i-PAC12-1 Tiger·tec Silver - ISO P Generation The Rocket test results against Kennametal ......
Transcript of i-PAC12-1 Tiger·tec Silver - ISO P Generation The Rocket test results against Kennametal ......
1 © by Walter AG
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationThe Rocket
i-PAC12-1
2 © by Walter AG
Table of content
1. General Information TigerTec Silver
– Results
– Main features / Difference
2. Geometry MP5 / RP5
– Product description
– Lab tests
– Field tests
3. Sales information
– General
– Handbook
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
3 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results competitors
Coromant; 26
Walter; 24
Kennametal; 8
Seco; 5
Kyocera; 4
Mitsubishi; 4
Sumitomo; 3
Valenite; 3ZCCT; 2
Ceratizit; 1Safety; 1
CoromantWalterKennametalSecoKyoceraMitsubishiSumitomoValeniteZCCTCeratizitSafety
Total: 81 Tests13.01.2012
4 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
74; 91%
4; 5%
3; 4%
Wins / Gewonnen
Equal / Gleich
Lost / Verloren
Total: 81 Tests13.01.2012
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results competitors
5 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results against Coromant
Material:Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
Mat.100Cr6 camshaft -MF GC4215 -FP5 WPP10S 200% posC45 Bar -WF GC4215 -FP5 WPP10S 187% pos4150 MOD., 230 - 260 BHN
WORM GEAR,-WM 4215 -FP5 WPP20S 157% pos
20MnCr5 Reduction gear -PF GC4205 -FP5 WPP10S 150% pos much better chip control16MnCr5 Reverse shaft -MF 1025 -FP5 WPP10S 150% posSt24 Fly wheel -PF GC4225 -FP5 WPP20S 150% pos4150 MOD. WORM GEAR, -WM 4215 -FP5 WPP20S 133% pos18CrMo4 & 17NiCrMo7 Shaft -LC GC4215 -FP5 WPP20S 125% pos
Cor vc was 230m/min & f 0,2mm / Walter vc was 250m/min and f 0,25
12379 Profile roller -QM GC4225 -FP5 WPP10S 100% equal20NiCr6 (1.5752) Satelite helic 34 -PR 4025 -MP3 WPP20S 200% pos41Cr4 Joint housing -PF GC4215 -MP3 WPP10S 200% posC45 Wheel shaft -PM GC4225 -MP3 WPP10S 140% pos much better chip control26MnB5 Profile sleeve -PM GC4225 -MP3 WPP20S 133% pos26MnB6 Profile sleeve -PM GC4225 -MP3 WPP20S 133% pos1.57105 (35NC6) Planet Carrier -PR 4245 -MP3 WPP20S 131% posC56 Forging Wheel Hub -PF 4215 -MP3 WPP10S 131% pos good chip controlC45 forging Sideshaft -PM 4235 -MP3 WPP20S 129% pos good chip controlC45 forging Sideshaft -QM 4225 -MP3 WPP10S 129% pos good chip control42CD4 Shock absorber -PM GC4225 -MP3 WPP10S 125% posC45 Bar -PR GC4205 -MP3 WPP10S 110% posX19CrNiMo4 Roll spindle -WMX GC4225 -MP3 WPP10S 100% equal42CrMo4 Input shaft -PM GC4225 -MP5 WPP20S 113% pos Better chip control with -MP5 vs. -PMC45 Flange -PM GC4225 -RP5 WPP20S 133% pos18CrMo4 Shaft -PM GC4215 -RP5 WPP20S 125% pos18CrMo4 Shaft -PF GC4215 -RP5 WPP10S 125% pos Cor Vc 240m/min / Walter Vc270m/minC45 Flange -PM GC4225 -RP5 WPP20S 120% pos Cor insert radius 1,6mm / Walter 1,2mm
Remarks:
GC42XX are currently the oldest grades from the big carbide companies and have a weak performance.
PR / SVPR:
6 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results against Walter „old“
Material:Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
41CrS4 vergütetRm(1000N/mm2) Ventigehäuse -NF3 WPP10 -FP5 WPP10S 333% pos Shorter chips an no notchingDIN Cf56E2Rm=700-800N/mm² Bearing Ring -NF3 WPP10 -FP5 WPP10S 140% pos
Improved chip control between -NF3 vs.-FP5. More process reliability
DIN 42CrS4+QT Ball jointFP5 Prototyp WPP10 -FP5 WPP10S 138% pos Chip control and surface finish
C56E2 Flansch -NM4 WPP20 -MP3 WPP10S 250% pos Good chip control38MnV6 Hub -NM4 WPP20 -MP3 WPP10S 171% posSt24 Fly wheel -NMT WPP30 -MP3 WPP30S 171% posC56E2 Flansch -NM6 WPP10 -MP3 WPP10S 167% pos Good chip control, reliableDIN EN-GJS-400-2 Shaft rotor -NR4 WSM20 -MP3 WPP10S 140% posSAE/AISI 4320 ball joint VW -NS6 WPP10 -MP3 WPP10S 109% pos100Cr6 Ring -NMT WPP10 -MP3 WPP10S 100% pos same tool life but better chip control
31CrMoV9 Piston -NM4 WPP05 -MP3 WPP10S 67% neg110Cr6 Outer ring -NM5 WAK20 -MP5 WPP10S 180% pos much better chip controlDIN 42CrMo4 Lenkkranz -NM4 WPP20 -MP5 WPP20S 167% pos16MnCr5 Kupplung -NM4 WPP20 -MP5 WPP30S 140% pos16MnCr5 Coupling body -NM4 WPP20 -MP5 WPP30S 140% pos better chip control20MnCrS5 Drive shaft -NM4 WPP20 -MP5 WPP20S 100% equalDIN 31CrMoV9 Rm=1100N/mm² shaft -NM5 WAK20 -RP5 WPP20S 288% pos Chip control betterCF53 & 20MnCr5 Hub -NM9 WPP30 -RP5 WPP30S 200% posDIN EN-GJS-400-2 Shaft rotor -NM4(A) WSM20 -RP5 WPP20S 167% pos Process reliability, Interrupted cutDIN 16MnCr5 shaft -NM5 WAK20 -RP5 WPP20S 147% pos Chip control betterDIN Cf53 Kugelnabe -NM9 WPP30 -RP5 WPP30S 147% posGG25 Bearing shield -NM5 WAK10 -RP5 WPP10S 140% pos Process reliability, Interrupted cutGGG50 Fly wheel -NM5 WAK20 -RP5 WPP10S 133% pos16MnCr55 Cilinder -NM4 WSM30 -RP5 WPP20S 100% pos
PR / SVPR:
Remarks:
Strong improved chip control with the FP5 and MP3 Geometries. Also tool life results with WPPS are good against the old grades.
7 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results against Kennametal
Remarks:
Attack first the old steel Turning grades KC91XX, since they have a lower performance, but a lot of customers are still using them. Attack also Beyond grades – especially in the lab we saw a not always consistent performance.
PR / SVPR:
Material:Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
42CrMo4-50CrMo4 Injektorkörper -FN/FF/FP KCP05 -FP5 WPP10S 100% pos
Very good chips, tool life can be improved even more
20MnCr5 Sonnenrad -MN KC9110 -MP3 WPP10S 250% posC56E5 Flange -RN KCP10 -MP3 WPP20S 200% pos
C45 Field Test -FN KCP25 -MP3 WPP20S 91% negResult received only as detailed E-mail.
Mat.-Nr. 1.2323 PIN -MG KC935 -MP5 WPP10S 125% posC45 Flange -MN KCP25 -RP5 WPP20S 120% pos good chip controlC45 Shaft -RP KCP25 -RP5 WPP10S 110% pos Walter insert was DNMG150612
GG15Bearing shield -UN KCK15 -RP5 WPP10S 77% neg
8 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results against Seco
Remarks:
Duratomic grades are most probably the strongest competitors right now (Lab tests), but in the areas of the flank wear Walter has a huge advantage.
PR / SVPR:
Material:Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
Mat.100Cr6 Camshaft CP 4 -M5 TP3500 -NM9 WPP30S 200% pos
100Cr6 Outer ring -MF2 TP1500 -FP5 WPP10S 150% pos much better chip control
16MnCr5 Planetary gear -MF2 TP1500 -FP5 WPP10S 150% pos much better chip control
100Cr6 camshaft CPN5 -M5 TP3500 -RP5 WPP20S 120% pos
S45CRack end ball joint -M5 TP500 -MP3 WPP10S 100% pos
MP3 showed better chip control, cutting speed was increased in 17%
9 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationFeldtestergebnisse gegen Mitsubishi
Remarks:
Not only tool life also chip control we could improve in a lot of cases.
PR / SVPR:
Material:Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
DIN C45(Rm=835-950N/mm²)
Nabe No.313369002 -SA/-MP UE6110 -FP5 WPP10S 222% pos
Customer said we have a muchbetter chip control.
Mat.41CrV4 axle -?? UE6110 -FP5 WPP10S 200% pos Chip control + surface finish
SAE/AISI 4320Rm=1000N/mm²
Pinion- RS240 (Ford) -SH UE6105 -FP5 WPP10S 158% pos
Better chip control with -FP5 vs. –SH.Walter´s insert presented more regular wear than the competitor,after 95pcs against 60pcs
42CrMoS4Steering knuckle -GH UC5115 -RP5 WPP10S 182% pos
10 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationField test results against “other” competitors
Remarks:
PR / SVPR:Competitor Material:
Workpiece /component:
ReferenceGeometry
Referencegrade
GeometryWalter
GradeWalter
Difference Walter [%] Result Remarks:
Ceratizit St24 Fly wheel -TM CTC1135 -FP5 WPP20S 171% posKyocera 27Mc5 Carrier -HQ CA5525 -MP3 WPP20S 183% posKyocera 9SMnPb30 Screw 1 -HT CA5515 -MP5 WPP10S 150% pos
Kyocera 9SMnPb30 Screw 2 -HT CA5515 -MP5 WPP10S 141% pos
Kyocera 9SMnPb30 Screw 3 -HT CA5515 -MP5 WPP10S 141% pos
Safety 1.7218, Flange -7B OR2500 -MP3 WPP20S 187% posSumitomo C45 Coupling -SA&-MP UE6110 -FP5 WPP10S 278% posSumitomo C50E Hollow wheel -NMP AC830P -MP3 WPP10S 200% pos
Sumitomo 4140 Pinion -ESU AC830P -MP3 WPP20S 100% equal
good chip control, but flank wear comparable to Sumitomo
Valenite TMS 63002 Pinion gear 2 -M3 5625 -MP3 WPP20S 300% posValenite TMS 63002 Pinion gear 3 -M4 5626 -MP3 WPP20S 300% posValenite TMS 63002 Pinion gear 1 -M3 5625 -MP3 WPP20S 225% pos
ZCCTZ100.DKW10.08.02 Cutting wheel -DF YBC152 -FP5 WPP10S 600% pos
ZCCT DIN CK45 Shaft rotor -DM YBC152 -RP5 WPP10S 208% pos
11 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationAverage tool life increase
Summary:
• 63% average tool life increase which does not even consider the additional productivity increase in a lot of cases.
• Maximum tool life increase + 600%
• 91% of the tests we won
• In 33% of the tests we could improve big times the chip control
• Really good results we achieved on forged components with the MP3 and FP5 geometry in the Automotive industry.
Tiger·tec® Silver
100%
163%
Competitor
12 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationTurnover pieces 08/2011 – 01/2012
*Forecast
13 © by Walter AG
Table of content
1. General Information TigerTec Silver
– Results
– Main features / Difference
2. Geometry MP5 / RP5
– Product description
– Lab tests
– Field tests
3. Sales information
– General
– Handbook
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
14 © by Walter AG
• FP5– Dokončení– Oceli
• MP3– Střední obrábění– Oceli s dlouhou třískou
• MP5– Střední obrábění– Oceli obecně
• RP5– Hrubování– Oceli
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationComplete geometry family
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
15 © by Walter AGJuly 2011 | VM | Drobniewski | Kußmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationGeometry MP5
Univerzální, stabilní 3-bodový lamač Od přerušovaných po čisté řezy
Vyztužený utvařeč v oblasti rádiusuVylepšená kontrola lámání třísky pro malé ApZvýšení životnosti / snížení opotřebení
Otevřený utvařeč na hlavním ostříJemný řez i při velké hodnotě Ap
16 © by Walter AG
• Střední obrábění ocelí obecně– Univerzální geometrie pro velký rozsah odlišných ocelí– Největší rozsah lámání třísky ze všech vbd– Od dlouhých čistých řezů po přerušované řezy– Nejprodávanější vbd pro obrábění ocelí-první volba
• Průmysl– Obecné obrábění– Job shops– Dealeři tuto geometrii milují– ... také pro velkoseriovou výrobu
• Typické parametry– ap: 0,8 – 5,0mm– f: 0,20 – 0,60mm
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationApplication area – MP5
17 © by Walter AG
MP5
NM4
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationEvolution NM4 to MP5
Larger, more stable chip breaker elements for longer tool life and also they do net get „washed“ out.
Tighter chip groove - Radius
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
18 © by Walter AG
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationEvolution NM4 to MP5
NM4
MP5
Universal, stable three center curve design on both inserts.
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
19 © by Walter AG
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationGeometry MP5 1
2
1
2
Additional chip breaking area of the MP5 in comparison the NM4 geometry
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
20 © by Walter AGJuly 2011 | VM | Drobniewski | Kußmaul
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationGeometry RP5
Stabilní, positivní 3° fazetaHrubování s menším řezným
odporem
Otevřený, hlubší a širší utvařečNízká teplota při obráběníRedukované opotřebení v porovnání s
předchozími geometriemi
Širší fazeta ve střední části hlavního ostříPrevence proti vyštipování při obrábění kovaných
obrobků
21 © by Walter AG
• Hrubování ocelí– Hrubování s velkou hloubkou Ap a posuvu– Redukce opotřebení díky novému designu– Obrábění s přerušovanými řezy
• Rozšířená aplikační oblast:– Obrábění GGG ocelolitin jako alternativa k NM5 WAK20 se
sortou WPP10S– Vyšší povlak WPP10S přináší výhodu když bojujete s
opotřebením boku při středních hodnotách Vc
• Průmysl– Power Generation– Velkoseriová výroba, např automobilový průmysl, typicky
kované hřídele kde F ≥r/2.– Obecné obrábění
• Typické parametry:– ap: 2,5 – 9,0mm– f: 0,25 – 0,90mm
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationApplication area - RP5
22 © by Walter AG
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationGeometry RP5 1
2
1
2
Additional application area of the RP5 in comparison to the NM9 geometry
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
23 © by Walter AG
NM9 Geometrie
T = 0,068 mm T = 0,110 mm
RP5 Geometrie
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationRP5 – vyvinuto pro delší životnost
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
24 © by Walter AG
25 © by Walter AG
Optimální životnost - součásti
Sekvence pro optimalizaci:
1. Maximalizovat hloubku třísky (ap)redukce počtu řezů
2. Maximalizovat posuv (f) Snížení času kontaktu
3. Upravit řeznou rychlost (Vc)Redukce: menší opotřebeníZvýšení: Vyšší produktivita
Pravidlo palce: Redukce řezné rychlosti o 10% a zvýšení posuvu o 10% způsobí zvýšení životnosti o cca 20%
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Tep
lota
ob
ráběn
í /
op
otř
eb
en
í
ap: hloubka třísky
Zvýšení ap, f, Vc
f: posuv
Vc: řezná rychlost
26 © by Walter AG
Table of content
1. General Information TigerTec Silver
– Results
– Main features / Difference
2. Geometry MP5 / RP5
– Product description
– Lab tests
– Field tests
3. Sales information
– General
– Handbook
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
27 © by Walter AG
Available Tiger·tec® Silver inserts i-PAC12-1
FP5 MP3 MP5 RP5
Step 1: i-PAC11-2Step 2: i-PAC12-1
Step 1: i-PAC11-2Step 2: i-PAC12-1
Step 1: i-PAC12-1Step 2: i-PAC12-2
i-PAC12-1Available or will be available by 01.04.2012
NRF
i-PAC12-1
NRR
Step 1: i-PAC12-1Step 2: i-PAC12-2
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
28 © by Walter AG
Link: Comparison_Table_ISO_Turning_Version_012012.xls
Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P GenerationCompetitor information
ISO Classification Walter Valenite Coromant Sandvik
Kennametal Widia Seco
ToolsMitsubishi
CarbideSumitomo
Electric Iscar Tungaloy Kyocera Safety TaeguTec Ceratizit
P
P01 WPP01 VP1505 GC1515 KCP05 TN7005TN7105 TT1300
P05 WPP05 VP1510 GC4005GC4205
KC9105KCP10 TP0500
UE6005UE6105
AC05AAC700G T9005 CA5505
P10 WPP10WPP10S
VP5515VP5615
GC4015GC4215 KC9110
TN7010TN7110
TP1000 TP1500
UE6110 UE6010 UC6010
ACZ310*AC1000AC810P
IC9015IC9150IC8150
T9015T9115
CA5515 CR7015 OR1500 TT1300
TT1500 CTC1110
P20 WPP20WPP20S
VP5525VP5625
GC4025 GC4225
KC9125KCP25
TN7015TN7115
TP2000 TP200
TP2500UE6020 AC2000
AC820P
IC9025IC9250IC8250
T9025T9125
AH710*
CA5525 CA5025 CR9025
OR2000 OR2500 OR2550
TT3500CTC1115 CTC1125CTCP125
P30 WPP30WPP30S
VP5535VP5635
GC4035GC4235
KC850 KC8050 KCP30
TN7025TP3000TP3500 UE6035
AC3000AC830P
IC9054IC8350 T9035 CA5535 OR3500
OR3550TT7100 KT450
CTC1130 GM40
P40 WAK30KC9040KC9140KCP40
TP400 TP40 UH6400 IC9054 OR5000
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
29 © by Walter AG
Sales informationUpgrade Strategy of current inserts
Current geometry Upgrade product
NF3 / WPP FP5 / WPPS
NS6 / WPP MP3 / WPPS
NMT / WPP MP3 / WPPS
NM4 / WPP MP5 / WPPS
NM9 / WPP RP5 / WPPS
NM6 / WPP RP5, further tests are needed for a final decision
NMT / WS10 / WSM Stays in the program
Upgrade strategy:• Price list 2013 with low sales volume will be phased out• Price list 2014 additional articles
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
30 © by Walter AG
• Tiger·tec® Silver BOW Promotion– Žádná globální promotion – každá WSC
si bude dělat promotion sama– Kup 20 dostaň 30– Geometrie: FP5, MP3, MP5, RP5– Start květen– Info lokální marketink
Sales informationPromotion activities
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
31 © by Walter AG
• Tiger·tec® Silver Consumer Box– 4 Geometries– To explain it at the customer– „Show and Tell“– Distribution April 2012– Please contact your local Marketing
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Sales informationPromotion activities
32 © by Walter AG
• Tiger·tec® Silver Hand Book– Tiger·tec® Silver - ISO P Generation– Included Geometries
– FP5– MP3– MP5– RP5– NRF– NRR
– Please note the complete program is in the hand book included - WPP05S and big Inserts of the MP5/RP5 geometries from i-PAC12-2.
– Available approx. April 2012– Please contact your local Marketing
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
Sales informationPromotion activities
33 © by Walter AG
Sales information
• Sales documents– Product innovation 12-1
• Sales start– 01. Januar 2012
– RP5 Step 1
– 01. April 2012 / i-PAC12-1– MP5 Step 1– FP5 Step 2– MP3 Step 2
– 01. Oktober 2012 / i-PAC12-2– MP5 Step 2 (IC bigger 12,7mm)– RP5 Step 2 (IC bigger 12,7mm)
Remarks: Some line items are maybe available earlier – VM-Marketing informs.
• Price– See PDF price list supplement
January 2012 | VM | Kussmaul
34 © by Walter AGJanuary 2012 | VM | Kussmaul