Home( lWPe a - Supreme Court of Florida · 2018. 7. 22. · ßenJy cas4 sza Locbao. ½ neux u.a. aw...

14
anew. coorr oF Floraon Home( lWPe a 3rnTe. or Floeaan. Resfbiwkd on Amal hem mt okshcTcootT o FfPeaL Yd1H Otsbex In erto Yte volusia CooaT/, VLoaion Igøl ße2eV ort JennicTtna Owrt3F] ½E ÑIÎhoríR Huma MetPeeuo2N1 sur6Tea CneaezrmanL Ins1 °1599 CnurìT1 RooD V%ß

Transcript of Home( lWPe a - Supreme Court of Florida · 2018. 7. 22. · ßenJy cas4 sza Locbao. ½ neux u.a. aw...

  • anew. coorr oF Floraon

    Home( lWPe a

    3rnTe. or Floeaan.

    Resfbiwkd

    on Amal hem mt okshcTcootT o FfPeaL Yd1H Otsbex

    In erto Yte volusia CooaT/, VLoaion

    Igøl ße2eV ort JennicTtna

    Owrt3F] ½E ÑIÎhoríR Huma MetPeeuo2N1 sur6Tea CneaezrmanL Ins1 °1599 CnurìT1 RooD V%ß

  • Thßt e nl~ FrvtTrøs L6e o

    TaßLe ol¯ f¾mkaTres . . . . ii

    �570Réllmtr&f6TftTrArtT . . . . 1

    óT&TemenT ol- CMe tw ikT a

    8umfrlfitY DÌ~ f¼Gume6T

    DTitT 01- Li w ort 16A .

    Te, Y1FTK DuTexcT CooET OFnfPrøl CseT. Defwo flT1Tienee Mxas asi liett fkose PLmo»e3 on Tais iricaineere,,1rimminHr �570esfbdoërtTODrt ceDeDTRnTIT 010 NtT ͯolla 3E£Tx.on 3.2)2.Lc15)lO, l'lePJOA STATtE5

    5

    Ce>ri clusinri , . . . . . %

    CISTY1CATE Dl'átimct . �042 , . . . . 9

  • TpN.s c# f¼Tlh_QtTuo

    CMO CfwS. Pola ru . ßRf©1 V. ÚlARÅhrtô , . . . a?3 U.6. Va,g9 tt%3) 91Li v.smv . . . . . . 493 So.al lass, lus¶ (NA· nss) HuriTet 16FnTe . 7

    en & ad ;»N, 94% Cho. M16) mtaf5rfi v.

  • Womics

    rec, enas, Tgnylog sr . 5% a aAs?,%Ho & n.}? thTehstmb v BA6Ld

    )

    &&e o y

    493 Ua lok9, bu U%s) '*dTOM hsrnTo . 3 99 a.3d ist, Wte CHn.alo) h3M vsmTe , . %o 2. ad %3, %8G CHe a whTL v csmTe . . . (M\ &QA 71' D 040lÚln.)Ü3)

    ) a,s

    hem1dhikulcarmuelthaca 3,11) . . 3. me tacco . 3, D)'A (ÒÛ5¼h)

    . . .

    . . .

    .

    . .

    . . y

    a a,s,& 5

    htm Cr>rtiDIGm: f ruch1,aan a . y

    -ne

  • flehmldARi óTáremrdr

    rhonet, ½ntpe, tßñs ÑE AptU4rè i ti thE Dishüd ceud et at al N1% Disk3d, in end k ¼Lusia enurth, ,Ê. Nes=led, c%k nF Hne ums L ne la ¡«L ua c»ue l~iHh bisI1üc. , ¡n niMot vol»sin (nordy, 1%ti Ptßenet wM be Refa as Defended ca Appet a othy pey1 tmme,. Regended wiu hE ÑE & AC5A bl h dA nAB�040péLLec.

    The symk»l c Appent wM be Refusel

    -O-

    -rhe emphs appen u he added fite dy Re e

  • :Trfiremeär o¥ rtee nøgnæs.

    1e Ks ines¼et cass, RGieset was Conskd and ónthnceJ 4t> CRims5 bl~ 15tje) ineskummf, ßnHeay othm kd moedre. ½knee was ddeceJ incomwe h cs ¼ni niQ u�541es a&ced in med m&;on l¾ healmenf.* ½ Depnt�041md em and haof cA kne nnee a era ckkmneJ the PF MA ÑEMÁe Compekn} ptocad '3 án) nnd Certfatieel mee

    e ceikün l'ù i wnludre Conmihm+ in an r2 rF 4t he plea nenein 9 'nùr counse L next que

    ed he Couch b appoin nn mped +6 E AlunÑ Ñnt enunset is> ttHke m wei Li he¼l

    b e, liew nnA rdea is plea. Cae.nynk n, py a- 3.

    %n) Coott rshed a kn b'hse eb>a ch as Conkeey ¼ thue 3.26 at ½wtes ße oppnin d ol'tuw ot mote speds rk15 EquAll dc& WÉÑ fä$ hA- tin) �522unseL tot Reques aesina apedMd . k>ul, hwe«e, hoicel Archeed blamne CcM>eknt h

    nd ¼ol DE Erth£e h bA 6 0 & más.

    C ee f a Al %is Cood h d n e 25th

    i e k na uws ¼und incompekd I on o

    aa>3.

    o r A ocob Lfgeh fd

  • O ai nRDacause the Role:s edabideel ts ned runde menk) (bn5%en) pe&has wae d hÊEA An ¾ese ) c we riwet esay hat%e viJeckpe-uheb oboulJ hrwe been áu gemeJ kaseJ upon papa l»pl fkmipis - clíd itel "cenkibuh h" is (brwidad ~The Ru F. b 0003 REiblÎ bric. is loul rib f%w he r*ls of pdmed h ajmp Smens tfd noteMe and itkeni cons½£nn3 eepas.'

    Both kal and Bä¼d ceaek> ba RdeJ con¼q to Moeik gules or ceiminni fundocea.vsetwum 3 ato tank:q WW (a\ anel ½is eme£s peoede, in Dtùen , pen? when d Cnids Cortk*s id ih

    As ej ks imue. n imeems oF]imes Ard edahl e; Ñ6m Ìili RÜtt Peb66 fY16i1M5 offhis

    Íó5dE. Übwevé£, fh e] AÑg DH Ofh'l % 2011, d an ráclenkrey enei , 6%k 6¥ Mo¢ik ennrekd ¼td ½e,case La e line&csWaks and Monk Rak,3 o reiminni Pecuebeu, ieea a Con½ny henem neds ¼ Laid. nsa avas). ~Tht& 1o% 16% 0%·a016).

    asse ad t½ aswas Da sad d to%.

    '7. 659 &% \D, 1O CÑn.Geo3X¶uoliK$ idàidth,¾d 60. w an:7N C%ma

  • E11tmicLolf¼60mW

    ResPonded cs»ci»ded th t f%cá has corrhnae5 Ráse the6nne claim, uk has been Considued on e mesib, eksfused of h the temi r oef Anheew

    is coud on mulNb occasions fikTwe amis fÛ ÜL E_gubì 'Ê2bMbH CÍhusE D w00R. 6MÑi Übrt5iffu�570

    uws)hmed h adhess \\¼uns of irwidéus &ces dibn undeathels irtcl f¼y pensi.shd Asfdy

    rt the kdmed of h1mk wh&e

    oala ne%1adion a eF¼e Mee a cass %ri 6½ Cand elepee fb&et o his a ht

    _$____

    n tes»n , such nesne on e tw as Irteffeåve f½sis¼dte oP(boHôel, 6tc, 5% 6 .ad 131t>, 13N Øle fl¶)(kDCwn, J., Obdcutein

    nu nn lot yóWe, an aas?,%He c i tùbuo disadììl

  • r nY Law ori f4fbt

    RGuajir

    T% Ì9% hETt1Er CoutT oY f4fblCaneT Ot%eo PeTiTwen huac, arel ½tute feet ÑénDmiss on Wis Irtromf%rr Olmm Wkrt RésfbtBruiT Obricmeo ThT IT C5D ní;r l'ellow átmee amwlsx0 l'Leti�523starés

    FoR f41) the Rr:teensólfikd fïkew Cbehdence H thi DufCome b uddemned and �040$isGood

    is clém ard,¼ekt y s neA«rtet h File any l'ue¼tt pense makes on is claim.

    f%k,at« roseds un he is erk%J h n new uilhnd p ni se k>nsed ori½ea½:s Failuee dischseÃd u e s.aioww tg agaiees an y

    pe¼cf hmei , fwl ¼el CowL hwk), iril'nem h m r#½e 11 % ßis Rde. %is chm hnsmee t sdet e unik cs¼s and oeda superme cwd

    FCNbriS I d , 393 Üó> T 3, $ 7 Ü�570o

    f½ì , tea sn.al 1%z18? CMaa»sYb Idvh cs4nk Mei 6eaA aCPN CH n. m5)C uoht

    &th a ¼al cru¢si is Rgo h Lsdoss otinlim

  • o e, vn d W c acou

    e boden idoøuf%d Fa eenbh esice e ucu\pn¼ na imprwhi µ tons tomfully ne ehedenSy 60½eesed k>y E Y 6, Art [M hEØhsé

    ¼6 esiJac2 uws makea),¾e e eFenM tons pee skirkÍFfildE6@, 523 us 2M asl·u DMhse akg Luep.dete %o cc,. %3 716 C¼. acolT meek ße makeinÜy peen t e n'ßenee musf demendeate a My �040lofReasonnhle pn and theappa sr Evidr«c oem disclosed htke · oa Fe¼WER [00U

    2n . ns i pg ke undædejetW , r,undea ban quæa n pabehiny aiFRcid h unkmias hal; cz ir1 e uèceme,áa, Lky,%s a n+9 l3¡ 6echlco, 6%ckhi, 527 u,s.,nt21e; urzihAshr .v. Ba�040y?a o.s2 ba (m3)(ex e aghk

    E

  • Rnks , Ne uefnN li>R the Lomacnueks =n Co . et ks �040Íìéte ReasonAUrs £oorteht�040net is a h lieve Oe Pehionet 'my l>e (bmpehd not W ie et ne 'ks intet0 ehn " Tirglé_v.c¼ð3b & -d atA .m CH A. 1 vsKgueg cc3S veskh5 6o ad 8%,5°i9 Øin. MD1).

    In SE. O O¥E CASns, le Le (sin-see. u

  • ¶>\rloot h 'T'\-\ñ 6 bcA RésTpacr \dAy£.._.

    n.orn s,10, A w o L\ - F%hbous FoohA«¥ 523L P9Eal v ons1oEJiL94.

    A\scd ny PRiers cc>uns As.sènq cva -Ti>3o cxassvoas ?

    IF ~T\rve. O c>nc½ i checs Í55o E M C i h Ic nS:C n ns lÅ ac 041e.c5por&>ar*, c'BcA emr¾ (')rkr cl She cb Ma. 1

    . 9-oa l se:g App "C." 1, a mos+ 1re ru+eA4vva*-AppeMan+ w as cergcese.n+e.d b pr w a+e enoese b m,c±æ1 Ma+Sie gçt Ese9 Fta. 7c Ar>, O\2 \o8O O Apr il ao , 'Ac3 i i , Coonv le A an Amendeck Mc+ oi 254îTö % ac_ate, \ ea , 'NoAc3men4 AnA Senkenc e. ( ub 9.o oen4 h an 254.* hear t r$c¼n4 ian, as c..on, s cae. A c, o A r i \ acy ae> i \ [vson adm¼Aed 4hat no gexas u:.... 4 i n, nS OS 4Yve ekScan Aan4 s cerv3ç>e+encz w made. hefe>ce. N was ¡¾¶n, c a c\ $>i\+g c>n c3eko her \s , aoo4 (See_ Appen a i x " A" 3 v ::N ,

    \-4awen.c m eo &S m 4 avor 04 + S+ a:4 e_ +he.'T-r i a Ti'okf 5+a+e d. +ha+ 14Scy.c cz>o\ A no+ Se+ re1ie \')O de- ( 570-J '% .300 $ C Van m 3c h 4h2 C cv Ur4s Or $r'3 \est a4e-c4 " -Tyy-ce is no atsucnent thak the de-Prend eM4 Ro¾nc4 m no+ a \ eS ad evne [see Âg een cb i x » & 1 'The.. Conct St>h se q>»en4 \ u cko éA fe \ ieS ,

    -W) aeç>e \ l an+s- Seem c1 pr W Me)A¾eroea W as1r , I¼n¼ \ l'). maz.av- Ésq F\c4, 7;>ar Me ((.o 31 I mi ma2_ar Aç>ecaba 4e the s ScA + a +he.

    O \ ( ns 09 an --L n i uh \ Scie4 r asea nS +he S ame r1n a we n4 a t Se,n+ a. nc_, n E.c ce r (sæ. Apç>en a, y

  • & liti5 6 CortsfillMDHhl.óEE 'Èrt k, 53(o Sad fd 20�040'll ±dfdh, 973 6t>. ad IM , 1A5'1 CHA. l%5h

    1k ½tinì cnud whs mseakd w% Pereble c¢euds b quesün Peh ' Hræts mcò) ampdas % km pi ne es c , twid thas, uns R uinJ k> Ru\E n% rtéÊ E ÔÌØh 5 o rnon Exped u hol Cm e e hrs H lótt nf 61È1X b, f es 7-°l)

    COHcLust_ost

    ofL the Rmesnrts

  • .Cr£nhcáts oFeseisce

    HEte£10£i W th tr hue thd Cetgrcl y has bém beryAed 8¼ønd6erieen L

    n P

    cc Honeaeßle PhME Ln a eer ol, Ttk oyPab b i TedÍ trt�041n e amHase, by

    vio u . mtril ort A o Au 9012>