HLURB Case Answer

8/9/2019 HLURB Case Answer

1/5

Republic of the PhilippinesOce of the President

HOUSING AND LAND USE REGULATOR !OARDN"tion"l #"pit"l Re$ion

NHA #o%pound& '"l(""n A)enueDili%"n& *ue+on #it(

,u"n Del" #ru+#o%pl"in"nt

-)ersus- HLUR! #"se NO. ///////

Ne0 S"n ,ose !uildersRespondent

1---------------------------------------------------1

Ne0 S"n ,ose !uilders

Third- P"rt( #o%pl"in"nt

-)ersus-

Go)ern%ent Ser)ice Insur"nce S(ste%Third-P"rt( Defened"nt

ANS2ER 2ITH THIRD PART #O3PLAINT AND #OUNTER-#LAI3

Respondent NE2 SAN ,OSE !UILDERS & IN#. 4NS,!I5 b( counsel respectfull(st"tes6

I.AD3ISSION

7. Respondent NS,!I "d%its the "lle$"tion cont"ined in the follo0in$ p"r"$r"phsof the #o%pl"int6

". P"r"$r"phs 7 "nd 8& insof"r "s the person"l circu%st"nce of thep"rties.

b. P"r"$r"phs 9&:&;&c Deni"ls

8. ?or re"son@f"cts st"ted in its Ar%"ti)e Alle$"tion@Defenses herein belo0"nd@or l"c of infor%"tion sucient t for% " belief "s to its truth or f"lsit(&respondent NS,!I speci>c"ll( denies the "lle$"tions in the follo0in$p"r"$r"phs of the #o%pl"int6


2/5

". P"r"$r"ph


3/5

". #o%pl"in"nt h"s no c"use of "ction "$"inst the defend"nts NS,!I "ndthe co%pl"int st"tes none.

i. #o%pl"in"nt "d%its th"t GSIS is the o0ner of the GSIS 3ETROHO3ES

ii. In the "fore%entioned Deed of Absolute S"le & it is cle"rl(stipul"ted th"t NS,!I h"s "ssi$ned "ll its ri$hts & interest& "nd

p"rticip"tion o)er the subFect condo%iniu% unit to GSIS.iii. Since the title of the subFect propert( is in the n"%e "nd

possession of GSIS& respondent NS,!I ob)iousl( 0ill not be "bleto co%pl( 0ith the reBuest of the co%pl"in"nts to rele"se the%the "fore%entioned condo%iniu% certi>c"te of title o)er thesubFect propert(.

i). As "fore%entioned ri$ht "fter the p"(%ents b( the co%pl"in"ntsof the subFect condo%iniu% units purch"se price "nd prior tothe >lin$ of the inst"nt co%pl"int& respondent NS,!I h"d "lre"d(reBuested for the rele"se of the titles fro% GSIS bec"use it is"lre"d( 0illin$ "nd re"d( to re%it the sh"re of the GSIS in theproceeds of the s"le of the condo%iniu% unit "nd the

correspondin$ %ort$"$e )"lue of its ri$ht in the "fore%entionedDeed of Absolute S"le in f")or of the co%pl"in"nt.

). GSIS up to d"te h"d not (et "cted on the respondents reBuestfor the rele"se of the title "nd for the si$nin$ of the Deed ofAbsolute S"le.

.#OUNTER #LAI3

;. Respondent NS,!I re-ple"ds b( refence & the fore$oin$ "e$"tions "nd b( 0"(of countercl"i%& further ")ers6

". As " result of the %"licious >lin$ of the present #o%pl"int&not0ithst"ndin$ th"t co%pl"int no0 th"t he h"s no c"use of "ction&respondent NS,!Is reput"tion is bes%irched entitlin$ it to %or"ld"%"$es in the conser)"ti)e su% of Php 8;&.

b. To ser)e "s "n e"%ple for the public $ood "nd to deter other fro%institutin$ pl"inl( un%eritorious co%pl"ints. #o%pl"ints should be"ssessed ee%pl"r( d"%"$es of "t le"st Php 8;&.

c. To defend itself fro% the b"seless suit& respondent NS,!I is constr"inedto en$"$e the ser)ices of the counsel for the "$reed fee of Php7& 0hich the pl"intiJ should rei%burse to the respondent NS,!I.

I.THIRD-PART #O3PLAINT


4/5

b. The defend"nt GSIS is the o0ner of the condo%iniu% unit subFect ofthis co%pl"int "nd h"s the title thereto bein$ sou$ht b( the co%pl"int.

c. 2hile it holds the %ort$"$e on the interest of the respondent NS,!Io)er the subFect condo%iniu% unit it h"s $i)en its consent to the s"leof the subFect unit b( NS,!I to the p"(%ent of NS,!Is %ort$"$eobli$"tion proportioned unit.

d. Respondent NS,!I is re"d( "nd 0illin$ to p"( respondent GSIS the%ort$"$e debt correspondin$ to the subFect unit but it stubbornl(refuses to rele"se the titles to the subFect propert(.

e. 3oreo)er& NS,!I h"s "lre"d( eecuted the correspondin$ Deed ofAbsolute S"le o)er the propert(& (et GSIS refused to si$n the s"%e.

f. #onseBuentl( in the e)ent the re%ote possibilit( th"t defend"nt NS,!Iis held li"ble for "n( cl"i% of #o%pl"in"nt& respondent GSIS should beheld li"ble for the s"%e.

PRAER

2HERE?ORE& it is respectfull( pr"(ed th"t Fud$%ent be rendered dis%issin$

the co%pl"int for f"ilure to co%pl( 0ith the rules "$"inst foru% shoppin$ "nd@orutter l"c of %erit "nd6

7. Dis%issin$ the inst"nt co%pl"int for utter l"c of %erit "$"inst respondentNS,!IK

8. On its countercl"i% & th"t co%pl"in"nt be ordered to p"( NS,!I the follo0in$su%s6

". Php 8;& "s %or"l d"%"$esb. Php 8;& "s ee%pl"r( d"%"$esc. Php 7& "s "ttorne(s feesd. #ost of suit

9. In the re%ote possibilit( respondent NS,!I is held li"ble for "n( "%ount toco%pl"in"nts& respondent GSIS be ordered to rei%burse for the s"%e.

Respondent NS,!I pr"(s for such other relief "nd re%edies "s "re Fust "nd eBuit"bleunder the pre%ises.

*ue+on #it( 3"rch 8;& 87.

ATT. ,OSE SAN ,UAN#ounsel for the Defend"nt

789 GH, St. *ue+on #it(Roll No. 789:;

PTR No. 789:; ,une 8;& 7CCC& *ue+on #it(I!P No. 789:; ,une 8;& 7CCC *ue+on #it(

#op( ?urnished6

Att(. ,u"n #"stillo#ounsel for the #o%pl"in"nt789 ?GH St. *ue+on #it(


5/5

E1PLANATION

Due to l"c of ")"il"ble %essen$eri"l st"J durin$ the %"teri"l ti%e cop( ofthe fore$oin$ ple"din$ 0ill be ser)ed upon the "ddressee b( re$istered %"il "ssho0n b( " re$istr( receipt hereto "tt"ched

HLURB Case Answer

Documents

Transcript of HLURB Case Answer