Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels...

16
Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based Mechanisms for the completion of the internal Gas Market

Transcript of Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels...

Page 1: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck

IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011

Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels

European Federation of Energy Traders

1

Market Based Mechanisms for the completion of the internal Gas Market

Page 2: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 2September 28 2010, Madrid

EBP

EBP

Riga

Wilna

TallinnHelsinki

Warschau

Bukarest

BratislavaBudapest

Prag

Wien

Ljubljana

Berlin

Stockholm

Kopenhagen

Luxemburg

Amsterdam

Brüssel

Paris

Rom

London

Dublin

MadridSofia

Lisbon Athens

Riga

Wilna

TallinnHelsinki

Warschau

Bukarest

BratislavaBudapest

Prag

Wien

Ljubljana

Berlin

Stockholm

Kopenhagen

Luxemburg

Amsterdam

Brüssel

Paris

Rom

London

Dublin

MadridSofia

Lisbon Athens

Riga

Wilna

TallinnHelsinki

Warschau

Bukarest

BratislavaBudapest

Prag

Wien

Ljubljana

Berlin

Stockholm

Kopenhagen

Luxemburg

Amsterdam

Brüssel

Paris

Rom

London

Dublin

MadridSofia

Riga

Wilna

TallinnHelsinki

Warschau

Bukarest

BratislavaBudapest

Prag

Wien

Ljubljana

Berlin

Stockholm

Kopenhagen

Luxemburg

Amsterdam

Brüssel

Paris

Rom

London

Dublin

MadridSofia

Lisbon AthensLisbon Athens

Riga

Wilna

TallinnHelsinki

Warschau

Bukarest

BratislavaBudapest

Prag

Wien

Ljubljana

Berlin

Stockholm

Kopenhagen

Luxemburg

Amsterdam

Brüssel

Paris

Rom

London

Dublin

MadridSofia

Lisbon Athens

The internal market: 25 interconnected hubs or a single European Balancing Point?

Page 3: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 3September 28 2010, Madrid

More. Wider. Deeper. And governed by a consistent set of market rules.

Page 4: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 4September 28 2010, Madrid

Selected European Hub prices cal year +1

25

26

27

28

04.0

3.11

11.0

3.11

18.0

3.11

25.0

3.11

01.0

4.11

08.0

4.11

15.0

4.11

22.0

4.11

29.0

4.11

06.0

5.11

13.0

5.11

20.0

5.11

27.0

5.11

03.0

6.11

10.0

6.11

17.0

6.11

24.0

6.11

01.0

7.11

08.0

7.11

15.0

7.11

22.0

7.11

29.0

7.11

05.0

8.11

12.0

8.11

19.0

8.11

26.0

8.11

02.0

9.11

09.0

9.11

16.0

9.11

23.0

9.11

30.0

9.11

date

Eu

ro/M

Wh NBP

TTF

NCG

ZEE

In these NW markets wholesale prices have converged already, both y+1…

Page 5: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 5September 28 2010, Madrid

… and m+1

NBP: Current price for November 11: 65.6 p/th (25.7 €/MWh)

TTF: Current price for November 11: 25.75 €/MWh

NCG: Current price for November 11: 25.80 €/MWh

PEG:Current price for November 11: 25.95 €/MWh

PSV:Current price for November 11: 33.30 €/MWh (last trade; no market yet)

Page 6: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 6September 28 2010, Madrid

More market based mechanisms needed in 3 dimensions: capacity use

Capacity use: overselling and buy back

Flow

Contractual congestion

Q max technot used

Q booked

Meter readings

1 365

Flow

Max theoretical

Worst case

Negotiated

Page 7: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 7September 28 2010, Madrid

More market based mechanisms needed in 3 dimensions: capacity investment

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 8: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 8September 28 2010, Madrid

Shippers bid at pre-defined price steps, starting with regulated tariff

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 9: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 9September 28 2010, Madrid

Shippers bid at pre-defined price steps, starting with regulated tariff

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 10: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 10September 28 2010, Madrid

Shippers bid at pre-defined price steps, starting with regulated tariff

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 11: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 11September 28 2010, Madrid

Clearing price reached as soon as volumes ≤ available quantity

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 12: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 12September 28 2010, Madrid

You could add unlimited price steps – or define trigger level for new investment

Price

step

Quarter

Avail. qty S1 S2

5 160

4 120 80 50 130

3 120 80 60 140

2 120 100 80 180

1 120 120 100 220

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 13: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 13September 28 2010, Madrid

Agreed level of market demand triggers investment of specified incremental capacity

Price

step

Quarter

Avail. qty S1 S2

5 160 80 40 120

4 120 80 50 130

3 120 80 60 140

2 120 100 80 180

1 120 120 100 220

Capacity investment: economic tests

Page 14: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 14September 28 2010, Madrid

More market based mechanisms needed in 3 dimensions: balancing.

0

+

-

t

Q [MW]

inputs

offtakes

6 6

System buy

System sell

Line pack

Balancing: single end-of-day cash-out

Page 15: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck 15September 28 2010, Madrid

More market based mechanisms needed in 3 dimensions: balancing

Individual load curve (adjusted)

t

Q [MW]

Network user buy

Individual load curve

N.u. nomination d-1

update of end of day forecast for NDM

N.u. nomination d (adjusted)

Balancing: single end-of-day cash-out

Page 16: Gunnar Steck IFIEC Energy Forum Brussels, November 22 2011 Gunnar Steck November 22 2011 Brussels European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Market Based.

Gunnar Steck September 28 2010, Madrid 16

European Federation of Energy Traders

Amstelveenseweg 9981081 JS Amsterdam

Tel: +31 (0)20 5207970Email: [email protected]

www.efet.org