Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99%...

31
Bert Bakker (LUMC), Bart Janssen (SXS) Milan Macek (Charles University, Prague) Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps in the process Project acronym: 3Gb-TEST Project full title: " Introducing diagnostic applications of ‘3Gb-testing’ in human genetics " Name of the coordinating person: E. Bakker, Leiden Grant agreement no: 602269 September 2013- 2015 Bert Bakker (LUMC), Bart Janssen (SXS)

Transcript of Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99%...

Page 1: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

Bert Bakker (LUMC), Bart Janssen (SXS) Milan Macek (Charles University, Prague)

Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation

Critical steps in the process

Project acronym: 3Gb-TESTProject full title: " Introducing diagnostic applications of ‘3Gb-testing’ in human genetics "Name of the coordinating person: E. Bakker, LeidenGrant agreement no: 602269September 2013- 2015

Bert Bakker (LUMC), Bart Janssen (SXS)

Page 2: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

Research = Diagnostics

2005- 2010- 2013

2009-2012

http://www.eurogentest.org/.........../final_draft_02-12-2014_v2.pdf

Page 3: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

3

Guidelines

Page 4: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

4

Page 5: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

5

Guidelines for NGS diagnostics

Page 6: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

6

Page 7: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

7

Page 8: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES
Page 9: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

9

TERMINOLOGY

Page 10: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

10

For diagnostic purpose, only genes with a known (i.e. published and confirmed) relationship between the abberant genotype and the pathology should be included in the analysis.

Page 11: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

11

‘Core gene’ list

Page 12: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

12

4

Page 13: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

‘Scoring system’ for gene panel and exomes

Page 14: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

14

LIST centre

core NL (Yes/No)

core cente(Yes/No)

core (# genes)

Total #genes

Targeted/WES score

Avaragehorizontal coverage (20x depth) Implem.

CARDIOcardiomyopathy AMC YES YES 45 46targeted B Yescardiomyopathy Groningen YES YES 45 52 Yescardiomyopathy Maastricht YES YES 45 46 Yescardiomyopathy Rotterdam YES YES 47 47targeted Yescardiomyopathy Utrecht YES YES 45 69targeted B >99%; >95% Yes

Transduction dis. Utrecht YES YES 33 B >95% YesAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes

CARDIO panel

Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C YesVision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES CHearing impairment

Nijmegen No 119 WES Clens luxatie VUMC ja 5 targeted A ja

SENSORY NEURAL DISEASES “gene panel”

Page 15: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

15

Page 16: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

16

Page 17: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

17

Page 18: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

18

Page 19: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

19

The quality of a sample can/ should be evaluated at 3 levels:

Page 20: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

20

Page 21: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

21

Page 22: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

22

Page 23: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

23

Page 24: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

24

Page 25: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

25

Page 26: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

26

Page 27: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

27

Page 28: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

28

Reporting

Page 29: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

29

Research vs Diagnostics

Page 30: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

30

Page 31: Guidelines for NGS diagnostics Validation Critical steps ... fileAritmia AMC YES 47 targeted A >99% Yes CARDIO panel Vision dis. AMC No 232 WES C Yes Vision dis. Nijmegen No 272 WES

31