Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

18
M. H. Beals Sheffield Hallam University @mhbeals DOWNLOAD SLIDES ABOUT ME

Transcript of Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

Page 1: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

M. H. BealsSheffield Hallam University

@mhbeals

DOWNLOAD SLIDES

ABOUT ME

Page 2: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

A PHILOSOPHY

Page 3: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

AN OVERVIEW

Digital Pathways to Close Reading

Digital Pathways to Big Data

Incorporating Theories of the Digital into Historical Teaching

Page 4: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

CLOSE READING 1.0

• Reading the Text

• Reading Around the Topic

• Who, What, When, Where and Why

• Bias

Page 5: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><text>ALICE, THE NEGRO.The following Account is copied from the Salopian Journal ofDec. 15, 1802.LATELY died, at Bristol, in Pennsylvania, a female slave, named ALICE, aged 116 years. She was born in Philadelphia, of parents who came from Barbadoes, and lived in that city until she was ten years old, when her master removed her to Dunk's Ferry; in which neighbourhood she continued to the end of her days. She remembers the ground on which Philadelphia stands, when it was a wilderness, and when the Indians (its chief inhabitants) hunted wild game in the woods, while the panther, the wolf, and the beast of the forest, were prowling about the wigwams and cabins in which they lived.</text>

CLOSE READING 2.0

Page 6: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><text>ALICE, THE NEGRO.The following Account is copied from the <attribution pub="Salopian Journal"pub_city="Shrewsbury" pub_country="United Kingdom">Salopian Journal</attribution>of Dec. 15, 1802. LATELY died, at <location coordinates="40°06′12″N 74°51′05″W" url="http://tools.wmflabs.org/geohack/geohack.php?pagename=Bristol%2C_Pennsylvania&params=40_06_12_N_74_51_05_W_type:city%289726%29_region:US-PA">Bristol, in Pennsylvania,</location> a female slave, named <individual name="Alice" born="1686" died="1802">ALICE</individual>, aged 116 years.

She was born in <location coordinates="39°57′N 75°10′W" url="http://tools.wmflabs.org/geohack/geohack.php?pagename=Philadelphia&params=39_57_N_75_10_W_type:city%281553165%29_region:US-PA"> Philadelphia</location>, of parents who came from Barbadoes, and lived inthat city until she was ten years old, when her master removed her to Dunk's Ferry;in which neighbourhood she continued to the end of her days. <claim validity="unclear" reason="born 4 years after founding">She remembers the ground on which Philadelphia stands, when it was a wilderness, and when the Indians(its chief inhabitants) hunted wild game in the woods, while the panther, the wolf, and the beast of the forest, were prowling about the wigwams and cabins in which they lived.</claim></text>

CLOSE READING 2.5

Page 7: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

CLOSE READING 3.0

Page 8: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DISTANT READING

• Linguistic Trends• Topic Modelling

• Sentiment Analysis

• Publication Trends• Reprint / Edition Tracking

• Digital Collaboration

• Integration of Close Reading

Page 9: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DISTANT READING

Page 10: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DISTANT READING

Page 11: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DIGITAL THEORY

To What Extent Does Digitisation and Digitally Native Content Effect

Our Sources and Our Role as Historians?

Page 12: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DIGITIZED ARCHIVES

• A Digital Version of a Traditional Space• A Different but Recognisable Experience• In-Built Authority and Credibility• Questions Raised:• Materiality

• Curation

• Malleability

Page 13: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

•Loss of Curation Autonomy • Digitisation Choices • Paywalls

•Software Limitations

•Digital Dependencies

•Temptation for Footnote Tableaus

DIGITISED MATERIAL

Page 14: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DIGITAL ARCHIVES

• Exists in Myriad Forms• Narrative Curation• Non-Linear Curation• Interactive Data Sets

• Raises Questions of• Authority• Authenticity• Versionality • Ephemerality

Page 15: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

DIGITAL MATERIAL

Image http://edtechdigest.wordpress.com/2013/11/18/trends-cartoon-ron-morgan/

• Google is not a Research Assistant• Hidden & Inconstant Algorithms • Herd Mentality Reshapes Focus

• Unclear Distinction Between • Information Gathering• Data Processing • Scholarly Analysis

Page 16: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

CONCLUSION

Lessons You Learn from Digital History andDigital Methods Training

You Are Not ReplaceableYou Are Not Alone

Page 17: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

CONCLUSION

Lessons Students Learn from Digital History andDigital Methods Training

Take Pride in Your WorkDon’t Be Afraid to Re-Purpose

Try HarderSeriously, Try Harder

Page 18: Help Them Try Harder: Integrating the Digital into Historical Thinking

BROUGHT TO YOU BY

Good Will And Faerie Dust

All Slides Use CC0 or CC-BY Images and Are Released Under The CC-BY 4.0 Licence

SLIDES ABOUT ME