Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
-
Upload
eric-goldman -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 1/97
2S'3% )-+,8))28,(-786-'8
2368,'%630-2%'39683*%44)%07
.)**6)=%ERH0-7%7,-00 MRHMZMHYEPP]ERHSRFILEPJSJEPP SXLIVWWMQMPEVP]WMXYEXIH 4PEMRXMJJW Z
7XYF,YF-RGHFEf7XYF,YFgIXEP (IJIRHERXW
()*)2(%28%44)00%28e7&6-)*
*VSQ+YMPJSVH'SYRX]':7
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 2/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 3/97
MM
7XYF,YF(MH2SX1EXIVMEPP]'SRXVMFYXI8S8LI-PPIKEP6IWEPI
4VMGI
)ZIR-J8LI'SYVX4VSTIVP]'SRWMHIVIH7XYF,YFeW)RXMVI&YWMRIWW7XYF,YF(MH2SX1EXIVMEPP]'SRXVMFYXI8S-PPIKEP8MGOIX4VMGIW
7XYF,YF(MH2SX)RGSYVEKI-PPIKEP8MGOIX4VMGIW
-: 8,)'3968)6632)3970=,)0(8,%8789&,9&:-30%8)(8,)9(84%
% %q:MSPEXMSR-W2SX%4IV7I9(84%:MSPEXMSR
& 8LI9(84%'PEMQ*EMPW&IGEYWI8LIVI;EW2S(IGITXMSRSV-RNYV]
'32'097-32 ')68-*-'%8)3*'3140-%2')
')68-*-'%8)3*7)6:-')
%44)2(-<
97'q %TT
2'+7q %TT
2'+7q %TT
2'+7q %TT
2'+7q %TT
%(()2(91
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 4/97
MMM
8%&0)3*'%7)7%2(%98,36-8-)7
'EWIW
%QSHISZ&IZIVP]2'%TT
&EVVIXXZ6SWIRXLEP 'EPXL'EP
&EVXPIXX1MPPMRK'S04Z;EPRYX+VSZI%YGXMSR
ERH6IEPX]'S2'%TT
&EX^IPZ7QMXL*HXL'MV
&EX^IPZ7QMXL*HXL'MV
&YVKIWWZ=SYV,SYWISJ6EPIMKL2'
&YW'EFPMRK-RGZ=SOIP]
2'%TT
(EPXSRZ'EQT2'
(EVXZ'VEMKWPMWX-RG*7YTTH2(-PP
(SIZ1]7TEGI-RG*HXL'MV
)H[EVHWZ;IWX 2'%TT
*EMV,SYWMRK'SYRGMPSJ7ER*IVRERHS:EPPI]Z6SSQQEXIWGSQ*HXL'MV TEWWMQ
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 5/97
MZ
*ILVWZ7XYF,YF-RG'EWI2SWPMTST
3V'MV'X7ITX
*8'Z%GGYWIEVGL*HXL'MV
*YVVZ*SRZMPPI1SVMWI]6IEPX]-RG2'%TT
+IRXV]ZI&E]-RG'EP%TTXL
+MFWSRZ'VEMKWPMWX-RG 2S'MZ;07(2=.YRI
+PSFEP6S]EPXMIW0XHZ<GIRXVMG:IRXYVIW00' *7YTTH(%VM^
+SHHEVHZ+SSKPI-RG*7YTTH2('EP
+VIIRZ%30*HH'MV
,EVVMWSRZ'MX]SJ7ERJSVH 2'%TT
.SLRWSRZ4LSIRM\1YX0MJI-RW'S2'
.YVMRZ+SSKPI-RG
*7YTTH)('EP
0MKKIXX+VSYT-RGZ7YREW2'%TT
0]SRW4cWLMT04Z1SVVMW'SWXYQIW-RG*HXL'MV
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 6/97
Z
1EVWLEPPZ1MPPIV 2'
1MPKVEQZ3VFMX^;SVPH[MHIIXEP%H2.7YTIV'X
1]IVW'LETQER-RGZ8LSQEW+)ZERW-RG2'
2IQIX'LIZVSPIX0XHZ'SRWYQIVEJJEMVWGSQ -RG*HXL'MV
2'7XEXI&HSJ6IKMWXVEXMSRJSV4VSJcP)RKcVWERH0ERH7YVZI]SVWZ-RXcP&YW1EGL'SVT2'%TT
24700'Z7XYF,YF-RG 2S&07;01EWW7YTIV'X.ER
3HIPPZ0IKEP&YGOW00' 2'%TT
3TWELPZ4MRILYVWX-RG2'%TT
7LEVTIZ;SVPERH 2'
7LMEQMPMZ6IEP)WXEXI+VSYTSJ2I[=SVO 2S2=0)<-72='X%TT.YRI
7XIXWIVZ8%44LEVQ4VSHW-RG2'%TT
7XSRIVZ)FE]-RG'MZ2S;0'EP7YTIV'X2SZ
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 7/97
ZM
9RMXIH0EFW-RGZ/Y]OIRHEPP 2'%TT
9RMXIH0EFW-RGZ/Y]OIRHEPP 2'
9RMZIVWEP'SQQcR7]W-RGZ0]GSW-RG*HWX'MV
;EPOIVZ*PIIX[SSH,SQIWSJ2SVXL'EVSPMRE2'
;IMRWXIMRZI&E]-RG 2S'MZ;07(2=.YRI
>IVERZ%QIVMGER3RPMRI-RG*HXL'MV
7XEXYXIW
97'q TEWWMQ
2'+7q TEWWMQ
2'+7q
2'+7q
2'+7q
2'+7q TEWWMQ
6YPIW
2'6'-:4F
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 8/97
2S'3% )-+,8))28,(-786-'8
2368,'%630-2%'39683*%44)%07
.)**6)=%ERH0-7%7,-00 MRHMZMHYEPP]ERHSRFILEPJSJEPP SXLIVWWMQMPEVP]WMXYEXIH 4PEMRXMJJW Z
7XYF,YF-RGHFEf7XYF,YFgIXEP (IJIRHERXW
()*)2(%28%44)00%28e7&6-)*
-779)746)7)28)(
- (-( 8,) 86-%0 '3968 )66 -2 ()8)61-2-2+ 8,%8789&,9&e7 '32(9'8 ;%7 79&.)'8 83 %2( :-30%8)( 2'+7q#
-- (-( 8,) 86-%0 '3968 )66 -2 ()8)61-2-2+ 8,%8789&,9&-7238)28-80)(83 -1192-8= 92()67)'8-323*8,)'31192-'%8-327()')2'=%'8#
--- (-( 8,) 86-%0 '3968 )66 -2 ()8)61-2-2+ 8,%8789&,9&e7 '32(9'8 '3278-898)( %2 92*%-6 %2(()')48-:) 86%() 46%'8-') -2 :-30%8-32 3* 2'+7q#
*VSQ+YMPJSVH'SYRX]':7
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 9/97
-2863(9'8-32
8LMWETTIEPGSRGIVRWERMWWYISJJMVWXMQTVIWWMSRMR2SVXL'EVSPMREMRZSPZMRK
XLI MRXIVTVIXEXMSR ERH ETTPMGEXMSR SJ E JYRHEQIRXEP JIHIVEP MQQYRMX] EKEMRWX
PMEFMPMX] JSV XLMVHTEVX] FILEZMSV SGGYVVMRK SR MRXIVEGXMZI [IFWMXIW PMOI 7XYF,YF
%KEMRWXXLIKVIEX[IMKLXSJEYXLSVMX]XLIGSYVXIVVIHMRVIJYWMRKXSEGGSVH7XYF,YF
MQQYRMX] JVSQ WYMX YRHIV WIGXMSR SJ XLI 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX
f'(%g97'q-JPIJXXSWXERHXLMWHIGMWMSRXLVIEXIRWXSHMWVYTXSRPMRI
EGXMZMXMIWERHGSQQIVGIEGVSWWEFVSEHVERKISJEGXSVWWMRKPMRKSYX2SVXL'EVSPMRE
EWELSWXMPIJSVYQJSVWYGLIRXIVTVMWIW
-RXLMWGEWI7XYF,YFE[IFWMXIXLEXTVSZMHIWEQEVOIXTPEGIJSVXLMVHTEVXMIW
XSFY]ERHWIPPXMGOIXWXSIRXIVXEMRQIRXIZIRXW[EWJSYRHXSLEZIZMSPEXIH2SVXL
'EVSPMREeW9RJEMVERH(IGITXMZI8VEHI4VEGXMGIW%GXf9(84%g2'+7q
EWEVIWYPXSJWEPIWQEHI SRXLI WMXIF]E XLMVHTEVX]VIWIPPIVf,SPSLERgMR
ZMSPEXMSRSJ2SVXL'EVSPMREeWQE\MQYQVIWEPIXMGOIXTVMGIWXEXYXI2'+7q
(IWTMXIXLIGSYVXeWI\TVIWWJMRHMRKW XLEX7XYF,YF [EWRSX XLI WIPPIV SJXLI
XMGOIXWEXMWWYIERHHMHRSX WIXXLITVMGISJXLIWIXMGOIXWXLIGSYVXGSRGPYHIHXLEX
7XYF,YFeWGSRHYGX[EWWYFNIGXXSERHZMSPEXIHq8LMWVYPMRKMWGSRXVEV]
XSXLIXIVQWSJXLIWXEXYXI[LMGLSRMXWJEGIETTPMIWSRP]XSEGXYEPWIPPIVWSJXMGOIXW
EW [IPP EW 2SVXL 'EVSPMRE TYFPMG TSPMG] [LMGL RS[ PMOI QSWX WXEXIW I\TVIWWP]
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 10/97
EPPS[WXMGOIXWXSFIWSPHSR[IFWMXIWMRI\GIWWSJXLIEQSYRXWIXJSVXLMRq
7II 2'+7q
8LI GSYVX MQTVSTIVP] VINIGXIH 7XYF,YFeW '(% HIJIRWI F] ETTP]MRK ER
YRTVIGIHIRXIH ERH IVVSRISYW PIKEP EREP]WMW %PXLSYKL PIEHMRK '(% GEWI PE[
QEOIWGPIEVXLEXE[IFWMXIPSWIWMXWMQQYRMX]SRP][LIRMXfQEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIWg
XSXLI GVIEXMSRSV HIZIPSTQIRXSJ XLI EPPIKIHP] MPPIKEP GSRXIRXEX MWWYI XLI GSYVX
EHSTXIH E PS[IV ZEKYI fIRGSYVEKIQIRXg WXERHEVH XLEX MW MRGSQTEXMFPI [MXL XLI
'(%eWMRXIRHIHFVSEHWGSTIEW[IPPEWTVIZEMPMRKEYXLSVMXMIW8LIGSYVXXLIRLIPH
XLEX f7XYF,YF IRGSYVEKIH MPPIKEP GSRXIRXg IZIR XLSYKL MX [EW YRHMWTYXIH XLEX
,SPSLEREPSRIWIPIGXIHXLIVIWEPITVMGIJSVXLIWSPHSYX,ERREL1SRXEREXMGOIXWLI
WSPH XS 4PEMRXMJJW ,EH XLI GSYVX ETTPMIH XLI GSVVIGX WXERHEVH MX [SYPH LEZI
HMWQMWWIHXLIGSQTPEMRXWMRGI7XYF,YFHMHRSXQEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIXSXLIGVIEXMSR
SVHIZIPSTQIRXSJXLIEPPIKIHP]MPPIKEPGSRXIRXi MIXLIVIWEPITVMGIMRZMSPEXMSRSJ
q
8LIGSYVXEPWSIVVIHF]RSXJSGYWMRKSRXLI GSRXIRXEXMWWYIHIWTMXIWIXXPIH
PE[QEOMRKGPIEVXLEXMXMWSRP]XLEXGSRXIRXXLEXMWXSFIGSRWMHIVIHYRHIVXLI'(%
-RWXIEH XLI GSYVX JSGYWIH SR XSSPW JIEXYVIW ERH TVSKVEQW XLEX [IVI EZEMPEFPI
KIRIVEPP]XSXLMVHTEVX]YWIVWSR7XYF,YFFYX[LMGLXLIGSYVXJSYRH[IVIRSXYWIH
F],SPSLER)ZIRXLIWIXSSPW[LMGLTVSZMHIXMGOIXTVMGIWWSYKLXF]SXLIVYWIVW
JSVGSQTEVEFPIXMGOIXWHMHRSX[EVVERXWXVMTTMRK7XYF,YFSJMQQYRMX]FIGEYWIE
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 11/97
VIWIPPIVMWJVIIXSGSRWMHIVSVVINIGXXLIMRJSVQEXMSRMRWIXXMRKXLITVMGI-RIZIV]
MRWXERGI MX MW [MXLMR XLI VIWIPPIVeW WSPI HMWGVIXMSR XS GLSSWI [LEXIZIV TVMGI LI
[ERXW
8LIGSYVXEPWSGVMXMGM^IH7XYF,YFJSVEPPS[MRKERHIRGSYVEKMRK0EVKI7IPPIVW
h[LSYRPMOI,SPSLEREVIMRXLIFYWMRIWWSJVIWIPPMRKPEVKIEQSYRXWSJXMGOIXWhXS
YWIXLIMVWMXIFIGEYWIXLIMVWEPIWWYTTSWIHP]MRJPYIRGIXLIQEVOIXTVMGISJXMGOIXW
[LMGLXLIGSYVXJSYRHQE]VIWYPXMRTVMGIWLMKLIVSVPS[IVXLERXLIJEGIEQSYRX
HITIRHMRK SR XLI IZIRX &YX [IFWMXIW HS RSX PSWI XLIMV MQQYRMX] FEWIH SR
EPPS[MRKSV IRGSYVEKMRKYWIVW XSYWIXLIMVWMXIWRSV HSXLI] PSWIMQQYRMX] IZIR
[LIRMPPIKEPGSRHYGXSGGYVWSVMWPMOIP]XSSGGYVSRXLIMVWMXIW'SRKVIWWeWMRXIRXMR
TEWWMRK XLI '(% XS JSWXIV XLI VSFYWX HIZIPSTQIRX SJ XLI -RXIVRIX F] TVSXIGXMRK
-RXIVRIX WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW EKEMRWX PMEFMPMX] JSV YWIVKIRIVEXIH GSRXIRX [SYPH FI
WMKRMJMGERXP] YRHIVQMRIH MJ XLI GSYVXeW VYPMRK [IVI YTLIPH 7YGL ER SYXGSQI
[SYPHLEZI E TEVXMGYPEVP] GLMPPMRK IJJIGX SR-RXIVRIX GSQQIVGI FIGEYWI MX[SYPH
MQTSWIXVIQIRHSYWGSWXWSR[IFWMXIWXSTSPMGIYWIVWERHXLIMQQIRWIZSPYQISJ
XLMVHTEVX]GSRXIRXTSWXIHSRXLIMVWMXIW
*YVXLIVIZIRMJfIRGSYVEKIQIRXg[IVIXLIGSVVIGXWXERHEVHXLIVIGSVHHSIW
RSXWYTTSVXEJMRHMRKXLEX7XYF,YFIRGSYVEKIHXMGOIXVIWEPITVMGIWMRZMSPEXMSRSJ
q8LIXMGOIXWMRUYIWXMSR[IVIXSEWSPHSYX,ERREL1SRXEREGSRGIVX%W
XLIGSYVXJSYRHfTYVGLEWIVWSJXMGOIXWXSWSPHSYXIZIRXWWLSYPHLEZII\TIGXIH
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 12/97
XLEXXLIXMGOIXW[IVIRSXSJJIVIHEXJEGIZEPYIg6T8LMWMWRSXFIGEYWISJ
ER]XLMRK 7XYF,YF HSIW MX MW FIGEYWI SJ WYTTP] ERH HIQERH JSV E TSTYPEV
IRXIVXEMRQIRXIZIRX
*MREPP] XLI GSYVX IVVIH MR VYPMRK SR XLI QIVMXW XLEX 7XYF,YF ZMSPEXIH XLI
9(84%IZIRXLSYKLXLIMWWYI[EWRSXTVIWIRXIHXSXLIGSYVXERHRSHMWGSZIV]
[EW GSRHYGXIH SR XLMW GPEMQ 8LI GSYVX WYQQEVMP] LIPH 7XYF,YF PMEFPI SR XLI
KVSYRHXLEXEZMSPEXMSRSJqMW TIVWIE9(84%ZMSPEXMSR8LMWVYPMRK[EW
[VSRKEWEQEXXIVSJPE[FIGEYWIXLIVIMWRSWXVMGXPMEFMPMX]MRXLMWGSRXI\X6EXLIV
4PEMRXMJJW QYWX TVSZI XLEX TE]MRK TVMGIW EFSZI JEGI ZEPYI [EW XLI VIWYPX SJ
fHIGITXMZIgSVfYRJEMVgGSRHYGXF]7XYF,YFERHXLIVIGSVHHSIWRSXWYTTSVXWYGL
EHIXIVQMREXMSR
-R WYQ XLI GSYVXeW VYPMRK WLSYPH FI VIZIVWIH ERH NYHKQIRX IRXIVIH MR
7XYF,YFeWJEZSV%PXIVREXMZIP] XLMW'SYVXWLSYPHVIZIVWIERHVIQERHJSVJYVXLIV
TVSGIIHMRKWSR4PEMRXMJJWeMRHMZMHYEPGPEMQW
78%8)1)283*8,)'%7)
3R 3GXSFIV 4PEMRXMJJW JMPIH XLIMV 'SQTPEMRX EW E TYXEXMZI GPEWW
EGXMSREPPIKMRKXLEX7XYF,YFZMSPEXIHqERHXLEXXLIZMSPEXMSR[EWE9(84%
ZMSPEXMSR %JXIVGSRWMHIVMRK7XYF,YFeWQSXMSRXSHMWQMWWXLIGSYVXHMWQMWWIHEPP
GPEMQWI\GITXJSVXLIEPPIKIH9(84%ZMSPEXMSR-RVYPMRKSRXLIQSXMSRXLIGSYVX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 13/97
HIXIVQMRIH XLEX HMWGSZIV] GSRGIVRMRK 7XYF,YFeW '(% MQQYRMX] HIJIRWI [EW
RIGIWWEV]ERHFMJYVGEXIHXLIGEWIERHPMQMXIHXLIWGSTISJHMWGSZIV]WSPIP]XSXLEX
MWWYI6TT
3R %YKYWX 4PEMRXMJJW JMPIH XLIMV 7IGSRH %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX
EPPIKMRKXLEX7XYF,YFZMSPEXIHqFIGEYWIMXEPPIKIHP]fWSPHERHSVJEGMPMXEXIH
ERH TEVXMGMTEXIH MR XLI WEPIg SJ XMGOIXW XS 4PEMRXMJJW f[MXL ORS[PIHKIg XLEX XLI
XMGOIXW [IVI VIWSPH MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ q 6 TT 7XYF,YF HIRMIH
4PEMRXMJJWe GPEMQW 6 T -R EHHMXMSR XS '(% MQQYRMX] 7XYF,YF EWWIVXIH
X[IPZISXLIVEJJMVQEXMZIHIJIRWIWMRGPYHMRKXLEX4PEMRXMJJWJEMPIHXSWXEXIEGPEMQ
JSVVIPMIJERHXLEXRSEGXSVSQMWWMSRF]7XYF,YFGEYWIH4PEMRXMJJWeHEQEKIWMJ
ER]6TT
%JXIV GSQTPIXMRK '(% MQQYRMX] HMWGSZIV] XLI TEVXMIW JMPIH WYQQEV]
NYHKQIRXQSXMSRWSRXLI'(%HIJIRWI3R*IFVYEV]XLIGSYVXKVERXIH
4PEMRXMJJWeQSXMSRERHHIRMIH7XYF,YFeWQSXMSRLSPHMRKXLEX'(%MQQYRMX]HMH
RSX ETTP] 6 TT 8LIR [MXLSYX ER] EREP]WMW SV FVMIJMRK ERH FEWIH
IRXMVIP] SR MXW VINIGXMSR SJ 7XYF,YFeW '(% HIJIRWI ERH [MXLSYX EHHVIWWMRK
7XYF,YFeWSXLIV HIJIRWIWXLIGSYVXIRXIVIHWYQQEV]NYHKQIRXSRXLIQIVMXWSJ
4PEMRXMJJWeMRHMZMHYEPGPEMQW6T
8LIGSYVXLEW]IXXSEHHVIWWER]GPEWWMWWYIWMRGPYHMRKGIVXMJMGEXMSR
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 14/97
8LI GSYVXJSYRHfRS NYWX VIEWSRgXSHIPE] IRXV] SJNYHKQIRX SR4PEMRXMJJWe
MRHMZMHYEP GPEMQW -H 6IGSKRM̂ MRK XLEX ER ETTIEP [SYPH TVSQSXI NYHMGMEP
IGSRSQ] ERH IJJMGMIRG] XLI GSYVX GIVXMJMIH MXW VYPMRK XS SFXEMR XLMW 'SYVXeW
MQQIHMEXIKYMHERGI -H 8LIGSYVXEPWSQEHIJMRHMRKWSJJEGXERHGSRGPYWMSRWSJ
PE[ XLEX EJJIGX EHHMXMSREP WYFWXERXMEP VMKLXW SJ 7XYF,YFiREQIP] XLEX q
ETTPMIWXS7XYF,YFERHXLEXWYGLZMSPEXMSRGSRWXMXYXIWE9(84%ZMSPEXMSR 6TT
7XYF,YF XMQIP] JMPIH MXW RSXMGI SJ ETTIEP 6 TT %PXIVREXMZIP]
7XYF,YFJMPIHETIXMXMSRJSV[VMXSJGIVXMSVEVM
78%8)1)283*8,)+6392(7*36%44)00%8)6):-);
6YPIFTVSZMHIWf;LIRQSVIXLERSRIGPEMQJSVVIPMIJMWTVIWIRXIHMRER
EGXMSRXLIGSYVXQE]IRXIVEJMREPNYHKQIRXEWXSSRISVQSVIFYXJI[IVXLEREPP
SJXLIGPEMQWSRP]MJXLIVIMWRSNYWXVIEWSRJSVHIPE]ERHMXMWWSHIXIVQMRIHMR
XLINYHKQIRXg%TTP]MRKXLMW6YPIXLIGSYVXJSYRHRSNYWXVIEWSRJSVHIPE]MRKER
ETTIEPERHXLEXERMQQIHMEXIETTIEP[SYPHTVSQSXINYHMGMEPIGSRSQ]6T
&IGEYWIXLISVHIVMWEJMREPNYHKQIRXSRSRISVQSVIFYXJI[IVXLEREPPSJXLI
GPEMQWERHXLIGSYVXQEHIXLI6YPIFGIVXMJMGEXMSRXLEXXLIVIMWRSNYWXVIEWSR
JSVHIPE]ETTIPPEXIVIZMI[MWQERHEXSV]7LEVTIZ;SVPERH 2'
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 15/97
%PXIVREXMZIP] XLMW 'SYVX WLSYPH I\IVGMWI MXW HMWGVIXMSR XS VIZMI[ ER
MRXIVPSGYXSV] SVHIV FIGEYWI HSMRK WS f[SYPH I\TIHMXI XLI EHQMRMWXVEXMSR SJ
NYWXMGIg0MKKIXX+VSYT-RGZ7YREW 2'%TT6IZMI[RS[
[SYPHWIVZIXLMWKSEPF]EZSMHMRKJVEKQIRXEV]VIZMI[ 7IIMH7TIGMJMGEPP]XLIVI
EVIGPIEVIVVSVWSJPE[XLEXGERFIEHHVIWWIHFIJSVIER]PIRKXL]ERHFYVHIRWSQI
GPEWWGIVXMJMGEXMSRERHHEQEKIWTVSGIIHMRKWGSQQIRGIERHER]RSXMGIWEVIWIRXXS
2SVXL'EVSPMREVIWMHIRXW
7XYF,YFEPWSJMPIHE[VMXTIXMXMSRFIGEYWI7XYF,YFeWEVKYQIRXWLEZIQIVMX
ERH KVERXMRK GIVXMSVEVM [SYPH FI MR XLI MRXIVIWX SJ NYWXMGI 7II 7XIXWIV Z 8%4
4LEVQ 4VSHW -RG 2' %TT 8LMW ETTIEP MRZSPZIW ER
MQTSVXERX UYIWXMSR SJ JMVWX MQTVIWWMSR MR 2SVXL 'EVSPMRE GSRGIVRMRK '(%
MQQYRMX] JSV [IFWMXI STIVEXSVW 8LI GSYVXeW WXERHEVH JSV HIXIVQMRMRK '(%
MQQYRMX]TPEGIW2SVXL'EVSPMREEWERSYXPMIVEQSRKXLITVIHSQMREXINYVMWHMGXMSRW
XLEX LEZI EHHVIWWIH XLMW MWWYI -X EPWS MRZSPZIW MQTSVXERX UYIWXMSRW SJ WXEXYXSV]
MRXIVTVIXEXMSRERHXLIWGSTISJPMEFMPMX]YRHIVXLI9(84%FIGEYWIXLIGSYVXJSYRH
PMEFMPMX]IZIR[MXLSYXHIGITXMSRSVMRNYV]GEYWIHF]7XYF,YF
%GGSVHMRKP]XLIETTIEPMWTVSTIVP]FIJSVIXLMW'SYVX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 16/97
78%8)1)283*8,)*%'87
- 789&,9&&%'/+6392(
7XYF,YFSTIVEXIWERSRPMRIXMGOIXQEVOIXTPEGIXLEXIREFPIWYWIVWXSFY]ERH
WIPPXMGOIXWXSIRXIVXEMRQIRXIZIRXW6T0MOISXLIVFYWMRIWWIW7XYF,YF
GSPPIGXWEJIIJVSQYWIVWMRI\GLERKIJSVYWMRKMXWWIVZMGIW9TSRGSQTPIXMSRSJE
VIWEPI7XYF,YFGSPPIGXWEWIVZMGIJIISJERHSJXLIXMGOIXWEPITVMGIJVSQ
XLIWIPPIVERHFY]IVVIWTIGXMZIP]6TT7XYF,YFeWWIVZMGIJIIGSZIVW
XLI GSWXW SJ TVSZMHMRK E XMGOIX QEVOIXTPEGI MRGPYHMRK TVSZMHMRK XLI TPEXJSVQ
GYWXSQIVWIVZMGIYWIVTVSXIGXMSRWMRXLIJSVQSJMXW*ER 4VSXIGX j+YEVERXIIERH
TVSGIWWMRKVIWEPIXVERWEGXMSRWYWMRKGVIHMXGEVHW6TT
8SYWI 7XYF,YFXLMVHTEVX] WIPPIVWPMOI ,SPSLERQYWXVIKMWXIV JSV E YWIV
EGGSYRX 6 T ;LIR VIKMWXIVMRK WIPPIVW QYWX EKVII XS 7XYF,YFeW 9WIV
%KVIIQIRX [LMGL TVSLMFMXW WIPPIVW JVSQ ZMSPEXMRK PE[W VIKYPEXMRK XLI WEPI SJ
XMGOIXW
=SYEKVIIRSXXSYWIXLMW7MXIJSVYRPE[JYPTYVTSWIWSVMRERYRPE[JYP QERRIV =SY EKVII XS GSQTP] [MXL EPP ETTPMGEFPIPSGEP WXEXI JIHIVEP ERH MRXIVREXMSREP PE[W WXEXYXIW ERHVIKYPEXMSRWVIKEVHMRKYWISJXLI7MXIERHXLIWIPPMRKSJXMGOIXW
6T
;LIRGLSSWMRKETVMGIHYVMRKXLIXMGOIXPMWXMRKGIVXEMRVIWIPPIVWQE]LEZI
EGGIWWXSER%ZIVEKI4VMGI8SSPERHSVE,MWXSVMGEP7EPIW8SSP6TT
8LI %ZIVEKI 4VMGI 8SSP TVSZMHIW XLI EZIVEKI TVMGI GLEVKIH F] VIWIPPIVW JSV
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 17/97
GSQTEVEFPI XMGOIXW ERH ETTIEVW SRP] EJXIV ERH MJ XLI WIPPIV MRTYXW E TVMGI XLEX MW
EFSZI XLI EZIVEKI TVMGI 6 TT &IJSVI XLI ,MWXSVMGEP
7EPIW8SSPTVSZMHIHXLIPEWXJMZITVMGIWGLEVKIHF]SXLIVVIWIPPIVWJSVGSQTEVEFPI
XMGOIXW6T3RP]XLI%ZIVEKI4VMGI8SSP[SYPHLEZIFIIREGGIWWMFPIXS
,SPSLEREPXLSYKLLIGSYPHRSXVIGEPP[LIXLIVMXETTIEVIHMRGSRRIGXMSR[MXLXLI
XVERWEGXMSR EX MWWYI 6 T 7XYF,YF EPWS LEW E 0EVKI7IPPIVW 4VSKVEQ
HIHMGEXIHXSWIPPIVW[LSWIPPPEVKIRYQFIVWSJXMGOIXW6TT,SPSLER[EW
RSXE0EVKI7IPPIV6T8LIVIJSVILIGSYPHRSXLEZIYXMPM^IHXLEX4VSKVEQ
&Y]IVWEVIMRJSVQIHXLEXXLI]EVIFY]MRKXMGOIXWJVSQXLMVHTEVX]VIWIPPIVW
ERHXLEXXLIVIWEPITVMGIQE]FILMKLIVXLERJEGIZEPYI*SVI\EQTPIIZIV] TEKI
SJ7XYF,YFeW[IFWMXIMRJSVQIH4PEMRXMJJW
=SYEVIFY]MRKXMGOIXWJVSQEXLMVHTEVX]RIMXLIV7XYF,YFGSQ
RSV 7XYF,YF -RGMWXLIXMGOIX WIPPIV 8MGOIXTVMGIW EVI WIX F]XLIWIPPIVERHQE]HMJJIVJVSQJEGIZEPYI
6 T 7XYF,YF EPWS HMWTPE]IH XLI JSPPS[MRK QIWWEKI TVMSV XS ER] FY]IV
TYVGLEWMRKXMGOIXWYWMRKXLI[IFWMXI
6IQIQFIV &IGEYWI]SYeVIFY]MRKJVSQERSXLIVJER]SYQE]FISVHIVMRKXMGOIXWTVMGIWEFSZIJEGIZEPYI
6T
-- 86%27%'8-32%8-779)
3R7ITXIQFIV,SPSLERPMWXIHJSVVIWEPIJSYVXMGOIXWXSEWSPHSYX
,ERREL1SRXEREGSRGIVXEXETVMGISJIEGLGSPPIGXMZIP]XLIf8MGOIXWg6
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 18/97
TT7XYF,YFHMHRSXS[RXLI8MGOIXWHMHRSXWIXXLITVMGIJSVXLI8MGOIXW
ERH[EWRSXXLIVIWIPPIV6TT,SPSLEREPSRIWIXXLIVIWEPI
TVMGIERHYRHIVWXSSHLIGSYPHLEZIWIXER]TVMGILI[ERXIH6TT
3R7ITXIQFIV4PEMRXMJJWTYVGLEWIHXLI8MGOIXWJVSQ,SPSLERYWMRK
7XYF,YF6T&EWIHSR,SPSLEReWWIPIGXMSRSJETVMGIERH4PEMRXMJJWe
[MPPMRKRIWW XSTE] XLEX TVMGI 7XYF,YF VIGIMZIH E XSXEP JII TIV 8MGOIX SJ
JVSQ,SPSLERJVSQ4PEMRXMJJW6TT7XYF,YF
HMH RSX XEOI TSWWIWWMSR SJ SV IZIV WIIXLI 8MGOIXW XLI] [IVI WIRX HMVIGXP] JVSQ
,SPSLER XS 4PEMRXMJJW 6 TT 4PEMRXMJJW RIZIVXLIPIWW WYIH 7XYF,YF
GPEMQMRKXLIJEGIZEPYISJIEGL8MGOIX[EWERHXLIVIJSVIZMSPEXIHq6
T
--- 86-%0'3968e7690-2+
8LISRP]MWWYIFIJSVIXLIGSYVXSRWYQQEV]NYHKQIRX[EW[LIXLIV7XYF,YF
[EW MQQYRI JVSQ PMEFMPMX] YRHIV XLI '(% 6 T 8LI GSYVX GSVVIGXP]
HIXIVQMRIH XLEX XLI '(% TVSZMHIW FVSEH MQQYRMX] XS fMRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV
WIVZMGIWg ERH fTVSXIGX?WA [IFWMXI STIVEXSVW JVSQ PMEFMPMX] JSV GSRXIRX TSWXIH F]
SXLIVWg 6 TT &YX XLI GSYVX YXMPM^IH ER MRGSVVIGX PIKEP WXERHEVH ERH
ETTPMIHMXXSMVVIPIZERXJEGXW
4PEMRXMJJWWIXXPIHXLIMVGPEMQWEKEMRWX,SPSLER6TT
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 19/97
8LI GSYVX HIJMRIH XLI WXERHEVH JSV [LIR ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI
PSWIW '(% MQQYRMX] EW f[LIR ?MXA QEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXIW XS ERHSV WTIGMJMGEPP]
IRGSYVEKIW XLI SJJIRHMRK GSRXIRXg 6 T 8LIVI MW RS FEWMW MR PE[ JSVXLI
WIGSRH TEVX SJ XLI GSYVXeW HIJMRMXMSR ERH XLI GSYVX ETTPMIH SRP] XLI
fIRGSYVEKIQIRXgTEVXSJMXWYRTVIGIHIRXIHWXERHEVHhYRGSYTPIHJVSQEQEXIVMEP
GSRXVMFYXMSRVIUYMVIQIRXhMRMXWVYPMRK
-RWXIEHSJJSGYWMRKMXWEREP]WMWSR[LIXLIV7XYF,YFQEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIH
XSXLIGPEMQIHMPPMGMXGSRXIRXi MI,SPSLEReWVIWEPITVMGIXLIGSYVXJSGYWIHSR
XSSPWKIRIVEPP]EZEMPEFPISR7XYF,YFFYX[LMGL[IVI RSX YWIHF],SPSLER6T
ERH XLI f0EVKI7IPPIVg TVSKVEQ SJ [LMGL ,SPSLER [EW RSX IZIR E
QIQFIV %TTP]MRK ER MRGSVVIGX WXERHEVH XS MVVIPIZERX JEGXW XLI GSYVX LIPH XLEX
7XYF,YF[EWRSXIRXMXPIHMQQYRMX]FIGEYWIMXIRGSYVEKIWERHWYKKIWXWXLEXXMGOIXW
FIWSPHEXQEVOIXZEPYIMVVIWTIGXMZISJ[LIXLIVQEVOIXZEPYII\GIIHWXLITIVQMXXIH
VIWEPITVMGISVRSX8LIGSYVXVIEGLIHXLMWHIXIVQMREXMSRIZIRXLSYKLMXWITEVEXIP]
JSYRHXLEXXLIVIWIPPIVRSX7XYF,YFHIGMHIW[LEXTVMGIXSGLEVKIJSVXMGOIXWWSPH
SR7XYF,YF -H
8LIGSYVXeWVYPMRKEPWS[IRXFI]SRHXLIUYIWXMSRSJ'(%MQQYRMX]hXLI
SRP]MWWYIXLITEVXMIWQSZIHJSVWYQQEV]NYHKQIRXSRhERHVYPIHSRXLIQIVMXWSJ
4PEMRXMJJWe GPEMQW 7TIGMJMGEPP] XLI GSYVX LIPH XLEX 7XYF,YFeW fEGXMZMXMIW
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 20/97
IWTIGMEPP] MXW FY]IVeW JIIWg ZMSPEXIH q 6 TT 8LI GSYVX EPWS
GSRGPYHIHXLEX7XYF,YFeWGSRHYGXZMSPEXIHq -H
%6+91)28
- 78%2(%6(3*6):-);
7XYF,YFeW ETTIEP GSRGIVRW UYIWXMSRW SJ PE[ [LMGL EVI VIZMI[IH F] XLMW
'SYVXHI RSZS7II,EVVMWSRZ'MX]SJ7ERJSVH 2'%TT
-- 8,)'3968e7'32'097-328,%8789&,9&:-30%8)(q
;%7)6632)397
8LIGSYVXLIPHXLEX7XYF,YF[EWWYFNIGXXSERHZMSPEXIHq&IGEYWI
XLMW GSRGPYWMSR [EW IVVSRISYW XLI GSYVXeW HIGMWMSR WLSYPH FI VIZIVWIH [MXLSYX
VIKEVHXS[LIXLIV'(%MQQYRMX]ETTPMIW
8LIXMGOIXWXEXYXIYREQFMKYSYWP]ETTPMIWSRP]XSWIPPIVWSVVIWIPPIVW
%R]TIVWSR[LMGLWIPPWSVVIWIPPW XMGOIXW WLEPPRSXFI TIVQMXXIH XS VIGSYT JYRHW KVIEXIV XLER XLIMV GSQFMRIH JEGIZEPYI SJ XLI XMGOIX XE\ ERH XLI EYXLSVM^IH WIVZMGI JII 8LMWWIVZMGIJIIQE]RSXI\GIIHXLVIIHSPPEVWJSVIEGLXMGOIX%R]TIVWSR[LMGLWIPPWSVSJJIVWXSWIPP EXMGOIX JSVE TVMGI KVIEXIV XLER XLI TVMGI TIVQMXXIH F] XLMW WIGXMSR WLEPP FIKYMPX]SJE'PEWWQMWHIQIERSV
q IQTLEWMW EHHIH q GPIEVP]HSIW RSX ETTP] XS7XYF,YF FIGEYWI
XLIYRHMWTYXIHVIGSVHGSRJMVQWXLEX7XYF,YF[EWRSXXLIWIPPIVSVVIWIPPIVSJXLI
8MGOIXW%WXLIGSYVXJSYRH
� ,SPSLER PMWXIH JSYV XMGOIXW c JSV WEPI EX E TVMGI SJTIVXMGOIX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 21/97
� 1V,SPSLERXIWXMJMIHXLEXLIYWIHXLIJM\IHTVMGIQIXLSHSRXLI;IFWMXIX]TMRKMRMRXLIFPERO7XYF,YFHMHRSXWIXXLITVMGIJSVLMQ
� 7XYF,YF HMH RSX WIX XLI TVMGI EX [LMGL 1VW ,MPP TYVGLEWIH XLI XMGOIXW -X HMH RSX IRXIV XLI TVMGI MR XLI FPEROSRMXW[IFWMXI
6TT8LIGSYVXEPWSRSXIHXLEX7XYF,YFfHSIWRSXKIRIVEPP]S[R
XLIXMGOIXWWSPHSRMXW[IFWMXIg6T
8LIGSYVXeWJMRHMRKWEVIJYPP]WYTTSVXIHF]XLIIZMHIRGI
5 7S[LIR]SYPMWXIHXLI,ERREL1SRXEREXMGOIXWEFPERO FS\ETTIEVIHERH]SYMRTYXEXMGOIXTVMGI#
% 'SVVIGX
5 (MH7XYF,YFVIUYMVI]SYXSTYXMRER]TEVXMGYPEVTVMGI#
% 2S
5 7S ]SYGSYPHLEZIPMWXIHXLIXMGOIXWMJ ]SY [ERXIH JSVEHSPPEV#
% 'SVVIGX
5 %RH]SYEPWSGSYPHLEZIPMWXIHXLIXMGOIXWMJ]SY[ERXIHXSJSVEQMPPMSRHSPPEVW#
% 'SVVIGX
5 6IKEVHMRKXLI,ERREL1SRXEREXMGOIXWHMH]SYS[RXLSWIXMGOIXW#
% =IW
5 %RH]SYWSPHXLSWIXMGOIXW#
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 22/97
% 'SVVIGX
5 %RH]SYWIPIGXIHXLITVMGIJSVXLSWIXMGOIXW#
% 'SVVIGX
5 (MH 7XYF,YF S[R XLI XMGOIXW XLEX ]SY WSPH XS XLI TPEMRXMJJW#
% 2S
5 (MH7XYF,YFWIPIGXXLITVMGIXLEX]SYX]TIHMRXSXLI FS\#
% 2S
6TT
-R XLI JEGI SJ XLMW YRHMWTYXIH IZMHIRGI ERH MXW S[R JMRHMRKW SJ JEGX XLI
GSYVXRIZIVXLIPIWWGSRGPYHIHXLEX7XYF,YF[EWRSHMJJIVIRXXLERETIVWSRWGEPTMRK
XMGOIXWSYXWMHIXLIIZIRX
-J E 7XYF,YF IQTPS]II WXSSH MR JVSRX SJ XLI +VIIRWFSVS
'SPMWIYQ FIJSVI XLI ,ERREL 1SRXERE GSRGIVX ERH SJJIVIH XSWIPPXMGOIXWFIPSRKMRKXSWSQISRIIPWIEXJEGIZEPYIERHMJXLI FY]IV [SYPH TE] E FY]IVeW JII XLEX I\GIIHIH XLEXIQTPS]II[SYPHLEZI ZMSPEXIHXLI WXEXYXI ERH FIIR WYFNIGX XS TVSWIGYXMSR 8LEX TVSGIWW MW TVIGMWIP] [LEX XEOIW TPEGI SR7XYF,YFeW[IFWMXI
6 T &YX XLI GSYVXeW EREPSK] MW MRETX -R XLI L]TSXLIXMGEP XLI 7XYF,YF
IQTPS]IIGPIEVP]MWXLIWIPPIV MIXLISJJIVSVSJXLIXMGOIXWLIVIXLIWIPPIV[EW
,SPSLERRSX7XYF,YFFIGEYWILIPMOIXLI7XYF,YFIQTPS]IIMRXLIL]TSXLIXMGEP
SJJIVIHXLIXMGOIXWEXETVMGILIWIX &]GSRXVEWXXLIGSYVXJSYRHXLEXf7XYF,YFHMH
RSX WIXXLITVMGIEX[LMGL1VW,MPPTYVGLEWIHXLIXMGOIXWg6T
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 23/97
-R XLI GSYVXeWL]TSXLIXMGEP XLIJIIMW GLEVKIHJSVXLIWEPI SJ XLIXMGOIXSR
7XYF,YF XLI JII MW GLEVKIH JSV YWMRK XLI WMXI RSX JSV XLI WEPI %QSRK SXLIV
XLMRKW XLI JII MW YWIH XS TVSZMHI 7XYF,YFeW *ER 4VSXIGX j +YEVERXII [LMGL
TVSXIGXW FY]IVW ERH WIPPIVW JVSQ FIMRK GLIEXIH F] KYEVERXIIMRK XLI HIPMZIV] SJ
TYVGLEWIH XMGOIXW ERH XLI TE]QIRX SJ QSRI] ERH XS GSZIV SXLIV GSWXW WYGL EW
GVIHMXGEVHJIIW[LMGLGERFISJXLIXMGOIXTVMGI
&IGEYWIZMSPEXMSRWSJqEVIWYFNIGXXSGVMQMREPTIREPXMIWXLIWXEXYXI
WLSYPHFIGSRWXVYIHREVVS[P]7IIIK2'7XEXI&HSJ6IKMWXVEXMSRJSV4VSJcP
)RKcVW ERH 0ERH 7YVZI]SVW Z -RXcP &YW 1EGL 'SVT 2' %TT
8LIVIJSVI ER] HSYFX GSRGIVRMRK [LIXLIV q ETTPMIW XS 7XYF,YF
WLSYPH FI VIWSPZIH MR7XYF,YFeW JEZSV 0IKMWPEXMZIGLERKIW XSq WYTTSVX
XLMW REVVS[ GSRWXVYGXMSR 0IWW XLER E ]IEV EJXIV XLMW XVERWEGXMSR XLI PIKMWPEXYVI
QSHMJMIH XLI WXEXYXI XS I\TVIWWP] TIVQMX VIWEPI XVERWEGXMSRW EFSZI JEGI ZEPYI MJ
EQSRKSXLIVUYEPMJMGEXMSRWfXLITIVWSRVIWIPPMRKXLIXMGOIXWSJJIVWXLIXMGOIXWJSV
8LIGSYVXGSRGPYHIHXLEX7XYF,YFeWWIVZMGIfWIPPIVJIIgHMHRSXZMSPEXIq FYXXLIRLIPHMRGSRWMWXIRXP]XLEXXLIWIVZMGIfFY]IVJIIgHMHZMSPEXIXLIWXEXYXI6T &IGEYWI7XYF,YFMWRSXXLI WIPPIVERH XLI JII MXGLEVKIW FSXLFY]IVW ERHWIPPIVWMWXSGSZIVXLIZEVMSYWGSWXWEWWSGMEXIH[MXLVYRRMRKMXWWMXIRIMXLIVJIIMWWYFNIGXXSq
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 24/97
VIWEPI SR E ;IFWMXI [MXL E XMGOIX KYEVERXIIg 2'+7 q 8LYW XLI
PIKMWPEXYVI VIGSKRM^IW XLI HMWXMRGXMSR FIX[IIR [IFWMXIWWYGL EW 7XYF,YF [LMGL
TVSZMHI E QEVOIXTPEGI FYX EVI RSX XLI WIPPIVW ERH EGXYEP fTIVWSR?WA VIWIPPMRK XLI
XMGOIXWg WYGL EW ,SPSLER GEPPMRK MRXS UYIWXMSR XLI GSYVXeW JEMPYVI XS HVE[ XLEX
HMWXMRGXMSR
%GGSVHMRKP]XLIGSYVXeWGSRGPYWMSRXLEX7XYF,YFeWGSRHYGX[EWWYFNIGXXS
ERHZMSPEXIHqWLSYPHFIVIZIVWIH
--- 8,)'3968)66)(-2'32'09(-2+8,%8789&,9&;%7238-1192)92()68,)'(%
8LI'(%TVSZMHIWMQQYRMX]JSVfMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWgXLEXLSWX
GSRXIRXSRXLI-RXIVRIXSVMKMREXMRKJVSQE XLMVHTEVX]8LI'(%WXEXIWMRVIPIZERX
TEVXf2STVSZMHIVSVYWIVSJERMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWLEPPFIXVIEXIHEWXLI
TYFPMWLIVSVWTIEOIVSJER]MRJSVQEXMSRTVSZMHIHF]ERSXLIVMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRX
TVSZMHIVg97'qG-XJYVXLIVTVSZMHIW[MXLPMQMXIHI\GITXMSRWRSX
ETTPMGEFPILIVIXLEXf?RASGEYWISJEGXMSRQE]FIFVSYKLXERHRSPMEFMPMX]QE]FI
MQTSWIHYRHIVER]7XEXISVPSGEPPE[XLEXMWMRGSRWMWXIRX[MXLXLMWWIGXMSRg -H
qI 2SRIXLIPIWW XLI GSYVXLIPH 7XYF,YF PMEFPI JSV XMGOIX WEPIWQEHISR
f'SYVXWQE]YWIWYFWIUYIRXIREGXQIRXWSVEQIRHQIRXWEWEREMHMREVVMZMRKEX
XLIGSVVIGXQIERMRKSJETVMSVWXEXYXIF]YXMPM^MRKREXYVEPMRJIVIRGIWEVMWMRKSYXSJXLI PIKMWPEXMZI LMWXSV] EW MX GSRXMRYIW XS IZSPZIg &YVKIWW Z =SYV ,SYWI SJ
6EPIMKL2'
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 25/97
7XYF,YF IZIR XLSYKL MX [EW YRHMWTYXIH XLEX ,SPSLER WIPIGXIH ERH TSWXIH XLI
GSRXIRXMITVMGIJSVXLI8MGOIXW8LIGSYVXeWLSPHMRKWLSYPHFIVIZIVWIH
% '(%-QQYRMX]-W&VSEH%RH'PIEVP]%TTPMIW
'SRKVIWWIREGXIHXLI'(%MRVIGSKRMXMSRSJf?XALIVETMHP]HIZIPSTMRKEVVE]
SJ-RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWgERHXLIJEGXXLEXXLIWIWIVZMGIW
fLEZIJPSYVMWLIHXS XLIFIRIJMXSJ EPP%QIVMGERW[MXLEQMRMQYQSJKSZIVRQIRX
VIKYPEXMSRg -H qE 'SRKVIWW WXEXIH XLEX fXLI TSPMG] SJ XLI 9RMXIH
7XEXIWgMWfXSTVSQSXIXLIGSRXMRYIHHIZIPSTQIRXSJXLI-RXIVRIXgERHfXSTVIWIVZI
XLI ZMFVERX ERH GSQTIXMXMZIJVII QEVOIX XLEX TVIWIRXP] I\MWXW JSV XLI -RXIVRIXERH
SXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWYRJIXXIVIHF]*IHIVEPSV7XEXIVIKYPEXMSRg -H
qF
'SYVXWLEZIXLIVIJSVIfKIRIVEPP]MRXIVTVIXIH7IGXMSRMQQYRMX]FVSEHP]
WSEWXSIJJIGXYEXI'SRKVIWWeWdTSPMG]GLSMGIRSXXSHIXIVLEVQJYPSRPMRIWTIIGL
XLVSYKL XLI VSYXI SJ MQTSWMRK XSVX PMEFMPMX] SR GSQTERMIW XLEX WIVZI EW
MRXIVQIHMEVMIW JSV SXLIV TEVXMIWe TSXIRXMEPP] MRNYVMSYW QIWWEKIWeg 9RMZIVWEP
'SQQcR7]W-RGZ0]GSW-RG*HWX'MVUYSXMRK>IVER
Z%Q3RPMRI-RG*HXL'MV
7IGXMSRfTVIGPYHIWGSYVXWJVSQIRXIVXEMRMRKGPEMQWXLEX[SYPHTPEGIE
GSQTYXIVWIVZMGITVSZMHIVMRETYFPMWLIVeWVSPIg >IVER*HEX%XXIQTXW
XS LSPH [IFWMXIW PMEFPI JSV fHIGMWMSRW VIPEXMRK XS XLI QSRMXSVMRK WGVIIRMRK ERH
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 26/97
HIPIXMSR SJ GSRXIRX JVSQ MXW RIX[SVOg EVI fWTIGMJMGEPP] TVSWGVMFI?HAg F] WIGXMSR
+VIIRZ%30*HH'MV WII>IVER*HEX
f*EGIH [MXL TSXIRXMEP PMEFMPMX] JSV IEGL QIWWEKI VITYFPMWLIH F] XLIMV WIVZMGIW
MRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGITVSZMHIVWQMKLXGLSSWIXSWIZIVIP]VIWXVMGXXLIRYQFIV
ERHX]TISJQIWWEKIWTSWXIH'SRKVIWWGLSWIXSMQQYRM^IWIVZMGITVSZMHIVWXS
EZSMHER]WYGLVIWXVMGXMZIIJJIGXg
;IFWMXIW EVI TVSXIGXIH F] XLI '(% MJ XLI IRXMX] MW ER fMRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIVWIVZMGIgXLIGPEMQWEXMWWYIWIIOXSXVIEXXLEXIRXMX]EWXLITYFPMWLIV
SVWTIEOIVSJXLIMRJSVQEXMSRKMZMRKVMWIXSXLIGPEMQWERHXLIMRJSVQEXMSR[EW
TVSZMHIHF]XLMVHTEVXMIWRSXF]XLIIRXMX]7IIIK+MFWSRZ'VEMKWPMWX-RG
2S 'MZ ;0 EX 7(2= .YRI 'SYVXW
GSRWXVYMRK XLMW WXERHEVH GSRWMWXIRXP] LEZI HMWXMRKYMWLIH FIX[IIR XLI WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIVXLEXLSWXIHXLIXLMVHTEVX]GSRXIRX[LMGLMWTVSXIGXIHF]XLI'(%ERH
XLIXLMVHTEVX][LSGVIEXIHXLIEPPIKIHP]YRPE[JYPGSRXIRX[LMGLMWRSX 7IIIK
2IQIX 'LIZVSPIX 0XH Z'SRWYQIVEJJEMVWGSQ-RG*HXL'MV
f?4APEMRXMJJWQE]LSPHPMEFPIXLITIVWSR[LSGVIEXIWSVHIZIPSTWYRPE[JYP
GSRXIRXFYXRSXXLIMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGITVSZMHIV[LSQIVIP]IREFPIWXLEX
GSRXIRXXSFITSWXIHSRPMRIg (SIZ1]7TEGI-RG*HXL'MV
f4EVXMIW QE] WYI XLI XLMVHTEVX] YWIV [LS KIRIVEXIH XLI ?EPPIKIH
YRPE[JYPA GSRXIRX FYX RSX XLI MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI XLEX IREFPIH XLIQ XS
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 27/97
TYFPMWL XLI GSRXIRX SRPMRIg &EVVIXX Z 6SWIRXLEP 'EP XL
7IGXMSR TVSZMHIW fE FPEROIX MQQYRMX] JVSQ XSVX PMEFMPMX] JSV SRPMRI
VITYFPMGEXMSRSJXLMVHTEVX]GSRXIRXg+IRXV]ZI&E]-RG 'EP%TTXL
VINIGXMRK EXXIQTX XS fLSPH I&E] VIWTSRWMFPI JSV I&E]eW
HMWWIQMREXMSRSJVITVIWIRXEXMSRWQEHIF]XLIMRHMZMHYEPHIJIRHERXWSVXLITSWXMRK
SJ GSQTMPEXMSRW SJ MRJSVQEXMSR KIRIVEXIH F] XLSWI HIJIRHERXW ERH SXLIV XLMVH
TEVXMIWg-RHIIHGSYVXWLEZIVIGSKRM^IHXLEX'(%MQQYRMX]ETTPMIWXS7XYF,YF
ERHSXLIV[IFWMXIWMRXLIXMGOIXVIWEPIGSRXI\X 7II*ILVWZ7XYF,YF-RG 'EWI
2S WPMT ST 3V 'MV 'X 7ITX 1MPKVEQ Z 3VFMX^
;SVPH[MHI-RG%H2.7YTIV'X
7XYF,YFQIIXWEPPXLVIIVIUYMVIQIRXWJSV'(%MQQYRMX]*MVWXMXTPEMRP]MW
ER fMRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIVWIVZMGIg [LMGL XLI WXEXYXI HIJMRIW EWfER] MRJSVQEXMSR
WIVZMGI W]WXIQ SV EGGIWW WSJX[EVI TVSZMHIV XLEX TVSZMHIW SV IREFPIW GSQTYXIV
EGGIWWF]QYPXMTPIYWIVWXSEGSQTYXIVWIVZIVg97'qJ'SYVXWLEZI
LIPHXLEXXLMWHIJMRMXMSRIQFVEGIWfE[MHIVERKISJG]FIVWTEGIWIVZMGIWg &EX^IPZ
7QMXL*HR VILcKIRFERGHIRMIH *HXL'MV
MRGPYHMRK[IFWMXIWPMOI7XYF,YF WII+IRXV]'EP%TTXLEXI&E]
MW ER fMRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIg 7XYF,YF YRUYIWXMSREFP] MW ER MRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIVWIVZMGITVSZMHIV
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 28/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 29/97
WIGXMSRJ[LMGLHIJMRIWERfMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIVgEWSRI[LSMW
fVIWTSRWMFPI MR[LSPISVMRTEVXJSV XLI GVIEXMSRSVHIZIPSTQIRXg SJXLI MPPIKEP
GSRXIRX
*YVXLIVQSVI XLI QEXIVMEP GSRXVMFYXMSR EREP]WMW JSGYWIW WTIGMJMGEPP]SR XLI
GPEMQIHMPPIKEPEWTIGXSJXLIGSRXIRXMRUYIWXMSR7IIIK6SSQQEXIW*HEX
fE [IFWMXI QE] FI MQQYRI JVSQ PMEFMPMX] JSV WSQI SJ XLI GSRXIRX MX
HMWTPE]W XS XLI TYFPMG FYX FI WYFNIGX XS PMEFMPMX] JSV SXLIV GSRXIRXg
'SRWYQIVEJJEMVWGSQ*HEXXLIEQIRHIHGSQTPEMRXfHSIWRSXWLS[SV
IZIR MRXMQEXIg XLEX 'SRWYQIVEJJEMVW fGSRXVMFYXIH XS XLI EPPIKIHP] JVEYHYPIRX
REXYVI SJ XLI GSQQIRXW EX MWWYIg IQTLEWMW EHHIH 8LI REXYVI ERH
GLEVEGXIVMWXMGW SJ XLI HIJIRHERXeW WIVZMGI EVI MVVIPIZERX I\GITX XS XLI I\XIRX XLI]
FIEV SR XLI HIZIPSTQIRX SJ XLI WTIGMJMG GSRXIRX EX MWWYI -R 6SSQQEXIW JSV
I\EQTPIXLIGSYVXVINIGXIH'(%MQQYRMX][LIVIHIJIRHERXHIWMKRIHMXW[IFWMXI
XSIPMGMXYRPE[JYPP]HMWGVMQMREXSV]MRJSVQEXMSRJVSQYWIVWEWEGSRHMXMSRSJYWMRK
XLI WMXI FYX JSYRH MQQYRMX] [MXL VIWTIGX XS YWIVWe HMWGVMQMREXSV] GSQQIRXW
MRGPYHIHMRXLIMVTVSJMPITEKIWFIGEYWIf6SSQQEXIWTYFPMWLIWXLIWIGSQQIRXWEW
[VMXXIRg*HEX
7IIEPWS +IRXV]'EP%TTXLEXRf;IRSXIXLIJEGXETTIPPERXWEPPIKI
I&E]MWERMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIVMWMVVIPIZERXMJI&E]HMHRSXMXWIPJGVIEXISVHIZIPSTXLIGSRXIRXJSV[LMGLETTIPPERXWWIIOXSLSPHMXPMEFPI 8LIGVMXMGEPMWWYIMW[LIXLIVI&E]EGXIHEWERMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIV [MXLVIWTIGXXSXLIMRJSVQEXMSRXLEXETTIPPERXWGPEMQMWJEPWISVQMWPIEHMRK gIQTLEWMWEHHIH
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 30/97
%PXLSYKLXLIGSYVXEGORS[PIHKIHXLMWfQEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIWgWXERHEVH6
TTMXHITEVXIHWLEVTP]JVSQMXERHJEWLMSRIHERSZIPERHJEVFVSEHIV
fIRGSYVEKIQIRXgWXERHEVHJSVHIXIVQMRMRK[LIXLIV7XYF,YFPSWIWMQQYRMX]8LI
GSYVX XLIR GSQTSYRHIH MXW IVVSV F] ETTP]MRK XLEX WXERHEVH RSX XS XLI GSRXIRX MR
UYIWXMSR FYX VEXLIV XS GIVXEMR XSSPW JIEXYVIW ERH TVSKVEQW XLEX EVI KIRIVEPP]
EZEMPEFPISR7XYF,YFIZIRXLSYKLXLI]TPE]IHRSVSPIMRXLIVIWEPITVMGIGLSWIR
F],SPSLER&SXLEWTIGXWSJXLIGSYVXeWVYPMRKEVI[VSRKEWEQEXXIVSJPE[
2YQIVSYW GSYVXW LEZI LIPH XLEX RIMXLIV QIVI IRGSYVEKIQIRX RSV
ORS[PIHKISJMPPIKEPGSRXIRXMWWYJJMGMIRXXSRIKEXI'(%MQQYRMX]EWMXHSIWRSX
VMWI XS XLI PIZIP SJ QEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXMRK XS XLI GSRXIRX %W XLI 2MRXL 'MVGYMX
WXEXIHMR 6SSQQEXIWf[IEOIRGSYVEKIQIRXGERRSXWXVMTE[IFWMXISJMXWWIGXMSR
MQQYRMX]g*HEX7MQMPEVP]MR 7XSRIVZI&E]-RGXLIGSYVX
VINIGXIH XLEX PS[ WXERHEVH WXEXMRK XLEX fRIMXLIV EKKVIWWMZI EHZIVXMWMRK RSV XLI
MQTSWMXMSR SJ E JII XVERWJSVQW ER MRXIVEGXMZI WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV MRXS E WIPPIV
VIWTSRWMFPIJSVMXIQWWSPHg2S;0EX'EP7YTIV'X
2SZ 0MOI[MWI MR >IVER XLI *SYVXL 'MVGYMX WXEXIH XLEX fMRXIVTVIXMRK
7IIEPWS 7LMEQMPMZ6IEP)WXEXI+VSYTSJ2I[=SVO 2S2=0)<-7EX2='X%TT.YRIf;IVINIGX7LMEQMPMeWGSRXIRXMSRXLEXHIJIRHERXW WLSYPH FI HIIQIH GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVW FIGEYWI XLI] GVIEXIH ERH VER E[IFWMXI[LMGLMQTPMGMXP]IRGSYVEKIHYWIVWXSTSWXRIKEXMZIGSQQIRXWg +PSFEP
6S]EPXMIW 0XH Z <GIRXVMG :IRXYVIW 00' * 7YTT H ( %VM ̂ f-X MW SFZMSYW XLEX E [IFWMXI IRXMXPIH 6MTSJJ 6ITSVX IRGSYVEKIW XLI TYFPMGEXMSR SJ HIJEQEXSV] GSRXIRX ,S[IZIV XLIVI MW RS EYXLSVMX] JSV XLI
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 31/97
qXSMQTSWIPMEFMPMX]SRWIVZMGITVSZMHIVW[MXLORS[PIHKISJ?MPPIKEPAGSRXIRX
SR XLIMV WIVZMGIW JEMPW LS[IZIV XS YRHIVWXERH XLI TVEGXMGEP MQTPMGEXMSRW SJ
RSXMGIPMEFMPMX]MRXLIMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIGSRXI\Xg*HEX
6SSQQEXIW [EVRIH SJ XLI HERKIV SJ GSRWXVYMRK XLI HIJMRMXMSR SJ
fMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIVgXSSFVSEHP]
?8ALI FVSEHIWX WIRWI SJ XLI XIVQ dHIZIPSTe GSYPH MRGPYHI XLIJYRGXMSRWSJERSVHMREV]WIEVGLIRKMRIhMRHIIHNYWXEFSYXER]JYRGXMSR TIVJSVQIH F] E [IFWMXI &YX XS VIEH XLI XIVQ WS FVSEHP][SYPHHIJIEXXLITYVTSWISJWIGXMSRF]W[EPPS[MRKYT IZIV] FMX SJ XLI MQQYRMX] XLEX XLI WIGXMSR SXLIV[MWI TVSZMHIW
*H EX %HSTXMRK E FVSEH fIRGSYVEKIQIRXg WXERHEVH YRHIV 2SVXL
'EVSPMRE PE[ h SRI MRGSRWMWXIRX [MXL XLI TYVTSWI SJ WIGXMSR ERH [MXL MXW
MRXIVTVIXEXMSRF]GSYVXWEGVSWWXLIGSYRXV]h[SYPHQEOIXLI7XEXIERSYXPMIVMRXLMW
EVIESJXLIPE[
-REHHMXMSRXSFIMRKJEVXSSI\TERWMZIXLIPEGOSJER]GPIEVWIRWI
TVSTSWMXMSRXLEXXLMWQEOIWXLI[IFWMXISTIVEXSVVIWTSRWMFPIMR[LSPISVMRTEVXJSVXLIfGVIEXMSRSVHIZIPSTQIRXgSJIZIV]TSWXSRMXWWMXIg
8LI GSYVXeW VIPMERGI SR E ORS[PIHKI SV [MPPJYP FPMRHRIWW WXERHEVH [LMGL
TVIWYQEFP]GSQIWJVSQ 24700'Z7XYF,YF-RG2S&07;0 1EWW 7YTIV 'X .ER 6TT MWQMWTPEGIH*MVWX '(% MQQYRMX] [EW RSX IZIR FVMIJIH F] XLI TEVXMIW SV VEMWIH EX SVEP
EVKYQIRX 8LI GSYVX [EW HIGMHMRK [LIXLIV 7XYF,YF XSVXMSYWP] MRXIVJIVIH [MXLEHZERXEKISYWVIPEXMSRWYRHIV1EWWEGLYWIXXWGSQQSRPE[RSXXLI1EWWEGLYWIXXWXMGOIXWXEXYXI7IGSRHXLIGSYVXI\TVIWWP]WXEXIHXLEXf7XYF,YFHSIWRSXPSWIXLIMQQYRMX]TVSZMHIHF]XLI'(%MJMXWMQTP]ORI[XLEXWIPPIVW[IVITSXIRXMEPP]MRZMSPEXMSRgSJXLIXMGOIXWXEXYXI -HEX8LMVHXLI1EWWEGLYWIXXWWXEXYXIETTIEVWXSFIFVSEHIVXLERqF]IRGSQTEWWMRKTIVWSRWfIRKEKIHMRXLIFYWMRIWWSJVIWIPPMRK ER] XMGOIXgRSX NYWXWIPPIVWERH XLI HIRMEP SJ7XYF,YFeW QSXMSR MRXLEX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 32/97
SJ [LEX fIRGSYVEKIQIRXg IRGSQTEWWIW MW TVSFPIQEXMG MR XLEX MX [SYPH GLMPP XLI
KVS[XLSJPE[JYPIGSQQIVGIF]MRZMXMRKGPEMQWHMVIGXIHEXVSYXMRISTIVEXMSRWSJ
[IFWMXIW PMOI 7XYF,YF XLEX WIVZI EW MRXIVQIHMEVMIW JSV XLMVHTEVX] GSRXIRX
%PXIVREXMZIP]MX[SYPHIVSHIXLIJSYRHEXMSRSJXLISTIR-RXIVRIXQEVOIXTPEGISV
VIUYMVI WMXIW PMOI 7XYF,YF XS QSRMXSV XLIMV WMXIW JSV MPPIKEP GSRHYGX RIMXLIV SJ
[LMGL'SRKVIWWMRXIRHIH7II +VIIR*HEX%WI\TPEMRIHF]XLI2MRXL
'MVGYMXMR 6SSQQEXIW
;IQYWXOIITJMVQP]MRQMRHXLEXXLMWMWERMQQYRMX]WXEXYXI[I EVI I\TSYRHMRK E TVSZMWMSR IREGXIH XS TVSXIGX [IFWMXIWEKEMRWX XLI IZMP SJ PMEFMPMX] JSV JEMPYVI XS VIQSZI SJJIRWMZIGSRXIRX ;IFWMXIW EVI GSQTPMGEXIH IRXIVTVMWIW ERH XLIVI [MPPEP[E]W FIGPSWI GEWIW [LIVIE GPIZIV PE[]IVGSYPHEVKYI XLEX
WSQIXLMRK XLI [IFWMXI STIVEXSV HMH IRGSYVEKIH XLI MPPIKEPMX]7YGL GPSWI GEWIW [I FIPMIZI QYWX FI VIWSPZIH MR JEZSV SJMQQYRMX]PIWX[IGYXXLILIEVXSYXSJWIGXMSRF]JSVGMRK[IFWMXIWXSJEGIHIEXLF]XIRXLSYWERHHYGOFMXIWJMKLXMRKSJJ
GPEMQW XLEX XLI] TVSQSXIH SV IRGSYVEKIH h SV EX PIEWX XEGMXP]EWWIRXIHXShXLIMPPIKEPMX]SJXLMVHTEVXMIW
*HEXIQTLEWMWMRSVMKMREP
7XYF,YF(MH2SX1EXIVMEPP]'SRXVMFYXI8S8LI-PPIKEP6IWEPI4VMGI
-R VINIGXMRK '(% MQQYRMX] XLI GSYVX VIPMIH SR 7XYF,YFeW f0EVKI7IPPIVW
TVSKVEQg XLI f%ZIVEKI 4VMGI [MRHS[g ERH XLI f,MWXSVMGEP 7EPIW 8SSPg XS
GEWI HMH RSX EQSYRX XS E VINIGXMSR SJ '(% MQQYRMX] EW QEXXIV SJ PE[ EW LIVI*SYVXLMRER]IZIRX 247 [EW[VSRKP]HIGMHIH7II 1MPKVEQ%HEXGVMXMGM^MRK 247 ERHLSPHMRKXLEX[IFWMXIW[IVIMQQYRIYRHIVXLI'(%JVSQWYMXYRHIV2I[.IVWI]eWXMGOIXWXEXYXI
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 33/97
GSRGPYHI XLEX 7XYF,YF fHMVIGXP] TEVXMGMTEXIH MR HIZIPSTMRK XLI TVMGMRK SR MXW
W]WXIQg 6 TT IQTLEWMW MR SVMKMREP &IGEYWI XLIWI EWTIGXW SJ
7XYF,YFeW FYWMRIWW EVI YRVIPEXIH XS XLI GLEPPIRKIH WEPI ERH HMH RSX QEXIVMEPP]
GSRXVMFYXI XS XLI TVMGI WSYKLX F] ,SPSLER XLI GSYVXeW VIPMERGI SR XLIQ [EW
QMWTPEGIH
*MVWX ,SPSLER [EW RSX E WIPPIV MR XLI f0EVKI7IPPIVW TVSKVEQg 7IGSRH
f?,SPSLERA[SYPHSRP]LEZILEHEGGIWWXSXLI%ZIVEKI4VMGI[MRHS[ERHRSXXLI
,MWXSVMGEP 7EPIW XSSPg 6 T %RH EW JSV XLI f%ZIVEKI 4VMGI [MRHS[g
,SPSLERfHMHRSXORS[MJLIYWIHXLIQSRXLISGGEWMSRXLEXLIPMWXIHLMW,ERREL
1SRXERE XMGOIXWg -H 8LYW XLIWI XSSPW JIEXYVIW ERH TVSKVEQW [LMGL EVI
KIRIVEPP] EZEMPEFPI SR 7XYF,YF HMH RSX fQEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXIg XS ,SPSLEReW
HIGMWMSRXSVIWIPPXLI8MGOIXWMRZMSPEXMSRSJq
,SPSLEREPSRIWIPIGXIHXLITVMGILI[ERXIHJSVXLI8MGOIXW,MWHIGMWMSRXS
WIIOETVMGIEFSZIJEGIZEPYILEHRSXLMRKXSHS[MXL7XYF,YFeWGSRHYGX-X[EWE
HIGMWMSRQEHIF],SPSLEREPSRIPMOIP]HVMZIRF]XLIJEGXXLEXXLIIZIRX[EWWSPH
SYX ERH HIQERHJSVXLI GSRGIVX[EWLMKL -RHIIHIZIR XLI GSYVXEGORS[PIHKIH
XLEXQEVOIXJSVGIWSJWYTTP]ERHHIQERHMRJPYIRGIHXLITVMGIGLSWIRF],SPSLER
WIPPIVWfWIIOMRKETVSJMXSRVIWEPIWSJXMGOIXWXSWSPHSYXIZIRXW[SYPHREXYVEPP]
HVMZIXLIQEVOIXXSTVMGIWEFSZIJEGIZEPYIg6T
8LYWXLIGSYVXeWVINIGXMSRSJ'(%MQQYRMX][EWIVVSRISYW
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 34/97
)ZIR-J8LI'SYVX4VSTIVP]'SRWMHIVIH7XYF,YFeW)RXMVI&YWMRIWW7XYF,YF(MH2SX1EXIVMEPP]'SRXVMFYXI8S-PPIKEP8MGOIX4VMGIW
)ZIR EWWYQMRK MX [IVI TVSTIV JSV XLI GSYVX XS GSRWMHIV 7XYF,YFeW IRXMVI
FYWMRIWW QSHIP 7XYF,YFWXMPPMW IRXMXPIHXS '(% MQQYRMX] 8LI XSSPWXLI GSYVX
VIPMIH YTSR XS HIR] 7XYF,YF MQQYRMX] EVI fGSRXIRXRIYXVEPg XSSPW XLEX GSYVXW
VSYXMRIP] LEZI LIPH HS RSX GSQTVSQMWI ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIeW
IRXMXPIQIRXXSMQQYRMX]7IIIK'SRWYQIVEJJEMVW*HEJJMVQMRK
HMWQMWWEP [LIVI WXVYGXYVI ERH HIWMKR SJ [IFWMXI HMH RSX fGSRXVMFYXI?A XS XLI
EPPIKIHP]JVEYHYPIRXREXYVISJXLIGSQQIRXWEXMWWYIg 6SSQQEXIWGSQ*H
EX YTLSPHMRK MQQYRMX] VIKEVHMRK YWIVeW HMWGVMQMREXSV] GSQQIRXW IK
f238PSSOMRKJSVFPEGO1YWPMQWgFIGEYWIf?XALIWYFWGVMFIVMWTVIWIRXIH[MXLE
FPERO XI\X FS\ MR [LMGL LI GER X]TI EW QYGL SV EW PMXXPI EFSYX LMQWIPJ EW LI
[MWLIWg ERH f6SSQQEXIW TYFPMWLIW XLIWI GSQQIRXW EW [VMXXIRg MH EX
fTVSZMHMRK RIYXVEP XSSPW XS GEVV] SYX [LEX QE] FI YRPE[JYP SV MPPMGMX ?LSYWMRKA
WIEVGLIW HSIW RSX EQSYRX XS dHIZIPSTQIRXe JSV TYVTSWIW SJ XLI MQQYRMX]
I\GITXMSRg .YVMR Z+SSKPI -RG*7YTTH)('EP
fWYKKIWXMRK OI][SVHW XS GSQTIXMRK EHZIVXMWIVWg EPPIKIH XS ZMSPEXI TPEMRXMJJeW
XVEHIQEVO HMH RSX HMWUYEPMJ] +SSKPI JVSQ '(% MQQYRMX] FIGEYWI XLI OI][SVH
WYKKIWXMSR XSSP [EW RIYXVEP ERH fHSIW RSXLMRK QSVI XLER TVSZMHI STXMSRW XLEX
EHZIVXMWIVWGSYPHEHSTXSVVINIGXEXXLIMVHMWGVIXMSRg
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 35/97
0MOIXLIWISXLIVGEWIW7XYF,YFeWf%ZIVEKI4VMGI[MRHS[gERHf,MWXSVMGEP
7EPIW8SSPgHSRSXfQEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIgXSMPPIKEPXMGOIXTVMGIW8SXLIGSRXVEV]
7XYF,YFHMWTPE]WE GSQTMPEXMSRSJ MRJSVQEXMSRHIVMZIHJVSQGSRXIRXTVSZMHIHF]
SXLIV VIWIPPIVW 9PXMQEXIP] XLI YWIV RSX 7XYF,YF HIGMHIW LS[ XS YWI XLI
MRJSVQEXMSR MJ EX EPP ,SPSLER I\TPEMRIH XLMW [LIR LI XIWXMJMIH VIKEVHMRK XLI
f%ZIVEKI4VMGI[MRHS[g[LMGLLILEHYWIHMRSXLIVXVERWEGXMSRW
5 (MHXLMWFS\ WE] XLEX ]SY WLSYPH MRGVIEWI XLITVMGI ]SYLEHMRTYX#
% 2S
5 (MHXLMWFS\ WE] XLEX ]SYWLSYPHHIGVIEWIXLITVMGI]SYLEHMRTYX#
% 2S
5 (MHMXXIPP]SYXSGLERKIXLITVMGI]SYLEHMRTYX#
% 2S6TT
8LIWEQILSPHWXVYIJSV7XYF,YFeWf0EVKI7IPPIVWTVSKVEQg7XYF,YFMWRSX
QEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXMRK XS SV IZIR IRGSYVEKMRK 0EVKI7IPPIVW XS WIPP EFSZI JEGI
ZEPYI MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI WXEXYXI 6EXLIV EGGSVHMRK XS XLI GSYVX 0EVKI7IPPIVW
EPVIEH]LEZIWIXSYXXSQEOIETVSJMX6T
1SVISZIVJSVWSPHSYXIZIRXW
8LIGSYVXeWVIPMERGISRSXLIVEWTIGXWSJ7XYF,YFeWf0EVKI7IPPIVWTVSKVEQgWYGLEW KMZMRK XLIQ ER EHHMXMSREP HE] XS PMWX XLIMV XMGOIXW SV 7XYF,YFeW FYWMRIWWKIRIVEPP] WYGL EW fGSRXVSP?PMRKA TE]QIRX ERH HIPMZIV] TVSLMFMXMRK GSRXEGX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 36/97
WYGLEWXLIGSRGIVXEXMWWYIXLIGSYVXEGORS[PIHKIHXLEXQEVOIXJSVGIWHVMZITVMGIW
EFSZI JEGI EQSYRXW *YVXLIV VIKEVHPIWW SJ 7XYF,YFeW MRXIVEGXMSRW [MXL
0EVKI7IPPIVWXLI]RSX7XYF,YFGLSSWIXLIVIWEPITVMGIJSVXLIMVXMGOIXW8LYWXLI
GSYVXIVVIHF]HIR]MRK7XYF,YFMQQYRMX]FIGEYWI7XYF,YFEPPS[IHIRGSYVEKIH
SV JEGMPMXEXIH 0EVKI7IPPIVW XS YWI MXW [IFWMXI -J XLEX [IVI XLI GSVVIGX WXERHEVH
'(%MQQYRMX][SYPHFIYREZEMPEFPIXSER][IFWMXIXLEXMRER][E]WSPMGMXWYWIVW
8LIGSYVXEPWSIVVIHMRVYPMRKXLEX7XYF,YFMRJPYIRGIWTVMGMRKF]IREFPMRK
0EVKI7IPPIVW XS GLSSWI XS LEZI XLIMV TVMGIW EYXSQEXMGEPP] MRGVIEWIH XS GSZIV
7XYF,YFeW WIPPIV WIVZMGI JII 8LMW XSSP HSIW RSX MRJPYIRGI TVMGMRK 8LI
0EVKI7IPPIV WIXW XLI TVMGI ERH MW QIVIP] KMZIR XLI STXMSR XS YWI E GEPGYPEXSV XS
MRGPYHIXLIJIISVETSVXMSRXLIVISJ8LIYWIVVIXEMRWWSPIHMWGVIXMSR[LIXLIVXSYWI
XLIGEPGYPEXSVSVRSX6T-XMWEXSSPXLEX7XYF,YFQIVIP]XYVRWSRJSVXLSWI
[LSGLSSWIXSYWIMXEWHIQSRWXVEXIHF]XLIVIGSVHIZMHIRGIWLS[MRKXLEXEXPIEWX
SJ0EVKI7IPPIVWGLSSWIRSXXSYWIXLMWXSSP -H
*MREPP] 7XYF,YF VIUYMVIW EPP WIPPIVW XS EKVII XS E 9WIV %KVIIQIRX XLEX
VIUYMVIW ERH [EVRW WIPPIVW XS GSQTP] [MXL ETTPMGEFPI PE[W %RH IZIV] TEKI SJ
FIX[IIRFY]IVERHWIPPIVg[EWQMWTPEGIHFIGEYWIXLMWGSRHYGXLEWRSXLMRKXSHS[MXLGSRXIRXSRXLIWMXIPIXEPSRIXLIGSRXIRXEXMWWYI6TT
8LIGSYVXEPWSMRGSVVIGXP]JSYRHXLEX7XYF,YFfTVSZMHIHEGYWXSQIVWIVZMGIXLEXMRWXVYGXW WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW SR TVMGMRK ?ERHA KMZIW dKIRIVEP KYMHERGIe SR TVMGMRKXSMRHMZMHYEPWIPPIVWERHXS0EVKI7IPPIVWg6T8LIIZMHIRGIMRXLIVIGSVHSRXLMWTSMRX[EWXSXLIGSRXVEV]6TT
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 37/97
7XYF,YFeW[IFWMXIGSRXEMRWEHMWGPEMQIVXLEXI\TVIWWP]WXEXIWXLEX7XYF,YFMWRSX
XLIWIPPIVERHXLEXXLITVMGIQE]HMJJIVJVSQJEGIZEPYI8LYWXLIGSYVXJSYRHXLEX
7XYF,YFfYWIHEPPXLIVMKLXHMWGPEMQIVWERH[EVRMRKWMRMXWYWIVEKVIIQIRXERHSR
MXW [IFWMXIg 6 T -R WYGL GMVGYQWXERGIW GSYVXW LEZI YTLIPH '(%
MQQYRMX]7IIIK (EVXZ'VEMKWPMWX-RG*7YTTH2(-PP
YTLSPHMRK'(%MQQYRMX]FIGEYWI[IFWMXIHMHfRS?XARIGIWWEVMP]GEPPJSVg
ERHfVITIEXIHP][EVR?IHAYWIVWRSXXSTSWX?MPPIKEPAGSRXIRXg +SHHEVHZ+SSKPI
-RG * 7YTT H 2( 'EP YTLSPHMRK '(% MQQYRMX]
[LIVI fXLI EPPIKIHP] QMWPIEHMRK TSWXMRKW [IVI GSRXVEV] XS +SSKPIeW I\TVIWW
TSPMG] [LMGL [EVRW EHZIVXMWIVW XLEX XLI] EVI VIWTSRWMFPI JSV XLI OI][SVHW XLI]
WIPIGXERHJSVIRWYVMRKXLEXXLIMVOI][SVHWHSRSXZMSPEXIER]PE[Wg
8LIGSYVXIZIRVIJIVVIHXS7XYF,YFeW*ER 4VSXIGX j+YEVERXIIEWEVIEWSR
JSVHIR]MRKMQQYRMX]6T&YXXLIWIWIVZMGIWEVIHIWMKRIHXSTVSZMHIYWIVW
[MXLEWEJIGYWXSQIVI\TIVMIRGIERHTPE]RSVSPIMRWIXXMRKXMGOIXTVMGIW7XYF,YF
[EWGVIEXIHEWEREPXIVREXMZIXSXMGOIXWGEPTMRKSRWXVIIXGSVRIVW[LIVIXLIVMWOWSJ
LEVQEVILMKL9WIVTVSXIGXMSRQIEWYVIWWYGLEWKYEVERXIIMRKXMGOIXWERHIRWYVMRK
XLI TE]QIRX SJ QSRI] [LMGL FIRIJMX FSXL FY]IVW ERH VIWIPPIVW WLSYPH FI
IRGSYVEKIH -QTPEYWMFP] PMROMRK XLIQ XS EPPIKIH MPPIKEP TVMGMRK EW E FEWMW JSV
HIR]MRK'(%MQQYRMX]EWXLIGSYVXHMHLEWXLISTTSWMXIIJJIGX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 38/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 39/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 40/97
XLII\XIRXVIWEPIWXSSOTPEGIMRZMSPEXMSRSJq7XYF,YFHMHRSXfIRGSYVEKIg
XLEXMPPIKEPFILEZMSV-X[EWRSXEfTVIHMGXEFPIGSRWIUYIRGIgSJMXWFYWMRIWWEWMR
6SSQQEXIW [LIVI XLI WMXI QEHI fERW[IVMRK XLI HMWGVMQMREXSV] UYIWXMSRW E
GSRHMXMSRSJHSMRKFYWMRIWWg*HEX-RWXIEHEW[SYPHFIXLIGEWIJSV
ER] WSPHSYX IZIRX [LIXLIV MX FI E ,ERREL 1SRXERE GSRGIVX SV E (YOI92'
FEWOIXFEPPKEQIQEVOIXJSVGIWHMGXEXITVMGIWEFSZIXLIJEGIEQSYRX'SRZIVWIP]
JSVPIWWTSTYPEVIZIRXWPMOIWSQI(YOIJSSXFEPPKEQIWTVMGIW[SYPHFII\TIGXIH
XSFI [IPPFIPS[JEGIZEPYIEKEMRHMGXEXIH F]XLI QEVOIX -X WXVEMRW GVIHYPMX] XS
WYKKIWX XLEX 7XYF,YF IRGSYVEKIW WIPPIVW XS GLEVKI QSVI SV PIWW XLER XLI JEGI
EQSYRXJSVXLIWIX]TIWSJIZIRXW%WSRIGSYVXLIPHf-JWIPPIVWYWMRK7XYF,YFeW
[IFWMXIWYGGIWWJYPP]GLEVKITVMGIWEFSZIJEGIZEPYIXLI]GERHSWSFIGEYWISJXLI
PE[SJWYTTP]ERHHIQERHg;IMRWXIMRZI&E]-RG 2S'MZ
;0EX7(2=.YRIHMWQMWWMRKGPEMQ
8LYWIZIRYRHIVXLIGSYVXeWMRGSVVIGXWXERHEVH7XYF,YFMWMQQYRI
-: 8,) '3968 )6632)3970= ,)0( 8,%8 789&,9& :-30%8)(8,)9(84%
%WEXLVIWLSPHQEXXIVXLI9(84%GPEMQ[EWRSXTVSTIVP]FIJSVIXLIGSYVX
7II6T8LITEVXMIWSRP]FVMIJIHERHQSZIHJSVWYQQEV]NYHKQIRXSR'(%
MQQYRMX]ERH7XYF,YFLEHRSRSXMGIXLEXXLIGSYVX[EWGSRWMHIVMRKSXLIVMWWYIW
'SRXVEV] XS XLI GSYVXeW WYKKIWXMSR 6 T IZIR YWIVW SJ [IFWMXIW PMOI'VEMKWPMWXPMWXXMGOIXWEFSZIJEGIZEPYI[LIRHMGXEXIHF]WYTTP]ERHHIQERH
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 41/97
8LYWXLIGSYVXWLSYPHRSXLEZIVIEGLIHXLIQIVMXWSJXLI9(84%GPEMQERHXLI
VYPMRKMWVIZIVWMFPISRXLMWFEWMWEPSRI'J%QSHISZ&IZIVP]2'%TT
ZEGEXMRKHIGMWMSRXLEXfEQSYRX?IHAXSWYQQEV]NYHKQIRXSREX
PIEWX SRI SJ XLI MWWYIWg FIGEYWI f?HAIJIRHERXW LEH RSX QSZIH JSV WYQQEV]
NYHKQIRXERHTPEMRXMJJLEHRSRSXMGIXLEXWYGL[EWFIMRKGSRWMHIVIHg*YVXLIVXLI
GSYVXeW9(84%VYPMRKMWGSRXVEV]XSPE[ERHWLSYPHFIVIZIVWIH
% %q:MSPEXMSR-W2SX% 4IV7I9(84%:MSPEXMSR
%WHMWGYWWIHEFSZI7XYF,YFHMHRSXZMSPEXIqERHXLYW7XYF,YFeW
GSRHYGXGERRSXFIfHIGITXMZIgSVfYRJEMVg1SVISZIVIZIRMJ7XYF,YFZMSPEXIH
qXLEXHSIW RSX EYXSQEXMGEPP]EQSYRX XSE 9(84% ZMSPEXMSR 8LMW 'SYVX
LEW QEHI GPIEV XLEX fXLIVI MW RS WYTTSVX JSV XLI TVSTSWMXMSR XLEX dZMSPEXMSRW SJ
WXEXYXIWKIRIVEPP]GSRWXMXYXIWE TIVWIHIGITXMZISVYRJEMVXVEHITVEGXMGIeg &EVXPIXX
1MPPMRK 'S Z ;EPRYX +VSZI %YGXMSR ERH 6IEPX] 'S 2' %TT
IQTLEWMWEHHIH
8LI PIKMWPEXYVI EPWS LEW QEHI XLMW GPIEV %W SJ %YKYWX XLI
PIKMWPEXYVIIREGXIHEWXEXYXII\TVIWWP]TIVQMXXMRKVIWEPIWEFSZIJEGIZEPYISRXLI
-RXIVRIX7IIq-RGSQTEVMWSRXLIPIKMWPEXYVII\TVIWWP]QEHIEHMJJIVIRX
7II EPWS ;EPOIV Z *PIIX[SSH ,SQIW SJ 2' -RG 2'
fZMSPEXMSRSJ EVIKYPEXSV]WXEXYXI[LMGLKSZIVRWFYWMRIWWEGXMZMXMIWQE]EPWSFIEZMSPEXMSR SJ 2' +IR 7XEX qg IQTLEWMW EHHIH 0]SRW 4cWLMT 04 Z
1SVVMW'SWXYQIW-RG*HXL'MVXVEHIQEVOERHGST]VMKLXZMSPEXMSRWEVIRSX TIVWIZMSPEXMSRWSJq
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 42/97
ZMSPEXMSR SJXLI XMGOIX WXEXYXIE 9(84%ZMSPEXMSR 7TIGMJMGEPP] ER] TIVWSR [LS
ORS[MRKP] WIPPW YWIW SV HMWXVMFYXIW fWSJX[EVI XLEX MW TVMQEVMP] HIWMKRIH SV
TVSHYGIH JSV XLI TYVTSWI SJMRXIVJIVMRK [MXL XLI STIVEXMSR SJE XMGOIX WIPPIV [LS
WIPPWSZIVXLI-RXIVRIXWLEPPFIMRZMSPEXMSRSJ+7g2'+7q
8LYW [LIR XLI PIKMWPEXYVI MRXIRHW E ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI XMGOIX WXEXYXI XS
GSRWXMXYXIE9(84%ZMSPEXMSRMXORS[WLS[XSHSWS 7IIIK3HIPPZ0IKEP
&YGOW00' 2'%TTLSPHMRK2'+7qZMSPEXMSR
[EWRSXE TIVWIZMSPEXMSRSJqFIGEYWIXLIPIKMWPEXYVITVSZMHIHXLEXGIVXEMR
ZMSPEXMSRW[IVIYRJEMVERHHIGITXMZIEGXWERHq[EWRSXEQSRKXLIQ8LIVI
[EWRSWYGLTVSZMWMSRLIVI
& 8LI9(84%'PEMQ*EMPW&IGEYWI8LIVI;EW2S(IGITXMSRSV-RNYV]
8S WYGGIIH SR E 9(84% GPEMQ E TPEMRXMJJ QYWX TVSZI f HIJIRHERXW
GSQQMXXIHERYRJEMVSVHIGITXMZIEGXSVTVEGXMGIMRSVEJJIGXMRKGSQQIVGIERH
XLEXTPEMRXMJJ[EWMRNYVIHXLIVIF]g &EVXPIXX 2'%TTEX%TVEGXMGIMW
fHIGITXMZIg SRP] MJ XLI GLEPPIRKIH GSRHYGX LEW XLI fGETEGMX] SV XIRHIRG] XS
HIGIMZIg .SLRWSRZ4LSIRM\1YX0MJI-RW'S2'2)H
EFVSKEXIHSRSXLIVKVSYRH 1]IVW'LETQER-RGZ8LSQEW
+)ZERW-RG2'f-RHIXIVQMRMRK[LIXLIVEVITVIWIRXEXMSRMW
HIGITXMZIMXWIJJIGXSRXLIEZIVEKIGSRWYQIVMWGSRWMHIVIHg3TWELPZ4MRILYVWX
-RG2'%TT
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 43/97
%TVEGXMGIMWfYRJEMVgMJMXfSJJIRHWIWXEFPMWLIHTYFPMGTSPMG]EW[IPPEW[LIR
XLI TVEGXMGI MW MQQSVEP YRIXLMGEP STTVIWWMZI YRWGVYTYPSYW SV WYFWXERXMEPP]
MRNYVMSYWXSGSRWYQIVWg 1EVWLEPPZ1MPPIV 2'f?8ALI
JEMVSVYRJEMVREXYVISJTEVXMGYPEVGSRHYGXMWXSFINYHKIHF]ZMI[MRKMXEKEMRWXXLI
FEGOKVSYRHSJEGXYEPLYQERI\TIVMIRGIERHF]HIXIVQMRMRKMXWMRXIRHIHERHEGXYEP
IJJIGXWYTSRSXLIVWg 9RMXIH0EFW-RGZ/Y]OIRHEPP 2'%TT
EJJcH 2' 'SYVXW EPWS LEZI VIUYMVIH fWSQI X]TI SJ
IKVIKMSYWSVEKKVEZEXMRKGMVGYQWXERGIWgFIJSVIGSRGPYHMRKXLEXEXVEHITVEGXMGIMW
E9(84%ZMSPEXMSR7II(EPXSRZ'EQT2'
%KEMRWXXLIJSVIKSMRKXLIGSYVXeWPMEFMPMX]HIXIVQMREXMSR[EW[VSRK&IJSVI
4PEMRXMJJW TYVGLEWIH XLI 8MGOIXW 7XYF,YFeW [IFWMXI HMWGPSWIH XLEX XLI] [IVI
FY]MRKXLIQJVSQEXLMVHTEVX]RSX7XYF,YFERHXLEXXLITVMGIWQE]FIEFSZI
JEGI ZEPYI -RHIIH XLI GSYVX JSYRH XLEX 4PEMRXMJJW f?PAMOI QSWX TYVGLEWIVW SJ
XMGOIXWXSWSPHSYXIZIRXWWLSYPHLEZII\TIGXIHXLEXXLIXMGOIXW[IVIRSXSJJIVIH
EXJEGIZEPYISVEXPIEWXQEHIWSQIMRUYMV]g6T7XYF,YFEPWSVIUYMVIH
,SPSLER XS EKVII RSX XS ZMSPEXI ETTPMGEFPI XMGOIX PE[W PMOI XLI WXEXYXI EX MWWYI
-RHIIHXLIGSYVXJSYRHXLEX7XYF,YFfYWIHEPPXLIVMKLXHMWGPEMQIVWERH[EVRMRKW
MR MXW YWIV EKVIIQIRX ERH SR MXW [IFWMXIg 6 T %GGSVHMRKP] 7XYF,YFeW
GSRHYGXGERRSXFIHIIQIHHIGITXMZISVYRJEMV 7II;IMRWXIMR;0
EXHMWQMWWMRK2I[=SVO9(84%GPEMQFIGEYWIRSfVIEWSREFPIGSRWYQIVg
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 44/97
GSYPHLEZIFIIRHIGIMZIH[LIVITYVGLEWIV[MPPMRKP]TEMHQEVOIXTVMGIERHGSYPH
LEZIGLIGOIHXSWIIMJWLI[EWTE]MRKQSVIXLERJEGIZEPYIf[MXLRSHMJJMGYPX]g
ERH7XYF,YFeWfHMWGPSWYVIWFIPMI?HAER]GPEMQSJHIGITXMSRg
1SVISZIVRSX[MXLWXERHMRKXLEXqMWEGSRWYQIVTVSXIGXMSRWXEXYXIER]
HSYFXW EW XS [LIXLIV 7XYF,YFeW GSRHYGX fSJJIRHW IWXEFPMWLIH TYFPMG TSPMG]g
WLSYPHFIVIWSPZIHMR7XYF,YFeWJEZSVWMRGIZMSPEXMSRWSJqEVIWYFNIGXXS
GVMQMREPTIREPXMIWERHXLYWfQYWXFIWXVMGXP]GSRWXVYIHg7IIIK*YVVZ*SRZMPPI
1SVMWI]6IEPX]-RG2'%TT
*MREPP] XLI GSYVX JEMPIH XS EHHVIWW [LIXLIV 4PEMRXMJJW [IVI MRNYVIH F]
7XYF,YFeW EGXMSRW IZIR XLSYKL MX MW [IPPWIXXPIH XLEX 4PEMRXMJJW QYWX fIWXEFPMWL
XLI] dWYJJIVIH EGXYEP MRNYV] EW E TVS\MQEXI VIWYPX SJ HIJIRHERXWe ?YRJEMV SV
HIGITXMZI EGXAeg )H[EVHW Z ;IWX 2' %TT ,IVI
4PEMRXMJJWfE[MPPMRKTYVGLEWIVg[LSfWLSYPHLEZII\TIGXIHXLEXXLIXMGOIXW[IVI
RSXSJJIVIHEXJEGIZEPYIg6TGERRSXWLS[MRNYV]ERHXSXLII\XIRXXLI]
GER ,SPSLER RSX 7XYF,YF GEYWIH XLI MRNYV] 7II IK &YW 'EFPMRK -RG Z
=SOIP] 2' %TT HMWQMWWMRK 9(84% GPEMQ [LIVI fRS
IZMHIRGIXIRHWXSWLS[?A TPEMRXMJJ WYJJIVIHEGXYEP MRNYV] EWE TVS\MQEXI VIWYPX SJ
HIJIRHERXeWHIGITXMZIWXEXIQIRXSVQMWVITVIWIRXEXMSRg
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 45/97
'32'097-32
*SV XLI JSVIKSMRK VIEWSRW XLI GSYVXeW VYPMRK WLSYPH FI VIZIVWIH ERH
NYHKQIRXIRXIVIHMR7XYF,YFeWJEZSV%PXIVREXMZIP]XLMW'SYVXWLSYPHVIZIVWIERH
VIQERHJSVJYVXLIVTVSGIIHMRKWSR4PEMRXMJJWeMRHMZMHYEPGPEMQW
6IWTIGXJYPP]WYFQMXXIHXLMWXLHE]SJ.YP]
/0+%8)7004
W.SLR,'YPZIV--- .SLR,'YPZIV---
2'&EV2S1SPP]01G-RXSWL
2'&EV2S,IEVWX8S[IV
XL*PSSV
2SVXL8V]SR7XVIIX'LEVPSXXI2SVXL'EVSPMRE(MVIGX)QEMPNSLRGYPZIV$OPKEXIWGSQ
2'%TT4F'IVXMJMGEXMSR-GIVXMJ]XLEXEPPSJXLIEXXSVRI]WPMWXIHFIPS[LEZIEYXLSVM^IHQIXSPMWX XLIMV REQIW SR XLMW HSGYQIRX EW MJ XLI] LEHWMKRIHMX
;)-0+387,%01%2+)7004
W(EZMH.0IRHIV (EZMH.0IRHIV
2=&EV2S
*MJXL%ZIRYI 2I[=SVO2=(MVIGX)QEMPHEZMHPIRHIV$[IMPGSQ
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 46/97
'330)=+3(;%6(/632-7,004
1MGLEIP+6LSHIW'%&EV2S
)EWXKEXI1EPP7ER(MIKS'%(MVIGX)QEMPVLSHIWQK$GSSPI]GSQ
%XXSVRI]WJSV(IJIRHERX%TTIPPERX
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 47/97
')68-*-'%8)3*'3140-%2')
4YVWYERXXS6YPINSJXLI6YPIWSJ%TTIPPEXI4VSGIHYVIGSYRWIPJSVXLI
%TTIPPERXGIVXMJMIWXLEXXLIJSVIKSMRKFVMIJ[LMGLMWTVITEVIHYWMRKETVSTSVXMSREP
JSRX MW PIWW XLER [SVHW I\GPYHMRK GSZIV MRHI\IW XEFPIW SJ EYXLSVMXMIW
GIVXMJMGEXIWSJWIVZMGIXLMWGIVXMJMGEXISJGSQTPMERGIERHETTIRHM\IWEWVITSVXIHF]
XLI[SVHTVSGIWWMRKWSJX[EVI
W.SLR,'YPZIV---.SLR,'YPZIV---
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 48/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 49/97
'SRXIRXWSJ%TTIRHM\
97'q
2'+7q
2'+7q
2'+7q
2'+7q
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 50/97
97'� 4EKI
�8LSQWSR6IYXIVW2S'PEMQXS3VMK97+SZ;SVOW
)JJIGXMZI3GXSFIV
9RMXIH7XEXIW'SHI%RRSXEXIH'YVVIRXRIWW8MXPI8IPIKVETLW8IPITLSRIWERH6EHMSXIPIKVETLW
'LETXIV;MVISV6EHMS'SQQYRMGEXMSR6IJW%RRSW
7YFGLETXIV--'SQQSR'EVVMIVW6IJW%RRSW
4EVX-'SQQSR'EVVMIV6IKYPEXMSR
�4VSXIGXMSRJSVTVMZEXIFPSGOMRKERHWGVIIRMRKSJSJJIRWMZIQEXIVMEP
E*MRHMRKW
8LI'SRKVIWWJMRHWXLIJSPPS[MRK
8LIVETMHP]HIZIPSTMRKEVVE]SJ-RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWEZEMPEFPIXSMRHMZMHYEP%QIVM
GERWVITVIWIRXERI\XVESVHMREV]EHZERGIMRXLIEZEMPEFMPMX]SJIHYGEXMSREPERHMRJSVQEXMSREPVIWSYVGIWXSSYVGMXM^IRW
8LIWIWIVZMGIWSJJIVYWIVWEKVIEXHIKVIISJGSRXVSPSZIVXLIMRJSVQEXMSRXLEXXLI]VIGIMZIEW[IPPEWXLITSXIRXMEPJSVIZIRKVIEXIVGSRXVSPMRXLIJYXYVIEWXIGLRSPSK]HIZIPSTW
8LI -RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWSJJIVEJSVYQJSVE XVYIHMZIVWMX]SJ TSPMXMGEPHMWGSYVWI
YRMUYISTTSVXYRMXMIWJSVGYPXYVEPHIZIPSTQIRXERHQ]VMEHEZIRYIWJSVMRXIPPIGXYEPEGXMZMX]
8LI -RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWLEZIJPSYVMWLIHXS XLIFIRIJMXSJ EPP%QIVMGERW[MXLE
QMRMQYQSJKSZIVRQIRXVIKYPEXMSR
-RGVIEWMRKP]%QIVMGERWEVIVIP]MRKSRMRXIVEGXMZIQIHMEJSVEZEVMIX]SJTSPMXMGEPIHYGEXMSREPGYPXYVEPERHIR
XIVXEMRQIRXWIVZMGIW
F4SPMG]
-XMWXLITSPMG]SJXLI9RMXIH7XEXIW
XSTVSQSXIXLIGSRXMRYIHHIZIPSTQIRXSJXLI-RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIQIHME
XSTVIWIVZIXLIZMFVERXERHGSQTIXMXMZIJVIIQEVOIXXLEXTVIWIRXP]I\MWXWJSVXLI-RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWYRJIXXIVIHF]*IHIVEPSV7XEXIVIKYPEXMSR
XSIRGSYVEKIXLIHIZIPSTQIRXSJXIGLRSPSKMIW[LMGLQE\MQM^IYWIVGSRXVSPSZIV[LEXMRJSVQEXMSRMWVIGIMZIH F]MRHMZMHYEPWJEQMPMIWERHWGLSSPW[LSYWIXLI-RXIVRIXERHSXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIW
-1-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 51/97
97'� 4EKI
�8LSQWSR6IYXIVW2S'PEMQXS3VMK97+SZ;SVOW
XSVIQSZIHMWMRGIRXMZIW JSVXLI HIZIPSTQIRXERH YXMPM^EXMSRSJ FPSGOMRKERH JMPXIVMRK XIGLRSPSKMIWXLEXIQ
TS[IVTEVIRXWXSVIWXVMGXXLIMVGLMPHVIRWEGGIWWXSSFNIGXMSREFPISVMRETTVSTVMEXISRPMRIQEXIVMEPERH
XSIRWYVIZMKSVSYWIRJSVGIQIRXSJ*IHIVEPGVMQMREPPE[WXSHIXIVERHTYRMWLXVEJJMGOMRKMRSFWGIRMX]WXEPOMRK
ERHLEVEWWQIRXF]QIERWSJGSQTYXIV
G4VSXIGXMSRJSVwKSSHWEQEVMXERxFPSGOMRKERHWGVIIRMRKSJSJJIRWMZIQEXIVMEP
8VIEXQIRXSJTYFPMWLIVSVWTIEOIV
2STVSZMHIVSVYWIVSJERMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWLEPPFIXVIEXIHEWXLITYFPMWLIVSVWTIEOIVSJER]MRJSVQEXMSRTVSZMHIHF]ERSXLIVMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIV
'MZMPPMEFMPMX]
2STVSZMHIVSVYWIVSJERMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWLEPPFILIPHPMEFPISREGGSYRXSJ
%ER]EGXMSRZSPYRXEVMP]XEOIRMRKSSHJEMXLXSVIWXVMGXEGGIWWXSSVEZEMPEFMPMX]SJQEXIVMEPXLEXXLITVSZMHIVSVYWIVGSRWMHIVWXSFISFWGIRIPI[HPEWGMZMSYWJMPXL]I\GIWWMZIP]ZMSPIRXLEVEWWMRKSVSXLIV[MWISFNIGXMSREFPI
[LIXLIVSVRSXWYGLQEXIVMEPMWGSRWXMXYXMSREPP]TVSXIGXIHSV
&ER]EGXMSRXEOIRXSIREFPISVQEOIEZEMPEFPIXSMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIVWSVSXLIVWXLIXIGLRMGEPQIERW
XSVIWXVMGXEGGIWWXSQEXIVMEPHIWGVMFIHMRTEVEKVETL
H3FPMKEXMSRWSJMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGI
%TVSZMHIVSJMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIWLEPPEXXLIXMQISJIRXIVMRKEREKVIIQIRX[MXLEGYWXSQIVJSVXLITVSZM
WMSRSJMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIERHMREQERRIVHIIQIHETTVSTVMEXIF]XLITVSZMHIVRSXMJ]WYGLGYWXSQIVXLEX TEVIRXEPGSRXVSPTVSXIGXMSRWWYGLEWGSQTYXIVLEVH[EVIWSJX[EVISVJMPXIVMRKWIVZMGIWEVIGSQQIVGMEPP]EZEMPEFPI
XLEXQE]EWWMWXXLIGYWXSQIVMRPMQMXMRKEGGIWWXSQEXIVMEPXLEXMWLEVQJYPXS QMRSVW7YGLRSXMGIWLEPPMHIRXMJ]SV
TVSZMHIXLIGYWXSQIV[MXLEGGIWWXSMRJSVQEXMSRMHIRXMJ]MRKGYVVIRXTVSZMHIVWSJWYGLTVSXIGXMSRW
I)JJIGXSRSXLIVPE[W
2SIJJIGXSRGVMQMREPPE[
2SXLMRKMRXLMWWIGXMSRWLEPPFIGSRWXVYIHXSMQTEMVXLIIRJSVGIQIRXSJWIGXMSRSVSJXLMWXMXPIGLETXIVVIPEXMRKXSSFWGIRMX]SVVIPEXMRKXSWI\YEPI\TPSMXEXMSRSJGLMPHVIRSJ8MXPISVER]SXLIV*IHIVEPGVMQMREPWXEXYXI
2SIJJIGXSRMRXIPPIGXYEPTVSTIVX]PE[
2SXLMRKMRXLMWWIGXMSRWLEPPFIGSRWXVYIHXSPMQMXSVI\TERHER]PE[TIVXEMRMRKXSMRXIPPIGXYEPTVSTIVX]
7XEXIPE[
2SXLMRKMRXLMWWIGXMSRWLEPPFIGSRWXVYIHXSTVIZIRXER]7XEXIJVSQIRJSVGMRKER]7XEXIPE[XLEXMWGSRWMWXIRX[MXL
-2-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 52/97
97'� 4EKI
�8LSQWSR6IYXIVW2S'PEMQXS3VMK97+SZ;SVOW
XLMWWIGXMSR2SGEYWISJEGXMSRQE]FIFVSYKLXERHRSPMEFMPMX]QE]FIMQTSWIHYRHIVER]7XEXISVPSGEPPE[XLEX
MWMRGSRWMWXIRX[MXLXLMWWIGXMSR
2SIJJIGXSR'SQQYRMGEXMSRW4VMZEG]PE[
2SXLMRKMRXLMWWIGXMSRWLEPPFIGSRWXVYIHXSPMQMXXLIETTPMGEXMSRSJXLI)PIGXVSRMG'SQQYRMGEXMSRW4VMZEG]%GX
SJSVER]SJXLIEQIRHQIRXWQEHIF]WYGL%GXSVER]WMQMPEV7XEXIPE[
J(IJMRMXMSRW
%WYWIHMRXLMWWIGXMSR
-RXIVRIX
8LI XIVQ w-RXIVRIXx QIERW XLI MRXIVREXMSREP GSQTYXIV RIX[SVO SJ FSXL *IHIVEP ERH RSR*IHIVEP MRXIVSTIVEFPI
TEGOIXW[MXGLIHHEXERIX[SVOW
-RXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGI
8LIXIVQwMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGIxQIERWER]MRJSVQEXMSRWIVZMGIW]WXIQSVEGGIWWWSJX[EVITVSZMHIVXLEX
TVSZMHIWSV IREFPIWGSQTYXIV EGGIWWF] QYPXMTPIYWIVW XSE GSQTYXIVWIVZIVMRGPYHMRKWTIGMJMGEPP]E WIVZMGISVW]WXIQXLEXTVSZMHIWEGGIWW XSXLI-RXIVRIXERH WYGLW]WXIQWSTIVEXIHSV WIVZMGIWSJJIVIHF] PMFVEVMIW SVIHYGE
XMSREPMRWXMXYXMSRW
-RJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIV
8LIXIVQwMRJSVQEXMSRGSRXIRXTVSZMHIVxQIERWER]TIVWSRSVIRXMX]XLEXMWVIWTSRWMFPIMR[LSPISVMRTEVXJSVXLI
GVIEXMSRSVHIZIPSTQIRXSJMRJSVQEXMSRTVSZMHIHXLVSYKLXLI-RXIVRIXSVER]SXLIVMRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIVWIVZMGI
%GGIWWWSJX[EVITVSZMHIV
8LIXIVQwEGGIWWWSJX[EVITVSZMHIVxQIERWETVSZMHIVSJ WSJX[EVIMRGPYHMRKGPMIRXSVWIVZIVWSJX[EVISV IRE FPMRKXSSPWXLEXHSER]SRISVQSVISJXLIJSPPS[MRK
%JMPXIVWGVIIREPPS[SVHMWEPPS[GSRXIRX
&TMGOGLSSWIEREP]^ISVHMKIWXGSRXIRXSV
'XVERWQMXVIGIMZIHMWTPE]JSV[EVHGEGLIWIEVGLWYFWIXSVKERM^IVISVKERM^ISVXVERWPEXIGSRXIRX
-3-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 53/97
+7 4EKI
�7EPISJEHQMWWMSRXMGOIXWMRI\GIWWSJTVMRXIHTVMGI
%R]TIVWSRJMVQSVGSVTSVEXMSRWLEPPFIEPPS[IHXSEHHEVIEWSREFPIWIVZMGIJIIXSXLIJEGIZEPYISJXLIXMGOIXWWSPHERHXLITIVWSRJMVQSVGSVTSVEXMSR[LMGLWIPPWSVVIWIPPWWYGLXMGOIXWWLEPPRSXFITIVQMXXIHXSVIGSYTJYRHWKVIEXIVXLERXLIGSQFMRIHJEGIZEPYISJXLIXMGOIXXE\ERHXLIEYXLSVM^IHWIVZMGIJII8LMWWIVZMGIJIIQE]RSXI\GIIHXLVIIHSPPEVWJSVIEGLXMGOIXI\GITXXLEXETVSQSXIVSVSTIVEXSVSJXLITVSTIVX][LIVIXLIIZIRX MWXSFILIPHERHEXMGOIXWEPIWEKIRG]QE]EKVIIMR[VMXMRKSREVIEWSREFPIWIVZMGIJIIKVIEXIVXLERXLVIIHSPPEVW
JSV XLI JMVWX WEPI SJ XMGOIXW F] XLI XMGOIX WEPIW EKIRX 8LMW WIVZMGI JII QE] FI E TVIIWXEFPMWLIHEQSYRXTIVXMGOIXSVETIVGIRXEKISJIEGLXMGOIX8LII\MWXIRGISJXLIWIVZMGIJII WLEPP FIQEHI ORS[RXS XLITYFPMG F] TVMRXMRKSV[VMXMRK XLI EQSYRX SJ XLI JIISR XLIXMGOIXW[LMGLEVITVMRXIHJSVXLIIZIRX%R]TIVWSRJMVQSVGSVTSVEXMSR[LMGLWIPPWSVSJJIVWXSWIPPEXMGOIXJSVETVMGIKVIEXIVXLERXLITVMGITIVQMXXIHF]XLMWWIGXMSRSVEWTIVQMXXIHF]+7WLEPPFIKYMPX]SJE'PEWWQMWHIQIERSVGGWGGGGGWGW)\7IWWGWGWWW
-4-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 54/97
+7 4EKI
� 'SRXMRKIRXVITIEPWIIRSXI -RXIVRIX WEPISJEHQMWWMSRXMGOIXWMRI\GIWWSJ
TVMRXIHTVMGIE -RXIVRIX6IWEPI %TIVWSRQE]VIWIPPEREHQMWWMSRXMGOIXYRHIVXLMWWIGXMSRSRXLI
-RXIVRIX EXE TVMGIKVIEXIVXLER XLITVMGISR XLIJEGISJ XLI XMGOIXSRP]MJEPPSJ XLIJSPPS[MRKGSRHMXMSRWEVIQIX
8LIZIRYI[LIVIXLIIZIRX[MPPSGGYVLEWRSXTVSLMFMXIHXLI-RXIVRIXXMGOIXVIWEPIEWTVSZMHIHYRHIVWYFWIGXMSRFSJXLMWWIGXMSR
8LITIVWSRVIWIPPMRKXLIXMGOIXSJJIVWXLIXMGOIXJSVVIWEPISRE;IFWMXI[MXLE XMGOIX KYEVERXII XLEX QIIXW XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ WYFWIGXMSR G SJ XLMWWIGXMSR%TVSWTIGXMZI TYVGLEWIVQYWX FIHMVIGXIH XS XLI KYEVERXII FIJSVIGSQTPIXMSRSJXLIVIWEPIXVERWEGXMSR
8LITIVWSRVIWIPPMRKXLIXMGOIXGSPPIGXWERHVIQMXWXSXLI7XEXIXLITVMZMPIKIXE\MREGGSVHERGI[MXL+7
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
XLMWWIGXMSRQYWXKYEVERXIIXSXLITYVGLEWIVEJYPPVIJYRHSJXLIEQSYRXTEMHJSVXLIXMGOIXYRHIVIEGLSJXLIJSPPS[MRKGSRHMXMSRW
8LIXMGOIXIHIZIRXMWGERGIPPIH6IEWSREFPILERHPMRKERHHIPMZIV]JIIWQE] FI[MXLLIPHJVSQXLIVIJYRHTVMGISJEGERGIPPIHXMGOIXIHIZIRXMJXLIXMGOIXKYEVERXIISRXLI;IFWMXIWTIGMJMGEPP]MRJSVQWXLITYVGLEWIVXLEXLERHPMRKERHHIPMZIV]JIIW[MPPFI[MXLLIPHJVSQXLIVIJYRHIHEQSYRX
8LITYVGLEWIV MW HIRMIH EHQMWWMSR XS XLI XMGOIXIH IZIRX 8LMW WYFHMZMWMSRHSIWRSXETTP]MJEHQMWWMSRXSXLIXMGOIXIHIZIRXMWHIRMIHXSXLITYVGLEWIV FIGEYWISJEREGXMSRSVSQMWWMSRSJXLITYVGLEWIV
8LIXMGOIXMWRSXHIPMZIVIH XS XLITYVGLEWIV MR XLIQERRIVHIWGVMFIHSR XLI;IFWMXISVTYVWYERXXSXLIHIPMZIV]KYEVERXIIQEHIF]XLIVIWIPPIVERHXLIJEMPYVIVIWYPXWMRXLITYVGLEWIVWMREFMPMX]XSEXXIRHXLIXMGOIXIHIZIRX
H 7XYHIRX 8MGOIXW 8LMW WIGXMSR HSIW RSX ETTP] XS WXYHIRX XMGOIXW MWWYIH F]MRWXMXYXMSRWSJLMKLIVIHYGEXMSRMR2SVXL'EVSPMREJSVWTSVXMRKIZIRXWI 6ITIEPIHF]7IWWMSR0E[WWGIJJIGXMZI.YRI
WWWWFG
-5-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 55/97
+7 4EKI
�4VSLMFMXMSRSRXMGOIXTYVGLEWMRKWSJX[EVI
E (IJMRMXMSR 8LIXIVQXMGOIXWIPPIVQIERW ETIVWSR[LSLEWI\IGYXIH E[VMXXIREKVIIQIRX[MXLXLIQEREKIQIRXSJER]ZIRYIMR2SVXL'EVSPMREJSVE WTSVXMRKIZIRXXLIEXIVQYWMGEPTIVJSVQERGISVTYFPMGIRXIVXEMRQIRXSJER]OMRHXSWIPPXMGOIXWXSXLIIZIRXSZIVXLI-RXIVRIXF 9RJEMV 8VEHI 4VEGXMGI % TIVWSR [LS ORS[MRKP] WIPPW KMZIW XVERWJIVW YWIW
HMWXVMFYXIW SVTSWWIWWIW WSJX[EVI XLEX MWTVMQEVMP] HIWMKRIHSVTVSHYGIH JSV XLI TYVTSWISJ
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
VIWTIGX XSXMGOIXW JSV[LMGLXLI TIVWSR SVJMVQMW XLI SVMKMREP XMGOIX WIPPIV WW
-6-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 56/97
+7 4EKI
�1IXLSHWSJGSQTIXMXMSREGXWERHTVEGXMGIWVIKYPEXIHPIKMWPEXMZITSPMG]E 9RJEMVQIXLSHWSJGSQTIXMXMSRMRSV EJJIGXMRKGSQQIVGI ERHYRJEMVSVHIGITXMZI
EGXWSVTVEGXMGIWMRSVEJJIGXMRKGSQQIVGIEVIHIGPEVIHYRPE[JYPF *SVTYVTSWIWSJ XLMWWIGXMSRGSQQIVGIMRGPYHIWEPPFYWMRIWWEGXMZMXMIWLS[IZIV
HIRSQMREXIH FYXHSIWRSX MRGPYHITVSJIWWMSREPWIVZMGIWVIRHIVIHF] EQIQFIV SJE PIEVRIH TVSJIWWMSRG 2SXLMRKMRXLMW WIGXMSRWLEPPETTP] XSEGXWHSRIF]XLITYFPMWLIVS[RIVEKIRXSV
IQTPS]IISJERI[WTETIVTIVMSHMGEPSVVEHMSSVXIPIZMWMSRWXEXMSRSVSXLIVEHZIVXMWMRKQIHMYQMRXLITYFPMGEXMSRSVHMWWIQMREXMSRSJEREHZIVXMWIQIRX[LIRXLIS[RIVEKIRXSVIQTPS]IIHMHRSXLEZIORS[PIHKISJXLIJEPWIQMWPIEHMRKSVHIGITXMZI GLEVEGXIVSJXLI EHZIVXMWIQIRXERH[LIRXLIRI[WTETIVTIVMSHMGEPSVVEHMSSVXIPIZMWMSRWXEXMSRSVSXLIVEHZIVXMWMRKQIHMYQHMHRSX LEZI E HMVIGX JMRERGMEP MRXIVIWX MR XLI WEPI SV HMWXVMFYXMSR SJ XLI EHZIVXMWIH TVSHYGX SVWIVZMGIH %R]TEVX]GPEMQMRKXSFII\IQTXJVSQXLITVSZMWMSRWSJXLMWWIGXMSRWLEPPLEZIXLI
FYVHIRSJTVSSJ[MXLVIWTIGXXSWYGLGPEMQGGWW
-7-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 57/97
',Z
%(()2(91
*ILVWZ7XYF,YF-RG'EWI2SWPMTST 3V'MV'X7ITX
+MFWSRZ'VEMKWPMWX-RG2S'MZ;07(2=.YRI
24700'Z7XYF,YF-RG2S&07;0
1EWW7YTIV'X.ER
7LMEQMPMZ6IEP)WXEXI+VSYTSJ2I[=SVO 2S2=
)<-72='X%TT.YRI
7XSRIVZ)FE]-RG'MZ2S;0'EP7YTIV'X2SZ
;IMRWXIMRZI&E]-RG2S'MZ;0
7(2=.YRI
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 58/97
-1-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 59/97
-2-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 60/97
3RP] XLI ;IWXPE[ GMXEXMSR MW GYVVIRXP] EZEMPEFPI
9RMXIH 7XEXIW (MWXVMGX 'SYVX
7( 2I[ =SVO
+-&732 4PEMRXMJJ
Z
'6%-+70-78 -2' (IJIRHERX
2S 'MZ 61&
.YRI
()'-7-32 36()6
6-',%6( 1 &)61%2 (MWXVMGX .YHKI
- &EGOKVSYRH
3R 7ITXIQFIV 'EPZMR +MFWSR
w4PEMRXMJJx SV w+MFWSRx JMPIH ER EQIRHIH GSQ
TPEMRX w%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRXx EKEMRWX 'VEMKWPMWX
-RG w(IJIRHERXx SV w'VEMKWPMWXx EPPIKMRK EQSRK
SXLIV XLMRKW XLEX wMR SV EVSYRH .YP] ER MRHM
ZMHYEP [LSWI MHIRXMX] MW YRORS[R EHZIVXMWIH XS
WIPP LERHKYRW SR ?(AIJIRHERXW MRXIVRIX [IFWMXIx
[[[GVEMKWPMWXSVK ERH XLEX wSR .YP] EX
ETTVS\MQEXIP] EQ MR XLI 'MX] SJ 2I[ =SVO
4PEMRXMJJ [EW WLSX WIZIVEP XMQIW F] .IWYW 3VXM^ [MXL
E LERHKYR [LMGL 1V 3VXM^ wTYVGLEWI?HA JVSQ ?XLEX
YRORS[RA MRHMZMHYEP [LS EHZIVXMWIH MXW WEPI
?SRA?(AIJIRHERXW MRXIVRIX [IFWMXIx %Q'SQTP��
4PEMRXMJJ EWWIVXW XLEX (IJIRHERX FVIEGLIH MXW
wHYX] SJ GEVI XS ?IARWYVI XLEX MRLIVIRXP] LE^EVHSYW
SFNIGXW WYGL EW LERHKYRW HMH RSX GSQI MRXS XLI
LERHW SJ MRHMZMHYEP?WA WYGL EW 1V 3VXM^x ERH
WIIOW EQSRK SXLIV VIPMIJ wGSQTIRWEXSV] HEQEKIW
MR XLI EQSYRX SJ ? QMPPMSRAx TYRMXMZI HEQEKIW
ERH XLI wETTSMRXQIRX SJ E *IHIVEP QSRMXSVx %Q
'SQTP � T WII EPWS MH ��
3R 2SZIQFIV (IJIRHERX QSZIH TYVWYERX XS 6YPI F SJ XLI *IHIVEP 6YPIW SJ 'MZMP
4VSGIHYVI w*IH 6 'MZ4x XS HMWQMWW XLI
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX EVKYMRK EQSRK SXLIV XLMRKW
XLEX HMWQMWWEP SJ XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX YRHIV
7IGXMSR SJ XLI 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX SJ
w'(%x 97' � IX WIU TYVWYERX
XS 6YPI F wMW TVSTIV ERH [EVVERXIHx*2
ERH 4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW JEMP FIGEYWI w 7IGXMSR
SJ XLI '(% TVSZMHIW ER EFWSPYXI FEV XS ER] GEYWI
SJ EGXMSR XLEX [SYPH QEOI ER MRXIVEGXMZI WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIV PMOI ?'AVEMKWPMWX PMEFPI JSV XLMVHTEVX]
GSRXIRX TSWXIH SR XLI MRXIVRIX XLVSYKL MXW WIVZMGIx
(IJ 1SX XS (MWQMWW HEXIH 2SZ
w(IJ1SXx EX (IJ 6ITP] MR *YVXLIV 7YTT SJ
4PEMRXMJJ W 1SX XS (MWQMWW HEXIH (IG
w(IJ6ITP]x EX WII EPWS ,IEVMRK 8V HEXIH
1E] w,IEVMRK 8Vx 0XV JVSQ .YWXMR 2
/MRRI] XS ,SR 6MGLEVH 1 &IVQER HEXIH 1E]
w(IJ 1E] 0XVx
*2 %R %JJMVQEXMZI HIJIRWI WYGL EW 7IG
XMSR MQQYRMX] MW KIRIVEPP] EHHVIWWIH
SR E 6YPI G QSXMSR JSV NYHKQIRX SR
XLI TPIEHMRKW SV E 6YPI QSXMSR JSV WYQ
QEV] NYHKQIRX WII 2SZEO Z 3ZIVXYVI
7IVZW -RG *7YTTH
)(2= 1EV FYX WSQI GSYVXW
LEZI LIPH XLEX MX MW TVSTIV XS IZEPYEXI E
7IGXMSR MQQYRMX] HIJIRWI wMR XLI GSR
XI\X SJ E F QSXMSRx [LIVI XLI RIGIW
WEV] JEGXW EVI ETTEVIRX SR XLI JEGI SJ XLI
GSQTPEMRX ERH XLI MQQYRMX] EZEMPEFPI YRHIV XLI '(% TVIGPYHIW E TPEMRXMJJ JVSQ
WXEXMRK E GPEMQ 2IQIX 'LIZVSPIX 0XH Z
'SRWYQIVEJJEMVWGSQ -RG *7YTTH
)(:E WII EPWS (SI Z
&EXIW 2S 'MZ ;0
EX )(8I\ (IG %W VI
JPIGXIH FIPS[ XLEX MW XLI TSWMXMSR XEOIR
LIVI
3R 2SZIQFIV 4PEMRXMJJ JMPIH ER ST
TSWMXMSR EVKYMRK EQSRK SXLIV XLMRKW XLEX 7IG
XMSR SJ XLI '(% TVSZMHIW ER EJJMVQEXMZI HI
JIRWI ERH wER EJJMVQEXMZI HIJIRWI MW KIRIVEPP] RSX
JSHHIV JSV E 6YPI F QSXMSRx ERH 7IGXMSR
wHSIW RSX TVSZMHI FPEROIX MQQYRMX] XS MRXIVEGX
MZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIWx 4P 3TTR XS (IJ 1SX XS
(MWQMWW HEXIH 2SZ w4P3TTRx EX
MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSRW ERH GMXEXMSR SQMXXIH WII EPWS
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-3-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 61/97
MH EX 0XV JVSQ 4EYP & (EPRSO] XS ,SR 6MGLEVH
1 &IVQER HEXIH 1E] w4P 1E]
0XVx EX 4PEMRXMJJ EPWS WIIOW ER SVHIV TYV
WYERX XS *IH6'MZ4 GSQTIPPMRK w?(AIJIRHERX
XS TE] WERGXMSRW MR XLI JSVQ SJ GSWXW ERH VIEWSREFPI
EXXSVRI]W JIIW JSV ?MXWA QIVMXPIWW QSXMSRx 4P
3TTR EX
3R (IGIQFIV (IJIRHERX JMPIH E VITP]
EVKYMRK EQSRK SXLIV XLMRKW XLEX XLIVI EVI RS
KVSYRHW JSV *IH6'MZ4 WERGXMSRW EKEMRWX (I
JIRHERX FIGEYWI w?XALIVI MW EQTPI TVIGIHIRX EG
ORS[PIHKMRK XLI FVIEHXL SJ 7IGXMSR W TVSXIG
XMSR ERH MXW ETTPMGEXMSR XS GPEMQW WYGL EW XLSWI EW
WIVXIH F] XLI ?4APEMRXMJJx (IJ 6ITP] EX
8LI TEVXMIW [EMZIH SVEP EVKYQIRX 7II 'EWI
1EREKIQIRX 4PER
*SV XLI VIEWSRW WIX JSVXL FIPS[ (IJIRHERXW
QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX MW
KVERXIH ERH 4PEMRXMJJW ETTPMGEXMSR JSV WERGXMSRW
MW HIRMIH
-- 0IKEP 7XERHEVH
w;LIR GSRWMHIVMRK E QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW YRHIV
6YPI F XLI 'SYVX QYWX EGGITX EW XVYI XLI
JEGXYEP EPPIKEXMSRW MR XLI GSQTPEMRX ERH HVE[ EPP
VIEWSREFPI MRJIVIRGIW MR JEZSV SJ XLI TPEMRXMJJx
1YVE[WOM Z 4EXEOM *7YTTH
7(2= %X XLI WEQI XMQI wE TPEMRXMJJW SF
PMKEXMSR XS TVSZMHI XLI KVSYRHW SJ LMW IRXMXPIQIRX XS
VIPMIJ VIUYMVIW QSVI XLER PEFIPW ERH GSRGPYWMSRW
ERH E JSVQYPEMG VIGMXEXMSR SJ XLI IPIQIRXW SJ E
GEYWI SJ EGXMSR [MPP RSX HSx &IPP %XPERXMG Z
8[SQFP] 97 MRXIVREP UYSXE
XMSRW ERH GMXEXMSR SQMXXIH WII EPWS %WLGVSJX Z
-UFEP 7'X ;0
1E] 8LI GSQTPEMRX QYWX TPIEH IRSYKL
JEGXW XS WXEXI E GPEMQ JSV VIPMIJ XLEX MW TPEYWMFPI SRMXW JEGI 7II %XPERXMG 6IGSVHMRK 'SVT Z 4VSNIGX
4PE]PMWX -RG *7YTTH
7(2=
w% QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW YRHIV ?*IH6'MZ4A
G MW KSZIVRIH F] XLI WEQI WXERHEVH EW E QSXMSR
YRHIV ?*IH6'MZ4A F x -R VI %HIW ERH
&IVK +VSYT -RZIWXSVW *H R H
'MV
--- %REP]WMW
*IH6'MZ4 F
(IJIRHERX EVKYIW XLEX *IH6'MZ4 F MW
XLI wETTVSTVMEXI ZILMGPIx XS WIIO HMWQMWWEP SJ XLI
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX FIGEYWI EQSRK SXLIV VIEWSRW
ER] HMWGSZIV] VIKEVHMRK (IJIRHERXW IJJSVXW XS WXST
XLI WIPPMRK SJ MPPIKEP KSSHW SR MXW [IFWMXI MW
wMVVIPIZERX XS ?(IJIRHERXWA 7IGXMSR TVSXIGXMSR
ERH GERRSX TVSZMHI E FEWMW XS HIR] ?(IJIRHERXWA
QSXMSRx (IJ 1E] 0XV EX WII EPWS
(IJ 6ITP] EX 4PEMRXMJJ GSYRXIVW EQSRK SXLIV
XLMRKW XLEX wHMWGSZIV] ?WLSYPHA FI LEH XS HIXIVQMRI
[LEX IJJSVXW MJ ER] ?(AIJIRHERX QEHI XS WXST XLI
WIPPMRK SJ MPPIKEP KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW SR MXW [IFWMXIx
ERH wXLIVI MW RS ?7IGXMSR A HIJIRWI IZMHIRX SR
XLI JEGI SJ XLI ?%QIRHIHA ?'ASQTPEMRX EW XLI
?%QIRHIHA ?'ASQTPEMRX HSIW RSX XVIEX XLI (IJIRH
ERX EW E WTIEOIV SV E TYFPMWLIV FYX EW E FYWMRIWWx
4P 3TTR EX MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSRW ERH GMXEXMSR
SQMXXIH 40 1E] 0XV EX
% HIJIRHERX QE] VEMWI ER EJJMVQEXMZI HIJIRWI
MR E TVIERW[IV 6YPI F QSXMSR [LIVI EW
LIVI XLI HIJIRWI ETTIEVW SR XLI JEGI SJ XLI GSQ
TPEMRX 7II 7XEILV Z ,EVXJSVH *MR 7IVZW +VSYT
-RG *H H 'MV WII EPWS
1'; -RG Z &EHFYWMRIWWFYVIEYGSQ 00' 2S
'MZ ;0 EX 2(8I\ %TV
w8LI '(% MJ ETTPMGEFPI MW ER ETTVSTVM
EXI KVSYRH JSV HMWQMWWEP SJ XLI GSQTPEMRX YRHIV
6YPI F FIGEYWI XLI %GX [SYPH TVIGPYHI
?TPEMRXMJJA JVSQ IWXEFPMWLMRK E WIX SJ JEGXW XLEX
[SYPH IRXMXPI MX XS VIPMIJx 1YVE[WOM
*7YTTH EX %XPERXMG 6IGSVHMRK *7YTTH %RH XLI 'SYVX GSRGPYHIW XLEX
MX MW TVSTIV ERH ETTVSTVMEXI XS IZEPYEXI (IJIRHERXW
7IGXMSR MQQYRMX] HIJIRWI MR XLI GSRXI\X SJ
*IH6'MZ4 F FIGEYWI EW JYVXLIV I\TPEMRIH
FIPS[ WII MRJVE TT XLI IPIQIRXW RIGIWWEV]
XS QEOI E JMRHMRK VIKEVHMRK 7IGXMSR MQQYRMX]
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-4-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 62/97
EVI ETTEVIRX JVSQ XLI JEGI SJ XLI %QIRHIH 'SQ
TPEMRX WII 2IQIX 'LIZVSPIX * 7YTT H EX
ERH HMWGSZIV] MRXS (IJIRHERXW IJJSVXW XS TVI
ZIRX XLI WEPI SJ MPPIKEP KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW SR MXW
[IFWMXI w[SYPH ?RSXA IWXEFPMWL E WIX SJ JEGXW XLEX
[SYPH IRXMXPI 4PEMRXMJJ? A XS VIPMIJx &EXIW ;0
EX 7II EPWS +PSFEP 6S]EPXMIW 0XH Z
<GIRXVMG :IRXYVIW 00' 2S 'MZ ;0
EX (%VM^ 3GX w?+AMZIR
XLI EPPIKEXMSRW XLI ETTPMGEXMSR SJ XLI '(% MW E
UYIWXMSR SJ PE[ ERH [MPP RSX FI EJJIGXIH F] HMWGSZ
IV]x*2
*2 )ZIR MJ XLI 'SYVX [IVI XS GSRGPYHI
XLEX (IJIRHERX WLSYPH LEZI QSZIH TYVWY
ERX XS 6YPI G XLI 'SYVX GSYPH TVSTIVP]XVIEX XLI MRWXERX 6YPI F QSXMSR EW E
6YPI G QSXMSR JSV NYHKQIRX SR XLI
TPIEHMRKW [MXL XLI WEQI VIWYPX 7II &EXIW
;0 EX WII EPWS (SI Z
1Z7TEGI -RG *7YTTH R
;(8I\ EJJH *H XL
'MV GIVX HIRMIH 7'X
7IGXMSR
(IJIRHERX EVKYIW TIVWYEWMZIP] XLEX MX MW IR
XMXPIH XS MQQYRMX] YRHIV 7IGXMSR SJ XLI '(% FIGEYWI EQSRK SXLIV VIEWSRW w?'AVEMKWPMWX MW E
TVSZMHIV ERH YWIV SJ MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGIWx w?XALI EPPIKIH LERHKYR EHZIVXMWIQIRX MHIR
XMJMIH MR XLI ?%QIRHIHA 'SQTPEMRX [EW TVSZMHIH F]
ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV RSX
?'AVEMKWPMWXx ERH wXLI ?%QIRHIHA 'SQTPEMRX SR MXW
JEGI MQTVSTIVP] WIIOW XS XVIEX ?'AVEMKWPMWX EW XLI
TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ XLI EPPIKIH EHZIVXMWIQIRXx
(IJ 1SX EX 4PEMRXMJJ GSYRXIVW YRTIV
WYEWMZIP] XLEX LI HSIW RSX WIIO XS LSPH (IJIRHERX
PMEFPI EW E WTIEOIV SV MR XLI VSPI SJ E TYFPMWLIV FYX
VEXLIV wEW E FYWMRIWW TPEMR ERH WMQTPIx 4P 1E]
0XV EX WII EPWS 4P 3TTR EX
7IGXMSR SJ XLI '(% TVSZMHIW GPIEVP] XLEX w
u?RAS TVSZMHIV SV YWIV SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV
WIVZMGI WLEPP FI XVIEXIH EW E TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ
ER] MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH F] ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR
GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVv ERH XLEX u?RAS GEYWI SJ EGXMSR
QE] FI FVSYKLX ERH PMEFMPMX] QE] FI MQTSWIH YRHIV
ER] 7XEXI SV PSGEP PE[ XLEX MW MRGSRWMWXIRX [MXL XLMW
WIGXMSRv w 1YVE[WOM *7YTTH EX
UYSXMRK 97' �� G I
EPXIVEXMSRW MR SVMKMREP WII EPWS &PYQIRXLEP Z
(VYHKI *7YTT ((' MR IR
EGXMRK XLI '(% w'SRKVIWW QEHI E TSPMG] GLSMGI
RSX XS HIXIV LEVQJYP SRPMRI WTIIGL XLVSYKL XLI WIT
EVEXI VSYXI SJ MQTSWMRK XSVX PMEFMPMX] SR GSQTERMIW
XLEX WIVZI EW MRXIVQIHMEVMIW JSV SXLIV TEVXMIW TSXIR
XMEPP] MRNYVMSYW QIWWEKIWx *2
*2 w8LI XIVQ uMRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGIv QIERW ER] MRJSVQEXMSR WIVZMGI W]W
XIQ SV EGGIWW WSJX[EVI TVSZMHIV XLEX TVSZMHIW SV IREFPIW GSQTYXIV EGGIWW F]
QYPXMTPI YWIVW XS E GSQTYXIV WIVZIV MR
GPYHMRK WTIGMJMGEPP] E WIVZMGI SV W]WXIQ
XLEX TVSZMHIW EGGIWW XS XLI -RXIVRIX ERH
WYGL W]WXIQW STIVEXIH SV WIVZMGIW SJJIVIH
F] PMFVEVMIW SV IHYGEXMSREP MRWXMXYXMSRWx
97' � J
w8LI XIVQ uMRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVS
ZMHIVv QIERW ER] TIVWSR SV IRXMX] XLEX MW
VIWTSRWMFPI MR [LSPI SV MR TEVX JSV XLI
GVIEXMSR SV HIZIPSTQIRX SJ MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH XLVSYKL XLI -RXIVRIX SV ER] SXL
IV MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIx -H �
J
'SYVXW IRKEKI MR E XLVII TEVX MRUYMV] [LIR HI
XIVQMRMRK XLI EZEMPEFMPMX] SJ MQQYRMX] YRHIV XLI
'(% MI w?MA [LIXLIV (IJIRHERX MW E TVSZMHIV SJ
ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI ?MMA MJ XLI TSWXMRKW
EX MWWYI EVI MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH F] ERSXLIV MR
JSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV ERH ?MMMA [LIXLIV
4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW WIIO XS XVIEX (IJIRHERX EW E TYF
PMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ XLMVH TEVX] GSRXIRXx 2IQIX 'LIZVSPIX *7YTTH EX w'SYVXW EGVSWW XLI
GSYRXV] LEZI VITIEXIHP] LIPH XLEX XLI '(%W KVERX
SJ MQQYRMX] WLSYPH FI GSRWXVYIH FVSEHP]x %XPERXMG
6IGSVHMRK *7YTTH EX
4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW EKEMRWX (IJIRHERX EVI FEVVIH
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-5-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 63/97
F] XLI '(% FIGEYWI IEGL TVSRK SJ XLI 7IGXMSR
MQQYRMX] XIWX MW WEXMWJMIH FEWIH YTSR XLI EPPIKE
XMSRW MR XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX 7II 2IQIX 'LIZ
VSPIX *7YTTH EX WII EPWS 1YVE[WOM
*7YTTH EX 1]WTEGI *H EX
+VIIR Z %Q 3RPMRI %30 *H
H 'MV GIVX HIRMIH 97
/VYWOE Z 4IVZIVXIH .YWXMGI *SYRH -RG 2S
'MZ ;0 EX R (%VM^
.YP] *MVWX XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX EP
PIKIW XLEX (IJIRHERX MW wER MRXIVRIX QIVGLERXx
%Q'SQTP� ERH 4PEMRXMJJ HSIW RSX ETTIEV XS
HMWTYXI XLEX 'VEMKWPMWX MW E TVSZMHIV SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI 7II 'LMGEKS 0E[]IVW 'SQQ
*SV 'MZMP 6MKLXW 9RHIV 0E[ -RG Z 'VEMKWPMWX -RG
*7YTTH 2(-PP MRXIVREPUYSXEXMSRW ERH GMXEXMSR SQMXXIH EJJH *H
XL 'MV WII EPWS 'EVEJERS Z 1IXVSW
TPEWLGSQ -RG *7YTTH
'('EP EJJH * H XL
'MV
7IGSRH XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX EGORS[
PIHKIW XLEX ER wYRORS[R MRHMZMHYEPx RSX XLI (I
JIRHERX TPEGIH XLI EHZIVXMWIQIRX YRHIV E GSHIH
GEXIKSV] SR XLI 'VEMKWPMWX [IFWMXI %Q'SQTP�
WII EPWS 'VEMKWPMWX *7YTTH EX
LSYWMRK RSXMGIW TSWXIH SR 'VEMKWPMWXW [IFWMXI wEVIuMRJSVQEXMSRv XLEX SVMKMREXIW RSX JVSQ 'VEMKWPMWX
FYX JVSQ uERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVv
REQIP] XLI YWIVW SJ 'VEMKWPMWXW [IFWMXIx UYSXMRK
9 7' � J %XPERXMG 6IGSVHMRK
*7YTTH EX
8LMVH 4PEMRXMJJ WIIOW XS LSPH (IJIRHERX PMEFPI
JSV MXW EPPIKIH JEMPYVI XS FPSGO WGVIIR SV SXLIV[MWI
TVIZIRX XLI HMWWIQMREXMSR SJ E XLMVH TEVX]W GSRXIRX
MI XLI KYR EHZIVXMWIQIRX MR UYIWXMSR WII &EXIW
;0 EX EPPIKMRK EQSRK SXLIV
XLMRKW XLEX (IJIRHERX wJEMPIH XS QSRMXSV VIKYPEXI
TVSTIVP] QEMRXEMR ERH TSPMGI XLI QIVGLERHMWI FIMRK
FSYKLX ERH WSPH SR MXW [IFWMXIx ERH wMW IMXLIV YR
EFPI SV YR[MPPMRK XS EPPSGEXI XLI RIGIWWEV] VI
WSYVGIW XS QSRMXSV TSPMGI QEMRXEMR ERH TVSTIVP]
WYTIVZMWI XLI KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW WSPH SR MXW [IF
WMXIx %Q 'SQTP �� WII EPWS 4P 3TTR EX
-X MW GPIEV XLEX 4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW EVI HMVIGXIH XS
[EVH 'VEMKWPMWX EW E wTYFPMWLIVx SJ XLMVH TEVX] GSR
XIRX ERH w7IGXMSR WTIGMJMGEPP] TVSWGVMFIW PMEFMP
MX] MR WYGL GMVGYQWXERGIWx +VIIR *H EX
MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSRW ERH GMXEXMSR SQMXXIH WII
1]WTEGI *7YTTH EX w4PEMRXMJJW EVKYI
XLMW WYMX MW FEWIH SR 1]7TEGIW RIKPMKIRX JEMPYVI XS
XEOI VIEWSREFPI WEJIX] QIEWYVIW XS OIIT ]SYRK GLMP
HVIR SJJ SJ MXW WMXI ERH RSX FEWIH SR 1]7TEGIW IHMX
SVMEP EGXW 2S QEXXIV LS[ EVXJYPP] 4PEMRXMJJW WIIO
XS TPIEH XLIMV GPEMQW XLI 'SYVX ZMI[W 4PEMRXMJJW
GPEMQW EW HMVIGXIH XS[EVH 1]7TEGI MR MXW TYFPMWL
MRK IHMXSVMEP ERHSV WGVIIRMRK GETEGMXMIWx +VIIR
*H EX EJJMVQMRK HMWQMWWEP SJ GPEMQ
XLEX %30 wRIKPMKIRX?P]A JEMP ?IHA XS TVSTIVP] TSPMGIMXW RIX[SVO JSV GSRXIRX XVERWQMXXIH F] MXW YWIVWx FI
GEYWI 7IGXMSR FEVW wEXXIQTXW XS LSPH %30 PM
EFPI JSV HIGMWMSRW VIPEXMRK XS XLI QSRMXSVMRK
WGVIIRMRK ERH HIPIXMSR SJ GSRXIRX JVSQ MXW RIX[SVO
EGXMSRW UYMRXIWWIRXMEPP] VIPEXIH XS E TYFPMWLIVW
VSPIx WII EPWS 7XSRIV Z I&E] -RG 2S
;0 EX 'EP7YTIV2SZ
VINIGXMRK TPEMRXMJJW wGSRXIRXMSR XLEX I&E] WLSYPH
FI LIPH VIWTSRWMFPI JSV JEMPMRK XS QSRMXSV XLI
TVSHYGXW EYGXMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGIx FIGEYWI
w'SRKVIWW MRXIRHIH XS VIQSZI ?XLVSYKL 7IGXMSR
A ER] PIKEP SFPMKEXMSR SJ MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGI TVSZMHIVW XS EXXIQTX XS MHIRXMJ] SV QSRMXSV XLI
WEPI SJ WYGL TVSHYGXWx
*IH6'MZ4
(IJIRHERX LEZMRK TVIZEMPIH SR MXW QSXMSR MX MW
ETTEVIRX XLEX MX ZMSPEXIH RS WXVMGXYVI SJ *IH6'MZ4
7II &I]EL Z 7GYPP] 2S 'MZ
;0 EX 7(2= 1EV )ZIR
EWWYQMRK EVKYIRHS XLEX 4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW [IVI RSX
FEVVIH F] 7IGXMSR SJ XLI '(% (IJIRHERXW QS
XMSR GERRSX FI GEPPIH JVMZSPSYW ERH (IJIRHERX wLEW
IZIV] VMKLX XS QSZI JSV HMWQMWWEPx EX XLMW XMQI
/SGL Z '+1 +VSYT -RG 2S 8, ' 1,
;0 EX 7(-RH %TV
4PEMRXMJJW ETTPMGEXMSR JSV WERGXMSRW MW EGGSVHMRKP]
HIRMIH 7II 1YVE[WOM *7YTTH EX
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-6-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 64/97
-: 'SRGPYWMSR ERH 3VHIV
*SV XLI JSVIKSMRK VIEWSRW (IJIRHERXW QS
XMSR XS HMWQMWW ? A MW KVERXIH ERH 4PEMRXMJJW ET
TPMGEXMSR JSV WERGXMSRW MW HIRMIH 8LI 'PIVO SJ
'SYVX MW VIWTIGXJYPP] VIUYIWXIH XS GPSWI XLMW GEWI
73 36()6)(
7(2=
+MFWSR Z 'VEMKWPMWX -RG
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
)2( 3* (3'91)28
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-7-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 65/97
3RP] XLI ;IWXPE[ GMXEXMSR MW GYVVIRXP] EZEMPEFPI
7YTIVMSV 'SYVX SJ 1EWWEGLYWIXXW
7YJJSPO 'SYRX]
247 00' ERSXLIV *2
*2 8LI 2I[ )RKPERH 4EXVMSXW 04
Z
789&,9& -2' SXLIVW*2
*2 7XIZIR 1G+VEXL 'EVSP 1G+VEXL ERH
.SLR (SIW
'MZMP %GXMSR 2S &07
.ER
1)136%2(91 3* ()'-7-32 %2( 36()6
32 ()*)2(%287 138-32 *36 4%68-%0
7911%6= .9(+1)28
6%04, ( +%287 .YWXMGI
8LI 2I[ )RKPERH 4EXVMSXW wXLI 4EXVMSXWx
LEZI FVSYKLX XLMW EGXMSR WIIOMRK EQSRK SXLIV
XLMRKW TIVQERIRX MRNYRGXMZI VIPMIJ FEVVMRK HIJIRH
ERX 7XYF,YF -RG w7XYF,YFx JVSQ TEVXMGMTEXMRK
MR XLI VIWEPI SJ 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW SR MXW MRXIVRIX [IFWMXI
*2%W EKEMRWX 7XYF,YF XLI %QIRHIH 'SQ
TPEMRX GPEMQW MRXIRXMSREP MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL EH
ZERXEKISYW VIPEXMSRW 'SYRX - QMWETTVSTVMEXMSR SJ
REQI 'SYRX -- ERH YRJEMV XVEHI TVEGXMGIW MR ZMSPE
XMSR SJ +0 G % � 'SYRX ---*2
-R 'SYRX
:-- XLI 4EXVMSXW EWO XLI 'SYVX XS LSPH EPP 7XYF,YF
TVSJMXW SFXEMRIH XLVSYKL XLI WEPI SJ 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW
MR E GSRWXVYGXMZI XVYWX 7XYF,YF LEW QSZIH JSV TEV
XMEP WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX SR 'SYRX - *SV XLI VIEWSRW
HIXEMPIH FIPS[ XLI QSXMSR MW ()2-)(
*2 8LI EGXMSR MW JSVQEPP] FVSYKLX F]X[S TPEMRXMJJW 247 00' w247x XLI
S[RIV SJ +MPPIXXI 7XEHMYQ ERH XLI MWWYIV SJ
TVIQMYQ WIEXMRK XMGOIXW XS XLI 4EXVMSXW
JSSXFEPP KEQIW ERH XLI 2I[ )RKPERH 4EX
VMSXW 04 w2)4x XLI MWWYIV SJ WIEWSR
XMGOIXW XS XLSWI KEQIW *SV WMQTPMGMX]W
WEOI XLMW 'SYVX GSPPIGXMZIP] WLEPP VIJIV XS
FSXL IRXMXMIW EW XLI 4EXVMSXW
*2 8LI 4EXVMSXW LEZI EPWS JMPIH E QSXMSR
JSV PIEZI XS JMPI ER EQIRHIH GSQTPEMRX XS
MRGPYHI EW EKEMRWX 7XYF,YF GPEMQW SJ
GMZMP GSRWTMVEG] XVIWTEWW ERH YR
NYWX IRVMGLQIRX ERH XS EHH EW E HIJIRHERX
0EWX 1MRYXI 8VERWEGXMSRW E [LSPP] S[RIH
WYFWMHMEV] SJ 7XYF,YF
&%'/+6392(
8LI JSPPS[MRK JEGXW EVI YRHMWTYXIH YRPIWW SXL
IV[MWI RSXIH )EGL WIEWSR XLI 4EXVMSXW QEOI EZEMP
EFPI XMGOIXW XS LSQI JSSXFEPP KEQIW 3ZIV EVI
WIEWSR XMGOIXW MWWYIH F] 2)4 XLI FEPERGI EVI
TVIQMYQ WIEXMRK XMGOIXW MWWYIH F] 247 9RXMP
XLI JSPPS[MRK [EVRMRK [EW TVMRXIH SR XLI FEGO SJ
IEGL XMGOIX MR PEVKI FPSGO PIXXIVW
%2= 2320-')27)( -2(-:-(9%0 6)
7)00-2+ 8,-7 8-'/)8 &= %2= 1)8,3(
-2'09(-2+ ;-8,398 0-1-8%8-32 -2
4)6732 32 %2 %9'8-32 ;)& 7-8) 36
38,)6;-7) 3:)6 8,) -28)62)8 %2(
%2= 0-')27)( -2(-:-(9%0 36 )28-8=
6)7)00-2+ 8,-7 8-'/)8 -2 :-30%8-32
3* %440-'%&0) 0%; -7 79&.)'8 83 %6
6)78 0)+%0 %'8-32 %2( 0377 3* 7)%
732 8-'/)8 46-:-0)+)7x*2
*2 8LI 4EXVMSXW VIZMWIH XLMW PERKYEKI JSV
XLI 2*0 WIEWSR XS VIEH w8LMW XMGOIX
MW E RSRXVERWJIVEFPI VIZSGEFPI PMGIRWI
%2= 4)6732 238 0-')27)( 49679
%28 83 1+0 G � % 6)
7)00-2+ 8,-7 8-'/)8 &= %2=
1)8,3( -2'09(-2+ ;-8,398 0-1
-8%8-32 -2 4)6732 32 %2 %9'
8-32 ;)& 7-8) 36 38,)6;-7)
3:)6 8,) -28)62)8 %2( %2= 4)6
732 36 )28-8= 73 0-')27)( 6)
7)00-2+ 8,-7 8-'/)8 32 %2 %9'
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-8-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 66/97
8-32 ;)& 7-8) 36 -2 :-30%8-32 3*
%440-'%&0) 0%; -7 79&.)'8 83
%66)78 0)+%0 %'8-32 %2( 0377
3* 7)%732 8-'/)8 46-:-0)+)7x
-R EHHMXMSR IEGL XMGOIX WXEXIH XLEX MX [EW E VI
ZSGEFPI PMGIRWI XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW VIWIVZIH XLI VMKLX
XS VIZSOI XLI XMGOIX EX ER] XMQI ERH JSV ER] VIEWSR
ERH XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW QE] VIJYWI EHQMWWMSR XS SV
INIGX ER] XMGOIX LSPHIV [LS JEMPW XS GSQTP] [MXL
ER] ETTPMGEFPI VYPIW SV XIVQW
-R ER IJJSVX XS QEMRXEMR [LEX XLI 4EXVMSXW HI
WGVMFI EW E WEJI WIGYVI ERH JEQMP]JVMIRHP] IRZMV
SRQIRX JSV LSQI KEQIW XLI] LEZI I\IVGMWIH XLIMV
VMKLX XS VIZSOI WIEWSR XMGOIXW [LIR XMGOIX LSPHIVW
IMXLIV XLI XMGOIX S[RIVW XLIQWIPZIW SV XLIMV KYIWXW
LEZI IRKEKIH MR [LEX XLI 4EXVMSXW GSRWMHIV XS FI
YRWEJI SV YREGGITXEFPI GSRHYGX 7II =EVHI 1IXEPW
-RG Z 2I[ )RKPERH 4EXVMSXW 04 1EWW%TT'X
8LYW JSV I\EQTPI WLSYPH E WIE
WSR XMGOIX LSPHIV KMZI LMW SV LIV XMGOIXW XS ERSXLIV
TIVWSR JSV ER] WMRKPI LSQI KEQI ERH WLSYPH XLI
4EXVMSXW INIGX XLEX TIVWSR JSV YREGGITXEFPI GSRHYGX
XLI 4EXVMSXW QE] VIZSOI XLI WIEWSR XMGOIXW VIKEVH
PIWW SJ XLI JEGX XLEX XLI SVMKMREP LSPHIV [EW RSX
TVIWIRX EX XLI KEQI 9TSR PIEVRMRK XLEX E XMGOIX
LSPHIV LEW MQTIVQMWWMFP] XVERWJIVVIH E XMGOIX SV XMGOIXW XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI VIZSOIH XLEX LSPHIVW WIE
WSR XMGOIXW ERH VIJYRHIH XLI JYPP JEGI ZEPYI -R XLMW
[E] EPP WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW EVI VIWTSRWMFPI JSV
XLI FILEZMSV SJ XLIMV KYIWXW -R SVHIV XS IJJIGXYEXI
XLMW TSPMG] IEGL XMGOIX FIEVW E YRMUYI FEV GSHI XLEX
MW IPIGXVSRMGEPP] WGERRIH YTSR IRXVERGI 7LSYPH XLI
4EXVMSXW GERGIP E XMGOIX XLI FEV GSHI MW ZSMHIH ERH
XLI XMGOIX MW YWIPIWW
8LI 4EXVMSXW EVI FPIWWIH [MXL QER] PS]EP JERW
[LS [MWL XS FY] WIEWSR XMGOIXW FYX EVI YREFPI XS HS
WS 8LI 4EXVMSXW LEZI XLIVIJSVI IWXEFPMWLIH E [EMXPMWX [LIVI JSV E HITSWMX TIV WIEX JERW QE]
NSMR XLI PMWX ERH E[EMX XLI STTSVXYRMX] XS FY] WIEWSR
XMGOIXW EW XLI] FIGSQI EZEMPEFPI 8LI HITSWMX MW
GVIHMXIH XS[EVH XLI TYVGLEWI SJ WIEWSR XMGOIXW [LIR
XLI] HS FIGSQI EZEMPEFPI ERH MW VIJYRHEFPI MJ RS
WIEXW EVI EZEMPEFPI [LIR XLI JER VIQSZIW LMW SV LIV
REQI JVSQ XLI [EMX PMWX
8LI 4EXVMSXW EPWS VIGSKRM^I XLEX WIEWSR XMGO
IX LSPHIVW QE] RSX FI EFPI XS EXXIRH EPP XLI TVI
WIEWSR ERH LSQI KEQIW *SV XLMW VIEWSR XLI 4EXVM
SXW TVSZMHI ER SRPMRI JSVYQ XLVSYKL 8MGOIX1EWXIV
GEPPIH 8MGOIX)\GLERKI [LIVIF] LSPHIVW QE] TSWX
XLIMV XMGOIXW SR E WIGYVI [IFWMXI EGGIWWMFPI SRP] XS
SXLIV WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW ERH [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW*2
3RGI E QEXGL MW QEHI SR 8MGOIX)\GLERKI
FIX[IIR XLI WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIV [LS LEW TSWXIH
XLI WIEXW ERH XLI TIVWSR WIIOMRK XLIQ XLI 4EXVMSXW
GERGIP XLI SVMKMREP XMGOIXW ZSMH XLI FEV GSHI ERH
MWWYI XS XLI VIGMTMIRX RI[ XMGOIXW [MXL E HMJJIVIRX
ERH ZEPMH FEV GSHI 8LI 4EXVMSXW WIPP XLI XMGOIXW EX
JEGI ZEPYI ERH VIMQFYVWI XLI SVMKMREP LSPHIV SJ XLIYRYWIH XMGOIXW 7MRGI XLI XMGOIXW WSPH XLVSYKL 8MGO
IX)\GLERKI EVI GERGIPPIH RSX XVERWJIVVIH XLI SVM
KMREP LSPHIV MW RSX VIWTSRWMFPI JSV XLI FILEZMSV SJ
TIVWSRW WMXXMRK MR XLSWI WIEXW 2IMXLIV XLI WIPPMRK
XMGOIX LSPHIV XLI TYVGLEWMRK XMGOIX LSPHIV RSV XLI
4EXVMSXW TVSJMX MR ER] [E] JVSQ ER] 8MGOIX)\GLERKI
XVERWEGXMSR*2
*2 8LVSYKL 8MGOIX)\GLERKI XLI 4EXVM
SXW EPWS WIPP XLI VIQEMRMRK KEQIW JVSQ WIE
WSR XMGOIXW XLEX LEH FIIR VIZSOIH
*2 3RP] 8MGOIX1EWXIV TVSJMXW JVSQ 8MGO
IX)\GLERKI XLVSYKL XLI JII MX GLEVKIW JSV
YWI SJ MXW XMGOIX I\GLERKI WIVZMGI
7XYF,YF STIVEXIW E [IFWMXI
[[[WXYFLYFGSQ XLEX EPPS[W TISTPI XS FY] ERH
WIPP XMGOIXW XS WTSVXMRK GSRGIVX XLIEXIV ERH SXLIV
PMZI IRXIVXEMRQIRX IZIRXW -R SVHIV XS YWI XLI [IF
WMXI ER MRHMZMHYEP QYWX VIKMWXIV EW E 7XYF,YF QIQ
FIV ERH EKVII EQSRK SXLIV XLMRKW XS GSQTP] [MXL
wEPP ETTPMGEFPI PSGEP WXEXI JIHIVEP ERH MRXIVREXMSREP
PE[W WXEXYXIW ERH VIKYPEXMSRW VIKEVHMRK XLI YWI SJ XLI 7MXI ERH XLI WIPPMRK SJ XMGOIXWx 3R MXW WIPPIV w5
%x TEKI 7XYF,YF WXEXIW XLEX 1EWWEGLYWIXXW PE[
TVSLMFMXW XLI VIWIPPMRK SJ XMGOIXW EX QSVI XLER
EFSZI JEGI ZEPYI I\GITX XLEX E PMGIRWIH FVSOIV QE]
GLEVKI EHHMXMSREP I\TIRWIW wVIPEXIH XS EGUYMVMRK
ERH WIPPMRK XLI XMGOIXx 7II +0 G �� %
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-9-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 67/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 68/97
4EXVMSXW &IGEYWI XLI 4EXVMSXW ZSMH XLI FEV
GSHI SR ER] GERGIPPIH XMGOIXW XLSWI XMGOIXW
WYFWIUYIRXP] WSPH SR 7XYF,YF EVI RSX
LSRSVIH EX XLI KEXI
(-7'977-32
8S TVIZEMP SR WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX XLI QSZMRK
TEVX] QYWX IWXEFPMWL XLEX XLIVI MW RS KIRYMRI MWWYI
SJ QEXIVMEP JEGX SR IZIV] IPIQIRX SJ E GPEMQ ERH
XLEX MX MW IRXMXPIH XS NYHKQIRX SR XLEX GPEMQ EW E
QEXXIV SJ PE[ 7II KIRIVEPP] 1EWW 6 'MZ 4 G
,MKLPERHW -RWYVERGI 'S Z %IVSZS\ -RG
1EWW ;LIVI XLI TEVX] STTSWMRK
WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX LEW XLI FYVHIR SJ TVSSJ EX XVMEP
XLI QSZMRK TEVX] MW IRXMXPIH XS WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX
MJ MX wHIQSRWXVEXIW F] VIJIVIRGI XS QEXIVMEP HIWGVMFIH MR 1EWW 6 'MZ 4 G YRQIX F] GSYR
XIVZEMPMRK QEXIVMEPW XLEX XLI TEVX] STTSWMRK XLI QS
XMSR LEW RS VIEWSREFPI I\TIGXEXMSR SJ TVSZMRK ER IW
WIRXMEP IPIQIRX SJ XLEX TEVX]W GEWIx /SYVSYZEGMPMW
Z +IRIVEP 1SXSVW 'SVT 1EWW
w8S FI WYGGIWWJYP E QSZMRK TEVX] RIIH RSX
WYFQMX EJJMVQEXMZI IZMHIRGI XS RIKEXI SRI SV QSVI
IPIQIRXW SJ XLI SXLIV TEVX]W GPEMQx -H -X MW WYJJM
GMIRX XS HIQSRWXVEXI XLEX wTVSSJ SJ XLEX IPIQIRX MW
YRPMOIP] XS FI JSVXLGSQMRK EX XVMEPx *PIWRIV Z
8IGLRMGEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW 'SVT 1EWW
4LVEWIH HMJJIVIRXP] WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX
WLSYPH FI KVERXIH [LIR MJ XLI TPEMRXMJJ [IVI XS TVI
ZEMP EX XVMEP SR IZMHIRGI MHIRXMGEP XS XLEX MR XLI WYQ
QEV] NYHKQIRX VIGSVH XLI GSYVX [SYPH FI VIUYMVIH
XS KVERX NYHKQIRX RSX[MXLWXERHMRK XLI ZIVHMGX FI
GEYWI IZIR [LIR ZMI[MRK XLI IZMHIRGI MR XLI PMKLX
QSWX JEZSVEFPI XS XLI TPEMRXMJJ RS VIEWSREFPI NYV]
GSYPH JMRH MR XLI TPEMRXMJJW JEZSV FEWIH SR XLEX IZMH
IRGI 7II KIRIVEPP] (SREPHWSR Z *EVVEOLER
1EWW w8LI WXERHEVH ETTPMIH XS E
QSXMSR JSV E HMVIGXIH ZIVHMGX MW MHIRXMGEP XS XLEX ET
TPMIH XS E QSXMSR JSV WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX x
(%RRSPJS Z 7XSRILEQ ,SYWMRK %YXLSVMX]
1EWW w8LI WXERHEVH XS FI YWIH SR
E QSXMSR JSV NYHKQIRX RSX[MXLWXERHMRK XLI ZIVHMGX
MW XLI WEQI EW XLEX SR E QSXMSR JSV E HMVIGXIH ZIV
HMGXx 'EQFVMHKITSVX 7EZMRKW &ERO Z &SIVWRIV
1EWW -R WYGL GEWIW E XVMEP
[SYPH FI E JYXMPI [EWXI SJ NYHMGMEP VIWSYVGIW FI
GEYWI XLI YPXMQEXI VIWYPX GSYPH RSX FI EPXIVIH F] XLI
NYV]W ZIVHMGX
%W RSXIH IEVPMIV XLI JSGYW SJ XLMW QSXMSR JSV
TEVXMEP WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX MW SR E WMRKPI GSYRX EP
PIKMRK MRXIRXMSREP MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL EHZERXEKISYW
VIPEXMSRW 8LI XSVX SJ MRXIRXMSREP MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL
EHZERXEKISYW VIPEXMSRW wTVSXIGXW E TPEMRXMJJW
TVIWIRX ERH JYXYVI IGSRSQMG MRXIVIWXW JVSQ [VSRK
JYP MRXIVJIVIRGIx &PEGOWXSRI Z 'EWLQER
1EWW 8LI 4EXVMSXW %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX IWWIRXMEPP] MRGSVTSVEXIW MRXS E WMRKPI
GPEMQ X[S VIPEXIH XSVXW XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXLGSRXVEGX ERH XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL E TVSWTIGXMZI
GSRXVEGXYEP VIPEXMSRWLMT -R WLSVX XLI 4EXVMSXW EPPIKI
FSXL XLEX 7XYF,YF LEW MRXIRXMSREPP] MRXIVJIVIH [MXL
MXW I\MWXMRK GSRXVEGXYEP VIPEXMSRWLMTW [MXL WIEWSR
XMGOIX LSPHIVW ERH [MXL MXW TVSWTIGXMZI GSRXVEGXYEP
VIPEXMSRWLMTW [MXL XLSWI WEQI WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW
ERH [MXL [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW 8LI QIPHMRK SJ XLIWI
XSVXW MRXS E WMRKPI GPEMQ LEW PMXXPI TVEGXMGEP GSR
WIUYIRGI WMRGI XLI WYFWXERXMZI IPIQIRXW EVI WYF
WXERXMEPP] WMQMPEV ERH 1EWWEGLYWIXXW GSYVXW LEZI RSX
GSRWMWXIRXP] HMWXMRKYMWLIH FIX[IIR XLI X[S 7LEJMV
Z 7XIIPI 1EWW R 'EZMGGLM Z /SWOM 1EWW%TT'X
8LI 4EXVMSXW XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GPEMQ GIRXIVW
EVSYRH XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT XLI] LEZI [MXL XLIMV JERW
FSXL WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW ERH XLSWI SR XLI [EMX PMWX
ERH XLIMV GSQQMXQIRX XS QEMRXEMR E WEJI ERH JEQMP]
JVMIRHP] IRZMVSRQIRX JSV LSQI KEQIW -R E RYXWLIPP
XLI 4EXVMSXW EVKYI
y w8LI TYVGLEWI SJ E XMGOIX XS E WTSVXW SV IRXIV
XEMRQIRX IZIRX X]TMGEPP] GVIEXIW RSXLMRK QSVI
XLER E VIZSGEFPI PMGIRWIx =EVHI 1IXEPW -RG Z 2I[ )RKPERH 4EXVMSXW 0XH 4EVXRIVWLMT
1EWW%TT'X EX 8LI 4EXVMSXW LEZI I\TVIWWP]
HIGPEVIH XLEX XLIMV XMGOIXW XS LSQI KEQIW EVI RSX
XVERWJIVEFPI ERH XLEX ER]SRI [LS GLSSWIW XS
XVERWJIV XLIQ I\GITX XLVSYKL 8MGOIX)\GLERKI
QE] LEZI XLIMV WIEWSR XMGOIXW VIZSOIH
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-11-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 69/97
y 8LI 4EXVMSXW GSQQMXQIRX XS RSRXVERWJIVEFMPMX]
MW MRXIRHIH XS TIVQMX XLIQ XS HIXIVQMRI [LS MW
VIWTSRWMFPI JSV MRETTVSTVMEXI FILEZMSV ERH LSPH
XLI XMGOIX LSPHIV VIWTSRWMFPI JSV WYGL FILEZMSV
[LMGL EPPS[W XLIQ XS QEMRXEMR GSRXVSP SZIV XLI
IRXMVI ZIRYI 7MRGI FY]IVW SR 7XYF,YF EVI PMOIP]
SRI XMQI ERSR]QSYW FY]IVW XLI] HS RSX LEZI XLI
WEQI MRGIRXMZI XS FILEZI ETTVSTVMEXIP] EW HS WIE
WSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW [LS ORS[ XLEX XLIMV XMGOIXW
QE] FI VIZSOIH EX ER] XMQI
y -R EHHMXMSR [LIR XMGOIXW EVI WSPH SR 7XYF
,YF XLI] EVI RSX SJJIVIH SR 8MGOIX)\GLERKI XS
SXLIV WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW ERH [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW
[LMGL MRXIVJIVIW [MXL XLI KSSH[MPP XLI 4EXVMSXW
LEZI JSWXIVIH [MXL XLIMV QSWX PS]EP JERW
8S TVIZEMP SR XLIMV XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GPEMQ
XLI 4EXVMSXW QYWX TVSZI XLEX w ?XLI]A LEH ER EH
ZERXEKISYW VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL E XLMVH TEVX] IK E
TVIWIRX SV TVSWTIGXMZI GSRXVEGX SV IQTPS]QIRX VIPE
XMSRWLMT ?7XYF,YFA ORS[MRKP] MRHYGIH E FVIEO
MRK SJ XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT ?7XYF,YFWA MRXIVJIVIRGI
[MXL XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT MR EHHMXMSR XS FIMRK MRXIRXMSR
EP [EW MQTVSTIV MR QSXMZI SV QIERW ERH XLI
?4EXVMSXW [IVIA LEVQIH F] ?7XYF,YFWA EGXMSRWx
&PEGOWXSRI Z 'EWLQER 1EWW EX GMXMRK
;IFIV Z 'SQQYRMX] 8IEQ[SVO -RG 1EWW ,EVQ LEW FIIR HIWGVMFIH EW E PSWW
SJ EHZERXEKI SV HEQEKI XS ER IGSRSQMG VIPEXMSR
WLMT XLEX VIWYPXIH HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI HIJIRHERXW GSR
HYGX /YVOIV Z ,MPP 1EWW%TT'X
6EXRIV Z 2SFPI 1EWW%TT'X
8LI LEVQ QYWX VIWYPX MR IGSRSQMG PSWW
[LIVI XLI TPEMRXMJJ HSIW RSX WYJJIV ER] TIGYRMEV]
PSWW EW E VIWYPX SJ XLI HIJIRHERXW EGXMSRW XLIVI GER
FI RS VIGSZIV] SR E XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GPEMQ
&MVFMKPME Z 7EMRX :MRGIRXW ,SWT -RG 1EWW
6EXRIV 1EWW%TT'X EX
IWWIRGI SJ XSVX MW HEQEKI XS FYWMRIWW VIPEXMSRWLMT
8IGL 4PYW -RG Z %RWIP 1EWW%TT'X
TIGYRMEV] PSWW MW IWWIRXMEP IPIQIRX SJ XSVX
7XYF,YF JSV TYVTSWIW SJ WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX
IWWIRXMEPP] GSRGIHIW XLEX XLIVI MW E KIRYMRI MWWYI SJ
JEGX EW XS [LIXLIV MX ORS[MRKP] MRHYGIH WIEWSR XMGO
IX LSPHIVW XS FVIEGL XLI XIVQW SJ XLIMV PMGIRWI F]
XVERWJIVVMRK XLIMV 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW -X EVKYIW XLEX MX MW
IRXMXPIH XS WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX FIGEYWI XLIVI MW RS
IZMHIRGI MR XLI WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX VIGSVH XLEX
[SYPH EPPS[ XLI 4EXVMSXW XS TVSZI ER] SJ XLI XLVII
SXLIV IPIQIRXW SJ E XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GPEMQ 7TI
GMJMGEPP] 7XYF,YF GSRXIRHW XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI
SJJIVIH RS IZMHIRGI XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI ER]
I\TIGXEXMSR SJ JMRERGMEP FIRIJMX MR XLIMV VIPEXMSRWLMT
[MXL IMXLIV WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW SV [EMX PMWX QIQ
FIVW XLEX 7XYF,YFW EPPIKIH MRXIVJIVIRGI [EW
MQTVSTIV MR QSXMZI SV QIERW SV XLEX XLI 4EXVM
SXW WYJJIVIH ER] TIGYRMEV] PSWW JVSQ XLI EPPIKIH
XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI 8LMW 'SYVX [MPP EHHVIWW IEGL
SJ XLIWI EVKYQIRXW MR XYVR
(MH XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI ER %HZERXEKISYW 6IPE
XMSRWLMT [MXL 7IEWSR 8MGOIX ,SPHIVW SV ;EMX 0MWX
1IQFIVW#
7XYF,YF JMVWX EVKYIW XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW GERRSX
WEXMWJ] XLI JMVWX IPIQIRX SJ XLIMV GPEMQXLEX XLI] LEH
E JMRERGMEPP] EHZERXEKISYW VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL XLIMV
WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW SV [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW w-X MW
[IPP WIXXPIH XLEX ER I\MWXMRK SV IZIR E TVSFEFPI JY
XYVI FYWMRIWW VIPEXMSRWLMT JVSQ [LMGL XLIVI MW E
VIEWSREFPI I\TIGXERG] SJ JMRERGMEP FIRIJMX MW
IRSYKLx XS WEXMWJ] XLMW IPIQIRX 3[IR Z ;MPPMEQW
1EWW 8LI 4EXVMSXW GIVXEMRP] LEZI ER I\MWXMRK VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL XLIMV WIE
WSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW JSV IEGL JSSXFEPP WIEWSR ERH E
TVSFEFPI JYXYVI FYWMRIWW VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL FSXL
XLIMV WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW [LS EVI RSX GSRXVEGXY
EPP] TVSQMWIH E VMKLX XS VIRI[ FYX KIRIVEPP] HS WS
ERH XLIMV [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW [LS NSMR XLI [EMX PMWX
XS FIGSQI IPMKMFPI JSV WIEWSR XMGOIXW EW XLI] FI
GSQI EZEMPEFPI
7XYF,YF LS[IZIV GSRXIRHW XLEX XLIVI MW RS
wVIEWSREFPI I\TIGXERG] SJ JMRERGMEP FIRIJMXx JVSQ
XLI 4EXVMSXW VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL I\MWXMRK WIEWSR XMGOIX
LSPHIVW FIGEYWI XLEX VIEWSREFPI I\TIGXERG] MW I\
XMRKYMWLIH SRGI XLI WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW TYVGLEWI
XLIMV XMGOIXW %GGSVHMRK XS 7XYF,YF IZIR MJ XLI 4EX
VMSXW [IVI XS VIZSOI XLI WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW
wPMGIRWIx JSV XLI WIEWSR FIGEYWI XLI XMGOIX LSPHIV
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-12-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 70/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 71/97
NYV] SJ XLI SXLIVv w -H EX UYSXMRK %RKPI Z
'LMGEKS 7X 4EYP ' 6] 'S 97
-X XLIR EHHIH w8LI [ERXSR HMWVIKEVH SJ XLI VMKLXW
SJ E GEVVMIV GEYWMRK MRNYV] XS MX [LMGL XLI FYWMRIWW
SJ TYVGLEWMRK ERH WIPPMRK RSRXVERWJIVEFPI VIHYGIH
VEXI XMGOIXW SJ RIGIWWMX] MRZSPZIH GSRWXMXYXI PIKEP
QEPMGIx &MXXIVQER EX -R WLSVX XLI 9RMXIH
7XEXIW 7YTVIQI 'SYVX HIGPEVIH XLEX MRXIRXMSREPP] MR
HYGMRK E FVIEGL SJ GSRXVEGX MW WYJJMGMIRX EPSRI XS IW
XEFPMWL QEPMGI 1EWWEGLYWIXXW PE[ VIUYMVIW QSVI
XLER MRHYGIQIRX ERH HSIW RSX GSRWMHIV MRHYGIQIRX
EPSRI XS WEXMWJ] XLI WITEVEXI IPIQIRX SJ MQTVSTIV
QSXMZI SV QIERW 7MQMPEVP] MR 8VERW[SVPH %MVPMRIW
XLI 2MRXL 'MVGYMX ETTPMIH 'EPMJSVRME PE[ KSZIVRMRK
XLI GEYWI SJ EGXMSR JSV XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL
FYWMRIWW VIPEXMSRW [LMGL HSIW RSX MRGPYHI XLI IPIQIRX SJ MQTVSTIV QSXMZI SV QIERW *H EX
*2
*2 8LI IPIQIRXW MR XLI 'EPMJSVRME
GEYWI SJ EGXMSR EVI
ER IGSRSQMG VIPEXMSRWLMT FIX[IIR XLI
TPEMRXMJJ ERH WSQI XLMVH TEVX] [MXL XLI
TVSFEFMPMX] SJ JYXYVI IGSRSQMG FIRIJMX XS
XLI TPEMRXMJJ XLI HIJIRHERXW ORS[
PIHKI SJ XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT MRXIRXMSREP
EGXW SR XLI TEVX SJ XLI HIJIRHERX HIWMKRIH XS HMWVYTX XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT EG
XYEP HMWVYTXMSR SJ XLI VIPEXMSRWLMT ERH
IGSRSQMG LEVQ XS XLI TPEMRXMJJ TVS\
MQEXIP] GEYWIH F] XLI EGXW SJ XLI HIJIRH
ERX
-H GMXMRK =SYWX Z 0SRKS 'EPH
R 'EP6TXV R
4H R
,IVI XLI 4EXVMSXW XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GPEMQ
EPPIKIW MQTVSTIV QIERW TIVLETW VIGSKRM^MRK XLEX7XYF,YFW QSXMZI XS QEOI QSRI] ERH FIRIJMX MXW
GYWXSQIVW HSIW RSX GSRWXMXYXI ER MQTVSTIV QSXMZI
YRHIV XLI PE[ 7II 9RMXIH 8VYGO 0IEWMRK 'SVT
1EWW EX /MRK Z (VMWGSPP 1EWW
-QTVSTIV QIERW QYWX GSRWMWX SJ GSR
HYGX XLEX ZMSPEXIW E WXEXYXI SV GSRWXMXYXIW E GSQQSR
PE[ XSVX /YVOIV 1EWW%TT'X EX
'EZMGGLM Z /SWOM 1EWW%TT'X EX
w-QTVSTIV QIERW MRGPYHI ZMSPEXMSR SJ E WXEXYXI SV
GSQQSRPE[ TVIGITX IK F] QIERW SJ XLVIEXW
QMWVITVIWIRXEXMSR SV HIJEQEXMSRx 8LI MWWYI
XLIR MW [LIXLIV XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI TVIWIRXIH IZMH
IRGI SJ MQTVSTIV QIERW
8LI 4EXVMSXW IWWIRXMEPP] EVKYI XLEX 7XYF,YF
MW IRKEKIH MR XLVII X]TIW SJ MPPIKEP GSRHYGX GSQ
QSR PE[ QMWVITVIWIRXEXMSR XVIWTEWW ERH GSRXVMFYX
MRK XS ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI wERXMWGEPTMRKx PE[W+0 G
� % ( %W XS GSQQSR PE[ QMWVIT
VIWIRXEXMSR XLI 4EXVMSXW EVKYI XLEX 7XYF,YF EJJMVQ
EXMZIP] WSYKLX XS TVIZIRX XLI 4EXVMSXW JVSQ PIEVRMRK
[LMGL SJ MXW WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW [IVI WIPPMRK XMGOIXW SRPMRI [MXL 7XYF,YF F] EPPS[MRK 0EVKI7IPPIVW
XS wQEWOx XMGOIX PSGEXMSRW F] PMWXMRK E HMJJIVIRX VS[
YT XS JMZI VS[W E[E] XLER XLEX TVMRXIH SR XLI SVM
KMREP XMGOIX ERH F] RSX MRJSVQMRK XLI FY]IV SJ XLI
I\EGX PSGEXMSR SJ XLI XMGOIXW YRXMP XLI FY]IV VIGIMZIW
XLIQ 8LMW 'SYVX LS[IZIV GER JMRH RSXLMRK MR XLI
VIGSVH XS WYTTSVX XLI GSRXIRXMSR XLEX 7XYF,YF [EW
QMWVITVIWIRXMRK XLI PSGEXMSR SJ XLI XMGOIXW XS XLI
FY]IV SJ XLI XMGOIXW %W JEV EW XLMW 'SYVX GER HMWGIVR
JVSQ XLMW VIGSVH XLI FY]IV MW XSPH XLEX LI MW FY]MRK
E XMGOIX [MXLMR JMZI VS[W SJ XLI MHIRXMJMIH PSGEXMSR
VEXLIV XLI TVIGMWI WIEX MHIRXMJMIH 2SV HSIW XLI VIGSVH VIJPIGX XLEX 7XYF,YF LEW MRHYGIH SV IRGSYV
EKIH XLIMV XMGOIX FY]IVW XS QEOI EJJMVQEXMZI QMWVIT
VIWIRXEXMSRW XS XLI 4EXVMSXW [LIR XLI] TVIWIRX XLIMV
XMGOIXW XS IRXIV +MPPIXXI 7XEHMYQ*2
8LI 4EXVMSXW
XLIVIJSVI EVI VIEPP] EVKYMRK XLEX 7XYF,YF IRKEKIW
MR MQTVSTIV QIERW F] QEOMRK MX LEVHIV JSV XLI 4EX
VMSXW XS HIXIGX [LS EQSRK MXW WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW
EVI WIPPMRK XMGOIXW SRPMRI XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF 8LMW
'SYVX HSIW RSX FIPMIZI XLEX XLMW EPSRI MW WYJJMGMIRX
XS GSRWXMXYXI XLI VIUYMVIH MQTVSTIV QIERW 6EXLIV
QMRMQM^MRK XLI VMWO SJ HIXIGXMSR MW WMQTP] TEVX SJ
7XYF,YFW MRHYGIQIRX XS GSQQMX XLI FVIEGL MXWIPJ
*2 'SQTEVI [MXL %QIVMGER %MVPMRIW
-RG Z 'LVMWXIRWIR * H XL
'MV MQTVSTIV GSRHYGX [LIVI HI
JIRHERX XMGOIX FVSOIV EPXIVIH EMVPMRI XMGOIXW
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-14-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 72/97
QERYJEGXYVIH TLSR] MHIRXMJMGEXMSR GEVHW
ERH MRWXVYGXIH XLI FY]IVW XS PMI XS EMVPMRI
XMGOIX EKIRXW %QIVMGER %MVPMRIW -RG Z
4PEXMRYQ ;SVPH 8VEZIP *7YTT
(9XEL MQTVSTIV GSR
HYGX [LIVI HIJIRHERX XMGOIX FVSOIV
wHIZIPSTIH ER IPEFSVEXI W]WXIQ SJ HIGIT
XMSRx MRGPYHMRK FSSOMRK JEPWI VIWIVZEXMSRW
ERH TVSZMHMRK XMGOIXW MR HMJJIVIRX REQI
JVSQ YWIV 2SVXL[IWX %MVPMRIW -RG Z 8LI
8MGOIX )\GL *7YTT
;(;EWL MQTVSTIV GSRHYGX
[LIVI HIJIRHERX MRWXVYGXIH TYVGLEWIVW SJ
RSRXVERWJIVEFPI JVIUYIRX JP]IV GIVXMJMGEXIW
XS WE] XMGOIXW [IVI KMJXW
%PXIVREXMZIP] XLI 4EXVMSXW EVKYI XLEX 7XYF,YF
IRKEKIH MR E QMWVITVIWIRXEXMSR SJ SQMWWMSR F] JEMP
MRK XS MRJSVQ MXW GYWXSQIVW XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW MRXIR
HIH XS IRJSVGI XLI TVSLMFMXMSR EKEMRWX XVERWJIV HI
GPEVIH SR XLIMV XMGOIXW 8LMW 'SYVX VIGSKRM^IW XLEX MX
MW ER YRJEMV EGX SV TVEGXMGI MR XVEHI ERH GSQQIVGI XS
JEMP XS HMWGPSWI XS E TVSWTIGXMZI FY]IV E ORS[R QE
XIVMEP JEGX XLEX QE] LEZI GEYWIH XLI TVSWTIGXMZI
FY]IV RSX XS IRXIV MRXS XLI XVERWEGXMSR 7II 9RHIV
[SSH Z 6MWQER 1EWW
'16 � 8LMW JEGX LS[IZIV [EW EPVIEH]
ORS[R XS XLI 4EXVMSXW XMGOIX LSPHIV WMRGI XLI [EVRMRK [EW GSRXEMRIH FSXL SR XLI FEGO SJ XLI XMGOIX ERH
MR XLI *ER +YMHI TVSZMHIH XS IEGL WIEWSR XMGOIX
LSPHIV [MXL XLIMV XMGOIXW IEGL ]IEV 8LMW JEGX QE]
RSX LEZI FIIR ORS[R F] XLI TVSWTIGXMZI XMGOIX FY]
IV SR 7XYF,YF FYX 7XYF,YFW *ER4VSXIGX +YEVER
XII TVSXIGXW XLIWI FY]IVW JVSQ XLI MRZEPMHEXMSR SJ
XMGOIXW XLI] TYVGLEWI F] EWWYVMRK XLIQ E JYPP VIJYRH
MJ XLI 4EXVMSXW GSRJMVQ XLEX XLI XMGOIXW EVI MRZEPMH
1SVISZIV WLSVXP] EJXIV XLMW PE[WYMX [EW JMVWX JMPIH
7XYF,YF TPEGIH SR XLI w2SXMJMGEXMSRWx TEKI SJ MXW
[IFWMXI E WIGXMSR HIZSXIH XS XLMW PE[WYMX XLEX QEOIW
GPIEV XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW EVI GLEPPIRKMRK XLI VMKLXW SJ
MRHMZMHYEPW XS VIWIPP XLIMV 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW SR 7XYF
,YF 'SRWIUYIRXP] IZIR ZMI[MRK XLI IZMHIRGI MR
XLI PMKLX QSWX JEZSVEFPI XS XLI 4EXVMSXW XLI IZMH
IRGI HSIW RSX WYTTSVX E JMRHMRK XLEX 7XYF,YF IR
KEKIH MR XLI MQTVSTIV QIERW SJ QMWVITVIWIRXEXMSR
IMXLIV YRHIV XLI GSQQSR PE[ SV YRHIV +0 G %
8LI 4EXVMSXW EPWS EPPIKI XLEX E RSRWIEWSR
XMGOIX LSPHIV GSQQMXW E XVIWTEWW [LIR LI YWIW E
XVERWJIVVIH XMGOIX XS IRXIV +MPPIXXI 7XEHMYQ XS [EXGL
E 4EXVMSXW KEQI ERH XLEX 7XYF,YF JEGMPMXEXIW WYGL E
XVIWTEWW 8LMW EVKYQIRX QE] LEZI FIIR TIVWYEWMZI
MJ XLI 4EXVMSXW PMOI ER EMVPMRI LEH TPEGIH E REQI SR
E XMGOIX ERH TIVQMXXIH SRP] XLEX TIVWSR ZIVMJMIH F]
TLSXSKVETLMG MHIRXMJMGEXMSR XS IRXIV XLI WXEHMYQ
[MXL XLEX XMGOIX FYX XLI] HMH RSX 8LI 4EXVMSXW
GSYRWIP GERHMHP] EHQMXXIH XLEX MJ E WIEWSR XMGOIX
LSPHIV KMZIW SV WIPPW E XMGOIX XS E JEQMP] QIQFIV
JVMIRH SV FYWMRIWW EWWSGMEXI XLI 4EXVMSXW [SYPH RSX
GSRWMHIV XLEX XVERWJIV XS NYWXMJ] E PSWW SJ WIEWSR
XMGOIX TVMZMPIKIW 'SRWIUYIRXP] XLI 4EXVMSXW HS RSXHIIQ XVERWJIV EPSRI XS [EVVERX VIZSGEXMSR SJ XLIMV
VIZSGEFPI WIEWSR XMGOIX wPMGIRWIx MX MW SRP] XVERWJIV
F] WEPI XS WXVERKIVW XLEX [EVVERXW VIZSGEXMSR 7MRGI
MX HSIW RSX GSRWMHIV EPP XLSWI [MXL XVERWJIVVIH XMGO
IXW XS FI XVIWTEWWIVW MX GERRSX TVIZEMP MR TVSZMRK
XLEX ER]SRI [MXL E XVERWJIVVIH XMGOIX WLSYPH FI
HIIQIH E XVIWTEWWIV
%W XS XLI wERXMWGEPTMRK PE[Wx +0 G �
% TVSZMHIW XLEX w?RAS TIVWSR WLEPP IRKEKI MR XLI
FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK ER] XMGOIX SV XMGOIXW SJ EHQMW
WMSR XS ER] XLIEXVMGEP I\LMFMXMSR TYFPMG WLS[ SV TYFPMG EQYWIQIRX SV I\LMFMXMSR [MXLSYX FIMRK PM
GIRWIH XLIVIJSV F] XLI 'SQQMWWMSRIV SJ 4YFPMG
7EJIX]x 8LI TVIGMWI QIERMRK SJ wIRKEK?MRKA MR
XLI FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK ER] XMGOIX SV XMGOIXWx LEW
]IX XS FI EVXMGYPEXIH F] SYV ETTIPPEXI GSYVXW 8LI
7YTVIQI .YHMGMEP 'SYVX HIGPEVIH MR wXLEX XLI
SJJIRGI HIRSYRGIH F] � % MW IRKEKMRK MR XLI
FYWMRIWW uSJ VIWIPPMRKv XMGOIXW ERH MX MW XLI SGGYTE
XMSR ERH RSX ER MWSPEXIH EGX [LMGL MW JSVFMHHIRx
'SQQSR[IEPXL Z 7SZVIRWO] 1EWW
-R 7SZVIRWO] XLI 'SYVX RSXIH XLEX wSRI
QE] FI IRKEKIH MR XLI FYWMRIWW SJ WIPPMRK EPXLSYKL
LI LEW QEHI RS WEPIx ERH EHHIH XLEX w?EA WMRKPI
WEPI XEOIR [MXL SXLIV GMVGYQWXERGIW QE] FI IRSYKL
XS QEOI SYX XLI SJJIRWI SJ HSMRK FYWMRIWWx -H EX
=IX XLMW EWWIVXMSR WLSYPH RSX WYKKIWX XLEX
E WMRKPI WEPI EPSRI [MXLSYX SXLIV GMVGYQWXERGIW
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-15-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 73/97
WYKKIWXMRK XLEX XLI TIVWSR MW MR XLI FYWMRIWW SJ VI
WIPPMRK XMGOIXW MW WYJJMGMIRX XS GSRWXMXYXI E ZMSPEXMSR
SJ � % 7SZVIRWO]W GSRZMGXMSR JSV ZMSPEXMRK
+0 G � % [EW EJJMVQIH FYX LI [EW SF
WIVZIH MR JVSRX SJ XLI SPH &SWXSR +EVHIR TVMSV XS E
[VIWXPMRK QEXGL GEPPMRK SYX XLEX LI LEH XMGOIXW JSV
WEPI ERH LI LEH WSPH X[S XMGOIXW JSV XLVII XMQIW XLI
JEGI ZEPYI TVMGI ERH LEH X[S QSVI SR LMW TIVWSR
[LIR LI [EW EVVIWXIH -H EX -X ETTIEVW XLEX XS
FI IRKEKIH MR XLI FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK SRI QYWX EX
XLI ZIV] PIEWX [MWL XS WIPP QSVI XLER SRI XMGOIX JSV
E TVSJMX FYX MX MW RSX GPIEV LS[ QER] WEPIW SV TVS
WTIGXMZI WEPIW EVI RIIHIH XS FIGSQI WS IRKEKIH
7II 0ERMIV Z 'MX] SJ &SWXSR *7YTTH
(1EWW WEPI SYXWMHI *IR[E] 4EVO SJ WMRKPI
XMGOIX EX JEGI ZEPYI MW RSX IRKEKMRK MR XLI FYWMRIWWSJ VIWIPPMRK
)ZIR PMGIRWIH XMGOIX FVSOIVW IRKEKIH MR XLI
FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK XMGOIXW EVI PMQMXIH MR XLI TVMGI
XLI] QE] GLEVKIXLI TVMGI SJ E VIWSPH XMGOIX QE] RSX
I\GIIH XLI TVMGI TVMRXIH SR XLI JEGI SJ XLI XMGOIX
TPYW TPYW WIVZMGI GLEVKIW +0 G (
8LI WIVZMGI GLEVKIW QE] RSX MRGPYHI XLI TYVGLEWI
TVMGI SJ XLI XMGOIX EFSZI JEGI ZEPYI WMRGI XLEX
w[SYPH EHH EW ER EPPS[EFPI GSWX SRI [LMGL IQEWGY
PEXIW XLI FEWMG TVSZMWMSR PMQMXMRK XLI TVMGI XS FI
GLEVKIHx 'SQQSR[IEPXL Z 7ERXERKIPS 1EWW%TT'X 'SRWIUYIRXP] MJ E
XMGOIX VIWIPPIV TYVGLEWIW E XMGOIX JSV LI
QE] RSX GLEVKI QSVI XLER TPYW TPYW WIVZMGI
GLEVKIW ERH QE] RSX MRGPYHI XLI TEMH EFSZI
JEGI ZEPYI EW E WIVZMGI GLEVKI 7II MH
8LMW 'SYVX RIIH RSX HIXIVQMRI SR WYQQEV]
NYHKQIRX LS[ QER] 7XYF,YF WIPPIVW SJ 4EXVMSXW
XMGOIXW EVI IRKEKIH MR XLI FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK XMGO
IXW WMRGI XLI IZMHIRGI MW GPIEV XLEX WSQI WIPPIVW
ERH FY]IVW EVI IRKEKIH MR XLEX FYWMRIWW %W RSXIH
IEVPMIV 7XYF,YF LEW E GEXIKSV] SJ WIPPIVW MX MHIRXM
JMIW EW w0EVKI7IPPIVWx [LMGL MX HIJMRIW EW XLSWI [LS
wXEOI E PEVKI MRXIVIWX MR XMGOIXW WTERRMRK SZIV QYP
XMTPI IZIRXW ERH KIRVIWx 7XYF,YFW HIJMRMXMSR SJ
0EVKI7IPPIVW QE] RSX QEXGL TVIGMWIP] XLI HIJMRMXMSR
YRHIV 1EWWEGLYWIXXW PE[ SJ XLSWI IRKEKIH MR XLI
FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK XMGOIXW YRHIV � % FYX MX MW
GPSWI IRSYKL XS WYKKIWX XLEX QSWX TIVLETW EPP
0EVKI7IPPIVW EVI WS IRKEKIH
8LIVI MW EFYRHERX IZMHIRGI MR XLI VIGSVH XLEX
XLI VIWEPI TVMGIW SJ 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW SR 7XYF,YF KIR
IVEPP] JEV I\GIIH XLI TVMGI XLVIWLSPH TIVQMXXIH YR
HIV � ( 7XYF,YF GSVVIGXP] SFWIVZIW XLEX MX HSIW
RSX WIPP XMGOIXW MXWIPJ FYX WMQTP] TVSZMHIW ER SRPMRI
JSVYQ JSV SXLIVW XS WIPP XMGOIXW 8LEX EPSRI
LS[IZIV MW RSX IRSYKL XS IWXEFPMWL XLEX MX HSIW RSX
IRKEKI MR MQTVSTIV QIERW 8LI 4EXVMSXW QE] TVSZI
XLEX 7XYF,YF MRHYGIH E FVIEGL SJ GSRXVEGX F] MQ
TVSTIV QIERW MJ XLI] GER WLS[ XLEX 7XYF,YF MRXIR
XMSREPP] MRHYGIH SV IRGSYVEKIH SXLIVW XS ZMSPEXI ��
% SV ( SV TVSJMXIH JVSQ WYGL ZMSPEXMSRW[LMPI HIGPMRMRK XS WXST SV PMQMX MX 7II 1IXVS
+SPH[]R1E]IV 7XYHMSW -RG Z +VSOWXIV 0XH
97 w +VSOWXIV x ETTP]MRK XLMW
WXERHEVH XS GPEMQ SJ GST]VMKLX MRJVMRKIQIRX EKEMRWX
WSJX[EVI GSQTER] XLEX JEGMPMXEXIH HS[RPSEH SJ
GST]VMKLXIH QYWMG ERH ZMHIS
+VSOWXIV HMWXVMFYXIH JVII WSJX[EVI TVSHYGXW XLEX
EPPS[IH YWIVW XS WLEVI IPIGXVSRMG JMPIW XLVSYKL TIIV
XSTIIV RIX[SVOW [LIVI YWIVWW GSQTYXIVW GSQQY
RMGEXIH HMVIGXP] [MXL IEGL SXLIV F]TEWWMRK GIRXVEP
WIVZIVW -H EX 6IGMTMIRXW YWIH XLI HIJIRHERXW WSJX[EVI TVMQEVMP] XS WLEVI ERH HS[RPSEH
GST]VMKLXIH QYWMG ERH ZMHIS JMPIW [MXLSYX EYXLSVM^
EXMSR -H EX 1+1 WYIH XLI HIJIRHERXW JSV
wXLIMV YWIVW GST]VMKLX MRJVMRKIQIRX EPPIKMRK XLEX
XLI] ORS[MRKP] ERH MRXIRXMSREPP] HMWXVMFYXIH XLIMV
WSJX[EVI XS IREFPI YWIVW XS VITVSHYGI ERH HMWXVMFYXI
GST]VMKLXIH [SVOW MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI 'ST]VMKLX
%GX 97' � IX WIU IH ERH 7YTT
--x -H EX %PXLSYKL XLI HIJIRHERX GSQ
TERMIW HMH RSX TVSJMX HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI HMWXVMFYXMSR
SJ XLI WSJX[EVI XLI] KIRIVEXIH MRGSQI F] WIPPMRK
EHZIVXMWMRK WTEGI ERH WXVIEQMRK XLI EHZIVXMWIQIRXW
XS WSJX[EVI YWIVW [LMPI XLI] IQTPS]IH XLI TVS
KVEQW -H EX
8LI 'SYVX RSXIH XLEX [LIVI E w[MHIP]
WLEVIH WIVZMGI SV TVSHYGX MW YWIH XS GSQQMX MR
JVMRKIQIRX MX QE] FI MQTSWWMFPI XS IRJSVGI VMKLXW
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-16-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 74/97
MR XLI TVSXIGXIH [SVO IJJIGXMZIP] EKEMRWX EPP HMVIGX
MRJVMRKIVW ?XLYWA XLI SRP] TVEGXMGEP EPXIVREXMZI FI
MRK XS KS EKEMRWX XLI HMWXVMFYXSV SJ XLI GST]MRK
HIZMGI JSV WIGSRHEV] PMEFMPMX] SR E XLISV] SJ GSR
XVMFYXSV] SV ZMGEVMSYW MRJVMRKIQIRX 3RI MRJVMRKIW
GSRXVMFYXSVMP] F] MRXIRXMSREPP] MRHYGMRK SV IRGSYV
EKMRK HMVIGX MRJVMRKIQIRX ERH MRJVMRKIW ZMGEVM
SYWP] F] TVSJMXMRK JVSQ HMVIGX MRJVMRKIQIRX [LMPI
HIGPMRMRK XS I\IVGMWI E VMKLX XS WXST SV PMQMX MXx
-H EX MRXIVREP GMXEXMSRW SQMXXIH %GXMZI
WXITW wHIWMKRIH XS IRGSYVEKI MRJVMRKIQIRX MRGPYHI
EHZIVXMWMRK MRWXVYGXMRK LS[ XS IRKEKI MR MRJVMRKI
QIRX WLS[MRK ER EJJMVQEXMZI MRXIRX XLEX XLI TVSHYGX
FI YWIH MR XLEX QERRIVx -H EX 8LI 'SYVX
LIPH XLEX wSRI [LS HMWXVMFYXIW E HIZMGI [MXL XLI SF
NIGX SJ TVSQSXMRK MXW YWI XS MRJVMRKI GST]VMKLX EWWLS[R F] GPIEV I\TVIWWMSR SV SXLIV EJJMVQEXMZI
WXITW XEOIR XS JSWXIV MRJVMRKIQIRX MW PMEFPI JSV XLI
VIWYPXMRK EGXW SJ MRJVMRKIQIRX F] XLMVH TEVXMIWx -H
EX 7II EPWS % 1 6IGSVHW -RG Z 2ETWXIV
-RG *H XL 'MV HIJIRHERX WIG
SRHEVMP] PMEFPI JSV GST]VMKLX MRJVMRKIQIRX [LIVI MX
ORI[ XLMVH TEVXMIW [IVI MRJVMRKMRK QEXIVMEPP] GSR
XVMFYXIH XS XLEX EGXMZMX] LEH E HMVIGX JMRERGMEP MR
XIVIWX MR XLI EGXMZMX] ERH JEMPIH XS XIVQMREXI XLI MR
JVMRKIQIRX
7XYF,YF GSRXIRHW XLEX MX MW TVSXIGXIH EKEMRWXER] EPPIKEXMSR XLEX MX ORS[MRKP] TEVXMGMTEXIH MR ER]
ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI wERXMWGEPTMRKx PE[W FIGEYWI MX VI
UYMVIW IEGL YWIV XS EKVII XS E YWIV EKVIIQIRX XLEX
TVSZMHIW MR TEVX
=SY EKVII RSX XS YWI XLMW 7MXI JSV YRPE[JYP TYV
TSWIW SV MR ER YRPE[JYP QERRIV =SY EKVII XS
GSQTP] [MXL EPP ETTPMGEFPI PSGEP WXEXI JIHIVEP
ERH MRXIVREXMSREP PE[W WXEXYXIW ERH VIKYPEXMSRW
VIKEVHMRK YWI SJ XLI 7MXI ERH XLI WIPPMRK SJ XMGO
IXW
=SY [EVVERX XLEX ]SY [MPP GSQTP] [MXL EPP ETTPMG
EFPI PSGEP WXEXI JIHIVEP ERH MRXIVREXMSREP PE[W
WXEXYXIW ERH VIKYPEXMSRW VIKEVHMRK YWI SJ XLI 7MXI
ERH WIPPMRK ZEPYI SJ XLI XMGOIXW
1SVISZIV SR MXW WIPPIV UYIWXMSR ERH ERW[IV
TEKI XLI 7XYF,YF [IFWMXI EWOW w,S[ HS - WIX
TVMGIW JSV Q] XMGOIXW#x ERH TVSZMHIW XLI ERW[IV
;LIR WIXXMRK XLI WEPI TVMGI SJ ]SYV XMGOIXW MX MW
]SYV VIWTSRWMFMPMX] XS GSQTP] [MXL EPP ETTPMGEFPI
PSGEP WXEXI JIHIVEP ERH MRXIVREXMSREP PE[W WXEX
YXIW ERH VIKYPEXMSRW
8S EWWMWX ]SY [MXL PMWXMRK ERH TVMGMRK ]SYV XMGO
IXW XLI 97 7XEXIW ERH 'EREHMER TVSZMRGIW [MXL
XMGOIX VIWEPI VIKYPEXMSRW EVI PMWXIH FIPS[
&IPS[ XLEX QIWWEKI RI\X XS w1EWWEGLYWIXXWx
MW E WYQQEV] SJ +0 G � % ERH � (
8LI 4EXVMSXW LS[IZIV MR WIIOMRK XS TVSZI XLEX
7XYF,YF ORS[MRKP] EMHIH XLI GSQQMWWMSR SJ MPPIKEP
GSRHYGX MW RSX PMQMXIH XS [LEX 7XYF,YF WEMH MX
QE] EPWS JSGYW GEVIJYPP] SR [LEX MX HMH ,IVI 7XYF
,YFW TVMGMRK WXVYGXYVI GIVXEMRP] QIERX XLEX MX
TVSJMXIH JVSQ ER] ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI ERXMWGEPTMRKx
PE[W WMRGI MXW VIZIRYI MRGVIEWIH MR HMVIGX TVSTSV
XMSR XS XLI TVMGI SJ XLI XMGOIX WSPH 1SVISZIV 7XYF
,YFW [IFWMXI HSIW RSX VIUYMVI XLI WIPPIV SV IZIR
EWO XLI WIPPIV XLI JEGI ZEPYI SJ XLI XMGOIX WS XLIVI
MW RS [E] JSV MX SV XLI FY]IV XS ORS[ [LIXLIV XLI
WEPIW TVMGI MW EFSZI XLI TVMGI XLVIWLSPH WIX YRHIV �
( 8LI EFWIRGI SJ WYGL MRJSVQEXMSR TIVQMXW MP
PIKEP XMGOIX WGEPTMRK XS SGGYV XLVSYKL XLI 7XYF,YF[IFWMXI ERH TVIZIRXW ER] TSPMGMRK SJ XLI [IFWMXI XS
TVSLMFMX WYGL WGEPTMRK 7XYF,YFW ETTEVIRX EJJMVQ
EXMZI GLSMGI RSX XS ORS[ XLI JEGI ZEPYI SJ XLI XMGO
IXW HSIW RSX QIER XLEX MX HMH RSX GSRXVMFYXI XS MPPIK
EP WGEPTMRK [MPPJYP FPMRHRIWW MW GIVXEMRP] RSX E HI
JIRWI XS XLMW GVMQI *MREPP] 7XYF,YF YRXMP EJ
JMVQEXMZIP] IRGSYVEKIH 0EVKI7IPPIVW MR XLI
0EVKI7IPPIVW ,ERHFSSO XS wGLIGO XLI [IFWMXI JVSQ
XMQI XS XMQI JSV YRHIVTVMGIH XMGOIXW SV I\GPYWMZI
PMWXMRKW XLEX QE] RSX FI WIIR IPWI[LIVIx ERH WXMPP
IRGSYVEKIW 0EVKI7IPPIVW XS FY] XLIWI YRHIVTVMGIH
XMGOIXW F] [EMZMRK JSV XLIQ XLI JII HYI JVSQ EPPSXLIV XMGOIX FY]IVW TIVGIRX SJ XLI WEPIW TVMGI %
JEGXJMRHIV VIEWSREFP] QE] GSRGPYHI XLEX XLI WS
GEPPIH wYRHIVTVMGIHx XMGOIXW EVI XMGOIXW TVMGIH [MXL
MR XLI PIKEP PMQMX WIX F] � ( ERH XLEX 7XYF,YF
F] IRGSYVEKMRK 0EVKI7IPPIVW XS FY] XLIWI XMGOIXW MW
IWWIRXMEPP] IRGSYVEKMRK 0EVKI7IPPIVW XS VIWIPP XLIWI
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-17-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 75/97
XMGOIXW EX LMKLIV TVMGIW JVSQ [LMGL 7XYF,YF [MPP
IRNS] E LMKLIV GSQQMWWMSR 8LIVIJSVI XLMW 'SYVX
JMRHW XLEX XLIVI MW E KIRYMRI MWWYI SJ QEXIVMEP JEGX EW
XS [LIXLIV 7XYF,YF MW MRXIRXMSREPP] MRHYGMRK SV IR
GSYVEKMRK SXLIVW XS ZMSPEXI �� % SV ( SV
TVSJMXMRK JVSQ WYGL ZMSPEXMSRW [LMPI HIGPMRMRK XS
WXST SV PMQMX XLIQ
7XYF,YF EVKYIW XLEX MX WLSYPH FI XVIEXIH RS
HMJJIVIRXP] JVSQ XLI RI[WTETIV w[ERXEHWx [LIVI E
WIPPIV SJ ER] TVSTIVX] MRGPYHMRK JSSXFEPP XMGOIXW MR
ZMXIW SXLIVW XS TYVGLEWI XLI TVSTIVX] SJXIR EX E WIX
TVMGI 8LIVI EVI LS[IZIV EX PIEWX X[S JYRHEQIRXEP
HMJJIVIRGIW FIX[IIR 7XYF,YFW [IFWMXI ERH XLI
w[ERXEHWx MR XLI GPEWWMJMIH TEKIW SJ E RI[WTETIV
SV GSQTEVEFPI [IFWMXI *MVWX XLI RI[WTETIV KIRIVEPP] GLEVKIW E JM\IH TVMGI JSV XLI EHZIVXMWIQIRX MXW
TVMGI MW RSX HITIRHIRX SR XLI EQSYRX SJ XLI WEPI
7II 'LMGEKS 0E[]IVW 'SQQ JSV 'MZMP 6MKLXW 9R
HIV 0E[ -RG Z 'VEMKWPMWX *H
XL 'MV 7IGSRH RI[WTETIVW HS RSX EJJMVQ
EXMZIP] WIIO XS MRGVIEWI XLI TVMGI GLEVKIH MR XLI
GPEWWMJMIH EH IWTIGMEPP] [LIR HSMRK WS QE] GSRWXM
XYXI E ZMSPEXMSR SJ PE[ -R 'VEMKWPMWX XLI 7IZIRXL
'MVGYMX VINIGXMRK E GPEMQ XLEX GVEMKWPMWX LIPTIH XS
ZMSPEXI XLI ERXMHMWGVMQMREXMSR PE[W MR XLI *EMV
,SYWMRK %GX RSXIH XLEX RSXLMRK MR XLI WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIH F] GVEMKWPMWX IRGSYVEKIH XLSWI TSWXMRKPMWXMRKW JSV VIRXEP SV WEPI TVSTIVXMIW XS EHH HMWGVMQ
MREXSV] TVIJIVIRGIW MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ XLI %GX -H EX
w*SV I\EQTPI GVEMKWPMWX HSIW RSX SJJIV E PS[IV
TVMGI XS TISTPI [LS MRGPYHI HMWGVMQMREXSV] WXEXI
QIRXW MR XLIMV TSWXMRKWx -H EX 'SQTEVI
[MXL 7II EPWS *EMV ,SYW 'SYRGMP SJ 7ER *VERGMWGS
:EPPI] Z 6SSQQEXIW 00' *H
XL GMV MRXIVRIX [IFWMXI HIWMKRIH XS QEXGL
TISTPI [MXL WTEVI VSSQW [MXL TISTPI PSSOMRK JSV E
TPEGI XS PMZI HSIW RSX QIVIP] TVSZMHI E JSVYQ [MXL
MR [LMGL YWIVW QE] ZMSPEXI XLI *EMV ,SYWMRK %GX
FYX EGXMZIP] IPMGMXW XLI HMWGVMQMREXSV] MPPIKEP GSR
XIRX SJ TSWXMRKW ERH MW XLYW wHMVIGXP] MRZSPZIH [MXL
HIZIPSTMRK ERH IRJSVGMRK E W]WXIQ XLEX WYFNIGXW
WYFWGVMFIVW XS EPPIKIHP] HMWGVMQMREXSV] LSYWMRK
TVEGXMGIWx
7XYF,YF GSRXIRHW XLEX MX MW IRXMXPIH XS MQ
QYRMX] TYVWYERX XS 9 7' � G SJ XLI
'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX SJ XLI
w'(%x 8LI TYVTSWI SJ XLI '(% [EW XS wTVSQSXI
XLI JVII I\GLERKI SJ MRJSVQEXMSR ERH MHIEW SZIV XLI
-RXIVRIX ERH XS IRGSYVEKI ZSPYRXEV] QSRMXSVMRK JSV
SJJIRWMZI SV SFWGIRI QEXIVMEPx 'EVEJERS Z 1IXVS
WTPEWLGSQ -RG *H XL
'MV -X TVSZMHIW MQQYRMX] XS XLSWI TVSZMHIVW
SJ MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIW XLEX TYFPMWL GSR
XIRX TVSZMHIH TVMQEVMP] F] XLMVH TEVXMIW -H EX
7II (SI Z 1]7TEGI -RG *H
XL 'MV FVSEH MQQYRMX] YRHIV � I\
XIRHW XS wEPP GPEMQW WXIQQMRK JVSQ ?ER MRXIVEGXMZI
WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVWA TYFPMGEXMSR SJ MRJSVQEXMSR GVI
EXIH F] XLMVH TEVXMIWx 8LMW 'SYVX VIGSKRM^IW XLEX7XYF,YF MW ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI XLEX
WIPPIVW [LS TSWX XLIMV XMGOIXW SR 7XYF,YF EVI MR
JSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVW [MXLMR XLI QIERMRK SJ
� ERH XLEX 7XYF,YF HSIW RSX PSWI XLI MQQYRMX]
TVSZMHIH F] XLI '(% MJ MX WMQTP] ORI[ XLEX MXW
WIPPIVW [IVI TSXIRXMEPP] MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ +0 G
� % SV � ( 7II 9RMZIVWEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW
7]W -RG Z 0]GSW *H WX
'MV w 7IGXMSR MQQYRMX] ETTPMIW IZIR
EJXIV RSXMGI SJ XLI TSXIRXMEPP] YRPE[JYP REXYVI SJ XLI
XLMVHTEVX] GSRXIRXx
,S[IZIV '(% MQQYRMX] wETTPMIW SRP] MJ
XLI MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV MW RSX EPWS
ER uMRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVv [LMGL MW HIJMRIH
EW WSQISRI [LS MW uVIWTSRWMFPI MR [LSPI SV MR
TEVXv JSV XLI GVIEXMSR SV HIZIPSTQIRX SJ XLI SJJIRH
MRK GSRXIRXx 6SSQQEXIW *H EX
97' � J 8LI 2MRXL 'MVGYMX LEW MRXIV
TVIXIH XLI XIVQ wHIZIPSTQIRXx EW wVIJIVVMRK RSX
QIVIP] XS EYKQIRXMRK XLI GSRXIRX KIRIVEPP] FYX XS
QEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXMRK XS MXW EPPIKIH YRPE[JYPRIWW
-R SXLIV [SVHW E [IFWMXI LIPTW XS HIZIPST YRPE[JYP
GSRXIRX ERH XLYW JEPPW [MXLMR XLI I\GITXMSR XS WIG
XMSR MJ MX GSRXVMFYXIW QEXIVMEPP] XS XLI EPPIKIH
MPPIKEPMX] SJ XLI GSRHYGXx 6SSQQEXIW *H EX
,IVI EW HMWGYWWIH IEVPMIV XLIVI MW IZMH
IRGI MR XLI VIGSVH XLEX 7XYF,YF QEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMF
YXIH XS XLI MPPIKEP wXMGOIX WGEPTMRKx SJ MXW WIPPIVW -R
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-18-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 76/97
IJJIGX XLI WEQI IZMHIRGI SJ ORS[MRK TEVXMGMTEXMSR
MR MPPIKEP wXMGOIX WGEPTMRKx XLEX MW WYJJMGMIRX MJ
TVSZIR XS IWXEFPMWL MQTVSTIV QIERW MW EPWS WYJJM
GMIRX XS TPEGI 7XYF,YF SYXWMHI XLI MQQYRMX]
TVSZMHIH F] XLI '(%
(MH XLI 4EXVMSXW WYJJIV ER] TIGYRMEV] PSWW EW E
VIWYPX SJ 7XYF,YFW EPPIKIH XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI#
7XYF,YF EVKYIW XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW GERRSX WLS[
ER] TIGYRMEV] PSWW ERH XLEX IZIR MJ XLI] GSYPH HS
WS ER] JMRERGMEP PSWW [SYPH RSX FI E VIWYPX SJ 7XYF
,YFW EGXMSRW 8LI KMWX SJ 7XYF,YFW EVKYQIRX MR
XLMW VIKEVH MW XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW VIGIMZI TE]QIRX JVSQ
WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW VIKEVHPIWW SJ ER] EPPIKIH MR
XIVJIVIRGI WMRGI XLI XMGOIXW EVI FSYKLX FIJSVI XLI]
EVI PMWXIH SR XLI [IFWMXI ERH MR ER] IZIRX ER] VIZSGEXMSR SJ WIEWSR XMGOIXW GERRSX VIWYPX MR TIGYRM
EV] PSWW [LIVI XLSWI XMGOIXW QE] FI WSPH MQQIHM
EXIP] XS [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW
8LI 4EXVMSXW EPPIKI X[S X]TIW SJ TIGYRMEV] PSWW
XLI PSWW SJ KSSH[MPP EVMWMRK JVSQ HEQEKI XS XLIMV
VIPEXMSRWLMT [MXL XLIMV WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW ERH
[EMX PMWX QIQFIVW ERH HMVIGX GSWXW EVMWMRK JVSQ XLI
WEPI SJ MRZEPMH XMGOIXW XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF 8LI EP
PIKIH PSWW SJ KSSH[MPP EVMWIW JVSQ XLI 4EXVMSXW GSQ
QMXQIRX XS TVSZMHI E WEJI ERH JEQMP]JVMIRHP] IR
ZMVSRQIRX JSV LSQI JSSXFEPP KEQIW 8LI 4EXVMSXWGSRXIRH XLEX WMRGI XLSWI [LS TYVGLEWI 4EXVMSXW
XMGOIXW SR 7XYF,YF EVI PMOIP] SRIXMQI ERSR]QSYW
FY]IVW ERH HS RSX LEZI XLI WEQI MRGIRXMZI XS FI
LEZI ETTVSTVMEXIP] EW HS XLSWI WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIVW
[LS ORS[ XLEX XLIMV XMGOIXW QE] FI VIZSOIH EX ER]
XMQI JSV FEH FILEZMSV 7XYF,YF MRXIVJIVIW [MXL XLI
KSSH[MPP XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI FYMPX [MXL XLIMV JERW F]
GVIEXMRK E GMZMP ZIRYI XS [EXGL E JSSXFEPP KEQI 8LI
4EXVMSXW EPWS EWWIVX XLEX 7XYF,YF MRXIVJIVIW [MXL XLI
KSSH[MPP XLI] LEZI JSWXIVIH [MXL XLIMV JERW F] EP
PS[MRK XMGOIXW XS FI WSPH SR 7XYF,YF VEXLIV XLER FI
SJJIVIH SR 8MGOIX)\GLERKI XS SXLIV WIEWSR XMGOIX
LSPHIVW ERH [EMX PMWX QIQFIVW 8LMW HMQMRMWLIW XLI
EZEMPEFMPMX] SJ 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW SR 8MGOIX)\GLERKI
ERH XLIVIF] HMQMRMWLIW SRI SJ XLI FIRIJMXW SJ FIMRK
E WIEWSR XMGOIX LSPHIV SV [EMX PMWX QIQFIV
8LI EPPIKIH HMVIGX GSWXW EVI WYWXEMRIH FIGEYWI
4EXVMSXW WXEJJ EX XMGOIX [MRHS[W QYWX VIWTSRH XS
MRUYMVMIW ERH GSQTPEMRXW JVSQ XLSWI JERW [LS LEZ
MRK TYVGLEWIH MRZEPMH XMGOIXW XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF EVI
XLIR XYVRIH E[E] EX XLI KEXI ERH EWO JSV XLI [VMXXIR
GSRJMVQEXMSR RIIHIH XS SFXEMR E VIJYRH SJ XLI XMGOIX
TVMGI XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF 4EXVMSXW WXEJJ QYWX MR
ZIWXMKEXI XMGOIX VIWEPI ERH VIZSOI WIEWSR XMGOIXW
JVSQ LSPHIVW [LS LEZI FIIR IRGSYVEKIH F] 7XYF
,YF XS WIPP XLIMV XMGOIXW SR MXW [IFWMXI ERH XLI
MRGVIEWIH PMOIPMLSSH SJ MQTVSTIV GSRHYGX F] ER
SR]QSYW 7XYF,YF FY]IVW RIGIWWMXEXIW MRGVIEWIH WI
GYVMX] QIEWYVIW
8LI IPIQIRX SJ IGSRSQMG PSWW VIUYMVIH XS
IWXEFPMWL XSVXMSYW MRXIVJIVIRGI GERRSX FI IWXEFPMWLIH
F] wWTIGYPEXMZI SV GSRNIGXYVEP PSWWIWx 'LIQE[E'SYRXV] +SPJ -RG Z ;RYO 1EWW%TT'X
-X MW RSX IRSYKL XLEX XLI GSRHYGX [EW
wMRXIRWIP] MVVMXEXMRKx -H EX w'LIQE[E MW E
GSVTSVEXMSR [LMGL LEW RS LIEVX XS EGLI SV YPGIV XS
FPIIH ERH MR ER] IZIRX MX MW RSX ZI\EXMSR FYX MRXIV
JIVIRGI [MXL FIRIJMGMEP VIPEXMSRW [MXL XLMVH TEVXMIW
[LMGL QYWX FI IWXEFPMWLIHx -H ;MXLSYX QSVI MX MW
RSX IRSYKL XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW EPPIKI HEQEKI XS XLI
WSQI[LEX ZEKYI ERH RSX IEWMP] UYERXMJMEFPI GSRGITX
SJ wKSSH[MPPx XLEX XLI] GPEMQ XLI] EWWMHYSYWP] GYP
XMZEXIH [MXL XLIMV JERW 8LIVI MW RS IZMHIRGI XLEX
JERW [LS SFXEMRIH XLIMV XMGOIXW JVSQ 7XYF,YF [IVIQSVI YRVYP] XLER SXLIV JERW SV XLEX MRWXERGIW SJ YR
VYP] GSRHYGX LEZI MRGVIEWIH EW E VIWYPX SJ 7XYF
,YFW XMGOIX WEPIW 2SV MW XLIVI ER] IZMHIRGI XLEX
QSVI MRHMZMHYEPW [SYPH WIIO XS FI WIEWSR XMGOIX
LSPHIVW MJ QSVI XMGOIXW [IVI QEHI EZEMPEFPI XLVSYKL
8MGOIX)\GLERKI VEXLIV XLER 7XYF,YF 2SV MW XLIVI
ER] IZMHIRGI XLEX ER] WYGL MRGVIEWIH MRXIVIWX MR
WIEWSR XMGOIXW [SYPH LEZI ER] JMRERGMEP MQTEGX SR
XLI 4EXVMSXW [LS EPVIEH] LEZI E [EMXMRK PMWX SJ EX
PIEWX JERW 2SV MW XLIVI ER] I\TIVX XIWXMQSR]
XLEX MJ XLI XIEQ [IVI TPEGIH SR XLI QEVOIX XS FI
WSPH XLI JEMV QEVOIX ZEPYI SJ XLI XIEQW KSSH[MPP
[SYPH FI KVIEXIV MJ 7XYF,YF WXSTTIH WIPPMRK 4EXVM
SXW XMGOIXW -R WLSVX SXLIV XLER XLI 4EXVMSXW EWWIV
XMSRW SJ HEQEKI MR XLMW VIKEVH XLI VIGSVH FIJSVI XLI
'SYVX TVSZMHIW RS IZMHIRGI SJ ER] EGXYEP TIGYRMEV]
PSWW SV JMRERGMEP LEVQ EW E VIWYPX SJ 7XYF,YFW EP
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-19-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 77/97
PIKIH MRXIVJIVIRGI [MXL wKSSH[MPPx SV ER] HMQMRY
XMSR MR XLI 4EXVMSXW EFMPMX] XS TVSZMHI E JEQMP]
JVMIRHP] IRZMVSRQIRX 7II 0EPSRHI Z )MWWRIV
1EWW STTSWMRK TEVX] GERRSX VIWX
SR TPIEHMRKW ERH QIVI EWWIVXMSRW SJ HMWTYXIH JEGXW
XS HIJIEX XLI QSXMSR JSV WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX
% JEV GPSWIV GEPP LS[IZIV MW [LIXLIV XLI 4EXVM
SXW MRGYV MRGVIEWIH EHQMRMWXVEXMZI GSWXW EW E VIWYPX
SJ XLI WEPI SJ MRZEPMH XMGOIXW XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF
8LIVI MW IZMHIRGI EPFIMX WGERX XLEX XLI 4EXVMSXW
TIVWSRRIP EX XMGOIX [MRHS[W QYWX HIEP [MXL GSQ
TPEMRXW ERH MRUYMVMIW JVSQ JERW [MXL XMGOIXW TYV
GLEWIH XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF [LS EVI XYVRIH E[E] EX
XLI KEXI ERH QYWX TVSZMHI XLIQ [MXL XLI GSRJMVQE
XMSR RIGIWWEV] JSV 7XYF,YF XS VIJYRH XLI XMGOIX TVMGI 8LIVI MW EPWS IZMHIRGI EKEMR WGERX XLEX XLI
WEPI SJ 4EXVMSXW XMGOIXW XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF MRGVIEWIW
XLI GSWX XS XLI 4EXVMSXW SJ MRZIWXMKEXMRK ERH EHHVIWW
MRK XMGOIX VIWEPI EGXMZMX] ;LMPI MX MW RSX GPIEV JVSQ
XLI VIGSVH FIJSVI XLI 'SYVX [LIXLIV EW E VIWYPX SJ
XLIWI EHHMXMSREP EHQMRMWXVEXMZI FYVHIRW XLI 4EXVMSXW
QYWX LMVI EHHMXMSREP TIVWSRRIP EHH XS XLI LSYVW
[SVOIH F] I\MWXMRK TIVWSRRIP HMZIVX GYVVIRX WXEJJ
JVSQ SXLIV HYXMIW SV TE] XLI WEQI IQTPS]IIW QSVI
XS TIVJSVQ EHHMXMSREP [SVO XLMW 'SYVX MW WEXMWJMIH
XLEX ZMI[MRK XLI IZMHIRGI MR XLI PMKLX QSWX JEZSV
EFPI XS XLI 4EXVMSXW XLIVI MW E KIRYMRI MWWYI SJ QEXIVMEP JEGX EW XS [LIXLIV XLI 4EXVMSXW LEZI MRGYVVIH
SV [MPP MRGYV EHHMXMSREP EHQMRMWXVEXMZI GSWXW EW E
VIWYPX SJ 7XYF,YFW GSRHYGX 8LIWI EHQMRMWXVEXMZI
GSWXW EVI EX FIWX E XSILSPH XS IWXEFPMWL TIGYRMEV]
PSWW FYX E XSILSPH MW WYJJMGMIRX XS WYVZMZI E QSXMSR
JSV WYQQEV] NYHKQIRX 1EVV )UYMTQIRX 'SVT Z
-83 'SVT 1EWW%TT'X
36()6
*SV XLI VIEWSRW WXEXIH EFSZI XLMW 'SYVX
36()67 XLEX 7XYF,YFW QSXMSR JSV TEVXMEP WYQ
QEV] NYHKQIRX SR 'SYRX - EPPIKMRK MRXIRXMSREP MR
XIVJIVIRGI [MXL EHZERXEKISYW VIPEXMSRW MW
()2-)(
1EWW7YTIV
247 00' Z 7XYF,YF -RG
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV
;0 1EWW7YTIV
)2( 3* (3'91)28
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 2)H 1EWW06TXV ;0 1EWW7YTIV
'MXI EW ;0 1EWW7YTIV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-20-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 78/97
?A 'LVMWXEOMW 7LMEQMPM G %TTIPPERX Z 8LI 6IEP )WXEXI +VSYT SJ 2I[ =SVO
-RG IX EP 6IWTSRHIRXW
2S
'3968 3* %44)%07 3* 2); =36/
2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
.YRI (IGMHIH
238-')
8,) 0)<-7 4%+-2%8-32 3* 8,-7 (3'91)28
-7 79&.)'8 83 ',%2+) 4)2(-2+ 6)0)%7) 3*
8,) *-2%0 49&0-7,)( :)67-32 8,-7
34-2-32 -7 92'366)'8)( %2( 79&.)'8 83
6):-7-32 &)*36) 49&0-'%8-32 -2 8,)
3**-'-%0 6)43687
46-36 ,-7836= 7LMEQMPM Z 6IEP )WXEXI +VSYT SJ
2= -RG %(H 2=7H 2=
%TT (MZ 0)<-7 2= %TT (MZ WX (ITX
(-7437-8-32 ?A 3VHIV EJJMVQIH [MXL GSWXW
'3927)0 .SREXLER 7 7LETMVS JSV ETTIPPERX
.SWITL (%QFVSWMS JSV VIWTSRHIRXW
.9(+)7 '-4%6-'/ . 3TMRMSR F] .YHKI 'MTEVMGO
.YHKIW +VEJJIS 6IEH ERH 7QMXL GSRGYV 'LMIJ .YHKI
0MTTQER HMWWIRXW ERH ZSXIW XS VIZIVWI MR ER STMRMSR MR
[LMGL .YHKIW 4MKSXX ERH .SRIW GSRGYV
34-2-32 &= '-4%6-'/
34-2-32
'-4%6-'/ .
3R XLMW ETTIEP [I GSRWMHIV JSV XLI JMVWX XMQI [LIXLIV
E TPEMRXMJJW GPEMQ EKEMRWX E [IFWMXI STIVEXSV EVMWMRK SYX SJ
EPPIKIHP] HIJEQEXSV] GSQQIRXW TSWXIH XS XLI [IFWMXI MW
FEVVIH F] XLI 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX '(%
GSHMJMIH EW 97' � ;I GSRGPYHI XLEX MX MW ERH XLEX
XLI HIJIRHERXW QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI GSQTPEMRX [EW
TVSTIVP] KVERXIH
%W WXEXIH MR XLI GSQTPEMRX TPEMRXMJJ 'LVMWXEOMW
7LMEQMPM MW XLI JSYRHIV ERH ')3 SJ ?A %VHSV 6IEPX]
'SVT %VHSV E 2I[ =SVO ETEVXQIRX VIRXEP ERH WEPIW
GSQTER] -R 1EVGL 7LMEQMPM JMPIH XLMW EGXMSR JSV
HIJEQEXMSR ERH YRJEMV GSQTIXMXMSR F] HMWTEVEKIQIRX
EKEMRWX HIJIRHERXW XLI 6IEP )WXEXI +VSYT SJ 2I[ =SVO
-RG 86)+2= (ERMIP &EYQ ERH 6]ER 1G'ERR
86)+2= MW E GSQTIXMXSV SJ %VHSVW EPWS IRKEKIH MR
WIPPMRK ERH VIRXMRK 2I[ =SVO 'MX] ETEVXQIRXW &EYQ MW
86)+2=W TVMRGMTEP ERH 'LMIJ 3TIVEXMRK 3JJMGIV ERH
1G'ERR MW &EYQW EWWMWXERX
8LIWI HIJIRHERXW ?A EPPIKIHP] EHQMRMWXIV ERH
GLSSWI GSRXIRX JSV E TYFPMGP] EGGIWWMFPI [IFWMXI E
FPSK HIHMGEXIH XS XLI 2I[ =SVO 'MX] VIEP IWXEXI
MRHYWXV] -R *IFVYEV] HIJIRHERXW EPPIKIHP]
TYFPMWLIH HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW EFSYX 7LMEQMPM SR XLI[IFWMXI 7TIGMJMGEPP] E PIRKXL] GSQQIRX [EW EHHIH XS E
HMWGYWWMSR XLVIEH F] E YWIV STIVEXMRK YRHIV XLI
TWIYHSR]Q %VHSV 6IEPX] 7YGOW 8LI GSQQIRX QEHI
WIZIVEP EPPIKIHP] HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW WYKKIWXMRK XLEX
7LMEQMPM QMWXVIEXIH LMW IQTPS]IIW ERH [EW VEGMWX ERH
ERXM7IQIXMG VIJIVVMRK XS SRI SJ XLI GSQTER]W EKIRXW EW
LMW XSOIR .I[ 1G'ERR MR LMW VSPI EW [IFWMXI
EHQMRMWXVEXSV QSZIH XLI GSQQIRX XS E WXERHEPSRI TSWX
4EKI -21-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 79/97
TVIJEGMRK MX [MXL XLI WXEXIQIRX XLEX XLI JSPPS[MRK WXSV]
GEQI XS YW EW E GSQQIRX ERH [I TVSQSXIH MX XS E
TSWX 8LI TSWX [EW KMZIR XLI LIEHMRK %VHSV 6IEPX] ERH
8LSWI 4ISTPI ERH XLI WYFLIEHMRK ERH RS[ MXW XMQI
JSV ]SYV [IIOP] HSWI SJ LEXI FVSYKLX XS ]SY YRIHMXIH
SRGI EKEMR F] %VHSV 6IEPX] 7YGOW ERH JSV XLI VIGSVH
[I EVI WS RSX EJVEMH 8LI TSWX [EW EGGSQTERMIH F] E
XVEHMXMSREP MQEKI SJ .IWYW 'LVMWX [MXL 7LMEQMPMW JEGI ERH
XLI [SVHW 'LVMW 7LMEQMPM /MRK SJ XLI 8SOIR .I[W
(IJIRHERXW QEMRXEMR XLEX SRP] 1G'ERR ?A
EHQMRMWXIVW XLI [IFWMXI 3R XLMW QSXMSR XS
HMWQMWW [I EGGITX TPEMRXMJJW EPPIKEXMSR XLEX EPP
1G'ERRW EGXMSRW [IVI XEOIR [MXL XLI
ORS[PIHKI SJ SV EGUYMIWGIRGI F] XLI SXLIV
HIJIRHERXW
7IZIVEP SJ XLI GSQQIRXW TSWXIH F] ERSR]QSYW YWIVWMR XLI IRWYMRK HMWGYWWMSR XLVIEH GSRXEMRIH JYVXLIV
EPPIKIHP] HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW MRGPYHMRK WYKKIWXMSRW
XLEX %VHSV [EW MR JMRERGMEP XVSYFPI ERH XLEX 7LMEQMPM
EFYWIH ERH GLIEXIH SR LMW [MJI 3RI SJ XLI GSQQIRXEXSVW
IRHIH F] WE]MRK GEPP QI E PMEV ERH -PP GSQI FEGO LIVI
ERH KIX 6)%00= WTIGMJMG 8LI GSQTPEMRX EPPIKIW XLEX
1G'ERR YRHIV E TWIYHSR]Q VIWTSRHIH PMEV MR ER
EXXIQTX XS IRGSYVEKI XLI YWIV XS WE] QSVI FYX XLEX
GSQQIRXEXSV HMH RSX TSWX JYVXLIV 7LMEQMPM VIWTSRHIH F]
HVEJXMRK E PIRKXL] GSQQIRX [LMGL [EW EHHIH XS XLI
HMWGYWWMSR XLVIEH 7LMEQMPM EPWS GSRXEGXIH 1G'ERR ERH
VIUYIWXIH XLEX LI VIQSZI XLI HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW FYX
1G'ERR VIJYWIH XS HS WS
7LMEQMPM FVSYKLX XLMW EGXMSR EPPIKMRK MR LMW
GSQTPEMRX XLEX XLI HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW [IVI QEHI [MXL
XLI MRXIRX XS MRNYVI LMW VITYXEXMSR ERH XLEX HIJIRHERXW
IMXLIV QEHI SV TYFPMWLIH XLI WXEXIQIRXW -R EHHMXMSR XS
HEQEKIW XLI GSQTPEMRX VIUYIWXW MRNYRGXMZI VIPMIJ
VIUYMVMRK HIJIRHERXW XS ?A WXST TYFPMGEXMSR SJ ER]
ERH EPP HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW GSRGIVRMRK 7LMEQMPM ERH
%VHSV ERH ER] JYVXLIV HMWTEVEKIQIRX ?A
(IJIRHERXW QSZIH XS HMWQMWW XLI GSQTPEMRX JSV
JEMPYVI XS WXEXI E GEYWI SJ EGXMSR '406 ?EA ?A -RWYTTSVX SJ XLI QSXMSR 1G'ERR WYFQMXXIH ER EJJMHEZMX
EGORS[PIHKMRK XLEX LI [EW XLI EHQMRMWXVEXSV ERH
QSHIVEXSV SJ XLI [IFWMXI [LMGL JYRGXMSRIH EW E ZMVXYEP
FYPPIXMR FSEVH SV STIR HMWGYWWMSR JSVYQ XS [LMGL
ER]SRI GSYPH EHH GSRXIRX MR XLI JSVQ SJ E GSQQIRX SR ER
I\MWXMRK TSWX 3RP] 1G'ERR MR LMW VSPI EW QSHIVEXSV
GSYPH GVIEXI WXERHEPSRI TSWXW GETEFPI SJ KIRIVEXMRK XLIMV
S[R HMWGYWWMSR XLVIEHW
7YTVIQI 'SYVX HIRMIH XLI QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW %W
VIPIZERX LIVI MX JSYRH XLEX WIGXMSR G SJ XLI '(%
97' � ?GA ?A HMH RSX VIUYMVI HMWQMWWEP SJ
TPEMRXMJJW GPEMQW WMRGI MRJSVQEXMSR EW XS HIJIRHERXW
VSPI MJ ER] MR EYXLSVMRK SV HIZIPSTMRK XLI GSRXIRX SJ XLI
[IFWMXI MW I\GPYWMZIP] [MXLMR XLIMV TSWWIWWMSR ERH
HMWGSZIV] LEH RSX ]IX SGGYVVIH
8LI %TTIPPEXI (MZMWMSR YRERMQSYWP] VIZIVWIH
KVERXIH XLI QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW ERH HMWQMWWIH XLI
GSQTPEMRX 8LI GSYVX I\TPEMRIH XLEX XLI '(% TVSXIGXW
[IFWMXI STIVEXSVW JVSQ PMEFMPMX] HIVMZIH JVSQ XLI I\IVGMWI
SJ E TYFPMWLIVW ?A XVEHMXMSREP IHMXSVMEP JYRGXMSRW WII
7LMEQMPM Z 6IEP )WXEXI +VSYT SJ 2I[ =SVO -RG %(H
2=7H ?WX (ITX A &IGEYWI XLI
GSQTPEMRX LIVI HSIW RSX EPPIKI XLEX HIJIRHERXW EYXLSVIH
XLI HIJEQEXSV] GSRXIRX FYX SRP] XLEX XLI] TYFPMWLIH ERH
IHMXIH MX XLI GSYVX GSRGPYHIH XLEX XLI '(% FEVW7LMEQMPMW GPEMQ ERH XLEX JYVXLIV HMWGSZIV] MW YRRIGIWWEV]
WII MH ;I KVERXIH 7LMEQMPM PIEZI XS ETTIEP 2=H
2)H 2=7H ?A ERH RS[
EJJMVQ
%PXLSYKL E TYFPMWLIV SJ HIJEQEXSV] QEXIVMEP
EYXLSVIH F] E XLMVHTEVX] MW KIRIVEPP] WYFNIGX XS XSVX
PMEFMPMX] 'SRKVIWW LEW GEVZIH SYX ER I\GITXMSR JSV
MRXIVRIX TYFPMGEXMSR F] IREGXMRK WIGXMSR SJ XLI '(%
TEWWIH EW TEVX SJ XLI 8IPIGSQQYRMGEXMSRW %GX SJ
4YF 0 7XEX ?XL 'SRK H 7IWW *IF
A 7IGXMSR IWXEFPMWLIW XLEX ?RAS TVSZMHIV SV
YWIV SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI WLEPP FI XVIEXIH EW
XLI TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ ER] MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH F]
ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV 97' � ?GA
?A ERH MX TVIIQTXW ER] WXEXI PE[ MRGPYHMRK
MQTSWMXMSR SJ XSVX PMEFMPMX] MRGSRWMWXIRX [MXL MXW
TVSXIGXMSRW WII 97' � ?IA ?A % HIJIRHERX MW
XLIVIJSVI MQQYRI JVSQ WXEXI PE[ PMEFMPMX] MJ MX MW E
TVSZMHIV ?A SV YWIV SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV
WIVZMGI XLI GSQTPEMRX WIIOW XS LSPH XLI HIJIRHERX
PMEFPI EW E TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV ERH XLI EGXMSR MW
FEWIH SR MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH F] ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR
GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV 97' � ?GA ?A WII EPWS *IH
8VEHI 'SQQR Z %GGYWIEVGL -RG *H
?XL 'MV A &EVRIW Z =ELSS -RG *H
?XL 'MV A 9RMZIVWEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW
7]W -RG Z 0]GSW -RG *H ?WX 'MV A
8LI WXEXYXI HIJMRIW ER MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV EW
ER] TIVWSR SV IRXMX] XLEX MW VIWTSRWMFPI MR [LSPI SV MR
TEVX JSV XLI GVIEXMSR SV HIZIPSTQIRX SJ MRJSVQEXMSR
TVSZMHIH ?A XLVSYKL XLI -RXIVRIX SV ER] SXLIV
4EKI 2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
-22-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 80/97
MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI 97' � ?JA ?A
7IGXMSR HIJMRIW ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV
WIVZMGI EW ER] MRJSVQEXMSR WIVZMGI W]WXIQ SV
EGGIWW WSJX[EVI TVSZMHIV XLEX TVSZMHIW SV IREFPIW
GSQTYXIV EGGIWW F] QYPXMTPI YWIVW XS E GSQTYXIV WIVZIV 97' � ?JA ?A
-R TEWWMRK WIGXMSR 'SRKVIWW EGORS[PIHKIH XLEX
?XALI -RXIVRIX SJJIV?WA E JSVYQ JSV E XVYI HMZIVWMX] SJ
TSPMXMGEP HMWGSYVWI YRMUYI STTSVXYRMXMIW JSV GYPXYVEP
HIZIPSTQIRX ERH Q]VMEH EZIRYIW JSV MRXIPPIGXYEP
EGXMZMX] 97' � ?EA ?A ?A ERH XLEX MX LEW
JPSYVMWLIH XS XLI FIRIJMX SJ EPP %QIVMGERW [MXL E
QMRMQYQ SJ KSZIVRQIRX VIKYPEXMSR 97' � ?EA
?A *YVXLIV MX MW XLI TSPMG] SJ XLI 9RMXIH 7XEXIW XS
TVIWIVZI XLI ZMFVERX ERH GSQTIXMXMZI JVII QEVOIX XLEX
TVIWIRXP] I\MWXW JSV XLI -RXIVRIX ERH SXLIV MRXIVEGXMZIGSQTYXIV WIVZMGIW YRJIXXIVIH F] *IHIVEP SV 7XEXI
VIKYPEXMSR 97' � ?FA ?A %W XLI *SYVXL 'MVGYMX
I\TPEMRIH MR XLI WIQMREP GEWI SJ >IVER Z %Q 3RPMRI -RG
*H ?XL 'MV A
'SRKVIWW VIGSKRM^IH XLI XLVIEX XLEX
XSVXFEWIH PE[WYMXW TSWI XS JVIIHSQ SJ
WTIIGL MR XLI RI[ ERH FYVKISRMRK -RXIVRIX
QIHMYQ 8LI MQTSWMXMSR SJ XSVX PMEFMPMX] SR
WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW JSV XLI GSQQYRMGEXMSRW
SJ SXLIVW VITVIWIRXIH JSV 'SRKVIWW
WMQTP] ERSXLIV JSVQ SJ MRXVYWMZI
KSZIVRQIRX VIKYPEXMSR SJ WTIIGL 7IGXMSR
[EW IREGXIH MR TEVX XS QEMRXEMR XLI
VSFYWX REXYVI SJ -RXIVRIX GSQQYRMGEXMSR
ERH EGGSVHMRKP] XS OIIT KSZIVRQIRX
MRXIVJIVIRGI MR XLI QIHMYQ XS E
QMRMQYQ
%HHMXMSREPP] WIGXMSR [EW HIWMKRIH XS
IRGSYVEKI WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW XS WIPJVIKYPEXI XLI
HMWWIQMREXMSR SJ SJJIRWMZI QEXIVMEP SZIV XLIMV WIVZMGIW
MH EX -R XLMW VIWTIGX XLI WXEXYXI [EW E VIWTSRWI XS
GEWIW WYGL EW 7XVEXXSR 3EOQSRX -RG Z 4VSHMK] 7IVZW 'S 2= 1MWG 0)<-7 ;0 ?7YT 'X
2= 'SYRX] A ?A MR [LMGL ER MRXIVRIX WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIV [EW JSYRH PMEFPI JSV HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW
TSWXIH F] XLMVH TEVXMIW FIGEYWI MX LEH ZSPYRXEVMP] WGVIIRIH
ERH IHMXIH WSQI SJJIRWMZI GSRXIRX ERH WS [EW GSRWMHIVIH
E TYFPMWLIV WII 7XVEXXSR 3EOQSRX -RG 2=
1MWG 0)<-7 ;0 EX ,6 6IT
XL 'SRK H 7IWW EX 7IGXMSR G
[EW QIERX XS YRHS XLI TIVZIVWI MRGIRXMZIW GVIEXIH F]
XLMW VIEWSRMRK [LMGL IJJIGXMZIP] TIREPM^IH TVSZMHIVW JSV
QSRMXSVMRK GSRXIRX WII >IVER *H EX 8LYW
WIGXMSR LEW X[S TEVEPPIP KSEPW 8LI WXEXYXI MW
HIWMKRIH EX SRGI XS TVSQSXI XLI JVII I\GLERKI SJ
MRJSVQEXMSR ERH MHIEW SZIV XLI -RXIVRIX ERH XS IRGSYVEKI
ZSPYRXEV] QSRMXSVMRK JSV SJJIRWMZI SV SFWGIRI QEXIVMEP
&EVRIW *H EX UYSXMRK 'EVEJERS Z
1IXVSWTPEWLGSQ -RG *H ?XL 'MV
A
&SXL WXEXI ERH JIHIVEP GSYVXW EVSYRH XLI GSYRXV] LEZI
KIRIVEPP] MRXIVTVIXIH 7IGXMSR MQQYRMX] FVSEHP] WS
EW XS IJJIGXYEXI 'SRKVIWWW TSPMG] GLSMGI RSX XS HIXIV
?A LEVQJYP SRPMRI WTIIGL XLVSYKL XLI VSYXI SJ
MQTSWMRK XSVX PMEFMPMX] SR GSQTERMIW XLEX WIVZI EW
MRXIVQIHMEVMIW JSV SXLIV TEVXMIW TSXIRXMEPP] MRNYVMSYWQIWWEKIW 9RMZIVWEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW 7]W *H EX
?A UYSXMRK >IVER *H EX WII EPWS
.SLRWSR Z %VHIR *H ?XL 'MV A ?8LI
QENSVMX] SJ JIHIVEP GMVGYMXW LEZI MRXIVTVIXIH XLI '(% XS
IWXEFPMWL FVSEH JIHIVEP MQQYRMX] XS ER] GEYWI SJ EGXMSR
XLEX [SYPH QEOI WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW PMEFPI JSV MRJSVQEXMSR
SVMKMREXMRK [MXL E XLMVHTEVX] YWIV SJ XLI WIVZMGIA
?MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSR QEVOW SQMXXIHA (SI Z 1]7TEGI -RG
*H ?XL 'MV A ?'SYVXW LEZI GSRWXVYIH
XLI MQQYRMX] TVSZMWMSRW MR � FVSEHP] MR EPP GEWIW
EVMWMRK JVSQ XLI TYFPMGEXMSR SJ YWIVKIRIVEXIH GSRXIRXA
&EVVIXX Z 6SWIRXLEP 'EP XL 'EP 6TXV H 4H ?A ?RSXMRK XLEX E FVSEH VIEHMRK
SJ WIGXMSR G MQQYRMX] LEW FIIR EGGITXIH MR
FSXL JIHIVEP ERH WXEXI GSYVXWA (SI Z %Q 3RPMRI -RG
*PE 0 ;IIOP] 7 7SH ?A
?EHSTXMRK XLI VIEWSRMRK MR >IVERA 2I[ =SVO XVMEP GSYVXW
LEZI EPWS XEOIR XLMW ZMI[ WII 6IMX Z =IPT -RG 1MWG
H 2=7H ?7YT 'X 2= 'SYRX]
A /YIVWXIMRIV Z 7GLVEHIV 7YT 'X 2= 'SYRX]
3GXSFIV 7LEJIV . MRHI\ 2S
2= 1MWG 0)<-7
;I LEZI RSX ]IX LEH SGGEWMSR XS EHHVIWW XLI WGSTI SJ
WIGXMSR W TVSXIGXMSRW -R 0YRRI] Z 4VSHMK] 7IVZW 'S
2=H 2)H 2=7H
?A [I XSSO RSXI SJ XLI ?A *SYVXL 'MVGYMXW
STMRMSR MR >IVER ERH MXW VSFYWX YRHIVWXERHMRK SJ '(%
MQQYRMX] EW IRGSQTEWWMRK FSXL TYFPMWLIV ERH HMWXVMFYXSV
PMEFMPMX] FYX [I PIJX XLI HIGMWMSR [LIXLIV XS EHSTX XLEX
MRXIVTVIXEXMSR JSV ERSXLIV HE] MH EX 8SHE] [I
JSPPS[ [LEX QE] JEMVP] FI GEPPIH XLI REXMSREP GSRWIRWYW
4EKI 2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
-23-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 81/97
WII &EVVIXX 'EP XL EX 4H EX R ?GMXMRK
GEWIWA ERH VIEH WIGXMSR EW KIRIVEPP] MQQYRM^MRK
MRXIVRIX WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW JVSQ PMEFMPMX] JSV XLMVHTEVX]
GSRXIRX [LIVIZIV WYGL PMEFMPMX] HITIRHW SR GLEVEGXIVM^MRK
XLI TVSZMHIV EW E TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ SFNIGXMSREFPI
QEXIVMEP
'SRWMWXIRX [MXL XLMW ZMI[ [I VIEH WIGXMSR XS FEV
PE[WYMXW WIIOMRK XS LSPH E WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV PMEFPI JSV MXW
I\IVGMWI SJ E TYFPMWLIVW XVEHMXMSREP IHMXSVMEP JYRGXMSRW
WYGL EW HIGMHMRK [LIXLIV XS TYFPMWL [MXLHVE[ TSWXTSRI
SV EPXIV GSRXIRX >IVER *H EX WII EPWS &EVRIW
*H EX ?TYFPMGEXMSR MRZSPZIW VIZMI[MRK
IHMXMRK ERH HIGMHMRK [LIXLIV XS TYFPMWL SV XS [MXLHVE[
JVSQ TYFPMGEXMSR XLMVHTEVX] GSRXIRXA 2SXEFP] XLI
WXEXYXI HSIW RSX HMJJIVIRXMEXI FIX[IIR RIYXVEP ERH
WIPIGXMZI TYFPMWLIVW WII IK &EX^IP Z 7QMXL *H
?XL 'MV A ?XLI I\GPYWMSR SJ TYFPMWLIV?A PMEFMPMX] RIGIWWEVMP] TVIGPYHIW PMEFMPMX] JSV
I\IVGMWMRK XLI YWYEP TVIVSKEXMZI SJ TYFPMWLIVW XS GLSSWI
EQSRK TVSJJIVIH QEXIVMEP ERH XS IHMX XLI QEXIVMEP
TYFPMWLIH [LMPI VIXEMRMRK MXW FEWMG JSVQ ERH QIWWEKIA
&PYQIRXLEP Z (VYHKI * 7YTT ?((' A
?'SRKVIWW LEW QEHI E TSPMG] GLSMGI F] TVSZMHMRK
MQQYRMX] IZIR [LIVI XLI MRXIVEGXMZI WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV LEW
ER EGXMZI IZIR EKKVIWWMZI VSPI MR QEOMRK EZEMPEFPI
GSRXIRX TVITEVIH F] SXLIVWA
7IVZMGI TVSZMHIVW EVI SRP] IRXMXPIH XS XLMW FVSEH
MQQYRMX] LS[IZIV [LIVI XLI GSRXIRX EX MWWYI MW
TVSZMHIH F] ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV
97' � ?GA ?A -X JSPPS[W XLEX MJ E HIJIRHERX WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIV MW MXWIPJ XLI GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV MX MW RSX WLMIPHIH
JVSQ ?A PMEFMPMX] WII IK 2IQIX 'LIZVSPIX 0XH Z
'SRWYQIVEJJEMVWGSQ -RG *H ?XL 'MV
A *EMV ,SYWMRK 'SYRGMP SJ 7ER *IVRERHS :EPPI] Z
6SSQQEXIWGSQ 00' *H ?XL 'MV
A 9RMZIVWEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW 7]W -RG *H EX
7MRGI E GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV MW ER] TEVX] VIWTSRWMFPI
MR TEVX JSV XLI GVIEXMSR SV HIZIPSTQIRX SJ MRJSVQEXMSR
97' � ?JA ?A ER] TMIGI SJ GSRXIRX GER LEZI
QYPXMTPI TVSZMHIVW
-X QE] FI HMJJMGYPX ?A MR GIVXEMR GEWIW XS
HIXIVQMRI [LIXLIV E WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV MW EPWS E GSRXIRX
TVSZMHIV TEVXMGYPEVP] WMRGI XLI HIJMRMXMSR SJ GSRXIRX
TVSZMHIV MW WS IPEWXMG ERH RS GSRWIRWYW LEW IQIVKIH
GSRGIVRMRK [LEX GSRHYGX GSRWXMXYXIW HIZIPSTQIRX
?8ALI FVSEHIWX WIRWI SJ XLI XIVQ
HIZIPST GSYPH MRGPYHI XLI JYRGXMSRW SJ ER
SVHMREV] WIEVGL IRKMRI MRHIIH NYWX
EFSYX ER] JYRGXMSR TIVJSVQIH F] E
[IFWMXI &YX XS VIEH XLI XIVQ WS FVSEHP]
[SYPH HIJIEX XLI TYVTSWIW SJ WIGXMSR
F] W[EPPS[MRK YT IZIV] FMX SJ XLI
MQQYRMX] XLEX XLI WIGXMSR SXLIV[MWI
TVSZMHIW %X XLI WEQI XMQI VIEHMRK XLI
I\GITXMSR JSV GSHIZIPSTIVW EW ETTP]MRK
SRP] XS GSRXIRX XLEX SVMKMREXIW IRXMVIP]
[MXL XLI [IFWMXI MKRSVIW XLI [SVHW
HIZIPSTQIRX MR TEVX MR XLI WXEXYXSV]
TEWWEKI 6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX
8LI 2MRXLW 'MVGYMXW ETTVSEGL [LMGL 7LMEQMPM EWOW YW XS
EHSTX MW XS MRXIVTVIX XLI XIVQ HIZIPSTQIRX EW VIJIVVMRK
RSX QIVIP] XS EYKQIRXMRK XLI GSRXIRX KIRIVEPP] FYX XSQEXIVMEPP] GSRXVMFYXMRK XS MXW EPPIKIH YRPE[JYPRIWW MH EX
8LMW ZMI[ [LMGL LEW FIIR GMXIH [MXL
ETTVSZEP F] XLI 8IRXL 'MVGYMX WII %GGYWIEVGL *H
EX GSRWMHIVW E [IFWMXI E GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV MJ MX
GSRXVMFYXIW QEXIVMEPP] ?A XS XLI EPPIKIH MPPIKEPMX] SJ
XLI GSRHYGX 6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX
-R XLI GEWI FIJSVI YW [I RIIH RSX HIGMHI [LIXLIV XS
ETTP] XLI 2MRXL 'MVGYMXW VIPEXMZIP] FVSEH ZMI[ SJ
HIZIPSTQIRX WMRGI IZIR YRHIV XLEX GSYVXW EREP]WMW
7LMEQMPMW GPEMQ JEMPW %PXLSYKL XLI WXEXIQIRXW EX MWWYI
EVI YRUYIWXMSREFP] SJJIRWMZI ERH SFRS\MSYW HIJIRHERXWEVI RSRIXLIPIWW WLMIPHIH JVSQ PMEFMPMX] F] WIGXMSR
7LMEQMPM HSIW RSX HMWTYXI XLEX HIJIRHERXW EW EPPIKIH
[IFWMXI STIVEXSVW EVI TVSZMHIVW SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI YRHIV 7IGXMSR WII
6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX R ?XLI QSWX
GSQQSR MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIW EVI [IFWMXIWA
9RMZIVWEP 'SQQYRMGEXMSR 7]W *H EX ?[IF
WMXI STIVEXSVW EVI TVSZMHIVW SJ MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV
WIVZMGIW [MXLMR XLI QIERMRK SJ WIGXMSR A *YVXLIV
XLI GPEMQW LIVI HIJEQEXMSR ERH YRJEMV GSQTIXMXMSR F]
HMWTEVEKIQIRX GPIEVP] WIIO XS LSPH XLI HIJIRHERXW
PMEFPI EW TYFPMWLIVW ERH WTIEOIVW 8LI VIQEMRMRK UYIWXMSR
MW [LIXLIV XEOMRK XLI JEGXW EPPIKIH MR XLI GSQTPEMRX EW
XVYI XLI HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW [IVI TVSZMHIH F]
ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV 97' � ?GA
?A
%W ER MRMXMEP QEXXIV XLI GSQTPEMRX EPPIKIW XLEX XLI
?A HIJEQEXSV] WXEXIQIRXW [IVI ?A JMVWX TSWXIH F]
ERSR]QSYW YWIVW XLIVI MW RS EPPIKEXMSR XLEX HIJIRHERXW
4EKI 2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
-24-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 82/97
EGXYEPP] EYXLSVIH XLI WXEXIQIRXW % [IFWMXI MW KIRIVEPP]
RSX E GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV [MXL VIWTIGX XS GSQQIRXW TSWXIH
F] XLMVHTEVX] YWIVW WII (M1IS Z 1E\ *IH %TT\
?H 'MV A ;I VINIGX 7LMEQMPMW GSRXIRXMSR
XLEX HIJIRHERXW WLSYPH FI HIIQIH GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVW
FIGEYWI XLI] GVIEXIH ERH VER E [IFWMXI [LMGL MQTPMGMXP]
IRGSYVEKIH YWIVW XS TSWX RIKEXMZI GSQQIRXW EFSYX XLI
2I[ =SVO 'MX] VIEP IWXEXI MRHYWXV] 'VIEXMRK ER STIR
JSVYQ JSV XLMVHTEVXMIW XS TSWX GSRXIRX MRGPYHMRK
RIKEXMZI GSQQIRXEV] MW EX XLI GSVI SJ [LEX WIGXMSR
TVSXIGXW WII %GGYWIEVGL -RG *H EX ?RSXMRK
XLEX SRPMRI QIWWEKI FSEVHW EVI XLI TVSXSX]TMGEP WIVZMGI
UYEPMJ]MRK JSV WIGXMSR MQQYRMX]A
1SVISZIV XLIVI MW RS EPPIKEXMSR XLEX XLI HIJEQEXSV]
GSQQIRXW [IVI TSWXIH MR VIWTSRWI XS ER] WTIGMJMG
MRZMXEXMSR JSV YWIVW XS FEWL 7LMEQMPM SV %VHSV GJ
(SGXSVW %WWSG -RG Z 5-4 ,SPHIV 00' 97 (MWX 0)<-7 ;0 ?( 'SRR A
)ZMHIRGI WYFQMXXIH F] 7LMEQMPM MR STTSWMXMSR XS
HIJIRHERXW QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW MRHMGEXIW XLEX XLI [IFWMXI
LEH FIIR STIVEXMRK JSV SZIV E ]IEV FIJSVI ER] SJ XLI
GSQQIRXW XLEX EVI ?A XLI WYFNIGX SJ XLMW PE[WYMX [IVI
TSWXIH ERH XLEX XLI TSWXIH GSQQIRXEV] WTERRIH E VERKI
SJ XSTMGW )ZIR EWWYQMRK XLEX WSPMGMXEXMSR GER GSRWXMXYXI
HIZIPSTQIRX XLMW MW TPEMRP] RSX E GEWI [LIVI XLI
[IFWMXI GER FI GLEVKIH [MXL WSPMGMXMRK XLI HIJEQEXSV]
GSRXIRX EX MWWYI 2SV GER MX FI WEMH XLEX 1G'ERRW EXXIQTX
EX TVSZSOMRK JYVXLIV GSQQIRXEV] MR XLI 7LMEQMPM
HMWGYWWMSR XLVIEH MW EGXMSREFPI WMRGI RSRI JSPPS[IH
8LI HIJIRHERXW HMH RSX FIGSQI GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVW
F] ZMVXYI SJ QSZMRK SRI SJ XLI GSQQIRXW XS MXW S[R TSWX
6ITSWXMRK GSRXIRX GVIEXIH ERH MRMXMEPP] TSWXIH F] E XLMVH
TEVX] MW [IPP[MXLMR E TYFPMWLIVW XVEHMXMSREP IHMXSVMEP
JYRGXMSRW >IVER *H EX -RHIIH XLMW GEWI MW
EREPSKSYW XS SXLIVW MR [LMGL WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW LEZI FIIR
TVSXIGXIH F] WIGXMSR EJXIV VITSWXMRK SV SXLIV[MWI
HMWWIQMREXMRK JEPWI MRJSVQEXMSR WYTTPMIH F] E XLMVH TEVX]
8S GMXI SRP] E JI[ I\EQTPIW MR &IR )^VE ;IMRWXIMR ERH
'S -RG Z %Q 3RPMRI -RG *H ?XL 'MV
A XLI HIJIRHERX WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV [SYPH TYFPMWL
YTHEXIH WIGYVMXMIW MRJSVQEXMSR WYTTPMIH F] XLMVH TEVXMIW
ERH HIVMZIH JVSQ E ZEVMIX] SJ WXSGO I\GLERKIW ERH
QEVOIXW 4PEMRXMJJ WYIH XLI TVSZMHIV JSV TYFPMWLMRK
MREGGYVEXI MRJSVQEXMSR ?A GSRGIVRMRK XLI TVMGI ERH
WLEVI ZSPYQI SJ TPEMRXMJJW WXSGO 8LI 8IRXL 'MVGYMX JSYRH
XLEX XLI MREGGYVEXI MRJSVQEXMSR [EW GVIEXIH F] XLMVH
TEVXMIW ERH XLI [IF TVSZMHIV [EW RSX VIWTSRWMFPI MR
[LSPI SV MR TEVX JSV ?MXWA GVIEXMSR ERH HIZIPSTQIRX MH
EX 8LI 2MRXL 'MVGYMX VIEGLIH XLI WEQI VIWYPX MR
&EX^IP *H EX GMXIH [MXL ETTVSZEP MR
6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX 8LIVI XLI IHMXSV SJ
ER IQEMP RI[WPIXXIV VIGIMZIH E XMT ERH MRGSVTSVEXIH MX MRXS
XLI RI[WPIXXIV EHHMRK E LIEHRSXI 8LI XMT TVSZIH JEPWI
FYX XLI 2MRXL 'MVGYMX JSYRH XLEX WIGXMSR TVSXIGXIH XLI
IHMXSV JVSQ FIMRK WYIH JSV PMFIP FIGEYWI LI LEH FIIR
QIVIP] IHMXMRK TSVXMSRW SJ ER IQEMP ERH WIPIGXMRK
QEXIVMEP JSV TYFPMGEXMSR &EX̂ IP *H EX
7MQMPEVP] MR (M1IS *IH %TT\ EX E GEWI UYMXI
PMOI XLMW SRI XLI TPEMRXMJJ WYIH JSV HIJEQEXMSR FEWIH SR
GSQQIRXW PIJX F] ERSR]QSYW YWIVW SR HIJIRHERXW
[IFWMXI [LIVI HIJIRHERX GSYPH WIPIGX [LMGL TSWXW XS
TYFPMWL ERH IHMX?IHA ?A XLIMV GSRXIRX (M1IS Z 1E\
* 7YTT H ?)( 4E A 8LI 8LMVH
'MVGYMX JSYRH XLEX XLI [IFWMXI TSWXW GSRWXMXYXI
MRJSVQEXMSR JYVRMWLIH F] XLMVH TEVX] MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX
TVSZMHIVW *IH %TT\ EX
7LMEQMPM ?A EVKYIW XLEX XLMW GEWI JMXW [MXLMR E
PMRI SJ JIHIVEP HIGMWMSRW MR [LMGL GSYVXW LEZI JSYRH XLEX
IZIR MJ XLI HEXE EVI WYTTPMIH F] XLMVH TEVXMIW E [IFWMXI
STIVEXSV QE] WXMPP GSRXVMFYXI XS XLI GSRXIRXW MPPIKEPMX] ERH
XLYW FI PMEFPI EW E HIZIPSTIV SJ XLI GSRXIRX
6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX WII EPWS %GGYWIEVGL
-RG *H EX 8LSWI GEWIW LS[IZIV EVI IEWMP]
HMWXMRKYMWLEFPI -R 6SSQQEXIWGSQ XLI RSRTEVXMIW
TVSZMHMRK XLI HEXE [IVI VIUYMVIH XS TSWX EGXMSREFPI
QEXIVMEP XS XLI HIJIRHERX [IFWMXI EW E GSRHMXMSR SJ YWI
ERH XLI [IFWMXIW [SVO MR HIZIPSTMRK XLI HMWGVMQMREXSV]UYIWXMSRW HMWGVMQMREXSV] ERW[IVW ERH HMWGVMQMREXSV]
WIEVGL QIGLERMWQ ?[EWA HMVIGXP] VIPEXIH XS XLI EPPIKIH
MPPIKEPMX] SJ XLI WMXI 6SSQQEXIWGSQ *H EX
,IVI MR GSRXVEWX XLIVI EVI RS EPPIKEXMSRW XLEX TSWXMRK
JEPWI ERH HIJEQEXSV] GSRXIRX [EW E GSRHMXMSR SJ YWI SV
XLEX XLI WMXI [SVOIH [MXL YWIVW XS HIZIPST XLI TSWXIH
GSQQIRXEV] 8LMW GEWI EPWS HMJJIVW GSRWMHIVEFP] JVSQ
%GGYWIEVGL -RG [LIVI XLI HIJIRHERX [IFWMXI TEMH
VIWIEVGLIVW XS SFXEMR MRJSVQEXMSR JSV XLI WMXI XS
HMWWIQMREXI XLEX [SYPH EPQSWX MRIZMXEFP] VIUYMVI ?XLI
VIWIEVGLIVA XS ZMSPEXI XLI 8IPIGSQQYRMGEXMSRW %GX SV XS
GMVGYQZIRX MX F] ?A JVEYH SV XLIJX %GGYWIEVGL -RG
*H EX 8LIVI MW RS GSQTEVEFPI
EPPIKEXMSR EKEMRWX XLIWI HIJIRHERXW
(IJIRHERXW ETTIEV XS LEZI FIIR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIVW
[MXL VIWTIGX XS XLI LIEHMRK WYFLIEHMRK ERH MPPYWXVEXMSR
XLEX EGGSQTERMIH XLI VITSWXMRK 8LEX GSRXIRX LS[IZIV MW
RSX HIJEQEXSV] EW E QEXXIV SJ PE[ 8LI GSQTPEMRX HSIW
RSX EPPIKI XLEX XLI LIEHMRK SV WYFLIEHMRK EVI EGXMSREFPI
4EKI 2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
-25-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 83/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 84/97
.I[MWL VIEP IWXEXI EKIRXW &YX E VIEWSREFPI VIEHIV
ZMI[MRK XLI LIEHMRK ERH MPPYWXVEXMSR QMKLX ZIV] [IPP
LEZI GSRGPYHIH XLEX XLI WMXI IHMXSV [EW IRHSVWMRK XLI
XVYXL SJ XLI ETTIRHIH JEGXW [LMGL EWWIVXIH XLEX TPEMRXMJJ
[EW ER ERXM7IQMXI [LS IQTPS]IH E WMRKPI .I[MWL VIEPXSV
MR SVHIV XS QEMRXEMR FYWMRIWW [MXL .I[MWL PERHPSVHW )ZIR
WIXXMRK EWMHI XLI TVIJEGI VIJIVVMRK XS XLI [IIOP] HSWI SJ
LEXI ERH XLI EPPIKEXMSRW SJ HIJIRHERXW IJJSVXW XS MRWXMKEXI
EHHMXMSREP EXXEGOW EKEMRWX TPEMRXMJJW GLEVEGXIV ERH
FYWMRIWW HIJIRHERXW EXXEGLQIRX SJ XLMW MPPYWXVEXMSR MJ
TVSZIR WLSYPH EPSRI HIJIEX XLIMV MQQYRMX] YRHIV XLI
'(% %W XLI QENSVMX] GSRGIHIW MX MW [IPP IWXEFPMWLIH MR
JIHIVEP PE[ XLEX E [IFWMXI LIPTW XS HIZIPST YRPE[JYP
GSRXIRX ERH XLYW JEPPW [MXLMR XLI I\GITXMSR XS WIGXMSR
MJ MX GSRXVMFYXIW QEXIVMEPP] XS XLI EPPIKIH MPPIKEPMX] SJ
XLI GSRHYGX *EMV ,SYW 'SYRGMP Z 6SSQQEXIWGSQ
00' *H ?XL 'MV A WII EPWS
*IHIVEP 8VEHI 'SQQR Z %GGYWIEVGL -RG *H ?XL 'MV A ?% WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV MW
VIWTSRWMFPI JSV XLI HIZIPSTQIRX SJ SJJIRWMZI GSRXIRX
SRP] MJ MX MR WSQI [E] WTIGMJMGEPP] IRGSYVEKIW
HIZIPSTQIRX ?A SJ [LEX MW SJJIRWMZI EFSYX XLI
GSRXIRXA
0MOI XLI QENSVMX] - EGGITX XLI REXMSREP GSRWIRWYW
SR WXEXYXSV] MQQYRMX] YRHIV XLI '(% ,S[IZIV - WII RS
FEWMW MR XLI VIGSVH JSV XLI QENSVMX]W GSRJMHIRX GSRGPYWMSR
XLEX HIJIRHERXW WIVZIH SRP] EW E TEWWMZI GSRHYMX SJ XLMW
HIJEQEXSV] QEXIVMEP ERH EVI XLIVIJSVI MQQYRI EW E
QEXXIV SJ PE[ %W XLI QENSVMX] RSXIW WIGXMSR SJ XLI'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX WYFXMXPIH 4VSXIGXMSR JSV
TVMZEXI FPSGOMRK ERH WGVIIRMRK SJ SJJIRWMZI QEXIVMEP
[EW TVSQTXIH F] XLI YRHIWMVEFPI VIWYPX MR 7XVEXXSR
3EOQSRX -RG Z 4VSHMK] 7IVZW 'S 2= 1MWG
0)<-7 ;0 ?7YT 'X 2EWWEY 'SYRX] 2=
A [LIVI XLI XVMEP GSYVX LIPH E WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV PMEFPI
MR E HIJEQEXMSR EGXMSR FEWIH SR MXW ZSPYRXEV] IJJSVXW XS
JMPXIV ERH IHMX SJJIRWMZI QIWWEKIW TSWXIH SR MXW FYPPIXMR
FSEVHW 8LMW IHMXSVMEP EGXMZMX] XLI GSYVX VIEWSRIH
VIRHIVIH XLI TVSZMHIV E TYFPMWLIV ERH XLYW VIWTSRWMFPI JSV
PMFIPSYW GSRXIRX TSWXIH SR MXW [IFWMXI WII 2=
1MWG 0)<-7 ?;0A EX
'SRGIVRIH XLEX GEWIW PMOI 7XVEXXSR 3EOQSRX -RG
[SYPH HMWGSYVEKI TVSZMHIVW JVSQ GIRWSVMRK SJJIRWMZI
GSRXIRX SR XLIMV S[R WMXIW 'SRKVIWW IREGXIH WIGXMSR
MR TEVX XS MRWYPEXI TVSZMHIVW JVSQ PMEFMPMX] JSV ER] EGXMSRZSPYRXEVMP] XEOIR MR KSSH ?A JEMXL XS VIWXVMGX EGGIWW XS
SV EZEMPEFMPMX] SJ QEXIVMEP XLEX XLI TVSZMHIV SV YWIV
GSRWMHIVW XS FI SFWGIRI PI[H PEWGMZMSYW JMPXL]
I\GIWWMZIP] ZMSPIRX LEVEWWMRK SV SXLIV[MWI
SFNIGXMSREFPI [LIXLIV SV RSX WYGL QEXIVMEP MW
GSRWXMXYXMSREPP] TVSXIGXIH 97' � ?GA ?A ?%A
&SXL ,SYWIW SJ 'SRKVIWW WXVIWWIH XLEX ?SARI SJ XLI
WTIGMJMG TYVTSWIW SJ XLMW WIGXMSR MW XS SZIVVYPI 7XVEXXSR
3EOQSRX Z 4VSHMK] ERH ER] SXLIV WMQMPEV HIGMWMSRW
[LMGL LEZI XVIEXIH WYGL TVSZMHIVW ERH YWIVW EW TYFPMWLIVW
SV WTIEOIVW SJ GSRXIRX XLEX MW RSX XLIMV S[R FIGEYWI XLI]
LEZI VIWXVMGXIH EGGIWW XS SFNIGXMSREFPI QEXIVMEP ,6 6IT XL 'SRK H 7IWW EX 7 6IT
XL 'SRK H 7IWW EX ?GSRXEMRMRK WEQI UYSXIA
;LMPI - HS RSX HMWTYXI XLI EHSTXMSR SJ E FVSEH
ETTVSEGL XS MQQYRMX] JSV SRPMRI ?A WIVZMGI
TVSZMHIVW YRHIV XLI '(% ER MRXIVTVIXEXMSR XLEX
MQQYRM^IW E FYWMRIWWW GSQTPMGMX] MR HIJEQMRK E HMVIGX
GSQTIXMXSV XEOIW YW WS JEV EJMIPH JVSQ XLI TYVTSWI SJ XLI
'(% EW XS QEOI MX YRVIGSKRM^EFPI (MWQMWWMRK XLMW EGXMSR
SR XLI TPIEHMRKW MW RSX VIUYMVIH F] XLI PIXXIV SJ XLI PE[
ERH HSIW RSX LSRSV MXW WTMVMX
3VHIV EJJMVQIH [MXL GSWXW 3TMRMSR F] .YHKI
'MTEVMGO
.YHKIW +VEJJIS 6IEH ERH ?A 7QMXL GSRGYV
'LMIJ .YHKI 0MTTQER HMWWIRXW ERH ZSXIW XS VIZIVWI MR ER
STMRMSR MR [LMGL .YHKIW 4MKSXX ERH .SRIW GSRGYV
(IGMHIH .YRI
4EKI 2= 7PMT 3T 2= 0)<-7
-27-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 85/97
7YTIVMSV 'SYVX 7ER *VERGMWGS 'SYRX] 'EPMJSVRME
6ERHEPP 7832)6 4PEMRXMJJ
Z
)&%= -2' E (IPE[EVI 'SVTSVEXMSR IX EP (I
JIRHERXW
2S
2SZ
36()6 +6%28-2+ ()*)2(%287 138-32
*36 7911%6= .9(+1)28
4300%/ .
(IJIRHERXW 1SXMSR JSV 7YQQEV] .YHKQIRXGEQI SR VIKYPEVP] JSV LIEVMRK SR 3GXSFIV
8LI UYIWXMSR XS FI HIGMHIH MW [LIXLIV I&E] IRNS]W
MQQYRMX] YRHIV XLI 'SQQYRMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX
w'(%x 97' � JSV XLI GSRHYGX YRHIVP]
MRK TPEMRXMJJW GPEMQW ,EZMRK VIZMI[IH XLI IZMH
IRGI PE[ ERH EVKYQIRX XLI 'SYVX GSRGPYHIW XLEX
I&E] MW MQQYRI JVSQ ER] PMEFMPMX] EVMWMRK JVSQ
TPEMRXMJJW GPEMQW ERH XLIVIJSVI KVERXW HIJIRHERXW
QSXMSR
I&E] MW ER SRPMRI EYGXMSR GSQTER] 4PEMRXMJJ
GPEMQW XLEX I&E] wLEW HIZIPSTIH E QIXLSH SJ STIVE
XMSR XLEX EPPS[W MX XS ORS[MRKP] VIET QEWWMZI TVSJMXW
JVSQ XLI WEPI SJ FSSXPIK ERH SXLIV YREYXLSVM^IH
uMRJVMRKMRKv WSYRH VIGSVHMRKW MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ &YWM
RIWW ERH 4VSJIWWMSRW 'SHI � x 4PEMRXMJJW
1IQSVERHYQ SJ 4SMRXW ERH %YXLSVMXMIW w4PEMRXMJJW
4 %x T 7TIGMJMGEPP] TPEMRXMJJ GPEMQW XLEX
I&E] ZMSPEXIW WIGXMSR MR XLEX w I&E] EGXY
EPP] WIPPW SV EX QMRMQYQ EHZIVXMWIW ERH SJJIVW JSV
WEPI ERH GEYWIW XLI WEPI SJ ZEVMSYW FSSXPIK ERH
SXLIV MRJVMRKMRK WSYRH VIGSVHMRKW MR HMVIGX ZMSPE
XMSR SJ WIZIVEP ETTPMGEFPI 4IREP 'SHI 4VSZMWMSRW 4IR'SHI �� L W [ I&E] MRHI
TIRHIRX SJ MXW YWIVW IRKEKIW MR YRJEMV FYWMRIWW
TVEGXMGIW MR XLEX ORS[MRK JYPP [IPP XLEX MRJVMRKMRK
WSYRH VIGSVHMRK EYGXMSRW EVI TVIZEPIRX SR MXW WMXI
I&E] EGXMZIP] TVSQSXIW ERH IREFPIW XLSWI EYGXMSRW
ERH XEOIW E GSQQMWWMSR SR IEGL WEPI IZIR XLSYKL
MX GSYPH IPMQMREXI WEMH MRJVMRKMRK EYGXMSR MJ MX
[ERXIH XS ERH I&E] MXWIPJ IRKEKIW MR GSRHYGX
PMOIP] XS HIGIMZI XLI TYFPMG MR XLEX MX ORS[W EFSYX
ERH EGXMZIP] JEGMPMXEXIW MRJVMRKMRK WSYRH VIGSVHMRK
EYGXMSRW IZIR XLSYKL EW MX EPWS ORS[W QER] SJ XLI
YPXMQEXI TYVGLEWIVW SJ XLI VIGSVHMRKW XVYP] HS RSX
VIEPM^I XLI] EVI FY]MRK MPPIKEP MXIQW [MXL RS VIWEPI
ZEPYI 4PEMRXMJJW 4 % T GMXMRK 7IGSRH
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX ��
(IJIRHERXW MQQYRMX] GPEMQ MW FEWIH SR
97' � G [LMGL WXEXIW XLEX w?RAS TVSZMHIV
SV YWIV SJ ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI WLEPP FI
XVIEXIH EW XLI TYFPMWLIV SV WTIEOIV SJ ER] MRJSVQEXMSR TVSZMHIH F] ERSXLIV MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVS
ZMHIVx ERH WIGXMSR I [LMGL TVSZMHIW MR TEVX
XLEX w?RAS GEYWI SJ EGXMSR QE] FI FVSYKLX ERH RS PM
EFMPMX] QE] FI MQTSWIH YRHIV ER] 7XEXI SV PSGEP PE[
XLEX MW MRGSRWMWXIRX [MXL XLMW WIGXMSRx 7IGXMSR
wGVIEXIW E JIHIVEP MQQYRMX] XS ER] WXEXI PE[ GEYWI
SJ EGXMSR XLEX [SYPH LSPH GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI TVS
ZMHIVW PMEFPI JSV MRJSVQEXMSR SVMKMREXMRK [MXL E XLMVH
TEVX] 7TIGMJMGEPP] � TVIGPYHIW GSYVXW JVSQ IR
XIVXEMRMRK GPEMQW XLEX [SYPH TPEGI E GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGI TVSZMHIV MR E TYFPMWLIVW VSPI 8LYW PE[WYMXW
WIIOMRK XS LSPH E WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV PMEFPI JSV MXW I\IVGMWI SJ E TYFPMWLIVW XVEHMXMSREP IHMXSVMEP JYRG
XMSRW WYGL EW HIGMHMRK [LIXLIV XS TYFPMWL [MXL
HVE[ TSWXTSRI SV EPXIV GSRXIRX EVI FEVVIHx
>IVER Z %QIVMGE 3RPMRI XL 'MV *H
-QQYRMX] YRHIV XLI '(% VIUYMVIW TVSSJ SJ
XLVII IPIQIRXW (IJIRHERX QYWX IWXEFPMWL XLEX
I&E] MW ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIW TVSZMHIV
XLEX I&E] MW RSX ER MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV
[MXL VIWTIGX XS XLI HMWTYXIH EGXMZMX] ERH XLEX
TPEMRXMJJ WIIOW XS LSPH I&E] PMEFPI JSV MRJSVQEXMSR
SVMKMREXMRK [MXL E XLMVHTEVX] YWIV SJ MXW WIVZMGI
-FMH *SV TYVTSWIW SJ XLMW QSXMSR MX MW YRHMWTYXIH
XLEX I&E] MW ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI TVS
ZMHIV EW HIJMRIH MR WIGXMSR J 4PEMRXMJJW
7ITEVEXI 7XEXIQIRX SJ 9RHMWTYXIH 1EXIVMEP *EGXW
w4PEMRXMJJW 1EXIVMEP *EGXWx � TK %HHM
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 'EP6TXVH ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV 9745H
'MXI EW ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-28-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 86/97
XMSREPP] I&E] LEW WEXMWJMIH MXW FYVHIR SJ IWXEFPMWL
MRK XLEX MX MW RSX ER MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV EW
HIJMRIH MR WIGXMSR J 8LI YRHMWTYXIH JEGXW
IWXEFPMWL XLEX XLI HIWGVMTXMSRW SJ XLI KSSHW ERH WIV
ZMGIW EYGXMSRIH SZIV XLI I&E] WIVZMGI EVI GVIEXIH
IRXMVIP] F] XLI WIPPIVW 4PEMRXMJJW 1EXIVMEP *EGXW �
TK I&E] MW RSX VIWTSRWMFPI JSV XLI GVIEXMSR SV
HIZIPSTQIRX SJ MRJSVQEXMSR VIPEXMRK XS ER] SJ XLI
TVSHYGXW JSV [LMGL MX TVSZMHIW EYGXMSR WIVZMGIW
;LMPI I&E] QE] EHH EHHMXMSREP MRJSVQEXMSR XS MXW
[IF TEKIW WYGL EW PSKSW GEXIKSV] LIEHMRKW ERH
WIPPIV VEXMRKW XLMW MRJSVQEXMSR MW RSX YRPMOI XLI MR
JSVQEXMSR EHHIH XS QER] [IF TEKIW XLI TYVTSWI SJ
[LMGL MW XS JEGMPMXEXI IEWI SJ YWI ERH EGGIWW XS XLI
GSRXIRX TVSZMHIH F] XLI XLMVHTEVX] I&E] XLIVI
JSVI MW RSX ER MRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV SV NSMRXMRJSVQEXMSR GSRXIRX TVSZMHIV [MXL VIWTIGX XS XLI HI
WGVMTXMSR SJ EYGXMSRIH KSSHW
8LI QSVI HMJJMGYPX UYIWXMSR MW [LIXLIV
TPEMRXMJJ MW WIIOMRK XS LSPH I&E] VIWTSRWMFPI JSV
GSRXIRX TVSZMHIH F] XLMVH TEVXMIW 4PEMRXMJJ HSIW RSX
GPEMQ XLEX XLIVI MW ER]XLMRK MQTVSTIV EFSYX XLI
QERRIV MR [LMGL I&E] GSRHYGXW MXW EYGXMSR FYWM
RIWW SXLIV XLER XLEX MX EYGXMSRW WSYRH VIGSVHMRKW
XLEX QE] RSX PE[JYPP] FI WSPH ,S[IZIV TPEMRXMJJ
GSRXIRHW XLEX I&E]W WIVZMGIW GSRWXMXYXI QSVI XLER
QIVI TYFPMGEXMSR SJ TVSHYGX HIWGVMTXMSRW TVITEVIH F] SXLIVW ERH EVI MRWXIEH MRHITIRHIRX EGXW SJ I&E]
MR JYVXLIVERGI SJ MPPIKEP WEPIW 8LIVIJSVI TPEMRXMJJ
GPEMQW XLMW WYMX HSIW RSX WIIO XS LSPH I&E] VI
WTSRWMFPI JSV XLI TYFPMGEXMSR SJ MRJSVQEXMSR
TVSZMHIH F] SXLIVW FYX JSV I&E]W S[R TEVXMGMTEXMSR
MR WIPPMRK GSRXVEFERH QYWMGEP VIGSVHMRKW
(IWTMXI TPEMRXMJJW EXXIQTX XS GLEVEGXIVM^I I&E]
EW ER EGXMZI TEVXMGMTERX MR XLI WEPI SJ TVSHYGXW EYG
XMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGI TPEMRXMJJ MW WIIOMRK XS LSPH
I&E] VIWTSRWMFPI JSV MRJSVQMRK TVSWTIGXMZI TYV
GLEWIVW XLEX MPPIKEP VIGSVHMRKW QE] FI TYVGLEWIH
MRJSVQEXMSR XLEX SVMKMREXIW [MXL XLI XLMVH TEVX]
WIPPIVW [LS YWI XLI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI 8LI YRGSR
XVSZIVXIH JEGXW IWXEFPMWL XLEX I&E]W VSPI HSIW RSX
I\XIRH FI]SRH XLI WGSTI SJ XLI JIHIVEP MQQYRMX]
I&E] TVSZMHIW ER MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI F]
[LMGL WIPPIVW SJ KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW HIWGVMFI SZIV
XLI -RXIVRIX XLI TVSHYGXW XLI] [MWL XS WIPP ERH WIPP
XLIQ XS XLI TIVWSR [LS EKVIIW F] WYFQMXXMRK E FMH
XLVSYKL I&E]W [IF WMXI MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL XLI
VYPIW SJ XLI WIVZMGI XS TE] XLI LMKLIWX TVMGI JSV XLI
TVSHYGX I&E] TVSZMHIW MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGIW JSV [LMGL MX GLEVKIW E JII NYWX EW %QIVMGE
3RPMRI TVSZMHIW MRXIVEGXMZI WIVZMGIW JSV [LMGL MX
GLEVKIW E JII I&E] HSIW RSX WIPIGX MXIQW XS FI EYG
XMSRIH HSIW RSX MRWTIGX SV GSQI MRXS TSWWIWWMSR SJ
XLSWI MXIQW EX ER] XMQI HSIW RSX HIWGVMFI XLI MXIQW
XS TVSWTIGXMZI FMHHIVW ERH HSIW RSX HIXIVQMRI XLI
QMRMQYQ TVMGI [LMGL XLI WIPPIV [MPP EGGITX JSV XLI
MXIQ I&E] HSIW EHZIVXMWI ERH TVSQSXI MXW EYGXMSR
WIVZMGI ERH GLEVKIW E JII JSV XLI YWI SJ MXW WIVZMGI
,S[IZIV RIMXLIV EKKVIWWMZI EHZIVXMWMRK RSV XLI MQ TSWMXMSR SJ E JIIMRGPYHMRK E JII FEWIH MR TEVX SR XLI
TVMGI EX [LMGL ER MXIQ MW WSPHXVERWJSVQW ER MRXIV
EGXMZI WIVZMGI TVSZMHIV MRXS E WIPPIV VIWTSRWMFPI JSV
MXIQW WSPH 'J &PYQIRXLEP Z (VYHKI
((' *7YTT %QIVMGE 3R
PMRI MQQYRI JVSQ PMEFMPMX] JSV PMFIPSYW WXEXIQIRXW
GSRXEMRIH MR XLI (VYHKI 6ITSVX IZIR XLSYKL %QIV
MGE 3RPMRI TEMH (VYHKI XS MRGPYHI XLI 6ITSVX SR MXW
WIVZMGI ERH EGXMZIP] EHZIVXMWIH XLI 6ITSVX F]
EQSRK SXLIV XLMRKW MWWYMRK E TVIWW VIPIEWI [LMGL
QEHI wGPIEV XLI OMRH SJ QEXIVMEP (VYHKI [SYPH
TVSZMHI XS %30 WYFWGVMFIVWKSWWMT ERH VYQSVERH
YVKIH TSXIRXMEP WYFWGVMFIVW XS WMKR SRXS %30 MR SV
HIV XS KIX XLI FIRIJMX SJ XLI (VYHKI 6ITSVXx
4PEMRXMJJ TSMRXW XS WIZIVEP SXLIV JIEXYVIW SJ
I&E]W WIVZMGI [LMGL LI GSRXIRHW XVERWJSVQ HIJIRH
ERX JVSQ E QIVI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGIW TVSZMHIV XS ER
EGXMZI TEVXMGMTERX MR XLI WEPI SJ XLI EYGXMSRIH KSSHW
ERH WIVZMGIW I&E] TVSZMHIW MRWYVERGI JSV EPP EYG
XMSRIH MXIQW YT XS PIWW E HIHYGXMFPI
4IVOMRW HIGPEVEXMSR )\ - 'SZIVEKI MW EZEMPEFPI
[LIVI E FY]IV TE]W JSV ER MXIQ FYX HSIW RSX VIGIMZI
MX SV [LIVI XLI FY]IV VIGIMZIW wER MXIQ XLEX MW PIWW
XLER [LEX MW HIWGVMFIHx -FMH 4VSZMHMRK MRWYVERGI
LS[IZIV MW RSX WIPPMRK SV SJJIVMRK XS WIPP XLI MR
WYVIH QIVGLERHMWI 4VSZMHMRK PMQMXIH MRWYVERGI JSV
EPP MXIQW EYGXMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGI QE] IRGSYVEKI
FY]IVW XS YWI XLI WIVZMGI FYX HSIW RSX QEOI I&E]
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 'EP6TXVH ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV 9745H
'MXI EW ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-29-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 87/97
XLI WIPPIV -J E WIPPIV QMWVITVIWIRXW ER EYGXMSRIH
MXIQ KMZMRK VMWI XS GSZIVEKI XLI MRWYVIV [MPP LEZI E
WYFVSKEXMSR GPEMQ EKEMRWX XLI WIPPIV FYX RSX EKEMRWX
I&E] 7II IK *MVIQERW *YRH -RW 'S Z
;MPWLMVI *MPQ :IRXYVIW -RG 'EP%TTXL
I&E] EPWS TVSZMHIW IWGVS[ ERH TE]
QIRX WIVZMGIW JSV [LMGL EHHMXMSREP JIIW EVI
GLEVKIH I&E] VIJIVW YWIVW XS M)WGVS[ [LMGL EG
GITXW TE]QIRX JVSQ XLI FY]IV ERH MR XYVR TE]W XLI
WIPPIV [LIR XLI FY]IV LEW VIGIMZIH ERH ETTVSZIH
XLI EYGXMSRIH QIVGLERHMWI I&E]W &MPPTSMRX WIVZMGI
IREFPIW FY]IVW XS TE] JSV EYGXMSRIH MXIQW F] GVIHMX
GEVH SV IPIGXVSRMG GLIGO 2IMXLIV XLI IWGVS[ WIVZMGI
RSV XLI &MPPTSMRX LS[IZIV VIRHIVW I&E] E WIPPIV
&SXL EVI QIVIP] EHHMXMSREP WIVZMGIW [LMGL TVSQSXI
XLI TVSZMHIRX ERH IJJMGMIRX YWI SJ I&E]W EYGXMSRWIVZMGI MVVIWTIGXMZI SJ XLI PIKEPMX] SV MPPIKEPMX] SJ
XLI MXIQ FIMRK EYGXMSRIH 8LIWI EHHMXMSREP JIEXYVIW
EVI EZEMPEFPI [MXL VIWTIGX XS EPP KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW
EYGXMSRIHXLI] EVI RSX PMQMXIH XS VIGSVHMRKW QYGL
PIWW XS MPPIKEP VIGSVHMRKW
4PEMRXMJJ EXXIQTXW XS HVE[ E HMWXMRGXMSR
FIX[IIR I&E]W MRXIVEGXMZI WIVZMGI [LMGL LI EVKYIW
MW FEWIH SR E WEPIW QSHIP ERH SXLIV MRXIVEGXMZI WIV
ZMGIW [LMGL EVI FEWIH SR FYPPIXMR FSEVH QSHIPW
;LMPI XLI QENSVMX] SJ GEWIW EHHVIWWMRK '(% MQ
QYRMX] QE] JMX XLI FYPPIXMR FSEVH HIWGVMTXMSR RSXLMRK MR XLSWI GEWIW SV MR XLI WXEXYXSV] PERKYEKI WS
PMQMXW XLI '(%W ETTPMGEXMSR % TVMRGMTEP SFNIGXMZI
SJ XLI MQQYRMX] TVSZMWMSR MW XS IRGSYVEKI GSQ
QIVGI SZIV XLI -RXIVRIX F] IRWYVMRK XLEX MRXIVEGXMZI
GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW EVI RSX LIPH VIWTSRWMFPI
JSV LS[ XLMVH TEVXMIW YWI XLIMV WIVZMGIW w-X MW XLI
TSPMG] SJ XLI 9RMXIH 7XEXIW XS TVIWIVZI XLI ZMFVERX
ERH GSQTIXMXMZI JVII QEVOIX XLEX TVIWIRXP] I\MWXW
JSV XLI -RXIVRIX ERH SXLIV MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIV
ZMGIW YRJIXXIVIH F] *IHIVEP SV 7XEXI VIKYPEXMSRx
97'% � F 8LMW TSPMG] MW FEWIH MR
TEVX SR 'SRKVIWW JMRHMRK XLEX w?MARGVIEWMRKP]
%QIVMGERW EVI VIP]MRK SR MRXIVEGXMZI QIHME JSV E
ZEVMIX] SJ TSPMXMGEP IHYGEXMSREP GYPXYVEP ERH IRXIV
XEMRQIRX WIVZMGIWx 97'% � E 8S
EGGSQTPMWL XLMW SFNIGXMZI XLI MQQYRMX] I\XIRHW
FI]SRH XLI TYFPMGEXMSR SJ LEVQJYP QEXIVMEP SZIV XLI
-RXIVRIX ERH IRGSQTEWWIW XLI HMWXVMFYXMSR SJ WYGL
QEXIVMEP MR XVERWEGXMSRW IJJIGXIH SZIV XLI -RXIVRIX
7II (SI Z %QIVMGE 3RPMRI *PE(MWX'X%TT
7SH VIZMI[ KVERXIH %TVMP
7SH MQQYRMX] I\XIRHW XS EGXMSR F] E
QSXLIV EKEMRWX %QIVMGE 3RPMRI JSV WIPPMRK ERH HMW
XVMFYXMRK TSVRSKVETLMG QEXIVMEP SJ LIV QMRSV WSR MR
ZMSPEXMSR SJ *PSVMHE PE[ 4PEMRXMJJW EXXIQTX XS MQ
TSWI VIWTSRWMFMPMX] SR I&E] EW XLI WIPPIV SJ MXIQW
EYGXMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGI MW RS HMJJIVIRX JVSQ XLI
YRWYGGIWWJYP EXXIQTXW XLEX LEZI FIIR QEHI XS LSPH
GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI TVSZMHIVW PMEFPI EW HMWXVMFYXSVW
VEXLIV XLER EW TYFPMWLIVW SJ HIJEQEXSV] SV TSVRS
KVETLMG QEXIVMEPW (SI Z %QIVMGE 3RPMRI WYTVE
7SH >IVER WYTVE *H
%X FSXXSQ TPEMRXMJJW GSRXIRXMSR MW XLEX I&E]
WLSYPH FI LIPH VIWTSRWMFPI JSV JEMPMRK XS QSRMXSV XLI
TVSHYGXW EYGXMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGI I&E] QYWX
ORS[ TPEMRXMJJ EWWIVXW XLEX MPPMGMX VIGSVHMRKW EVI FI
MRK EYGXMSRIH SZIV MXW WIVZMGI 8LI ZIV] HIWGVMTXMSR
SJ WSQI VIGSVHMRKW IK wFSSXPIKx XETIW MHIRXMJMIW
WSQI EW GSRXVEFERH WS XLEX TPEMRXMJJ GSRXIRHW I&E]
QYWX FI HIIQIH XS LEZI RSXMGI XLEX XLIWI QE] RSX
PE[JYPP] FI WSPH ERH F] JEMPMRK XS MRXIVZIRI QYWX
FI HIIQIH XS LEZI ORS[MRKP] NSMRIH MR XLI YRPE[
JYP WEPI ,S[IZIV GEWIW HIGMHIH YRHIV XLI '(%
YRMJSVQP] LEZI LIPH XLEX RSXMGI SJ TSWXMRKW [LMGLMRHMGEXI MPPIKEPMX] HSIW RSX HIJIEX MQQYRMX] 7II
>IVER WYTVE *H EX (SI Z %QIVMGE
3RPMRI WYTVE 7SH EX 8LI GSYVXW
LEZI VIGSKRM^IH XLEX MQTSWMRK PMEFMPMX] FEWIH SR
RSXMGI SJ GSRXIRX MR XLI MRXIVEGXMZI GSQTYXIV WIVZMGI
GSRXI\X [SYPH GVIEXI ER MRGIRXMZI JSV TVSZMHIVW XS
VIWXVMGX WTIIGL ERH EFWXEMR JVSQ WIPJVIKYPEXMSR
XLIVIF] HIJIEXMRK XLI TYVTSWIW SJ WIGXMSR
-FMH
8LI VIGSVH VIJPIGXW XLEX EX ER] KMZIR XMQI I&E]
LEW SZIV QMPPMSR PMWXMRKW SR MXW [IFWMXI ETTVS\MQ
EXIP] MR XLI QYWMG GEXIKSV] EPSRI
4PEMRXMJJW 1EXIVMEP *EGXW � TK ,S[IZIV
QER] SJ XLIWI TVSHYGXW QE] FI GSRXVEFERH ERH
LS[IZIV QER] MX QMKLX FI TSWWMFPI JSV HIJIRHERX XS
MHIRXMJ] EW WYGL 'SRKVIWW MRXIRHIH XS VIQSZI ER]
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 'EP6TXVH ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV 9745H
'MXI EW ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-30-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 88/97
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 89/97
4ISTPI Z &IIQER WYTVE GSQTEVI EPWS ;MPGS\ Z
*MVWX -RXIVWXEXI &ERO SJ 3VIKSR (3VI
*7YTT EJJH EW QSH XL 'MV
*H '38[S *MVI )UYMTQIRX 'S Z 9RMXIH
7XEXIW XL 'MV *H GIVX HIR
97 QIVI TEVEPPIP EGXMZMX] F] GSQ
TIXMXSVW HSIW RSX GSRWXMXYXI MPPIKEP EKVIIQIRX XS VI
WXVEMR XVEHI EFWIRX GSRHYGX MRGSRWMWXIRX [MXL FIWX
MRXIVIWXW SJ GSQTIXMXSVW GSRWMHIVIH MRHITIRHIRXP]
8LI YRGSRXVSZIVXIH GMVGYQWXERGIW MR XLMW GEWI HS
RSX VMWI XS WYGL E PIZIP
%GGSVHMRKP] HIJIRHERXW QSXMSR JSV WYQ
QEV] NYHKQIRX QYWX FI +6%28)(
'EP7YTIV
7XSRIV Z I&E] -RG
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 'EP6TXVH ;0
'EP7YTIVMSV 9745H
)2( 3* (3'91)28
4EKI
2SX 6ITSVXIH MR 'EP6TXVH ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV 9745H
'MXI EW ;0 'EP7YTIVMSV
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-32-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 90/97
3RP] XLI ;IWXPE[ GMXEXMSR MW GYVVIRXP] EZEMPEFPI
9RMXIH 7XEXIW (MWXVMGX 'SYVX
7( 2I[ =SVO
%RHVIE ;)-278)-2 4PEMRXMJJ
Z
)&%= -2' 7XYFLYF -RG 2I[ =SVO =EROIIW
4EVXRIVWLMT ERH .SLR (SI (IJIRHERXW
2S 'MZ .*/
.YRI
6ERHEPP 2I[QER )WU 2I[QER %WWSGMEXIW
4' 1EVO 6MJOMR )WU ;SPJ ,EPHIRWXIMR %HPIV *VIIQER ,IV^ 004 JSV 4PEMRXMJJ
(EZMH 0IRHIV )WU )VMG ,SGLWXEHX )WU 1EVO
*MSVI )WU ;IMP +SXWLEP 1ERKIW 004 JSV (I
JIRHERXW
3TMRMSR ERH 3VHIV
.3,2 * /))2%2 (MWXVMGX .YHKI
&IJSVI XLI 'SYVX MW (IJIRHERXW I&E] -RG
7XYF,YF -RG ERH XLI 2I[ =SVO =EROIIW 4EVXRIV
WLMTW QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX
TYVWYERX XS 6YPI F SJ XLI *IHIVEP 6YPIW SJ
'MZMP 4VSGIHYVI *SV XLI VIEWSRW XLEX JSPPS[ XLI
QSXMSR MW KVERXIH
- &EGOKVSYRH
(IJIRHERX I&E] STIVEXIW ER MRXIVRIX EYGXMSR
[IFWMXI 3R .ERYEV] I&E] ERRSYRGIH MR E
TVIWW VIPIEWI XLEX MX TPERRIH XS EGUYMVI (IJIRHERX
7XYF,YF %Q'SQTP� 7XYF,YF MW ER SRPMRI
QEVOIXTPEGI JSV XLI VIWEPI SJ WTSVXMRK IZIRX GSR
GIVX ERH XLIEXIV XMGOIXW 7XYF,YF MXWIPJ HSIW RSX
S[R XLI XMGOIXW XLEX EVI VIWSPH SR MXW [IFWMXI -RWXIEH 7XYF,YF STIVEXIW MR [LEX MW ORS[R EW XLI
WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEVOIX E QEVOIX JSV XLMVH
TEVXMIW{VERKMRK JVSQ XMGOIX FVSOIVW XS GEWYEP
WIPPIVW [LS LEZI I\XVE XMGOIXW{XS VIWIPP XMGOIXW XLI]
LEZI TYVGLEWIH HMVIGXP] JVSQ E ZIRHSV -H ��
9RPMOI I&E] WIPPIVW SR 7XYF,YF EVI ERSR]Q
SYW -H 7XYF,YF HSIW RSX JYRGXMSR EW ER EYGXMSR
MRWXIEH XMGOIX WIPPIVW WIX XLIMV S[R TVMGIW JSV TVS
WTIGXMZI FY]IVW XS EGGITX SV VINIGX 8LI %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX EPPIKIW SR MRJSVQEXMSR ERH FIPMIJ XLEX MR
7XYF,YF XLI =EROIIW ERH 1ENSV 0IEKYI
&EWIFEPP IRXIVIH MRXS ER EKVIIQIRX QEOMRK 7XYF
,YF XLI I\GPYWMZI VIWEPI QEVOIXTPEGI JSV XMGOIXW XS
QER] 1ENSV 0IEKYI &EWIFEPP KEQIW MRGPYHMRK
=EROIIW KEQIW -H �
8LI =EROIIW SJJIV GYWXSQIVW X[S STXMSRW JSV
TYVGLEWMRK FEWIFEPP XMGOIXW SR XLI MRXIVRIX 'YWXSQ
IVW GER FY] XMGOIXW HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =EROIIW SRPMRI
FS\ SJJMGI [MXL HMVIGX WEPIW GYWXSQIVW GER JSVIKS TETIV XMGOIXW MR JEZSV SJ IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW MWWYIH F]
8MGOIXQEWXIV )RXIVXEMRQIRX XLI =EROIIW I\GPYWMZI
TVMQEV] XMGOIX EKIRX -H �� 8LI =EROIIW
[IFWMXI EPWS LEW E PMRO XS 7XYF,YF -H � -J
JSV I\EQTPI E GYWXSQIV GSYPH RSX JMRH XLI WIEXW WLI
[ERXIH JSV WEPI HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =EROIIW SRPMRI
FS\ SJJMGI WLI GSYPH KS XS 7XYF,YF ERH XV] XS TYV
GLEWI XLIQ JVSQ ERSXLIV JER 0MOI 8MGOIXQEWXIV
7XYF,YF GER MWWYI IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW XLEX XLI GYW
XSQIV TVMRXW SYX ERH FVMRKW XS XLI IZIRX ZIRYI -H
� )PIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW MWWYIH XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF HS
RSX VIJPIGX XLI JEGI ZEPYI EPWS ORS[R EW XLIwIWXEFPMWLIH TVMGIx SJ XLI XMGOIX -H �
4PEMRXMJJ %RHVIE ;IMRWXIMR EPPIKIW XLEX SR .YRI
WLI [IRX XS XLI =EROIIW [IFWMXI PSSOMRK
JSV XMGOIXW XS XLI .YP] 6S]EPW=EROIIW
KEQI EX =EROII 7XEHMYQ -H � 4PEMRXMJJ EX
XIQTXIH XS TYVGLEWI XMGOIXW HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =ER
OIIW FYX [EW YRWYGGIWWJYP WLI GPEMQW XLEX XLI
=EROIIW [IFWMXI VIHMVIGXIH LIV XS 7XYF,YF -H �
4PEMRXMJJ YPXMQEXIP] TYVGLEWIH WM\ XMGOIXW MR XLI
+VERHWXERH 3YXJMIPH 7IGXMSR 6S[ JVSQ E
WIPPIV XLI .SLR (SI (IJIRHERX SR 7XYF,YF -H�
7LI TEMH TIV XMGOIX TPYW E WIVZMGI
JII ERH E JII XS VIGIMZI XLI XMGOIXW IPIGXVSRMG
EPP] -H 8LI IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW HMH RSX VIJPIGX
XLIMV JEGI ZEPYI [LMGL 4PEMRXMJJ EPPIKIW XS FI
-H �� z )\ %
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-33-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 91/97
4PEMRXMJJ LEW EQIRHIH LIV GSQTPEMRX SRGI EW
SJ VMKLX 8LI KVEZEQIR SJ XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX
MW XLEX 7XYF,YFW SRPMRI QEVOIXTPEGI IZEHIW
GIVXEMR 2I[ =SVO WXEXI PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVIQIRXW KSZ
IVRMRK XMGOIX VIWIPPIVW ERH 7XYF,YFW JEMPYVI XS
HMWGPSWI E WIPPIVW MHIRXMX] ERH XLI JEGI ZEPYI SJ
VIWSPH XMGOIXW MW E HIGITXMZI TVEGXMGI MR ZMSPEXMSR SJ
2I[ =SVO PE[ 4PEMRXMJJ TVSTSWIW XS VITVIWIRX E
GPEWW GSQTSWIH SJ w?EAPP TIVWSRW I\GPYWMZI SJ XLI
(IJIRHERXW ERH XLIMV IQTPS]IIW [LS TYVGLEWIH
XMGOIXW XS E 2I[ =SVO =EROIIW KEQI SR 7XYF
,YFGSQ JVSQ 2SZIQFIV XLVSYKL WYGL
XMQI MR XLI JYXYVI [LIR XLI IJJIGXW SJ (IJIRHERXW
?EPPIKIH PMGIRWMRK ZMSPEXMSRA LEZI GIEWIHx -H �
EW [IPP EW E WYFGPEWW SJ XLSWI TYVGLEWIVW [LS
VIGIMZIH XLIMV =EROIIW XMGOIXW IPIGXVSRMGEPP]XLVSYKL 7XYF,YF -H �
-- (MWGYWWMSR
3R E 6YPI F QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI GSYVX
QYWX XIWX XLI wPIKEP WYJJMGMIRG] SJ XLI GSQTPEMRX
XEOMRK MXW JEGXYEP EPPIKEXMSRW XS FI XVYI ERH HVE[MRK
EPP VIEWSREFPI MRJIVIRGIW MR XLI TPEMRXMJJW JEZSVx
,EVVMW Z 1MPPW *H H 'MV
4PEMRXMJJ QMWXEOIRP] GMXIW XLI 'SRPI] Z +MFWSR wRS
WIX SJ JEGXWx WXERHEVH MR STTSWMXMSR XS (IJIRHERXW
QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW ,S[IZIV XLI 7YTVIQI 'SYVX
LEW QEHI GPIEV XLEX wSRP] E GSQTPEMRX XLEX WXEXIW E TPEYWMFPI GPEMQ JSV VIPMIJ WYVZMZIW E QSXMSR XS HMW
QMWWx %WLGVSJX Z -UFEP 7'X
w(IXIVQMRMRK [LIXLIV E GSQTPEMRX WXEXIW E
TPEYWMFPI GPEMQ JSV VIPMIJ ?MWA E GSRXI\XWTIGMJMG
XEWO XLEX VIUYMVIW XLI VIZMI[MRK GSYVX XS HVE[ SR MXW
NYHMGMEP I\TIVMIRGI ERH GSQQSR WIRWIx -H
% 7XERHMRK XS 7YI (IJIRHERX I&E]
%VXMGPI --- WXERHMRK VIUYMVIW XLEX E TPEMRXMJJ
WYJJIV ER MRNYV]MRJEGX IWXEFPMWL E GEYWEP GSR
RIGXMSR FIX[IIR XLI MRNYV] ERH XLI GSRHYGX SJ XLI
HIJIRHERX ERH HIQSRWXVEXI XLI PMOIPMLSSH XLEX
XLI MRNYV] [MPP FI VIHVIWWIH F] XLI VIUYIWXIH VIPMIJ
7II 0YNER Z (IJIRHIVW SJ ;MPHPMJI 97
2IMXLIV 4PEMRXMJJ RSV ER] QIQFIV SJ XLI
TVSTSWIH GPEWW TYVGLEWIH XMGOIXW XLVSYKL ER I&E]
EYGXMSR 8LI SRP] JEGXYEP EPPIKEXMSR MR XLI %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX MRZSPZMRK I&E] MW XLEX MX EGUYMVIH 7XYF
,YF MR MR SVHIV XS GSQTIXI MR XLI WIGSRHEV]
XMGOIX QEVOIX 8LYW XLI WSPI FEWMW JSV 4PEMRXMJJW
WXERHMRK XS WYI I&E] MW MXW TEVIRXWYFWMHMEV] VIPE
XMSRWLMT [MXL 7XYF,YF
-X MW [IPP EGGITXIH XLEX E TEVIRX GSVTSVEXMSR MW
RSX PMEFPI JSV XLI EGXMSRW SJ MXW WYFWMHMEV] EFWIRX
JEGXW WYJJMGMIRX XS TMIVGI XLI GSVTSVEXI ZIMP 7II
IK &MPP] Z 'SRWSP 1EGL 8SSP 'SVT 2)H
2= w-X MW XVYI XLEX SR SGGEWMSR
XLI GSYVXW [MPP HMWVIKEVH XLI WITEVEXI PIKEP TIVWSR
EPMX] SJ XLI GSVTSVEXMSR ERH EWWMKR PMEFMPMX] XS MXW
S[RIVW &YX WYGL PMEFMPMX] GER RIZIV FI TVIHMG
EXIH WSPIP] YTSR XLI JEGX SJ E TEVIRX GSVTSVEXMSRW
S[RIVWLMT SJ E GSRXVSPPMRK MRXIVIWX MR XLI WLEVIW SJ MXW WYFWMHMEV]x 9RHIV 2I[ =SVO PE[ TMIVGMRK XLI
GSVTSVEXI ZIMP VIUYMVIW E WLS[MRK XLEX w XLI
S[RIVW I\IVGMWIH GSQTPIXI HSQMREXMSR SJ XLI GSV
TSVEXMSR MR VIWTIGX XS XLI XVERWEGXMSR EXXEGOIH ERH
XLEX WYGL HSQMREXMSR [EW YWIH XS GSQQMX E
JVEYH SV [VSRK EKEMRWX XLI TPEMRXMJJ [LMGL VIWYPXIH
MR TPEMRXMJJW MRNYV]x 1SVVMW Z 2= 7XEXI (ITX SJ
8E\EXMSR *MR 2)H z
2= %W GSRGIHIH EX SVEP EVKYQIRX SR XLMW
QSXMSR 4PEMRXMJJ LEW RSX TPIEHIH JEGXW XS IWXEFPMWL
IMXLIV SJ 1SVVMW W VIUYMVIQIRXW *EGXSVW XIRHMRK XS
WLS[ HSQMREXMSR WYGL EW SZIVPETTMRK QEREKIQIRX GSQMRKPIH EWWIXW MREHIUYEXI GETMXEPM^EXMSR
ERH JEMPYVI XS GSRHYGX EVQW PIRKXL XVERWEGXMSRW EVI
IRXMVIP] EFWIRX JVSQ XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX 7II
;Q 4EWWEPEGUYE &YMPHIVW -RG Z 6IWRMGO (I
ZIPSTIVW 7SYXL -RG *H H
'MV 2SV MW XLIVI ER] EPPIKEXMSR XLEX I&E] EG
UYMVIH SV SXLIV[MWI YWIH 7XYF,YF XS MRNYVI
4PEMRXMJJ 4PEMRXMJJ LEW RSX WXEXIH E GPEMQ JSV TMIV
GMRK XLI GSVTSVEXI ZIMP ERH XLYW LEW RSX IWXEFPMWLIH
WXERHMRK XS WYI 7XYF,YFW TEVIRX GSQTER] 2IZIV
XLIPIWW XLI GSYVX [MPP GSRWMHIV XLI ZMEFMPMX] SJ
4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQW EKEMRWX (IJIRHERX I&E] MR ER
EFYRHERGI SJ GEYXMSR
& 2I[ =SVO %VXW ERH 'YPXYVEP %JJEMVW 0E[
'PEMQ
8LVII WIGXMSRW SJ 2I[ =SVOW %VXW ERH 'YP
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-34-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 92/97
XYVEP %JJEMVW 0E[ w%'%0x JSVQ XLI FEWMW SJ
4PEMRXMJJW JMVWX GPEMQ 8LI %'%0 KVERXW E TVMZEXI
VMKLX SJ EGXMSR XS ER] TIVWSR MRNYVIH F] E ZMSPEXMSR
SJ ER] SJ XLI XLVII WIGXMSRW HMWGYWWIH FIPS[ 7II
2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ �
%'%0 �
%'%0 � VIKYPEXIW XLI TVSZMWMSR SJ JEGI
ZEPYI XMGOIX TVMGI MRJSVQEXMSR
)ZIV] STIVEXSV SJ E TPEGI SJ IRXIVXEMRQIRX WLEPP
MJ E TVMGI FI GLEVKIH JSV EHQMWWMSR XLIVIXS TVMRX
SV IRHSVWI SR XLI JEGI SJ IEGL WYGL XMGOIX XLI IW
XEFPMWLIH TVMGI*2
SV XLI JMREP EYGXMSR TVMGI MJ
WYGL XMGOIX [EW WSPH SV VIWSPH F] EYGXMSR XLVSYKL
XLI STIVEXSV SV MXW EKIRX
*2 )WXEFPMWLIH TVMGI wQIERW XLI TVMGI
JM\IH EX XLI XMQI SJ WEPI F] XLI STIVEXSV SJ
ER] TPEGI SJ IRXIVXEMRQIRX JSV EHQMWWMSR
XLIVIXS [LMGL QYWX FI TVMRXIH SV IRHSVWIH
SR IEGL XMGOIX SJ EHQMWWMSRx 2= %VXW
'YPX %JJ 0E[ �
2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ �
4PEMRXMJJ EPPIKIW XLEX I&E] 7XYF,YF ERH XLI =ER
OIIW EVI IEGL HMVIGXP] PMEFPI YRHIV � JSV SQMX
XMRK XLI JEGI ZEPYI JVSQ LIV IPIGXVSRMG =EROIIWXMGOIXW &] MXW S[R XIVQW � SRP] ETTPMIW XS
wSTIVEXSVWx %R STIVEXSV MW wER] TIVWSR [LS S[RW
STIVEXIW SV GSRXVSPW E TPEGI SJ IRXIVXEMRQIRX SV
[LS TVSQSXIW SV TVSHYGIW ER IRXIVXEMRQIRXx 2=
%VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ � 8LIVI MW RS EPPIK
EXMSR RSV GSYPH XLIVI FI XLEX (IJIRHERXW I&E] SV
7XYF,YF S[R STIVEXI SV GSRXVSP =EROII 7XEHMYQ
SV TVSQSXI SV TVSHYGI 1ENSV 0IEKYI &EWIFEPP
KEQIW *YVXLIVQSVI %'%0 � [LMGL MQ
QIHMEXIP] JSPPS[W XLI wSTIVEXSVx XMGOIX TVMGMRK VIK
YPEXMSR EX MWWYI QERHEXIW XLEX ER] TEVX] wXLEX VI
WIPPW XMGOIXW SV JEGMPMXEXIW XLI VIWEPI SV VIWEPI EYGXMSR
SJ XMGOIXW FIX[IIR MRHITIRHIRX TEVXMIW F] ER]
QIERWx QEOI GIVXEMR VIJYRH KYEVERXIIW XS TYV
GLEWIVW 8LI WXEVO GSRXVEWX MR PERKYEKI YWIH MR GSR
WIGYXMZI WYFWIGXMSRW SJ XLI WXEXYXI MRHMGEXIW XLEX XLI
2I[ =SVO 0IKMWPEXYVI GSYPH LEZI MQTSWIH ER SF
PMKEXMSR SR [IFWMXIW XLEX JEGMPMXEXI XLI VIWEPI MI
7XYF,YF SV VIWEPI EYGXMSR MI I&E] SJ XMGOIXW XS
TVMRX JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR SR WYGL XMGOIXW FYX
GLSWI RSX XS HS WS 8LYW XLI %'%0 � GPEMQ
EW XS I&E] ERH 7XYF,YF JEMPW EW E QEXXIV SJ PE[
8LI wSTIVEXSVx VIKYPEXIH F] � GER SRP] FI XLI
=EROIIW
4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQ EKEMRWX XLI =EROIIW MW PIKEPP]
HIJMGMIRX EW [IPP 4PEMRXMJJ GSRGIHIW XLEX XMGOIXW TYV
GLEWIH HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI SRPMRI FS\ SJJMGI MWWYIH
F] 8MGOIXQEWXIV SR FILEPJ SJ XLI =EROIIW VIJPIGX
XLIMV JEGI ZEPYI %Q'SQTP� 8LYW XLI =ER
OIIW HMVIGX WEPIW GSQTP] [MXL � 4PEMRXMJJ EV
KYIW XLEX XLI =EROIIW SFPMKEXMSR YRHIV � XS
IRWYVI XLEX wIEGL WYGL XMGOIXx MRGPYHIW MXW JEGIZEPYI ETTPMIW RSX SRP] XS HMVIGX WEPIW FYX EPWS XS VI
WEPIW SR XLI WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEVOIX 4PEMRXMJJW XLI
SV] MW XLEX XLI =EROIIW EVI PMEFPI JSV 7XYF,YFW JEMP
YVI XS MRGPYHI JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR SR IPIGXVSRMG
EPP] VIMWWYIH XMGOIXW
8LMW MRXIVTVIXEXMSR MW YRXIREFPI MR PMKLX SJ XLI
PERKYEKI SJ XLI WXEXYXI EW [IPP EW XLI VIEPMXMIW SJ XLI
WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEVOIX 8LI 'SYVX GERRSX GSR
GPYHI XLEX XLI 0IKMWPEXYVI QIERX XS MQTSWI ER SRKS
MRK HYX] SR STIVEXSVW XS IRWYVI XLEX IZIV] VIWSPH
XMGOIX MRGPYHIW JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR [LIVI XLIWXEXYXI WMRKPIW SYX SRP] SRI EVIE SJ XLI WIGSRHEV]
XMGOIX QEVOIX{VIWEPI EYGXMSRW GSRHYGXIH F] XLI ST
IVEXSV SV MXW EKIRX{XS WYFNIGX XS XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW
SJ � 1SVISZIV IZIR JSV XLSWI VIWEPI EYG
XMSRW XLEX EVI YRHSYFXIHP] VIKYPEXIH F] %'%0 �
ER STIVEXSV RIIH RSX IRWYVI XLEX VIWSPH XMGO
IXW MRGPYHI JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR MRWXIEH XLI ST
IVEXSV QYWX TVMRX SR XLSWI XMGOIXW XLIMV wJMREP EYG
XMSR TVMGIx [LMGL GSYPH FI LMKLIV SV PS[IV XLER XLI
IWXEFPMWLIH TVMGI 8LI FVSEH HYX] 4PEMRXMJJ WIIOW XS
MQTSWI SR STIVEXSVW WYGL EW XLI =EROIIW JMRHW RS
WYTTSVX MR XLI XI\X SJ �
2SV MW WYGL E HYX] MR ER] [E] IRJSVGIEFPI
%'%0 � VIUYMVIW STIVEXSVW XS TVMRX XLI JMREP
EYGXMSR TVMGI SR XMGOIXW SRP] [LIVI XLI STIVEXSV MX
WIPJ SV MXW EKIRX GSRHYGXW XLI EYGXMSR{MR SXLIV
[SVHW SRP] [LIVI XLI STIVEXSV VIXEMRW WSQI GSRXVSP
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-35-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 93/97
SZIV XLI XMGOIXW WYGL XLEX GSQTP]MRK [MXL XLI WXEXYXI
[SYPH FI JIEWMFPI 9RHIV 4PEMRXMJJW VIEHMRK SJ XLI
WXEXYXI XLI =EROIIW [SYPH FI PMEFPI ER] XMQI E
WGEPTIV WXERHMRK SR E WXVIIX GSVRIV WIPPW E XMGOIX
[MXL EPXIVIH SV RS IWXEFPMWLIH TVMGI MRJSVQEXMSR
8LIVI MW WMQTP] RS [E] XLI =EROIIW GER TSPMGI
IEGL ERH IZIV] XLMVH TEVX] XMGOIX WEPI XS IRWYVI XLEX
XLI JMREP TYVGLEWIV VIGIMZIW XLI XMGOIX MR XLI WEQI
JSVQ ERH [MXL XLI WEQI JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR EW
[LIR MX [EW SVMKMREPP] MWWYIH F] XLI =EROIIW
%PXLSYKL XLI] GERRSX QSRMXSV EPP WEPIW SR XLI
WIGSRHEV] QEVOIX 4PEMRXMJJ EVKYIW XLEX XLI =EROIIW
EVI PMEFPI JSV 7XYF,YFW JEMPYVI XS TVMRX JEGI ZEPYI
MRJSVQEXMSR SR IPIGXVSRMGEPP] VIMWWYIH XMGOIXW F]
ZMVXYI SJ XLIMV FYWMRIWW EVVERKIQIRX 7IXXMRKXS SRI WMHI XLI JEGX XLEX XLI WXEXYXI SRP] VIKYPEXIW
VIWEPI EYGXMSRW [LMGL RIMXLIV XLI =EROIIW RSV
7XYF,YF GSRHYGX %'%0 � VIUYMVIW ER STIV
EXSVW SZIVWMKLX SJ XLMVH TEVX] WEPIW F] XLI STIVEXSVW
EKIRX ,IVI XLIVI EVI RS JEGXYEP EPPIKEXMSRW IWXEF
PMWLMRK ER EKIRG] VIPEXMSRWLMT FIX[IIR XLI =EROIIW
ERH 7XYF,YF 9RHIV 2I[ =SVO PE[ ER EKIRG] VI
PEXMSRWLMT wVIWYPXW JVSQ E QERMJIWXEXMSR SJ GSRWIRX
F] SRI TIVWSR XS ERSXLIV XLEX XLI SXLIV WLEPP EGX SR
LMW FILEPJ ERH WYFNIGX XS LMW GSRXVSP ERH XLI GSR
WIRX F] XLI SXLIV XS EGXx 2= 1EVMRI +IR -RW
'S Z 8VEHIPMRI 00' *H H'MV MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSR SQMXXIH 7XYF,YF
HSIW RSX WIPP XMGOIXW SR FILEPJ SJ XLI =EROIIW MX MW E
TPEXJSVQ JSV XLMVH TEVX] S[RIVW XS VIWIPP XMGOIXW %P
XLSYKL XLI EKVIIQIRX KMZIW 7XYF,YF XLI EFMP
MX] XS VIMWWYI XMGOIXW IPIGXVSRMGEPP] 7XYF,YF TIV
JSVQW XLMW WIVZMGI SR FILEPJ SJ XLI XLMVH TEVX] XMGOIX
WIPPIV RSX XLI =EROIIW XLI =EROIIW HS RSX S[R SV
GSRXVSP XLI XMGOIXW XLEX EVI WSPH SR XLI WIGSRHEV]
XMGOIX QEVOIX *MREPP] XLIVI MW RS EPPIKEXMSR XLEX XLI
=EROIIW LEZI ER]XLMRK XS HS [MXL XLI TVMGMRK SV
WYTTP] SJ XMGOIXW SR 7XYF,YF SV XLEX XLI] I\IVGMWI
GSRXVSP SZIV 7XYF,YF MR ER] [E] 8LI %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX HSIW RSX WIX JSVXL ER] JEGXYEP FEWMW SR
[LMGL XLI 'SYVX GER LSPH XLI =EROIIW PMEFPI JSV
XMGOIXW PEGOMRK JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR XLEX EVI WSPH
SR XLI 7XYF,YF [IFWMXI
4PEMRXMJJ EXXIQTXW XS WEPZEKI XLMW GPEMQ F] EV
KYMRK XLEX %'%0 EVXMGPI EW E [LSPI [EW MRXIR
HIH XS VIKYPEXI XLI WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEVOIX 8LMW MW
GIVXEMRP] SRI KSEP SJ XLI WXEXYXI FYX XLEX KSEP HSIW
RSX SZIVVMHI XLI YREQFMKYSYW PERKYEKI SJ �
%HHMXMSREPP] 4PEMRXMJJ EVKYIW XLEX (IJIRHERXW HS
RSX TVMRX XLI JEGI ZEPYI SR VIWSPH IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW
wFIGEYWI XLI] HS RSX [ERX GSRWYQIVW XS ORS[ XLI
)WXEFPMWLIH 4VMGI EW MX [SYPH LEZI E RIKEXMZI IJJIGX
YTSR XMGOIX WEPIWx 3TT EX *MVWX 4PEMRXMJJ SJ
JIVW RS I\TPEREXMSR EW XS LS[ ORS[PIHKI XLEX XLI
7XYF,YF PMWX TVMGI MW LMKLIV XLER JEGI ZEPYI [SYPH
RIKEXMZIP] EJJIGX XLI HIWMVEFMPMX] SJ XMGOIXW TEVXMGY
PEVP] XMGOIXW XS E WSPH SYX KEQI SV LSQI KEQI
EKEMRWX XLI 6IH 7S\ 1SVI MQTSVXERXP] LS[IZIV
XLI 'SYVX GERRSX VI[VMXI E WXEXYXI FIGEYWI 4PEMRXMJJ EXXVMFYXIW MQTVSTIV QSXMZIW XS (IJIRHERXW EGXMSRW
XLI VIEWSRW JSV SQMXXMRK XLI JEGI ZEPYI SR VIMWWYIH
IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW EVI WMQTP] MVVIPIZERX MR PMKLX SJ
GPIEV WXEXYXSV] EYXLSVMX] XS WS HS %R STIVEXSVW SF
PMKEXMSR YRHIV %'%0 � [MXL VIWTIGX XS WIG
SRHEV] XMGOIX WEPIW MW XS IRWYVI XLEX XMGOIXW WSPH F]
XLI STIVEXSV SV MXW EKIRX MR E VIWEPI EYGXMSR VIJPIGX
XLI JMREP EYGXMSR TVMGI %W 4PEMRXMJJ HMH RSX TYVGLEWI
XMGOIXW HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =EROIIW SV MR E VIWEPI EYG
XMSR LIPH F] XLI =EROIIW SV MXW EKIRX XLI %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX JEMPW XS WXEXI E GPEMQ EKEMRWX XLI =ER
OIIW
%'%0 �
2I[ =SVO PE[ VIUYMVIW GIVXEMR XMGOIX VI
WIPPIVW XS SFXEMR PMGIRWIW XS STIVEXI XLIMV FYWMRIWWIW
2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ � :MSPEXMSR SJ
XLI PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVIQIRX MW TYRMWLEFPI EW QMWHI
QIERSV XMGOIX WTIGYPEXMSR 2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ
0E[ � 8LI %'%0 I\IQTXW GIVXEMR [IFWMXIW
JVSQ MXW PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVIQIRXW
%R] STIVEXSV SV QEREKIV SJ E [IFWMXI XLEX WIVZIW
EW E TPEXJSVQ XS JEGMPMXEXI VIWEPI SV VIWEPI F] [E]
SJ E GSQTIXMXMZI FMHHMRK TVSGIWW WSPIP] FIX[IIR
XLMVH TEVXMIW ERH HSIW RSX MR ER] SXLIV QERRIV IR
KEKI MR VIWEPIW SJ XMGOIXW XS TPEGIW SJ IRXIVXEMR
QIRX WLEPP FI I\IQTX JVSQ XLI PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVI
QIRXW SJ XLMW WIGXMSR
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-36-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 94/97
2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ �
4PEMRXMJJ EGORS[PIHKIW XLEX XLMW I\IQTXMSR ETTPMIW
XS I&E] ERH 7XYF,YF %Q'SQTP� -R ER EX
XIQTX XS GMVGYQZIRX XLMW WXEXYXSV] I\IQTXMSR
4PEMRXMJJ EWOW XLI 'SYVX XS VIGSKRM^I HIVMZEXMZI PMEF
MPMX] [MXL VIWTIGX XS I&E] ERH 7XYF,YF JSV MRXIR
XMSREPP] EMHMRK ERH EFIXXMRK YRPMGIRWIH XMGOIX VI
WIPPIVW PMOI XLI .SLR (SI (IJIRHERX F] TVSZMHMRK
XLIQ [MXL E TPEXJSVQ XS ERSR]QSYWP] WIPP XMGOIXW
8LI ZIV] REXYVI SJ 7XYF,YF ERH I&E]W FYWM
RIWW MW XS EMH ERH EFIX XLMVH TEVX] XMGOIX WEPIW F]
WIPPIVW [LS EVI QSWX PMOIP] YRPMGIRWIH 8LI 0IKMW
PEXYVI [EW [IPP E[EVI SJ XLMW JEGX EW MX WMRKPIH SYX
[IFWMXIW XLEX wJEGMPMXEXIx XLMVH TEVX] XMGOIX WEPIW MR
XLI XI\X SJ XLI WXEXYXI MXWIPJ -J XLI 0IKMWPEXYVI[MWLIH XS VIKYPEXI I&E] ERH 7XYF,YFW GSRHYGX MX
GSYPH LEZI WMQTP] VIUYMVIH XLI GSQTERMIW XS SFXEMR
VIWIPPIV PMGIRWIW JSV XLIQWIPZIW -R PMKLX SJ MXW WTI
GMJMG GLSMGI RSX XS MQTSWI WYGL VIWXVMGXMSRW SR I&E]
ERH 7XYF,YFW FYWMRIWWIW XLI 'SYVX GERRSX GSR
GPYHI XLEX XLI 0IKMWPEXYVI [SYPH MRXIRH JSV XLI %'
%0 XS RSRIXLIPIWW XVET (IJIRHERXW MR E RIX SJ HIVMZ
EXMZI PMEFMPMX] FEWIH SR XLIMV YWIVW EGXMSRW 8S VI
GSKRM̂ I XLMW WSVX SJ FEGOHSSV EMHMRK ERH EFIXXMRK
GPEMQ [SYPH FI XS [VMXI XLI I&E]7XYF,YF I\IQT
XMSR SYX SJ %'%0 � IRXMVIP] %MHMRK ERH
EFIXXMRK ER %'%0 ZMSPEXMSR MW RSX GSKRM^EFPIEKEMRWX (IJIRHERXW I&E] ERH 7XYF,YF EW E QEXXIV
SJ PE[ 1SVISZIV [MXL VIWTIGX XS XLI ERSR]QMX] SJ
7XYF,YFW QEVOIXTPEGI IZIR MJ XLI EMHMRK ERH EFIX
XMRK XLISV] [IVI PIKEPP] ZMEFPI 4PEMRXMJJ GERRSX
TSMRX XS ER] TVSZMWMSR SJ 2I[ =SVO PE[ XLEX VI
UYMVIW XMGOIX VIWIPPIVW PMGIRWIH SV RSX XS HMWGPSWI
XLIMV MHIRXMXMIW %W (IJIRHERXW I&E] ERH 7XYF,YF
EVI I\IQTX JVSQ XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ �
4PEMRXMJJW GPEMQ JEMPW EW E QEXXIV SJ PE[ %W XLIVI MW
RS EPPIKEXMSR XLEX XLI =EROIIW VIWIPP XMGOIXW SV EMH
ERH EFIX XLI VIWEPI SJ XLIMV XMGOIXW XLI �
GPEMQ EKEMRWX XLI =EROIIW JEMPW EW [IPP
%'%0 �
*MREPP] XLI %'%0 WTIGMJMIW XLEX
-R IZIV] TVMRGMTEP SJJMGI SV FVERGL SJJMGI FYVIEY
EKIRG] SV WYFEKIRG] SJ ER] PMGIRWII YRHIV XLMW
EVXMGPI XLIVI WLEPP FI GSRWTMGYSYWP] TSWXIH ERH EX
EPP XMQIW HMWTPE]IH E TVMGI PMWX WLS[MRK XLI IWXEF
PMWLIH TVMGI GLEVKIH F] XLI STIVEXSV SJ XLI TPEGI
SJ IRXIVXEMRQIRX JSV [LMGL E XMGOIX MW FIMRK WSPH
F] WYGL PMGIRWII XSKIXLIV [MXL XLI TVMGI FIMRK
GLEVKIH F] WYGL PMGIRWII JSV XLI VIWEPI SJ WYGL
XMGOIX WS XLEX EPP TIVWSRW ZMWMXMRK WYGL TPEGI QE]
VIEHMP] WII XLI WEQI *YVXLIV MJ XLI PMGIRWII
GSRHYGXW FYWMRIWW XLVSYKL XLI YWI SJ XLI MRXIVRIX
XLI WEQI TVMGI PMWX SV L]TIVPMRO XS XLI WEQI WLEPP
FI GSRWTMGYSYWP] HMWTPE]IH SR XLI MRXIVRIX TEKI
SR [LMGL XMGOIXW EVI EGGIWWIH
2= %VXW 'YPX %JJ 0E[ �
4PEMRXMJJ EPPIKIW XLEX 7XYF,YF EMHW XMGOIX VIWIPPIVW MR
ZMSPEXMRK XLMW WXEXYXI F] wRSX EPPS[MRK E XMGOIX VIWIPPIV ?XSA TSWX XLI JEGI ZEPYI SV E L]TIVPMRO XS XLI
JEGI ZEPYI EX XLI XMQI SJ WEPIx %Q'SQTP�
7IGXMSR SR MXW JEGI SRP] ETTPMIW XS
wPMGIRWIIWx %W 4PEMRXMJJ GSRGIHIW XLEX I&E] ERH
7XYF,YF EVI I\IQTX JVSQ XLI PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVI
QIRXW SJ %'%0 � XLIWI (IJIRHERXW EVI RSX
PMGIRWIIW 8S IRHVYR XLMW I\IQTXMSR 4PEMRXMJJ
EKEMR VIWSVXW XS ER EMHMRK ERH EFIXXMRK XLISV] &YX
EW I\TPEMRIH EFSZI EMHMRK ERH EFIXXMRK MW RSX PIK
EPP] GSKRM^EFPI MR PMKLX SJ XLI 0IKMWPEXYVIW HIXIVQ
MREXMSR RSX XS VIKYPEXI I&E] ERH 7XYF,YFW XMGOIXVIWEPI FYWMRIWWIW %KEMR EW XLI =EROIIW HS RSX VI
WIPP XLIMV S[R XMGOIXW SV EMH ERH EFIX XMGOIX VIWIPPIVW
MR LMHMRK TVMGI PMWXW XLI] GER LEZI RS PMEFMPMX] YR
HIV �
-R GSRGPYWMSR RSRI SJ XLI EFSZIGMXIH %'%0
WIGXMSRW VIKYPEXI (IJIRHERXW TEVXMGMTEXMSR MR XLI
WEPI SJ =EROIIW XMGOIXW SR XLI WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEV
OIX *YVXLIVQSVI 4PEMRXMJJW EXXIQTX XS EZSMH XLI
TPEMR PERKYEKI SJ XLI %'%0 [MXL ER EMHMRK ERH
EFIXXMRK XLISV] SJ PMEFMPMX] JEMPW EW E QEXXIV SJ PE[
8LYW (IJIRHERXW QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI %'%0GPEMQ MW KVERXIH ,EZMRK HIXIVQMRIH XLEX XLI
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX JEMPW XS WXEXI E GPEMQ EKEMRWX
ER] SJ XLI (IJIRHERXW XLI 'SYVX RIIH RSX VIEGL XLI
MWWYI SJ (IJIRHERXW MQQYRMX] YRHIV XLI 'SQQY
RMGEXMSRW (IGIRG] %GX 97' � G
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-37-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 95/97
' 2I[ =SVO +IRIVEP &YWMRIWW 0E[ (IGITXMZI
4VEGXMGIW 'PEMQ
2I[ =SVOW +IRIVEP &YWMRIWW 0E[ w+&0x
QEOIW YRPE[JYP w?HAIGITXMZI EGXW SV TVEGXMGIW MR XLI
GSRHYGX SJ ER] FYWMRIWW XVEHI SV GSQQIVGI SV MR
XLI JYVRMWLMRK SJ ER] WIVZMGI MR XLMW WXEXIx 2=
+IR &YW 0E[ � E w8S QEOI SYX E TVMQE
JEGMI GEWI YRHIV 7IGXMSR E TPEMRXMJJ QYWX
HIQSRWXVEXI XLEX XLI HIJIRHERXW HIGITXMZI EGXW
[IVI HMVIGXIH EX GSRWYQIVW XLI EGXW EVI QMWPIEHMRK
MR E QEXIVMEP [E] ERH XLI TPEMRXMJJ LEW FIIR MR
NYVIH EW E VIWYPXx 1EYVM^MS Z +SPHWQMXL *H
H 'MV GMXMRK 3W[IKS 0EFSVIVW
0SGEP 4IRWMSR *YRH Z 1EVMRI 1MHPERH &ERO
2)H 2= 2I[ =SVO GSYVXW
ETTP] ER SFNIGXMZI HIJMRMXMSR SJ HIGITXMZI EGXW ERH TVEGXMGIW GSRGIVRIH SRP] [MXL wXLSWI PMOIP] XS QMW
PIEH E VIEWSREFPI GSRWYQIV EGXMRK VIEWSREFP] YRHIV
XLI GMVGYQWXERGIWx 3W[IKS 0EFSVIVW 0SGEP
2)H EX w8LIVI GER FI RS GPEMQ JSV HIGITX
MZI EGXW SV TVEGXMGIW LS[IZIV [LIR XLI EPPIKIH HI
GITXMZI TVEGXMGI [EW JYPP] HMWGPSWIHx 'LMWXI Z ,S
XIPWGSQ 04 *7YTTH
7(2= MRXIVREP UYSXEXMSR SQMXXIH
8LI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX EPPIKIW XLEX (IJIRH
ERXW ZMSPEXI +&0 � F] EMHMRK ERH EFIXXMRK ER
SR]QSYW XLMVH TEVXMIW MR VIWIPPMRK XMGOIXW [MXLSYX E PMGIRWI ERH [MXLSYX HMWGPSWMRK XLI
JEGI ZEPYI SJ XLI XMGOIXW JSV VIWEPI 8LYW XLI HI
GITXMZI TVEGXMGIW GPEMQ MW TVIHMGEXIH SR ZMSPEXMSRW
SJ XLI %'%0 ,EZMRK HIXIVQMRIH XLEX XLI %'%0
HSIW RSX TVSLMFMX WYGL GSRHYGX MX MW HMJJMGYPX XS YR
HIVWXERH LS[ (IJIRHERXW FYWMRIWW TVEGXMGIW EVI HI
GITXMZI
4PEMRXMJJ EVKYIW XLEX FIGEYWI XLI =EROIIW
[IFWMXI PMROW XS 7XYF,YF ERH 7XYF,YF WIPPIVW EVI
ERSR]QSYW wXLI PIEWX WSTLMWXMGEXIH GSRWYQIV
[SYPH PMOIP] EWWYQI XLEX ?WLI MWA TYVGLEWMRK XMGOIXW
HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =EROIIWx 3TT EX ,S[IZIV
XLI ETTPMGEFPI PIKEP WXERHEVH MW [LIXLIV E VIEWSR
EFPI GSRWYQIV RSX XLI PIEWX WSTLMWXMGEXIH GSR
WYQIV [SYPH FI QMWPIH F] (IJIRHERXW EGXMSRW
4PEMRXMJJ EPPIKIW XLEX WLI [IRX XS XLI =EROIIW [IF
WMXI ERH JSPPS[IH E L]TIVPMRO XS XLI 7XYF,YF [IF
WMXI -R WS HSMRK WLI PIJX XLI =EROIIW [IFWMXI ERH
[EW VIHMVIGXIH XS ER IRXMVIP] RI[ [IFWMXI [MXL E
HMJJIVIRX 960 8LEX [IFWMXI PMWXW JSV WEPI XMGOIXW XS
RYQIVSYW RSR=EROIIW IZIRXW MRGPYHMRK QYWMG
GSRGIVXW XLI GMVGYW 2%7'%6 VEGIW ERH SXLIV 1E
NSV 0IEKYI &EWIFEPP KEQIW 4PEMRXMJJW S[R XMGOIX
[EW TVMRXIH JVSQ XLI 960
wQ]EGGSYRXWXYFLYFGSQx ERH MRGPYHIW FSXL E
7XYF,YF GYWXSQIV RYQFIV ERH E 7XYF,YF GSRJMVQ
EXMSR RYQFIV %Q'SQTP )\ % 8IPPMRKP]
4PEMRXMJJ HSIW RSX EPPIKI XLEX WLI TIVWSREPP] FI
PMIZIH WLI [EW TYVGLEWMRK XMGOIXW HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI
=EROIIW SRPMRI FS\ SJJMGI SV XLEX WLI HMH RSX YRHIV
WXERH XLEX 7XYF,YF MW ER SRPMRI QEVOIXTPEGI JSV XLI
VIWEPI SJ XMGOIXW F] SXLIV JERW -UFEP HMVIGXW XLI'SYVX XS ETTP] MXW GSQQSR WIRWI [LIR HIXIVQMRMRK
XLI TPEYWMFMPMX] SJ E GPEMQ{GSQQSR WIRWI HMGXEXIW
XLEX RS VIEWSREFPI GSRWYQIV GSYPH TPEYWMFP] XLMRO
XLEX 7XYF,YF XMGOIXW GSQI HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =ER
OIIW [LIR JEGIH [MXL SZIV[LIPQMRK IZMHIRGI XS
XLI GSRXVEV]
4PEMRXMJJ JYVXLIV EVKYIW XLEX 7XYF,YFW JEMPYVI
XS TVMRX XLI JEGI ZEPYI SR VIWSPH XMGOIXW SRP] VIMR
JSVGIW XLI QMWGSRGITXMSR XLEX XLI XMGOIXW [IVI WSPH
F] XLI =EROIIW -J E GSRWYQIV FIPMIZIW XLEX WLI MW
FY]MRK HMVIGXP] JVSQ E ZIRHSV WLI QE] RSX VIEPM^IXLEX XLI 7XYF,YF TVMGI GER FI LMKLIV XLER XLI IWXEF
PMWLIH TVMGI SJ XLI XMGOIXW 4PEMRXMJJ EGORS[PIHKIW
XLEX 7XYF,YF STIVEXIW MR XLI WIGSRHEV] XMGOIX QEV
OIX -R SVHIV JSV 7XYF,YFW JEMPYVI XS TVMRX XLI JEGI
ZEPYI SR E VIMWWYIH XMGOIX XS FI HIGITXMZI E FY]IV
[SYPH LEZI XS FIPMIZI XLEX E VIWIPPIV MR TSWWIWWMSR
SJ E PMQMXIH VIWSYVGI [LMGL MW PMOIP] RSX EZEMPEFPI
HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI ZIRHSV HSIW RSX GLEVKI E TVIQM
YQ JSV LIV KSSHW 8LMW PMRI SJ VIEWSRMRK wEXXVMFYXIW
XS GSRWYQIVW E PIZIP SJ WXYTMHMX] XLEX XLI 'SYVX GER
RSX GSYRXIRERGI ERH XLEX MW RSX EGXMSREFPI YRHIV
+&0 � x 'LMWXI *7YTTH EX z
HMWQMWWMRK GPEMQ XLEX ,SXIPWGSQW JEMPYVI XS HMW
GPSWI XLI JEGX XLEX MX QEHI E TVSJMX SR IEGL VIWIVZE
XMSR FSSOIH SR MXW [IFWMXI [EW HIGITXMZI FIGEYWI
w?EAR] VIEWSREFPI GSRWYQIV [SYPH YRHIVWXERH XLEX
FYWMRIWWIW EVI MR FYWMRIWW XS QEOI E TVSJMXx 0MOI
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-38-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 96/97
ER] VIEWSREFPI GSRWYQIV 4PEMRXMJJ ORI[ WLI [EW
TYVGLEWMRK XMGOIXW SR XLI WIGSRHEV] QEVOIX 8LI
.SLR (SI 7XYF,YF WIPPIV UYSXIH LIV TIV XMGOIX
[LMGL MW I\EGXP] [LEX WLI TEMH 8LI JEGI ZEPYI SJ
XMGOIXW MR IEGL WIGXMSR SJ =EROII 7XEHMYQ MW TYFPMG
EPP] EZEMPEFPI SR XLI =EROIIW [IFWMXI ERH EW
4PEMRXMJJ ORI[ XLI WIGXMSR ERH VS[ SJ XLI XMGOIXW JSV
WEPI SR 7XYF,YF WLI GSYPH LEZI GSQTEVIH XLI
7XYF,YF TVMGI XS XLI JEGI ZEPYI [MXL RS HMJJMGYPX]
4PEMRXMJJ WMQTP] LEW RSX TPIEHIH ER] HIGITXMZI EGX
F] ER] SJ XLI XLVII (IJIRHERXW
*YVXLIVQSVI 4PEMRXMJJ GSRGIHIW XLEX 7XYF
,YFW [IFWMXI [EVRW GYWXSQIVW SJ XLI I\EGX JEGXW
WLI GPEMQW [IVI SFWGYVIH F] (IJIRHERXW JEMPYVI XS
TVMRX JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR SR LIV XMGOIXW )ZIV]WMRKPI TEKI SJ XLI [IFWMXI XS [LMGL 4PEMRXMJJ [EW VI
HMVIGXIH MRGPYHIH E HMWGPEMQIV XLEX w=SY EVI FY]MRK
XMGOIXW JVSQ E XLMVH TEVX] RIMXLIV 7XYF,YFGSQ RSV
7XYF,YF -RG MW XLI XMGOIX WIPPIVx 7II (IGPEVEXMSR
SJ )VMG ,SGLWXEHX )\W z 7MQMPEVP] IZIV]
TEKI SR 7XYF,YFW [IFWMXI MRGPYHIW E HMWGPEMQIV
XLEX w8MGOIX TVMGIW EVI WIX F] WIPPIVW ERH QE] HMJJIV
JVSQ JEGI ZEPYIx -H ;LMPI RSX HMWTSWMXMZI XLIWI
HMWGPSWYVIW FIPMI ER] GPEMQ SJ HIGITXMSR
%HHMXMSREPP] 4PEMRXMJJ LEW TPIEHIH RS JEGXW IW
XEFPMWLMRK XLEX (IJIRHERXW EPPIKIHP] HIGITXMZI EGXWGEYWIH ER] MRNYV] 8LI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX WIXW
JSVXL X[S EPPIKIH MRNYVMIW PEGO SJ MRJSVQEXMSR
EFSYX TVMGMRK ERH XLEX GSRWYQIVW EVI wJSVGIHx
XS TE] LMKLIV XMGOIX TVMGIW FIGEYWI XLI WIPPIVW EVI
ERSR]QSYW ERH XLI VIMWWYIH XMGOIXW HS RSX VIJPIGX
XLIMV JEGI ZEPYI %Q'SQTP� � z 0EGO
SJ MRJSVQEXMSR MW RSX ER MRNYV] MX MW XLI JEGXYEP YR
HIVTMRRMRK SJ XLI +&0 � GPEMQ %W XS LMKLIV
TVMGIW 4PEMRXMJJ [EW IZMHIRXP] [MPPMRK XS TE]
TIV XMGOIX XS WII XLI =EROIIW 8LIVI MW RS GPEMQ XLEX
WLI [SYPH RSX LEZI QEHI XLI TYVGLEWI LEH WLI
ORS[R XLEX XLI 7XYF,YF XMGOIXW [IVI QSVI I\
TIRWMZI XLER XLI XMGOIXW WLI EXXIQTXIH FYX [EW YR
EFPI XS TYVGLEWI HMVIGXP] JVSQ XLI =EROIIW 7MQMP
EVP] XLIVI MW RS GPEMQ XLEX 4PEMRXMJJ [SYPH RSX LEZI
QEHI XLI TYVGLEWI LEH 7XYF,YF HMWGPSWIH XLI MHIR
XMX] SJ XLI .SLR (SI WIPPIV *MREPP] XLIVI MW RS GSR
GIMZEFPI I\TPEREXMSR EW XS LS[ WIPPIV ERSR]QMX] SV
XLI JEGX XLEX IPIGXVSRMG XMGOIXW HS RSX MRGPYHI JEGI
ZEPYI wJSVGIWx GSRWYQIVW XS SZIVTE] JSV XMGOIXW
&EH WIEXW PEWX QMRYXI PMWXMRKW SV XMGOIXW XS YRTSTY
PEV KEQIW QE] WIPP SR 7XYF,YF JSV PIWW XLER JEGI
ZEPYI -J WIPPIVW YWMRK 7XYF,YFW [IFWMXI WYGGIWW
JYPP] GLEVKI TVMGIW EFSZI JEGI ZEPYI XLI] GER HS WS
FIGEYWI SJ XLI PE[ SJ WYTTP] ERH HIQERH RSX FI
GEYWI 7XYF,YF EPPIKIHP] [MXLLSPHW TVMGI MRJSVQE
XMSR JVSQ GSRWYQIVW %W 4PEMRXMJJ LEW TPIEHIH
RIMXLIV E QEXIVMEP HIGITXMSR RSV ER MRNYV] XLI +&0
� GPEMQ MW HMWQMWWIH
( 1SXMSR XS %QIRH
%X SVEP EVKYQIRX SR XLMW QSXMSR SR .YRI
4PEMRXMJJW GSYRWIP MRJSVQIH XLI 'SYVX XLEX LIMRXIRHIH XS WIIO PIEZI XS JMPI E WIGSRH %QIRHIH
'SQTPEMRX MR SVHIV XS QEOI X[S QEXIVMEP GLERKIW XS
XLI JMVWX %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX 6YPI E SJ XLI
*IHIVEP 6YPIW SJ 'MZMP 4VSGIHYVI WTIGMJMIW XLEX EJXIV
E TEVX] LEW EQIRHIH E TPIEHMRK SRGI EW SJ VMKLX JY
XYVI EQIRHQIRXW QE] SRP] FI TIVQMXXIH SR GSRWIRX
SV F] PIEZI SJ GSYVX %PXLSYKL w?XALI 'SYVX WLSYPH
JVIIP] KMZI PIEZI [LIR NYWXMGI WS VIUYMVIWx
*IH6'MZ4 E [LIVI XLIVI MW wYRHYI HIPE]
FEH JEMXL SV HMPEXSV] QSXMZI SR XLI TEVX SJ XLI
QSZERX VITIEXIH JEMPYVI XS GYVI HIJMGMIRGMIW F]
EQIRHQIRXW TVIZMSYWP] EPPS[IH YRHYI TVINYHMGI XSXLI STTSWMRK TEVX] F] ZMVXYI SJ EPPS[ERGI SJ XLI
EQIRHQIRX ?SVA JYXMPMX] SJ EQIRHQIRXx XLI 'SYVX
QE] HIR] E QSXMSR XS EQIRH *SQER Z (EZMW
97
*MVWX [LIVIEW TEVEKVETL SJ XLI JMVWX
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX GSRGIHIH XLEX I&E] ERH 7XYF
,YF [IVI I\IQTX JVSQ XLI PMGIRWMRK VIUYMVIQIRXW
SJ %'%0 � 4PEMRXMJJ TVSTSWIW XS EQIRH TEVE
KVETL XS EPPIKI XLEX w%'%0 � VIUYMVIW XLI
PMGIRWMRK SJ XMGOIX FVSOIVW FYX TVSZMHIW ER I\IQT
XMSR JSV MRXIVRIX [IFWMXIW WYGL EW I&E] ERH 7XYF
,YF KIRIVEPP] ,S[IZIV XLEX I\IQTXMSR HSIW RSX
ETTP] XS XLI WEPI SJ =EROIIW XMGOIXW FIGEYWI 7XYF
,YF HSIW QSVI XLER QIVIP] TVSZMHI E PSGEXMSR XLEX
JEGMPMXEXIW XLI WEPI SJ XMGOIXW F] XLMVH TEVXMIWx .YRI
3VEP %VKYQIRX 8V EX z 8LYW
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
� 8LSQWSR 6IYXIVW 2S 'PEMQ XS 3VMK 97 +SZ ;SVOW
-39-
8/6/2019 Hill v StubHub Appellants Brief
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hill-v-stubhub-appellants-brief 97/97
4PEMRXMJJ [MWLIW XS VIZIVWI GSYVWI ERH EVKYI XLEX
7XYF,YF MW RSX I\IQTX JVSQ � W PMGIRWMRK VI
UYMVIQIRX FIGEYWI MX LEW XLI EFMPMX] XS VIMWWYI IPIG
XVSRMG XMGOIXW 8LIVI MW RS VSSQ MR XLI WXEXYXSV] I\
IQTXMSR JSV XLI HMWXMRGXMSR 4PEMRXMJJ TVSTSWIW 7XYF
,YFW EFMPMX] XS VIMWWYI =EROIIW XMGOIXW HSIW RSX
XVERWJSVQ MX JVSQ E wTPEXJSVQ XS JEGMPMXEXI VIWEPI
WSPIP] FIX[IIR XLMVH TEVXMIWx XS E GSVTSVEXMSR XLEX
wIRKEKI?WA MR XLI FYWMRIWW SJ VIWIPPMRK ER] XMGOIXW XS
E TPEGI SJ IRXIVXEMRQIRXx %'%0 � 7XYF
,YF HSIW RSX S[R SV WIPP XLI =EROIIW XMGOIXW XLEX MX
IPIGXVSRMGEPP] VIMWWYIW RSV HSIW MX WIX VIWEPI TVMGIW
-X WMQTP] SJJIVW ER EHHMXMSREP WIVZMGI EW TEVX SJ MXW
VSPI EW E JEGMPMXEXSV SJ XLMVH TEVX] XMGOIX WEPIW %W MR
HMGEXIH F] XLI YRIUYMZSGEP PERKYEKI SJ XLI WXEXYXI
7XYF,YF MW RSX VIUYMVIH XS SFXEMR E VIWIPPIV PMGIRWI4PEMRXMJJW TVSTSWIH EQIRHQIRX XS TEVEKVETL
[SYPH FI JYXMPI FIGEYWI MX GERRSX GMVGYQZIRX XLI
WXEXYXSV] I\IQTXMSR
7IGSRH 4PEMRXMJJ TVSTSWIW XS I\TERH SR XLI EP
PIKEXMSRW SJ MRNYV] YRHIV +&0 � 7TIGMJMGEPP]
4PEMRXMJJ [SYPH EQIRH TEVEKVETL SJ XLI
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX XS WXEXI XLEX XLI JEMPYVI XS EPIVX
GSRWYQIVW [LIR XLI 7XYF,YF PMWX TVMGI MW LMKLIV
XLER JEGI ZEPYI wEVXMJMGMEPP] GVIEXIW HIQERH JSV
XMGOIXW MR XLI WIGSRHEV] QEVOIX XLEX LEW XLI IJJIGX
SJ VEMWMRK XLI TVMGI SJ XLI XMGOIXW MR XLI WIGSRHEV]QEVOIXx .YRI 3VEP %VKYQIRX 8V EX
z 8LMW EPPIKEXMSR MW EW STEUYI EW XLI GYVVIRX
I\TPEREXMSR SJ MRNYV] 1SVISZIV IZIR EGGITXMRK EW
XVYI XLI HYFMSYW TVSTSWMXMSR XLEX 7XYF,YFW JEMPYVI
XS TVSZMHI JEGI ZEPYI MRJSVQEXMSR wJSVGIWx GYWXSQ
IVW XS SZIVTE] JSV XMGOIXW 4PEMRXMJJ WXMPP LEW RSX
TPIEHIH ER] HIGITXMSR %R] VIEWSREFPI GSRWYQIV
4PEMRXMJJW GPEVMJMGEXMSR SJ LIV XLISV] SJ MRNYV] YRHIV
+&0 � [SYPH RSX WEZI XLI GPEMQ JVSQ HMW
QMWWEP ERH MW XLIVIJSVI JYXMPI 8LIVI MW RS RIIH XS
IQFEVO SR GSWXP] ERH XMQI MRXIRWMZI FVMIJMRK SJ E
QSXMSR XS EQIRH FIGEYWI RIMXLIV TVSTSWIH EQIRH
QIRX [SYPH SZIVGSQI XLI %QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRXW
PIKEP HIJIGXW 8LI 4PEMRXMJJ LEW WXVYGO SYX
--- 'SRGPYWMSR
(IJIRHERXW QSXMSR XS HMWQMWW XLI
%QIRHIH 'SQTPEMRX MW KVERXIH MR EPP VIWTIGXW %W
RS EHHMXMSREP JEGXYEP EPPIKEXMSRW GER VIQIH] XLI
PIKEP HIJIGXW HMWGYWWIH LIVIMR XLI %QIRHIH 'SQ
TPEMRX MW HMWQMWWIH [MXL TVINYHMGI 8LI 'PIVO SJ
'SYVX MW HMVIGXIH XS GPSWI XLMW GEWI
73 36()6)(
7(2=
;IMRWXIMR Z I&E] -RG
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
)2( 3* (3'91)28
4EKI
7PMT 'ST] ;0 7(2=
'MXI EW ;0 7(2=
-40-