Good Governance and Bad Neighbors? The Limits of the Transformative Power of Europe

7/27/2019 Good Governance and Bad Neighbors? The Limits of the Transformative Power of Europe

1/21

Good Governance and Bad Neighbors?

T Lt f t Tf Pw f Eu

Tj A. Bzl V Hll

N. 35 | D 2011

WORKING PAPER


2/21

2 | KFGWorking Paper No. 35| December 2011

KFG Working Paper Series

Edited by the Kolleg-Forschergruppe T T P E

T KFG W P S t t t ult f t Kll-Fu y

t ll t ul. It t x wll t tt

x tl xtl u Eu t Eu U.

All KFG W P ll t KFG wt t www.tfu.u t

l t tf-u@fu-l..

Cyt f t u: Tj A. Bzl, V Hll

Etl t u: A B D M

Bzl, Tj A./ Hll, V 2011: G G B N? T Lt f t Tf Pw f

Eu, KFG W P S, N. 35, D 2011, Kll-Fu (KFG) T Tf Pw f

Eu F Utt Bl.

ISSN 1868-6834 (Pt)

ISSN 1868-7601 (Itt)

T ul fu y t G R Fu (DFG).

F Utt Bl

Kll-Fu

T Tf Pw f Eu:

T Eu U t Du f I

It. 26

14195 Bl

Gy

P: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096

tf-u@fu-l.

www.tfu.u


3/21

Good Governance and Bad Neighbors? | 3

Good Governance and Bad Neighbors?

The Limits of the Transformative Power of Europe

Tj A. Bzl V Hll

Abstract

T EU Et Elt t f t (fw) uful xt f

t lt . By tt, t EU tf w

t w -xtt -- t (l) t Sut t (w) t Et.

Bt t ly y ut l l (l) . Wl

t Wt Bl Tuy t tw , t wt

t t ly, t Eu N Cut

(ENC) t tu t t tt f t t l. E w t

f t tu , ty wll t t lly

t ly ll w l. T w tt t l-

tw EU t uful tf f ut.

Tf, t u tt t f t Eu Nu Ply (ENP)

u t t l f t l t. Hw, w u tt t t f EU tlz

t t t tw lt t ut. Tu,

ully t t tu u u lt

t EU . E f t ENC , t wul ully t u

t tly tw l t uly

f . G t EU f f tlty tt-ul, t ENP t

lt f t. T ENP lly l tf w w

t t t, t l t t u utt

y l t tt t f .


4/21


V Hll w ttl t t Cll

R Ct (SFB) 700 G A f Lt Stt t t F

Utt Bl. Tt wt Tj A. Bzl, t t

tf f l z u t wl. I 2010, lt P.D. ll t F Utt Bl t l f

y u t tw t Eu U t u

t Ml Et Nt Af.

Ctt: .ull@fu-l.

T A

Tj A. Bzl Pf f Pll S l t f Eu

It t t O Su Itut f Pll S, F Utt Bl. H

tt qu f G, tul ult f

Euz wll t u f l wt ut f

t Eu U. S Ot 2008, t t R Cll T

Tf Pw f Eu tt wt T R.

Ctt: [email protected].


5/21


Contents

1. Itu 6

2. M M, ut W Hw? 7

3. Z t t Eu N: G At t T? 11

4. EU Extl G D t M D? 14

5. Clu 17

Lttu 19


6/21


1. I1

R t tf w f Eu t. Wt t f t Eu U (EU)

tw, w w yt t l-wl xt t tf- w f t EU. A t f t Ctl Et Eu ut (CEEC), t EU t

tf t tutu f t t ft , tlty, ty. T

EU Et Elt t f t (fw) uful xt f

t lt . By tt, t EU tf w t w

-xtt -- t (l) t Sut t (w) t Et. Bt t

ly y ut l l (l) . Wl t Wt

Bl Tuy t tw , t wt t -

t ly, t Eu N Cut (ENC) t

tu t t tt f t t l. E w t f t

tu , ty wll t t lly t

ly ll w l.

T w tt t l tw EU t uful

tf f ut. Tf, t u tt t f t

Eu Nu Ply (ENP) u t t l f t l t tt t

lt t futlly w: [M], t t

f , t ul f Euz (Slf 2009). Wl

f t Wt Nwly It Stt t Sut Cuu ut t ft f -

t t t lu tt futu, t EU t l tt ll t Mt ut

ul xt w wtut . Hw, y t qu f llty f

, t xt ul t t l: W u tt t t f EU -

tlz t t t tw lt t

ut. Tu, ully t t tu u u

lt t EU . E f t ENC , t wul

ully t u t tly tw l t

uly f . G t EU f f tlty tt-ul, t ENP

t lt f t. T ENP lly l tf-

w w t t t t l t t u

utt y l t tt t f .

I t utt u ut, t t t f t t tjty f t w CEE

tt wt t Wt Bl Tuy, w t - t, wll t

Et Sut ENC, w l t t l. A -

lty t u f t f t CEEC, w ly qu lly

ll f t tt y w t EU t t tl 1991.

1 El f t t t t 2011 EUSA Bl Itl Cf t Ju

Fx f t KFG. T ut wul l t t T Dtz, T R, Gy M, Lt H, Wlf

K, Jul L, D P, t t f t KFG R Cllquu T Tf

Pw f Eu f t tu t, wll S Stl W Wu f t lu-

l t.


7/21


St f lw ll, Tuy t Wt Bl t tw t

l tt y t EU z t tl t ut

1999. Yt, t t l wt t t . D

t CEEC Tuy wll u wy w t EU ut ut t l t. A tWt Bl ujt t xtl t f tt-ul y y -

tl t, w t EU w t t ly tw. Wl tly t lt,

t EU t tlz t t tf w.

T t f t z t t ENC t xl t t f t ENP, w t

EU t u lt t t t . Ul Tuy t Wt

Bl, t l t t Et Sut ENC. V t tu -

f ut t Et-Sut . If t ENP ly

t, t t t uf. I t l t f t , w u tt t lly

ult t t EU ut t lt.

T lu wt l t EU tlz t t tf

w, w ully l t f - , w f t t j-

ty f t EU .

2. M M, W H?

S t f t Cl W, t EU ut t ly ft , tlty ty t

t-ut ut y lly x t l f . T

t t t tul l tl l t t tutu -

ly, t EU l t tl x tt ly w ft y w

( lty) ft y ut (ty-ul) (Slf t l. 2003;

f. Slf/Sl 2005). Bt tut l t , w

l u l wt t EU C Ct wt -

l tl t t tt t f ty f tt tu. T l t f

t f t f t EU tf w, w xl t u

ty f Et Elt, t l f t Wt Bl ut Tuy wll

t l f t t ENC (t l M 2006; Slf/Sl 2004). I t

f (tt l) , t EU ully t tf

t t ut.

Yt, f t ly f tu

ut t lt tu. W ll l ll t t w ul f -

tw t EU t t tf t tutu f ut,

t , t qulty f t tu,

t t. Hw, t t ll ut t l tt ut y t

l A N Euz.


8/21


T lttu l t t f t qulty f -

t tu. Wl t ll (f) tt ut, t

t ly lt. W u t tt t F Hu F t Wl

Ix wt t Plty IV-S t u t qulty f t tu (Hu/Tll 2005). It tu ul tutul lt f y w lty

llty t t tut t. F , w ly t Buu Qulty t f t

Itl Cuty R Gu, ul y t Pll R S Gu. Nxt t t t t

x f t, t uty f uuy, wll t utt t, t -

t l lut ly ful y-t-y t fu tu l t u

ut f t ty t f t Wl B Wlw G

It t Btl Tf Ix. I , t tt wll t t

1970/1980 tu llw t t lt t f t Cl W, w t t

tl u t qulty f tt t 1990.

Ft, f t CEEC, t t tt, ll. Mt f t CEEC, w

j t EU 2004 2007, ly, lly ll f tt -

y w ty 1993, w t tly ul ty

tt t t t EU 1999 (u 1 9). Oly Et, Lt, Sl,

R, w ll tt wll lw t CEE , w t t

qulty. C tu tt lty w uful ly t f

utl w , utt, lt f t f w. Wl

t t f t tt t t t w ll l l- -

f Sl R (Sz/Vu 2012), t w f

ly lt ut wt t tu (t f t CEEC; S-

lf 2005; Vu 2005). T EU tly ut ut tly t t uful

t f t CEEC (f. Klly 2004; Su 2004; Slf t l. 2006).


9/21


Figure 1: Democracy and Statehood in Europe and Beyond (1993-2009)

Su: t F t Wl Ix (F Hu), t Plty S (Plty IV), t Buu Qultyt (Pll R S Gu).

S, Tuy (TR) t Wt Bl (WB) utl t EU z

t tl t ut 1999 2000, ly. Wl ty tt t u lw

ll f t tt y t t CEEC, ty l. Sl t t CEEC, EU

lty tly w ll f l C, w ut t lt t

, M, f w t EU t , wll Mt,

w t ttu, S, w ut t fllw ut. At t , t Wt

Bl ujt t tt-ul z t y t xtl

t, lu t Ut N (UN) t Nt Atl Tty Oz (NATO) (f. El

), w t ult t t t f EU lty, t ,

tl ty-ul y , t t. M, Al l

t EU lty t t C, M, Mt, -

y f t t tu lly lt (El

2009) l ll tly. B Hz K, lly, uly l-

t l f (El ). Tuy, y tt,

u t tw t tt y t t l lty f t

2005 (Pu 2010; T 2005). D f Tuy tt l

f t t u uly t


10/21


CEEC t Wt Bl (Pt 1997). Flly, EU lty t t ly w

ll f l. T t f Tuy Al, f t, y

u f t EU f f tt l wt t ll f l

lt t w (El 2009; Nut/Dzt 2012; Ylz 2011).

T, t ENC, w l , ll t y t t-

w .2 T A t Mt w tw

, ut ty t y lw ll. Wl ltly

t x f St Rul tt f t Et Pt f t EU, t qulty

ltly . Buu qulty t Sut ENC t t Et, ut t ll f

lw t Eu . W t lt t ll f Tuy t Sut, t

tt t y lw ll t Et. Wt t f ul

wt , w, qul. Clty ly tut. A l

t EU t f ll t t tlty (Bzl t l. 2008; Hll/St 2009; Yu 2009;), t

t f j t EU ully t ly y tf w.

I u, y ut f t , t ul wt f t EU t -

t j. W t w wt t t ul f

ut t t t t t tw

wt t ut ly ty l wt t t

utl . T CEEC Tuy ly t f u wy, w

t ut tt t t f j t EU f t t u

tw . T Wt Bl, y tt, ly lw t t t

CEEC Tuy. M f lt t f t EU u t t tt-

ul y t fl. Yt, t t tjt f t

Wt Bl ut (lu K) t ut wt t l t l

u t t t , t , t t

wt l f t tt ty tt tt, t t (Bzl 2011).

W t w t u tt lt. Hw, t y wll tt

tt f t t . N-

w tt f u t u t f tt ly uul tt t w

2 A t ut lly lt y t Eu C t ENP, w fu x

Et Sut : I t Et, w lu ll x ENC u , ly A

(ARM), Azj (AZE), Blu (BLR), G (GRG), Ml (MLD), U (UKR). R t Sut

ENC, w lu Al (ALG), Eyt (EGY), J (JOR), L (LEB), M (MOR), Sy (SYR), Tu

(TUN) A utt tt lwy tt t t EU Mt ly.

W xlu Il Pl, u ty lly ttu t f t t Sut ,

w t ly u t t Ml Et t. Il u ll f - l-

t qulty t t t Mt Pl ly t yt tt. W

l xlu Ly, u t EU l ul 2004 t, t EU Ly ly

lwly tl ltl l l t t wt t Sut ENC, lly ly t t EU t .


11/21


f ut . T ll f l t EU ul w t. Flly,

f t w t ll wll t f, lt tt uly u t

t lt t. Clty ully t w, t f wy t -

l zl f ut lt. M ttly, t EU ully t credible t t l. It z t Wt Bl ut tl

t t, t u f t lw ll f tt y. Yt, ly C,

w l wt Bul R y w, utlly t t l

t j t EU t xt y t .

M y , t t f t ENC lly t u f

t ENC l uly f t EU ul l -

lt.3 T qu t wt t w ENP lt. A ll, w

tly l wt t EU f Tuy, t U, t

Sut Cuu, w (l) (Bzl/Pu 2011; Gw t l.

2009; Ylz 2011). T xt z t t ENC t xl lt f

. O , t A t Mt, t t Wt Nwly

It Stt t t Sut Cuu ut w ll tw -

. Yt, w z , w u u tu wt t Eu .

3. Z E N: G A T?

A w ly , t t y t : Wl t

Sut ENC w lt , t qulty f t Et t

l, lt t tly ll t t Sut. At uty ll, w, t

t f t ut ut l t. T ly y t

uu qulty t . T ll w ly y t ut

t Sut t Et wl f ll t, t uu qulty tt .

T t w lul f tw , ut f w wt t ut,

w t wt t - t f t f . Z t t

Eu , w tf w tu t t Wl B Wlw G It

f Gt E tt ly lt wt t t u ut t u

tu f t ENC f t f 1998-2009 (u 2 12).

3 T A S tly ww f tuty f lly t

Sut Mt, ut f Ot 2011, t ut f Eyt, Ly, Tu

t t f u t ut t z ll .


12/21


Figure 2: Democracy and Statehood in the European Neighborhood (1998-2009)

Su: t F t Wl Ix (F Hu), t Plty S (Plty IV), t Wl BWlw G It f Gt E (Wl B).

Fu t f tw l , w -

fy fu u f ENC (tl 1 13): Ft, ut wy f t EU l f

wt ll f t qulty ; , ut wt

qulty ut w ll t lt tt-

; t, ut wt t t t tw ut l ;

fut, ut tt w t , wt ly lt

. Itly, t tjt ut t tw t ytlly l t

t (l) ll f y tt t ul ut.


13/21


Table 1: Paerns of Change in Governance in the ENCs 1998-2009 (FH/PIV)

l

(2)

A, G, J

(4)

Al, Azj, Eyt, Sy

l(1)

Blu, Ml, Morocco, Tunisia

(3)

L, U

(1) Failing authoritarian states?

Fu ENC f t Et t Sut y l t f :

Blu, Ml, M, Tu w t t f -

2009 t ty 1998, lt t y t . R uu qulty, t

tu f tly, wt ly t f M Tu

j l t f Ml lly Blu. C t qulty l

y. Wl M w lt Ml ly ll , t l u u

Blu lly Tu. W t f t y t ll f y

tt. Ll f qulty lly Ml xtly lw Blu,

wll lw t f t ENC Sut, Tu u ll f uu

qulty t t t t ft ll f t t ENC. A M lly Tu tt f

lly ll f tt ly x tt , ty t

l t t u f l utt tt.

(2) Consolidang authoritarian states?

F A, G, J, t tw f tw 1998

2009 wt t tw ut l . T

qulty t u A J, w t ll u tl G. At

t , G t t l tw t , ut y

2009, ll t ut wll t l . A, w l tjt t y

t (l) ll.

(3) Failing democrac states?

Oly tw f t ENC ut l uu qulty f 1998 t 2009: L t

Sut U t Et. Wl t l f uu qulty t f L, t l

f U. It qulty tt f t ut, ut t j

L ly u t ut f t, wt f ut t

Plty S 2005 20 y f tu tu .


14/21


(4) Consolidang democrac states?

Flly, Al, Azj, Eyt, Sy t t Tuy t Wt Bl

ut, t f . Wl t tuf tw t ut, ty tt ty ll tt f y lw ll

f t ul qulty f . Al t t l

t : uu qulty ul tw 1998 2003 qulty

ul tw 2003 2009. Wl t f lw t Sut f , t

lt t Et ENC . C t u ll Azj

Eyt. Wl Sy x t tw , t

qulty t xtly lw ll 2009, t t 1998.

I u, t t f ut t tw (u-) w yt l-

wt t l ll f y tt t tu f . Z t t

Eu l t ut

t fu f t ut. If t EU

t ENP t () t , t lly l. If t EU

tt l t tlz , t fw u y tw l-

t tt t ul ut. A tlz w, t t t lt

lt t l wt t ll fu tlty. Hw w ut f t

t uty tt ut t Sut Et ? A ty t ult f

l ttt y t EU ty t t lt?

4. EU Exl G D Mk D?

T EU l -z-t-ll tul fw f t

xtl l wt () ut (Bzl t l. 2007). T ENP tt -x

ly fw w , w, lwy l l tut ly tz

l wt t EU ll ly u t, y, . T

Eu-Mt A At (EMAA) t Sut t Pt C

At (PCA) t Et f t ll f ll lu lty. T EU

ty-ul tu u xtl . T Eu N

Pt Itut (ENPI) l t f (u-)l Tl At

t t Cwlt f It Stt (TACIS) Mu t t

tqu (MEDA) 2007. I , t ENC ll t u f t u

t Eu I f Dy Hu Rt (EIDHR, 2000), Tw (2003), Tl

At If Ex (TAIEX) (2006). T EU tl jt ulltl

fw f ll ENC. It, t Eu-Mt Pt (1995) tly t U

f t Mt (2008) -xt wt t Et Pt (2009).


15/21


Wl t EU l tul fw, t tt ut tly t l-

t (Bzl t l. 2008). T t l t tt j f

u, f t fu uty t t t u t uty

t t f u t. M futlly, t EU jut t t f ltl l tf t ll lty, u t xlu lu t t ly fw

w -- ul ut. Tu, Sy Blu, w t uy

f t ENC, t ly w t fully tt t t tul fw f t ENP

ult f EU ( x-t lty). Nt t EMAA t wt Sy

2004 t 2008, t PCA wt Blu 1995 utly f. Altu

PCA w 1995, t t t f u t t utt l u Alx

Lu u 1996 (Ml 1997). Slly, t EU fu t t EMAA t wt

Sy 2004 u f t l t Ml Et t, , t 2008,

t tu ll (Eu C 2008). Azj Eyt lt lw

tt y Blu Sy, w, t PCA/EMAA wt t EU f ty

t fully t ENP. Ty l A Pl wt t EU t f ll f f

tl l t, lu t TAIEX Tw P f t EU. T -

l ttt t xl y t tjt u Sy, Eyt, Azj ll

lwly tw wl t t t f Blu. S

L Ml wtut w t l wt t EU.

T EU tt w t u t l tf. T tw t l

f t ENC, M U, w t t tt lt y t EU

ltl l y t t tul fw f t ENP. I 2008, t EU M

t jt ut tl M statut avanc Eu-Mt l

f , l t EMAA t Eu N Ply

A Pl (ENP AP). I l , t EU U 2009 A A,

l t ENP AP f w t. Yt, t t O Rlu

2004/2005, U t tly , t wt t tt y.

N M, w t t . Lw, G -

t tt ut t y, w, t tt y t EU US

f y Ru ( Hll/St 2009). Ot ut tt l ut-

lly tt t lt t l y t l w.

Itly, Al t ENC tt t tt y t lt 1990.

At t , t t ly Sut ENC wt EMAA f tt t t t t t

ENP, fu t t t x f ENP AP t

(Ptu/P 2003).

Oll, t tt f t EU t f t ll f -

y tt t tu f t. Wl t EU t

t ft f ut, t t EU l ttt t t u

y tt tt, u y uty f Azj (Bzl t l. 2008)

t () l f Sy Eyt t Ml Et Ct (Yu 2009). A w ly

, t t uty f t lt wt ul ll f tt


16/21


y t. T ENC y tly t qulty f t -

tu t l wt t t l t ( ). T u t

tjt y ft tt lly t ly u y

t EU t Nu Ply. I t t f lt t EU l,w u t f j tt (Al, Blu, G, L,

Ml) t f t f qulty (Al, Azj, Eyt, L,

Sy, U).

T j t L u t t u f lt t

t t f t f Rq H, P Mt f L, 2005, y t

Il-L w 2006 l uu t u f Ml Sul t El

Lu Pt 2008. I Ml, t fz t Tt, w Ru ty

t j t tl, t ly ll t ly f f f t

Ml tt ut l u t ll tlty. Wl t EU tly t l f t

l f tt t tw ut, t t t t lu t txt f t ENP

t u f t (G 2012). Cly, Al tly

tt w t l w 2002 (ll) lf lwly tu t l t fllw

y. T EU uuly t 1992 u tu t ltl

Al, f EMAA wt Al w ly u tly 1997-1999

lt f t ll tu ul t l (Hu 2002). Hw, ltl l-

wt t EU tt t t-t , wt t lu f t EMAA

2002 ty-ul u MEDA, lly 2004. T EU tly t ly

j l t l w, llw t Al t ly , ut t

t ut t f lwly l tt. T u f xtl t

t f t u G, w u t y

t EU t ut t Sl t t t u (Bzl/ Pu

2011). Cly, EU t tut t t l tt f Blu, tu

t wul ut qu; t EU t u t lw qulty f

Blu tu t t u t ( Hll/St 2009).

Tu ly, t Blu ul tt t f t EU tw

t, Blu t t f l ll f ty-ul xlu f l

EU u TAIEX Tw. T wul ut tt t EU tut t t ll

t f t t , t lt t ut w t ly t

t w t f j ll t tt

t f f lt t.

I t qulty f t ut Al, Azj, Eyt, L, Sy,

U ll t lly uly . Elly f Azj, t -

t ly t. It Sy Eyt tt f xtly lw ll

t y f ty t, Sy ll wt qulty t EU

. A f, t t L t u t -

ut t u t tul t t u. T l Al U. F Al,

t t t y lw ll t l t t u f t f lt t


17/21


u 2002. It llw t t f Al ll tu, lu l, w

lly xl t t t Al. I , ll t l

l l w y t tt f l, lul , l

ty, ll . Al y uu ly t ENP, lut f t EU ly f (Ptu/P 2003), t EU

l t t w. T t f t ENP z U qully w t. T

z t U uly . Hw, f -

Wt t t EU f f (Yu 2009), t lt ul

Vt Yuy t 2010, w ult l. T O Rlu

2004/2005 l t tu t EU t u f tlz-

t tu f t l lu.

5. Cl

Dt t , t EU ut t xt uty, tlty, -

ty t t y t t Sut Et (Bzl 2010; Slf/Sltz

2009;Yu 2009). T ENP u t , t lt ul tly. Wt

fw x, t ENC t f t tu. T tll

f t qulty tly tt t EU l f y , ut t

ut qu f z tlty . T EU t wt -

t t tt t f tt tu t t wt t

l ty t t ly f t tu. I y , t tt

t t l t lly ult t t EU . Tu,

f t ENP t, t t tlz t t tf x

tu (Bzl 2010; Yu 2001). I t f t CEEC, t EU tlz y u t

t wt w t EU t w ly wll t t tw

lt . I t ENC, y tt, t EU lt uty u t -

t wt w t t t t t l. A ult, EU

ty-ul tt t f - l t

t utut ly. T t w f t utt Tu, Eyt, Ly

l u ut t t t EU t t t ll tlty u -

xtl, u utll y uty.

It f t ly t tll wt t t lt wll t l t t Sut

l t y; t tly l tlty, t lt t t u. T

ut u t t tt t t l t tw l utt-

tt t Eu . Dt t f ll tf t f

t Cl W, t Et ENC t tu t tly x l

t t ly Blu, ut l U G t l lu. It t

wt t w f utt ult utl l t-

t t f utt t Ml Et Nt Af. I y t, t ENP


18/21


ll t wt t ut t A wl. T Eu C tlf wl-

t flu t Sut lz tt Eu ul t

t tt4 t t ENP. Wt t tt

lty u f l f5

t tu t ENP t l f t f t and , t .

T l ful f t EU t Ly Sy t t t l y w

G A ut ll t u t -y ul t t

tt t EU l t z tlty y. S t t f

t EU t u wt t t t Nt Af t Ml

Et. Wl EU t ll fu y ul, lu ltl f, ut f

l ty, tu f t juy f , t t t -

u, t f Tu t t tt t EU t lly t tt

t t , ully t f lt tl

(Pll 2011). T tly t f t w y tty y w t Eu C

t t y tt wt t ut lf f t EU, lu Tu, Ly, Eyt

Sy, f w Ey C O t y l tt t l f

qulty wul t u (P 2011).

I t w, t tf w f Eu t (ly) u y t l f -

f t Et Sut , ut y t EU f f tlty tf

.

4 Stf Fl, EU C l f Elt Eu Nu Ply, qut :Stlu 2010.

5 Nt Butl, C w, qut : Su 2004.


19/21


L

Brzel, Tanja A. 2010: T Tf Pw f Eu Rl: T Lt f Extl Euz-

, : KFG W P S 11, Kll-Fu (KFG) T Tf Pw f

Eu, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Brzel, Tanja A. 2011: W Euz Ht Lt Stt: T Wt Bl Tt C

f t Tf Pw f Eu, : KFG W P S 30, Kll-Fu

T Tf Pw f Eu, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Brzel, Tanja A./Pamuk, Yasemin 2011: Ptl f Euz. F Cu t Sut-

Cuu, : Wt Eu Pl 35 (1).

Brzel, Tanja A./Pamuk, Yasemin/Stahn, Andreas 2008: G G t Eu U, : B-

l At zu Eu It 7, Ct f Eu Stu, Bl: F

Utt Bl.

Brzel, Tanja A./Pamuk, Yasemin/Stahn, Andreas 2008: O Sz Ft All? Hw t Eu U P-

t G G It N A, : SFB 700 W P S 18, Sf-

u 700, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Elbasani, Arolda 2009: EU At Clty D Dwl. T Lt f Eu-

z Cll Ctxt, KFG W P S 2, Kll-Fu (KFG) T

Tf Pw f Eu, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Elbasani, Arolda (ed.) ( ): EU Elt Itul Rf t Wt Bl.

European Commission 2008: F-Wl t Sy V-P Mt Al D, : P R-

l IP/08/1761, Bul, 24.11.2008, Bul: Eu C.

Gawrich, Andrea/Melnykovska, Inna/Schweickert, Rainer2009: Nu Euz tu

ENP - T C f U, : KFG W P S 3, Kll-Fu (KFG) T

Tf Pw f Eu, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Giandomenico, Jessica 2012: EU Clty Tf Pw M: E f

Eltl Mt, : El, Al (.) 2012: Eu It Tf

t Wt Bl: Euz Bu Uul?, L: Rutl.

Hadenius, Axel/Teorell, Jan 2005: A Alt I f Dy, Mx Cty: C

Ct Mt, IPSA.

Hugh, Roberts 2002: D t D: T Eu U t Al D, : Dz-

9, 1, 106-134.

Kelley, Judith G. 2004: Itl At t D S: M Clty Sl-

z y Itl Itu, : Itl Oz 58, 3, 425-457.

Magen, Amichai 2006: T Sw f Elt: C t Eu U Nu Ply

A Cl?, : Clu Jul f Eu Lw 12, 2, 495-538.

Mihalisko, Kathleen J. 1997, Blu: Rtt t Autt, : Dw, K/P, Bu ()

1997: D utt Ru, U, Blu, Ml,

C: C Uty P.

Papadimitriou, Dimitris/Phinnemore, David 2003: Ex Euz t t W Wl: T

Tw Ex At Rf t Ct Cut By, : Jul

f Sutt Eu t Bl S Stu 3, 2, 1-22.

Parrot, Bruce 1997: P Pt-Cut D, : Dw, K/P, Bu

() 1997: T Cl f Dy Et-Ctl Eu, C: C U-

ty P.

Phillips, Leigh 2011: At t t ll f t Af, : ://u./19/31835,25 Fuy 2011.

Popescu, Nicu 2010: EU F Ply Pt-t Ct: Stlt It, L: Rutl.


20/21


Popp, Valenna 2011: EU t t l l wt l- ut, : ://u.

/19/113551, 12 Ot 2011.

Saatcioglu, Beken 2010: U t Cl Puzzl. T C f Tuy AKP u EU C-

lty, KFG W P S 14, Kll-Fu (KFG) T Tf Pw f

Eu, Bl: F Utt Bl.

Sadurski, Wojciech 2004: A Dy D: T It f EU Elt u D-

y t Nw M Stt f Ctl Et Eu, : Eu Lw Jul 10, 4,

371-401.

Schimmelfennig, Frank 2005, Stt Clul Itl Slz: M I-

, Pty Ctll Sut Cl Ctl Et Eu, : It-

l Oz 4, 827-860.

Schimmelfennig, Frank 2009: Euz y Eu, : ://www.lw./l-

2009-3 (22 N 2011).

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Engert, Stefan/Knobel, Heiko 2003: Ct, Ctt Cl. T I-

t f EU D Clty Lt, Sl Tuy, : Jul f C M-

t Stu 41, 3, 495-518.

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Engert, Stefan/Knobel, Heiko 2006: Itl Slz Eu. Eu-

Oz, Pll Clty D C, Hull: Pl Ml-

l.

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Scholtz, Hanno 2009: EU Dy P t Eu Nu.

Pll Clty, E Dlt Tl Ex, : Eu U

Pl 9, 2, 187-215.

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Sedelmeier, Ulrich 2004: G y Clty: EU Rul Tf t t

Ct Cut f Ctl Et Eu, Jul f Eu Pul Ply 11, 4: 661-

679.

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Sedelmeier, Ulrich 2005: T Euz f Ctl Et Eu,It, NY: Cll Uty P.

Sderbaum, Fredrik2004: T Pll Ey f Rl. T C f Sut Af, Bt:

Pl MMll.

Tocci, Nathalie 2005: Euz Tuy: T A f Rf?, : Sut Eu Sty

& Pl 10, 1, 73-83.

Vachudova, Milada A. 2005: Eu U: Dy, L It A Cu,

Oxf: Oxf Uty P.

van Hllen, Vera/Stahn, Andreas 2009: C EU US Dy P t Mt

t Nwly It Stt, : M, A/MFul, Ml/R, T ()

2009: Dy P t US t EU C, Hull: Pl Mll.

Yilmaz, Gzde 2011: I T Puzzl? Cl wt Mty Rt Tuy (1999-2010), : KFG

W PS 23, Kll-Fu (KFG) T Tf Pw f Eu,

Bl: F Utt Bl.

Youngs, Richard2001: T Eu U t P f Dy: Eu Mt

A Pl, Oxf: Oxf Uty P.

Youngs, Richard2009: Dy P Extl G?, : Jul f Eu Pul

Ply 16, 6, 895-915.

Youngs, Richard2009: A D Nt O N l? Eu Rl U O Rlu, :

Itl Pl 46, 4, 358-375.


21/21

T Kll-F - E A Ex

I R

T Kll-Fu (KFG) w fu lu-

y t G R Fu 2008. It t-

f t KFG t lly ul t

w t lt wt y u t wt ll u f ju .

T Kll-Fu T Tf Pw f Eu

tt Eu t Bl-B-

u tulz t wt t u-

tu. It x t l f t EU -

t t f , lyz t t

f tl xtl u t :

Ity t Pul S

Cl, Clty By

C Rl Eu Extl Rl

Good Governance and Bad Neighbors? The Limits of the Transformative Power of Europe

Documents

Transcript of Good Governance and Bad Neighbors? The Limits of the Transformative Power of Europe