Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion...

34
2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 1 Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in Closed String Field Theory Isao Kishimoto (Univ. of Tokyo) [KMW1] I.K., Y. Matsuo, E. Watanabe, PRD68 (2003) 126006 [KMW2] I.K., Y. Matsuo, E. Watanabe, PTP111 (2004) 433 [KM] I.K., Y. Matsuo, PLB590(2004)303 (+ I.K., Y. Matsuo, H. Isono, E. Watanabe, work in progress )

Transcript of Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion...

Page 1: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 1

Idempotency Equation and

Boundary States

in Closed String Field Theory

Isao Kishimoto(Univ. of Tokyo)

[KMW1] I.K., Y. Matsuo, E. Watanabe, PRD68 (2003) 126006

[KMW2] I.K., Y. Matsuo, E. Watanabe, PTP111 (2004) 433

[KM] I.K., Y. Matsuo, PLB590(2004)303

(+ I.K., Y. Matsuo, H. Isono, E. Watanabe, work in progress )

Page 2: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 2

Introduction

• Sen’s conjecture:Witten’s open SFT

∃ tachyon vacuum

• Vacuum String Field Theory (VSFT)[Rastelli-Sen-Zwiebach(2000)]

D-brane~ Projector with respect to Witten’s * product.

(Sliver, Butterfly,… )

D25-brane

Page 3: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 3

D-brane ~ Boundary state ← closed string

Closed SFT description is more natural (!?)

HIKKO cubic CSFT (Nonpolynomial CSFT)

Page 4: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 4

Contents

• Introduction

• Star product in closed SFT

• Star product of boundary states [KMW1]

• Idempotency equation [KMW1,KMW2]

• Fluctuations [KMW1,KMW2]

• Cardy states and idempotents [KM]

• TD,TD/Z2 compactification

• Summary and discussion

Page 5: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 5

Star product in closed SFT

* product is defined by 3-string vertex:

• HIKKO (Hata-Itoh-Kugo-Kunitomo-Ogawa) type

and ghost sector (to be compatible with BRST invariance)

with projection:

Page 6: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 6

α3

α1α2

Overlapping condition for 3 closed strings

Interaction point

Page 7: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 7

• Explicit representation of the 3-string vertex:

solution to overlapping condition [HIKKO]

( Gaussian !)

Page 8: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 8

: Neumann coefficients of light-cone type

We can prove various relations. [Mandelstam, Green-Schwarz,…]

[Yoneya(1987)]

Page 9: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 9

Star product of boundary stateThe boundary state for Dp-brane with constant flux:

Page 10: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 10

“idempotency equation”

Page 11: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 11

Page 12: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 12

Idempotency equation

The boundary state which corresponds to Dp-brane is

a solution to this equation in the following sense.

Page 13: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 13

• Boundary state as an “idempotent” :

Page 14: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 14

Fluctuations

By straightforward computation in oscillator language, we found scalar

and vector type “solutions”:

Page 15: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 15

Page 16: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 16

Page 17: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 17

A sufficient condition for this solution : primary with weight 1

Page 18: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 18

By modifying the vector type fluctuation [Murakami-Nakatsu(2002)] :

Page 19: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 19

Page 20: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 20

Cardy states and idempotents• On the flat ( Rd ) background, we have *product formula

for Ishibashi states :

Conjecture

Cardy states ~ idempotents in closed SFT

even on nontrivial backgrounds.

Page 21: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 21

Page 22: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 22

• Orbifold (M/Γ)

Page 23: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 23

[cf. Billo et al.(2001)]

Page 24: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 24

• Fusion ring of RCFT

[Verlinde(1988)]

[T.Kawai (1989)]

Page 25: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 25

TD,TD/Z2 compactification

Explicit formulation of closed SFT on TD,TD/Z2is known. [HIKKO(1987), Itoh-Kunitomo(1988)]

We can compute *product of Ishibashi states directly.

3-string vertex is modified:

Page 26: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 26

*products of these states are not diagonal.

→ We consider following linear combinations:

Page 27: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 27

Page 28: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 28

Page 29: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 29

doubling

~ doubling of open string 1-loop

1

2

3

1

2

3

T/2

regularize

T

Page 30: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 30

[Asakawa-Kugo-Takahashi(1999)]

Page 31: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 31

cut

Boundary 1

Boundary 2

Ratio of 1-loop amplitude:

Page 32: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 32

(※) Neumann type idempotents are obtained from Dirichlet type by T-duality :

Page 33: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33

Summary and discussion

• Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation

in closed SFT (on RD,TD,TD/Z2 ).

• Variation around idempotents gives open string

spectrum.

• Idempotents ~ Cardy states

: detailed correspondence?

• Closed version of VSFT? (Veneziano amplitude,…)

• More nontrivial background? (other orbifolds,…)

• Supersymmetric extension? (HIKKO’s NSR vertex,…)

Page 34: Idempotency Equation and Boundary States in …2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 33 Summary and discussion •Cardy states satisfy idempotency equation in closed SFT (on R D,T ,TD/Z 2). •Variation

2004/6/2 seminar@RIKEN 34

• 3-string vertex in Nonpolynomial CSFT

• n-string vertices (n≧4) in nonpolynomial CSFT?

We can also prove idempotency straightforwardly:

(Computation is simplified by closed sting version of MSFT. [Bars-Kishimoto-Matsuo] )

← closed string version of Witten’s * product