How Oil and Gas Development Affects Local Governments and ...
Transcript of How Oil and Gas Development Affects Local Governments and ...
How Oil and Gas Development Affects Local Governments and Communities
Alan Krupnick Co-Director of Center for Energy and Climate Economics
Community Impacts and Interactions Initiative
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Fiscal Impacts (Newell and Raimi)
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Leasing
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Road Damage and Accidents
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Education
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Sample State - Colorado
Dropout Rate – A short-lived spike occurred in top producing counties, but ultimately disappeared.
-
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
9,000
-
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013C
ompl
etio
ns
Dro
pout
Rat
e
Top Producing Counties
Control Counties
Completions in Prod. Co.
Solid Waste
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Wastewater Modeling
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Siting and Habitat Modeling
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Industry/Community protocols
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Inactive Wells Report
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors
Thank you
For further questions:[email protected]
Shale Schools Overview
Geography: Colorado, Montana, North Dakota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West VirginiaPrimary metrics: Student population, student/ teacher ratio, finances, dropout rate, and test scoresMethodology: Difference in difference complimented by in person interviews
Sample State - Colorado
Instructional Expenditures - Despite an oil and gas boom, top producing counties lag control counties and have experienced a net decline since 2000.
-
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
$5,000
$5,200
$5,400
$5,600
$5,800
$6,000
$6,200
$6,400
$6,600
$6,800
$7,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013M
illio
n M
CF
2014
Rea
l Dol
lars
Top Producing Counties
Control Counties
Gas in Top Counties
Sample State - Colorado
Property Taxes – Property tax revenue to schools in top producing counties experienced greater year over year fluctuation.
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Top Producing Counties
Control Counties
Primary Takeaways from Bakken (ND & MT) InterviewsBoom presented challenges related to student growth (primarily in elementary grades), student mobility (extremely high turnover / recycling), student preparation and new teacher hiring and retention. Few dropouts were reported. Financial health, particularly for new capital projects, relied on voter approval, which varied greatly by district. Interviewees frequently cited frustration with state funding mechanism (East / West divide).
Risk/Benefit Matrix and Modeling
Traditional Burdens
Air, Surface water groundwater, land
Community Burdens
Noise, light, odor, road accidents, damage, congestion
Local Government impacts
Financial, Staff, Infrastructure, Education
Additional community impacts
Econ development, Property, Relationships, Crime, Health care, housing
Externalities Health, Ecosystem, Economic
MitigationRegulation, Voluntary/best practice, Community Processes
SGD Stages: Initial Assessment Leasing/Permitting Exploration Development Production Plugging and Abandonment
Habitat, soil trash, seismicity
Tourism, Agriculture, Water-using sectors