8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 1/14

“OF BEARS, BUMBLE-BEES AND SPIDERS: THE

ROLE OF EXPATRIATES IN CONTROLLINGFOREIGN SUBSIDIARIES”ANNE-WIL HARZING (2001)

 JOURNAL OF WORLD BUSINESS, 36(4), 336-379Se!"#$ G$%&' 2 0*03*1

+$ee"e$. R%!!" /Ne! (143), #!e A%$ (13143) Re5e# %#

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 2/14

Introdut!on

I'%$#"e %8 I"e$"#!%"# $#"8e$

D!e$e"e Be:ee" Be#$, B&5e-Bee #";S'!;e$

<%$e A$=&e"/e%;%%=>

S&''%$!"= A$=&e"? E'!$!# E@!;e"e

D!e$e" R%e 8%$ D!e$e" S!&#!%"

/e%;%%=!# L!!#!%"

O&$ <$!!&e

F%%; 8%$ %&=

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 3/14

I"#ort$n% o& Int%rn$t!on$' Tr$n(&%r(

Or)$n!($t!on$' &unt!on( o& !nt%rn$t!on$' tr$n(&%r(:

to *'' #o(!t!on(, d%+%'o# "$n$)%"%nt, ontro' $nd

oord!n$t% r%$t!n) or)$n!($t!on$' d%+%'o#"%nt

I"8%$#%"$%

e#"!!"$e#!"=>!'%$#" !"

/N< (D% +$###;,

194?B#$e G%#,

199)C

E!!"=!e$#&$e

!!e; #";!="%$e e

%$=#"!#!%"# 8&"!%"8&e; 5>

!"e$"#!%"#$#"8e$ %8#"#=e$C

 ! #$!e$e;$ee

! 5##"e5> e#!"!"=

e%$=#"!#!%"# 8&"!%" %8!"e$"#!%"#$#"8e$C

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 4/14

D!%r%n%( B%t.%%n B%$r, Bu"/'%-B%%($nd S#!d%r(

r"$' D!r%t Contro' So!$'!($t!on In&or"$' Co""un!$t!

• Ee&#e'e$%"#*&&$#%"$% ;!$e>#"; !";!$e>

• B&$e#&$#!*F%$

#!e;• <#"

$e'#e*%'!e" H ;e!!%"-#!"=

• Le@e %8;%!"#"e

•<$e#e $%'%!"#!%"5e:ee"&5!;!#$> #";HC

• <%"$% $%&=%!#!#!%"

• <$e#e !"8%$#%&"!#!%""e:%$

(!"!"= !"%

• S'!;e$ :e#@e#" !"8%$#%&"!#!%""e:%$C

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 5/14

Cor% Ar)u"%nt:

Three mechanisms, one goal.

“To help ensure the proper behaviours of people in

the organisation.” (Merchant, 1985)

 e$e ! # !="!#" '%!!@e %$$e#!%" 5e:ee"e e@e %8 e'#$!#e '$ee"e #"; # $ee >'e

%8 %"$%. F%$# D!$e E'#$!#e <%"$% (Be#$),S%!#!#!%" (B&5e Bee) #"; I"8%$#

<%&"!#!%" (S'!;e$)C

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 6/14

M%t0odo'o)1

22

234

D!e$e"<%&"$!e

Re'%"e

R#e

L#$=e-S#e I"e$"#!%"#/#! S&$@e>

5673W%>O:"e;S&5!;!#$!e%8 /N<

104/N<S#'e;(H !"

 J#'#", US

#"; E&$%'e

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 7/14

Su##ort!n) Ar)u"%nt(:E"#!r!$' E+!d%n%

A%&= # $ee $e#!%"!'#$e !=> !="!#", e

%$$e#!%" ! $%"=e$ 8%$ ;!$e

e'#$!#e %"$% #" ! ! 8%$e :% !";!$e >'e %8 %"$%

(''C 371)C

W!e e'#$!#e #''e#$ %'e$8%$ e!$ $%e # 5e#$ !"#"> =!@e" !&#!%", e!$ $%e #

5&5e5ee #"; '!;e$ #$e%$e !'%$#" !" %e

!&#!%" #" %e$ (''C 372)C

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 8/14

D!%r%nt Ro'%( &or D!%r%nt S!tu$t!on(

• e %$e ;e'e";e" e &5!;!#$> ! %" eH, e %$e ;!$e %"$% &e; 5> ee'#$!#eC

• I"8%$# %"$% e#"! #$e 5e%!"=%$e !'%$#", #"; e'#$!#e #" #!e@e! >'e %8 %"$%C

•

W! $!!"= e$=e$ #"; #&!!!%", 5e#$ #";5&5e5ee #$e 5% "ee#$>, 5e#&e e'e$%"# %"# #!e@e; $%&=e'#$!#!%" ! e #!" :#> % !"e=$#e :%

%'#"!eC +>!# '$ee"e ! e$e8%$e

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 9/14

M%t0odo'o)!$' L!"!t$t!on(

A #e $e'%";e"

S&;> %"> 8%&e; %" Ge$#" /N<CRee#$ %&; 5e %"!"&e; !" %&"$!e

# &e !"8%$# %"$% %$eC/e#'%$ #$e &5e!@e $e'%";e"#":e$ != "% !"% e #e=%$!eC

/#! &$@e> e#> % %5&$e e $&O"> %%e; # $#"8e$ %8 e'#$!#e 8$%e#;&#$e$ % &5!;!#$!e

S#'e !"&;e; %"> :%> %:"e;

&5!;!#$!e

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 10/14

Our Cr!t!8u%

• e '#'e$ ;%e "% '$%@!;e #;e&#ee'!$!# e!"= %8 e ;!$e*!";!$e%"$% $%eC

• A#;e!#> %"@!"!"= 5& e";!"= %&e'#$!#e #" 5e %>, e$e8%$e 8$% #%$=#"!#!%"# 'e$'e!@e :e 5e!e@e e$e

#$e K#: !" e &;>C

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 11/14

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 12/14

Food For T0ou)0t

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 13/14

8/9/2019 Harzing: of bears, bumble bees and spiders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/harzing-of-bears-bumble-bees-and-spiders 14/14

 #" %&MA"> &e!%"