GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
-
Upload
nathan-lyttle -
Category
Documents
-
view
224 -
download
0
Transcript of GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
1/21
AO 91 Rev. 11111 Criminal Complaint
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COUR
United States
of
America
v.
Willard Dean Hall
Defendant s)
for the
Eastern District
of
Kentucky
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
CRIMIN L COMPL INT
MAY 12
2 16
EDWARD 8. ATKINS
U.S. Magistrate Judge
I the complainant in this case, state that the following is true
to
the best of my knowledge and belief.
On
or about the date(s)
of
_ 1_ 2_0_1_5_to_1
_1 _2_4 _2_0_15 n the comia of _n_o_tt n the
Eastern District
of
_e_n_tu_cc_k J__y the defendant(s) violated:
Code Section
18 U.S.C.
§
2251 (a)
18 U.S.C. § 2251 (a)(2)
18 U.S.C. § 2251(a)(4)
Offense Description
Production
of
Child Pornography - 2 counts
Receipt
of
Child Pornography - 2 counts
Possession
of
Child Pornography - 1 count
This criminal complaint is based on these facts:
SEE AFFIDAVIT
Continued on the attached sheet.
Sworn to before me and signed in my presence.
12--
Date: 051,Y1 72016
City and state:
Pikeville, Kentucky
rJ ~ : / : ' . ~ , : };t,.,{ 3;
;i,
Special
Agent
Thad Lambdin
Printed name
nd
title
$ ~ ~ . _ , i s ; I S ' ~ > Signed By
~ E d w a r d B . A t k i n s e ~
\ a . s r R • C ' ~ # United tates Magistrate
udge
Judge s signature
Hon. Edward B. Atkins, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name nd title
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 1 of 1 - Page ID#: 1
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
2/21
AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT
O
CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
I ,
Specia l
Agent
Thad Lambdin
of the
Federa l
Bureau
of
Inves t iga t ion , being
duly sworn
under
oath, do
hereby depose
and
s t a t e :
INTRODUCTION
1.
I have
been
a
Spec ia l Agent
with
the
Federa l
Bureau of
Inves t iga t ion ,
United
Sta t e s
Department
of
Jus t i ce ,
s ince Apr i l
2003,
and
am
cur ren t ly ass igned to the Louisv i l le Divis ion,
London
Resident Agency. My
re spons ib i l i t i e s
inc lude the
i n v es t ig a t io n of var ious c r imina l offenses , inc lud ing crimes
involving
the sexual
exp lo i t a t ion
of ch i ld ren ;
s p e c i f i c a l l y the
product ion,
di s t r ibu t ion ,
r ece ip t
and possess ion of ch i ld
pornography.
From
2000
to
2003,
and
p r i o r
to
becoming
a
Specia l
Agent,
I
was
a
Systems Adminis t ra tor for both the county and
c i t y of Huntington,
Indiana ,
where
in add i t ion
to my pr imary
re spons ib i l i t i e s ,
I as s i s t ed
the Huntington Pol ice Department
with reviews of s u s p ec t s computers for ch i ld pornography. Pr ior
to
t h i s
employment
1992
to 2000),
I
was
a
Patrolman
with
the
Huntington Ci ty Pol ice Department, Huntington, Indiana
for
approximate ly 8 1/2
years .
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 1 of 19 - Page ID#: 2
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
3/21
2.
In
the
course
of
my employment with
the
Federal
Bureau of
Inves t iga t ion , I have par t i c ipa t ed
in
the execu t ion of search
warran ts r e su l t ing in the se izu re of computers ,
magnet ic s torage
media for computers, o ther
e lec t ron ic
media, and
o ther
i tems
evidencing v io la t ions of federa l law.
3.
As a federa l
agent ,
I am author ized
to
i nves t iga te
v io la t ions of
United
Sta t e s laws
and to
execute warrants i ssued
under
the
au thor i ty
of the
United
Sta te s .
4.
I am
i nves t iga t ing the
cr iminal a c t i v i t i e s o f
Willard Dean
Hall , who res ides a t 5326 WY 1087
E,
Mousie, Kentucky 41839. As
wi l l be
shown
below, I submit there i s probable cause
t o be l i eve
t ha t Willard Dean Hal l has produced, d i s t r i bu t ed and possessed
ch i ld
pornography,
i n v io la t ion
o f
18
U.S.C.
§ §
2251 a) ,
2252 a) 2) ,
2252 a) 4) .
5.
The s tatements in t h i s a f f i d a v i t
are
based in par t on
in format ion provided by
Kentucky
Sta t e Pol ice KSP)
Detec t ive
Joseph Dials , ass igned
to SP
Post 13, Hazard, Kentucky, and on
my
i nves t iga t ion
of
t h i s
mat te r .
Since
t h i s a f f idav i t
i s
being
submit ted fo r the l im i t ed purpose of secur ing a cr imina l
complaint , I have not
inc luded each
and every
fac t
known to me
concerning
t h i s i nves t iga t ion .
2
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 2 of 19 - Page ID#: 3
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
4/21
ST TUTORY AUTHORITY
6.
This
i n v es t ig a t io n concerns a l l e ge d v io l a t i o n s of 18 U.S.C.
§ § 2251 a) , 2252 a) 2), 2252 a) 4), r e l a t i n g to m a t e r i a l
involv ing
the
sexual ex p lo i t a t i o n o f minors .
a . 18 U.S.C. § 2251 a) p ro h ib i t s using persuading
inducing or e n t i c i ng a minor
to
engage in s e xua l ly
e x p l i c i t
conduct
for
t he
purpose
o f
producing
vi sua l
dep ic t ions o f such
conduct
and
t h a t t he s e de p i c t i ons
were
produced using mate r i a l s t h a t had been mailed
sh ipped or t r a n spo r t e d in i n t e r s t a t e o r fo re ign
commerce.
b . 18
U.S.C. § 2252 a) 2)
p ro h ib i t s
knowingly
r ece iv ing
o r
d i s t r i b u t i n g
by computer
or
mai l
any
v i sua l de p ic t i on
of minors
engaging
in
s e xua l ly e x p l i c i t conduct
t h a t
has
been mailed sh ipped or t r anspor ted in
i n t e r s t a t e or
fo re ign
commerce. That se c t i on a l s o p ro h ib i t s knowingly
reproduc ing any v i sua l de p ic t i on o f minors engaging in
sexua l ly e x p l i c i t conduct for d i s t r i b u t i o n
in
i n t e r s t a t e
or
fo re ign
commerce
by
any
means,
inc lud ing
by computer
or
the
mai l .
c . 18 U.S.C. § 2252 a)
4)
p ro h ib i t s possess ing one or more
books,
magazines,
p er io d ica l s f i lms
o r
othe r ma te r i a l s
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 3 of 19 - Page ID#: 4
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
5/21
which conta in v i su a l depic t ions
of minors
engaged in
sexua l ly
e x p l i c i t
conduct t h a t
have been
t r anspor ted
in
i n t e r s t a t e
or fo re ign
commerce,
or
t ha t
were
produced
using
mate r i a l s t h a t had t r av e l ed in i n t e r s t a t e or
fore ign
commerce.
DEFINITIONS
7.
The
fo l lowing
d e f i n i t i o n s
apply
to
t h i s
Aff idav i t :
a.
Chi ld Pornography inc ludes
any
visua l dep ic t ion of
sexua l ly
e x p l i c i t conduct where (a) the p roduc t ion
of
the
v i su a l depic t ion involved
the
use
of a
minor
engaged
in sexua l ly
e x p l i c i t
conduct ;
(b) the
v i su a l depic t ion
was a d i g i t a l
image,
computer
image,
or computer-
genera ted
image
t h a t
i s
or
i s
i n d i s t i n g u i sh ab le
from,
t ha t of
a
minor
engaged i n sexua l ly e x p l i c i t conduct ;
or
(c) the v i su a l depic t ion has been c rea ted adapted , o r
modif ied to appear
t h a t
an
i den t i f i ab le minor
i s
engaged
in sexua l ly
e x p l i c i t
conduct . See
18 U.S.C. §
2256(8) .
b. Computer r e f e r s to an e lec t ron ic
magnet ic ,
opt ica l
e lec t rochemica l or othe r
high speed
da ta process ing
device
performing log ica l
or s to rage func t ions and
inc ludes any da ta storage f a c i l i t y or communications
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 4 of 19 - Page ID#: 5
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
6/21
f a c i l i t y
d i r e c t l y
r e l a t e d
to
or opera t ing in con junc t ion
wi th such d e v i c e . See 18 U.S.C.
§ 1030 (e)
(1)
c . I n t e r n e t Pro toco l address
o r
IP address r e f e r s to a
unique number used
by
a
computer to access t he In t e rn e t .
d. Minor means any p e rso n under the age
o f
18
years .
See
18 u.s.c.
§
2256(1).
e . Sexua l ly
e x p l i c i t
conduc t i s
a
t e rm
t h a t
ap p l i e s
to
v i su a l d ep i c t i o n s t h a t
involve
the use
o f a
minor ,
see
18
U.S.C.
§
2256(8)
(A),
o r
t h a t
have
been
crea t ed ,
adap ted ,
o r
modif ied
to appear
to dep ic t an i d e n t i f i a b l e
minor ,
see 18
U.S.C. §
2256(8)
(C). In t hose con tex t s ,
t he te rm r e f e r s
t o ac t u a l
or s imula t ed (a) sexua l
i n t e r co u r se
( i nc lud ing g e n i t a l - g e n i t a l , o r a l - g e n i t a l , or
ora l - ana l ) , whether between
p e rso n s
of the same o r
oppos i t e
sex ;
(b)
b e s t i a l i t y ;
c)
mas turba t ion ;
d)
s a d i s t i c or
masoch is t i c
abuse;
o r (e)
l a s c i v i o u s
ex h ib i t i o n o f t he g en i t a l s
or
pubic
a reas
o f
any
person.
See
18
U.S.C. §
2256(2)
(A).
f . Visu a l dep ic t ions i nc lude undeveloped
f i lm
and
video tape , and
da ta
s t o r ed on computer
disk o r
by
e l e c t r o n i c
means, which i s
capab le
o f
conver s ion
i n t o
a
v i s u a l image. See
18 U.S.C.
§ 2256(5) .
g. The t e rms r eco r d s , documents , and ma t e r i a l s
i nc lude a l l i n fo rmat ion recorded
in
any form,
v i su a l
or
5
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 5 of 19 - Page ID#: 6
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
7/21
au ra l , and
by
any means,
whether
in handmade form
inc lud ing , but no t l imi ted to , wr i t ings , drawings,
pain t ing) ,
photographic form
inc luding, but not l imi ted
to , microf i lm,
microf iche , pr in t s , s l i de s ,
negat ives ,
video tapes , motion pic tu res , photocopies) ; mechanical
form
inc lud ing ,
but no t
l imi ted
to , phonograph
records ,
pr in t ing ,
t yp ing) ;
or
e l ec t r i c a l ,
e l ec t ro n i c or
magnet ic
form inc lud ing , but no t
l imi ted
to ,
tape recordings ,
cas s e t t e s ,
compact
discs ,
e l ec t ro n i c
or
magnet ic
storage
devices such
as
f loppy d i s k e t t e s ,
hard di sks , CD-ROMs,
d i g i t a l
video disks DVDs),
Personal
Digi ta l Ass i s tan ts
PDAs), Multi Media Cards
MMCs), memory
s t i cks ,
opt ica l
di sks ,
p r i n t e r b u f fe r s , smart cards , memory ca lcu la to rs ,
e l ec t ro n i c dia l e r s , Bernoul l i dr ives , or e l ec t ro n i c
notebooks, as
wel l
as
d ig i t a l
data
f i l e s and
p r in to u t s
or
readouts
from
any magnet ic , e l e c t r i c a l or
e lec t ron ic
s to rage dev ice ) .
B CKGROUND OF
THE
INVESTIGATION
8.
On
or
about
Monday,
November
23, 2015,
Detec t ive Dia l s
received informat ion
from Carr Creek
Elementary School Ass is tan t
Pr inc ipa l
Debbi Back, t h a t
t he re
were four
s tuden t s , Student 1
12 years old) , Student 2 13 years old) , Student 3 12 years
6
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 6 of 19 - Page ID#: 7
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
8/21
old)
and Student
4 (13
years
old) who had
sen t nude photographs
of
themselves to
a
person named Jimmy Slone v ia Facebook. The
Facebook account for Jimmy
Slone
ind ica ted Slone was
a
15-year
old male. Facebook i s an onl ine
( in t e rne t -based)
soc ia l
networking s i t e t ha t includes
a
Messenger ap p l i ca t i o n al lowing
users to exchange messages and computer f i l e s , including d i g i t a l
images.
Based
on
y
t r a in ing and
exper ience , I
know
t ha t
access ing Facebook necessa r i ly requ i res use
of
the i n t e rne t ,
which i s
a
f a c i l i t y
o f
i n t e r s t a t e commerce.
9.
On November 24, 2015, Detec t ive Dials
spoke
with
the
s tudents i d e n t i f i e d
by
Debbi Back. Student received
a
nude
photo of
Jimmy
Slone from
Jimmy
Slone
and
sen t two
nude photos
of Student
to
Jimmy Slone
via Facebook Messenger. This
occurred
about
two weeks pr io r .
Student
2
sen t
Jimmy
Slone
nude
p ic tu r e s of Student
2
on Facebook and
Jimmy Slone sen t Student
2
nude
p ic tu r e s
o f Student on
Facebook.
Student
3
d id not
send
nude photos of Student 3, but Student
3
ind ica ted Student
4
had
nude p ic tu r e s of Student
2 t ha t
were supposed
to
have come from
Jimmy Slone s
Facebook
account . Student
4
received
nude photos
of
Student
2
from
Jimmy
Slone
on
Student
4 s c e l l
phone.
Jimmy
Slone
a l so
t o l d Student
4
t h a t he had
nude photos
of Student
1,
but
never
sen t those to Student 4.
7
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 7 of 19 - Page ID#: 8
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
9/21
10. n or
about February 11, 2016,
Detect ive Dials obta ined a
search
warran t for Facebook records for
the
Jimmy Slone Facebook
account . n or about March 29, 2016,
Detect ive Dia ls
reviewed
the Facebook mate r i a l s re turned
pursuant to the search
warran t
and v e r i f i ed there were
seve ra l
images of
suspected
ch i ld
pornography conta ined
in
the account . The
major i ty
of messages
showed
an
or ig ina t ion In te rne t Protocol IP)
address of
199.116.159.129 for the user
of
the Jimmy Slone account .
11.
n
or
about
March 30, 2016, Detect ive Dials obta ined a
Grand Jury Subpoena
request ing Thacker
Grigsby
Communications,
the
In te rne t Service
Provider ISP) t h a t
con t ro ls IP
address
199.116.159.129, fo r subsc r ibe r
informat ion. On or
about
March
31,
2016, Thacker
Grigsby Communications
i den t i f i ed Willard
Dean
Hall as
the subsc r ibe r to
IP
address
199.116.159.129,
a t 5326
WY 1087 E,
Mousie,
Kentucky.
12. n or about Apr i l 4, 2016
Detect ive
Dials obta ined and
executed
a sea rch
warran t
for
Willard
Dean H a l l s res idence ,
5326
WY 1087
E, Mousie,
Kentucky.
During the execu t ion
of
the
search
warrant , Wil lard
Dean
Hall ,
a
43-year -old
male,
was
in terviewed
and confessed
to
co n t ro l l i n g mul t ip le Facebook
accounts, i nc lud ing the
Jimmy
Slone
Facebook
account ,
and
using
these accounts
t o ob ta in nude images
of
female minors .
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 8 of 19 - Page ID#: 9
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
10/21
13.
Based on my review
of the
Facebook account
records re turned
pursuant to the February 11, 2016
search
warran t and my
knowledge
of
Wil lard
Dean H a l l s
s ta tements
in h i s Apr i l 4, 2016
in te rv iew with Detec t ive Dia l s , I have found t ha t Willard Dean
Hall used
the
Facebook
persona
Jimmy
Slone
to use, persuade,
induce, and en t i ce
a t l e a s t two minors
to engage
in
sexua l ly
exp l i c i t
conduct
for the
purpose of producing
v i su a l
depic t ions
of
such conduct .
In
some
cases
he
t h rea tened
to
d i s t r i b u t e
previously obta ined
images to
convince minors to produce new
images
of ch i ld
pornography. The fo l lowing paragraphs
are
examples
of
Wil la rd
Dean H a l l s Facebook conver sa t ions
involving
the
product ion, rece ip t ,
and
di s t r ibu t ion of ch i ld
pornography.
14.
On 11/03/2015,
the
fol lowing
exchange
took
place
between
Willard
Dean
Hal l ,
using
the
Jimmy Slone (JS) Facebook account ,
and Student (Sl ) , a 12-year-old minor:
Sl
ow
old
are
u
JS 15
going
on
16
Sl
I m
12
JS
You show
your
boobs
Sl
wanted
me
to
so
JS
I
want to
see
your
pussy and
ass
9
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 9 of 19 - Page ID#: 10
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
11/21
Sl Why
JS You show
them to me and wil l
show
you mine dick
Sl I f
show u wil l u delec t
them
JS Yes
promise
Sl
Who
do l i ve with
JS Jus t
my mom but she i s gone
r ight now
JS Can
see them
Sl Delect the
t ex t
to or wont
JS
wil l de le te
every th ing
Sl
K
Sl
I ll
show u
Friday because
I m on my
per iod
Sl
That s
when
get
off of
it
JS
d o n t
care about
t ha t ju s t want
to
see
Sl
Show
me yours f i r s t
JS
[sends photo
of
a
penis
being
held
by
a
l e f t
hand]
JS Now your tu rn
Sl [sends photo of
he rse l f
in blue
s h i r t and
l i g h t e r blue
shor t s with
r igh t
wris t
band; r igh t
hand by
c ro tch
area
with f inger beside vagina]
JS
Can t see it
JS
You
can
do b e t t e r
Sl [sends another photo of he rse l f in blue
sh i r t
with
r igh t wris t
band;
her r igh t hand
i s
pul l ing l i g h t e r
blue shor t s to s ide so vagina i s displayed]
1
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 10 of 19 - Page ID#: 11
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
12/21
Sl [sends blue
thumbs
up
png]
JS What
about
the ass
Sl [sends
another
close
up
of
her
vagina l area
with
her
r igh t
hand v i s ib l e pul l ing l igh te r blue shor t s to
s ide ;
blue
sh i r t
v i s ib l e above shor t s . ]
Sl
Not
r igh t
now
JS
Have
you had sex yet
Sl No
I m
12
JS
Could
you
take
mine
Sl How would ever do
t ha t
with u
JS We
could
meet some t ime
Sl
Where
JS
Maybe
go out
Sl My dad won t l e t me so no
JS
o
you
know
where
the
big
y
market
i s
Sl Yes
15.
On
9/23/2015, the
fol lowing
exchange took place between
Willard
Dean
Hal l again us ing the JS Facebook account , and
Student 5
(S5),
a 16-year-old female minor:
S5 I l o s t
wif i
JS Can I have one
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 11 of 19 - Page ID#: 12
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
13/21
SS [sends non-pornographic photo in school se t t i ng ,
wearing an orange/red Aeropostal sh i r t ]
JS
Flash me
SS Why
JS I need
t
SS Why
JS
I need to
see
SS
Meet
me a t
brake
stand a t
the
sc iences
room ups ta i r s
dams
JS
I m
n i t there
JS
Not
SS What u mean
JS
I m not a t
school
SS
Why
JS
Sick
SS
Yewh
JS That s
the t r u t h
SS Yup
JS Can j
get
a f lash ing p ie
SS
U
a i n t here
JS
Well
I know
what
your going
to
say
so
I
wil l
ju s t
get
me
one
o f f
ksmeron
messages
JS
Sorry
I
asked
and bothered
you
SS
Ok
bye
2
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 12 of 19 - Page ID#: 13
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
14/21
JS Well
I wil l get
a l l them pies
of f
message t ha t
I
sent
ksmeron
S5 Cause I
won t send one
JS Yes
SS
Why
JS
I
need
one
SS
You don t
need one
JS Yes
I
do
JS
Fine
you
keep
I
wil l
get
20
from him
messages
JS His
SS
[sends
a pic ture of
her breas t s , r igh t hand pul l ing up
black s h i r t
and poss ib ly
a
bra. Not the
same
clothes
as the previously
descr ibed
photo]
JS Thought you
d id n t
have
any
SS
Well
there
so
JS
How
many
more do you
have
JS I wanted a new one
JS
Not one
I
seen
before
SS I
d o n t have Anymore
JS Well do you want to make
a deal
r igh t
now
JS
I f
you
give me
a new
t i t t y
pie
and
pussy
pie
I
wil l
de le te every body s
messages I
sent p ies to
SS That s not fa r
u
l i ed to me
u
sa id
u
would never
ask
for any pies
anymore
3
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 13 of 19 - Page ID#: 14
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
15/21
JS I so r r y
baby but
a f t e r I de le ted a l l them and the
message
me and you had missed looking a t them
JS What do you say uou want to make t h a t dea l
JS
But
it s
got
to
be new pies one I
d i d n t
see
before
SS o
d o n t
cause u
l i e d
to me
JS I m so r r y I
did
JS See if I go
back
and
ge t the
pies
o f f the
messages it
would be maybe 40
or 50 of
them
JS
Well
ok
I
j u s t
wanted
you
to
send
2
new
ones
and
I
would
d e le t e a l l t he re
messages
SS
Yeah t h a t s going to
be another
l i e
JS o it s not baby
JS
But
t h a t s
f ine you
keep them
2
p i e s
and I w i l l go ge t
them othe r
ones o f f
them
messages
S5 Ok
JS
Can
I
ge t
2 new p i e s
SS [sends a pic tu re of h e r s e l f l i f t i n g a black blouse
above
her
b reas t s ;
she has
a
c lo th jacke t
with
zipper
on over
the sh i r t ]
S5 One
JS
o
2
SS One
JS I want the
pussy
p ie
SS Why
4
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 14 of 19 - Page ID#: 15
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
16/21
JS I want t
SS I d o n t want to give t
JS
Fine
wil l get
t off the
messages
sen t
your
mom
SS Real ly
JS
Yes
JS So do get
t
from
you
or
the
messages
SS [sends closeup
of her vagina
with f ingers spreading
he rse l f
open,
with black b louse , ch in , and ha i r
v is ib le
in
top
r igh t
of
photo;
some
pink
wri t ing
i s
v is ib le on the sh i r t ]
JS You can do b e t t e r
JS The cam was to high
SS U d id n t say t has
to
be good
so
JS You knew t did
SS
Nope
JS
Do
a
good one
SS Later
JS Now
SS
Why
now
JS
Fine you
keep
t
wil l go get a l l the
pies from
your
moms
and
her
boyfr iend
and
ksmeronss
messages
SS Ok
JS So
you
won t do a good one
SS nd u won t stop
asking
5
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 15 of 19 - Page ID#: 16
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
17/21
JS
Last
t ime
I
ask wil l you do
a new
pussy pie
or
do
I go
get a l l
them
other pic tu res
S5
[send png of blue
thumbs
up]
JS Which one
JS
Well
when
you
take t ime from Joseph sand can
t a l k
to
me l e t
me
fucking
know
S5
[sends another
photo
of vaginal
area with f ingers
pul l ing area open with black b louse v is ib le above
and
to
r igh t ;
some
pink
writ ing
i s
vi s ib l e
on
the
shi r t ]
JS That s the same
one you sent
before the cam is to high
S5
o
it s
not
S5
[sends another photo
of vaginal a rea
with f ingers from
r igh t hand opening
area for view; black blouse
with
pink
wri t ing vis ib le ]
JS
That s
nice
ju s t
needs
me
more l i g h t
S5 o
JS
Yes
it does
S5
Well I m not doing
it
JS
Why are you
mad
S5 I
a i n t
JS
I t
seems
l i ke you
are
S5
o
JS Why
are your nips hard
S5 There
not
6
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 16 of 19 - Page ID#: 17
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
18/21
JS Looks
l i ke
thay are in tha t pie you sen t
JS May I see your face
SS [sends photo
wi th
same
orange/red
Aeroposta l top
on
as
in
the i n i t i a l
non-pornographic photo sen t to
JS]
JS And
you
smi led
JS and it s on Facebook
JS
Give
me
one
t h a t i s n t on Facebook al ready
SS [sends photo of
V s
face; black blouse wi th p ink
wri t ing
i s
vi s ib l e
in
photo]
JS There i s the
smile
have been wai t ing
to
see
JS Thank you fo r it
SS Yw
JS love you
SS
U
ti
JS
Let
me
ask
you
if
we
was
t oge the r
and
alone
somewhere
could
I ea t your
pussy
and suck your
tits
SS idk
16. I
have
reviewed the Jimmy
Slone
Facebook warrant
response
and
v e r i f i ed t h e re
a re numerous
images of ch i ld pornography
presen t
and
t h a t
Willard
Dean
Hal l used, persuaded, induced,
and
en t i ced Student and Student S to produce images of ch i ld
pornography. Wil la rd Dean
Hal l persuaded Student to
produce
and t r ansmi t to
him
mul t ip le p ic tu res of
her
p u l l i n g
her
shor t s
7
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 17 of 19 - Page ID#: 18
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
19/21
to
the s ide to provide
a
l a s c iv io u s
c lose -up
di sp lay
of
her
vagina .
Wil la rd Dean
Hal l persuaded
Student 5
to
produce and
t ransmit to him mul t ip le
close-up
p ic tu res
of her us ing
her
f ingers
to spread
open
her
vagina di sp lay ing t
in a l asc iv ious
manner.
He
t h rea tened to
disseminate
othe r
pic tu res
of Student 5
to convince her
to
produce
and t r ansmi t
to him
these images
of
ch i ld pornography. Moreover I v e r i f i ed
the
i d e n t i t y and age of
Student with Dwight
Creech
the
pr inc ipa l
of Carr Creek
Elementary School .
Willard
Dean
Hall
i den t i f i ed
Student
5
and
s t a t ed
t h a t
she was a
s tuden t
a t
Knott County Centra l High
School. He
a l so s t a t ed t h a t he had
spoken
to Student
5
in
person but did not t e l l
her
t h a t he
was the
person us ing the
Jimmy
Slone
Facebook
account .
I
confirmed
the i d e n t i t y
and age
of
Student
5
with Bobby Pol lard the
pr inc ipa l of Knott
County
Centra l
High
School .
17. In add i t ion to confess ing to
Detect ive
Dials t h a t
he
obta ined
nude
images of minors us ing the Jimmy Slone Facebook
account
as
well as othe r accounts not
named
in t h i s
Aff idav i t
Willa rd Dean Hall a lso confessed to
Detect ive
Dials t h a t
add i t iona l
nude
images
of
minors
would
be found
on
the
i tems
se ized dur ing the search warrant .
8
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 18 of 19 - Page ID#: 19
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
20/21
CONCLUSION
The above-descr ibed conduct
invo lv ing
Student 1 and
Student
5 provide probable cause t h a t Wil la rd Dean Hal l v io l a t ed 18
u.s.c. § 2251 a) product ion
of
ch i ld
pornography)
and 18 U.S.C.
§
2252 a) 2) ( r ece ip t
of
ch i ld pornography)
on a t l e a s t two
occas ions . Wil lard Dean H a l l s
admissions to
Detect ive Dia ls ,
cor robora ted
by the presence of mul t ip le images
of
ch i ld
pornography
in
the
response
to the search
warran t fo r
the Jimmy
Slone
Facebook
account ,
provide probable
cause
t h a t
Willard
Dean
Hall
v io l a t ed 18 U.S.C. § 2252 a) 4) (possess ion of ch i ld
pornography)
/ha 2 4- . t
/ 4J
£ SA
vv• f L.
/e/ .:u --v..
Thad
Lambdin
Spec ia l
Agent
FEDERAL
BUREAU
OF
INVESTIGATION
9
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-1 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 19 of 19 - Page ID#: 20
-
8/17/2019 GRAPHIC: Willard Hall affidavit
21/21
I t c. _ ;\ \ :r -
o
z - ~
E A
Rule 4 1 ddendum
Per Rule 4 l(d)(3) and Rule 4.1, the Court processed the warrant remotely. The Court verified
the Affiant's identity (by AUSA confirmation, through Affiant self-identification, and by
personal knowledge), with badge # / f
5
0 c./ . Affiant simply attested to the affidavit and
application, which the AUSA transmitted by remote electronic means (e-mail). The Court issued
the original warrant and transmitted same to the Applicant, via the AUSA, by remote electronic
m ~ ~ a i l . S I Q 1 n M B l f , e s s
complied with Rule 4.1.
f
~ \
Edward
B t k i n s e ~ E STERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY
\ ~
~ United
States
Magistrate Judge FILED
°'lTB.-la ,.:
Edward B Atkins,
MAY 2
2 16
United States Magistrate Judge
~ · ·
EDWARD 8 ATKINS
U.S. Magistrate Judge
Date and Time:
Case: 7:16-mj-00002-EBA Doc #: 1-2 Filed: 05/12/16 Page: 1 of 1 - Page ID#: 21