How Do We Get The Deficit To Zero?
description
Transcript of How Do We Get The Deficit To Zero?
How Do We GetThe Deficit To Zero?
Or, “There is no such thing as a free lunch.”
Paul M. JonesMid-South Tea Party General Meeting
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Who Cares?• Portugal, Italy, Ireland,
Greece, Spain (PIIGS)
• Deficit spending for decades
• Under Euro, cannot inflate
• Can’t borrow any more
• IMF bailout, austerity measures
• Strikes, riots in response
Greek Riots
2010 Federal Budget
• Revenues: $2,165,000,000,000
• Spending: $3,721,000,000,000
• Deficit: $1,556,000,000,000
• (source: http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb, table S-4; graphic from Heritage)
Big Numbers• Count to a million:
11.57 days
• Count to a billion:31.68 years
• Count to a trillion:31,688 years
• Count the deficit:49,306 years
Human-Scale Numbers• Revenues per household:
$18,276
• Spending: per household:$31,406
• Deficit per household:$13,130
• (source: http://www.tampabay.com/opinion/columns/washington-will-spend-31406-per-household-this-year/1086283, via Heritage)
Fiscal Responsibility
• Raise taxes by 72% per household,keep spending in place
• Cut spending by 44% per household,keep taxes in place
What To Cut?• Earmarks
• Foreign aid
• Farm subsidies
• Bailouts
• IRS
• ???
It’s Not EnoughPer HouseholdSocial Security/MedicareDefenseAntipovertyUnemploymentInterest on the debtVeteransʼ benefitsFederal employee retirement benefitsEducationHighways/transitHealth research/regulationMortgage creditEverything elseTotal spendingTotal revenuesDeficit
-$9,949.00-$6,071.00-$5,466.00-$1,640.00-$1,585.00-$1,052.00-$1,018.00-$914.00-$613.00-$550.00-$470.00
-$2,078.00-$31,406.00$18,276.00-$13,130.00
It’s Not EnoughPer HouseholdSocial Security/MedicareDefenseAntipovertyUnemploymentInterest on the debtVeteransʼ benefitsFederal employee retirement benefitsEducationHighways/transitHealth research/regulationMortgage creditEverything elseTotal spendingTotal revenuesDeficit
-$9,949.00-$6,071.00-$5,466.00-$1,640.00-$1,585.00-$1,052.00-$1,018.00-$914.00-$613.00-$550.00-$470.00
-$2,078.00-$31,406.00$18,276.00-$13,130.00
-$21,486
Draconian Example•Keep all taxes
• Cut everything except ...
• Social Security/Medicare
• Defense
• Antipoverty
• Debt Interest
• $4795 deficit
The (Hard) Solution
• Not enough to demand low taxes
• Not enough to cut spending “in general”
• Need to cut spending in the most popular (i.e., most expensive) programs
• By large amounts (44% on average)
Volunteers?
• Who will volunteer to take the hit?
• Social Security? Medicare? Food stamps?
• Reduced defense? Veterans? Retirees?
Social Issues• Sexy, emotional, compelling:
• Immigration enforcement
• Abortion
• Gay marriage
• Drug war
• “Others are doing wrong.”
Fiscal Issues
• Deficits spending is not sexy ...
• ... but with deficits, we follow PIIGS.
• After a debt crisis, social issues will pale.
• We are doing wrong.
What We Can Do
• Send back the free lunch
• Politicians do what they get rewarded for
• Tell politicians to cut spending 44% ...
• ... especially our favorite programs ...
• ... and re-elect them when they do!
• Cutting “billions”? Not serious.
The Things We LovePer HouseholdSocial Security/MedicareDefenseAntipovertyUnemploymentInterest on the debtVeteransʼ benefitsFederal employee retirement benefitsEducationHighways/transitHealth research/regulationMortgage creditEverything elseTotal spendingTotal revenuesDeficit
-$9,949.00-$6,071.00-$5,466.00-$1,640.00-$1,585.00-$1,052.00-$1,018.00-$914.00-$613.00-$550.00-$470.00
-$2,078.00-$31,406.00$18,276.00-$13,130.00
-$21,486
Truth ...
• Not fair; violates expectations
• 44% sooner, or 100% later
• Inflation, confiscation, collapse
• Constitution ignored now? Wait until US bankruptcy. (Argentina 2001)
... or Consequences
Conclusion
• Cutting spending is a true sacrifice
• Lives, fortunes, sacred honor
• A 44% reduction in spending now ...
• ... or Greece later
• Paul M. Jones
• http://paul-m-jones.com
• @pmjones