Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy...

59
Cold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Transcript of Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy...

Page 1: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Cold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design

Andy Smith P. Eng.

Rob Harlan

Grant MacEwanUniversity

April 27, 2011

Page 2: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Year Round Food Production in Alberta?

Page 3: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Why?

Greenhouse gas footprint of imported foodVulnerability to: peak oil, peak natural gasFuel price instabilitySupport the local economyFresh, safe and nutritious foodFood security

Page 4: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 5: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Dr. Mohyuddin MirzaGlen SweetmanDr. Nick SavidovBelinda ChobanDr. Huiqing GuoMike HillDan LangfordGwen SimpsonShanthu ManoGodo StoykeJessica RoderEva BogdanWilliam DeKramerEckhart StoykeRob AvisAnaya Gene-WebbHenry NeufeldPeter AmerogenBrian JohnstonEd WeissPaul Cabaj Steffan Bertelsen

Alberta Greenhouse Growers AssociationGreenhouse Specialist Saskatchewan Ministry of AgricultureGreenhouse Specialist Crop Diversification Centre SouthGreenhouse Specialist Crop Diversification Centre NorthUniversity of SaskatchewanSolar Energy Society of AlbertaSolNorth EngineeringInspired Market GardensCarbon BustersCarbon BustersCanada Green Builders AssociationCommunity FuturesOrganic Master Gardener ProgrammeCarbon BustersVerge PermacultureAmitola Design ConceptsUnited Fabrication and Welding Habitat Studio WorkshopSolNorth EngineeringSolar Energy Society of AlbertaTaktika Sustainability StrategiesSaskatchewan Greenhouse Growers Association

Cold Climate Solar Greenhouse Project

Page 6: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Alberta Agriculture Growing Forward Programme

University of Alberta Devonian GardensAlberta Crop Diversification Centre North

Thanks to:

Page 7: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

China has over 650,000 acres of solar greenhouses90% of Northern China’s winter vegetables

are grown in solar greenhouses

Page 8: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 9: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Q. Zhang University of Mannitoba

Page 10: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 11: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Summer Shading

Page 12: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 13: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 14: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 15: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 16: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 17: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

CoalHeating

Page 18: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 19: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

University of Manitoba

Page 20: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

University of Manitoba Solar Greenhouse Project

Page 21: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Q. Zhang -University of Manitoba

Solar Greenhouse Temperature Monitoring

Page 22: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Chinese Style Solar Greenhousein Elie, Manitoba Feb. 19, 2005

Page 23: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Limitations of the Chinese Design:

•Labor intensive•Exterior insulation - challenge of snow removal•Significant heat loss through the glazing •Soil thermal storage system is uninsulated•Planting medium has been limited to soil•Poly glazing wasteful, not very ecological•Limited seasonal/annual storage capability

Page 24: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Active Solar Heating System

Richard Lane and Chuck MartenOneida First Nation - Wisconsin

Page 25: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

The Community Greenhouse Project Invermere. BC

Active Solar Heating System

Annual Storage

Photovoltaics

Page 26: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

A -35oC Daywww.greenhouse365.ca

Active Solar Heating System

Page 27: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Internal InsulationBlanket

GrowTunnels

KaleSpinachArugulaScallionsParsleyMizumaEndive

DandelionClaytonia

Swiss ChardGreen Chicory

HardyCrops

Page 28: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

SOUTH

8'

7'

15'

R-5 movable insulating blanket

R-40 !

insulation

R-40 !

insulation

8" concrete

4" concrete

single pane glazing

R-5 movable insulating blanket

R-30 movable insulating blanket

Page 29: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

-10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Jan Feb

Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep

Oct

Nov Dec

4

0

-1

-5-4-6

-3-1

000

5

60

35

16

6

1003

16

4850

72

Northern Alberta Solar Greenhouse

GJ

Insulated + Thermal Mass Increase mass+ R-30 vertical cover

5 4

Dan Langford - Sol North Engineering

Page 30: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Earth Charging System

University of Manitoba

LED Lighting

Page 31: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Design Parameters for the Edmonton Region

53 degrees North Latitude5400-6000 heating degree days

Winters are cold but often sunny 55%-65% clearSignificant direct beam winter radiation 70-80% of total

Challenging winter sun angles

December Conditions7.5 hour day

Solar radiation is is limited to 400 watts/m214 degree sun altitude on winter solstice solar noon

11 degree weighted average altitude month of December

Page 32: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 33: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 34: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 35: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 36: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 37: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 38: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Incident Angle

Page 39: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Lighting and Energy

Page 40: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Lighting and Energy

Page 41: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Lighting and Energy

Page 42: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Lighting and Energy

Page 43: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 44: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 45: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 46: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 47: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 48: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 49: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 50: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Glazing Insulation (Internal)

Page 51: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Glazing Insulation (External)

Page 52: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Shutter Examples

Page 53: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Shutter Examples

Page 54: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 55: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 56: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011
Page 57: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

Build and Monitor Three Options:

1 Chinese Design•Interior curtain - highest R-value, no shading

•Reduced overhead glazing - double plastic

•Roof access for snow removal and reglazing

•Heating system required

•Double low-iron glass, punched windows 4’X8’

•9’ frame spacing - 70% open

•Shutters - awning type

11 Concentrating Solar Design with Stacked Clearstory

111 Concentrating Solar Design with Vertical Curtainwall•Double low-iron glass in an aluminum frame

•12’ frame spacing - 80% open

•Shutters - bifold or casement type

Preliminary Recommendations - Charette Results

Page 58: Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011 · PDF fileCold Climate Solar Greenhouse Design Andy Smith P. Eng. Rob Harlan Grant MacEwan University April 27, 2011

System Tests:

•Light bar reflector (vertical glazed options)•Ground dehumidification with heat storage•Earth tube preheat/precool•Dual Core HRV•LED lighting

Preliminary Recommendations - Charette Results