I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing...

21
1 I. Introduction. It was recognised by Wordsworth’s major contemporaries that he, whatever objections they might have to some of his opinions and achievements, was “the greatest, most inaugurative, and most representative poet of his time1 ; and that, as Leigh Hunt put it in 1814, Wordsworth “is the head of a great new age in poetry”. 2 As early as 1800 Coleridge acclaimed Wordsworth as “a greater poet than any since Milton”. 3 Wordsworth makes the attempt to reconstruct his past self the focal point of his perhaps most important poetical work, The Prelude. Not the faithfulness of this reconstruction, but the re-enactment of the process of recollection and poetic creation are what Wordsworth wants to draw the reader’s attention to. In The Prelude, the imaginative process of becoming conscious of oneself means becoming conscious of what had previously been unconscious, which is the reason why nature and human nature play an important role in all of his poetry. This paper is intended to show that although most critics call Wordsworth’s poetry autobiographical, the term personal poetry is much more suitable. Furthermore, it is its task to depict the main constituents of the concept underlying his poetic work and the relevance of one of his main motifs, nature. It will be the aim of this paper to show the development of his deeply felt love for nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The Prelude. 1 Cf. M.H. Abrams in: Wordsworth, Jonathan et. al. (ed.), Wordsworth and the Age of English Romanticism. New Brunswick and London: Rutgers, 1987, p. VII. 2 Ibid, p. VII. 3 Ibid, p. VII.

Transcript of I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing...

Page 1: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

1

I. Introduction.

It was recognised by Wordsworth’s major contemporaries that he, whatever objections

they might have to some of his opinions and achievements, was “the greatest, most

inaugurative, and most representative poet of his time”1; and that, as Leigh Hunt put it

in 1814, Wordsworth “is the head of a great new age in poetry”.2 As early as 1800

Coleridge acclaimed Wordsworth as “a greater poet than any since Milton”.3

Wordsworth makes the attempt to reconstruct his past self the focal point of his perhaps

most important poetical work, The Prelude. Not the faithfulness of this reconstruction,

but the re-enactment of the process of recollection and poetic creation are what

Wordsworth wants to draw the reader’s attention to.

In The Prelude, the imaginative process of becoming conscious of oneself means

becoming conscious of what had previously been unconscious, which is the reason why

nature and human nature play an important role in all of his poetry.

This paper is intended to show that although most critics call Wordsworth’s poetry

autobiographical, the term personal poetry is much more suitable. Furthermore, it is its

task to depict the main constituents of the concept underlying his poetic work and the

relevance of one of his main motifs, nature.

It will be the aim of this paper to show the development of his deeply felt love for

nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The

Prelude.

1 Cf. M.H. Abrams in: Wordsworth, Jonathan et. al. (ed.), Wordsworth and the Age of English Romanticism.

New Brunswick and London: Rutgers, 1987, p. VII. 2 Ibid, p. VII.

3 Ibid, p. VII.

Page 2: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

2

II. Autobiographical vs. Personal Poetry.

The overwhelming majority of critics call Wordsworth’s poetry, especially The Prelude,

an autobiographical work, such as Standop and Mertner4 as well as Seeber

5. The latter

describes The Prelude as self-portrayal and says that the poet himself is placed in the

centre of attention as source of truth and as authentical person. Davies says in his

biography of Wordsworth:

“This vast autobiographical poem, which was later called The Prelude, is the account of

a man and his mind growing up. It is mainly about his schooldays and early manhood,

and in it he recalls in great detail and with great emotion his early experiences and

impressions.”6

But for many reasons it seems necessary to distinguish autobiographical poetry from

what may be called personal poetry and although Wordsworth himself called The

Prelude an “autobiographical poem”, it is much more a testimony to the “growth of a

poet’s mind” as its subtitle suggests.

Gillies describes The Prelude as a very special autobiographical project that is “rivalled

in complexity only by such famous fictional or nonfictional autobiographical ventures

as Rousseau’s Confessions and Reveries, Laurence Sterne’s Tristam Shandy or Marcel

Proust’s A la recherche du temps perdu.”7 In The Prelude, the narrator’s consciousness

and not the story of his life is the ultimate arena and guarantor of what is narrated.

If Wordsworth had constructed this poem as an autobiography, he would have included

factual information about himself as a historical person in the first place. There are

many hints to what he experienced in the course of his life, but by no means do they

constitute the main object of his great work of poetry. In fact, what the reader gets to

know about Wordsworth life can only be called fragmentary.

Concerning this, it is a rather striking fact that nine out of fourteen books of The

Prelude contain explicit references to either places or events that can be associated with

his biography8. Therefore, a reader might think that he only has to read these books in

4 Standop, Ewald and Edgar Mertner, Englische Literaturgeschichte. Heidelberg: Quelle & Meyer,

21971, p. 408.

5 Seeber, Hans Ulrich (ed.), Englische Literaturgeschichte. Stuttgart: J.B. Metzler,

21993, p. 228.

6 Davies,Hunter, William Wordsworth. A Biography. Guernsey: Sutton Publishing Ltd. 1997, p. 1.

7 Gillies, Stephen Thomas, Poetic Discourse and Self-enactment. Microreprod., Konstanz: Univ.1989, p.86/87.

8 See Reiner, Friederike und Erwin, Wordsworth’s Personal Poetry. Schriftenreihe der Zeitschrift Moderne

Sprachen des Verbandes der österreichischen Neuphilologen. Heft 43. Wien:TVÖ 1995, p.13.

Page 3: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

3

order to get sufficient information about the poet’s personal background, but he’ll

realise soon that this is not the case. For instance, the first 280 lines of the poem

“Childhood and School-time” (Book I) actually refer to the time between 1795 and

1798, namely his settling down at Racedown and the decision to compose The Prelude.

Only after this introduction, Wordsworth turns to his childhood and some incidents of

his school-time, which is continued in Book II. But there are passages referring to his

childhood in most of the other books as well, e.g. he tells us in Book IV (lines 104-130)

about a dog that used to be his companion when he was still a boy and Book V informs

us about his early reading. Finally, the reader must turn to Book XIV to learn that he

was taught endurance and independence in his school-days.9

The strongest argument against a purely autobiographical reading of The Prelude is the

choice of persons. If Wordsworth had intended to write this poem as a description of his

life and circumstances, one would expect him to have included lots of information about

his parents, brothers and sisters, friends and teachers, which is, indeed, not the case.

Nothing satisfactory, in this respect, is to be found in The Prelude: he doesn’t mention

his father even once in the more than 7000 lines, his mother only once in Book V (lines

256-293), his sister and muse Dorothy three times ( Book VI lines 199-203, Book XI

lines 335-357 and Book XIV lines 232-267), his wife once in Book XIV lines (266-

275) and completely ignores his French mistress, Mlle

Annette Vallon, who after all bore

him a child and although he devotes three books to his residence in France.10

By

contrast, he very often addresses his fellow-poet and personal friend Samuel Taylor

Coleridge, to whom the poem is dedicated. On the other hand, Wordsworth describes in

great detail some chance-acquaintances such as the maid of Buttermere (Book VII, lines

286-329), a mother and child he met at London (Book VIII, lines 333-399), the solitary

soldier (Book IV, lines 387-469 and the boy of Winander (Book V, lines 364-392).

As for the events related in The Prelude, neither their choice nor their treatment meets

the requirements of an autobiography. Quite a lot of the incidents he describes are not

essential to his biography, whereas much more important events in his life are totally

9 Ibid, p. 14.

10 It is noteworthy in this regard that the phenomenon of love between man and woman is practically absent from

his work. Very little information concerning the poet’s attitude towards love can be found in the Lucy-poems. It

is possible that he thought that the problem of love was too intimate and exclusively personal, so that he was

reserved about them out of discretion.

Page 4: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

4

ignored. For instance, he dwells extensively on his first year at Cambridge (Book III),

whereas he provides very little information about the years that followed.

So what functions do the autobiographical elements fulfil after all? Friederike and

Erwin Reiner suggest that Wordsworth introduced autobiographical bits into the poem

“not for their own sake but with the intention of making them a vehicle for poetic ideas as

well as in order to discuss what he thinks to have been the main stages (not of his earthly

existence, but only) of the development of his mind.”11

Wordsworth never attempted to present the whole of his personality at a certain period

of his life, but tried to describe his poetic development in the different books of The

Prelude. In order to achieve this, the chronology of the events is sacrificed to their

arrangement according to their psychological impact, which serves as an explanation for

minor information about his youth being scattered all over the poem.

What the author concentrated on in his perhaps most important poem were not personal

data but the inner development of his poetic genius. It is this emphasis on intellectual

and emotional realities that make it a highly personal work. The poet himself insists on

the distinction between outward and inner realities with emphasis on the latter and he

certainly intended The Prelude to be much more a work of personal poetry than a purely

autobiographical poem which can be seen in the following statement:

“Of genius, power,

Creation and divinity itself

Have I been speaking, for my theme has been

What passed within me. Not of outward things

Done visibly for other minds, words, signs,

Symbols or actions, but of my own heart

Have I been speaking, and my youthful mind.”

(The Prelude III, ll.170-176)

Moreover, Wordsworth himself described his poetry in the preface to The Excursion as

“the history of the Author’s mind” and not that of physical existence.

This inevitably leads to the question which function the “I” has in Wordsworth’s poetry.

It would be misleading to attribute the quality of personal poetry to all of his poems in

which the first person singular appears. Only in a limited number of these poems does

the “I” really unveil aspects of his personality, such as The Prelude, Tintern Abbey,

Resolution and Independence, and Nutting.

11

Ibid, p. 16.

Page 5: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

5

In the other poems, the pronoun might be described as aesthetical giving the poem a

certain cohesion and personal centre. This is certainly true of The Excursion, in which

the three protagonists, a wanderer, a solitary and a pastor, seem to represent different

aspects of Wordsworth’s own personality. Additionally, the aesthetic “I” is used to

heighten the poem’s “true-life appeal”:

“(...) if in The Thorn the poet represents himself as having seen the thornbush and as

having heard its mournful complaints personally, the reader will be more inclined to

believe the strange happenings related than if the legend were told in an objective and

impersonal way.”12

12

Ibid, p. 26.

Page 6: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

6

III. Wordsworth’s Conception of Poetic Creation.

Wordsworth made very detailed statements about the function and the essence of

poetry, which can mainly be found in three prose texts, namely the preface to the 1802

edition of the Lyrical Ballads13

, in An Essay, Supplementary to the Preface and in the

preface to the edition of Wordsworth’s collected poems.

a.) The Personality of the Poet and the Concept underlying Poetic Production. 14

Wordsworth states in the preface to the Lyrical Ballads of 1802 that the poet is first of

all “a man speaking to man” and he owns “nothing different in kind from men, only in

degree”. The difference between the poet and ordinary man is explained when the

former is characterised as being “endowed with more lively sensibility, more enthusiasm

and tenderness”, and as having “a greater knowledge of human nature, and a more

comprehensive soul, than are supposed to be common among mankind”. The poet’s

function is to express “the general passions and thoughts and feelings of men”.

Wordsworth is thoroughly convinced that the poet’s work is of great importance to

society and mankind in general when he says

“He is the rock of defence for human nature; an upholder and preserver, carrying

everywhere with him relationship and love...; the Poet binds together by passion and

knowledge the vast empire of human society, as it is spread over the whole earth and over

all time.”

This undoubtedly leads to the conviction that the poet has great responsibility for both

individuals and society: he must support and give strength to the individual to preserve

his personal identity and his dignity as a human being and to help these individuals to

form a stable society.

The two friends Wordsworth and Coleridge didn’t share the same opinion about poetic

activity. In Biographia Literaria, Coleridge states the differences between

Wordsworth’s plans concerning the underlying concept of the Lyrical Ballads they were

about to produce together and his own:

“The thought suggested itself (to which of us I do not recollect) that a series of poems

might be composed of two sorts. In the one, the incidents and agents were to be, in part at

13

This collection of poems by Wordsworth and Coleridge was first published in 1798. Wordsworth’s famous

“Preface” appeared in the second edition (1800) and was considerably revised for the third edition (1802). 14

All quotations in this section, unless otherwise stated, are taken from the edition of 1802, see previous

footnote.

Page 7: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

7

least, supernatural;... For the second class, subjects were to be chosen from ordinary

life;... it was agreed that my endeavours should be directed to persons and characters

supernatural, or at least romantic;... Mr. Wordsworth,..., was to propose to himself as his

object to give the charm of novelty to things of every day, and to excite a feeling

analogues to the supernatural, by awakening the mind’s attention from the lethargy of

custom and directing it to the loveliness and the wonders of the world before us; an

inexhaustible treasure, but for which, in consequence of the film of familiarity and selfish

solicitude, we have eyes yet see not, ears that hear not, and hearts that neither feel nor

understand.”15

As can be seen from this statement, Wordsworth shall add a somewhat mystic and

sublime element in every-day objects, whereas Coleridge wanted to give the fantastic an

ordinary and real appearance. But these concepts, as different as they may seem, do

indeed share their very basis: the romantic opinion that both the natural and the

supernatural are part of one whole. What these two ambitious poets wanted to

accomplish was the elevation of the natural world to a state of sublimity and to find the

“Glanz des Immerwährenden im Gegenwärtigen”16

as well as presenting the inherent

universal order within things. Thus, Wordsworth sees himself as teacher to his readers

as he says in a letter to Sir George Beaumont:

“Every great poet is a teacher. I wish either to be considered as a teacher, or as

nothing”17

,

and he furthermore says that

“The appropriate business of poetry... her appropriate employment, her privilege and her

duty, is to treat things not as they are, but as they appear; not as they exist in themselves,

but as they seem to exist to the senses, and to the passions.”18

b.) The Gifts Necessary for the Creation of Poetry.

During all his career, Wordsworth wondered if he was altogether fit to be a poet, which

can be seen in the following statement taken from The Prelude (Book I, lines 149-157):

“... I neither seem

To lack that first great gift, the vital soul,

Nor general Truths, which are themselves a sort

Of Elements and Agents, Under-powers,

15

Engell, James and W.J. Bate (ed.), Biographia Literaria or Biographical Sketches of my Literary Life and

Opinions, Princeton UP: 1983, chapter XIV, p. 6f in: Coburn, Kathleen and Bart Winer (ed.), The Collected

Works of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Princeton UP: 1971, vol. VII. 16

Reinicke, Uta, The Vital Soul. Naturerleben als kreative Weltbegegnung bei William Wordsworth. In:

Erzgräber, Willi und Paul Goetsch (ed.), Neue Studien zur Anglistik und Amerikanistik, vol. 63, Frankfurt a.M.:

Peter Lang, 1994, S.263. 17

de Selincourt, Ernest (ed.), The Letters of William and Dorothy Wordsworth, Oxford: UP, 1937, vol. 1, p. 170. 18

Essay, Supplementary to the Preface (1815), in: Hutchinson, Thomas (ed.), Wordsworth. Poetical Works. With

Introductions and Notes. Oxford, 1904, p. 743.

Page 8: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

8

Subordinate helpers of the living mind:

Nor am I naked of external things,

Forms, images, nor numerous other aids

Of less regard, though won perhaps with toil

And needful for to build a Poet’s praise.”

The “vital soul” is supposedly identical with what he calls “creative soul” or “creative

sensibilities” in other passages of the text,19

“general truths” seem to stand for facts and

ideas suitable to be the object of poetry, and the “external things” obviously stand for a

poet’s “technical tools”, such as rhythm, rhyme, imagery and so forth.

According to Wordsworth, six qualities are needed to produce poetry; qualities which

might be regarded as different faculties of the “vital soul” and which he defined in the

preface to the 1815 edition of The Prelude:20

Observation and Description:

“...i.e. the ability to observe with accuracy things as they are in themselves, and with

fidelity to describe them, unmodified by any passion or feeling existing in the mind of the

describer, whether the things depicted be actually present to the senses, or have a place

only in the memory.”

Sensibility:

“...the more exquisite it is, the wider will be the range of a poet’s perceptions; and the

more will he be incited to observe objects, both as they exist in themselves and as re-

acted upon by his own mind.”

Reflection:

“...which makes the poet acquainted with the value of actions, images, thoughts, and

feelings; and assists the sensibility in perceiving their connection with each other.”

Imagination and Fancy:

“...to modify, to create, and to associate.”

Invention:

“... by which characters are composed out of materials supplied by observation; (...) and

such incidents and situations produced are most impressive to the imagination, and most

fitted to do justice to the characters, sentiments, and passions, which the Poet undertakes

to illustrate.”

Judgement:

“...to decide how and where, and in what degree, each of these faculties ought to be

exerted.”

19

For “creative soul” see Book XII, line 207 and for “creative sensibilities” Book II, line 360. 20

See Reiner, p. 10.

Page 9: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

9

c.) The Difficulties of Poetic Creation.

Wordsworth shows in his poetry the working of creative imagination with its insight

and vision. This imagination was for him a potential gift to all human life, the task of

poetry being to retain and strengthen it. He knew well that the production of poetry is a

hard technical labour requiring many gifts that ordinary people do not have, as well as

the imagination which is potential in all. King states that the reader is not aware of the

labour but “only of the inevitability and the effortless power of the completed poem to

deal imaginatively with its theme”21

. Being an optimist, Wordsworth was quite certain

that he could fulfil the challenge of being a poet but from time to time he must admit in

his work that poetic creation is a difficult task, e.g. in The Prelude I, lines 135-139:

“The Poet, gentle creature as he is,

Hath, like the Lover, his unruly times;

His fits when he is neither sick nor well,

Though no distress be near him but his own

Unmanageable thoughts.”

It is a matter of fact that a human mind cannot produce poetry at its best at all times, and

this also includes a genius such as Wordsworth. There are many hints at his problems in

writing, e.g. he suffered from “the toil of verse” (IV, 111), which meant to him “much

pains and little progress” (IV, 112) and there where times when “imagination slept”

(III, 257). In The Prelude I, lines 257-269 he describes the life of a poet as follows:

“Baffled and plagued by a mind that every hour

Turns recreant to her task; takes heart again,

Then feels immediately some hollow thought

Hang like an interdict upon her hopes.

This is my lot; for either still I find

Some imperfection in the chosen theme,

Or see of absolute accomplishment

Much wanting, so much wanting, in myself,

That I recoil and droop, and seek repose

In listlessness from plain perplexity,

Unprofitably travelling toward the grave,

Like a false steward who hath much received

And renders nothing back.”

The choice of subject-matter is also a great difficulty. Many a project is not carried out

because it would throw too much of an “awful burden” (I, line 234) on the poet.

21

King, Alec, Wordsworth and the Artist’s Vision. An Essay in Interpretation. London: The Athlone Press, 1966,

p. 10.

Page 10: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

10

The history of his own self which Wordsworth tries to reconstruct transcends normal

states of consciousness, but it also transcends his ability to fully reconstruct it through

the double medium of memory of poetic fiction.22

d.) The Object of Poetry.

So what is in fact worthy to be an object of poetry? The most “valuable object of

writing”, Wordsworth says, is

“the great and universal passions of men, the most general and interesting of their

occupations, and the entire world of nature before me”.23

Indeed, the two most important themes of his poetry are man and nature. But by no

means did he want to limit the field of poetic work:

“The object of the Poet’s thoughts are everywhere; though the eyes and senses of man

are, it is true, his favourite guides, yet he will follow wheresoever he can find one

atmosphere of sensation in which to move his wings.”

In another passage, he introduces a further argument :

“[The] object [of poetry] is truth, not individual and local, but general, and operative; not

standing upon external testimony, but carried alive into the heart by passion.”

It is necessary to remember that Wordsworth put a poet’s work on a new basis. As

Altieri states in Enlarging the Temple, Romanticism changed the status of poetics.

“Before Wordsworth and Coleridge”, he writes, “poetics was either a descriptive or

normative procedure for dealing with practical aesthetic questions”, but they “insisted

that poetics depends on philosophy”24

.

According to what Seeber says had the findings of Newton and Descartes the effect that

the world became demystified because they interpreted it as a big “machine”. Therefore,

myths and analogies could no longer serve as sources of knowledge, and thus

Wordsworth tried to make the every-day knowledge in the hearts of ordinary people a

starting-point of his poetry. Thus, poetics as he sees it, is the “organ” of an elementary

knowledge in regard to man as feeling being25

:

“To this knowledge which all men carry about with them, and to these sympathies in

which, without any other discipline than that of our daily life, we are fitted to take delight,

the poet principally directs his attention. [...] Poetry is the first and the last of all

knowledge – it is as immortal as the heart of man.”26

22

See Gillies, p. 86. 23

Cf. footnote 14. 24

Altieri, Charles, Enlarging the Temple. London: Associated University Presses, p. 30. 25

Seeber, p. 236-267 26

Cf. Preface to Lyrical Ballads, 1800.

Page 11: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

11

And he furthermore says

“The principal object, then, proposed in these Poems was to choose incidents and

situations from common life, and to relate or describe them, throughout, as far as was

possible in a selection of language really used by men, and, at the same time, to throw

over them a certain colouring of imagination, whereby ordinary things should be

presented to the mind in an unusual aspect.”27

Wordsworth understands himself as a prophet of truth, and this self-imposed moral

imperative forbids him to produce any poetry that is of only local or temporary

relevance. In this regard, Wordsworth agrees with Aristotle that every good poem must

have a worthy purpose.

The poet himself becomes the centre as source of truth and as authentic person:

“Erkenntnis über sich selbst und andere bezieht das Ich aus dem Herzen, nicht aus der

Vernunft. [...] In der expressiven Ausdruckskunst der Romantik verschiebt sich der

Schwerpunkt des Interesses von der Machart des Werkes auf die Person des Dichters,

dessen Sprache Menschen verbinden und der sich abzeichnenden Professionalisierung

und Zersplitterung der Kultur entgegenwirken soll.”28

e.) Wordsworth’s Ideal Reader.

The process of reading is as important as the process of writing itself; even the best seed

is obsolete if there is no fertile soil it can be planted into. It will rot, fade away and soon

be forgotten as well as a poem that is not read in a way that could unfold the full impact

of the objects it describes. It can be assumed that in Wordsworth’s opinion the

interchange between text and reader justified the author’s existence. This would

furthermore explain why he constantly revised and corrected his poetical work, e.g. he

started to add and change passages of The Prelude right after its appearance in 1793.

The poem A Poet’s Epitaph, first published in 1799, is about the reception of poetry. It

is not enough if the poet carefully chooses the words in a poem but an attentive reader

with an open mind is required to give life to the poet’s speculations. A poetic text

remains static and inanimate if the reader doesn’t actively participate and those, who

don’t have a refined perceptive quality, only find the poet’s contempt. The inability to

love (“first learn to love one living thing”, l.3) and the analytic mind (“the keenness of

27

Hutchinson, Thomas (ed.), Wordsworth. Poetical Works. With Introductions and Notes. Oxford: 1904, p. 734. 28

Seeber, p. 228.

Page 12: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

12

that practised eye”, l.7) serve as examples for qualities that make it impossible for

people to fully comprehend the impact of the objects being discussed in literary activity.

In the poem he names people who will not understand his way of thinking, namely

doctors, physicians, moralists and intellectuals, whose souls ”can cling nor form, nor

feeling, great or small” (ll. 29/30) and whose views “sleep in [...] intellectual crust”

(l.34).

The ideal reader will, through his “quiet eye” (l.51) himself visualise the objects being

described in poetry through the process of reading and find “random truths” (l.50) in

“common things that round us lie” (l.49). Uta Reinicke says about the ideal reader:

“Wordsworths idealisierter Leser begegnet einem poetischen Text nicht mit der

gelangweilten Schwerfälligkeit des Gelehrten [...], der lediglich die Bequemlichkeit sucht,

[...] sondern scheint die in der Natur wirkende Harmonie im eigenen Erleben sogar noch

zu übertreffen [...]. Die vermeintliche Schwäche eines solchen Lesers, dessen poetisches

Gemüt ihn sensibel und aufnahmebereit für geheime Offenbarungen der Natur macht,

erhebt ihn zum adäquaten Leser von Wordsworths Dichtung.”29

If the reader is a “vital soul” (The Prelude I, l.161) like the poet himself, he can get a

notion of the underlying structure of the world in all its facets and gain insight into the

divine universality in which he finds comfort and reassurance.

Wordsworth’s aim is to be a poet that can be understood by even the simplest human

beings which is mirrored in the choice of persons in his poems, as well as in his use of

language, as already been hinted at in the previous chapter.

In a comment on The Thorn in the 1800 edition of his Poetical Works he says about

words and their function:

“Words, a Poet’s words more particularly, ought to be weighed in the balance of feeling

[...]. For the Reader cannot be too often reminded that Poetry is passion: it is the history

or science of feelings.”

Only if the poet manages to touch people’s hearts and make them see what he saw

himself just as if they had been in his company when he observed the natural objects

described in his poems, can the poet be a creator of “the faculties by a process of

smoothness and delight” (The Prelude I, l.330).

29

Reinicke, p. 285/286.

Page 13: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

13

IV. The Motif of Nature in Wordsworth’s Personal Poetry.

a.) The Development of Wordsworth’s Love for Nature.

Wordsworth’s love for nature can be felt in practically all his poetical work: the first

two books of The Prelude are almost totally devoted to the genesis of this love, and

shorter remarks can be found in almost every other book of this epic as well as in many

other poems.

The author distinguishes different stages of this development: already his childhood was

spent in close contact with nature which becomes obvious in the following passage from

The Prelude (I, ll.270-274), where he refers full of pride to the river Derwent in

Cumberland where he was born:

“That one, the fairest of all rivers, loved

To blend his murmurs with my nurse’s song,

And, from his alder shades and rocky falls,

And from his fords and shallows, sent a voice

That flowed along my dreams...”

An interesting facet of his experience of the outdoors in those early years of his life was

the feeling that nature was watching him and that invisible beings threatened to punish

him when he did some boyish mischief. Thus, when stealing a bird that had been caught

in a snare, he had the impression of steps pursuing him:

“I heard among the solitary hills

Low breathing coming after me, and sounds

Of undistinguishable motion, steps

Almost as silent as the turf they trod.”

(The Prelude I, ll.322-325)

As he grew older, a change of attitude towards nature took place:

“[...] the adolescent Wordsworth felt that nature was a living presence pervading

everything, and his originally rather superficial love of individual natural objects

gradually gave way to deeper feelings.”30

The poet himself describes this change as follows:

“Those incidental charms which first attached

My heart to rural objects, day by day

Grew weaker, and I hasten on to tell

How nature, intervenient till this time

And secondary, now at length was sought

For her own sake”

(The Prelude I, ll. 447-452)

30

Reiner, p.30.

Page 14: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

14

More and more, Wordsworth experienced an almost mystic communion with nature as

such, whose individual phenomena and beauties only deepened his understanding and

veneration of it. Too much company, however, made the poet long for solitude and it is

very important to note that the “I” describing the objects in his poems, such as in “I

wandered lonely as a cloud”, is alone.

Seeber writes in this respect:

“Bei Wordsworth [ist] der Augenblick des Glücks des mit sich selbst und der Natur

übereinstimmenden Ichs die Wirkung eines Naturerlebnisses in der Einsamkeit einer

gesellschaftsfernen Situation.[...] Das Gemüt des Dichters fühlt sich wie bei einer

Bekehrung bereichert. [...] Die Einsamkeit des Beschauers [ist] die Voraussetzung der

Offenheit und Empfänglichkeit des Herzens. Und schließlich: [...] In [...] poetischen

Naturtexten [beansprucht] weniger die Natur als vielmehr das Erleben des Subjekts, der

private Mensch, das ganze Interesse. Naturdichtung handelt nicht von der Natur, sondern

von der Beziehung zwischen Mensch und Natur.”31

By and by, nature began to fulfil still another function in Wordsworth’s life, that of

solacing him and of providing to him a refuge from the loud and often unpoetical world

around him. During his troubled Cambridge years, when he became fully conscious of

his vocation for poetry32

, Wordsworth’s aversion to social life and his need for solitary

enjoyment and veneration of the wonders of nature grew even more pronounced33

, but it

already showed in his school-days. Recalling how he used to go skating with his

friends, he remarks in The Prelude I, ll. 447-449:

“Not seldom from the uproar I retired

Into a silent bay, or sportively

Glanced sideway, leaving the tumultuous throng.”

Wordsworth emphasises natural laws and stresses the creative mind. Consequently, the

poets are forced outside the society to find their models for authentic experience.34

Apart from being a haven to withdraw to from human society, nature was Wordsworth’s

elixir that enabled him to overcome many personal sorrows and disappointments. Thus,

when England declared war on France and when he learned that the French had in turn

“... changed a war of self-defence

For one of conquest, losing sight of all

Which they had struggled for”

(The Prelude XI, ll.207-209),

Wordsworth was so shocked that he almost lost belief in justice and reason and suffered

from an intellectual and emotional breakdown, but, after his recovery, he undertook to

31

Seeber, p. 229. 32

Cf. The Prelude IV, ll. 333-338. 33

Cf. The Prelude III, ll. 90-111. 34

Cf. Altieri, p. 39.

Page 15: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

15

establish on new principles the grounds of hope in high human possibilities. It was, in

fact, apart from the care of his sister, the influence of nature that helped him out of this

deep inner crisis as he tells the reader in The Prelude XI, ll. 350-357:

“... Nature’s self,

By all varieties of human love

Assisted, led me back through opening day

To those sweet counsels between head and heart

Whence grew that genuine knowledge, fraught with peace,

Which, through the later sinkings of this cause,

Hath still upheld me, and upholds me now

In the catastrophe...”

The French Revolution, which he had known at first hand during two sojourns in France

in 1790 and 1791-1792, played a very important role in Wordsworth’s life. He saw the

events in France through the perspective of biblical prophecy, and in The Prelude he

records his early boundless hopes for France, his disillusion, dismay and horror.

According to Jonathan Wordsworth, the purpose of The Prelude was to re-establish for

himself and his readers hope, courage and a revised basis for civilised values in an age

of profound cultural demoralisation.35

b.) Wordsworth as a Pupil of Nature.

When at a very early age, he began to love nature more or less unconsciously, it was

above all on account of its beauty. Many years later, remembering what he experienced

at the age of ten, the poet writes:

“I held unconscious intercourse with beauty

Old as creation, drinking in a pure

Organic pleasure from the silver wreaths

Of curling mist, or from the level plain

Of waters coloured by impending clouds”

(The Prelude I, ll. 562-566)

As an adult, when he had become more conscious of his feelings, he adored nature

above all as his great teacher – “the fostering power that taught him how to read in the

book of the universe.”36

As already mentioned above, the young Wordsworth had the feeling that nature

constantly observed and might even punish him for any misdeeds. But luckily, he refers

to many more joyful events than fearful ones as the boat-stealing scene (The Prelude I,

35

Cf. Wordsworth, Jonathan et al., p. X. 36

Reiner, p.44.

Page 16: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

16

ll. 357-400, see below), e.g. in the following verses he praises nature for the reassurance

and shelter it gave him:

“[...] oh, then, the calm

And dead still water lay upon my mind

Even with a weight of pleasure, and the sky,

Never before so beautiful, sank down

Into my heart, and held me like a dream!

Thus were my sympathies enlarged, and thus

Daily the common range of visible things

Grew dear to me.”

(The Prelude II, ll.170-177)

He actually turned to nature for advice and consolation and placed all his hope in earth

and sky: “I called on both to teach me what they might” (The Prelude III, l.112).

Especially in the first three books of The Prelude, Wordsworth very often refers to

nature as his teacher, and the lessons he is grateful for are not only aesthetic but also

moral ones. In fact he ascribes to nature all his virtues, purity of heart, modesty of

tastes, confidence in others etc., as can be seen in the following passage:

“If in my youth I have been pure in heart,

If, mingling with the world, I am content

With my own modest pleasures, and have lived

With God and Nature communing, removed

From little enmities and low desires,

The gift is yours.”

(The Prelude II, ll.427-432)

c.) Wordsworth’s Animism of Nature.

Wordsworth conceived of nature as some personal power that had a favourable

influence on his life. The idea that nature, as a living cosmic power, made him suffer

intentionally for his misdeeds, is one aspect of his belief in nature’s direct and personal

interference with his life. One of the most remarkable scenes described in The Prelude

has to do with such a punishing intervention: In the famous boat-stealing scene (The

Prelude I, l.357-400), the reader is told how the poet as a young boy tried to cross a lake

with a boat he had stolen on the shore. Suddenly, a huge peak appeared right in front of

him and almost frightened him to death:

“And growing still in stature the grim shape

Towered up between me and the stars, and still,

For so it seemed, with purpose of its own

And measured motion like a living thing,

Strode after me.”

(The Prelude I, ll.381-385)

Page 17: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

17

This frightful experience had a lasting effect on him. After having brought the boat back

to where he had taken it from, all the pleasant images of nature disappeared from his

mind and were replaced by dreadful visions that haunted him even in his dreams as

described a few lines onwards:

“No familiar shapes

Remained, no pleasant images of trees,

Of sea or sky, no colours of green fields;

But huge and mighty forms, that do not live

Like living men, moved slowly through the mind

By day, and were a trouble to my dreams.”

(The Prelude I, ll.395-400)

This experience made the young poet believe that even those parts in nature which are

usually considered inanimate, had a mysterious life of their own. He speaks of

mysterious “Presences of Nature in the Sky/ And on the earth” (The Prelude I, ll. 464/

465) and of the “Souls of lonely places” (I, l. 466). He was utterly convinced that

everything in nature was animated. Life is everywhere, even in still and silent nature.

Charles Lamb, who knew Wordsworth personally, remarked in a review on The

Excursion in Quarterly Review in 1814: “In his poetry nothing in Nature is dead.

Nature is synonymous with life”37

, and Wordsworth himself says about his poetic

conception:

“To every natural form, rock, fruit, or flower,

Even the loose stones that cover the highway,

I gave a moral life: I saw them feel,

Or linked them to some feeling: the great mass

Lay bedded in a quickening soul, and all

That I beheld respired with inward meaning.

(The Prelude III, ll.127-132).

The boat-stealing scene already mentioned above is immediately followed by these

famous lines where he speaks about the “Spirit of the universe”:

“Wisdom and Spirit of the universe!

Thou Soul that art the eternity of thought,

That givest to forms and images a breath

And everlasting motion, not in vain

By day or star-light thus from my first dawn

Of childhood didst thou intertwine for me

The passions that build up our human soul.”

(The Prelude I, ll.401-407).

It is very likely that this spirit he refers to is the same as what he calls the “Soul of

Nature” in The Prelude XII, l.93. Whenever Wordsworth mentions this cosmic power,

37

Knight, William (ed.), Wordsworthiana, London: Macmillan, 1889, p.246.

Page 18: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

18

he does this with great thankfulness for the influence it had on him during all his life.

Unfortunately, he doesn’t give the reader more information about this but Friederike

and Erwin Reiner conclude that these terms might have had some religious value for the

poet.38

Thus, his fundamental religious attitude would be that of pantheism39

but even in

his most personal poetry not enough statements can be found to speculate on his

religious faith.

The poet’s fancy becomes even more whimsical when he attributes to inanimate objects

or phenomena human or animal characteristics and even character traits which makes

the reader protest against such a “travesty” as Barstow calls it.40

d.) Wordsworth’s Mystic Experience of Nature.

But what Wordsworth does believe in is this all-embodying, universal power, that

Melvin Rader calls “the organic interrelatedness of things”41

, and this concept finds a

parallel in the tradition of mystic experience.42

The experience of gaining insight into this power allows the poet to speculate on a great

being that combines all elements of nature to a harmonic whole:

“Eine annähernde Beschreibung einer solchen ahnungsvoll erspürten Gegenwart jener

unsichtbaren Macht wird allein durch eine Benennung von Naturphänomenen möglich,

die das Unnennbare [...] zu beherbergen scheinen und zugleich davon belebt wird. [...]

Eine Annäherung an das Unsagbare geschieht im Naturerleben des Menschen.

Bezeichnend ist, daß der Mensch gleichsam wie ein Naturphänomen [...] aufgefaßt wird.

Er ist als ein Teil eines Ganzen in einen unbegreiflichen Gesamtzusammenhang

eingegliedert. Zum Mittler für eine derartige Wahrnehmung wird die besondere

Gestimmtheit des Gemüts.”43

Thus, it can be said that an element of mysticism is an essential ingredient of

Wordsworth’s relationship to nature. As it was a highly personal experience of the poet,

the mystic union into which he was able to enter with the soul of nature cannot be

explained, neither in abstract nor in realistic terms. But the most impressive expression

of this kind is found in Tintern Abbey, where Wordsworth describes the “strange mood

of unearthly happiness” into which the remembrance of the banks of the Wye

transported him:

38

Reiner, p.37. 39

See http://www.ph-erfurt.de/~neumann/intro/rhetor2.html 40

See Barstow, Marjorie Latta, Wordsworth’s Theory of Poetic Diction, Oxford: UP, 1917, p. 101. 41

Rader, Melvin, Wordsworth. A Philosophical Approach, Oxford: Clarendon, 1967, p.189. 42

See entry on mysticism in the Encyclopedia Britannica. Havens, vol. 1, p.178. 43

Reinicke, p.203.

Page 19: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

19

“that blessed mood,

In which the burthen of the mystery,

In which the heavy and the weary weight

Of all his unintelligible world,

Is lightened: - that serene and blessed mood,

In which the affections gently lead us on,

Until, the breath of this corporeal frame

And even the motion of our human blood

Almost suspended, we are laid asleep

In body, and become a living soul:

While with an eye made quiet by the power

Of harmony, and the deep power of joy,

We see into the life of things.

(Tintern Abbey, ll.37-49).

This passage describes an extraordinary state of body and mind: vital bodily functions

such as breathing and blood-circulation almost come to a standstill, while feeling and

insight are heightened. The poet reaches spiritual regions that seem to be inaccessible to

ordinary people in an intention that almost leads to a loss of consciousness. Only if the

poet’s whole personality becomes a “vital soul” (The Prelude I, l.161), can he enter that

visionary state of mind which leads to a “spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings”

which then allows him, as already quoted above, to “see into the life of things”.

It becomes quite clear in the following passage, describing an incident wandering

around a lake, that the senses played almost no part in the kind of ecstasy which

overcame the poet but that it was in fact a matter of feeling and spiritual movement,

“Of that external scene which round me lay,

Little, in this abstraction, did I see;

Remembered less; but I had inward hopes

And swellings of the spirit, was rapt and soothed,

Conversed with promises, had glimmering views

How life pervades the undecaying mind.

(The Prelude IV, ll.160-165),

and some further lines about the same incident describe the phenomenon that the poet’s

mystic union with nature was accompanied by a momentary enormous increase in vital

energy that leads to infinite well-being:

“... a comfort seemed to touch

A heart that had not been disconsolate;

Strength came where weakness was not known to be,

At least not felt; and restoration came

Like an intruder knocking at the door

Of unacknowledged weariness.”

(The Prelude IV, ll.153-158)

Page 20: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

20

V. Conclusion.

What this paper has tried to show is how personal most of Wordsworth’s poetry is and

that although he himself called The Prelude an “autobiographical poem”, the term

personal poetry seems to be more suitable. The poems discussed have permitted to trace

the different stages of the development of his mind as poet; his happy childhood spent

in close contact with nature, his time at Cambridge, where he became fully conscious of

his vocation, the serious moral crisis he suffered from the failure of the French

Revolution in which he put all his hopes and finally the poets recovery due to the help

and positive influence of both his sister and muse Dorothy as well as nature itself.

All these stages of the growth and development of his poetic genius are reflected in his

literary work and most prominently in The Prelude, in which, as the author himself said:

“...the discipline

And consummation of a Poet’s mind,

In everything that stood most prominent,

Have faithfully been pictured...”

(The Prelude XIV, ll. 303-306).

It was Wordsworth’s aim as poet to seek for beauty in nature in all its shapes, and to

interpret this beauty in spiritual terms. It is fascinating for the modern reader how close

his contact to nature was and that he even went so far as to attribute human

characteristics to supposedly inanimate objects.

It has been shown that Wordsworth wanted to re-establish for himself and for his

readers hope, courage and a revised basis for a society in times of horror and dismay

when he decided to compose The Prelude. It is this intention and his picture of himself

as a teacher of mankind that makes his poetic work so appealing and interesting to

readers even in our times. We too live in such times of catastrophe and social decay,

naming the destruction of the ozone layer and pollution in general, the extinction of

animal wildlife, mass unemployment, violation of human rights in dictatorships all over

the world, the spreading of lethal epidemics like AIDS and cholera, famines in the third

world regions and the dangerous potential in the former Soviet Union as just a few

examples.

Page 21: I. Introduction. - audimax · I. Introduction. It was recognised ... nature and his changing attitude towards it with examples taken mainly from The ... Tintern Abbey, Resolution

21

VI. Bibliography.

Altieri, Charles, Enlarging the Temple, London: The Athlone Press, 1979.

Davies, Hunter, William Wordsworth. A Biography. Guernsey: Sutton Publishing Ltd.,

1997.

de Selincourt, Ernest (ed.), The Letters of William and Dorothy Wordsworth, Oxford:

UP, 1937, vol. 1.

de Selincourt, Ernest, (ed.), Wordsworth, William. The Prelude or Growth of a Poet’s

Mind, Oxford: UP, 1933, rev. 1985.

Engell, James and W.J. Bate (ed.), Biographia Literaria or Biographical Sketches of my

Literary Life and Opinions, Princeton: UP, 1983,. In: Erzgräber, Willi und Paul Goetsch

(ed.), Neue Studien zur Anglistik und Amerikanistik, vol. 63, Frankfurt a. M.: Peter

Lang, 1994.

Gillies, Stephen Thomas, Poetic Discourse and Self-enactment. A Study of

Wordsworth’s and Coleridge’s New Mode of Poetic Discourse. Microreproduktion

e.Ms., 255 Bl., Konstanz: Univ., Diss., 1989.

Hutchinson, Thomas (ed.), Wordsworth. Poetical Works. With Introduction and Notes.

A New Edition, revised by Ernest de Selincourt, Oxford: UP, 1946.

Knight, William (ed.), Wordswortiana, London: Macmillan, 1889.

Maxwell, J.C. (ed.), William Wordsworth. The Prelude. A Parallel Text. Penguin:

Harmondsworth, 1971.

Rader, Melvin, Wordsworth. A Philosophical Approach, Oxford: Clarendon, 1967.

Reiner, Friederike und Erwin, Wordsworth’s Personal Poetry. In: Schriftenreihe der

Zeitschrift Moderne Sprachen des Verbandes der österreichischen Neuphilologen. Heft

43. Wien: TVÖ 1995.

Reinicke, Uta, The Vital Soul. Naturerleben als kreative Weltbegegnung bei William

Wordsworth. In: Erzgräber, Willi und Paul Goetsch, (ed.), Neue Studien zur Anglistik

und Amerikanistik, vol. 62, Frankfurt a. M.: Peter Lang, 1994.

Seeber, Hans-Ulrich (ed.), Englische Literaturgeschichte. Stuttgart: J.B. Metzler, 21993.

Standop, Ewald and Edgar Mertner, Englische Literaturgeschichte. Heidelberg: Quelle

und Meyer, 21971.

Wordsworth, Jonathan, Michael C. Jaye and Robert Woof (ed.), Wordsworth and the

Age of English Romanticism. New Brunswick and London: Rutgers, 1987.