HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

18
*HUJLS *VU[PU\L *:=7 (UU\HS 9LWVY[ +H[H *VSSLJ[PVU HUK >HP]LY :\ITPZZPVU 7VY[HS (SS 0UZ[P[\[PVUZ VM /PNOLY ,K\JH[PVU PU 4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z T\Z[ Z\ITP[ [OL PUMVYTH[PVU OLYLPU [V [OL 4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z +LWHY[TLU[ VM /PNOLY ,K\JH[PVU W\YZ\HU[ [V *OHW[LY VM [OL (J[Z VM ;OL *HTW\Z :L_\HS (ZZH\S[ 3H^ PZ VUL VM [OL ÄYZ[ Z[H[L SH^Z VM P[Z RPUK ZWLJPÄJHSS` MVJ\ZLK VU JHTW\Z YLZWVUZLZ [V ZL_\HS ]PVSLUJL ;OL SH^ HWWSPLZ [V IV[O W\ISPJ HUK WYP]H[L OPNOLY LK\JH[PVU PUZ[P[\[PVUZ SVJH[LK PU [OL *VTTVU^LHS[O HUK H\[OVYPaLK [V NYHU[ KLNYLLZ HUK OHZ [^V THQVY ZLJ[PVUZ! H ZLJ[PVU WLY[HPUPUN [V [OL YLX\PYLTLU[ [OH[ HSS PUZ[P[\[PVUZ JVUK\J[ ZL_\HS TPZJVUK\J[ JSPTH[L Z\Y]L`Z H[ SLHZ[ VUJL L]LY` MV\Y `LHYZ" HUK HUV[OLY ZLJ[PVU ^OPJO PTWVZLZ ZWLJPÄJ WVSPJ` WYVJLK\YL HUK YLWVY[PUN YLX\PYLTLU[Z VU PUZ[P[\[PVUZ» LɈVY[Z [V PKLU[PM` WYL]LU[ HUK YLZWVUK [V ZL_\HS TPZJVUK\J[ ;OPZ VUSPUL WVY[HS ^PSS ZLY]L [V M\SÄSS [OL YLX\PYLTLU[ [OH[ PUZ[P[\[PVUZ YLWVY[ ZWLJPÄJ ZL_\HS TPZJVUK\J[ PUJPKLU[ KH[H HZ YLX\PYLK I` [OL SH^" HZ ^LSS HZ WYV]PKL H \ZLYMYPLUKS` TLJOHUPZT [V WYV]PKL Z[H[\Z \WKH[LZ HUK KVJ\TLU[H[PVU YLSH[LK [V SVJHS SH^ LUMVYJLTLU[ HNLUJ` 3,( 46<Z YLNPZ[YH[PVU HUK ^HP]LY YLX\LZ[Z YLSH[LK [V :L_\HS (ZZH\S[ *YPZPZ :LY]PJL *LU[LYZ :(*:*Z HUK HKKP[PVUHS *HTW\Z :HML[` HUK =PVSLUJL 7YL]LU[PVU *:=7 PUMVYTH[PVU HZ HWWYVWYPH[L -VY TVYL PUMVYTH[PVU VU [OL *HTW\Z :L_\HS (ZZH\S[ 3H^ HUK V[OLY *:=7 TH[[LYZ WSLHZL ]PZP[ V\Y ^LIZP[L @V\ HYL Z[HY[PUN H *:=7 (UU\HS 9LWVY[ MVY ;LZ[ 0UZ[P[\[PVU ;V NL[ Z[HY[LK WSLHZL JSPJR *VU[PU\L

Transcript of HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

Page 1: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

*HUJLS *VU[PU\L

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

+H[H�*VSSLJ[PVU�HUK�>HP]LY�:\ITPZZPVU�7VY[HS(SS�0UZ[P[\[PVUZ�VM�/PNOLY�,K\JH[PVU�PU�4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z�T\Z[�Z\ITP[�[OL�PUMVYTH[PVU�OLYLPU�[V�[OL�4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z�+LWHY[TLU[VM�/PNOLY�,K\JH[PVU�W\YZ\HU[�[V�*OHW[LY�����VM�[OL�(J[Z�VM�����

;OL°�����*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H^�PZ�VUL�VM�[OL�ÄYZ[�Z[H[L�SH^Z�VM�P[Z�RPUK�ZWLJPÄJHSS`�MVJ\ZLK�VU�JHTW\Z�YLZWVUZLZ�[V�ZL_\HS]PVSLUJL��;OL�SH^�HWWSPLZ�[V�IV[O�W\ISPJ�HUK�WYP]H[L�OPNOLY�LK\JH[PVU�PUZ[P[\[PVUZ�SVJH[LK�PU�[OL�*VTTVU^LHS[O�HUK�H\[OVYPaLK�[VNYHU[�KLNYLLZ�HUK�OHZ�[^V�THQVY�ZLJ[PVUZ!�H�ZLJ[PVU�WLY[HPUPUN�[V�[OL�YLX\PYLTLU[�[OH[�HSS�PUZ[P[\[PVUZ�JVUK\J[�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[JSPTH[L�Z\Y]L`Z�H[�SLHZ[�VUJL�L]LY`�MV\Y�`LHYZ"�HUK�HUV[OLY�ZLJ[PVU�^OPJO�PTWVZLZ�ZWLJPÄJ�WVSPJ �̀�WYVJLK\YL�HUK�YLWVY[PUNYLX\PYLTLU[Z�VU�PUZ[P[\[PVUZ»�LɈVY[Z�[V�PKLU[PM �̀�WYL]LU[��HUK�YLZWVUK�[V�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�

;OPZ�VUSPUL�WVY[HS�^PSS�ZLY]L�[V�M\SÄSS�[OL�YLX\PYLTLU[�[OH[�PUZ[P[\[PVUZ�YLWVY[�ZWLJPÄJ�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�PUJPKLU[�KH[H��HZ�YLX\PYLK�I`[OL�SH^"�HZ�^LSS�HZ�WYV]PKL�H�\ZLY�MYPLUKS`�TLJOHUPZT�[V�WYV]PKL�Z[H[\Z�\WKH[LZ�HUK�KVJ\TLU[H[PVU�YLSH[LK�[V�SVJHS�SH^LUMVYJLTLU[�HNLUJ`��3,(��46<Z��YLNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�^HP]LY�YLX\LZ[Z�YLSH[LK�[V�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�*YPZPZ�:LY]PJL�*LU[LYZ��:(*:*Z���HUKHKKP[PVUHS�*HTW\Z�:HML[`�HUK�=PVSLUJL�7YL]LU[PVU��*:=7��PUMVYTH[PVU�HZ�HWWYVWYPH[L��-VY�TVYL�PUMVYTH[PVU�VU�[OL������*HTW\Z:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H^�HUK�V[OLY�*:=7�TH[[LYZ��WSLHZL�]PZP[�V\Y�^LIZP[L�

@V\�HYL�Z[HY[PUN�H�*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[�MVY�;LZ[�0UZ[P[\[PVU�

;V�NL[�Z[HY[LK�WSLHZL�JSPJR�*VU[PU\L�

Page 2: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

0UZ[P[\[PVU�5HTL

*HTW\Z�3VJH[PVU�5HTL

*HTW\Z�3VJH[PVU(KKYLZZ

;LZ[�0UZ[P[\[PVU

*:=7�:LJVUKHY`*VU[HJ[

;LZ[�<ZLY��ZHYHPUX\PYPLZ'KOL�THZZ�LK\� *:=7�7YPTHY`�*VU[HJ[ -PYZ[5HTL�3HZ[5HTL��[LZ['KOL�THZZ�LK\�

*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z

7SLHZL�\WKH[L�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�*:=7�JVU[HJ[Z�VU�ÄSL�ILSV �̂

7SLHZL�HKK�LHJO�VM�[OL�MVSSV^PUN�\ZLYZ�HUK�[OLPY�JVU[HJ[�PUMVYTH[PVU�MVY�LHJO�YVSL�H[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�I`�ZLSLJ[PUN�[OL���PM�[OL�\ZLY�PZUV[�HSYLHK`�WHY[�VM�[OL�,+]LYH�Z`Z[LT�

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 3: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

�VM�YLWVY[Z�I`�Z[\KLU[Z�HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z

�VM�YLWVY[Z�I`�Z[\KLU[Z�HNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ

�VM�YLWVY[Z�I`�LTWSV`LLZ�HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z

�VM�YLWVY[Z�I`�LTWSV`LLZ�HNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ

�VM�HUVU`TV\Z�YLWVY[Z�HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z

�VM�HUVU`TV\Z�YLWVY[Z�HNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ

;V[HS�YLWVY[Z

�VM�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(�I`�Z[\KLU[ZHNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z�VM�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(�I`�Z[\KLU[ZHNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ�VM�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(�I`�LTWSV`LLZHNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z�VM�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(�I`�LTWSV`LLZHNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ�VM�HUVU`TV\Z�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z�VM�HUVU`TV\Z�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�HU�3,(HNHPUZ[�LTWSV`LLZ;V[HS�YLWVY[Z�PU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�3,(Z

�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL

�VM�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL

;V[HS�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL

0UJPKLU[�+H[H

-VY�[OL�ÄLSKZ�ILSV �̂�WSLHZL�LU[LY�[OL�PUJPKLU[�KH[H�YLX\PYLK�I`�4�.�3��J�����:LJ[PVU����,�X��HUK�����*49����������

���;V[HS�U\TILY�VM�YLWVY[Z�VM�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�YLWVY[LK�[V�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�;P[SL�0?�JVVYKPUH[VY�I`�H�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OLPUZ[P[\[PVU�HNHPUZ[�HUV[OLY�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU

���;V[HS�U\TILY�VM�YLWVY[Z�THKL�I`�H�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HNHPUZ[�HUV[OLY�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVUPU]LZ[PNH[LK�I`�H�SVJHS�VY�Z[H[L�SH^�LUMVYJLTLU[�HNLUJ`��3,(���PM�RUV^U

���5\TILY�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL�MVY�]PVSH[PUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�WVSPJPLZ�WYVOPIP[PUN�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J["

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

Page 4: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�MV\UK�UV[�YLZWVUZPISL

�VM�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�UV[�YLZWVUZPISL

;V[HS�MV\UK�UV[�YLZWVUZPISL

�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL�HNHPUZ[�^OPJOKPZJPWSPUHY`�HJ[PVUZ�^LYL�PTWVZLK�I`�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVUHZ�H�YLZ\S[�VM�H�ÄUKPUN�VM�YLZWVUZPIPSP[`�VM�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL�HNHPUZ[�^OPJOKPZJPWSPUHY`�HJ[PVUZ�^LYL�PTWVZLK�I`�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVUHZ�H�YLZ\S[�VM�H�ÄUKPUN�VM�YLZWVUZPIPSP[`;V[HS�KPZJPWSPUHY`�HJ[PVUZ

���5\TILY�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�UV[�YLZWVUZPISL�MVY�]PVSH[PUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�WVSPJPLZ�WYVOPIP[PUN�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J["

���5\TILY�VM�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�MV\UK�YLZWVUZPISL�MVY�]PVSH[PUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�WVSPJPLZ�WYVOPIP[PUN�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[��HNHPUZ[^OPJO�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PTWVZLK�KPZJPWSPUHY`�HJ[PVUZ�HZ�H�YLZ\S[�VM�H�ÄUKPUN�VM�YLZWVUZPIPSP[`�MVY�]PVSH[PUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�WVSPJPLZWYVOPIP[PUN�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J["

7SLHZL�UV[L!�[OL�4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z�+LWHY[TLU[�VM�/PNOLY�,K\JH[PVU��+/,��\UKLYZ[HUKZ�[OH[�LHJO�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�\UPX\L�HUK�TH`�OH]LT\S[PWSL�HWWSPJHISL�WVSPJPLZ��WYVJLK\YLZ��VɉJLZ��VY�Z[HɈ�^OPJO�V]LYZLL�PUZ[P[\[PVUHS�YLZWVUZLZ�[V�PUJPKLU[Z�VM�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�HZKLÄULK�\UKLY�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�;V�[OL�L_[LU[�P[�PZ�OLSWM\S�MVY�PUZ[P[\[PVUZ�[V�WYV]PKL�JVU[L_[�YLNHYKPUN�[OL�HIV]L�YLWVY[LK�KH[H��VY�MLLKIHJR�VU�[OL�JVU[LU[�HUK�MVYTH[�VM�[OLZL�X\LZ[PVUZ�PU�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�WSLHZL�\ZL�[OLÄLSKZ�ILSV^�[V�WYV]PKL�HU`�HKKP[PVUHS�L_WSHUH[PVU�VY�JVTTLU[Z�`V\�^PZO�MVY�[OL�+/,�[V�JVUZPKLY�HSVUNZPKL�[OL�KH[H�Z\ITP[[LK�PU�[OPZ

YLWVY[��

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 5: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

(NLUJ`�UHTL

4\UPJPWHSP[` +P]PZPVU

:[YLL[�HKKYLZZ *P[`

APW�JVKL 7OVUL�U\TILY

*VU[HJ[��VW[PVUHS�

1\YPZKPJ[PVU

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�HKKYLZZ�HUK�JVU[HJ[�PUMVYTH[PVU�MVY�[OL�SVJHS�3,(�VY�3,(Z�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVU�VU�VY�HYV\UK�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z4HZZHJO\ZL[[Z�JHTW\Z�LZ��YLX\PYLK�W\YZ\HU[�[V�����*49����������H��

(KK�HU�(NLUJ`

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 6: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

3,(�46<Z

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�PUMVYTH[PVU�ILSV^�YLNHYKPUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�LU[YHUJL�PU[V�HU`�3,(�46<Z�YLX\PYLK�W\YZ\HU[�[V�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU���,�J�������*49��������HUK�����*49�����������PM�HWWSPJHISL��

���/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<��[OL�[LYTZ�VM�^OPJO�HYL�PU�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�����*49��������^P[O�LHJO�3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVVU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PU[P[\[PVU�Z�JHTW\ZLZ&

@LZ� 5V

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 7: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

3,(�46<Z

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�PUMVYTH[PVU�ILSV^�YLNHYKPUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�LU[YHUJL�PU[V�HU`�3,(�46<Z�YLX\PYLK�W\YZ\HU[�[V�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU���,�J�������*49��������HUK�����*49�����������PM�HWWSPJHISL��

���/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<��[OL�[LYTZ�VM�^OPJO�HYL�PU�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�����*49��������^P[O�LHJO�3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVVU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PU[P[\[PVU�Z�JHTW\ZLZ&

@LZ� 5V7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�OHZ�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<��[OL�[LYTZ�VM�^OPJO�HYL�PU�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�����*49��������^P[O�LHJO3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVU�VU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU»Z�JHTW\ZLZ�

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�0UP[PHSZ�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�JVW`�VM�[OL�HWWSPJHISL�46<�VY�46<Z�

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�:[H[\Z�<WKH[L�VU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU����,�J��������*49�������3VJHS�3H^,UMVYJLTLU[�46<Z�

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 8: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

0M�V[OLY��WSLHZL�ZWLJPM`

3,(�46<Z

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�PUMVYTH[PVU�ILSV^�YLNHYKPUN�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�LU[YHUJL�PU[V�HU`�3,(�46<Z�YLX\PYLK�W\YZ\HU[�[V�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU���,�J�������*49��������HUK�����*49�����������PM�HWWSPJHISL��

���/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<��[OL�[LYTZ�VM�^OPJO�HYL�PU�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�����*49��������^P[O�LHJO�3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVVU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PU[P[\[PVU�Z�JHTW\ZLZ&

@LZ� 5V0M�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�OHZ�KL[LYTPULK�[OH[��W\YZ\HU[�[V�����*49�����������LU[YHUJL�PU[V�VUL�VY�TVYL�46<Z�^P[O�[LYTZ�[OH[�HYL�PUJVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�����*49��������^P[O�LHJO�3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVU�VU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU»Z�JHTW\ZLZ��PZ�PUMLHZPISL�WSLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OPZ�KL[LYTPUH[PVU�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OL�ÄLSK�ILSV �̂

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�0UP[PHSZ�

7SLHZL�PUKPJH[L�HU`�HWWSPJHISL�YLHZVUZ�MVY�^O`�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�OHZ�KL[LYTPULK�W\YZ\HU[�[V�����*49����������[OH[�LU[YHUJL�PU[VZ\JO�HU�46<�VY�46<Z�I`�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�PUMLHZPISL��7SLHZL�ZLSLJ[�VUL�VY�T\S[PWSL�YLHZVUZ�MVY�[OL�SVJHS�3,(�VY�3,(Z»�HJ[PVU�VYPUHJ[PVU�[OH[�TH`�HWWS �̀

<U[PTLS`�VY�UV�YLZWVUZL�MYVT�[OL�SVJHS�3,(�VY�3,(Z�[V�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�YLHZVUHISL�YLX\LZ[Z�[V�LU[LY�PU[V�Z\JO�HU�46<0M�HSSV^LK��[OL�46<�^V\SK�JH\ZL�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[V�IL�PU�]PVSH[PVU�VM�Z[H[L�VY�MLKLYHS�SH^(U�46<�JV\SK�UV[�IL�ULNV[PH[LK�VY�ÄUHSPaLK�KLZWP[L�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�VM�IV[O�[OL�SVJHS�3,(�VY�3,(Z�HUK�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU6[OLY��WSLHZL�L_WSHPU�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�:[H[\Z�<WKH[L�VU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU����,�J��������*49�������3VJHS�3H^,UMVYJLTLU[�46<Z��^OPJO�PUJS\KLZ�H�Z\TTHY`�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V^HYKZ�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�HU�46<�VY�46<Z�^P[OLHJO�3,(�^P[O�Q\YPZKPJ[PVU�VU�VY�HYV\UK�LHJO�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU»Z�JHTW\ZLZ�[OH[�TLL[�[OL�TPUPT\T�YLX\PYLTLU[Z�ZL[�MVY[O�PU����*49�������

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 9: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7\YZ\HU[�[V�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�KVLZ�UV[�WYV]PKL�P[Z�V^U�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�:(*:*��ZOHSS�LU[LY�PU[V�HUK�THPU[HPU�HU�46<�^P[O�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�M\UKLK�I`�[OL�KLWHY[TLUVM�W\ISPJ�OLHS[O��+7/��HUK�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�WYVNYHT��+=7��M\UKLK�I`�+7/�

0UZ[P[\[PVUZ�[OH[�HSYLHK`�OH]L�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�PU�WSHJL�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�

(U�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�WSHUZ�[V�HKK�[V�VY�HKQ\Z[�P[Z�L_PZ[PUN�VU�JHTW\Z�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�TLL[�[OL�PU[LU[�VM�[OL�Z[H[\[L�ZOV\SK�\ZL0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���[V�THRL�[OL�HWWYVWYPH[L�JOHUNLZ��0/,Z�[OH[�KV�UV[�VɈLY�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_WLJ[LK�[V�LUNHNL�PUNVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V�ZLJ\YL�[OL�Z[H[\[VYPS`�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�K\YPUN�0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���

0M�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�LUJV\U[LYPUN�JOHSSLUNLZ�PU�[OPZ�WYVJLZZ�KLZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��HUK�VY�YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL��P[�TH`�YLX\LZ[H�^HP]LY�[OYV\NO�[OPZ�HUU\HS�YLWVY[�

7SLHZL�PUKPJH[L�PU�[OL�ÄLSKZ�ILSV^�^OL[OLY�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�OHZ�HU�:(*:*��OHZ�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�H[�SLHZ[�VULJVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*�HUK�+=7�M\UKLK�I`�+7/��VY�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ�[PTL�

0�ILSPL]L�T`�PUZ[P[\[PVU���

���0Z�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�ILJH\ZL�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�WYV]PKLZ�P[Z�V^U�:(*:*�

���/HZ�TL[�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�I`�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�VUL�VY�TVYL�46<Z�^P[O�VUL�VY�TVYL�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�M\UKLK�I`�+7/

���+LZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL�[V�LU[LY�PU[V�[OL�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�HUK�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ[PTL�

:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 10: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7\YZ\HU[�[V�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�KVLZ�UV[�WYV]PKL�P[Z�V^U�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�:(*:*��ZOHSS�LU[LY�PU[V�HUK�THPU[HPU�HU�46<�^P[O�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�M\UKLK�I`�[OL�KLWHY[TLUVM�W\ISPJ�OLHS[O��+7/��HUK�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�WYVNYHT��+=7��M\UKLK�I`�+7/�

0UZ[P[\[PVUZ�[OH[�HSYLHK`�OH]L�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�PU�WSHJL�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�

(U�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�WSHUZ�[V�HKK�[V�VY�HKQ\Z[�P[Z�L_PZ[PUN�VU�JHTW\Z�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�TLL[�[OL�PU[LU[�VM�[OL�Z[H[\[L�ZOV\SK�\ZL0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���[V�THRL�[OL�HWWYVWYPH[L�JOHUNLZ��0/,Z�[OH[�KV�UV[�VɈLY�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_WLJ[LK�[V�LUNHNL�PUNVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V�ZLJ\YL�[OL�Z[H[\[VYPS`�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�K\YPUN�0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���

0M�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�LUJV\U[LYPUN�JOHSSLUNLZ�PU�[OPZ�WYVJLZZ�KLZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��HUK�VY�YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL��P[�TH`�YLX\LZ[H�^HP]LY�[OYV\NO�[OPZ�HUU\HS�YLWVY[�

7SLHZL�PUKPJH[L�PU�[OL�ÄLSKZ�ILSV^�^OL[OLY�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�OHZ�HU�:(*:*��OHZ�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�H[�SLHZ[�VULJVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*�HUK�+=7�M\UKLK�I`�+7/��VY�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ�[PTL�

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

(KKYLZZ

>LIZP[L

0�ILSPL]L�T`�PUZ[P[\[PVU���

���0Z�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�ILJH\ZL�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�WYV]PKLZ�P[Z�V^U�:(*:*�

���/HZ�TL[�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�I`�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�VUL�VY�TVYL�46<Z�^P[O�VUL�VY�TVYL�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�M\UKLK�I`�+7/

���+LZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL�[V�LU[LY�PU[V�[OL�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�HUK�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ[PTL�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�WYV]PKLZ�P[Z�V^U�:(*:*�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�:(*:*�WYV]PKLZ�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJLZ�VU�JHTW\Z�PU�YLZWVUZL�[V�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�[V�Z[\KLU[Z�HUKLTWSV`LLZ��PUJS\KPUN�HJJLZZ�[V�H�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�U\YZL�L_HTPULY��VɈ�JHTW\Z�PZ�HJJLW[HISL�"�VY�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJLZ�I`PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�:(*:*�LUZ\YLZ�[OH[�H�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�HISL�[V�HJJLZZ�MYLL�HUK�JVUÄKLU[PHS�JV\UZLSPUNHUK�HK]VJHJ`�ZLY]PJLZ�LP[OLY�VU�JHTW\Z�VY�VɈ�JHTW\Z�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�:(*:*�LUJV\YHNLZ�JVVWLYH[PVU�HUK�[YHPUPUNZ�IL[^LLU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HUK�[OL�:(*:*�[V�LUZ\YL�HU\UKLYZ[HUKPUN�VM�[OL�YVSLZ�[OH[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HUK�ZHJZJ�ZOV\SK�WSH`�PU�YLZWVUKPUN�[V�YLWVY[Z�HUK�KPZJSVZ\YLZ�VM�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HUK�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�WYV[VJVSZ�MVY�WYV]PKPUN�Z\WWVY[�HUK�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�[OL�Z[\KLU[ZHUK�LTWSV`LLZ�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�HKKYLZZ��^LIZP[L��WOVUL�U\TILY��HUK�LTHPS�HKKYLZZ�MVY�[OL�:(*:*

:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

Page 11: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

7OVUL�U\TILY

,THPS

+PYLJ[VY�UHTL

+PYLJ[VY�[P[SL

+PYLJ[VY�LTHPS

7OVUL�U\TILY

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�UHTL��[P[SL��LTHPS�HKKYLZZ��HUK�WOVUL�U\TILY�MVY�[OL�:(*:*�+PYLJ[VY

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 12: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7\YZ\HU[�[V�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�KVLZ�UV[�WYV]PKL�P[Z�V^U�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�:(*:*��ZOHSS�LU[LY�PU[V�HUK�THPU[HPU�HU�46<�^P[O�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�M\UKLK�I`�[OL�KLWHY[TLUVM�W\ISPJ�OLHS[O��+7/��HUK�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�WYVNYHT��+=7��M\UKLK�I`�+7/�

0UZ[P[\[PVUZ�[OH[�HSYLHK`�OH]L�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�PU�WSHJL�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�

(U�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�WSHUZ�[V�HKK�[V�VY�HKQ\Z[�P[Z�L_PZ[PUN�VU�JHTW\Z�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�TLL[�[OL�PU[LU[�VM�[OL�Z[H[\[L�ZOV\SK�\ZL0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���[V�THRL�[OL�HWWYVWYPH[L�JOHUNLZ��0/,Z�[OH[�KV�UV[�VɈLY�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_WLJ[LK�[V�LUNHNL�PUNVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V�ZLJ\YL�[OL�Z[H[\[VYPS`�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�K\YPUN�0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���

0M�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�LUJV\U[LYPUN�JOHSSLUNLZ�PU�[OPZ�WYVJLZZ�KLZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��HUK�VY�YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL��P[�TH`�YLX\LZ[H�^HP]LY�[OYV\NO�[OPZ�HUU\HS�YLWVY[�

7SLHZL�PUKPJH[L�PU�[OL�ÄLSKZ�ILSV^�^OL[OLY�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�OHZ�HU�:(*:*��OHZ�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�H[�SLHZ[�VULJVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*�HUK�+=7�M\UKLK�I`�+7/��VY�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ�[PTL�

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

0�ILSPL]L�T`�PUZ[P[\[PVU���

���0Z�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�ILJH\ZL�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�WYV]PKLZ�P[Z�V^U�:(*:*�

���/HZ�TL[�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�I`�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�VUL�VY�TVYL�46<Z�^P[O�VUL�VY�TVYL�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�M\UKLK�I`�+7/

���+LZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL�[V�LU[LY�PU[V�[OL�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�HUK�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ[PTL�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�JVW`�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU»Z�46<�VY�46<Z�^P[O�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK��+7/�M\UKLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�46<�VY�46<Z�WYV]PKL�HU�VɈ�JHTW\Z�HS[LYUH[P]L�MVY�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�[V�YLJLP]L�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZZLY]PJLZ��PUJS\KPUN�HJJLZZ�[V�H�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�U\YZL�L_HTPULY�PM�H]HPSHISL��VY�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJLZ�PU�YLZWVUZL�[V�ZL_\HSTPZJVUK\J[�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�46<�VY�46<Z�LUZ\YL�[OH[�H�Z[\KLU[�VY�LTWSV`LL�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�HISL�[V�HJJLZZ�MYLL�HUK�JVUÄKLU[PHSJV\UZLSPUN�HUK�HK]VJHJ`�ZLY]PJLZ�LP[OLY�VU�JHTW\Z�VY�VɈ�JHTW\Z�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�46<�VY�46<Z�LUJV\YHNL�JVVWLYH[PVU�HUK�[YHPUPUNZ�IL[^LLU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HUK�[OL�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�VY�WYVNYHT[V�LUZ\YL�HU�\UKLYZ[HUKPUN�VM�[OL�YVSLZ�[OH[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU��ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�HUK�WYVNYHT�ZOV\SK�WSH`�PU�YLZWVUKPUN�[V�YLWVY[Z�HUKKPZJSVZ\YLZ�VM�ZL_\HS�TPZJVUK\J[�HNHPUZ[�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HUK�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU»Z�WYV[VJVSZ�MVY�WYV]PKPUNZ\WWVY[�HUK�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�[OL�Z[\KLU[Z�HUK�LTWSV`LLZ�I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZ�ÄLSK�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�:[H[\Z�<WKH[L�VU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU����,�O��46<Z�^P[O�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�*YPZPZ:LY]PJL�*LU[LYZ��^OPJO�PUJS\KLZ�H�Z\TTHY`�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V^HYKZ�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK��+7/�M\UKLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�[OH[�TLL[�[OL�YLX\PYLTLU[Z�VM�:LJ[PVU����,�O��

:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

Page 13: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 14: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7\YZ\HU[�[V�[OL������*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�3H �̂�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�KVLZ�UV[�WYV]PKL�P[Z�V^U�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�:(*:*��ZOHSS�LU[LY�PU[V�HUK�THPU[HPU�HU�46<�^P[O�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�ZL_\HS�HZZH\S[�JYPZPZ�ZLY]PJL�JLU[LY�M\UKLK�I`�[OL�KLWHY[TLUVM�W\ISPJ�OLHS[O��+7/��HUK�H�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�KVTLZ[PJ�]PVSLUJL�WYVNYHT��+=7��M\UKLK�I`�+7/�

0UZ[P[\[PVUZ�[OH[�HSYLHK`�OH]L�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�PU�WSHJL�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�

(U�PUZ[P[\[PVU�[OH[�WSHUZ�[V�HKK�[V�VY�HKQ\Z[�P[Z�L_PZ[PUN�VU�JHTW\Z�ZLY]PJLZ�[V�TLL[�[OL�PU[LU[�VM�[OL�Z[H[\[L�ZOV\SK�\ZL0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���[V�THRL�[OL�HWWYVWYPH[L�JOHUNLZ��0/,Z�[OH[�KV�UV[�VɈLY�Z\JO�ZLY]PJLZ�VU�JHTW\Z�HYL�L_WLJ[LK�[V�LUNHNL�PUNVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V�ZLJ\YL�[OL�Z[H[\[VYPS`�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�K\YPUN�0TWSLTLU[H[PVU�@LHY���

0M�HU�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�LUJV\U[LYPUN�JOHSSLUNLZ�PU�[OPZ�WYVJLZZ�KLZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��HUK�VY�YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL��P[�TH`�YLX\LZ[H�^HP]LY�[OYV\NO�[OPZ�HUU\HS�YLWVY[�

7SLHZL�PUKPJH[L�PU�[OL�ÄLSKZ�ILSV^�^OL[OLY�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�OHZ�HU�:(*:*��OHZ�LU[LYLK�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�H[�SLHZ[�VULJVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*�HUK�+=7�M\UKLK�I`�+7/��VY�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ�[PTL�

*,6�VY�7YLZPKLU[�PUP[PHSZ

0�ILSPL]L�T`�PUZ[P[\[PVU���

���0Z�L_LTW[�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�ILJH\ZL�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�HSYLHK`�WYV]PKLZ�P[Z�V^U�:(*:*�

���/HZ�TL[�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�I`�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�VUL�VY�TVYL�46<Z�^P[O�VUL�VY�TVYL�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�M\UKLK�I`�+7/

���+LZWP[L�P[Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z��YLX\PYLZ�HKKP[PVUHS�[PTL�[V�LU[LY�PU[V�[OL�YLX\PYLK�46<Z�HUK�PZ�ZLLRPUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OPZ�Z[H[\[VY`�YLX\PYLTLU[�H[�[OPZ[PTL�

7SLHZL�JLY[PM`�[OH[�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�PZ�YLX\LZ[PUN�H�^HP]LY�MYVT�[OL�:(*:*�+=7�46<�YLX\PYLTLU[�HZ�H�YLZ\S[�VM�IV[O�UV[�OH]PUN�P[Z�V^U:(*:*�HUK�UV[�VI[HPUPUN�H�ZPNULK�46<�KLZWP[L�HJ[PUN�PU�NVVK�MHP[O�W\YZ\HU[�[V�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU����,�O��WHY����I`�PUP[PHSPUN�[OPZÄLSK�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�:[H[\Z�<WKH[L�VU�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�JVTWSPHUJL�^P[O�4�.�3��J����:LJ[PVU����,�O��46<Z�^P[O�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[�*YPZPZ:LY]PJL�*LU[LYZ��^OPJO�PUJS\KLZ�H�Z\TTHY`�VM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�NVVK�MHP[O�LɈVY[Z�[V^HYKZ�LU[LYPUN�PU[V�HU�46<�^P[O�JVTT\UP[`�IHZLK��+7/�M\UKLK�:(*:*Z�HUK�+=7Z�[OH[�TLL[�[OL�YLX\PYLTLU[Z�VM�:LJ[PVU����,�O��

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :H]L�HUK�7YVJLLK�[V�5L_[�:LJ[PVU

Page 15: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7SLHZL�PUMVYT�[OL�+/,�VMHU`�HYLHZ�^OLYL

[LJOUPJHS�HZZPZ[HUJL�TH`IL�OLSWM\S�PU�JVTWS`PUN

^P[O�LP[OLY�[OL�����*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[3H^�VY�����*49�������

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�HU`HKKP[PVUHS�X\LZ[PVUZ�

JVTTLU[Z��VY�JVUJLYUZOLYL�

(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�L]LY�HKTPUPZ[LYLK�H�:L_\HS�4PZJVUK\J[�:\Y]L`&

@LZ� 5V

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :\ITP[

Page 16: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�[OL�KH[LVM�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�Z�TVZ[YLJLU[S`�HKTPUPZ[LYLK

:L_\HS�4PZJVUK\J[*SPTH[L�:\Y]L �̀

7SLHZL�L_WSHPU�^OH[�RPUKVM�Z\Y]L`�PUZ[Y\TLU[�VY

[LTWSH[L�^HZ�\ZLK��L�N��PU�OV\ZL�Z\Y]L`�[VVS�((<��(9*���,]LY�

/LHS[O`�4PUKZ��L[J���

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�SPZ[�VM[OL�KH[H�ÄLSKZ�[OH[�^LYL

JVSSLJ[LK�

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�H�JVW`�VMVY�SPUR�[V�[OL�W\ISPZOLKYLWVY[�VM�[OL�Z\Y]L`�Z

ÄUKPUNZ�

7SLHZL�PUMVYT�[OL�+/,�VMHU`�HYLHZ�^OLYL

[LJOUPJHS�HZZPZ[HUJL�TH`IL�OLSWM\S�PU�JVTWS`PUN

^P[O�LP[OLY�[OL�����*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[3H^�VY�����*49�������

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�HU`HKKP[PVUHS�X\LZ[PVUZ�

JVTTLU[Z��VY�JVUJLYUZOLYL�

(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�L]LY�HKTPUPZ[LYLK�H�:L_\HS�4PZJVUK\J[�:\Y]L`&

@LZ� 5V

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

VY

;V�H[[HJO�H�ÄSL�KYHN� �KYVW�OLYL�VY�JSPJR�[V�JOVVZL� 5V�ÄSL�JOVZLU&KRRVH�)LOH

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

Page 17: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :\ITP[

Page 18: HS 9LWVY[ - mass.edu

:\ITPZZPVU 9L]PL^ *VTTLU[Z� � :[H[\Z!� <UZ\ITP[[LK /PZ[VY`

���*:=7�*VU[HJ[Z ���0UJPKLU[�+H[H ���1\YPZKPJ[PVU ���3,(�46<Z ���:(*:*�9LNPZ[YH[PVU�HUK�>HP]LYZ

���(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

7SLHZL�PUMVYT�[OL�+/,�VMHU`�HYLHZ�^OLYL

[LJOUPJHS�HZZPZ[HUJL�TH`IL�OLSWM\S�PU�JVTWS`PUN

^P[O�LP[OLY�[OL�����*HTW\Z�:L_\HS�(ZZH\S[3H^�VY�����*49�������

7SLHZL�WYV]PKL�HU`HKKP[PVUHS�X\LZ[PVUZ�

JVTTLU[Z��VY�JVUJLYUZOLYL�

(KKP[PVUHS�0UMVYTH[PVU

/HZ�[OL�PUZ[P[\[PVU�L]LY�HKTPUPZ[LYLK�H�:L_\HS�4PZJVUK\J[�:\Y]L`&

@LZ� 5V

*:=7�(UU\HS�9LWVY[

:H]L�HUK�,_P[ :H]L :\ITP[