Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human...

23
Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar, Marimuthu Chikkaiah Naicker College, Erode, Tamil Nadu, India 5 May 2010 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/22505/ MPRA Paper No. 22505, posted 05 May 2010 13:47 UTC

Transcript of Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human...

Page 1: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Human Development Measurement: A

broader approach in India

Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar, Marimuthu

Chikkaiah Naicker College, Erode, Tamil Nadu, India

5 May 2010

Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/22505/

MPRA Paper No. 22505, posted 05 May 2010 13:47 UTC

Page 2: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

�������������� ����������� ������������������������

������

��

��������

���������� ���������������������������������������������� ������

���������� ������������������������������

����� ������ ���������

� ��

������������������������������������� ���������������� ������

���������� ������������������������������

����� ������ �������

Page 3: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

�������������� ����������� ������������������������

������

�� � !�"#$�!%�&%#'()%�%" $ &*"�+%,%- .&%$/0��'�*/�*$�& $%1�/%)&'�

)�*$�2(&#$�/%)&'0��3�*/�*'�/2%�'%" $+� $%��2 !�"#$�!%�&%#'()%�%" $ &*"�

+%,%- .&%$/� *$� 2(&#$� #'.%"/'0� �2%'%� 4(%'/* $'� 2#+� 5%%$� #'6%+� #$+�

#)7(%+�3 )�'%,%)#-�1%#)'���(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�" $"%./�#$+�*/'�*$+%8�7*,%'�

#$'!%)� 3 )� /2%'%� 4(%'/* $'�� �2*'� #*&'� / � +%.*"/� /2%� " $"%./� 3� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/�#$+�*/'�&%#'()%&%$/�%'.%"*#--1�*$�/2%��$+*#$�" $/%8/��

��3/%)� /2%� %" $+�9 )-+�9#)� %" $ &*"� 7) !/2� #$+� +%,%- .&%$/�

2#,%� ""(.*%+�#�.)%+ &*$#$/�. '*/* $�*$�/2%�' "* �%" $ &*"�#'.%"/'���(/�

/2%� %&.2#'*'� !#'� 7*,%$� / � &#/%)*#-� #$+� & $%1� #'.%"/'�� �" $ &*"�

�) !/2� &%#'()%+� &#*$-1� 51� /2%� & $%1� &%/)*"'� !2%)%#'� /2%� 2(&#$�

'.2%)%� #-& '/� $%7-%"/%+� *$� /2%� ' "* �%" $ &*"� &%#'()%&%$/�� �/� /2#/�

.%)* +� +%,%- .&%$/� '/(+*%'� #-' � 3 "('%+� /2%�&#/%)*#-� #'.%"/'� $-1�� �(/�

%" $ &*"�7) !/2�&('/�(-/*&#/%-1�5%$%3*/�2(&#$�5%*$7'���2#/�&('/�5%�/2%�

#*&� 3�7 #-� 3�#$1�6*$+� 3�' "* �%" $ &*"�+%,%- .&%$/���

�� �$" &%� 7) !/2� *'� $%"%''#)1� 5(/� $ /� '(33*"*%$/� 3 )� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/�� �/� *'� !*+%-1� #''(&%+� /2#/� /2%� 3)(*/'� 3� %" $ &*"� 7) !/2�

/)*"6-%+� + !$� #(/ &#/*"#--1� #$+� 5%$%3*/%+� /2%� . )� &#''%'�� #)* ('�

'/(+*%'� )%,%#-'� /2#/� *$")%#'%� *$� ���� .%)� "#.*/#� *$" &%� #$+� $#/* $#-�

Page 4: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� :�

*$" &%� #)%� $ /� 2#,%� &("2� *&.#"/� $� 2(&#$� -*3%�� �$")%#'%+� *$" &%�

'2 (-+� *&.) ,%� .% .-%;'� -*3%� 5(/� *$� )%#-*/1� &%)%� *$" &%� 7) !/2� 2#,%�

3#*-%+�/ �)%+("%�/2%�' "* �%" $ &*"�+%.)*,#/* $� 3�. )�.% .-%�#$+�/2%)%�

*'� $ � '(33*"*%$/� /)*"6-%+ !$� %33%"/� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� 51� %" $ &*"�

7) !/2�� � <��" ($/)1;'� +%,%- .&%$/� *'� #� " &.-%8� .) "%''� /2#/� #+,#$"%'�

2(&#$� "#.#5*-*/*%'�� +%,%- .&%$/� #$+� '/#$+#)+� 3� -*,*$7�� �2%� .) "%''�

*$, -,%'�"2#$7%'� *$�4(#$/*/#/*,%��4(#-*/#/*,%�� '/)("/()#-� #$+� *$'/*/(/* $#-��

/%&. )#-��'.#/*#-�#$+� /2%)�/1.%� 3�"2#$7%'���2%�7) !/2�*$�*$" &%�#- $7�

!*/2� +*'.#)*/*%'�'.#/*#-�� '%"/ )#-� #$+� *$/%).%)' $#-� )%.)%'%$/'� $-1� $%�

+*&%$'* $� 3� +%,%- .&%$/�� �2%� /2%)� +*&%$'* $� *$"-(+%'� %+("#/* $��

2%#-/2�� 7%$+%)� #$+� 4(#-*/1� 3� -*3%�� �2('� 3) &� /2%� ,%)#--� +%,%- .&%$/�

. *$/� 3�,*%!��*/�*'�$ /� $-1�*$" &%�7) !/2��5(/�#-' �2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�

#") ''�)%7* $'�&#//%)'=�>�#)*����:���?�� �" $ &*"� 7) !/2�� !%#-/2�

#$+�*$" &%�#)%�/2%�&%#$'@�/2%�%$+� 3�+%,%- .&%$/�&('/�5%�2(&#$�!%--�A�

5%*$7��<�(&#$�5%*$7'�#)%�/2%�)%#-�%$+� 3�#--�#"/*,*/*%'@�+%,%- .&%$/�&('/�

5%�"%$/%)%+� $�%$2#$"*$7�/2%*)�#"2*%,%&%$/'��3)%%+ &'�#$+�"#.#5*-*/*%'��

�/�*'�/2%�-*,%'�/2%�-%#+�/2#/�*'� 3�*$/)*$'*"�*&. )/#$"%��$ /�/2%�" && +*/*%'�

)� *$" &%�/2#/� /2%1�2#..%$� / �.) "%''�� �$" &%�" && +*/*%'�><5#'*"=� )�

/2%)!*'%?�#$+�!%#-/2�+ � 3�" ()'%�2#,%�*$'/)(&%$/#-�*&. )/#$"%�5(/�/2%1�

+ � $ /� " $'/*/(/%� #� +*)%"/�&%#'()%� 3� /2%� -*,*$7� '/#$+#)+� */'%-3=� >(+2*)�

�$#$+�B��&#)/1#���%$��CC�?���

Page 5: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

������������ ������!�"�������������

� �(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�*'�&("2�& )%�/2#$�/2%�)*'%� )�3#--� 3�$#/* $#-�

*$" &%���/�*'�#5 (/�")%#/*$7�#$�%$,*) $&%$/�*$�!2*"2�.% .-%�"#$�+%,%- .�

/2%*)�3(--�. /%$/*#-�#$+�-%#+�.) +("/*,%��")%#/*,%�-*,%'�*$�#"" )+�!*/2�/2%*)�

$%%+'� #$+� *$/%)%'/'�� *$"%� .% .-%� #)%� /2%� )%#-� !%#-/2� 3� /2%� $#/* $'��

+%,%- .&%$/� '2 (-+� 5%� #5 (/� %8.#$+*$7� /2%� "2 *"%'� 3� .% .-%� 2#,%� / �

-%#+�-*,%'�/2#/�/2%1�,#-(%���$+�*/�*'�/2('�#5 (/�&("2�& )%�/2#$�%" $ &*"�

7) !/2�� !2*"2� $-1� #� &%#$'� A� *3� #� ,%)1� *&. )/#$/� $%� 3� %$-#)7*$7�

.% .-%;'�"2 *"%'���

�� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� !#'� .) 3 ($+� &#*$-1� 51� �&#)/1#�

%$� #$+� �#25(5�(-��#4�� �2*'� " $"%./� 7*,%'� *&. )/#$/� 3 )� 2(&#$�

"2 *"%'��"#.#5*-*/*%'�#$+�,#-(%'���"" )+*$7�/ �/2*'�" $"%./�2(&#$�5%*$7'�

#)%�/2%�7%//*$7�"%$/)%�'/#7%�*$�/2%�.) "%''� 3�%" $ &*"�+%,%- .&%$/�#$+�

*/'�+*'/)*5(/* $�#'.%"/'��<�#/2%)�/2#$�" $"%$/)#/*$7� $-1� $�' &%�' -*/#)1�

#$+� /)#+*/* $#-� &%#'()%� 3� %" $ &*"� .) 7)%''� >'("2� #'� 7) ''� $#/* $#-�

.) +("/� .%)� 2%#+?�� D2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/;� #"" ($/*$7� *$, -,%'� #�

'1'/%&#/*"� %8#&*$#/* $� 3� #� !%#-/2� 3� *$3 )&#/* $� #5 (/� 2 !� 2(&#$�

5%*$7'� *$�%#"2�' "*%/1� -*,%�>*$"-(+*$7� /2%*)�'/#/%� 3�%+("#/* $�#$+�2%#-/2�

"#)%��#& $7� /2%)�,#)*#5-%'?���/�5)*$7'�#$�*$%'"#.#5-1�.-()#-*'/�" $"%./* $�

3� .) 7)%''� / � /2%�%8%)"*'%� 3�+%,%- .&%$/� %,#-(#/* $���(&#$� -*,%'�#)%�

5#//%)%+�#$+�+*&*$*'2%+�*$�#--�6*$+'� 3�+*33%)%$/�!#1'��#$+�/2%�3*)'/�/#'6��

Page 6: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

'%%$� *$� /2%� .%)'.%"/*,%�� *'� / � #"6$ !-%+7%� /2#/� +%.)*,#/* $'� 3� ,%)1�

+*33%)%$/� 6*$+'� 2#,%� / � 5%� #"" && +#/%+�!*/2*$� #� 7%$%)#-� ,%)#)"2*$7�

3)#&%! )6=�>�&#)/1#����%$�:���?���

�� �$" &%�" $"%./�#$#-1'%'�/2%�7) !/2�" $"%./�*$�4(#$/*/#/*,%�#'.%"/'�

!2%)%� #'� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� 7*,%'� *&. )/#$"%� / � 4(#-*/#/*,%�

#'.%"/'�� �/� "%$/%)'� /2%� .% .-%;'� !%-3#)%� *$� */'� #$#-1'*'�� �(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� 7*,%'� &("2� & )%� *&. )/#$"%� / � 2(&#$� -*,%'��

�"" )+*$7� / � /2%� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� 7) !/2� *$� *$" &%� *'�

$%"%''#)1� 5(/� /2%� #+,#$"%&%$/� *$� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� '2 (-+� 5%� /2%�

(-/*&#/%� %$+�� �%,%- .&%$/� *'� #5 (/� %$-#)7*$7� .% .-%;'� "2 *"%'� 51�

%$2#$"*$7� /2%*)� 3($"/* $*$7� #$+� "#.#5*-*/*%'�� �%,%- .&%$/� *'� 3� /2%�

.% .-%��3 )�/2%�.% .-%�#$+�51�/2%�.% .-%���2%�3*)'/�)%3%)'�/ �2(&#$�"#.*/#-�

3 )&#/* $�#$+�2(&#$�)%' ()"%�+%,%- .&%$/�/2) (72�$(/)*/* $��2%#-/2�#$+�

%+("#/* $�� �%,%- .&%$/� 3 )� /2%� .% .-%� '/)%''%'� /2#/� /2%� 5%$%3*/� 3�

%" $ &*"�7) !/2�&('/�5%�/)#$'-#/%+�*$/ �-*,%'� 3�.% .-%���%,%- .&%$/�51�

/2%�.% .-%�&%#$'�/2#/�.% .-%�&('/�5%�#5-%�/ �*$3-(%$"%�/2%�.) "%''�!2*"2�

#33%"/'� /2%*)� -*,%'���%,%- .&%$/�&('/� 5%� !$%+� #) ($+� .% .-%� #$+� $ /�

.% .-%�#) ($+�+%,%- .&%$/��

�� �2*'� " $"%./� *'� ,%)1� &("2� %&.2#'*E%+� 51� �$*/%+� #/* $'�

�%,%- .&%$/� �) 7)#&&%�� �$� */'� �CC�� )%. )/� */� '#*+� /2#/� <2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/� *'� /2%� +%,%- .&%$/� 3� /2%� .% .-%� 3 )� /2%� .% .-%� 51� /2%�

Page 7: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� F�

.% .-%�� �%,%- .&%$/� 3� /2%� .% .-%� &%#$'� *$,%'/*$7� *$� 2(&#$�

"#.#5*-*/*%'�� !2%/2%)� *$� %+("#/* $� )� 2%#-/2� )� '6*--'�� ' � /2#/� /2%1� "#$�

! )6� .) +("/*,%-1� #$+� ")%#/*,%-1�� �%,%- .&%$/� 3 )� /2%� .% .-%� &%#$'�

%$'()*$7�/2#/�/2%�%" $ &*"�7) !/2�/2%1�7%$%)#/%�*'�+*'/)*5(/%+�!*+%-1�#$+�

3#*)-1���%,%- .&%$/�51� /2%�.% .-%�>&%#$'?�7*,*$7�%,%)1 $%�#�"2#$"%� / �

.#)/*"*.#/%=�>� �������:���?���

�� �%,%- .&%$/� *'� &%#$*$73(-� *3� */� '2*3/'� .% .-%� 3) &� *--�5%*$7� / �

!%--�5%*$7�!*/2�%4(*/1���3�%" $ &*"�7) !/2�*'�$ /�%4(#--1�+*'/)*5(/%+�/2%$�

&#G )*/1� 3� /2%� .% .-%� #)%� "#(72/� 51� /2%� ,*"* ('� "*)"-%� 3� . ,%)/1��

�$")%#'*$7�/2%�#,%)#7%�.%)�"#.*/#�*$" &%�&#1�$ /�2#,%�/2%�+%'*)%+�%33%"/��

*3� */� *'� $ /� %4(#--1� )%�+*'/)*5(/%+�� �� 7) !/2� !*/2� %4(#-� +*'/)*5(/* $� *'�

&("2� $%%+%+� 3 )� ,%)� #--� +%,%- .&%$/�� �2%)%� *'� #� '2*3/� *$� /2%� 3 "('� 3�

+%,%- .&%$/� .%)'.%"/*,%� 3) &� #�&%)%� %8.#$'* $� 3� 7 +'� #$+� '%),*"%'�

#$+� /2%� " $'%4(%$/� 7) !/2� *$� .%)� "#.*/#� *$" &%� / � .-#$$*$7� 3 )�

%$2#$"%&%$/� 3�2(&#$�!%--�5%*$7���2%�$ /* $� 3�2(&#$�!%--�5%*$7�*/'%-3�

*'�& )%�5) #+-1�" $"%*,%+�/ �*$"-(+%��$ /� $-1�" $'(&./* $� 3�7 +'�#$+�

'%),*"%'� 5(/� #-' � /2%� #""%''*5*-*/1� 3� #--� '%"/* $'� 3� /2%� . .(-#/* $��

%'.%"*#--1� /2%� +%.)*,%+� #$+� /2 '%� !2 � #)%� -*,*$7� 5%- !� /2%� $ )&#/*,%�

&*$*&#-�. ,%)/1�-*$%��/ �/2%�5#'*"�$%"%''*/*%'� 3�#�.) +("/*,%�#$+�' "*#--1�

&%#$*$73(-�-*3%���

Page 8: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *'� *$+%%+� #� ,%)1� 5) #+%)� " $"%./� /2#$�� ��

#..) #"2�� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� #$#-1'%� /2%� +*'/)*5(/* $#-� #'.%"/'� 3�

%" $ &*"�7) !/2���/�.(/'�.% .-%�#/�/2%�"%$/)%� 3�+%,%- .&%$/���"" )+*$7�

/ ��&#)/1#�%$�#$+��#25(5�(-��#4��<� ��*'�#�&%#'()%� 3�/2%�#& ($/� 3�

/2%�&%#$'� 3�!%--� 5%*$7� /2#/�.% .-%�2#,%�� 5(/� */�+ %'$;/� /%--�('� /2#/� /2%�

.% .-%�*$, -,%+�#)%�'(""%%+'�*$�7%//*$7� (/� 3�/2%*)�&%#$'��/ �/2%*)�%$+'�

#$+�� ��)%3-%"/'�&#)6%/�.)*"%'� *$�& $%/#)1� /%)&'���2 '%�.)*"%'�4(*%/-1�

)%7*'/%)�/2%�.)%,#*-*$7�%" $ &*"�#$+�.()"2#'*$7�. !%)�*$�/2%�'1'/%&�5(/�

/2%1� #)%� '*-%$/� #5 (/� /2%� +*'/)*5(/* $�� "2#)#"/%)� )� 4(#-*/1� 3� %" $ &*"�

7) !/2=��������������

�������#�� ������!�"��������

� �#25(5� A� (-�� �#4�� $%� 3� /2%� #)"2*/%"/� #$+� )%3*$%)� 3� �(&#$�

�%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� '#*+� /2#/� /2%� 5#'*"� .(). '%� 3� +%,%- .&%$/� *'� / �

%$-#)7%� .% .-%;'� "2 *"%'�� �% .-%� 3/%$� ,#-(%� #"2*%,%&%$/'� /2#/� + � $ /�

'2 !�(.�#/�#--�� )�$ /�*&&%+*#/%-1�� *$�*$" &%� )�7) !/2�3*7()%'H�7)%#/%)�

#""%''� / � 6$ !-%+7%�� 5%//%)� $(/)*/* $� #$+� 2%#-/2� '%),*"%'�� & )%� '%"()%�

-*,%-*2 +'�� '%"()*/1� #7#*$'/� *$" &%� #$+� .21'*"#-� ,* -%$"%�� '#/*'31*$7�

-%*'()%�2 ()'��. -*/*"#-�#$+�"(-/()#-�3)%%+ &'�#$+�'%$'%� 3�.#)/*"*.#/* $�*$�

" &&($*/1�#"/*,*/*%'���2('�/2%� 5G%"/*,%$%''� 3�+%,%- .&%$/�*'�/ �")%#/%�

$� %$#5-*$7� %$,*) $&%$/� 3 )� .% .-%� / � %$G 1� - $7�� 2%#-/21� #$+� ")%#/*,%�

-*,%'�� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *'� / � ")%#/%� $� %$#5-*$7� %$,*) $&%$/� 3 )�

Page 9: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� I�

.% .-%� / �%$G 1� - $7��2%#-/21�#$+�")%#/*,%� -*,%'���(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/� *'�

#5 (/� .% .-%�� #5 (/� %8.#$+*$7� /2%*)� "2 *"%'� / � -%#+� -*,%'� /2%1� ,#-(%��

<�(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *'� #� .) "%''� 3� %$-#)7*$7� .% .-%;'� "2 *"%'�� �$�

.)*$"*.-%�� /2%'%�"2 *"%'�"#$�5%� *$3*$*/%�#$+�"2#$7%� ,%)� /*&%���(/�#/�#--�

-%,%-'� 3� +%,%- .&%$/�� /2%� /2)%%� %''%$/*#-� $%'� #)%� 3 )� .% .-%� / � -%#+� #�

- $7� #$+� 2%#-/21� -*3%�� / � #"4(*)%� 6$ !-%+7%� #$+� / � 2#,%� #""%''� / �

)%' ()"%'�$%%+%+�3 )�#�+%"%$/�'/#$+� 3�-*,*$7=>�� ��������CC�?���

�� �2%� )%#' $� 5%2*$+� 3 )� " $"%$/)#/*$7� $� /2%'%� /2)%%� 5#'*"�

+*&%$'* $'� 3�"#.#5*-*/*%'�*'�*3� /2%'%�#)%�#"2*%,%+�/2%$�/2%1�! (-+� .%$�

(.� .. )/($*/*%'�*$� /2%)�+*&%$'* $'� 3�2(&#$�-*,%'�,#-(%+�51�.% .-%�#$+�

/2%'%�#)%� /2%�& '/�5#'*"�"#.#5*-*/*%'�3 )�2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�#)%� / � -%#+�

- $7�#$+�2%#-/21�-*,%'��/ �5%�6$ !-%+7%��/ �2#,%�#""%''�/ �/2%�)%' ()"%'�

$%%+%+�3 )�#�+%"%$/�'/#$+#)+� 3�-*,*$7�#$+�/ �5%�#5-%�/ �.#)/*"*.#/%�*$�/2%�

-*3%� " &&($*/1� #"/*,*/*%'�� �3� /2%'%� "2 *"%'� #)%� $ /� #,#*-#5-%�� &#$1�

.. )/($*/*%'�*$�-*3%�)%&#*$�*$#""%''*5-%��

�(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� #..) #"2%'� - 6� /2%� *$" &%� #'.%"/� *$� #�

+*33%)%$/�!#1���$" &%�*'�"-%#)-1� $-1� $%� ./* $�/2#/�.% .-%�! (-+�-*6%�/ �

2#,%�� 5(/� */� *'� $ /� /2%� '(&� / /#-� 3� /2%*)� -*,%'��9%--�5%*$7� 3� #� ' "*%/1�

+%.%$+'� $� 2 !� #$+� 3 )�!2#/� .(). '%� /2%� *$" &%� *'� 5%*$7� ('%+�� �) 3��

�&#)/1#�%$�'#*+�/2#/�2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/��#'�#$�#..) #"2��*'�" $"%)$%+�

Page 10: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ��

!*/2�!2#/���/#6%�/ �5%�/2%�5#'*"�+%,%- .&%$/�*+%#@�$#&%-1��#+,#$"*$7�/2%�

)*"2$%''� 3�2(&#$�-*3%��)#/2%)�/2#$�/2%�)*"2$%''� 3�/2%�%" $ &1�*$�!2*"2�

2(&#$�5%*$7'�-*,%��!2*"2�*'� $-1�#�.#'/���

�� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� #..) #"2� " $"%)$'� #5 (/� %$2#$"*$7� 2(&#$�

"#.#5*-*/*%'� ,#-(%'�� "2 *"%'�� 3)%%+ &� #$+� .#)/*"*.#/* $� *$� +%& ")#/*"�

.) "%''���/�5)*$7'�/ 7%/2%)�/2%�.) +("/* $�#$+�+*'/)*5(/* $� 3�" && +*/*%'�

#$+� /2%�%8.#$'* $� 3�#$+�('%� 3�2(&#$�"#.#5*-*/*%'�� �/�+%$ /%'�5 /2� /2%�

.) "%''� 3�!*+%$*$7�.% .-%;'�"2 *"%'�*�%�� $�!2#/�.% .-%�'2 (-+�2#,%��5%�

#$+� + � / � 5%� #5-%� / � %$'()%� /2%*)� !$� -*,%-*2 +� #$+� /2%� -%,%-� 3� /2%*)�

#"2*%,%+�!%--�5%*$7��

��(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� " $"%./� '%%6'� %4(*/1�� $ /� $-1� *$� /%)&'� 3�

!%#-/2� )� *$" &%�� 5(/� #-' � *$� /%)&'� 3� 5#'*"� "#.#5*-*/*%'� #$+�

.. )/($*/*%'�� �) &� /2*'� .%)'.%"/*,%�� %,%)1 $%� '2 (-+� 2#,%� /2%�

.. )/($*/1� / � 5%� %+("#/%+� #$+� / � -%#+� #� - $7� #$+� 2%#-/21� -*3%���(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/�$ /� $-1�" $"%)$'�!*/2�/2%�*$")%#'%+�*$" &%�" &*$7� (/� 3�

/2%� 3)(*/'� 3� %" $ &*"� +%,%- .&%$/� 5(/� #-' � *$")%#'*$7� /2%� 7)%#/%)�

3)%%+ &� #$+� "#.#5*-*/*%'�� /2%� )#$7%� 3� "2 *"%'� #$+� .. )/($*/*%'� / �

%$2#$"%�/2%�2(&#$�!%--�5%*$7��

��"" )+*$7� / � �&#)/1#� %$� /2%� "2 *"%'� /2#/� $%� 2#'� #)%� /%)&%+�

<"#.#5*-*/*%'=�#$+�/2%�#"/(#-�-%,%-'� 3�#"2*%,%&%$/�#//#*$%+�*$�/2%�,#)* ('�

Page 11: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� C�

+*&%$'* $'�#)%�"#--%+�<3($"/* $*$7;'=���2('�2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�*'�7*,%$�

51� /2%� %$2#$"%&%$/� 3� /2%� '%/� 3� "2 *"%'� )� "#.#5*-*/*%'� 3� *$+*,*+(#-'��

!2%)%#'�3($"/* $*$7;'�#)%�#�'%/� 3�D5%*$7';�#$+�D+ *$7';�3 )�%8#&.-%��/2%�

-%,%-� 3�%+("#/* $��/2%�'/#/%� 3�2%#-/2�#$+�/2%�%8/%$/� 3�.#)/*"*.#/* $�*$�/2%�

. -*/*"#-�.) "%''��

�<�(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� 2#'� /! � '*+%'H� /2%� 3 )&#/* $� 3� 2(&#$�

"#.#5*-*/*%'�'("2�#'�*&.) ,%+�2%#-/2��6$ !-%+7%�#$+�'6*--'�A�#$+�/2%�('%�

.% .-%� &#6%� 3� /2%*)� #"4(*)%+� "#.#5*-*/*%'� A� 3 )� -%*'()%�� .) +("/*,%�

.(). '%'� )�5%*$7�#"/*,%� *$�"(-/()#-��' "*#-�#$+�. -*/*"#-�#33#*)'=>�� ���

�����CC�?��

�� ������!�"�����������$�

� �%#'()*$7�" ($/)1;'�+%,%- .&%$/�!*/2�/2%�2%-.� 3�$#/* $#-�*$" &%�

#$+�J� )�.%)�"#.*/#�*$" &%�2#'�5%%$�!*+%-1�")*/*"*'%+�#$+�/2%)%�2#'�5%%$�

.%).%/(#/%+� #//%&./� / � *+%$/*31� #$� #-/%)$#/*,%� *$+*"#/ )� !2*"2� ! (-+�

" ,%)�#--�/2%�#'.%"/'� 3�+%,%- .&%$/��<�2%)%�2#'�5%%$�#�- $7�'%#)"2�3 )�#�

& )%� " &.)%2%$'*,%�&%#'()%� 3� +%,%- .&%$/� /2#/� " (-+� "#./()%� #--�� )�

&#$1�& )%�� 3�/2%�"2 *"%'�.% .-%�&#6%�#�&%#'()%�/2#/�! (-+�'%),%�#'�#�

5%//%)�1#)+�'/*"6� 3�/2%�' "* �%" $ &*"�.) 7)%''� 3�$#/* $'=�>�#25(5�(-�

�#4�:���?��

Page 12: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

� �$*/%+� #/* $'� �%,%- .&%$/� �) 7)#&&%� *$� */'� �CC�;'� �(&#$�

�%,%- .&%$/� �%. )/� *$/) +("%+� #� $%!� *$+%8� *�%�� �(&#$� �%,%- .&%$/�

�$+%8�� �/� *'� #� +*33%)%$/� /1.%� 3� *$+*"#/ )�!2*"2� *'� +)#!$� 51�&%)7*$7� 3�

%" $ &*"�#$+�' "*#-�*$+*"#/ )'��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��$+%8�&%#'()%'�#�

" ($/)1;'� #"2*%,%&%$/'� *$� /2)%%� #'.%"/'� 3� +%,%- .&%$/�� /2%1� #)%��

- $7%,*/1�*'�&%#'()%+�51�-*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�#/�5*)/2��6$ !-%+7%�*'�&%#'()%+�

51� #� " &5*$#/* $� 3� /2%� #+(-/� -*/%)#"1� )#/%� #$+� /2%� " &5*$%+� 7) ''�

.)*&#)1��'%" $+#)1�#$+�/%)/*#)1�%$) -&%$/�)#/* ��#$+�'/#$+#)+� 3�-*,*$7�*'�

&%#'()%+� 51� ���� .%)� "#.*/#� >���� �� K?�� <�2%� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/�

*$+%8� >���?� *'� #� " &. '*/%� *$+*"#/ )�� �/� " ,%)'� /2)%%� +*&%$'* $'� 3�

2(&#$�!%-3#)%H�*$" &%��%+("#/* $�#$+�2%#-/2���/'�.(). '%�*'�$ /�/ �7*,%�#�

" &.-%/%� .*"/()%� 3� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� 5(/� / � .) ,*+%� #� &%#'()%� /2#/�

7 %'�5%1 $+�*$" &%���2%�����*'�#�.#)#&%/%)�3 )�"2#$7%'�*$�2(&#$�!%--�

A� 5%*$7� #$+� 3 )� " &5*$*$7� .) 7)%''� *$� +*33%)%$/� )%7* $'=� >� �������

:��F?��

� � ��/� *'� $ /� $-1� 3 "('%+� *$" &%� #'.%"/� 5(/� #-' � ' "*#-� #'.%"/'�� �/� *'�

5) #+%$�/2%�#''%''&%$/� 3�+%,%- .&%$/���(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��$+%8�*'�#�

&%#'()%� 3�#,%)#7%�#"2*%,%&%$/�*$�5#'*"�2(&#$�"#.#5*-*/*%'���/�" &5*$%'�

/2)%%� %-%&%$/'� ,*E�� #""%''� / � *$" &%� #$+� #''%/'� $%%+%+� 3 )� #� +%"%$/�

'/#$+#)+� 3� -*,*$7�� 6$ !-%+7%� #"4(*'*/* $�� #$+�%$G 1&%$/� 3� #� - $7� #$+�

2%#-/21�-*3%��<�2%��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��$+%8�>���?��*$/) +("%+�*$��CC��

Page 13: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

51��#25(5� (-� �#4� #$+� " --%#7(%'�� )%3-%"/'� #"2*%,%&%$/'� *$� D/2%� & '/�

5#'*"� 2(&#$� "#.#5*-*/*%'� -%#+*$7� #� - $7� -*3%�� 5%*$7� 6$ !-%+7%�� #$+�

%$G 1*$7� #� +%"%$/� '/#$+#)+� 3� -*,*$7;� /2#/� "#$� 5%� )%.)%'%$/%+� #'� 2%#-/2��

%+("#/* $�� #$+� *$" &%�� !2*"2� #)%� *$+%%+� /2%� /2)%%� .*--#)'� 3� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/=� >9��� :��:?�� �(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8� &%#'()%'� /2%�

-#"6� 3�2(&#$�"#.#5*-*/*%'���#.#5*-*/*%'��51�+%3*$*/* $��"#$$ /�5%�+*)%"/-1�

&%#'()%+�� 5(/� /2%� 3($"/* $*$7� "#$� 5%� &%#'()%+�� 3 )� %8#&.-%�� /2%�

#"2*%,%&%$/'�*$�%#"2�+*&%$'* $�5 /2�#/�/2%�*$+*,*+(#-�>2 ('%2 -+?�#$+�#/�

/2%�$#/* $#-�-%,%-���2%'%�#"2*%,%&%$/'�#)%�7%$%)#--1�*+%$/*3*%+�51�.) .%)�

*$+*"#/ )'�)%3-%"/*$7� /2%�.%)3 )&#$"%� *$� /2%�#'' "*#/%+�+*&%$'* $���2%)%�

" (-+�%*/2%)�5%� $%�*$+*"#/ )�� )�#'�*'�& )%� 3/%$�/2%�"#'%��#�!2 -%�)#$7%�

3�*$+*"#/ )'�#,#*-#5-%�3 )�%#"2�"#.#5*-*/1�+*&%$'* $���$� /2%)�! )+'�� $%�

$ )&#--1� 2#'� #� ,%"/ )� 3� 3($"/* $*$7;'� )#/2%)� /2#$� #� '"#-#)� *$+*"#/ )�

" ))%'. $+*$7�/ �%#"2�+ &#*$��

���� ���#� � ���� ��!�"������� ����$%� ���&��

���'�����

� �2%)%�*'�#$�#''(&./* $�/2#/�/2%�*$" &%� 3�#�' "*%/1�)%3-%"/'�#--�*/'�

/2%)�#"2*%,%&%$/'���(/�*$�)%#-*/1��/2%)%�*'�$ �#(/ &#/*"�/)#$'-#/* $� 3�/2%�

*$" &%� 3�#�' "*%/1�*$/ �/2%�.% .-%;'�!%-3#)%���2#/�*'�/2%�.)*&#)1�)%#' $�

3 )�*$%4(#-*/1�#& $7�.% .-%���%$"%��/2%)%�*'�#�$%%+�3 )�+*33%)%$/�*$+*"#/ )�

!2*"2�" (-+�" ,%)�5 /2�' "*#-�#$+�%" $ &*"#-�#'.%"/'� 3�.% .-%���(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8� *'� 5#'%+� $� ' "*#-� #$+� %" $ &*"� #'.%"/'�� �2%�

Page 14: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� �:�

" $,%$/* $#-�&%#'()%� 3�!%--�5%*$7� '("2� #'����� )� .%)� "#.*/#� *$" &%�

#$+�%,%$�/2%*)�+*'/)*5(/* $#--1�'%$'*/*,%�,#)*#$/'�#)%�*$2%)%$/-1�-*&*/%+�*$�

"#./()*$7�/2%'%�($+%)�#'.%"/'� 3�!%--�5%*$7�#$+�/2%�" $/*$7%$/�.) "%''� 3�

+%,%- .&%$/�� �2%� ���� )� *$" &%�� *$� 7%$%)#-�� *'� #� &%#$'� .%)2#.'� /2%�

& '/� .)%+ &*$#$/� $%� *$� 5/#*$*$7� ,#-(%+� (/" &%� *$� /2%� " ()'%� 3�

+%,%- .&%$/���$� /2%� /2%)�2#$+�� /2%�2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/� *$+*"#/ )'�#)%�

& '/�#..) .)*#/%�*$�"#./()*$7�+%'*)#5-%�D (/" &%';�3 )�!2*"2�/2%�D&%#$';�

#)%�(-/*&#/%-1�%$7#7%+�*$�/2%�.) "%''� 3�+%,%- .&%$/��

�� �(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/�*$+%8�*'�5#'%+� $�/2)%%�*$+*"#/ )'H�- $7%,*/1��

#'� &%#'()%+� 51� -*3%� %8.%"/#$"1� #/� 5*)/2�� %+("#/* $� #//#*$&%$/�� #'�

&%#'()%+� 51� #� " &5*$#/* $� 3� #+(-/� -*/%)#"1� >/! �/2*)+� !%*72/?� #$+�

" &5*$%+� .)*&#)1�� '%" $+#)1� #$+� /%)/*#)1� %$) -&%$/� )#/* '� > $%�/2*)+�

!%*72/?�#$+�'/#$+#)+� 3�-*,*$7��#'�&%#'()%+�51�)%#-�����.%)�"#.*/#�>����

K?��

� � )� /2%� " $'/)("/* $� 3� /2%� *$+%8�� 3*8%+�&*$*&(&� #$+�&#8*&(&�

,#-(%'�2#,%�5%%$�%'/#5-*'2%+�3 )�%#"2� 3�/2%'%�*$+*"#/ )'H�

�� �����*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�#/�5*)/2� � H� :F�1%#)'�#$+��F�1%#)'�

� :����+(-/�-*/%)#"1� � � � H� �L�#$+����L�

� ����� &5*$%+�7) ''�%$) -&%$/�)#/* � H� �L�#$+����L�

� �����%#-�����.%)�"#.*/#�>����K?�� H� K����#$+�K�������

� �

Page 15: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

� �%)3 )&#$"%�*$�%#"2�+*&%$'* $�*'�%8.)%''%+�#'�#�,#-(%�5%/!%%$���

#$+���51�#..-1*$7�3 -- !*$7�7%$%)#-�3 )&(-#H�

�*&%$'* $�*$+%8H���� ����������#"/(#-�,#-(%�A�&*$*&(&�,#-(%�

&#8*&(&�,#-(%�A�&*$*&(&�,#-(%�

� �2%� ���� *'� #� '*&.-%� #,%)#7%� 3� /2%� -*3%� %8.%"/#$"1� *$+%8��

%+("#/* $#-� #//#*$&%$/� *$+%8� #$+� #+G('/%+� )%#-�����.%)� "#.*/#� >����K?�

*$+%8��#$+�' �*/�*'�+%)*,%+�51�+*,*+*$7�/2%�'(&� 3�/2%�/2)%%�*$+*"%'�51����

����� M��J�� >-*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�*$+%8?�N��J��>%+("#/* $�*$+%8?�

N��J��>����*$+%8?���

���������������� �2%$� /2%� " ($/)*%'� #)%� )#$6%+� #"" )+*$7� / � /2%*)� ���� ,#-(%���

� ($/)*%'�!*/2�������#$+�#5 ,%�����,#-(%�#)%� " $'*+%)%+� #'�2*72�����

" ($/)*%'�� " ($/)*%'� 2#,*$7� ���� ,#-(%� 5%/!%%$� ��F�����ICC� #)%�

" $'*+%)%+�#'�&%+*(&�����" ($/)*%'�#$+�" ($/)*%'�2#,*$7�5%- !���F���

����,#-(%�#)%�" $'*+%)%+�#'�- !�����" ($/)*%'��

� ������!�"����������'��������������

� �$� :����� /2%� �-#$$*$7� � &&*''* $� 3� �$+*#� )%-%#'%+� */'� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/�)%. )/� *�%��� #/* $#-��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�> ���?���

�/� +%,%- .%+� */'� !$� /#/%�!*'%� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8�� � �$+*#;'�

2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8� *'� '-*72/-1� +*33%)%$/� 3) &� � ��;'� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8�� � �$+*#� *$"-(+%+�3%!�& )%�,#)*#5-%'� / �#))*,%�2(&#$�

Page 16: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

+%,%- .&%$/� *$+%8�� � �*6%� � ���� �$+*#� #-' � #''%''%+� /2%� '#&%� /2)%%�

+*&%$'* $'� 3�2(&#$�+%,%- .&%$/��/2%1�#)%��- $7%,*/1��/2%�#5*-*/1�/ �-*,%�

- $7� #$+� 2%#-/21� -*3%�� %+("#/* $�� /2%� #5*-*/1� / � )%#+�� !)*/%� #$+� #"4(*)%�

6$ !-%+7%� #$+� " &&#$+� ,%)� )%' ()"%'�/2%� #5*-*/1� / � %$G 1� #� +%"%$/�

'/#$+#)+� 3�-*,*$7�#$+�2#,%�#�' "*#--1�&%#$*$73(-�-*3%�5(/�/ �&%#'()%�/2%�

2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� */� - 6� 3%!� & )%� *$+*"%'� 3 )� #''%''&%$/�� � 92*-%�

"2 '*$7�/2%�*$+*"#/ )'��� ���" $'*+%)� $-1�-*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�#/�5*)/2�3 )�

/2%�&%#'()%&%$/� 3�- $7%,*/1��!2%)%#'���$+*#�2#'�"2 '%$�-*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�

#/�5*)/2�#/�#7%� $%�#$+�/2%�)%"*.) "#-� 3�/2%�*$3#$/�& )/#-*/1�)#/%�#$+����F�

!%*72/#7%�2#'�7*,%$�3 )�/2%� -*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�#/�5*)/2�#/�#7%� $%�#$+����F�

!%*72/#7%�2#'�7*,%$�3 )�/2%�)%"*.) "#-� 3�/2%�*$3#$/�& )/#-*/1�)#/%��

� � )�/2%�"#-"(-#/* $� 3�%+("#/* $�*$+%8�>6$ !-%+7%?�� ���*'�5%*$7�

('%+� #+(-/� -*/%)#"1� )#/%� > $%�/2*)+� !%*72/#7%?� #$+� #+G('/%+� *$/%$'*/1� 3�

3 )&#-�%+("#/* $�>���F�!%*72/#7%?���(/��$+*#�2#'�(/*-*E%+�-*/%)#"1�)#/%�3 )�

/2%�#7%�7) (.�I�1%#)'�>���F�!%*72/#7%?�#$+�#+G('/%+� *$/%$'*/1� 3� 3 )&#-�

%+("#/* $�>���F?�!%*72/#7%��

� �2%�'/#$+#)+� 3�-*,*$7�*'�&%#'()%+�51�)%#-�����.%)�"#.*/#�>������

K?� 51� /2%� � ���� �$+*#�� $� /2%� /2%)� 2#$+�� 2#'� ('%+� *$3-#/* $� #$+�

*$%4(#-*/1� #+G('/%+� .%)� "#.*/#� " $'(&./* $� %8.%$+*/()%� 3 )� /2%�

Page 17: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� �F�

&%#'()%&%$/� 3�%" $ &*"�#//#*$&%$/���1�/2%�*$"-('* $� 3�/2%'%�'%$'*/*,%�

*$+*"#/ )'���$+*#�2#'�5) #+%$%+�/2%�����&%#'()%&%$/��

� �"" )+*$7� / � � ��� ���� &%#'()%&%$/�� �$+*#;'� ���� ,#-(%� !#'�

����C� *$��CC�� #$+���FC�� *$� :���� 5(/� #"" )+*$7� / � /2%� #/* $#-��(&#$�

�%,%- .&%$/��%. )/� 3� �-#$$*$7�� &&*''* $�� �$+*#�� /2%����� ,#-(%� 3�

�$+*#�!#'� ������ *$� �CC�� #$+� ���I:� *$� :����� �/� '%%&'� /2#/� #"" )+*$7� / �

�$+*#;'� ���� "#-"(-#/* $� &%/2 +�� �$+*#� *'� ,%)1� &("2� -#77%+� *$� ���� *$�

:���� /2#$� /2%� � ��;'� "#-"(-#/* $�� 5(/� /2*'� *'� &#*$-1� 5%"#('%� 3� /2%�

*$"-('* $� 3�& )%�'%$'*/*,%�*$+*"#/ )'�-*6%�*$3#$/�& )/#-*/1�#$+�*$%4(#-*/1�

#+G('/%+�.%)�"#.*/#�" $'(&./* $�%8.%$+*/()%��

������&(�������'� "����������

����G��M���J��8�∑�

��

�>8*?�

G�*'�/2%�" $"%)$�/#/%�/#6%$�3 )�/2%�#''%''&%$/�

*�)%3%)�/ �/2)%%�*$+*"#/ )'����2%1�#)%�- $7%,*/1��%+("#/* $#-�#$+�%" $ &*"�

#//#*$&%$/��

?>

?>�:

��

���

���

���

−= �

!2%)%���8*G�)%3%)'�/ �#//#*$&%$/� 3�/2%�'/#/%� $�/2%�*�/2�*$+*"#/ )��

8�*�*'�/2%�&*$*&(&�'"#-*$7�$ )&'�#$+��

8:*�*'�/2%�&#8*&(&�'"#-*$7�$ )&'�

Page 18: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

8��*'�*$3-#/* $�#$+�*$%4(#-*/1�#+G('/%+�.%)�"#.*/#�" $'(&./* $�%8.%$+*/()%��

8:��*'�>%��8����F?�N�>%:�8����F?��

!2%)%���

� %��*'�-*/%)#"1�)#/%�3 )�/2%�#7%�7) (.�I�1%#)'�

� #$+�%:�*'�#+G('/%+�*$/%$'*/1� 3�3 )&#-�%+("#/* $��

8��M�>2��8����F?�N�>2:�8����F?�

!2%)%���

� 2��*'�-*3%�%8.%"/#$"1�#/�#7%� $%�#$+��

� 2:�*'�/2%�)%"*.) "#-� 3�/2%�*$3#$/�& )#-*/1�)#/%��

�� �2%� '"#-*$7� $ )&'� ('%+� 3 )� /2%� #''%''&%$/� #)%�� 3 )� .%)� "#.*/#�

" $'(&./* $�%8.%$+*/()%�.%)�& $/2��/2%�&*$*&(&�$ )&'��'��F�#$+�/2%�

&#8*&(&�!#'��'��:F�3 )�-*/%)#"1�)#/%�IN�1%#)'��/2%�&*$*&(&�$ )&'�!#'�

��#$+�/2%�&#8*&(&�!#'������3 )�#+G('/%+�*$/%$'*/1�3 )�3 )&#-�%+("#/* $��

/2%�&*$*&(&�$ )&'�!#'���#$+�/2%�&#8*&(&�!#'�I��3 )�-*3%�%8.%"/#$"%�#/�

#7%� $%�� /2%� &*$*&(&� $ )&'� !#'� F�� 1%#)'� #$+� /2%� &#8*&(&� !#'� ���

1%#)'�#$+�3 )�*$3#$/�& )#-*/1�)#/%� $-1�&*$*&(&�$ )&'�!#'�('%+�*�%��:��

.%)���������

� �#'%+� $� /2*'�����3 )&(-#���(&#$��%,%- .&%$/� �$+%8�2#'�5%%$�

%'/*&#/%+� 3 )� /2%� /#/%'� #$+��$* $� �%))*/ )*%'� 3 )� /2%� .%)* +'� 3� �C����

�CC��#$+�:�����

Page 19: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� �I�

�#5-%� H���

���� 3��$+*#�3 )��C�����CC��#$+�:����3 )��#G )�/#/%'��

-� �� /#/%'� �C��� �CC�� :����

�� �������#-(%�

�����#$6�

�����#-(%�

�����#$6�

�����#-(%�

�����#$6�

�� �%)#-#� ��F��� �� ��FC�� �� ������ ��

:� �($G#5�� ������ :� ���IF� :� ��F�I� :�

�� �#&*-� #+(� ������ I� ������ �� ��F��� ��

�� �#2#)#'/)#� ������ �� ���F:� �� ��F:�� ��

F� �#)1#$#� ����� F� ������ F� ��F�C� F�

�� �(G)#/� ����� �� ������ �� ���IC� ��

I� �#)$#/#6#� ������ �� ����:� I� ���I�� I�

�� 9%'/��%$7#-�� ����F� �� ������ �� ���I:� ��

C� �#G#'/2#$� ��:F�� �:� ����I� ��� ���:�� C�

��� �$+2)#��)#+%'2� ��:C�� C� ���II� C� ������ ���

��� �)*''#� ��:�I� ��� ����F� �:� ������ ���

�:� �#+21#��)#+%'2� ��:�F� ��� ���:�� ��� ���C�� �:�

��� �//#)��)#+%'2� ��:FF� ��� ������ ��� ������ ���

��� �''#&�� ��:I:� ��� ������ ��� ������ ���

�F� �*2#)�� ��:�I� �F� ������ �F� ����I� �F�

�� � ���� ����:� �� ������ �� ���I:� ��

()"%H� ����:������ ,/� 3��$+*#����

� �) &�/2%�/#5-%�*/� *'�"-%#)�/2#/��%)#-#�!#'�/2%�$(&5%)� $%�/#/%�*$�

2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/� *$� �C��>��F��?�� �CC�>��FC�?� #$+� :���>�����?��

�($G#5� 3 -- !%+� /2#/�!*/2�:$+� . '*/* $� *$��C��>�����?�� �CC�>���IF?� #$+�

:���>��F�I?���#&*-� #+(�!#'�#/�I/2�. '*/* $�*$��C��>�����?�5(/�*&.) ,%+�

*/'�. '*/* $�/ ��)+�*$��CC�>�����?�#$+�:���>��F��?���#2#)#'/)#�!#'�#/�/2%�

�)+� .-#"%� *$� �C��>�����?� 5(/� '-*..%+� / � �/2� .-#"%� *$� �CC�>���F:?� #$+�

:���>��F:�?���#)1#$#�!#'� #/� F/2� .-#"%� *$��C��>�����?�� �CC�>�����?� #$+�

:���>��F�C?�#-' ��

Page 20: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� ���

� �*2#)�!#'�#/��F/2�.-#"%�!*/2�,%)1�- !�����,#-(%���/� ""(.*%+�/2#/�

. '*/* $� *$� #--� /2%� 1%#)'� *$� �C��>��:�I?�� �CC�>�����?� #$+� :���>����I?��

�''#&�!#'� #/� ��/2� .-#"%� *$� �C��>��:I:?�� �CC�>�����?� #$+� /2%$� '-*..%+�

/ !#)+'� ��/2� .-#"%� *$� :���>�����?�� /2*'� *'� ,%)1� . )� .%)3 )&#$"%���//#)�

�)#+%'2� !#'� ""(.*%+� ��/2� .-#"%� *$� �C��>��:FF?�� �CC�>�����?� #$+�

:���>�����?�� �#+21#� �)#+%'2� !#'� #/� �:/2� . '*/* $� *$� :���>���C�?� 5(/�

" &.#)*$7� !*/2� �C��>��:�F?� #$+� �CC�� >���:�?� */� !#'� #$� *&.) ,%&%$/�

5%"#('%� */� !#'� #/� ��/2� .-#"%� *$� �CC�� #$+� ��/2� *$� :����� �)*''#� !#'�

'"*--#/*$7� 5%/!%%$� ��/2� #$+� �:/2� . '*/* $� *$� �C��>��:�I?�� �CC�>����F?�

#$+�:���>�����?��

� �(G)#/�� �#)$#/#6#�� 9%'/� �%$7#-�� �#G#'/2#$� #$+� �$+2)#� �)#+%'2�

!%)%�#/�&*++-%�. '*/* $�#/��/2��I/2���/2��C/2��#$+���/2�. '*/* $�)%'.%"/*,%-1��

�2%*)�����,#-(%'�!%)%����IC�����I������I:�����:��#$+�������)%'.%"/*,%-1�

*$�:������2%�����,#-(%'� 3��$+*#�!%)%�����:�*$��C����������*$��CC��#$+�

���I:�*$�:�����

��������������

Page 21: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� �C�

����" (���(�

� �

� �2%� #/* $#-� �(&#$� �%,%- .&%$/� �%. )/� 3� �$+*#� " ,%)'�&("2�

& )%�!*+%)�#$+�'%$'*/*,%�*$+*"#/ )'�/2#$�/2%�� ���3 )�/2%�&%#'()%&%$/�

3� ����� �$+*#;'� ���� 2#'� " &.(/%+� /#/%�!*'%� 2(&#$� +%,%- .&%$/�

*$+%8��/2*'�2%-.'�/ �*$+%$/*31�/2%�& '/�5#"6!#)+�/#/%'�*$��$+*#�*$�2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/� #'.%"/'�� /� $-1� /2#/�� /2%� ���� *$+("%'� /2%� /#/%�

� ,%)$&%$/'� *$� �$+*#�� 3 )� /2%� .(5-*"#/* $� 3� /2%*)� !$� 2(&#$�

+%,%- .&%$/�)%. )/�� �$� /2%�/#/%��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/'�� /2%�����

&%#'()%�2#'�#$#-1'%'�,%)1�+%%.-1�/2%�5#"6!#)+$%''� 3�/2%�/#/%';�' "* �

%" $ &*"�'/#/('�#$+�/2%�+*'/)*"/�!*'%�����2#,%�#-' �5%%$�+%,%- .%+��51�

/2('��/2%�.) "%''� 3�" &.(/*$7�����#/�&*") �-%,%-�2#,%�#-' �5%%$�"#))*%+�

(/�*$��$+*#���

Page 22: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� :��

'���'����(��&#)/1#����%$�>:���?��<���%"#+%� 3��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/=��O ()$#-� 3��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/�� -(&%�����.��I�:������� ,%)$&%$/� 3��$+*#�>:���?��< #/* $#-��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�:���=���-#$$*$7�� &&*''* $� 3��$+*#�� %!��%-2*����#)*�����>:���?��<�" $ &*"��) !/2�#$+��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/���&.*)*"#-��,*+%$"%�3) &��$+*#$�/#/%'=���%$/)%�3 )��%,%- .&%$/�/(+*%'���2*)(,#$#$/2#.()#&���(+2*)��$#$+�#$+��&#)/1#����%$�>�CC�?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��$+%8H��%/2 + - 71�#$+��%#'()%&%$/=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6����-��#4���#25(5��>:���?��<�2%��*)/2� 3��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��$+%8=��.���:I���I�*$��%#+*$7'�*$��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/���+*/%+�51�#6*6 ��(+(+#��#))�#$+�����2*,#��(&#)���83 )+��$*,%)'*/1��)%''���83 )+���� ���>�CC�?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/��CC�H�� $"%./�#$+��%#'()%&%$/� 3��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6���� ���>�CCF?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/��CCFH��%$+%)�#$+��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6���� ���>�CCI?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/��CCIH��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/�� ��)#+*"#/%�� ,%)/1=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6���� ���>:��:?��< (/2��'*#��(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�:��:=��� ���� %!��%-2*��� ������� ���>:���?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�:���H��*--%$$*(&��%,%- .&%$/�� #-'H���� &.#"/�#& $7� #/* $'�/ ��$+��(&#$�� ,%)/1=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6���� ���>:��F?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�:��F=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6���� ���>:���?��<�(&#$��%,%- .&%$/��%. )/�:���H��%1 $+�'"#)"*/1H�� !%)��. ,%)/1�#$+�/2%�7- 5#-�!#/%)�")*'*'=���$*/%+� #/* $'��%,%- .&%$/��) 7)#&&%�� %!�� )6��

Page 23: Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India · Munich Personal RePEc Archive Human Development Measurement: A broader approach in India Sarvalingam, A and Sivakumar,

� :��

�9���>:��:?��<�%#-/2���" $ &*"��) !/2�#$+�� ,%)/1��%+("/* $=��� &&*''* $� $��#") %" $ &*"'�#$+��%#-/2��9 )-+��%#-/2��)7#$*E#/* $���%$%,#��