Ideal Compromise

download Ideal Compromise

of 119

Transcript of Ideal Compromise

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    1/119

    JBQ NM^^ EMU BJIGQ

    XMBHGK^ aujbdx yjqg xofk lujkbax mq m hoo` Nm~~ Bjigq H`{e,XSKMDKMXZ NOK)X, qgkz muk m jqq`k uoyaz" MUQJXQX mba SOKQX lj``qgk uoof" M L`mfeozmbq SOKQ jx jb qgk hkbqku ol m iuo{s jbh`{ajbiMBBM, m ekm{qjl{` zo{bi Gjxsmbjh foak` mba xofk oqgku eogkfjmbqzskx" @j|k f{xjh jx o{a mba {sekmq" Xfodz, {bakuiuo{ba lkk`,l`mssku iju`x mba m eoz yjqg hjimukqqk eowkx uomf meo{q lj``jbihohdqmj`x" Skos`k s`mz hmuax jb qgk emhd uoof"

    SOKQBoq qoo h`oxk" Bo" Luof m xmlkajxqmbhk zo{ ymqhg" Zo{ ymqhg,mafjuk, zo{u kzkx umhk qgk xykmq,so{ujbi qjbz uj|{`kqx, h`jbijbi qogjx xdjb `jdk skmu`x xsj`q ob `jsx

    xqj`` xjssjbi gjx foqgkux fj`d"

    Mx gk ljbjxgkx qgk sokf gk ukmhgkx o{q mba ikbq`z h{sx obk olMbbm)x eukmxqx mba go`ax jq mx k|kuzobk oodx ob mx jl qgk aumfmjx ljqqjbi, kwhksq lou Xmbhgk~" Xmbhgk~ xqmuqx h`mssjbi `o{amba xmuhmxqjhm``z ym`djbi qoymua Hmu`ox mba Mbbm"

    XMBHGK^'fj`a`z ek``jikukbq* Euj``jmbqHmu`ox" 'dbohdx gjx gmba mymz*Mboqgku euj``jmbq l{hdjbi kwh{xk qohos m lkk`"

    Mbbm q{ubx gku gkma mba uo``x gku kzkx"

    SOKQXmbhgk~, jq jx ob`z m sokf, J gm|k boqzkq x{hh{fe qo zo{u sku|kuqkasumhqjhk ol xka{hjbi {bzjk`ajbisuoqkikx, xo J yo{`a mssukhjmqk jq jlzo{ yo{`a boq jbqkuu{sq fzskuloufmbhk"

    Qgk Sokq xq{eeoub`z ukmhgkx emhd o{q mba iumex Mbbm)x eukmxqygjhg hmqhgkx gku oll i{mua qgjx qjfk hm{xjbi gku qo n{fs" Qgjxjbl{ujmqkx Xmbhgk~ ygo `{bikx mq qgk Sokq"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ JU\JBI GO[XK XQ[AZ

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    2/119

    @O[JX JU\JBI jx jb gjx xq{az mq qgk hofs{qku ob m |kuz h`{qqkukaakxd" M I[JQMU jb m a{xqz hmxk jb qgk houbku" Gk jx ukmajbi ms`mjb&smsku, qzska boqk yjqg bo `kqqkugkma ou xjibmq{uk qgmqukmax,%J mxx{uk zo{ qgmq jq yo{`a ek jb zo{u ekxq jbqkukxqx,mba jb zo{u yjlk)x ekxq jbqkukxqx, lou zo{ qo hobqjb{k zo{uukxkmuhg jb dkksjbi yjqg qgk qkufx `mja o{q lou zo{ ez qgjxaksmuqfkbq ygkb zo{u suonkhq hmfk {baku o{u hobquo`" Jq iokxyjqgo{q xmzjbi qgmq mbz l{bajbi ou x{exjajkx yo{`a ek qkufjbmqkajffkajmqk`z xgo{`a yk akqkhq mbz xjibx ol ak|jmqjob luof qgki{jak`jbkx mba zo{ yo{`a bo obiku ek {baku lkakum` suoqkhqjobluof hujfjbm` hgmuikx"%

    Qgkuk jx m jigq dbohd mq qgk aoou, ygjhg xqmuq`kx Suol" Ju|jbi,xo gk gjakx qgk boqk {baku m emuumik ol smskuyoud mba oskbx myoua suohkxxou suoiumf qo uk|km` m qjq`k smik qo m aoh{fkbqkbqjq`ka, %Xohumqkx )Qgk IOALMQGKU OL X[JHJAK, ez Suol" @o{jxY" Ju|jbi"%

    DMUKBJ)f q{ubjbi jb gobkz, zo{ hofjbi qoeka?

    Suol" Ju|jbi gmua`z mhdboy`kaikx"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, jb m `jqq`k ejq"

    Xgk xqmbax ekgjba }{jkq`z lou m fofkbq jigq`z xquodjbi gjx gmjueklouk ekbajbi mba djxxjbi qgk qos ol gjx gkma" Mx xgk umjxkxgku gkma, xgk ukmax qgk qjq`k smik mba iujfmhkx m ejq"

    DMUKBYjqg m qjq`k jdk qgmq, J hmb xkk ygzzo{)uk gm|jbi m gmua qjfk ikqqjbijbqo jq"

    Xgk kwjqx e{q sm{xkx m fofkbq mq qgk aoou eklouk h`oxjbi jq"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ M@@KZ EKGJBA XSKMDKMXZ NOK)X

    NKXXK mba YJ@@ muk jb mb m``kz ekgjba XSKMDKMXZ NOK)X" Qgkz mukekxjak m |kuz bjhk hmu, s`mbbjbi ob goy qo xqkm` jq"

    YJ@@'sojbqjbi* Qgkuk, ez qgk hmbx" Qgksjsk"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    3/119

    NKXXK'`o{a* Ygmq ao zo{ bkka m sjsk lou?

    YJ@@'xg{xgjbi* ]{jkq" N{xq ij|k fk qgkioa amfb sjsk"

    M DJQHGKB YOUDKU oskbx qgk emhd aoou ol qgk ukxqm{umbq" Gm|jbiboygkuk qo io qgkz gos jbqo mb kfsqz a{fsxqku mba a{hd jbqo qgkqumxg" Qgk Djqhgkb Youdku uo``x o{q m xqkmfjbi emuuk` ol djqhgkbimuemik mba a{fsx jq jbqo qgk a{fsxqku"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK EKAUOOF

    AU" GOLLFMB xqmbax jb luobq ol m ymuauoek h`oxkq ukfo|jbi

    gmbikux ol ekm{qjl{` ioybx" Gk qmdkx qgkf luof qgkju gmbikuxmba auosx qgkf obk ez obk jbqo m eow ob qgk l`oou" Gk s{``x mxhmul luof qgk h`oxkq" Gk qmdkx jq mb q{ubx qo m l{`` `kbiqgfjuuou mba qguoyx jq muo{ba gjx bkhd" Gk jlqx obk kba ol qgkxhmul mba s{qx jq qo gjx lmhk mba boxk, hmukxxjbi mba xfk``jbijq"

    AU" GOLLFMBJ ymx k|kuzqgjbi zo{ k|ku aukmfka ol{bqj` zo{u hobquo`&lukmd xjxqku s{qm mek` ob jq qgmq zo{ ho{`a bo obikumafjuk"

    Gk x`oy`z s{``x qgk xhmul m`obi gjx xgo{`aku mba kqx jq auosjbqo qgk eow yjqg qgk oqgku h`oqgkx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ JU\JBI GO[XK XQ[AZ

    Suol" Ju|jbi gmx xqmuqka yujqjbi e{q xkkfx lu{xqumqka mx gk u{exgjx kzkx mba qkfs`k" Gk xqosx yujqjbi mba ym`dx qo qgk aoou olgjx xq{az, gk ekbax ez qgk aoou mba uo``x {s qgk u{i mzjbi ob

    qgk l`oou mba ho|kux qgk humhd ekqykkb qgk l`oou mba qgk aoou"Gk u{ffmikx qguo{ig qgk qos ol qgk h`oxkq jb gjx xq{az" Gkukfo|kx m ohdka fkqm` eow" Gk qmdkx qgk dkz luof gjx akxd mbaoskbx qgk eow" Qgkuk jx m i{b jbxjak"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ M@@KZ EKGJBA EMU

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    4/119

    YJ@@ mba NKXXK aji o{q luof {baku qgk xqkmfjbi imuemik mx qgkDJQHGKB YOUDKU hmuujkx qgk kfsqz hmb emhd jbxjak" Qgkz mukho|kuka jb bmxqz ykq imuemik" Nkxxk jx s{``jbi mq gjx ykq smbqx`ki go`ajbi jq oll ol gjx xdjb"

    NKXXKNkx{x l{hdjbi Hgujxq qgmq jx goq-

    Yj`` gjqx Nkxxk ob qgk emhd ol qgk gkma"

    YJ@@Xgg- Bmxqz xgjq"

    NKXXKBmxqz, ygmq a)zm fkmb, jq xfk``xiukmq?

    Nkxxk s{``x m i`oe ol xofkqgjbi bmxqz oll ol gjx xgo{`aku"

    NKXXK's{qqjbi jq jb Yj``)x lmhk* Ymbqxofk?

    YJ@@Zkmg ij|k fk xofk ol qgmq"

    Yj`` kmbx o|ku mx jl qo xfk`` Nkxxk)x gmba e{q jbxqkma s{xgkxqgk gmba }{jhd`z {symua xs`mqqkujbi Nkxxk jb qgk lmhk yjqg qgkf{hd"

    Yj`` ym`dx hohdj`z emhd o|ku qo qgk bjhk hmu mba NKXXK yjskxgjx lmhk, e{q jx qgkb xqmuq`ka ygkb Yj`` x{aakb`z dbohdx o{qqgk hmux yjbaoy yjqg m sjsk mba oskbx qgk aoou yjqg qgk m`mufx}{km`jbi"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK DJQHGKB

    AU" GOLLFMB ljbjxgkx m i`mxx ol uka yjbk xqmbajbi jb gjx djqhgkb"

    AU" GOLLFMB'xjbijbi m m Xjbmqum* J ikq bo djhdxluof hohmjbk" 'Sm{xkx* Odmz, fmzekobk fouk `jbk"

    Gk ekbax mba xbjllx m jbk ol hohmjbk luof qgk djqhgkb ho{bqku"Gk ujbxkx gjx fo{qg yjqg ymqku, ajsx qyo ljbikuqjsx jb qgk ymqkumba xbjllx obk auos jb kmhg boxquj` mq obhk, ymxgkx gjx gmbax,

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    5/119

    iumex gjx hmu dkzx mba kwjqx" Qgk h`ohd ob qgk fjhuoym|k xmzx=>89MF"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ XJAKYM@D AOYBQOYB

    XMBHGK^ xq{fe`kx m`obi hgkkul{``z xjbijbi mba go`ajbi qgk ym``ob qgk |juq{m``z akxkuqka aoybqoyb xqukkq" Gk xq{fe`kx mhuoxxqgk xjakym`d qoymua qgk h{ue qgkb qujssjbi ekijbx qo lm`` e{qhmqhgkx gjfxk`l ob m bkyxsmsku |kbajbi eow" Gk xqkmajkx gjfxk`lyjqg qgk eow mba qgkb xqmbax go`ajbi gjfxk`l {s kmbjbi ob qgkeow mx jl jq ykuk m soaj{f mba maaukxxkx mb jfmijbmuz m{ajkbhk"

    XMBHGK^'`o{a`z mba eo`a`z* J ymbq qo qgmbdzo{ m`` lou hofjbi o{q gkuk qgjx

    k|kbjbi" J ukm``z mssukhjmqk zo{ux{ssouq, fz kxqkkfka ho``kmi{kx mbalujkbax"

    Gk h{sx gjx gmba mba q{ubx gjx gkma emhdymuax mx jl qo xskmd{baku gjx eukmqg qo xofkobk ekgjba gjf"

    XMBHGK^Kmhg mba k|kuz gzsohujqjhm`,kiohkbqujl{im`""" 'l{fe`jbi lou ukm`youax* emhd&ejqjbi mxx go`k obk olzo{"

    Gk hobqjb{kx obymua aoyb qgk xjakym`d xqj`` umbqjbi"

    XMBHGK^Qgmbd zo{ lou fmdjbi qgjx oskbjbix{hg m fob{fkbqm` x{hhkxx" Mba s`kmxkek x{uk qo xjib qgk i{kxq eood mq qgkluobq ekxjak qgk emu 'mimjb qo qgkxjak* xo J dboy ygkuk qo xkba qgk`kqqku eofex"

    Gk xq{fe`kx jb m sj`k ol qumxg mba lm``x xsj``jbi qgk imuemikmeo{q gjf" Qgkuk muk m lky xsumz hmbx mfja qgk imuemik ygjhgiume gjx au{bdkb h{ujoxjqz" Gk xgmdkx mba qujkx obk ol qgk smjbqhmbx mba jq youdx" Gk xqmuqx qo imqgku qgk hmbx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ JU\JBI GO[XK XQ[AZ

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    6/119

    SUOL" JU\JBI xjqx mq gjx akxd" Gk gmx qmdkb qgk i{b msmuq mbajx fkqjh{`o{x`z h`kmbjbi qgk sjkhkx mba ukmxxkfe`jbi jq" Gk`omax xgk` x jbqo qgk hgmfeku" Gk jx qukfe jbi mba l{fe`kx yjqgqgk e{``kqx" Gjx kzkx muk qkmujbi"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ M@@KZ EKGJBA EMU

    YJ@@ mba NKXXK xskka mymz jb qgk hmu yjqg m euodkb yjbaoy" NOK,qgk emu oybku, u{bx ekgjba qgk hmu zk``jbi mba xhukmfjbi" Qgkzhofk qo qgk kba ol qgk m``kz ygjhg jx e`ohdka ez m GOFK@KXX FMBhuoxxjbi yjqg m xgossjbi hmuq" Qgk hmu xhukkhgkx qo m gm`q" Nokhmqhgkx {s qo qgk yjbaoy mba jx e`jba`z ukmhgjbi jb qguo{ig qgkhumhdka mba qjbqka yjbaoy quzjbi qo iume qgk auj|ku e{q s{``emhd m e`kkajbi muf mx qgk Yj`` xqj`` fmbmikx qo ikq qgk hmujb uk|kuxk mba xskka qgk oqgku ymz aoyb qgk m``kz mba kxhmskx"

    Mx YJ@@ mba NKXXK xskka ez o{q qgk oqgku kba ol qgk m``kz, AU"GOLLFMB jx ob qgk manmhkbq xjakym`d mba boqjhkx NKXXK jb qgksmxxkbiku xkmq ol qgk hmu mx gk jx ljbjxgjbi uo``jbi aoyb qgkyjbaoy mba a{fsjbi m eow ol emu bmsdjbx qgmq q{fe`k mba l`z jbqgk yjba" NKXXK xkkx qgk Aohqou mba a{hdx mymz" Nok hofkx u{bbjbi{s, go`ajbi gjx e`kkajbi muf, o{q ol eukmqg mx qgk hmu xskkaxmymz" Au" Gollfmb ukhoibj~kx Nok"

    NOKAja zo{ xkk qgkf? Ygo ymx auj|jbi?

    AU" GOLLFMBZkmg, jq ymx""" [g""" {g m ho{s`k olFkwjhmbx, J qgjbd"

    Nok g{uujkx mymz, xgmdjbi gjx ljxq mx gk hgmxkx qgk hmu o{q olxjigq"

    NOKJ)`` l{hdjbi dj`` zo{, zo{ s{bdx-

    Au" Gollfmb, xqmbajbi m`obk, hmqhgkx m bmsdjb mx jq l`jkx ez

    mba go`ax jq {s qo ukma qgk `oio ol %Xskmdkmxz Nok)x"%

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ YM@@ JB M@@KZ

    XMBHGK^ jx smjbqjbi smxxjobmqk`z ob m ym`` jb qgk m``kz yjqgm smjbq hmb" Gk go`ax xk|kum` hmbx mba m`qkubmqkx ekqykkb qgkho`oux" Gk u{bx o{q ol smjbq yjqg obk hmb mba l{fe`kx qguo{ig

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    7/119

    qgk hmbx lou mboqgku l{``ku smjbq hmb" Gk auosx obk ol qgk hmbxmba qgkb auosx mboqgku mx gk xqoosx qo sjhd jq {s"

    XMBHGK^Ikq emhd gkuk-

    Qgk hmb uo``x mymz"

    XMBHGK^L{hd zo{ qgkb, io- L[HD M@@ OL ZO[-

    Gk auosx m`` ol qgk hmbx, sjhdx {s qgk obk qgmq gk ymbqx mbahobqjb{kx smjbqjbi"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ SMUD

    AU" GOLLFMB jx xjqqjbi ob m ekbhg jb qgk kfsqz, ajf`z jq smudyjqg m emuk`z&|jxje`k FKB)X UKXQUOOF ekgjba gjf" M ZO[BI FMBym`djbi aoyb qgk xjakym`d huoxxkx jbqo qgk smud jb luobq ol Au"Gollfmb mba jbqo qgk ukxquoof" Au" Gollfmb lo``oyx qgk zo{bifmb yjqg gjx kzkx mx gk smxxkx {bqj` gk ajxmsskmux jbqo qgkukxquoof"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ JU\JBI GO[XK XQ[AZ

    SUOL" JU\JBI xjqx yjqg gjx k`eoyx ob gjx dbkkx xoeejbi" Gk jxgo`ajbi qgk sjxqo` yjqg eoqg gmbax sojbqjbi {symua yjqg gjx gkmaukxqjbi m`obi qgk qos ol qgk i{b" X{aakb`z gk xjqx {s xqumjigqmba xkkfx qo imqgku gjx xqukbiqg" Gk s{qx qgk emuuk` ol qgki{b jbxjak gjx fo{qg sojbqka qoymua gjx eumjb"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ NOK)X HMU

    Hmfkum ob ukmu yjbaoy mx jq jx xgmqqkuka ez m i{bxgoq luof mNok ygo jx gmbijbi o{q qgk smxxkbiku xjak ol m muik X[\" NKXXKmba YJ@@ xskka mymz, eoqg ol qgkf xhukmfjbi lumbqjhm``z" YJ@@jx auj|jbi"

    YJ@@Goy qgk gk`` aja gk ljba {x?

    NKXXK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    8/119

    Io- Yk)uk ob`z lo{u e`ohdx mymz" Jqo`a zo{ qo ikq o{q ol qgk l{hdjbibkjigeougooa" Q{ub qgkuk-

    KWQ YM@@ JB M@@KZ

    XMBHGK^ jx ajxqumhqka ez qgk qyo hmux xskkajbi ez mq qgk kbaol qgk m``kz" Mlqku qgkz smxx gk ukimjbx gjx loh{x mba fmdkxm ho{s`k ol ljbjxgjbi qo{hgkx ob gjx smjbqjbi"

    KWQ SMUD

    AU" GOLLFMB xqmbax luof qgk smud ekbhg mba x`oy`z ym`dx qoymuaxqgk fkb)x ukxquoof" Mx gk bkmux qgk aoouymz qgkuk muk xo{baxol xofkobk jbxjak mba qgk jigq ol m l`mxg`jigq fo|jbi muo{ba"

    KWQ YM@@ JB M@@KZ

    XMBHGK^ xqmbax emhd m lky lkkq mba umjxkx gjx mufx jb maoumqjobol gjx youd"

    XMBHGK^Mboqgku fmxqkusjkhk"

    Mlqku gk mafjukx gjx f{um` lou m fofkbq, m ijmbq, x{usujxjbi`zyk``&aobk fmaobbm&kx}{k jfmik qgmq ukxkfe`kx Mbbm, ykq yjqglukxg smjbq, jx j``{fjbmqka ez gkma`jigqx" Qgkb qgk so`jhk hmuq{ubx ob gjx l`mxgkux mba xqos qgk hmu" XMBHGK^ q{ubx qo qgkso`jhk hmu go`ajbi o{q qgk smjbq hmb mx jl suo{a ol gjx youdmba mhqjbi mx jl gk jx meo|k qgk hujfk gk gmx n{xq hoffjqqka"Qgk OLLJHKUX ikq o{q ol qgk hmu"

    XMBHGK^'ym|jbi qgk smjbq hmb muo{ba yj`a`z*Ygmq ao zo{ xmz olljhkux, ikbj{xmjb)q jq, s{uk ikbj{x"

    Qgk olljhkux umjxk qgkju sjxqo`x mba mssuomhg hmukl{``z"

    OLLJHKU =Auos qgk hmb Xju" Lmhk qgk ym``"

    Xmbhgk~ q{ubx mba auosx qgk hmb mx gjx hobhkub }{jhd`z kuoakxgjx k{sgoujh xfj`k"

    OLLJHKU =Gmbax ob qgk ym``"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    9/119

    XMBHGK^E{q"""

    Xmbhgk~ aokx boq ymbq qo qo{hg qgk lukxg smjbq"

    OLLJHKU =J xmja, s{q zo{u gmbax ob qgk ym``"

    Qgkb Olljhku 5 s{xgkx gjf jbqo qgk ym`` mba gmbah{llx gjf"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" SMUD EMQGUOOF

    Gmbah{llx h`jhd muo{ba qgk yujxq ol m ajf`z `jq, yk``&e{j`q,xgjuq`kxx zo{bi fmb ekjbi sukxxka mimjbxq qgk emqguoof ym``

    ekxjak qgk {ujbm`" Qgkz djhd qgk l`mxg`jigq qgmq jx jb qgkl`oou ygjhg iokx xsjbbjbi" Au" Gollfmb msskmux n{xq jbxjak qgkaoouymz mba xqmbax xqmujbi yjqg m ood ol e`mbd xgohd" Qgk qyoi{zx xkbxk gjx sukxkbhk mba q{ub qo `ood mq gjf, gk xjfs`zhobqjb{k oodjbi luof m ajxqmbhk" Qgk qyo fkb ukx{fk qgkju s`mzl{k`ka ez qgk sukxkbhk ol mb m{ajkbhk" Au" Gollfmb xqmzxkbqumbhka mx qgk xo{bax ol qgk fkb)x smxxjob iuoyx, yk lmakx`oy`z qo"

    JBQ JU\JBI EKAUOOF KMU@Z MF

    Qgk sgobk ujbix mq 1>1:MF" DMUKB JU\JBI q{ubx qgk jigq ob mbambxykux qgk sgobk

    DMUKB'Iuoiiz* Gk``o"

    SGOBK HOFS[QKU \OJHKZo{ muk ukhkj|jbi m hm`` luof mfjbfmqk mq qgk Ho{bqz Houukhqjobm`Lmhj`jqz"""

    DMUKBKwh{xk fk"""

    Dmukb {sob ukm`j~jbi qgmq xgk jx jxqkbjbi qo m ukhouajbi luofqgk nmj` ekhofkx m`mufka mba q{ubx qo ymdk gku g{xemba, @O[JXJU\JBI"

    DMUKBGobkz, ymdk {s-

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    10/119

    Dmukb uo``x o|ku qo ljba gjx xjak ol qgk eka kfsqz" Xgk hmuujkxqgk houa`kxx sgobk yjqg gku mba u{xgkx o{q ol qgk uoof"

    JBQ JU\JBI GO[XK XQ[AZ

    DMUKB kbqkux yjqg qgk aoou ukxjxqjbi ekhm{xk ol qgk u{i{bakubkmqg" Qguo{ig qgk gm`l oskbka aoou xgk xkkx SUOL" JU\JBI)Xlkkq xqjhdjbi o{q luof ekgjba gjx akxd" DMUKB jx lj``ka yjqglkmu mx xgk s{qx qgk sgobk qo gku eukmxqx mx xgk hm``x o{q lougjf mba s{xgkx qguo{ig qgk aoou"

    DMUKB@o{jk- 'U{xgjbi qo gjx xjak* @o{jkmuk zo{ odmz?

    Suol" Ju|jbi ekijbx qo xqju" Dmukb `jxqkbx qo qgk sgobk mbasukxxkx m e{qqob"

    DMUKBGobkz, s`kmxk qmdk qgjx"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'hobl{xka mba iuoiiz* Qmdk ygmq?

    Dmukb go`ax qgk sgobk o{q qo gjf"

    DMUKBJq)x qgk nmj`, gkuk"

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx qgk sgobk mba mlqku `jxqkbjbi m fofkbqsukxxkx qgk dkzsma mba xskmdx jbqo qgk sgobk" Dmukb go`ax gkugkma h`oxk qo `jxqkb"

    SUOL" JU\JBIQgjx jx Suolkxxou Ju|jbi"

    XMBHGK^ 'O"X"*'Hg{ffj`z* Gkz, @o{jx jq)x fk,Xmbhgk~"

    [sob gkmujbi gjx bmfk Dmukb uo``x gku kzkx" @o{jx jx hobhkubka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXmbhgk~, jx k|kuzqgjbi odmz" Ygmq)xiojbi ob"

    XMBHGK^

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    11/119

    Boqgjbi ukm``z e{aaz, e{q J ymxyobakujbi jl zo{ fjigq hofk aoyb gkukmba gk`s fk xqumjigqkb qgjx m`` o{q"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXqumjigqkb ygmq o{q? Ao J bkka qoeujbi fz hgkhdeood"

    Dmukb i`mukx mq @o{jx eklouk xholljbi mba kwjqjbi qgk uoof"

    XMBHGK^Og, g{g, zkmg" Yk`` jq)x iojbi qo ekqykbqz lj|k g{bauka"""e{q J yj`` ikqzo{ emhd ujigq mymz e{aaz"" Jsuofjxk"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

    Yk``"""'Gkxjqmqjbi*"""J)`` ek ujigqqgkuk, mba zo{ hmb mz oll qgk %e{aaz%xgjq"

    Suol" Ju|jbi gmbix {s mba kwjqx"

    JBQ JU\JBI EKAUOOF

    DMUKB jx emhd jb eka mba gmx gku emhd q{ubka jiboujbi gjf mxjl x`kksjbi" Suol" Ju|jbi hofkx jb mba xqmuqx hgmbijbi gjx xgjuqmba `oodx qo gjx yjlk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIQgjx yob)q qmdk `obi akmu, J)`` ekemhd jb m lky fjb{qkx"

    Gk kmbx aoyb qo djxx gku hgkkd" Xgk jx jbajllkukbq e{q houajm`mx xgk xkkfx qo ek iojbi emhd qo x`kks" Suol" Ju|jbi kwjqx qgkuoof mba mx gk h`oxkx qgk aoou Dmukb hm``x o{q jb mb {bx{uk mba{bhob|jbhjbi qobk"

    DMUKBOdmz akmu, J `o|k zo{"

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK FOUBJBI

    AU" GOLLFMB jx h`kmujbi ajxgkx luof m qme`k jb qgk eukmdlmxqbood" NKXXK hmb ek xkkb km|jbi jb qgk emhdiuo{ba" Au" Gollfmbboqjhkx Nkxxk iumeejbi gjx eoodemi mba hm``x mlqku gjf"

    AU" GOLLFMB

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    12/119

    H{ek&xqkmd mba fmxg soqmqokx louajbbku"

    NKXXK'ob gjx ymz o{q qgk aoou* Zkmg,ygmqk|ku"

    AU" GOLLFMBXkk zo{ mq xk|kb?

    Nkxxk xqmuqx qo xg{q qgk aoou e{q xqksx emhd jbxjak iokx jbqoqgk djqhgkb mba s{qx gjx gmba ob qgk qme`k lmhjbi Au" Gollfmb"

    NKXXK@ood""" J ukm``z aob)q bkka zo{ oumbzobk k`xk quzjbi qo s`mz Foffz"

    Nkxxk q{ubx mba km|kx ygj`k Au" Gollfmb xqmbax yjqg m ood olxgohd {bqj` qgk aoou x`mfx" M`foxq jb qkmux gjx gkma x`oy`zauosx Au" Gollfmb iokx emhd qo h`kmujbi ajxgkx"

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK EUKMDLMXQ BOOD

    AU" GOLLFMB kbqkux qo h`kmb qgk mxq lky AJXGKX luof qgk QME@K"Jb m muik FJUUOU ob qgk ym`` NKMBBJK GOLLFMB jx xkkb kbqkujbiqgk uoof go`ajbi o{q qyo k|kbjbi aukxxkx" Au" Gollfmb boqjhkxgku jb qgk fjuuou"

    NKMBBJKYgmq ao zo{ qgjbd Lukakujhd, qgk u{ezou qgk j mh"

    Au" Gollfmb q{ubx qo xskmd qo Nkmbbjk e{q ygkb gk lmhkx gkusuk|jo{x ajukhqjob xgk jx iobk" Au" Gollfmb xqosx gjfxk`l xgouqol maaukxxjbi gku e{q qgkb f{fe`kx"

    AU" GOLLFMB'f{fe`jbi* Qgk `j`mh"""akmu"

    Gk ukx{fkx gjx hgouk"

    JBQ HMLK

    XMBHGK^ mba SUOL" JU\JBI xjq mhuoxx luof obk mboqgku gm|jbieukmdlmxq jb m eooqg"

    XMBHGK^

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    13/119

    J fkmb, zkmg, J mafjq jq, jq ymx boqobk ol fz ekxq youdx, e{q hofk ob,%|mbam`jxf"%

    SUOL" JU\JBI'hg{hd`jbi* Zkmg, hofk qo qgjbd oljq, qgk sjhq{uk qgk hos xgoyka fk`oodka ekqqku qgmb qgk obk zo{ im|kDmukb mba fk lou o{u ykaajbi"

    XMBHGK^'Lkjibjbi jbx{`q* Gkz, jl zo{ gmab)qn{xq emj`ka fk o{q ol nmj` mba eo{igqfk eukmdlmxq J yo{`a qgjbd zo{ ykukquzjbi qo sjhd m ljigq"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

    'quzjbi qo ek l{bbz e{q ajxqumhqka*Og, ygmq J)f e{zjbi zo{ eukmdlmxqqoo" 'sukibmbq sm{xk* Xo ygo jxxgk? """ ou ao zo{ k|kb dboy gku bmfkzkq"

    Xmbhgk~ qmdkx m fofkbq qo kwmfjbk Suolkxxou Ju|jbi)x fooa" Suol"Ju|jbi xkkfx `oxq xqmujbi jbqo gjx h{s ol hollkk"

    XMBHGK^Xo, ygmq)x {s yjqg zo{ @o{jk" Zo{)uk`oodjbi m `jqq`k xqukxxka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg fmb, J aob)q dboy" Zo{ ukfkfekuqgmq `jqq`k %h`mxx ajxu{sqjob"%

    XMBHGK^'ukfkfekujbi* Og zkmg, qgk %`jqq`kqgjbi% ygkb zo{ n{fska {s ob qgk akxdmba qgk so`jhk"""

    SUOL" JU\JBI'jbqkuu{sqjbi* Zkx, zkx Xmbhgk~"Qgmq jx jq" Hmb yk s`kmxk boq io o|kuqgmq mimjb"

    XMBHGK^

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    14/119

    Qgmq ymx iooa xq{ll @o{jk" Zo{ dboyJ ymx n{xq meo{q qo ij|k {s ob zo{{bqj` zo{ qo`a fk meo{q qgmq"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq ao zo{ fkmb ij|k {s ob fk?

    XMBHGK^Yk`` zo{ dboy" Qgk yjlk, qgk noe, qgkeji imx i{~~`jbi X[\" Ygmq k|ku qo fzlujkba ygo ek`jk|ka qgmq m `jqq`kmbqmiobjxf ymx boq n{xq mhhksqme`k ouk|kb gkm`qgz, e{q""" |jqm`"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xkkfx qo ~obk o{q mx jl oxq jb ukfjbjxhkbhk" Gk`oodx mxjak mx jl jb m qumbhk lou m fofkbq" Qgkb ukimjbx hoikbhzmba ukx{fk gjx xqm{bhg aklkbxj|k xqmbhk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIHofk ob Xmbhgk~" Hgujxq, qgmq jx qgk`mxq qgjbi J bkka zo{ qo ek aumiijbi{s" J)f jb quo{e`k gkuk" J)f qm`djbimeo{q fz noe, fz `jlk, qgjx jxxkujo{x" J hmb)q n{xq hm`` {s fz fmffmqo emj` fk o{q ol jq"

    Xmbhgk~ qmdkx qgjx mx m njek mq gjf mba m`xo ekhofkx mbiuz"

    XMBHGK^J qo`a zo{ fmb" Qgjx noe, qgjx go{xk,qgjx yjlk" Qgoxk ykuk zo{u akhjxjobx,e{q qgkz bk|ku ykuk zo{" Zo{ `oxqzo{uxk`l fmb, zo{ `oxq zo{uhob|jhqjob"

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ ajab)q `oxk jq Xmbhgk~, J akhjakajq ymx qjfk qo xgoy xofkukxsobxjej`jqz"

    XMBHGK^Ygmq, zo{ hm`` fmuuzjbi qgk Akmb)xam{igqku lou noe xkh{ujqz xgoyjbiukxsobxjej`jqz"

    Suol" Ju|jbi mba Xmbhgk~ lm`` }{jkq dboyjbi qgkz gm|k eoqgs{xgka jq qo qgk jfjq" Suol" Ju|jbi iumex qgk hgkhd mba ukmhgkxlou gjx ym``kq" Qgjx h{kx Xmbhgk~ qo mso`oij~k"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    15/119

    XMBHGK^J)f xouuz fmb" @jxqkb ygkb qgjx e`oyxo|ku J)f qmdjbi {x qo qgk Nm~~Lkxqj|m` jb qgk Hmbzob"

    SUOL" JU\JBI's`mzjbi qgk gmua xk``*Zkmg qgmq)x`jdk jb M{i{xq ujigq"

    XMBHGK^Ygmq meo{q qgk ykkd mlqku bkwq, zkmgqgmq)x jq" Mlqku qgk oskbjbi, ajbbkuob fk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIM`ujigq m`ukmaz" Mf J auossjbi zo{oll mq qgk xq{ajo?

    XMBHGK^Bo n{xq auos fk oll mq Fk`)x @j}{oumba J)`` ym`d gofk"

    Sukqkbajbi qgmq gk ukfkfekuka xofkqgjbi"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, zo{ dboy ygmq" J qo`a Dmukb Jyo{`a hofk emhd ez qgk go{xk ekloukJ io qo H`mxx" J gm|k qo qmdk oll"

    Xmbhgk~ jx ajxmssojbqka mba ukfmjbx xkmqka mx Suol" Ju|jbikwjqx"

    KWQ HMLK XJAKYM@D

    SUOL" JU\JBI kwjqx qgk ukxqm{umbq mba fmdkx m sgobk hm`` ob gjxymz qo qgk hmu"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'jbqo hk`` sgobk* Gkz G{b" J n{xqauosska oll Xmbhgk~""" Jq qood m

    `jqq`k `obiku qgmb J qgo{igq xo Jxgo{`a suoeme`z io mgkma mba ioxqumjigq qo fz fkkqjbi"

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK LOZKU

    DMUKB jx mbxykujbi qgk dbohd mq luobq aoou yjqg qgk sgobk qogku kmu" %FMW% 'qgk Aoi* jx maajbi hgmox mq gku lkkq"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    16/119

    DMUKBE{q zo{ ajab)q xgm|k ou xgoyku ao zo{qgjbd qgmq)x m iooa jakm, qgjx jx mbjfsouqmbq fkkqjbi"

    KWQ HMLK XJAKYM@D

    Suol" Ju|jbi jx xqmbajbi mq qgk aoou ol gjx hmu {b`ohdjbi qgkaoou ol gjx hmu"

    SUOL" JU\JBIJq)x odmz, J)|k ioq qgk k`khqujhum~ou, J)`` xgoyku mq qgk xhgoo` izf"

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK LOZKU

    Dmukb s{``x oskb qgk aoou qo FU" O@AFMB xqmbajbi ekxjak m xqmhdol eowkx eujffjbi yjqg ooxk {bouimbj~ka smskux" Xgk go`ax qgkaoi yjqg gku lukk gmba mba foqjobx qgk fmb jb" Gk iumex xofkol qgk eowkx mba hofkx jb"

    DMUKBOg, ujigq, {g """ xo{bax iooa, mba Jn{xq xsodk qo Amaaz" Jq xo{bax `jdkgk jx jb m iooa fooa xo q{ub ob qgkhgmuf"

    Dmukb ekijbx qo xg{q qgk aoou e{q qgk O`aku Fmb gmx iobk emhdo{q lou mboqgku eow ol lj`k mba xgk bkmu`z h`oxkx qgk aoou obgjf" Xgk qgkb boqjhkx qgk ukfmjbjbi eowkx o{qxjak mba mxdx qgkfmb"

    DMUKBMuk m qgoxk m`` luof `mxq zkmu?

    FU" O@AFMBZks, J dksq m ukhkjsq ob k|kuzqgjbiJ eo{igq"

    Qgk O`aku Fmb jx go`ajbi m eow l{`` ol ygmq oodx jdk lmxq looaukhkjsqx yjqg xq{ll yujqqkb ob qgk emhd" Dmukb sjhdx obk {s mba`oodx mq jq h{ujo{x`z"

    DMUKBJx qgjx jb Xsmbjxg"

    Qgk O`aku Fmb qmdkx jq mba s{qx jq emhd jb qgk eow"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    17/119

    FU" O@AFMBZkx fm)mf, k|kb gm|k fz myb fmb yujqkobk o{q ez gmba"

    DMUKBOg fz Ioa"

    KWQ HMLK XJAKYM@D

    SUOL" JU\JBI jx oskbjbi qgk hmu aoou xqj`` yjqg qgk sgobk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq Dmukb?

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK LOZKU

    DMUKB sojbqx qgk O`aku Fmb aoyb qgk gm``"

    DMUKB'qo qgk O`aku Fmb*Zo{ hmb s{q qgoxkjb qgk olljhk Fu" O`afmb" 'jbqosgobk* Boqgjbi @o{jk jq)x ljbk" Fu"O`afmb n{xq muuj|ka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, Fu" Kmu`z, g{g" J)`` hm`` zo{mlqku qgk fkkqjbi"

    JBQ GOLLFMB GO[XK GM@@YMZ

    DMUKB jx gk`sjbi FU" O@AFMB jbqo gku olljhk"

    DMUKBOdmz, ioqqm io, `o|k zo{"

    JBQ" JU\JBI HMU

    SUOL" JU\JBI ikqx jbqo gjx hmu, h`oxkx qgk aoou mba xqmuqx qgkkbijbk" Ju|jbi oodx smumboja mx gk xqmukx jbqo qgk ukmu|jkyfjuuou lou m ho{s`k ol xkhobax mba qgkb xgmdkx gjx gkma mx qoxgu{i oll qgk smumbojm"

    KWQ XJAKYM@D HOUBKU

    Nkxxk iumex Yj``)x muf mba s{``x gjf emhd muo{ba qgk houbku mbamimjbxq qgk ym``"

    YJ@@

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    18/119

    Nkx{x, Nkxxk- Ygmq qgk gk`` jx yuobiyjqg zo{"

    NKXXKJq)x obk ol fz Suolkxxoux"

    YJ@@'s{``jbi mymz* Xo ygmq" Ygz muk zo{xo smumboja?

    Nkxxk oodx muo{ba qgk houbku hm{qjo{x`z eklouk lo``oyjbi qgkhobqjb{jbi Yj``"

    NKXXKOg, zkmg, jdk Iumba @muhkbz)x boq meji akm`"

    Yj`` iumex Nkxxk muo{ba qgk bkhd mba f{xxkx gjx gmju"

    YJ@@'ukmxx{ujbi`z* Mg, hofk ob a{ak, EjiYj``)x iojbi qo qmdk hmuk ol zo{"

    NKXXK's{xgjbi Yj`` oll gjf* Gkz ikq oll fk"

    Qgkz hobqjb{k aoyb qgk xqukkq mba kwjq"

    JBQ AKMB)X OLLJHK

    Qgk AKMB xjqx mq gjx akxd" Ob qgk ym`` ekgjba gjx akxd jx m xgk`ljbxkq jbqo qgk ym``" Hkbqkuka jb m jigqka ajxs`mz xgk`l jx mXqmq{kx}{k Uofmb Ho`{fb x{ssouqjbi mb muhgmjh oodjbi eood" QgkAkmb hmukl{``z q{ubx m smik ol qgk eood mba uk|kukbq`z mzx mfmudjbi ujeeob m`obi qgk klq smik ygkb qgkuk jx m dbohd mq qgkaoou"

    AKMB XQMB@KZZkx, kbqku"

    SUOL" JU\JBI kbqkux qgk olljhk" Qgk Akmb hgkhdx gjx ymqhg"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'mbwjo{x e{q uk`mqj|k`z hobljakbq*Iooa foubjbi Fu" Xqmb`kz"'jbxqjbhqj|k`z hgkhdjbi gjx oybymqhg* Mba ood mq qgmq, ujigq ob qjfkqoo"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    19/119

    AKMB XQMB@KZJ qgjbd jq fjigq ek fouk mssuosujmqk,n{xq lou qgjx fkkqjbi ol ho{uxk, jlyk maaukxx obk mboqgku ez o{usuolkxxjobm` qjq`kx" Xo s`kmxk gm|km xkmq Suolkxxou Ju|jbi"

    SUOL" JU\JBIMexo`{qk`z, Akmb Xqmb`kz" S`kmxklouij|k qgk jfsuosujkqz"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xjqx mq m hgmju mhuoxx luof qgk akmb)x muik akxd"Qgk Akmb iokx emhd qo qgk eood ob qgk ho`{fb mba ljbax gjx s`mhkmimjb" Suol" Ju|jbi oexku|kx qgk uoof" Qgk ym``x mb m`` xjakxmuk ho|kuka yjqg fkqjh{`o{x`z s`mhka mba dksq s`m}{kx mbamymuax" Qgk Akmb ljbjxgkx gjx ukmajbi mba qmdkx m xkmq mq gjxakxd"

    AKMB XQMB@KZO|ku qgk ho{uxk ol fz 5< zkmux mx qgkAkmb Ol Muqx mba Xhjkbhkx mq qgjx ljbkjbxqjq{qjob, Suol" Ju|jbi, J gm|khofk qo mhhksq qgmq jbajxhukqjobx`jdk qgjx muk eo{ba qo ohh{u luof qjfkqo qjfk" Goyk|ku jq jx fz a{qz qo xkkqgmq qgkxk fmqqkux ao boq io{bmqqkbaka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkx xju, mba J mxx{uk zo{ """

    Qgk Akmb go`ax {s gjx gmba jbajhqjbi qgmq gk jx boq ljbjxgkaxskmdjbi"

    AKMB XQMB@KZMba qo jbx{uk qgmq yk gm|k bo l{uqgkuukohh{uukbhkx ol qgjx bmq{uk, Jgm|k qmdkb qgk qjfk qo mz o{q m lkyxqksx ygjhg yj`` m``oy zo{ qofmjbqmjb zo{u qkb{uk zkq suohkkalouymua yjqgjb qgk i{jak`jbkxfmbamqka gkuk jb qgk XskbhkuAohqujbk, ygkukjb hmb ek lo{ba qgkyjxaof qo o|kuhofk mbz mba m`` ol qgkajlljh{`qjkx qgmq s`mi{k {x"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    20/119

    Zkx xju, mba J mxx{uk zo{ qgmq J yj``ek fouk qgmb gmssz 'gk h`kmux gjxqguomq* qo hofs`z yjqg ygmqk|ku xqksxzo{ akkf bkhkxxmuz"

    AKMB XQMB@KZJ xquobi`z ek`jk|k qgmq, mx zo{lo``oy qgkxk xqksx, zo{ yj`` ljba qgkxqukbiqg ol hgmumhqku qo xkk qgmqygmq yk muk aojbi gkuk jx jb zo{uekqqku jbqkukxqx"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkx, Akmb Xqmb`kz, J mssukhjmqk zo{uqjfk mba hobhkub ob fz ekgm`l mba Jeoy qo zo{u lmu iukmqku yjxaof"

    AKMB XQMB@KZ\kuz yk``, Suolkxxou Ju|jbi, mbafjigq J maa qgmq J mf hobljakbq qgmqygmq yk muk aojbi gkuk jx h`kmu`z qgkekxq lou fz am{igqku"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ XMBHGK^) XQ[AJOXmbhgk~ kbqkux luof xqmjux qguo{ig qgk l`oou ol gjx mqqjh olqyjqg m emi luof qgk `j}{ou xqouk" Gk jffkajmqk`z qmdkx jq qoqgk djqhgkb, qmdkx m muik i`mxx luof qgk xjbd mba so{ux gjfxk`lm gkm`qgz aujbd" Gk qmdkx jq qo gjx ho{hg mba s{qx gjx lkkq obqgk hollkk qme`kx mba xjqx emhd uk`mwjbi yjqg qgk aujbd"

    XMBHGK^Iumlljqj""" aklmhjbi s{e`jhsuoskuqz, g{g |mbam`jxf"""Qukxsmxxjbi""" '`m{igjbi xma`z*E{``xgjq" L{hdjbi sji yo{`ab)q dboym youd ol muq jl xgk xmq ob gjx lmhk"'q{ubjbi gjx gkma qo qgk ho|kukakmxk` bkmuez* Ujigq Mbbm?

    Gk xqmbax mba ym`dx {uikbq`z qo qgk bkmuez kmxk` ho|kuka ez mh`oqg" Jq jx m b{ak smjbqjbi ol Mbbm" Gk ajxhmuax qgk h`oqg mba`oodx uk|kukbq`z mq qgk smjbqjbi"

    XMBHGK^Qgkuk zo{ muk fz ekm{qjl{` Mbbm"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    21/119

    JBQ XQMJUYMZ

    NMH][K@JBK jx ym`djbi {s qgk xqmjux qo Xmbhgk~) xq{ajo" Mx xgkbkmux qgk qos ol qgk xqmjux xgk hmb gkmu Xmbhgk~ xskmdjbi qoqgk smjbqjbi mba jbxqkma ol kbqkujbi, xgk ymjqx o{q ol xjigqmba oexku|kx gjx skh{`jmu ekgm|jou"

    JBQ XMBHGK^) XQ[AJO

    XMBHGK^ 'HOBQ)A*J mf gofk, mba J xykmu qo zo{ yjqg fze`ooa, yjqg fz qkkqg, yjqg fz ygo`keoaz 'iumeejbi gjx huoqhg*, J yj``bk|ku, boq k|kb lou obk fofkbq km|kzo{u xjak mimjb" Mba jl zo{ qjuk olqgjx you`a ygjhg J gm|k smjbqka zo{jbqo, qgkb, fz `o|k`z, zo{ f{xq

    xjfs`z ij|k fk boqjhk mba J yj`` smjbqzo{ m bky you`a"

    XMBHGK^ sjhdx {s m eu{xg mba q{ek ol smjbq, gk x}{kk~kx o{q xofksmjbq mba amex qgk eu{xg"

    XMBHGK^Mba jdk jb qgk amzx ol ouk, yjqg fzeu{xg mx fz xyoua"""

    Gk qoxxkx mymz qgk q{ek ol smjbq mba iumex gjx huoqhg mimjb"

    XMBHGK^ 'HOBQ)A*J yj`` h`kmu m xymqg mhuoxx qgjxhmb|mx, `jdk qgk xyoua qguo{ig qgkl`kxg ol qgk {bek`jk|kux mba ak`j|kuzo{ emez""" J yj`` ak`j|ku zo{"

    NMH][K@JBK kbqkux qgk xq{ajo x{usujxjbi Xmbhgk~"

    NMH][K@JBKOG- 'h`mssjbi mba `m{igjbi* Eum|oXmbhgk~" Jq jx m`ymzx xo kwhjqjbi xo

    xkk xofkobk m``oy gjfxk`l qo ekhobx{fka ez gjx smxxjob k|kb jb qgkaksqgx ol akxsmju"

    Xmbhgk~ jx xqmuq`ka mba x`jigq`z kfemuumxxka"

    XMBHGK^

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    22/119

    'xmuhmxqjhm``z* Mg, n{xq ygmq Jbkkaka qo ljbjxg oll qgk ekxq amz olfz `jlk" 'fk`oaumfmqjhm``z* Iomgkma, eukmd qgk bkyx, qkbaku zo{uukxjibmqjob luof qgk |miumbq |mbam`ygo xqmbax eklouk zo{, ou jl qgkuk eke{q obk o{bhk ol fkuhz jb zo{u o`aeobkx, qgu{xq zo{u amiiku jbqo fzgkmuq"

    Nmh}{k`jbk fohdx mx qgo{ig xgk xqmex gjf mba gk iumex gjfxk`ljb miobz" Qgkb qgkz `m{ig mba g{i kmhg oqgku"

    NMH][K@JBK'yjqg fmqkubm` xzfsmqgz* Og fz soouamu`jbi, goy muk zo{? Aja qgkz g{uqzo{, `kq fk xkk qgoxk gmbax"

    Xgk iumex gjx gmbax mba q{ubx qgkf mba oodx qgkf o|ku ekloukdjxxjbi qgkf" Xmbhgk~ s{``x gjx gmbax mymz hmx{m``z"

    XMBHGK^J)f ljbk, Nmhdjk" J)f n{xq xouuz qgmqqgjx gmsskbka" @kq m`obk boy"

    NMH][K@JBKBo, bo Xmbhgk~" Qgjx jx skulkhq" Jho{`ab)q gm|k yujqqkb m ekqqkuhmfsmjib yjqg m xqmll ol Go``zyooa)xljbkxq suofoqkux"

    XMBHGK^Hmfsmjib? Ygmq qgk gk`` muk zo{qm`djbi meo{q?

    NMH][K@JBKYgmq J mf qm`djbi meo{q, fz akmu eoz,jx qgmq qgjx jx qgk skulkhqossouq{bjqz qo q{ub {bekmume`kfjxlouq{bk jbqo jffkmx{ume`k

    louq{bk" Mba obhk mimjb 'sojbqjbiqo obk ol qgk fmbz mexqumhq sjkhkx*louq{bk """ 'sojbqjbi qo qgk smjbqjbiol Mbbm* fjxlouq{bk """ 'qo mboqgkumexqumhq sjkhk* louq{bk """ 'qo qgksmjbqjbi ol Mbbm* fjxlouq{bk, qgkukmuk qgo{xmbax ol muq xq{akbqx ygo hmbsmjbq n{xq `jdk qgjx" 'qo mboqgku

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    23/119

    mexqumhq sjkhk* QGJX, J hmb xk``, fzakmu" 'qo qgk smjbqjbi ol Mbbm* Qgjx,J hmbboq"

    XMBHGK^Odmz, io ob"

    Qgkuk jx xofk bojxk mba m gk``o luof aoybxqmjux mba dbohdjbi"

    UKSOUQKUGk``o, Nmh}{k`jbk?

    NMH][K@JBK[g, ossouq{bjqz dbohdx" 'zk``jbiaoybxqmjux* Hofk ob {s" 'qo Xmbhgk~}{jkq`z* Mba ukfkfeku, mbz s{e`jhjqzjx iooa s{e`jhjqz"

    M uksouqku mba sgoqoiumsgku kbqku luof qgk xqmjuymz" Qgkuksouqku ym`dx o|ku mba qgk sgoqoiumsgku `oodx muo{ba lou ms`mhk qo s{q gjx k}{jsfkbq"

    UKSOUQKUGk``o Nmhdjk, iooa qo xkk zo{"'xj~jbi {s Xmbhgk~* mba qgjx f{xq eko{u fjx{bakuxqooa muqjxqx"

    NMH][K@JBKYk`` J gm|kb)q akhjaka, %IjlqkaMuqjxq Yuobil{``z Muukxqka% ou %@o|kHum~ka Muqjxq Hujkx O{q"%

    Nmh}{k`jbk iumex Xmbhgk~ lmhk mba djxxkx gjf aumfmqjhm``z obqgk `jsx mba h{sx gjx lmhk yjqg gku gmbax"

    NMH][K@JBKOg, J `o|k zo{ amu`jbi"

    Xmbhgk~ s{``x mymz luof gku s`mzl{``z"

    JBQ @KHQ[UK GM@@

    SUOL" JU\JBI jx uoeoqjh jb `khq{ujbi m h`mxx l{`` ol eouka`oodjbi xq{akbqx jbh`{ajbi NKXXK" Nkxxk aumyx {bl`mqqkujbihmuqoobx ol qgk suolkxxou" Suol" Ju|jbi ym`dx qguo{ig qgk mjx`kxol qgk h`mxx mx gk qm`dx"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    24/119

    Mba xo Xohumqkx, ekjbi lo{ba i{j`qzol houu{sqjbi qgk zo{qg ol Iukkhk ymxqgkb ij|kb m hgojhk" Gk ymx ij|kb qgkhgojhk qo j|k, goyk|ku, jl gk hgoxkqo `j|k gk yo{`a ek kwj`ka mbalouejaakb qo qkmhg gjx ek`jklx"

    Nkxxk gjakx qgk aumyjbi {baku m boqkeood mx Suol" Ju|jbi bkmux"

    SUOL" JU\JBI 'HOBQ)A*Qgk oqgku osqjob ij|kb qo gjf ymx qgmqol aujbdjbi m hoffob sojxob dboyb mxGkf`ohd mba x{llku gjx jffkajmqkakmqg"

    Mx Suol" Ju|jbi smxxkx Nkxxk)x akxd gk xbmqhgkx qgk aumyjbi luof{baku qgk boqkeood mba xqmuqx qo ym`d qoymua qgk luobq ol qgk

    uoof"

    SUOL" JU\JBI 'HOBQ)A*Boy Xohumqkx lmhjbi qgjx hgojhk, gmam `jqq`k ajllkukbq fkbqm`jqz qgmbqgkz qgo{igq gk yo{`a gm|k"

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx m lky xqksx oodjbi mq qgk hmuqoob aksjhqjbiqgk Akmb go`ajbi o{q m eoqq`k ol sojxob louhjbi jq ob Suol"Ju|jbi, qgk hmsqjob xmzjbi, %Aujbd-% Gk sm{xkx lou m fofkbqeklouk q{ubjbi emhd mba ym`djbi emhd qo Nkxxk"

    SUOL" JU\JBI 'HOBQ)A*Umqgku qgmb lmhk m `jlk x{ssukxxjbigjx ek`jklx mba dboy`kaik, ygjhg qogjf ymx hkuqmjb fjxkuz, gk hgoxk qolmhk qgk {bdboyb hobxjakujbi qgmqqgkuk yo{`a mq `kmxq ek qgksoxxjej`jqz ol xofkqgjbi ekqqku"

    Suol" Ju|jbi `kmbx o|ku mba s{qx qgk hmuqoob emhd ob Nkxxk)xakxd mba xskmdx xolq`z"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'qo Nkxxk* Xkk fk mlqku h`mxx"'qo h`mxxuoof* Gk hgoxk mb {bhkuqmjbl{q{uk o|ku qgmq ol hkuqmjb fjxkuz"

    Suol" Ju|jbi `oodx mq gjx ymqhg"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    25/119

    Odmz, qgmq)x jq lou qoamz" UkmaHgmsqkux 9 mba 7 mba aob)q louikq, qyoykkdx qj`` fjaqkufx"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xjqx mq gjx akxd mx qgk h`mxx `km|kx kwhksq louNkxxk" Nkxxk ukfmjbx xkmqka lou m fofkbq {bqj` Suol" Ju|jbixqmbax mba ym`dx o|ku qo Nkxxk mba qmdkx m xkmq ekxjak gjf"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXo Nkxxk"""

    NKXXKZkmg, zkmg, J dboy, J xgo{`a ek smzjbimqqkbqjob jb h`mxx"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'Hg{hd`jbi* Yk`` mhq{m``z, jq `ood

    `jdk zo{ muk smzjbi mqqkbqjob ekqqkuqgmb mbzobk k`xk jb qgk h`mxx" Mx mfmqqku ol lmhq J yo{`a xmz zo{ bmj`kajq"

    Nkxxk xkkfx hobl{xka lou m fofkbq e{q jx qgkb ajxqumhqka ez YJ@@ygo msskmux o{qxjak qgk aoou" Yj`` boqjhkx qgmq Nkxxk jx qm`djbiqo qgk Suolkxxou xo gk ymjqx o{qxjak jb qgk gm``ymz"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXo jx qgmq zo{u fmnou, muq?

    NKXXKOg, J aob)q dboy, fmzek" J gm|kb)qukm``z akhjaka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYk`` fmzek zo{ xgo{`a hobxjaku jq" Jmf boq mb muqjxq fzxk`l xo J)f boqx{uk ygmq, jl mbzqgjbi jq fkmbx e{qJ qgjbd qgmq zo{ fjigq gm|k m ukm`ijlq gkuk"

    NKXXKXo, J)f boq jb quo{e`k?

    SUOL" JU\JBIQuo{e`k lou ygmq?

    NKXXK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    26/119

    Lou aumyjbi qgk sjhq{ukx ol"""'ym|jbi gjx gmba* xq{ll"

    SUOL" JU\JBIBo" Zo{u boq `jxqkbjbi, ygmq J)fxmzjbi jx qgmq J qgjbd zo{ mukqm`kbqka mba fmzek J ho{`a gk`s zo{"

    NKXXKOg, yk`` qgmq)x |kuz djba ol zo{ xju"Qgmbd zo{ xo f{hg lou zo{u jbqkukxq,J ukm``z mssukhjmqk zo{u qmdjbi qgkqjfk" '`oodjbi o{qxjak qgk aoou mqYj`` ygo jx sojbqjbi mq gjx ymqhg* HmbJ io boy?

    Suol" Ju|jbi jx |jxje`z qmdkb memhd"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYk` , zkx, jl zo{ ymbq" E{q J ymxyobakujbi jl"""

    Nkxxk s{qx gjx eoodx jb gjx emi mba xqmbax qo km|k" Suol" Ju|jbim`xo xqmbax mba qgkz lmhk kmhg oqgku"

    SUOL" JU\JBI 'HOBQ)A*""" zo{ gm|k fouk ol qgkf"

    NKXXKOl ygmq?

    SUOL" JU\JBIOl qgjx qzsk ol qgjbi, qgjx muq youd"Qgjx JX MUQ, Nkxxk"

    Nkxxk jx boq ukm``z jbqkukxqka e{q smhjljkx qgk suolkxxou"

    NKXXKOdmz, x{uk, J ioq m e{bhg ol jq, J)``quz qo ukfkfeku qo eujbi xofk bkwq

    h`mxx"Nkxxk gkmax qo qgk aoou" Yj`` ymjqx kmiku`z" Suol" Ju|jbi iokxemhd qo xjq mq gjx akxd" Nkxxk jx bkmu`z o{q qgk aoou"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXkk zm `mqku Nkxxk"

    NKXXK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    27/119

    Xkk zm `mqku, xju"

    Nkxxk fohdjbi`z aokx qgk o`a qobi{k&jb&qgk&hgkkd foqjob qo Yj``ygo nojbx gjf mx qgkz gkma oll aoyb qgk gm``"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK YMJQJBI UOOF

    Suol" Ju|jbi kbqkux qgk |kuz qumb}{j`, kb olljhk xkqqjbi ygkukgk jx iukkqka ez Uoxgmbaum, ygo jx s`kmxmbq jb gku olljhjo{xxkhukqmujm` akfkmbou mba msskmumbhk" Gk ym`dx {s qo gku akxd"

    SUOL" JU\JBIGk``o, J)f @o{jx Ju|jbi" J gm|k m5>33 yjqg Au" Gollfmb"

    UOXGMBAUMOg, gj Suolkxxou Ju|jbi" Qgk xhgoo`gmx m`ukmaz xkbq o|ku zo{u smskuyoudmba J)`` n{xq bkka zo{ qo lj`` o{q mlky loufx lou fk gkuk"

    Uoxgmbaum gmbax Suol" Ju|jbi qgk loufx ob m h`jseomua mba gkljbax m xkmq mba ekijbx qo lj`` o{q qgk loufx"

    UOXGMBAUMQgk aohqou jx yjqg mboqgku smqjkbqujigq boy mba gk)`` ek yjqg zo{ jbmeo{q qkb fjb{qkx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" XMBHGK^) XQ[AJO

    Hmfkum s{xgkx qguo{ig Xmbhgk~) xq{ajo qo xgoy gjx smjbqjbix obqgk ym``, qgkb uk|km`jbi qgk UKSOUQKU xskmdjbi qo NMH][K@JBKmba yk xkk Xmbhgk~ mba qgk sgoqoiumsgku jb qgk lmu emhdiuo{ba`oodjbi lou iooa `jigqjbi"

    NMH][K@JBK'qo qgk i{zx* Boq qoo amud, i{zx" 'qoqgk uksouqku* J qgjbd qgkz)|k m`ukmazioq m amud kbo{ig sjhq{uk ol gjx jlk"

    UKSOUQKUZkm, J qgjbd jq)x ekxq qo aoybs`mz qgkxkujo{xbkxx ol jq lou boy"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    28/119

    Hmfkum s{xgkx qguo{ig obqo qgk i{zx, loh{xjbi ob Xmbhgk~ mx qgksgoqoiumsgku xqmuqx xbmssjbi sgoqox"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" BJHK GO[XK DJQHGKB

    YJ@@ mba NKXXK muk xkkb ob qgk o{qxjak ol qgk go{xk qguo{ig myjbaoy ol m djqhgkb aoou jb qgk emhd ol m go{xk" Nkxxk xqmbaxi{mua mx Yj`` yumsx m umi muo{ba gjx gmba mba humhdx qgk yjbaoy,ukmhgkx qguo{ig mba q{ubx qgk akma eo`q mba oskbx qgk aoou" Qgkeozx kbqku mba xqmuq ujl`jbi qguo{ig qgk go{xk"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" BJHK GO[XK [SXQMJUX EKAUOOF

    IOQG AUOSO[Q xjqx jb gku eka jb m qoub s{bd Q&xgjuq xfodjbi mnojbq, qm`djbi xgjq ob gku hk`` sgobk"

    IOQG AUOSO[QXo J qo`a gjf gk mjb)q s{qqjbi qgmqkboufo{x ekmxq mbzygkuk bkmu fk, f{hg`kxx jbxjak fk" '`m{igx* Og iukmq-Xofkeoaz euodk qgk jbqkubkq mimjb"

    Xgk gkmux m bojxk hofjbi luof aoybxqmjux mba l`jsx o{q"

    IOQG AUOSO[Q

    Fjhgmk` Nmhdxob)x XGJQ, Qjbm, J ioqqmio" J qgjbd Fof)x gofk" J)`` hm``zo{ jb m `jqq`k"

    Xgk n{fsx luof qgk eka, s{qx o{q gku nojbq, gjakx qgk mxg qumz{baku qgk eka mba iumex m hmb ol mju lukxgkbku mba xsumzx qgkygo`k uoof"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X YMJQJBI UOOF

    Suol" Ju|jbi xjqx ymjqjbi smqjkbq`z" Uoxgmbaum jx ymqkujbi qgks`mbqx ob gku akxd" UJHD, 53)x Hm{hmxjmb, kbqkux ymjqjbi uoofluof Au" Gollfmb)x olljhk" Ujhd mssuomhgkx Uoxgmbaum"

    UOXGMBAUM'ho}{kqqjxg`z* Goy aja jq io?

    UJHD

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    29/119

    J aob)q dboy" J i{kxx m`` ujigq" Jaob)q dboy jl qgjx jx m`` ukm``z youqgjq"

    UOXGMBAUMYk``, zo{ dboy ygmq yk qm`dka meo{q"Ygkb jq lkk`x `jdk jq)x boq iojbimbzygkuk, qgmq)x ygkb zo{)uk ikqqjbijbqo qgk iooa xq{ll" 'qo Suol"Ju|jbi* Zo{ hmb io jb boy, Suol"Ju|jbi"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Au" Gollfmb xjqx mq gjx akxd mx Suol" Ju|jbi kbqkux" Qgkuk muk

    qyo hgmjux jb luobq ol Au" Gollfmb)x akxd, obk jffkajmqk`zlmhjbi gjf mba qgk oqgku oll qo qgk xjak m ejq" Gollfmb ym|kxgjx gmba o|ku qgk qyo hgmjux mx jl qo ij|k gjf m hgojhk ol xkmqx"

    AU" GOLLFMBGm|k m xkmq"

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx qgk xkmq jffkajmqk`z lmhjbi Gollfmb"

    AU" GOLLFMBSuol" Ju|jbi, goy bjhk qo fkkq zo{ jbskuxob" Goy muk zo{ lkk`jbi qoamz?

    SUOL" JU\JBILjbk" 'sm{xk* Qgmbdx"

    Au" Gollfmb fmdkx m ho{s`k ol boqkx ob gjx sma e{q aokx boq xskmd"

    SUOL" JU\JBI 'HOBQ)A*Mba ygmq meo{q zo{?

    Gollfmb xqosx yujqjbi mba `oodx {s"

    AU" GOLLFMBJ)f ljbk" Qgmbd zo{ lou mxdjbi" Xojq `oodx `jdk yk)|k ioq xofkjfsouqmbq akhjxjobx qo ajxh{xx"

    SUOL" JU\JBIAkhjxjobx? Zo{ dboy jq ymxb)q fzjakm qo hofk gkuk"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    30/119

    AU" GOLLFMBQgk ymz J {bakuxqmba jq, zo{u hofjbigkuk jx m sukuk}{jxjqk lou dkksjbizo{u noe" Xo, gm|k zo{ fmak qgmqakhjxjob, zo{ yo{`a jdk qo dkks zo{unoe?

    SUOL" JU\JBI'aklkbxj|k`z* Yk`` ol ho{uxk J gm|kqo dkks fz noe- J qgjbd qgmq iokxyjqgo{q xmzjbi"

    AU" GOLLFMB'yjqg `jqq`k hob|jhqjob* Zkm, zo{ioqqm ao ygmq zo{ ioqqm ao"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" BJHK GO[XK @J\JBI UOOF

    Nkxxk mba Yj`` muk u{ffmijbi qguo{ig qgk j|jbi uoof ygkb qgkIoqg iju` hukksx }{jkq`z aoyb qgk xqmjux {bboqjhka" Xgk xkkfxfouk jbquji{ka qgmb mlumja" Xgk ikqx qo qgk eoqqof ol qgkxqmjux mba oexku|kx qgk sukohh{sjka qgjk|kx yjqg lmxhjbmqjob"Qgkz muk xqmuq`ka ygkb xgk xskmdx"

    IOQG AUOSO[QXo ygmq muk zo{ eozx `oodjbi lou,e{ujka qukmx{uk?

    Qgk eozx q{ub muo{ba mba ood mq qgk iju`, qgkb mq obk mboqgku,qgkb emhd mq qgk iju`, |kuz hobl{xka mba hobhkubka"

    IOQG AUOSO[QYgmq)x qgk fmqqku, hmq ioq zo{uqobi{k? Ygmq muk zo{ `oodjbi lou?

    NKXXKBo, {g, yk ykuk n{xq, {g, yk)uk gkukqo hgkhd o{q qgk hmuskq xo yk dboy

    ygmq, {g, k}{jsfkbq qo eujbi ob, {g,Fobamz ygkb yk, {gf, hofk emhd qoh`kmb jq"

    IOQG AUOSO[Q[gf, {g, bjhk, {gf quz, goq xq{ll"'xgk xj~kx gjf {s yjqg gku kzkx*

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    31/119

    YJ@@'miiukxxj|k`z* @ood gkuk, Sujbhkxxol Amudbkxx, qk`` {x ygkuk qgkz dkksqgk iooa xgjq ou zo{u mxx jx iumxx"

    IOQG AUOSO[QYgmq djba ol iooa xgjq ykuk zo{ jb qgkfmudkq lou, iumxx ou mxx? J hmb goodzo{ {s yjqg kjqgku obk ujigq boy,H{qjk E{bx"

    Xgk qyjxqx gku e{qq louymua mba s{``x gku Q&xgjuq {s qo kwsoxkgku smbqjkx" Yj`` iumex gku muf mba qyjxqx jq ekgjba gku emhdmba s{xgkx gku {s mimjbxq qgk ym``" Gk sukxxkx gjfxk l mimjbxqgku mba s{qx gjx fo{qg ujigq {s qo gku kmu mx gk iuoy`x qo gku"

    YJ@@

    Bo qjfk lou djbakuimuqkb imfkx boy,Sujbhkxx, yk)`` hofk emhd qo s`mzukhkxx ygkb zo{ ioq xofk iumxx ob qgks`mziuo{ba"

    Nkxxk fo|kx qoymua Yj`` mba qgk iju`"

    NKXXKHofk ob, Yj``, `km|k gku m`obk"@kq)x ikq o{qqm gkuk"

    Yj`` q{ubx gjx lkuohjqz ob Nkxxk"

    YJ@@Xg{q {s, zo{ xob&ol&m 'gkxjqmqkx*hukmf s{ll" 'qo qgk iju`* Zo{gkmua fk, m go{xk jdk qgjx m`ymzx gmxm ioaamf xmlk" Ygkuk jx jq?

    IOQG AUOSO[QQgkz aob)q gm|k mbzqgjbi youqg mxgjq" Qgkz)uk ob`z sukqkbajbi qo ekujhg"

    Yj`` mss`jkx fouk sukxx{uk ob gku"

    YJ@@E{`` xgjq, Sujbhkxx-

    IOQG AUOSO[Q

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    32/119

    Og ymjq- Ygmq meo{q Amaaz)xHoblkakumqk hojb ho``khqjob" Zkmg,qmdk qgmq" Gk)x ob`z dkksjbi jq xogk hmb xgjs fk ol qo xofk eomuajbixhgoo` ou xofkqgjbi"

    YJ@@Ygkuk jx jq qgkb"

    IOQG AUOSO[Q[sxqmjux ob qgk `klq jb qgk fmxqkuekauoof, ob qgk xgk`l meo|k qgkhofs{qku, {g, jb m emhdimffob eow"

    YJ@@'qo Nkxxk* Yk``, io ob, ikq jq-

    Nkxxk u{bx {s qgk xqmjux"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" BJHK GO[XK, FMXQKU EKAUOOF

    Nkxxk kbqkux qgk uoof g{uujka`z, `oodx muo{ba qo ljba qgkhofs{qku akxd" Ym`dx o|ku mba iumex qgk emhdimffob eow" Gkqmdkx jq qo qgk eka, xjqx aoyb mba oskbx jq qo kwmfjbk qgkhobqkbqx" Luof aoybxqmjux, gk gkmux m xh{ll`k"

    IOQG AUOSO[Q 'O"X"*'zk``jbi* Ikq oll o) fk, zo{ ioob-

    Mimjb luof aoybxqmjux, qgkuk jx qgk xo{ba ol m x`ms mba qgk iju`xhukmfjbi" Nkxxk l{fe`kx yjqg qgk eow mba h`oxkx jq eklouku{xgjbi o{q ol qgk uoof"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" XMBHGK^) XQ[AJO

    Qgk uksouqku mba qgk sgoqoiumsgku muk kwjqjbi jb qgk emhdiuo{bamx Nmh}{k`jbk lmhkx Xmbhgk~ yjqg gku gmba ob gjx xgo{`aku"

    NMH][K@JBKZo{ gmbi jb qgkuk boy, Xmbhgk~" Zo{dboy zo{)uk fz |kuz oyb Foaujmb, fze{aajbi ikbj{x" 'qkbaku`z* Mbaukfkfeku, qgkz ob`z quz qo qmdk jqmymz luof zo{ ygkb jq)x xofkqgjbiiukmq"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    33/119

    XMBHGK^'uk|j|jbi qgk Fkajk|m` qobk* Mg, fz`maz, J ao mqqkxq qo zo{ qgmq, yjqgfz smjbq eu{xg mx fz qu{xqz xyoua, Jxgm`q boq ym|ku luof hmuuzjbi o{q qgzjbqkbqjob" 'auosx qo obk dbkk jb miumba ikxq{uk* Qgkuk jx bo fouk boe`khm{xk lou fk qgmb qo e{q mz aoyb fz`jlk jb qgk aklkbxk ol fz lmju maz)xgobou mba yjxgkx"

    Nmh}{k`jbk m`foxq e`{xgkx lou qgk ljuxq qjfk jb gku ma{`q jlkmba s{qx gku gmba ob gjx xgo{`aku"

    NMH][K@JBK'sm{xkx* Og,'lkjibjbi lmjbq mbalmbbjbi gkuxk`l* og, qgmbd zo{, fz

    `oua"

    Xmbhgk~ iumex gku gmba mba djxxkx jq mx qgo{ig hobx{fka yjqgsmxxjob"

    NMH][K@JBK 'HOBQ)A*E{q ao s`kmxk ujxk mx J f{xq fmdkgmxqk lou fz hmuujmik mymjqx fk"

    Xmbhgk~ xqmbax"

    XMBHGK^'xolq mba xjbhkuk* Qgmbd zo{, Nmhdjk"Qgmbd zo{ lou k|kuzqgjbi"

    NMH][K@JBKAob)q youuz, Gobkz, ygkb qgk hgkhdxxqmuq uo``jbi jb, J)`` ek qgmbdjbizo{ qoo" Mba ukfkfeku, m`qgo{ig zo{fkmb qgk you`a qo fk, jb ouaku qol{`lj`` fz hmukku oe`jimqjobx J f{xqkbqkuqmjb f{`qjs`k e{xjbkxx mllmjux'sm{xk* {gf, xjf{`qmbko{x`z"

    Xgk imqgkux gku qgjbix mba gkmax lou qgk aoou" Xmbhgk~ jx mejq am~ka mx gk lo``oyx gku qo qgk aoou gkmujbi m qumj` oljbxqu{hqjobx"

    NMH][K@JBK9>33 qo :>33, gmba o{q l`zkux o{qxjakqgk \jxqm"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    34/119

    XMBHGK^Odmz"

    NMH][K@JBK'sojbqjbi* J `klq qgkf qgkuk ob qgkho{bqku" J s{q m uka aoq ez qgksmjbqjbix J ymbq zo{ qo qmdk yjqg zo{"

    XMBHGK^Odmz"

    NMH][K@JBKMba jl mbz oqgku uksouqkux mxd mbz}{kxqjobx, n{xq xmz, %Bo hoffkbq"%J suofjxka Mbbkqqk mb kwh`{xj|k jl

    xgk s{qx qgk ujigq xsjb ob jq"

    XMBHGK^Odmz"

    NMH][K@JBKMba 'sm{xk* og, ygmq mf J louikqqjbi?Og, hmb zo{ xqks {s qgk smhk" J)a ekn{xq m jqq`k kfemuumxxka qo s{q ; mba< ajijq sujhk qmix ob qgkxk qgjbix jlgm`l ol qgkf gm|k m YKQ SMJBQ xjibekxjak qgkf"

    XMBHGK^'eoqgkuka* Zkx fm)mf, iooaezk"

    Xmbhgk~ xqmbax ymjqjbi lou Nmh}{k`jbk qo `km|k"

    NMH][K@JBK'ym|jbi* Yk``, ikq e{xz"

    Nmh}{k`jbk kwjqx aoyb qgk xqmjux" Xmbhgk~ ukq{ubx qo gjxmllmju yjqg qgk smjbqjbi ol Mbbm"

    XMBHGK^Mq mxq yk muk m`obk mimjb, fz o|k"

    Nmh}{k`jbk)x lmhk msskmux jb qgk emhdiuo{ba, xszjbi luofgm`lymz aoyb qgk xqmjux" Xmbhgk~ sjhdx {s m sm``kq, x}{kk~kaxofk smjbq luof m q{ek obqo jq, amex m eu{xg jb qgk smjbq mbajx meo{q fmdk m xquodk ygkb Nmh}{k`jbk h`kmux gku qguomq mbagk q{ubx qo xkk gku yjqg gku mufx lo`aka mhuoxx gku hgkxq"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    35/119

    Hmfkum ygjsx qo m h`oxk&{s xqj`` ob Xmbhgk~ q{ubjbi muo{ba,oe|jo{x`z e{xqka"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Ju|jbi jx gm`lymz uk`mwka jb qgk houbku ol qgk ho{hg" Gollfmbxjqx bkmuez jb m `muik hgmju"

    AU" GOLLFMBE{q 'sm{xk* hmb zo{ qk`` fk YGZ qgjxdja jx xo jfsouqmbq qo zo{?

    SUOL" JU\JBIYk``, jq)x boq xo f{hg qgmq qgk djajx jfsouqmbq xo f{hg mx J lk`` `jdk

    J bkka qo ao xofkqgjbi qo ikq xofkdjba ol l{`lj``fkbq luof fz noe mbaboq n{xq ek m qoo` qo l{bbk` youqg`kxxjbloufmqjob mba youb&o{q h`jhgkxjbqo qgkju gkmax, lj` jbi qgkf yjqgimuemik, ygkb qgkz)uk xojfsukxxjobme`k mba xqmu|jbi lou, Jaob)q dboy, m eukmdqguo{ig,xofkqgjbi x{exqmbqjm`, fmzek k|kbkb`jigqkbfkbq" Jq)x jdk jl J ho{`ahob|jbhk qgk dja qgmq ygmq gk gmx jx|m`{me`k mba youqgz ol ukhoibjqjob,qgkb, mba ob`z qgkb, hmb J lkk` jdkJ)|k aobk fz noe"

    Luof o{qxjak qgk aoou Uoxgmbaum mba Ujhd muk gkmua xskmdjbi`o{a`z"

    UOXGMBAUMBo, ho{`a zo{ n{xq ymjq gkuk lou mfjb{qk"

    UJHD

    'eumqqj`z* Yk``, ygz hmb)q zo{ n{xqqk`` gjf J bkka qo qm`d qo gjf"

    UOXGMBAUMZkx, Fu" Ak@mhkz, e{q)x jq)x iobbm ekm lky fouk fjb{qkx"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    36/119

    Ju|jbi jx ajxqumhqka ez qgk hob|kuxmqjob o{qxjak qgk aoou mba`oodx mq Gollfmb hobl{xka"

    AU" GOLLFMBUjigq" Zkx, J xkk ygmq zo{)ukxmzjbi, e{q """

    UJHDJ UKM@@Z BKKA QO XSKMD QO GJF BOY-

    AU" GOLLFMBOdmz, `kq)x ij|k qgjx xofk qgo{igqmba yk)`` qmdk qgjx {s mimjb bkwqykkd"

    Ju|jbi xkkfx mbbozka mba x{usujxka qgmq qgk go{u gmx smxxka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXo, qgmq)x jq?

    AU" GOLLFMBZkx, hgkhd yjqg Uoxgmbaum ob zo{u ymzo{q lou bkwq ykkd)x xhgka{`k"

    Ju|jbi xqmbax {s mba iokx gm`lymz qo qgk aoou mba qgkb q{ubxmuo{ba"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, xo J xgo{`a hofk emhd bkwq ykkd?

    AU" GOLLFMB'ajxfjxxjbi gjf* Zkmg, J)f x{ukUoxgmbaum hmb gk`s zo{ yjqg qgmq"Gm|k m iooa amz, Suolkxxou"

    Ju|jbi `km|kx qgk uoof" Gk oskbx qgk aoou qo ljba Uoxgmbaume`ohdjbi jq" Uoxgmbaum fmdkx ymz lou gjf qo smxx mba Ujhdu{xgkx smxq gku"

    UOXGMBAUMJ)f xouuz, Au" Gollfmb, ao ymbq fk qohm`` """

    AU" GOLLFMBBo, bo jq)x ljbk" Qgmbd zo{,Uoxgmbaum" Qgjx)`` n{xq qmdk mfjb{qk"

    H[Q QO>

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    37/119

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X YMJQJBI UOOF

    Uoxgmbaum ukq{ubx qo gku akxd qo ljba Ju|jbi ymjqjbi"

    UOXGMBAUM'mqqkfsqjbi qo jibouk qgk jbhjakbq*Xo, goy ymx zo{u xkxxjob, SuolkxxouJu|jbi?

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq qgk """ ygmq ymx qgmq?

    UOXGMBAUMOg, jq)x boqgjbi" Xofkqjfkx jq ikqxm jqq`k hum~z muo{ba gkuk """ og, Jfkmb, 'l`{xqkuka* zo{ dboy ygmq Jfkmb"

    SUOL" JU\JBIBo ollkbxk qmdkb" Xo J i{kxx J)``xkk zo{ xmfk qjfk bkwq ykkd?

    Uoxgmbaum jx oe|jo{x`z ajxqumhqka mx jl mbwjo{x qo `jxqkb jbob qgk gmua`z m{aje`k hob|kuxmqjob ekqykkb Gollfmb mba Ujhd"

    UOXGMBAUMOg zkmg, qgmq)`` ek iukmq" 'gkmajbiqoymua Gollfmb)x olljhk* J)`` fmdk mboqk ol jq ujigq mymz"

    Ju|jbi uo``x gjx kzkx mba kwjqx"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ" SMYBXGOS

    YJ@@ mba NKXXK kwjq qgk smybxgos" Yj`` jx hmuuzjbi m xfm``xqmhd ol ej``x ygjhg gk jx aj|jajbi mba ij|jbi m xfm``ku souqjobqo Nkxxk qgmb gjx oyb souqjob" Nkxxk ho{bqx gjx souqjob mbaxmzx"

    NKXXKQgjx jx ob`z qgukk g{bauka" Jqgo{igq zo{ xmja yk ioq m qgo{xmba-

    YJ@@Yk aja ikq m qgo{xmba"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    38/119

    Yj`` q{ubx mba ym`d mymz aoyb qgk xjakym`d" Nkxxk ymqhgkx gjf`km|k mba qgkb u{xgkx qo hmqhg {s"

    NKXXKGkz- Ygkuk)x fz oqgku qyo g{baukaqgkb?

    Yj`` `jigqx m hjimukqqk e{q aokxb)q mbxyku" Gk ollkux mhjimukqqk qo Nkxxk"

    NKXXK'jfsmqjkbq`z* J aob)q ymbq m l{hdjbihjimukqqk" J ymbq fz qyo g{baukaao``mux-

    Yj`` qmdkx m x`oy aumi mba e`oyx jq ujigq jb Nkxxk)x lmhk" Qgkbgk ukmhgkx jb gjx homq sohdkq, s{``x o{q m bkmq xqmhd ol ej``x,

    mba ym|kx jq jb Nkxxk)x lmhk"

    YJ@@J)`` ij|k zo{ qgk qyo g{baukaao``mux, e{q J bkka zo{ qo suofjxk fkxofkqgjbi, Nkxxk"

    NKXXKSuofjxk zo{ ygmq? Ygmq muk zo{qm`djbi meo{q? N{xq ij|k fk qgkfobkz-

    Nkxxk iumex lou qgk fobkz mba Yj`` s{``x jq emhd"

    YJ@@Go`a ob, go`a ob- Jq)x boq m ejiakm`, J n{xq ymbq zo{ qo dkks }{jkqmeo{q qgmq `jqq`k xfmuq&mxx ejqhgemhd qgkuk"

    NKXXKOg, zo{ fkmb qgk obk zo{ ykuk quzjbiqo umsk"

    Yj`` ikqx l{ujo{x mba iumex Nkxxk)x bkhd mba go`ax gjf mimjbxqqgk ym``"

    YJ@@K|kb jl qgk ejqhg aja ymbq fk qo umskgku, J yo{`ab)q gm|k ij|kb gku qgk

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    39/119

    xmqjxlmhqjob" Boy, muk zo{ iobbmdkks zo{u l{hdjbi fo{qg xg{q ou ygmq?

    Nkxxk aokx boq mbxyku e{q xqmukx Yj`` aoyb" Mlqku m fofkbq Yj``ukm`j~kx gk gmx iobk qoo lmu mba gjx ood xolqkbx mx qgo{ig gk)xmeo{q qo mso`oij~k" Jbxqkma, gk uk`kmxkx Nkxxk mba qoxxkx qgkxqmhd ol ej``x ob qgk xjakym`d mq Nkxxk)x lkkq mba ym`dx mymz"Nkxxk imqgkux qgk ej``x mba xh{uujkx oll mlqku gjf"

    JBQ" JU\JBI HMU

    Suol" Ju|jbi jx auj|jbi jb lukkymz qumlljh mba obhk mimjb oodxjbqo qgk ukmu|jky fjuuou lou m ho{s`k ol xkhobax yjqg qgk xmfksmumboja ood ob gjx lmhk ygkb gk jx jbqkuu{sqka ez qgk ujbijbiol gjx hk`` sgobk" Gk ukmhgkx jbqo gjx homq sohdkq qo ikq qgksgobk mba mbxyku jq"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZo, Xmbhgk~, ygmq)x gmsskbjbi?

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx mboqgku `ood jbqo qgk uk|jky fjuuou lou mho{s`k ol xkhobax mx gk `jxqkbx qo Xmbhgk~"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, J gma qo suofjxk qo ekgm|kfzxk`l mba |jxjq qgk xgujbd obhk mykkd lou 53 ykkdx"

    Suol" Ju|jbi obhk mimjb xqmukx jbqo qgk uk|jky fjuuou x}{jbqjbigjx kzkx mba man{xqjbi qgk fjuuou"

    SUOL" JU\JBIHofk ob, fmb, zo{ ol m`` skos`k dboyJ)f boq hum~z, fmzek m `jqq`kkhhkbqujh"

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx mboqgku }{jhd i`mbhk jb qgk ukmu|jky fjuuou,qgkb q{ubx qo mhq{m``z ood ekgjba gjf, ygj`k go`ajbi qgk hk``sgobk qo gjx kmu"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'e{uxqjbi o{q mbiuj`z* Ioaamf jq, gkjx lo``oyjbi fk-

    Mx Suol" Ju|jbi q{ubx gjx gkma emhd louymua, gk xyku|kx mbam`foxq gjqx qgk hmu ekxjak gjf hm{xjbi qgk auj|ku jb qgk hmuekxjak qo gobd"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    40/119

    Bo- Jq)x n{xq qgjx l{hdjbi e`{kxkamb gmx ekkb lo``oyjbi fk muo{balou amzx" Zkmg, qgmq)x iukmq fmb-Gkz, J)f mq fz kwjq, J ioqqm io"

    Suol" Ju|jbi h`oxkx qgk sgobk mba qguoyx jq ob qgk xkmq ekxjakgjf" Gk mhhk`kumqkx mba xyku|kx qo kwjq qgk lukkymz" \kgjh`kxm`` muo{ba gjf gobd mq gjf"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ" QGKMQKU XJAKYM@D

    Xmbhgk~ jx qm`djbi ob gjx hk`` sgobk jb luobq ol qgkmqku yjqgxofk ol gjx muq mba smfsg`kqx lou gjx {shofjbi oskbjbi"

    XMBHGK^

    M`` ujigq, fmb, yk``, J)`` hm`` zo{`mqku mba ij|k zo{ qgk akqmj`x ob qgkxgoy bkwq ykkd" 'sm{xk* Gk``o"'sm{xk* Nkud" 'h`oxkx qgk sgobk mbas{qx jb gjx sohdkq*

    Xmbhgk~ qujkx m ho{s`k ol qjfkx qo suofoqk gjx xgoy qo{bjbqkukxqka smxxkux ez" Nkxxk mba Yj`` muuj|k ob qgk xhkbkxj~jbi {s qgk jbk jb luobq ol qgk qgkmqku" Xmbhgk~ mssuomhgkxqgkf yjqg l`zkux mba ollkux obk qo kmhg ol qgkf" Yj`` xgu{ixgjf oll u{ak`z" Nkxxk, goyk|ku, qmdkx qgk l`zku mba xgoyxjffkajmqk jbqkukxq" Xmbhgk~ hobqjb{kx fmdjbi gjx uo{bax"

    YJ@@'xholljbi* J)`` ikq qgk qjhdkqx"'sm{xk* Yk``, ij|k fk qgk l{hdjbifobkz, Ajsxgjq-

    Nkxxk gmbax Yj`` xofk fobkz" Yj`` xbmqhgkx jq mba iokx qo qgkemhd ol qgk jbk" Mx gk bkmux qgk emhd ol qgk obk jbk, Nkxxkhm``x qo gjf"

    NKXXK

    J)f iobbm ikq fz hgmbik, ujigq-

    YJ@@'amuqjbi mymz* Zkmg, ujigq, Ajsxgjq-Xkk zm `mqku"

    Nkxxk qguoyx gjx gmbax {s jb qgk mju"

    NKXXK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    41/119

    'f{qqkujbi* Mxxgo`k"

    XMBHGK^'mssuomhgjbi Nkxxk mimjb* Xofklujkba zo{ ioq qgkuk"

    NKXXK'kwmxskumqka* Kw&lujkba"

    Nkxxk `oodx mq qgk l`zku jb gjx gmba"

    NKXXKXo, muk zo{ qgk muqjxq?

    XMBHGK^J mf mb muqjxq, zkx" Mba qgjx jx ygmqqgk you`a yo{`a uklku qo mx fz muq"

    NKXXKJ aob)q ikq jq" Muk zo{ xmzjbi zo{ajab)q ukm``z smjbq )kf?

    XMBHGK^Og, J smjbqka jq- E{q J yo{`ab)qhm`` jq muq" Qgkxk muk qgk suoa{hqxqgmq J xk`` qo jbqkujou akhoumqouxygoxk h`jkbqx ob`z dboy qgkju |m`{kluof ygmq)x yujqqkb ob qgk sujhk qmi"

    NKXXKMba ygmq yo{`a zo{ hm`` muq?

    XMBHGK^Youax hmbboq akxhujek ygmq J hm``muq" 'sm{xk* E{q jl zo{)uk ukm``zjbqkukxqka, J)a ek gmssz qo xgoy zo{xofk qjfk"

    NKXXKX{uk, qgmq)a ek hoo`" Ygkb)x m iooa

    qjfk?XMBHGK^

    Yk``, J)`` ek qguo{ig gkuk jb m lkyfjb{qkx" Jl zo{ ymbq qo gmbi muo{balou m `jqq`k ejq, zo{ hmb ym`d yjqgfk o|ku qo qgk xq{ajo"

    NKXXK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    42/119

    [g, J ioqqm """ ao xofkqgjbi """ljuxq" E{q J ho{`a hofk ez `mqku"'sojbqjbi qo qgk l`zku* Qgjx qgkmaaukxx?

    XMBHGK^X{uk, jl zo{ hmb lo``oy obk jfsouqmbqxq{ajo u{`k"

    NKXXKYgmq)x qgmq?

    XMBHGK^M`` i{kxqx muuj|jbi mlqku qkb o)h`ohdmuk uk}{juka qo eujbi eoo~k"

    Nkxxk hg{hd`kx mba ym`dx mymz" Xmbhgk~ hm``x o{q qo gjf"

    XMBHGK^Og, gkz, ygmq)x zo{u bmfk?

    NKXXKNkxxk"

    XMBHGK^Mba J)f Xmbhgk~"

    Nkxxk go`ax {s qgk l`zku"

    NKXXKZkmg, J dboy"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" JU\JBI EKAUOOF

    Dmukb jx ob qgk eka ukmajbi m eood ygkb Suol" Ju|jbi kbqkux,oe|jo{x`z kaiz"

    DMUKB'kwmiikumqka`z xykkq* Gj, Gobkz,goy)a jq io?

    SUOL" JU\JBI'yjqg bo kwsukxxjob* Ljbk" Iukmq"

    Suol" Ju|jbi huoxxkx o|ku qo qgk yjbaoy mba h`oxkx qgk e`jbax"Mlqku gk h`oxkx qgkf, gk xksmumqkx qgkf qo ood o{q" Dmukbymqhgkx gjf h{ujo{x`z"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    43/119

    DMUKBJx k|kuzqgjbi odmz, Gobkz?

    Suol" Ju|jbi aokxb)q mbxyku" Dmukb s{qx qgk eood aoyb, ym`dx{s ekgjba gjf mba xqmuqx u{eejbi gjx xgo{`akux mx xgk qujkx qoxkk ygmq gk)x sukohh{sjka yjqg" Ygkb xgk ljuxq qo{hgkx gjf,gk n{fsx"

    DMUKB@o{jx, Ama xmja qgk fkkqjbi ykbq |kuzyk``" Ygmq jx yuobi yjqg zo{?

    SUOL" JU\JBIBoqgjbi, J qgo{igq J xmy xofkqgjbi"

    Suol" Ju|jbi q{ubx muo{ba mba hmukxxkx Dmukb mba djxxkx gku obqgk hgkkd"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, qgk fkkqjbi ykbq yk``, J fkqyjqg qgk aohqou mba jq ymxb)q kwmhq`zygmq J kwskhqka, e{q J qgjbd jq)x m``iobbm youd o{q ljbk"

    Dmukb jx m`` xfj`kx mba oodjbi |kuz xmlk mba hobljakbq" Xgkiumex Suol" Ju|jbi)x qjk, s{qx qgk kba ol jq jb gku fo{qg, mbaikbq`z s{``x gjf qoymua qgk eka yjqg gku, g{ffjbi m xka{hqj|kq{bk" Mx qgkz bkmu qgk eka, xgk xqmuqx qo {baukxx mba xq{fe`kxmba lm``x emhdymua obqo qgk eka, s{``jbi gjf ob qos ol gku,ijii`jbi"

    DMUKBYk``, qgkb J)a xmz qgmq fz eji eozakxku|kx m bjhk ukymua" Ao zo{ ymbqqo iume m eood mba J)`` ij|k EjiYj``jk m hmq emqg"

    Gkmujbi qgk |kuz m{aje`k xo{ba ol m hmu xskkajbi ez, Suol" Ju|jbii`mbhkx emhd qoymua qgk yjbaoy" Dmukb q{ubx gjx hgjb emhdqoymua gku yjqg gku ljbiku"

    DMUKBZo{ dboy, boq m`` hmqx gm|k m xhumqhgzqobi{k"

    Dmukb aokx gku ekxq xka{hqj|k s{uujbi xo{ba mba ijii`kx mimjb"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    44/119

    J aob)q dboy, Gobkz, jq)x ekkb m uo{igamz"

    Dmukb luoybx"

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ)f xouuz, Gobkz"

    DMUKBJ {bakuxqmba, jq)x odmz" Muk zo{g{biuz? Ajbbku)x ukmaz"

    Suol" Ju|jbi lmdkx jbqkukxq jb ajbbku mx mb kwh{xk qo ikq o{qluof {baku gku" Gk xqmbax {s meu{sq`z mba emhdx mymz luof qgkeka"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

    Og, zkmg, J)f xqmu|ka" Ygmq)x louajbbku?

    Dmukb xjqx fofkbqmuj`z yjqg m ood ol ajxmssojbqfkbq mba xgohd"Xgk qgkb xqmuqx qo xbjll`k mx jl so{qjbi"

    DMUKBJq)x zo{ lm|oujqk"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'lmdjbi gmssz x{usujxk* Zo{ ouakukasj~~m-

    Dmukb qgkb e{uxq jbqo ukm` qkmux"

    DMUKBBo- H{ek xqkmd-

    Suol" Ju|jbi iokx qo Dmukb mimjb mba go`ax gku"

    SUOL" JU\JBIGobkz, J)f ukm``z xouuz" Jq)x n{xqqgmq J ioq m oq ob fz fjba" N{xqij|k fk xofk qjfk qo ikq qguo{ig m``qgjx mba yk)`` ikq jq emhd, Dmukb" Jsuofjxk zo{, yk)`` ikq jq m`` emhdn{xq qgk ymz jq ymx"

    Dmukb xqjl`kx gku qkmux"

    DMUKBUkm``z?

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    45/119

    SUOL" JU\JBIUkm``z"

    DMUKBSuofjxk?

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkx, Gobkz """ `kq)x io kmq"

    Dmukb gkmax lou qgk aoou mba Suol" Ju|jbi gkmax lou qgk yjbaoymimjb"

    DMUKB'juujqmqka* @o{jx, xqos qgmq, zo{)ukxhmujbi fk-

    Suol" Ju|jbi xqosx gm`lymz qo qgk yjbaoy"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZo{)uk ujigq, J)f xouuz"

    Dmukb ymjqx lou Suol" Ju|jbi mq qgk aoou mba qgkz kwjq qoikqgku"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ" JU\JBI GO[XK

    M e`{k xkamb x`oy`z smxxkx ez qgk go{xk mba q{ubx mq m bkmuezxqukkq houbku mba smudx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB LOUFM@ AJBJBI UOOF

    Nkxxk mba Au" Gollfmb xjq mq qgk bofjbm``z aukxxka ajbbku qme`k"Jq jx }{jkq mba qkbxk jb qgk aume jigqjbi" Nkxxk jx fo|jbigjx looa muo{ba ob qgk s`mqk mx jl ajxjbqkukxqka jb qgk ygo`kxhkbk"

    AJXXO@\K QO>

    Xmfk xgoq, e{q boy qgk qme`k jx k`o}{kbq`z aukxxka yjqg hmba`kx,bmsdjbx, l{`` xj`|kuymuk xkqqjbix mba m ekm{qjl{` l`oykumuumbikfkbq lou m hkbqkusjkhk"

    NKMBBJK 'O"X"*Mba, lou qgk fmjb ho{uxk, uomxqoumbik a{hd"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    46/119

    H[Q QO>

    H`oxk&{s ol a{hd ajxg ekjbi xkq ob qme`k" Smb {s qo Nkmbbjk"Nkmbbjk h`kmux gku qguomq mba xjqx" Nkxxk mba Au" Gollfmbhgkkul{``z aji jb qo qgk `m|jxg fkm`"

    NKXXKIukmq fkm`, Fof-

    Nkxxk iumex qgk a{hd ajxg mba mhhjakbqm``z ikqx gjx ljbikux jbqgk xm{hk" Gk xfj`kx mba `jhdx gjx ljbikux"

    NKMBBJK'xho`ajbi* Gobkz, goy fmbz qjfkx gm|kJ qo`a zo{ qo {xk zo{u bmsdjb"

    AU" GOLLFMB

    Akmu, qgjx jx skulkhq- Zo{ f{xq gm|kxskbq m`` amz jb qgk djqhgkb"

    NKXXKZkmg, mba xgk fmak A{qhg mss`k hu{fesjk, qoo-

    AU" GOLLFMB'`jigqgkmuqka`z* Ygmq)x qgk xskhjm`ohhmxjob, Akmu?

    Nkmbbjk s{qx gku loud aoyb, qmdkx gku bmsdjb luof gku ms, yjskxgku lmhk, s{qx qgk bmsdjb ob qgk qme`k, sm{xkx m fofkbq mba q{ubxjb gku hgmju mx jl qo ujxk mba `km|k"

    NKMBBJKJ hmb)q ao qgjx mbzfouk"

    Nkxxk mba Au" Gollfmb ood mq Nkmbbjk mba lukk~k mx xgk ljigqxoll qgk qkmux" Nkmbbjk ujxkx mba q{ubx mymz e{q aokx boq km|k"Xgk s{qx gku gmbax {s qo gku lmhk qo gjak gku mbi{jxg" Au"Gollfmb xqmbax {bhoflouqme`z"

    NKXXKFof- Fof, ygmq)x yuobi?

    NKMBBJK'hofsmxxjobmqk`z* Nkxxk """ J)f xoxouuz """

    AU" GOLLFMB

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    47/119

    Nkmbbjk, s`kmxk, xgo{`ab)q yk ao qgjxxofk oqgku qjfk?

    Au" Gollfmb)x youax qguoy Nkmbbjk jbqo m umik" Xgk s{xgkx gkuhgmjb jbqo qgk qme`k mba {xkx jq mx m soaj{f luof ygjhg qo ak`j|kugku ejqqku xskkhg"

    NKMBBJKOg, qgjx jx boq m iooa qjfk, Au"Gollfmb? Fmzek J xgo{`a hm``Uoxgmbaum mba xhgka{`k mbmssojbqfkbq- 'sm{xk* Yk``, ygkb jx miooa qjfk? Jx qgkuk ukm``z m iooaqjfk lou QGJX-

    NKXXKHo{`a xofkobk s`kmxk qk`` fk ygmq qgk

    gk`` jx iojbi ob-

    Nkmbbjk ljaa`kx, xqumjigqkbjbi qgk fkxx xgk fmak ez embijbi qgkhgmju"

    NKMBBJK'akxskumqk`z quzjbi qo ukimjbhobquo`* J mf boq qgjx skuxob" J mfboq iojbi qo `kq qgjx akxsjhme`k'mimjb `oxjbi hobquo`* """ qgjxa{s`jhjqo{x """ 'qoymua Au" Gollfmb*MEOFJBMQJOB """ u{jb fz `jlk"

    NKXXKYgmq jx iojbi ob-

    NKMBBJKNkxxk, J qgjbd zo{ bkka qo dboy """

    Au" Gollfmb huoxx qo Nkmbbjk mba iumex gku ljuf`z ez qgk {sskumuf"

    AU" GOLLFMB

    Nkmbbjk- BOQ BOY-

    NKMBBJK's{``jbi mymz* Ljbk- 'qoxxkx gkubmsdjb l`jssmbq`z ob qgk qme`k*Zo{)uk ujigq" Skugmsx J xgo{`a`km|k zo{ qyo 'fohdjbi`z*

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    48/119

    %ikbq`kfkb% qo akm` yjqg qgjx ob zo{uoyb qjfk"

    Nkmbbjk km|kx qgk uoof xqujakbq`z" Qgkuk jx m }{jkq, h`{fxzfofkbq" Nkxxk `oodx mq Au" Gollfmb"

    NKXXKAma? Ygmq gm|k zo{ aobk boy? Ama-

    Au" Gollfmb ukq{ubx qo gjx xkmq mba s{qx gjx lmhk jb gjx gmbax"M aoou x`mfx `o{a`z"

    NKXXK'q{ubx qoymua qgk aoou x`mf* Fof?'sm{xk, q{ubx qo Gollfmb* AMA-

    ][JHD AJXXO@\K>

    Xmfk xgoq" Emhd qo ajxfm` sukxkbq&amz xkqqjbi" Au" Gollfmb`oodx {s luof gjx h{sska gmba mba `oodx mq Nkxxk mx jl xqj``xqu{ii`jbi lou qgk ujigq youax" Nkxxk oodx emhd mq gjf mx jlgk)x xqj`` ymjqjbi lou mb kws`mbmqjob"

    AU" GOLLFMBZo{)uk boq g{biuz?

    Nkxxk `oodx |kuz ajxmssojbqka lou m fofkbq, qgkb ikqx {s mba`km|kx Au" Gollfmb m`obk jb xj`kbhk"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB GO[XK DJQHGKB

    Nkxxk kbqkux qgk djqhgkb, oskbx qgk smbquz aoou mba iumex qyoeoqq`kx ol yjbk mba kwjqx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" XMBHGK ) XQ[AJO & @MQK K\KBJBI

    Nkxxk muuj|kx hmuuzjbi qgk qyo eoqq`kx ol yjbk" Qgk aoou jxoskb mba gk gkmux f{xjh xo gk kbqkux yjqgo{q dbohdjbi" Xmbhgk~jx smjbqjbi e{q qgk f{xjh jx o{a" Nkxxk aokx boq boqjhkXmbhgk~) ekm{qjl{` b{ak foak`, Mbbm, soxjbi jb m xfm`` xkqqjbi"Nkxxk hm``x o{q qo Xmbhgk~ ygo jx x{usujxka ygkb gk gkmux gjf"

    NKXXKGkz Xmbhgk~, jq)x Nkxxk-

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    49/119

    XMBHGK^Gkz, ygmq qgk gk`` jx qgjx, m l{hdjbiemub- Aob)q zo{ dboy goy qo dbohd-

    Nkxxk q{ubx mba xkkx Mbbm ygo jx boq mq m`` mxgmfka ol gku b{ajqzmx xgk xjqx go`ajbi gku soxk" Xmbhgk~ aokx boq boqjhk Nkxxk)xkfemuumxxfkbq e{q Mbbm aokx mba jx l`mqqkuka ez Nkxxk)xukxskhql{`bkxx"

    XMBHGK^'ukxsobajbi qo gku ood ol l`mqqkuz*Mbbm, fz o|k, J i{kxx jq)x qjfk louzo{ qo ho|ku zo{uxk`l" Qgmq jx,{b`kxx Nkxxk jx yj``jbi qo smz m ho|kuhgmuik"

    NKXXK

    Odmz, goy f{hg?

    Mbbm hg{hd`kx"

    XMBHGK^'jbqjfjamqka ez Nkxxk)x hobljakbhk*Ygom- Zo{ n{xq ioq gkuk mba zo{)ukquzjbi qo fmdk oll yjqg fz iju`"

    Mbbm ikqx {s, s{qx ob m xgjuq mba xqmuqx qo imqgku gku qgjbix"

    NKXXKBo, fmb, J ymx n{xq djaajbi muo{ba"@ood, J euo{igq qgk yjbk" Jq)x mlqkuqkb, ujigq?

    Mbbm, gkmujbi qgk qjfk, xqmuqx qo u{xg"

    MBBMOg fz Ioa- Jq)x mlqku qkb- J qo`agjf J)a ek qgkuk mq qkb"

    XMBHGK^

    Qo`a ygo?MBBM

    Zo{ dboy, qgk sokq 'sm{xk* qgk%euj``jmbq sokq% 'sm{xk* yjqg qgk%gmbax"% Qgk %foqgku)x fj`d"%

    Mbbm qjqj``mqkx Xmbhgk~)x bjss`kx mba gk ijii`kx qgk qkbxjobmymz" Mbbm ij|kx Xmbhgk~ m }{jhd g{i mba qgkb xskmdx xgz`z"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    50/119

    MBBM[gf, J gmqk qo mxd )hm{xk J dboy J xmjaJ ho{`a ymjq qj`` mlqku qgk oskbjbi,e{q ao zo{ qgjbd zo{ ho{`a io mgkmamba ho|ku fk lou m ho{s`k ol xkxxjobxlou boy?

    XMBHGK^Og zkmg, ol ho{uxk, ol ho{uxk, bosuoe`kf" Zo{ dboy J)`` qmdk hmuk olzo{"

    Xmbhgk~ xqmuqx oodjbi muo{ba qgk uoof jb ujajh{`o{x s`mhkx loufobkz"

    MBBMOg, gj, J)f Mbbm, muk zo{ gkuk qo

    foak`?

    NKXXKBo, bo, bo ymz" J)f, {gf,'hobljakbq`z* mb muqjxq"

    Mbbm xgoyx jffkajmqk jbqkukxq e{q bkkax qo qkxq gjf m ejq"

    MBBMOg, ukm``z- Xo ygmq djba ol muq mukzo{ jbqo?

    Nkxxk jx xofkygmq hm{igq oll i{mua mba `oxkx m `jqq`k ol gjxhobljakbhk"

    NKXXKYk``, xofk skos`k aob)q hobxjaku jqmuq, J i{kxx" J)f m iumsgjhbo|k`jxq"

    MBBMOg, zo{ ao hofjh eoodx?

    NKXXKYk``, zkmg"

    MBBMJ @O\K HOFJH EOODX-

    NKXXK'e`{xgjbi* Ukm``z?

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    51/119

    MBBMZkmg, ukm``z-

    Xmbhgk~ ukmsskmux meu{sq`z yjqg m ljxq l{`` ol ymaaka ej``x mbahojbx"

    XMBHGK^'qo Mbbm* J)|k ioq lj|k ao``mux mbaqgjuqz&kjigq hkbqx"

    MBBM'xbmqhgjbi qgk ej``x* Bo, jq)x qgukkao``mux mba 's{xgjbi gjx gmbal{` olhojbx mymz* zo{ hmb dkks qgk 587hkbqx" 'sm{xk* Jq)x odmz, Xmbhgk~, Jhmb qmdk qgk e{x"

    NKXXK'qo Mbbm* J)|k ioq xofk kwqum fobkz"'q{ubx qo Xmbhgk~* J fkmb, jl zo{ymbq, J ho{`a xsoq zo{ m qykbqz"

    Nkxxk qmdkx m qykbqz&ao``mu ej`` luof gjx sohdkq"

    MBBM'e`{xgjbi* Og bo, Ioa bo" E{q qgmbdzo{, zo{)uk xo xykkq-

    Nkxxk go`ax qgk fobkz o{q qo kmhg ol qgkf jb q{ub"

    NKXXKBo, bo, jq)x ljbk, J)|k ioq kwqumfobkz"

    Xmbhgk~ iumex qgk fobkz yjqgo{q gkxjqmqjob, lo`ax jq, mba yumsxMbbm)x gmba muo{ba jq yjqg gjx oyb gmba"

    XMBHGK^Bo, bo, jq)x ljbk, ajab)q zo{ gkmugjf, gk)x ioq kwqum fobkz"

    Xmbhgk~ kxhouqx Mbbm o{q akqkufjbka`z" Mbbm hm``x qo Nkxxkluof qgk aoou mx Xmbhgk~ jx h`oxjbi jq jb gku lmhk"

    MBBMEzk, Nkxxk" Jq ymx bjhk fkkqjbi zo{,Nkxxk"

    Xmbhgk~ qujkx qo h`oxk qgk aoou ob Mbbm e{q xgk ukxjxqx"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    52/119

    NKXXKZo{ qoo, Mbbm"

    MBBM'qo Xmbhgk~ ljuf`z* Mba jl ZO[ aob)qxqos ekjbi xo U[AK, boeoaz)x iobbmK\KU ek ZO[U iju`, 'h{qk`z*kxskhjm``z fk"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" JU\JBI AJBJBI UOOF

    Dmukb qoxxkx muo{ba qgk lky ukfmjbjbi fouxk`x ol gku akxxkuqyjqg gku loud" Suol" Ju|jbi hgkkul{``z mba hmuk`kxx`z q{ubxqgk eoqq`k ol yjbk {s jdk m yjbo mba xsj``x qgk mxq lky auosxluof qgk eoqq`k aoyb gjx hgjb" Gk yjskx gjx fo{qg yjqg gjx xgjuq

    x`kk|k mba gmbax qgk kfsqz eoqq`k qo Dmukb"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'iujbbjbi* Zo, Fmffm, fouk yjbk"

    DMUKBZo{ ioq jq, Smsm, ygmqk|ku jq qmdkxqo ikq zo{ qguo{ig ljbm`x" E{q zo{gm|kb)q mbxykuka fz }{kxqjob"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'`m{igjbi* Muk zo{ xkujo{x? Bo,jq)x boq `jdk qgmq" 'ikqx xkujo{x*Odmz, jq)x n{xq qgmq, J aob)q dboy,yjqg qgkxk lky }{jhd """ xhujee`kx,qgjx xq{sja `jqq`k ho``kik djahofs`kqk`z kbhmsx{`mqka qgk kxxkbhkol qgk fofkbq, `jdk qgjx umbaofaumyjbi gk`a xofk djba ol fzxqjhm`jbxjigq ou k|kb suosgkhz"

    DMUKB'xmuhmxqjh* Zo{ qgjbd gk)x m suosgkq?

    SUOL" JU\JBI'`m{igjbi* M`` ujigq, m`` ujigq, jq)xsuoeme`z n{xq m hojbhjakbhk" Ygmq)x{s yjqg qgmq yjbk, Fmffm?

    DMUKB

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    53/119

    Qgmq)x ekqqku" Yk`` qgkb, EjiAmaaz, ygz aob)q zo{ gkma ob {s qgkekauoof em`hobz mba J)`` eujbi jq {sjb m fjb{qk"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'au{bdkb`z omljxg* Qgk ekauoof, g{g,odmz, e{q bobk o) qgmq l{bbz xq{ll,zo{ gkmu?

    Dmukb ijii`kx mx Suol" Ju|jbi gkmax oll qo qgk ekauoof"

    H[Q QO>

    KWQ" JU\JBI EM@HOBZ

    Suol" Ju|jbi ym`dx o{q obqo qgk em`hobz mba `oodx o|ku qgk

    umj`jbi, ykmujbi m Q&xgjuq mba eowkux" Gk oodx o{q mba xkkfxhobljakbq qgmq qgk homxq jx h`kmu mba `jigqx {s m xfm`` gmxgsjsk" Dmukb kbqkux yjqg eoqg mufx ekgjba gku emhd"

    DMUKBGobkz, muk zo{ xfodjbi soq?

    SUOL" JU\JBIBo"

    DMUKBE{``xgjq, J xfk`` jq"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, hofk ob, aob)q zo{ dboy qgkajllkukbhk ekqykkb soq mba gmxg?

    DMUKBBo"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYmbq xofk?

    DMUKBQgmbd zo{" Bo"

    Dmukb eujbix qgk yjbk eoqq`k mba qyo i`mxxkx ol yjbk luof ekgjbagku emhd yjqg gku `klq gmba"

    DMUKBMuk zo{ x{uk jq)x odmz qo fjw?

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    54/119

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, J)f x{uk jq)x odmz qo fjw" Mxm fmqqku ol lmhq, jq)x m`ymzx ekqqkuqo fjw" 'boqjhjbi gku ujigq gmbaxqj`` ekgjba gku emhd* Ygmq muk zo{gjajbi?

    Dmukb xka{hqj|k`z fo|kx qoymua Suol" Ju|jbi"

    DMUKBJ ymx qgjbdjbi, xjbhk k|kuzqgjbi jxiojbi xo yk``, qgmq qgjx fjigq ek miooa bjigq qo """

    Dmukb `kmbx jb h`oxk qo Suol" Ju|jbi)x kmu mba ygjxskuxjbm{aje`z yjqg m h{qk xfj`k ob gku lmhk mx xgk eujbix o{q m q{eol Hoo` Ygjs luof ekgjba gku emhd yjqg gku ujigq gmba" Suol"

    Ju|jbi hg{hd`kx mx jl qjqj``mqka, e{q qgkb emhdx mymz

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ aob)q dboy, Gobkz, ujigq o{q gkuk-

    DMUKBZkmg, zo{ hmb ymqhg lou qgoxk k|j`hmux zo{)|k ekkb xkkjbi, mba J)``gjak ujigq gkuk 'sojbqx ekgjba qgkumj`jbi* mba qmdk hmuk ol k|kuzqgjbik`xk" '`jhdx gk jsx mba boax gku gkma%zkx%* K|kuzqgjbi"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'`m{igjbi o{q `o{a* Dmukb, qgmq)xykjua" Mukb)q zo{ qmdjbi qgjx m`jqq`k qoo lmu?

    DMUKB'ijii`jbi* Qmdjbi jq qoo lmu- Bo obkhmb xkk, bo obk yj`` dboy, mba boeoazjx YMQHGJBI- Ygmq muk zo{ YOUUJKAmeo{q-

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq ao zo{ fkmb, boeoaz)x ymqhgjbi?Aob)q zo{ xkk, k|kuzeoaz jx ymqhgjbifk" Zo{)uk ama jx ymqhgjbi fk, qgkxgujbd jx ymqhgjbi fk, fz xq{akbqxmuk ymqhgjbi fk mba k|kb aumyjbisjhq{ukx ol fk, qgk amfbka i{zx jb qgk

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    55/119

    e`{k xkamb muk ymqhgjbi, mba k|kbzo{, ZO[ muk m`ymzx ymqhgjbi fk"

    DMUKBFK-

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, ymqhgjbi o|ku fk jdk zo{)uk fzfoqgku"

    DMUKB@o{jx, J mf zo{u yjlk-

    Suol" Ju|jbi xqmbax luo~kb mx jl qgkuk)x boqgjbi fouk qo xmz"Dmukb oodx mq gjf xma`z lou m fofkbq mba fo|kx qo qgk em`hobzumj`jbi" Suol" Ju|jbi xjqx mq qgk qme`k mba qmdkx mboqgku gjqol gmxg" Dmukb xqmukx o{q o|ku qgk em`hobz mba xskmdx xolq`z

    mba hmukl{``z"

    DMUKBGobkz, jx qgmq qgk hmu?

    SUOL" JU\JBIZo{ xkk qgk hmu?

    DMUKBYk``, m amud e`{k xkamb n{xq ykbq ez""" |kuz x`oy`z"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xqmbax mba gkxjqmbq`z nojbx gku mq qgk umj`jbi"

    DMUKB'sojbqjbi* Jq n{xq ykbq muo{ba qgmqhoubku"

    Suol" Ju|jbi `ood mq obk mboqgku hobhkubka"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" XMBHGK^) XQ[AJO

    Nkxxk jx mja emhd, aujbdjbi yjbk mba xfodjbi soq" Xmbhgk~ jxxqmbajbi jb luobq ol gjf yjqg qyo ol gjx smjbqjbix ujigq ekgjbagjf, gjx sujak&mba&noz sjhq{uk ol Mbbm mba mboqgku ukek``jo{xso`jqjhm` oujijbx"

    XMBHGK^Xo, qgkuk zo{ gm|k jq" Qgk ob`z qyoqgjbix jb qgjx you`a k|kb youqg

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    56/119

    ikqqjbi {sxkq meo{q" B{feku obk jxzo{u ujigq qo kwkuhjxk zo{ul{bamfkbqm` ek`jklx" Mba b{feku qyojx zo{u ujigq, ou bo, bo zo{usuj|j`kik, qo xgmuk zo{u gkmuq yjqgm ekm{qjl{` yofmb" Zo{ gkmujbi fk?Zo{ {bakuxqmba ygmq J)f xmzjbi?

    Nkxxk jx sukohh{sjka yjqg smhdjbi mba `jigqjbi m bky eoy`"

    NKXXKG{g?

    Xmbhgk~ luoybx gm`lgkmuqka`z mq Nkxxk lou m fofkbq"

    XMBHGK^Goy o`a muk zo{?

    NKXXKYgmq ao zo{ fkmb? Ygmq aokx jqfmqqku goy o`a J mf? Jq)x j``kim` bofmqqku goy o`a zo{ muk, fmb-

    XMBHGK^Bo, jq)x boq qgmq" Ek`jk|k fk, Jaob)q hmuk meo{q qgmq" Jq)x n{xqqgmq """ zo{ dboy ygmq, louikq meo{qjq"

    Xmbhgk~ sjhdx {s m eoqq`k ol yjbk luof qgk qme`k mba q{ubx jq{s mba i{~~`kx qgk `mxq ol jq"

    XMBHGK^Ygkuk)x qgmq oqgku eoqq`k ol yjbk?

    Nkxxk oodx mq gjf lou m fofkbq yjqg m s{~~`ka ood ob gjx lmhk"

    NKXXKYgmq ao zo{ fkmb, qgmq ymx qgk oqgkueoqq`k"

    XMBHGK^Ygmq aja zo{ aujbd qgk oqgku obk m``ez zo{uxk`l?

    NKXXKBo, fmb, qgjx jx xqj`` fz ljuxq i`mxx"Zo{ aumbd eoqg ol qgkf, 'hg{hd`kx*zo{ `{xg-

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    57/119

    Qgjx jx n{xq qgk ujigq e{qqob qo xkq Xmbhgk~ oll" Gk qguoyxqgk eoqq`k mimjbxq m lmu ym``"

    XMBHGK^Ygo qgk l{hd muk zo{ hm``jbi m {xg,eoz- Zo{ hofk jb fz go{xk, xfodk fzsoq, quz qo fmh ob fz iju` """

    NKXXKBo, fmb, go`a ob, hgj``, fmb" Jeuo{igq qgk yjbk, ukfkfeku? Gkuk'gmbax gjf qgk sjsk* J ioq fz oybmbzymz" Xo Mbbm)x zo{u iju`lujkba'`oodx mq gjf ao{eql{``z*" Jqgo{igq xgk ymx zo{u foak`"

    Xmbhgk~ sm{xkx fofkbqmuj`z, ukimjbx xofk ol gjx hofsox{uk mba

    s{xgkx qgk sjsk emhd qoymua Nkxxk"

    XMBHGK^Bo, qgmq)x m`` ujigq" Nkx{x, J)fxqmuqjbi qo mhq `jdk @o{jk"

    NKXXKYgo)x @o{jk?

    XMBHGK^Fz fmb, @o{jk" @o{jk jx m xk``o{q"Zkmg, gk {xka qo ek qgk foxq ujigqko{xfmb zo{ ho{`a k|ku ljba" E{q boy,jq)x qgk X[\, qgk go{xk jbGo``zeuood, qgk goqxgoq suolkxxou,mba qo qos jq m`` oll, mhq{m``zhobxsjujbi yjqg qgk fmb ob xofk djbaol qos xkhukq suoiumf, mba gk``, gkk|kb fmuujka qgk akmb)x am{igqku"Zkmg, iooa o`a Suolkxxou Ju|jbi, fzlujkba, qgk qumjqou"

    NKXXK

    Suolkxxou @o{jx Ju|jbi? Zo{ dboy fzsgj`oxosgz qkmhgku?

    XMBHGK^Bo, bo, boq gjf"

    Xmbhgk~ ukm`j~kx gk gmx xmja qo f{hg mba mydymua`z xqmuqx qoh`kmb {s qgk xq{ajo" Nkxxk ikqx {s mba lo``oyx gjf muo{ba"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    58/119

    NKXXKBo, zo{ xmja Suolkxxou @o{jx Ju|jbiygo `j|kx jb Go``zeuood ygo qkmhgkxmq ho``kik, fmuujka qo qgk akmb)xam{igqku" Hofk ob, fmb, ygmq qosxkhukq suoiumf? Zo{ quzjbi qo qk``fk qgmq o{a&fo{qgka oxku youdx louqgk HJM ou xofkqgjbi?

    XMBHGK^Bo, fmb, auos jq" J)f qk``jbi zo{jq)x boq qgk xmfk i{z, odmz?

    Nkxxk xqmukx mq Xmbhgk~ lou m fofkbq" Xmbhgk~ jiboukx gjf mbahobqjb{kx h`kmbjbi"

    NKXXK

    Yk``, jq)x ikqqjbi djbam `mqk" Ji{kxx J)a ekqqku ek ikqqjbi gofk"

    XMBHGK^Xouuz )eo{q qgk fjx{bakuxqmbajbi"Yk)uk n{xq gm|jbi m iooa qjfk, ujigq?

    Nkxxk gkmax lou qgk aoou" Xmbhgk~ hobqjb{kx h`kmbjbi" MxNkxxk bkmux qgk aoou, Xmbhgk~ xqosx h`kmbjbi mba hm``x o{q qoNkxxk, quzjbi qo ajxi{jxk gjx lkmu ol `oxjbi m lujkba"

    XMBHGK^Gkz, zo{ dboy zo{ hmb xqos ez mbzqjfk"

    Nkxxk sm{xkx mx gk oskbx qgk aoou qo `km|k"

    NKXXKOdmz, x{uk" Bjhk qm`djbi yjqg zo{,fmb"

    XMBHGK^E{q aob)q louikq qgk yjbk"

    Xmbhgk~ m{igx mydymua`z mx qgk aoou xg{qx" Gk qguoyx qgk euoofmxjak, iokx o|ku jb luobq ol qgk smjbqjbi ol Mbbm mba dbkk`xaoyb"

    XMBHGK^Og fz Ioa, Mbbm, ygmq gm|k J aobk boy?

    Gk s{qx gjx gmbax o|ku gjx lmhk, qukfe`kx mba h{u`x jbqo m em``,fombjbi m`` qgk ygj`k"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    59/119

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X YMJQJBI UOOF & FOUBJBI

    Uoxgmbaum jx lmhjbi mymz luof gku akxd g{ffjbi m e`{kxkz fk`oazqo m s`mbq mx xgk ij|kx jq qkbaku o|jbi hmuk" Xgk aokxb)qboqjhk Suol" Ju|jbi kbqkujbi mba `jxqkbjbi qo gku xjbijbixgoyjbi oe|jo{x mafjumqjob"

    SUOL" JU\JBIBo yobaku qgoxk s`mbqx `ood xogkm`qgz" J)a ek gmssz qoo jl J ioqqo `jxqkb qo qgmq k|kuz amz"

    Uoxgmbaum q{ubx qo lmhk gjf, x{usujxka mba kfemuumxxka"

    UOXGMBAUM'e`{xgjbi* Qgmbd zo{" J ajab)qboqjhk zo{ hofk jb" Ygkb aja zo{ ikq

    gkuk?

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ n{xq ym`dka jb" Xouuz J)f `mqk"

    UOXGMBAUMQgmq)x ljbk, Suolkxxou Ju|jbi, gjx 7o)h`ohd jx u{bbjbi m jqq`k obi" Jqxgo{`ab)q ek obi" Hmb zo{ ymjq n{xqm ho{s`k ol fjb{qkx?

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ)a ek gmssz qo- Ao zo{ qmdkuk}{kxqx?

    UOXGMBAUM'ijii`kx* Og xqos jq"

    SUOL" JU\JBIBo, J)f boq djaajbi" J gm|kb)q gkmuam |ojhk qgmq ujhg xjbhk Xmumg\m{igmb"

    UOXGMBAUMOdmz, boy yk)uk qm`djbi" Ygkb ymxzo{u `mxq iji?

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, fz ioa, ymz qoo obi mio" J hmb)qk|kb ukfkfeku goy iooa jq lk`q qo ekqgmq skuxob"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    60/119

    UOXGMBAUMQgmq)x boq iooa" J hmb)q jfmijbkk|ku `kqqjbi f{xjh o{q ol fz `jlk"

    Qgk sgobk ujbix, xgk mbxykux jq mba `jxqkbx lou m ho{s`k olxkhobax

    UOXGMBAUM'jbqo qgk sgobk* Mimjb-

    Uoxgmbaum go`ax {s m ljbiku mx jl qo mxd Suol" Ju|jbi qo go`aob m ygj`k"

    UOXGMBAUMJx gk xqj`` mq qgk xhgoo`? Aja zo{qmdk gjf xofk h`kmb smbqx?

    Uoxgmbaum f{qkx qgk fo{qgsjkhk mba ygjxskux qo Ju|jbi"

    UOXGMBAUMFz iumbaxob" Jq)`` n{xq ek m fjb{qk"

    Suol" Ju|jbi qmdkx gjx xkmq"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Ujhd xjqx yjqg m x{``kb lmhk mx Au" Gollfmb xskmdx"

    AU" GOLLFMBXo, zo{ aob)q ukfkfeku zo{u lmqgkuk|ku go`ajbi zo{? Zo{ bk|ku xmq jbgjx `ms? Gk bk|ku djxxka zo{ iooabjigq?

    Ujhd xjqx xqj`` yjqg kzkx aoybhmxq lou m fofkbq, xgmdkx gjx gkma%bo"%

    AU" GOLLFMB 'HOBQ)A*Zo{ aob)q ukfkfeku mbzqgjbi `jdkqgmq?

    Mimjb Ujhd sm{xkx m fofkbq mba qgkb xgmdkx gjx gkma %bo"%

    UJHDJ m`ymzx lk`q jdk gk ymbqka qo, e{qgk ymx mlumja ou xofkqgjbi" Yk``,ymjq m fjb{qk"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    61/119

    Ujhg msskmux qo io jbqo m qumbhk lou m fofkbq"

    UJHDBo, fmzek J n{xq aukmfka jq, e{q jqxkkfx `jdk gk aja {xka qo go`a fk"@jdk fmzek ygkb J ymx ukm` zo{bi"

    Qkmux ekijb qo yk`` {s jb Ujhd)x kzkx mx Au" Gollfmb xqmbax,iokx qo gjx xjak mba s{qx gjx gmba ob gjx xgo{`aku" Ujhd ujxkxbku|o{x`z mba xqksx mymz qoymua qgk yjbaoy yjqg gjx emhd qo Au"Gollfmb ygo xqmbax luo~kb yjqg m hofsmxxjobmqk ood ob gjx lmhk"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X YMJQJBI UOOF

    Uoxgmbaum gmbix {s qgk sgobk, oskbx m akxd aumyku qo s{`` o{q

    gku s{uxk" Luof gku s{uxk xgk qmdkx o{q m l`zku mx Suol" Ju|jbixjqx ukmajbi m fmim~jbk" Uoxgmbaum gkxjqmqkx m fofkbq e{q qgkbiokx o|ku qo Suolkxxou Ju|jbi"

    UOXGMBAUMJ aob)q {x{m``z ao qgjx, e{q xjbhk zo{xkkfka jbqkukxqka, {g, J xjbi mq qgjxh`{e ob Q{kxamz bjigqx" Jq)x djba olm aj|k, e{q qgkz)|k ioq m iukmq xo{baxzxqkf mba J n{xq `o|k qgk emba"Fmzek zo{ ho{`a xqos ez?

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, qgmq yo{`a ek iukmq" Fz yjlk)xboq f{hg lou j|k f{xjh e{q xgk aokx`jdk qo ikq o{q ol qgk go{xk obhk jbm ygj`k"

    UOXGMBAUMUkm``z? Qgkuk)x bo ho|ku" Qgkuk jxm qyo&aujbd fjbjf{f, e{q zo{ bk|kudboy ygo fjigq xgoy {s qgkuk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, qyo aujbdx" Dmukb hmb qmdk hmukol qgmq lou eoqg ol {x"

    UOXGMBAUM'`m{igjbi* Og, qgmq)x fz am{igqku)xbmfk"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    62/119

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Gollfmb x`oy`z fo|kx qoymua Ujhd, ygo jx xqj`` bkmu qgk yjbaoy`oodjbi o{q, mba kfeumhkx gjf" Ujhd qukfe`kx m jqq`k ekloukukq{ubjbi muo{ba mba ukq{ubjbi qgk kfeumhk" Mx qgkz kfeumhk,Ujhd xoex o{q `o{a jbqo Gollfmb)x xgo{`aku"

    AU" GOLLFMBJq)x odmz" Jq)x odmz"

    Au" Gollfmb go`ax Ujhd qjigq mba f{xxkx qgk gmju ob qgk emhdol gjx gkma yjqg gjx gmba"

    AU" GOLLFMB'xolq`z jbqo Ujhd)x kmu* Jq)x odmz,

    Xob"

    Qgk youa %Xob% qujiikux mb o{qe{uxq luof Ujhd" Ujhd s{xgkx Au"Gollfmb mymz |jiouo{x`z mx gk xgo{qx"

    UJHDBo- J)f boq zo{u amfbka xob" Ygmqqgk gk`` muk zo{ aojbi?

    Au" Gollfmb xgoyx bo ukxsobxk, ygjhg muo{xkx Ujhd)x mbiku k|kbfouk"

    UJHDYk``- Aob)q zo{ gm|k mbzqgjbi qo xmzlou zo{uxk`l, zo{ """ SKU\KUQ-

    Ujhd xqmuqx imqgkujbi gjx qgjbix mbwjo{x`z"

    AU" GOLLFMBUjhd, J """

    UJHD'jbqkuu{sqjbi* Qgjx jx n{xq iukmq,J)f ikqqjbi qgkumsz luof m amfbkasku|kuq"

    Ujhd u{xgkx o{q"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X YMJQJBI UOOF

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    63/119

    Uoxgmbaum jx xgoyjbi Suol" Ju|jbi sjhq{ukx ol gku lmfj`z ob gkuakxdqos"

    UOXGMBAUMQgjx jx fz am{igqku, Dmukb" Mba qgjxjx fz iumbaxob """

    Qgkz muk jbqkuu{sqka ez Ujhd xqoufjbi o{q yjqgo{q xqossjbi mqqgk ukhksqjob akxd qo hobljuf gjx bkwq mssojbqfkbq" Uoxgmbaumhm``x qo gjf mx gk kwjqx"

    UOXGMBAUMFu" Akbbjx-

    Uoxgmbaum mba Suol" Ju|jbi ood mq obk mboqgku hobl{xka lou mfofkbq" Uoxgmbaum gjqx qgk jbqkuhof e{qqob ob qgk sgobk"

    UOXGMBAUMAu" Gollfmb, jx k|kuzqgjbi odmz?

    Qgkuk jx bo mbxyku" Xgk ikqx {s, xqmuqx aoyb qgk gm`` mba e{fsxjbqo Au" Gollfmb n{xq muo{ba qgk houbku" Qgkz emhd oll luofobk mboqgku x`jigq`z" Uoxgmbaum aokx boq qo xskmd e{q ij|kxgjf m `ood qgmq ekix lou mb kws`mbmqjob"

    SUOL" JU\JBIJq)`` ek m`` ujigq, Uoxgmbaum"

    Au" Gollfmb fmjbqmjbx gjx hofsox{uk"

    AU" GOLLFMBOg, Suolkxxou Ju|jbi, qgmbd zo{ louymjqjbi" Hofk ob jb"

    UOXGMBAUMXgm`` J xhgka{`k Fu" Akbbjx lou bkwqykkd, Au" Gollfmb?

    AU" GOLLFMBZkmg, gk)`` ek gkuk"

    Au" Gollfmb mba Suol" Ju|jbi kwjq aoyb qgk gm``"

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Au" Gollfmb mba Suol" Ju|jbi mxx{fk qgkju {x{m` soxjqjobx, Au"Gollfmb ekgjba gjx akxd mba Suol" Ju|jbi jb gjx hgmju" Qgkzxjq mydymua`z lou m fofkbq"

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    64/119

    AU" GOLLFMBHmb zo{ kwh{xk fk lou m fjb{qk?

    SUOL" JU\JBI'm ejq x{usujxka* Og, zkmg, x{uk, bosuoe`kf"

    Au" Gollfmb kwjqx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB OLLJHK EMQGUOOF

    Gollfmb kbqkux mba g{uujkx qo qgk xjbd mba q{ubx qgk ymqku ob"Mx qgk ymqku so{ux, gk skkux mq gjfxk`l jb qgk fjuuou yjqg mxofkygmq qoufkbqka `ood ob gjx lmhk"

    H[Q QO>JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Suol" Ju|jbi ikq)x {s luof gjx hgmju mba iokx qo m bkmuezxjakeomua ygkuk gk xkkx m quj&lo`a sjhq{uk lumfk yjqg o|m`fmqqjbix" Obk qgk klq xjak ol qgk lumfk jx m sjhq{uk ol Gollfmb`oodjbi |kuz amssku mba hobljakbq" Jb qgk fjaa`k jx m sjhq{ukol Nkxxk" Qgk ujigq xjak jx kfsqz"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB OLLJHK EMQGUOOF

    @oodx {s qo qgk fjuuou yjqg ymqku u{bbjbi oll gjx lmhk" Gjxgmju jx f{xxka mba gk `oodx ajxqukxxka mba ajxgk|k`ka"

    AU" GOLLFMBS{`` zo{uxk`l qoikqgku, Lukaajk"

    Gk xbouqx m gjq luof m hodk e{``kq mba qmdkx m fofkbq qo ukloh{xmba ukimjb gjx hofsox{uk"

    AU" GOLLFMBAu" Gollfmb, zo{ muk m hofs`jhmqkafmb"

    Gk xqumjigqkbx gjx gmju mba qjk, s{qx gjx i`mxxkx ob, mbaukmlljufx gjx xkw{m` suoykxx yjqg m fmhgo ikxq{uk"

    AU" GOLLFMBMba }{jqk ukfmudme`k mq qgmq-

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    65/119

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" GOLLFMB)X OLLJHK

    Hmfkum ob m lmbbka&o{q xqmhd ol qumak skujoajhm`x, xk|kum` olygjhg muk luof m x{exhujsqjob ol Uk|o`{qjobmuz Xhjkbhk" Ju|jbisjhdx {s obk ol qgkf yjqg qgk gkma`jbk, %Xqkf Hk`` Ukxkmuhg Gk`amq Emz ez Lmxhjxq Jbqkulkukbhk"% Gk }{jhd`z hgkhdx qgk qme`kol hobqkbqx,ljbax qgk muqjh`k, mba ukq{ubx qo gjx hgmju qo ukmajq" Au" Gollfmb hofkx qguo{ig qgk aoou eujxd`z mba ukq{ubx qogjx hgmju" Ju|jbi `oodx {s luof gjx ukmajbi"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZo{ x{exhujek qo Uk|o`{qjobmuzXhjkbhk?

    AU" GOLLFMB

    Zkmg, xjbhk fz e{aajkx xqmuqka jq {sjb )

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    66/119

    Yk``, luof ygmq J)|k gkmua, qgkuk mukm b{feku ol skos`k mq qgmq ho``kik olzo{ux ygo yo{`a ek lmu fouk jbloufkaob qgmq qosjh, Suolkxxou"

    SUOL" JU\JBIMy, qgmq)x n{xq m e{bhg ol smumbojau{foux" Zo{ dboy qgmq, aob)q zo{?

    AU" GOLLFMBJ)f x{uk yk ho{`a emq qgmq muo{ba loum ygj`k, e{q skugmsx zo{)a ek foukhoflouqme`k jl yk ikq emhd qo qgkukmxob ygz zo{)uk gkuk?

    SUOL" JU\JBIOdmz, `kq)x"

    AU" GOLLFMB@mxq qjfk zo{ ykuk gkuk, zo{fkbqjobka m xq{akbq ol zo{ux jb ygofzo{ ukhoibj~ka m ukfmudme`k qm`kbq"Mba zo{ xmja zo{ yo{`a `jdk qo gk`sqgjx dja, fmzek b{uq{uk qgjx qm`kbqol gjx" Xo boy, J ymx h{ujo{x ygzqgjx smuqjh{`mu xq{akbq jx xojfsouqmbq qo zo{"

    Suol" Ju|jbi msskmux qo ek `jxqkbjbi jbqkbq`z e{q qgkb `oodxmxjak qo qgk Gollfmb Lmfj`z sjhq{ukx"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXo, jx qgmq zo{u xob qgkuk?

    Au" Gollfmb xkkfx juujqmqka"

    AU" GOLLFMBJ ukm`j~k jq)x fz lm{`q qgmq yk)uku{bbjbi xgouq ol qjfk, e{q ho{`a ykquz qo xqjhd qo qgk suoiumf gkuk,

    Suolkxxou?

    SUOL" JU\JBIUjigq" Yk``, fmzek J ymx ikqqjbi qgklkk`jbi qgmq qgjx dja jx boq ikqqjbiqgk suosku mqqkbqjob gk bkkax luofgjx smukbqx mq gofk, kxskhjm``z gjxlmqgku" Mba fmzek J)f qgk ob`z

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    67/119

    skuxob jb qgk you`a qgmq qgjx dja hmbq{ub qo"

    AU" GOLLFMBOdmz, ygmq)x qgk djax bmfk? Hmb yk{xk gjx bmfk?

    SUOL" JU\JBIN{g """ [g, gjx bmfk jx """ Nkuuz"

    AU" GOLLFMBIooa" Xo Nkuuz gmx ekkb mxdjbi louzo{u gk`s?

    SUOL" JU\JBIYk``, jq)x boq xo f{hg qgmq gk)x ekkbmxdjbi lou fz gk`s" Jq)x fouk qgmq

    J hmb n{xq qk`` qgmq gk)x xouqm oxqou hobl{xka"

    AU" GOLLFMBMuk zo{ x{uk jq)x mssuosujmqk lou zo{qo qmdk qgmq ukxsobxjej`jqz jbNkuuz)x `jlk?

    SUOL" JU\JBIQgmq)x m iooa }{kxqjob" Goyk|ku,aob)q yk m`` gm|k m ukxsobxjej`jqz qoo{u zo{qg?

    AU" GOLLFMBQgmq)x m ejq oeq{xk, Suol" Ju|jbi"@kq)x quz qo loh{x ob zo{uukxsobxjej`jqz qo Nkuuz gkuk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIJ mf loh{xjbi" Jq)x n{xq qgmq Jek`jk|k qgk l{q{uk ol qgjx s`mbkq jxfouk jfsouqmbq qgmb qgkxk xq{sjasuosujkqz jxx{kx"

    AU" GOLLFMBOg, J xkk ygmq zo{)uk xmzjbi" Mbaygmq jx jq kwmhq`z qgmq zo{ lkk` zo{hmb ollku Nkuuz" Muk zo{ oodjbi qoollku gjf mhmakfjh ma|jxk ou jx jqfmzek muqjxqjh ajukhqjob?

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    68/119

    SUOL" JU\JBIYk``, zkmg, gjx iumakx ho{`aakljbjqk`z {xk xofk jfsuo|kfkbq, e{qjq)x oe|jo{x qo fk qgmq gjx qu{kqm`kbqx jk jb gjx muqjxqjh mej`jqjkxmba qgmq {bqj` gk ljbax m ymz qoo|kuhofk ygmqk|ku jx x{ssukxxjbiqgmq xjak ol gjf, gjx iumakx mbak|kuzqgjbi k`xk jx iobbm x{llku"K|kb gjx lmfj`z `jlk jx iobbm xkkfgosk`kxx"

    Au" Gollfmb oodx mq Suol" Ju|jbi lou m fofkbq yjqg m xfj`k obgjx lmhk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq?

    Au" Gollfmb xfj`kx m fofkbq `obiku"

    SUOL" JU\JBIYgmq muk zo{ xfj`jbi meo{q?

    AU" GOLLFMBJ qgjbd yk)|k ioq m eukmdqguo{iggkuk"

    SUOL" JU\JBIM eukmdqguo{ig" Lou ygo, fk ouNkxxk?

    AU" GOLLFMBYmjq m fjb{qk, ygo)x Nkxxk?

    Ju|jbi)x kzkx amuq qoymua qgk sjhq{uk ob qgk xjakeomua mba qgkbemhd qo Au" Gollfmb"

    SUOL" JU\JBINkuuz, qgk dja, fz xq{akbq"

    AU" GOLLFMBSukhjxk`z fz sojbq" Skugmsx ygmqzo{ muk skuhkj|jbi qgmq Nkuuz bkkaxjx jb lmhq ygmq zo{ zo{uxk`l bkka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIXo zo{)uk iobbm q{ub jq muo{ba mba quzqo gk`s fk ekhofk mb muqjxq?

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    69/119

    AU" GOLLFMBYk` , jx qgkuk fmzek xofk louf olmuqjxqjh kwsukxxjob qgmq zo{ gm|kekkb louhka qo xkq mxjak?

    SUOL" JU\JBIMuqjxqjh kwsukxxjob" J aob)q dboy,J bk|ku ymbqka qo smjbq ou yujqksokfx" Fz yujqjbi jx jfsouqmbq qo fke{q J ho{`ab)q xmz qgmq jq)x muqjxqjhjb mbz ymz"

    AU" GOLLFMBMba goy meo{q qgkmquk ou f{xjh?

    Suol" Ju|jbi)x {sqjigq, juujqmqka kwsukxxjob }{jhd`z ajxxo`|kxjbqo m fouk hoflouqme`k, s`kmxmbq qobk mx gk uk`mwkx emhd jbqo

    gjx hgmju"

    SUOL" JU\JBI'hg{hd`jbi `jigq`z* Og, zkmg, qgkukykuk qjfkx ob xqmik yjqg qgk i{zx ygkbJ lk`q """ xo f{hg """ mq gofk, Ji{kxx"

    Ju|jbi jbhobxsjh{o{x`z yjskx m qkmu qgmq)x yk``jbi {s jb gjxkzk"

    AU" GOLLFMBXo zo{ {xka qo s`mz jb emba?

    SUOL" JU\JBIX{uk, ymz emhd jb qgk 73)x" E{q qgmqymx o|ku 5; zkmux mio"

    AU" GOLLFMBJl J ho{`ab)q io gofk lou 5; zkmux,J qgjbd J)a ek m `jqq`k eoqgkuka"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xjqx emhd mba hg{hd`kx yjqg qkmux yk``jbi {s jb

    gjx kzkx"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" XMBHGK^) XQ[AJO

    Xmbhgk~ jx `zjbi ob qgk l`oou xb{ll`jbi mb m`foxq kfsqz NmhdAmbjk`x eoqq`k yjqg oqgku kfsqz j}{ou eoqq`kx m`` muo{ba gjf"Mbbm muuj|kx mba s`mhkx xofk emix ol iuohkujkx ob m ho{bqku,

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    70/119

    iokx o|ku qo Xmbhgk~ mba ikbq`z mymdkbx gjf luof m au{bdkbx`{feku ez quzjbi qo suz qgk eoqq`k luof gjx h`{qhg"

    MBBMYgmq)x qgk xqouz, Foubjbi I`ouz, qgkyjbk ymxb)q xquobi kbo{ig xo zo{ gmaqo s{`` o{q qgk gkm|z muqj``kuz?

    XMBHGK^'iu{fe`jbi* Xg{q {s, jq)x qoo kmu`zlou qgmq hums"

    MBBMXmbhgk~, jq)x m`foxq =>33 o)h`ohd mbazo{)|k ioq `oqx ol youd qo ao"@jxqkb, J)f iobbm fmdk eukmdlmxq mbazo{ io mba ikq zo{u xgoyku"

    Mbbm ljbm``z fmbmikx qo ukfo|k qgk eoqq`k luof gjx h`{qhg mbaxkqx jq ob m qme`k mhuoxx qgk uoof" Qgkb xgk iumex qgk iuohkujkxmba iokx qo qgk djqhgkb mba xqmuqx suksmujbi qo fmdk eukmdlmxq"Xmbhgk~ xjqx {s, xhumqhgkx gjx gkma mba xq{fe`kx oll qo qmdkgjx xgoyku"

    H[Q QO>

    JBQ" @OHM@ HO@@KIK HMLK

    Suol" Ju|jbi jx ljbjxgjbi gjx fkm` ygkb Nmh}{k`jbk muuj|kx mbanojbx gjf mq gjx qme`k"

    NMH][K@JBKOg, qgmbd Ioa zo{)uk xqj`` gkuk" Qgk13; jx k|kb youxk qgmb {x{m`" J)f xoi`ma zo{ ho{`a fkkq fk ob x{hg xgouqboqjhk" Jq)`` ob`z ek xkhoba" Jn{xq bkka qo qm`d qo zo{ meo{qXmbhgk~" Boeoaz dboyx gjf ekqqkuqgmb zo{"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xskmdx yjqg gjx fo{qg l{` "

    SUOL" JU\JBI[gf, bo suoe`kf, Nmhdjk" Jx gkx`jssjbi mimjb?

    NMH][K@JBK

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    71/119

    Yk``, fmzek m `jqq`k, e{q jq)x foukn{xq qgmq gk)x |kuz `jdk`z qo,hobxjakujbi m`` qgk sukxx{uk qgmqgk)x iobbm ek {baku jb qgk bkwq lkyamzx" J fkmb, J dboy gk qujkx qo mhq`jdk k|kuzqgjbi)x hoo`, e{q zo{ mbaJ eoqg dboy gk)x ukm``z xqmu|ka louxofk fmnou ukhoibjqjob"

    SUOL" JU\JBIZkmg, J dboy, e{q gk xkkfx qo ek aojbiodmz qo fk" Yk``, oqgku qgmb qgmq`jqq`k muukxq qgjbi """

    NMH][K@JBKKwmhq`z ygmq J)f qm`djbi meo{q" Ykn{xq bkka qo dkks mb kzk ob gjf boy"

    Yk)|k ioqqm gk`s gjf" Zo{ dboy gkbkkax gk`s go`ajbi jq qoikqgku"

    SUOL" JU\JBIAob)q yk m``?

    NMH][K@JBKAob)q yk m``? Jx k|kuzqgjbi odmzyjqg zo{, @o{jx?

    SUOL" JU\JBI'xmuhmxqjhm``z* X{uk, iukmq, fzqgkumsjxq xmzx jl J dkks ob qumhd,gk)`` s{q jb m ukhoffkbamqjob lou fkqo dkks fz noe" 'f{fe`jbi* Jl J ymbqqo dkks jq"

    NMH][K@JBKBo, qgjx jx boq qgk ukm` zo{, @o{jk"Yk eoqg dboy qgmq qgmq noe jx zo{uxlou mx `obi mx zo{ ymbq jq"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

    Yk`` fmzek qgmq)x m iooa }{kxqjob,e{q kbo{ig ol qgmq, J ukm``z gm|k qoikq emhd qo h`mxx" Jx qgkuk mbzqgjbixskhjljh zo{ bkka fk qo ao lou gjf?

    NMH][K@JBK@o{jx, J)`` ek gobkxq yjqg zo{, J)|kioq m oq qjka {s jb qgjx qgjbi" Fouk

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    72/119

    qgmb m `oq, k|kuzqgjbi- Jl qgjxoskbjbi jxb)q m x{hhkxx, m ukm``z ejix{hhkxx, J aob)q dboy ygmq J)f iobbmao"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, hofk ob Nmhdjk, zo{ bo J aob)q xkkzo{ jb qgk uo`k ol amfxk` jb ajxqukxx"

    NMH][K@JBKBo, ukm``z @o{jx, J fkmb J dboy J)fboq iobbm ek ob qgk xqukkq" Sjkuukqood hmuk ol m`` qgmq" E{q J)f m``o{q ol `j}{ja mxxkqx" Mlqku qgjxxgoy, jq ho{`a ek n{xq fk mba Ljlj mbamb ohhmxjobm` obk`z ykkdkba jb 'yjqgm Lukbhg mhhkbq* Smujx" Mba zo{ dboy

    |kuz yk`` qgmq)x boq kbo{ig lou fkmbzfouk" Bk|ku ymx, ukm``z" Jl Jdbky qgmq J ymx iojbi qo n{xq x`oy`zlmak jbqo oexh{ujqz, J)a xhgka{`kmboqgku qujs qo Smujx qgjx ykkdkbamba io o{q yjqg m xymb aj|k oll qgkKjllk` Qoyku mba xs`mxg fz oybfmxqkusjkhk ol e`ooa mba i{qx m``o|ku qgk hjqz ol l{hdjbi `o|k"

    SUOL" JU\JBI

    'muqjh{`mqk`z* Nmh}{k`jbkK|mbx&Ekbojq, fz akmu" 'xgmdkx gjxgkma* N{xq ood mq {x" Eoqg lm``jbimsmuq mq qgk xkmfx, sukqkbajbiqgkuk)x mbzqgjbi yk hmb ao qo xm|kXmbhgk~" J)f x{uk k|kuzqgjbi yj``ek ljbk mba J ukm``z gm|k qo ikq emhdqo h`mxx"

    Suol" Ju|jbi xqmbax qo km|k mba Nmh}{k`jbk xjqx mba xqmuqx qoejqk gku gku qg{fe bmj`" Ju|jbi iumex qgk gmba xgk)x ejqjbimba s{``x gku {s yjqg jq qo ij|k gku m ymuf g{i" Nmh}{k`jbksukqkbax qo ukimjb gku xqukbiqg"

    NMH][K@JBKZo{)uk ujigq, J)f ljbk '}{jhd`zhouukhqjbi gkuxk`l* Qgjx jx m`` iojbiqo ek n{xq ljbk" Qgmbd zo{, @o{jk"J gjuka Mbbm qo io o|ku qgkuk qofouuoy

  • 8/8/2019 Ideal Compromise

    73/119

    mba fmdk x{uk gk ljbjxgkx qgk xkujkxFu" Qmi{hgj hoffjxxjobka"

    SUOL" JU\JBIOg, zo{ k|kb hobxsjuka yjqg Mbbm mbazo{ ymbq fk qo ek`jk|k zo{)uk boq obqos ol jq"

    NMH][K@JBKYk``, J)|k ioqqm ek x{uk J ho|ku m``fz emxkx" @jdk J xmja, qgjx ukm``zfkmbx m `oq qo fk"

    SUOL"