Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

40
Hedge Fund Investment Strategies 1 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

description

Hedge Fund Investment Strategies. Hedge Fund Investment Strategies. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Page 1: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

1 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 2: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Hedge Fund Investment Strategies Hedge funds employ dynamic investment strategies designed to find

unique opportunities in the market and then actively trade their portfolio investments (both long and short) in an effort to maintain high and diversified absolute returns (often using leverage to enhance returns)

By contrast, most mutual funds only take long positions in securities and are less active in trading their portfolio investments (usually without leverage) as they attempt to create returns that track (and ideally outperform) the market

There are four broad groups of hedge fund strategies: arbitrage, event-driven, equity-related and macro The first two groups in many cases attempt to achieve returns that are

uncorrelated with general market movements, where managers try to find price discrepancies between related securities, using derivatives and active trading based on computer driven models and extensive research

The second two groups are impacted by movements in the market, and they require intelligent anticipation of price changes in stocks, bonds, foreign exchange and physical commodities

2 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 3: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Four CategoriesHedge Fund Strategies Can be Grouped into Four Major Categories

Source: McKinsey Global Institute; Hedge Fund Research, Inc.; David Stowell

Subcategory Description

Arbi

trag

e

Fixed-income based arbitrage

Exploits pricing inefficiencies in fixed-income markets, combining long/short positions of various fixed income securities

Convertible arbitrage

Purchases convertible bonds and hedges equity risk by selling short the underlying common stock

Relative value arbitrage

Exploits pricing inefficiencies across asset classes-e.g., pairs trading, dividend arbitrage, yield curve trades

Even

t Dr

iven

Distressed securities

Invests in companies in a distressed situation (e.g. bankruptcies, restructuring), and/or shorts companies expected to experience distress

Merger arbitrage Generates returns by going long on the target and shorting the stock of the acquiring company

Activism Seeks to obtain representation in companies' board of directors in order to shape company policy and strategic direction

Equi

ty

Base

d Equity long/short Consists of a core holding of particular equity securities, hedged with short sales of stocks to minimize overall market exposure

Equity non-hedge Commonly known as "stock picking"; invests long in particular equity securities

Mac

ro

Global Macro Leveraged bets on anticipated price movements of stock markets, interest rates, foreign exchange, and physical commodities

Emerging markets Invests a major share of portfolio in securities of companies or the sovereign debt of developing or "emerging" countries; investments are primarily long

3 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 4: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Strategies are DiversifiedHedge Fund Strategies Have Become More Diversified

Note 1: Hedge Fund Research’s “Relative Value” classification is comparable to the “Arbitrage” classification used in the book.Source: Hedge Fund Research, Inc.

14%24%

10%

24%37%

32%

39%20%

1990 2008

Macro

Equity-based

Event-driven

Relative Value 1

4 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 5: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Equity-Based StrategiesEquity Long/Short

Also known as equity hedge strategyIt is different from equity market-neutral

strategy, where managers utually hold a number of long equity position and an equal, or close to equal, dollar amount of offsetting short equity position, so that the net exposure is close to zero (dollar neutrality).

Non-Hedged EquityNo hedge involved, and investment is only long

(not short)

5 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 6: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Equity Long/Short A hedge fund manager that focuses on equity long/short investing

starts with a fundamental analysis of individual companies, combined with research on risks and opportunities particular to a company’s industry, country of incorporation, competitors and the overall macroeconomic environment in which the company operates

This strategy attempts to shift the principal risk from market risk to manager risk, which requires skilled stock selection to generate alpha through a concurrent purchase and sale of similar securities in an attempt to exploit relative mispricings, while decreasing market risk

Managers consider ways to reduce volatility by either diversifying or hedging positions across industries and regions and hedging undiversifiable market risk

However, the overall risk in this strategy is determined by whether a manager is attempting to prioritize returns (by having more concentration and leverage) or low risk (by creating lower volatility through diversification, lower leverage and hedging)

6 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 7: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Buy on margin (page 133-138, Jaeger)

Broker typically lend 50% of the value of stock to be purchasedVary across securities

Brokers will not lend funds against risky stocksMargin requirement (margin=equity/assets) could be 5% or less

for government securities. In the security business, the down payment is called the haircut.

Suppose you have $100,000 in a brokerage account, and you want to buy $200,000 worth of IBM stock. So you borrow $100,000 from the broker, pledging the 2000 shares of stock as collateral. The broker charges an interest of 5% annually.What if IBM price goes up by 5% or down by 20% in a

year?

7 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 8: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Short sellPage 139-146, Jaeger’s bookYou open an account with $100,000 and you sell

short 1000 shares of Amazon.com at $100 each.What if the price goes down to $50/share or

goes up to $120/share?Borrowing a stock is costlyAlso note that short selling creates a new

interest-bearing assets Under what condition, short selling is most

profitable? Boxing a short position (page 145-146)

8 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 9: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Diversification and hedgingBoth are ways to reduce risk

Diversification, see chapter 7, JaegerHedging, see chapter 9, from page 146

Shorting against the boxBasis risk

9 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 10: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Equity Long/ShortLong/Short Strategy Overview

Continued onto next page…

Strategy Overview:

• Definition: Strategy by which manager concurrently buys and sells similar securities or indexes in an attempt to exploit relative mispricings, while neutralizing a risk common in those securities

• Examples: Equities (Long JP Morgan, Short Citigroup); Yield curve (Short 2 Yr Treasuries, Long 10 Yr Treasuries); CDOs (Long equity Tranche, Short mezzanine Tranche)…

• Direction: Can be neutral, net long, or net short

• Rationale: Shifts principal risk from market risk to manager risk based on premise that skilled stock selection generates alpha

Mechanics of a Long / Short Strategy (Equity):

$9M in proceeds from short sale

$9M in Stock B borrowed

Investor: Short position

$9M in Stock A to prime broker

$9M to purchase Stock A long

Establishes $1M liquidity buffer

STRATEGY

EXECUTION

Screening Security selection

Weight positions & trade

Portfolio long/short

ratio

Manage portfolio

risk

• Fundamental research

• Quant screening• Networking

• Forecasting• Valuation• Mgmt.

interviews

• Devise strategy• Determine

weights• Consider

execution ability• Risk manage

• Gross mkt. exposure• Net mkt. exposure• Beta adj. market

exposure• Leverage

• Focus on short• Volatility• Review limits• Review losses• Review gains

HF Manager

Prime Broker

$10M Initial Investment

Step 1:

Step 2:Prime Broker

Step 3:Prime Broker

Investor: Long position

$9M collateral for borrowing

Stock B

$9M Stock B for short sale

Prime Broker

Step 4:

Step 5:Prime Broker

Step 6:Prime Broker

Sec. Lender(s)

Sec. Lender(s)

10 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 11: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Equity Long/ShortLong/Short Strategy Return Sources and Costs:

Return Sources:• Performance

• Alpha on long position plus alpha on short position• Interest rebate

• Short sale proceeds invested by prime broker in short term securities• Rebate = Interest on short sale proceeds – prime broker lender fee and expenses• Rebate is usually = 75-90% of interest on short sale proceeds

• Liquidity buffer interest • Liquidity buffer posted to pay for daily mark to market adjustments and to pay dividends to stock

lenders (arranged by prime brokers)• Liquidity buffer earns short term interest

Costs:• Share borrow costs• Margin costs on short position• Transaction costs

Return Attribution:

0.00%

2.00%

4.00%

6.00%

8.00%

10.00%

12.00%

14.00%

16.00%

Long Position Short Position

Dividend Income on

Long Position

Rebate on Short

Position

Interest Earned on Liquidity

Buffer

Cost of Borrowing

Shares

Margin Costs on Short Position

Net Return

+3.5%+1.0%

+1.0% +0.2%

-0.2% -0.5%

14.0%

9.0%

11 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 12: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

More on Long-shortBenefits: (1) performance, (2) Interest

rebate, (3) liquidity buffer interestCosts: (1) share borrowing costs, (2)

margin costs on short position, (3) transaction costs

Thoughts from Jacobs & Levy (97, The Long and Short on Long-Short)Market-neutral long-short + long index futureMarket-neutral long-short HF is not an asset

class

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies12

Page 13: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Macro StrategiesGlobal macro

Make leverage bets on anticipated price movements in stock and bond markets, interest rates, foreign exchange, and physical commodities.

Also known as global asset allocators

Emerging marketSecurities of companies and sovereign bonds

13 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 14: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Global Macro A macro focused hedge fund makes leveraged bets on anticipated

price movements in stock and bond markets, interest rates, foreign exchange and physical commodities

This strategy also takes positions in financial derivatives such as forwards, options and swaps on assets such as stocks, bonds, commodities, loans, and real estate and on indexes that are focused on interest rates, stock and bond markets, exchange rates, and instruments that relate to inflation

A macro-focused fund considers economic forecasts, analysis about global flow of funds, interest rate trends, political changes, relations between governments, individual country political and economic policies and other broad systemic considerations

A well-known practitioner of a global macro investment is George Soros, who sold short more than $10 billion of pound sterling in 1992, successfully profiting from the Bank of England’s reluctance to either raise its interest rates to levels comparable to rates in other European countries or to float its currency

14 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 15: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Two types of global Asset allocatorsDiscretionary managers

Rely on some blend of fundamental analysis and technical analysis to form a reasonable investment judgmentGrowth variablesInformation variablesInterest ratesTrade flow and capital flowsEquity valuation variables: P/E, price to cash flow, business

value, etcSystemic managers

Follow definite rules for putting on and taking off positionsPage 237 (JAEGER)

15 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 16: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Emerging MarketsAn emerging market focused hedge fund

invests most of its funds in either the securities of companies in developing (emerging) countries or the sovereign debt of these countries

Emerging markets is a term used to describe a country’s social or business activity that is characterized by rapid growth and industrialization

Typically investors demand greater returns because of incremental risks

16 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 17: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Arbitrage StrategiesFixed income-based arbitrageConvertible arbitrageRelative value arbitrage

17 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 18: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Fixed Income Arbitrage Fixed income arbitrage funds attempt to exploit pricing

inefficiencies in fixed income markets by combining long/short positions of various fixed income securities

For example, historically, because of the limited liquidity of the Italian bond futures market, the currency-hedged returns from this market in the short term were lower than the short-term returns in the very liquid U.S. Treasury bond market

However, over a longer period of time, the hedged returns became nearly identical

Fixed income arbitrageurs benefitted from the eventual convergence of hedged yields between currency-hedged Italian bond futures and U.S. Treasury bonds by shorting relatively expensive U.S. Treasury bonds and purchasing relatively cheap Italian bond futures

18 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 19: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Fixed Income Arbitrage Another example involves 30-year on-the-run and off-the-

run U.S. Treasury bonds Liquidity discrepancies between the most recently issued

30-year Treasury bonds (called on-the-run bonds) and 29.75 year Treasury bonds that were originally issued one quarter earlier (called off-the-run bonds) sometimes causes a slight difference in pricing between the two bonds

This can be exploited by buying cheaper off-the-run bonds and shorting the more expensive on-the-run bonds

Since the price of the two bonds should converge within three months (both bonds becoming off-the-run bonds), this trading position should create a profit for the arbitrageur

19 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 20: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Convertible Arbitrage A convertible bond can be thought of as a fixed-income security

that has an embedded equity call option The convertible investor has the right, but not the obligation to

convert (exchange) the bond into a predetermined number of common shares

The investor will presumably convert sometime at or before the maturity of the bond if the value of the common shares exceeds the cash redemption value of the bond

The convertible therefore has both debt and equity characteristics and, as a result, provides an asymmetrical risk and return profile

Until the investor converts the bond into common shares of the issuer, the issuer is obligated to pay a fixed coupon to the investor and repay the bond at maturity if conversion never occurs

A convertible’s price is sensitive to, among other things, changes in market interest rates, credit risk of the issuer, and the issuer’s common share price and share price volatility

20 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 21: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Convertible Arbitrage Convertible Arbitrage is a market neutral investment strategy that

involves the simultaneous purchase of convertible securities and the short sale of common shares (selling borrowed stock) that underlie the convertible

An investor attempts to exploit inefficiencies in the pricing of the convertible in relation to the security’s embedded call option on the convertible issuer’s common stock

In addition, there are cash flows associated with the arbitrage position that combine with the security’s inefficient pricing to create favorable returns to an investor who is able to properly manage a hedge position through a dynamic hedging process

The hedge involves selling short a percentage of the shares that the convertible can convert into based on the change in the convertible’s price with respect to the change in the underlying common stock price (delta) and the change in delta with respect to the change in the underlying common stock (gamma)

21 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 22: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Convertible Arbitrage The short position must be adjusted frequently in an attempt to

neutralize the impact of changing common share prices during the life of the convertible security (this process of managing the short position in the issuer’s stock is called “delta hedging”)

If hedging is done properly, whenever the convertible issuer’s common share price decreases, the gain from the short stock position should exceed the loss from the convertible holding, and whenever the issuer’s common share price increases, the gain from the convertible holding should exceed the loss from the short stock position

The investor will also receive the convertible’s coupon payment and interest income associated with the short stock sale

However, this cash flow is reduced by paying a cash amount to stock lenders equal to the dividend the lenders would have received if the stock were not loaned to the convertible investor, and further reduced by stock borrow costs and interest expense on any borrowings to finance the investment

22 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 23: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 23

Mechanics of Convertible ArbitrageA convertible arbitrageur attempts to purchase undervalued convertibles and simultaneously short a number of common shares that the convertible can convert into (the "conversion ratio"). The number of shares sold short depends on the conversion ratio and the delta. The delta measures the change in the convertible's price with respect to the change in the underlying common stock price, which represents the convertible's equity sensitivity for very small stock price changes. The arbitrageur's objective is to create an attractive rate of return regardless of the changing price of the underlying shares. This is achieved by capturing the cash flows available on different transactions that relate to the convertible as well as directly from the convertible and by profiting from buying a theoretically cheap convertible. Many convertibles are originally issued at a price below their theoretical value because the stock price volatility assumed in the convertible pricing is below the actual volatility that is expected during the life of the convertible. A summary of potential convertible returns is as follows:

1. Income GenerationThe arbitrageur tries to generate income while hedging the risks of various components of a convertible bond. Income from a convertible hedge comes from the following: Coupon + interest on Short Proceeds – Stock Dividend – Stock Borrow Cost. This income is increased if the arbitrageur leverages the investment (two or three times leverage is common). However, costs associated with hedging interest rate and credit risks reduce the income. An example of income generation, which is linked to Figure 2, follows:

Exhibit 12.4 (1 of 7)

Page 24: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 24

Mechanics of Convertible ArbitrageAssuming that an issuer’s common stock price is $41.54 and dividend yield is 1% when a $1,000 convertible is issued and the convertible has a 2.5% coupon, a conversion ratio of 21.2037, 53% average short stock position (with 2% interest income available from this position) and a stock borrow cost of 0.25% on the short proceeds, over a one year horizon, the total income from a delta hedged convertible would be $28.50, which is equal to 2.9% of the $1,000 convertible:

Page 25: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 25

Mechanics of Convertible Arbitrage2. Monetizing VolatilityBecause of the nonlinear relationship between prices for the convertible and for the underlying stock, there is an additional gain potential in creating a delta neutral position between the convertible and the stock. This is explained in Figure 1. At point 1, the green line represents the long convertible position, whereas the dotted line represents the delta neutral exposure. Therefore, if the stock price were to fall from position 1, the gain on the short stock position is greater than the loss from the long convertible position (position A). However, if the stock were to gain, the loss on the short would be less than the gain on the convertible (position B).

Page 26: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 26

Mechanics of Convertible ArbitrageFigure 1: MONETIZING VOLATILITY

60

Conv

ertib

le p

rice,

par

ity

∆2 Rehedge stock at new delta hedge ratio (short more stock as delta higher)

"Ratcheting" profits

∆1 Long convert and short stock at initial delta hedge ratio

80

100

120

40

20

1400

B Stock rises Profit= (CB gain) – (short stock loss)

50 100 150 200

Stock price

A Stock fallsProfit = (short stock gain) – (CB loss)

0

Page 27: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 27

Mechanics of Convertible Arbitrage

Figure 2: CONVERTIBLE ARBITRAGE TRADE

Convertible arbitrage fundinitial case Long convertible 101.375 par = $1,013.75

Amount of short shares 21.2037*53% = 11.24Short value = 11.24 (shares)*41.54 (price) = $466.82Net cash outlay = $546.93

+5% scenario Current share price = $43.617Loss from short = $466.82 – (11.24*43.617) = $23.34Gain from convertible = (1,038.071 – 1,013.75) = $24.32Net gain = 24.32-23.34 = $.98New hedge delta = 58.11%

-5% scenario Current share price = $39.463Gain from short = $466.82 – (11.24*39.463) = $23.34Loss from convertible = (1,013.75 – 991.782) = $21.97Net gain = 23.34-21.97 = $1.37New hedge delta = 46.75%

Stock Px = $41.54Convertible delta = 53%Conv. Ratio = 21.2037 sharesConvertible Px = 101.375% par

Note: calculations are not rounded.

Page 28: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 28

Mechanics of Convertible Arbitrage

Figure 3: LONG-ONLY TRADE (ONE YEAR)

Long-only fundinitial case Long convertible 101.3755 par = $1,013.75

Net cash outlay = $1,013.75+5% scenario Current share price = $43.617

Gain from convertible = (1,038.071 – 1,013.75) = $24.32Coupon for 1 year = 2.5Net gain = $26.82

-5% scenario Current share price = $39.463Loss from convertible = (1,013.75 – 991.782) = $21.97Coupon for 1 year = 2.5Net loss = $19.47

Stock Px = $41.54Convertible delta = 53%Conv. Ratio = 21.2037 sharesConvertible Px = 101.375% par

Note: calculations are not rounded.

Page 29: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Mechanics of Convertible Arbitrage3. Purchasing Undervalued ConvertibleAn important source of additional potential profit comes from purchasing a convertible at a price that is below its theoretical value, from an implied volatility perspective. When this happens and the convertible exposures are properly neutralized through delta hedging, incremental profits will be created over time based on the below-market purchase. These profits will be even higher if there is an increase in volatility during the holding period. However, if volatility decreases, this potential profit opportunity can turn into a potential loss. If a convertible is purchased at a 2% discount to theoretical value, this could result in a profit of $20 (2% of the $1,000 convertible).

4. Summary of ReturnsThe total one-year convertible return in this hypothetical, hedged convertible is comprised of o Income Generation (2.9%), o Monetizing Volatility (1.4%), o Purchasing an Undervalued Convertible (2%, calculated for a one-year holding period).

This results in a hypothetical return of 6.3%.If one-half of this convertible is purchased with $500 borrowed from a Prime Broker at 2%, the total one-year return from this investment would be approximately 10.6% ($1,000 x 6.3% = $63. $63 - $10 interest cost = $53. $53/$500 = 10.6%)

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies 29

Page 30: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Relative Value Arbitrage Relative value arbitrage exploits pricing inefficiencies across

asset classes An example of this is “pairs trading”, which involves two

companies that are competitors or peers in the same industry that have stocks with a strong historical correlation in daily stock price movements

When this correlation breaks down (one stock increases in price while the other stock decreases in price) a pairs trader will sell short the outperforming stock and buy the underperforming stock, betting that the “spread” between the two stocks will eventually converge

When, and if, convergence occurs, there can be significant trading profits

Of course, if divergence occurs, notwithstanding the strong historical correlations, this trade can lose money

30 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 31: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Equity Market Neutral StrategiesPage 242, Jaeger bookMarket neutral long-short equity

Pair trading: e.g., taking a long position in Cisco, paired with a short position in Microsoft

Single-sector fundamental investors: long-short stocks in the single sector – develop a detailed knowledge of the companies in which he is investing, from both the long and short sides

Multi-sector fundamental investors: scoring stocks based on a wide variety of factors; then buying the stocks that score high and selling short the stocks that score low.

Multi-sector technical traders: care about price movement and relative pricing. Look for situations in which prices have gotten out of line but are expected to go back in line within days.

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies31

Page 32: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Event Driven Strategies Event driven strategies focus on significant transactional

events such as M&A transactions, bankruptcy reorganizations, recapitalizations and other specific corporate events that create pricing inefficienciesEvent-Driven Investment Opportunities: Catalysts and Events

Source: Highbridge Capital Management, LLC

Strategic (Hard Catalysts)

Risk ArbitrageStrategic Alternative ReviewsSpin-Offs / Breakup CandidatesActivist Shareholders / Proxy ContestsHolding Company Discounts / Stub TradesTakeover Candidates

Operational

Merger / Synergy BenefitsRestructuring Programs / Turnaround StoriesSenior Management Turnover

Financial

Liquidity Events / Credit Re-RatingsRecapitalizationsPrimary Equity and Debt OfferingsBankruptcy ReorganizationsAccounting Changes / Issues

Legal / Regulatory

LitigationRegulationsLegislation

Technical

Broken Risk Arbitrage SituationsSecondary Equity and Equity-Linked Offerings

32 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 33: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Activist InvestorsActivist investors take minority equity or equity

derivative positions in a company and then try to influence the company’s senior management and board to consider initiatives that the activist considers important in order to enhance shareholder value

This strategy is sometimes called Shareholder ActivismActivist investors often attempt to influence other

major investors to support their recommendation to the company, which sometimes leads to proxy solicitations designed to change the management composition of the company

Activist investors commonly push for lower costs, lower cash balances, greater share repurchases, higher dividends and increased debt, among other things

33 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 34: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Merger Arbitrage• In a stock-for-stock acquisition, some traders will buy the target

company’s stock and simultaneously short the acquiring company’s stock, creating a “risk arb” position that is called Merger Arbitrage or Risk Arbitrage

• The purchase is motivated by the fact that after announcement of a pending acquisition, the target company’s share price typically trades at a lower price in the market compared to the price reflected by the Exchange Ratio that will apply at the time of closing

• Traders who expect that the closing will eventually occur can make trading profits by buying the target company’s stock and then receiving the acquiring company’s stock at closing, creating value in excess of their purchase cost

• To hedge against a potential drop in value of the acquiring company’s stock, the trader sells short the same number of shares to be received at closing in the acquiring company’s stock based on the Exchange Ratio

• Risk arb trading puts downward pressure on the acquiring company’s stock and upward pressure on the selling company’s stock

34 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 35: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Merger Arbitrage• As an example, if an acquiring company agrees to

purchase a target company’s stock at an Exchange Ratio of 1.5x, then at closing, the acquirer will deliver 1.5 shares for every share of the target’s stock

• Assume that just prior to when the transaction is announced, the target’s stock price is $25, the acquirer’s stock is $20, and it will be six months until the transaction closes

• Since 1.5 acquirer shares will be delivered, the value to be received by target company shareholders is $30 per share

• However, because there is some probability the acquisition doesn’t close in 6 months, the target company stock will likely trade below $30 until the date of closing

35 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 36: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Merger Arbitrage• If the target stock trades at, for example, $28 after announcement,

for every share of target stock that risk arbs purchase at $28, they will simultaneously short 1.5 shares of the acquirer’s stock

• This trade enables risk arbs to profit from the probable increase in the target’s share price up to $30, assuming the closing takes place, while hedging its position (the shares received by risk arbs at closing will be delivered to the parties that originally lent shares to them)

• The objective for risk arbs is to capture the spread between the target company’s share price after announcement of the deal and the offer price for the target company, as established by the Exchange Ratio, without exposure to a potential drop in the acquirer’s share price

• However, if the transaction doesn’t close or the terms change, the risk arbs’ position becomes problematic and presents either a diminution in profit or a potential loss

36 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 37: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Merger ArbitrageShare for Share Merger Arbitrage

• The Arbitrageur gainso The Arbitrage spread (difference

between Target stock when acquisition announced and bid price when closes)

o Dividends paid on Target stocko Interest on proceeds of short selling

(less borrow costs and dividends paid on shorted Acquirer stock)

• The arbitrage spread can be accentuated if the bid is repriced higher, possibly through the presence of another bidder

• The Target stock will drop to the pre-announcement price (or below), causing losses

• The Acquirer stock price might increase, causing a loss on the short position

UPSIDE:The Deal Closes

DOWNSIDE:The Deal Does NOT Close

In most cases, the amount an arbitrageur will lose if the deal does not close far outweighs the gain if the deal closes

37 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 38: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Distressed Securities Distressed securities investment strategies are directed at companies

in distressed situations such as bankruptcies and restructurings or companies that are expected to experience distress in the future

Distressed securities are stocks, bonds and trade or financial claims of companies in, or about to enter or exit, bankruptcy or financial distress

The prices of these securities fall in anticipation of financial distress when their holders choose to sell rather than remain invested in a financially troubled company (and there is a lack of buyers)

If a company that is already distressed appears ready to emerge from this condition, the prices of the company’s securities may increase

Due to the market’s inability to always properly value these securities, and the inability of many institutional investors to own distressed securities, these securities can sometimes be purchased at significant discounts to their risk adjusted value

38 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 39: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

Distressed SecuritiesDistressed Securities Return

Capitalize on the knowledge, flexibility, and patience that creditors of a company do not have

Bonds Many institutional investors, like pension funds, are barred by their charters or regulators from directly buying or holding below investment-grade bonds (Ba1 / BB+ or lower)

Bank Debt Banks often prefer to sell their bad loans to remove them from their books and use the freed-up cash to make other investments

Trade Claims Holders of trade claims are in the business of producing goods or providing services and have limited expertise in assessing the likelihood of being paid once a distressed company files for bankruptcy

39 L3: Hedge Fund Strategies

Page 40: Hedge Fund Investment Strategies

More on distressed securitiesPage 277- 281, Jaeger bookProfessional investors in distressed companies

assume that the equity is worthless, so their task is to decide which class of debt offers the most attractive risk-reward tradeoff.

Value of the strategyInvestment skill (to tell which security has value)Offer liquidity to traditional investors who prefer

investment gradesDistressed debt investors try to invest in good

companies that have a bad capital structureDistressed debt market is relatively small and it is

linked to the broader economy.

L3: Hedge Fund Strategies40