Hometown Associations and their Present and Future ... Hometown associations fulfill several...
Embed Size (px)
Transcript of Hometown Associations and their Present and Future ... Hometown associations fulfill several...
Hometown Associations and
their Present and Future
New Development Opportunities?
Report commissioned by the
U.S. Agency for International Development
The research and evaluation of this project is part of a group effort of colleagues and institutions
concerned with hometown associations. The study is first dedicated to a much appreciated and
missed colleague, Federico Torres. He analyzed remittance flows and sought to equally
understand the economic contributions of hometown associations. Our conversations about the
importance of these contributions are remembered and acknowledged in this report in his
The study involved meetings and interviews, and data analysis. My colleague Natasha Iskander
played an important role in the initial stages of this project in jointly conducting some of the
interviews in Mexico. I thank Carlos Gonzalez Gutiérrez, now executive director of the Institute
of Mexicans Living Abroad, who provided substantive support to this project with information
and contacts about hometown associations. Carlos believes in the Mexican diaspora and its
national identity. Fernando Creixell of the Mexican Embassy in Washington, and Malú Guerra
at SEDESOL offices in Mexico City, provided very important support in meeting with
government officials in the four Mexican states. I also thank Mario Riestra of the Office of
Attention to Migrants of the state of Puebla for his assistance in identifying government officials.
Diana Álvarez of the Guanajuato office offered us invaluable support to carry out the analysis in
that state. Thanks also to Elizabeth Chavolla Sánchez of the Jalisco office who also dedicated
her time to identify and speak to key officials.
In Washington I thank Michelle Lapointe and her substantive research assistance in preparing the
datasets and editorial work for the study and Gillian Morejon, who with Michelle, worked in
reviewing the literature and carrying out interviews in Chicago and Los Angeles with community
leaders. The team work effort of this project contributed to improve the quality of the study.
Stephanie Larson, Seth Kroop, Eric Jacobstein, and Mariandrea Chamorro also worked in
various stages of this project, particularly in conducting interviews with hometown associations
and preparing the datasets. Finally, thanks to Jeremy Smith at USAID for his comments and
earlier encouragement to conduct this study and commitment to find development partnership
opportunities with HTAs and its diaspora. I also thank Jolyne Sanjak at USAID for her thorough
review of the study.
Transnational migration and globalization have transformed the relationship between the United
States and Latin America. New players have emerged, expanding the scope of international
One player promoting local development is the hometown association (HTA) formed by
immigrants who seek to support their places of origin, maintain relationships with local
communities, and retain a sense of community as they adjust to life in the United States (Orozco
2000). Hometown associations fulfill several functions, from social exchange, to political
influence, to the pursuit of low-scale development goals in their home community.
This report is an assessment of the development capacity of HTAs and the effectiveness of
matching grants. Among the findings in this study are that hometown associations are small
philanthropic organizations that generally provide assistance to their communities of origin and
often participate in collaborative development efforts. The aggregate amount of their
contribution and the support relative to the community needs provides important effect on local
As the report will show, the majority of the associations’ activities involve support to public and
economic infrastructure activities, such as road construction and pavement, electrification, and
construction of school and health facilities.
The study also analyzes a partnership scheme between the three levels of government (local,
state and federal) and hometown associations, known as 3x1. The analysis of 3x1 projects show
that they deliver significant resources to rural areas in Mexico. More importantly, when the
contributions are viewed in the context of the local receiving communities, the impact is more
substantive. Most 3x1 projects involve work in public infrastructure, and there are differences
among states and municipalities.
The report also offers some recommendations geared towards forging a collaborative
relationship between HTAs and institutions such as a foreign aid donors. These
recommendations include technical assistance to identify social development projects,
partnerships similar to current foreign aid donor projects, and support in the provision of a
financial infrastructure in areas where 20 percent of households receive remittances but no
financial institution is present.
The study is based on an analysis of more than one hundred interviews, visits to officials in four
Mexican states and over 30 communities in Zacatecas, Guanajuato, Jalisco and Michoacan. The
study was conducted with a grant from USAID to determine the development role of hometown
1. Hometown Associations, Development and Local Change
This is an assessment of whether HTAs function as development agents and whether
opportunities exist to enhance their capacity.
Among the findings that emerge from this study are that HTAs are generally philanthropic
groups with the capacity to work on various kinds of development projects. Below are some of
1. Mexican HTAs are small philanthropic organizations; 2. Their organizational structure is commensurate to the groups’ proposed goals; 3. The activities focus on basic health, education and public infrastructure; 4. The resources raised are relatively small in volume; 5. Donations are significant to the recipient localities; 6. Partnership with governments enhance development goals.
This report reviews specific patterns of HTAs relating to their partnership capacity and their
goals in promoting development.
Central to this section is a balanced view about the development capacities and opportunities that
HTAs pose for Mexico. These associations perform an array of activities and in many cases
provide a valuable source of social capital and a potential for development. These projects have
a positive development effect on the receiving communities because these projects target the
community’s basic needs.
This report is based on contacts with over 400 Mexican HTAs and interviews of more than 100,
visits to more than twenty communities implementing 3x1 partnership projects, and interviews
with government officials and community leaders in the United States and Mexico during a
period of seven months (see methodology in the appendix).
a. Hometown associations at work and their relationship to development
Hometown associations fulfill several functions, from social exchange and political influence to
the pursuit of low scale development goals in their home community. Organizations made up of
Salvadorans, Guatemalans, Mexicans, Guyanese, Dominicans, as well as Colombians and
Nicaraguans, have increasingly been working to improve their towns.
Although few studies had been conducted on HTAs prior to 2000 (Alarcon 2000, Orozco 2000,
Zabin 1998), there is a growing movement of literature that is paying attention to HTAs.1
The literature has focused on four areas: a) to build a theoretical framework related to
transnationalism or diasporas; b) to introduce new conceptual understandings of migration trends
by providing a description of the attributes of HTAs; c) to provide case studies that may
constitute building blocks from which to generalize; and d) to look at the relationship between
their work and its impact through partnerships with the state.
Central to this literature is that the activism of associations possesses a transnational dimension,
which is tied to strong social networks and capabilities that define their agendas. The literature
has also shown that the practices of these groups stretch into social, political and economic
With the emergence of HTAs and their efforts to improve their communities, it is important to
determine the extent of their ability to participate in development and to forge alliances with
other players. Little is known about the effectiveness of their efforts on local economic
Certain features that make it possible for an organization to work on development projects
include: choosing to promote some form of social, economic, or cultural development, the ability