German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures...

20
Knowledge for Tomorrow CMC Rocket Thrust Chamber Technology Status and Perspectives M. Ortelt, H. Hald, D. Koch [email protected] German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures and Design AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6 th R&T DAYS, Paris, 19.11.2015, Session 3, WG2 Technologies for Future Liquid Propulsion DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 1

Transcript of German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures...

Page 1: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Knowledge for Tomorrow

CMC Rocket Thrust Chamber TechnologyStatus and Perspectives

M. Ortelt, H. Hald, D. [email protected]

German Aerospace Center (DLR)Institute of Structures and Design

AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS, Paris, 19.11.2015, Session 3, WG2 Technologies for Future Liquid Propulsion

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 1

Page 2: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Outline

- Conceptional aspects of the transpiration cooled CMC TCA

- Development status- Structural components- Materials- Test data

- Some future perspectives for CMC in space propulsion components

- Summary & outlook

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 2

Page 3: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

CMC thrust chamber – Design concept

Transpiration cooled CMC thrust chamber – design principle

- Decoupling of single components – no bonding- Decoupling of mechanical and thermal loads- Specific hybrid interface technologies- Selective inner liner design

Features

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 3

Page 4: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

- Standard CFD systems (FLUENT, CFX, …) are constructive (pure flow coupling)- Ongoing tool-development for ‚structure-flow-coupling‘ (TAU)- Investigations on materials out-flow homogeneity

Functional aspectsDLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 4

Page 5: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

System analysis of transpiration cooling

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

12%

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000

Coolan

t ratio [‐]

Vacuum thrust [kN]

Tw = 800 K  dc = 50 mm

 dc = 100 mm

 dc = 200 mm

 dc = 440 mm

 dc = 1000 mm

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

12%

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000

Coolan

t ratio [‐]

Vacuum thrust [kN]

Tw = 1200 K  dc = 50 mm

 dc = 100 mm

 dc = 200 mm

 dc = 440 mm

 dc = 1000 mm

- Comparison of chamber size (scaling)- 50 mm chamber demonstration

- O/F = 5.5 (injector)- Contraction ratio 6.25- Characteristic chamber length l*=1.84 m- 7 % coolant ratio- Damage free operation- Amount of coolant depends on

- Hotgas conditions, As, T- D + p required coolant ratio

- Further coolant ratio reduction potential- Chamber length can be shortened

High operational efficiency predicted

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 5

Page 6: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Processes for Manufacturing of Nonoxide CMC

C, SiC fibers in C, SiC, SiC(N) matrix

Polymer Infiltrationand Pyrolysis

(PIP)

Liquid SiliconInfiltration

(LSI)

Combi-Process(PIP+LSI, CVI+LSI)

Chemical VaporInfiltration

(CVI)Focus at DLR Stuttgart

preform (e.g. fabrics, filament winding)

fiber-coating if necessary

infiltration (e.g. RTM)with C-precursor

pyrolysis (inert atmosphere) carbon matrix

finishing

siliconisation(inert gas, T>1420°C, Si+CSiC) stoichiometric SiC-matrix

preform (e.g. fabrics, filament winding)

fibrer coating

infiltration (e.g. RTM)with Si-precursor (e.g. polysilazane)

pyrolysis(inert atmosphere, T~1000°C,

e.g. polysilazane SiCN-matrix)

finishing

3-6 times todecreaseporosity

PIP

intermediate machiningjoining

Koch et al., DLR Werkstoffkoll. 2013LSI

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 6

Page 7: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Processing of Ceramic Matrix Composites (DLR-ST, BT)

• Autoclave30 bar, 350 °C

• Warm Press 350°C

• RTM 300°C• Pyrolysis, LSI, 2000°C• Machining Center

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 7

Page 8: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Thrust chamber – potential CMC derivativesInitial C/C model material LOX-sensitive!Other derivatives damage free after efficiently cooled and non-cooled operation:

Oxipol AvA-Z-ISC C/SiCN C/C (CVI)

10 35 18 7

2.3 2.6 1.6 1.6

Density kg/cm3

Open porosity [%] (porosity + permeability kd / kf adaptable by manufacturing process)

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 8

Page 9: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

CMC thrust chamber – Components

Co-axial injector

Applied injectorsystems forcyl. 50 mm

Porous metal injector

Porous CMC injector

Elements of

oxide

CMC

for

the

LOX

injectionIntegrated ‚BlackEngine‘ demonstrator, cyl. 50 mm

C/C-SiC face-plate

Inner liner segment

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 9

Page 10: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

CMC thrust chamber – mechanical interfacesCharacteristic hybrid interface types

Bolt interface for CFRP-metal joining Load-de-coupling double-shell nozzle extension

with keyed joint elements for CMC-metal joining

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 10

Page 11: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Thrust chamber - hot gas verification (LOX/LH2; LOX/GH2)

120 s, pc = 55 bar, LOX / LH2 operation, = 15 %

Structure testsP8

Efficiency testP6.12012

20 s, pc = 55 bar, LOX / GH2 (120 K), = 9 % Demonstration of the integrated CMC TCA

P6.1 firing testDec 2013

P8 (2005)

LOX / LH2, 65 70 bar52 s, 5 6 kg/s, τ = 4.2 % 90 bar tests

Vulcain contour

cyl. 50 mm

Contraction 6.25

cyl. 50 mm

Vulcain contour

cyl. 80 mm

Component tests

P8, 2008

cyl. 50 mm

C/C damages

near injector!C/C damage free

CMCs damage free

CMCs damage free

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 11

Page 12: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Thrust chamber – pressure loads during hot-runSegmented chamber module

Adequate pressure drops

at 8 % C/C porosity!

cyl. 50 mmInner liner:

Initial modelmaterial

C/C

O/F = 5.5

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 12

Page 13: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

0 10 20 30 40

Temperature [K]

Time [s]

U_T_1_8 [K]

U_T_2_8 [K]

U_T_3_8 [K]

U_T_4_8 [K]

U_T_1_9 [K]

U_T_2_9 [K]

U_T_3_9 [K]

U_T_4_9 [K]

Nominal hotrun-sequence

O/F = 5.5; = 6.72 %; pc 55 bar

Thrust chamber – thermal loads during hot-run

Cooling turned off

O/F = 2.0

Max. Tsurface 1800 K

750 /{

P6.1, 2012

cyl. 50 mm

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 13

Page 14: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

CMC injector (‚Cone Injector‘)Features, goals, results

Mechanical design Flow designStart-up Steady stateChannel morphology

Demonstrator

LH2O/GN2

Spray test

Design

principle

0

0,05

0,1

0,15

0,2

0,25

0,3

‐6000 ‐1000 4000 9000 14000

M‐GH2‐COOL [kg/s]

M‐GH2‐INJ [kg/s]

M‐LOX‐INJ [kg/s]

DLR ‐ Cone Injector test campaign 'IZ2' ‐MASS FLOW CURVES

Time [s]

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

‐6000 ‐1000 4000 9000 14000

P_I_GH1 [bar]

P_I_GH2 [bar]

P_I_GH3 [bar]

P_I_LOX [bar]

U_P_IGN [bar]

Time [s]

DLR ‐ Cone injector test campaign 'IZ2' ‐ PRESSURE CURVES

Initially successful hotruns, P6.1, Dec 2013

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 14

Page 15: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Hyperboloid chamber contour – Orbital propulsion size

Comparison referred to typical 500 N class

Hyperboloid geometry

Numerical comparison

at similar performance

Hyperboloid chamber design

Perfectly combined with ‚cone injector‘ technology

- Advantages for- film cooling- transpiration cooling

- Composite affine structure manufacturing (winding technique)

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 15

Page 16: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Hyperboloid chamber contour – Comparison VINCI size

Including insert

Without insert

Dynamic viscosity

Heat flux

Performance

Contour Mass flow Total heat flux Specific heat flux[kg/s] [MW] [MW/m2]

Classical 43 16 55

Hyperboloid without insert 42 16 56

Hyperboloid including insert 43 27 52

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 16

Page 17: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Future potential - Preburner

Application principle

(oxide CMCs for ox-rich systems)

- Standard injector technologyconcerning …

- functional design- mixture ratio

- Propellant overhead injectedthrough chamber wall

- Long life and light weightstructures, similar to CMC thrust chamber design

Features

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 17

Page 18: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Further activities

- ALM / SLM technology for injector systems

- CMC components for hybrid propulsion systems

- Paraffin / N2O: Hybrid thruster

- CMC thrust chamber for an ADN orbital propulsion system

- Investigations on alternative propellants for CMC high performance thrust chamber application

- LOX / LCH4

- LOX / kerosene

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 18

Page 19: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Summary- The transpiration cooled CMC thrust chamber principle could be demonstrated successfully

- a simplified and de-coupled design principle has been proven

- no critical material degradation under efficient operation, considering scaling aspects

- mechanically safe structures

- First firing tests of the ceramic ‚cone injector‘ concept successful and promising

- Adequate hybrid mechanical interfaces demonstrated

- New hyperboloid thrust chamber contour numerically validated

- CMC application potential for ADN thruster (orbital propulsion)

- CMCs principally interesting for hybrid propulsion systems

- Preburner application (in particular ox-rich)

- Up-coming SLM technology

- Alternative propellants

Outlook

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 19

Page 20: German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures …elib.dlr.de/100842/1/2015-11-19_6th-RT-DAYS-Paris_Presentation_DLR... · German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Structures

Thank you for your attention!

DLR-ST-IBT > M. Ortelt / H. Hald / D. Koch > Presentation > AIRBUS DS – Space Systems - 6th R&T DAYS > Paris > France, 19.11.2015 • Chart 20