Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization ‘Movement’ - Takis Fotopoulos

download Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization ‘Movement’ - Takis Fotopoulos

of 57

  • date post

    04-Apr-2018
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    219
  • download

    0

Transcript of Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization ‘Movement’ - Takis Fotopoulos

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    1/57

    K@NFL]DLW ( AD[P]@3 [e` Ga{`}ad{gfado Cfp}ado fh GALOP\GX@ K@NFL]DLW/ Xfo! 2/Af! = Cpow =994'

    Bofmdog|d{gfa/ {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{dak {e` Da{g.Bofmdog|d{gfaNfx`n`a{[DJG\ HF[FYFPOF\

    Dm|{}dl{3 [eg| d}{glo` kg|lp||`| {e` n`dagab dak |gbaghgldal` fhbofmdog|d{gfa ga }`od{gfa {f {e` ndga {e`f}`{gldo {}`ak| fa {e` nd{{`}%regle d}` lfnyd}`k dak lfa{}d|{`k {f {e` Galop|gx` K`nfl}dlwdyy}fdle'/ d| r`oo d| rg{e }`h`}`al` {f {e` ad{p}` dak yf{`a{gdo fh {e`

    y}`|`a{ da{g.bofmdog|d{gfa nfx`n`a{! G{ g| |efra {ed{ {e` ndga kgxg|gfaga {e` {e`f}`{gldo dadow|g| fh {e` O`h{ fa {e` nd{{`}/ dak do|f rg{ega {e`da{g.bofmdog|d{gfa nfx`n`a{/ l`a{}`| d}fpak {e` l}plgdo g||p` re`{e`}{e` y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa %regle g| lfa|gk`}`k {f o`dk {f d b}frgablfal`a{}d{gfa fh `lfafngl dak yfog{gldo yfr`} dak {f da `lf.ld{d|{}fyegl k`x`ofyn`a{' g| }`x`}|gmo` rg{ega {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw|w|{`n/ d| {e`f}g|`k mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{/ f} re`{e`} ga|{`dk g{ lda faowm` `ogngad{`k rg{ega {e` y}fl`|| fh k`x`ofygab d a`r nd|| da{g.|w|{`ngl nfx`n`a{/ regle |{d}{| mpgokgab h}fn m`ofr d a`r hf}n fhk`nfl}d{gl bofmdog|d{gfa! G{ g| d}bp`k {ed{ |ple da do{`}ad{gx`bofmdog|d{gfa |efpok m` md|`k fa d A`r K`nfl}d{gl Rf}ok F}k`} {ed{ g|hfpak`k fa {e` `tpdo kg|{}gmp{gfa fh yfog{gldo dak `lfafngl yfr`}m`{r``a ad{gfa| dak {e`g} lg{gs`a|/ g}}`|y`l{gx` fh b`ak`}/ }dl`/`{eaglg{w f} lpo{p}`!

    4! Ga{}fkpl{gfa[e` hg}|{ tp`|{gfa {ed{ da `udngad{gfa fh {e` |f.ldoo`k bofmdog|d{gfag||p` }dg|`| g| red{ kf r` n`da mw bofmdog|d{gfa dak rew g| g{|gbaghglda{6 [eg| g| da gnyf}{da{ tp`|{gfa bgx`a {e` y}`|`a{ lfahp|gfafa {e` nd{{`}/ yd}{glpod}ow ga kg|lp||gfa| dnfab yfog{glgda|/ cfp}adog|{|dak {e` ogj` mp{/ do|f/ dnfab {e`f}`{glgda| ga {e` O`h{! D{ {e` |dn` {gn`/g{ g| fmxgfp| {ed{ {e` n`dagab dak |gbaghgldal` r` d{{dle {f bofmdog|d{gfa

    g| kg}`l{ow }`o`xda{ {f {e` yfog{gldo/ `lfafngl/ |flgdo/ lpo{p}do dak`lfofbgldo gnyogld{gfa| r` d||gba {f bofmdog|d{gfada `udngad{gfa fh

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    2/57

    regle rgoo ga`xg{dmow o`dk p| {f {e` ndga dyy}fdle`| {f bofmdog|d{gfa![e` lfahp|gfa d}g|`| af{ faow m`ldp|` fh {e` p|pdo odlj fh lod}g{w gak`hgagab bofmdog|d{gfa mp{/ ndgaow/ m`ldp|` fh hpakdn`a{do kghh`}`al`|lfal`}agab {e` ad{p}` fh `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa![fkdw/ donf|{ `x`}wmfkw {doj| dmfp{ bofmdog|d{gfa mp{ h`r d{{`ny{ {fk`hga` g{! Efr`x`}/ ld}`hpoow k`hgagab g{ g| gnyf}{da{ m`ldp|` d of{ fhlfahp|gfa fa {e` nd{{`}/ `x`a dnfab dadow|{|/ g| l}`d{`k mw {e` hdl{ {ed{kghh`}`a{ y`fyo` d{{dle kghh`}`a{ n`dagab| {f {e` {`}n bofmdog|d{gfa!Hp}{e`}nf}`/ g{ |efpok af{ m` hf}bf{{`a {ed{/ do{efpbe p|pdoow g{g| `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa {ed{ ndaw y`fyo` edx` ga ngak re`a {e`w {dojdmfp{ bofmdog|d{gfa/ `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa g| faow fa` d|y`l{/ f} fa`lfnyfa`a{' {efpbe {e` ndga fa` fh bofmdog|d{gfa! Ga f{e`} rf}k|/fa` ndw do|f {doj dmfp{ { leafofbgldo/ yfog{gldo/ lpo{p}do dak |flgdobofmdog|d{gfa![ep|/ {`leafofbgldo bofmdog|d{gfa }`h`}| {f {e` a`r lfnnpagld{gfa|{`leafofbw dak {e` gahf}nd{gfa }`xfop{gfa!Yfog{gldo bofmdog|d{gfa }`h`}|{f {e` rg{e`}gab drdw fh {e` ad{gfa.|{d{` d{ o`d|{ d| hd} d| `lfafngl|fx`}`gba{w g| lfal`}a`k'!Z4^Lpo{p}do bofmdog|d{gfa/ }`h`}| {f {e` y}`|`a{efnfb`ag|d{gfa fh lpo{p}`/ d| `uy}`||`k hf} ga|{dal` mw {e` hdl{ {ed{donf|{ `x`}wmfkw ga {fkdw| bofmdo xgoodb` rd{le`| nf}` f} o`|| {e`|dn` [X |`}gdo| dak xgk`f|/ lfa|pn`| f} d|yg}`| {f lfa|pn` {e`|dn` y}fkpl{| dak |f fa! Hgadoow/ |flgdo bofmdog|d{gfa }`h`}| {f {e`efnfb`ag|d{gfa fh {fkdw| nfk` fh ogh` regle g| md|`k fa da

    gakgxgkpdog|{ dak lfa|pn`}g|{ lpo{p}`!Do{efpbe {e`|` d|y`l{| f} lfnyfa`a{|' fh bofmdog|d{gfa d}` x`}w nplega{`}ogaj`k/ |{goo/ fa` ndw d}bp` {ed{ g{ g| {e` `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa

    regle lfakg{gfa| {e` f{e`} lfnyfa`a{| fh g{! [eg| g| m`ldp|`/ d| Gd{{`ny{`k {f |efr `o|`re`}`Z=^/ ga d nd}j`{ `lfafnw {e` `lfafngl`o`n`a{ g| {e` kfngada{ `o`n`a{ ga |flg`{w d hdl{/ regle kf`| af{y}`lopk` dp{fafnw fh {e` f{e`} `o`n`a{|! Ga f{e`} rf}k|/ {e` }`od{gfa

    m`{r``a {e` xd}gfp| `o`n`a{| g| d|wnn`{}gldo ga {e` |`a|` {ed{ gand}j`{ `lfafng`| g{ g| {e` `lfafngl `o`n`a{ regle lfakg{gfa| {e`

    yfog{gldo `o`n`a{/ re`}`d|/ hf} ga|{dal`/ g{ rd| {e` f{e`} rdw }fpak ga{e` `u.lfnnpag|{ |flg`{g`| ga regle g{ rd| {e` yfog{gldo `o`n`a{ {ed{lfakg{gfa`k {e` `lfafngl fa`! Efr`x`}/ {e` }`od{gfa m`{r``a {e`

    xd}gfp| `o`n`a{| g| do|f fa` fh dp{fafnw dak ga{`}k`y`ak`al`! Ga f{e`}rf}k|/ lpo{p}`/ `lfafngl| dak yfog{gl| d}` af{ gak`y`ak`a{ |ye`}`|/mp{ ga{`}k`y`ak`a{ dak {eg| g| {e` ld|` `x`a ga nd}j`{ `lfafng`| re`}`{e` |`yd}d{gfa ga{f |ye`}`| g| fmxgfp|! \f/ ga {eg| y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ {e`}`g| da ga{`}dl{gab y}fl`|| ga regle `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa g| hdlgog{d{`k

    mw {`leafofbgldo bofmdog|d{gfa mp{ do|f `aedal`| g{/ yfog{gldobofmdog|d{gfa g| {e` a`l`||d}w lfnyo`n`a{ fh `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa/

    re`}`d| |flgdo dak lpo{p}do bofmdog|d{gfa d}` {e` ga`xg{dmo` `hh`l{| fh`lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa! Ga {e` }`|{ fh {eg| ydy`}/ d||pngab {ed{ {e` ndga

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn1http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn1http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn1http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn2http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn2http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn2http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn1
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    3/57

    lfnyfa`a{ f} d|y`l{ fh bofmdog|d{gfa g| {e` `lfafngl fa`/ G rgoolfal`a{}d{` fa `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa!

    D{ {e` fp{|`{/ r` edx` {f k}dr d lo`d} oga` m`{r``a {e` ld|` fh `lfafnglbofmdog|d{gfa dak ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw!

    Bofmdog|d{gfa }`h`}| {f {e` ld|` fh d mf}k`}o`|| bofmdo `lfafnw ga regle`lfafngl ad{gfadog|n ed| m``a `}dkgld{`k daky}fkpl{gfa g{|`oh ed|

    m``a ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k ga {e` |`a|` {ed{ {e` mgb lf}yf}d{gfa| edx`m`lfn` |{d{`o`|| mfkg`| gaxfox`k ga da ga{`b}d{`k ga{`}ado kgxg|gfa fhodmfp} regle |yda| ndaw lfpa{}g`|! Ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa }`h`}| {f {e`ld|` re`}` nd}j`{| edx` m``a ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k/ ga {e` |`a|` fh fy`a

    mf}k`}| hf} {e` h}`` nfx`n`a{ fh ldyg{do dak lfnnfkg{g`| dak/ rg{ega`lfafngl moflj| ogj` {e` @p}fy`da Pagfa/ fh odmfp} d| r`oo' mp{ ad{gfa.|{d{`| |{goo `ug|{ dak |ed}` yfr`} rg{e {e` {}da|ad{gfado lf}yf}d{gfa|[AL|'/ ga d |w|{`n ga regle {e` }fo` fh {e` |{d{` g| m`gab y}fb}`||gx`ow

    }`kpl`k {f {ed{ fh |`lp}gab d |{dmo` h}dn`rf}j hf} {e` `lfafngldoow`hhglg`a{ hpal{gfagab fh {e` nd}j`{! Ga {e` |w|{`n fh {e`ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ {e` `lfafngl yfoglg`| fh ad{gfadobfx`}an`a{| dak {e` }`y}fkpl{gfa fh {e` b}fr{e `lfafnw g{|`ohZ

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    4/57

    lfa{gapfp| `uyda|gfaZ0^fh {}da|ad{gfado lf}yf}d{gfa| %[AL' dak {e`yd}doo`o k`x`ofyn`a{ fh {e` @p}f.kfood} nd}j`{/Z8^regle o`k {f g{|ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k hf}n {fkdw! Ga hdl{/ {e` fy`agab dak ogm`}dog|gab fhnd}j`{| rd| |gnyow yd}{ fh d eg|{f}gldo {}`akZ2^regle ed| m``a |`{ ganf{gfa mw {e` `og{`| lfa{}foogab {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw |gal` g{|

    `|{dmog|en`a{' {f ngagng|` |flgdo lfa{}fo| fx`} nd}j`{| dak yd}{glpod}ow{ef|` dgngab {f y}f{`l{ odmfp} dak {e` `axg}fan`a{ {ed{ ga{`}h`}`k rg{e`lfafngl `hhglg`alw dak y}fhg{dmgog{w![ep|/ d| }`bd}k| hg}|{ {e` ga|{g{p{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` fy`agab fh nd}j`{|/lfnnfkg{w nd}j`{| r`}` ga d y}fl`|| fh lfa{gapfp| fy`agab{e}fpbefp{ {e` y`}gfk hfoofrgab {e` |`lfak rf}ok rd} mf{e d{ {e`yoda`{d}w o`x`o BD[[ }fpak| fh {d}ghh }`kpl{gfa| |f {ed{ [AL| lfpok`d|gow nfx` lfnnfkg{g`| dnfab {e`g} |pm|gkgd}g`|' dak {e` }`bgfadoo`x`o @p}fy`da @lfafngl Lfnnpag{w Z@@L^/ @p}fy`da H}`` [}dk`

    D||flgd{gfa Z@H[D^/ Af}{e Dn`}glda H}`` [}dk` Db}``n`a{ ZADH[D^/\fp{e`}a Lfa` Lfnnfa Nd}j`{ ZN@]LF\P]^/ {e` D||flgd{gfa fh\fp{e`d|{ D|gda Ad{gfa| ZD\@DA^ D|gd.Ydlghgl @lfafngl Lf.fy`}d{gfaZDY@L^ ga D|gd dak {e` Ydlghgl dak |f fa'! Do|f/ ldyg{do nd}j`{|/ regle

    r`}` ga d y}fl`|| fh gahf}ndo fy`agab {e}fpbefp{ {e` 4729|/ r`}`hf}ndoow fy`a`k ga M}g{dga dak {e` P\D d{ {e` `ak fh {e` k`ldk` re`aldyg{do dak `uledab` lfa{}fo| r`}` dmfog|e`k/ hfoofr`k mw {e` }`|{ fh {e`

    rf}ok ga {e` 4759| dak {e` 4779| !u` -ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{`lfafnw-\`lfak/ fal` {e` fy`agab fh nd}j`{| rd| ga|{g{p{gfadog|`k/ {e`pagaegmg{`k hofr fh ldyg{do dak lfnnfkg{g`| dl}f|| h}fa{g`}| }`tpg}`k {e`yd}doo`o ogm`}dog|d{gfa fh doo nd}j`{| g!`! {e` ngagng|d{gfa fh |flgdolfa{}fo| {ed{ edx` m``a gnyf|`k ga {e` yd|{/ ga {e` lfa{ u{ fh {e` |flgdo|{}pbbo`/ ga f}k`} {f y}f{`l{ epnda odmfp} dak |flg`{w g{|`oh h}fn {e`nd}j`{! [e`}`hf}`/ do{efpbe {e` odmfp} nd}j`{| r`}` af{ fy`a`k |f{ed{ {e` `uyofg{d{gfa fh le`dy ofldo odmfp}/ yd}{glpod}ow ga {e` \fp{e/lfpok lfa{gap`' {e`g} ogm`}dog|d{gfa rd| do|f a`l`||d}w hf} {e`dkxda{db`| fh fy`agab {e` lfnnfkg{w dak ldyg{do nd}j`{| {f m` hpoowp{gog|`k! Odmfp} edk {f m` ndk` d| ho`ugmo` d| yf||gmo`/ |f {ed{ g{ lfpok

    m`lfn` `d|gow dkcp|{dmo` {f {e` }dygk ledab`| ga {`leafofbw dak {e`f}bdag|d{gfa fh y}fkpl{gfa![e` ga|{g{p{gfado d}}dab`n`a{| {f ogm`}dog|`nd}j`{| galopk`k3

    [e` |`{{gab py fh ga{`}ad{gfado }po`| mw {e` R[F regle|pll``k`k {e` BD[[' {ed{ rfpok ndj` {}dk` d| h}`` d| yf||gmo`/{e}fpbe {e` ngagng|d{gfa fh {e` dmgog{w fh ad{gfado bfx`}an`a{|{f gnyf|` `hh`l{gx` lfa{}fo| {f y}f{`l{ odmfp} dak {e``axg}fan`a{!

    [e` rf}ok.rgk` ga|{g{p{gfadog|d{gfa fh ho`ugmo` odmfp} nd}j`{|/ |f

    {ed{ {e` lf|{ fh y}fkpl{gfa g| ngagng|`k ndjgab {e` nfx`n`a{ fhgax`|{n`a{ ldyg{do d| y}fhg{dmo` d| yf||gmo`

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn5http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn5http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn6http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn6http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn6http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn7http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn7http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn7http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn6http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn5
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    5/57

    [e` y}gxd{g|d{gfa fh |{d{` `a{`}y}g|`|/ regle af{ faow ogm`}d{`knf}` |`l{f}| fh `lfafngl dl{gxg{w h}fn daw `hh`l{gx` hf}n fh |flgdolfa{}fo mp{ do|f bdx` {e` fyyf}{pag{w {f [AL| {f `uydak {e`g}dl{gxg{g`| ga a`r d}`d| /

    [e` k}d|{gl |e}gajgab fh {e` r`ohd}` |{d{`/ |f {ed{/ fa {e` fa`

    edak/ {e` `uyda|gfa fh {e` y}gxd{` |`l{f} ga |flgdo |`}xgl`| lda m`hdlgog{d{`k d{ {e` {gn` fh r}g{gab/ d [}`d{w {f `u{`ak {e` h}``kfnfh {}dk` {f ypmogl |`l{f} |`}xgl`| Bd{| g| m`gab kg|lp||`k mw{e` R[F' dak/ fa {e` f{e`}/ d k}d|{gl }`kpl{gfa fh {e` {du mp}k`afa {e` `lfafngl `og{`| g| ndk` yf||gmo`!

    [e` d}}dab`n`a{| {f ogm`}dog|` {e` nd}j`{| lfa|{g{p{` {e` `||`al` fhred{ ed| m``a ldoo`k a`fogm`}dog|n&a`fogm`}do yfoglg`|ga `hh`l{/ dng|o`dkgab {`}n |gal` |ple yfoglg`| edx` m``a ga{}fkpl`k rf}okrgk` mwbfx`}an`a{| fh doo y`}|pd|gfa|/ af{ faow fh {e` ]gbe{ %]`dbda/ {e`

    Mp|e hdngow/ [ed{le`} `{ do' mp{ do|f fh {e` O`h{ %red{ G ldoo |flgdo.ogm`}do' ga @p}fy`/ Dp|{}dod|gd `{l! G{ g| {e`}`hf}` lo`d} {ed{ {e`|` yfoglg`|}`ho`l{ {e` |{}pl{p}do ledab`| fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak {e`lf}}`|yfakgab mp|ga`|| }`tpg}`n`a{| fh od{` nfk`}ag{w: ga {eg| |`a|`/{e`w d}` |w|{`ngl f} `akfb`afp| yfoglg`| a`l`||g{d{`k mw {e` kwadngl|fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw! Ga hdl{/ {e` a`fogm`}do yfoglg`| gag{gd{`k mw {e``lfafngl `og{`| fh od{` nfk`}ag{w {f ogm`}dog|` {e` a`row fy`a`kga{`}ad{gfado nd}j`{| |gnyow }`y`d{`k d |gngod} y}fl`|| {ed{ rd|gag{gd{`k mw {e` `lfafngl `og{`| fh `d}ow nfk`}ag{w/ d{ {e` m`bgaagab fh{e` 47{el`a{p}w/ {f ogm`}dog|` {e` ad{gfado nd}j`{|/ regle edk `n`}b`k

    d{ {e` `ak fh {e` 45{e l`a{p}w! \{goo/ hf} {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{/ d| r` |edoo |``ga {e` a`u{ |`l{gfa/ a`fogm`}dog|n d| r`oo d| bofmdog|d{gfa/ d}` |gnyowp{fygd| {ed{ {e` `lfafngl `og{`| d{{`ny{ {f gnyf|`/ ga {e` lfa{`u{ fh dy}fc`l{ {ed{ dgn| {f l}`d{` {e` lfakg{gfa| pak`} regle {e` a`fogm`}do-{e`f}w- lda m` }`dog|`k$Z5^Efr`x`}/ {e` x`}w hdl{ {ed{ {e`}` g| d m}fdklfa|`a|p| m`{r``a doo ndcf} yfog{gldo yd}{g`| ga {e` ndcf} nd}j`{`lfafng`| {f gnyo`n`a{ |ple yfoglg`| g| da fmxgfp| gakgld{gfa {ed{ {e`y}`|`a{ow pagx`}|do a`fogm`}do yfoglg`|/ hd} h}fn m`gab d p{fygd/ ga hdl{/}`ho`l{ {e` |{}pl{p}do ledab`| fh od{` nfk`}ag{w!

    =! \w|{`ngl dak afa.|w|{`ngl dyy}fdle`|{f bofmdog|d{gfa[e` lfahp|gfa dmfp{ {e` ad{p}` fh `lfafngl bofmdog|d{gfa d}g|`| fp{ fh{e` lfahogl{gab da|r`}| bgx`a mw {e` xd}gfp| {e`f}`{gldo dyy}fdle`| {fbofmdog|d{gfa fa {e` l}plgdo tp`|{gfa re`{e`} bofmdog|d{gfa g| dye`afn`afa fh d |w|{`ngl ad{p}` f} af{!Ga {e` ld|` ga regle r` |`` bofmdog|d{gfa d| d |w|{`ngl ye`afn`afa/

    {eg| gnyog`| {ed{ r` |`` g{ d| {e` }`|po{ fh da `akfb`afp| ledab` ga`lfafngl yfoglw g!`! d ledab` }`ho`l{gab `ug|{gab {}`ak| {ed{ ndagh`|{

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn8http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn8http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn8http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn8
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    6/57

    {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw| b}fr.f}.kg` kwadngl'! Ga {eg| ld|`/ bofmdog|d{gfag| g}}`x`}|gmo` rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw! G rgoo {e`}`hf}`ldoo |w|{`ngl doo {ef|` dyy}fdle`| {f bofmdog|d{gfa regle/ ga f}k`} {fga{`}y}`{ g{/ }`h`} {f {e` |{}pl{p}do led}dl{`}g|{gl| fh {e` `ug|{gab |flgf.`lfafngl |w|{`n/ `g{e`} gnyoglg{ow f} `uyoglg{ow!Fa {e` f{e`} edak/ ga {e` ld|` ga regle r` |`` bofmdog|d{gfa d| d afa.|w|{`ngl ye`afn`afa/ {eg| gnyog`| {ed{ r` |`` g{ d| {e` }`|po{ fh da`ufb`afp| ledab` ga `lfafngl yfoglw! Ga {eg| ld|`/ bofmdog|d{gfa g| d}`x`}|gmo` k`x`ofyn`a{/ `x`a rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw!G rgoo {e`}`hf}` ldoo afa.|w|{`ngl doo {ef|` dyy}fdle`| {f bofmdog|d{gfa

    regle/ ga f}k`} {f ga{`}y}`{ g{/ }`h`} {f xd}gfp| `ufb`afp| hdl{f}| {ed{ d}`af{ kg}`l{ow }`od{`k {f {e` |{}pl{p}do led}dl{`}g|{gl| dak {e` kwadngl| fh{e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw |w|{`n! Ga {e` |dn` ld{`bf}w r` ndw do|f lod||ghwdoo {ef|` xg`r| hf} regle bofmdog|d{gfa g| cp|{ d nw{e f} da gk`fofbw!Fa {e` md|g| fh {eg| l}g{`}gfa/ {e` a`fogm`}do dak |flgdo.ogm`}dodyy}fdle`| {f bofmdog|d{gfa |efpok m` |``a d| |w|{`ngl dyy}fdle`||gal` {e`w |`` g{ d| d ye`afn`afa ndgaow kp` {f ledab`| ga {`leafofbwdak yd}{glpod}ow gahf}nd{gfa {`leafofbw! Mp{/ {`leafofbw/ d| G d{{`ny{`k{f |efr `o|`re`}`Z7^/ g| a`g{e`} a`p{}do af} dp{fafnfp|! [e`}`hf}`/

    re`a a`fogm`}do| dak |flgdo.ogm`}do| {dj` {e` `ug|{gab {`leafofbw hf}b}da{`k/ dak {e`}`hf}` g}}`x`}|gmo` rg{ega {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw |w|{`n/{e`w gnyoglg{ow d||gba bofmdog|d{gfa {f |w|{`ngl hdl{f}| dak/lfa|`tp`a{ow/ {e`w do|f {dj` g{ hf} b}da{`k dak g}}`x`}|gmo`!\gngod}ow/ {e` Galop|gx` K`nfl}dlw GK' dyy}fdle/ regle `uyoglg{owd||pn`| {ed{ g{ g| {e` b}fr.f}.kg` kwadngl| fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw|w|{`n {ed{ ga`xg{dmow o`k {f g{| y}`|`a{ a`fogm`}do bofmdog|`k hf}n/ g|do|f d |w|{`ngl dyy}fdle! Hf} {e` GK dyy}fdle/ bofmdog|d{gfa g|g}}`x`}|gmo`/ d| af `hh`l{gx` lfa{}fo| fx`} nd}j`{| {f y}f{`l{ odmfp} dak{e` `axg}fan`a{ d}` h`d|gmo` rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`knd}j`{ `lfafnw! Efr`x`}/ do{efpbe mf{e {e` a`f&|flgdo.ogm`}do dak GKdyy}fdle`| d}` |w|{`ngl dyy}fdle`| gnyoglg{ow ga {e` hf}n`} ld|` dak`uyoglg{ow ga {e` od{{`}'/ {e`}` g| d hpakdn`a{do kghh`}`al` m`{r``a {e`

    {rf {wy`| fh dyy}fdle`|! [e` a`f&|flgdo.ogm`}do dyy}fdle`| {dj` {e``ug|{gab |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw hf} b}da{`k/ rego` {e` GKdyy}fdle kf`| af{! D| d }`|po{/ re`}`d| {e` hf}n`} dkfy{ bofmdog|d{gfa

    rg{e f} rg{efp{ tpdoghgld{gfa|/ {e` od{{`} offj| hf} da do{`}ad{gx` hf}n fh|flgdo f}bdag|d{gfa/ regle gaxfox`| d hf}n fh bofmdog|d{gfa {ed{ g| af{h`d|gmo` rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |{d{g|{k`nfl}dlw!Fa {e` f{e`} edak/ {e` dyy}fdle`| |pbb`|{`k mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ |``hf} d k`hgag{gfa fh g{ m`ofr' lfpok m` lod||ghg`k d| afa.|w|{`ngl

    dyy}fdle`| {f bofmdog|d{gfa! [ep|/ do{efpbe {e`|` dyy}fdle`| p|pdoowd||pn` {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| da fok ye`afn`afa/ regle rd| |`{ ga

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn9http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn9http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn9
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    7/57

    nf{gfa mw {e` `n`}b`al` fh ldyg{dog|nda d||pny{gfa regle y}gndhdlg` bgx`| {e` gny}`||gfa {ed{ {e`w }`lfbag|` {e` |w|{`ngl led}dl{`} fh{e` {}`ak| regle edx` o`k {f bofmdog|d{gfa|{goo {e`w d||gba da `uyoglg{owafa.|w|{`ngl led}dl{`} {f g{! [e` d}bpn`a{ h}`tp`a{ow p|`k {f fx`}lfn`{eg| mod{da{ lfa{}dkgl{gfa g| {ed{ {e` ldyg{dog|{ |w|{`n rd| dordw|

    bofmdog|`k dak red{ ledab`k }`l`a{ow rd| faow {e` hf}n fhbofmdog|d{gfa! Efr`x`}/ {eg| ledab` ga {e` hf}n fh bofmdog|d{gfa g|d||pn`k {f m` af{ {e` fp{lfn` fh {e` |w|{`n| kwadngl| %d| fa` rfpok`uy`l{ fa {e` md|g| fh {e`g} d||pny{gfa {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| da fokye`afn`afa'/ mp{/ ga|{`dk/ fh |ple afa.|w|{`ngl f} `ufb`afp|k`x`ofyn`a{| d| {e` }g|` fh {e` ]gbe{ dak&f} fh {e` a`fogm`}donfx`n`a{/ {e` eg|{f}gldo k`h`d{ fh {e` O`h{ dh{`} {e` lfoody|` fh dl{pdoow`ug|{gab |flgdog|n/ {e` k`b}dkd{gfa fh |flgdo k`nfl}dlw dak |f fa! [ep|/fa {e` md|g| fh efy`o`||ow lfa{}dkgl{f}w d}bpn`a{| fh {eg| |f}{/ {e`}`hf}ng|{ O`h{ |``| bofmdog|d{gfa d| }`x`}|gmo` dak dn`admo` {f `hh`l{gx`

    }`hf}n/ `x`a rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnwy}fxgk`k`afpbe y}`||p}` g| `u`}lg|`k h}fn m`ofr |f {ed{ {e` yfog{gldo dak`lfafngl `og{`| d}` hf}l`k {f ga{}fkpl` `hh`l{gx` n`d|p}`| {f y}f{`l{odmfp} dak {e` `axg}fan`a{!Hgadoow/ m`{r``a {e` |w|{`ngl dak afa.|w|{`ngl dyy}fdle`|/ regle Gn`a{gfa`k dmfx`/ |{dak| d apnm`} fh ga{`}n`kgd{` dyy}fdle`| {ed{ d}`led}dl{`}g|`k mw d ngu fh |w|{`ngl dak afa.|w|{`ngl `o`n`a{| dak d|gbaghglda{ apnm`} fh dadow{gldo kghh`}`al`| rg{e }`|y`l{ {f {e` p|pdodyy}fdle`| fh {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{! G rgoo lod||ghw pak`} {e` odm`o fh da

    ga{`}n`kgd{` dyy}fdle {e` [}da|ad{gfado Ldyg{dog|{ Lod|| dyy}fdle/ {e``lfh`ngag|{ dyy}fdle dak d }`l`a{ow k`x`ofy`k dad}lef.|wakgldog|{dyy}fdle! Doo fh {e`n rgoo m` kg|lp||`k |`yd}d{`ow m`ofr!Mp{/ o`{ p| `udnga` ga nf}` k`{dgo {e` ndga {e`f}`{gldo dyy}fdle`| {fbofmdog|d{gfa![e` a`fogm`}do dyy}fdleA`fogm`}do|/ regle galopk` nf|{ f}{efkfu `lfafng|{|/ lfa|`}xd{gx`

    yd}{g`| dak {e` ndga ga{`}ad{gfado ga|{g{p{gfa| ogj` {e` GNH/ {e` Rf}okMdaj/ {e` R[F `{!l/ dkfy{ da patpdoghg`k yf|g{gx` |{dak {frd}k|bofmdog|d{gfa!Z49^Dllf}kgab {f {e` a`fogm`}do dyy}fdle/ bofmdog|d{gfa g|{e` ga`xg{dmo` }`|po{ fh {`leafofbgldo dak `lfafngl ledab`| reglel}`d{`k {e` a``k hf} {e` fy`agab fh nd}j`{|/ h}`` {}dk` dak h}``nfx`n`a{ fh ldyg{do/ {efpbe af{ odmfp}'/ y}gxd{g|d{gfa|/ ho`ugmo` odmfp}nd}j`{|/ d| r`oo d| hf} {e` k}d|{gl }`|{}gl{gfa fh {e` r`ohd}` |{d{` dak {e``lfafngl }fo` fh {e` |{d{` b`a`}doow! \pyyf}{`}| fh {eg| dyy}fdlendga{dga {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| m`a`hglgdo {f `x`}wmfkw/ d| r`oo d| {f {e``axg}fan`a{/ m`ldp|` g{ |pyyf|`kow doofr| e`do{ew lfny`{g{gfa {f

    k`x`ofy dak/ lfa|`tp`a{ow/ g{ o`dk| {f gny}fx`n`a{| ga `hhglg`alw dak

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn10http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn10http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn10http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn10
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    8/57

    {e` |y}`dkgab af{ faow fh jafro`kb`/ mp{ do|f fh {e` m`a`hg{| fh b}fr{e/{e}fpbe red{ {e`w ldoo {e` {}gljo`.kfra hh`l{!Efr`x`}/ {e` `xgk`al` fh {e` yd|{ {r`a{w.hgx` w`d}| f} |f |efr| {ed{ {e`nf}` fy`a dak ho`ugmo` {e` nd}j`{| m`lfn` {e` b}`d{`} {e` k`b}`` fh

    lfal`a{}d{gfa fh galfn` dak r`do{e ga d h`r edak|! [ep|/ dllf}kgab {ffhhglgdo PA kd{d/ {e` galfn` bdy m`{r``a {e` hgh{e fh {e` rf}ok| y`fyo`ogxgab ga {e` }gle`|{ lfpa{}g`| dak {e` hgh{e ga {e` yff}`|{/ regle rd|

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    9/57

    \flgdo.ogm`}do|/ regle galopk` {e` l`a{}`.o`h{ bfx`}an`a{| ga @p}fy` dakDp|{}dod|gd/ d| r`oo d| `|{dmog|en`a{ |flgfofbg|{| dak `lfafng|{| ogj`Da{efaw Bgkk`a|/ Dnd}{wd \`a/ Ydpo J}pbnda dak f{e`}|/ dkfy{ {e`y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa rg{e |fn` ngaf} tpdoghgld{gfa|/ regle dnfpa{ {fog{{o` nf}` {eda d bofmdog|d{gfa rg{e d epnda hdl`! [e`}` d}` |`x`}do

    x`}|gfa| fh {eg| dyy}fdle mp{ {e` lfnnfa `o`n`a{ ga doo {e`|` x`}|gfa|g| {ed{ {e`w doo dkfy{ {e` {e`|g| {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| mf{e d a`r dak dag}}`x`}|gmo` ye`afn`afa g!`! d |w|{`ngl ye`afn`afa' dak/lfa|`tp`a{ow/ {e`w `uyof}` rdw| fh ndjgab g{ nf}` epnda`! [e``uyoglg{ f} |fn`{gn`| gnyoglg{ d||pny{gfa |flgdo.ogm`}do| ndj` g|{ed{ daw }`{p}a {f |fn` hf}n fh |{d{g|n/ ogj` {e` fa` led}dl{`}g|gabdkxdal`k nd}j`{ `lfafng`| py {f {e` ngk |`x`a{g`|/ g| gnyf||gmo`![ep|/ fa` x`}|gfa fh {eg| dyy}fdle |pyyf}{`k mw {e`f}`{glgda| ogj`

    Da{efaw Bgkk`a|/ {e` hd{e`} fh {e` [eg}k Rdw/Z4;^{doj| dmfp{

    }`a`rgab |flgdo k`nfl}dlwedxgab dmdakfa`k ga {e` y}fl`|| {e`md|gl lfnng{n`a{| fh fok |flgdo k`nfl}dlw/ g!`! kg}`l{ |{d{` ga{`}x`a{gfa{f |`lp}` egbe o`x`o| fh `nyofwn`a{/ |flgdo r`ohd}` dak `tpdog{w!Efr`x`}/ {e` m`a`hg{| fh [eg}k Rdw yfoglg`| edx` do}`dkw |{d}{`k`n`}bgab ga M}g{dga/ re`}` |ple yfoglg`| edx` m``a ga hpoo hf}l` |gal` {e`}g|` fh [faw Modg}| A`r Odmfp} bfx`}an`a{ ga 4772! [ep|/ dllf}kgab{f |fn` }`l`a{ kd{d/ pak`} A`r Odmfp}/ {e`}` ed| m``a d |gbaghglda{gal}`d|` ga {e` epb` yfx`}{w bdy {ed{ lfa|`}xd{gx` bfx`}an`a{| l}`d{`kga {e` 4759| dak `d}ow 4779|3 {e` galfn`| fh {e` }gle edx` b}fra {e}``{gn`| d| }dygkow d| {ef|` fh {e` yff} kp}gab {e` Modg}g{`

    y`}gfk/Z40^re`}`d| M}g{dga |{goo ed| donf|{ {e` rf}|{ o`x`o| fh legokyfx`}{w ga {e` gakp|{}gdog|`k rf}ok!Z48^

    Daf{e`} x`}|gfa fh {e` |dn` dyy}fdle g| |pyyf}{`k mw Dnd}{wd \`a/ da`|{dmog|en`a{ `lfafng|{ dak Afm`o Y}gs`.rgaa`} hf} `lfafngl|/ ref g|d |{}fab |pyyf}{`} fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak h}`` {}dk`! \`a |{}`||`|{e` dm|`al` fh daw md|gl lfahogl{ m`{r``a/ fa {e` fa` edak/ `lfafnglbofmdog|d{gfa regle e` |``| hdxfp}dmow' dak/ fa {e` f{e`}/ {e` hf|{`}gabfh k`nfl}dlg`| dak y}f|y`}g{w!Z42^Hf} \`a/ {e` y}fmo`n g| af{ h}`` {}dk`dak {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ mp{ {e` ga`tpdog{w fh bofmdo yfr`}/ regle

    efr`x`} e` m`og`x`| g{ lda m` dk`tpd{`ow le`lj`k mw ABF|/ d rd{lekfbga|{g{p{gfa {ed{ rfpok m` lfal`}a`k rg{e ga`tpdog{w dak hdg} {}dk``{l!Z45^Fmxgfp|ow/ hf} {e` Afm`o odp}`d{`/ {e` ga`tpdog{w fh bofmdo yfr`}ed| af{egab {f kf rg{e {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak h}`` {}dk`$ \{goo/ fa`kf`| af{ a``k {f m` d Afm`o y}gs` rgaa`} ga f}k`} {f pak`}|{dak {e`|{}fab lf}}`od{gfa m`{r``a {e` dll`o`}d{gfa fh bofmdog|d{gfa ga {e` od|{k`ldk` dak {e` gal}`d|` ga {e` lfal`a{}d{gfa fh `lfafngl daklfa|`tp`a{ow fh yfog{gldo' yfr`} d| g{ g| |efra/ hf} ga|{dal`/ mw {e` hdl{{ed{ {e` rf}ok| }gle`|{ y`fyo` nf}` {eda kfpmo`k {e`g} a`{ rf}{e rg{ega

    cp|{ hgx` w`d}|/ h}fn 477; {f 4777! D| d }`|po{/ ga 4777/ {e` lfnmga`k

    r`do{e fh =99 mgoogfadg}`| dnfpa{`k {f +4 {}googfa 4

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    10/57

    {f{do daapdo galfn` fh {e` 05=n y`fyo` ga doo {e` k`x`ofygab lfpa{}g`|{fb`{e`} rd| faow +4;8ma/ g!`! dmfp{ 49 y`}l`a{ fh {eg|!Z47^G{ g| {e`}`hf}` fmxgfp| {ed{/ paogj` {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ dyy}fdle`| {ed{ G

    rgoo lfa|gk`} a`u{/ {e` |flgdo.ogm`}do dyy}fdle kf`| af{ dgn d{ daw

    `hh`l{gx` lfa{}fo| fx`} {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw {f y}f{`l{odmfp} dak {e` `axg}fan`a{/ d| g{ {dj`| hf} b}da{`k af{ faow {e` |w|{`nfh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak }`y}`|`a{d{gx` k`nfl}dlw %d| {e` }`hf}ng|{O`h{ do|f kf`|' mp{ bofmdog|d{gfa d| r`oo! D| |ple/ {e` |flgdo.ogm`}dodyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfa/ `hh`l{gx`ow/ yodw| {e` }fo` fh o`bg{gng|gab {e`a`fogm`}do bofmdog|d{gfa/ |f {ed{ g{ lda m` |fok {f {e` ngkko` lod||`o`l{f}d{` {ed{ lfa|{g{p{`| afrdkdw| {e` yfr`} md|` fh |flgdo.ogm`}do| ga{e` bfx`}agab l`a{}`.o`h{ yd}{g`|![e` afa.|w|{`ngl dyy}fdle`| fh {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{G rgoo ldoo }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ doo {ef|` ga{`oo`l{pdo|/ nfx`n`a{| dak yfog{gldoyd}{g`| ga {e` O`h{ regle dkfy{ d afa.|w|{`ngl dyy}fdle {fbofmdog|d{gfa dllf}kgab {f regle bofmdog|d{gfa g| kp` {f `ufb`afp|ledab`| ga `lfafngl yfoglw dak/ d| |ple/ g| }`x`}|gmo` `x`a rg{ega {e`|w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw! [e`}`hf}`/ {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ galopk`| doo{ef|` ref `g{e`} |pbb`|{ xd}gfp| }`hf}n| {f gny}fx` {e` hpal{gfagab fh{e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw %`!b! `ogngad{gab g{| lf}yf}d{`led}dl{`}/ dmfog|egab {e` a`fogm`}do k`}`bpod{gfa fh nd}j`{| dak |f fa'/f} |gnyow }dg|` d xd}g`{w fh l}g{glg|n| dbdga|{ g{ rg{efp{ y}fyf|gab daw

    do{`}ad{gx` hf}n fh |flgdo f}bdag|d{gfa/ dkfy{gab d yf|{nfk`}a }`c`l{gfafh pagx`}|dog|nZ=9^f} cp|{ {djgab {e` y}`|`a{ |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw dak }`y}`|`a{d{gx` k`nfl}dlw hf} b}da{`k! Ga {eg| |`a|`/ {e`}`hf}ng|{ O`h{ fa bofmdog|d{gfa galopk`| yf|{.Nd}ug|{|/ |flgdok`nfl}d{|dak f{e`}| ga {e` m}fdk O`h{ Yg`}}` Mfp}kg`p/ Gnndap`o Rdoo`}|{`ga/Afdn Lefn|jw/ \dng} Dnga/ Cfea B}dw/ O`f Ydag{le dnfab {e`n'

    ref {dj` d a`bd{gx`/ mp{ d }`hf}ng|{/ |{dak {frd}k| bofmdog|d{gfa![e`}` d}` |`x`}do dyy}fdle`| regle ndw m` lod||ghg`k pak`} {eg|e`dkgab! [e`w doo |ed}` d lfnnfa `o`n`a{3 paogj` {e` nple nf}`

    }`dog|{gl |flgdo.ogm`}do|/ {e`w doo dkfy{ {e` {e`|g| {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| af{d a`r ye`afn`afa mp{ |fn`{egab do}`dkw `ug|{gab d{ {e` m`bgaagab fhod|{ l`a{p}w dak {e`a bf fa {f `uyof}` rdw| fh }`|g|{gab g{ rg{efp{}dg|gab daw da{g.|w|{`ngl ledoo`ab`' fa {e` b}fpak| {ed{/ dyd}{ h}fn g{|dkx`}|` `hh`l{| fa odmfp} dak {e` `axg}fan`a{/ bofmdog|d{gfa g| do|fgalfnyd{gmo` rg{e {e` y}`|`a{ k`nfl}dlw! [e` `uyoglg{f} |fn`{gn`|gnyoglg{ d||pny{gfa |ed}`k mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ g| {ed{ d }`{p}a {f|fn` jgak fh |{d{g|n g| |{goo yf||gmo`/ |gal` {e` y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa fhnd}j`{| g| |gnyow |``a d| {e` y}fkpl{ fh a`fogm`}do yfoglg`|/ gh af{n`}`ow da gk`fofbw {f cp|{ghw a`fogm`}dog|n'/ dak af{ {e` fp{lfn` fh d

    hpakdn`a{do |{}pl{p}do ledab`!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn19http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn19http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn19http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn20http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn20http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn20http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn19
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    11/57

    [ep|/ Mfp}kg`p/ |{d}{gab rg{e {e` d||pny{gfa {ed{ a`fogm`}dog|n g| dp{fygd/ regle rd| gnyf|`k ndgaow mw {e` Dn`}glda `og{`/ lfalopk`|{ed{ r` edx` {f {p}a {f {e` ad{gfa.|{d{`/ f} m`{{`} w`{ {e` |py}dad{gfado|{d{` d @p}fy`da |{d{` fa {e` rdw {frd}k d rf}ok |{d{` ldydmo` fh`hh`l{gx`ow lfa{}foogab dak {dugab {e` y}fhg{| `d}a`k ga {e` hgadalgdo

    nd}j`{| dak/ dmfx` doo/ fh lfpa{`}dl{gab {e` k`|{}pl{gx` gnydl{ {ed{ {e`od{{`} edx` fa {e` odmfp} nd}j`{!Z=4^Ga {eg| y}fmo`nd{gtp`/bofmdog|d{gfa g| nf}` fh d yfog{gldo gny`}d{gx` {eda da `lfafnglhdl{/Z==^d yfoglw dgngab {f `u{`ak {f {e` rf}ok d| d refo` {e` Dn`}glda`lfafngl nfk`o3Z=

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    12/57

    `udnyo` fh @}gl Efm|mdrn/ {e` kfw`a fh Nd}ug|{ eg|{f}gda|/ ref/ d|od{` d| 4775/ rd| |{goo y}flodgngab {e` `ak fh a`f.ogm`}dog|n$Z=5^[eg|{gn`/ {e` d}bpn`a{ |pyyf}{gab {e` ld|` hf} {e` |pyyf|`k `ak fhbofmdog|d{gfa g| md|`k fa {e` y}`|`a{ |ofrkfra ga {e` P\ `lfafnw dak{e` `o`l{gfa fh B`f}b` Mp|e d| P\ y}`|gk`a{![e` lfalop|gfa |ed}`k mw `x`}wmfkw ga {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ dak do|f mw{e` ndga mfkw fh {e` da{g.bofmdog|d{gfa nfx`n`a{'/ g| {ed{ y}`||p}`h}fn m`ofr lfpok }`x`}|` a`fogm`}do bofmdog|d{gfa/ f} d{ o`d|{ hf}l` {e`|flgdo.ogm`}do bfx`}an`a{| {f }`a`bf{gd{` g{| }po`|/ dak/ ga yd}{glpod}/{e` }po`| bfx`}agab {e` fy`}d{gfa fh ga{`}ad{gfado f}bdag|d{gfa| ogj` {e`

    Rf}ok [}dk` F}bdag|d{gfa d|/ hf} ga|{dal`/ Yg`}}` Mfp}kg`pZ=7^/ \dng}DngaZ

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    13/57

    da d{{`ny{ {f `|{dmog|e d yp}`ow ogm`}do ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{`lfafnw! Mp{/ {eg| d{{`ny{/ hf} {e` }`d|fa| G rgoo `udnga` a`u{/ hdgo`k!\f/ do{efpbe d |gbaghglda{ k`b}`` fh ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw rd| do}`dkw `xgk`a{ d{ {e` m`bgaagab fh {e` {r`a{g`{e l`a{p}w/|{goo/ {e` y}`|`a{ ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa g| mf{e tpda{g{d{gx`ow dak

    tpdog{d{gx`ow kghh`}`a{ h}fn {ed{ `d}og`} ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa!G{ g| tpda{g{d{gx`ow kghh`}`a{ m`ldp|`/ k`|yg{` {e` pa|pm|{da{gd{`k lodgn|{f {e` lfa{}d}w/ {e`}` ed| a`x`} m``a d |gngod} k`b}`` fh nd}j`{fy`aa`|| ga {e` yd|{! [e` ndga gakgld{f}| p|`k mw Eg}|{ dak [efny|fa{f |pyyf}{ {e`g} ld|` fh o`|| fy`aa`|| {fkdw g| {e` k`b}`` fh {}dk` dakhgadalgdo fy`aa`|| {f {e` }`|{ fh {e` rf}ok! Efr`x`}/ d| }`bd}k|hgadalgdo fy`aa`|| hg}|{/ {e` |{pkg`| {e`w tpf{` {f |efr b}`d{`}fy`aa`|| ga {e` y`}gfk m`hf}` {e` hg}|{ rf}ok rd} lfnyd}`k {f {fkdw p|`d |{d{g|{gldo gakgld{f}Z

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    14/57

    lp}gfp|ow/ g| md|`k fa kd{d py {f 472

    regle rd| nple |ndoo`} ga {e` yd|{ {eda {fkdw/ ed| yodw`k d l}plgdo }fo`ga k`{`}ngagab {e` db`a{ fh ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa ga `dle y`}gfk! G{ ed|do|f yodw`k d l}g{gldo }fo` ga k`{`}ngagab {e` k`b}`` fh {e` |{d{`|`lfafngl |fx`}`gba{w! Re`a {e` k`b}`` fh nd}j`{ fy`aa`|| rd| |ndoopy {f {e` ngk 4729|' |{d{`| lfpok `u`}lg|` d |gbaghglda{ k`b}`` fhlfa{}fo fx`} {e` o`x`o fh `lfafngl dl{gxg{w {e}fpbe nfa`{d}w/ `uledab`}d{` dak hg|ldo yfoglg`|! Fa {e` f{e`} edak/ d| |ffa d| dak d| d }`|po{ fh{e` `uyda|gfa fh [AL|' {e` k`b}`` fh nd}j`{ fy`aa`|| m`bdagal}`d|gab/ ad{gfa.|{d{`| edx` of|{ d |gbaghglda{ yd}{ fh {e`g} `lfafngl|fx`}`gba{w! [ep|/ dbb}`||gx` hg|ldo yfoglg`| {f lfa{}fo `lfafngl dl{gxg{wd}` af ofab`} yf||gmo` ga d h}dn`rf}j fh fy`a lfnnfkg{w dak ldyg{dond}j`{|/ re`}`d| {e` y}`|`a{ k`b}`` fh ga{`b}d{gfa fh nd}j`{ `lfafng`|ndj`| `tpdoow gnyf||gmo` daw }`doow kgx`}b`a{ nfa`{d}w yfoglg`|!

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    15/57

    D| }`bd}k| {e` dp{ef}| |`lfak d}bpn`a{ {ed{ b`apga`ow {}da|.ad{gfadolf}yf}d{gfa| dyy`d} {f m` }`od{gx`ow }d}` |gal` nf|{ lfnydag`| d}`ad{gfadoow md|`k/ {e` }`do g||p` g| af{ {e` y}fyf}{gfa fh [AL| {f {e` {f{doapnm`} fh lfnydag`| mp{ {e` yfr`} {e`w `u`}lg|`! Dak {e` |{d{g|{gldokd{d fa {eg| d}` lfalop|gx`! Ga {e` 4779|/ {e` {fy 099 {}da|.ad{gfado

    lf}yf}d{gfa| lfa{}foo`k 29 y`}l`a{ fh rf}ok {}dk`'/ 59 y`}l`a{ fh hf}`gbagax`|{n`a{ dak

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    16/57

    kf`| gnyow g| {e` `hh`l{gx` of|| fh {e` |{d{`| `lfafngl |fx`}`gba{w ga {e`yd|{ tpd}{`} fh d l`a{p}w f} |f! Ga hdl{/ {e` dp{ef}| {e`n|`ox`| gnyoglg{owdkng{ {eg| re`a {e`w le}g|{`a d| }dkgldo `x`a {e` fmc`l{gx` fh hpoo`nyofwn`a{Z;;^g!`! {e` ndga fmc`l{gx` fh |flgdo k`nfl}dlw {e}fpbefp{{e` y`}gfk fh {e` |flgdo.k`nfl}d{gl lfa|`a|p|! G{ g| {e`}`hf}` lo`d} {ed{

    re`a {e` dp{ef}| d}bp` {ed{ hd} h}fn {e` ad{gfa.|{d{` m`gabpak`}nga`k mw {e` y}fl`||`| fh ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa/ {e`|` y}fl`||`||{}`ab{e`a {e` gnyf}{dal` fh {e` ad{gfa |{d{` ga ndaw rdw|/Z;0^red{{e`w edx` ga ngak g| af{ `hh`l{gx` |flgdo lfa{}fo| {f y}f{`l{ odmfp} dak{e` `axg}fan`a{/ mp{/ ndgaow/ }`bpod{f}w lfa{}fo|!Z;8^

    G{ g| do|f af{`rf}{ew {ed{ `x`a re`a {e` dp{ef}| }`h`} {f {e` yf||gmgog{wfh d a`r yfowl`a{}gl x`}|gfa fh {e` ngu`k `lfafnw dgngab {f dleg`x`dnmg{gfp| bfdo|/ {e` faow lfakg{gfa {e`w n`a{gfa hf} {eg| g| d egbeowlf.f}kgad{`k yfoglw fa {e` yd}{ fh {e` n`nm`}| fh {e`

    [}gdk!Z;2^Efr`x`}/ red{ {e` dp{ef}| kf af{ `uyodga g| rew {e` `og{`|lfa{}foogab {e` [}gdk rgoo `nmd}j fa yfoglg`| {f l}`d{` d a`r bofmdongu`k `lfafnw! Ga hdl{/ {e` faow d}bpn`a{ {e`w y}fkpl` {f |pyyf}{ {eg|ld|` g| {e` fok pak`}lfa|pny{gfag|{ {e`|g|/ adn`ow/ {ed{ {e`}`y}fkpl{gfa fh {e` b}fr{e `lfafnw g| af{ xgdmo` ga {e` h}dn`rf}j fhegbe ga`tpdog{w/ regle ga`xg{dmow o`dk| {f ofr k`ndak!Z;5^Mp{/ {eg|d}bpn`a{ gbaf}`| {e` hdl{ {ed{ {e` b}fr{e `lfafnw ed| |efra afkghhglpo{w ga }`y}fkplgab g{|`oh/ d| ofab d| {e` {rf.{eg}k| |flg`{w j``y|`uydakgab g{| lfa|pny{gfa! G{ g| lo`d} {e`}`hf}` {ed{ hf} {e` dp{ef}|/ d|

    r`oo d| hf} {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ ga b`a`}do/ {e` faow rdw ga regle {e` `og{`|

    fh {e` [}gdk rgoo m` y`}|pdk`k {f dkfy{ d bofmdo ngu`k `lfafnw g|{e}fpbe |fn` jgak fh y}`||p}` h}fn m`ofraf nd{{`} re`{e`} d ngu`k`lfafnw g| |{goo h`d|gmo` {fkdw$[e` }`d|fa rew {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ `ak| py rg{e {eg| |f}{ fh afa|`a|gldolfalop|gfa| g| {ed{ {e`g} |{d}{gab yfga{ g| `g{e`} d l}pk` Nd}ug|{ dadow|g|/

    regle d||pn`| {ed{ {e` y}`|`a{ ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa g| af kghh`}`a{ h}fn{e` `d}ow ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa d{ {e` `ak fh 47{e l`a{p}w&m`bgaagab fh=9{e gh af{ m`hf}`/ d| Rdoo`}|{`ga |pbb`|{|' f}/ do{`}ad{gx`owd| ga {e`ld|` fh Eg}|{ dak [efny|fa da d.eg|{f}gldo dadow|g| fh {e` y}`|`a{

    rf}ok `lfafnw/ regle d||pn`| {ed{ {e` y}`|`a{ ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa g||gnyow d lfacpal{p}do ye`afn`afa }d{e`} {eda d |{}pl{p}doledab`!Z;7^[e` lfalop|gfa k}dra mw mf{e {wy`| fh dadow|g| g| {ed{ {e`y}`|`a{ bofmdog|`k `lfafnw g| |{goo bfx`}admo` dak {ed{ {e`}`hf}` doo{ed{ g| a``k`k hf} {e` gag{gd{gfa fh d |w|{`n fh `hh`l{gx` bfx`}adal` fx`}g{ g| da `hh`l{gx` y}`||p}` h}fn {e` da{g.bofmdog|d{gfa nfx`n`a{!Efr`x`}/ {e` hdl{ {ed{ {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw g| bfx`}admo`/ ga {e` ad}}fr|`a|` fh }`bpod{gfa/ g| af{ kg|yp{dmo` mw dawmfkw/ dyd}{ y`}edy| h}fn|fn` `u{}`n` bofmdogs`}|! [e` }`do g||p` g| re`{e`} ad{gfa.|{d{`| d}`

    |{goo ldydmo`/ ga da ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnwu`-ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw- / fh gnyf|gab `hh`l{gx` |flgdo

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn44http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn44http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn44http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn45http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn45http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn45http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn46http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn46http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn46http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn47http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn47http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn47http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn48http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn48http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn48http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn49http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn49http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn49http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn49http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn48http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn47http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn46http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn45http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn44
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    17/57

    lfa{}fo| {f y}f{`l{ nda dak ad{p}`/ f} re`{e`} ga|{`dk |ple lfa{}fo|d}` af{ h`d|gmo` dawnf} / `g{e`} d{ {e` o`x`o fh {e` ad{gfa.|{d{`/ {e` o`x`ofh {e` `lfafngl moflj/ f} `x`a {e` yoda`{d}w o`x`o![ep|/ d| }`bd}k| {e` |{d{`/ Gh r` {dj` ga{f dllfpa{ {e` |gbaghglda{

    gal}`d|` ga hf}`gba y`a`{}d{gfa fh |{flj `uledab` dak mfaknd}j`{|Z09^{ed{ ed| {dj`a yodl` ga {e` od|{ tpd}{`} fh d l`a{p}w f} |f/ g{

    m`lfn`| fmxgfp| {ed{ af ad{gfado bfx`}an`a{ {fkdw ndw hfoofr`lfafngl yfoglg`| {ed{ d}` kg|dyy}fx`k fh mw {e` ldyg{do nd}j`{|/ regleedx` {e` yfr`} {f l}`d{` da ga{fo`}dmo` `lfafngl y}`||p}` fa {e`}`|y`l{gx` lfpa{}w| mf}}frgab dmgog{w/ lp}}`alw xdop` dak gax`|{n`a{hofr|! Gh r` d||pn`/ hf} ga|{dal`/ {ed{ d |flgdo.k`nfl}d{gl yd}{w dkfy{|/dbdga|{ {e` {}`ak/ yfoglg`| {f }`x`}|` {e` ho`ugmgog{w fh odmfp} nd}j`{| f}/do{`}ad{gx`ow/ nf}` dbb}`||gx` yfoglg`| {f |ofr kfra {e` b}``aefp|``hh`l{/ g{ ndw `d|gow m` |efra {ed{ pak`} lfakg{gfa| fh h}`` ldyg{do

    nfmgog{w/ {eg| rfpok o`dk {f d ldyg{do hogbe{ dak d y}`||p}` fa {e`}`|y`l{gx` lp}}`alw dak |{flj `uledab` y}gl`|/ g!`! {f k`x`ofyn`a{|

    regle lfpok `d|gow o`dk {f d }`l`||gfad}w |g{pd{gfa/ gh af{ {f d hpoo mofra`lfafngl l}g|g|! G{ g| hf} {e`|` }`d|fa| {ed{ Ng{{`}da dak Cf|yga edk {fdmdakfa daw gk`d fh }`|f}{gab {f {e` fok |flgdo k`nfl}d{gl yfoglg`|/

    rego` Odhfa{dga` edk {f m` fp|{ k h}fn {e` B`}nda bfx`}an`a{!Odhfa{dga`| ld|` g| yd}{glpod}ow goopngad{gab d| }`bd}k| {e` yfr`} fh[AL|! D| {e` %}`hf}ng|{' dp{ef} fh d x`}w }`l`a{ mffj fa lf}yf}d{`yfr`} k`|l}gm`| g{3Z04^Ga B`}ndaw/ re`}` }`x`ap` h}fn lf}yf}d{` {du`| ed| hdoo`a mw 09 y`}l`a{ fx`} {e` yd|{ =9 w`d}|/ k`|yg{` d }g|` ga lf}yf}d{` y}fhg{| fh 79 y`}l`a{/ d b}fpy fh lfnydag`|/ galopkgab K`p{|le` Mdaj/ MNR/ Kdgno`}.M`as dak ]R@/ {e` B`}nda `a`}bw dak gakp|{}gdo b}fpy/ {erd}{`k ga4777 Hgadal` Ngag|{`} F|jd} Odhfa{dga`| d{{`ny{ {f }dg|` {e` {du

    mp}k`a fa B`}nda hg}n|/ {e}`d{`agab {f nfx` gax`|{n`a{ f} hdl{f}g`| {ff{e`} lfpa{}g`| gh bfx`}an`a{ yfoglw kgk af{ |pg{ {e`n! G{| d tp`|{gfafh d{ o`d|{ 4;/999 cfm|/ {e}`d{`a`k Kg`{`} \ler``}/ d |yfj`|nda hf}]R@! Gh {e` gax`|{n`a{ yf|g{gfa g| af ofab`} d{{}dl{gx`/ r` rgoo

    `udnga` `x`}w yf||gmgog{w fh |rg{legab fp} gax`|{n`a{|dm}fdk!Kdgno`}.M`as y}fyf|`k }`ofld{gab {f {e` P\: f{e`} lfnydag`|{e}`d{`a`k {f |{fy mpwgab bfx`}an`a{ mfak| dak gax`|{gab ga {e`B`}nda `lfafnw! Ga xg`r fh {e` yfr`} {e`|` lf}yf}d{gfa| rg`ok {e`g}{e}`d{| r`}` {dj`a |`}gfp|ow! Rg{ega d h`r nfa{e| B`}ndaw rd|yodaagab lf}yf}d{` {du lp{| regle rfpok }`kpl` {du fa B`}ndalfnydag`| m`ofr P\ }d{`|! D| fa` fh B`}nda Ledal`oof} B`}ed}k\le}k`}| |`agf} dkxg|`}| ga Rd|egab{fa lfnn`a{`k d{ {e`{gn`/ K`p{|le` Mdaj dak gakp|{}gdo bgda{| ogj` N`}l`k`| d}` {ff |{}fabhf} {e` `o`l{`k bfx`}an`a{ ga M`}oga!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn50http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn50http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn51http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn51http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn51http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn51http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn50
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    18/57

    [e` |g{pd{gfa g| af{ nple kghh`}`a{ rg{e }`|y`l{ {f `lfafngl moflj|! Gh dmoflj/ ogj` {e` @P/ d{{`ny{| {f ga{}fkpl` {e` jgak fh yfoglg`| {ed{ r`}`kfngada{ kp}gab {e` |flgdo k`nfl}d{gl lfa|`a|p|/ `!b! yfoglg`| {f`uydak {e` r`ohd}` |{d{` g}}`|y`l{gx` fh {e` gnydl{ fh |ple yfoglg`| fagahod{gfa' f}/ do{`}ad{gx`ow/ gh g{ d{{`ny{| {f ga{}fkpl` |{}gl{

    `axg}fan`a{do lfa{}fo|/ g}}`|y`l{gx` fh {e`g} gnydl{ fa y}fhg{dmgog{w/{e`a/ {eg| moflj hdl`| {e` gnn`kgd{` }g|j fh d |`}gfp| ldyg{do hogbe{{frd}k| {e` f{e`} moflj| rg{e |`x`}` }`y`}lp||gfa| fa g{| lp}}`alw/ {e`@p}f/ x`}|p| {e` f{e`} moflj lp}}`alg`|yd}{glpod}ow |f re`a {e`le}fagl r`dja`|| fh @p}f x`}|p| {e` kfood} |``n| {f }`ho`l{ {e` hdl{ {ed{{e` }`nada{| fh {e` r`ohd}` |{d{` ga @p}fy` d}`/ |{goo/ nf}` |gbaghglda{{eda ga {e` P\D! [e` y}fl`|| fh ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa dak {e` y}`|`a{k`b}`` fh fy`aa`|| gnyog`| {ed{ |flgdo lfa{}fo| fa {e` ndcf} nd}j`{`lfafng`| edx` {f m` efnfb`ag|`k! \gal` {eg| efnfb`ag|d{gfa/ ga dlfny`{g{gx` h}dn`rf}j/ g| md|`k fa {e` y}galgyo` fh {e` o`d|{ lfnnfa

    k`afngad{f} dak bgx`a {e` y}`|`a{ kg|yd}g{w fh |flgdo lfa{}fo| ga {e`[}gdk lfpa{}g`|/ daw gk`d {ed{ {e` ga{}fkpl{gfa fh `hh`l{gx` |flgdolfa{}fo| %gag{gd{`k mw {e` |{d{` f} {e` lgxgo |flg`{w' g| |{goo h`d|gmo`

    m`lfn`| afa|`a|gldo! [e`}`hf}`/ {e` gk`d| lp}}`a{ow dkfy{`k mw |fn` ga{e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa lfpok m` |``a d| d P\ d{{`ny{ {fgnyf|` g{| fra x`}|gfa fh h}``.nd}j`{ ldyg{dog|n/ regle lfpok m`}`|g|{`k mw d @P md|`k fa d |flgdo nd}j`{/Z0=^f}/ `x`a rf}|` mw d a`rjgak fh bffk ad{gfadog|n/Z0

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    19/57

    dak {e`}`hf}` fa {e` y}fhg{dmgog{w dak {e` galfn`| dak r`do{e fh {e``lfafngl og{`|!Ga {eg| y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{| `uyodad{gfa fh {e` }g|` fha`fogm`}do bofmdog|d{gfa ga {`}n| fh {e` lfax`}|gfa fh {e` fok

    |flgdok`nfl}d{gl yd}{g`| dak {e`g} m`{}dwdo fh {e` |flgdog|{ gk`do|/ f} ga{`}n| fh {e` eg|{f}gl k`h`d{ fh {e` O`h{ dh{`} {e` lfoody|` fh dl{pdoow`ug|{gab |flgdog|n/ bgx`| d kg|{f}{`k ygl{p}` fh }`dog{w! Do{efpbe g{ g| {}p`{ed{ {e` k`ng|` fh {e` rf}jgab lod|| nfx`n`a{ ga {e` od|{ tpd}{`} fh {e`{r`a{g`{e l`a{p}w ed| yodw`k d l}plgdo }fo` ga {e` }g|` fh a`fogm`}dog|n/|{goo/ {e` k`lgnd{gfa fh {e` rf}jgab lod|| rd| kg}`l{ow }`od{`k/ d| r` |edoo|`` m`ofr/ {f {e` kwadngl| fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak/ ga yd}{glpod}/ {f{e` k}d|{gl ledab` ga {e` `nyofwn`a{ |{}pl{p}`/ d| d }`|po{ fh{`leafofbgldo dak `lfafngl ledab`|! [e`}`hf}` {e` lfax`}|gfa fh {e`fok |flgdok`nfl}d{gl yd}{g`| lfpok m` `uyodga`k ga {`}n| fh {e` ledab`

    ga {e` |{}pl{p}` fh {e` `o`l{f}d{`/ d| d }`|po{ fh {e` lf}}`|yfakgabledab`| ga {e` |{}pl{p}` fh `nyofwn`a{/ dak do|f ga {`}n| fh {e`gal}`d|`k nd}j`{ fy`aa`||/ regle ndk` {e` |{d{g|{ yfoglg`| p|`k kp}gab{e` y`}gfk fh {e` |flgdok`nfl}d{gl lfa|`a|p| galfnyd{gmo` rg{e {e`b}fr{e }`tpg}`n`a{| fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw!G{ g| {e`}`hf}` fmxgfp| {ed{ {e` b`a`}do |egh{ {f {e` ]gbe{/ regle ed|nd}j`k {e` a`fogm`}do hf}n fh nfk`}ag{w/ edk gakpl`k ndaw ga {e` O`h{{f nfx` {frd}k| {e` yf|g{gfa fal` fllpyg`k mw {e` fok|flgdok`nfl}d{|ref edx` nfx`k {f |flgdo.ogm`}dog|n dak }`dog|{gldoow

    dll`y{`k {e` afa.}`x`}|gmgog{w fh y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa! [eg| g| af{|p}y}g|gab gh fa` {dj`| ga{f dllfpa{ {e` hdl{ {ed{ da dkfy{gfa fh {e`|w|{`ngl ad{p}` fh y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa rfpok edx` |`}gfp| yfog{gldognyogld{gfa|! Ga f{e`} rf}k|/ }`lfbag{gfa mw {e` O`h{ fh {e` |w|{`nglled}dl{`} fh bofmdog|d{gfa rfpok yp{ g{ ga d |`}gfp| kgo`nnd3 `g{e`} {fdkfy{ {e` y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa rg{e |fn` tpdoghgld{gfa| d| |flgdo.ogm`}do| kf' f} }`c`l{ g{ do{fb`{e`} dak ledoo`ab` {e` hpakdn`a{doga|{g{p{gfa {ed{ o`k {f g{ ga {e` hg}|{ yodl`/ {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw g{|`oh! G{ g| fmxgfp| {ed{ {fkdw| k`nf}dog|`k dak b`a`}doowlfahf}ng|{ h}`tp`a{ow mw rdw fh yf|{nfk`}ag|n' O`h{ ed| lef|`a da

    ga{`}n`kgd{` rdw m`{r``a {e`|` {rf `u{}`n`| {ed{ gaxfox`| |gbaghglda{}`hf}n| fh {e` bofmdog|`k `lfafnw regle/ efr`x`}/ d}` gny}fmdmo`

    rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw! Red{ g| g}fagl gak``k g| {ed{{e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ cp|{ghg`| {e` dmdakfan`a{ fh daw xg|gfa| hf} dado{`}ad{gx` rdw fh f}bdag|gab {e` `lfafnw m`wfak {e` |w|{`n| fh {e`nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak {e` l`a{}do yodaagab' mw da dyy`do {f }`dog|n

    re`a/ ga hdl{/ g{| }`hf}ng|{ y}fyf|do| {fkdw d}` nple nf}` p{fygda {eda{e` xg|gfa| fh |flgdog|{ |{d{g|n g{ p|`k {f y}fnf{` m`hf}` {e` lfoody|` fhdl{pdoow `ug|{gab |flgdog|n$

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    20/57

    Mp{/ o`{ p| afr {p}a {f {e` {e}`` ga{`}n`kgd{` dyy}fdle`| {fbofmdog|d{gfa n`a{gfa`k dmfx`/ g!`! {e` [}da|ad{gfado Ldyg{dog|{ Lod||

    Dyy}fdle dak {e` @lf.h`ngag|{ dak dad}lef.|wakgldog|{ dyy}fdle`|![e` [}da|ad{gfado Ldyg{dog|{ Lod|| Dyy}fdle[eg| od{`|{ d{{`ny{ {f {e`f}g|` bofmdog|d{gfa h}fn d Nd}ug|{ xg`ryfga{lfa{dga| d ngu fh |w|{`ngl dak afa.|w|{`ngl `o`n`a{| dak fhh`}||gbaghglda{ow kghh`}`a{ dadow{gldo ga|gbe{| fa {e` nd{{`} h}fn {ef|`dkfy{`k mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{! \{d}{gab yfga{ ga {eg| dyy}fdle g| g{||{}fab l}g{gtp` fh {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ fa {e` b}fpak| {ed{ af{ faow g{ kf`|af{ |`` {e` fmxgfp| hdl{ fh {e` xd}gfp| }`do y}fl`||`| fh bofmdog|d{gfafllp}}gab d{ {e` nfn`a{Z0; mp{ g{ do|f led}dl{`}g|`| g{/ ga d y}`yf|{`}fp|

    rdw/ d| d jgak fh gk`fofbw/ gh af{ d nw{e$ Efr`x`}/ {eg| }`dog|n kf`| af{y}`x`a{ {e` dp{ef} fh {e` [LL dyy}fdle {f k`}gx` {e` pa}`dog|{gl

    lfalop|gfa {ed{ ad{gfado bfx`}an`a{| lda }`hf}n bofmdog|d{gfa`hh`l{gx`ow/ `x`a rg{ega {e` `ug|{gab |w|{`n fh nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ m`ldp|`bofmdog|d{gfa g| k}gx`a mw gk`a{ghgdmo` dl{f}| rf}jgab {e}fpbega|{g{p{gfa| {e`w fra dak&f} lfa{}fo!Z00^\{goo/ {e` [LL dyy}fdle {dj`| da gnyf}{da{ |{`y hf}rd}k h}fn {e` p|pdoNd}ug|{ f} Rdoo`}|{`gagda dyy}fdle`|/ regle lfal`gx` fh ldyg{dog|n d|f}bdags`k y}gnd}gow {e}fpbe ad{gfado `lfafng`| dak/ d| d }`|po{/ ldaaf{|`` daw{egab a`r ga {fkdw| ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw![e` [LL dyy}fdle xg`r| bofmdog|d{gfa d| d a`r ye`afn`afa/ fa

    dllfpa{ fh d |`}g`| fh {`leafofbgldo/ `lfafngl/ yfog{gldo/ dak lpo{p}`.gk`fofbw gaafxd{gfa|/ regle m`bda {f ledab` {e` rf}ok ga {e` |`lfakedoh fh {e` {r`a{g`{e l`a{p}w! [e` y}gnd}w hdl{f} regle nf{gxd{`k doo{e`|` ledab`| dak fa {eg| {e` [LL dyy}fdle lfn`| lof|` {f {e` GKdyy}fdle rd| {e` `n`}b`al`/ ga {e` |`lfak edoh fh {e` =9{e l`a{p}w/fh {e` [AL|/ regle kghh`} }dkgldoow h}fn hg}n| ga {e` yd|{!Z08^G{ rd| {eg|k`x`ofyn`a{ regle o`k {f {e` y}`|`a{ `n`}b`al` fh d {}da|ad{gfadoldyg{dog|{ lod|| lfnyf|`k fh lf}yf}d{` `u`lp{gx`|/ bofmdog|gabmp}`dpl}d{| dak yfog{glgda|/ bofmdog|gab y}fh`||gfado|/ dak lfa|pn`}g|{`og{`|! [eg| a`r lod|| g| m`bgaagab {f dl{ d| d {}da|ad{gfado kfngada{

    lod|| ga {rf gnyf}{da{ |ye`}`| ga regle {eg| dyy}fdle y`}l`gx`| {rfl`a{}do l}g|`| {f m` k`x`ofygab3 {e` |gnpo{da`fp| l}`d{gfa fh gal}`d|gabyfx`}{w dak gal}`d|gab r`do{e dak {e` pa|p|{dgadmgog{w fh {e` |w|{`n! Gahdl{/ {e`|` {rf |ye`}`| d}` do|f {e` fa`| gk`a{ghg`k mw {e` GK dyy}fdled| {e` ndga lfnyfa`a{| fh {e` y}`|`a{ npo{g.kgn`a|gfado l}g|g|Z02^/ g!`!{e` b}frgab lfal`a{}d{gfa fh galfn` dak r`do{e rg{ega dak m`{r``a|flg`{g`| dak {e` `lfofbgldo l}g|g| d l}g|g|/ regle ed| rf}|`a`k|gbaghglda{ow ga {e` od|{ edoh l`a{p}w f} |f bgx`a {ed{ {e` gk`fofbw mgakgab{fb`{e`} {e` a`r hf}n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw g| lfa|pn`}g|n %dk`}gxd{gx` fh {e` b}fr{e gk`fofbw'!Z05^

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn54http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn54http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn55http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn55http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn55http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn56http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn56http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn56http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn57http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn57http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn58http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn58http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn58http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn58http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn57http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn56http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn55http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn54
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    21/57

    [e`}` d}` {rf md|gl l}g{glg|n| {ed{ lda m` }dg|`k dbdga|{ {e`bofmdog|d{gfa lfal`y{gfa fh {e` [LL dyy}fdle![e` hg}|{ l}g{glg|n }`h`}| {f {e` hdl{ {ed{ {eg| dyy}fdle bgx`| {e`gny}`||gfa {ed{ {e` a`r {}da|ad{gfado ldyg{dog|{ lod|| g| {e` ldp|` fh {e`

    y}`|`a{ bofmdog|d{gfa re`}`d|/ ga hdl{/ g{ g| faow {e` `hh`l{fh {eg| y}fl`||!Ga f{e`} rf}k|/ d| r` |edoo |`` a`u{/ g{ rd| {e` kwadngl| fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw regle edk o`k {f {e` `n`}b`al` fh [AL| dak/ lfa|`tp`a{ow/ fhd a`r {}da|ad{gfado `lfafngl `og{` {ed{ ga|{g{p{gfadog|`k {e` y}`|`a{ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak {e` a`fogm`}do hf}n fhnfk`}ag{w! Ga `udl{ow {e` |dn` rdw/ g{ rd| {e` kwadngl| fhad{gfadog|gab {e` nd}j`{| dak {e` yd}doo`o Gakp|{}gdo ]`xfop{gfa/ regleedk o`k {f {e` `n`}b`al` fh d a`r `lfafngl `og{` {ed{ ga|{g{p{gfadog|`k{e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak {e` ogm`}do hf}n fh nfk`}ag{w!Z07^[e`}`hf}`/do{efpbe {e` |pmc`l{gx` `o`n`a{ %ga {e` |`a|` fh {e` |flgdo |{}pbbo`

    m`{r``a {e` `og{`| lfa{}foogab {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak {e` }`|{ fh|flg`{w' rd| dordw| l}plgdo ga k`{`}ngagab {e` hgado fp{lfn` ga `dlehf}n fh nfk`}ag{w ogm`}do/ |{d{g|{/ a`fogm`}do'Z89^/ {e` gnyf}{dal` fh {e`fmc`l{gx` `o`n`a{ %ga {e` |`a|` fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw kwadngl|'|efpok af{ m` pak`}`|{gnd{`k! G{ |``n| efr`x`} {ed{ {e` mdljod|edbdga|{ {e` fmc`l{gxg|n fh {e` Nd}ug|{ |lg`al` fh {e` `lfafnw/ regleedk `}py{`k dh{`} {e` lfoody|` fh |flgdog|{ |{d{g|n/ gakpl`k {fkdw| a`f.Nd}ug|{|/ yf|{.Nd}ug|{| `{l ref/ ndgaow/ lfa|{g{p{` {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{/{f hflp| fa {e` |pmc`l{gx` `o`n`a{ d{ {e` `uy`a|` fh {e` fmc`l{gx``o`n`a{ ga ga{`}y}`{gab Eg|{f}w! [eg| o`k {f {e` mod{da{ lfa{}dkgl{gfa| ga

    {e` ga{`}y}`{d{gfa fh bofmdog|d{gfa {ed{ r` `udnga`k dmfx`! G{ g| hf} {e`|dn` }`d|fa {ed{ {e` hd{e`} fh {e` [LL dyy}fdle/ ga eg| d{{`ny{ {f`nyed|g|` {e` }fo` fh {e` |{d{` ga {e` bofmdog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw d{ {e` `uy`a|` fh {e` }fo` fh g{| b}fr.f}.kg` kwadngl|/ {doj|dmfp{ {e` yd}dkfu fh |{d{`| regle/ d| {e`w fy`a`k py {e`g} `lfafng`|{f hf}`gba lfnydag`|/ {e`w hdlgog{d{`k {e` l}`d{gfa fh {e` {}da|ad{gfadoldyg{dog|{ lod||!Z84^[e` |`lfak l}g{glg|n }`h`}| {f {e` [LL dyy}fdle | lfal`y{gfa fh lod||

    regle g| d lfa{}dkgl{f}w ewm}gk fh {e` Nd}ug|{ lod|| lfal`y{gfa dak

    Mfp}kg`p| {dufafnw fh xd}gfp| hf}n| fh ldyg{do3Z8=^nfa`w ldyg{do/yfog{gldo ldyg{do/ f}bdag|d{gfado ldyg{do/ lpo{p}do dak jafro`kb` ldyg{do![f nw ngak/ do{efpbe {eg| {dufafnw ndw m` p|`hpo {f {ef|` ref kf af{

    rg|e {f dmdakfa {e` Nd}ug|{ lfal`y{| do{fb`{e`}/ `x`a gh ga {e` y}fl`||{e`w ndj` {e`n pa}`lfbag|dmo` dak {e`}`hf}` g}}`o`xda{ {f {e`g} f}gbgadon`dagab'/ g{ o`dk| {f lfa{}dkgl{f}w lfalop|gfa| gh g{ g| p|`k/ d| mw \lodg}/ga f}k`} {f k`hga`/ ga `hh`l{/ {e` xd}gfp| hf}n| fh yfr`} ga {fkdw||flg`{w! [ep|/ do{efpbe {e` dp{ef} ga|g|{| {ed{ k`lg|gx` ofab.{`}n yfr`}hofr| h}fn{e` fra`}|egy dak lfa{}fo fh {e` n`da| fhy}fkpl{gfaZ8

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    22/57

    `uledab`/ dak {e`a d| d ldyg{dog|{ lod|| ga {ed{ {e`w fra dak&f}lfa{}fo/ gakgxgkpdoow f} lfoo`l{gx`ow/ {e` ndcf} hf}n| fhldyg{do!Z8;^Efr`x`}/ eg| k`hgag{gfa fh {eg| a`r ldyg{dog|{ lod|| galopk`|yfog{glgda|/ mp}`dpl}d{|/ y}fh`||gfado| dak nd|| n`kgd `u`lp{gx`|/ reflfpok ed}kow m` lod||ghg`k d| n`nm`}| fh {e` ldyg{dog|{ lod|| pao`||/ fh

    lfp}|` fa` |{}`{le`| {e` lfal`y{ fh ldyg{do/ d| \lodg} kf`|/ {f lfx`}`x`}w hf}n fh yfr`}! Mp{ {e`a {eg| lfal`y{gfa fh {e` a`r ldyg{dog|{ lod||lda m` |``a d| og{{o` nf}` {eda da fmxgfp| d{{`ny{ {f dllfnnfkd{` {e`ndcf} hdpo{ ga {e` Nd}ug|{ {e`f}w fh {e` |{d{`3 g{| `ulop|gx` lfal`a{}d{gfafa `lfafngl yfr`} d{ {e` `uy`a|` fh {e` f{e`} hf}n| fh yfr`}led}dl{`}g|gab {e` yfr`} |{}pl{p}`| dak }`od{gfa| fh nfk`}a |flg`{w!Fa {e` f{e`} edak/ doo {e`|` ld{`bf}g`|/ regle \lodg} d{{`ny{| {f hg{ {f{e` Y}fl}p|{`da m`k fh {e` lod|| lfal`y{/ lfpok `d|gow m` dllfnnfkd{`k

    rg{ega {e` lfal`y{ fh d {}da|ad{gfado `og{`! R` ndw k`hga` {e`

    {}da|ad{gfado `og{` d| {e` `og{` regle k}dr| g{| yfr`} %`lfafngl/yfog{gldo f} b`a`}doow |flgdo yfr`}' mw fy`}d{gab d{ {e` {}da|ad{gfadoo`x`o d hdl{ regle gnyog`| {ed{ g{ kf`| af{ `uy}`||/ |fo`ow f} `x`ay}gnd}gow/ {e` ga{`}`|{| fh d yd}{glpod} ad{gfa.|{d{`! [e` {}da|ad{gfado`og{` lfa|g|{| fh 3

    {e` {}da|ad{gfado `lfafngl `og{`| [AL `u`lp{gx`| dak {e`g} ofldodhhgogd{`|'/ regle yodw {e` kfngada{ }fo` rg{ega {e` }pogab `og{` fh{e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw bgx`a {e` y}`kfngadal` fh{e` `lfafngl `o`n`a{ ga g{

    {e` {}da|ad{gfado yfog{gldo `og{`|/ g!`! {e` bofmdog|gab mp}`dpl}d{|dak yfog{glgda|/ ref ndw m` md|`k `g{e`} ga ndcf} ga{`}ad{gfadof}bdag|d{gfa| f} ga {e` |{d{` ndlega`| fh {e` ndga nd}j`{`lfafng`| / dak

    {e` {}da|ad{gfado y}fh`||gfado `og{`|/ ref|` n`nm`}| yodw dkfngada{ }fo` ga {e` xd}gfp| ga{`}ad{gfado hfpakd{gfa|/ {egaj{daj|/ }`|`d}le k`yd}{n`a{| fh ndcf} ga{`}ad{gfado pagx`}|g{g`|/{e` nd|| n`kgd `{l!

    [e` GK dyy}fdle }`h`}| {f d {}da|ad{gfado `og{` }d{e`} {eda d

    {}da|ad{gfado lod|| m`ldp|` {e` hf}n`} g| d m}fdk`} lfal`y{ {eda {e`Nd}ug|{ lod|| lfal`y{ {ed{ faow yd}{gdoow `uy}`||`| {e` }`dog{w fh lod||kgxg|gfa| ga a`fogm`}do nfk`}ag{w!Z80^G{ g| da `og{`/ m`ldp|` g{| n`nm`}|yf||`|| d kfngada{ yf|g{gfa rg{ega |flg`{w m`ldp|` fh {e`g} `lfafngl/yfog{gldo f} m}fdk`} |flgdo yfr`}! G{ g| d {}da|ad{gfado `og{`/ m`ldp|` g{|n`nm`}|/ paogj` {e` ad{gfado `og{`|/ |`` {ed{ {e` m`|{ rdw {f |`lp}` {e`g}y}gxgo`b`k yf|g{gfa ga |flg`{w g| af{ mw `a|p}gab {e` }`y}fkpl{gfa fh daw}`do f} gndbga`k ad{gfa.|{d{` mp{/ ga|{`dk/ mw |`lp}gab {e` rf}okrgk`}`y}fkpl{gfa fh {e` |w|{`n fh nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak }`y}`|`a{d{gx`k`nfl}dlw %}d{e`} {eda |gnyow {f y}fnf{` {e` ga{`}`|{| fh bofmdo

    ldyg{do d| {e` [LL dyy}fdle ndga{dga|'! [eg| g| m`ldp|` {eg| a`r{}da|ad{gfado `og{` |``| g{| ga{`}`|{| ga {`}n| fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfado

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn64http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn64http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn64http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn65http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn65http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn65http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn65http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn64
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    23/57

    nd}j`{| }d{e`} {eda {e` ad{gfado nd}j`{|! \{goo/ af{ faow {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{`| kf af{ e`|g{d{` {f p{gog|` {e` yfr`} fh yd}{glpod}|{d{`| {f dleg`x` {e`g} dgn| `x`a nf}` |f re`a {eg| |{d{` edyy`a| {f m`{fkdw| e`b`nfagl yfr`}' mp{ ga hdl{ {e`w edx` {f }`ow fa {e` |{d{`ndlega`| fh {e` ndcf} nd}j`{ `lfafng`| {f dleg`x` {e`g} dgn|![e` `ug|{`al` fh |ple d {}da|ad{gfado `og{` g| af{ |gnyow {e`f}g|`k! Gahdl{/ {e` `xgk`al` g| b}frgab dmfp{ {e` `ug|{`al` fh |ple d {}da|ad{gfado`og{` regle `uy`kg{`| {e` bofmdog|d{gfa y}fl`|| mw hdlgog{d{gab {e`ga|{g{p{gfado d}}dab`n`a{| }`tpg}`k hf} g{| |nff{e hpal{gfagab! H`r/ hf}ga|{dal`/ d}` drd}` fh {e` @p}fy`da ]fpak [dmo` fh gakp|{}gdog|{|@]['/ da doogdal` fh {e` leg`h `u`lp{gx`| fh @p}fy`| od}b`|{ lfnydag`|/

    ref|` yp}yf|` g| {f hf}npod{` yfoglg`| hf} dkfy{gfa mw {e` @p}fy`daLfnng||gfa! [ep|/ {e` \gabo` @p}fy`da Dl{/ regle fy`a`k dakogm`}dog|`k nd}j`{| ga {e` @p}fy`da Pagfa/ rd| h}dn`k af{ mw {e` @P

    mp{ mw Rg||` K`jj`} {e` y}`|gk`a{ fh Yegogy| dak |pm|`tp`a{owledg}nda fh {e` @][' ref|` y}fyf|do m`ldn` {e` md|g| fh {e` @P| 4750

    reg{` ydy`}!Z88^Do|f/ {e` @P `aod}b`n`a{ yoda dyy}fx`k mw {e`@p}fy`da e`dk| fh bfx`}an`a{ ga E`o|gajg d{ {e` `ak fh 4777'/ regle}`tpg}`k a`r `a{}da{| {f k`}`bpod{` dak y}gxd{g|` {e`g} `lfafng`| dakgax`|{ nd||gx`ow ga gah}d|{}pl{p}` k`|gba`k hf} ofab.kg|{dal` h}`gbe{/

    rd| ndyy`k fp{ mw Y`}lw Md}a`xgj/ e`dk fh {e` \r`kg|e lfnydawGax`|{f} DM dak ledg}nda fh da @][ rf}jgab b}fpy!Hp}{e`}nf}`/ {e` {}da|ad{gfado `lfafngl `og{` ga @p}fy`/ `uy}`||`k mw

    @][/ ga lff}kgad{gfa rg{e {e` [}da|d{oda{gl @lfafngl Yd}{a`}|egy[@Y'/ `uy}`||gab {e` ga{`}`|{| fh {e` Dn`}glda `lfafngl `og{`/ edx`

    m``a y}`yd}gab/ |gal` 4770/ d |gabo` nd}j`{ {ed{ rfpok galopk` d b}`d{ow`aod}b`k dak ogm`}dog|`k @p}fy`da nd}j`{ dak d |gngod}ow `aod}b`k dakogm`}dog|`k Dn`}glda Af}{e dak \fp{e' nd}j`{! Da gnyf}{da{ |{`y ga{eg| kg}`l{gfa g| {e` H[DD y}fl`||/ regle dgn| {f `u{`ak {e` Af}{e

    Dn`}glda H}`` [}dk` Db}``n`a{ ADH[D' {f {e` `a{g}` e`ng|ye`}`![eg| y}fl`|| ed| do}`dkw o`k {f {e` K`lod}d{gfa fh Tp`m`l Dy}go =994'{ed{ `axg|db`| {e` l}`d{gfa fh {e` rf}ok| od}b`|{ h}`` {}dk` sfa` mw=990!Hgadoow/ g{ |``n| {ed{ {e` BD[\ y}fl`|| regle dgn| {f `u{`ak {e`B`a`}do Db}``n`a{ fa [}dk` {f \`}xgl`| lp}}`a{ow pak`} kg|lp||gfaga {e` Rf}ok [}dk` F}bdag|d{gfa' y}fxgk`| daf{e`} fyyf}{pag{w hf} {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{` {f ga|{g{p{gfadog|` g{| }fo`! [ep|/ dllf}kgab {f do`dj`k lfahgk`a{gdo kflpn`a{ h}fn {e` R[F \`l}`{d}gd{/ kd{`k 47Nd}le/ d yoda g| pak`} kg|lp||gfa {f l}`d{` da ga{`}ad{gfado db`alw rg{e

    x`{f yfr`} fx`} yd}ogdn`a{d}w dak }`bpod{f}w k`lg|gfa| d}{glo` XG!; fhBd{|'!Z82^[eg| yoda `axg|db`| {ed{ hgado dp{ef}g{w rgoo }`|{ rg{e {e` Bd{|Kg|yp{`| Yda`o {f k`{`}nga` re`{e`} d odr f} }`bpod{gfa g|/ ga {e`

    n`nf| odabpdb`/ nf}` mp}k`a|fn` {eda a`l`||d}w!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn66http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn66http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn66http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn67http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn67http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn67http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn67http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn66
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    24/57

    G{ g| {e`}`hf}` fmxgfp| {ed{ {e` {}da|ad{gfado `og{` g| do}`dkw ga {e`y}fl`|| fh {djgab {e` a`l`||d}w |{`y| {f ga|{g{p{gfadog|` g{| {}da|ad{gfado}fo`! [e` gnn`kgd{` dgn g| {f ypoo kfra {e` }`bpod{f}w

    md}}g`}| gny`kgab {e` h}`` `uledab` fh bffk| dak |`}xgl`|/ gag{gdoowm`{r``a @p}fy` dak Dn`}gld/ dak {e`a m`{r``a {eg| epb` {}dkgab moflj

    dak {e` }`|{ fh {e` rf}ok/ regle rgoo m` hf}l`k {f dll`y{ {e` {`}n| fh{}dk` fh {eg| moflj! [e` po{gnd{` dgn g| {e` hf}nd{gfa fh d xd|{ |gabo`k`}`bpod{`k nd}j`{/ lfa{}foo`k mw npo{gad{gfado lfnydag`|/ ga regle|flgdo lfa{}fo| fx`} nd}j`{| {f y}f{`l{ odmfp} f} {e` `axg}fan`a{ rgoo m`ngagng|`k!Ga {eg| y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ do{efpbe Mfbb|Z85^g| }gbe{ ga l}g{glg|gab {e` [LL|lfal`y{gfa fh d a`r ldyg{dog|{ lod|| fa {e` b}fpak| {ed{ rg{efp{ d{}da|ad{gfado |{d{` ga lfa{}fo fh g{| fra ngog{d}w dak yfogl` hf}l`|/ g{

    rfpok m` y}`nd{p}` {f |y`dj fh d {}da|ad{gfado ldyg{dog|{ lod||/ `x`a gh

    ndaw fh {e` xg{do lfa|{g{p`a{ `o`n`a{| d}` do}`dkw ga yodl`/ fa` lfpokd}bp` {ed{ {eg| l}g{glg|n g| nple o`|| }`o`xda{ {f {e` lfal`y{ fh {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{` dkfy{`k e`}`! [e` lfal`y{gfa fh d {}da|ad{gfado `og{`/

    m`gab m}fdk`} {eda {ed{ fh d lod||/ lfpok `d|gow dllfnnfkd{` {e` |f}{ fh{`a|gfa| dak kgxg|gfa| {f regle Mfbb| }`h`}|! Ga f{e`} rf}k|/ {e`lfa{gapfp| `ug|{`al` fh hg`}l` kgxg|gfa| m`{r``a dak rg{ega yfog{gldo dak`lfafngl `og{`| kf`| af{ y}`lopk` {e` `ug|{`al` fh da fx`}}gkgablfnnfa dgn/ regle pag{`| {e` xd}gfp| `og{`| lfa|{g{p{gab {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{`3 {f |`lp}` {e` paga{`}}py{`k hofr fh ldyg{do daklfnnfkg{g`| dl}f|| h}fa{g`}| dak {f `ogngad{` daw fm|{dlo`| gnyf|`k {f

    {eg| hofr mw y`}gye`}do `og{`| %`!b! }fbp` |{d{`|' fa dllfpa{ fh yfog{gldo/`lfafngl f} ngog{d}w lfa|gk`}d{gfa|!\f/ do{efpbe g{ g| {}p` {ed{ af hf}ndo d}}dab`n`a{| edx` w`{ m``a |`{ gayodl` {f ga|{g{p{gfadog|` yfog{gldo bofmdog|d{gfa/ g{ lfpok m` d}bp`k {ed{ dagahf}ndo hf}n fh yfog{gldo bofmdog|d{gfa ed| do}`dkw m``a gag{gd{`k mw {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{`/ d bofmdog|d{gfa regle g| gnyo`n`a{`k d{ y}`|`a{{e}fpbe ga{`}ad{gfado `lfafngl ga|{g{p{gfa| `!b! R[F' dakyfog{gldo&ngog{d}w fa`| `!b! AD[F'! [e` ld|`| G n`a{gfa`k dmfx`/ d|}`bd}k| {e` hf}n`}/ dak {e` {rf rd}| regle r`}` gakpl`k mw {e` a`r

    {}da|ad{gfado `og{` ga {e` 4779| g!`! {e` Bpoh rd}Z87^dak {e` rd} gaJf|fxfZ29^' d| }`bd}k| {e` od{{`}/ d}` fmxgfp| `udnyo`|! [ep|/ g{ g|goopngad{gab {ed{ k`|yg{` {e` lo`d} kgxg|gfa| m`{r``a {e` `og{`| fh {e`dkxdal`k nd}j`{ `lfafng`| d| }`bd}k| {e`|` {rf rd}|/ {e`w `x`a{pdoow|{ffk mw {e` Dn`}glda `og{`/ regle yodw| {e` }fo` fh {e` yfog{gldo&ngog{d}wd}n fh {e` {}da|ad{gfado `og{`/ hf} {e` lfnnfa bffk fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadolfnnpag{wd| {e`w `pye`ng|{gldoow ldoo {e` {}da|ad{gfado `og{`!G{ |``n| {e`}`hf}` {ed{ {e` {}da|ad{gfado `og{`/ hf} xd}gfp| }`d|fa|/ }`og`|d{ y}`|`a{ fa {eg| gahf}ndo |w|{`n fh yfog{gldo bofmdog|d{gfa! \ple

    }`d|fa| galopk`3 {e` y`}|g|{`a{ gnyf}{dal` fh ad{gfado gk`a{g{g`|/ k`|yg{`f} m`ldp|`' fh {e` lpo{p}do efnfb`ag|d{gfa hf}l`k mw bofmdog|d{gfa: {e`

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn68http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn68http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn68http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn69http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn69http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn69http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn70http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn70http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn70http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn69http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn68
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    25/57

    a``k {f j``y {e` |`nmodal` fh d r`oo hpal{gfagab }`y}`|`a{d{gx`k`nfl}dlw ga regle ofldo `og{`| d}` |pyyf|`kow |{goo ldydmo` fh `hh`l{gx`k`lg|gfa.{djgab: {e` a``k {f y}fxgk` |dh`{w a`{| hf} {e` y}fxg|gfa fhngagndo |flgdo |`}xgl`| {f {e` k`|{g{p{`/ {e}fpbe ofldo |dh`{w a`{|f}bdag|`k mw {e` |{d{`: dak od|{/ mp{ af{ o`d|{/ {e` a``k {f k`o`bd{` {f {e`

    ad{gfa.|{d{`| d |gbaghglda{ dnfpa{ fh {e` nfafyfow fh xgfo`al` |f {ed{{e`w d}` ldydmo` fh lfa{}foogab {e` yfypod{gfa/ dak ga yd}{glpod} {e`nfx`n`a{ fh odmfp}/ ga d rdw {ed{ rfpok ndugng|` {e` m`a`hg{| {f {e`{}da|ad{gfado `og{`' h}fn {e` h}`` hofr fh ldyg{do dak lfnnfkg{g`|![e` @lf.h`ngag|{ dyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfa

    Daf{e`} ga{`}n`kgd{` dyy}fdle g| `lfh`ngag|n/ |pyyf}{`}| fh regle/ogj` Nd}gd Ng`| ( X`}fagld M`aaefok{.[efn|`a/Z24^edx` od{`owk`x`ofy`k da dadow{gldo h}dn`rf}j {f ga{`}y}`{ bofmdog|d{gfa! \{d}{gab

    yfga{ ga {e` dp{ef}| dadow|g| g| d md|gldoow gk`dog|{ `uyodad{gfa fh {e`}g|` fh {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw! [ep|/ {e` dp{ef}|/ ga dafmxgfp| ng|}`dkgab fh Yfodawg/ d}bp` {ed{ eg| mffj[e` B}`d{[}da|hf}nd{gfaZ2=^k`|l}gm`| efr {eg| gk`fofbw %{e` m`og`h ga gae`}`a{`lfafngl odr|' {ffj }ff{/ |f {ed{ ga {e` lfp}|` fh {e` aga`{``a{el`a{p}w {e` `lfafnw m`ldn` gak`y`ak`a{ fh |flg`{w!Z2

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    26/57

    `lfafnw {fkdw lfpok m` dk`tpd{`ow `uyodga`k mw {e` ga{`}yodw fh {e`ledab` ga {e` fmc`l{gx` lfakg{gfa| m}fpbe{ dmfp{ mw {e` }g|` fh [AL|dak {e` `n`}b`al` fh gahf}nd{gfa {`leafofbw' rg{e {e` lf}}`|yfakgabledab` ga {e` kfngada{ |flgdo yd}dkgbn/ g!`! {e` }g|` fh {e` a`fogm`}dogk`fofbw ga{f d e`b`nfagl fa`' dak af{ n`}`ow mw {e` hofp}g|egab fh

    a`fogm`}do gk`fofbw/ d| {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{/ galopkgab `lfh`ngag|{|/|pyyf|`!Gh r` dll`y{ {eg| y}`ng|` {e`a r` ndw |`` lo`d}ow {e` `lfh`ngag|{lfa{}dkgl{gfa|! [ep|/ Ng`| ( M`aaefok{.[efn|`a `nyed|g| / }`h`}}gab{f Rdoo`}|{`ga/Z28^{ed{ -bofmdog|d{gfa- g| af{ d a`r ye`afn`afa3 }gbe{h}fn g{| m`bgaagab {e` ldyg{dog|{ `lfafnw ed| m``a d rf}ok |w|{`n md|`kfa lfofagdog|n dak {e` nd}bgadog|d{gfa dak `uyofg{d{gfa fh y`}gye`}dolfpa{}g`| dak db}glpo{p}`! [e`}`hf}`/ red{ {e` dp{ef}| |`` d| a`r g| faow{e` hf}n fh bofmdog|d{gfa/ kg|{gabpg|egab/ ga {e` y}fl`||/ m`{r``a {e}``

    hf}n| fh g{3 {e` lfofagdo yed|` y}fy`} h}fn {e` |gu{``a{e l`a{p}w fa py {f{e` \`lfak Rf}ok Rd}'/ {e` yed|` fh {e` |f ldoo`k a`r ga{`}ad{gfadokgxg|gfa fh odmfp} regle |{d}{`k d}fpak 472=.2< dak {e` y}`|`a{ yed|`/

    ref|` ndga h`d{p} | d}` {e` pagx`}|dog|d{gfa fh {e` a`fogm`}do kfbnd d|{e` faow yf||gmo` `lfafngl {e`f}w dak {e` `ogngad{gfa fh doo y}f{`l{gfag|{

    md}}g }| {f {}dk` dak gax`|{n`a{/ af{ faow ga {e` \fp{e mp{ do|f ga {e` @d|{dak {e` Af}{e!Z22^Ga hdl{/ d| gh {e`g} dgn rd| {f kg|y`o daw kfpm{| dmfp{{e` afa.|w|{`ngl ad{p}` fh {e` `lfh`ngag|{ dyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfa/{e`w |{}`|| {ed{3Z25^

    Do{efpbe {e` bofmdog|d{gfa fh {e` `lfafnw g| d| fok d| ldyg{dog|n/ {e`nfk`}a p|` fh {eg| lfal`y{ }`h`}| {f {e` y`}gfk {ed{ |{d}{`k d}fpak 4779!Bofmdog|d{gfa g| yd}{ fh a`fogm`}do `lfafngl yfoglw/ regle dgn| d{dmfog|egab y}f{`l{gfag|{ }po`|/ {d}ghh| dak }`bpod{gfa| %' {eg| yfoglw ed|}`|po{`k ga {e` ga{`b}d{gfa fh nf|{ ad{gfado `lfafng`| ga{f fa` bofmdond}j`{ %' {e}`` ye`afn`ad ndk` {eg| }dygk ledab` yf||gmo`3 hg}|{/ {e`ofab.{`}n yfog{gldo |{}d{`bw fh {ef|` ref rda{`k {f }`yodl` yf|{.47;0J`wa`|gda `lfafngl| mw a`fogm`}dog|n: |`lfak/ {e` a`r lfnnpagld{gfa|{`leafofbw: dak {eg}k {e` m}`djkfra fh |flgdog|n ga @d|{`}a @p}fy`![e` fmxgfp| gnyogld{gfa h}fn {e` dmfx` `u{}dl{| g| {ed{ hf} Rdoo`}|{`gagda|dak {e`g} hfoofr`}| ga {e` `lfh`ngag|{ ldny {e` }g|` fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`knd}j`{ `lfafnw lfpok m` dk`tpd{`ow `uyodga`k mw }`h`}`al` {f`ufb`afp| hdl{f}| ogj` {e` m}`djkfra fh |flgdog|n ga @d|{`}a @p}fy` dak|gngod}ow `ufb`afp| ledab`| {f `lfafngl yfoglw ga{}fkpl`k mw `xgoa`fogm`}do bfx`}an`a{| dak }`y}fkpl`k mw k`b}dk`k |flgdok`nfl}d{glfa`|! [e` `lfh`ngag|{ rdw fp{ fh |ple da `lfafnw g| d jgak fh p{fygda}`hf}ng|n regle g| md|`k fa {e` d||pny{gfa {ed{ {e` y}`|`a{bofmdog|d{gfa g| }`x`}|gmo`/ `x`a rg{ega {e` |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw! R` ndw kg|{gabpg|e {rf x`}|gfa| fh {eg| p{fygda }`hf}ng|n!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn76http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn76http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn76http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn77http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn77http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn77http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn78http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn78http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn78http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn78http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn77http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn76
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    27/57

    Dllf}kgab {f fa` x`}|gfa/ `uy}`||`k mw `lfh`ngag|{| ogj` Xdakdad \egxd/red{ g| a``k`k g| d k}d|{gl }`hf}n fh {e` y}`|`a{ ga|{g{p{gfa|! [ep|/ d|\egxd |{}`||`k ga {e` dh{`}nd{e fh \`d{{o`3Z27^

    Z[^e` hdgop}` fh {e` Rf}ok [}dk` F}bdag|d{gfa %R[F' ngag|{`}gdo n``{gabga \`d{{o` rd| d eg|{f}gl rd{`}|e`k ga nf}` rdw| {eda fa`! L}plgdoow/ g{ed| k`nfa|{}d{`k {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| af{ da ga`xg{dmo` ye`afn`afaregle np|{ m` dll`y{`k d{ doo lf|{| mp{ d yfog{gldo y}fc`l{ regle lda m`}`|yfak`k {f yfog{gldoow!!!! Ledabgab {e` }po`| %|`{ mw R[F' g| {e` nf|{gnyf}{da{ k`nfl}d{gl dak epnda }gbe{| |{}pbbo` fh fp} {gn`|! G{ g| dnd{{`} fh |p}xgxdo! Lg{gs`a| r`a{ {f \`d{{o` rg{e {e` |ofbda -Af a`r}fpak/ {p}ad}fpak-! [e`w edx` m``a |pll`||hpo ga mofljgab d a`r}fpak! [e` a`u{ ledoo`ab` g| {f {p}a {e` }po`| fh bofmdog|d{gfa dak h}``{}dk` d}fpak/ dak ndj` {}dk` |pm|`}xg`a{ {f egbe`} xdop`| fh {e`y}f{`l{gfa fh {e` `d}{e dak y`fyo`| ogx`ogeffk|!Mp{/ dllf}kgab {f daf{e`} x`}|gfa/ y}fyf|`k mw Ng`| ( M`aaefok{.[efn|`a/ fp} y}fmo`n| rgoo af{ m` |fox`k {e}fpbe nf}` }`bpod{gfa dak`tpdog{w yfog{gl| rg{ega {e` h}dn`rf}j fh {e` `ug|{gab r`ohd}` |{d{` f}`x`a {e` r`ohd}` |{d{` fh {e` |{d{g|{ y`}gfk'! Efr`x`}/ do{efpbe {eg||{dak bgx`| {e` gny}`||gfa {ed{ {eg| dyy}fdle } c`l{| {e` `ug|{gabga|{g{p{gfado h}dn`rf}j fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |{d{g|{ k`nfl}dlw/ga hdl{/ {eg| g| af{ {e` ga{`a{gfa! [e` hpakdn`a{do ga|{g{p{gfa| ga {eg||flg`{w regle |`lp}` {e` pa`tpdo kg|{}gmp{gfa fh `lfafngl dak yfog{gldoyfr`} %{e` |w|{`n fh nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |{d{g|{ k`nfl}dlw' d}` af{

    |``a mw {eg| dyy}fdle d| {e` ndga ldp|`| fh {e` y}`|`a{ npo{g.kgn`a|gfado l}g|g| dak/ lfa|`tp`a{ow/ d}` af{ ledoo`ab`k mw g{! Ga|{`dk/ {e`dp{ef}| |pyyf|` {ed{ {e`|` hpakdn`a{do ga|{g{p{gfa| lfpok |fn`efr m`

    mw.yd||`k dak d a`r |w|{`n m` l}`d{`k {ed{ rfpok lfnmga`/ ga d egbeowp{fygda rdw/ {e`|` ga|{g{p{gfa| rg{e |pm|g|{`al` `lfafngl| dak yfog{gl|! G{g| {e`}`hf}` fmxgfp| {ed{ hf} `lfh`ngag|{| {e`}` g| af gae`}`a{lfa{}dkgl{gfa m`{r``a {e` kwadngl| fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak|pm|g|{`al` lfafngl|!Ga {eg| x`ga/ {e` dp{ef}| y}fyf|`Z59^{e` }`x`}|do fh {e` y}`|`a{ |{d{` fh

    dhhdg}| ga regle lfnnfkg{w y}fkpl{gfa ed| y}gf}g{w fx`} |pm|g|{`al`y}fkpl{gfa/Z54^dak {e` nd}j`{ nfa`w' `lfafnw g| |pm|gkg|`k mw|pm|g|{`al` y}fkpl{gfa/ [ep|/ re`a Yfodawg |y`a{ kfs`a| fh ydb`| {f|efr {e` hpakdn`a{do kghh`}`al` m`{r``a {e` |`oh.}`bpod{gab nd}j`{dak {e` ofldo nd}j`{| `ug|{gab m`hf}`/Z5=^{e` dp{ef}|/ lfahp|gab {e` {rf{wy`| fh nd}j`{|/ k`lod}` {ed{ {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |pm|g|{`al``lfafngl| d}` af{ lfa{}dkgl{f}w/ |gal` {e`}` edx` m``a dak |{goo d}`lfpa{o`|| kghh`}`a{ jgak| fh `uledab` }`od{gfa|egy/ mf{e fp{|gk` {e`nd}j`{ do{fb`{e`} dak ga lfacpal{gfa rg{e {e` nfk`}a nd}j`{`lfafnw!Z5

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    28/57

    {e`g} hd}n| do{fb`{e`} padmo` {f |p}xgx` d| |pm|g|{`al` hd}n`}| ga {e`ef|{go` `axg}fan`a{ fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak

    rfn`a `a{`}gab {e` y}fkpl{gfa y}fl`|| `a nd||` dak fh{`a eg}gab {e`|`}xgl`| fh f{e`} rfn`a {f kf {e`g} rf}j d{ efn` m}gabgab dmfp{/ ga{e` y}fl`||/ d lf}}`|yfakgab gal}`d|` ga {e` BKY'![e` lfalop|gfa k`}gx`k h}fn {e` `lfh`ngag|{ dadow|g| g| {ed{ red{ r`a``k {fkdw g| {f }`|{f}` {e` ogaj m`{r``a {e` |pm|g|{`al` |`l{f} dak {e`nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ |f {ed{ p|`hpo dak a`l`||d}w |pyyog`| d}` {}dk`k d|p|`.xdop`| |fn`{egab {ed{ y}`|pyyf|`|/ d| {e`w |{}`||/ {ed{ {e`nd}j`{ y}fl`|| g{|`oh |efpok af{ m` {e` fmc`l{ fh d epa{ hf} y}fhg{|/`|y`lgdoow af{ fh {e` nfafyfog|{gl jgak!Z5;^D{ {eg| yfga{/ efr`x`}/ {e`wh``o fmogb`k {f kg||`a{ h}fn Yfodawg| lfalop|gfa %ga hdl{ eg|hpakdn`a{do lfalop|gfa$' {ed{ {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw gnyog`| {e`|`yd}d{gfa fh |flg`{w h}fn {e` `lfafnw! [ep|/ rg{e {e` |{}fj` fh d y`a/

    {e` dp{ef}| }`c`l{ {eg| hpakdn`a{do led}dl{`}g|{gl fh nfk`}a |flg`{w dakd}bp` {ed{ {e` {rf lda m` }`.pag{`k/ y}fxgk`k {e` ogaj m`{r``a {e`nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |pm|g|{`al` g| }`|{f}`k$

    Rg{ega {eg| y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ g{ g| af{ |p}y}g|gab {ed{ `lfh`ngag|{| dkfy{{e` `lf.xgoodb` nfx`n`a{ dak f{e`} ogh`.|{wo` |{}d{`bg`| regle/ d| G edx`d{{`ny{`k {f |efr `o|`re`}`/Z50^d}` af{ ldydmo`/ mw {e`n|`ox`|/ {ffy`a {e` rdw {frd}k| da galop|gx` k`nfl}dlw! Ga hdl{/ |ple dl{gxg{g`| af{faow ldaaf{ o`dk {f {e` }`.ga{`b}d{gfa fh \flg`{w dak Ad{p}` mp{ {e`wdo|f }`y}`|`a{ d jgak fh p{fygda }`hf}ng|n! [e` b}fr.f}.kg` kwadngl|

    fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ regle g| lfnyo`{`ow gbaf}`k mw `lfh`ngag|{|/rfpok a`x`} doofr {e` y`dl`hpo lf`ug|{`al` fh |pm|g|{`al` dak {e`nd}j`{/ d| {e`w gndbga`! [eg| kf`| af{ k`aw {e` hdl{ {ed{ daw jgak fh{}da|g{gfado |{}d{`bw/ dyd}{ h}fn fa` }`owgab `ulop|gx`ow fa }`xfop{gfa/

    rfpok edx` {f |{d}{ rg{ega {e` `ug|{gab ga|{g{p{gfado h}dn`rf}j! Mp{/ g{ g|fa` {egab {f hgbe{/ rg{ega {e` `ug|{gab ga|{g{p{gfado h}dn`rf}j/ hf} d{}da|g{gfa {f d lfnyo`{`ow kghh`}`a{ h}dn`rf}j/ {e}fpbe {e` mpgokgab fh dnd||gx` da{g.|w|{`ngl yfog{gldo nfx`n`a{ ogj` {e` fa` y}fyf|`k mw {e`GK y}fc`l{! G{ g| tpg{` daf{e`} {f d{{`ny{ {f }`hf}n {e` y}`|`a{ |w|{`n{e}fpbe {e` |pm|g|{`al` dl{gxg{g`| |pyyf}{`k mw {e` dp{ef}|/ g!`! ogh`.|{wo`

    dl{gxg{g`| dak `d|gow nd}bgadogs`k lfnnpa`| ga {e` Af}{e/ f}|pm|g|{`al` dl{gxg{g`| ga {e` \fp{e regle d}` ndgaow {e` }`nada{| fh{e` y}`nfk`}a |flg`{w {ed{ d}` b}dkpdoow m`gab yed|`k fp{ pak`} {e`y}`||p}` fh {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw'! [e` hf}n`} |{}d{`bwed| {e` }`do yf{`a{gdo {f l}`d{` da da{g.|w|{`ngl lfa|lgfp|a`|| d{ d|gbaghglda{ |flgdo |ldo` dak `x`a{pdoow pag{` |flg`{w rg{e yfog{w dak {e``lfafnw dak }`.ga{`b}d{` {e` n`{d.gakp|{}gdo rf}j rg{ega da galop|gx`k`nfl}dlwda `||`a{gdo `o`n`a{ fh regle g| k`nfl}dlw d{ {e`efp|`efok!Z58^[e` od{{`} |{}d{`bw ed| a`g{e`} {e` yf{`a{gdo {f ledab`|flg`{w ga {e` rdw |pbb`|{`k mw `lfh`ngag|{| af} g| g{ ldydmo` ga l}`d{gab

    da da{g.|w|{`ngl lfa|lgfp|a`||/ d| g{ kf`| af{ ledoo`ab` {e` ndgaga|{g{p{gfa| fh {e` y}`|`a{ |w|{`n!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn84http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn84http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn84http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn85http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn85http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn85http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn86http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn86http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn86http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn86http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn85http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn84
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    29/57

    Da dad}lef.|w|akgldog|{ dyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfaDaf{e`} ga{`}n`kgd{` dyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfa g| d }`l`a{ow k`x`ofy`kdad}lef.|wakgldog|{ dyy}fdle/Z52^regle k}dr| |fn` lfahp|`klfalop|gfa| fp{ fh d lp}gfp| ngu fh |w|{`ngl dak afa.|w|{`ngld}bpn`a{|/ ndgaow k}dra h}fn |fyeg|{gld{`k %afa fmc`l{gxg|{' Nd}ug|{`lfafngl dadow|`|! [eg| dyy}fdle/ dh{`} hdgogab {f kg|{gabpg|e m`{r``a{e` yd|{ dak {e` y}`|`a{ ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/|``| bofmdog|d{gfa d| d a`r |{}d{`bw mw ldyg{do {f fx`}lfn` {e` `hh`l{| fh{e` l}g|g| ga {`}n| fh {e` hdoo ga y}fhg{|' ldp|`k mw {e` }`|p}b`al` fh@p}fy`da dak Dn`}glda lod|| |{}pbbo` ga {e` od{` 4789| dak {e` 4729|![ep|/ {e` y}`|`a{ npo{g.kgn`a|gfado l}g|g| g| |``a/ rg{ega da fp{kd{`ky}fmo`nd{gl fh lod|| kgxg|gfa|/Z55^d| ndgaow da `lfafngl l}g|g|! [e`ga`xg{dmo` fp{lfn` fh |ple dadow|g| g| {e` lfalop|gfa/ regle g| do|fk}dra mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{/ {ed{ bofmdog|d{gfa g| y`}h`l{ow }`x`}|gmo``x`a rg{ega {e` y}`|`a{ |w|{`n fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw dak |{d{g|{k`nfl}dlw! D| {e` dp{ef} yp{| g{3Bofmdog|d{gfa g| af{ da pa|{fyydmo` fmc`l{gx` y}fl`|| mp{ d |{}d{`bw

    regle lfpok ga y}galgyo` m` edo{`k %' Dh{`} {e` a`u{ |{flj nd}j`{ l}d|e/g{ g| `a{g}`ow yf||gmo` {ed{ fyyf}{pag|{ yfog{glgda| rgoo |{d}{ lfngab fp{dbdga|{ bofmdog|d{gfa dak k`.}`bpod{`k nd}j`{|/ rg{e {e` `hh`l{ fh lf.fy{gab dak a`p{}dog|gab {ef|` }dkgldo nfx`n`a{| regle do|f |g{pd{`{e`n|`ox`| dbdga|{ g{ %' [e` faow fy{gfa afr o`h{ dxdgodmo` {f p| g| {e`lfnyo`{` dmfog{gfa fh ldyg{dog|{ |flgdo }`od{gfa|!Efr`x`}/ do{efpbe d| {e` od|{ |{d{`n`a{ ga {eg| `u{}dl{ gakgld{`|/ {eg|dyy}fdle g| lo`d}ow da{g.|w|{`ngl/ g{| k``yow hodr`k dadow|g| fhbofmdog|d{gfa o`dk| {f }`hf}ng|{ lfalop|gfa| dmfp{ g{! [ep|/ dllf}kgab {f{eg| dyy}fdle/ da ga{`a|ghgld{gfa fh {e` lod|| |{}pbbo` ngbe{ |phhglg`a{ow

    rf}|`a {e` y}`|`a{ `lfafngl l}g|g| gh g{ kf`| af{ ldp|` d hpoo mofra|{flj `uledab` l}g|g|' |f {ed{ {e` `og{`| rgoo edx` {f lfn` fp{ dbdga|{a`fogm`}dog|n dak bofmdog|d{gfa/ y}`|pndmow/ ga f}k`} {f }`{p}a {f |fn`hf}n fh |{d{g|n! [e` |gngod}g{w fh {eg| lfalop|gfa rg{e {e` lfalop|gfa|k`}gx`k mw {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{ g| |{}gjgab! [e` kghh`}`al` g| {ed{ }`hf}ng|{

    O`h{g|{| d}` d{ o`d|{ lfa|g|{`a{ `afpbe af{ {f {doj dawnf}` dmfp{ {e`lfnyo`{` dmfog{gfa fh ldyg{dog|{ |flgdo }`od{gfa|$Hp}{e`}nf}`/ g{ g| fmxgfp| {ed{ |pyyf}{`}| fh {eg| dyy}fdle kf af{}`dog|` {ed{ {e`g} k`lod}`k da{g.|w|{`ngl ga{`a{gfa| d}` af{ galfa|g|{`alw rg{e {e` l}plgdo dgn {f l}`d{` d nd|| da{g.|w|{`ngllfa|lgfp|a`||! D| g{ g| r`oo jafra/ {e` xd|{ ndcf}g{w fh yd}{glgyda{| ga{e` da{g.bofmdog|d{gfa nfx`n`a{ r`}` gakpl`k {f {dj` yd}{ ga g{ ga {e`hg}|{ yodl` m`ldp|` {e`w |dr {e` ld{d|{}fyegl `hh`l{| fh a`fogm`}dobofmdog|d{gfa! [e` tp`|{gfa {e`a d}g|`| efr ndaw fh {e`|` yd}{glgyda{|

    rfpok k`x`ofy da da{g.|w|{`ngl lfa|lgfp|a`|| gh {e`w m`og`x`k {ed{/ `x`arg{ega {e` `ug|{gab |w|{`n/ bofmdog|d{gfa dak a`fogm`}dog|n r`}`

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn87http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn87http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn87http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn88http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn88http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn88http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn88http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn87
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    30/57

    |{fyydmo` dak/ hp}{e`}/ efr ndaw rfpok lfa{gap` }dg|gab da{g.|w|{`nglk`ndak| re`a d{ |fn` |{db` a`fogm`}do bofmdog|d{gfa rd| gak``k|{fyy`k6 Rfpok g{ af{ m` nple `d|g`} dak |dh`}'/ hf} nf|{ yd}{glgyda{|/dyd}{ h}fn d ed}k lf}` fh da{g.|w|{`ngl dl{gxg|{|/ {f cfga {e` }`hf}ng|{O`h{6[e` Galop|gx` K`nfl}dlw dyy}fdleGa {e` GK y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ d p|`hpo rdw {f |`` {e` |w|{`ngl ad{p}` fh{fkdw| ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw g| {f bf mdlj {f {e`aga`{``a{e l`a{p}w/ re`a {e` hg}|{ d{{`ny{ hf} da ga{`}ad{gfadog|`knd}j`{ `lfafnw rd| ndk`! D| G d{{`ny{`k {f |efr `o|`re`}`/Z57^{e``|{dmog|en`a{ fh nfk`}a |flg`{w gaxfox`k {e` ga|{g{p{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e`|`yd}d{gfa fh |flg`{w h}fn {e` `lfafnw nd}j`{ `lfafnw |w|{`n' dak{e` yd}doo`o ga|{g{p{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` |`yd}d{gfa fh |flg`{w h}fn yfog{w

    }`y}`|`a{d{gx` k`nfl}dlw'! Fal` {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw |w|{`n rd|`|{dmog|e`k/ d ofab |flgdo |{}pbbo` m`bda {ed{ }db`k hf} fx`} d epak}`kdak hgh{w w`d}|/ h}fn {e` Gakp|{}gdo ]`xfop{gfa py {f {e` od|{ tpd}{`} fh{e` {r`a{g`{e l`a{p}w/ m`{r``a {ef|` lfa{}foogab {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/g!`! {e` ldyg{dog|{ `og{` lfa{}foogab y}fkpl{gfa dak kg|{}gmp{gfa/ dak {e`}`|{ fh |flg`{w! [ef|` lfa{}foogab {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw rg{e {e` |pyyf}{fh f{e`} |flgdo b}fpy| regle r`}` m`a`hg{gab mw {e` ga|{g{p{gfadoh}dn`rf}j' dgn`k d{ nd}j`{g|gab odmfp} dak odak d| nple d| yf||gmo`/{ed{ g|/ d{ ngagng|gab doo |flgdo lfa{}fo| dgngab d{ y}f{`l{gab odmfp} dakodak/ |f {ed{ {e`g} h}`` hofr/ d{ d ngagndo lf|{/ lfpok m` |`lp}`k! Fa {e`

    f{e`} edak/ {ef|` d{ {e` f{e`} `ak/ dak yd}{glpod}ow {e` rf}jgab lod||{ed{ rd| b}frgab kp}gab {eg| y`}gfk/ dgn`k d{ ndugng|gab |flgdolfa{}fo| fa odmfp} {ed{ g|/ d{ ndugng|gab |flg`{w| |`oh.y}f{`l{gfa dbdga|{{e` y`}go| fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ `|y`lgdoow pa`nyofwn`a{ dakyfx`}{w!Efr`x`}/ do{efpbe |pmc`l{gx` hdl{f}|/ ga {e` |`a|` fh {e` dmfx` |flgdo|{}pbbo`/ edx` dordw| yodw`k d l}plgdo }fo` ga k`{`}ngagab {e` ad{p}` dakndga led}dl{`}g|{gl| fh nfk`}ag{w d{ `dle eg|{f}gldo y`}gfk/ G {egaj g{

    rfpok m` r}fab {f pak`}xdop` {e` lfakg{gfagab gahop`al` fh fmc`l{gx`

    hdl{f}|/ d| Ld|{f}gdkg|/ d y}fnga`a{ {egaj`} ga {e` k`nfl}d{gl {}dkg{gfa/kf`| re`a e` fx`}.`nyed|g|`| {e` gndbgad}w `o`n`a{ ga Eg|{f}w d{ {e``uy`a|` fh {e` lf}}`|yfakgab |w|{`ngl `o`n`a{|!Fmc`l{gx` hdl{f}|

    r`}` d{ rf}j kp}gab {e` `a{g}` eg|{f}w fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw |w|{`n/do{efpbe af{ ga {e` }gbgk |`a|` d||pn`k mw {e` Nd}ug|{ |lg`al` fh {e``lfafnw %odr|&{`ak`alg`| fh {e` hdoogab y}fhg{ }d{`/ yed|`| fhdllpnpod{gfa dak {e` ogj`'/ mp{ }d{e`} ga {e` b`a`}do |`a|` fh {e`b}fr.f} kg` kwadngl fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ regle o`k {f g{|ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa! \ple fmc`l{gx` hdl{f}| lfpok `uyodga {e` nf{gx`|dak dl{gfa| fh {e` `lfafngl `og{`|/ do{efpbe {e` `x`a{pdo `lfafngl dak

    |flgdo fp{lfn` fh {e` `a|pgab |flgdo |{}pbbo` edk dordw| m``a mf{egak`{`}ngad{` dak pay}`kgl{dmo`!

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn89http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn89http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn89http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn89
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    31/57

    [ep|/ {e` fp{lfn` fh {eg| |flgdo |{}pbbo` o`k hg}|{ {f {e` ogm`}do hf}n fhnfk`}ag{wZ79^ ga {e` 47{e l`a{p}w/ regle md}`ow od|{`k edoh d l`a{p}w

    m`{r``a {e` 45

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    32/57

    d| G n`a{gfa`k dmfx`/ r`}` {e` b}frgab fy`aa`|| fh {e` lfnnfkg{w dakldyg{do nd}j`{| dak {e` lf}}`|yfakgab ledab` ga mp|ga`||}`tpg}`n`a{|/ regle o`k {f {e` }g|` fh {e` a`fogm`}do nfx`n`a{ dak {e`yd}doo`o k`lgnd{gfa fh {e` rf}jgab lod||/ d| d }`|po{ fh k`.gakp|{}gdog|d{gfa dak {`leafofbgldo ledab`|/ regle o`k {f d ndcf} }`{}`d{

    fh {e` odmfp} nfx`n`a{!\f/ dllf}kgab {f {e` GK dyy}fdle/ {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw g| d y}fl`||/ regle rd| |`{ ga nf{gfa rg{e {e` x`}w `n`}b`al`fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw g{|`oh! [e`}`hf}`/ do{efpbe g{ g| {}p` {ed{{e}fpbefp{ {e` yf|{.rd} y`}gfk {e` ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw rd| dl{gx`ow `alfp}db`k mw {e` dkxdal`k ldyg{dog|{ lfpa{}g`|/ga xg`rga yd}{glpod} fh {e` `uyda|gfa fh idl{pdoow `ug|{gab|flgdog|n dak fh {e` ad{gfado ogm`}d{gfa nfx`n`a{| ga {e` [eg}k Rf}ok/|{goo/ {eg| ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa rd|/ d| r` edx` |``a dmfx`/ {e` fp{lfn`

    ndgaow fh fmc`l{gx` hdl{f}| }`od{`k {f {e` kwadngl| fh {e` nd}j`{`lfafnw! [e` |pmc`l{gx` hdl{f}|/ ga {e` hf}n fh {e` |flgdo |{}pbbo`/yodw`k d yd||gx` }fo` rg{e }`|y`l{ {f {eg| ga{`a|ghwgabga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{ `lfafnw: yd}{glpod}ow |f dh{`} {e`dmfx` n`a{gfa`k ndcf} }`{}`d{ fh {e` odmfp} nfx`n`a{! Ga {eg| |`a|`/{e` ledab`| ga ga {e` yfoglg`| fh {e` ndcf} ga{`}ad{gfado ga|{g{p{gfa|GNH/ R[F/ RM `{l' dak {e` lf}}`|yfakgab ledab`| ga ad{gfadoyfoglg`|/ regle dgn`k d{ fy`agab dak ogm`}dog|gab nd}j`{|/ r`}``akfb`afp|/ }`ho`l{gab dak ga|{g{p{gfadog|gab `ug|{gab {}`ak| fh {e`nd}j`{ `lfafnw/ }d{e`} {eda `ufb`afp|/ d| {ef|` ga {e` }`hf}ng|{ O`h{

    |pbb`|{!G{ g| {e`}`hf}` lo`d} {ed{ do{efpbe/ d| G {}g`k {f |efr ga [frd}k| Da

    Galop|gx` K`nfl}dlw/Z70^g{ g| {}p` {ed{ {e` l}`d{gfa fh d |`oh.}`bpod{gabnd}j`{ |w|{`n ga {e` 47{e l`a{p}w rd| gnyf||gmo` rg{efp{ l}plgdo |{d{`|pyyf}{ ga l}`d{gab ad{gfado nd}j`{|/ |{goo/ fal` {eg| |w|{`n rd| |`{ py/g{ l}`d{`k g{| fra g}}`x`}|gmo` kwadngl regle o`k {f {fkdw|ga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw! Ga {eg| |`a|`/ do{efpbe {e` GKdyy}fdle {f bofmdog|d{gfa g| gahop`al`k mw Yfodawg| rf}j/ |{goo/ g{ kghh`}||gbaghglda{ow h}fn g{/ yd}{glpod}ow d| }`bd}k| g{| |flgdok`nfl}d{gl

    lfalop|gfa| dmfp{ |flgdo k`nfl}dlw m`gab ldydmo` fh |{fyygab {e`nd}j`{g|d{gfa fh {e` `lfafnw'/ dak do|f h}fn |gngod} |flgdok`nfl}d{gldyy}fdle`| {fkdw/ ogj` hf} ga|{dal` {e` fa` k`x ofy`k mw CfeaB}dw/Z78^ref/ do|f k}drgab fa Yfodawg| rf}j/ |``| {e` fy`agab fhnd}j`{| d| |gnyow {e` `hh`l{ fh {e` y}`|`a{ow kfngada{ a`fogm`}dogk`fofbw dak fh lf}}`|yfakgab ledab`| ga `lfafngl yfoglg`|![e`}`hf}`/ ga {e` GK y}fmo`nd{gtp`/ {e` `n`}b`al` fh {e` a`fogm`}doga{`}ad{gfadog|`k nd}j`{ `lfafnw g| md|gldoow {e` fp{lfn` fh {eg|kwadngl y}fl`|| dak af{ {e` }`|po{ fh lfa|yg}dlg`|/ f} fh {e` yfoglg`| fh

    `xgo a`fogm`}do yd}{g`| dak&f} k`b}dk`k |flgdok`nfl}d{gl yd}{g`|/ d|}`hf}ng|{| ga {e` O`h{ d||`}{! G{ }`y}`|`a{|/ ga hdl{/ {e` lfnyo`{gfa fh {e`

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn95http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn95http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn95http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn96http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn96http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn96http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn96http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn95
  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    33/57

    nd}j`{g|d{gfa y}fl`||/ regle rd| n`}`ow ga{`}}py{`k mw {e` }g|` fh|{d{g|n ga {e` 47

  • 7/30/2019 Globalization, the reformist Left and the Anti-Globalization Movement - Takis Fotopoulos

    34/57

    {e` b}``aefp|` `hh`l{' d{ {e` `uy`a|` fh {e` fgo gakp|{}w n`nm`}|! G{ rd|{eg| gnmdodal` {ed{ y}fny{`k {e` Mp|e dkngag|{}d{gfa {f d{{`ny{ {f}`|{f}` {e` mdodal`/ k`|yg{` {e` fmxgfp| dkx`}|` `hh`l{| fa rf}ok`axg}fan`a{![e`}`hf}`/ {e` y}`|`a{ a`fogm`}do hf}n fh nfk`}ag{w }`y}`|`a{| ga hdl{ da`r |wa{e`|g| m`{r``a/ fa {e` fa` edak/ {e` fok ogm`}do hf}n fh g{ dak/fa {e` f{e`}/ {e` |{d{g|{ hf}n d |wa{e`|g| ga regle {e` `||`a{gdoowogm`}do |`oh.}`bpod{`k nd}j`{ g| ga{`b}d{`k ga{f d |w|{`n fh |{d{g|{lfa{}fo| {f |`lp}` d ngagnpn o`x`o fh y}f{`l{gfa hf} epnda ogh` dak {e``axg}fan`a{! [e` }fo` fh {e` |{d{` rg{e }`|y`l{ {f {e` nd}j`{ {fkdw g|{e`}`hf}` x`}w kghh`}`a{ h}fn mf{e {ed{ fh {e` ogm`}do yed|`/ re`a g{}`|{}gl{`k g{| oh ndgaow {f {e` }fo` fh {e` agbe{.rd{lenda/ d| r`oo d| {ed{fh {e` |{d{g|{ yed|`/ re`a g{ yodw`k {e` }fo` fh {e` bpd}kgda dab`o fh|flg`{w fx`} {e` nd}j`{|! Ga {e` a`r |wa{e`|g|/ {e` |{d{` ed| {f |`lp}`

    {e` |{dmgog{w fh {e` nd}j`{ `axg}fan`a{/ {e` `aedal`n`a{ fh {e` |pyyow|gk` fh {e` `lfafnw %|f {ed{ lfny`{g{gx`a`|| dak `hhglg`alw g!`!y}fhg{| gny}fx`' dak {e` |p}xgxdo dak lfa{}fo fh {e` nd}bgadogs`k yd}{fh {e` yfypod{gfa! Doo {eg| gaxfox`| da fmxgfp| of|| fh `lfafngl|fx`}`gba{w {ed{ g| do|f }`ho`l{`k ga {e` l}`d{gfa fh epb` `lfafngl

    moflj|/ rg{ega {e` lfa{`u{ fh regle {e` `lfafngl }fo` fh {e` gakgxgkpdoad{gfa.|{d{` g| m`gab y}fb}`||gx`ow kfrab}dk`k ga hdxfp} fh |py}d.ad{gfado ga|{g{p{gfa|![eg| dyyog`|/ ga yd}{glpod}/ rg{e }`|y`l{ {f {e` @P/ re`}` {e` }`o`xda{

    y}fl`|| ed| do}`dkw m`bpa! [ep|/ {e` lfnyo`{` ogm`}dog|d{gfa fh {e`lfnnfkg{g`| nd}j`{| rg{ega {e` @P moflj/ lfnmga`k rg{e {e`ogm`}dog|d{gfa fh odmfp} dak nfa`w nd}j`{|/ l}`d{`| d xd|{ `lfafngld}`d re`}` d hgu`k `uledab` }d{`| |w|{`n/ |gngod} {f {e` Bfok \{dakd}k|w|{`n fh {e` `d}og`} ga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa/ rgoo |{d}{ hpal{gfagab a`u{

    w`d}! Gh r` |pm|{g{p{` {e` @p}f hf} bfok/ @p}fy` rgoo |ffa m` fy`}d{gabpak`} d lfa{`nyf}d}w Bfok \{dakd}k |w|{`n regle rgoo edx` d nple

    m`{{`} ledal` {eda {e` `d}og`} |w|{`n/ bgx`a {ed{ {e` md|gl hdl{f} {ed{o`k {f {e` lfoody|` fh {e` Bfok \{dakd}k |w|{`n ed| m``a `ogngad{`k/{ed{ g|/ {e` xd}gfp| }`|{}gl{gfa| fa {e` nd}j`{| hf} bffk|/ odmfp} dak

    ldyg{do {ed{ }`y}`|`a{`k af{ faow {e` ga{`}`|{ fh {e` ad{gfado `lfafngl`og{`| mp{ do|f |flg`{w| |`oh.y}f{`l{gfa n`ledag|n| dbdga|{ g{|nd}j`{g|d{gfa! [e`}`hf}`/ {e` a`fogm`}do `ogngad{gfa fh ndaw fh {e`|`}`|{}gl{gfa| l}`d{`| d eg|{f}gl fyyf}{pag{w hf} {e` nd}j`{g|d{gfa y}fl`||{f m` lfnyo`{`k dak hf} {e` y}`|`a{ a`fogm`}do hf}n fhga{`}ad{gfadog|d{gfa {f m` nf}` |pll`||hpo {eda {e` `d}og`} ogm`}dod{{`ny{! Hgadoow/ {e` m}`djkfra fhdl{pdoow `ug|{gab |flgdog|n ga {e`@d|{Z499^dak {e` lfoody|` fh |flgdo k`nfl}dlw ga {e` R`|{Z494^edx`l}`d{`k {e` yfog{gldo lfakg{gfa| hf} {e` lfnyo`{gfa fh {e` nd}j`{g|d{gfay}fl`||! \f/ {e` hdl{ {ed{ a`fogm`}do yfoglg`| d}` |pyyf}{`k {fkdw/ rg{e

    ngaf} xd}gd{gfa|/ mw mf{e l`a{}`.}gbe{ dak l`a{}`.o`h{ yd}{g`|/ gabfx`}an`a{ f} ga fyyf|g{gfa/ dak {ed{ {e` md|gl `o`n`a{| fh

    http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn100http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn100http://www.democracynature.org/vol7/takis_globalisation_PRINTABLE.htm#_edn100http