipment Applying the MICE concept to communication cables may allow for better selection of cables that are appropriate for the substation environment Care should be used to identify when cables are rated with their connectors or just the cables themselves It is common that communication cable connectors are provided separate from the cable so the ratings of the connectors also needs to be investigated because a connector failure can also lead to communication degradation and even to complete failure
60Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12345678
91011
1213141516171819202122
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex C
(normative)
Control and power cable selection
This annex provides guidance for selection of metallic type cables for various types of installations and applications The proper design of cable systems requires the consideration of many factors These factors include circuit application ambient temperature conductor temperature earth thermal resistivity load factor current loading system fault level voltage drop system nominal voltage and grounding method of installation and number of conductors being installed
C1 Conductor
The cable conductor is selected based upon cost-efficient material industry sizes ampacity requirements voltage drop and short-circuit criteria The selection of power cables may also include consideration of the cost of losses
C11 Material
One of the most important properties of a conductor material is its conductivity In 1913 the International Electrotechnical Commission adopted the International Annealed Copper Standard (IACS) that set the conductivity of copper to be 100 Conductors are typically specified based on this standard
Copper conductor may be uncoated or coated with tin lead alloy or nickel Normally uncoated conductor is used but coated conductor may be used to ease stripping of the insulation from the conductor and to make soldering easier Note that soldering is not a typical termination method for utilities
Aluminum conductor is usually electrical conductor grade which has a volume conductivity of approximately 61 that of copper For the same diameter aluminum conductors have a lower conductivity than copper Aluminumrsquos advantage is a 20 lower mass for equivalent conductivity
Control and instrumentation cable conductor is almost always copper Aluminum conductor may be considered for larger power cables Factors that influence the selection of either copper or aluminum for conductors include
f) Aluminum metal has historically been less expensive than copper
g) Aluminum conductor terminations require special treatment copper terminations do not
h) For equivalent ampacity aluminum conductor has a lower mass that makes it easier to handle for larger cable sizes
i) For equivalent ampacity copper conductor is smaller and can be installed in smaller raceways
61Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456789
10
111213
14
15161718
19202122
23242526
272829
30
3132
3334
3536
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
C12 Size
Conductor size is measured by its cross-sectional area expressed in circular mils (cmil) or mm2 One circular mil is defined as the area of a circle 1 mil (000 1 in) in diameter In North America conductors below 250 kcmil are assigned American Wire Gauge (AWG) numbers for easy reference The AWG number increases as the cross-sectional area decreases
1 cmil = 5067 times 10minus4 mm2 (07854 times 10minus6 in2)
Conductor size is selected to meet ampacity voltage drop and short-circuit criteria The selection of power cables may include consideration of the cost of losses
C13 Construction
Conductors may be either solid or stranded Solid conductors may be used for sizes up to 12 AWG Solid conductors larger than 12 AWG are stiff and difficult to install therefore stranded construction is normally used for these larger conductors Solid conductors are typically used for building wiring or lighting circuits but typically not used for control and instrumentation
The number of strands and size of each strand for a given size is dependent on the use of the conductor ASTM B 8-2004 [B4] defines the number and size of conductor stranding Common stranding classes are summarized in Table C1 The number of strands per conductor is standardized and is summarized in Table C2 Substation installations normally use Class B stranding for most field and equipment-to-equipment circuits and Class K stranding for switchboard (panel) wiring
Table C8mdashConductor stranding
Class Use
B Power cablesC Power cables where more flexible stranding than Class B is desiredD Power cables where extra flexible stranding is desiredG All cables for portable useH All cables where extreme flexibility is required such as for use on take-up reels etcI Apparatus cables and motor leadsK Cords and cables composed of 30 AWG copper wiresM Cords and cables composed of 34 AWG copper wires
Table C9mdashStranding construction
Class 14-2 AWG 1-40 AWG 250ndash500 MCM
B 7 19 37C 19 37 61D 37 61 91G 49 133 259H 133 259 427K 41 (14 AWG)
65 (12 AWG)- -
62Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2345
6
78
9
10111213
141516171819
20
21
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
C2 Ampacity
C21 Ampacity for power cables
The ampacity of a cable depends on the temperature of the surrounding air or earth the temperature rise of the cable materials and proximity to other cables The maximum temperature usually occurs at the conductor-insulation interface The maximum allowable insulation temperature limits cable ampacity
Maximum allowable insulation temperature has been determined through testing and experience for the commonly used materials and is a function of time For example for XLPE insulation 90 degC is the maximum acceptable continuous temperature 130 degC is the maximum for the duration of an emergency and 250 degC is the maximum for very short time durations (eg short circuits) The steady-state load short- time cyclic load emergency load and fault conditions are usually considered in determining the ampacity required for a cable
Losses (I2R) in the conductor and magnetically induced losses in the insulation shield and the raceway are the principal causes of the insulation temperature rise Shields or sheaths that are grounded at more than one point may carry induced circulating currents and reduce the ampacity of the cable The magnitude of circulating currents flowing in shields grounded at more than one point depends on the mutual inductance between the cable shielding and the cable conductors the mutual inductance to the conductors in other cables the current in these conductors and the impedance of the shield
Below-ground cables are usually installed in trench or duct or direct buried Above-ground cables are usually installed in conduit wireway tray or suspended between supports Cables may be routed through foundations walls or fire barriers and raceway may be partially or totally enclosed The installation that results in the highest insulation temperature should be used to determine the ampacity of a cable routed through several configurations
If a number of cables are installed in close proximity to each other and all are carrying current each cable will be derated The reason for derating is reduced heat dissipation in a group of cables compared with a single isolated cable or conduit Group correction factors should be used to find reduced ampacity of cables in the group
The cable materials themselves can affect heat transfer and ampacity For example the thermal conductivity of EPR is lower than that of XLPE and the ampacity of the EPR cable will be less for the same insulation thickness
The thermal conductivity of earth surrounding below-ground cables is one of the most important parameters in determining ampacity There is significant variation of earth thermal conductivity with location and time and IEEE Std 442-1991 [B55] provides guidance for earth conductivity measurements However many engineers have found it acceptable to use typical values For a typical loam or clay containing normal amounts of moisture the resistivity is usually in the range of 60 degC cmW to 120 degC cmW When the earth resistivity is not known a value of 90 degC cmW is suggested in IEEE Std 835
The ampacity of below-ground cable is also dependent upon the load factor which is the ratio of the average current over a designated period of time to the peak current occurring in that period Ampacities for typical load factors of 50 75 and 100 are given in IEEE Std 835
Methods for determining ampacity and the tables of ampacities for a large number of typical cable and below-grade and above-grade installation configurations are included in IEEE Std 835 In addition IEEE Std 835 includes guidance for determining ampacities for configurations not included in the tables
63Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3456
789
101112
13141516171819
2021222324
25262728
293031
32333435363738
394041
42434445
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Finite element techniques have been used to calculate below-ground cable ampacity These techniques will allow the designer to account for specific cable construction and installation details
C22 Ampacity for other cables
Ampacity of protection and control type cables are determined using applicable national codes For example in the United States the NEC [B 100] could be used
Most codes include derating factors that account for multiple conductors per raceways However for randomly installed cables in tray the industry accepted method for determining ampacity is given in NEMA WC 51ICEA P-54-440 [B95]
Cable ampacity should be equal to or larger than the trip rating of the rating of the circuit overload protection which is typically 125 of the expected circuit load
C3 Voltage drop
Voltage drop should be considered when selecting conductor size The voltage drop requirements should be such that the equipment operates within its design limits Voltage drop for motor feeders should be considered for both starting and running conditions to ensure the motor operates within its design limits
Voltage drop is calculated according to Equation (C1) as follows
ΔV =V SminusV L (C1)
where
ΔV is the voltage dropVS is the source voltage VL is the load voltage
An exact solution for calculating voltage drop may be determined using Equation (C2a) however an iterative approach is required since the load voltage is not typically known
V S=radic(V L cosθ+ IR )2+V Lsin θ+ IX )2(C2)
where
I is the load current R is the conductor resistance X is the load voltageθ is the load power flow angle
Rather in this case the voltage drop can be approximated based on conductor impedance and load current using Equation (C2b) as follows
ΔV =V SminusV L=IRcosθ+ IX sinθ (C3)
64Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
4
56
789
1011
12
13141516
17
18
19
202122232425
26
27
282930313233
34
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Equation (C2b) is not suitable for power factors less than approximately 70 such as for motor starting or larger cables with high reactance For situations like this Equation (C2a) may be used Alternatively computer software may be used to determine the exact solution Hand calculations will typically be done using the approximate solution
Voltage drop is commonly expressed as a percentage of the source voltage An acceptable voltage drop is determined based on an overall knowledge of the system Typical limits are 3 from source to load center 3 from load center to load and 5 total from source to load
Voltage drop is normally based on full load current However there is often diversity in the load on lighting and receptacle circuits and the actual load that may occur on a receptacle circuit cannot be accurately predicted In calculating receptacle circuit load for determination of conductor size a value of 60 of the receptacle rating is often used unless the actual load is known
The calculation of voltage drop requires knowledge of the conductorrsquos impedance determined as detailed in the following clause It is recommended that a voltage drop be calculated initially at the maximum conductor operating temperature because the ampacity is based on this too In cases where a cable will be sized based on voltage drop and one size is marginal for voltage drop voltage drop may be recalculated at the expected cable operating temperature
C31 Cable impedance
The impedance of a cable may be determined from tables or by calculation Calculations are commonly used for larger size high current cables since there may be many variables that affect the impedance For small conductor sizes table values may be used with only a small error
Table C3 provides parameters for common substation cables For other sizes refer to manufacturer catalogs
Table C10mdash Parameters for common substation cables (600 V insulation)
Conductor size Rdca
(mΩm)Rdca
(Ω1000prime)
Numberof
conductors
90 degCampacity
(A)
Approximate outside diameter (OD)
Nonshielded Shielded
(AWG) (cmil) (mm) (in) (mm) (in)
18 1620 2608 795 2 14 84 0330 102 04004 112 97 0380 113 04457 98 114 0450 131 051512 7 157 0620 173 068019 7 183 0720 198 0780
16 2580 1637 499 2 18 90 0355 107 04204 144 104 0410 121 04757 126 123 0485 147 058012 9 169 0665 185 073019 9 197 0775 213 0840
14 4110 1030 314 2 25 97 0380 113 04454 20 112 0440 128 05057 175 132 0520 157 062012 125 183 0720 199 078019 125 213 0840 240 0945
12 6530 650 198 2 30 107 0420 123 0485
65Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234
567
89
101112
131415161718
19
20212223
2425
26
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
4 24 123 0485 147 05807 21 156 0615 171 067512 15 203 0800 230 090519 15 248 0975 264 1040
10 10 380 407 124 2 40 119 0470 136 05354 32 146 0575 163 06407 28 175 0690 191 075012 20 240 0945 257 1010
8 16 510 255 078 1 55 71 0280 104 04102 55 160 0630 177 06953 55 170 0670 185 07304 44 187 0735 203 0800
6 26 240 161 049 1 75 89 0350 114 04502 75 180 0710 197 07753 75 192 0755 208 08204 60 211 0830 237 0935
4 41 740 101 031 1 95 102 0400 127 05002 95 206 0810 232 09153 95 230 0905 245 09654 76 251 0990 268 1055
2 66 360 0636 0194 1 130 118 0465 150 05902 130 248 0975 263 10353 130 263 1035 279 11004 104 290 1140 305 1200
a Ampacities and DC resistance are based on 90 degC conductor temperature and a 30 degC ambientb Ampacities are for raceways cable or earth (directly buried)c For four-conductor cables where only three conductors are carrying current the ampacity for a three-conductor cable may be usedd For ambient temperatures of other than 30 degC the correction factors under Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] should be used
Reactance values are not significant at power frequencies for the conductor sizes listed in the table
C311 DC resistance
The first step to determine the impedance is to calculate the dc resistance of the conductor This may be found from manufacturerrsquos published information from tables such as the NEC [B100] and NEMA WC 57-2004ICEA S-73-532 [B96] or estimated using Equation (C3) Equation (C3) is valid for a temperature range of approximately 100 degC When using tables it may be necessary to adjust the values to account for a different operating temperature or cable type
Rdc= ρ11A [1+α1 ( t2minust1) ] FS F L
μΩm (μΩft) (C4)
where
ρ1 is the resistivity of material at temperature t1 from Table C4A is the conductor area in mm2 (cmil)α1 is the temperature coefficient at temperature t1 from Table C4
66Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234567
89
10
111213141516
17
18
192021
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
FS is the stranding factor typically 102 for stranded conductor and 10 for solid conductor
FL is the stranding lay factor typically 104 for stranded conductor and 10 for solid conductor
t1 is the base temperature for other parameters 20 degC (68degF)t2 is the cable operating temperature in degC (degF)
Table C11mdashParameters for DC resistance
Conductormaterial Parameter Metric
(size in cmil)Metric
(size in mm2)Imperial
(size in cmil)
Copper (100 IACS)
ρ1 34026 Ω cmilm 0017241 Ω mm2m 10371 Ω cmilft
α 1 000393 degC 000393 degC 000218degFAluminum (61 IACS)
ρ1
[t1 = 20 degC (68degF)] 55781 Ω cmil m 0028265 Ω mm2m 17002 Ω cmilft
α 1 000403 degC 000403 degC 0 00224degF
Equation (C4) is used to calculate the resistance for a specific length of conductor as follows
Rdc=ρ1LA [1+α1 ( t2minust1) ] FS F Ltimes10minus6
(Ω) (C5)
where the parameters are the same as Equation (C3) and Table C4 except
L is the conductor length in meters (feet)
In many cases there is a need to determine the size for a desired resistance Equation (C4) may be rearranged to calculate the area and for convenience is given as the following Equation (C5)
A=ρ1L
Rdc[1+α1 ( t2minust1) ] FS F Ltimes10minus6
mm2 (cmil) (C6)
C312 AC resistance
For ac circuits the conductor resistance increases due to several factors that include conductor skin effect conductor proximity effect shield eddy currents shield circulating currents and steel conduit losses The ac resistance is determined from the following Equation (C6)
Rac=Rdc(1+Y cs+Y cp+Y se+Y sc+Y p ) (C7)
where
Rdc is the dc resistivity at reference temperature microΩm (microΩft)Ycs is the conductor skin effectYcp is the conductor proximity effect Yse is the shield eddy currentYsc is the shield circulating current Yp is the steel conduit losses
67Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123456
7
89
10
11121314151617
18
19
202122
23
24
252627282930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Note the factors used to calculate Rac are based on a per-unit resistance measured in micro-ohmsmeter (micro-ohmsfoot)
C3121 Conductor skin effectmdashYcs
The skin effect is caused by the varying current intensity that results in varying inductance through a conductorrsquos cross section The inductance is maximum at the center of the conductor and minimum on the surface Skin effect varies with temperature frequency stranding and coating and can typically be ignored for cables 350 kcmil and smaller (less than 1 impact) The skin effect factor is approximated using Equation (C7a) for Rdc in μΩm and Equation (C7b) for Rdc in μΩft
Y cs=11
( Rdc
3 28k S+13 124
Rdc k Sminus25 27
( Rdc kS )2 )
2
(C8)
Y cs=11
( Rdc
kS+ 4
Rdc kSminus 256
( Rdc k S)2 )
2
(C9)
where
kS is a constant from Table C5
Table C12mdash Recommended values for kS and kP
C3122 Conductor proximity effectmdashYcp
This effect is due to the force developed by currents flowing in the same direction in adjacent conductors which concentrates electrons in the remote portions of a conductor Ycp increases as spacing between conductors is decreased The factor is calculated using Equation (C8) Equation (C9a) and Equation (C9b)
Y cp= f ( xp)( DC
S )2 ( 1 18
f ( xp )+0 27+0 312( DC
S )2)
(C10)
68Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
C o n d u ctor typ e C o a tin g kS kP
C oncentric round N one tin or alloy 1 0 1 0 C om pact round N o n e 1 0 0 6
N O TE mdash This table is a sum m ary of Table II by N eher and M cG rath [B86]
123
4
56789
10
11
12
13
14
15
17
18
19
20212223
24
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
where
f(xp) is calculated according to Equation (C9a) for metric units or Equation (C9b) for imperial units
kP is a constant from Table C5DC is the diameter of the conductor in millimeters (inches)S is the center-to-center spacing of conductors in millimeters (inches)
For metric units
f ( xp)=11
( Rdc
3 28 k p+13124
Rdck pminus25 27
( Rdc k p )2 )
2
(C11)
For imperial units
f ( xp)=11
(Rdc
k p+ 4
Rdc k pminus 256
(Rdc k p )2)
2
(C12)
C3123 Shield eddy currentsmdashYse
These losses are negligible except in power cables Losses are produced in cable shields due to eddy currents produced in the shield as a function of conductor proximity Equations for calculating these losses are given in the Neher and McGrath reference [B86]
C3124 Shield circulating currentsmdashYsc
This is significant for single conductor shielded cables spaced apart Circulating currents will flow in cable shields when they are grounded at both ends This is accounted for by the factor Ysc calculated using Equation (C 10) as follows
Y sc=RS
Rdc ( XM2
X M2 +RS
2 )(C13)
where
RS is the dc resistance of conductor sheath in μΩm (μΩft)XM is the mutual inductance of shield and conductor in μΩm (μΩft)
The value of XM is dependent on the cable configuration Equation (C 1 1a) or Equation (C 1 1b) may be used for the typical situation where three single conductors are in the cradled configuration in a duct for 60 Hz See Neher and McGrath [B86] for other situations
For metric units
69Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2345678
9
10
11
12
131415
16
171819
20
21
222324252627
28
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
X M=173 6 log10( 2 SDSM )
(μΩm) (C14)
For imperial units
X M=52 92 log10( 2 SDSM )
(μΩft) (C15)
where
S is the axial spacing of adjacent cables in millimeters (inches)DSM is the mean diameter of the shield in millimeters (inches)
C3125 Losses in steel conduitsmdashYp
The magnetic field from current in cables causes hysteresis and eddy current losses in the steel conduit This heats the conduit and raises the conductor temperature When all three phases are in a conduit the magnetic field is significantly reduced due to phase cancellation For a single conductor cable there is no cancellation and the heating is significant so this situation should be avoided Loss factor may be calculated using Equation (C12a) for metric values and Equation (C12b) for imperial values
For metric units
Y P=6 89 Sminus0 89 DP
Rdc (C16)
For imperial units
Y P=089 Sminus0 115 DP
Rdc (C17)
where
S is the center-to-center line spacing between conductors in millimeters (inches)DP is the inner diameter of conduit in millimeters (inches)
C313 Reactance
The reactance of a cable is a function of the spacing between conductors and the conductor diameter Reactance is zero for dc circuits and insignificant for cable sizes less than 40 AWG For a three-phase circuit the per-phase reactance is given by Equation (C13a) or Equation (C13b) For a two-wire single- phase circuit the reactance will be twice that given by Equation (C13a) or Equation (C13b)
For metric units
70Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
567
8
91011121314
15
16
17
18
19
2021
22
2324252627
28
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
X=2 πf (0 4606 log10( S rC )+00502 )
(μΩmphase) (C18)
For imperial units
X=2 πf (0 1404 log10( S rC )+0 0153 )
(μΩftphase) (C19)
where
f is frequency in Hertz
Srsquo is equal to 3radic AtimesBtimesC for the configurations shown in Figure C1 in millimeters
(inches)rC is the radius of bare conductor in millimeters (inches)
Figure C2mdash Common cable configurations
C32 Load
Information on the load being supplied is required Typically load current and power factor are required Consideration should be given to whether the type of load is constant current constant power or constant impedance The characteristics of the different load types are summarized in Table C6 It is recommended that current be determined for the desired load voltage If the current is available only for a specific voltage then the current may be estimated using the formula in Table C6
71Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
A Equilateral Triangle
A
A
C
B
B Right Triangle
C
A
C Symmetrical Flat
C
B
C
A B
D Cradle
B
1
2
3
4
5
678
910
11
121314151617
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Table C13mdash Load characteristics
Load type Examples Characteristics Estimating for different voltage
Constant power Motorsmdashfull load lighting V uarr and I darr orV darr and I uarr
Inew = Iold (VoldVnew)
Constant impedance Motor starting heating I varies with voltage Inew = Iold (VnewVold)
C4 Short-circuit capability
All cables should be checked to ensure they are capable of carrying the available fault current The short- circuit rating of an insulated conductor is based on the maximum allowable conductor temperature and insulation temperature
Conductor temperature is dependent on the current magnitude and duration Equation (C14) is used to estimate conductor temperature and is valid only for short durations The maximum recommended conductor temperature is 250 degC to prevent conductor annealing
I SC=A radic486 9t F
log10(T 2+K o
T 1+K o) (amperes) (C20)
where
ISC is the symmetrical short-circuit current in amperesA is the conductor area in square millimetersK0 is the inverse of material temperature coefficient at 0 degC per Table C7tF is the duration of fault in secondsT1 is the conductor temperature before the fault in degCT2 is the conductor temperature after fault in degC
Table C14mdash Parameters for Equation (C14)
Conductor type K0
Copper 100 IACS 2345Aluminum 61 IACS 2281
In most cases the short-circuit current is known and the required conductor area needs to be determined and Equation (C15a) and Equation (C15b) may be used
For metric units
A=I SC
radic486 9tF
log10(T 2+K0
T 1+K0)
mm2 (C21)
For imperial units
72Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456
789
10
11
121314151617
18
192021
22
23
24
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
A=I SC
radic 0 0125tF
log10( T2+K0
T1+ K0)
cmil (C22)
The maximum insulation temperature is dependent on the material used Table C8 lists maximum temperatures for common insulation materials Conductor temperature should be limited to the insulation maximum temperature when the insulation maximum temperature is less than 250 degC
Table C15mdash Insulation material temperature ratings
Insulation material Short-circuit temperaturerating ( degC)
XLPE and EPR 250SR 300Paper rubber varnish cambric 200PE PVC 150
C5 Insulation
The selection of the cable insulation system also includes consideration of cost and performance under normal and abnormal conditions Dielectric losses resistance to flame propagation and gas generation when burned are the most common performance considerations
C51 Voltage rating
The selection of the cable voltage rating is based on the service conditions of Annex B the electrical circuit frequency phasing and grounding configuration and the steady-state and transient conductor voltages with respect to ground and other energized conductors
A voltage rating has been assigned to each standard configuration of insulation material and thickness in NEMA WC 57ICEA S-73-532 [B96] The selected voltage rating should result in a cable insulation system that maintains the energized conductor voltage without installation breakdown under normal operating conditions
C52 Thermal stability
The cable should maintain its required insulating properties when subjected to its rated thermal limit (the combination of its maximum ambient temperature and its own generated heat) during the service life
In some cable installations specifications may call for safe operation under high-temperature conditions PE has a maximum service temperature of 80 degC and therefore it should be replaced by other dielectrics where high-temperature operation is required Chlorosulfonated PE (CSPE) is normally only rated up to 90 degC so better choices include XLPE or EPR Silicone Rubber compound has been used in high-temperature cables (as high as 200 degC) or where cable fire propagation is a consideration
73Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2345
6
7
8
9101112
13
141516
17181920
21
222324
252627282930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Outdoor cables are typically rated 75 degC (eginsulated with heat resistant thermoplastic (type THWN) Typical indoor cables are rated to 90 degC (eg type THHN)
C53 Moisture resistance
The cable should maintain its required insulating properties for its service life when installed in wet locations especially underground
C54 Chemical resistance
The cable should maintain its required insulating properties when exposed to chemical environments The cable manufacturer should be consulted for recommendations for specific chemical requirements to which the cable may be exposed
C55 Flame propagation resistance
Cables installed in open or enclosed cable trays wireways or in other raceway systems where flame propagation is of concern should pass the IEEE Std 1202-1991 [B68] flame tests
C6 Jacket
The cable jacket or outer covering (if any) is selected to meet mechanical protection fire resistance and environmental criteria or to provide a moisture barrier for the insulation system
C61 Material
Jacket covering may consist of thermoset materials such as cross-linked chlorinated PE (CPE) or chlorosulfonated polyethylene (CSPE) thermoplastic materials such as PVC andor metal armor such as aluminum interlocked armor galvanized steel interlocked armor continuous smooth or corrugated extruded aluminum armor or continuously welded smooth or corrugated metallic armor with or without an overall nonmetallic sheath All thermoset and thermoplastic jacket covering materials shall be selected suitable for the conductor insulation temperature rating and the environment in which they are to be installed Other acceptable jacket cover materials include cross-linked polychloroprene (PCP) or cross- linked polyolefin (XLPO) In the past lead sheaths were commonly used but are being phased out due to the adverse effects of lead in the environment
C62 Markings
The jacket should be marked in a permanent fashion approximately every meter (few feet) with the following recommended information consecutive length manufacturer year of manufacture cable type size and voltage
C7 Attenuation
Attenuation is a ratio comparing the power of the signal at the beginning and the end of a communication cable Attenuation is measured in decibels per unit length and indicates the loss of signal in the cable
74Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
45
6
789
10
1112
13
141516
17
18192021222324252627
28
293031
32
333435
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
C8 Cable capacitance
Cable capacitance is the ability of cable to store electrical charge Capacitance is measured in picofarads per unit length High capacitance of communication cables slows down the signals High capacitance of long control cables 60 m and more (200 ft) may lead to transient overvoltages over circuit elements (relay coils contacts etc) during switching of the circuit resulting in the damage to these elements
75Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23456
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex D
(informative)
Design checklist for metallic communication cables entering a
substation
The following is a design checklist for metallic communications cable entering a substation
D1 Pre-design
Determine the equipment data transfer capacity and speed requirements (refer to IEEE Std 487-2000 [B56] and IEEE Std 1590 [B71] for more information on requirements) This information is usually obtained from the hardware or device manufacturer
Determine the level of reliability or operations integrity required for the individual system This information may be available from company policy documents or specific engineering or design standards
D2 Communications requirements
Determine service types and service performance objective classifications per IEEE Std 487-2000 [B56]
Establish the number of POTS (plain old telephone service) lines needed
mdash What is the number of voice circuits (normal and emergency)
mdash Are any extensions into the substation or switchyard required
mdash How many dial-up circuits are needed
a) Revenue meters
b) Transient fault recorder or protective relay interrogation
c) Security or fire alarms
mdash What dedicated telephone circuits are needed
a) Remote SCADA terminals
b) Protective relay tripping schemes
Is circuit-sharing equipment needed to limit the number of dial-up circuits
Define special requirements for coaxial cable [antennas or capacitive voltage transformers (CVTs)] CAT-5 or other application specific requirements for particular hardware
76Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
789
101112
13
1415
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
2728
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
D3 Cable protection requirements
Determine the GPR and fault current levels for the site This information is often obtained through other departments (eg planning department)
Define the level of protection required for EMF interference (shielding)
What level of physical security is needed (eg should cabling from the ROW (right of way) be enclosed in a rigid conduit in high risk areas)
Is the cable required to meet special application criteria (eg specific outer jacket design due to corrosive atmosphere coal generation or industrial processes nearby)
D4 Site conditions
Can common routesruns be used (eg the communications circuits run isolated from but in the same duct bank as station service power)
Are easements required for the telephone company or service provider
D5 Interface with telephone companyservice provider
Contact the telephone company or service provider with information from D 1 through D4
Determine the number and types of circuits including service types and service performance objective classifications for each circuit
Determine the number of circuit protective devices required for the determined GPR Generally one protective device is required per circuit Note that short fiber optic links eliminate the need for GPR protective devices however the cost of fiber to hard wirecopper multiplex equipment may be cost prohibitive for a small substation
Request the telephone companyservice provider installation costs for their equipment services and interconnection at the nearest public right-of-way
Request the telephone companyservice provider describe the monthly costs for all leased or rented circuits (POTS dedicated circuits high-speed interconnections)
Define the equipment to be provided by the telephone companyservice provider and by the substation owner
Obtain the telephone companyservice providerrsquos construction requirements for cabling and wallboard standards
mdash Is the owner required to provide a conduitraceway from the public ROW
mdash What type terminal blocks will be used
mdash Should the wallboard be ply-metal or another material
mdash What is needed to mount telephone companyservice provider terminal blocks
mdash Is a dedicated 120 V (ac) or 125 V (dc) power source needed
77Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
56
78
9
1011
12
13
1415
1617
18192021
2223
2425
2627
2829
30
31
32
33
34
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
D6 Cost considerations
Prepare an economic cost summary including the following
mdash Installation labor costs for the telephone companyservice provider internal utility company personnel and independent contractors
mdash Equipment costs for the hardware GPR circuit protection wallboard circuit or cable runs past the telephone companyservice providerrsquos terminal blocks grounding etc
mdash Total monthly rental costs
Examine possible alternatives and their associated economics eg microwave link for protective relay tripping schemes fiber optics for high-speed SCADA data transfer or relay interrogation
D7 Communications system design
Develop a basis of design for the complete system There may be general utility specifications and design criteria based upon experience and regional design criteria
Prepare a block diagram detailing the equipment locations (telephone board network router etc)
Define the communication cable types and routes (eg twisted and shielded pairs CAT-5 coaxial cables multiple pair cables)
Review the final design with the substation owner and maintenance crews and the telephone companyservice provider
78Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
34
56
7
89
10
11
1213
1415
1617
1819
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex E
(normative)
Cable raceway design
This annex provides guidance for both a means of supporting cable runs between electrical equipment and physical protection to the cables Raceway systems consist primarily of cable tray and conduit
When designing the raceway for communications cable keep in mind that there may be necessary requirements for separation of the communication cables from power and control cables to reduce EMI for some communication cables Care should be taken in protecting communication cables that are office rated and not rated for the substation environment They generally do not have control cable grade jackets and if run in an exposed area should be provided additional physical protection by the cable raceway design
Some communication cable may have a 600V jacket or may have a 300V jacket Cables with a 300V jacket are typically provided a mechanical separation from the power and control cables rated at 600V This may require a dedicated raceway for communication cables
It may also be necessary to provide separation or protection of the communication cable to prevent physical damage if the cable jacket is not suitable for the application
Adequate raceways should be provided throughout the cable path as a cable may traverse different environments in the control house This is not as common as in a commercial location but there may a separate communications room where the environmental conditioning may be much different than the main control room Always design the raceway and cable to the worst environmental conditions a cable will traverse
It is best to create a separate communication cable raceway that provides adequate separation and protection from existing control and power cables Because communication cables are used this cable tray may be much smaller than the main cable tray and simply hung below it Use of fiberglass materials for the tray is acceptable
E1 Raceway fill and determining raceway sizes
Raceways should be adequately sized as determined by the maximum recommended percentage fill of the raceway area Conduit fill is based on the following Equation (E1)
Fill=sumCableare aRacewayarea
times100 (E1)
Guidance for the maximum conduit fill is given in the NEC [B100] If the fill limitations and cable area are known the raceway area can be calculated and an adequate size can be selected
79Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456
789
101112
131415
1617
1819202122
23242526
27
2829
30
3132
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
E2 Conduit
E21 Conduit application
a) RMC or IMC zinc-coated conduit may be exposed in wet and dry locations embedded in concrete and direct buried in soil If they are installed direct buried in soil consideration should be given to the zinc coating having a limited life and corrosion may be rapid after the zinc coating is consumed or damaged
b) When used in cinder fills the conduit should be protected by noncinder concrete at least 5 cm (2 in) thick When used where excessive alkaline conditions exist the conduit should be protected by a coat of bituminous paint or similar material PVC-coated steel conduit may be used in corrosive environments Plugs should be used to seal spare conduits in wet locations
c) EPC-40 or EPC-80 conduit may be used exposed EPT and Type EB duct must be encased in concrete and Type DB duct may be direct buried without concrete encasement
d) Since ABS and PVC conduit may have different properties a review should be made of their brittleness and impact strength characteristics Coefficient of expansion should also be considered for outdoor applications Flammability of such conduits is of particular concern in indoor exposed locations Burning or excessive heating of PVC in the presence of moisture may result in the formation of hydrochloric acid which can attack reinforcing steel deposit chlorides on stainless steel surfaces or attack electrical contact surfaces The use of exposed PVC conduit indoors should generally be avoided but may be considered for limited use in corrosive environments
e) EMT may be used in dry accessible locations to perform the same functions as RMC conduit except in areas that are judged to be hazardous Guidance in the determination of hazardous areas is given in the NEC [B100]
f) Aluminum conduit (alloy 6061) plastic-coated steel conduit Type DB PVC or ABS duct EPC-40 or EPC-80 PVC conduit and FRE conduit may be used in areas where a highly corrosive environment may exist and for other applications where uncoated steel conduit would not be suitable Aluminum conduit may be exposed in wet and dry locations Aluminum conduit should not be embedded in concrete or direct buried in soil unless coated (bitumastic compound etc) to prevent corrosion Aluminum conduit may be used exposed or concealed where a strong magnetic field exists however conduit supports should not form a magnetic circuit around the conduit if all the cables of the electrical circuit are not in the same conduit
g) The cable system should be compatible with drainage systems for surface water oil or other fluids but preferably should be installed to avoid accumulated fluids
h) The cable system should be capable of operating in conditions of water immersion ambient temperature excursions and limited concentrations of chemicals Protection should be provided against attack by insects rodents or other indigenous animals
i) Cable trays conduits and troughs are sometimes run above grade in substations supported from equipment structures or specially designed ground-mounted structures Troughs constructed of concrete or other material may be laid on the grade Cost savings may be realized when comparing above-grade trays conduit and troughs to similar below-grade systems
80Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3456
789
1011
121314
151617181920212223
242526
272829303132333435
3637
383940
4142434445
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
j) Care should be taken in routing above-grade systems to minimize interference with traffic and equipment access and to avoid infringing on minimum electrical clearances
k) Above-grade systems are more vulnerable to fires mechanical damage environmental elements and seismic forces and offer greater susceptibility to electrostatic and electromagnetic coupling than if the cables were below grade
l) Above-ground pull boxes are sometimes used for distribution panels and for common connections such as current or voltage leads The judicious location of these boxes may result in considerable savings
m) Electrical non-metallic tubing (ENT) may be used as an inner duct to protect and segregate optical fibers and low-voltage communications cables in cable trench systems cable trays and in rigid electrical conduits By convention blue colored ENT is intended for branch and feeder circuits yellow colored ENT for communications and red colored ENT for fire alarm and emergency systems
E22 Conduit system design
E221 Exposed conduit
a) Flexible conduit should be used between rigid conduit and equipment connection boxes where vibration or settling is anticipated or where the use of rigid conduit is not practical Liquid-tight flexible conduit is commonly used for this application Flexible conduit length should be as short as practical but consistent with its own minimum bending radius the minimum bending radius of the cable to be installed and the relative motion expected between connection points A separate ground wire should be installed if the flexible conduit is not part of the grounding and bonding system See the NEC [B 100] for additional guidance
b) Where it is possible for water or other liquids to enter conduits sloping of conduit runs and drainage of low points should be provided
c) Electrical equipment enclosures should have conduit installed in a manner to prevent the entrance of water and condensation Drain fittings and air vents in the equipment enclosure should also be considered Expansion couplings should be installed in the conduit run or at the enclosure to prevent damage caused by frost heaving or expansion
d) The entire metallic conduit system whether rigid or flexible should be electrically continuous and grounded
e) When installed in conduit of magnetic material all phases of three-phase ac circuits and both legs of single-phase ac circuits should be installed in the same conduit or sleeve
f) All conduit systems should have suitable pull points (pull boxes manholes etc) to avoid over- tensioning the cable during installation
E222 Embedded conduits and manholes
a) Spacing of embedded conduits should permit fittings to be installed
81Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
456
789
1011121314
15
16
1718192021222324
2526
2728293031
3233
343536
3738
39
40
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
b) Conduit in duct runs containing one phase of a three-phase power circuit or one leg of a single- phase power circuit should not be supported by reinforcing steel forming closed magnetic paths around individual conduits Reinforcing steel in the manhole walls should not form closed loops around individual nonmetallic conduit entering the manhole Nonmetallic spacers should be used
c) Concrete curbs or other means of protection should be provided where other than RMC conduits turn upward out of floor slabs
d) The lower surface of concrete-encased duct banks should be located below the frost line When this is not practical lean concrete or porous fill can be used between the frost line and the duct bank
e) Concrete-encased duct banks should be adequately reinforced under roads and in areas where heavy equipment may be moved over the duct bank
f) Direct buried nonmetallic conduits should not be installed under roadways or in areas where heavy equipment may be moved over them unless the conduits are made from resilient compounds suitable for this service or are protected structurally
g) Conduits in duct banks should be sloped downward toward manholes or drain points
h) Duct lengths should not exceed those which will develop pulling tensions or sidewall pressures in excess of those allowed by the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations
i) Manholes should be oriented to minimize bends in duct banks
j) Manholes should have a sump if necessary to facilitate the use of a pump
k) Manholes should be provided with the means for attachment of cable-pulling devices to facilitate pulling cables out of conduits in a straight line
l) Provisions should be made to facilitate racking of cables along the walls of the manhole
m) Exposed metal in manholes such as conduits racks and ladders should be grounded
n) End bells should be provided where conduits enter manholes or building walls
o) Manholes and manhole openings should be sized so that the cable manufacturerrsquos minimum allowable cable bending radii are not violated
p) When installed in conduit of magnetic material all phases of three-phase ac circuits and both legs of single-phase ac circuits should be installed in the same conduit or sleeve
E23 Conduit installation
a) Supports of exposed conduits should follow industry standards See the NEC [B100] for additional information
b) When embedded in concrete installed indoors in wet areas and placed in all outdoor locations threaded conduit joints and connections should be made watertight and rustproof by means of the application of a conductive thread compound which will not insulate the joint Each threaded joint should be cleaned to remove all of the
82Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12345
67
89
10
1112
131415
16
1718
19
20
2122
2324
25
26
2728
293031
32
3334
35363738
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
cutting oil before the compound is applied The compound should be applied only to the male conduit threads to prevent obstruction
c) Running threads should not be utilized and welding of conduits should not be done
d) Field bends should not be of lesser radius than suggested by the NEC [B100] and should show no appreciable flattening of the conduit
e) Large radius bends should be used to reduce the cable sidewall pressure during cable installation and in conduit runs when the bending radius of the cable to be contained in the conduit exceeds the radius of standard bends
f) Conduits installed in concrete should have their ends plugged or capped before the concrete is poured
g) All conduit interiors should be free of burrs and should be cleaned after installation
h) Exposed conduit should be marked in a distinct permanent manner at each end and at points of entry to and exit from enclosed areas
i) Flexible conduit connections should be used for all motor terminal boxes and other equipment which is subject to vibration The connections should be of minimum lengths and should employ at least the minimum bending radii established by the cable manufacturer
j) Conduit should not be installed in proximity to hot pipes or other heat sources
k) Proper fittings should be used at conduit ends to prevent cable damage
l) Conduits should be installed so as to prevent damage to the cable system from the movement of vehicles and equipment
m) Conduit entrances to control buildings should be provided with barriers against rodents and fire
E3 Cable tray
E31 Tray design
a) Cable tray design should be based upon the required loading and the maximum spacing between supports Loading calculations should include the static weight of cables and a concentrated load of 890 N (200 lb) at midspan The tray load factor (safety factor) should be at least 15 based on collapse of the tray when supported as a simple beam Refer to NEMA VE 1- 2002 [B93] for metallic tray or NEMA FG 1-1993 [B89] for fiberglass tray
b) When the ladder-type tray is specified rung spacing should be a nominal 23 cm (9 in) For horizontal elbows rung spacing should be maintained at the center line
c) Design should minimize the possibility of the accumulation of fluids and debris on covers or in trays
83Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
45
678
910
11
1213
14151617
18
19
2021
2223
24
25
262728293031
3233
3435
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
E32 Tray system design
a) In general vertical spacing for cable trays should be 30 cm (12 in) measured from the bottom of the upper tray to the top of the lower tray A minimum clearance of 23 cm (9 in) should be maintained between the top of a tray and beams piping etc to facilitate installation of cables in the tray
b) Cables installed in stacked cable trays should be arranged by descending voltage levels with the higher voltage at the top
c) When stacking trays the structural integrity of components and the pullout values of support anchors and attachments should be verified
d) Provisions for horizontal and vertical separation of redundant system circuits are described in Annex I
E33 Tray application
The materials from which the tray is fabricated include aluminum galvanized steel and fiberglass In selecting material for trays the following should be considered
a) A galvanized tray installed outdoors will corrode in locations such as near the ocean or immediately adjacent to a cooling tower where the tray is continuously wetted by chemically treated water If an aluminum tray is used for such applications a corrosive-resistant type should be specified Special coatings for a steel tray may also serve as satisfactory protection against corrosion The use of a nonmetallic tray should also be considered for such applications
b) For cable trays and tray supports located outdoors the effect of the elements on both the structure and the trays should be considered Ice snow and wind loadings should be added to loads described in item a) of E31 Aluminum alloys 6061-T6 6063-T6 and 5052-M34 are acceptable with careful recognition of the differences in strength Mill-galvanized steel should normally be used only for indoor applications in non-corrosive environments Hot-dipped galvanized-after-fabrication steel should be used for outdoor and damp locations
c) When the galvanized surface on the steel tray is broken the area should be coated to protect against corrosion
d) Consideration should be given to the relative structural integrity of aluminum versus steel tray during a fire
E34 Tray load capacity
a) The quantity of cable installed in any tray may be limited by the structural capacity of the tray and its supports Tray load capacity is defined as the allowable weight of wires and cables carried by the tray This value is independent of the dead load of the tray system In addition to and concurrent with the tray load capacity and the dead load of the tray system any tray should neither fail nor be permanently distorted by a concentrated load of 890 N (200 lb) at midspan at the center line of the tray or on either side rail
b) A percentage fill limit is needed for randomly filled trays because cables are not laid in neat rows and secured in place This results in cable crossing and void areas which take up much of the tray cross-sectional area Generally a 30 to 40 fill for power
84Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2345
67
89
1011
12
1314
151617181920
21222324252627
2829
3031
32
33343536373839
40414212
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
and control cables and a 40 to 50 fill for instrumentation cables is suggested This will result in a tray loading in which no cables will be installed above the top of the side rails of the cable tray except as necessary at intersections and where cables enter or exit the cable tray systems
c) The quantity of cables in any tray may be limited by the capacity of the cables at the bottom of the tray in order to withstand the bearing load imposed by cables located adjacent and above This restraint is generally applicable to instrumentation cables but may also apply to power and control cables
E4 Cable tray installation
E41 Dropouts
a) Drop-out fittings should be provided when it is required to maintain the minimum cable training radius
b) Where conduit is attached to the tray to carry exiting cable the conduit should be rigidly clamped to the side rail When conduit is rigidly clamped consideration should be given to the forces at the connection during dynamic (seismic) loading of the tray and conduit system Conduit connections through the tray bottom or side rail should be avoided
E42 Covers
a) Horizontal trays exposed to falling objects or to the accumulation of debris should have covers
b) Covers should be provided on exposed vertical tray risers at floor levels and other locations where possible physical damage to the cables could occur
c) Where covers are used on trays containing power cables consideration should be given to ventilation requirements and cable ampacity derating
E43 Grounding
Cable tray systems should be electrically continuous and solidly grounded When cable trays are used as raceways for solidly grounded or low-impedance grounded power systems consideration should be given to the tray system ampacity as a conductor Inadequate ampacity or discontinuities in the tray system may require that a ground conductor be attached to and run parallel with the tray or that a ground strap be added across the discontinuities or expansion fittings The ground conductor may be bare coated or insulated depending upon metallic compatibility
E44 Identification
Cable tray sections should be permanently identified with the tray section number as required by the drawings or construction specifications
85Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234
5678
9
10
1112
1314151617
18
1920
2122
2324
25
26272829303132
33
3435
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
E45 Supports
The type and spacing of cable tray supports will depend on the loads Tray sections should be supported near section ends and at fittings such as tees crosses and elbows Refer to NEMA VE 1-2002 [B93]
E46 Location
Trays should not be installed in proximity to heating pipes and other heat sources
E5 Wireways
Wireways are generally sheet metal troughs with hinged or removable covers for housing and protecting wires and cables Wireways are for exposed installations only and should not be used in hazardous areas Guidance in the determination of hazardous areas is given in the NEC [B100] Consideration should be given to the wireway material where corrosive vapors exist In outdoor locations wireways should be of raintight construction The sum of the cross-sectional areas of all conductors should not exceed 40 of the interior cross-sectional area of the wireway Taps from wireways should be made with rigid intermediate metal electrical metallic tubing flexible-metal conduit or armored cable
E6 Direct burial tunnels and trenches
This clause provides guidance for the installation of cables that are direct buried or installed in permanent tunnels or trenches
E61 Direct burial
Direct burial of cables is a method whereby cables are laid in an excavation in the earth with cables branching off to various pieces of equipment The excavation is then backfilled
A layer of sand is usually installed below and above the cables to prevent mechanical damage Care should be exercised in backfilling to avoid large or sharp rocks cinders slag or other harmful materials
A warning system to prevent accidental damage during excavation is advisable Several methods used are treated wood planks a thin layer of colored lean concrete a layer of sand strips of plastic and markers above ground Untreated wood planks may attract termites and overtreatment may result in leaching of chemicals harmful to the cables
Spare cables or ducts may be installed before backfilling
This system has low initial cost but does not lend itself to changes or additions and provides limited protection against the environment Damage to cables is more difficult to locate and repair in a direct burial system than in a permanent trench system
E62 Cable tunnels
Walk-through cable tunnels can be used where there will be a large number of cables
86Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
234
5
6
7
89
101112131415
16
1718
19
2021
222324
25262728
29
303132
33
34
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
This system has the advantages of minimum interference to traffic and drainage good physical protection ease of adding cables shielding effect of the ground mat and the capacity for a large number of cables
Disadvantages include high initial cost and danger that fire could propagate between cable trays and along the length of the tunnel Fire hazards may be reduced by providing fire stops
E63 Permanent trenches
Trench systems consist of main runs located to bring large groups of cables through the centers of equipment groups with short runs of conduit smaller trenches or direct-burial cable branching off to individual pieces of equipment Typical trench configurations are shown in Figure E1
Figure E3mdashTypical trench configurationsDuct entrances may be made at the bottom of open-bottom trenches or through knockouts in the sides of solid trenches
Trenches may be made of cast-in-place concrete fiber pipes coated with bitumastic or precast material
Where trenches interfere with traffic in the substation vehicle crossoversmdashpermanent or temporarymdashmay be provided as needed Warning posts or signs should be used to warn vehicular traffic of the presence of trenches
The trenches may interfere with surface drainage and can be sloped to storm sewers sump pits or French drains Open-bottom trenches may dissipate drainage water but are vulnerable to rodents A layer of sand applied around the cables in the trench may protect the cables from damage by rodents Trenches at cable entrances into control buildings should be sloped away from the building for drainage purposes and be equipped with barriers to prevent rodents from entering the control building
87Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
45
6
789
10
1112
1314
1516
171819
202122232425
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
When selecting the route or layout of the permanent cable trench considerations should be taken to prevent the spread of cable or oil fires within the cable trench For more fire protection information reference IEEE 979
The tops of the trench walls may be used to support hangers for grounded shield conductors The covers of trenches may be used for walkways Consideration should be given to grounding metal walkways and also to providing safety clearance above raised walkways Added concern should be given to the flammability of wood
E631 Floor trenches
Trenches cast into concrete floors may be extensive with trenches run wherever required or a few trenches may be run under the switchboards with conduits branching to various pieces of equipment
Removable covers may be made of metal plywood or other materials Nonmetallic cover materials should be fire retardant Trenches cast into concrete floors should be covered It should be noted that metal covers in the rear of switchboards present a handling hazard and nonmetallic fire-retardant material should be used
Where cables pass through holes cut in covers for example in rear or inside of switchboards the edges should be covered to prevent cable damage from sharp edges
E632 Raised floors
Raised floors provide maximum flexibility for additions or changes Entrance from the outside into the raised floor system may be made at any point along the control house wall
Use of a fire protection system under the floor should be considered
88Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
4567
8
91011
12131415
1617
18
1920
21
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex F
(normative)
Routing
Ethernet cables may be routed per TIA-1005 with the understanding that a substationrsquos telecommunication spaces are not as widely varied as an industrial space and commercial space The number of moves adds and changes are rare in the substation environment resulting in the limited application of patch cables between Ethernet switches and IEDs The addition of patch panels for Ethernet represents another failure point that decreases the reliability of the communications path by introducing other elements with a finite reliability in an environment where communication failures may not be tolerated Similar routing could be applied to other communications cable such as serial coaxial and fiber cables
Cabling requirements (permanent link and channel) for category 3 category 5e category 6 and category 6A 100-ohm balanced twisted-pair cabling are specified in ANSITIA-568-C2 See ANSITIA-568-C2 for component transmission performance and ANSITIA-1152 for associated field test equipment requirements
Lack of separation between power and telecommunications cabling may have transmission performance implications Refer to requirements in 522 of TIA-1005 for Ethernet copper cable pathway separation from EMI sources
Routing for redundancy or diversity is addressed in Annex I
F1 Length
Cable routing in the switchyard should provide the shortest possible runs where practical to minimize voltage drops in the auxiliary power and control cables and loss of signal in a communication cable etc as well as to reduce amount of cable required
F2 Turns
Layouts should be designed to avoid sharp corners and provide adequate space to meet bending radius and cable pull requirements for specific types of cables Layouts should consider future installation of foundations and cable routings It may be beneficial to have cable layouts perpendicular or parallel to the main buses to avoid crossing at angles and to maximize routing space
F3 Physical location and grouping
Physical separation of redundant cable systems generally utilize separate raceway systems or barriers within raceways such as cable trays and cable trenches to isolate wiring of normal power supplies primary relaying and control and the primary battery system from the wiring of backup power supplies backup or secondary relaying and control and the secondary battery system
Physical separation between a transient source and other cables is an effective means of transient control Because mutual capacitance and mutual inductance are greatly influenced by
89Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456789
1011
12131415
161718
19
20
212223
24
2526272829
30
3132333435
3637
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
circuit spacing small increases in distance may produce substantial decreases in interaction between circuits (Dietrich et al [B11])
Shield conductors on both sides of the cable trench or a single conductor on the EHV bus side of the cable trench can reduce induced transient voltage A shield conductor above conduits directly buried in the ground may also reduce transient voltages To help further reduce transient voltages control cables can be routed perpendicular to the EHV busses Maximum practical separation between control cables and EHV buses that are in parallel should be maintained Where possible control cables should be routed perpendicular to EHV (345 kV or greater) busses (ldquoInduced transient voltage reductions in Bonneville Power Administration 500 kV substationrdquo [B25] ldquoProtection against transientsrdquo [B104]) When control cables must be run parallel to EHV busses maximum practical separation should be maintained between the cables and the busses (Dietrich et al [B11]) and it is recommended to place a ground conductor in the cable trench above the shielded control cables on the side of the trench closest to the overhead bus or preferably both sides of the trench
NOTEmdashTests indicate that in some cases nonshielded control cables may be used without paralleling ground cables when they are parallel and are located at a distance greater than 15 m (50 ft) from or are perpendicular to a typical 345 kV bus (Garton and Stolt [B22])
Great care should be exercised in routing cables through areas of potentially high ground grid current (either power-frequency or high-frequency currents) (ldquoInduced transient voltage reductions in Bonneville Power Administration 500 kV substationrdquo [B25]) When practical control cables may be installed below the main ground grid
All cables from the same equipment should be close together particularly to the first manhole or equivalent in the switchyard (ldquoInduced transient voltage reductions in Bonneville Power Administration 500 kV substationrdquo [B25])
Cables connected to equipment having comparable sensitivities should be grouped together and then the maximum separation should be maintained between groups High-voltage cables should not be in duct runs or trenches with control cables (Dietrich et al [B1 1] ldquoInduced transient voltage reductions in Bonneville Power Administration 500 kV substationrdquo [B25] ldquoProtection against transientsrdquo [B104])
F4 Fire impact
For cases where possible catastrophic failure of equipment leads to fire all critical cables may be routed to avoid coincidental fire damage This affects the proximity routing of trenches and the use of radial raceways rather than a grouped raceway
Cable trenches may be installed at a higher elevation than the surrounding area to limit the possibility of oil or flaming oil from entering the cable trench Stacking cable trays with primary and backup systems should be avoided to reduce the possibility of a fire damaging both systems
90Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3456789
1011121314
151617
18192021
222324
2526272829
30
313233
34353637
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex G
(normative)
Transient protection of instrumentation control and power cable
This annex provides information on the origin of transients in substations and guidance for cable shielding and shield grounding for medium-voltage power instrumentation control coaxial and triaxial cable systems
G1 Origin of transients in substations
This clause provides information on the origins of EMI voltages in the substation environment
G11 Switching arcs
One of the most frequently encountered sources of EMI in high-voltage yards (230 kV and higher voltage) is during energization or de-energization of the bus by an air-break switch or a circuit switcher Typically during this type of switching intense and repeated sparkovers occur across the gap between the moving arms At each sparkover oscillatory transient currents with 200 A to 1500 A crests circulate in buses in the ground grid in bushing capacitances in CVTs and in other apparatus with significant capacitances to ground The number of individual transients in an opening or closing operation can vary from 5 000 to 10 000 (Gavazza and Wiggins [B23])
The transients are coupled to the low-voltage wiring by three basic modes These are as follows
a) Radiated magnetic or electric field coupling
b) Conducted coupling through stray capacitances such as those associated with
bushings CTs and CVTs
c) Conductive voltage gradients across ground grid conductors
G12 Capacitor bank switching
Switching of grounded capacitance banks introduces transients in overhead buses and in the ground grid In many instances design requirements dictate installation of several banks in parallel This necessitates ldquoback-to-backrdquo switching of two or more banks The ldquoback-to-backrdquo switching of large capacitor banks by a circuit switcher can produce an intense transient electromagnetic field in the vicinity of the banks These high-energy transients typically couple to cables through the overhead bus and the ground grid conductors
In many respects these switching transients are similar to those generated by an air break switch energizing or de-energizing a section of bus These transients differ from the other transients in regards to the magnitude of the transient current and its associated frequencies While the current magnitudes range from 5 000 A to 20 000 A the frequency components contain four widely separated ranges listed as follows (ldquoShunt capacitor switching EMI voltages their reduction in Bonneville Power Administration substationsrdquo [B26])
91Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456
7
8
9
1011121314151617
1819
20
21
22
23
24
252627282930
313233343536
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
a) Frequencies in the megahertz range due to distributed parameters of the buses and the lines
b) Medium frequency oscillations occurring between the two banks contain the frequency range of 5 kHz to 15 kHz (these frequencies are dominant in back-to-back switching)
c) Low-frequency oscillations occurring between the capacitor banks and the power-frequency source contain the frequency range of 400 Hz to 600 Hz (these frequencies are dominant in the case of a bank switched against the bus)
d) 50 Hz or 60 Hz source frequency
The modes by which the voltage and current transients are coupled to the cables are basically the same as those listed in G11
G13 Lightning
Lightning is another source that can cause intense EMI in low-voltage circuits In general lightning is a high-energy unidirectional surge with a steep wave front In the frequency domain a broad frequency band represents this type of surge The frequency range covered by this spectrum is from dc to megahertz
The following are some ways lightning can cause over-voltages on cables
a) Direct strike to the mast or overhead shield wire in the substation
b) Lightning entering the substation through overhead transmission or distribution lines
c) Induced lightning transients due to strikes in the vicinity of the substation
The surge current flows into earth via ground grid conductors and through the multi-grounded shield and neutral network There are two primary modes of coupling to the cables The inductive coupling is due to voltage and current waves traveling in the overhead shield wires in the buses and in the ground grid conductors The conductive coupling consists of voltage gradients along the ground grid conductors due to flow of transient current
In a substation a transient grid potential rise (TGPR) with respect to a remote ground may also exist This transient voltage most likely will couple to telecommunication lines entering the substation from remote locations If proper isolation is not provided this voltage may cause damage to the telecommunication equipment in the substation The magnitude of TGPR is proportional to the peak magnitude and rate of rise of the stroke current and the surge impedance of the grounding system
G14 Power-frequency faults (50 Hz or 60 Hz)
Electronic devices are vulnerable to damage if a large magnitude of power-frequency fault current flows in the ground grid conductors due to a phase-to-ground fault Erroneous operations of relay circuits are known to occur under these conditions
There are two basic modes of coupling which exist when a phase-to-ground fault occurs in a substation The induced voltage on the cable due to the fault current flowing in ground conductors is one mode of coupling More dominant coupling however is the conductive voltage gradient along the ground grid conductors resulting from the current flow
92Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
345
678
9
1011
12
13141516
17
18
19
20
2122232425
262728293031
32
333435
36373839
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Coupling due to GPR with respect to remote ground may exist on telecommunication circuits entering the substation The GPR magnitude will be proportional to the fault current entering the earth from the ground grid conductors and the ground grid resistance to remote ground (IEEE Std 487-2000 [B56] EPRI EL-5990-SR [B18] Perfecky and Tibensky [B103]) Sometimes the telecommunication circuit leaving the substation parallels the power line In this case the total coupling would be a net result of GPR and the induced voltage due to fault current flowing in that power line
G15 Sources within cable circuits
During interruption of dc current in an inductor such as a relay coil a large induced voltage may appear across the inductor due to Faradayrsquos Law (V =L didt) (ldquoTransient pickup in 500 kV control circuitsrdquo [B117]) Normally the maximum voltage will exist at the instant of interruption The surge voltage magnitude is proportional to the impedance of the supply circuit and the speed of interruption Voltages in excess of 10 kV have been observed across a 125 V coil in laboratory tests but 25 kV with 5 micros rise time is a typical value to be expected Once produced these powerful fast rising high-voltage pulses are conducted throughout the supply circuit and can affect adjacent circuits where capacitive coupling exists Full battery voltage appears initially across the impedance of the adjacent circuit and then decays exponentially in accordance with the resistance-capacitance time constant of the circuit (ldquoProtection against transientsrdquo [B104])
The extensive use of surge capacitors on solid-state equipment and the longer control cable runs associated with EHV stations have substantially increased the capacitance between control wiring and ground Inadvertent momentary grounds on control wiring cause a discharge or a redistribution of charge on this capacitance Although this seldom causes failure the equipment may malfunction
Saturation of CTs by high-magnitude fault currents including the dc offset can result in the induction of high voltages in the secondary windings This phenomenon is repeated for each transition from saturation in one direction to saturation in the other The voltage appearing in the secondary consists of high- magnitude spikes with alternating polarity persisting for an interval of a few milliseconds every half cycle (ldquoProtection against transientsrdquo [B104])
G2 Protection measuresmdashGeneral considerations
There are two types of voltages that develop at cable terminations when the cable is exposed to high energy transients At this point it is important to visualize two loop areas enclosed by cable pair including its terminal equipment The loop area enclosed between the conductors of a pair is relatively small and typically links a fraction of disturbing field The voltage so developed across the conductors is called differential mode voltage In general the differential mode voltages are too small to cause any equipment damage However the loop currents that result from these voltages sometimes are responsible for erroneous operations of protective devices Using a twisted pair cable may eliminate this problem altogether Responsible for most damages are the common mode voltages at the terminals The common mode voltage results due to the loop formed between the pair and ground grid conductors A strong coupling from disturbing fields usually exists due to the large area enclosed by this loop The common mode voltage is defined as the voltage between the cable conductors and the ground The main objective of conductive shields is to minimize or preferably eliminate these voltages and resulting currents
Common and differential mode voltages at cable terminations cannot be completely eliminated but can be limited in magnitude Since transient voltages are coupled to the cables due to their exposure in the substation yard the responsibility of providing protection to reduce these coupled transients rests with utility engineers On the other hand designing the
93Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234567
8
910111213141516171819
2021222324
2526272829
30
3132333435363738394041424344
45464748
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
electronic equipment to withstand certain transient levels as specified by the standards (ERPI EL-2982 Project 1359-2 [B17] IEC 61000-4-12006 [B41] IEC 61000-4-42004 [B42] IEC 61000-4-52005 [B43] IEEE Std C37901-2002 [B73]) and providing appropriate surge suppressors at the terminals is traditionally a manufacturerrsquos responsibility Discussion on terminal protection is beyond the scope of this guide The following protection measures are discussed in this clause
a) Cable routing
b) Shield and shield grounding
c) Substation grounding and parallel ground conductors
G21 Cable routing
Radial arrangement of instrumentation and control circuits will reduce transient voltages by minimizing the loop sizes between the cable pairs running to the same apparatus This is effectively accomplished by
mdash Installing the cable pairs running to the same apparatus in one trench or conduit
mdash Avoiding the loop formed due to cables running from one apparatus to another apparatus and returning by different route
mdash Running the circuits in a tree fashion with a separate branch to each equipment such as breaker transformer etc
The trench or conduit carrying the cables should not run parallel to the overhead HV buses In cases where this is unavoidable provide as much separation distance as practically feasible to reduce the capacitive coupling from the buses
A substation may have underground HV circuit running across the yard A power-frequency fault current in the HV cable may cause a transient in control cables laid in parallel and in proximity due to magnetic coupling Avoiding the parallel run or providing a larger separation distance can reduce the transient overvoltage
G22 Shield and shield grounding
In general shielded cables regardless of ground connections at the ends provide immunity from magnetically coupled voltages This protection is a result of eddy currents set up by the external magnetic field in the coaxial shield The eddy currents in the shield then produce the opposing field reducing the field coupled to the signal conductors Due to its high conductivity and immunity from saturation a nonmagnetic (nonferrous) material is typically used for shielding purpose A typical nonmagnetic material used for shielding purpose may include copper aluminum bronze or lead The shielding efficiency of a nonmagnetic eddy-current shield is directly proportional to the following (Buckingham and Gooding [B8])
a) Shield diameter
b) Shield thickness
c) Conductivity (or 1resistivity)
d) Frequency
e) Permeability
94Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123456
7
8
9
10
111213
14
1516
1718
192021
22232425
26
2728293031323334
35
36
37
38
39
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
The lower the shield impedance the greater its transient voltage cancellation efficiency Generally lower surge impedance permits larger induced transient currents to flow in the shield (ldquoMethods of reducing transient overvoltages in substation control cablesrdquo [B84]) Table G1 lists the conductivity data of four commonly used shielding materials
Table G16mdash Conductivity data for four commonly used shielding materials
Copper Aluminum Bronzea Lead
Conductivity mho-meter 58 354 255 45a90 copper 10 zinc
The protection provided by an ungrounded shield is not adequate in high-voltage and high current noise environments of substations For example an ungrounded shield cannot protect the cable from capacitively coupled voltages Typically 1 of the transient voltage on a high-voltage bus is coupled to a cable with ungrounded shield This can amount to a common mode voltage of several thousand volts With the shield grounded at one end the capacitively-coupled electric field is prevented from terminating on the cable resulting in virtually no differential or common mode voltage
Grounding the shield at one end effectively protects the equipment at that end but equipment connected at the ungrounded end remains unprotected In some instances shield-to-ground and conductor-to-ground voltages may even increase at the ungrounded end (Dietrich et al [B1 1] ldquoMethods of reducing transient overvoltages in substation control cablesrdquo [B84]) For providing protection at both ends of the cable the shield should be grounded at both ends (Garton and Stolt [B22]) Grounding the shield at both ends links a minimum external field due to reduced loop area enclosed by the cable pairs and shield conductor Several field and laboratory tests show that grounding the shield at both ends reduce the common mode voltage between 50 and 200 times (ldquoControl circuit transients in electric power systemsrdquo [B78] ldquoControl circuit transientsrdquo [B79])
The shield conductors are not rated to carry power-frequency fault currents For this reason one or more ground conductors should be installed in the proximity of the cable circuits where shield conductors are grounded at both ends
In the case of an unbalanced circuit (equipment circuit is not grounded in the electrical middle) a differential voltage across the pair develops if the impedance on each side of the signal ground in the terminal equipment is different This differential voltage will be proportional to the current due to the common mode voltage during the transient Depending on the unbalance at the terminal grounding the shield at both ends may increase this differential voltage For a given transient this differential voltage can be reduced by grounding the signal circuit nearly in the electrical middle (IEEE Std 1050-1996 [B65])
It is necessary to keep the shield in a cable intact as a broken or separated shield can greatly reduce the shield efficiency Also in a substation where there may at times be large fault currents a problem arises if the shield is grounded at two widely separated locations The power-frequency potential difference on the ground grid may cause enough current to flow in the shield to cause damage Installation of one or more 20 or 40 AWG bare copper conductors in parallel would significantly reduce the current flow in the shield
95Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234
5
6
7
89
1011121314
15161718192021222324
252627
28293031323334
353637383940
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
G23 Substation grounding and parallel ground conductors
The design of ground grid systems the methods of grounding equipment and shielding of cable circuits have a large influence on EMI voltages that appear at the terminals
The ground grid even when designed with a very low resistance cannot be considered as an equal-voltage surface Substantial grid voltage differences may exist particularly in a large substation yard Several factors influence voltage gradients across the ground grid conductors These factors include the impedance of grid conductors grid geometry distribution of ground currents (see IEEE Std 80-2000 [B48]) earth resistivity (see ldquoTransient pickup in 500 kV control circuitsrdquo [B1 17] and IEEE Std 81-1983 [B49]) and magnitude and frequency of the transient (Gillies and Ramberg [B24])
Since it is impractical to eliminate voltage gradients along ground grid conductors additional measures are necessary to reduce their influence on the cables Typically this measure consists of installing low- impedance ground conductors in proximity and parallel to the affected circuits These conductors carry currents proportional to voltage gradients along the grid conductors and serve several purposes The flow of currents in these conductors induces a counter voltage in the control circuits and also reduces the conductive voltage difference between the two terminals In the case of a power-frequency fault these ground conductors carry most of the fault currents protecting the shield conductors grounded at both ends
The following are some guidelines to maximize protection from parallel ground conductors
a) Ground conductors in trenches
1) Install conductors with sufficient conductivity to carry maximum available fault current in the substation and having adequate mechanical strength A typical installation uses 20 or 40 bare copper conductor
2) Attach a minimum of two ground conductors on the topside of each trench If required additional ground conductors can be placed outside but in proximity of the trench This places the ground conductors between the radiated EMI source and the cables (ldquoTransient pickup in 500 kV control circuitsrdquo [B117])
3) Connect ground conductors with ground grid mesh conductors at several locations
b) Ground conductors parallel to duct banks
1) Place a minimum of two ground conductors at the top edges of the duct bank Ground conductors can also be placed in conduits provided that they intercept radiated fields
2) Establish a ground bus around the perimeter of the manhole with at least two ties to the substation grid This ground bus provides a convenient means of grounding individual cable shields if required
c) Parallel ground conductors for directly buried cables
96Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
456789
10
1112131415161718
19
20
212223
2425262728
2930
31
323334
353637
38
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
1) Place one or more ground conductors in proximity of each cable run if cable paths are diverse
d) Protection for unshielded cables
1) Ground conductors provide protection to both shielded and unshielded cables However unshielded cables receive more benefit from the parallel ground conductors To be most effective the ground conductors should be as close to the cables as possible
2) In an unshielded cable grounding of unused pair(s) at both ends provides the most effective protection (ldquoTransient pickup in 500 kV control circuitsrdquo [B117]) Provisions should be made for replacement with shield conductors should the unused conductors later be used for active circuits A parallel ground conductor should accompany the cable if a spare pair is grounded at both ends
G3 Protection measuresmdashspecial circuits
This clause provides shielding and grounding guidelines for special circuits such as circuits to CVTs CTs capacitor banks and coupling capacitor line tuning equipment The clause also provides shielding guidelines for high-voltage power cables coaxial and triaxial cables and the cables carrying low magnitude signals
G31 Instrument transformers (CVTs and CTs)
Equipment such as CVTs can couple high common-mode voltages to low-voltage secondary cables originating from the base cabinet The source of transients in many of such cases is the capacitive current interruption by an air break switch The surge impedances of the ground leads connecting the CVT bases to local ground grid are primarily responsible for developing these high transient voltages The transient voltages are coupled to the low-voltage circuit via devicersquos stray capacitance
Measuring CTs are normally located in breaker bushings The bushing capacitances generate the voltage transients on breaker casings in the same manner as the CVT devices These transients then can be coupled to CT secondary circuits or any low-voltage circuit or equipment residing in the breaker cabinet
The coupled voltages are typically reduced by lowering surge impedances of the ground leads and the surrounding ground grid This can be accomplished by mounting the CVT or breaker cabinets as close to the ground as permitted by clearance standards and by providing multiple low-resistance conductors between the cabinets (for three standalone cabinets) and between the cabinets and the station ground grid The secondary circuits exiting the cabinets should run in the vicinity of the ground leads Additionally the secondary cables should be laid out radially and as close to the ground grid conductors as possible If ground grid conductors in the proximity are not available dedicated ground conductors should be installed Using shielded cables for secondary circuits can provide additional immunity In such a case the shield should be grounded at both ends Instrument transformer secondaries should be connected to ground at only one point (see IEEE Std C57133-2005 [B76]) Making the ground connection at the relay or control building has the following advantages
a) Voltage rise is minimized near the relay equipment
b) The shock hazard to personnel in the building is reduced
97Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4567
89
101112
13
14151617
18
192021222324
25262728
293031323334353637383940
41
42
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
c) All grounds are at one location facilitating checking
CT secondary leads in a primary voltage area exceeding 600 V should be protected as required by Rule 150 of the NESC (Accredited Standards Committee C2-2002)
G32 Shunt capacitor banks
In the case of a grounded shunt capacitor installation operated at 115 kV and higher voltage the EMI can be controlled by the use of shielded cables and grounding the shields at both ends However in the case of multiple banks requiring back-to-back switching special protection measures may be necessary (ldquoShunt capacitor switching EMI voltages their reduction in Bonneville Power Administration substationsrdquo [B26]) A pre-insertion resistor or current limiting reactor inserted between the banks can substantially reduce the switching transient in back-to-back switching Closing the circuit switcher at a ldquozero voltagerdquo point on the voltage wave can also reduce the transient significantly Special shielding and grounding practices as listed below may however be required in absence of such mitigation methods
a) Route instrumentation and control circuits directly under the supply buses and close to ldquopeninsulardquo ground grid conductors until they are a minimum of 6 m (20 ft) within the influence of the main substation ground grid
b) Ground the end of the cable shield in the capacitor yard to a ldquopeninsulardquo grounding system
c) Ground the cable shield to the ground grid at the nearest manhole hand hole trench or tunnel adjacent to the capacitors
d) Ground the shield at the entrance to the control or relay house
e) If the shield is extended beyond the entrance into the control or relay house ground the shield at the switchboard or other cable termination
f) Capacitor yard lighting and receptacle circuits should also be shielded if the light posts are grounded to ldquopeninsulardquo grounding If the light posts are not grounded to ldquopeninsulardquo grounding they should be located a minimum of 2 m (6 ft) away from any structure that is grounded to the ldquopeninsulardquo grounding This will reduce the probability of personnel simultaneously contacting both structures and being in series with the potential difference between the peninsula and the rest of the grid during capacitor switching or during a fault
g) In the manhole adjacent to the capacitor yard where capacitor cable shields are grounded ground all other cable shields even if they are not related to the capacitors Also ground all cable shields grounded in this manhole at their remote ends During capacitor switching and faults the potential of the peninsula ground grid and the area around the first manhole may be quite high A high voltage could exist between cables if some shields are not grounded and between the ends of the shields if both ends are not grounded
h) High-voltage shunt capacitor banks of a given voltage should have the neutrals from individual banks connected together and then connected to the station ground grid at only one point To facilitate single point grounding all capacitor banks of a given voltage should be at one location
98Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
56789
10111213
141516
1718
1920
21
2223
24252627282930
31323334353637
38394041
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
G33 Gas insulated substations (GIS)
Operation of high-voltage (725 kV and above) GIS breakers and disconnect switches generate transients with much faster rise time than air insulated equipment resulting in higher frequency transients (frequency bandwidth roughly one order of magnitude greater) that can increase the coupling of interference into control wiring Transients can also be generated within substation grounds GIS manufacturers will typically supply shielded cable for control and power circuits between equipment and the local control panel on the skid Shielded cable is also recommended for (customer) circuits terminating at the GIS equipment or in the near vicinity of GIS equipment Shields should be grounded at both ends and the grounding pigtails are to be as short as possible grounded immediately inside the control cabinet The grounds prevent bringing the transients into the control cabinet where they could couple with other conductors For more information refer to IEEE Standard C371221 [BXX] and [B32]
G34 High susceptibility circuits
This subclause provides guidance for shielding and grounding of control and instrumentation circuits with high susceptibility to steady-state noise High susceptibility circuits are those carrying low level voltage and current signals A thermocouple circuit carrying analog signals in millivolt range is one good example of this type of circuit
The protection measures described in this section may not be necessary if interference due to steady-state noise is not a concern even for high susceptibility circuits Users should follow the general shielding and grounding practices described in G2 in such cases
For further details on shielding and grounding of high susceptibility circuits see IEEE Std 1050-2004 [B65] For information on application of instrumentation and control cables for SCADA see IEEE Std C371-2007 [B72]
G341 Use of twisted pair cable
The use of twisted pair cables is an effective method for reducing steady-state differential mode noise on high susceptibility cables Using cables with twisted pair conductors and individually insulated shields over each pair is also effective in minimizing crosstalk in communication circuits
G342 Grounding of signal circuit
The signal circuit may originate at a source such as a transducer and terminate at a receiver (load) such as a recorder or a SCADA RTU either directly or through an amplifier
If the receiver is receiving the signal from a grounded voltage source a thermocouple for example the receiver input should be capable of high common-mode rejection This can be accomplished by either isolating the receiver from the ground or installing a differential amplifier with isolated guard at the receiver input terminals Isolating the circuits from ground effectively opens the ground common-mode voltage path in the signal circuit If a single-ended amplifier already exists at the input terminal of the receiver the low side of the signal circuit is not broken and should be considered grounded at the terminal In this case the same isolation procedure as indicated above should be followed
When an ungrounded transducer is used the receiver may not need isolation In such a case a single-ended amplifier can be installed at the input terminal if required
99Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23456789
101112
13
14
15161718
192021
222324
25
26272829
30
3132
3334353637383940
414212
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
G343 Shield grounding
In the case of a high susceptibility circuit the shield may be connected to ground at only one point preferably where the signal equipment is grounded If the shield is grounded at some point other than where the signal equipment is grounded charging currents may flow in the shield because of the difference in voltages between signal and shield ground locations Similarly if the shield is grounded at more than one point voltage gradients along the ground conductors may drive current through the shield In either case the common mode noise current in the shield can induce differential mode noise in the signal leads Depending on the unbalance in the signal circuit noise voltages of sufficient magnitudes may be developed to reduce the accuracy of the signal sensing equipment
In a system with a grounded transducer at one end and an isolated differential amplifier at the receiving end connecting the cable shield to the amplifier guard shield may reduce the amplifierrsquos common-mode rejection capability A preferred practice in such a case is to isolate the cable shield from the amplifier guard shield and to ground the shield only at the transducer end This shield grounding practice minimizes the shield-induced common-mode current while permitting the amplifier to operate at maximum common- mode rejection capability
To provide immunity from transient overvoltages the nongrounded end of the shield may be grounded through a suitable capacitor or a surge suppressor varistor
G35 Shielding terminations at the equipment
The following guidelines may be followed for the circuits entering equipment located in the control house or yard
a) If cable shields are grounded at the entrance of the control house they should be extended beyond the building entrance and grounded at their final terminations in the cabinet
b) To minimize the size of the loop formed between the cable and the shield carry the shield with the cable as far towards the equipment as practical before grounding
G36 Cables and shielding for power-line carrier (PLC) equipment
The circuits for PLC equipment typically consist of three specific types of cables These types are as follows insulated single conductor coaxial cable and triaxial cable For additional guidance on PLC and circuits refer to IEEE Std 643-1980 [B61])
G361 Insulated single conductor
An insulated single conductor is used to connect a coupling capacitor to line-tuning equipment or outdoor transmitting and receiving equipment It can also be used as the interconnecting lead for short bypasses
Bare conductors and coaxial cables should be avoided for these applications since either one can introduce excessive leakage currents or excessive stray capacitance
Since a single conductor is at a high impedance point when connected between a coupling capacitor and a line tuner stray capacitance-to-ground and leakage currents can affect the coupling circuit performance The stray capacitance can cause a reduction in bandwidth and the leakage currents can cause a loss in carrier power
100Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23456789
10
11121314151617
1819
20
2122
232425
2627
28
293031
32
333435
3637
3839404112
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
To reduce stray capacitance and leakage currents either of the following methods may be used
a) An insulated single conductor should be run as directly as possible between its required terminations It should be mounted on insulators and fed through bushings at each end The conductor insulation should be unbroken between its ends to maintain low leakage
b) An insulated single conductor can be installed in a nonmagnetic flexible metal conduit which is sheathed in a vinyl jacket The insulated single conductor should be isolated from the flexible metal conduit with nonconductive washers spaced about 150 mm (6 in) apart If the conductor has a significant portion of its length outside the flexible metal conduit it should be mounted on insulators and fed through bushings at its ends as in item a)
A typical insulated carrier lead 12 mm (048 in) in diameter consists of a single 8 AWG 19-strand conductor having rubber insulation and a neoprene outer jacket
G362 Coaxial cables
This type of cable is sometimes used for a low-impedance interconnection between a line tuner and a transmitterreceiver or between line tuners in a long bypass It is sometimes used between an impedance- matching transformer in a coupling capacitor base and a transmitterreceiver
In these applications the copper braid (shield) that forms the outer conductor of the cable should be grounded at the transmitterreceiver end only (or at only one end of a bypass) If both shield ends are grounded large surge currents can flow under certain conditions causing saturation of the impedance- matching transformer and resulting in an inoperative carrier channel
G363 Triaxial cables (or shielded coaxial cable)
On transmission lines operating at voltages greater than 230 kV triaxial cable may be used instead of coaxial cable This cable provides an additional heavy shield which does not carry signal currents The outer shield is capable of carrying large induced surge currents under fault conditions and is grounded at both ends This arrangement provides an effective shielding against both magnetic and electrostatic induction
101Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3456
789
101112
1314
15
16171819
2021222324
25
2627282930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex H
(normative)
Electrical segregation
Physical separation between a transient source and control cables is an effective means of transient control Because mutual capacitance and mutual inductance are greatly influenced by circuit spacing small increases in distance may produce substantial decreases in interaction between circuits
Table H1 provides the allowable mixing requirements for segregation of various types of circuits in raceways Table H1 is not intended to cover typical lsquobuildingrsquo wiring such as for lighting heatingair conditioning receptacles etc This type wiring generally should follow national or local electrical codes
Table H17mdash Circuit mixingsegregation in raceways
Raceway system Circuit types typically installed together
Individual ducts conduits Control and instrumentation and power only if le 120 V (ac) Single conductor smaller than 6 AWG must be segregated from multiconductor cable except in runs le 6 m (20 ft) Communication circuits should be in a dedicated duct whenever possible or sub-duct if in a shared duct
Duct banks All types segregated as necessary into individual ducts
Trench All types Barrier recommended for power circuits greater than 240 V (ac) Communication circuits should be installed in a sub-duct
Tray or wireways Control and instrumentation communication power only if le 120 V (ac) Communication circuits should be installed in a sub-duct
Connecting raceways le 18 m (6 ft) (eg between junction box and equipment cabinet)
Control and instrumentation communication power only if le 120 V (ac) Communication circuits should be installed in a sub-duct
aControl and instrumentation circuits include dc circuits ac control circuits potential transformer circuits current transformer circuits and instrumentation (milli-
amp or low voltage) circuits For the purposes of raceway assignment dc power circuits to equipment such as to motor operated air switches circuit breaker
charging mechanisms etc or for dc lighting are considered the same as control circuitsbPrimary dc circuits including charger to battery battery to distribution panel and panel to panel primary connections are to be in dedicated raceways
cThe station service feeder from the station service transformer to the primary distribution panel may be in a dedicated raceway
102Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4567
89
1011
12
1314151617
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex I
(normative)
Separation of redundant cables
This annex provides guidance for the separation of redundant cable systems
Communication cables may be used in communication systems that provide redundancy on a variety of levels Care should be undertaken to understand how the communication cables impact redundant functionality For example communication redundancy may involve redundant communications ports on each device where two cables may be providing communication access to one device In this case it may or may not be desirable to have these two cables follow the same path One other common example is when primary and secondary IEDs both have a single communication cable but both IEDs may not be used in a redundant fashion for all functionality In the case where both devices support the same functions in a redundant manner the discussion below may be applied
Communication cables may also be impacted by diversity or redundancy requirements Some applications may require communications cables for primary and secondarybackup functions to take different paths within the substation to reduce the likelihood that the same failure mode will simultaneously affect both cables Consult specific application requirements for the level of diversity required
I1 Redundant cable systems
Redundant cable systems are two or more systems serving the same objective They may be systems where personnel safety is involved such as fire pumps or systems provided with redundancy because of the severity of economic consequences of equipment damage or system reliability Primary and backup relay control cables and normal and backup station service supplies are practical examples of redundant cable systems
I2 Design considerations
Redundant cable systems should be physically and electrically separated to ensure that no single event whether physical in nature or electrical in nature would prevent a required specific substation operation The degree and type of separation required varies with the importance of the cable systems the equipment they serve and potential hazards in particular areas of the substation System owners or regulatory agencies may have requirements that mandate certain redundancy and separation practices
I3 Separation
Physical and electrical separation of redundant cable systems increases the reliability of the cable systems and the equipment they serve Possible methods to provide physical and electrical separation include
mdash Installation of redundant systems in separate raceways trays trenches or conduits with diverse physical routing
mdash Fire barrier between systems that are contained within the same raceway
103Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
56789
10111213
1415161718
19
2021222324
25
262728293031
32
333435
3637
38
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
mdash Avoidance of stacked cable trays or raceways that contain redundant systems
mdash Use of independent electrical power sources (DC battery AC station service source) and distribution panels for power cables in separate cable systems
mdash Physical separation of power or signal sources (instrument transformers monitoringindication devices DC battery AC station service source or power distribution panels) for control and instrumentation cables
mdash Physical separation of connected devices (protective relays and relaying panels RTUrsquos HMIrsquos DFRrsquos phone system fiber splicepatch panels) for control instrumentation communication and fiber cables
104Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
456
789
10
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex J
(normative)
Cable pulling tension calculations
Ethernet cables have cable pulling limits and minimum bend radius defined in TIA-568-C0 For other types of copper communication cables the manufacturerrsquos pulling tension and bend radius guidelines shall be followed
J1 Cable pulling design limits and calculations
The following design limits and formulas provided in this clause should be utilized when determining the maximum safe cable pulling lengths and tensions Raceway fill maximum sidewall pressure jam ratio and minimum bending radius are design limits which should be examined in designing a proper cable pull
These design limits are prerequisites needed in designing a cable raceway system Once these limits are determined for a particular cable the raceway system can then be designed If the system has already been designed modifications may be required in order to pull the cable without damage
Conduit and duct system design should consider the maximum pulling lengths of cable to be installed The maximum pulling length of a cable or cables is determined by the maximum allowable pulling tension and sidewall pressure The pulling length will be limited by one of these factors
Pull points or manholes should be installed wherever calculations show that expected pulling tensions exceed either maximum allowable pulling tension or sidewall pressure Also an industry ldquorule of thumbrdquo is no more than 360deg of total bends along the cable pull though actual calculations will override this ldquorule of thumbrdquo
A sample calculation for determining cable pulling tensions is shown in J4 and O6
J2 Design limits
J21 Maximum allowable pulling tension
The maximum allowable pulling tension is the minimum value of Tmax from the applicable following guidelines unless otherwise indicated by the cable manufacturer
The maximum tension on an individual conductor should not exceed
T cond=KtimesA (J1)
where
Tcond is the maximum allowable pulling tension on individual conductor in newtons (pounds)
A is the cross-sectional area of each conductor in square millimeters (mm2) (kcmil)105
Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456
7
89
1011
12131415
16171819
20212223
24
25
26
2728
29
30
31
32333412
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
K equals 70 Nmm2 (8 lbkcmil) for annealed copper and hard aluminumK equals 525 Nmm2 (6 lbkcmil) for 34 hard aluminum
When pulling together two or three conductors of equal size the pulling tension should not exceed twice the maximum tension of an individual conductor ie
T max=2timesTcond (J2)
When pulling more than three conductors of equal size together the pulling tension should not exceed 60 of the maximum tension of an individual conductor times the number of conductors (ldquoNrdquo) ie
T max=0 6timesNtimesT cond (J3)
When pulling using a pulling eye the maximum tension for a single-conductor cable should not exceed 222 kN (5000 lb) and the maximum tension for two or more conductors should not exceed 267 kN (6000 lb) The cable manufacturer should be consulted when tensions exceeding these limits are expected
When pulling by basket grip over a nonleaded jacketed cable the pulling tension should not exceed 445 kN (1000 lb)
When using a basket-weave type pulling grip applied over a lead-sheathed cable the force should not exceed 667 kN (1500 lb) as determined by the following formula
T max=Km π ( Dminust ) (J4)
where
t is the lead sheath thickness in millimeters (inches)D is the OD of lead sheath in millimeters (inches)Km is the maximum allowable pulling stress in MPa (1034 MPa to 138 MPa
[1500 to 200 psi] depending on the lead alloy)
NOTEmdashFor lead-sheathed cables with neoprene jackets Tmax = 445 kN (1000 lb)
Pulling instructions for coaxial triaxial and other special cables should follow the manufacturerrsquos recommendations
J22 Maximum allowable sidewall pressure
Sidewall pressure P is defined as the tension out of a bend expressed in newtons (pounds) divided by the radius of the bend expressed in millimeters (feet) The sidewall pressure on a cable can be calculated by the following equations
Single cable in conduit
P=T 0
r (J5)106
Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12345
6
789
10
11121314
1516
1718
19
20
212223242526
2728
29
303132
33
3412
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Three cables in cradle configuration where the center cable presses hardest against the conduit
P=(3cminus2)T0
3 r (J6)
Three cables in triangular configuration where the pressure is divided between the two bottom cables
P=T 0
2 r (J7)
Four cables in diamond configuration where the bottom cable is subjected to the greatest crushing force
P=(3cminus2)T0
3 r (J8)
where
P is the sidewall pressure in newtonsmillimeter (poundsfoot) of radiusTo is the tension out of the bend in newtons (pounds)c is the weight correction factor (refer to J31)r is the inside radius of bend in millimeters (feet)
Equation (J6) Equation (J7) and Equation (J8) calculate the sidewall pressure for the cable with the highest sidewall pressure
The maximum allowable sidewall pressure is 7300 Nm (500 lbft) of radius for multiconductor power cables and single-conductor power cables 6 AWG and larger subject to verification by the cable manufacturer The recommended maximum allowable sidewall pressure for control cables and single- conductor power cable 8 AWG and smaller is 4380 Nm (300 lbft) of radius subject to verification by the cable manufacturer For instrumentation cable the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations should be obtained
J23 Jam ratio
Jamming is the wedging of cables in a conduit when three cables lie side by side in the same plane Jam ratio is defined for three cables of equal diameter as the ratio of the conduit inside diameter (D) to the cable outside diameter (d) The jam ratio is a concern because jamming in the conduit could cause damage to one or more of the cables The possibility of jamming is greater when the cables change direction Therefore the inside diameter of the conduit at the bend is used in determining the jam ratio
Jamming cannot occur when
Dd
gt3 0
Jamming is not likely when107
Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
34
5
67
8
9
1011121314
1516
171819202122
23
242526272829
30
31
3212
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Dd
lt2 8
Jamming is probable when
2 8le Dd
le3 0
A 40 conduit fill gives a jam ratio of 274 which is in the region where jamming is not likely The inside diameter of a field-bent conduit is usually increased by 5 to account for the oval cross-section that occurs Adding 5 for a field bent conduit yields a jam ratio of 287 which is in the region where jamming is probable
J24 Minimum bending radius
The minimum bending radius is the minimum radius to which a cable can be bent while under a pulling tension providing the maximum sidewall pressure is not exceeded The values given are usually stated as a multiple of cable diameter and are a function of the cable diameter and whether the cable is nonshielded shielded armored or single or multiple conductor Guidance for minimum bending radii can be obtained from the NEC [B100] or the cable manufacturer
J3 Cable-pulling calculations
The equations used to calculate the expected cable-pulling tension are based on the number of cables to be pulled the type of raceway the cable configuration in the raceway and the raceway layout
J31 Straight sections of conduit or duct
For a straight section of conduit or duct the pulling tension is equal to the length of the straight run multiplied by the weight per unit length of cable the coefficient of friction and the weight correction factor
In SI units
T = Lmgfc (J9)
where
T is the pulling tension in a straight duct in newtonsL is the length of the straight duct in metersm is the mass of the cable per unit length in kilogramsmeterg is the acceleration of gravity in 981 ms2
f is the coefficient of frictionc is the weight correction factor
In English units
T = Lwfc (J10)
where
108Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4567
8
910111213
14
151617
18
192021
22
23
24
2526272829303132
33
34
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
T is the total pulling tension of straight run in poundsL is the length of the straight run in feetw is the weight of the cable(s) in poundsfoot
The coefficient of friction is usually assumed to be as given in Table J 1
Table J18mdash Coefficient of friction f
Dry cable or ducts 05Well-lubricated cable and ducts 015 to 035
The weight correction factor takes into account the added frictional forces that exist between triangular or cradle arranged cables resulting in a greater pulling tension than when pulling a single cable The weight correction factor can be calculated by the following equations
Three single cables in cradled configuration
c=1+ 43 ( d
Dminusd )2
(J11)
Three single cables in triangular configuration
c= 1
radic1minus( dDminusd )
2
(J12)
Four single cables in diamond configuration
c=1+2( dDminusd )
2
(J13)
where
D is the conduit inside diameterd is the single conductor cable outside diameter
The weight correction factor for three single-conductor cables can be determined from Figure J1
109Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12345
6
7
89
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
1819202122
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Figure J4mdash Weight correction factor (c)
J32 Inclined sections of raceway
The expected pulling tension of a cable in an inclined section of duct may be calculated from the following Equation (J13) and Equation (J14)
T up=wL(cf cos α+sin α ) (J14)
T down=wL( cf cosαminussin α ) (J15)
where
α is the angle of the incline from horizontal
110Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
45
6
7
8
9
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
J33 Horizontal and vertical bends
The tension out of a horizontal or vertical conduit bend is normally calculated from the following approximate equation
T out=T in ecf θ(J16)
where
Tout is the tension out of bend in kilonewtons (pounds)Tin is the tension into the bend in kilonewtons (pounds)θ is the angle of the change in direction produced by bend in radians
This is a simplified equation which ignores the weight of the cable It is very accurate where the incoming tension at a bend is equal to or greater than 10 times the product of cable weight per meter (foot) times the bend radius (r) expressed in meters (feet) If the tension into a bend is less than 10wr the exact equations can be found in ldquoPipe-line design for pipe-type feedersrdquo [B107] Cases in which the exact equations may become necessary are where light tensions enter large radii bends Usually Equation (J15) is precise enough for normal installations
J4 Sample calculation
This subclause is intended to illustrate the calculations required to determine cable pulling tensions in a typical run from a manhole to a riser pole The typical duct run used for the calculations is shown in Figure J2
Figure J5mdash Duct layout for example calculationsThe cable to be used in this example installation is 3-1c 750 kcmil triplexed frac34 hard-drawn aluminum cable with 13 concentric neutral The completed weight of this cable is 784 Nm (5375 lbft 8 kgm) and the OD for each cable is 409 cm (161 in) Plastic conduit suitable for direct burial (Type DB) is to be used for this example installation Assume that pulling eye is used for cable pulling
111Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
AB
C D E
F G
Riser Pole
Substation Manhole
A-B ndash 3 m (10 ft) Vertical RiserB-C ndash 12 m (4 ft) 90o Inside Radius Vertical CurveC-D ndash 152 m (500 ft)D-E ndash 38 m (125 ft) 45o Inside Radius Vertical CurveE-F ndash 30 m (100 ft)F-G ndash 38 m (125 ft) 45o Inside Radius Vertical CurveG-H ndash 60 m (200 ft)
H
1
23
4
5
6789
101112131415
16
171819
2021
2223242526
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
J41 Conduit fill and jam ratio
In determining the size of conduit required consideration should be given to conduit fill and jam ratio Using Equation (E1) of this guide the percent fill is given in Equation (J16)
Fill=sumCablearea
Racewayareatimes100
(J17)
Using 10 cm (4 in) conduit with an internal diameter of 1023 cm (4026 in)
Fill=3 π ( 4 09
2 )2
π (10 232 )
2 times100=47 98
98
Since 4798 exceeds the maximum allowable fill of 40 the percent fill should be calculated for the next larger size conduit 13 cm (5 in) with an internal diameter of 1282 cm (5047 in)
Fill=3π ( 4 09
2 )2
π (12 822 )
2 times100=30 5
This is an acceptable fill
The jam ratio as discussed in J23 should be calculated next Assuming field bending of the conduit
JamRatio=1 05 D
d (J18)
where
D is the conduit inside diameterd is the single conductor cable outside diameter
JamRatio=1 05(12 82)
4 09=3 29
Jamming cannot occur based on J23 of this guide Also where triplexed cable is used jamming is not a problem since jamming is the wedging of cables in a conduit when three cables lie side by side in the same plane
112Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
5
6
789
10
11
1213
14
15
161718
19
20
212223
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
J42 Maximum allowable pulling tension
The maximum allowable pulling tension for this example cable is calculated by using Equation (J1) and Equation (J2)
Tcond = K middot A
Tcond = (525)(381) = 20 kN (4500 lb)
Tmax = 2 middot Tcond = 2 times 20 = 40 kN (9000 lb)
However as indicated in J2 1 the maximum tension for two or more conductors should not exceed 267 kN (6000 lb) when pulling using a pulling eye
J43 Minimum bending radius
The minimum bending radius in accordance with the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendation for the example cable is 12 times the overall diameter of the cable The cabling factor for three conductors triplexed is 2155
Minimum bending radius = (12)(2155)(409) = 1056 cm (416 in)
J44 Pulling tensions
The pulling tensions for the example are calculated using Equation (J9a) or Equation (J9b) for straight runs and Equation (J15) for vertical or horizontal bends
Pulling from A towards H
Since pulling down the vertical section A-B and around the curve B-C would require a negligible tension the calculations are started at C
The weight correction factor (c) for three single cables in a triangular configuration is calculated using Equation (J11)
c= 1
radic1minus( 4 0912 82minus4 09 )
2minus1 13
Therefore assuming a dry cable or duct with a coefficient of friction of 05
TD = (152)(8)(981)(05)(113) = 673 kN (1518 lb)
TE = TDecfθ
where
θ is the angle of the change in direction produced by bend in radians
NOTEmdashConversion factor from degrees to radians is 001745
TE = 673 e(113)(05)(45)(001745)
113Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
5
6
78
9
101112
13
14
1516
17
1819
2021
22
23
24
25
26
272829
30
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
TE = 673 e04437
TE = 105 kN (2366 lb)
TF = TE + (30)(8)(981)(05)(113)
TF = 105 + 133
TF = 118 kN (2670 lb)
TG = T Fecfθ
TG = 118e(113)(05)(45)(001745)
TG = 118 e04437
TG = 184 kN (4161 lb)
TH = TG + (60)(8)(981)(05)(113)
TH = 184 + 266
TH = 211 kN (4768 lb)
This is within the maximum allowable tension of 267 kN (6000 lb) However the maximum sidewall pressure of 7300 Nm (500 lbft) should also be checked The maximum sidewall pressure for this pull will occur at curve F-G and is calculated using Equation (J7)
P=(1 13)(18 400 )
(2 )(3 810 )=
274 kN (188 lbft) 1
P=( 113 x 18400)(2 x 3800) =274 Nmm = 2740Nm = 274 kNm
This is acceptable
Pulling from H towards A
TG = Lmgfc
TG = (60)(8)(981)(05)(113)
TG = 266 kN (607 lb)
TF = TGecfθ
TF = 27e04437
TF = 42 kN (946 lb)
TE = TF + (30)(8)(981)(05)(113)
TE = 42 + 13
TE = 55 kN (1250 lb)
TD = 55ecfθ
114Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
131415
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2912
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
TD = 55e(113)(05)(45)(001745)
TD = 55e04437
TD = 86 kN (1948 lb)
TC = TD + (152)(8)(981)(05)(113)
TC = 86 + 67
TC = 153 kN (3466 lb)
TB = 153ecfθ
TB = 153e(113)(05)(90)(001745)
TB = 153e08873
TB = 372 kN (8417 lb)
This tension exceeds the maximum allowable tension of 267 N (6000 lb) Therefore a cable pull from H to A should not be permitted The cable should be pulled from A to H The let-off reel should be at the riser pole and the cable should be pulled toward the manhole in order not to exceed the maximum allowable pulling tension or sidewall pressure
115Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11121314
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex K
(normative)
Handling
This annex provides guidance for the construction methods materials and precautions in handling and storing cable
Care should be used when using gel-filled communication cables The gel should only be cleaned using manufacturer-recommended cleaning solutions Improper clean up of the gel may result in cable damage
K1 Storage
Reels should be stored upright on their flanges and handled in such a manner as to prevent deterioration of or physical damage to the reel or to the cable During storage the ends of the cables should be sealed against the entrance of moisture or contamination Reels should be stored on solid ground to prevent the flanges from sinking into the earth Cables should be stored in an environment that does not exceed the storage environmental specification provided by the vendor
NOTEmdashWhen stored outside for long periods of time (longer than typical installation staging periods) the cable will require protection from sunlight (UV radiation) It is preferable to store the cable inside if UV protection cannot be provided
K2 Protection of cable
a) If the cable manufacturerrsquos recommended maximum pulling tension sidewall pressure or the minimum bending or training radius is violated damage could occur to the cable conductor insulation shield or jacket This could lead to premature failure andor poor life-cycle operation
b) Special care should be exercised during welding soldering and splicing operations to prevent damage to cables If necessary cables should be protected by fire-resistant material
c) Cables should be sealed before pulling and resealed after pulling regardless of location
d) If water has entered the cable a vacuum should be pulled on the cable or the cable should be purged with nitrogen to extract the water and tested for dryness
e) Prior to and after the cable pull is complete the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations for minimum bending radii should be followed
116Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
45
678
9
101112131415
161718
19
20212223
242526
2728
2930
3132
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex L
(normative)
Installation
This annex provides guidance for the construction methods materials and precautions in installing cable systems Fiber optic cable is addressed separately in Section 6
L1 Installation
a) The cable manufacturerrsquos recommended temperature limits should be followed when pulling or handling cables during extreme low temperatures Handling or pulling cables in extremely low temperatures can cause damage to the cable sheathing jacketing or insulation To prevent damage of this nature store cables in a heated building at least 24 hours prior to installation
b) Table L1 provides the cable manufacturerrsquos recommended low temperature limits for handling and pulling cables with various types of jackets or insulations
c) Cable-pulling lubricants should be compatible with the cable outer surface and should not set up or harden during cable installation The lubricant should not set up so as to prevent the cable from being pulled out of the conduit at a later time Cable lubricants should not support combustion
d) Pulling winches and other necessary equipment should be of adequate capacity to ensure a steady continuous pull on the cable Use of truck bumpers is not recommended for longer pulls due to risk of unsteady pull
e) Cable reels should be supported so that the cable may be unreeled and fed into the raceway without subjecting the cable to a reverse bend as it is pulled from the reel
f) A tension measuring device should be used on runs when pulling-force calculations indicate that allowable stresses may be approached
g) Pulling tension will be increased when the cable is pulled off the reel Turning the reel and feeding slack cable to the duct entrance will reduce the pulling tension
h) A suitable feeder device should be used to protect and guide the cable from the cable reel into the raceway The radius of the feeder device should not be less than the minimum bending radius of the cable If a feeder device is not used the cable should be hand-guided into the raceway
i) A swivel should be attached between the pulling eye and the pulling cable Projections and sharp edges on pulling hardware should be taped or otherwise covered to protect against snagging at conduit joints and to prevent damage to the conduit
j) The direction of pulling has a large influence on the pulling tension in conduit runs containing bends Whenever a choice is possible the cable should be pulled so that the bend or bends are closest to the reel The worst condition possible is to pull out of a bend at or near the end of the run
117Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
45
6
789
1011
1213
14151617
181920
2122
2324
2526
27282930
31323334
35363738
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
k) Pulling instructions for all cable should follow the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations
l) Cable should be pulled only into clean raceways An appropriately-sized mandrel should be pulled through all underground ducts prior to cable pulling Any abrasions or sharp edges that might damage the cable should be removed
m) After cable installation has started trays and trenches should be cleaned periodically as necessary to prevent the accumulation of debris
n) Sufficient cable slack should be left in each manhole and temporarily supported so that the cable can be trained to its final location on racks hangers or trays along the sides of the manhole Cable joints should not be placed directly on racks or hangers (IEEE Std 404-2000 [B54])
o) The use of single- or multi-roller cable sheaves of the proper radius should be used when installing cable around sharp corners or obstructions Minimum bending radius should never be less than that recommended by the manufacturer
p) Cables should be installed in raceway systems that have adequately sized bends boxes and fittings so that the cable manufacturerrsquos minimum allowable bending radii and sidewall pressures for cable installations are not violated Guidance for the number of bends between pull points and guidance on conduit fill can be found in the NEC [B100]
q) Cables should be identified by a permanent marker at each end in accordance with the design documents
r) Careful consideration should be given not only to design engineering and material cost but also to the installed cost for the initial as well as the ultimate installation Maintenance and replacement costs also should be considered It is desirable that the system be designed so that additions and changes can be made with ease economy and minimum outages
s) The ends of all cables should be properly sealed during and after installation to prevent moisture collection as ambient temperature and humidity change
Table L19mdash Low temperature limits for cable handling and pullinga
Cable insulation or jacket materialLow temperature limits
DegreesCelsius
DegreesFahrenheit
EPR low temperature PVC mdash40 mdash40CPE mdash35 mdash31PVC mdash10 +14CSPE mdash20 mdash4Neoprene (PCP) mdash20 mdash4XLPE mdash40 mdash40Paper-insulated lead-sheathed mdash12 +10aIf a cable has an insulation and jacket with different materials the higher temperature limit should be used
118Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
345
67
89
1011
121314
1516171819
2021
2223242526
2728
29
3031
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
L2 Supporting cables in vertical runs
Recommendations for supporting special cables such as armored shielded and coaxial should be obtained from the cable manufacturer
The weight of a vertical cable should not be supported by the terminals to which it is connected To prevent damage by deformation due to excessive bearing pressure or cable tension vertically run cables should be supported by holding devices in the tray in the ends of the conduit or in boxes inserted at intervals in the conduit system
Cables with copper conductors regardless of their voltage class installed in vertical runs should be supported in accordance with Table L2
Table L20mdash Cable vertical support distances
Maximum distances between cable supports
Conductor sizes Maximum distance
AWG or kcmil ft m
14 to 10 100 3020 to 40 80 24250 to 350 60 18Over 350 to 500 50 15Over 500 to 750 40 12Over 750 35 10
L3 Securing cables in vertical runs
Cables installed in vertical cable tray should be secured to the cable tray at least every 15 m (5 ft)
L4 Training cables
Cables installed in trays should be neatly trained to facilitate identification and removal and to maximize tray fill
L5 Cable conductor terminations
a) Cable conductors should extend from terminal to terminal without splicing Wire connections to the terminal blocks relays instruments control device etc should be lugged Wire loops around terminals are not acceptable for stranded conductors
b) Terminal lugs should be installed without removing conductor strands
c) At all terminals suitable designations should be installed on each wire
d) All connections should be made so that undue bending or distortion shall not occur when any wire is removed from a stud or terminal
e) Wiring provided for connection of equipment which will be mounted by others should be of ample length and terminated in a coil or pigtail
119Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4567
89
10
11
1213
14
1516
17
181920
21
22
2324
2526
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
f) Before applying the wiring all edges corners and abrading surfaces which may come in contact with the wires should be provided with an insulating cushion to prevent damage to the wire insulation All holes through which wires pass should have their edges insulated
g) Solderless indent type terminal lugs either seamless or having a brazed seam with one hole closed-end tongue are recommended Indent should be adequate for connection The pad of the terminal should have adequate surface to make contact with terminal block or devices
h) If bare terminal lugs are used insulating sleeves may be used to cover the lug barrel and any exposed part of the conductor
i) All terminals should be accessible for tightening with a straight socket wrench or screwdriver
j) Connections to main control buses should be made with solderless connectors
k) Where large size conductors are connected to a terminal block adequate clearance for insulation should be provided between conductors and between conductor and ground Terminal lugs for large size conductors should be compression type
l) The use of mechanical lugs on large conductors (such as main lugs in panelboards) requires proper strip length of insulation and torquing to recommended values
120Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1234
5678
910
1112
13
141516
1718
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex M
(normative)
Acceptance testing
This annex provides guidance for the testing of cables after installation and prior to their connection to equipment and includes cable terminations connectors and splices
M1 Purpose
The purpose of these tests is to verify that cable insulation damage did not occur during storage and installation and that the cable was properly spliced and terminated It should be noted however that these tests may not detect damage that may eventually lead to cable failure in service eg damage to the cable jacket or insulation shield on medium-voltage cable or to low-voltage cable insulation
M2 Tests
A simple continuity test can be performed to identify any broken conductors Low-voltage power cables may be insulation-resistance tested prior to connecting cables to equipment These cables may be tested as part of the system checkout
The low-voltage power cable insulation resistance tests should measure the insulation resistance between any possible combination of conductors in the same cable and between each conductor and station ground with all other conductors grounded in the same cable
Safety precautions should be observed during all phases of testing Cable ends should be properly cleaned of all conducting material Cable test results environmental conditions and data should be recorded and filed for maintenance reference The following ldquomeggerrdquo test may be performed on each control and power circuit as applicable for multiconductor or shielded cables in conjunction with the cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations It should be noted that in dry conditions the integrity of single-conductor cables may be difficult to validate with this test This is true even in metallic conduits unless the damaged area happens to be in contact with the conduit
The test voltage should be a minimum of 500 V (dc) The minimum acceptable insulation resistance is R in MΩ = (rated voltage in kilovolts + 1) times 3048length in meters (1000length in feet)
a) See Table M21 for 600 V cable the resistance values
Table M21mdash Resistance values for 600 V cable
Lengthm (ft)
RMΩ
305 (100) 16610 (200) 8914 (300) 53122 (400) 4152 (500) 32
121Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
45
6
789
1011
12
131415
161718
1920212223242526
272829
30
31
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
183 (600) 27213 (700) 23244 (800) 2274 (900) 18305 (1000
)16
b) Testing of control cable and prefabricated cable assemblies in a similar manner is suggested The cable manufacturerrsquos recommendations should always be considered
122Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex N
(normative)
Recommended maintenance and inspection
In regard to communication cables failure of the cable will result in communications trouble Depending on the failure mode that communication loss can be exceedingly temporary and cyclical to permanent There are many other communications problems that can cause communication failure Any communication failure does not indicate a cable failure but when a cable fails that failure is likely to cause a communication failure In this regard monitoring communication status can be thought of potentially monitoring the cable health
With respect to maintenance and inspection of communication cables the following clauses can be adapted to apply to communication cables
N1 General
In regard to maintenance and inspection practices manufacturerrsquos recommendations should be followed if they exist unless operating experience dictates otherwise The following information should be viewed as general guidelines only and should be modified to suit the situation
Furthermore it is understood that not all sections of the cable runs can be inspected due to the routing of the circuit through ducts or conduits or because it is direct buried or installed in a heavily utilized cable tray Therefore decisions based on inspections of accessible areas may have some associated risk since the ldquobadrdquo section of the cable may not be visible or easily accessible It may be assumed that if one section is in poor shape then the nonaccessible sections could be in worse shape Testing coupled with inspections is the best way to reduce this risk
N2 Inspections
Normally inspections are done only when system investigations indicate the problem may lie in the cable connection or when a condition assessment is required for potential sale of the facility cable aging or as part of a reliability-centered-maintenance program
Visual inspection consists of looking for cracks splits or cuts in the cable jackets (or outer covering) or possible signs of wear due to cable movement during thermal cycling or some other item rubbing against the cable These breaches in the cablersquos protective jacket or insulation may allow moisture to infiltrate which can lead to corrosion of the shielding or cable sheath or an electrical fault Bulges and indentations can indicate moisture ingress or insulating material movement which can also lead to corrosion or insulation failure
The cable termination connection should be tested for tightness by lightly tugging on them while any bolted connections should be checked for proper tightness Infra-red technology can also be used for larger power cables to check for overheating which can indicate loose connections if clearances cannot be obtained
123Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
456789
1011
12
13141516
17181920212223
24
252627
282930313233
34353637
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
N3 Testing methods for metallic cables
a) Continuity A ldquoring-throughrdquo test using a simple door bell and battery circuit (or a cable tracing device) can be used to confirm the cable is connected to the correct location The cable circuit needs to be taken out of service during this testing though This test method can also be used to check the continuity of any cable sheath shield or grounding connection
b) Insulation A ldquoleakage testrdquo uses a device to apply a voltage equivalent to at least 50 of the cablersquos voltage rating to the cablersquos conductor and a ground point to test the cablersquos insulation The voltage is applied for one minute The cable circuit needs to be taken out of service and disconnected during this testing yet any sheath or shield should remain in place and grounded Insulation in good condition should have minimum leakage current and the voltage should not vary more than 10 (of the selected test voltage) The leakage current should be steady or decreased from the initial reading Unstabilized or increasing current levels over time indicate deterioration
For all 600 V rated cables a minimum of 500 V (dc) is recommended to ensure problems are properly detected Since the magnitude of leakage current is highly dependent upon a variety of factors (temperature humidity condition of insulating material length of cable under test) these conditions should be recorded to assess deterioration over time
c) Shield Any protective cable shield can also be tested using this same method but the voltage applied should only be 50 of its nominal rating and it should be applied to cablersquos sheath or shield which has been disconnected and isolated from ground
An ldquoinsulation testrdquo again using a device to apply a voltage between the cablersquos conductor and its sheath or shield at equivalent to 50 of the cables voltage rating can be used to test the cablersquos insulation The duration of this test should be one minute The cablersquos sheath or shield and the conductor should be disconnected and isolated from ground Again insulation in good condition should have minimum leakage current and the voltage should not vary more than 10
For cables without sheaths or shielding it should be noted that there is no difference between results of the ldquoleakage testrdquo or ldquoinsulation testrdquo
N4 Maintenance
The cycle of a regular maintenance program for cable and wires will depend on the age of the cables the operating and environment conditions type of cable and outage availability It is recommended that a visual inspection be done on at least an annual basis and that testing be done only when a problem is suspected
Cables installed in extreme conditions such as wet or high-temperature locations may need to be inspected and tested on a more frequent basis depending on their age
For cables with potheads or shrink-type terminations which are installed in high-contamination areas it is recommended that they be cleaned on a regular basis dictated by operating experience to avoid the risk of electrical flashover to ground Cable terminations should be cleaned using the manufacturerrsquos recommendations with the cable circuit out of service and isolated Cleaning with high-pressure water is possible in some outdoor locations but hand cleaning is preferred
124Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23456
789
101112131415
1617181920
212223
242526272829
3031
32
33343536
3738
394041424344
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
For cable circuits installed in less hostile environments the amount of dust or other matter collecting on the terminations (or around them) needs to be monitored on a regular basis to ensure the electrical clearances are not compromised Again the same cleaning methods apply
125Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
123
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Annex O
(informative)
Example for small substation
O1 General
This annex presents a typical distribution substation and steps through the process of designing the cable system for it Typical values are used for this sample and are for illustration purposes only
O2 Design parameters
Details of the substation are provided in Table O1 through Table O4 and in the one line diagram (see Figure O1) Each circuit breaker is controlled remotely by an energy management system (EMS) and locally from the control building An RTU is installed in the control building and is connected to the EMS via the local phone company system Metering data is obtained from the electronic protective relays (often referred to as intelligent electronic devices or IEDs)
The control building is supplied as a prefabricated module with lighting receptacles fire protection security heating air conditioning and ventilation All wiring for the control building is specified by the supplier according to the NEC [B100]
AC supplies are also required for auxiliary circuits to outdoor lighting and power receptacles for installation and testing equipment such as SF6 gas carts and transformer oil plants
Outdoor lighting consists of four 100 W high-pressure sodium (HPS) floodlights mounted on equipment structures The four 100 W HPS floodlights will be supplied by two circuits each with two of the floodlights (ie 200 W per circuit)
Outdoor receptacles will be provided at following two central locations 1) near the transformers and 69 kV circuit breakers and 2) in the 12 kV equipment area The maximum load expected for these receptacles is 240120 V 40 A 90 PF
Table O22mdash Site conditions
Parameter Value
Ambient temperature 0 degC to 40 degCLightning activity number of flashes per 100 kmyr 4Earth conditions Dry rocks may be found in soil
Table O23mdash Electric system parameters
Parameter HV LV
Nominal voltage phase to phase 69 kV 1247 kVFrequency 60 Hz 60 HzMaximum fault current three-phase rms 15 kA 10 kA
126Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
567
8
91011121314
151617
1819
202122
232425
26
27
28
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Table O24mdash Substation parameters
Parameter Value
DC systemType 60 cell battery with chargerVoltage 125 V (dc) nom 105 V (dc) EODa
Continuous load 5 AFault level 1 kA
AC station service systemType 1 phase 15 kVAVoltage 240120 VLoad 15 kVAShort-circuit level (ISC) 15 kACircuit breaker clearing time Maximum two cycles at ISC
Circuit breaker (69 kV and 1247 kV)CTs 20005 A C400 20 Ω total burdenTrip coil 10 A 90 V (dc) to 140 V (dc)Close coil 5 A 90 V (dc) to 140 V (dc)Alarms and status points 5
Spring charging motor10 A run 24 A inrush115 V (ac) plusmn10
AC load60 W light 15 A receptacle 200 W heater
TransformerCooling fan motors 6 times 1 kW 230 V (ac)Alarm and status points 10
Control cabinet ac load60 W light 15 A receptacle 200 W heater 120 V (ac)
Motor-operated disconnect switches (69 kV and 1247 kV)
Motor2 A run 5 A inrush 125 V (dc) 90 V (dc) minimum
Cabinet heater 30 W at 120 V (ac)Status points 3
Voltage transformerSecondaries Wye connected
aEOD is the end of discharge which is used as the supply voltage for critical dc circuits
Table O25mdash Design parameters
Voltage drop criteria Value
DC supply voltage for critical circuits 105 V (dc) (EOD)a
DC supply voltage 116 V (dc)AC supply voltage 120240 V (ac)Feeders circuit voltage drop 3 maximumBranch circuit voltage drop 3 maximumOverall voltage drop 5 maximumVT voltage drop 1 maximum
aEOD is the end of discharge which is used as the supply voltage for critical dc circuits
127Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Figure O6mdash One line diagram
O3 Select cables construction
O31 Conductor material
Refer to C11
Copper conductor will be used for all cables in this installation Conductors will be stranded The minimum size for field cables will be 18 AWG for mechanical strength The minimum size for cables in the control building will be 22 AWG
NOTEmdashFor conductor sizes 18 AWG and smaller the mechanical strength may be lower than required for pulling A larger conductor size may be required to increase the mechanical strength for difficult pulling situations (eg long runs many bends)
O32 Insulation
Refer to C5
The cables will be installed in a dry environment with an ambient temperature up to 40 degC The cables will be used both indoors and outdoors PVC conduit will be used outdoors for both above ground and below ground installations Cable tray will be used indoors PVC conduit cannot be used with cables having operating temperatures above 75 degC This means that cables with a temperature rating up to 75 degC may be used Those with a higher temperature rating may also be used but not at a temperature above 75 degC Other thermoplastic pipes can be used as conduit for operating temperatures above 75 degC such as PE or chlorinated PVC
128Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4
5
678
91011
12
13
1415161718192012
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
All equipment being wired is rated for 75 degC wiring
Various choices are available for this type of cable Cables with XLPE insulation and an overall PE jacket will be used Color coding would be based on national standards or the utilityrsquos standard
O33 Voltage rating
Refer to 432 and C51
The voltages used for the protection control and station service supplies are either 125 V dc or 120240 V ac Voltage rating of either 600 V or 1000 V could be considered A cable voltage rating of 600 V will be selected for this installation since the voltage rating is over twice the highest voltage used
O34 Shielding and grounding
Refer to 47 and Annex G
The voltage levels are 69 kV and 1247 kV There are no capacitors or high-voltage equipment (230 kV or greater) in the station meaning there are no significant sources of EMI The lightning frequency is small and can be ignored as an EMI source Based on this nonshielded cable will be used
O35 Number of conductors
Cables with 1 3 4 7 12 and 19 conductors are available for the project Cables with 22 AWG or smaller conductors are available with 3 pair 6 pair or 18 pair
O4 Determine raceway routing
Refer to Annex F
The site is rectangular with equipment located by voltage level from high to low voltage and symmetrical when multiple equipment devices are used (eg the two transformers are located adjacent to each other) Refer to the site plan in Figure O2 The raceway design will be based on cost and practicality Options considered include direct burial conduit tray and trench
The chosen raceway will consist of a main concrete cable trench with conduit runs to individual equipment This results in short conduit runs that create few pulling problems and a main trench that is economical The main trench also will accommodate future expansion of the substation The main trench will be located away from the transformer For this substation 6 m (20 ft) was chosen as a safe distance to avoid spewing oil Also the cable trench will be located and the station sloped so oil spills do not flow into the cable trench
The routing to each piece of equipment is shown in Figure O3 The cable lengths from each piece of equipment to the control building are listed in Table O5
129Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
234
5
6
789
10
11
12
13141516
17
1819
20
21
22232425
262728293031
3233
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Figure O7mdash Site plan
130Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Figure O8mdash Cable routing plan
131Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
Table O26mdashCable lengths
EquipmentLength
(See note)
m ft
Transformer no 1 (T1) 38 125Transformer no 2 (T2) 34 1 1269 kV circuit breaker (69CB 1) 54 17769 kV circuit breaker (69CB2) 52 17169 kV circuit breaker (69CB3) 41 13512 kV circuit breaker (12CB1) 33 10912 kV circuit breaker (12CB2) 18 6012 kV circuit breaker (12CB11) 36 11912 kV circuit breaker (12CB12) 33 10912 kV circuit breaker (12CB13) 21 6812 kV circuit breaker (12CB14) 18 5969 kV motor operated disconnect switch (69DT1) 47 15469 kV motor operated disconnect switch (69DT2) 36 11812 kV motor operated disconnect switch (12D3) 26 8469 kV VT (69VT1) 50 16469 kV VT (69VT2) 46 15212 kV VT (12VT1) 31 10312 kV VT (12VT2) 16 54Station service supply no 1 (SST1) 30 100Station service supply no 2 (SST2) 16 54Receptacle no 1 (R1) 22 72Receptacle no 2 (R2) 38 125Floodlight no 1 (FL 1) 16 52Floodlight no 2 (distance is between 1 and 2) (FL2) 28 92Floodlight no 3 (FL3) 62 203Floodlight no 4 (distance is between 3 and 4) (FL4) 28 92
NOTEmdashLengths from equipment terminal cabinet to control building are rounded to the nearest meter or foot and include allowance for leads at both ends of a run
O5 Cable sizing
O51 69 kV circuit breaker cables
Typically the same conductor sizes will be used for protection and control cables for all circuit breakers AC and dc supply conductors are often larger and may be sized for each circuit breaker
O511 Trip coil cables
The same conductor size will be used for all circuit breakers The farthest circuit breaker is 54 m (176 ft) away from the control building The battery voltage will be the end of discharge value of 105 V
132Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
67
8
910
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O5111 Ampacity
Per Articles 310-15 and 220-10 of the NEC [B100] for a noncontinuous load the conductor ampacity will be 100 of the rated current
Required ampacity = 10 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature) (Note that the over current protection for this conductor would be limited to 15 A per Article 2404(D) of the NEC [B100])
NOTEmdashThe NEC ampacity is based on a continuous load Using the NEC tables for noncontinuous loads will result in conservative sizing However ampacity is not usually the governing factor for cable selection and should not lead to over design
O5112 Voltage drop
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 105 V plusmn 005
= 525 V
mdash Per unit length resistance for maximum circuit breaker cable length of 54 m (176 ft) at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = 525 V10 A
= 0525 Ω
NOTEmdashThese conductors will be in nonmetallic conduits and Rdc = Rac for these smaller size conductors
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times (2 times 54 m) 0525 Ω times [1 + 000393 (75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times
104 at 75 degC
= 9030 cmil
The next size up commercial size is 10 AWG (10 380 cmil)
mdash Actual voltage drop for 10 AWG
Rdc = 3402559110 380 cmil times [1 + 000393 (75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 39698 mΩm
Vdrop = 39698 mΩm times 54 mrun times 2 runs times 10 A
= 429 V
133Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
5678
910
11
12
13
14
15
1617
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O5113 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
Short-circuit magnitude is 1 kA
Trip time for ISC is no more than two cycles (0033 s) for the equipment used This time varies
according to the specific equipment used
Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C15 (for XLPE or EPR)
Initial temperature is 75 degC
NOTEmdashThis is conservative Given a noncontinuous load it is unlikely that the conductor temperature will be this high Justification could be made for using a lower temperature (eg ambient temperature) if this became a governing factor in cable sizing
mdash Using Equation (C15b) the minimum conductor size for short-circuit capability is
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [(T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)]05
A = 1 kA (00125 0033) log10 [(250 + 2345) (75 + 2345)]05
A = 3699 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 14 AWG (4110 cmil)
O5114 Cable selection
The minimum conductor size for ampacity voltage drop and short-circuit capability is 10 AWG The resulting voltage drop for this conductor is 42
O512 Close coil
The same cable will be used for both the trip and close coils The conductor size of 10 AWG for the 10 A trip coil current will be suitable for the 5 A close coil
The trip coil and close coil conductors will be in the same cable Trip coil monitoring is also being used in this situation and will require one additional conductor A total of five conductors are required A seven- conductor cable will be used allowing two spare conductors for future use
O513 Current transformers
The secondary circuit conductors for the CTs will be sized here The circuit breaker has CTs on both sides of the circuit breaker that are rated 20005 A C400 for a total burden of 20 Ω The same conductor size will be used for all circuit breakers The farthest circuit breaker is 54 m (176 ft) away from the control building
134Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
89
10
11
12
13
1415
16
17
1819
20
2122
232425
26
27282930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O5131 Ampacity
The CTs have a ratio of 20005 (ratio of 400) The maximum expected secondary current will be 086 A for fully rated transformer load of 41 MVA (41 MVA 69 kV radic3 400 = 3431 A 400 = 086 A)
Per Article 220-10 of the NEC [B100] for a continuous load the conductor ampacity should be 125 of the load
Required ampacity = 086 A times 125 = 11 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O5132 Burden
The total burden for the CT circuit should be 20 Ω or less to maintain its accuracy This will include the burden of the CT winding the circuit conductors and relay(s)
mdash CT windings have a burden of approximately 00025 Ωturn For the CTs used on the circuit breaker we have
Burden (CT) = 00025 Ωturn times 20005 turns
= 1 Ω
mdash The relay has a burden of 001 Ω
mdash The maximum allowable resistance of the secondary conductors is
Burden (cond) = 2 minus 1 minus 001
= 099 Ω
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591times (2 times 54 m)099 Ω times [1 + 000393 (75 degC ndash 20 degC) ] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 4789 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 12 AWG (6530 cmil)
O5133 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
Short-circuit magnitude is 20 A (20 times full load current)
135Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
45
6
789
10
1112
1314
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
2223
24
2526
27
28
29
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
mdash Trip time is usually less than ten cycles but failure of a protection circuit could lead to a duration of over 1 s For this calculation 2 s will be used
Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C15
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
mdash Using Equation (C15b) the minimum conductor size for short-circuit capability is
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [ (T2 + K0(T1 + K0)] 05
= 20 A (001252) log 10 [(250 + 2345)(75 + 2345)] 05
= 73 cmil
The next size up commercial size is 22 AWG (642 cmil)
O5134 Cable selection
The minimum conductor size for ampacity burden and short-circuit capability is 12 AWG
O514 Motor supply
The circuit breaker spring charging motor is operated at 115 V (ac) has a 10 A running current and a 24 A inrush current The power factor is 90 and 25 for run and starting respectively
O5141 Ampacity
Per Articles 310-15 and 220-10 of the NEC [B100] for a noncontinuous load the conductor ampacity will be 100 of the rated current
Required ampacity = 10 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O5142 Voltage drop
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 120 V times 005
= 6 V
mdash Resistance at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = 6 V 10 A
136Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4
5
6
7
89
10
11
12
13
1415
16
1718
19
202122
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
= 06 Ω
NOTEmdashThese conductors will be in nonmetallic conduits and Rdc = Rac
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times (2 times 54 m)06 Ω times [1 + 000393 (75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 7901 cmil
The next size up commercial size is 10 AWG (10 380cmil)
mdash Check starting voltage
Rdc = 3402559110 380cmil times [1 + 000393 (75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 42289 mΩm
Vdrop = IR cos θ
= 24 A times (42289 mΩm times 54 mrun times 2 runs)
= 110 V
Vmotor = 120 V ndash 110 V = 109 V
The motor starting voltage is above the minimum voltage of 1035 V (115 V ndash 10)
O5143 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
Short-circuit level is 15 kA
mdash Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C15
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
NOTEmdashThis is conservative Given a noncontinuous load it is unlikely that the conductor temperature will be this high Justification could be made for using the ambient temperature if this became a governing factor in cable sizing
mdash Clearing time typically two cycles (0033 s)
mdash Using Equation (C15b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [ (T2 + K0)(T1 + K0) ] 05
= 15 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345)(75 + 2345)] 05
137Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
45
6
7
8
910
11
12
13
14
15
1617
18
19
20
2122
23
2425
26
27
28
29
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
= 5549 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 12 AWG (6530 cmil)
O5144 Cable selection
A conductor size of 10 AWG will satisfy ampacity voltage drop and short-circuit capability requirements for the circuit breaker spring charging motor
O515 Auxiliary ac supply
The full load current is 173 A (15 A receptacle + 60 W + 200 W114 V)
O5151 Ampacity
The heaters will be assumed to be continuous loads and the light and receptacle noncontinuous loads For ampacity 125 of continuous load and 100 of noncontinuous load will be used
Required ampacity = (150 W times 125)114 V + 15 A + (60 W114 V) = 172 A
A 20 A protective device is used to protect the circuit Per Table 310-16 and Section 2404(D) of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature 10 AWG has an ampacity of 308 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O5152 Voltage drop
The conductor will be sized for voltage drop based on an 8 A load connected to the receptacle with a unity power factor and both the heater and light on This gives a current of 98 A8 A + (60 W + 200 W) 114 V
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 120 V times 005
= 60 V
mdash Per unit length resistance for maximum circuit breaker cable length of 54 m (176 ft) at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = 60 V98 A
= 0549 Ω
NOTEmdashFor this size of cable in non metallic conduit Rdc = Rac
mdash Using Equation (C5)
138Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
23
4
56
7
8
9
1011
12
131415
16
171819
20
21
22
23
2425
26
27
28
29
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
A = 34025591 times (2 times 54 m)0549 Ω times [1 + 000393(75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 8641 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 10 AWG (10 380 cmil)
mdash Per unit resistance at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = Rdc = 340255910 380 cmil times [1 + 000393(75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 42289 mΩm
mdash Actual voltage drop for 10 AWG
Vdrop = 42289 mΩm times 54 mrun times 2 runs times 98
A = 45 V or 38
O5153 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
Short-circuit level is 15 kA
mdash Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C8
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
NOTEmdashThis is conservative Given a noncontinuous load it is unlikely that the conductor temperature will be this high Justification could be made for using the ambient temperature if this became a governing factor in cable sizing
mdash Clearing time typically two cycles (0033 s)
mdash Using Equation (C15b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [ (T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)] 05
= 15 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345)(75 + 2345)] 05
= 5549 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 12 AWG (6530 cmil)
O5154 Cable selection
A 10 AWG conductor results in a voltage drop of 38 This conductor size also satisfies the minimum size for ampacity and for short-circuit capability
O516 Alarm and status
Since the current in these conductors is small they will not be individually sized A 16 AWG conductor will be used for these applications Five (5) status alarm and status points are required in this situation This
139Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4
5
67
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
1718
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
2627
28
2930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
will require ten conductors A 12-conductor cable will be used providing two spare conductors for future use
O52 Disconnect switch
O521 Motor supply
Motorized disconnect switches have a motor operator that uses 125 V (dc) has a 2 A run current and a 5 A inrush current It is not essential for the motors to be able to operate under all conditions (ie manual operation is possible even for motor operated disconnect switches) The disconnect switch motors are not critical equipment and are expected to operate at the battery end of discharge voltage
O5211 Ampacity
The specified current is at the rated voltage of 125 V The normal expected battery voltage is 116 V and equipment terminal voltage for a 5 voltage drop will be 110 V The current will then be 216 A (2 A times 125 V110 V)
Per Articles 310-15 and 220-10 of the NEC [B100] for a noncontinuous load the conductor ampacity will be 100 of the rated current
Required ampacity = 23 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O5212 Voltage drop
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 116 V times 005
= 58 V
mdash Resistance at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = 58 V 23 A
= 2552 Ω
NOTEmdashThese conductors will be in nonmetallic conduits and Rdc = Rac
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times (2 times 47 m)2552 Ω times [1 + 000393(75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
140Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4
5678
9
101112
1314
15
161718
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2930
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
= 1617 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 18 AWG (1620 cmil)
O5213 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
mdash Short-circuit level is 10 kA
mdash Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C8
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
NOTEmdashThis is conservative Given a noncontinuous load it is unlikely that the conductor temperature will be this high Justification could be made for using the ambient temperature if this became a governing factor in cable sizing
mdash Clearing time typically two cycles (0033 s)
mdash Using Equation (C15b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [(T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)] 05
= 10 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345)(75 + 2345)] 05
= 3399 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 14 AWG (4110 cmil)
O5214 Cable selection
A conductor size of 14 AWG will satisfy ampacity voltage drop and short-circuit capability requirements for the circuit breaker spring charging motor
mdash Check starting voltage
Rdc = 340255914110 cmil times [1+ 000393(75 degC ndash 20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 1068 mΩm
Vdrop = 1068 mΩm times 47 mrun times 2 runs times 5 A
= 50 V
Vmotor = 116 V ndash 50 V
= 111 V
The motor starting voltage is above the minimum voltage of 90 V
141Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
89
10
11
12
13
14
15
1617
18
1920
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O522 Status and alarms
Since the current in these conductors is small they will not be individually sized A 16 AWG conductor will be used for these applications Three (3) position contacts are required in this situation This will require six conductors A seven-conductor cable will be used providing one spare conductor for future use
NOTEmdashFor conductor sizes 16 AWG and smaller the mechanical strength may be lower than required for pulling Additional conductor or a larger conductor size may be required to increase the mechanical strength of a cable
O523 Auxiliary ac supply
O5231 Ampacity
The heaters will be assumed to be continuous load
Required ampacity = (30 W times 125)114 V = 033 A
Per Table 310-16 and Article 2404(D) of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O5232 Voltage drop
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 120 V times 005
= 60 V
mdash Total circuit resistance for maximum cable length of 47 m (144 ft) at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = 60 V033 A
= 228 Ω
NOTEmdashFor this size of cable in non metallic conduit Rdc = Rac
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times (2 times 47 m)228 Ω times [1+000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 181 cmil
The smallest size used for field cables is 18 AWG (1620 cmil)
142Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
234
56
7
8
9
10
111213
14
15
16
17
18
1920
21
22
23
24
2526
27
28
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O5233 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
mdash Short-circuit level is 15 kA
mdash Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C8
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
mdash Clearing time typically two cycles (0033 s)
mdash Using Equation (C15b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [(T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)] 05
= 15 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345)(75 + 2345)] 05
= 5549 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 12 AWG (6530 cmil)
Because the current is small the operating temperature may be much lower than the assumed 75 degC To see if a smaller conductor could be used an approximation will be made by solving Equation (C15b) for T2 with T1 at ambient Using 14 AWG conductor a temperature rise of 1deg is expected Initial temperature is 41 degC Again using Equation (C 1 5b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [(T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)] 05
= 15 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345) (41 + 2345)] 05
= 4944 cmil
The next larger commercial size remains 12 AWG
O5234 Cable selection
A 12 AWG conductor is required to satisfy short-circuit capability The resulting voltage drop is 004
mdash Voltage drop for 12 AWG
Rac = Rdc
= 340255916530 cmil times [1 + 000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 59836 mΩm
Vdrop = 59836 mΩm times 47 mrun times 2 runs times 033 A
= 017 V or 014
143Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12131415
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O53 Transformer
O531 Current transformers
The secondary conductors for the CTs will be sized here The power transformer has CTs on both the high- voltage and low-voltage sides On the high-voltage side 20005 and 6005 CTs are used On the low- voltage side 20005 CTs are used All CTs are C400 type which can have a total burden of 20 Ω
Conductors sized for the circuit breaker CTs will also be suitable for the power transformer CTs Per O513 the minimum conductor size for ampacity burden and short-circuit capability is 12 AWG
O532 Status and alarms
Ten (10) status and alarm points are required for the power transformers This will require a total of 20 conductors Two 12-conductor cables will be used providing four spare conductors for future use
O533 Auxiliary ac supply
The power transformers have cooling fan motors with a total load of 6 kW at 240 V (ac) 95 PF The control cabinet has 115 V (ac) loads consisting of a 60 W light a 15 A receptacle and a 200 W heater For voltage drop the largest load would be at maximum temperature with the fans operating the light on and an 8 A load connected to the receptacle It is assumed the cabinet heater would not operate when the fans are operating
NOTEmdashThe 115 V loads are all on the same line but it is be possible to put the loads on different lines to reduce the peak load Also each load has its own over current protection after the external terminal block
O5331 Ampacity
The load will be assumed to be continuous loads
Required ampacity = 6 kW230 V095 PF + (200 W + 60 W)115 V + 15 A times 125 = 559 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature 6 AWG with an ampacity of 572 A (adjusted for ambient temperature) is the smallest suitable size
O5332 Voltage drop
The conductor will be sized for voltage drop for a load of 6 kW230 V095 + 60 W115 V + 8 A = 36 A
Refer to C3
mdash The target voltage drop is 5 overall
Vdrop = 240 V times 005
= 120 V
144Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2
345
67
8
910
11
1213141516
1718
19
20
21
222324
25
26
27
28
29
30
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
mdash Per unit length resistance for maximum circuit breaker cable length of 38 m (114 ft) at a temperature of 75 degC
Rdc = Rac = 120 V 36 A
= 0332 Ω
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times (2 times 38 m) 0332 Ω times [1+000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 10 003 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 10 AWG (10 380 cmil)
O5333 Short-circuit capability
Refer to C4
mdash Short-circuit level is 15 kA
mdash Short-time maximum conductor temperature is 250 degC per Table C8
mdash Initial temperature is 75 degC
mdash Clearing time typically two cycles (0033 s)
mdash Using Equation (C15b)
A = ISC 00125 tF log10 [ (T2 + K0)(T1 + K0)] 05
= 15 kA (001250033) log10 [(250 + 2345) (41 + 2345)] 05
= 4944 cmil
The next larger commercial size remains 12 AWG (6530 cmil)
O5334 Cable selection
A 6 AWG conductor is required for ampacity Based on this conductor size the voltage drop will be 17
mdash Actual voltage drop for 6 AWG
Rac = Rdc = 3402559136240 cmil times [1+000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 14891 mΩm
Vdrop = 14891 mΩm times 38 mrun times 2 runs times 36 A
= 457 V or 19
145Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
12
3
4
5
67
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O54 Voltage transformers
The secondary conductors for the VTs will be sized for steady-state operation The VT secondaries are connected wye giving a voltage of 120 Vradic3 or 6928 V The VTs have a maximum allowable burden of 75 VA at 85 PF The same conductor size will be used for all VTs The farthest VT is 50 m (148 ft) away from the control building
O541 Ampacity
Per Article 220-10 of the NEC [B100] for a continuous load the conductor ampacity should be 125 of the load
Required ampacity = 75 VA times 125120 V radic3 = 045 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest listed size is 14 AWG which has an ampacity of 176 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O542 Voltage drop
Refer to C3 Designing to the maximum burden will not provide for accurate voltages at the relay Voltage drop will be the design parameter and the total burden will be verified to be below the maximum
mdash The target voltage drop is 1 for high accuracy
Vdrop = 693 V times 001
= 069 V
mdash Conductor resistance for a balanced system voltage maximum burden and a temperature of 75 degC
Rdc = Rac = 069 V 036 A
= 192Ω
NOTEmdashFor this size of cable in non metallic conduit Rdc = Rac
mdash Using Equation (C5)
A = 34025591 times 50 m) 131 Ω j1+ 000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 1075 cmil
The next larger commercial size is 18 AWG (1620 cmil)
O543 Short-circuit capability
The short-circuit capability of a VT is low and does not need to be considered
146Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
2345
6
78
9
101112
13
1415
16
17
18
1920
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12
P525D2 March 2014Draft Guide for the Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Substations
O544 Cable selection
The minimum conductor size for ampacity and voltage drop is 14 AWG Allowing 01 A for relay burden (electronic relays have burdens in the order of 02 VA) the total burden will be 82 VA less than the 75 VA maximum
mdash Actual voltage drop for 6 AWG
Rac = Rdc = 34025591 4110 cmil times [1 + 000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 1068 mΩm
Burden = (1068 mΩm times 50 m times (01 A 085 PF)2) + (693 V times 01 A 085 PF) = 82 VA
O55 Station service supply
The two station service supplies have a 15 kVA capacity Only one is used to supply the load at a time The total connected load with allowance for additional equipment in the future is 10 kW with an average power factor of 90
O551 Ampacity
Required ampacity = (15 kVA times 125) 230 = 815 A
Per Table 310-16 of the NEC [B100] for 75 degC conductor temperature and for a 40 degC ambient temperature the smallest suitable size is 3 AWG which has an ampacity of 88 A (adjusted for ambient temperature)
O552 Voltage drop
Load for voltage drop will be 10 kW at 90 PF or 483 A
The transformer taps will be adjusted to provide a voltage of approximately 120 V at the service panel The transformer has four taps of 125 each Voltage drop will be calculated for the 3 AWG conductor required for ampacity
mdash Per unit resistance at a temperature of 75 degC
Rac = Rdc = 34025591 52620 cmil times [1+ 000393(75 degCndash20 degC)] times 102 times 104 at 75 degC
= 08342 mΩm
Vdrop = 08342 mΩm times 38 mrun times 2 runs times 483 A
= 31 V or 13
Setting the transformer tap at +125 will result in a service panel voltage of 2399 V (240 times 10125 ndash 31 V)
147Copyright copy 2008 IEEE All rights reserved
1
234
5
6
7
8
9
101112
13
14
151617
18
19
202122
23
2425
26
27
28
2930
12