Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

download Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

of 236

Transcript of Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    1/236

    The Online Library of Liberty

    A Project Of Liberty Fund, Inc.

    William Godwin,An Enquiry ConcerningPolitical Justice, Vol. I. [1793]

    The Online Library Of Liberty

    =>H E-B (D GI) >H J>H= N >GIN J, ., G>KI, -G_I, JI> JI> HI>H= > 1960 IJG H>IN G GHH>>>K>JH. 2010 LH I= 50I= >KGHGN NG I= J><

    >GIN J.

    I >H GI I= > >GGN >GIN L H>I=II://.>GINJ.G= LH HI>H= > 2004 > GG IJGI=G I= JI> GIN J, . _ JI GJI I= JI=G G I>I, I JH I= H>I'H LGJ HG= ,I H I=G I>IH > I=G GIH (", H>> D), G I JH I= =JGH HHNH, JI> >H, HIJNH, H K>H>I I= L H>I. =>H I>I >H H GI I=GI >GGN >GIN DD L=>= I>H KG 1,000 H

    FJIH JI >GIN LG, >H K> G =GG >HG>I> I=I GH > I= >GIN J H L H>IH >H I=G>HI-L LG>II G I= LG [G\ (),G [>GIN.\ I >H I G N JI LG>II JI 2300B.C. > I= JG> >IN-HII GHI N GF.

    _ JI G JI >GIN J, ., G I= > >GGN >GIN GI, H II I= D>GIG I @>GINJ.GH>I >GIN J'H > L H>I I LLL.>GINJ.G< GI= )> >7G6GN ; >7GINI .>GINJ.G

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    2/236

    BE D, C.8335 A>H >I G>, J>I 300>>H, > 46250-1684

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    3/236

    Edition Used:

    A EFJ>GN C8G>< *>I>86 $JHI>8, 69 >IH #`J8 G6 0>GIJ 69 "6>HH, K. 1 (: ..$. $.>H, 1793).

    AJI=G: >> L>

    About This Title:

    L>ZH HI L LG >I> I=GN. G>II > I= GN

    NGH I= G= KJI> G I= GGG = GK>H KHII>< G>I>FJ JJHI HI>IJI>H I>>HI>N GHH I=I >>K>JH I I=HII HI GK> G I=>G H. " >K I=I >I>= H J>I>H. =>H LG =H >H>G NH G> I=>GH.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

    http://oll.libertyfund.org/person/28http://oll.libertyfund.org/person/28
  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    4/236

    About Liberty Fund:

    >GIN J, . >H G>KI, JI> JI> HI>H=

    I JG H>IN G GHH> >>K>JH.

    Copyright Information:

    = IMI >H > I= J> >.

    Fair Use Statement:

    =>H IG> >H JI > I JGI=G I= JI> GIN J, . HH I=GL>H HII > I= CNG> HI> K, I=>H IG> N JH GN GJI> > JGHH. I N I JH > N LNG G_I.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    5/236

    Table Of Contents

    G.

    A EFJ>GNG>< >I> $JHI>: B . =GI >I> HI>IJI>HC=. .: IGJI>C=. .: ">HIGN >I> >INC=. .: = G C=GIGH G>I =>G

    GI>HC=. .: =G G>> CJHH G GKI

    CH>G. >IGIJG. EJI>. >I> $JHI>C=. .: `J >I> HI>IJI>H EM>_C=. .: "J KI>H C GIJ

    GKIC=. .: I= I> I =H G>>H G I=

    `J C>IGI .: G =NH> CJHHGI .: I> C=GIGHC=. .: I= I> I =H G>>H G I=

    `J JMJGNA EFJ>GNG>< >I> $JHI>: B .CE

    >INC=. .: IGJI>C=. .: $JHI>

    A>M, . . . 87.: J>>A>M, . .: DJ>IN >C=. .: >H G>KI $JGNG>< >I> $JHI>: B .CE

    KGIC=. .: NHIH >I> G>IGHC=. .: I= > CIGIC=. .: G>HHC=. .: >I> AJI=G>INC=. .: HI>C=. .: >

    A>MC=. .: GH KGI

    A EFJ>GNG>< >I> $JHI>: B.CEAE G>>H

    C=. .: H>HI

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    6/236

    C=. .: KJI>HI> .: DJI>H C>I>OI> .: E^I>< KJI>HI> .: >I> AHH>I>HI> .: I= >H G I B DH>G

    C=. .: NG>>C=. .: I= CJI>KI> GJI=I> .: AHIGI G G GJI=I> .: >G>IN

    A>M, . . . 233.: I= CM> BILGHI>< >GIJ

    A>M, . >, . 242.: I= EMJ>< >H>IGHA>M, . >>, . 252.: JI >G>IN HJC=. .: G > HH>INC=. .: GH G I= DIG> HH>IN

    C=. .: I= =>H I= "J >C=. .: I= G>> >GIJC=. .: I= N >GIJ

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    7/236

    B I CIIH

    PREFACE.

    FE LGH >IGIJG G = > I>, I= I=HL=>= IGI > I=> IGN LN I= G>>H H>. BJI I= =J > > KGN >HH IG GI> I>G GJ > I=>G KJ N I= GI> HJHFJI>HKG>H. " >I =H LNH H>G N > FJ>GGH,I=I G>< LGH I=>H > H=J G I> I I> HJGH, I=I I=G GJI>H >J>< I= GLHI=I =K H> ^G I=HKH, H=J HJHI>IJI > I=>G.

    I LJ HIG HI=>< I=>H > LG I H>G >>I>H, IG I= , I=GG J. " >K >I>H I I= GG K=> >G G>IN. =I HG>I> I=>H HGKH I = >H>I>, L=>= HH N I GGI>H GI>JG GH G, >HI M>I>< JGIII> I I= INGI> I HJ= IGI>H, MJH>KN >IH >GI>I> JH, KI G >GKI. "LH G>GJH GJ>< LG, G I= GJH L=>= H=J G>H L>I=JI >< HIG =>IH

    H>G>IN, GI>IJ JHI>.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    8/236

    "K>< HII I= H>GI>H > L=>= I= LG G>I, >I >HGG I I> L >GJHIH I= JI> >IH =>HIGN.= HI>IH >I I>H G N H I= HJI> FJ>GN = < = GHI > I= LG>IG'H III>. I >H L ILK NGH H>

    = HI>H_, I=I G=N LH H>H N GGJI. " L I=>H K>I> I I= >I>LG>I>I I GJH I= I> =>HIG>H. GN II= H I> = G>K I> >HIGJI> G G>G G= LG>IGH J I= IJG >I= L>< GG, -NHITB 9 6 (6IJG, JHHJ "KI>JH.< G = I=J>G>H I=>H > I= GI I>H JHI>, IJ, G>HH, I=H I= >I IGJI=. >I>M>IN >H I= GGGH I=I I HIGI LH N N >H HJ I I= H>GHH HI HIGJI>. I= H KI =LH I= IG>I> > L=>= HI I I=>H LG.

    J= LH I= GGI> L=>= JG I JGI I=GHI IGI>H. = >GI MJI> N >H>HH > LLGH. I LH GI > I= I= N 1791: I= H>I>LH I= L>< IG, =H I=GG J> H H>MI I=H. =>H G> LH KI I I= JGHL>I= JG>II GJG. I LG I L>H= >I = I H H > II> GI I= JI>>IN I= LG J >IH GN G.

    = G>I>< I= L>< IGI>H, H L H I= H>I>,LH >`J N I= H G>>, H>G I G> GI> HI= L>I= I= HHGN >GI>. =G>I>< LH G I=I GH , < G I=H>I> LH _>H=. >HKIH GI=>H >GJHI. = >H I= JI=G GGH>JJH >H FJ>G>H K. = G I= HJI, I= G JGIN = H IJGHI >I. =>H >GJHI =H => >I LIG>I>H. = G>> I=H H>HIH > H>>JGN I= _GHI , GHI>N I >JG I= I I= LG, I=I G =H I= HI N I= JI = =H JGHJ.

    = G> > L=>= I= LG H >IH G >H H>I I G I=>G

    NIN, I G KGN H M>JH L= >H I GN IH>I= I= HI>IJI>. N >H G>H N

    KJIGN HJHG>I> I GN I= M GHJI>< L= H= G I GJ >>H, I=JH IGHH I= I L>I= I= >IN >K>JH. =>H LH >I L=N JGH L= I= LGLH JGI; >I L> HGN HJH I=I HJ= >I J GJ N IGI> > I= LG>IG'H H> L N >K I= K> GJJG, >H I GHJI L=H= I I= N I= J>I> N JHI>IJI>

    G G =I; >I >H , I=I G I GHJIG N J I= LGI= KGHI> I. I >H L I IG> L=I=G, > >I>I I=H G>< G=IH J JG >GIN, >H I JG I= G I= >K> LG, L=>=, H> I= KI< G >IH MGHH IH I= >HHJ>< G IJJI K>, >H N >IH KGN IJG I HIJN G`M>. I >H I IG> L=I=G GI >H G GHJGHH>< I= I>K>IN >, JII>< I I=>HFJ>H>I>H H>. HI>< I= KI > GH K>LI= JI=G =H G =>H GHJI>. =IKG JI =>HJIGN N JGHJ, I=N L> I I H= =>HIGFJ>>IN. = JIN = >H HI J I >H=GH I= HH>HI> N GHI G HJ= G>H GI>N K>>HH>IJ I=I =>, I=I KG G>< < L>I= >I G HI>HIGN HI>.

    BJI, MJH>KN I=>H GG>JH J>GII H>GI>,>I >H I= GIJ I= GHI LG I G G J> I=I>H > HIGJ, >GHH L>I= I= HI GJG=H>H HJ= IG>H H G =G >KG. A I=

    GJ>H I= =J > G > GH HI >I. =>H>GJHI N G I GI I= I=I=G. BJI >I >H I= GGIN IGJI= I GHH, I GK

    K>IG>JH KG KGN KGHGN. I GFJ>GH I= >>^G J I= H _G I=I, I GH I= G> GH L=>= L>HJ.

    $JGN 7, 1793.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    10/236

    B% . C"A. .= HJIGH.

    B% . C"A. .

    NHI >>^G:

    HH>K

    >:

    B I CIIH

    AnENQUIRY

    ConcerningPOLITICAL JUSTIC

    Book I.OF THE IMPORTANCE OF POLITICALINSTITUTIONS

    CHAP. I.

    INTRODUCTION

    I= HJI GH.YHNHI >>^GY HH>K>Y >GIN.YHNHI >GIN MI.

    T"E FJHI> L=>= _GHI GHIH >IH > FJ>GN G>I> >HI>IJI>, GIH I I= >GI I= I> L=>= >H I=HJI FJ>GN. A L> HH I= =J

    H>H>H I= HI H>G I G =JH> I GI; I=I >IIJ G =>HH GHJG >H MIGN I GGGI I=H L=>= G GG>JH IGH>IGN. =I=H L=>= N GHG I= II>I I=>H I, G KG>JH. >I J GK I=I HJ >I>>HI>IJI> LH I=GH I= HI LGJ GGI>>K>J GKI I= H>H, >I LJL I=I >I>H LH I=_GHI HI >GII HJI =J >KHI>.

    = >>H > > I=>H GHI =K >K>. BN HI >I >H aG, I=I I=>^GI I>^GI GH GN I= G; I=I> I= I >IN >; I=I >I >H >I=G I= JIN G I= L>H =HI >JHIG>JH >>K>J I JHN =>H L>I= GH HG>H >JHIGN.

    A H HH, > I>< I= H G>>H,

    =K K I I= >^GI IJG. B>K>< I=I I=>G G>I,

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    11/236

    >GIN.

    B% . C"A. .

    HNHI >GINMI.

    B% . C"A. .

    I=N =K GI> >H=> I=IHGK I M>I G, =K I= OJH J>HI>H=>< KGHG>H >KI>. >I=G I=HHHH =H JGH >> I HG> I I= H> GI> >I>H G-> KG KGN I=G.

    BJI I= KIH L=I >H IG >I>>GIN =K LNH JGJH. =N =K I=>H >GIN G>>N> IL GI>H; I= HJG>IN JG GHH, I=HJG>IN JG GGIN. =N =K G>K I=II=H IH J I ^I JI N I= >GI>>>HIGI> KHI>< > I= IG LG HJa>I I K G I I=>H>>HIGI>. =N =K , H G HH H G

    IN; I=N =K H>G I=>H FJ>IN H >G>K>HIGI> >H.

    BJI, L=> I=N =K I=JH MIH>K > I= I I=>G, I=N H I =K I= I= IL GG HHH >G< >I>H H I HJG>I >GI, N> GI I= G >GKI. =N =K GI > I=>G MGI>H GI=G N FJ> HH JHI> >H> GHH>, I= N H>JHHH I= >I>II> I= >^GI GIH I= H> HNHI, L=I=G H >IGIH I I= >IGJGH >>K>JH, G I I= M>H >HI>IJIH HIIH I>H* .

    I N =LKG GH I H>G L=I=G I= H> >I>H I HL=I > I HJHI. I N>GN FJHI>, L=I=G G H>G > >IH >>I ^IH,

    I= > I=H >I I GJ. >, G M, HG >IH M>HI J I= M>HI III>. N I ? A, K> H G >IH M>HI JI= M>HI GGG. N I IH J I= FJ>G>< > =HI, N >IHIGI I= >HKGN HI>H=I IGJI=? I JH H>G I= HJI > I=>H >I K>L. >I GK I=I I= H> >I>H >H I=JH J>>I > >IH>GI, I= KIH >GIN L> =K >I>

    GI>, >IH >GGH L> >>I L>I= I= >IH G>>H.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    12/236

    B% . C"A.. GFJN LG:

    < I=>IH:

    B% . C"A..

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. II.

    HISTORY OF POLITICAL SOCIETY

    GFJN LGY< I= >IHY< I= GHYI=G=YI= H=.YJHH LG.YLH.YHI>H.YJI>.YJGI> G

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    13/236

    < I=

    GH:

    B% . C"A..

    I= G=:

    I= EH=.

    CJHH LG.

    B% . C"A..

    IG >>FJ>IJH H; I=LG LH KM G I=G =JG NGH NI= >GGJI>H I=H,

    H, HIGGIN NGH LG >GN G HJG>G>IN L>I= I= =JH AJHIG>, IGLGHN I= >>IGN IGHI>H J>H I= JGII=.

    E LG G HIG, IG >IGK I I= LG C=GH I= _GHI =>H G>I. HG LH I= HI>IJI> HII N I=GKJI>, I= L LG _ I>ILGG N >< >>, I= J GGJ =GH I= >< GJHH>.

    A L=I G > HI HH I= GIMIH J L=>= LG >HJGI? =I GI> J HH>N

    =K K =>H I= HI >HIJG G I=H =H>< L=I=G "GN I= H>MI= GELG I= JGI= H=J =K I= HIN >< EH HLG G I= JGH GG>< =>H JIGN >G>G N G, H >I JHI HHG>N =K >I= >I> I= II= >>>H=HKG> G>KI HII>; I= >?

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    14/236

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    15/236

    B% . C"A..

    EJGI> G>>IN I >I I=I I=H K>H G GN, I=I LGH, MJI>H HI>H MI>GI JI I= LG. BJI J => I H>G L=I=GI=N N G>. LJ =K => I=I >K> >N >H

    I> J L=>= I= HKGHI >KHI> N JN N.

    =, > I=I>H, IJG=>H=N GH, >IH G,I= N L GHN = I=I H= HI> G I=G < >I. >I G=KGN I=>< I=I >H HI >GII >IGHI>I >H G I=I, L= I= I=GN >H L> I L=N IN, > >G, G GI= _I IKGN HI>IJI>. I=G I= >IHI = I=I I=>H H= I= _ GHJI, I= GI>N HJI >H>G I HJ> HJ= H, HJ= >K>> GHKG.

    = G>>IN I=>H >GKI L> HJa>IN HI>H=,> L H>G, _GHI, I=I I= G =GIGH G I= GHJI I=>G GI>H: ,HN, I=I I= H GI>< J> H I= HI H>G. >I> I I=HGI L> J, I=>GN, I=I I= ^IH >I> >HI>IJI> G I HH H>JJH > I> I= >G>>; , JGI=N, I=I GI>>>IN >H I= HIJFJ>K =GIG>HI>H I= =J H>H, H I=I I=>I>, H L H I= >IIJ HII , N GHJI > JGH GK >GKI.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    16/236

    B% . C"A.. >I

    G>>H.

    B% . C"A..

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. III.

    THE MORAL CHARACTERS OF MENORIGINATE IN THEIR PERCEPTIONS

    >I G>>H.YI>H I I=>H HHGI>YG I= GNI>H >IHYG I= H>G H-GHGKI>YG H-KYG >INYG I= K>H =>GYINGN.YHJHH.YJH>.

    WE G>< >I I= LG L>I= JH >IG>>H: HFJIN L G >I=G

    K>GIJJH GK>>JH H L _GHI >I M>HI. IGJI= G K>I I= I=>H, I N L= L> N>I= HJI >GI> H>GI>. EKGNG>>>H GH>I>. EKGN GH>I> H>HIH >I=I> I HI IL >HI>I >H, L=>= GaG IHI= = I=G. I=GGI= G>>H >I, I= >H JHI H I.BJI I=>< G>IGKGI>, I= I=IL I G>< G-HI>H= >H>I I= LGL>I= JH.

    I I= >I G>> , I=I K>GIJ >H GJ I L=>= L G>

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    17/236

    B% . C"A..

    I>H I I=>HHHGI>: GI= GN I>H >IH:

    B% . C"A..

    G, I=>G G>IN G >HI= L=>= >HI IG> I=>G KJ.

    HIN, I=G >H I= > >, >IH IJG HJG, I=>, I= IN I= GLG.

    = >H I=G > I= GHI HII H>I>_ >GKI, I=IL> >K I=I I=>H KHI => GI>H I>H >HHI=>< I=I L G>< >I I= LG L>I= JH, NHI> , H=JI J > I= =J GN,L=H IGHJGH G I GJHIH H= GFJ>G? = H I G>K I=I I=N GG N HG>H >GHH>H, > G`M>?

    EMG> =H N N HJH KGH II=H GH>I L> J M>I> J I GIN > =GN L>I= I=. ==> I I= I =>H >GI= >H IINJGK> L>I= >H, MI HJ= H =>H M>HI > I= L N =K HJ>. ">H _GHI >GHH>H GI=H HJG >. BJI = =H GH> I I> >I=G I= G I= I=G, GK>JHN IMG>.

    A GI> >GG>II> I= I= = L> GJ I=I

    IGI> I= _= >H I= I> H IGI> L> I _GHI J> L>I=H> I=JI N >II> I GI> >I, I I=JI I=J. AIG GI>JG GI>I>H, I= IJG I= I> L> G>K; >IL> GG L>I= H>JHHH >IH IN; KI= = HIGI= JI J I= G= N I I=I >HH>G. GHI I I= =>, I=JH G >HIGJI, >I L> GJ HJG HII I= G. " L> HIGI= JI =>H = I I= `, L>

    =K G=H> I= > JG>< I> ==H I I= HHI>.

    AI I= IN, I= N>H >HIIJHN H, L= NHJHI, G L=>= H G=, >H K ILGHI=; I=>H I> >H H HIJH, H I L>I= aJIN GKI N INH>G >I. >IH I=G >H HJ= GH>IN; I N G= I I=>G GI=JI GJ>< I=>H ^I. GLH L> IIN

    >>^GI I =>, L= =H KG J I= HH>I L>I=

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    18/236

    G I= H>G

    H-GHGKI>:

    G H-K;

    B% . C"A..

    G >IN:

    G I= K>H =>G:

    B% . C"A.

    . INGN:

    I= ^IH IH >H H>H GH> H M>HIH I> >IGJ N MG>.

    I =H H>, I=I I= H>G H-GHGKI> >H >I. L=I >H I N I=>H H>G? JHI L

    I JGHI N >I, GG M>HI I-M>HI? D L GG N I=>< JI JH>I >H G= I HI, GK>JHN I JG MG> I=I>KH G GG >I HHHHH. I= >H > I= G M>I, KGN IGN > I=>GGI>. A => H>GH HJG I=H >, < G = =K N >I> GHI>< I= H>< I M>HI.

    A, >I =H H>, I=I H-K >H >I. BJI I=G

    I GGG G HN II>. BN I=K H L JGHI I= GI> HJG, >H> >: JI I=>H >H N I= JIN GI> JG I=G . = KG >I=I LH G>>I >

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    19/236

    HJHH.

    B% . C"A..

    CJH>.

    HH>HI JI N >GI>JI GN. I=>H JIG >I>GJHI, > L>I= I= N >>>IN GIH JGHH, L G GHI L>I= I= _GHI H> K>. AHH>HI>H HHGN, J>K I I= M>HI, I= =I= I= IH>IN I= >I. E>G > I= >I KG I=H L= GII

    => >H JHHGN. L I L>I== JG HH>HI G>HNI I= I L= >I HH I GFJ>H>I, > JG > GJG GJH I > KGN H >GGK, > L I>, >GIJ>IN G HI>N, G I=I I L GI>H > I= >IIJ JGG JG ^HG>H H L >HI> >I I= I= K>H INGI; JI LG > FJ < I= I= K>H HK. I >H I I> KGN I I=I > FJ>GI= >H JHI>, GIG>JI> G>IN, I=H I>H G

    G G M>HI>< > I= >H >IH. HFJ, L= LHIG>, G L= L GJ I=, L G>H I HI I= M>I>< >I= HH >JGN, >< GHII. AK ,HI>IH I=>H HGI I > I L, > JG I> > L>I= HNIH . = H >>>IN, I=I JH I >H>G I= L>I= H>G>I INGN N N>>< I I=>G >GIJ>I>H, IGLGH>IIH IJH >H>HII G>>JH JI, I I> N>< I= H HJGN, H I I=G L_ I= JGHN. =, I=I =HHGK I= HFJH I=>H IGII, =L HIH G >II, =L >HG I=N G > H HHI I= HI, L> HJGG>H I I= GN>>I>H GK>IN > =>G* ?

    G I=H GH>I HJa>IN GH, I=II= G FJ>I>H G I= GJ I=>GHH>H J I=, I=I I=G >H >HI G> GH>IN I K>. JG K>GIJH K>H N IG II= >>IH L=>= I= =>HIGN JG >KH, > I=H

    >>IH J >KHI KGN >GG IN, K> LJ MI>GI G I= LG. = IH N >aJI, N HL G. BJI = L>KG HGI >I; I= L= >H M>JH G I= _I =>HH>H, L> L>> =>H I>K>IN I FJ>GN>I I= ^I>< I=>H MI>GI> > L= G > GI, FJ>GN L=>= G>HH J=, > >I I > G>IN G>H KGNI=> >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    20/236

    B% . C"A..

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. IV.

    THREE PRINCIPAL CAUSES OF MORALIMPROVEMENT CONSIDERED

    . #EA/E._IH >IGIJG.YMH.YHHI> GGI>H >IGIJG.Y>IH IH.. ED/CA#)(._IH JI>.YJHH >IH >>>IN.. *)##CA $/-#CE._IH >I> >HI>IJI>.YJ>KGH>IN >IH

    >`JYGK N I= >HIH H>IN.YG> K>.

    T"EE G I=G G>> JHH N L=>= I= =J> >H K ILGH HII GI>;>IGIJG, G I= >^JH> LHJHH>, L=I=G LG>II G G;JI>, G H= G I= GN >GHH> G>>HJ I= =>I=GI JGJ> >; >I> JHI>, G I=I> N G>> G>IN IGJI= >I I= GI> J>IN. I JH I IGN GK>L = I=H.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    21/236

    B% . C"A.. B_IH >IGIJG.

    EMH.

    B% . C"A..

    EHHI>GGI>H >IGIJG.

    B I CIIH

    I. LITERATURE

    FE H G LGJ, I I=H I> G HJIGN > I=>G IN, I=>IGIJG. >I=JI FJ>G>< G I= GHI >II= JH I=>H =, >I >H HJa>INK>I > I, I=I I= =J > >H HIGI L>I=GJ> >HI. = KG>JH >>H GK>>< > >^GIJIG>H < >^GI HHH J I= HHJI, G HI >JG; NI I=H >>H N IGJ. L I= ^IJ LN G MI>GI>< I=HGJ>H >HIH HH I >IGIJG.

    >IGIJG =H G> I= L= I=>>< LGGHI>< I= >H I= HNHI I=J>KGH, MI>GI J I=>H HJI I= GH G I= I>. >IGIJG =H J I= IJG I= =J >, I=GH =K HI>H= GI>M>H GHI>< , H LI =H GHI>< IIG,I=I G II G JFJHI>. D>HJHH> =HHGI> L>I= IG GH>J>IN I= GG >GINKG HKGN; I= >LG>I=GH, I=>GH, I= G HJI>K GHGH > KJG HI>H,

    G HI MI>I. GJ> = >IGJ >JGG>K>>I>H J I= HJI IG; HJI>=H GN HGI> I=I GI G >H HI KJG I=G GHG>IN. > N >HIH I= I> K> =K > I GJ J>KGHK>I>, >I JHI =LKG H>G, I=I >I=H I > I GJ >GGG, > >I= I GII >G N I= JI=G>IN >I> I=G HJ= I=>< H IGJI=, >I JHI >>N HIGJ JI N I= >H> > L>I= >.= GHIHH I>K>IN >II L> G I> GI> > GM GGG; JI I=H L> N>JGH, L=> I= IGJI=H I=I H>N HG> HIJGN IH, L> N I= G>I. GGI> H GHG GH =>H JI>H L>I= I=H I=G, I= L H =>H G II, I=G>>H = I =HI>N I L> KGI=GL, I=

    J L=>= =>H > LH MH I H>>HIG >`J,

    L> _G. A I=I >H GFJ>H>I > I=H >HJHH>H >HJ>>I HJI>, HJa>I KG>IN HNHIH

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    22/236

    B% . C"A..

    IH IH.

    B% . C"A.

    .

    >>H. => L N >HJI JI I= HI LN >< I=> >IH LG JI IG>`>< G< >H I HG I GJI>, H> L> KL>I= G> HIG>H. , L= IJG I=>G III> I I= JHH

    _ FJ>GN, HI> G L= GI I= >JG GGGH G>H >, G I I > I=I I= JG >H L>I=JI_I HH. BJI I=>H I I= H, > IGJI= IHI =K N G M>HI. EGGGH L>, JG>< I=L= G> I=>G G>H I=I =K HH JHJHI G =K I=>GG II>; JI, > > N H> L >HKG H>IGNIGJI=, >I I KGI=GL.

    J= G I= GKJG >IGIJG. BJI, K H=J L >II= > I=>G J G, I I= H I> HJH I=I IGJI= >HI= >II GI>_G N L=>= > >>N GI LJ NI N H HJa>IN L I=I >IGIJG >H FJI I I= JGHH =J >GKI. >IGIJG, GI>JGN I=I >IGIJG N L=>= GJ> >H HJGH, I= > >H HIGJ< I _GG I, M>HIH N H I= GI> L. = JI>IJ, I HI > I= GHI HII =J H>IN,I GI >IH >J>I>H. G I=I JGH >I LJ HHGN, I=I I= N H=J KJG, I=I KGN >>K>J H=J =K >HJG G GH>< G`I>, I=I I=G H=J H>H J>>HI>IJI>, L=>=, =K>< H= G >IH H>H, H=J JIGII=>G GH HII H>IN, > >I > I G I=HH>I> IGJI=, LJ I HI I= >>IGHJI >I.

    BJI > GGHI>< I=>H HII H>IN H I= JI>I GHJI, LH=J >JG K>JH N. = >HKGN IGJI= >H JGHJ>I HJ= KHI MII, I=I >I >H HGN

    HH> I GHG> JH I >I. =H H, L=>= H I GHI I G I= >>IH =J JGHI>, > I= >HIH I=I G>H G ,GI>G GI=G GI=G I= G HN L G= I=. AGI> FJI>IN IGJI= L> HJa>I G I= HJKGH> INGN JHJGI>; I=>H HJKGH>, N G`I G,L> HH>HI JG JGHI> I= >HKGN IGJI=. I= I>, >I >H I HN I _ I= MI GI> >HKGN I=IJHI HHG>N G >I> >GI>. = G> GI>>IN >JHI> L> H=GI, > GGI> H >I>

    GI>IJ J>H G>> H=G > JG >HFJ>H>I>. = I=HI H>G GI I>, >I=G G JGH G >`J,

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    23/236

    H K> I= `IN >IH >HI>IJI>H, I=L= L> H GG IGFJ>N N HGI HI I HJGH I=.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    24/236

    B_IH JI>.

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A.. CJHH >IH>>>IN.

    B I CIIH

    II. EDUCATION

    BJI, > >I G I=I >IGIJG, J> N I= GIN >HI>IJI> >H>>, >H >FJI I I=GGI> I= H>H, >I N G=H >, I=I JI>, N H , >HI= HI HJH>>G>H G >< J >IH IH. EJI> N=K I= KI< > > >IH G> HII, H>GG G JIJG, H NI J>HI L>I= LH; >I >H GH >>, I=I I= IH >H J= H>G II G>GIJJH >HH>I>H > JGJ> JGHI>I LG GI JGHKH. GGJH K>>JH JI> , H >I =H H=L I , I= HJG JG GK>IN, JI>, G>K I=H GGGH, HH IGHI >IH H I= HI IJG M=NGG >IH HJI K>GIJJH JG.

    L> > I= J> KG I =K I= K>I> INGN G I= HK G>. " =H KG G>II IIG>J= > I= HJHH >GIJ>IN, I I=GG L=K GHIHH, >HII, IHI> G JJHI. " =H

    >JG I >H FJ>IN >, I=GG >HI HH>I, =JIHH IGI JI GH HI>IH, = >H I >L>I= GJ>, >H I > I H HI>I I=>GI H>GH IG LI=, HJG, I= _I>H JMJGN. >GIJ =H LNH GHI I => JG I= HI IIGI>K G, H I= HJGHI>J HJHH > KGN =JG JGHJ>I, I= KG->> >H>II, >_>IN HJG>G > KJ IKGN I=G FJ>H>I>.

    I I JI I=I HJ= JI> >H JI IGJ KGN H>G ^IH. I= LG> I= J> L> I= HIIG HH KGN >^GI G L=I =>H G>K>H K>GIJ >I >I I HH> H I IG I= >, H IGG >I G HI I= >`J M I=JGIH JMJGN. I> >I N GH I JI I=HJa>N JI>. "L N >HIH N L MI I_, > L=>= =H GG> >I MJI>, H

    >II GI, H I GJ I=HMIGG>GN ^IH? =G JHI I= GIG =>H =K

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    25/236

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A..

    JI, L= H= I=JH KI =>H J> K I= GGGH >? I= LG I= >>>I G I >GI= G>=H >I >HI>I>H, = L> HGN MI GI=>H G. I= LG J >IG>KH=> H_H=HH, = L> I L=N >H>IGHI. H= L>I=

    > I GG N I= G>HI* , GI>H JG I=JH GH,I= >>K>J L> I LNH =K I= H>>>IN I H>G, G I= JG=K JHJG I= I L L G> I=NH>H I=NHIGN GI>_, = L> I L I= IGJI=, I=GGI I= >I; = L> I HHHH I= G>IG>, I=GGI JG>H= >I I I=G. A; > I=JH >H=, I=JH HJG>G I G>KH=> G>H, J, L= L> HI I I= GI> N>< => >JI>KI>< I= > N, L= = H=J >HIGJI>< I=LG?

    EJI>, > I= HH > L=>= >I =H N JGHI,I=J K>L J>>I LG, >H M>II I I= HH GG>. I GGH >IH IH LN > I>.= >H I=I I= >KIG HH > =>H=>H, I= =>H=G > >KHI>< I=HNHI I= J>KGH, G HJ=, H G L H> I GHJa>I I I= GJI> I=JH KIH. BJI I= JI> =K HG>>< >H I= GKGH I=>H. I NH >H >I> LGH, HH => JHH GI= GJI> H>. IH, L=>= >H I > >IHL IJG >GI>, H>N HJH G >aJI,I= I=I JIGI>< J>KGH GGG, G>< I= NJI=J> HI I= I H H >IH I, LJ HGN JGI I=G>< G I= , G I HI KGN H JG, J>H.

    =G GN J G I=>H JI >HKI >I> JHI>, I=I G=H>K H=, I=I>>IN >H I I= GK JIGI> I,I=I GH >>H > >IH H=I= GIG I= J>?

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    26/236

    B_IH >I> JHI>.

    B% . C"A..

    >KGH>IN >IH

    >`J:

    GK N I=>HIH H>IN.

    B% . C"A..

    B I CIIH

    III. POLITICAL JUSTICE

    = _IH >I> JHI> L> HI JGHI, >L H>G H>IN > I= HI G=H>K

    K>L, I>< >I JG HI>I I= GGJH>HI>IJI>H N L=>= I= =J > =H II = > >IH GG, H L H I=HL J >>H J> >>K>J>IGHI, L=>= G=H N I GNM>, > GG I I=>G >< K.

    L > L=IKG >I H>G, L I

    K> G>K>I> >HI>IJI> >HJ>GN HIG< > I=I KGN >I > L=>= I=aN JI> LH _>I, I= MII >IH GI>. =I>I > H LN >`JH JG JI L> =GN >HJI. I >HHJa>IN K>JH I=I HI> H JI IGG >I, G GHJI >I. A I=^IH I=I N G>> I >I I= GI> J>INN GJ, >I GJH J G=H>K H. I GIH H>>G >H > I= L=, G H>G GI I= H>IN. =I>K >I M=>>IH, I= HI>JJH >I K, JH

    I=N G _II I GJ ^I J >. =N L> I=GG>K>IN >`J I L= I=N G FJN GHH. >GIJ,L=G K>GIJ >H I= GHJI, L> H I IH GIJLI=JHH II>. I L> >I=G , G G I , HG>_ JG GH KIH>IGHI H>GI>H.I L> GG I=H I= GIH, HJGI HJG>IN JGGI>IJ, L= LG G >IH HI G> >H.

    A, >I> G KJG I=aN >I> >HI>IJI>H, G>HH G I=MIH>K >`J L=>= GI> H G>>H,GI HNHI H>IN, =K J I MGI. JGHI>I>, >GI G H=, H JI> >IGHI, G GGGH I=I =K LNH IIL>I= I= HI MIH>K HFJH. "L >G> I I=GHI N I= ^IH HJGHI>I> M=>>I > I= >I> >IG>I, I==J>>I> I= H= >JH I= BG> L>LH HI I

    HIGN I=HKH J I= JG > I=>G =JHH? =IG =GG>N >G I= I= >HI > L=>= H

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    27/236

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A..

    G> K>.

    JI>IJH > G> JIG>H I GGJKI> H I= IGJHI >N? BJI, =LKG LGJ I=HGGGH N , I= >G IGJI=, > HI>H=, LJ >GN H HK N H=,HJGHI>I> G >I, L> GIJN MH I >IG

    LG >>H, >HGK>< N >KJIGN HJG I=JI = =H HI GHJ I I. > HG >I G IGJI=, H I > I= >HI >IH HHI GIJGH IIG G>>. HNHI H>IN H I=GJI= >HI, H I GFJIN IHJGIJ, >GIN JHI>. BJI IGJI= >H> >IH G=H =G>JH H>HII.

    = GI> I=>H >GJHI >JH I H J>< HGKI>, I=I >I N

    GHN JI L=I=G GGG J KG G> G K, > I >I HJGI. =IJG > >H I I I= GI> >H, I=>GGGH >^G. I= G>HGI I=H >H>IH IGJ I HI JGHJ>I. EGGG LJ > G I> =K I= GHJI JG GI> GI>H; JI, H JGGI>H G I>JN =JN >I GGI, JG GGGH LJ =K IGN, JG J IGHJHII>I>, I= > I=I LG GNI>< `H= L= I=N H I I>< G, G>>>< L>, J KG=K >I> >IH >G H >I = I G>G N>K> JI=G>IN. LJ I =K H < GHJ I=HKHI=I I N I= >IG>H,G I= I I=I I> >JI >>,> I= GHJH> = I >I> N GKJH,LIH H. A HNHI I >H I>>H =NG>HN, LJ GHINJHI >IH HJIH I I=> JHIN J I>H G LGI= >GI. A HII, I=I H=J HI> G >H>IGN >GI> I=H, I=JH GIJNHI>JI>< >IH GH I I GJGN, LJ H >HI>H=G > >< KG>IN. A JIGN, > L=>=H >IN _ H=J H I I I= >HH I>, KJG >IGHI,LJ I < I= GH> HGK>>IN >I.

    =H GGH HJ, I=I >H GHI >IH, I

    I= JH> I L=>= I=H G>>H G I. I >, I=I GGJH >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    28/236

    B% . C"A.

    .

    ^G FJI HJI> G I= M>HI G K>, H>IH I= GJI> =J >I> >, JHI =K >I G >IH > FJ>I>H I HLG< L=>= = GK>JH M>HI.

    = GH>I> HHGI > I=>H I> >H JJIN IGJ. AK> >H I=>< G I= GGG >HI GJ >I GI>, I H I= G>> JG JI. BJI GGG >HGIJN =HI>< I >IH L II>. >>JH JI >H H>HKG I >KK >JG>JH HFJH. JHI> I=GG N>IH L IJG >H >II _II G JG M>HI. BJIIH = J I= HG>< I=G >H > H>IN, JIH HI I >IH I>* .\ I KH HJHI G IJG GGGH. I GKGHH I= GH>I>H >, , >HI HJ^G>< JH I

    GLG, I=H JH I LG GGI>. I GIH JH I H I= J>LG, I > >KI> >GKI, JI > I>>GKG G I= >H>H JG HIGH, H > >I LG I=IJG > LNH I >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    29/236

    B% . C"A. .

    GN GJ, IL H > H>IN:

    B% . C"A. .

    G>I, 1. >MIG KGIN.

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. V.

    INFLUENCE OF POLITICAL INSTITUTIONSEXEMPLIFIED

    GGN GJ, IL H > H>INYG>I, 1. >MIG KGINY2. > I= HIII> I= G>=Y3. > I=>GINGNYGG GIY1. N HI>Y2. N I=>>HIGI> LY3. N I= >FJ>IN >I>.

    T"E aN >I> >HI>IJI>H L> GG HI>G K>I, > L FJ>G >I I= =>HIGN I=

    HI H>G K>H I GHI M>HI>< >H>IN; > >I H=L I=I I=N G>K I=>G >KIGNG >I> >HI>IJI>.

    L I= K I I= >IG>G >N I>H, L=>= I I=>H I> GK> > I= LG, L> L I H>HI > I= >GGI=G _GHI N K>, G HN NGJ. < I= >=>IIH N JIGNI=G M>HI H>G > >>K>J I HHHH =>H I=

    HJHI I=G, G H>G H K=I GHIHH, H IGI => I FJ>G >I N H >H>HII L>I= GG JHI>; JJIN > I=I JIGN I J=GN L JI N GGI. KGN JL>I= GI >>IN I> I= HHG>H >,, I>>< I=, JHN GK>< IG >IH HJG`J>I>H,III> LJ H >IH LG. G>KI >IGHI LJ K>H>NG L>I= J> K> H>IN I=I IGN=H >>H IL=>= I=H K>H L I=>G M>HI, I= IGII N L=>=I=N N K>I G G>.

    >GHI I= >I >H I HGK, I=I, > I= HIG_ HIIH EJG, I= >FJ>IN GGIN=H G>H I G>< =>G >=>IIH G G>K HI KGN I> I=I GG > IG G HJG. =>G JIHI >JHIGN HGNHJaH G I=>G HJGI. = L =>G L>I= >HJGI L> I= LG GG > GKG> MGHH>G J HH

    G H I=H HJI>H L=>= G GIJN >>I I

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    30/236

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    31/236

    3. > I=>GINGN:

    B% . C"A. .

    B% . C"A. .

    I= G GH, =K HGI H>JHHHI=I I=N HHHH I=>< N L=>= I=N H HJGN HHGII=>G G-> I=>G >G>GH I >HI, H I=HJG I=>G FJ>G GI>J I= HJIJJHHH I=>G IGI>IH. = G >H HIGJ

    L>I= I=>H M=>>I>; = H =>H L >HG>H; = LH =LJLG> G =>H ^GIH I I> HG >II I=>HG>HIH J G >>IN. " IGHJ =>H I=I G>G < =GI.

    A I=>G >HKIH I I I KGINL>I= >HII H>HIH > I= >H JHJGI> I= G>=. I= G LJ > I=G GHIH H

    =>H > =>H=> >>^G, , H>JHI=I = HHHHH KGN I=>< I=I >H IGJN =JG I HJN H =>H G>= >HKN, =>H > I G>I => I H. " HH H > =J KG HI>H_ L>I= =>H HHHH>H JHH = I= HI I= < I I=GH; I=I =HI H-HI, N L=>= =>H >G>G >H GG>K I I=N, >HGG I= >HIGJI < => L>I= GHH> >JHI>. N JIG>H JHI> >H KLN HJI H>>II>, I= I= =>I>H HI >>N GG>H =>H JH HI I=JGII G>HH. JIG>H L=G I=>H H=HHGI> >H I HI>H=, JHI> >H GFJIN IIG MH>K JG=H, I= L>I= I= HGKG>N K>IG>JH. A H>JHHH I=H IH JHI MI I GG I= G>= >II JI>JH ^ > =>H >I= I= G, I >H>G => L>I= IG KGG>IIG> ING>. G H I=>H >>GI GHH> HI>HN=>H HI>H. = G>= G > HJ= JIG>H >GIN G>>GIN I= HIGH I= HII; HFJ GGIJN GJ>< GHH> >I HNHI, G>K>< I=

    G I=I >II I LG, L=>= >H HI> =K G> I I=.

    = >>H >>K>JH, HFJI=>G H>GH, G H>G >H I=>< JI >>IJG>< G I>, L> LNH > IN. BJI I= GH GK>>< > NJIG>H G JGIN JI I >GHH K>I>, I=I>IIN, K>GIJ, JGHI>< >JHIGN G I=>H KGN I=>G IH

    >>K > H>IN, H>N NI=H L= LJ JGHI I >II I I= GHI? DH = _

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    32/236

    GGGI:

    B% . C"A. .

    1. N HI>:

    B% . C"A. .

    G > =>H > LI I=>G HH>HI KJG? " >HGHIN IJIH I G G.= HH I=I >H G I => >H, =, G>= NJGH NL=IKG H, I> I=H HJG`J>I>H L=>= G G, NJ N I= HJG >

    GI>. AG> HJ= JIG>H >H K>L H I=IH. I >H H G L>I= HJG G I= HGJH =HIN. I >H H I= HI>> >H =HH I= I= J>HI>H=>< JJI>, I=G JI MHL=>= G I >H => J I= LG H G JI I= =>H. " =HIH I I= G>IN I=I JGN, I= G L=>== GH; , II= =>H GGIN, HG>_H I= >IIN,

    KG>IN =GIG L=>= > > =>HKGH>IN.

    J= G I= JHH, I=I, > >^GI GI N GHGIN I G= J I= GGIN =I=G. I JH H>G =L G I=N >I >I=G GN G I> >HI>IJI>. =IKG IH IGH I= >JG>H III J KGIN, GHH I I=H I> I= >G>I H>G I= GJH JJI> LI=. I= >H I JGHJ G >IH L H, H G I=HHJ _I>H >I JG=H, JI G I= H GHHI=I G>G>N GI I I= FJ>H>I> G>, G I= K >HI>I> G II."L L LJ G>O I= HHHH> G>=H, > I=N LG I N I=>G FJ>G H I=>GIGI>IH > H>IJ, L>I= N I LG I I=>G_, HG> HGKG GN I KGI I=I LG>I JI> I= LG? >GI> LG I K GGIN I= G>=, II I=HII FJN KGIN, I= K LJ H I J>KGH HH>. I JH H>G > L=I GHIH >I>

    >HI>IJI> >H GG HJHGK>I I I=>H HH>.

    >GHI I=, HI> >H > HI KGN JIGN = HI I= G. J= >H I==GIG I= = I=>JHIG>JH GJHI> >H G> I HIGN I= > I=I GNHJ I= =H =>H JIJG HJH>HI, G I HJN =>H L>I=I= I=I JHJIH > =>H I=. J= LH I= H>G>I I= I GKJ LH G, L=>= > HKG I=>G GK>H>H

    MJH>KN J I= =J >JHIG>JH, MI G I=>G GI> I=H L= LG HI I HJGI

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    33/236

    2. N I=>>HIGI> L:

    B% . C"A. .

    >I. =JH > EH I GJH = >> HH I= >I > IJGN I= IMH HJI> =K MG> >I> I=>GI >>H GJ JG>< I= H G>. =>H >H III, L=I=G^IJ G , I I=GL I= JGI= G I= G>= J I= G,

    H HJ= >H M=>>I> I= H>G>I HI>. I=H G>> GGN I=G ^H, L=>= I= LI=>GGI I= J>IN =K III> I >I, G IGIH >I G>H, II L>I= I= HI G>=J J>H=IH. = G>= G JGIG I= MJI> I= HI GI> GHH>K H>I>K LH.>H IIH G K>H=N >HH I HJ= H G I JG=H I=. => I= HI K>I >N >H N IGKI >I>H I= G I _M I= G> JG, I=NG G>K I= _I I=I GJ J=

    LJ HI I= H I=>G >JHIGN.

    N, I= >>HIGI> L >H I HH>>FJ>IJH I= I= H>G>I > L=>= >I >H G.G I= I II= >>HIG. ", L= L HI =L I H GI > I=GI> IG JHI>, J ^G I JG=H I= >IHJI>H I I= =>. I= >I

    JHI> LH KLN I GHH>>II>, LGJ G>, =HL, G GG GHI, LG GI>H J= H >>HIGL>I= IG >GI>>IN H G H G >IH; JI I=JG >I ^H, HFJ I= GFJN GH, K =G L> G I KJG JH. JHH GI>< I GGIN I= GI> L >H GG>K I HJ= >I= H I GG JHI> >^IJ. = IH, I= JI>> H G JGI I JGI, I= GJH H JH, IIG>H, HGIG>H, GH, I= GL>< G>H,

    >H, G>I>H G>GH, L=I =H HI>H I= JH JGI>IN I= L, GG >I I GK>H I GH>I, GI>JGNMJ I= >KG>H= >I G I= >IHI = GGHH. I=>< GI>N >H G GI> I= I HJG I FJHI>H IGKGHN = HN >H>, L=>=,> L>I= I= > I= JJH>GKIH > I= HIGJI> JG>H, LJ >HJG I=FJ>I >I> H.

    =>GN, I= >FJ>IN >I>H JHJN >I> N

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    34/236

    3. N I=>FJ>IN >I>H.

    B% . C"A. .

    >I> >HI>IJI>, >H JI M LI=. I=>I G=>H I= HI, > JGN II= GHI N, >I HII> JHGN > I M>I >>>I G. = I>>

    >=>II IG G =>H HJG>G; LJ=K I=JI >II HH I= H=N, I IJ= I= K> GLN I= GJ HIG KG =>H >JH G>. = H G>>HLG MIH>KN GKI JG I= J HNHI. = KHH,L= LH GK HI J I= HII, L G I= G>IGGN _I =>H G, LJ HGN

    KIJG I HJHI I=I = LH I= H H>H. =>H =LKGHI>IJI JIJG K>I H>IJI>. =G >H GH>IN > I GI=G I= I= JIH>; I L>I= LG>I FJ>GN >I I= I>I I= JHIGI I=

    HJHHJ. EG>KGH>H J I=>G HJG>GH. = L-< =>H IGFJ>>IN >HIJG NI=>G HJGN >I HGHH. =>H GH>IN >N JGK I I= HI HJIGN JGHH.EKGN > GI> JIG>H J GG, >H>G L>I= I= H>JHHH >I>OH=>, I =>H I>K a>I G I= K, I=I, > >H, = J I

    IG J; = LJ I= I= JG>H KN, GHII H>G.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    35/236

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    36/236

    IH >I >H J, G I=I HH G>H I=I >JHHH G_I >I =H H> M=>>I.

    IH >< LH GN G I=H >KJIGNG>H, L=>= >IH G M G J I JIIG

    > I= G>HI HIG M>HI, L=>=, GK>JHN II= > M>I>< >IN G GJG>< HH>HI,HIJHN G>H G I= GI> >J JG > G. =H G>H, L= IJNJIIG, HJI GI> I => N L= I=N GJIIG; , >< HGK I HIIN HH>I L>I=GI> G>>GN >GHH>H I M>I I= > I=H>GHH>H > I= =GG, N IGLGH GI GG`I> I= H>G G>. EG I J>I N

    >GI> I I=G, L> H GI JH I JIIG H H>HJ G I= JGH M>I>< III>: I=>H HJ L> GNGFJIN GJG I GH I KG>IN, L> I I LG N KI> G I= >GI> >I I KN. BJI I= >HI >H MIG G I=H H> H J>I>, L=>= L HHHH > L>I= H I=>G>G >H, I I= NH>H HIGI> L=>= >, I=JI >H N JGHI >I I= HJ>HI GI>H >, >H >H HGI K L>I= >HG G I=M>HI >. = MI HI I H> GI> >H I=I G>H, G I= J>< IH I=GI> I=>G GHH >^GH. >I=JIG>H I=G GG, L>I=JI GG I>: I=JI JHI LH G>H >H GI> I=I N GG N I= > L>I=JI KGI>< I>IH IJG, I=I>I=G I= GJI G I= HKJHHH I= HKG HIH I=

    >IIJ GH >>INH I >GI HIGI>. = HHI> I-N >H HH, >H>>G, L>I= I= HHI> NHIGN, >G >H GHI>< I= JI I I. >I=JI I=>H I= >I L>, L=>= LH HHGN I I= _GHIM>HI HI > >IH GI>H N= >H >> > I= KGN I> I=J< I=JH > GG , H I=> FJ>I L>I= >IH L LGH GIH GHIHH H>G

    IG GI=G G >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    37/236

    CM>IN GH I_GHI J>KGH.

    GKK>I>H.

    B% . C"A..

    BJI, I=JI N H >HH>, I IGI= JHH I=I JGG I I= GJI> I H I I= HH G I=I I=>H >H FJ>H>I> HLHI> KJ. = KGN HIH, LG L I JGHJ

    I=, LJ G > HH NG>I=. = >HI >H>HJG IL I= I=G G JG KGI>JIHJH JIIG N >H, I= >JHHH M>I IGLGH >K>, I= HN L=>= GGI>H G HGI G I=>G HJHIH LGH G I=, I= G=H>K >HIG>JI> GIH H=, KGH, I>KH GI>H, I= >`M>H LGH NL=>= I= =G IG>I>H =G >G GH I=>G I= HJ= JHHI, I=I =, L= I= => I L I=I I= JHH IH = IJN GG,G L= I= I=G LH I >I>IN FJ>I L>I= I=GK IJG >, LJ GJ I= >H=I I= >HH>.

    A H >KI>, L JI I >GHH JH L>I= HH I= GK IJG , >H I=I =I> LG>I>H=> LG>IGH, I =K GJGH I >GJJH>IGH>I> H I= N FJI HJI>. G>IN G > G GH, I= I=I H>< I=HJH LGH >I JG ILIN H> IH G IIGH, _>< I=H IH > I=G LGH. = L =KM> I= HJI >II G HN, G>K I= HIH

    N L=>= I=>H JG LH >H=, G=H I= >H>IN I= JG L> GI=G J JH, H = I=I H= =K JI >> J>IH, L> =K KHIG > J I= HJI, I= =I=I N H>GH I= > I= =>G LG>I>< =H KG HJGH N=I>, I=>H G I= KGN IJG I=>GH H>GN HN>, I=H J >< I H>N IN IH, N H GI> H=>I G N =I I I GGHI.=N =K =LKG IL >H LG>I> >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    38/236

    B% . C"A..

    A>I>.

    I= G, I=G G I= KJG =>G LG>I>< KGN LG N >IHGGH>< >IJG; JI I= KJ I=>GK>I>H G >I.

    ">G LG>I>< H= N > H>G > I=_GHI >HI H IL I= HHGN I>. = >IJG I= LG = I= GGHI I= >, H >>IN H I= I=G. BJI,I=JI, I=N L> >IN HH>I; I=>IJG I _GHI >GIN, IGLGH G HIINHJ >IH GGHI HJ. I >H > I=>H GI=I I= GI> HHH C=> I >HHIN, I=>G =>G LG>I>I. = =GIG GG>I I I=I LG I=N

    LG I FJ>I L>I=, G >I > I HJGGN. E= I= HNH =LKG LH >HI>I LG > I=G.= M>I I=I HJI I=H IL=GIGH L>I= G H>N>< I=>G J>, I=J G>IN I==GIGH = =>I=GI GG>I I >H >^GIHGI, L=N JI L>I= I=I L >II KN. =JH HGI GJH G =GGLH GJ. I=G HH I= LG, I=J, LH >< >K> >IIL HJH, I= H GHH LH N. =>H >H _GHI HIILGH =I> NH>H. LG, HJ= H I= >IGI>)!G I= GI>A>H GN HJ GIN H>, I=JHJG>H=H _GHI HI I I= >_. BJI, I=JH NG=H GHI JH L>I= >I K>L I= G > L=>= =I LH GJ, NI I= IJ GJI> I=I >H G=H =J >HKG>H, I=I L=>= GFJ>GI= HI GHKG>< G`I>, I= J>HI JGG >GJHIH, I= HI I>I I=GJH HJHFJI>GKIH, I=GJIJIH I= >FJ>INIL LI I= J J= G I=I=>H, H> I= HI >K>>H H>IN >H>_>IN >^GI G L=I = LJ =K , L= HIG> I= _IH = =H G>K G >IGIJG I= GIH. I JHHJGKN I= GI= KG L>I= I= JGH , =JHH,>HJGH, =GKHIH, JIJGH, >HIGJIH, =>H,II= I= LGH >I>H=N.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    39/236

    B% . C"A..

    J= LH > =>H G> HII, HJ= >H H L I GHI = =>. H >I HH> GJH I II L=I = =H GN ,L>I=JI >< >GHH L>I= HIG< GHI>I I=>GKIH = =H NI I >H=? =G >H H> I=I >H

    I >I>H; I=G >H GI I=I N I GG> I HI> =>. I=>H IGJ I=G H>H, L=N I GH? I=>H IGJ I=G GIH, L=N I H>>HI>IJI>? = KGN I> I=>H H HH>, >H > I= =>H >H I= IG L>I= L=>=L J IGJI=. I JH ,I=I L N G_I N I= MG> >; JI I JH I , H > I= L>H JG HIGH LH HJ= H I K

    G G JIJG >GKI.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    40/236

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A.. = FJHI>HII.

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. VII.

    OF THE OBJECTION TO THESE PRINCIPLESFROM THE INFLUENCE OF CLIMATE

    Part I.

    OF MORAL AND PHYSICAL CAUSES

    I= FJHI> HII.YGK>H HHI> G`I>.YGJHH GFJIN >HI G =NH>.YHJG>G>IN I= GG

    K>I G I= KG>I>H =J =GIG.YGI> =NH>JHHGGM2014GI>>IN>>IN G`I>.Y=NH>JHH > I= _GHI >HI HJG>G, IGLGH G.YI>G I= ^I G > >H.YJH>.

    T"EE G GI> GH>I>H L=>= N H>G>>^GIN, >I=G H GG>H `L>< G I=G>>H GN HI>H=, G H HJG L G>IN I=HG>>H. I= _GHI K>L I=N G I>I I G

    GH>JJH HIII, > I= H I IJG M>I>.G M:

    = JHH L=>= G I GI J I==J > N >K> >I IL HHH;GI>H, L=>= G GG >GIN HJI GH>JIH I I>; GI>H, L=>= I >>GIN JI= >, N GG>< I= > G ,G I= IGGN HJ >I>K. AG>< I I=HNHI GN HI>H=, I= GG I=H G I G< H GI>KN >a>I HJG>I H I HI > I= HI>I H HI I=>K>>GI, >I N I JHHH I M> G I I=>H I=N =K G, I= GHH L=>= =K >J I=I HG> H J= I I= HI G= I= =JHI>IJI>.

    GHH>H J JG HHH N I >I=G H =NH> G GJHH. >HH>I> I= N GIH J I= >

    G>>N > I= _GHI I=H LNH, H>< L>I=JI N G>GI> I= JGHI>< I >> JH I >HHI>HI>

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    41/236

    GK>H HHI> G`I>.

    B% . C"A..

    G JHHGFJIN>HI G=NH>.

    B% . C"A..

    >. CGG J>H=I ^IH JH G>>N > I=IIG , H>, I=JI >GIN >IGJH >J HII I= >, >I >`JH JG JI, N H >I >H G`I J NI= JGHI>I I>K I>.

    I N JG>JH HJI> I M> =L GI=H HHH G >HI>I G = I=G. II > JII=I HHI> >H H I > I= ^>G. IHHHHH I= >>I>I>K. I >H I=I G L=>= I= >IIH L>I= L=>= L G FJ>I II=>G GI>H. IH _GHI ^I J > H > I= G>IN HH G G`I> =>. H HH I= >GHH>HJ JG HHH G GH N JH, N HFJIN GH>HI > I= JIHI. BJI >I LJ IG>I> I aG I=I

    I=N LNH GH. GH>H >IH I= ^HG>< MG>.

    L=>, I=J GI>JG >HIH GH, HFJ INGHI, NI J= I=>G ^I >H > HHI HG> I >GI> =>. [ >J HHI>, GHJ NH I=I >I >HL>HG I HJ>I, I=JH =G>H= H >IH>`J, I= I GH>HI. >K NH JGIJI, GHHN >I> JKJG >IH, GG NI=>H I> HII LGI=. HI>HN NHI=I N H>IJI> >H HJ= H I GG MGI> JGH, >K I=I I= III LJ GJ I=>< JI GI>K GJ>IHH IGIJG. G> >HIHH, HJI>K.\

    "L >^GI LJ I= HJ N H>IJI>, > LG >IN HI>IH =GJHH, >JHIGN JG [I=I G>N N =H L I KGI KJG >I LG.\ "L H>N LJI=>H MIG >HKI =>H > = G J I= _IH IG>H G =>H KJG, > I= G>N N = JI > I= L>I= =>H L> =>G, I= HI >JHIG>JH GLGH I HIL J =>H, G >>IN I HJG I=>H JIGN? [>,\ L G I, [G=H _I I= II=-=, GGH > HIG< I=>>< H>G>IMGI>.\ "L < LJ I=H I = JI HI HJ JMI > >I>H >JG>JH IJG G >`>I I= N, G JIG N I= > L>I= JIG _GHH, L=I >H

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    42/236

    B% . C"A..

    JG>G>IN I=GG K>IG I=KG>I>H =J =GIG.

    B% . C"A..

    I= L=>= > HJ= >HIH >H HJ^G? H I= GI, [BI ,INGI! =J NHI HIGN I= H= AMG=JH, JI I=J HII IJ= AMG=JH =>H?\ "L J= > LH GN JGN JI>JH RK G=>H= CGG, L= = HI>N

    = =>H = I KJG N I= `H? "L J= >H JGN I= HKH, L= H>< > I= >HI IGIJGH, HGHI>N GK I=>G IGIGH I G >JH GG>IN?

    = IGJI= I=I HH I GHJI G I=H H>GI>H >H, I=I>>HH>I> N H G> > GGI> H >I >HH N I= HI I= >; I=I JG J> I> L>I=I= IG> J>KGH >H I I= GN JG =>; I=I I= >>>IN I= JGHI>< G>IIJ MGI> >H G>>N ^>G G

    H>GI>, M>HI>< N > I= L=>=>I >H >GIN GGG.

    [= =G I-N,\ L G I, [H= N >> G G>N IH=G KGI >I LG I-GGL.\ K>< I= H>GI> =L G I=>HI L=G >I M>HIH >H > G>IN G >IIJ IJG, I JH M> I L=I > I=>H HGI >H I= IGJ >M =JI>H. =K GN HI>H= >I H JI, I=I I=G G >I >H. HFJ, > LG G>>N GJHIH HJ= HI=I IH=G, I=>G =GIGH I>H LJ J=>. = H LI=G, I=I NJ LG, LJ H I, GN LJ I N I=>H IHIG= LJ GKI N I= >GI>>IN I=>HIJG, > GGI> H I= N K, L=>= =HHG>N JHI , >I I= H IH=G.

    EKGN I=>< I=I =H I= J>G>IN I=>H ^I, GIN >HI>H=H I= =GIG G I=I

    I=G, >H I IG I I= HH>I> >H. BJI HH>I>>H I= IJG GH>>, I= HI JGJH HI>< JG HH>I>H, G >IIJ, I >I, J>IJ I= GHH >^GH I=>G JGG>< > NK I> G . I >H I=JH I=I GH JGGJHIH.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    43/236

    GI> =NH> JHHGG.

    B% . C"A..

    GI>>IN G`I>.

    G>IN I= IH=G, >HI H>GN^I>< I= HH >, ^IH > >I IN G >I=G K G L >I; G >I=G II>H, G I JHN I I

    >HJG I II I I=. I >H N L, L=H IGII =H IG JJ I= L>I= MIG >N, L=H JI>H G I GJH N HIG< J>IG>II>>IIH, L= I=JH >N >GI. >I H=J H>[I=I I= LI=G > >H I ` I GJ I=HHFJH, JI I=I I=G G >H >IGGJI>H L=>=HGN N L>I=HI;\ >I N HLG, I=I I=HJG I H I >HI G I= a>I G>>H =J =GIG, I=I I= HNHI L=>= IG>H JGG>HH G >^GI HJG, G>G>N GIJGH

    L= I= > G >IGGJI> =H HJH>.

    =G FJHI> G >IGHI>< I= I=I L=>= L GL H>G>H> > I=>H H >I H,L=I=G I=H GHH I L>HN L= GHG> I I=HKH GI> >H>> G M>JH I G>= I=>G >H L>I=H>, G L=I=G I= IGGN >I IIG I IGJHI KGN I=>I HH> I=IL H=J I G>K G I= KGN IJG I=I=>< I= KI= I= L>H HHHHH KG I= >H= , I=I I= >IH> L=>= I=N GH L> H I=>< G I I=H >L=>= I=N >^G? I=H GI>JGH > L=>= JG JI >H>GI GN N MIG >GHH>H L GH I= >G>G>H; L >^G G I= > I= >IN L>I= L=>= LGGH, G, GG J IN G`I>H N < G>K IG> HJHI GI> GH>H. G>K I=I >I =H JG LG HJG,

    I=GG >K >I H >K>. >K I= GIH>I L=>= >I >H G H K>< ILGH G = I=G, = FJ>G I= >H >HI H. >K I= H HIG>>< HI = I=G, = G>K I= I> >IG>>IN, IN IJ, I= HLHH, G>>IN >GI> I>. I I= HHI> > > I= =. I G`I J >IH JHH, >IH HI, I= HIGJIJG I= GIH> L=>= >I GH>H, I= >K> >I >HH, I= HFJHL>I= L=>= >I N II, I= G>H I=I N > I=>G ^IH, L=I=G MIG G >IG, IG> G

    >IIJ.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    44/236

    =NH> JHH> I= _GHI>HI

    B% . C"A.. HJG>G,IGLGHG.

    I> GI= ^I G > >H.

    B% . C"A..

    I >H IGJ I=I I= >I >MG> > I I=JHNH JG J >HHGII>H =>H=NJI >IH HIIG>K> HHI>H. J= >IN >GH H G>< >GHH>H. > >H > >IH

    >N GN L=I I=H =>H=GH HG>,I= GIJG I>H. BJI I= GI=G >IKH, I= G >I >>K>J>HH. E= =H=>IH GJ>H I=I G GGN =>H L. ">KH > >II J>KGH =>H L GI>IHL>I= I= >GHI IG KJ IGJI=. >I= I=H =GH I= HJHH>K GI>H =>H >, J I=H I= JH>H = GLH I= JI = HGKH." >I >K>IN LH, I=I =NH> JHH, I=J I= =>HIGN , H> >I I=>I= I= MGHH> GI>H G`I>.=N G I= GJ>H L >K G I= JH IGJI= H=, I=I HI>IJI I= IGJ H>H >HI>I> IL . = >^G ILHK I= _GHI I= =JH>H > GI H>IJ, N HG> I I= >^GI>GHH>H J I=>G HHH. BJI I=>H >^G LJ HI >GI>. = >H L>H N LJ KG=K IG I= =J >, > , > HIH, G>K >I=G G I= G`I>H >HKG>H I=>G

    >H HIGH.

    " L G JG>H= L>I= HLG I I= GG ^IHI=I =NH> JHH G I GJ JGJIH. [BG G M GH I JFJHI> >GI I I= =GIG FJ>_I>H =GHH H G GI>I=G GJI JI JHH I FJNa>JH > I= H ? "L H >I I=II= GH >H G=H KG

    GJN JI>KI; I I= H I> I=I L =K HJG>INHI I= L>HHI =>H=G'H < J?\

    HLG, I=I I= M>HI =NH> JHH I IGKGI. I= H I=>G aN >H HLL J >I= HJG>G >GI G`I> H>. >H I=IGGN I=N G I HI . G I> = G =>H >N, MI H G H LHHHGN G I= G I= H>H, > H>IJ; G K >I=N LG MJ G FJ>I L>I= I= >GKIH

    >I>H I=>G HIGH, I=JII I= H>IN = I=G, I= GI> G > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    45/236

    CJH>.

    B% . C"A..

    H>JJH < I=, H > I= >^GI HHH =GHH H I=N LJ I=GL>H G>K G I=>GGIH >K>>H G =->K>>H >JG: , > I= GJI>H K I> LGJHGK, G IL I= IL HH LJ H.

    J= >H I= =GIG H>G H >>K>J. ">H GI J N MIG>G JHH >>IN,GJ>< GI> ^IH J => >IN I= MG>H GH; = >H GI J N MIG>GJHH >IN, I=>G >GHH>H JG>H=>< => L>I= IG>HG G`I>, HHJ>< I= G I>KH I I G I GG>G I> >K>>H HII, N HI G

    I= L=. " I=I LJ =>K>J,LJ >HGN >HN =>H ^GIH, > = G>>N HJH JGH N I= GI>H =I , GNHH >HIJG J I= > G. = IGJ >HIGJIH G>`J, G H>G KGH>, J>H=I GLG, I=M=>>I> H=IH GLGH, L=>= L>H GGG N I= KGNIJG I= I=>< HIIN G>< < L>I= I=.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    46/236

    B% . C"A.. C=GIG I= G>HI=.

    B I CIIH

    Part Ii.

    OF NATIONAL CHARACTERS

    =GIG I= G>HI=.Y I>H >GIN.YI=HHGI> >JHIGI.YMG> KJGH I=HGH>IGJ>< >GIN.

    A >H I= =GIG I= >>K>J, H N L MI I _ >IL>I= I>H H . = GI>H L >I> >HI>IJI> L> >GII >IGHI>H >I IG>`>< JLGI=N I>. =JH I=G

    G GI>JG GHH>H, HJ= H I=I I= G>HI=, L=>=JHI LNH GI I I= GJI> GI>JG =GIG.

    G>HIH G J H>H JHI I =K I=>G >>H>HI I L>I= >>>I G; I=N L>I=GG >G>JH, >I>I H>I>. =>G HJHH L>I= > HJ I= >> I=>G HJG>G >; I=NL> I=GG GI>JGN M>JH JI GH, I=>GGII L> G GH G. = G >H > I=N L> >GGI>H >I L=>= I=N N GL I=N L> HIJ>JH I . =N G >IGKH I HHJ I=MIG>G GI KI>; JI >I >H >HH> I=I I=>H H=JI I>H G G H> HH >HIGI>. =>G>GI >H I L>I= I=>G G G HJH IHJG>G>IN KG I= GHI >; I=N JHI I=GG IGH GJ> >>>I >I=. =>G GHG>IN HJ I= GI> GI>JG >>H > I= LG; I=N JHII=GG >H I G FJ>GN; I=N JHI =K >HJ I=>G >H >GHH N HI=>< >^GI G I= G

    K>. GI>JG G JHH N > H >HIH >>I,G=H HJGH I= >`J G I I= =GIG I=>G GHH>; JI, MJH>KN HJ= MI>H, G>HIH G>H, >IH =K HIG>>< H>>G>IN GH >HH>I>. I= H G L N GHI HHJG I=I G > L=IKGJIGN L> _G, K>G>I > GGI> I I=>GG, I=I KHHH HKH L> > JG>>.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    47/236

    B% . C"A.. A I>H >GIN.

    B% . C"A..

    = IGJI= I=>H M> =H > GIINJ>KGHN >II; JI >I =H aG I [>HH> I HI>H= G GI> LG ^>I >IH.\ JH I JH

    aGI>, I JH H>G L=I GHH LJ HHGN >GG I >IGJ G I N JIGN.

    = HLG I I=>H FJHI> >H I J > I= HLG I I=II=G, L=I=G G =K N G H> KII =K, I= JG G>< GHI>< >I J G> I G KI LJ>J => I HI G =>H > JI>J

    >H= L, G G =>H G> L>H, GK >H>IGHI ; > LJ GHJ => I GG H I >, _I> I IGIJG, L=I G >H HHGN, I= I=I H=J >G =>H JGHI> H I=H I=>I=>G IGJ JGH? =J _ >I HHGN IFJ>G _GHI L=I >I = LH I>K, L=I=G I=ILG KJG I I= HHHH> I=N = I G>HIH I >GI I=>G H>H, GH I HJI G I=>G HJH>HI, > HIN I=GJM>I> . BJI L=I=G I=N >H N I=H G I=G GJ>H, L=IKG I= > IGGG I=I >JH I= FJ>IN I HJ>I I =K I=>G=H J => I=, I= HJGGI KG I=>G=H, I=H G FJHI>H GH. GJI= N GHI I

    I= > HJ= >GGH>HI> K>, G=H N HJ= JHI >G>H I I=>G G=H>, H JI>IN I FJG I=HI HI>I GHHHH>H. I I= GHH _ >IH LN >IGH> G HI, I I= >I> IGJI=H >HKG N I= HI I= EJG HI I=>G H>HH> I=I L H>IGN KGIH H=J I . I >H I=GGIN IGJI= I HG; , MJH>KN KJH>H, >IH KIH > = HJ>< HL=IG JGJH I= > I=I L=>= LI G. = JHH, L=>=HJH >IH GH, I G >I, JI G I= LI=J

    >IGI JHN HI> HKG> >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    48/236

    = HHGI>>JHIGI

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A..

    EMG>KJGH I=HGH>IN I> N =LKGHL G I=H>GHH, G, L=>= JIH I I= H, I=GI>>>IN G. = HJH>I> LJ G, > L LG I > I I=JH HJ >II,

    H=JI J > =JH, HJG>I N HI I=G G JGGH. ">I=GI I=N =K GHJ, G L=I HJG>IN=H I III IGI>? I=I I=N LG HI>IJI GH, I=I I= HJG>I JG L=>= I=NLG LH HHGN G I=>G GHGKI>.=N =K I=GG HJ>II I L=>H HIGL G LIG, G=H > I=>H INGN I HH>> >H I H>I>. =

    HJH>> HGH, I=N G`I, I=N GH, I= > >HJ>I G I I=G I=GJH I=>GH, I GI> I>H L= I= K> I=>G GH =HI GJ I= G I= HJGH JIJ H>IN. IH I= G GI>, I= HII GHJH> I=G>IN I= GHH _.

    =I L> I= HFJ I=>H >>? > I= >`J >I GKI I= G G>< I= K>JH H I=>G=>HH? H I=G N =J JGHI>< I=I L> IG>K IGJI= > I=>H, L= G>N GIN GHI?H I=G > I=I L> >K >> I H =GG> INGN? G>IN I= =>H ^ I=HKH, L= I= >> >H >HHK. = IN N H>IN GGHJ I HJG N _I I I=HKH, I=G >H IJJI G K> I ^I >I. = ^GI LJ I GH>HI GH,I I N >I. = G>HGH G I > I=>G =, I= GH >G I= I=I >I >H I> I GIJG I I=>G H.=N =K I I=>G I HIGH, H> I I=>G GHJI>. =N FJ>INK I= H> L=G I=N LG =>I=GI

    >JG, GI I= HH>G > I=G .

    I JH G I=>H I=GN L>I= I= =>HIGN >. I= I=GN IGJ, L N MI I _ I=>=>IIH >< GK>H > >^GIHIIH, L>N >HG>>I N I= >`J II HH>>I N GH >I. =JH I= HH G I= G;JI I= I L HH I= NGH, L _ I= HG>JH

    HIJG> =GIG I= >G. =JH I= AI=>H LG>KN, IGI>< >JH, JI I= =H J>H=,

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    49/236

    B% . C"A.

    .

    B% . C"A..

    = J.YI LJ GH I MI I=I>^GI GH , >IG>M L>I= = I=G, JI >^GINH> IGHI. =JH I=JGH G GK, H>G, JI I= G GH ,LGN >IJ.YG>< IG>H HN I

    < I=HKH, =K>< >II HNI=N L>I= I= L>I=L= I=N GH>, N MI I =K >G>IN GH. =>G H>IJI> GGH I= H>JJH, I= JIH >>K>JH G`I >H=JG J I= L=, I=>G GHL> GI>JGN HG GJI, JHH I=N H=J =I JG JG H J>G >J H I GG KJGIG GJII> GJ>IHH. =JH I= AG>H > I= EHI G HJ>KGHN >HI>H= < I= I>H L>I= L= I=NGH>, H I= $LH > EJG; JI I= AG>H G H J= I G G>IN, H I= $LH G

    MIGI>.Y=I GH >H I=G IL I=>I I= G GH, IL I= H I= GHI >=>IIH IN, IL I= JH I= G=? D>GJH >JJH HG>H I= JH H GI>JGNK I I>IJG>IN, AG>HII aGH I=I I=N G I= NLG> I> L= G I LG G>>N G > G>H, L >< MIGG>GN ^I J , H I=N JIH >G>G >H. BJI I= GKGH I=>H GH I I= I. H >I HJH I=I I= >JH? => I= G=, I= GH I= GH>H =K GG G I=>G IN, I=>GH, I= JGH I= C=>H G I HH >HI>H= NI= HG>JHHH I=>G GII. I LH I= >> I=>IH I=I I= GI=G I>H LG > >K>>HI> >GKI; JI I= GH =K J I=I I= EH= GI >G>G > >IGGN > I N I> > I= LG. H >IHHGI, I=I I= GI=G I>H G G =GN JGI FJGIG? I LJ =K IGJG I HN I=I FJHI>H JHJN N KGIN J IN. = JGH, L= G I=HGIH GIGN >K I= GI> GK>H I= >G, I I= G H = LN, L= LG K>< L>I=H>>G K>LH G I= HH GGN HGIH AG>. I=>G MIGG=H =I N IG> I==GIGH I>H, I= I= GH I= I=G. I JI I=I > I=>H

    KGN >HI J= N HG> I I= LGI=HH

    HIG> >I I= =, I I= > HFJIJ HIJH GI>>IN I= I=G. AH I L=I >H G I=

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    50/236

    B% . C"A..

    H >IGJ>GIN

    B% . C"A..

    I=>H, I= GN =H I NI >HKG. =NH> JHH =KGN G I LGJ, I> G H GJI GI>.

    "H >I KGJH I>H G L L>I= I=

    H I= I= HI >HI>H= G I>H> I= GI>H LG.

    I >H JHJN H>, I=I GI=G I>H G HI >I I L>, HJI=G I L. A>II>< I=>H HGKI> > >IH J G,>I LJ N GK I=I >I N GI J I= H JG G, I I=I >I >`JH I=H _G G= I= GI>H >II . BJI I= IGJI= I=_GHI I=H GGH N L JI. = GH G I

    =K HJa>IN >I I I= HJGH I= II.A< I= GH>H =GIG LH G KI I= I=I =G G>G. I >H HN I I> N I=>< I= G L>KH =>G, >M=FJG.

    AH I L I= >GJHI N JI G G GJHH. = =I I= >I >KH HG I IJG>IN > =I JIG>H. A I=I=H >GJHIH GJ K> JHN, JHH L=>=>K>IN I I >` I= HH>H* .

    = GHJI I=H GH>H I= JIHI>GI I => L= HJIH J G>>H H >II HFJ L=I>HKG>H N > G >I>H>, >, L= L =K HGI> HI JGIN L=I G I=>IIJ GFJ>H>IH I=I I L>H K>GIJ, > G>>JH G>> >H I >IGJ >IH, I>I JGJH>H. AG>IGH I= HJI II>N >>< L>I=

    I=JH>H J I= KIGIN I= FJ >H > I KGN H> _I, =K NI J I=I I=GGJI>H HI>H I= JHJGI>H G>HIGN LG I GI> K>H>H I= LG, JGGG >>II>H I>I I JG GI>.

    BJI I=>H =NI=H>H L> J > =>< JIHI I'H HG>JH G`I>. C I=G N HII > I=I GGH I=> I= MG>H GH? C I=G

    G> > L=>= >I >H HHGN I = I= =J H>H > >I> J>I HH JI GH I=I

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    51/236

    B% . C"A..

    I=>G HJG>IIH H, H > I= H >IH I=G HGI, H=J GK> G I= H I=>G HJH>HIL>I=JI >< J I= G I= MGI>H J >JHIGN.=GKG G II I I= _GHI JI>H =J>IN >I= , I GK> G I=>G HI I= >KH>H

    =J>H I= HN, I=G I=N L> JI JI J FJN KGN I=G MGI> I=I N HHGN I I=>G HJG>IN LG. GHI I I= HI>IJI> L=>= H= JI I= >I H> >I>I= >GI>< I=>G L ^>GH, J< I=>G IHIH< I=HKH, =G>H=>< > I=>G HH N HH >IN, FJ>IN >, NJ I JI I=IGHG>IN K>GIJ L> I= GHJI.

    = G >H >GIN > N JIGN G I I= , JI

    I=H =>LH H>IN >I GI> JG I= >GN JI G`I>< GH; K I I= H >HIGJIGH; I= JH>HH >H . =>H =LKG >H I I >H= JI > G JNG > I= HFJ. = GGG >H, I >IGI>< I= LGHI GH , JI > HJH>< =GI>, I >HHIN >< GLG I >IH >H=I.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    52/236

    B% . C"A.. =

    I> HII

    JG I=>HI>

    B% . C"A..

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. VIII.

    OF THE OBJECTION TO THESE PRINCIPLESFROM THE INFLUENCE OF LUXURY

    I= I> HII.YHJG I=>H I>.YGJI GJI>>INYG GI>INYG HNI=NYG I= IJG IGJI=.YI= G>>IN GHKG H>G.

    T"EE >H I=G GH>I> GI>K I I= HJI,L=>= >HHH I H>G H HHGI>>HI>I > >IH, I= H GI>JGG= I=I

    L=>= =H JHI >HJHH; I=GH>I> L=>= aGH, [I=II>H >>>K>JH G HJI I I= = NJI= GH =KHJ >I G>IJ,>I >H I > I= LG HI> I GHIGI= I K>.\

    =>H > =H GIN J J I= GI> I>H HIG > I= GIJ. >GIJ H I= I>K NI

    GI > > I= GI> I= GIJJH, L= >H I JHI I MIH>K G. " JHI H I= _IH IG>H G >H>IGHIG>< I=H _IH. IH >>I K>LH JJI>KI> =K I > I= G IGJ K>GIJ, I=JIN MIGKK>JH MFJ>H>I >HI N I= =GH_H=HH G I= JJH=>< GGJI> L=>= =K GK> >I=>G L I>H, =K GJGG > >I> I I= GHIH GLN G I= JGI ">HG= JGG G >. =>H >I> =H I=^HG>< >H>II, I I= >II GH =>H=N.

    I N IGJ, I=I >H GG I= GJ> I I=GI> L>H, I=I I= H K>GIJ >H >I>G =J I= I= GH >IH H>I. I=>H H >I LJ=K JHIG I G I> HJ > JMJGN, I

    >>K>J L>I= _G =>IH LG>K>J

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    53/236

    JI GJI>>IN:

    B% . C"A..

    G GI>IN:

    G HNI=N:

    B% . C"A..

    L= >>II HI>IJI> LH G>< HI I I= I=G LJ I=I G>H =K >G FJ>I.

    = >I> I>H >H G `JIJI> J HH HI>I > >IH GH>HI I

    H>HII KJG G I=>G >GKI, I=I=I >>K>JH. I>H H I=>G GH L> HH_G > GGG I= I=GH. A GI> JG L> N >

    KGN H >HH I >HI I I= K> IGJI=. =>HJG L> GIJN>GH. EKGN L KGI L> I= H KGI>< I=GH. GGI> H I= N >H>H >H JH I=GH L> KG>, HJ>I I I= KG>IN 'H IGH GHHHH>H.

    A I I=>H I=I H G GIJN < ^I= HI I=G H HJ. =MI L> I =K H N GJ>HI HJJ. JH HI> I> N H GKJI> > >IH^>GH I HHHH G HI>IJI>. = =>G I= GHI G L> G > G _G >I =>IH I=>>>>IN I= K>>JH MIG>IN I=>G I=GH L> K I GI >, G >H>K J >GI == LH >IGJ I _GHI, L> > I= HJ>< >HI>IJI>H =< I= =GIG I>H >H KGN >^GI G >_>IN= G>G>N GJIGN >>K>J. GH ,L= I=N =K >I=G K>IGN >>K>JH. =N >I I= JIJMGI>H = I=G, I= J>I GH M H= JGH I I=I

    JHIGN HGI L=G I=LG GH N >H IG> > JG>< N GH =>H GGGH; JI >H H > = H=J > I>GN L H>IJI>. ">H =>IH G GI=GJH I>KH I> =>JH GI>H N I= GJGG =>HGG I>H, I= L= H>IN G>KH >JH G I=H JH I=I IH J N >>K>J. L >H GHJGH L>I= I=GI> IGJI= I GKI G >< >I

    >>>IN >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    54/236

    G I= IJG IGJI=

    B% . C"A..

    = G>>IN GHKGH>G

    B% . C"A..

    = FJHI> N > G>IN GJ I FJ>GN, L=I=G I= =J JGHI>< I= G>>I IGJI=, L=I=G >I HH>G ^GI H HIGJJH I M>HI H I LG I=>GIGJ >IGHIH. G I I=>H H

    >K>I. I =H GN HJa>IN G, I=I L=IKG >H>I>N G>I>N LG HH IG>K> HFJ I I= LG >. G=N GM L> N LI= N>HKIHJa>I GI> >GI>, >IIG>, JI> HGK>>IN. >I J GK, I=I >I GJ KI FJ GGI>, I=I >IH >I> LJ I I >H=>, G=N >HGG,>H I=G I> J I= I= GI= I L= I=HGH>I>H LG GG , I=I LJ JG I HJ>I

    I >I? H I=G I> J I= I= GI=, I=I LJHJ>I I I= >H>I>H >IH >>HIGI>, I= LGH >IH>H, I= K>H= GKJH N L=>= >I >H >I>,> I=N L >I I GN MGH >HH > I= GG H>IN?

    BJI >I =H GI=G JHI> GI N >IG KH IG>JH JHJGI> I HHGI I= JHI G>>H =J H>IN, I=N LJ J I GIJII=, LJ H N I=>G K>=>IH I I=>G GG K>H GGJI>: I=I >H, I=N LJ I= =G> G I=I H=J GKI =>H GIJG. =NLJ GJH I=HKH H G G I=>G I=GI >^GI K>LH; JI, IG =K>< GH I> I J I=>G K>I>H, I=N LJ HJN > JGHI>< I= IGJI= I=>G G>>H >< I=>G >`J.

    LNH I J I=>G G=H>H GGHH. =GG L GGGH L=>= I=N G IN, L=>= N I GHK>I GGL >FJI K>L I= IGI>K GHI GI=>G =>. GHI HJG N G G GI> > I= >HII HG= I K>. =GKG G JHLG I> N HJI >H GHI I I=>G K>L, GGHI I> GJGH I>H >K>IN LH. "K>< I=JH HI > I= FJ>H>I> IGJI=, >I I H>N >K H HI. A N , =K>JG>JH HFJH K>JG L=>= I=N =K < JG, =K>< H= >I ^, L>

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    55/236

    HGN KJIG>N GHIG I= >H=> I=N =K >=>I.I=>< G> I= I I= GK>K H=, L=>= HI >IGI I=>G GHI K>I> IGJI=.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    56/236

    B% . C"A.. IJG I=FJ>GN

    B% . C"A..

    JGHJ>I

    B I CIIH

    AnENQUIRY

    ConcerningPOLITICAL JUSTIC

    Book Ii.PRINCIPLES OF SOCIETY

    CHAP. I.

    INTRODUCTIONIJG I= FJ>GNY JGHJ>< >I.Y>HI>I> ILH>IN H GI GI>H KGIL>I= GJII> I= IG>G= H= H>GGI >G; , =K>< I=JH G =>H IK JHI H> I I=> I=I I= LG >H I= GJI N G K>, I=I >K IIN _ JI I=G G>H >I>LG* .\ AG>HIGN I= GN , JH I=I I>I I J N I=G JI>I= I=I G> IGI.

    I >H I HJHI I=I I=>H H = LH I I=

    >GIN I= >IGHIH >, >IG> HJH > =>HHG= IG IGJI=, =H IN KGH> I= _GHI HI I= >KHI>.

    =G G IL H, G>< I L=>= L NFJ>G >I I= G> H>IN I=G M> I= =>HIG>N, I=I >H,H>G > L=I G I=N =K G JH=>N, I=I >H,H>G I= G G>>H J L=>= I=N . = _GHI

    I=H HJIH >H I L>I=JI >IH JH; JI I= H >H => >GI. = _GHI >H FJHI>

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    57/236

    B% . C"A..

    G; I= H HJHI. I LJ IG>K> HFJGI>N H>G, G L=I HJG N G H>IN`L, N L=I >IH G>>H LG HI>, J L LNH HJG I=>G G>IN I I= >IIH IGJI=

    JHI>.

    I >H GI=G HHGN G L IG J I= HJI GJNI >HI>H= IL H>IN I I _GHI G I= H JIJHH>HI. =N > I GH I=I N GHIG>ILJ HHGN, I G>K>J GH I= H>IN, ILGH = I=G, G ILGH I= L=. =HH>IN GHIG>I IG =H MGHH I=>H > L>I= J>G >>IN.[>IN ^GI > I=HKH,

    =K >^GI G>H. >IN >H GJ N JG LIH, HH. >IN >H > KGN HII HH>IH HI HII JI HHGN K>* .\

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    58/236

    B% . C"A.

    . CI> >I>H GH

    EMII >< JHI>

    B% . C"A..

    JI JHI>: >

    B I CIIH

    CHAP. II.

    OF JUSTICE

    I> >I>H GH.YMII >< JHI>.YHJI JHI>: >.Y>IH >HIG>JI> HJG N I=>IN >IH HJIYN =>H JHJHH.Y>N ^I>H>GM2014IJH>H>G.YI>H: G>>IN.Y MI> HII.Y.Y>I>.Y> >I> JHI>.

    F L=I =H H> >I GH, I=I I=

    HJI I= GHI FJ>GN >H HIG>IN H>< GII I= H> GH. G>IN >HI= HJG G L=>= >IH JI M>HJHI GL, I=N L> HL=IGG > I= GHI >HI, > L HHJ I= IG JHI> H G G JIN.

    =I I=>H I> >H HJa>IN MGHH>K I= HJI L> G, > L H>G G I GN, IJ, IG, G N I=H JI>H L=>= > HG H>< GIG>HI>H= G JHI>. =N H=J G I=>HG>>, GJGI I=>H KJG, HI> G I=>H >JIGI I= IJG G>IN, >I JHI >I=GG>K>J, >I=G L>I=JI >IG=>I= IJ KI>K>JH. E>I=GLN >I _IH I= L=, JH >>K>JH G GIH I=L=. =GG I >I >H JHI, I GG >I >H JJHI. JHI>=K N >I >H JHI I=I H=J IG>JI KGN I=>< >N LG I I= _I I= L=.

    CH>G > GN I=GL J JG >KHI>,>, FJ>II>< G I= GHI I= >I> K>L, LM> JHI> GN H >I M>HIH >K>JH. $JHI> >H GJ JI G>I> I= I> G>>I >< L>I= I=G. AG=H>K M> L=>= =H > L J I= HJI>H, [I=I L H=J K JG >HM>, I=J< H>G G>I H JGG>>, >H I L>I= I= HIG>IHH =>H=>

    JGN.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    59/236

    IH >HIG>JI>HJG N I=>IN >IHHJI:

    B% . C"A..

    N =>H JHJHH

    B% . C"A.

    .

    >N ^I>H>G

    H L N >I I FJIII>. BJI > G>IN >I >H G I=I JH>H >< G LGI= >GI I= I=I=G. A >H G LGI= I= HI;

    JH, >< HHHH =>H, = >H G G_ =>HH. I= HGI= >JHIG>JH G=>H= CGN LH GLGI= I= =>H =G>, I=G G L JH I=I LJ =H>II I GJ, > =>H LG > `H, I= > N I= J GHGK,L=>= I= IL JH I=G

    I= G>KI H>GI> I= >. G II L>I= G IL G>>I >I= H>IN, I>, > H HH L>I= I= L= >N >. HFJ I=I > J= L> HIJ>K I I= ,HJH I I= I L= = LH >K>< I= GI =>H>GI =JH, H=J GI>< I= _I I=JHH, L= =K JG N I= GJH >I H GGG,

    K> HFJI J=>HH. N, N _I LJ MIGI=G I= I=>H, G KGN >>K>J I=JH JG =H IIG G H>IN, =H IG>JI > =>H IJG I I==>HH, I= >GI> >GKI I=GH.

    JH>< = NH I= =G>, J, GI=G I= I=I H=J =K >. = > LH GN GG I I=I I= =G>. BJIJGHI>< >H I= JIN I=I G>KH I= IGJI= I=>H H>>G GH>I>H; JHI> >H I= G>> I=I GI= =G> I =K GGG I= G=>H=

    I =GH. =K I=GL>H LJ =K G= JHI>.

    JH>< I= =G> = N L>, N I=GG N IG. =>H LJ I IG I= IGJI= I= GH>I>. = > LJ HI> G KJ I= I=I I= =G>;

    JHI>, JG, JJIGI JHI>, LJ HI> =K GGG I=IL=>= LH HI KJ. $JHI> LJ =K IJ I I= M I= I=G. =I >H I=G >

    I= GJ [N,\ I KGIJG I= >H>H KGHI>< IGJI=?N L> G N I=G N G GHI>IJI, >>JH, N> >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    60/236

    GI>IJ

    H>G

    B% . C"A..

    I>H:

    G >HHGI L> > MIGGI> I I= L=>= I=I =J >< LHLGI=N I= >HI>I> GG. =JH KGN K>L I= HJI G>GI> N >

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    61/236

    G JI>>IN

    B% . C"A..

    A MI>HII

    D

    B% . C"A..

    IGGN I I= HIG>I >`M> >H>H JHI>. =>aJIN >K>< I=>H >H L>< GN I JG J>< I=>HH>I> G L=>= I> >H =H, L>I= I= I> >IH.= >HH>I>, I=I LJ GG K>GIJ I K> H JJIN HJI GI>;

    I= GGJH MG>H I=>H >HH>I> N L=>= LG< I>H HI, > JK>, >H I G, JI N JG>< JG >I> KGI >I G> I= H I, [I=I JIJG _IHIH I >GH I= HH KI I>, I=I I >GH I= HHKI I> >H I IG>JI I I= N ^GI GL=I = GN >H? J I I= HI_> HFJH GHJI G >^GI; G NHIIN GJN FJ>G>I I= HGIH I=H L>I= L= I, GI=>G > L G I=>>>IN =J JKGHN I?

    =G HH I G IGJI= > I= GK =>`N G I= JFJ >HIG>JI> GGIN, > KJG N GK>>< > G>GNHH G N L> =>G, N GI=GH GI>H, G GK> G HIG>< G >>K>JH >K>JH, >I HH H > I=G JHI GI> >HIG>JI> I= HH >< HJG>I HJN < I= HH^G>< >I, I=I = N =K =>H > GHJG. BJII=>H G >II I , >H I >II L>I= . I GN HH; HH => GIJN JG, >I>I> L>I= L=>= I=H L> III. JHI

    HKGN HGJJJH > HJG>< JI I= FJI>IN HJN;, L>I= GHI I N > GI>JG, JHI GG =L >II>H NI JGHI I= IGJ N>< >I G I= J>_I.

    "K>< H>G I= GHH L>I= L= JHI>>H KGHI, I JH MI FJ>G >I I= L=>= L G >H JHI I=I H=J I= N LG. DH N GH

    > >HIGHH N I G G>? I >H N JIN II, >I G= JIN > GJH> >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    62/236

    B% . C"A..

    I=>H G>> I J>KGH >I>, >I >H JH, >GG>< _I J >>K>J, N > H >HIH>`>I >JGN HJG>G IJ J NH G H>IN. LI= H JHI>, I=I >H I N >>K>J N L ,>H I I= L=. , L=> G _I J , >I

    G, > HIG>>< FJ>I , I=I >JG>< I=L=, N I> HH I G>K>JH L= I= L= >H H?EKGN I=>< > N LG. =I I I= HI? ; G NH GI I= L=. BH>, >IL> GGN = JI I=I I= GI >< G I=GH KGNI=>< > N LG, L> G >IH MJI> I= GHGKI> N L M>HI; G > I=G LGH, >I L> GGN = JI I=I G ILIN NGH I= > . I= MIGG>GN

    H H=J JG > L=>= GI I= GFJ>GH I=I H=J II I >. I=G HH, >I >H JHI I=I H=J GJ I>I> N N N > > I= JIHI K> I=HI >I> G HGK>.*

    L> HJH G M I=I >I >H G>I=G H I= GJ>I =>H >JHIGN, G I=>=G>I =>H HIGH. $JHI> > I GHGGIN H IGJHI, H J => IJGN I H>G >L=I G >I N HI N G I= >GH >GIN,LGIJ. " =H G>HH H=>>< >II I= L> =>H G>. G G >< I>I I L GJH G =K>< N H HIN >II > I= HGK> =>I=GN, = >H > I= N JHI> >FJI > =L>I== N GI> G I=I HGK>. I=>< G>IGKGI>. CJ I=I GI> =K IIG G GLGI=>N N? =I >I J >H >> > I= KGN IGH I=GH>I>. = >I LH JHI >I H=J =K H N.YI= H G H N GGIN, = N GH H IGJHI >

    = >. J I N N IIH, NJGHI> I=IN , H H I= MII N JIN.

    BJI JHI> >H G>G. >I JHI I=I H=J G _I,>I >H JHI I=I I=G H=J G>K >I, , > L>I== G=> I=I I L=>= = >H I>I, = N JHIN >. N>H > LI I JH I=I HG. =G >H L >I> >HI>IJI> I=I =H I G= I=>H H, I

    IGHG I=>H GGIN G I =>.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    63/236

    B% . C"A..

    B% . C"A.. A>I>

    >I>JHI>

    BJI > I= N H> JHI>, JHH >I H=L I=I I= N G _INN, =>H > >H H I, H > = = N > =>H HHHH>, G = HJ> L>I= H >I =H HI>H HLG, [I=I I=G >H G I= GH, I=I HIH > I= N =K I HG, HFJ JHI I >GIN I HIL >I H H.\ HLG,> N GH ^G =>H I N LH JI . =H I=GH I=I I _ < I I=GG>= I HH>HI (G>= , HN, G KGN >H G>=, L= =HG N I= =>H JHI H>H ), I I . G I= GH ^G, >G _IHH, JI NH G>H HGN HH> I =

    I=I IL H= MIN FJ _IHH, G I=I H= FJN GI> I= _IHH I= H I= I=G.

    I >H I=GG >HH> G I G J N KJG, N => G>IH G I= L JHI>,K L> HJH > I= I J= > KJG H>>K>J G H GI I= H H J= HJIGIG I= H H J= HJI >JHI>.

    = >G HI GN ^G N I=G>< GH>H I= I JHI>H G>> JI> > HH GFJ>GN. = GH>JHIGI> M, N GGG I=I N >JI II= > GI>JGH, L> I >K>I I= , I=GG>IN N>< G JHI> H G>IG> > I=>KHI> >I> IGJI=.

    >IN >H I=>< G I= K>JH. IH >H >IH JI>H JHI I=H, I=

    G GG>JH G>IGGN I= I= I=G. =I =H I= H>IN G>G G ? = FJHI> >H GN HLG:KGN I=>< I=I >I >H N JIN I . AN I=>< G? CGI>N I.C I=N =G I>H? C I=N >I N JIN I >I >IG,I IGI G HHHH>I N >H >I I=II= H>IN >H J I G >IH GH? EKGN I=>< I=I IG>JI I I=>G LG. BJI I= IJG I=>G LG >H_ N I= IJG >. =I L> HI IG>JI I >I, L=>=GH >>IIH I K>GIJ, _H JH

    L>I= JHHH JG >, GJNGKH L=IKG > JG MGI>H.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    64/236

    B% . C"A..

    =J >I aG, [I=I >I >H I > I= LG N >I>HNHI I HJG I JH I=H KI GL>< L> HI> >IGKGI>. I >H J I IG>JIKGN I=>< >I >H I I=H JGHH, LH KG NI J =GN JI J I=>IH >`J >I= JIHI >I, I=G JHI I= G=>G I, I=I I= JKGHN I. =G >H I=>< I=I >I>>HI>IJI>H HHJGN , I=N K> H>I>KNJIGI>< I= IGJ >IGHIH I=>G HJIH. BJI G>>JHGJH G>IGGN >HI>I>H H>I>KN JIGI I=.=G >H HGN N >_I> H>IN JI =H > >I HI GJH >I=G >H=>G _I, >I >H I IH I I=

    >GKI I= J>IN, >I JKGHN I.

    > >GGN >GIN: A EFJ>GN CG>< >I> $JHI>, . .

    K7.0 (GINJ.GI/90

  • 8/13/2019 Godwin - an Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    65/236

    B% . C"A.. AED.I>KH HJ>>.

    1. EH G

    >

    2. BK

    B% . C"A.. A>M

    B I CIIH

    APPENDIX, No. I. P. 87.

    OF SUICIDE

    I>KH HJ>>: 1. H G >.Y2.K.YGING H>G.

    T" GH>< L> M> I JH I= < >HJIH HJ>>. ["K G>GJHIH I HIGN NH > GG I HG > G >HH G=H >HH> I >

    H>IJI>, I=I H= MJ I= HH>>>IN JIJG>, K>K HH>H >IN IG>K>, I K> >, L=>= >H H>K>; G >H= >H >GN K>. =M GI>IJ > JG>< I=, > I=G LG I=GH>GI>, LJ GN ^G IIG I>K G I>J>K.

    [H I=G I= H > L=>= HJ>> >H K>GIJ?\=I H= L I=> I= GH>< NJG J KJIGN I=, GG, [I=I I= JI>H GI> >< HHHH LG GJH, I=I, IG =K>< HI =>H > > I= HGK> =>HJIGN, J HH>, I GG =>H I= HJG >I> _I?\ =>H LH I= I>K I= HJ>> CGJH,>H D>JH. I= H I>K GK> > I= J=>G HJ>> CI,