HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC]...

42
HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICS Prepared for a FNL/BNL Workshop September 16 - 17, 2006 Batavia, Illinois William G. Pariseau University of Utah

Transcript of HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC]...

Page 1: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSELROCK MECHANICS

Prepared for a FNL/BNL WorkshopSeptember 16 - 17, 2006

Batavia, Illinois

William G. PariseauUniversity of Utah

Page 2: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

DISCUSSION OBJECTIVE:

To show why I think the Megaton detector is do-able at the

Homestake Site.

Page 3: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

APPROACH

Present empirical and scientific evidence for project feasibility.

Empirical = 100 yrs operating experience.Scientific = 20 yrs rock mechanics research.

Page 4: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

100-kiloton detector cavern

Page 5: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

10 100-kiloton cavern array (M. Laurenti)

(chlorine detector)

4850 Level(plan view)

Page 6: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

LOCATIONS

*FNL*BNL

Page 7: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER
Page 8: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

ROSS SHAFT – HOMESTAKE MINE

Page 9: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

VERTICALSECTION:

Geology &Pillar Reserve

Page 10: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

PLAN VIEW: Geology, Historic Mining, Pillar Reserve

Central pillar is a 60 ft section in the center of the original 200 ft pillar(brown)

ROSS SHAFT

Page 11: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Ross Shaft pillarview using mine planning software(Homestake fold limbs in brown.)

Four point MPBX’snear Ross Shaft pillar

(Hole collars on 3350 L)

Page 12: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Projects at the Homestake Mine

• 1983-85 Vertical Crater Retreat (VCR) Pillars [US Bureau of Mines Research Contract with the University of Utah & Homestake Mine]

• 1987-90 Cable Bolts (bird cage, conventional) [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME & GMTC]

• 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ]

Page 13: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

VERTICAL CRATER RETREATMINING METHOD

Page 14: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER
Page 15: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Cable bolt drift –cleaning boreholeextensometer holes.

Page 16: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Top sill and hole collarswith stemming bags inpreparation for blasting.

Page 17: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

INSTALLATION OF BOREHOLE EXTENSOMETERS

Page 18: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

MPBX’s after installation

Mechanical reading checkon electrical reading

Page 19: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Data acquisition system

Shaft station relay

Surface station control

Page 20: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER
Page 21: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

How does one get to a satisfactory correlation?

Page 22: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

APPROACH to the PROJECT• Mine measurements for monitoring (safety) and for

data to compare with model calculations.

• Laboratory testing for rock properties, elastic moduli and strengths.

• FE modeling: stress, strain, displacements.

• Model calibration against displacements and extent of yield zones (constrained by anchor loss), elastic-plastic scale factors.

• Use of calibrated model for parametric design analysis.

Page 23: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Laboratory Testing

Poorman

Test core

Page 24: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Laboratory σ-ε testing (anisotropic)

Page 25: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Deep, wide vein mine – well developed foliation

Page 26: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Local direction of anisotropy following folding of the Poorman (yellow), Homestake (pink)and Ellison (orange) formations.

VERTICALSECTION

Colored portionis 1350 ft widex 1830 ft high.

Page 27: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

In situ stressmeasurement

summaryin terms of

principal stressesand

directions.

Page 28: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Stress Measurement

HI-cells

Page 29: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Panel 3Cross Section

Outline of GeologyStope Dimensions

FE Mesh Size

Page 30: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

OVERALL 3D VIEW OF MESH

Page 31: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Finite element excavation sequence(seven cuts shown).

Page 32: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

INSTRUMENTATION and MINEMEASUREMENTS ofDISPLACEMENTS

Page 33: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Jeff Johnson

Kevin DonovanFei Duan Mel Poad

ca 1983

Page 34: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Main Conclusion

With adequate site investigation, large caverns can be reliably engineered

and excavated at Homestake.

Page 35: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

“site investigation”

• Exploration drill holes for geology and geologic structure (mapping).

• Drill core for laboratory testing to determine rock properties (moduli, strengths).

• In situ stress measurements.

Page 36: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Suggestion: Start “small”with a pilot-scale excavation.

• To confirm site exploration data.

• To allow for monitoring with MPBX’s, etc.

• To allow for FE model calibration leading to full-scale design.

Page 37: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Ross Shaft pillarview using mine planning software(Homestake fold limbs in brown.)

Four point MPBX’snear Ross Shaft pillar

(Hole collars on 3350 L)

Page 38: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Ext 8: DisplacementRoss Pillar3350 Level

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

1.25

1.5

1.75

2

2.25

0 365 730 1095 1460 1825 2190 2555 2920 3285 3650

Time since installation, days

Dis

plac

emen

t, in

ches

E8-30' E8-60'E8-90' E8-120'Blasted Center Pillar East Panel(3500 +18 to 3650 +90) Blasted Center Pillar West Panel(3500 +42 to 3650 +90)

6/24/94First Reading Date

Page 39: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

DAY’S END (June, 1994)

Mike Stahl, Chief Rock Mech. E.Bob King, SRL Tech.

Brett PariseauMel Poad, SRL Mgr.

Page 40: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

NUSL offers unique opportunities in a variety ofdisciplines – controlled experiments on an

exceptionally large rock mass – over 350 milesof “tunnels” for access and instrumentation.

Rock mass scale (whole mine experiments) -103 m Stope, cavity scale -102 m

Tunnel, shaft scale -101 mBorehole, “laboratory” scale -10-1 m

Grain, sub-lab scale -10-3 m

CONNECTIONS, RELATIONS, INTERACTIONS,INFORMATION EXCHANGE BTWN SCALES?

Page 41: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

THIS IS THE PLACE!

Page 42: HOMESTAKE MINE/DUSEL ROCK MECHANICSdiwan/nwg/fnal-bnl/sep16-17-2006/FermiSept06... · HME & GMTC] • 1987-2003+ Ross Shaft Pillar study [Cooperative UU/ USBM/ HME ] VERTICAL CRATER

Thank you!