Haldia Institute of Technology
-
Upload
prithwirajroy10 -
Category
Documents
-
view
227 -
download
0
Transcript of Haldia Institute of Technology
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
1/24
HALDIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
ECONOMIC LOAD DISPATCH PROBLEMCONSIDERING TRANSMISSION LOSS
BY
Abhishek Basu(06/EE/14)
Prithwiraj Roy(06/EE/19)
Kalyanbar Sarkar(06/EE/20)
Rajib Manal(06/EE/28)
Under
Mr.Budhaditya Biswas
DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING
HALDIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
2/24
The Head
Department of Electrical Engineering
Haldia Institute of TechnologyHIT/ICARE Complex
PO-Hatiberia,HaldiaMidnapore (E),West Bengal-721 657
Respected Sir,
In accordance with the requirements of the degree of bachelor of Technology in the department
of Electrical Engineering , Haldia Institute of Technology. I present the following thesis entitled
ECONOMIC LOAD DISPATCH PROBLEM CONSIDERING
TRANSMISSION LOSS.
This work was performed under the supervision of Mr.Budhaditya Biswas.
.
We declare that the work submitted in this thesis is our own except as acknowledge in the text
and references ,and has not been previously submitted for a degree at the Institute or any other
Institution.
Your Sincerely, Guided by
Abhishek Basu (06/EE/14) (....)
Prithwiraj Roy(06/EE/19)
Kalynbor Sarkar(06/EE/20)
Rajib Mandal(06/EE/28) Mr.Budhaditya Biswas
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
3/24
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the thesis entitled ECONOMIC LOAD DISPATCH PROBLEM
CONSIDERING TRANSMISSION LOSS
.is a bona fide work carried by mukesh kumar layak in partial fulfillment of the requirement for
the degree of BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY in ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING under
supervision of Mr.Budhaditya Biswas
during the academic year 2008-2009 & this has not been submitted elsewhere for a similardegree.
Countersigned by
Dr. Prithwiraj Purkait
Head
Department of Electrical Engineering
Haldia Institute of Technology
Haldia
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
4/24
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Apart from the efforts of ours, the success of this project depends largely on the encouragement
and guidelines of many others. I take this opportunity to express our gratitude to the people who
have been instrumental in the successful completion of this project.
I would like to show my greatest appreciation to Mr. Budhaditya Biswas
I cant say thank you enough for their tremendous support and help. I felt motivated and
encouraged every time when they came for helping me. Without their encouragement and
guidance this project would not have materialized.
The guidance and support received from other sir in department to this project, was vital for the
success of the project. I am grateful for their constant support and help.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
5/24
INTRODUCTION
Economic operation and planning of electric energy generating systems have always been given
proper attention in the electric power system industry. A saving in the cost of generation
represents a significant reduction in the operating cost (including the fuel cost) and this area has
warranted a great deal of attention from operating and planning engineers. The original problem
of economic dispatch of thermal power generating system used to be solved by numerous
methods. However, with the development of mathematical tools and advanced computational
methods, the economic scheduling of generators has become more accurate and can be applied
even in complex networks. Thermal scheduling being the prime importance, hydrothermal
coordination scheduling has emerged as another aspect of economic scheduling.
The basic purpose of economic operation of power system is to reduce fuel cost
for the operation of power system, economic operation is achieved when the generators in the
system share load to minimize overall generation cost. The main economic factor in the power
system operation is the cost of generation real power. In any power system, this cost has two
components, viz.,
The fixed being determined by the capital investment, interest charged on the moneyborrowed, tax paid, labour charge, salary given to staff and any other expenses thatcontinue irrespective of the load on the power system, and
The variable cost, a function of loading on generating units, losses, daily loadrequirements and purchase or sale of power.
The present text relating the economic operation of a power system is concerned about
minimising the variable cost factor only as the persons responsible for the operation of a
power system have little control over the fixed costs.
A power system is a mix of different modes of generation out of which thermal, hydro
and nuclear contribute a major share. However, economic operation has conventionally been
considered by proper scheduling of thermal or hydrogenation only or both, as, for the safety of
nuclear station, these types of stations are required to be operated at a fixed load only and there
is little scope to schedule the generation of nuclear type in practice.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
6/24
INPUT-OUTPUT OPERATIONAL CHARACTERISTICS OF DIFFERENT
POWER PLANTS
Thermal generating unit :
It is a well-established physical principal that with increase in difference between the
temperature and pressure of the input and output of any heat operated device (say, a turbine),
more mechanical power will be developed for the same amount of heat energy input. The
overall efficiency of thermal units is then determined by measuring he heat input, i.e. the
electrical energy output. Conventionally, this represents input-output curves and can be
developed for each generating unit involved. An efficient unit develops a given amount of
power with less fuel input. Hence, it has become the usual practice to load the more efficient
unit before loading the lesser efficient unit.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
7/24
Hydel power station:
The input-output characteristics for a typical hydro unit has been shown below. Though
apparently it may seen that the input of a hydro plant costs nothing, but a little thinking reveals
that the input water flow costs are due to capacity of the storage, agricultural requirement and
cost of running the plant during dry season. Also, artificial storage requirement imposes cost to
control the water output from the turbine due to agricultural needs.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
8/24
INCREMENTAL FUEL RATE (IFR) CURVES
The input-output curves, obtained from the operating data of power station, can be utilized to
get the incremental fuel rate (IFR or IR) curve from the relation.
IFR = incremental change in input /incremental change in output
Thus, by calculating the shape of the input-output curves at various points of operation, the
profile ofIFR can be obtained. IFR profiles for typical thermal and hydro power stations are
shown below.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
9/24
INCREMENTAL FUEL COST (IFC) CURVE
This curve can be obtained from IFR curve by multiplying the IFR by the cost of fuel per Kcal.
As in a power station, fuel cost governs the actual total cost. Hence, IFC is very significant in
economic loading of the generation unit. The IFC curves will be similar to the IFC characteristic
in configuration.
It is obvious that the slopes of the input-output curve and incremental fuel rate curve
do not change for different fuels or change in the cost of the same fuel. This time a multiplying
factor may be used so that the actual cost is a realistic one. The unit ofIFC (or simply the IC) is
unit of cost/MWhr.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
10/24
CONSTRAINTS IN ECONOMIC OPERATION OF POWER SYSTEM
Primary Constraints:
These constraints arise out of the necessity for the system to balance the load demand and
generation. They are also called equality constraints. If Pi and Qi are the scheduled electrical
generation, Ploadi and Qloadi are the respective load demands, it is obvious that the following
equation must be satisfied at the load bus.
Real power position at load bus
Pi Ploadi Pl = Mi = 0
Qi Qloadi - Ql = Ni = 0
Where Mi and Ni represents the power residuals at bus-i and Pl and Ql the power flow to the
neighbouring system given by
Pl = j=1N
ViVjYij cos(ij-ij)
Ql = j=1N
ViVjYij sin(ij-ij)
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
11/24
Secondary Constraints:
These constraints arise due o physical and operational limitations of respective units ands
components and are known as inequality constraints. Power inequality constraints are applicable
for proper operation; for each generator we should have a minimum and maximum permissible
output and the unit production should be constrained to ensure that
Pimin Pi Pimax, i= 1,2,., NP
Qimin Qi Qimax , i= 1,2,.., NQ
NP and NQ being the total number of real and reactive sources in the system.
In addition to their inequality constraints, another constraints Pi2+Qi2(Sirated)2 must be satisfied,
where Sirated denotes the complex power capability of the generating unit without any
overloading.
Dynamic Constraints:
These constraints arise where fast changes in generation are required for picking up the
increasing load demand. Here,
dPi(t)/dtat=min dPi(t)/dt dPi(t)/dtat=max
Similarly, for reactive power constraints,
dQi(t)/dtat=min dQi(t)/dt dQi(t)/dtat=max
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
12/24
Spare Capacity Constraints:
In order to account for the errors in load prediction, any sudden and fast change in load demands
and the inadvertent loss of scheduled generation, spare capacity constraints are frequentlyutilised. In this constraints, the total generation available at any time should be in excess of he
total anticipated load demand and any system loss by an amount not less than a specified
minimum spare capacity PSPS.
Therefore, Pig i=1N Pl+PSPS+Ploadi
For groups of generators, when all plants are not equally operationally suitable for taking up
additional load, this constraints is then given by
Pig Pl+PSPS+Ploadi
Where PSPS is the spare capacity generation for specified generators.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
13/24
Thermal Constraints of Transmission Lines:
These constrains arise when power injection (+S) or power drawl (-S) is allowed such that
[Simax] Str [Simin], i= 1,2,(tr)n
Where (tn)n represents the number of branches and Str the branch power transfer in MVA.
Bus Voltage and Angle Constraints:
These constraints arise in order to maintain voltage profle at load bus and limiting the overload
capacity.
Here,
Vimin Vi Vimax, i= 1,2,., N
imin i imax , j 1 j=2,.., M
whee N represents the number of units and M the number of loads in the system.
Operatonal Constraints:
In case the transformer tap position needs to be included for optimization, the tap position ai
should lie within the range available in the transformer, i.e. aimin ai aimax.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
14/24
Optimal Operation
Let us assume that it is known a priori which generators are to run to meet a particular loaddemand on the station. This is, given a station with h generators committed and the active power
load PD given, the real power generation PGi for each generator has to be allocated so as tominimize the total cost.
k
C= 7 Ci (PGi) (Rs/h) (1)
i=1
Subject to the inequality constraint
PGi min< PGi < PGi max i=1, 2... k (2)
Where PGi min and PGi max are the lower and upper real power generation limits of the ith
generator. Obviously,
k
7 PGi max >PD (3)
i=1
Considerations of spinning reserve require that
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
15/24
7 PGi max > PD
In Eq.1, it is assumed that the cost C is largely dependent on the real power
generation PGi and is insensitive to reactive power generation QGi.
Since Ci (PGi) is nonlinear, and Ci is independent of PGj (j{i), this is a separablenonlinear programming problem.
Only the inequality constraint of Eq. (3) is not effective, and between total power
generation and load demand is
k
7 PGi PD =0 (4)
i=1
The problem can then be solved by the method ofLagrange multipliers, which is used for
minimizing (or maximizing) a function with side conditions in the form of equality constraints.
Using this method we define an augmented cost function (Lagrangian) as
_ k
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
16/24
C = C -P (7 PGi PD ) (5)
i=1
Where P is the Lagrangian multiplier.
Minimization is achieved by the condition
_
xC /x PGi =0
or dCi/dPGi = P, i = 1, 2,, k (6)
Where dCi/dPGi is the incremental cost of the ith generator (units: Rs/MWh).
Equation (6) can be written as
dC1/dPG1 = dC2/dPG2=.. = dCn /dPGn =P (7)
i.e., optimal loading of generators corresponds to the equal incremental cost point of all the
generators. Equation (4), called the coordination equation numbering n is solved
simultaneously with the load demand in equation 13, to yield a solution for the Lagrange
multiplier P and the optimal generation of n generators.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
17/24
Economic allocation of generator between different plants in a
system considering system transmission loss( economic
dispatch) :
Economic allocation of generator between different generating plants has been
considered previously. When considering the economic allocation of generation between
different plants in an integrated system, the transmission losses are to be considered. This
leads to the dispatch of power in an economical way so as to make the overall cost to be
minimum , Let there be N plants in a system interconnected by transmission line and
ties
Let P1, P2,PNrefer to the generation ofN plants, respectively in MW . Let
the total load be Pload(constant)and loss in the lines be Pl.. The constraint equation will be
i=1N -Pi+Pl+Pload=R
(Rbeing the residual power and should approach zero during steady state power system
operation)
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
18/24
Let the net fuel input cost per hour be F which is the summation of fuel costs per hour of
each of the units governed by the generator powerP,
i.e. F =i=1NFi(Pi) Rs/hr
application of Lagrangian technique in order to optimize real power generation gives
L=F+,be the multiplier , necessary condition for cost function to be minimum has
been obtained by setting the first derivative of the lagrangian with respect to each of the
independent variable to zero, i,e. L/Pi =0.
Here L =F+(i=1N-Pi+Pl+Pload) and with L/Pi=0 we can write
dFi(Pi)/dPi (1-Pi/Pl)=0
or, dFi(Pi)/dPi + Pl/Pi =
this equation represents the modified economic operation criterion for the thermal plants
with transmission losses considered.
This equation may be written as
dFi(Pi)/dPi[1/1-Pl/Pi] =
or dF(Pi)/dPi*PFi =
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
19/24
PFi =[1- Pl/Pi]-1
PFi is known as Penalty factor the equation is known as the exact coordination equation .
in dFi(Pi)/dPi beang the incremental cost Pl/Pi known as the incremental
transmission loss. N number of optimum dispatch equations along with the constraint
suffice for determining (N+1) unknown P1,P2,..Pn and .
[i.e Pi-Pl=Pload
thus dF(Pi)/dPi*PFi = dF(Pi)/dPi*1/1- (Pi-Pl) = dF(Pi)/dPi * Pi-Pload
== dFi(Pi)/dPload
When dFi(Pi)/dPload is the incremental cost of the received power for plant i and the
penalty factor Pi-Pload . this also means that as Piincremental has a longer
proportion dissipated as loss, (Pi-Pload) approaches unity and the penalty factorPFi ,
increases without bound , thus for a larger penalty factor unit-i should be operated at low
increment cost implying a low power output.]
For N number of plants the coordination equation are given as
dF1(P1)/dP1 [1- dPl/dP1]= 0
dF2(P2)/dP2 [1- dPl/dP2]= 0
.
.
.
dFN(PN)/dPN [1- dPl/dPN]= 0
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
20/24
while the constraints equation is given by
i=1N(Pi)+Pload+Pl= R
If the numerical value f the partial derivative of the line losses with respect to each
generator output (dPl/dPi) is known, the generator output power may be adjusted to
satisfy the following equation
dFi(Pi)/dPi[1/(1-dPl/dPi)]=, i=1,2,3..N
the optimal economy is thus achieved when the products of the incremental fel cost times
the penalty factor is the same for all plants,
i.e.
dF1(P1)/dP1PF1= dF2(P2)/dP2PF2=..= dFN(PN)/dPNPFN =
stands here for the incremental cost f the received power in unit of (currency/MWhr)
and hense during economic operation of plants with losses being considered,
= Incremental fuel cost/(1-Incremental transmission loss)
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
21/24
Mathematical Calculation:
Consider a simple power system consisting of two generating plants and one load as shown in
below figure
Plant 1 I1 I2 plant 2
A C B
I1+I2
Fig: a simple system connecting two generating plants to one load
Let Rac, Rbc, and Rcd be the resistance of the lines AC,BC and CD respectively. For the given
system we can write the transmission loss as
PL = 3 I1^2 Rac + 3 I2^2 Rbc + 3 I1 + I2^2 Rcd (1)
If we assume that I1 and I2 are in phase,
I1 + I2 = I1 + I2 (2)
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
22/24
PL = 3 I1^2 (Rac + Rcd ) + 3 I2^2 (Rbc + Rcd ) + 6 I1 I2 Rcd
(3)
Let P1 and P2 be the three-phase power output of plants 1 and 2 at P.F of COS J1 andCOS J2, and V1 and V2 be the bus voltage at the plants.
I1 = P1 / (3 V1 COS J1 ), I2 = P2 / (3 V2 COS J2 )
Substituting the values of I1 and I2 in equation (3) we get
PL = P1^2 (Rac + Rcd ) + 2 P1P2 Rcd + P2^2 Rac + Rcd
V1 ^2 cos J1^2 V1 V2 cos J1cosJ2 V1^2 cos J1^2...(4)
Equation (4) can be written as
PL = P1^2 B11 + 2 P1P2B12 + P2^2 B22
Where, B11 = (Rac + Rcd ) , B12 = Rcd
V1 ^2 cos J1^2 V1 V2 cos J1cosJ2
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
23/24
B22 = Rac + Rcd .. (5)
V1^2 cos J1^2
The terms B11, B12 and B22 are called loss coefficient
If the voltage in equation (5) is line-to-line voltages in kilo volts and line resistances are in ohms,
the unit for the loss coefficients will be in reciprocal megawatts. Then, in equation (4) with three-
phase powers in megawatts, PL will be in megawatts also. If all the quantities are in per unit, te
coefficients will be in per unit.
It is seen that the loss coefficients depend on source voltages and p.f. The source voltages
and p.f depends on and vary with system conditions. However B coefficients are constants. It is
sufficiently accurate to calculate B coefficient for some average operating conditions use these
value for economic loading for all the load variations. However for large load variation or major
system changes, several sets of loss coefficients are used.
-
8/8/2019 Haldia Institute of Technology
24/24