HANSA TRUST AGM/media/Files/H/Hansa... · Templeton Emerging Markets Investment Trust Tetragon...
Transcript of HANSA TRUST AGM/media/Files/H/Hansa... · Templeton Emerging Markets Investment Trust Tetragon...
HANSA TRUSTAGMJuly 2017
2
HANSA TRUSTDirectors’ Holdings and Applied Discount
As at 30 June 2017
NAV £319.6m
NAV per share (p) 1,331.8
Ordinary Share Price (p) 912.5
‘A’ Ordinary Share Price (p) 898.5
Director Ordinary Shares ‘A’ Ordinary Shares
Value of holding at Share Price
Value of holding at NAV
Discount
William Salomon 2,115,869 98,700 £20,194,124 £29,494,261 £9,300,136
Jonathan Davie 4,000 26,000 £270,110 £399,549 £129,439
Alex Hammond‐Chambers 4,900 10,600 £139,954 £206,433 £66,480
Lord Oxford 1,850 1,850 £33,504 £49,278 £15,774
Geoffrey Wood 1,000 2,000 £27,095 £39,955 £12,860
TOTAL 2,127,619 139,150 £20,664,786 £30,189,475 £9,524,689
HANSA TRUSTAGMThe Edison GroupJuly 2017
Edison Investment ResearchEdison Advisors
The Edison Group
An Overview of Edison
Introduction to Edison Group
Edison at a glance
“An investment research and advisory company”
Edison Investment ResearchTwo operating brands:
Edison Advisors
Established 2003
Regulated across all key territories
Corporate client base of 400+ companies across 40+ countries
Preferred partner with leading stock exchanges around the world
Deep sector expertise – multiple sectors
Market leading investment research platform
Different advisory offering, fully leveraging our research platform
People
110+Analysts & support
80+Reports published last year
2,500+Investor meetings
(per annum)
2,000+Countries research read
100+North America Pan Europe Middle East
Asia Pacific
Edison Investment Research is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority
1
Edison Business Model
EDISONINVESTMENTRESEARCH
Equity research serviceAward winning Read in 100+ countries Top ranked on Google InvestorTrack® ‐ readership tracking
Buy‐side services*Expert speaker eventsSector briefingsWhite papers and sector reportsRegular contact with funds*All provided at Edison’s expense
Compliance wall
Investor relationsFull service IR Investor marketingInvestor targetingRoadshows Market feedback
ConsultingDue Diligence
EDISONADVISORS
Commercial/Vendor
Independent valuationsFundraising/IPO/Pre‐IPO reportsStrategy Reports Transaction Support
2
3
Exchanges
Large market cap
Mid to small market cap
Private companies
Some of our Corporate Clients
Edison Research
Investment companies client list
4
Aberdeen New Thai Aberdeen Private Equity FundAcorn Income FundBankers Investment Trust (The)BB BiotechBB Healthcare TrustBiotech Growth Trust (The)BlackRock Greater Europe Blackrock Latin American Investment TrustBrunner Investment Trust (The) Canadian General InvestmentsCVC Credit Partners European OpportunitiesDeutsche Beteiligungs AGDiverse Income TrustEuropean Assets Trust European Investment Trust (The)F&C Managed Portfolio TrustFidelity China Special Situations Fidelity European ValuesFinlab AGFinsbury Growth & Income Trust Foreign & Colonial Investment TrustGerman Startups AGHansa Trust HarbourVest Global Private Equity HBM Healthcare Investments AGHeliad AGHenderson Far East Income TrustHenderson International Income Trust Henderson Alternative Strategies Invesco Asia TrustIS Private EquityJPMorgan European Smaller Companies TrustJPMorgan Global Convertibles Income FundJPMorgan Global Growth & Income Trust
Jupiter UK Growth Investment TrustJupiter GreenJupiter US Smaller Companies TrustLaw Debenture Corporation Lazard World Trust FundLowland Investment CompanyMartin Currie Asia Unconstrained TrustMartin Currie Global Portfolio TrustMerchants Trust (The)MIC AGMiton Global Opportunities Mutares AGQatar Investment FundScherzer & Co AGSchroder AsiaPacific FundScottish Investment TrustScottish Oriental Smaller CompaniesSecurities Trust of ScotlandSeneca Global Income and Growth TrustStandard Life Equity Income TrustStandard Life Investments European Private Equity Standard Life Investments Property Income Trust Standard Life UK Smaller CompaniesTempleton Emerging Markets Investment Trust Tetragon Financial GroupTR European Growth Trust UK Commercial Property TrustUtilico Emerging MarketsVietnam Enterprise InvestmentsVinacapital Vietnam Opportunity Fund Witan Investment TrustWitan Pacific Investment TrustWorldwide Healthcare Trust
Edison Research
Global Unrestricted Distribution & Discovery
Edison TV
Conferences
5
Edison Research
Hansa Trust: research note distribution
6
• Direct email to thousands of fund managers, institutional investors, IFAs and private client brokers
• 25 online financial investment partners, including Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters and Factset
• Hargreaves Lansdown via RNS (£70bn AUM)• Alliance Trust Savings (£14bn AUM)• Interactive Investor (£19bn AUM)
• Dedicated distribution to New Zealand investors, including on FundSource, the leading research house of the NZ stock exchange
• An announcement on social media accounts (including Twitter, LinkedIn, GooglePlus), notifying relevant investors and journalists
Investor OutreachInvestor Relations
Strategic Investor Relations Programme: Hansa Trust
7
Build understanding of the investment case
Build shareholder register
Improve stock liquidity
Emphasis on quality investors
Full spectrum of investors
Narrow discount
Programme detailsStrategy goals
Research reports with global open‐access distribution
Investor perception / market pulse studies
Highly targeted professional investor meetings
Research readership – InvestorTrack
Shareholder register analysis – Hansa & peer trusts
Proprietary investor relationships
Meeting feedback
Edison TV
Media engagement
Retail investor events
Investor OutreachInvestor Relations
Highlights: regional wealth manager meetings June 2017
8
A number of investors were familiar with Hansa Trust but had not met with the company in some time. Edison facilitated a first ‘reconnect’ meeting and many investors were keen to schedule further follow up meetings
Many investors felt that the wide discount and portfolio repositioning made Hansa potentially attractive
All investors were supportive of Alec Letchfield and his strategy on shaping the portfolio: ‘Alec is a safe pair of hands’
Investors would like improved articulation of the Ocean Wilsons investment case
Frankfurt+49 (0)69 78 8076 960
Schumannstrasse 34b60325, FrankfurtGermany
London+44 (0)20 3077 5700
280 High HolbornLondon WC1V 7EEUnited Kingdom
New York+1 646 653 7026
295 Madison Avenue,18th Floor, New York, NY 10017 United States
Sydney+61 (0)2 9258 1161
Level 12, Office 1205, 95 Pitt StreetSydney, NSW 2000, Australia
Contact Us
www.edisongroup.com
Charities we support
Tel Aviv+972 (0)54 978 4802
Medinat Yehudim 60Herzlia PituachIsrael 4676652
HANSA TRUSTAGMPortfolio Manager ReportJuly 2017
HANSA TRUSTRecap………our aims and aspirations for Hansa Trust
15
• A proprietor‐led vehicle with strong alignment (rather than an asset gathering entity)
• A multi‐asset fund that offers something different from most other portfolios in the market place
• A fund aspiring to generate long‐term returns and not short‐term focused
• A focus on real risk rather than relative returns
• Dynamically managed asset allocation
• A fund providing access to best‐in‐class managers not normally available to the man on the street and direct equity investments
HANSA TRUSTRecap…………Strategic review
16
63.0%
23.3%
13.7%
31 December 2013
UK Equity Wilson Sons Eclectic
15.3%
33.3%
19.6%
20.1%
11.7%
30 June 2017
Global Equity Core Regional Funds Wilson Sons Eclectic Diversifying
Performance Review
17
HANSA TRUSTPerformance to end June 2017
18
Source: Hansa Trust internal, unaudited, data: Bloomberg, Morningstar, FTSE
Financial YTD Year to end March 2017 1 year(to end June 2017)
5 years (p.a.)(to end June 2017)
10 years (p.a.)(to end June 2017)
Performance (NAV) 3.7% 22.0% 23.9% 7.2% 3.6%
Performance ex. OWHL 4.2% 14.1% 18.7% 9.8% 3.1%
Benchmark 0.8% 3.3% 3.2% 3.2% 3.9%
Ordinary Share 6.6% 21.1% 31.2% 5.7% 0.1%
A’ Ordinary Share 7.1% 19.3% 29.5% 6.5% 0.8%
50
75
100
125
150
Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11 Jun-12 Jun-13 Jun-14 Jun-15 Jun-16 Jun-17
NAV cum income Benchmark
19
HANSA TRUSTPerformance post strategy change (end March 2014 to end June 2017)
Cash performance is negative because of FX/loans held by Hansa Trust
‐5.0%
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
35.0%
40.0%
Global Equities Core Regional Funds Eclectic & DiversifyingAssets (ex OWIL)
Ocean Wilsons HoldingsLimited
Cash Benchmark
54,279
,110
4,58
8,69
94,23
9,71
04,23
6,06
73,44
8,99
42,30
3,07
62,02
5,27
31,89
9,43
01,01
9,54
191
2,60
765
4,23
457
6,82
910
8,93
171
,386
39,303
3,66
5,28
22,67
2,97
41,75
2,87
51,64
1,42
299
1,81
998
5,86
525
0,50
719
0,20
212
9,72
311
8,69
560
,769
3,45
6
4,62
6,98
252
,320
949,95
757
3,84
334
8,07
681
,765
79,131
51,261
12,350
447,44
939
,194
10,188
,393
2,37
0,68
736
1,53
72,19
0,31
2
79,041
225,61
71,75
8,62
9
35,160
58,870
70,000
77,211
308,16
51,13
0,51
72,58
0,17
5 148,06
420
2,69
3
7,67
4
£‐
£10,000,000
£20,000,000
£30,000,000
£40,000,000
£50,000,000
£60,000,000
£70,000,000
Select Equ
ity Offs
hore
Vulcan
Value
Equ
ityFind
lay Pa
rk American
SISF Asia
n To
tal R
eturn
Goo
dhart: Ha
njo
Adelph
i Eur Select E
quity
BlackR
ock Eu
r Hed
geIndu
s Jap
an Lon
g Only
Prince Stree
t Inst
NTA
sian Discov
ery
Vang
uard Dev Eur ex UK
BlackR
ock Fron
tiers
iSha
res M
SCI EM
SR Globa
l Frontiers
iSha
res E
uro Stoxx
Ode
y Ab
solute Return
Pershing
Squ
are
UBM
Hansteen
Holding
sAltitud
e Group
Broo
ks M
acdo
nald
NCC
Group
Hilto
n Fo
odAc
ertec
Bayer A
GSo
ftba
nkAlph
abet
Interactive Brok
ers
CVS He
alth
Howard Hu
ghes Corp
Berkshire
Hatha
way
Work Group
White M
ountains
Libe
rty Globa
lAll Leisure
Goa
ls So
ccer Cen
tres
GAM
Star T
ech
SPDR
MSC
I World Fins
Globa
l Event Partners L
tdField Street Offs
hore
Hudson
Bay
MKP
Opp
Offs
hore
Keynes Dynam
ic B Strategy
Cantab
CCP
Core Macro
CZ Abs Alpha
UCITS
Argentiere Fun
dSchrod
er GAIA Blue
Tren
dJLP Cred
it Opp
BNY Ab
s Return Bo
nd Fun
dGladw
yne GBP
Ocean
Wilson
s Holding
sDV
4 Ltd
Cash/FX
Holdings so
ld during pe
riod
Total
20
HANSA TRUSTPerformance contribution since strategy change (end March 2014 to end June 2017)
Core Regional Funds Equities Eclectic ‐ SectorDiversifying ‐Alternatives
Diversifying –Fixed Income
Ocean Wilsons HoldingsPrivate Equity
Market Outlook & Portfolio Positioning
21
HANSA TRUSTOutlook......The business cycle is maturing
22
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
Forw
ard P/E
S&P 500 P/E Ratio
+/‐1 St Dev S&P 500 Fwd PE
Markets are becoming expensive and the rally is getting older
HANSA TRUSTOutlook…….but we do not believe we have reached the top yet
23
303540455055606570
80859095
100105110115120
Jan‐08
Sep‐08
May‐09
Jan‐10
Sep‐10
May‐11
Jan‐12
Sep‐12
May‐13
Jan‐14
Sep‐14
May‐15
Jan‐16
Sep‐16
May‐17
German IFO US ISM Man. PMI (RHS)
UK Man. PMI (RHS)
Bear markets and recession tend to go hand‐in‐hand Economic indicators remain positive
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
0‐19 20‐39 40‐59 60‐79 80+
2016 Population Profile
Frontier BRIC Developed
HANSA TRUSTPortfolio positioning…….frontier markets
24
Source: World Bank, IMF
Frontier market working age populations are in a sweet spot
020406080
100120140160180200
Dec‐20
10
Apr‐20
11
Aug‐20
11
Dec‐20
11
Apr‐20
12
Aug‐20
12
Dec‐20
12
Apr‐20
13
Aug‐20
13
Dec‐20
13
Apr‐20
14
Aug‐20
14
Dec‐20
14
Apr‐20
15
Aug‐20
15
Dec‐20
15
Apr‐20
16
Aug‐20
16
Dec‐20
16
Apr‐20
17
HANSA TRUSTPortfolio positioning…….Japan
25
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
‐
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
Mar‐10 Mar‐11 Mar‐12 Mar‐13 Mar‐14 Mar‐15 Mar‐16 Mar‐17
Divide
nds (Ye
n)
Buyb
acks (Y
en bn)
Buybacks executed (LHS)
Avg Dividend per share (RHS)
Japanese companies are increasingly paying out excess capital
Source: Goldman Sachs Research
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Feb‐20
11
Jun‐20
11
Oct‐201
1
Feb‐20
12
Jun‐20
12
Oct‐201
2
Feb‐20
13
Jun‐20
13
Oct‐201
3
Feb‐20
14
Jun‐20
14
Oct‐201
4
Feb‐20
15
Jun‐20
15
Oct‐201
5
Feb‐20
16
Jun‐20
16
Oct‐201
6
Feb‐20
17
Jun‐20
17
HANSA TRUSTPortfolio positioning…….Europe
26
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
P/BROE
Europe ROE Europe PB
Source: Bloomberg, MSCI
European returns have barely recovered post the Global Financial Crisis
020406080
100120140160180200
Nov
‐200
7
May‐200
8
Nov
‐200
8
May‐200
9
Nov
‐200
9
May‐201
0
Nov
‐201
0
May‐201
1
Nov
‐201
1
May‐201
2
Nov
‐201
2
May‐201
3
Nov
‐201
3
May‐201
4
Nov
‐201
4
May‐201
5
Nov
‐201
5
May‐201
6
Nov
‐201
6
May‐201
7
HANSA TRUSTPortfolio positioning…….defensive investments
27
We have added a basket of more defensive investments, but not government bonds
0
5
10
15
2010 year government bond yields
US UK
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
HANSA TRUSTConclusion
28
• Markets are in the more mature stages of their lifecycle
• Higher valuations remove the safety net, can lead to higher portfolio volatility and being susceptible to disappointment
• For this reason we are getting prepared to add to more defensive positions as the cycle evolves
• It is also the case though that for now we see continued upside in equities. Often the later, momentum stages of stock market cycles can represent powerful periods for performance
Appendix
29
65,126
,265
2,76
5,48
22,48
2,18
02,43
1,48
52,02
5,60
51,93
5,35
41,85
6,09
181
3,96
076
6,63
663
1,50
960
3,31
341
4,28
737
9,73
510
8,93
171
,386
39,303
2,02
7,03
51,71
1,62
51,63
2,44
21,02
0,15
475
7,01
025
0,50
723
3,50
319
0,20
212
9,72
311
8,69
560
,769
35,000
3,45
6
3,84
6,54
252
,320
1,01
4,53
829
1,17
218
7,63
194
,806
86,733
45,333
12,350
1,81
8,67
536
,661
31,226
,570
221,37
6 6,54
4,83
7
79,041
930,11
6
35,160
58,870
77,211
308,16
53,60
9,32
1 148,06
421
8,15
7
7,67
4
376,87
9
£‐
£10,000,000
£20,000,000
£30,000,000
£40,000,000
£50,000,000
£60,000,000
£70,000,000
£80,000,000
Goo
dhart: Ha
njo
Find
lay Pa
rk American
Vulcan
Value
Equ
ityIndu
s Jap
an Lon
g Only
SISF Asia
n To
tal R
eturn
Select Equ
ity Offs
hore
Adelph
i Eur Select E
quity
Vang
uard Dev Eur ex UK
Prince Stree
t Inst
NTA
sian Discov
ery
BlackR
ock Eu
r Hed
gePe
rshing
Squ
are
BlackR
ock Fron
tiers
iSha
res M
SCI EM
SR Globa
l Frontiers
iSha
res E
uro Stoxx
Ode
y Ab
solute Return
Hansteen
Holding
sAltitud
e Group
Broo
ks M
acdo
nald
UBM
Hilto
n Fo
odAc
ertec
Goa
ls So
ccer Cen
tres
Bayer A
GSo
ftba
nkAlph
abet
Interactive Brok
ers
Work Group
CVS He
alth
Howard Hu
ghes Corp
Berkshire
Hatha
way
White M
ountains
Libe
rty Globa
lNCC
Group
GAM
Star T
ech
SPDR
MSC
I World Fins
Globa
l Event Partners L
tdField Street Offs
hore
Hudson
Bay
Keynes Dynam
ic B Strategy
MKP
Opp
Offs
hore
Cantab
CCP
Core Macro
CZ Abs Alpha
UCITS
Argentiere Fun
dSchrod
er GAIA Blue
Tren
dJLP Cred
it Opp
BNY Ab
s Return Bo
nd Fun
dGladw
yne GBP
Ocean
Wilson
s Holding
sDV
4 Ltd
Cash/FX
Holdings so
ld during pe
riod
Total
30
HANSA TRUSTPerformance contribution one year to end June 2017
Core Regional Funds Equities Eclectic ‐ SectorDiversifying ‐Alternatives
Diversifying –Fixed Income
Ocean Wilsons Holdings
Private Equity
14.1%
5.6%
7.2%
4.9%
1.5%
15.3%
3.8%
1.0%
7.7%
10.9%
3.7%
1.9%
19.6%
2.8%
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
HANSA TRUSTCurrent Portfolio Positioning (as at 30 June 2017)
31
Source: Hansa Trust internal, unaudited
Core Regional Funds Thematic / Diversified Strategic
26.5%
18.5%
8.5%0.7%7.3%
7.9%
20.5%
1.5%8.6%
Geographic Exposure
North America UK Developed EuropeEmerging Europe Japan Asia Pacific ex JapanLatin America Middle East and Africa Diversifying Hedge Funds
1.2% 2.2%26.9%
10.8%
3.2%5.4%
11.2%
15.8%
1.9%0.4%
8.4%12.6%
Sector Exposure
Energy Materials IndustrialsConsumer Discretionary Consumer Staples HealthcareFinancials Information Technology Telecommunication ServicesUtilities Real Estate Diversifying Hedge Funds / Cash
32
HANSA TRUSTPortfolio Characteristics (as at 30 June 2017)
Look‐through analysis of Hansa Trust portfolio, including holdings in Ocean Wilson (Investments) Ltd *
2.8%
29.9%
12.7%
10.5%5.8%
4.0%
34.3%
Liquidity
Cash 1 Week 1 month 3 months 6 months > 6 months Fixed
40.0%
4.5%6.7%0.3%15.3%
19.6%
8.3%2.2% 3.0%Asset Type
Long Only Long‐Short Private EquityPrivate Debt Global Equities Wilson SonsDiversifying Hedge Funds Fixed Income Cash
* Based on top 30 holdings as announced by Ocean Wilsons Holdings 31 Dec 2016
HANSA TRUSTFees
33
PASSIVELow cost but guaranteed sub market returns. Also structurally biased towards those companies and sectors that are becoming more expensive and not managed for market risk
HANSA TRUST
THIRD PARTYCan be higher cost with two layers of fees in a fund structure. However, you can invest in best‐in‐class managers globally (unlikely to be able to do this internally), access all markets/sectors and sell those managers which are underperforming
INTERNALLower cost than third party managers and provides another source of alpha in a portfolio. However you are typically locked into your internal offering regardless of how good it is!
The fee debate is nuanced. Clearly you want to keep fees down to reduce friction but going low cost may work to your detriment in the longer term. We have blended elements of all the options in Hansa Trust.
34
HANSA TRUSTFees
Weighted average management fee = 1.21%. This includes the management fee paid to HansaCapital Partners LLP as well as management fees paid to third parties for the underlying funds.
49.3%
40.8%
5.2%4.5%
Annual 3rd Party Management Fees on Underlying Holdings
0% 0 < x ≤ 1% 1 < x ≤ 1.5% 1.5 < x ≤ 2%
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
Fees as %
of N
AV
Management Fee 3rd party fees Retail class Other costs
Our management fee is reduced from 1% as it is not charged on Ocean Wilsons Holdings
Third party fees within Hansa Trust
* Schroder Global Diversified Growth: 37.5% is externally / passively managed – not clear if third party fees are included.
Witan, Jupiter, Baring: third party fees are included in other costs.
Internally managed therefore no third party fees
Hansa Trust total = 1.57%
HANSA TRUSTFees
34
HANSA TRUSTInvestment process…..Global equity selection
36
Our global equity portfolio is composed of 20 – 45 names, is diversified, has a high active share and is built from the bottom up
IMPORTANT NOTICE
This presentation pack is issued by Hansa Capital Partners LLP, which is authorised and regulated by theFinancial Conduct Authority.
Hansa Capital Partners LLP is the Manager and Company Secretary to Hansa Trust PLC.
Investment Trusts are UK Public Listed companies and are not authorised or regulated by the FinancialConduct Authority.
The staff at Hansa Capital Partners LLP and/or the Directors of Hansa Trust PLC may hold positions inthe securities mentioned in this presentation or may buy, sell or offer to make a purchase or sale of suchsecurities from time to time.
This presentation pack is not a prospectus, does not contain any representations, and does not constituteor form part of any offer or invitation to buy, underwrite or solicit any offer to purchase securities, norshall it or any part of it form the basis of or be relied upon in connection with any contract therefore.
This presentation pack has been solely supplied for your information and you may not be reproduce it,distribute it to another person or publish it, in any case in whole and in part, for any purpose.The information contained in this pack is selective, is for background purposes only and is subject toamendment.
Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The price of shares and incomegenerated may fall as well as rise. An investor may not get back the amount invested.